SPECIAL FEATURE: ELEVEN SEPTEMBER UCLA SCHOOL OF LAW

THE MAGAZINE OF THE SCHOOL OF LAW VOL. 25–NO. 1 FALL 2001 The Law and Beyond UCLA School of Law Commencement 2001 UCLA Contents SCHOOL OF LAW

THE MAGAZINE OF THE SCHOOL OF LAW VOL. 25–NO. 1 FALL 2001 2 A MESSAGE FROM DEAN JONATHAN D. VARAT

UCLA Law Magazine 4 ELEVEN SEPTEMBER © 2001 Regents of the University of California Jonathan D. Varat - Introduction Phillip Trimble - War Powers and the September 11 Attack UCLA School of Law Khaled Abou El Fadl - Defeatism, Alienation and Contemporary Islam Suite 951476 Clyde Spillenger - No Blank Check to Wage War Los Angeles, CA 90095-1476 Jerry Kang - What 12-7 Has to Teach Us About 9-11 Jody Freeman - Environmental Patriotism Jonathan D. Varat, Dean Regina McConahay, Director, Communications Center Justin Hughes - Staying the Course Managing Editor and Publisher, UCLA Law Magazine Phillip Carter ’04 - The Long Haul Robert DeBarge, Editor Eugene Volokh ’92 and Stewart Baker ’76 – Civil Liberties in Wartime Frank Lopez, Art Coordinator Charles Cannon, Cover Concept 18 THE LAW AND BEYOND Tricia Rauen, Treehouse Design, Designer By Jill Brown ’91 Typecraft, Inc., Printer Photographers: Mary Ann Stuehrmann, Regina McConahay Law and Anthropology Law and Economics UCLA School of Law Board of Advisors Law and History William M. Bitting ’65 Islamic Law Jonathan Chait ’75 Philosophy and Political Theory Stephen E. Claman ’59 Political Science and International Relations Deborah David ’75 Psychology Hugo de Castro ’60 David Fleming ’59 Sociology and Public Policy 1 Arthur Greenberg ’52 Antonia Hernandez ’74 31 CIVILITY Michael Masin ’69 Jonathan D. Varat The Honorable Veronica Simmons McBeth ’75 Hon. Richard D. Fybel ’71 Ralph Shapiro’58 Bill Vaughn ’55 Robert Wynne ’67 Bruce Clemens ’75 Kenneth Ziffren ’65

UCLA Law Alumni Association Board of Directors 33 FACULTY Shedrick O. Davis ’87, President New Faculty; Lynn Stout, Russell Korobkin, Gary Rowe Wendy Aron DeTata ’96, Vice President New Visiting Professors and Lecturers Beth K. Cranston ’86, Secretary Recent Scholarship Dennis L. Perez ’82, Treasurer Salute to Gary T. Schwartz The Honorable Steven Z. Perren ’67, Alumni Representative The Honorable George Schiavelli [Ret.] ’74, Past President Leslie H. Abramson ’69 42 HERITAGE Jason K. Axe ’96 Twenty Years of the Law School Musical Keenan Behrle ’69 The Honorable Kenneth A. Black ’74 44 MAJOR GIFTS Meredith Blake ’95 The Charles R. Williams Project on Sexual Orientation and the Law The Honorable Bob S. Bowers ’72 The Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP Endowment Jeffrey Cowan ’91 Michael A.K. Dan ’69 The Ann C. Rosenfield Endowment Fund Supporting the Gary T. Schwartz Greg Ellis ’85 memorial Symposium The Honorable Norman L. Epstein ’58 Hector G. Gallegos ’94 50 EVENTS John Gastelum ’83 Richard W. Havel ’71 STUDENTS Kathleen Marston Hogaboom ’80 56 Christopher Kim ’78 Eric G. Lardiere ’83 57 ALUMNI Margaret Levy ’75 Class Action Cathy Reed ’90 WTC: Minute by Minute, September 11, 2001 - Les Jacobowitz ’85 Brette Simon ’94 Salute to the Honorable George Schiavelli [Ret.] ’74 Lon S. Sobel ’69 Alumni Events and Reunions Arthur G. Spence ’69 Class Notes The Honorable Marjorie S. Steinberg ’75 The Honorable James F. Stiven ’69 Randolph Visser ’74 77 HONOR ROLL AND ANNUAL REPORT Donna Cox Wells ’92 Planned Giving by Sandra Kass Gilman ’75 Cheryl A. Williams ’97 Students who Give

Louise Lillard ’85, Alumni Editorial Advisor Kristine Werlinich, Director, Alumni Relations

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Message from the Dean

Message from the Dean

Dear Members of the Law School Community, In response to our distance from New York and Washington, we would not accept helplessness. We reached ach year the opening of school arrives with a whirl- out to one another and to the victims. The School of Law wind of excitement and activity. Welcoming return- joined the wider UCLA community in a memorial service at E ing faculty and students, and introducing our new Dickson Plaza. Students, staff, and faculty raised money for arrivals to our community, fill our busy days. It was amid the Red Cross, and BLSA expects record donors for its annu- this spirit of renewal and launching our academic year that al October blood drive here at the School of Law. I am proud the horror of September 11, 2001, stopped us short. of our faculty and our students for their solidarity in support First there was the shock and tragic devastation that we of one another as we mourn our losses, the losses of our fel- all experienced. We immediately scrambled to confirm the low Americans, and indeed, liberty loving citizens of the security and safety of our students placed in externships in world. Christopher Gidden ’04, a U.S. Navy counter terror- Washington D.C., New York City, and key offices on the East ism expert, was called away from our school to active duty Coast. We contacted our professors visiting at law schools in just hours after the attack. Our thoughts and prayers went

2 New York City, and the Boston and Washington D.C. areas. with him, and his colleagues, and all the heroes who protect As we go to press, we believe that everyone in our immedi- our way of life. While Chris was away, our community kept ate community is safe, and we will continue to monitor our in touch with him, and he kept up with his lessons through alumni family. If you have sustained the loss of a loved one, e-mail and other postings. He has returned—for now—and please accept our deepest condolences. has resumed his first-year classes. In the immediate aftermath of the attacks, like so many The First Monday in October, which marks each year’s others, we both kept on with our beginning of a new Term of the business and shared our deep Supreme Court of the United sense of loss and emotional tur- States, has become an annual day moil. With the School of Law in for reexamination of legal devel- session, students gathered in opments and proposals. It is espe- classrooms, of course, but also cially fitting, then, as an initial together in the student lounge, in step toward furthering our com- the courtyard, and—with our mon understanding of some of larger UCLA community—on the the central questions raised after lawn in front of Royce Hall. the recent tragedies, that the During office hours and class School of Law, the Near Eastern time, students and professors dis- Legal Society, and the Student Bar cussed the events of the day and Association co-sponsored “A Law the rule of law and its challenges School Forum on Law and the in times like these, but also the Aftermath of September 11” on emotional and social conse- Monday, October 1. Two days quences to us all. later, Professor Abou El Fadl and I

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Message from the Dean

took part in a campus-wide panel discussion sponsored by Charles R. Williams Project on Sexual Orientation and the the International Studies & Overseas Programs. There is Law. And the UCLA Law Review Symposium, in perpetuity, more that can be done, and in time will be done, to address will have the generous sponsorship of Skadden, Arps, Slate, the reality of the lawless assault on our country and its long- Meagher & Flom LLP thanks, in large part, to the efforts of term consequences. For now, I invite you to read the thought- Harriet Posner ’84 and Jeffrey Cohen ’88. ful reflections of our scholars, among them Professors The Alumni section offers the ever-popular Class Notes Khaled Abou El Fadl, Jody Freeman, Justin and news of our alumni family, as well as a Hughes, Jerry Kang, Clyde Spillenger, and minute-by-minute report from NYC from “I am proud of our Phillip Trimble and a student, Phillip Les Jacobowitz ’85. The Honor Roll contains faculty and our Carter ’04, who is a Truman Scholar and Developement information and a very Army reserve officer. students for their informative message from Sandra Kass

