Lefferts Manor a Singular New York City Community
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Lefferts Manor A Singular New York City Community Suzanne Spellen with Dominique M. Carson 2 Lefferts Manor A Singular New York City Community Suzanne Spellen with Dominique M. Carson 1 Acklowledgments THANKS TO ALL who helped Special thanks as well to to make this Lefferts Manor Professor John Petito who led Association (LMA) Centennial us back to the NYU archival Yearbook possible especially— material, which contained LMA President, Pia Raymond, his graduate work on Lefferts LMA Vice-President, Vincent Manor history and who also Lisi, former LMA Board member graciously shared his exhaustive Mary Miller, former Board background materials from member Paul Morin, Board his research. member Bob Marvin and Lefferts Manor neighbor Ada Terry. And last but certainly not least, special note of thanks to Mary Special thanks to our Lefferts Miller who shared her idea Manor neighbor, Professor for a Yearbook commemorating Ronald Howell, who provided LMA’s centennial and who guidance on the selection and contributed her guidance, work of those who penned the knowledge of LMA’s history article for this Yearbook on the and wise counsel throughout history of Lefferts Manor—Ms. our efforts to bring this to Suzanne Spellen with Ms. publication. And to Vincent Lisi Dominique Carson. for his professional expertise and artistry in designing this beautiful Also thanks to John Zarillo, souvenir of LMA history. Senior Archivist of the New York University Archives for assisting It has been a pleasure to work us every step of the way in with you all on this special project. gaining access to archival material containing the research on Lefferts Carlene V. Braithwaite Manor conducted under the LMA Board Member New York University (NYU) Public History Program in 1991– 92. Published by the Lefferts Manor Association LeffertsManor.org © 2020 by the Lefferts Manor Association All rights reserved. Published 2020. Typeset in Athelas and Interstate ISBN 00-0000 Contents 4 Prologue 6 Introduction 12 A Singular New York City Community 14 A Short History 16 The Lefferts Family 20 Creating Lefferts Manor 26 Living with the Covenant in the Manor 30 The Holmes Case 32 Life in Lefferts Manor 36 Missing Ben Edwards 38 Lefferts Manor Timeline 40 Sources and Bibliography 41 Recommended Further Reading and Selected References 42 Single-Family Covenant 43 Lefferts Manor Association Yearbook 1930—31 Lefferts Manor Association Yearbook 1938 115 Map of Lefferts Manor Prologue To top off these centennial celebrations and with gratitude to all who have worked to make them truly memorable, the LMA Board and its Centennial Committee present to you this special centennial edition of the Lefferts Manor Association Yearbook. This Yearbook begins with a thoughtful reflection on the history of LMA and THE LEFFERTS Manor Association Lefferts Manor by long-time (LMA) was founded in 1919 by a resident and former Board group of neighbors to ensure the member, Mary Miller. Providing continued viability of Lefferts a look back on LMA through Manor as a stable harmonious the years, Mary’s introduction residential community in the guides us through notable heart of a growing section LMA activities and events of Brooklyn near Prospect which now are a part of Lefferts Park. In June of 2019, the LMA Manor history. The Yearbook’s annual house tour marked the centerpiece is an article on centennial of Lefferts Manor by Lefferts Manor. Working with focusing on the stunning and the LMA Board, the Centennial varied landmarked architecture Committee for this Yearbook of the neighborhood’s homes. embarked on research on the Later in September, we were history of LMA and Lefferts pleased to host a very special Manor. The article—Lefferts centennial Gala with music, food, Manor: A Singular New York City drink and fellowship at Brooklyn Community—summarizes some Commons. The Gala event was of that history. The article was well attended by many neighbors, crafted by Ms. Suzanne Spellen, friends and supporters of Lefferts working with Ms. Dominique Manor. Carson, a research intern 4 retained by the Lefferts Manor who seek to learn more about Board, under the guidance this unique community. of Lefferts Manor neighbor, journalist and author, Professor It is hoped you enjoy this Ronald Howell. In addition to souvenir of Lefferts Manor’s the article, the Committee has 100 years. Special thanks to all created a timeline on the history who assisted in the 2019 Lefferts of Lefferts Manor, with photos Manor centennial events and in and pictures of significant events our look back over the history over the past years which are of this community and this noteworthy and memorable. Also organization. reproduced are two Yearbooks issued by LMA in the 1930s to Pia Raymond is President of the Lefferts Manor memorialize its activities. When