Riverside State Papers Foreign, 1603-1640
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Gale Primary Sources Start at the source. Riverside State Papers Foreign, 1603-1640 Professor Thomas Cogswell University of California Various source media, State Papers Online EMPOWER™ RESEARCH On first opening volumes of the early seventeenth- these documents, and this happy development in turn century State Papers Foreign, readers are dazzled by the reveals that these documents, long dismissed as collection's contents and its comprehensiveness. In bureaucratic minutiae, can tell us much about almost all other areas of early modern history, questions as varied as court patronage, contemporary researchers have to become accustomed to working religious issues, parliamentary affairs, consumption with stray surviving documents from a much larger patterns of luxury goods as well as dynastic and correspondence, much of which has subsequently strategic politics. disappeared. Yet SP Foreign contains practically the While it is now infinitely easier to access State Papers complete early Stuart diplomatic archive with precious Foreign, its bulk remains daunting. It becomes less few exceptions. So vast is the collection that we can not forbidding once researchers appreciate that these only follow in abundant detail as monarchs and volumes are the products of a handful of state actors ministers, ambassadors and agents discussed the operating in predictable genres of reportage. major and minor events of the period, but we can often reconstruct the evolution of a particularly important I. Dramatis Personae treaty through various drafts. Given the importance of these documents, to which subsequent statesmen and To open a volume of SP Foreign is to step into the inner diplomats regularly referred, it is scarcely surprising sanctum of the arcana imperii, the secrets of state that Whitehall bureaucrats kept a very careful record of which contemporaries were so eager to glimpse and them. monarchs to conceal. Here the king looms so large as to obscure even the Privy Council, save for occasional The importance of these materials makes it all the ceremonial roles when its members were trooped out more remarkable that aside from a few honorable to ratify a decision that the king had already made. Not exceptions, so little has been made of them.[1] The surprisingly, this collection is periodically studded with scholarly indifference is the more baffling since the personal letters between the English monarchs and handwriting by and large is particularly clear. To be their fellow rulers – Philip III and IV, Louis XIII, Marie de sure, traditional diplomatic history has rarely, if ever, Medicis, Christian IV, Gustavus Adolphus, Ferdinand II been among the trendier historiographical fields. But and III, Maurice and Frederick Henry – and leading much of the neglect can be ascribed to comparative ministers – Lerma, Olivares, Luynes and Richelieu. inaccessibility; after all, these records have been only While the initial delight of reading their letters fades available at The National Archives, and their sheer after appreciating their formality, they can signal mass required months, if not years, of research at Kew important diplomatic shifts among "cousins"; English in order to understand even a few years of the goals in the French match, for example, are clearly seventeenth century. Mercifully this lamentable state of evident in James's short note to Louis applauding the affairs has ended with the introduction of Part Four of forthcoming wedding between Charles and Henrietta the State Papers Online, which at last allows scholars Maria, which would ensure "la paix bien et prosperité and their students from around the globe full access to des pais voisins et principalement du Palatinat."[2] Such high-level personal correspondence, however, industrious minister and lead to awkward delays. represents only a small fraction of SP Foreign. Nevertheless rare indeed is a dispatch in SP Foreign from London not signed by the monarch or a Secretary For obvious reasons James I and Charles I and their of State. secretaries carried the diplomatic details close to their administrative chests. A royal kinsman like the Marquis Their letters generally went to an "ordinary" resident of Hamilton was reduced to offering to help James I ambassador. The early Stuarts maintained permanent with "any hard words" in a sensitive dispatch from posts in Madrid, Paris, The Hague and Copenhagen with Madrid, a gambit that earned a grin from the king but a northern Italian envoy shuttling between Venice and nary a glimpse of the letter.