Arxiv:2105.05857V1 [Cond-Mat.Str-El] 12 May 2021
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Kekul´espiral order at all nonzero integer fillings in twisted bilayer graphene Y.H. Kwan,1 G. Wagner,1 T. Soejima,2 M.P. Zaletel,2, 3 S.H. Simon,1 S.A. Parameswaran,1 and N. Bultinck1, 4 1Rudolf Peierls Centre for Theoretical Physics, University of Oxford, Oxford OX1 3PU, United Kingdom 2Department of Physics, University of California, Berkeley, California 94720, USA 3Materials Sciences Division, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, California 94720, USA 4Department of Physics, Ghent University, 9000 Ghent, Belgium We study magic angle graphene in the presence of both strain and particle-hole symmetry break- ing due to non-local inter-layer tunneling. We perform a self-consistent Hartree-Fock study that incorporates these effects alongside realistic interaction and substrate potentials, and explore a com- prehensive set of competing orders including those that break translational symmetry at arbitrary wavevectors. We find that at all non-zero integer fillings very small strains, comparable to those measured in scanning tunneling experiments, stabilize a fundamentally new type of time-reversal symmetric and spatially non-uniform order. This order, which we dub the `incommensurate Kekul´e spiral' (IKS) order, spontaneously breaks both the emergent valley-charge conservation and moir´e translation symmetries, but preserves a modified translation symmetry T^0 | which simultaneously shifts the spatial coordinates and rotates the U(1) angle which characterizes the spontaneous inter- valley coherence. We discuss the phenomenological and microscopic properties of this order. We argue that our findings are consistent with all experimental observations reported so far, suggesting a unified explanation of the global phase diagram in terms of the IKS order. I. INTRODUCTION metal dichalcogenides [9], its applicability to TBG is lim- ited by the `fragile topology' of the BM bands [10, 11]. The discovery of superconductivity proximate to cor- The latter requires that the simplest tight-binding model related insulating behaviour in a variety of graphene that faithfully captures the symmetries of TBG involves a moir´eheterostructures [1{4] has triggered intensive ef- pair of crystallographically-inequivalent Wannier orbitals forts to explore the phase structure of these highly tun- centered on sites of a honeycomb lattice, but with their able two-dimensional materials. In the best-studied ex- charge densities peaked on a triangular lattice formed by ample, twisted bilayer graphene (TBG) tuned to a `magic the centers of its hexagons [10, 12, 13]. A corollary of angle' of approximately 1°, the enhancement of correla- this Wannier representation is that it implies a higher tions is associated to the formation of extremely narrow degree of itineracy than can be captured via a minimal bands due to the reconstruction of the electronic disper- honeycomb lattice Hubbard model with on-site repulsion sion by the moir´esuperlattice. As noted by Bistritzer and nearest-neighbor hopping. and MacDonald (BM) [5], this can be elegantly captured The utility of a Hubbard description is further chal- within a continuum model [6{8] where Dirac cones con- lenged by the early experimental observation of a quan- tributed by isolated graphene layers are coupled by inter- tized anomalous Hall (QAH) resistance in TBG samples layer tunneling modulated at the moir´escale. The BM aligned with a hexagonal boron nitride (hBN) substrate, model serves as a starting point for most theoretical stud- at an electron density corresponding to filling 7 of the 8 ies of TBG. On combining the degeneracies correspond- bands [14]. [In the convention where ν = 0 represents the ing to spin and microscopic valley indices with the Dirac filling at neutrality, this corresponds to ν = +3.] Since structure enforced by exact and approximate symmetries this occurs in the absence of an external magnetic field, it of the moi´re band structure, the model reveals that the indicates the spontaneous breaking of time reversal sym- striking effects reported in experiments occur when the metry (TRS). One explanation of this phenomenon in- Fermi energy is tuned to lie within an octet of nearly-flat vokes a compelling analogy to the other paradigmatic bands that straddle charge neutrality. The phase dia- setting for strong correlations: the celebrated Landau gram of TBG then turns on the question of how electron levels (LLs) of an electron in a magnetic field. The TBG correlations and other perturbations such as strain and flat bands are endowed with non-trivial topology encoded arXiv:2105.05857v2 [cond-mat.str-el] 12 Aug 2021 substrate effects lift the approximate degeneracy within in the winding of their Bloch functions across the moir´e this subspace to select between a variety of competing Brillouin zone (mBZ); the inclusion of substrate poten- ground states. tial triggers the opening of gaps between the moir´eDirac At first sight, the phase diagram of TBG resembles points (by breaking one of the protecting symmetries), that of the cuprate high-temperature superconductors, and