This issue of the UCLA Law Magazine solidarity in support Gilman ’75. also highlights the breadth of interdiscipli- Our graduating Class of 2001 is honored of one another as we nary legal education offered at your law in our Alumni section and on the inside cover. school—just one more gauge of the excep- mourn our losses, Also posted on the inside front cover are tional quality of the legal education we pro- the losses of our some highlights of upcoming events we hope vide and one more reason to take pride in you include in your calendar. fellow Americans, your alma mater. In the cover feature, The Sadly, Sue Young, the wife of Chancellor 3 Law and Beyond, Jill Brown ’91, a lecturer in and indeed, liberty Emeritus Charles Young and the “First our Clinical Law Program, documents the loving citizens of Lady” of UCLA for nearly thirty years, died tremendous benefits UCLA Law students September 28 after a long battle with cancer. the world.” enjoy from studying with a faculty who pos- Sue Young was a generous friend to the sess experience and academic credentials in School of Law in a number of ways, includ- a number of fields, including international relations and ing as a partner with Chancellor Young in contributing to the political science, economics, philosophy, psychology, Islamic Hugh and Hazel Darling Law Library Building Project. Sue law, history, sociology, and more. Young will long be honored and fondly remembered here. Our Faculty section is dedicated to our beloved colleague, Our country faces new challenges now, and tomorrow’s Gary Schwartz, who died this summer, whom we will stewards of democracy will lead a nation that more frequently remember October 29, 2001, at a campus memorial service, may be threatened with serious harm, or even be perceived as and whose life's work we will celebrate on April 19, 2002, at fragile. We, the UCLA Law family, feel a renewed commitment the Ann C. Rosenfield Symposium. Also in this section, to educating our next generation of lawyers for their crucial meet our newest faculty members, and our visitors. role in preserving our nation’s strength and its freedoms, and Turn to Heritage to reminisce over photos recalling twenty we call upon our alumni to provide your support to the years of the Law School Musical. Our Events and Student sec- school and guidance as mentors. I hope to see many of you tions report on outstanding achievements and enjoyable October 29, when we gather to honor the life of Gary Schwartz, events, followed by a photo essay of School of Law lectures, a stalwart soldier in the fields of legal education and reform. symposia, and awards ceremonies. A new Major Gifts section contains news of two exciting and generous gifts. A $2.5 mil- lion donation from Charles R. Williams, facilitated by Arnie Kassoy ’68, of Manatt, Phelps & Phillips, will endow The

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Eleven September

In the wake of the terrorist attacks of September 11, there is much

to understand and to learn, including very significantly our nation’s

legal responses and the legality and wisdom of our nation’s military,

political, social, and economic responses. We continue to grieve for

4

those lost and those left behind and to seek wise paths for all of our

futures. We continue to emphasize the importance of caring for one

another and for making sure that our community is free of discrim-

inatory acts or harassment of any kind, as sadly has been the case in

too many parts of our country. As institutions of higher education,

UCLA in general and our law school in particular not only have a

special opportunity and obligation to educate our community on all

these matters, but we are well positioned to do so. Law and educa-

tion—always important—become absolutely essential in times of

national stress like this is. Here are some thoughts from our students

and professors.

— JONATHAN D. VARAT

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Eleven September

WAR POWERS AND view such a response is desirable, in Iraq, Libya, Lebanon, and Syria, just to THE SEPTEMBER 11 order to underscore the gravity of the name some in the Middle East). matter and to assuage the public cry Third, we will need to offer ATTACK for justice. Nevertheless, the trick is to inducements for genuine cooperation, fashion an attack or series of attacks on not only from key states like Iran but PHILLIP TRIMBLE demonstrably relevant targets, without also from states that may not in fact killing thousands of innocents and turn out to be willing to match action The issues raised by Tuesday’s attack fueling even more hatred of America in on the ground with public rhetoric. are less about constitutional war pow- the Islamic world. It is a challenge to This will require money to support the ers than about war wisdom. Under this Government to use military force foreign police and intelligence help we national and international law, the in ways that actually punish demon- seek. For these appropriations of foreign President has fully adequate legal strably responsible parties without in assistance Congress will have to be gen- authority to react in self-defense turn inciting more terrorist fervor and erous to a greater degree than in the past. against this invasion of our territory. actually increasing the danger to the Even the most vigorous critics of exec- physical security of the country. utive power concede that under the The most important, and most dif- Constitution the President is empow- ficult, challenge for the country— ered, in Madison’s words, to “repel Congress as well as the President—is to sudden attacks.” One might quibble create an anti-terrorism coalition in over whether “repelling“ an attack, Europe, Asia, and Africa, as well as the which in the eighteenth century would Middle East that will suppress terrorist have been a land or naval invasion by a conspiracies at their roots. This cannot foreign state, extends in this era to a be done by the United States and military response outside the United NATO from outside, but must be done 5 States to an attack by unknown forces, internally through effective law- but the principle supporting the legiti- enforcement and education by govern- macy of an immediate response of a ments, many of which we have been at military nature seems implicit in the odds with over a whole range of issues. original understanding of executive To induce neutral, indifferent, and power. Moreover, Congress has even traditionally hostile governments expressly acknowledged this executive to effectively stop terrorist conspira- power and, in addition, has specifically cies, to deploy sufficient police effort to authorized the use of “all necessary law-enforcement, to share intelligence and appropriate force“ against the per- information, and to cooperate securely sons and organizations that conducted in trans-border investigations, will the attack and those states that aided or require significant inducements. This harbored the terrorists. Likewise, will be the hard part. under international law, the United First and most generally, the Fourth, we will need to change States has the right of self-defense Administration will have to engage failed policies based on economic sanc- under Article 51 of the UN Charter, and other nations, bilaterally and multilat- tions and isolation in favor of induce- NATO members have invoked Article 5 erally, and regain that vague but critical ments to cooperation and interaction. of the NATO Treaty, declaring the quality of American world leadership. This would require Congressional attack as an “attack against them all,” That will require a revision of the tone action as well as new Executive Policy. so that each of them is obligated “to and attitude of this Administration Fifth, the President and political, take such action as it deems necessary, across the full spectrum of foreign policy social, and religious leaders through- including the use of armed force, to issues. It need not require abandoning out the country should mount serious restore and maintain the security of the National Missile Defense or accepting the public educational efforts to help the North Atlantic area.“ Kyoto Protocol, but it will require gen- American people better understand the The legal authority of the President uine negotiation with our treaty partners. extent and basis of the anger against to wage some kind of war is therefore Second, we will need to reestablish our country, as well as extending pub- clear. The wisdom of doing so is more or substantially upgrade diplomatic lic exposure to the expression of com- complex. No doubt some military relations with states that have been passion that is common to all religious response will be launched, and in my anathema to us in the past (e.g. Iran, traditions.

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Eleven September

Finally, while we affirm our support DEFEATISM, Islam. But, ultimately, this did not for Israel, we need to effectively disas- ALIENATION, AND matter, and several Arab-looking or sociate the United States from support Muslim-looking people have been of the Israeli occupation of Palestine. CONTEMPORARY killed or beaten in several places in the The fundamental changes in policy ISLAM United States. that I am recommending of course can- This is distressing because terror- not happen quickly, and can only be What happened to the Islamic ism is first and foremost a hate crime. brought about if accompanied by tangible Hate crimes, and terrorism, rely on a civilization that produced such benefits in terms of cooperation from symbolic communicative act of vio- members of the antiterrorism coalition. tolerance, knowledge, and beauty lence that is intended to terrorize a Reciprocity is the protection against throughout its history? third party. Like terrorism, hate crimes responding, and appearing to respond, assume guilt by association, target a to the attack itself. In the meantime, let KHALED ABOU EL FADL group as a whole, and indiscriminately us hope that military vengeance does select a victim—often the selection of not preclude the kinds of positive Extreme acts of violence, such as the the victim is a factor of opportunity, vis- responses that will actually protect the recent terrorist attacks, test the mettle ibility, and perceived symbolic value physical security of the country. and moral depth of societies—the soci- more than anything else. ety that is targeted by the violence and It is important to approach the the society that generated it. For reality of terrorism from this perspec- Phillip R. Trimble Professor teaches instance, the Japanese stealth attack on tive because such an approach enables International Law, Law and National Pearl Harbor tested both the aggressor us to squarely reflect upon the ways Security, Law and Foreign Policy, and the victim. Pearl Harbor chal- that we, and others around us, inad- and International Human Rights. He lenged the moral integrity of Japanese vertently contribute to this crime. Hate served as Vice-Provost and Director for 6 normative values, but also tested us— crimes, such as the recent terrorist International Studies and Overseas the victim. On our part, we responded attacks, call for a serious introspective Programs at UCLA for 1999–2000. A to an extreme act of aggression with pause by all. It is imperative that noted scholar in international law, he another extreme act—we interned our aggressors, victims, and so-called has been a consultant to the U.S. Arms Japanese citizens in concentration camps, bystanders stop to consider the ways in Control and Disarmament Agency, all of which resulted in deep fissures in which our behavior patterns, discours- counsel to the U.S. Delegation to the our constitutional and civil rights fab- es, and attitudes contribute to the per- 1990 Nuclear Test Talks, and on an ric and the infamous Korematsu case. petuation of such extreme acts of hate arbitral panel under the U.S.-Canada We do not have a very good record and vengeance. Free Trade Agreement. His lengthy public when responding to aggression—as a For instance, as Americans we career included service as Assistant society we tend to vent our anger and ought to reflect upon the ways that our Legal Advisor for Economic Affairs, hurt at our own citizens and then spend own Middle East policies and the arro- Department of State, during the Nixon, decades expressing regret and talking gance by which we deal with dark- Ford, and Carter administrations; as about lessons learned. Considering the skinned people we collectively refer to Deputy Mayor of New York City; and scale of what has been called the sec- as Arabs contributes to the radicaliza- as American Ambassador to Nepal ond Pearl Harbor, unfortunately, I fear tion and polarization of Muslims. On during the Carter administration. that there is already an explosion of the other hand, Muslims, American hate crimes against Muslim and Arab- and otherwise, should reflect upon the Americans, both by common citizens ways that their own discourses and and police enforcement agencies. symbolisms contribute to a belligerent Islamophobic experts started splatter- and morally irresponsible attitude ing the airwaves with endless talk towards Western countries. about the Islamic threat and “I told you There is no doubt that the vast so’s.” Anticipating the backlash, Muslim majority of Muslims are not terrorists and Arab organizations have rushed to and will never take part in acts of vio- issue condemnations against terrorism lence or hate. And, there is also little and hate-motivated violence, and have doubt that Muslim and Arab organiza- gone to great pains to explain that ter- tions have every reason to be genuinely rorists who happen to be Muslim, do concerned about Islamophobics and the not represent Muslims at large, or type of frenzied atmosphere of hate they

