The Tournament and Its Role in the Court Culture of Emperor Maximilian I
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
i The Tournament and its Role in the Court Culture of Emperor Maximilian I (1459-1519) Natalie Margaret Anderson Submitted in accordance with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy The University of Leeds, Institute for Medieval Studies March 2017 ii The candidate confirms that the work submitted is her own and that appropriate credit has been given where reference has been made to the work of others. This copy has been supplied on the understanding that it is copyright material and that no quotation from the thesis may be published without proper acknowledgement. © 2017 The University of Leeds and Natalie Margaret Anderson The right of Natalie Margaret Anderson to be identified as Author of this work has been asserted by Natalie Margaret Anderson in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. iii Acknowledgements I must first acknowledge the help and support of my supervisors, Dr Alan V. Murray and Dr Karen Watts. They have been there since the beginning when I took part in their ‘Tournaments’ module during my MA studies, which first introduced me to the fantastical world of Maximilian’s tournaments. They also helped me to craft the idea for this research project while I was still exploring the exciting but daunting prospect of undertaking a PhD. Their words of advice, patience, and sometimes much-needed prodding over the past four years helped to bring about this thesis. Thank you as well to my examiners, Professor Stephen Alford and Professor Maria Hayward, whose insights helped to greatly improve this thesis. Thank you to the University of Leeds, whose funding in the form of a Leeds International Research Scholarship made this research possible. Research grants from the Extraordinary Postgraduate Fund in the School of History, Leeds, as well as from the Royal Historical Society have also made travel to various conferences possible. During this time, I have been exceptionally fortunate to have access to all of the wonderful resources available at the Royal Armouries in Leeds. Their tournament arms and armour collection, as well as their library, have proven incredibly useful. I would particularly like to thank Stuart Ivinson from the library for his assistance over the years and for the numerous trips to fetch various Turnierbücher for me. Thank you also to Dr Romedio Schmitz-Esser for his help and guidance in Munich, as well as to Dr Jörg Schwarz, who gave me the opportunity to visit several important sites in Innsbruck. To Prof. Dr Hiram Kümper of the University of Mannheim for inviting me to speak to his students and enabling me to see the Maximilian exhibit at the Reiss-Engelhorn Museum. To Dr Cornelia Linde of the German Historical Institute for introducing me to some great opportunities at the GHI. To Dr Gloria Allaire of the University of Kentucky, for her iv vote of confidence in inviting me to step in as plenary speaker at the ICLS Congress in 2016 and her assistance in getting me there. And to Dr Stefan Krause of the Kunsthistorisches Museum for his time and assistance in Vienna. I would also like to thank all the citizens of the Institute for Medieval Studies – the faculty, staff, and students. I have made some wonderful friends here over the years who made the PhD journey, with all its ups and downs, an unforgettable and often joyous experience. Thank you to Dr Melanie Brunner for all the helpful coffee and conversation. In particular, to the members of Alan’s ‘Fight Club’: the opportunity to share research and insight, chat, and drink wine with you has been one of my highlights. To my parents, Bob and Roberta Anderson: your unquestioning and unswerving belief in my medieval dreams over the (many) years can never be repaid. To my aunt Peggy and uncle Marty, for all your unrepayable support. To Ian and Bronwen McGregor, for taking in a poor PhD student. And to Iolo, my partner in adventures. v Abstract This thesis is an extensive and interdisciplinary study of the tournaments of Holy Roman Emperor Maximilian I (1459-1519). It draws upon material, literary, narrative, and visual sources to create a holistic view of what the late medieval German tournament looked like in the court of Maximilian. Its scope includes the types of tournaments held, historical context and influences, the network of participants, the environment, the practicalities, and the symbolism. It also invesitagates Maximilian’s influence on the tournament at this time, and its role in shaping his legacy. At its heart, by examining various narrative sources, this thesis presents a chronological study of the primary tournaments in which Maximilian was involved during his lifetime. Using this study, the thesis explores the various styles of joust practiced at the tournament under Maximilian, and the arms and armour, as well as decorative elements, employed in each. Finally, it explores the role of the tournament specifically as it pertained to Maximilian’s courtly culture. This thesis makes use of an unprecedented range of sources in presenting its findings. By drawing upon extant Maximilian-related tournament arms and armour, as well as visual depictions of his tournaments, alongside both fictional and real-life accounts of these events, new information may be gathered which brings to light previously unexplored findings and draws connections which have not before been made. This research demonstrates the central role which tournaments played during Maximilian’s reign. It attempts to categorise and catalogue the numerous styles of joust which the emperor promoted by analysing their distinct features. Further, it reveals his influence upon them and, in turn, theirs upon him, through the crafting of his memory in the form of public spectacle and various literary and artistic works. vi Table of Contents Acknowledgements ........................................................................................................................... iii Abstract ................................................................................................................................................ v Table of Contents .............................................................................................................................. vi List of Tables and Figures ................................................................................................................ ix A Note on Spellings .......................................................................................................................... xi Introduction ......................................................................................................................................... 1 0.1 Research Aims .......................................................................................................................... 1 0.2 Historiography .......................................................................................................................... 5 0.3 Research Questions and Thesis Outline .............................................................................12 Chapter 1: Sources for Tournament Culture in the Time of Maximilian I ..............................16 1.1 Introduction ............................................................................................................................16 1.2 Narrative Sources ...................................................................................................................16 1.2.a Maximilian through the Eyes of His Contemporaries ................................................... 19 1.3 Visual Sources ........................................................................................................................32 1.3 Maximilian’s Personal Works ...............................................................................................39 1.5 Material Culture ......................................................................................................................46 1.6 Conclusions ............................................................................................................................46 Chapter 2: Tournaments in the Life and Career of Maximilian .................................................48 2.1 Introduction ............................................................................................................................48 2.2 The Burgundian Inheritence and Influences .....................................................................50 2.3 Archduke of Austria and King of the Romans .................................................................65 2.4 Maximilian as Emperor and the Establishment of Tournaments in his Court ............73 2.5 A New Century and Consolidation of Power ....................................................................91 2.6 Conclusions ......................................................................................................................... 102 Chapter 3: The Language of the Tournament and Varieties of the Joust ............................. 106 3.1 Introduction ......................................................................................................................... 106 3.2 Tournament Terminology and the Difficulties of Translation .................................... 107 3.2.a The Etymology of Gestech and Rennen ............................................................................. 109 3.2.b The Trouble with ‘Joust of War’ and ‘Joust of Peace’ ................................................. 111