Association since 2019. one reads through these 1930s Yearbooks, it is easy to notice the similarities between some of the issues of the day and those of interest now—street lighting, tree preservation, enforcement of local traffic regulations and an overall concern for the continued viability of the neighborhood as a friendly, stable and very special place to live. Provided also is a recommended reading list. In addition to material that may be familiar and those noted in the article, the list contains materials uncovered during the centennial research which should serve as a resource for additional reading and source material for those 5 Introduction by the LMA. It was managed for over thirty years by Carole Schaffer, a Midwood I resident and pillar of the community who was known as the House Tour Lady. Her husband, Art Schaffer, joined with Curtis Bryce, Bob Marvin, Hein Jurgensen and others to petition the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission for historic AS WE CELEBRATE the centennial designation of the area, which of the founding of the Lefferts was granted in 1979. When the Manor Association this year, I extent of historic designation am taking the opportunity to was not as wide as hoped for, the reflect on the significance of this LMA under the leadership of Ben institution in creating a unique, Edwards was instrumental in the wonderful community. Our eventual designation of Ocean hope is that this LMA Yearbook, on the Park in 2009 and Chester incorporating copies of those Court in 2014. produced in 1930-31 and 1938, will help bring forward for the next In the mid 1980s Nancy Asher one hundred years a sense of the spearheaded a campaign to history and development of this place oak flower barrels along special area and the role of the the sidewalks because so many LMA in “the bringing together of street trees were missing. The the residents of that district for Association has ever since their better acquaintance, and for organized yearly planting of their mutual benefit.” flowers paid for by the LMA. Independent of LMA, Manor By the time I moved here in 1981, residents organized a paid the annual PLGNA House and security patrol that cruised Garden Tour had been running the neighborhood during the since 1969. Although founded difficult years of the crack by the Prospect Lefferts Gardens cocaine epidemic. A more Neighborhood Association, a cheerful practice, the hanging larger neighborhood association of holiday wreaths on the doors established the same year, the of LMA members started in the House Tour relied heavily on late 1990s. LMA President Ben Manor residents for its success, Edwards worked with elected and was eventually sponsored officials, particularly Marty 6 Markowitz, our State Senator be a lot of different celebrations, and later Borough President, but we came up with the idea to install tree guards and of having one community-wide the bishop’s crook street lights celebration in 1993 to celebrate appropriate to the historic the founding of Lefferts Manor. character of the Manor. The timeline was short. I Besides the twice-a-year headed up the project and we meetings held by the LMA to involved the New York University discuss neighborhood issues, Program in Public History in an individual blocks promote a academic year of researching sense of community with block the history of our area. The parties and progressive dinners. graduate students in the masters’ The LMA puts out The Echo, a program presented their research, neighborhood newsletter, several collectively titled Transforming the times a year. The Manor also Fields: Flatbush from Dutch Farms became a host to the larger to Urban Homes to the community community by working with at the Lefferts Homestead the 71st Precinct on the annual on May 3, 1992. Much of their Halloween Parade. Starting in research was incorporated into 1996 Manor residents on Rutland, an exhibit in the Homestead, Midwood and Maple Streets mounted by the Association in have decorated their homes in cooperation with the Prospect ghoulish themes and opened Park Alliance, from October 9 to their doors to hand out candy to December 19, 1993. an increasing number of trick-or- treaters drawn from ever larger Our neighborhood has been parts of Brooklyn when word of rocked by two major tragedies. the fun and benefits spread. The November 1, 1918 subway accident under the intersection It must have been in the late of Flatbush Avenue and Malbone 1980s that Carole Schaffer and Street was so devastating that I were having the canonical Malbone Street had to be Lefferts Manor conversation renamed and is now Empire “When will my house be Boulevard. The wreck, due to a ‘finished’?”. I said I wanted to runaway train making a sharp have a big party for my house turn where different subway when it turned 100 years old in lines connected, killed 93 people, 2011. Carole’s house is among the including Joseph I.