Dietrich Von Bern and “Historical” Narrative in the German Middle Ages

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Dietrich Von Bern and “Historical” Narrative in the German Middle Ages 1 Dietrich von Bern and “Historical” Narrative in the German Middle Ages: An Investigation of Strategies for Establishing Credibility in Four Poems of the Middle High German Dietrichepik by Jonathan Martin Senior Honors Thesis Submitted for German and MEMS, March 26th, 2010 Advised by Professor Helmut Puff © Jonathan Seelye Martin 2010 2 Acknowledgements My special thanks are owed to Dr. Helmut Puff, who has made his advice, time, and considerable knowledge available to me throughout the process of writing this thesis. He has steered me away from many misconceptions and improved my writing for clarity and style. It is very much thanks to him that this thesis appears in the form that it currently does. I also must thank him for repeatedly reminding me that one is never fully satisfied with an end product: there is always something left to improve or expand upon, and this is especially true of an overly ambitious project like mine. In a large part due to his wonderful help, I hope to continue working on and improving my knowledge of this topic, which at first I despised but have come to love, in the future. My thanks also go out to Drs. Peggy McCracken, Kerstin Barndt, George Hoffmann, and Patricia Simons, who have at various times read and commented on drafts of my work and helped guide me through the process of writing and researching this thesis. My other professors and instructors, both here and at Freiburg, have also been inspirations for me, and I must especially thank Maria “Frau” Caswell for teaching me German, Dr. Robert Kyes for teaching me Middle High German, Gina Soter for teaching me Latin, Björn-Michael Harms of Freiburg for introducing me to the Dietrichepik to begin with, and Dr. Lenka Jiroušková of Freiburg for guiding me into Medieval Latin. In addition, I must thank my friend Esei Murakishi who was kind enough to read through my whole draft from a modern English and Philosophy perspective. My mother, father, sister, and other friends, though they have little idea what I am writing about, have been a great source of support as well. Amicis meis Quinto et Scipioni et Telemacho et alteris amicis amicabusque dicendum est quod (si mihi structuram Latinæ mediævalis permittetis) auxilium vestrum adversis interdum in rebus valde mihi sustinuit per ultimi tempus anni mei apud Universitatem Michiganiensem. Vitam longam prosperitatemque ut professores aut profestrices aut professionales alii opto ut habeatis. Gratias vobis omnibus ago et semper agebo. 3 Table of Contents 1. Introduction: Saga, History, Aventiure, and Dietrich von Bern ................................................ 4 2. Historicity and Fictionality in the High and Late Middle Ages ............................................. 18 2.1. Defining Fabula, Argumentum, Historia and Veritas ...................................................... 19 2.2. The Debate in the Reception over Theoderic/Dietrich von Bern ...................................... 28 The Historiographically Accepted Life of Theoderic the Great .......................................... 30 Eleventh-Century Reception: The Quedlinburg Annals and Frutolf of Michelsberg ........... 32 Twelfth-Century Evidence: The Kaiserchronik ................................................................... 36 Thirteenth-Century Evidence ............................................................................................. 40 Fourteenth-Century Evidence: Heinrich of Munich, and Jakob Twinger ............................ 41 2.3. The Dietrich-saga‟s Disputed Historicity in Learned Reception ...................................... 46 3. Historical Dietrichepik: The Dialog between Learned Writing and Dietrichs Flucht .............. 47 3.1 Truth-Claims and Signs of Self-Reflexivity in Dietrichs Flucht ....................................... 50 2.2. Dialog between Dietrichs Flucht and the Learned Tradition: The Poem‟s Credibility ..... 59 3.3. The Lack of Fantastical Elements in Dietrichs Flucht ..................................................... 64 3.4. Defended Historicity in Dietrichs Flucht ........................................................................ 68 4. The Aventiure-Like Poems: the Eckenlied and the Virginal ................................................... 