Entering the Lists
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
VOLUME 3 No. 3 MARCH 2003 tSiS journal ^^^^1 ^^^^1 ^ Association of Jewish Refugees Entering the lists At the end of 2002 the Independent asked were on a par with sharing a lice-infested mendacity of the deep-dyed Israel- 52 public figures - from Tariq Ali to bunk in the gulag. Ali, the patrician baiters, the decibels of their Michael Winner - to list their heroes and onetime barricade-builder in Grosvenor vituperation keep rising. A favourite villains of the year. The villains named Square turned all-purpose pundit, shows tactic of theirs is the 'double standards' 3nd shamed in the paper's columns cavalier disregard for the meaning of charge (i.e. why should Iraq be barred extended from such transient celebrities words, the basic raw material of punditry. from acquiring nuclear weapons if Israel 3s conman Peter Foster and butler Paul Having demeaned the term refusenik, he has them?). This contention leaves out Durrell to the likes of George Bush and waters down the connotation of of account the pivotal fact that the Ariel Sharon. The last named two untermenschen by attaching that loan Jewish state was almost strangled at received six 'villain' nominations each word from Hitler's vocabulary to birth by its Arab neighbours, whose out, since President Bush also figured as Sharon's perception ofthe Mestinians. combined population today is 20 times hero' on one entry, the Israeli that of Israel. (If one adds non- premier won the villainy stakes Arab Muslim states like Iran and by a short head. Not that the 52 Pakistan to the equation, Israel "lovers and shakers' showed total bias: three actually listed is outnumbered 50 to one.) Osama bin Laden as their devil, More crucially, it ignores the 3nd one each nominated geopolitical reality that even a Saddam Hussein and Robert nuclear-armed Israel could Mugabe. Still, the fact remains never hope to suborn the 22 •J^t Ariel Sharon topped the states in the Arab League - tlevils' league table. while the latter, led by an A- bomb-happy Saddam Hussein, Astonishingly, no one named could obliterate Israel. the Iranian, Syrian and Saudi heads of Tom Stoppard Woody Allen state, who finance suicide bombings, or The fact is that two years into Sharon's The unthinking refusal of many '^e mullahs who sentenced a Nigerian premiership, Palestinian students attend bystanders to take this on board is one of adulteress' to death by stoning, or the Israeli universities and Palestinian the woes that currently beset us. head of Cairo TV responsible for voters elect Knesset members who Another is the fact that some ofthe most Greening The Protocols of the Elders potentially affect the shape of the cerebrally endowed of our co '^fZion. incoming government. Of course, religionists - Chomsky, Hobsbawm - It would not have been so bad if at least Palestinians in the Territories are have squeezed their brains into the vice ^^le of Sharon's accusers had nominated suffering death and hardship, but they are of Marxism, and consequently reject the Israeli opposition candidate Amron casualties in a war for whose outbreak Zionism as 'bourgeois-imperialist'. A M'tzna as their hero, but none Sharon bears less culpability than Arafat. third is that Jewish-born luminaries 'Mentioned the fact that, uniquely in the Tariq Ali seems to think that his with the double qualification that their *1iddle East, an Israeli prime minister background entitles him to pontificate brains have not been addled by Marxist ^ actually be voted out of office. about the Middle East. He, who currently dogma and that they enjoy 'street cred' - Tariq Ali made Noam Chomsky his peddles pacifist nostrums to resolve the Tom Stoppard, Woody Allen - seem ^''o - picking a Jew who, professing to Iraq crisis, has in the past done little to indifferent to the fate of Israel. ^^^ Israel as Washington's catspaw, resolve the crisis in our northern cities. Would that we still had an Isaiah ^uld not shed a single tear over its Where was he when disaffected Berlin in our midst who could plead the des^traction . In his encomium on Pakistanis in Bradford made a public case for the existence of a Jewish state Ch,omsky , Tariq Ali gives him the bonfire of Salman Rushdie's Satanic before the bar of public opinion. Is it too •^•"etentious appellation refusenik - as if Verses and, a decade later, burnt buildings much to hope that someone of the ^upying a professorial chair at the in their own city? calibre of Simon Schama will step into Massachusett: s Institute of Technology But even if we can show up the the breach? AJR JOURNAL MARCH 2003 Schizophrenia AJR supports third under dreaming Holocaust spires Memorial Day Richard Grunberger Ronald Channing The other night, BB2's Arts Review discussed Christopher Hampton's The For the third year in succession, the Talking Cure (currently showing at the University of Sussex marked Holocaust At Camden's Holocaust memorial are, National Theatre). This is a play about Memorial Day with a full programme on left to right. Rabbi Janet Burden, who the