San Diego Regional Analysis of Impediments to Fair Housing Choice

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

San Diego Regional Analysis of Impediments to Fair Housing Choice SAN DIEGO REGIONAL ANALYSIS OF IMPEDIMENTS TO FAIR HOUSING CHOICE MAY 2020 Lead Agency City of San Diego Economic Development Department 1200 Third Avenue, 14th Floor San Diego, CA 92101 SAN DIEGO REGIONAL ANALYSIS OF IMPEDIMENTS TO FAIR HOUSING CHOICE Table of Contents Chapter 1: Introduction A. Purpose of Report ................................................................................................................................ 1 B. Geographic Area Covered .................................................................................................................. 2 C. Fair Housing Legal Framework ......................................................................................................... 2 D. Fair Housing Defined .......................................................................................................................... 5 E. Organization of Report ....................................................................................................................... 6 F. Data Sources ......................................................................................................................................... 7 Chapter 2: Community Outreach A. Community Workshops ...................................................................................................................... 8 B. Targeted Stakeholder Interviews ...................................................................................................... 11 C. Fair Housing Survey .......................................................................................................................... 14 D. Public Review of Draft AI ................................................................................................................ 18 Chapter 3: Community Profile A. Demographic Profile ......................................................................................................................... 19 B. Household Characteristics ................................................................................................................ 28 C. Special Needs Groups ....................................................................................................................... 33 D. Hate Crimes ........................................................................................................................................ 53 E. Income Profile .................................................................................................................................... 56 F. Housing Profile ................................................................................................................................... 66 G. Housing Condition ............................................................................................................................. 71 H. Housing Cost and Affordability ....................................................................................................... 74 I. Housing Problems .............................................................................................................................. 80 J. Publicly Assisted Housing ................................................................................................................. 84 K. Licensed Community Care Facilities ............................................................................................... 92 L. Accessibility to Opportunities .......................................................................................................... 95 M. ADA-Compliant Public Facilities (Section 504 Assessment) .................................................... 101 N. Exposure to Adverse Community Factors ................................................................................... 102 Chapter 4: Lending Practices A. Background ....................................................................................................................................... 120 B. Overall Lending Patterns ................................................................................................................ 122 C. Lending by Race/Ethnicity and Income....................................................................................... 125 D. Lending Patterns by Tract Characteristics .................................................................................... 128 E. Major Lenders ................................................................................................................................... 129 F. Sub-Prime Lending Market ............................................................................................................. 130 Chapter 5: Public Policies A. Policies and Programs Affecting Housing Development .......................................................... 132 B. Zoning Ordinance ............................................................................................................................ 139 C. Variety of Housing Opportunity .................................................................................................... 143 D. Building Codes and Occupancy Standards ................................................................................... 152 E. Affordable Housing Development ................................................................................................ 154 CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION i SAN DIEGO REGIONAL ANALYSIS OF IMPEDIMENTS TO FAIR HOUSING CHOICE F. Other Land Use Policies, Programs, and Controls ..................................................................... 158 G. Policies Causing Displacement or Affect Housing Choice of Minorities and Persons with Disabilities ......................................................................................................................................... 163 H. Local Housing Authorities .............................................................................................................. 164 I. California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) .......................................................................... 164 J. Community Representation and Participation ............................................................................. 165 Chapter 6: Fair Housing Profile A. Fair Housing in the Homeownership Market .............................................................................. 167 B. Fair Housing in the Rental Housing Market ................................................................................ 171 C. Fair Housing Services ...................................................................................................................... 176 D. California Department of Fair Employment and Housing (DFEH) ....................................... 177 E. Fair Housing Statistics ..................................................................................................................... 178 F. Fair Housing Testing ....................................................................................................................... 182 G. U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development ............................................................ 187 H. Hate Crimes ...................................................................................................................................... 190 Chapter 7: Fair Housing Action Plan A. Regional Impediments ..................................................................................................................... 192 B. Jurisdiction-Specific Impediments ................................................................................................. 198 List of Tables Table 1: Community Workshop Locations .................................................................................................... 8 Table 2: Stakeholder Interviews ..................................................................................................................... 