By Minister 576 SHRI JAGESH DESAI
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
575 Statement [RAJYA SABHA] by Minister 576 SHRI JAGESH DESAI: Madam, the Finance Minister has given a very, very exhaustive statement without concealing any facts. I compliment the Finance Minister on disclosing the total facts as they stood from the beginning to the end. Madam, now you may call the Minister. SHRI S. JAIPAL REDDY: Is Mr. Rajesh Pilot suffering from jet-lag? THE VICE-CHAIRMAN (SHRIMATI STATEMENT BY MINISTER SUSHMA SWARAJ): He is coming. I have already asked. Fatal Bomb attack on Shri P. Siva Reddy, Telugu Desam M.L.A., Andhra Pradesh THE MINISTER OF STATE IN THE MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS (SHRI RAJESH PILOT): Madam, with your per- mission. 1 make a statement on the fatal bomb attack on Shri P. Siva Reddy, Telugu Desam ML.A. ( Interruptions). [The Deputy Chairman in the Chair] As per the information received from the State Government, Shri P. Siva Reddy, Telugu Desam (TDP) MLA from Jammala- madugu was attending the Monsoon Session of the A.P. Legislative Assembly. He was provided with two State Police guards. He also had two private gunmen who accom- panied him. On 7-8-1993 at about 9.00 A.M. Shri P. Siva Reddy. MLA (TDP) alongwith the official gunman Shri K. Nathaneil, Head Constable 477 and two more private gunmen SHRI JAGESH DESAI: Madam Deputy visited the house of Shri N. Chandrababu Naidu, M.L.A. (TDP) and from there he Chairperson, only one sentence. visited the house of Shri D. Venkateswara Rao. MP (TDP) at Banjara Hills, at 10.30 A.M. At 11.40 A.M., Shri P. Siva Reddy asked Shri K. Nathaneil and his two private gunmen to go back to his quarter. No. 135. New MLA Quarters, and SHRI JAGESH DESAI: I will start so he proceeded with Shri Kala Venkata Rao, that my claim will be there. M.L.A. ITDP) in a Maruti car to attend a marriage at Shri Satya Sai Kalayana Mandapam. Srinagar Colony, without taking any securitymen with him. The gunman of Shri Rao was also not with him. Around 577 Statement [10 AUG. 1993] by Minister 578 12.00 noon, when he was coming out of supplied by the Government spokesman the marriage hall and getting into the to the press. Therefore, I am surprised Maruti car, some unidentified persons that the Minister chose to depend on hurled bombs at Shri P. Siva Reddy, who this statement when so much water has died on the spot. Shri Rao, and Shri A. flowed since then. He should be able Suryanarayana Raju, former Deputy Spea- to say as to what information he has in ker, A.P. Legislative Assembly, were also regard to the allegations levelled against injured in the bomb attack and they were the Home Minister of Andhra Pradesh. admitted in Hospital and they are pro- The wife of the deceased MLA, Mr. Siva gressing. Two culprits have been ap- Reddy herself lodged a complaint against prehended so far. The Police have regis- the Home Minister of Andhra Pradesh. tered a case, under relevant legal provi- The Home Minister of Andhra Pradesh sions, which has been entrusted to the is the prime accused in the case according State CID for investigation. to the wife of the slain MLA. What have you got to say on that? On the afternoon of 8th August, 1993, Shri P. Siva Reddy's body was buried in SHRIMATI RENUKA CHOWDHURY his native village in Gundlakyunta near (Andhra Pradesh): Madam, the state- Jammalamadugu with police honours in the ment says that Mr. Siva Reddy asked presence of senior officials. The Bandh Mr. K. Nathaneil and two private gun- call given by T.D.P. on 8th August, 1993, men to go back to his quarter. I am, passed off peacefully but for a few minor asking a specific question. Who were incidents. Madam, there is a second state- those constables and what were their badge ment also. numbers—I mean, the people who were allotted to Mr. Siva Reddy after the THE DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: Let him Speaker had given a direction in the As- read the second statement also. ( Interrup- sembly in Andhra Pradesh? How much tions) security was given to him and how many people were there? What are their SHRI S. JAIPAL REDDY (Andhra Pra- names and what is their badge number desh): Madam, why can't we dispose of and which vehicle was given to them? the first statement first? (Interruptions) SHRI P. UPENDRA (Andhra Pradesh): THE DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: Don't get Madam, this is not a complete statement. agitated. The Minister is requesting some- All this has appeared in the newspapers. thing and I have to think of it. Another One expected something more from the thing is. we have spent the whole day Home Minister—what the State Govern- asking questions and in discussing it. There ment informed him about this matter and would be no problem in having it