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Eleven September

are capable of generating. Nevertheless, cultural venues such as local mosques. of Islamic law define morality—there as a Muslim scholar, I feel that the hor- Even in the United States, it is not are no moral considerations that can be ror of recent terrorist attacks demand a unusual to hear such remarkably irre- found outside the technical law. serious conscientious pause —a reflec- sponsible and unethical rhetoric Paradoxically, however, it also rejects tive stand upon the prevailing moral repeated in local Islamic centers or uni- the classical juristic tradition as an his- and ethical structure of contemporary versity Muslim student organizations. torical aberration and insists on a de Islam. There is little doubt that terror- All of this begs the question: What novo and literal reinterpretation of all ism and hate crimes are most often an happened to the Islamic civilization that Islamic texts. But the de novo reinterpre- aberration. Terrorism, however, is often produced such tolerance, knowledge, tation of Islam is not forward looking; an extreme manifestation of underlying and beauty throughout its history? There rather, it claims to bring Islam back to its mainstream social and ideological cur- is a lot that has happened—Islamic civ- pristine and authentic self. According rents prevalent in a particular culture. ilization has been wiped out by an to puritan theology, there was an Terrorism is not a virus that suddenly aggressive and racist European civiliza- Islamic golden age—a period of infects the brain of a person; rather, it tion; by Colonialism; and by the expul- absolute utopia that lasted from the takes long-standing and cumulative sion of the Palestinians. Furthermore, time of the Prophet until the death of cultural and rhetorical dynamics to virulently despotic and exploitative the fourth Rightly Guided Caliph. The produce a terrorist. The classical culture of Islamic law is uncompromisingly hostile to all acts of terrorism. Terrorism, known as hirabah in Islamic law, was considered cowardly, predatory, and a grand sin punishable by death. In fact, the Muslim juristic tradition equated ter- 7 rorism with the Quranic concept of fitnah (betrayal and oppression), which the Quran describes as a crime against humanity. Consequently, classical Muslim jurists considered crimes of terror to be “acts of corruption on the earth”—the most heinous and repre- hensible type of crime committed against humanity at large. More specif- ically, classical Islamic law explicitly regimes have taken power in nearly puritanical insist that if Muslims purify prohibited the taking or slaying of every Muslim country, and, like most their religion from all corruptions and hostages or diplomats, even in retaliation third world countries, Muslim nation external influences, they will be able to against unlawful acts by the enemy. In states remain underdeveloped and bring back this Golden Age with all its addition, it prohibited stealth or indis- continued to suffer from chronic eco- glory and power. As part of this para- criminate attacks against enemies, nomic and political problems. But most digm, this puritanism tends to be dis- Muslim or non-Muslim, and prohibit- importantly, a dogmatic, puritan, and tinctly anti-intellectual. Intellectualism ed the use of weapons of mass and ethically oblivious form of Islam has or social thinking that attempts to have indiscriminate destruction, such as fire continued to develop and predominate a critical approach to Quranic interpre- or the poisoning of water wells. since the 1970s. tation, or that introduces nuances of It would be disingenuous, however, This puritan brand of contempo- meaning to the text, or that attempts to to propose that this classical attitude is rary Islam is well represented today in integrate socio-historical insights into predominant, or even that familiar, several Muslim regimes and mass- the understanding of the doctrines of especially in modern Arab-Muslim cul- based Islamic movements. This brand the Islamic law, is considered to be pure ture. To put it simply and bluntly, I, like of Islamic theology is largely dismis- sophistry and a corruption of the purity many other Muslims, grew up with an sive of the classical juristic tradition, of the Divine message. unhealthy dose of highly opportunis- and is also dismissive of any notions of Fundamentally, however, this puri- tic, anti-Western, and belligerent rheto- universal and innate moral or ethical tan theology projects its own frustrations ric delivered not only through the offi- values. This orientation insists that and aspirations upon the text. In fact, cial media but also through popular only the mechanics and technicalities one notes that it responds to the feelings

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Eleven September

of powerlessness and defeat with arrogance. Second, confronted by the Our foreign policy towards Muslim uncompromising symbolic displays of challenges of modernity, many Muslim nations remains guided by considerations power, not only against non-Muslims, intellectuals and activists have tended of realpolitik and pure self-interest. In but also against Muslim women. It is to give precedence to the logic of prag- this vein, we supported and continue not accidental that this puritan orienta- matism over any other competing nor- to support very repressive and corrupt tion is the most virulent in flexing its mative requirements. Invoking the logic governments with abysmal human muscles against women, and that it is of necessity or public interest to justify rights records. While touting the cause also plagued by erotic fantasies of virgins a variety of courses of action, at the of freedom and democracy, we consis- in heaven submissively catering to the expense of normative moral impera- tently refer to these repressive govern- whim and desire of men. tives, has become common practice. ments as our friends and allies. Even This contemporary orientation is Effectively then, Muslims have gotten more, we arrogantly claim to be the anchored in profound into the habit of pay- leader of the free world—whatever feelings of defeatism, ing homage to the pre- that means—but have not proven to be alienation, and frus- I, like many other sumed superiority of a very benevolent or principled leader. tration. It is a theology Muslims, grew up with the Islamic tradition, The claim of leadership comes with that is alienated not an unhealthy dose of but have marginalized a heavy responsibility. It should be only from the institu- this idealistic image in understood that the leader becomes the highly opportunistic, tions of power of the everyday life. symbolic scapegoat for the frustrations modern world, but also anti-Western, and The reality of contem- and failures of its purported followers. from its own Islamic belligerent rhetoric porary Muslims is Significantly, when the leader relies on heritage and tradition. delivered not only unfortunate. Easy oil the logic of unprincipled and pragmat- Importantly, this puri- money, easy apologet- ic interest, the lesson taught to others is through the official tan trend compensates ics, easy puritanism, not a particularly moral one. media but also through 8 for those feelings of and easy appeals to defeatism and alien- popular cultural venues the logic of necessity Professor Khaled Abou El Fadl, the Omar ation with a distinct have all but obliterated such as local mosques. and Azmeralda Alfi Distinguished Fellow sense of self-righteous the incentive for intro- Even in the United in Islamic Law, is one of the leading arrogance vis-à-vis the spection and critical States, it is not authorities in Islamic law in the United nondescript “other”— insight. Arab and States and Europe. He teaches Islamic whether the other is unusual to hear such Muslim organizations Law, Middle Eastern Investment Law, the West, non-believers remarkably irresponsible in the U.S. are right to Immigration Law, and courses related to in general, or even worry about hate and unethical rhetoric human rights and terrorism. Muslim women. crimes and stereotypi- repeated in local It is certainly true cal projections of that the extreme and Islamic centers or Muslim and the violent form of puritan university Muslim Islamic religion. The Islam does not repre- student organizations. problem, however, is sent the vast majority that Muslims them- — of Muslims today. But selves responded to there are two ways in Khaled Abou El Fadl the challenge of which contemporary modernity by stereo- Muslim culture, Arab typing and then com- or non-Arab, inadvertently contribute pletely ignoring their own rich moral to and feed these extreme trends. First, tradition. It is not surprising that some since the fall of the Ottoman Empire extremists have taken this tendency to and the onslaught of colonialism, its logical and heinous extreme. Islamic intellectuals have busied them- Nonetheless, there are several ways (l to r) ISOP Vice-Provost Geoffrey Garrett selves with the task of “defending in which the United States contributed hosted Dean Varat, Professor Abou El Fadl Islam“ by rampant apologetics. This to the emergence of these same extreme and other scholars to a campus-wide has produced a culture that eschews trends. We, ourselves, have tended to teach-in October 3. UCLA added 50 classes self-critical and introspective insight throw around the rhetoric of moral to its curriculum in response to the events and embraces projection of blame and imperatives and commitments, but our of September 11. Law professors a fantasy-like level of confidence and foreign policy fell far short of our rhetoric. participated in the courses.