70 4.1. The Eckenlied and the Debate surrounding Dietrich von Bern ........................................ 73 Oral Hearsay: Praising nach wane .................................................................................... 76 Dietrich‟s Ride to Hell Mirrored in Eckenlied E7?............................................................. 83 Bringing Dietrich into Focus: Ecke‟s Search for Dietrich; Dietrich‟s Ride to Jochgrimm .. 87 Truth-Claim, Irony, and Further Signs of Self-Reflexivity in the Eckenlied ........................ 94 The Eckenlied as Self-Aware ........................................................................................... 102 4.2. The Virginal and the Flow of Information ..................................................................... 103 Finding and Defining aventiure ....................................................................................... 107 Messengers, Letters, and Summaries ............................................................................... 114 Truth-Claim, Politics, and märchenhafte Unbestimmtheit................................................ 120 The Virginal between the Saga and Literate Poetry ......................................................... 133 4.3. Apud Germanos perdurarunt gigantes – On the Vorzeit ................................................ 134 4.4. Historical aventiure ...................................................................................................... 140 5. The Dietrichepik as “Probable” History ............................................................................... 141 Abreviations............................................................................................................................ 147 Bibliography ........................................................................................................................... 148 Primary Literature .............................................................................................................. 148 Secondary Literature ........................................................................................................... 149 4 1. Introduction: Saga, History, Aventiure, and Dietrich von Bern Who was Dietrich von Bern? If one were to ask a German-speaker from the Middle Ages, one might receive two different answers. The majority of German-speakers would probably say that Dietrich von Bern was an exile from his kingdom of Verona (Bern). He had been driven away by his uncle Ermenrich and lived in exile at the court of Etzel (Attila), King of the Huns, for thirty years before eventually reconquering his country. In addition to this story, which I will refer to as the exile-saga (in German, Fluchtsage), they would have said things about Dietrich which seem to us today to belong to a world of fantasy, namely that Dietrich went on numerous adventures wherein he fought dwarves, giants, and dragons. A few, especially clerics, might have then supplied a different picture, saying that Dietrich von Bern was an Ostrogothic king and Arian heretic who was born after Attila‟s and Ermenrich‟s (Ermanaric) deaths and who invaded Italy at the behest of the Byzantine emperor Zenon in order to drive the usurping barbarian Odoacer from Rome. There he ruled for thirty years before engaging in a persecution of Catholics and dying a sudden death at the hands of a vengeful God. One would receive, in short, two images of Dietrich, images which are not compatible. How is one to reconcile them? It is important to recognize that these two ideas of Dietrich von Bern derive from different sources of transmission. The story which clerics might tell is based on Latin chronicles about the Ostrogothic king Theoderic the Great, who ruled in Italy from 493 until his death in 526, and was indeed born around the time of Attila‟s death and long after the fourth century Gothic King Ermanaric.1 The majority response derives from a series of popular narratives 1 For a summary of the lives of these three major characters and a summary of theories for their changed roles in the exile-saga, see Joachim Heinzle (1999). Einführung in die mittelhochdeutsche Dietrichepik. Berlin/New York: Walter de Gruyter, 2-7. 