sepa- what the intelligence agencies were doing, rately. Don't get unnecessarily agitated. because for the last few days before the Mr. Minister, let one statement be cleared murder, Mr. Siva Redy was apprehending first and then we will ask you to make some attack and people from Cuddapah the second statement. There are two state- district were gathering in.. Hyderabad in ments. The Members from Andhra Pra- batches. They were staying in hotels desh want to ask some clarifications on for several days. What were the intelli- the statement relating to Andhra Pradesh. gence agencies doing in spite of the com- 1 don't think there is anything for very plaint of the MLA? Why didn't they many clarifications. Those who want to take a pre-emptive action? ask one or two questions, they can ask. (Interruptions) SHRI MENTAY PADMANABHAM (Andhra Pradesh): Madam, this is a SHRI S. JAIPAL REDDY: Madam, blissfully vague statement and this is the statement made by the Minister is not even worth the paper on which it is obviously based on information furnished typed. I am really unhappy about it. by the Government at least 48 hours ear- This is not the statement which I expect- lier than now. It is not even based on ed from the Minister. Madam, serious latest information available to us and allegations are there. Nothing has been 579 Statement [RAJYA SABHA] by Minister 580 [Sh. Mentay Padmanabham] give that security to him? Normally two security persons are provided to all replied here. (Interruptions) Madam, legislators. Even MPs are provided with you allow me to speak. two security persons whenever they go to their places. These two security persons THE DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: I have are not adequate. They are generally allowed you the whole day. You have given to all the 227 or 337 MLAs. This discussed this issue the whole day. is a normal practice. ...(Interruptions)... This is a normal practice. He wanted SHRI MENTAY PADMANABHAM: additional security. Because of the gra- You have not allowed me the whole day. vity of the situation, because of the en- You have allowed everybody else during mity he had with the Home Minister, the whole day. {Interruptions) This is because of his involvement in local politics, a matter about which we are concerned. he wanted additional security. That addi- Let me have some say. Let me take tional security which was given to him some information from the hon. Minister. by the District Superintendent was with- drawn. Again, he was asking for addi- tional security which in spite of the speci- THE DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: All fic directions given by the State Govern- right. But you ask him what you want ment, in spite of the specific direction to ask. (Interruptions) given by the Speaker and in spite of the direction given by the High Court, the SHRI MENTAY PADMANABHAM: Government did not give. Why? what Madam, 1 would like to know from the are the reasons for this? Did the State Minister whether an attack was made on Government explain it to him? Is the Mr. Siva Reddy on 8-5-93 in Jammalama- State Government prepared to institute an dugu village—his native place—and then inquiry into this failure of the State he approached the State Government. The Government? Is the Central Government State Government directed him to take going to institute an inquiry into the failure the security from the district authorities. of the State Government in providing Then he approached the District Superin- security to Mr. Siva Reddy? What are tendent of Police. Having come to know the replies of the hon. Minister? the gravity of the situation, the District Superintendent of Police provided him some security. Later on, the State Government intervened, the Home Minis- ter intervened and the additional security provided to him by the district authorities was withdrawn on 13-7-92. Is it true or not? Another thing is, in December Mr. Siva Reddy approached the High Court. The High Court gave clear-cut directions to the Government to provide him the secu- rity needed for protecting his life. Why didn't the State Government follow the directions given by the High Court? The next point is this. In the Legis- lative Assembly itself, on 6th of August, one day before he was murdered, the Speaker gave a specific direction. He gave a specific direction to the Govern- ment on the floor of the House that Mr. Reddy should be provided with all the security he needed immeditely, without delay. Then why didn't the Government 581 Statement [10 AUG. 1993] by Minister 582 SHRI JAGMOHAN (Nominated): Madam, the point is, whenever there is a security threat to a particular individ- ual, the Intelligence or the Special Branch of the State Police normally prepares a list of persons from whom the threat is expected.