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Eleven September

NO BLANK CHECK “A comment current both in private conversations and in TO WAGE WAR the official Chinese press is that while terrorism is morally

unjustified, U.S. policy makers must understand that U.S. CLYDE SPILLENGER bullying and unilateral action outside the scope of international Many Americans are understandably law, combined with the political, economic, and military dominance concerned about the threat to our civil of the U.S. that leaves many countries without any effective liberties in the wake of the disastrous channel to redress their grievances, increases the likelihood of events of September 11. But these events, and the rhetoric of government terrorist attacks on the U.S. Accordingly, the U.S. should refrain officials in the days since, have from such hegemonic behavior and exercise its power within exposed an even greater threat to our established international law.” safety: When it comes to foreign poli- cy and America’s role in the world, we — are rarely a true democracy; we rarely Randall Peerenboom even have much idea of what is going on. This veil of ignorance has con- Professor Randall Peerenboom teaches International Human Rights, tributed in no small part to these Comparative Law: China, and Doing Business in China, the only recent ghastly events. If we are to pre- transactional clinic of its kind in the United States. His experience includes vent a repetition of them, we as citizens four years negotiating international business transactions in Beijing, must reclaim some authority over our role in the world, and not simply China, where he is now. endorse a “war on terrorism.” Simple justice and morality demand 9 that we regard the acts of the terrorists A VIEW FROM BEIJING and those with whom they worked as evil, irredeemable deeds, and that we tirelessly seek justice for their victims. BEIJING—With respect to the U.S. response to the terrorist attacks, China’s leaders have empha- But our revulsion and our determina- sized three principles: tion to bring evil-doers to justice do not require us to abandon the search ■ China is willing to cooperate with the U.S. and other nations in the struggle against terrorism. for the larger causes of such deeds. ■ Any military action should be based on firm evidence and have a clearly defined objective not Sheer pragmatism, not to say the desire for self-preservation, requires involving mass attacks on innocent civilians. that we do all we can to prevent future ■ Responses should be “consistent with the U.N. charter and the principles of international law,” repetitions of these events. with the U.N. Security Council playing its due role. As a permanent member of the Security Such a pragmatic imperative is Council, China would have the power to veto any responses that it found objectionable. not adequately served simply by beef- ing up our intelligence capabilities or Historically, China has been cautious about external intervention in the internal sovereign affairs by retaliating with military or econom- ic violence. If widespread hatred of of other states, especially by Western powers or Western regional forces such as NATO. On the other the United States is the seedbed of acts hand, China faces its own potential terrorist threats, particularly in the predominantly Muslim western like those of September 11, we would province of Xinjiang. In recent years, China has made overtures to the Taliban government of do well to reflect on the roots of that Afghanistan in the hopes that the Taliban would cooperate in reducing external support for Xinjiang hatred. Understanding it does not separatists. The U.S. threats to take military action against the Taliban government if bin Laden is not require that we ratify it, or accede to its handed over has put Beijing in an uncomfortable position of having to choose between its antiterrorism fantastic and coercive manifestations, or refrain from passing judgment on stance and its efforts to form an alliance with the Taliban to undermine support for Xinjiang separatism. despicable acts. It does, however, A U.S. attack on Afghanistan would also result in U.S. troops on China’s borders. require that we pause to examine how U.S. policies and attitudes have helped Randall Peerenboom in the making of the world we now regard with fear and revulsion.

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Eleven September

With few exceptions, Americans ing and how is that affecting the lives do not have a particularly cosmopolitan of millions throughout the world; how vision or understanding of what we are might we reverse the unremitting hos- content to call the “Arab world.” For tility to the U.S. pledged by large num- many of us, that vision consists of tur- bers throughout the Arab world; in a baned sheiks conspiring to raise the word, how we can establish a genuine price of oil; of Arafat, Khomeini, security against terrorist attacks, and not Saddam, and Qadhafi; of nameless ter- simply a temporary and uneasy shield rorists hijacking airplanes; of huddled enforced by punitive military and eco- masses who may have been buried nomic policies, policies that would under the sands of Desert Storm, beget future violence directed at us. although we’re not quite sure, because Readers will understandably ask those faceless masses seem somehow how such easy generalities can be always to be replenished by other face- translated into specific proposals. As to less masses. Human empathy or iden- that, Professor Trimble’s wise observa- tification with the people of this storm- tions are well worth heeding. There is no tossed, largely poverty-stricken region is suggestion here that there is a simple in short supply. route to take in the Israeli-Palestinian Nor—and this is the most signifi- conflict, which is the lightning rod (but cant point—are most of us truly aware scarcely the only cause) for Arab of the role the U.S. has played, for gen- whether indirectly as in the slaughter resentment of the West and the U.S. in erations, overtly and covertly, in the of Lebanese civilians during Israel’s particular. Nor is there any assurance world that was once the Ottoman invasion in 1982, or directly as in the that militant hostility to the United 10 Empire. As Professor Abou El Fadl has Gulf War, where military violence was States can easily be altered in those noted, the destruction of that culture at followed by the economic sanctions regimes for which that hostility is an the hands of an advancing Western that have wrought havoc upon the essential, if pathetic, motive force. Of imperialism eventually laid much of the lives of half a million children in Iraq. paramount importance, however, is Islamic world bare for the attractions of Whether one agrees or disagrees that that we citizens not abdicate our a dogmatic, warlike, fundamentalist such acts can legitimately be termed responsibility to understand, and to variant of Islam. At times we have con- “state terrorism“ on a par morally with exercise meaningful influence over, the nived at this development, most obvi- the cowardly acts of September 11 is uses to which our sovereign power is ously in the now bitterly ironic fact that not important. What is important is being put. President Bush has assured we supported Osama bin Laden and that the historical behavior of the U.S. us that “We will lead the world to vic- his allies in Afghanistan in the 1980s in toward the “Arab world“ has con- tory, to victory,” but over whom, and at their effort to expel Soviet forces. vinced many there that militant resist- whose expense? No American should Indeed, our interest in the Arab world ance to the U.S., violent if necessary, is feel satisfied to endorse a “war“ of (apart from our desire for inexpensive justified. undetermined length and unarticulated natural resources and markets for our That is the history that so many aims. To confer unchecked power on products) often seemed limited to any Americans, mesmerized by a few our government to prosecute a “war on assistance we might wring from it in images and truisms concerning the terrorism,” with no assurance that we will the war against communism. No won- “Arab-Israeli conflict,” have perceived not be spreading the same misery and der, as reported by Tariq Ali in The only dimly. We are now asked to write generating the same rage that lie behind Nation, one Pakistani general explained a blank check for a “war on terrorism,” the recent events, is unacceptable. militant anti-American feeling in his to “destroy the terrorist networks,” PATRIOTISM country as follows: “Pakistan was the even to restore the glory days of the condom the Americans needed to enter C.I.A. by permitting it once again to Professor Clyde Spillenger currently Afghanistan. . . . We’ve served our pur- employ what are euphemistically teaches Civil Procedure, Conflict of pose and they think we can be just called “unsavory characters“ (i.e. ter- Laws, and American Legal History. flushed down the toilet.” rorists) as operatives and to engage in His principal research interest is in Many in the Arab world under- the magnificent business of state-spon- American legal and constitutional histo- stand that American money and mili- sored assassination. What is not ry. Of particular note are his articles on tary equipment have been involved in explained is what our avowed policy Louis D. Brandeis. the loss of untold innocent life, should be; who are we really support-

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Eleven September

*In certain Asian and Asian American cul- cultures, practicing foreign religions The internment was challenged in tures, memorable events are noted in date (Shinto, Buddhism), American society courts of law, but the Supreme Court forms like this. For instance, Koreans call could not distinguish between the affirmed the constitutionality of the the 1992 Los Angeles riots sa-i-gu—4-29. Empire of Japan and Americans of curfew and exclusion orders in the Japanese descent. As General DeWitt, 1943 and 1944 cases of Hirabayashi, WHAT 12-7 HAS TO in charge of the Western Defense Yasui, and Korematsu. While protesting TEACH ABOUT 9-11* Command, put it, “A Jap’s a Jap.” In loudly that racial prejudice should trigger testimony, he elaborated: “[R]racial the highest scrutiny, the Court never-

