Peggy Fletcher Stack, the Salt Lake Tribune
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
UTAH’S INDEPENDENT VOICE SINCE 1871 NOV. 7, 2014 « FRIDAY » SLTRIB.COM U. football • Oregon’s offense formidable > C1 SYMPHONY MUSICIANS HIT THE BAR — THEY’LL PLAY AT O’SHUCKS, FACING DUCKS FREE OF CHARGE > D1 SAME-SEX MARRIAGE BANS RELIGION • A LIFELONG QUEST FOR HARMONY Ruling BYU grads found may call love in Paris, a new FRANCISCO KJOLSETH | The Tribune Utah House Republicans chose faith decades later Rep. Greg Hughes as the new House speaker during a closed for high election meeting Thursday at the state Capitol. court’s GOP picks review Hughes “ 6th U.S. Circuit Court If it is con- of Appeals says that as new stitutionally states have the right to irrational to set rules for marriage. speaker stand by the By DAN SEWELL man-woman The Associated Press Utah politics • definition of Cincinnati • The march to- Dunnigan, who led marriage, it ward gay marriage across the Swallow investigation, U.S. hit a roadblock Thursday must be con- is chosen as House stitutionally when afederalappeals courtup- held laws againstthepractice in majority leader. irrational to four states, creating asplitin the stand by the legal system that increases the By ROBERT GEHRKE monogamous chancestheSupremeCourtwill The Salt Lake Tribune step in to decide the issue once definition of and for all. Rep. Greg Hughes was elect- marriage.” The cases decided were from ed Thursday as the new speak- Ohio, Michigan, Kentucky and er of the Utah House, prom- JEFFREY Tennessee. ising to bring energy and SUTTON Breaking ranks with oth- transparency to the position 6th Circuit judge er federal courts around the and to be inclusive of all of the country, the 6th U.S. Circuit viewpoints in the body. Court of Appeals ruled 2-1 that “Being a House member and Utah A.G. states have the right to set rules being able to be engaged in this to review for marriage and that changing is the honor of my life, and a definition that dates to “the I’m just grateful to be here,” ruling earliest days of human history” Hughes said. “I don’t think it’s State attorney is better done throughthepoliti- completely sunk in.” general’s office cal process, not the courts. Hughes, a Pittsburgh native plans to review “Surely the people should re- who lives in Draper, was first the 6th Circuit ceivesome deferencein deciding elected to the House in 2002. ruling to see if when the time is ripe to move TRENT NELSON | The Salt Lake Tribune He manages apartments and there could be from one picture of marriage An interfaith choir, accompanied by Mary Lou Prince, rehearses Thursday at the South Valley construction projects. implications for to another,” said Circuit Judge Unitarian Universalist Society church in Salt Lake City in preparation for a performance Friday A one-time amateur boxer Utah. › A4 Please see COURT, A4 at the LDS Assembly Hall on Temple Square. and fight promoter, his repu- tation at the Capitol is one of a laid-back wise-cracker to One became a friends and allies, and a pug- minister, the other nacious street-brawler willing a composer, and to mix it up with opponents. Judge rejects Hughes, who is currently together they are the House majority whip, beat building interfaith out House Majority Leader connections within the Brad Dee, and former House feds’ claims Speaker Mel Brown in the Mormon heartland. vote among his colleagues to replace House Speaker Becky for prairie dog By PEGGY FLETCHER STACK Lockhart, who is retiring. The Salt Lake Tribune The Republican caucus held the vote Thursday in a closed- protection Patty Willis and Mary Lou SCOTT SOMMERDORF | The Salt Lake Tribune door meeting. The vote tallies Prince fell madly, deeply for The Rev. Patty Willis, left, pastor at South Valley Unitarian Please see SPEAKER, A4 Ruling • The full impact of the each other in the City of Love Universalist Society church in Cottonwood Heights, and her decision remains unclear as the state —back when Mormonismstill wife, Mary Lou Prince, the church’s music director, tell their viewedtheirmutual attraction story Thursday in their Salt Lake City home. [ says it intends to protect the rodent. as a sinful choice. The year was 1978 and the By REBECCA WALSH and BRETT PRETTYMAN two Brigham Young Univer- HI The Salt Lake Tribune sity graduates met at a Par- Friday’s performance is LDS congregation. They What • A free cantata by Mary Lou Prince and Patty Willis 63 A federal judge has rejected the U.S. government’s spentmany clandestinenights, about the beauty of the Earth 36 justification for protecting the Utah prairie dog. walking along the Seine or se- When • Friday, 7:30 p.m. LO In a ruling issued Tuesday, U.S. District Judge Dee questered in an apartment, Where • LDS Assembly Hall on Temple Square in Salt Lake Today • Mostly sunny and Benson struck down regulations