High-end EUV Photomask Repairs for advanced nodes
Dr. Michael Waldow
Product Manager
vZTech - Virtual SMS Tech Conference, 18.05.2021
Agenda
1 Introduction
2 High-end EUV photomask repairs
3 Summary
- Carl ZEISS SMT GmbH, Dr. Michael Waldow, Semiconductor Mask Solutions
- 18.05.2021
- 2
Agenda
1 Introduction
2 High-end EUV photomask repairs
3 Summary
- Carl ZEISS SMT GmbH, Dr. Michael Waldow, Semiconductor Mask Solutions
- 18.05.2021
- 3
Introduction
EUV High-Volume manufacturing ramping up
SAMSUNG newsroom MAY 21, 2021
“…new production line in Pyeongtaek, Korea…will produce 14-
nanometer DRAM and 5-nanometer logic, …based on EUV...”
Anandtech.com - APRIL 02, 2021
C. C. Wei – TSMC - CEO & Vice Chairman* JULY 16, 2020
‚Next, let me talk about our N5 ramp up and N4 introduction. N5 is the foundry industry's most advanced solution with best PPA. N5 is already in volume
production with good yield, while we continue to improve the productivity and performance of the EUV tools. We are seeing robust
demand for N5 and expect a strong ramp of N5 in the second half of this year, driven by both 5G smartphones and HPC applications.‘
“… South Korea authorities this week gave SK Hynix a green light to build a new, 120 trillion won ($106.35 billion) fab complex….
using process technologies that rely on extreme ultraviolet lithography (EUV)…’
▪ EUV is becoming more and more important and
Intel: The Empire Strikes Back**
MAY 21, 2021
amount of EUV lithographic layers is rising
‚while the outlook on EUV was still quite uncertain. Hence, Intel's initial 7nm
seems to have used EUV quite conservatively, in relatively few layers. Intel said the new 7nm process flow (as it has been developed since mid-2020) uses over
100% more EUV. We have now fully embraced EUV", Pat Gelsinger
said…’
▪ First consumer products based on EUV technology are already on the market
▪ On the other hand EUV photomasks possess the highest numbers of defects
Sources
Efficient and reliable way to repair high- end photomasks is essential
**Q2 2020 Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co Ltd Earnings Call,
**https://seekingalpha.com/article/4427816-intel-the-empire-strikes-back
- Carl ZEISS SMT GmbH, Dr. Michael Waldow, Semiconductor Mask Solutions
- 18.05.2021
- 4
Introduction – Photomask repair
MeRiT® Mask repair technology
Photomask repair tool MeRiT® at a glance
▪ MeRiT® neXT system is the industry-standard
for high-end photomask repair systems
▪ Enables the repair of smallest defects on todays’ photomasks
Principle of operation
▪ Exposure with focused electron beam
▪ Adsorption of precursor molecules
- Repair of clear defects - deposition
- Repair of opaque defects - etching
- Carl ZEISS SMT GmbH, Dr. Michael Waldow, Semiconductor Mask Solutions
- 18.05.2021
- 5
What is contributing to resolution of MeRiT® Tools
Analogy: What contributes to draw with high accuracy?