11 Table 3: Perpetrators of Alleged Discrimination ........................................................................................ 15 Table 4: Location of Alleged Discrimination .............................................................................................. 15 Table 5: Basis of Alleged Discrimination ..................................................................................................... 16 Table 6: Reason for Not Reporting Alleged Discrimination ..................................................................... 17 Table 7: Basis of Alleged Hate Crime ........................................................................................................... 17 Table 8: Population Growth (2000-2035) .................................................................................................... 20 Table 9: Age Characteristics ........................................................................................................................... 21 Table 10: Racial and Ethnic Composition.................................................................................................... 23 Table 11: Minority Population by Sub-region ............................................................................................. 25 Table 12: Language and Linguistic Isolation................................................................................................ 27 Table 13: Household Growth by Jurisdiction.............................................................................................. 29 Table
Recommended publications
  • Best Practices for Lease Insurance Specifications
    BEST PRACTICES FOR LEASE INSURANCE SPECIFICATIONS CHECKLIST VERSUS NARRATIVE FORMAT William H. Locke, Jr. Graves Dougherty Hearon & Moody Austin, Texas ACREL Annual Meeting Leasing and Insurance Committees Chicago October, 2012 1685471v2 TABLE OF CONTENTS I. INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................................................................................... 1 A. Contractual Risk Allocation .................................................................................................................................... 1 B. Risk of Casualty Loss and Injuries in Leased Premises .......................................................................................... 1 C. Heightened Risk Concern Arising During Periods of Financial Distress ................................................................ 2 D. Annotated Forms ..................................................................................................................................................... 2 II. FORMS ........................................................................................................................................................................... 3 A. Lease Provisions ...................................................................................................................................................... 3 1. Form A.1. - Insurance Specifications as Exhibit to Lease ............................................................................... 3 A. General
    [Show full text]
  • Chapter 3: Escrow, Taxes, and Insurance
    HB-2-3550 CHAPTER 3: ESCROW, TAXES, AND INSURANCE 3.1 INTRODUCTION To protect the Agency’s interest in the security property, the Servicing and Asset Management Office (Servicing Office) must ensure that real estate taxes and any other local assessments are paid and that the property remains adequately insured. To ensure that funds are available for these purposes, the Agency requires most borrowers who receive new loans to deposit funds to an escrow account. Borrowers who are not required to establish an escrow account may do so voluntarily. If an escrow account has been established, payments for insurance, taxes, and other assessments are made by the Agency. If an escrow account has not been established, the borrower is responsible for making timely payments. Section 1 of this chapter describes basic requirements for paying taxes and maintaining insurance coverage; Section 2 provides procedure for establishing and maintaining the escrow account; and Section 3 discusses procedures for addressing insured and uninsured losses to the security property. SECTION 1: TAX AND INSURANCE REQUIREMENTS [7 CFR 3550.60 and 3550.61] 3.2 TAXES AND OTHER LOCAL ASSESSMENTS The Agency contracts with a tax service to secure tax information for all borrowers. The tax service obtains tax bills due for payment, determines the optimal time to pay the taxes in order to take advantage of any discounts, and provides delinquent tax status on the portfolio. A. Tax Service Fee All borrowers are charged a tax service fee. Borrowers who obtain a subsequent loan are not required to pay a second tax service fee.
    [Show full text]
  • U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Sacramento District 1325 J Street Sacramento, California Contract: DACA05-97-D-0013, Task 0001 FOSTER WHEELER ENVIRONMENTAL CORPORATION
    CALIFORNIA HISTORIC MILITARY BUILDINGS AND STRUCTURES INVENTORY VOLUME II: THE HISTORY AND HISTORIC RESOURCES OF THE MILITARY IN CALIFORNIA, 1769-1989 by Stephen D. Mikesell Prepared for: U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Sacramento District 1325 J Street Sacramento, California Contract: DACA05-97-D-0013, Task 0001 FOSTER WHEELER ENVIRONMENTAL CORPORATION Prepared by: JRP JRP HISTORICAL CONSULTING SERVICES Davis, California 95616 March 2000 California llistoric Military Buildings and Stnictures Inventory, Volume II CONTENTS CONTENTS ..................................................................................................................................... i FIGURES ....................................................................................................................................... iii LIST OF ACRONYMS .................................................................................................................. iv PREFACE .................................................................................................................................... viii 1.0 INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................................. 1-1 2.0 COLONIAL ERA (1769-1846) .............................................................................................. 2-1 2.1 Spanish-Mexican Era Buildings Owned by the Military ............................................... 2-8 2.2 Conclusions ..................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • OTTER Sea Trials Promising, but Require Further Analysis
    Highlights EAG OUTREACH UPDATE U.S. VIRGIN ISLANDS VISIT BLADE INSPECTION TECH MICROGRIDS WASTE-TO-ENERGY TECH SURGEENERGY ACADEMIC GROUP QUARTERLY NEWSLETTER SUMMER / FALL 2018 USS Spruance (DDG 111) does a high speed run during Super Trials. In April, the Energy Academic Group at NPS sent a student thesis team to Naval Base San Diego to gather data relating to recent transits by the USS Spruance and USS Stockdale (DDG 106). The data will help form the basis of a more detailed analysis of OTTER’s expected fuel savings and the factors that impact transit fuel consumption. Photo courtesy U.S. Navy. fuel use against OTTER’s predictions. This April, the Energy Academic OTTER Sea Trials Although operational and maintenance Group at NPS sent a student thesis considerations on the WASP didn’t team to Naval Base San Diego to gather Promising, But allow for full testing of OTTER’s data in support of OTTER. The team optimized transit planning capabilities, collected data relating to recent transits Require Further the testing demonstrated OTTER’s by the USS Stockdale (DDG-106) and USS Analysis ease of use, ability to adapt to engine Spruance (DDG-111) that will help form mode constraints, and ability to create the basis of a more detailed analysis Last fall, the Energy Academic Group reasonable fuel consumption estimates. of OTTER’s expected fuel savings and conducted testing of the Optimized The test also highlighted several the factors that impact transit fuel Transit Tool & Easy Reference (OTTER) important considerations for future consumption. The work of this thesis on the USS Wasp (LHD-1) as it transited trials.