on the capture and cuddling and talking nonstop City breezy. > B8 killing, or “takes,”of thethreatenedrodenton nonfed- about music and art, French Who • Performing will be an interfaith choir from the eral land because wildlife managers could not prove cuisine and poetry, language South Valley Unitarian Universalist Society, the First Unitari- [ theanimal “has asubstantial effect on interstate com- and literature. an Church and a Kaysville Mormon ward Classified Ads Y1 Money A9 merce.” And faith. Comics D14 Obituaries B5 The Pacific Legal Foundation sued 18 months ago Both were multigeneration- So the lovers reluctantly About two years ago, the Editorials A10 Puzzles D15 on behalf of People fortheEthicalTreatmentof Prop- al members of The Church of split up, only to be reunited couple — now officially mar- Film Finder D3 Sports C1 erty Owners (PETPO), a Cedar City group including Jesus Christ of Latter-day after one failed marriage (for ried — returned to the Bee- Legals B4, C7 Television D16 local government leaders, who want to control the Saints and neither wanted to Willis) and shifting views on hive State, where Willis was VOLUME 289 | NUMBER 24 small mammal on private and public property, in- live asecret life withinabelief religion (for both). They lived hired as pastor at the South cludingin thetown cemetery,at parksandon airport system that, at the time, saw abroad for decades, teaching, Valley Unitarian Universalist runways. their feelings as illegitimate, writing, seeking, travelingand Society (SVUU) church and Please see PRAIRIE DOGS, A4 immoral, even perverse. tastingvariousfaithtraditions. Please see HARMONY, A4 A4 UTAH & NATION » Friday, November 7, 2014 THE SALT LAKE TRIBUNE proposals on whether to ex- considering options for the case straight to the Supreme Utah A.G. to Speaker pand Medicaid to cover more construction of a new prison. Court Court, for a definitive ruling ≥ Continued from A1 low-income Utahns. Gov. He sponsored legislation ≥ Continued from A1 on whether gays have a con- review the Gary Herbert has reached in 2009 that did away with stitutional right to wed. were not announced. an agreement in principle Utah’s requirements that Jeffrey Sutton, writing for The dissenting judge sug- decision on gay Rep. Jim Dunnigan, with the U.S. Department of bars and taverns be private himself and a fellow George gested that might have been R-Taylorsville, who recent- Health and Human Services clubs and required establish- W. Bush appointee, whileaBill the goal of Sutton and Judge marriage bans ly led the investigation of to cover the poorest Utahns ments to scan patrons’ iden- Clinton appointee dissented. Deborah Cook in their ruling. former Attorney General and subsidize insurance for tification. Cincinnati attorney Al Ger- “Because the correct result State attorneys plan to re- John Swallow, was select- those up to 138 percent of the In 2008, Hughes was the hardstein, who represent- is so obvious, one is tempted view a6thU.S. CircuitCourtof ed by the caucus as the new poverty level. subject of an ethics com- ed gay plaintiffs in two of the to speculate that the majori- Appeals decision upolding gay House majority leader. Rep. But Republican legislators plaint that alleged he at- cases, said he was disappoint- ty has purposefully taken the marriage bans in four states to Francis Gibson, R-Mapleton, in both the House and Sen- tempted to bribe a colleague ed and will appeal to the na- contrary position to create the determine whether the ruling was elected House majority ate are wary of the long-term to support school vouchers, tion’s highest court. circuit split,” Judge Martha hasimplcations forUtah’s own whip, and Rep. Brad Wilson, cost of the proposal. had strong-armed lobbyists Ohio Attorney General Craig Daugherty wrote. same-sex marriage laws, an at- R-Kaysville, was selected as Hughes said he plans to into backing the voucher Mike DeWine’s office, which In October, the Supreme torney general’s office spokes- assistant whip. draw on the expertise of movement and of intimidat- argued in support of the vot- Court turned away appeals woman said Thursday. Senate President Wayne Dunnigan, who owns an in- ing political opponents. er-passed 2004 Ohio ban from five states seeking to up- “It’s a complicated legal anal- Niederhauser, R-Sandy, who surance agency, and Gibson, At the time, Hughes called on gay marriage, said it was hold their same-sex marriage ysis, so it’s not that easy to say,” was re-elected Thursday to who is a health care admin- it a politically motivated “pleased thecourtagreed with bans. The ruling had the ef- Missy Larsen said. his leadership post, said he istrator, as well as four phy- hatchet job timed on the eve ourargumentsthat important fect of expanding gay mar- Gay marriage became le- got to know Hughes when sicians in the Legislature to of the election.