[3] Even a favorite like the Turin and a permanent agent in Brussels.With financial Duke of Buckingham, while obviously strongly assistance from the Levant Company, they also had an influential, rarely intruded directly in diplomacy; ambassador at the Sublime Porte in Istanbul. They instead he generally acted through the monarch and maintained more intermittent representation with the the secretaries of state. James I and Charles I spent a German Empire, Sweden, Poland, Muscovy and considerable portion of their time carefully attending to Switzerland. Learned gentlemen who devoted decades the latest reports abroad, and when some envoys' of their lives to diplomacy, these men numbered agents proved unbearably prolix – a celebrated polymaths like Sir Henry Wotton and Sir Edward offender in this regard, for example, was William Herbert, dutiful office-wallahs like Sir Walter Aston and Trumbull – the secretaries prepared summaries for the Sir Robert Anstruther, and policy wonks like Sir monarch. After reflecting on the news and discussing it Thomas Edmondes, Sir Isaac Wake, Sir Thomas Roe, with his intimates, the king then issued carefully Sir John Digby, later the Earl of Bristol, and Sir Dudley prepared instructions to individual ministers Carleton, later Viscount Carleton. All were abroad.While the monarch could convey subsequent sophisticated observers both of the peculiarities of the alterations in a personal letter to the ambassador, he state where they resided and of the slightest political more often did so through a letter from one of his two shifts back in Whitehall. While the rate of reply from secretaries of state. London could sometimes be maddening slow, these ambassadors generally wrote a dispatch back to The diplomatic responsibilities of the two Secretaries of Whitehall at least once a week, and more frequently State varied in the early Stuart regime. Sometimes the when a crisis developed. When these ambassadors two ministers divided responsibilities, one handling occasionally returned to England on leave, their Protestant states and the other Catholic ones. More secretaries would then assume the duty of drafting commonly, one Secretary would take care of all foreign regular reports to Whitehall, and their reports affairs, relying on his colleague only in emergencies. introduce us to rising men like Thomas Rowlandson, This arrangement allowed one man a full Henry de Vic, Thomas Lorkin and John Woodford. understanding of sometimes intricate negotiations across the continent. But it also meant that in crises, While these envoys would have happily handled all the workload could overwhelm even the most business, James and Charles also sent abroad "extraordinary" ambassadors to conduct specific high for example, received occasional letters from his level negotiations often regarding a marriage alliance, brother, Bishop George Carleton, and his brother-in- a military league or a peace treaty. In these situations, law, Sir Richard Harrison, and more frequent ones from the ordinary ambassador was generally relegated to John Chamberlain. Equally fascinating is the chatter the sidelines. The extraordinary ambassadors were from second tier diplomatic personnel like Dudley either veteran diplomats with the steadiest of hands Carleton writing to his uncle, the famous ambassador, (Digby, Carleton and Wake) or prominent courtiers like or Sir Francis Nethersole's private letters commenting the Earl of Carlisle, the Earl of Holland, the Earl of on English affairs to Carlisle and Elizabeth of Bohemia. Arundel and the Duke of Buckingham himself. Such SP Foreign also contains sets of private letters like "extraordinary" ambassadors generally measured their those from Woodford in Paris to friends in London as foreign stays in months, if not weeks, and on their well as Carleton's letters back to Chamberlain.[4] departure, the diplomatic business reverted to the Finally the other correspondents in the series are the "ordinary" envoy. These extraordinary missions often various foreign envoys in London. For a host of obvious included an attached special agent, part courier and reasons – to protest a new policy or a legal judgment, part confidant; men like Tobie Mathew, Kenelm Digby, to negotiate details of a commercial arrangement, to William Becher and Edward Clerke. congratulate on a monarch's recovered health, While the bulk of SP Foreign is filled with formal marriage, new wife and/or child, or simply to nag about diplomatic business, it also contains less official a sore diplomatic point – these ambassadors made correspondence. To see the full range of a their presence felt in Whitehall and in SP Foreign. Thus contemporary diplomat's correspondence, we have only readers will become acquainted with major figures like to go to the British Library and inspect the extensive the Conde de Gondomar, the Marquis d'Effiat and Abbé Trumbull Manuscripts, only a small percentage of Scaglia and minor ones like Tillières, Van Male and which can be described as official.