    [Show full text]
  • S a M P L E D O C U M E N T Allstate Insurance Company Standard
    Allstate Insurance Company S Standard HomeownersA PolicyM Policy: P Effective: Issued to: L E D O C U M Allstate Insurance Company The Company Named in the Policy Declarations A Stock Company----Home Office: Northbrook, Illinois 60062 E AP1 N T Table of Contents General Definitions Used In This Policy..................................2 Insurable Interest and Our Liability .........................11 InsuringSAgreement....................................................3 What You Must Do After A Loss.............................11 Agreements We Make With You...............................4 Our Settlement Options............................................12 Conformity To State Statutes ....................................4 How We Pay For A Loss...........................................12 Coverage Changes......................................................4 Our Settlement Of Loss ............................................14 Policy Transfer .A...........................................................4 Appraisal.....................................................................14 Continued Coverage After Your Death.....................4 Abandoned Property.................................................14 Cancellation .................................................................4 Permission Granted To You.....................................14 Concealment Or Fraud ..M.............................................5 Our Rights To Recover Payment.............................14 Our Rights To Obtain Salvage..................................14
    [Show full text]
  • Property Insurance Requirements TO
    U.S. Department of Housing and OMB Approval No. 2502-0029 Property Insurance Urban Development (exp. 10/31/2012) Requirements Federal Housing Administration Public reporting burden for this collection of information is estimated to average .08 hours per response, including the time for reviewing instructions, searching existing data sources, gathering and maintaining the data needed, and completing and reviewing the collection of information. This is part of the basic application package for insured mortgages for construction of rental housing projects. This is a requirement under Section 207(b) of the National Housing Act (Public Law 479, 48 Stat. 1246, 12 U.S.C., 1701 et. seq.), authorizing the Secretary of HUD to insured mortgages. The information establishes property insurance requirements for a proposed multifamily project. The information is required to obtain benefits. Privacy Act Notice - The United States Department of Housing and Urban Development, Federal Housing Administration, is authorized to solicit the information requested in this form by virtue of Title 12, United States Code, Section 1701 et. seq., and regulations promulgated thereunder at Title 12, Code of Federal Regulations. While no assurances of confidentiality is pledged to respondents, HUD generally discloses this data only in response to a Freedom of Information request. This agency may not conduct or sponsor, and a person is not required to respond to, a collection of information unless that collection displays a valid OMB control number. _______________________________________________
    [Show full text]
  • Over Insurance Statutes by State State Statute Statutory Wording Alabama Alaska Over-Insurance Prohibited
    Over Insurance Statutes by State State Statute Statutory Wording Alabama Alaska Over-Insurance Prohibited. (a) Over-insurance shall be considered to exist if property or an insurable interest in property is insured by one or more insurance contracts against the same hazard in an amount in excess of the fair value of the property or of the interest, as determined on the effective date of the insurance or the renewal of it. AS 21.60.010 (b) In this section the term "fair value" means the cost of replacement less depreciation that is properly applicable to the subject insured. (c) A person may not knowingly issue, place, procure, or accept an insurance contract that would result in over-insurance of the property or interest in the property proposed to be insured, except as provided in AS 21.60.020 . (d) Each violation of this section shall subject the violator to the penalties provided in AS 21.90.020 . Arizona 6-909 Prohibited Acts (Banking Law) P. A mortgage broker shall not require a person seeking a loan secured by real property to obtain property insurance coverage in an amount that exceeds the replacement cost of the improvements as established by the property insurer. 44-1208 44-1208. Loans secured by real estate; prohibited practices; insurance Except for consumer lender loans regulated pursuant to section 6-636, for any loan that is secured by real property, a person shall not require as a condition of the loan that the borrower obtain property insurance coverage in an amount that exceeds the replacement cost of the improvements as established by the property insurer.