5 transmitted to us today in a group of epic poems collectively known as the Dietrichepik.2 All in all, eleven extant poems are devoted to Dietrich‟s exploits, making him the most popular hero of the German Middle Ages.3 Those that deal with the exile-saga are called the historical Dietrichepik (historische Dietrichepik), referring to their more obviously historical nature from a contemporary standpoint: they emphasize battles, armies, kingship, and campaigns. The second group of Dietrich-narratives, those which contain such things as his exploits fighting dragons, giants, dwarves, and other heroes, are referred to as the aventiure-like Dietrichepik (aventiurehafte Dietrichepik). This label derives from the Middle High German word aventiure, meaning both a strange or wondrous event or series of events and the narration or reporting of that event or series of events. It emphasizes the supposed similarity of these poems to Arthurian romance.4 How could the differences between these two traditions, one popular and one clerical, have arisen? One could assume, as some scholars
Recommended publications
  • Inhalt. Erste Abteilung. Die Ermunarichstige. Suite Erstes Kapitel
    Inhalt. Erste Abteilung. Die Ermunarichstige. Suite Erstes Kapitel. Die gotische Überlieferung ;•{ § i .X -i Zweites Kapitel. Die Entwicklung der Überlieferung in Nordeuropa .... 15 § 2. Svanhild und der Ehebruch ]g § 3. Erpr. GuBnin. Jönakr. Spätere Reminiscenzen an alte Züge. Gruppierung der Quellen 19 § 4. HamBismâl str. 24 — 30 und damit correspondierende Stellen ... 20 § 5. Die Aufstachelung der Brüder in HamBismâl und GuBrûnarhvçt . 35 § 6. Die Fortsetzung von GuBrûnarhvçt 43 § 7. HamBismâl 2. 3. Ragnarsdrâpa 3. 4. Saxo. Nähere Gruppierung der Quellen 47 § 8. Die Berichte der Prosaquellen 48 Drittes Kapitel. Der böse Ratgeber 53 § 9 53 Viertes Kapitel. Die Harlunge 65 § 10. Die Brüder und ihr Beschützer 65 § 11. Die Verwandtschaft mit Ermanarich. Die Anklage wider die Har­ lunge und ihre Bestrafung. Das Grundmotiv der Erzählung . 77 Zweite Abteilung. Die Sage von Dietrich von Bern. Fünftes Kapitel. Flucht. Aufenthalt bei Attila. Rückkehr 83 § 12. Einleitende Bemerkungen über das gegenseitige Verhältnis der Hauptabteilungen der Erzählung 83 § 13. Die Quellen von c. 276 — 290 der ÜiBrekssaga (Erminreks Feind­ schaft wider seine Söhne, seine Neffen und Dietrich. Die Flucht) 90 § 14. Die Quellen von c. 316—339 der ÜiSrekssaga (Schlacht bei Gronsport) 98 § 15. Die Quellen von c. 395 — 414, 9 der ÜiBrekssaga (Dietrichs Heimkehr) 108 § 16 Die Quellen von c. 340. 341 der ÜiSrekssaga (Erkas Tod) . 118 § 17. Der Zusammenhang der zu I resp. H gehörenden Teile der Erzählung 118 § 18. Die Quellen von c. 429—437 der ÜiBrekssaga (Helmis Heldentaten) 124 § 19. Historische Übersicht der Überlieferung von ÜE. Gr. R. H . 128 § 20. Die Anfänge der Exildichtung 133 § 21. Die junge Tradition 137 1.
    [Show full text]
  • The Germanic Heldenlied and the Poetic Edda: Speculations on Preliterary History
    Oral Tradition, 19/1 (2004): 43-62 The Germanic Heldenlied and the Poetic Edda: Speculations on Preliterary History Edward R. Haymes One of the proudest inventions of German scholarship in the nineteenth century was the Heldenlied, the heroic song, which was seen by scholars as the main conduit of Germanic heroic legend from the Period of Migrations to the time of their being written down in the Middle Ages. The concept stems indirectly from the suggestions of several eighteenth-century Homeric scholars that since the Homeric poems were much too long to have been memorized and performed in oral tradition, they must have existed as shorter, episodic songs. Friedrich August Wolf’s well-known Prolegomena ad Homerum (1795) collected evidence for the idea that writing was not used for poetry until long after Homer’s time. He argued for a thorough recension of the poem under (or perhaps by) Pisistratus in the sixth century BCE as the first comprehensive written Homer. These ideas were almost immediately applied to the Middle High German Nibelungenlied by Karl Lachmann (1816), who was trained as a classical philologist and indeed continued to contribute in that area at the same time that he was one of the most influential members of the generation that founded the new discipline of Germanistik. On the basis of rough spots and contradictions (not only Homer nods!) Lachmann thought he could recognize twenty separate Lieder in the Middle High German epic. At the same time that Lachmann was deconstructing the German medieval epic, Elias Lönnrot was assembling the Finnish epic he called Kalevala from shorter songs in conscious imitation of the Homer (or Pisistratus) described by Wolf.