Analogy: Contributions to draw with high accuracy
Ink Spilling
Drawing
Small
Shiver/
Tremor
Sharpness
- Carl ZEISS SMT GmbH, Dr. Michael Waldow, Semiconductor Mask Solutions
- 18.05.2021
- 6
What is contributing to resolution of MeRiT® Tools
Transfer to MeRiT® technology - Electron beam as a pen and precursor molecules as ink
Contributions to MeRiT® repair resolution
Secondary Electrons
Repair
Resolution
System
Jitter
E- Beam Spot Size
- Carl ZEISS SMT GmbH, Dr. Michael Waldow, Semiconductor Mask Solutions
- 18.05.2021
- 7
Contributing to resolution of MeRiT® Tools
Main factor I to Repair Resolution – Secondary Electrons
Secondary electrons as function of electron voltage
140% 120% 100%
80%
60%
Secondary Electrons
40% 20%
0%
Repair
Resolution
- 200
- 400
- 600
- 800
- 1000
- 1500
- 2000
Electron beam voltage [V]
▪ Scattered secondary electrons increase significantly with increasing voltages
E- Beam Spot
Size
System Jitter
Higher repair resolutions can be achieved by operation at lower electron beam voltages
- Carl ZEISS SMT GmbH, Dr. Michael Waldow, Semiconductor Mask Solutions
- 18.05.2021
- 8
Contributing to resolution of MeRiT® Tools
Main factor II to Repair Resolution – Electron Beam Spot Size
Beam spot size as function of electron voltage
140% 120% 100%
80%
Standard column
New column
60%
Secondary Electrons
40% 20%
0%
Repair
Resolution
- 200
- 400
- 600
- 800
- 1000
- 1500
- 2000
Electron beam voltage [V]
▪ In general electron beam column resolution decreases with
E- Beam Spot Size
decreasing voltage
System Jitter
For higher repair resolution a new column with a smaller beam spot size at given voltage need to be used
- Carl ZEISS SMT GmbH, Dr. Michael Waldow, Semiconductor Mask Solutions
- 18.05.2021
- 9
Contributing to resolution of MeRiT® Tools
Main factor III to Repair Resolution – System Dynamics
Tool jitter as as function of diffrent tool platforms
Tool Jitter MeRIT tools
100%
75%
Standard Tool Platform
50% 25%
0%
New Tool PLatform
Secondary Electrons
-25% -50% -75%
-100%
Repair
Resolution
- 0
- 0,2
- 0,4
- 0,6
- 0,8
- 1
- 1,2
- 1,4
Time [s]
▪ MeRiT® repair resolution is detoriated by tool vibrations/jitter
System
Jitter
E- Beam Spot
Size
In order to make use of full potential of new MeRiT® repair tools, system jitter has to be minimized
- Carl ZEISS SMT GmbH, Dr. Michael Waldow, Semiconductor Mask Solutions
- 18.05.2021
- 10
MeRiT® LE overview
Next generation mask repair tool
MeRiT® LE - What‘s new?
1. MeRiT® LE is operating at lower electron voltage
▪ Tool is optimized for lower energy of 400eV compared to
MeRiT® neXT, which operates at 600eV
2. MeRiT® LE is equiped with a new electron beam column
▪ Tool is equipped with Low-kV Objective Lens optimized for low beam energies
3. Improved system jitter enabling highest repair resolution
▪ Re-designed tool platform including improved acoustic enclosure and improved tool damping
- Carl ZEISS SMT GmbH, Dr. Michael Waldow, Semiconductor Mask Solutions
- 18.05.2021
- 11
Agenda
1 Introduction
2 High-end EUV photomask repairs
3 Summary
- Carl ZEISS SMT GmbH, Dr. Michael Waldow, Semiconductor Mask Solutions
- 18.05.2021
- 12
High-end EUV photomask repairs
MeRiT® repair and AIMS® EUV actinic measurements in the mask shop ecosystem
Mask making process
Pattern
Generation
Cleaning
- Metrology
- Tuning
- Inspection
- Disposition
- Repair
Verification
MeRiT® Repair
AIMS® EUV
AIMS® EUV
- 1
- 2
- 4
3
-
-
-
- Defective
- Defect-free
- EUV mask
- EUV mask
Printability test by
AIMS® EUV technology
Detailed analysis by high resolution e-beam
E-beam mask repair by MeRiT®
Printability check after repair by AIMS® EUV
- Carl ZEISS SMT GmbH, Dr. Michael Waldow, Semiconductor Mask Solutions
- 18.05.2021
- 13
High-end EUV photomask repairs
EUV ETCH repair of bridge defect
Bridge Defect
Defect Type: Bridge defect
▪ Length 500nm ▪ Half-Pitch 60nm on mask
MeRiT® LE repair
Pre-repair SEM image
MeRiT® LE
Post-repair SEM image
repair
AIMS® EUV analysis
- Carl ZEISS SMT GmbH, Dr. Michael Waldow, Semiconductor Mask Solutions
- 18.05.2021
- 14
High-end EUV photomask repairs
AIMS® EUV Analysis of bridge defect repair
Analysis of CD with AIMS™ Auto Analysis (AAA)
Post-repair aerial image by AIMS™ EUV
Bridge Defect
x
MeRiT® LE repair
Shown results are at best focus
y
Along center of defect
▪ Along the center of the defect the CD variation is
AIMS® EUV analysis
below the CD variation of the reference structures
▪ A maximum ΔCD of 2.6nm results for the repair
Successful EUV bridge repair verified by AIMS® EUV
- Carl ZEISS SMT GmbH, Dr. Michael Waldow, Semiconductor Mask Solutions
- 18.05.2021
- 15
High-end EUV photomask repairs
Small extrusion defect on a EUV photomask
Defect Type: Extrusion
Bridge Defect
Analysis of CD with AIMS® Auto Analysis (AAA)
▪ Length 500nm ▪ Half-Pitch 88nm on mask
98 96 94 92 90 88 86 84
CD Along center of defect
SEM defect image
Tiny <10nm extrusion!