JERRY KANG affinities are not severed by migration. theless deferred to the government’s The Japanese race is vague claims of mili- an enemy race and tary necessity. Was the The terrorist attacks on 9-11 have fre- while many second internment in fact jus- quently been analogized to Pearl Harbor. and third generation tified as a matter of In many ways, the analogy is apt. Just Japanese born on military necessity? A as that attack launched us into World United States soil, pos- Congressionally War II, the attacks on the World Trade sessed of United appointed blue ribbon Center and the Pentagon have launched States citizenship have commission concluded us into a new kind of war, against terror- become ’Americanized’ in 1982 that the “broad ism. But waging this sort of borderless the racial strains are historical causes which war poses great risks, not only to the undiluted.” As gov- Professor Jerry shaped these decisions soldiers commanded to fight but also ernment reports rushed Kang (L) and Fred were race prejudice, to core American values. In this way, to the conclusion that war hysteria, and a Pearl Harbor raises other disturbing Korematsu, one of Japanese Americans failure of political memories, those of the internment. the most famous aided and abetted the leadership,” not any 11 Like the recent explosions on the attack, the wheels of the litigants in the history genuine military neces- East Coast, the bombing of Pearl Harbor internment machinery of the U.S. Supreme sity. In other words, it on 12-7, shattered our feeling of national began turning. was a tragic wartime security. How could this have happened? Court, who challenged On February 19, mistake. For that, all Ordinary individuals, prominent jour- the internment of 1942, President Franklin branches of the U.S. nalists, and government officials soon 110,000 Japanese Roosevelt issued government have apol- started pointing the finger at the Executive Order 9066, Americans by the U.S. ogized. Japanese in America. Viewing these which authorized mil- government during What lessons then “Orientals“ as incurably foreign, speaking itary commanders in should we learn from foreign languages, perpetuating foreign WWII. Professor Kang the Western U.S. to issue this mistake? One les- warns of parallels whatever orders were son could be that this necessary for national to the treatment was just an accident, security. Although of Muslims today. in a time of war, and prompted by DeWitt’s that the Supreme ominously titled “Final Court erred because it Recommendation“ for mass intern- was not given complete, accurate infor- ment, the Order conveniently made no mation. It turns out that the Executive mention of race or ethnicity. In March, Branch (Department of War and Congress criminalized disobedience of Department of Justice) suppressed key military regulations issued pursuant to evidence from the Office of Naval the executive order. By December, an Intelligence, Federal Bureau of efficient, empowered military had con- Investigation, and Federal centrated nearly all Japanese on the Communications Commission. This West Coast into ten desolate camps, exculpatory evidence, in the form of surrounded by barbed wire and armed smoking gun documents (burned sentries. All this without the declara- reports, edited footnotes, and the like), tion of martial law. All this without any was uncovered in the early 1980s and individualized determinations of guilt helped eventually reverse the criminal or disloyalty. convictions of the World War II litigants.

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Eleven September

Applied to the present crisis, this les- rity risk. This presents a horrible mize and mitigate collateral environ- son would counsel against law enforce- Catch-22: Because America has treated mental damage wherever possible. ment zeal that prevents a fair, balanced you badly, you have reason to be dis- Environmental losses are casualties consideration of all the facts by our loyal; therefore, America has reason to too. They ought to be included in our political leaders, the judiciary, and the treat you still more badly, by restricting strategic thinking about where and American people. your civil rights. In our public and pri- what to strike. This is in our national But learning only this lesson vate response to the horrors of 9-11, will interest. Patriotism and environmen- would be to commit another error. We we force another group of Americans talism go hand in hand. did not intern en masse German and into the same impossible situation? I As the President has made clear, Italian Americans, even though we were hope that by learning the lessons of 12-7 our response will come at a price. One at war with those nations too. We did we will not. of the costs, which will affect all of us not intern en masse the huge numbers down the road, will be environmental of Japanese in Hawaii (where Pearl Professor Jerry Kang teaches Asian degradation. Depending on where and Harbor is), for doing so would have American Jurisprudence, how we strike, we risk exposing large meant shutting down that economy. Communications Law & Policy, and populations, including our own troops, We did not abstain from drafting Civil Procedure. Besides his newly to lethal toxic substances. We have some Japanese Americans from the very published course books in communications experience with the long-term effects internment camps that kept jailed their law and policy and Japanese internment, of exposing military and civilian per- traumatized parents. The Supreme his scholarly works address cyberspace sonnel to potentially dangerous chemi- Court knew and understood this. Even privacy and “cyber-race“ (the techno- cals such as the defoliant Agent Orange without the suppressed evidence, social construction of race in cyberspace). in Vietnam and a variety of toxic agents Justice Murphy knew enough to dis- in the Gulf War. These health effects sent in Korematsu and lament that the can be devastating. 12 majority had fallen into “the ugly Just as terrorism knows no borders, abyss of racism.” The more important ENVIRONMENTAL neither do environmental problems. lesson, then, is not that wartime creates PATRIOTISM Those environmental harms that do mistakes; instead, it is that wartime not affect foreign civilians or our own

coupled with racism and intolerance JODY FREEMAN troops directly will eventually come create particular types of mistakes. home to roost in the form of polluted Specifically, we overestimate the threat air and water, destroyed habitat, and posed by racial “others“ (in WW II, As the U.S. prepares to respond to the even climate change—which affect us Japanese Americans; today, Arab ghastly terrorist attacks of September 11, all. Surely, the environmental devasta- Americans, Muslims, Middle Easterners, the hard task will be to choose among tion from the Gulf War (recall oil fields immigrants, and anyone who looks like effective options while minimizing the ablaze) ought to give us pause. “them”). Simultaneously, we underesti- costs. Environmental concerns might Environmental losses that occur halfway mate how our response to those threats seem trivial and even unpatriotic at a around the world will not observe geo- burden those “others“ (in WW II, shatter- time like this, but the environmental graphic boundaries. ing lives through the internment; today, effects of military action pose long- In addition to human casualties, intimidation and violence by individuals, term dangers that we would be foolish our counter-attacks might ravage fragile and racial profiling by the state). to ignore. Thinking in environmental ecosystems. An ecosystem sounds awfully And what will happen if we make terms at this moment should not be abstract compared to the concrete image such mistakes today? Consider another surprising. We must be alert to the like- of those toppling towers and the com- analogy with the internment. In lihood that aggression toward the pelling figure of Osama bin Laden. But Hirabayashi, the Court noted that United States may increasingly take environmental problems are real and they because American society had discrim- the form of environmental terrorism, are serious. Ecosystem health is crucial inated against the Japanese legally, including biological and chemical war- to the viability of future generations. politically, and economically, they had fare. Even conventional attacks create Domestically, the terrorist attacks been kept from assimilating and inte- environmental risk. Witness the con- and plans for our response have neces- grating into mainstream society. Exactly cern over asbestos exposure for rescue sarily pushed every other priority off right. But then, the Court went on the workers at the World Trade Center. the national agenda. Here too, however, explain—in an entirely rational but still Terrorists may not care about such we should be careful. The understandable disturbing way—that therefore the things, but we should. Our military need for bipartisanship will weaken the Japanese posed a greater national secu- response should be tailored to mini- Democratic and moderate Republican

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Eleven September

opposition to Bush's environmental cooperation prompts a reconsideration it is a disaster that will have a far agenda which, prior to September 11, of that decision when the dust settles. greater impact on their world—and included ambitious plans to open mil- As Prime Minister Tony Blair has they, in turn, can affect that impact. lions of acres of public lands to drilling, said, terrorists place no moral limits on As I explained to my class that including the pristine Arctic National their actions. They will stop at nothing. day, in the next months and years, we Wildlife Refuge, and to favor fossil fuel It is fair to suggest that in a crisis, some as a society will rethink everything burning over renewable energy. matters must be put to one side. But even from privacy to business organizations Conflict in the Gulf may embolden the if this war is inevitable, the environ- to architecture. Businesses will look at administration in its quest for greater mental effects of our response both at Morgan Stanley’s experience—occupy- oil independence, without any account- home and abroad require careful con- ing much of the World Trade Center— ing of the environmental consequences. sideration because of their serious and think again about the virtues of Many of the Bush administration’s long-term implications. The environment further decentralization of operations. environmental initiatives, which ought to is often thought to be an issue for the Just as architecture in the 1970s seemed be subject to debate, will slip under the wealthy, a luxurious concern best to respond to the turmoil of the 1960s radar, including the budget proposal to addressed in times of prosperity. But it (consider the fortress-like administration shift a significant percentage of EPA’s is exactly in times like these that we ought building at the University of Michigan enforcement capacity to the states. to be especially mindful of the fragility of or the FBI building in Washington), we Environmental rulemaking on matters the planet we are now trying to repair. may see architecture change in the like arsenic levels in drinking water, once future. Aside from a defiant impulse to front page news, will now likely be rele- rebuild the World Trade Center itself, Jody Freeman was named Professor of gated to the background. Ironically, the perhaps we will want smaller build- the Year by the Class of 2001 and teaches administration’s recent multilateralism ings—that are easier to evacuate and Environmental Law, Administrative Law, in seeking broad support in the new not as self-promotingly visible. Perhaps and Toxic Torts. She is also a fellow at the war on terrorism stands in sharp contrast we will insist, despite what our engi- Bren School for Environmental Science 13 to its unilateral decision to abandon the neers tell us, that big buildings be built and Management at UC Santa Barbara. Kyoto Protocol, the international stronger. Consider that when an admit- agreement to control greenhouse gas tedly lighter, slower plane (a B-25 bomber emissions responsible for global warm- traveling at about 200 mph) crashed ing. Let’s hope that this new spirit of into the Empire State Building in 1945, STAYING THE that majestic skyscraper sustained rela- COURSE tively little damage. “Contributions to But most of our rethinking will environmental JUSTIN HUGHES concern law—how we will balance organizations are understandable demands for improved likely to dry up in the When I was a law student, the security with our right to privacy, our freedom to travel, our free speech, our near term given the Challenger space shuttle blew up. Students gathered in the student policy of welcoming immigrants, and tremendous outpouring lounge for hours, watching in disbelief. our commitment to a tolerant society. of charitable giving In a way, it was more existential than Once we learn how the terrorists to the disaster relief Tuesday, September 11. We watched learned to fly these Boeing planes, should efforts and the sense the same ten seconds of the shuttle we place new restrictions on pilot train- that nothing else, at explosion over and over again, without ing? Access to flight simulators? First there being a trace of the Shuttle any- Amendment experts may rightly be the moment, matters.” where in the world. That day was a concerned about such restrictions—we — technological disaster, a mechanical may have, in effect, a replay of the debates Ann Carlson disaster that Americans, in our inimical about publishing how to build a bomb. fashion, could quickly fix. As to privacy, expect a rash of pro- Professor Ann Carlson is What law students watched on posals to improve security which will Founding Director and Tuesday, September 11, and the week have varying degrees of impact on peo- current Co-Director of following in our student lounge, was a ple’s anonymity. There had been some the Frank G. Wells social and political disaster. Watching outcry earlier this year when (unbe- Environmental Law Clinic. the events unfold was a lot less exis- knownst to them) fans attending this tential and a lot more practical because year’s SuperBowl in Tampa Bay had