    [Show full text]
  • Homeowners Insurance Application
    Homeowners Insurance Application Named Insured(s) and Mailing Address Insurance Company 650 Davis Street San Francisco, CA 94111 Primary Email: Insured Property Primary Phone #: Alternate Phone #: Bought through: NOTICE OF INSURANCE INFORMATION PRACTICES In some insurance transactions, we may not be able to get all the information we need directly from you. In that case, we may obtain information from outside sources at our own expense. We would also like to inform you that without prior authorization, we may as permitted by law, provide information about you contained in our records and files to certain persons or organizations. NOTICE: As part of Esurance's underwriting/qualification procedure and subject to applicable laws and regulations, we may obtain information regarding you and other individuals who may be covered by the insurance you are applying for, including: (i) driving record, based on state motor vehicle reports and loss information reports; (ii) your prior insurance record, if any, which will be obtained from your current or prior carrier(s); (iii) credit reports; and (iv) claim history, based on loss information reports. Policy Number Purchase Date and Time Effective Date Expiration Date Primary Applicant Information Name Date of Birth Gender Marital Status Education Level Existing Esurance Policy Drivers License Number DL State Currently Insured - Auto Length of Time with Current Auto Carrier Length of Time with Prior Auto Carrier Years with Prior Property Company Type of Current Property Policy Co -Applican t Information
    [Show full text]
  • Mortgage Impairment / Mortgagee's Errors & Omissions Insurance
    Mortgage Impairment / Mortgagee’s Errors & Omissions Insurance – Frequently Asked Questions What is Mortgage Impairment / Mortgagee’s Errors & Omissions insurance? Mortgage Impairment provides insurance coverage to a financial institution for a loss to its “mortgage interest” (defined as interest in real property as security for a loan) caused by the lack, or inadequacy, of insurance for Required Perils. Required Perils are the perils against which the mortgage agreement requires the borrower to insure the collateral property. These perils are fire, flood, and other similar direct physical damage perils. These Required Perils are typically covered by homeowner’s insurance, fire and extended coverage insurance, and flood insurance policies. Mortgagee’s Errors & Omissions provides liability insurance to a financial institution for negligent acts, errors, or omissions in procuring and/or failing to maintain insurance for Required Perils (as detailed above). What does this coverage do for me as a mortgage lender or mortgage servicer? Mortgage Impairment insurance covers loss Mortgagee’s Errors & Omissions insurance to the insured’s “mortgage interest” resulting covers the insured’s liability in: from physical damage to mortgaged property and: Failing to obtain or maintain required property insurance, Lack, or inadequacy, of insurance including flood insurance for Required Perils Flood zone determination Lack, or inadequacy, of insurance Failing to secure FHA/VA/PMI for Non-Required Perils (such as guarantees earthquake and flood insurance Failing to obtain or maintain life or Tax seizure disability insurance on the borrower Defective title (mortgagor) Failing to pay real estate taxes or special assessments What are some examples of claims that have been covered by this insurance? Mortgage Impairment A medium sized financial institution suffered a loss as a result of fire damage to a large residential property.
    [Show full text]
  • Property/Liability Insurance Risk Management and Securitization
    PROPERTY/LIABILITY INSURANCE RISK MANAGEMENT AND SECURITIZATION Biography Trent R. Vaughn, FCAS, MAAA, is Vice President of Actuarial/Pricing at GRE Insurance Group in Keene, NH. Mr. Vaughn is a 1990 graduate of Central College in Pella, Iowa. He is also the author of a recent Proceedings paper and has been a member of the CAS Examination Committee since 1996. Acknowledgments The author would like to thank an anonymous reviewer from the CAS Continuing Education Committee for his or her helpful comments. PROPERTY/LIABILITY INSURANCE RISK MANAGEMENT AND SECURITIZATION Abstract This paper presents a comprehensive framework for property/liability insurance risk management and securitization. Section 2 presents a rationale for P/L insurance risk management. Sections 3 through 6 describe and evaluate the four categories of P/L insurance risk management techniques: (1) maintaining internal capital within the organization, (2) managing asset risk, (3) managing underwriting risk, and (4) managing the covariance between asset and liability returns. Securitization is specifically discussed as a potential method of managing underwriting risk. Lastly, Section 7 outlines four key guidelines for cost- effective risk management. 1. INTRODUCTION In recent years, the property-liability insurance industry has witnessed intense competition from alternative risk management techniques, such as large deductibles and retentions, risk retention groups, and captive insurance companies. Moreover, the next decade promises to bring additional competition from new players in the P/L insurance industry, including commercial banks and securities firms. In order to survive in this competitive new landscape, P/L insurers must manage total risk in a cost-efficient manner. This paper provides a rationale for P/L insurance risk management, then describes four categories of risk management techniques utilized by insurers.