    [Show full text]
  • Die Glorie Der Mittelalterlichen Buchproduktion: Vom Manuskript
    applyparastyle “fig//caption/p[1]” parastyle “FigCapt” Mediaevistik 33 . 2020 71 2020 Albrecht Classen University of Arizona 1 Die Glorie der mittelalterlichen Buchproduktion: 1 Vom Manuskript zur Inkunabel, aus literatur- und 71 kulturhistorischer Sicht. Wie dunkel war also das Mittelalter? 88 2020 Abstract: Wenngleich die Geschichte der mittelalterlichen Handschrift bereits vielfach un- tersucht worden ist, lohnt es sich immer wieder, die zentrale Rolle der Handschriften für die moderne Bewertung jener mittelalterlichen Gesellschaft in Betracht zu ziehen. Immer noch hören wir viel zu schnell vom sogenannten ‘dunklen Mittelalter’, so als ob jeder Aspekt der damaligen Zeit negativ oder primitiv, ja barbarisch gewesen wäre. Kulturhistorisch erweist sich solch ein Pauschalurteil sowieso immer als höchst problematisch. Indem hier erneut die Entste- hung und das Wesen mittelalterlicher Handschriften vor allem im literarhistorischen Kontext betrachtet wird, ergibt sich die ungemein wichtige Möglichkeit, innovative epistemologische Kategorien zu entwickeln, um unser Wahrnehmungsvermögen vergangener Kulturen wie der des europäischen Mittelalters kritisch zu schärfen und zu erkennen, dass unsere Urteile über die Vergangenheit meist doch durch konkrete subjektive Filter bestimmt sind, die kaum der kritischen Überprüfung standzuhalten vermögen. Mittelalterliche Handschriften repräsentie- ren bestimmt nicht die gesamte Gesellschaft der damaligen Zeit, vielmehr nur die intellektuelle und soziale Elite, aber sie bestätigen auf ihre Weise, dass auch in der Vormoderne ungemein hochentwickelte und ästhetisch und philosophisch bedeutsamste Kunst- und Schriftwerke ent- stehen konnten. Keywords: Handschriften, Illuminationen, mittelalterlicher Literaturbetrieb, Überlieferung mittelalterlicher Texte, Autorporträts, Sammelcodices, Glorie des Mittelalters Einleitung Zwischen 1504 und 15016 bemühte sich der Bozener Zöllner Hans Ried darum, im Auftrag von Kaiser Maximilian I. das später so benannte Ambraser Heldenbuch per Hand zu schreiben.
    [Show full text]
  • Gegend Von Den Leuten Der "Hapschlüssel" (Hauptschlüssel) Genannt Wurde, Weil Er Die Versperrten Türen Zu Öffnen V
    King Laurin and His Rose Garden bove the forested knolls between Tiers and Eggental as a queen. At that point, Dietrich offered Laurin peace. Every- one was in agreement—except Wittege. Valley, near Bolzano, there towers a rocky mountain that bears the name Rosengarten (Rose Garden). This A Laurin showed his newly acquired friends his treasures, and is the story of its genesis. entertained them. They ate and drank together; when evening fell, they all retired. A squire awakened Laurin, though, and re- Long ago, the rocks were less steep and completely cov- ported that Wittege was trying to enter the mountain with a ered with red roses. A dwarf people and their king, named group of armed men. Laurin and his men marched out and drove Laurin, lived on these rose-blanketed slopes. The mountain it- Wittege and his down the mountain. Hildebrand heard the noise self was hollow, and contained numerous passages and halls. of battle, and immediately suspected a betrayal. He awoke his The borders of this mysterious realm were drawn only by thin comrades, and sent them to hold the gates. Laurin saw that he silk thread, which demarcated the roses. Peace reigned in King had done this, and thought that Wittege and Hildebrand had ar- Laurin's realm, and there was no violence at all. ranged to attack the dwarves during the night. The dwarfs donned magic hats upon Laurin’s order. This enabled them to de- One day, King Laurin learned that a neighbouring king had feat the enemy, whom they cast into the dungeons.