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Eleven September

their faces scanned for find an acceptable way general retreat into private life.” Not matches to criminal “I taught my law to bring our strength on Tuesday, not tomorrow, not ever. records. A few head- school class that day to bear against these lines have also been for the same reason terrorists. Visiting Professor Justin Hughes joins the made by cameras On all these issues, UCLA faculty for the 2001–2002 academic year that the campus was meant to capture, the university students teaching Copyright Law, Trademark Law, “red-handed” so to open: that neither we of today—not just the and the Law of Cyberspace. He is a former speak, people who nor any other law students—are the ABA Baxter Scholar at the Hague Court. run stop lights. We democratic society can policymakers of tomor- can expect Tuesday’s let ourselves be row. They might as tragedy to shift the well join the fray now. brought to a halt when debate about such sur- It will be their civil lib- THE LONG HAUL veillance, with more someone strikes at us. erties at stake—as well citizens preferring the If anything, we must as their universities, PHILLIP CARTER ’04 comfort of the cam- prove that we will office towers, and 767s eras instead of the that could be on future continue being Patriotism means more than affixing a somewhat greater free- target rosters. flag to your car, or answering a CNN dom of anonymity. exactly what we are.” As usual, there has poll in favor of war. Almost all of The debates about — been some doom and America now drapes itself in red, privacy, free speech, gloom. The media is Justin Hughes white, and blue—embracing the out- and everything else constantly telling us ward symbols of our American identity. on the Internet will that America is But true patriotism requires a level of also be reshaped by Tuesday. There are changed forever, sometimes with the commitment and sacrifice that runs far 14 already reports that the FBI is seeking tinge that we will inevitably lose some deeper than these outward symbols. greater cooperation from Internet freedoms. On Tuesday night, one net- The war we now face will be dif- Service Providers in their monitoring work characterized Washington as ferent than any the world has ever of net traffic through the “Carnivore” “under siege” just because there was seen. It will require sacrifices on the system (a name that shows the FBI can armed military in the city. For those of magnitude of those of World War II. blunder in even the simplest of public who have lived in places through sus- Black Tuesday was but a glimpse of the relations situations). tained periods of terrorism—like Paris hell that will be unleashed upon our cities during a bit of the 1980s or long and towns. Before this conflict ends, stretches of time in Jerusalem—this we will see more death and destruction seems an overstatement. inflicted on us; more innocence destroyed. A democratic, civil society like We must adjust to a world where we are ours—with rich procedural protections not safe in our own nation. No amount and robust civil rights—can survive a lot. of intelligence or security will prevent As I said to my class, there is only one our enemies’ bold and determined acts thing a civil society cannot survive. In from killing innocent Americans. the words of the political philosopher There is no question that another attack John Rawls “If we are to remain free will occur on American soil—the only and equal citizens, we cannot afford a question is whether we will be ready. We will have to send our sons and daughters into harm’s way. They will And there will be much to do in face an enemy that our own C.I.A. international law—how civilized trained to be the very best guerillas in nations may justly—and effectively— the world. Our soldiers and Marines will respond when invisible enemies wage fight in the most unforgiving terrain “war” upon us. Just as the young imaginable; terrain so difficult that it United States had to seek out and stopped the Soviet war machine dead attack stateless pirates who were in its tracks. It is true that our military plaguing American ships in the early possesses the best technology, the best eighteenth century, we will have to intelligence, and the best aviation in

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Eleven September

places like Kuwait and Panama. Even BAILOUT THE in Somalia, we watched from afar. We AIRLINE INDUSTRY do not know the hardships we are about to face. In many respects, the best NOW parallel to draw here is with Pearl Harbor. Our innocence resembles the In 1979, Chrysler Corporation was on the brink innocence of that generation. High of financial ruin. Thousands of jobs hung in the school seniors and college students balance while federal and state governments today must feel the same emotions that helped facilitate an out-of-court workout. The the world. But it is also true that this students felt in 1941. Will we fight? resulting bailout package consisted of govern- type of war will not be won by hi-tech Will they call me? Will I go? Will I die? ment loan guarantees, among other things. As gadgetry. This type of war will be won The sacrifice will extend beyond a result, Chrysler averted bankruptcy and not by tough men and women fighting as those who actually go to fight. Every one penny was ever paid on the loan guaran- infantry has fought for thousands of American will feel the pain of this war, tees. Moreover, communities were preserved. years—on their feet, at close range, either directly through terror attacks or The ripple effect of the bankruptcy of thou- within sight of their enemy. For almost indirectly through the deprivations of sands of parts suppliers and their employees three decades, our all-volunteer mili- prolonged total war. Unlike World War also was averted. tary has shouldered the burden of II, where our nation fought abroad but In 2001, the airline industry is on the America’s defense. This will likely had peace at home, this war will con- brink of financial ruin. Free market econo- change for this war. sume our homes and our targets. We mists will howl at the suggestion, but it is time Few among us remember the daily will fight the forces of terror in our for another government bailout. Unless the tragedy visited on families during cities and our backyards while our sol- government is prepared to nationalize the air- Vietnam, Korea, and World War II. My diers fight overseas. Our diplomatic lines, the government must help stabilize the generation has never felt the pain of a and military actions abroad will now turbulent private markets. Only government 15 protracted conflict. We have seen war, have repercussions at home, and will intervention will prevent the massive financial but only through the lens of CNN in be paid for in American blood. ruin that will accompany the bankruptcy of Patriotism is important. We must America’s major air carriers. The ripple effect all come together to rally behind those would extend through the entire economy as “Throughout the day, I who have lost loved ones, behind our airline manufacturers, travel agents, hotels, saw that many of my leaders, and behind our cause. But we resorts, and tourist destinations suffer their classmates found comfort must remember that empty symbolism own financial calamity. and gestures of patriotism are not The thought of a government bailout runs within the walls of our enough. We must back those symbolic counter to our free market instincts. But our law school. Many of us, acts with our own personal courage— markets are not perfect; at the margin, they are myself included, are not our own willingness to sacrifice. We chaotic. We cannot ignore the enormous trans- action costs that would result from the meltdown from California and had have started this war with an answer of defiance. But in the hard months of our airline industry. State and federal govern- no family to turn to. and years ahead, our defiance will be ments will save billions in unemployment ben- In one of my classes we tested. We must persevere until we efits and lost tax revenues alone if they step up discussed the events of attain total victory, or else America’s to the plate and provide loan guarantees. enemies will rule our country with ter- There is little time for speech and debate. The the day. This was extremely ror for generations to come. time to act is now. beneficial. Finally, we had an opportunity to express Ken Klee Phillip Carter ’04 is a Truman Scholar our feelings, concerns, and and Army reserve officer. He was named fears. Looking back, I can 1996 UCLA Senior of the Year. Bankruptcy expert Professor Ken Klee was one of the attorneys who represented understand why we had Chrysler Corporation and Chrysler class that day.” Financial Corporation in their 1979–1980 — financial restructuring. He actively par-

Brett D. Cook ’04 ticipated in creating the government loan guarantee program.