assigns nonzero Chern numbers to the bands, mak- with electrostatic gating playing the role of chemical ing them topologically equivalent to LLs. The absence doping. This prompted initial attempts to model cor- of explicit TRS breaking is reflected in the assignment of relation effects within a single-band Hubbard model for equal and opposite Chern numbers to different valleys, electronic states localized to a triangular moir´esuperlat- which are exchanged by TRS. At ν = 3, electrons in tice. Although this approach has proven fruitful in study- the two remaining unfilled bands spontaneously polarize ing moir´eheterostructures of MoS2 and other transition- into one of the two valleys. This allows them to min- 2 imize their interaction energy by virtue of Pauli exclu- TBG must involve substantial further-neighbour inter- sion, leading to an insulator that spontaneously breaks actions. Meanwhile, corrections to the flat band limit 2 TRS, with a quantized Hall resistivity of ρxy = h=e | particularly from particle-hole symmetry breaking | protected by the charge gap. Recently, a similar QAH can significantly modify the Hartree potential, penal- state was also observed at ν = 1 [15]. While the forma- izing full occupation of the mBZ. Since exchange in- tion of such orbital Chern insulator states can in prin- teractions still favor insulating behaviour, one resolu- ciple be captured within a Hubbard description [16], its tion is to reconstruct the bands via finite-wavevector close parallels to quantum Hall ferromagnetism [17{19] ordering. Thus, from both points of view, it appears (QHFM) has motivated a distinct perspective, where that conditions in TBG might favor translational sym- TBG is viewed as a generalized multicomponent quan- metry breaking states over their competitors. Despite tum Hall system. This naturally explains both the ob- this, relatively little work has focused on this possibil- served QAH response as well the propensity for insulat- ity, with rare exceptions [16, 22, 28, 46{50], of which ing states at commensurate filling, and motivates a sigma we highlight a few. Refs. [16, 48] identified a unidi- model description based on a hierarchy of perturbations rectional charge density wave order that doubles the around a `hidden' limit with U(4) U(4) symmetry [20{ moir´eunit cell in an interaction-only model with spin 22]. The QHFM picture receives× further experimental and valley degeneracy suppressed, but this does not ap- support by the observed stabilization of QAH insulators pear to be energetically competitive with translationally- with Chern numbers C = 3; 2; 1 at ν = 1; 2; 3 invariant states in more realistic situations. More re- on applying a small out-of-plane± ± magnetic± field,± even± ± in cently, a different period-doubling stripe order stabilized the absence of substrate alignment [15, 23{26]. How- by Hartree effects was invoked to explain the occurrence ever, the TBG bands nevertheless retain features absent of commensurate-filling insulators whose Chern numbers in LLs. For instance, their dispersion (though small) re- depart from those expected from the naive QHFM pic- mains nonzero, and is enhanced when particle-hole sym- ture [28] (although we suggest an alternative and possibly metry breaking effects are incorporated | especially in more natural translation-breaking order at these fillings the electron-doped regime | or upon inclusion of strain. below). Ref. [51] studies a valley spiral state in magnet- Such effects are likely important in giving an accurate ically encapsulated TBG. This is a similar state to the description of experimental samples. As a case in point, one we describe below, albeit the physical origin and the even at commensurate fillings some experiments1 report parameter space within which that state exists are quite gapless states or insulators with Chern numbers distinct different2. For completeness, we note that translational from those of the noninteracting bands [15, 27, 28]. This symmetry breaking has recently been observed in closely suggests that departures from the flat band/QHFM limit related twisted monolayer-bilayer graphene moir´ehet- are non-negligible and that the competition between itin- erostructures [52], and was proposed theoretically to ex- eracy and localization characteristic of Hubbard physics plain insulating states observed in twisted bilayer WSe2 remains relevant to TBG. [53]. But despite these previous works, to date there has Given its enticing position at the intersection of two been no systematic analysis of translational symmetry dominant themes of strong correlations, it is natural to breaking in realistic TBG systems, and so the extent to conjecture that orders that are `natural' from both per- which such symmetry breaking is a common phenomenon spectives could be particularly robust candidate ground across the wide range of parameters relevant to experi- states in TBG. One example (and our focus here) is mental samples remains unclear. furnished by states with broken translation symmetry, which emerge in relatively well-understood limits of both In this work, we explore translational symmetry break- the Hubbard and quantum Hall settings.