Trophic Interrelationships, Life-Histories and Taxonomy of Some
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
TROPHIC INTERRELATIONSHIPS} LIFE-HISTORIES AND TAXONOMY OF SOME INVERTEBRATES ASSOCIATED WITH AQUATIC MACROPHYTES IN LAKE GRASMERE A thesis presented for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Zoology in the University of Canterbury, Christchurch, New Zealand by JOHN DOUGLAS STARK 1981 i CONTENTS Page List of Tables v List of Plates vii List of Figures vii Abstract ix CHAPTER GENERAL INTRODUCTION 1 I I STUDY AREA 3 2.1 INTRODUCTION 3 2.1.1 Location, Formation and Catchment of Lake Grasmere 3 2.2 CLIMATE 4 2 .3 LAKE GRASMERE 5 2.3.1 Physical Features 5 2.3.2 Chemical and Biological Features 6 III QUANTITATIVE SAMPLING PROGRAM 11 3.1 AIMS OF THE QUANTITATIVE SAMPLING PROGRAM 11 3.2 METHODS 12 3.2.1 Sampling Methods 12 3.2.2 pilot Survey and Analysis of Sample Variabili ty 18 3.2.3 The Main Quantitative Sampling Program 22 (a) Field procedure 22 (b) Laboratory procedure 24 3.3 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 24 3.3.1 Sampling Variability 24 3.3.2 Community Species Composition 28 3.3.3 Known Habitat Requirements of Some Freshwater Invertebrates 34 3.3.4 Invertebrate Community Relationships 39 (1) Invertebrate communities on different macrophytes 39 (2) Invertebrate communities at different depths 43 (3) site groups and species groups 45 (a) Introduction 45 (b) Data processing 46 (c) si te groups 48 (d) Species groups 52 3.3,5 Seasonal Changes in Invertebrate Communities at the Site Groups 63 (1) Introduction 63 (2) Procedure 63 (a) Species diversity 63 (b) community similarity indices 64 (3) Results 65 (a) Species diversity 65 (b) Community similarity 67 ii Chapter Page 3.3.6 Seasonal Changes in the Abundance of 70 Major Taxa at the site Groups (1) site group A 71 (2) Site group B 72 (3) Site group C 74 (4) Site group D 76 3.4 CONCLUSIONS 77 3.4.1 The Composition of Invertebrate Communities at the Site Groups in Terms of Species Groups and Major Taxa 77 3.4.2 Comparison of Species Diversity and Invertebrate Density at Different site Groups 83 3.4.3 Community Similarity 84 IV TROPHIC INTERRELATIONSHIPS OF SOME MACROPHYTE-ASSOCIATED INVERTEBRATES 87 4.1 INTRODUCTION 87 4.2 METHODS 89 4.2.1 Faecal Analysis 89 (1) Field procedure 89 (2) Laboratory procedure 91 4.2.2 Periphyton Analysis 95 4.3 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 96 4.3.1 Introduction 96 4.3.2 Periphyton Analyses 97 4.3.3 Invertebrate Faecal Analyses 98 (1) Paroxyethira hendersoni and 98 P. tillyardi (2) Hudsonema amabilis 100 (3) Triplectides cephalotes 104 (4) Nymphula nitens 108 (5) Xanthocnemis zealandica 111 (6) Potamopyrgus antipodarum 115 (7) Observations on the gut contents of Chironomidae 118 V LIFE-HISTORY INFORMATION ON SELECTED 121 INSECTS 5.1 INTRODUCTION 121 5.2 METHODS 122 5.3 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 124 5.3.1 Hudsonema amabilis 124 5.3.2 Triplectides cephalotes 126 5.3.3 pycnocentrodes aureola 127 5.3.4 Oecetis unicolor 129 5.3.5 Oxyethira albiceps, paroxyethira 130 hendersoni and P. tillyardi 5.3.6 Nymphula nitens 131 5.3.7 Xanthocnemis zealandica 133 iii Chapter Page VI TAXONOMY OF NEW ZEALAND HYDROPTILIDAE 137 (TRICHOPTERA) AND CHIRONOMIDAE (DI RA) 6.1 INTRODUCTION 137 6.2 TAXONOMY OF THE LARVAE OF NEW ZEALAND HYDROPTILIDAE 137 6.2.1 Key to the Larval Hydroptilidae of New Zealand 139 6.2.2 Distribution of the New Zealand species of Hydroptilidae 140 6.2.3 Description of the larva of paroxyethira tillyardi 144 6.3 TAXONOMY OF NEW ZEALAND CHIRONOMIDAE 147 6.3.1 Key to Larval Chironomidae of New Zealand 149 6.3.2 Key to Adult Male Chironomidae of New Zealand 160 6.3.3 Description of the Adult Male of Eukiefferiella sp. 171 6.3.4 Chironomid Larvae and from Lake Grasmere 173 (1) Tanypodinae 175 (2) Podonominae 177 (3) Orthocladiinae 177 (4) Chironominae 180 VII GENERAL DISCUSSION 181 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS 193 REF ENCES 195 APPENDICES 1 Full collection records of macrophyte-associated invertebrates collected during the pilot survey, 219 Lake Grasmere (14 April 1976) 2 Full collection records of macrophyte-associated invertebrates collected during the main 220-232 quantitative sampling program (September 1976 - October 1977) (Appendices 2.1- 2.13) 3 Chironomid larvae and pupae collected during the quantitative sampling program (September 1976 - 233-236 October 1977). 