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Eleven September

“Our freedom and our rights, CIVIL LIBERTIES IN tossed them the intelligence to curry their favor. It gave me a helpless sink- many of us take for granted WARTIME ing in my stomach—the same one we because we have never been all felt last Tuesday. STEWART BAKER ’76 AND denied their protection The risk that worries me isn’t that EUGENE VOLOKH ’92 here or elsewhere.” our leaders will suddenly embrace authoritarianism. It’s that they’ll keep — This exchange originally appeared leaking, and the press will keep reporting, M. Catherine OliverSmith ’04 online in Slate Magazine, September 18, and the terrorists will keep getting 2001, as part of a week-long series on smarter. That we’ll go on treating the civil liberties and national security. Defense Department and the intelli- gence agencies the way Chicago’s Near Dear Eugene North Side treats its cops—expecting absolute protection while offering a Frankly, I don’t hear a lot of calls for mix of Christmas tidings and genial sacrificing civil liberties today. Anyone contempt. who’s dug deep enough has probably Why aren’t we debating when already seen twenty warnings about journalists should reveal the names of the risk to civil liberties for every pro- officials who compromise secret mili- posal they’ve heard that would signifi- tary plans? Sure, they’d be burning cantly restrict our freedoms—unless their sources. But in the light of recent you think that curbside check-in is events, what conceivable calculation enshrined somewhere in the Magna makes protecting The Washington Post’s Carta (a position the ACLU’s probably 16 sources more important than protect- briefing at this moment). ing the CIA’s? Why do we insist on looking for an Authoritarian Bogeyman Under the Stewart Baker ’76 Bed? If you’d asked Queen Victoria about the threats her society faced, she’d probably have worried aloud Stewart Baker ’76 is head of the about a breakdown in sexual and other technology practice at Steptoe & morality. Ask a Hollywood producer Johnson, a former general counsel of the same question, and he’ll cite the the National Security Agency, and threat of sex-hating moralists. Every co-author of The Limits of Trust: age seems to warn itself most sternly Cryptography, Governments, about the risks that are least likely to and Electronic Commerce. The images on these pages reflect UCLA’s do it harm. and the UCLA School of Law’s interest in When I was in government and I honoring the victims of the September 11 read some press story about the foreign attack and seeking answers to the issues adversaries we were spying on, I knew Dear Stewart that surround us. Dean Varat and Professor our enemies would read the same story. They then would go back Abou El Fadl participated in a teach-in I’ve long bristled when people have through their communications to find talked about civil liberty, which is to sponsored by the International Studies & the message we had intercepted. They say freedom from government oppres- Overseas Programs, pictured on page 8. would add encryption to the channel sion, as if it were the most important The student lounge was a gathering site to or get rid of the compromised equip- thing in life. And, yes, it can seem that watch news accounts—and be inter- ment or execute the spy that gave us way—when we are physically safe. viewed by the media. UCLA Chancellor our insights. Sooner or later, we’d pay But when our lives are in danger, we a price—a price that would never be Carnesale led an all-campus service held realize that we’d like to have both free- known by the cheerily iconoclastic at Dickson Plaza. The School of Law also dom from government oppression and reporters, so proud of wresting their freedom from oppression by others. held a private forum October 1, which was story from the heart of overweening Once we see that, it’s pretty obvious not photographed. authority or the climbing officials who that some trade-offs might be needed.

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Eleven September

And no one has a magic formula for Intelligence agencies, vital as they “I would like to say ‘thanks’ how to make these trade-offs. are to our survival, are subject to all the to all of my classmates and So not having any real answer to flaws of human institutions. They may any really tough questions, let me just err; and it’s hard for the public to professors that have been so offer a few general thoughts: decide whether they’ve erred enough supportive with their e-mails. to need substantial reform unless the Additionally, I will forever 1. This isn’t about civil liberties in public is told the underlying facts. be impressed with UCLA Law wartime. The phrase suggests that I can’t say this for certain; you we’re somehow in a temporary spent years at the NSA and I didn’t. for all of their hard work wartime that calls for temporary I’m an expert on constitutional law, not in putting together a system measures, which will vanish when on intelligence policy. I have no doubt to help me continue my course that in many situations, perhaps most, we return to peacetime. Well, peace- work even while deployed time isn’t going to happen. So the press silence is the right answer. And overseas. The School of Law measures we adopt today—consti- perhaps, to anticipate one response, tutional rules, statutes, and perhaps secrecy is so important to intelligence- has been incredibly supportive even media ethics principles— gathering that the checks and balances and I really appreciate all won’t be temporary. They won’t go must be provided solely by confiden- that they have done.” away. This doesn’t mean these tial congressional oversight commit- — measures are wrong; they may be tees—not by the press, the public, and good permanent measures to have. the policy experts among the public. Christopher Gidden ’04 But let’s not fool ourselves that we So I hope that the press takes your can have them just for a few months advice very much to heart. Certainly and then return to business as usual. they should think many times before Lieutenant Commander (Select) This is going to be business as usual. publishing anything that might help 17 Christopher Gidden of the U.S. Navy terrorists. But at the same time, the ques- graduated from the University of 2. All the time we limit some freedoms tion, “Who will guard the guardians?” Pennsylvania with a triple major in in order to get some security—and (a question one might also ask about political science, finance, and we have to. Consider the constitu- the press, but that I ask here about the management. He served on active tionally recognized power of the intelligence community), remains. And duty for more than six years in Asia police to search even your home, if we need to guard not just against our and Europe and for the past two they have probable cause and a war- leaders suddenly embracing authoritar- years as a federal special agent rant. Consider airport X-ray search- ianism, but against much more mun- specializing in counterintelligence es. Consider the government’s abili- dane failings as well—failings that and counterterrorism. ty to arrest and detain alleged dan- unfortunately tend to thrive more in gerous criminals, if probable cause is the absence of public scrutiny. present, even before they are tried and convicted. Should we allow still Eugene Volokh ’92 more searches? More detentions? More speech restrictions? Fewer? Professor Eugene Volokh ’92 teaches 3. Unintended Consequences. Finally, constitutional law at the UCLA School we have to remember an obvious but of Law and is the author of a new book, too easily forgotten point: Good The First Amendment: Law, Cases, intentions don’t equal good effects. Problems, and Policy Arguments, Disarming the public is intended to and many law review articles on rights decrease armed violence; but there’s questions. good reason to think that this doesn’t work. Arming airplane passengers, as some now suggest, is intended to facilitate armed resistance to terror- ists; but there’s good reason to think that this won’t work, either.

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 The Law and Beyond The Law and Beyond JILL BROWN ’91

tudents at the UCLA School of Law benefit from a fac- who joined the faculty this year: Russell Korobkin, who is inter- ulty, all of whom excelled in their legal studies and are ested in rational choice theory, Lynn Stout, who brings expert- S recognized as leading scholars in a wide array of legal ise in economics, and Gary Rowe, an American legal historian. subjects. Additionally, many of our professors hold doctorates ■ “One of the many features that makes our faculty so impres- or have significant expertise in fields other than law. These fac- sive is the amazing variety of people with knowledge in other ulty members bring insights from their other disciplines— fields,” says Dean Jonathan Varat. “Their backgrounds enrich anthropology, behavioral science, economics, history, interna- both our curriculum and the scholarship that they produce.” ■ tional relations, Islamic studies, philosophy, political theory, This issue of the magazine takes a look at how these faculty psychology, public policy, and sociology—to their teaching and members bring perspectives from disciplines other than the law scholarship. Among those who employ their training in other to their legal teaching and scholarship. fields to enrich their law teaching and scholarship are three

18 LAW AND ANTHROPOLOGY or America, or another country.” It was He also teaches Community Law, Law the challenge of this “New Africa“ that and Social Change, and Torts. An inter- Michael J. Connell Professor of Law drew Professor Abel’s scholarly attention. national authority on legal anthropolo- Rick Abel remembers his days as a Following completion of his LL.B. gy, he is the editor of African Law graduate student in London, and from Columbia, Professor Abel spent Studies and of the Law & Society Review; speaks with a fond sadness. “Africa two years reading African law and and a member of the editorial boards of was a continent of hope in the mid six- legal anthropology in London, and journals in the law and society fields in ties,” he recalls. “Before we fully real- then did a year of field work in Kenya, the United States, Europe, and Australia. ized the impact of the scourge that is studying the ways in which primary He has served as president of the inter- AIDS, and such sweeping poverty and courts staffed by and serving the national Law & Society Association. famine, there was the excitement of African population had preserved Professor Abel is spending the fall 2001 political change. To its credit, the gov- indigenous notions of law and proce- semester as a visiting professor at New ernment of South Africa called upon dure within European institutions. He York University. scholars from all over the world to par- began teaching at Yale in 1969, and ticipate in constructing its new consti- returned to the University of London Taimie Bryant holds a Ph.D. in tution. The result is a court system that School of Oriental and African Studies, anthropology from UCLA, where she is thoughtful in borrowing what it needs completing his Ph.D. in law followed focused on the substantive fields of from constitutions, court decisions, by an LL.D. from the University of legal and psychological anthropology and policies from all over the world Westminster. He joined the UCLA Law while pursuing various research topics and weaving faculty in 1974 and has been active in in Japan. She teaches courses that com- it into the the Program in Public Interest Law and bine perspectives from anthropology South African Policy and the Concentration in and law, including Japanese Law and rule of law. To Critical Race Studies. His publications Society, Japanese Family Law, Nonprofit this day opin- include critical studies of racism, Organizations, and Animals and the Law. ions from the apartheid, the profession of law, and Professor Bryant’s Animals and the South African lawyers in society. Law course uses case studies and exam- Supreme An expert in the profession of law ination of proposed legislation to give Court might in the United States as well as in students an overview of current social cite cases England and Wales, Professor Abel and legal issues involving food animals,