AIMS® EUV
printability test
AIMS® EUV defect image
- -500
- 0
- 500
Y position / nm
MeRiT® LE repair
▪ Aerial image is clearly affected by tiny extrusion defect
▪ On average detected CD deviation from reference analysed to be smaller than 10nm
- Carl ZEISS SMT GmbH, Dr. Michael Waldow, Semiconductor Mask Solutions
- 18.05.2021
- 16
High-end EUV photomask repairs
EUV ETCH repair of small extrusion defect
Defect Type: Extrusion repair
▪ Length 500nm
Extrusion Defect
▪ Half-Pitch 88nm on mask
Tiny <10nm extrusion!
MeRiT® LE repair
Pre-repair SEM image
AIMS® EUV analysis
MeRiT® LE repair
Post-repair SEM image
- Carl ZEISS SMT GmbH, Dr. Michael Waldow, Semiconductor Mask Solutions
- 18.05.2021
- 17
High-end EUV repairs
AIMS® EUV Analysis of tiny extrusion repair
Analysis of CD with AIMS® Auto Analysis (AAA)
Post-repair aerial image by AIMS® EUV
Extrusion Defect
92 90 88 86 84
Repair
x
MeRiT® LE repair
Shown results are at best focus
y
Along center of defect
- 0
- 500
- 1000
- 1500
CD Center Y [nm]
▪ Along the center of the defect the CD variation is
AIMS® EUV analysis
below the CD variation of the reference structures
▪ A maximum ΔCD of 3.3nm results for the repair
Successful tiny extrusion repair <10nm verified by AIMS® EUV
- Carl ZEISS SMT GmbH, Dr. Michael Waldow, Semiconductor Mask Solutions
- 18.05.2021
- 18
High-end EUV photomask repairs
EUV DEPO broken-line defect repair
Defect Type: Broken-line
▪ Length 500nm
Broken Line Defect
▪ Half-Pitch 60nm on mask
MeRiT® LE repair
Pre-repair SEM image
MeRiT® LE
AIMS® EUV analysis
Post-repair SEM image
repair
- Carl ZEISS SMT GmbH, Dr. Michael Waldow, Semiconductor Mask Solutions
- 18.05.2021
- 19
High-end EUV photomask repairs
AIMS® EUV Analysis of broken line defect repair
Post-repair aerial image by AIMS™ EUV
Analysis of CD with AIMS™ Auto Analysis (AAA)
Broken Line Defect
62 61 60 59 58 57 56
x
MeRiT® LE repair
Shown results are at best focus
Along center of defect
y
- -800
- -600
- -400
- -200
- 0
- 200
- 400
- 600
- 800
y / nm
▪ Along the center of the defect the CD variation is
AIMS® EUV analysis
about the CD variation of the reference structures
▪ A maximum ΔCD of 3.8nm results for the repair
Successful EUV broken line repair verified by AIMS® EUV
- Carl ZEISS SMT GmbH, Dr. Michael Waldow, Semiconductor Mask Solutions
- 18.05.2021
- 20