4 Indices of precision (D) for macrophyte dry weight and invertebrate densities obtained from replicate 237-239 samples during the quantitative sampling program and ·the pilot survey (densities expressed as numbers/sample and numbers/g dry wt of macrophyte) . (Appendices 4.1 - 4.6) iv Appendices - Cont'd Page 5 Adult insects collected in hand-nets and light traps from the shore of Lake Grasmere, 240-246 (Appendices 5.1 - 5.7) 6 Percentage composition of the faecal material in terms of major food categories, and generic composition of the diatom category, for different 247-256 size groups or instars of seven invertebrate species for each month of collection and overall. (Appendices 6.1 - 6.10) v LIST OF TABLES Table Page 3.1 Factors affecting quantitative sampling in littoral macrophyte beds. 17 3.2 Number of replicate samples required to estimate densities of various invertebrate taxa (+ 20% of the mean) on various macrophytes. 20 3.3 Number of replicate samples required to estimate reliably the dry weight of macrophyte for nine habitat types, and the index of precision when two or three replicates are taken. 20 3.4 Sample type and numbers of replicates to be collected during the quantitative sampling program. 21 3.5 Physical features of the sampling sites. 23 3.6 Sampling dates, sites and numbers of samples collected during the quantitative sampling program. 23 3.7 Results of tests to determine whether numbers/sample or numbers/g dry wt of macrophyte gave significantly less variable density estimates during the quantitative sampling program. 27 3.8 Aquatic macro invertebrates collected from Lake Grasmere, Cass, April 1976 - December 1978. 29 3.9 Percentage composition and mean numbers per sample of macroinvertebrates collected from 13 sites in Lake Grasmere, September 1976 - October 1977. 33 3.10 Percentage representation of species groups at site groups, and the percentage of total invertebrate numbers per sample occurring at each site group. 53 3.11 Percentage occurrence of the taxa of species group 6 among the four site groups. 56 3.12 Species composition of Cladocera in quantitative samples from each site group and total numbers of each species collected, April - October 1977. 57 3.13 Percentage representation of each cladoceran species between the four site groups and overall mean numbers per sample at each site group. 57 3.14 Species composition of Chironomidae in quantitative samples from each site group and all sites combined. 58 3.15 Percentage representation of each chironomid in each of four site groups and overall mean numbers per sample at each site group. 59 3.16 Numbers of samples collected from the site groups, September 1976 - October 1977. 67 3.17 Percentage contribution of the taxa of individual species groups to invertebrate communities of the site groups. 79 3.18 Percentage occurrence of the taxa of species group 6 at each site group. 80 3.19 Contribution of major taxa to invertebrate communities at each site group and for all site groups combined. 81 vi List of Tables - Cont'd 3.20 Percentage composition of Mollusca at each site group. 81 3.21 Biological index values for major taxa at each site group. 82 3.22 Overall species diversity, species evenness, species richness, numbers of taxa, mean invertebrate densities and numbers of for each site group. 83 3.23 Average values of CC and PSc between sampling dates and for replicate from individual sites for each site group. 85 4.1 Size classes of invertebrates used in faecal analyses. 90 4.2 Standard areas of diatoms used to calculate projected areas of diatoms in faecal analyses. 93 4.3 Composition of periphyton communities on successive lengths of Elodea canadensis stern collected from the eastern sampling area of Lake Grasmere (8 April 1977). 98 4.4 Percentage of Hudsonema amabilis larvae in instars 2 - 5 whose faeces contained various preY,items. 102 4.5 Percentage of H. amabilis larvae in instars 2 5 whose faeces contained each of the major food categories. 104 4.6 Percentage of Triplectides cephalotes larvae in instars 2 - 5 whose faeces contained various prey items. 105 4.7 Percentage of T. cephalotes larvae in instars 2 - 5 whose faeces contained each of the major food categories. 106 4.8 Percentage of Nymphula nitens larvae in three size classes whose faeces contained each of the major food categories. 109 4.9 Percentage of Xanthocnemis zealandica larvae in three size classes whose faecal pellets contained each of the major food categories. 112 4.10 Percentage of X. zealandica larvae in three size classes whose faecal pellets contained various prey items. 113 4.11 Seasonal occurrence of prey items in the faecal pellets of X. zealandica. 116 6.1 Maximum lengths and widths of respiratory trumpets and caudal swim fins of Gressittius antarcticus, Macropelopia languidus, and M. umbrosa. 176 7.1 Taxonomic comparisons of macrophyte-associated invertebrate faunas of Lake Grasmere, New Zealand and other lakes in New Zealand and overseas. 182 7.2 Dominant invertebrate groups in macrophyte zones of some northern hemisphere lakes. 184 7.3 Feeding types (% by number) in relation to habitat in some New Zealand lakes. 187 vii LIST OF PLATES Plate Facing page 2.1 Lake Grasmere from the southern end. 6 3.1 The cylinder-sampler.