    [Show full text]
  • The Karlamagnús Compendium
    Háskóli Íslands Hugvísindasvið Medieval Icelandic Studies The Karlamagnús Compendium Genre and Meaning in AM 180a-b fol. Ritgerð til M.A.-prófs Harry Williams Kt.: 151183-4419 Leiðbeinandi: Svanhildur Óskarsdóttir September 2017 Abstract This thesis is an examination of the fifteenth century manuscript AM 180a-b fol.; made up of a copy of the A version of Karlamagnús saga (180a) and seven further sagas - Konráðs saga keisarasonar, Dunstanus saga, Katrínar saga, Bærings saga, Knýtlinga saga, Vitus saga and Laurentius saga (180b), it originally formed one codex. The thesis has two main aims: to consider the generic position of Karlamagnús saga as it existed for the compilers of the manuscript and to speculate on the producers, purpose and use of the manuscript by means of a holistic consideration of its parts. The first aim is prompted by viewing the sagas of 180b as a reflection of the generic ambiguity of Karlamagnús saga. While patently belonging to the riddarasögur, Karlamagnús saga has affinities with hagiography and the konungasögur; representatives of these three generic classes are to be found in 180b. Structured by the theme of saintliness, in which a chronological line of saintly figures is presented, as well as shared geographical referents, the codex is marked by a wide-ranging intellectual curiosity. This is attributed to the concerns of the North Icelandic Benedictine School, the presence of which is marked in the manuscript, and to the wider intellectual atmosphere of fourteenth century Iceland in which saints' lives and romances were possibly written by the same people. 2 Ágrip Þessi ritgerð skoðar fimmtándu aldar handritið AM 180a-b fol.; sem samanstendur af A gerð Karlamagnúsar sögu (180a) ásamt sjö öðrum sögum- Konráðs sögu keisarasonar, Dunstanusar sögu, Katrínar sögu, Bærings sögu, Knýtlinga sögu, Vitus sögu og Laurentiusar sögu (180b), sem upphaflega mynduðu saman eitt handrit.
    [Show full text]
  • Der Herr Der Bilder. Vorstellungslenkung Und Perspektivierung Im „Laurin“*
    4 10.3726/92140_487 487 BJÖRN REICH Der Herr der Bilder. Vorstellungslenkung und Perspektivierung im „Laurin“* „Czu Berne waz geseßen / eyn degen so vormeßen /der waz geheysen Dytherich“ 1 (VV. 1 ff.) – so lauten die ersten Verse des Laurin. Dieser Prolog mit der waz gesezzen- Formel und dem anschließenden ‚Heldenvergleich‘, wie er sich ähnlich im Sigenot oder 2 Eckenlied findet, bildet den typischen Textbeginn für die aventiurehafte Dietrichepik. Wie so oft geht es um die Frage nach der Exzellenz Dietrichs von Bern. Diese Exzellenz – wiewohl zunächst im Herrscherlob bestätigt („sie pristen en vor alle man“, V. 19) – wird (ähnlich wie im Eckenlied) sogleich durch Hildebrand in Frage gestellt, der darauf hinweist, dass Dietrich die Aventiure der Zwerge unbekannt sei. Es geht wieder einmal 3 darum, das Heldentum Dietrichs auszuloten oder besser, das ‚Bild‘/die imago, die Vorstel- lung von dem, was bzw. wer ‚Dietrich‘ sei, zu umkreisen, denn die fama Dietrichs sichert ihm nie einen festen Status, immer wieder keimen Zweifel an seinem Heldentum auf.4 Bei der Frage nach dem ‚Bild‘ Dietrichs von Bern, also der Frage danach, ob die positiven Vorstellungen, die man sich von Dietrich macht, gerechtfertigt sind oder nicht, ist der Laurin ein besonders interessanter Text: Dietrich bekommt es hier mit einem Gegner zu tun, der sich als ein wahrer Meister der ‚Bilder‘ und grandioser Manipula- tor von Vorstellungen entpuppt. Im Folgenden soll gezeigt werden, welche bildsteuernde, imaginationsbeeinflussende Kraft der Zwerg Laurin besitzt und wie sie zur Gefahr für Dietrich und seine Gesellen wird (I.). An das Thema der imaginativen Manipulation anschließend, wird die Handlung des Textes einem ständigen Wechsel von Perspek- tivierungen unterworfen (II.).