    [Show full text]
  • San Diego County Facts and Figures
    San Diego County Facts and Figures POPULATION1: EMPLOYMENT MIX: (Industry)1 Year: 2018 2019 2020 2019 2020 Employees Employees Total: 3,337,456 3,340,312 3,343,355 Government2 251,600 235,900 1San Diego County is the second most populous county in California and fifth most populous in the United States. Professional and Business Services 261,300 253,400 Source: California Department of Finance. Trade, Transportation and Utilities 232,900 220,500 Note: Population for 2019 was restated. Educational and Health Services 220,800 211,800 Leisure and Hospitality 200,600 130,400 INCORPORATED CITIES: 18 Manufacturing 117,300 112,900 Financial Activities 77,500 74,000 Construction 84,800 87,800 Other Services 54,500 40,600 CIVILIAN LABOR FORCE: Information Technology 23,500 21,900 Year: 2019 2020 Farming 9,000 8,400 Total: 1,590,600 1,538,400 Mining and Logging 400 300 Source: California Employment Development Department. Total 1,534,200 1,397,900 1Industry employment is by place of work; excludes self-employed individuals, unpaid family workers, and household domestic workers. 2Excludes the U.S. Department of Defense. Source: California Employment Development Department UNEMPLOYMENT RATE: Year: 2019 2020 TEN LARGEST EMPLOYERS: Percentage: 3.2% 9.2% 2019 2020 Source: California Employment Development Department. Employees Employees U.C. San Diego 35,847 35,802 Sharp Healthcare 18,700 19,468 County of San Diego 18,025 17,954 City of San Diego 11,545 11,820 San Diego Community College District 6,805 5,400 General Atomics (and affiliated companies) 6,777 6,745 San Diego State University 6,371 6,454 Rady Children’s Hospital-San Diego 5,541 5,711 YMCA of San Diego County 5,517 5,057 Sempra Energy 4,741 5,063 Sources: San Diego Business Journal Book of Lists (2020) & County of San Diego Fiscal Year 2019-20 Adopted Operational Plan.
    [Show full text]
  • Overview of Lender-Place Insurance Products, Markets and Issues Birny Birnbaum
    Overview of Lender-Place Insurance Products, Markets and Issues Birny Birnbaum Lender-Placed Insurance Regulatory Working Group Outreach Session, June 13, 2013 © Birny Birnbaum Consulting, Inc. Birnbaum LPI Overview Page 1 June 13, 2013 Overview of Lender-Placed Insurnce Topics Covered 1. Ensuring Continuous Insurance Coverage 2. The LPI Policy 3. LPI Underwriting of Loan Portfolio 4. Blanket LPI vs. “Regular” LPI 5. Insurance Tracking 6. Other Features of LPI 7. Market Participants 8. Operation of Insurance Tracking and LPI 9. LPI Pricing 10. LPI Premium Charges Relative to Voluntary Property Insurance 11. LPI Flood 12. LPI Insurers 13. LPI by State 14. LPI Loss Ratios 15. Reverse Competition 16. Recent Regulatory Activity Involving LPI 17. Issues of Concern Birnbaum LPI Overview Page 2 June 13, 2013 1. Ensuring Continuous Insurance Coverage Mortgage loan agreements include a requirement that the borrower maintain insurance to protect the property serving as collateral for the loan and, if the borrower fails to maintain the required insurance or fails to provide required evidence of insurance, the lender, through the servicer, may place insurance on the property serving as collateral for the loan and charge the borrower for this insurance. When the mortgage owner hires a mortgage servicer to service the loan on behalf of the mortgage owner, the mortgage servicing agreement requires the servicer to maintain continuous insurance coverage on the properties serving as collateral for the mortgage loans. Lender-Placed Insurance (LPI) is an important tool for mortgage servicers to meet this requirement and for mortgage markets to operate smoothly. LPI is a master insurance policy issued to the mortgage servicer as the policyholder and insured.
    [Show full text]