formative stage in the development recited memorial prayers, playwright campus of talks, films and discussions, of psychoanalysis and focuses on the Julia Pascal, the Mayor, and children of attracting students and lecturers of all fraught relationship between Sigmund the Kindertransport, Bertha Leverton and disciplines from this and the Freud and Carl Jung. Ruth Fallman , neighbouring University of Brighton, as However, the discussion, which should I well as teachers from local schools. This Wiener Library, the publication of a have been about the merits of the play, year's programme, centred on the memorial book entitled Before They was sidetracked early on when Tom theme 'Survivors and Refugees, 1933- Perished: Photographs Found in Paulin denied Jung any standing as a 2000', was introduced by Sussex's Vice Auschwitz was complemented by an thinker. Jeanette Winterson tried to Chancellor, Prof Aiasdair Smith, and address given by the German defend the Swiss psychologist but was Brighton's Vice Chancellor, Prof Sir Ambassador, HE Thomas Matussek. This slapped down by Paulin, who rubbished David Watson, who presented an was followed by a moving recollection Jung's ideas about the 'racial address on the German-American by Auschwitz survivor and author Arno subconscious' and his theory of philosopher Hannah Arendt. Lustiger and a commentary on archetypes as so much mumbo-jumbo. Holocaust survivor Janina Fischler photographs drawn from the book by Then the Oxford don landed his killer Martinho's eye-witness testimony of the Dr Hanno Loewy of the Fritz Bauer blow: he quoted Jung's deeply ambiguous dissolufion of the Lodz ghetto was Institute in Frankfurt. attitude to Nazism. followed by that of Professor Abdul At the Jewish Museum, Finchley, the One part of me was pleased to note that LalEad, a refugee from Afghanistan. exhibition Am I My Brother's Keeper?, Paulin has not forgiven those European Headmaster Anthony Edkins led a which explores the subject of rescue in intellectuals who committed la trahison discussion group on the challenges the Holocaust, occasioned an opening des clercs by compounding with Nazi posed by presenting the moral lecture by Prof Mark Roseman on the ideology in the 1930s. Another part of me dilemmas inherent in the Holocaust to Wannsee Conference in January 1942 was puzzled as to how this attitude children with limited horizons. and its infiuence on what became squared with Paulin's lapse into Sussex's Centre for German-Jewish known as the 'final solufion'. Goebbels-style demonisation of Israeli Studies, under its Director, Prof Edward Senior AJR staff attended a Holocaust soldiers and Nazi-style rhetoric calling Timms, are especially pleased that this commemoration event organised bV for the murder of Orthodox settlers from pioneering venture continues to receive the London Borough of Camdei the USA. the generous support of the AJR, dedicated to the national them^ Someone who is as sensitive as Paulin furthering the relafionship established 'Children and the Holocaust'. AmonS is to the erosion of humanitarian values between the two organisations by the those speaking in the Council chambe' by the poison of prewar racism cannot be late Max Kochmann, former AJR were two children of th^ oblivious to the alarming overlap Chairman and chairman of the Centre's Kindertransport, Bertha Leverton an'' between anti-Zionism and antisemitism. support committee. Ruth Fallman, a former pupil of th^ This overlap has existed since the 1920s, Earlier in the week, AJR's Head of Berlin School for the Deaf, Julia Pascal' when the Muslim Brotherhood first Community Relations, Ronald playwright and writer on the Holocaust preached jihad, and Amin al Husseini, the Channing, discussed the significance of Rabbi Janet Burden, Councillor Rog^ Mufti of Jerusalem, incited a pogrom in Holocaust Memorial Day and the work Robinson, whose Dutch family perishe** Hebron in response to Jewish of the AJR with presenter Estelle Lovatt in the Holocaust, and the Mayor " immigration. on north London's Shalom radio. At the Camden. However justified the Palestinians may be in demanding national self- determination, they forfeit such a claim AJR Journal Richard Grunberger Editor-in-Chief JACKMAN • by denying the same right to the Jews. Ronald Channing Executive Editor And how sincere can protestations to the Howard Spier Editorial and Production SILVERMAN contrary be when Arab anti-Zionists - AJR Journal, 1 Hampstead Gate, COMMERCIAL PROPERTY CONSULTANTS whether secularists like Arafat and la Frognal, London NW3 6AL Saddam or Islamists - subscribe to the Tel: 020 7431 6161 Fax: 020 7431 8454 e-mail: [email protected] 26 Conduit Street, London WIR 9TA same image of the Jew as delineated in wvvw.ajr.org.uk Telephone: 020 7409 0771 Fax: 020 7493 80l' the Protocols ofthe Elders of Zion ? AJR JOURNAL MARCH 2003 Roll of dishonour Richard Grunberger NEWTONS Leading Hampstead Solicitors The Albrecht Diirer exhibition at the destroying Jewish religious institutions advise on British Museum features a portrait ofthe and secular Hebrew culture.