    [Show full text]
  • The Heuristic Value of German Literature: the Eternal Plea for the Relevance of Medieval and Early Modern Literature from a Practical/Pedagogical Perspective
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by The University of Sydney: Sydney eScholarship Journals... The Heuristic Value of German Literature: The Eternal Plea for the Relevance of Medieval and Early Modern Literature from a Practical/Pedagogical Perspective Albrecht Classen Introduction1 The question of what the meaning of the Humanities might be for the current student generation continues to vex us all. We can all try to look backwards and explain the significance of past literary documents as being contributions to the canon of all literary studies. That would be the answer of an archivist. We can also try to understand literary texts from the pre- modern period as expressions of the overarching endeavor to make sense of human life, to figure out the meaning of human life, and to explain the purpose of our existence. At first look, this seems to be quite self-evident, but at a closer analysis we can realize how much both medieval and modern literary manifestations are simply waiting for us to gain deeper understanding of human interactions, conflicts, and cooperation. This article continues with previous efforts to make sense of medieval narratives and to demonstrate how much they can serve as literary expressions for the further explorations of human identity, ethics, morality, and religion. The central argument for the humanistic value of literature, as developed here, is predicated on practical experiences in teaching the history of German literature and has profited from numerous critical reflections on modern challenges to our discipline. The Relevance of the Humanities For a long time the very same question has occupied the Humanities most profoundly, and it is a question which will be raised over and over again in the future, irrespective of current answers and responses to the issue at 1 Albrecht Classen is Distinguished Professor of German Studies at the University of Arizona.
    [Show full text]
  • The Art of War in the Middle Ages, A.D. 378-1515
    Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2007 with funding from IVIicrosoft Corporation http://www.archive.org/details/artofwarinmiddleOOomanuoft otl^xan: ^rt§e ^ssag 1884 THE ART OF WAR IN THE MIDDLE AGES PRINTED BY HORACE HART, PRINTER TO THE UNIVERSITY THE ART OF WAR [N THE MIDDLE AGES A.D. 37^—15^5 BY C. W. C. OMAN, B.A. FELLOW OF ALL SOULS COLLEGE WITH MAPS AND PLANS OXFORD B. H. BLACKWELL, 50 BROAD STREET LONDON T. FISHER UNWIN, 26 PATERNOSTER SQUARE 1885 [^// rights reserved '\ O/M The Author desires to acknowledge much kind help received in the revision and correction of this Essay from the Rev. H. B. George, of New College, and Mr. F. York Powell, of Christ Church. 6/ 37 05 , — — CONTENTS. PAGE ' Introduction . i CHAPTER 1. The Transition from Roman to Medieval forms in War (a.d. 378-582). Disappearance of the Legion.—Constantine's reorgajiization. The German tribes . — Battle of Adrianople.—Theodosius accepts its teaching.—Vegetius and the army at the end of the fourth century. —The Goths and the Huns. Army of the Eastern Empire.— Cavalry all-important . 3— 14 CHAPTER n. The Early Middle Ages (a.d. 476-1066). Paucity of Data for the period.—The Franks in the sixth cen- tury.—Battle of Tours.—^Armies of Charles the Great. The Franks become horsemen.—The Northman and the Magyar.—Rise of Feudalism.—The Anglo-Saxons and their wars.—The Danes and the Fyrd.—Military importance of the Thegnhood.—The House-Carles.—Battle of Hastings . Battle of Durazzo 15 — 27 W — VI CONTENTS.
    [Show full text]
  • Gothic Introduction – Part 1: Linguistic Affiliations and External History Roadmap
    RYAN P. SANDELL Gothic Introduction – Part 1: Linguistic Affiliations and External History Roadmap . What is Gothic? . Linguistic History of Gothic . Linguistic Relationships: Genetic and External . External History of the Goths Gothic – Introduction, Part 1 2 What is Gothic? . Gothic is the oldest attested language (mostly 4th c. CE) of the Germanic branch of the Indo-European family. It is the only substantially attested East Germanic language. Corpus consists largely of a translation (Greek-to-Gothic) of the biblical New Testament, attributed to the bishop Wulfila. Primary manuscript, the Codex Argenteus, accessible in published form since 1655. Grammatical Typology: broadly similar to other old Germanic languages (Old High German, Old English, Old Norse). External History: extensive contact with the Roman Empire from the 3rd c. CE (Romania, Ukraine); leading role in 4th / 5th c. wars; Gothic kingdoms in Italy, Iberia in 6th-8th c. Gothic – Introduction, Part 1 3 What Gothic is not... Gothic – Introduction, Part 1 4 Linguistic History of Gothic . Earliest substantively attested Germanic language. • Only well-attested East Germanic language. The language is a “snapshot” from the middle of the 4th c. CE. • Biblical translation was produced in the 4th c. CE. • Some shorter and fragmentary texts date to the 5th and 6th c. CE. Gothic was extinct in Western and Central Europe by the 8th c. CE, at latest. In the Ukraine, communities of Gothic speakers may have existed into the 17th or 18th century. • Vita of St. Cyril (9th c.) mentions Gothic as a liturgical language in the Crimea. • Wordlist of “Crimean Gothic” collected in the 16th c.
    [Show full text]
  • Jordanes and the Invention of Roman-Gothic History Dissertation
    Empire of Hope and Tragedy: Jordanes and the Invention of Roman-Gothic History Dissertation Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy in the Graduate School of The Ohio State University By Brian Swain Graduate Program in History The Ohio State University 2014 Dissertation Committee: Timothy Gregory, Co-advisor Anthony Kaldellis Kristina Sessa, Co-advisor Copyright by Brian Swain 2014 Abstract This dissertation explores the intersection of political and ethnic conflict during the emperor Justinian’s wars of reconquest through the figure and texts of Jordanes, the earliest barbarian voice to survive antiquity. Jordanes was ethnically Gothic - and yet he also claimed a Roman identity. Writing from Constantinople in 551, he penned two Latin histories on the Gothic and Roman pasts respectively. Crucially, Jordanes wrote while Goths and Romans clashed in the imperial war to reclaim the Italian homeland that had been under Gothic rule since 493. That a Roman Goth wrote about Goths while Rome was at war with Goths is significant and has no analogue in the ancient record. I argue that it was precisely this conflict which prompted Jordanes’ historical inquiry. Jordanes, though, has long been considered a mere copyist, and seldom treated as an historian with ideas of his own. And the few scholars who have treated Jordanes as an original author have dampened the significance of his Gothicness by arguing that barbarian ethnicities were evanescent and subsumed by the gravity of a Roman political identity. They hold that Jordanes was simply a Roman who can tell us only about Roman things, and supported the Roman emperor in his war against the Goths.
    [Show full text]
  • Handschrift B
    WW 1/2004 Gerhardt, Kriemhilds Ende 7 Kriemhilds Ende in der ,NibeIungenlied'-Handschrift b Von Christoph Gerhardt I. In der ehemaligen Hundeshagenschen Berliner ,Nibelungenlied'-Handschrift (b) aus Ostschwaben (Augsburg), um 1436 bis 1442,' finden sich zwei Interpolationen. Die eine von ihnen hat in jüngster Zeit einige Aufmerksamkeit auf sich gezogen im Zusam­ menhang mit der vor kurzem erstmals vollständig veröffentlichten Darmstädter ,Nibe- lungenlied'-Handschrift (n).2 Den Inhalt der 23 Strophen analysiert Göhler ausführlich und zeigt, dass die kurz vor dem endgültigen Burgundenuntergang spielende Szene z.T. bereits Gesagtes variiert, neue Akzente setzt, aber auch ganz neue erzählerische Ele­ mente bringt, also eine eigenständige Erzählsequenz darstellt. Um die andere Erweite­ rung ist es vergleichsweise in letzter Zeit ziemlich still geblieben; sie betrifft Kriemhilds Ende.3 Zunächst sei diese ,Nibelungenlied'-Interpolation besprochen, danach soll sie neben weitere vergleichbare Episoden gestellt werden; abschließend will ich eine These über die Herkunft des Zusatzes aufstellen und aus ihr einige allgemeine Bemerkungen ablei­ ten. 1 S. Bibliographie zum Nibelungenlied und zur Klage v. Willy Krogmann/Ulrich Pretzel, 4. stark erweiterte Aufl. unter redaktioneller Mitarbeit v. Herta Haas/Wolfgang Bachofer (Bibliographien z. dt. Lit. d. Mittelalters 1), Berlin 1966, S. 18f. Zur Problematik der Datierung s. Theodor Abeling, Das Nibelungenlied und seine Literatur. Eine Bibliographie und vier Abhandlungen (Teutonia 7), Leipzig 1907, S. 182. 2 S. Eine spätmittelalterliche Fassung des Nibelungenliedes. Die Handschrift 4257 der Hessischen Landes- und Hochschulbibliothek Darmstadt, hrsg. und eingeleitet von Peter Göhler (Philologica Germanica 21), Wien 1999, bes. S. 18Ff., 160-163; Das Nibelungenlied nach der Handschrift n. Hs. 4257 der Hessischen Landes- und Hochschulbibliothek, hrsg.
    [Show full text]
  • The Editing of Eddic Poetry Judy Quinn
    A HANDBOOK TO EDDIC POETRY This is the first comprehensive and accessible survey in English of Old Norse eddic poetry: a remarkable body of literature rooted in the Viking Age, which is a critical source for the study of early Scandinavian myths, poetics, culture, and society. Dramatically recreating the voices of the legendary past, eddic poems distil moments of high emotion as human heroes and supernatural beings alike grapple with betrayal, loyalty, mortality, and love. These poems relate the most famous deeds of gods such as Óðinn and Þórr with their adversaries the giants; they bring to life the often fraught interactions between kings, queens, and heroes as well as their encounters with valkyries, elves, dragons, and dwarfs. Written by leading international scholars, the chapters in this volume showcase the poetic riches of the eddic corpus and reveal its relevance to the history of poetics, gender studies, pre-Christian religions, art history, and archaeology. carolyne larrington is Official Fellow and Tutor at St John’s College, University of Oxford. judy quinn is Reader in Old Norse Literature in the Department of Anglo-Saxon, Norse and Celtic at the University of Cambridge. brittany schorn is a Research Associate in the Department of Anglo-Saxon, Norse and Celtic at the University of Cambridge. A HANDBOOK TO EDDIC POETRY Myths and Legends of Early Scandinavia CAROLYNE LARRINGTON University of Oxford JUDY QUINN University of Cambridge BRITTANY SCHORN University of Cambridge University Printing House, Cambridge cb2 8bs, United Kingdom Cambridge University Press is part of the University of Cambridge. It furthers the University’s mission by disseminating knowledge in the pursuit of education, learning, and research at the highest international levels of excellence.
    [Show full text]