RICK ABEL from Britain, often teaches courses on that subject. companion animals, laboratory animals,

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 The Law and Beyond

of demographic changes, such as those new ways of thinking about legal reported in the 2000 Census, the Los issues, and both seek to increase the Angeles Times knows whom to call— comfort level of students in dealing Richard Sander, a regular “source” with empirical data and research. In who is always ready with empirical my first-year property course, I follow a studies and expert testimony on policy more conventional curriculum, but I do issues ranging from urban housing to introduce economic analysis at points living wages. Providing insight on along the way, such as in covering nui- many law and econom- sance law and landlord- ics issues, he speaks to tenant law.” TAIMIE BRYANT students in the class- “One of my current room; faculty, govern- projects examines the wild animals, and performing animals. ment agencies, and civic effect of fair housing laws Students read about attitudes toward organizations at collo- upon housing discrimi- animals and farm husbandry practices quia and town hall meet- nation and segregation. in Europe and the U.S., in addition to ings; and to the general We have developed a materials about the laws themselves. public through the media. computer simulation “I also incorporate discussion and He also has written model in which we can materials about non-legal means of widely on public policy, program different improving the condition of animals,” including class-based assumptions about how Professor Bryant explains. RICHARD SANDER affirmative action pro- the housing market and Her scholarship examines the law grams for law school “…the more how the laws will work, within an anthropological context: “I am admissions and housing and then evaluate which interested in questions of how law dramatic change segregation, and has assumptions best describe 19 operates within society—does it only is in the faculty. conducted a series of the realities we observe solidify change that occurs through other Probably a majority leading studies on legal in urban America. This avenues of education and practice? To education and the legal of our recent hires makes discussions of the what extent are legislation and litiga- profession. now have post- law more meaningful: tion part of the processes of change in Professor Sander graduate training We have some idea of society?” Currently, she is analyzing pursued a doctorate in whether particular laws how nonprofit organizations in Japan in some social economics while getting are having an effect, and have operated both before and after the science field, in his law degree at how legal and enforce- 1998 nonprofit incorporation law was addition to legal Northwestern University. ment strategies can passed in Japan. She also writes about His master’s degree in training. Legal improve,” he observes. attitudes toward feral cats and how those economics is from scholarship has Professor Sander attitudes are reflected in local ordinances. Harvard. “I’ve always increased dramati- notices a trend toward had a strong interest in cally in empirical, people coming to the LAW AND ECONOMICS public policy," he says, statistical, and study, practice, and “and it seemed to me teaching of law with an methodological Law and economics are natural partners, that approaching policy interdisciplinary approach sophistication and exploring legal problems through from two fields would and academic back- the lens of economic analysis has give me much more per- over the past grounds beyond the law. become one of the dominant trends in spective, and a wider generation.” He points out that “the legal scholarship. Indeed, even those range of analytical tools.” level and breadth of stu- legal scholars who reject economic His work comes alive dent training is gradually analysis spend much of their time in the classroom. Professor Sander increasing, and I am regularly responding to those who endorse it. A explains, “Two of my courses directly impressed by the projects students are substantial number of our faculty draw on my social science training: I able to carry off. But the more dramat- members regularly bring economic teach Quantitative Methods for Lawyers ic change is in the faculty. Probably a perspectives to the classroom and to in the general law school curriculum, majority of our recent hires now have their writing. and Public Policy Analysis within the post-graduate training in some social When researching stories about public interest law curriculum. Both science field, in addition to legal train- the economic and sociological impact courses aim to introduce students to ing. Legal scholarship has increased

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 The Law and Beyond

dramatically in empirical, statistical, and Economic Organization (“Deals”) for law methodological sophistication over the students and business students in the past generation.” Professor Sander has Anderson School of Management. He worked closely with Dean Jonathan Varat has taught Federal Tax, Corporate Tax, and Associate Dean Myra Saunders to International Tax, Tax Systems in provide better “research infrastruc- Transition, and Contracts. ture” for faculty doing empirical and A popular teacher, Professor Zolt interdisciplinary work. The result: the received UCLA’s Distinguished Teaching UCLA Law Empirical Research Group, Award in 1989, the School of Law’s which in its three years of operation ERIC ZOLT Rutter Award for Excellence in Teaching has already become a model for other in 1997, and has twice been elected by the Eric Zolt’s research and teaching law schools. graduating class as Professor of the Year. interest are in individual, corporate, Professor Zolt says he is anxious to and international taxation and the tax return to Los Angeles before his systems of transitional economies. He already fragile tennis game deterio- joined the UCLA Law faculty in 1985, rates any further. and since July 2000, has been a Visiting Professor at the Harvard Law School, serving as Faculty Director of the International Tax Program, and as the John Harvey Gregory Lecturer on World Organizations. Professor Zolt received a B.S. in JOHN WILEY Economics from the Wharton School, 20 University of Pennsylvania, and a John Wiley integrates economic M.B.A. and J.D. from the University of theory and analysis into his course, Chicago. The following year he became Antitrust Law. “Any good antitrust WILLIAM KLEIN a CPA. He has twice served as the lawyer or scholar must be competent in Jacquin D. Bierman Visiting Professor economic analysis,” he says. Much of Richard C. Maxwell Professor of of Taxation, Yale Law School, and as a this theory is just rigorous common sense, Law Emeritus (recalled to teach) William visiting professor at NYU and Aoyoma as with the notion that “a monopolist Klein, a member of the faculty since Gakuin in Tokyo, Japan. will charge what the traffic will bear.” 1971, majored in economics in college Before practicing law, Professor The key, according to him, is to under- and has found the subject valuable Zolt was a member of the research staff stand the logical core of the theory well throughout his legal career. He has of the Center for Policy Alternatives at enough to describe it in terms that taught and written in the fields of fed- the Massachusetts Institute of every judge and juror can understand. eral income taxation and business Technology. Before beginning teaching, Professor Wiley has received the organizations, and currently co-teaches he was a partner in the Chicago office University-wide Harriet and Charles Elements of Economic Organizations, a of Kirkland & Ellis. He has served in Luckman Distinguished Teaching Award. course offered jointly by the School of two positions at the Office of Tax Policy, A former federal prosecutor, Law and the Anderson Graduate U.S. Department of the Treasury. He Professor Wiley holds an M.A. in eco- School of Management. The course was Deputy Tax Legislative Counsel nomics from UC Berkeley. He combined relies on outside speakers from law and the founder and Director of the economic theory with criminal law and business who describe and explain Treasury’s Tax Advisory Program for topics in two essays for the forthcoming specific “deals.” Students study the rel- Eastern Europe and the former Soviet second edition of the Encyclopedia of evant documents and write papers Union. Working with the IMF, the Crime and Justice: “Economic Crime: examining underlying common ele- World Bank, and the U.S. Treasury Antitrust Offenses“ and (with co-author ments such as allocation of control, Department, Professor Zolt has provided Eric Zolt) “Economic Crime: Tax risk, and return, and the role of incentives technical assistance in reforming tax Offenses.” Professor Wiley’s advice? in mediating conflict of interest. “My systems in over twenty-five countries. “File your returns, and if someone approach can be thought of as applied, Professor Zolt is on the faculty of invites you to join an international or common sense, economics, informed the UCLA Corporate Law Program and price fixing cartel, just say no.” or suggested by formal economics.” co-teaches a course on Elements of In his writing, Professor Klein uses

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 The Law and Beyond

the basic concepts and insights of eco- Professor Bainbridge emphasizes nomic theory but translates them into both the positive and normative uses of plain English. His book, Business economic analysis. “The point of the Organization and Finance, explores eco- positive economic analysis of law is to nomic incentives and their effect on the determine how people are likely to behave organization of economic activity. His under a given legal regime,” he explains. recent article, “Connected Contracts“ (co- “Would issuers of securities voluntarily authored with fellow UCLA Law disclose optimal levels of information in Professors Mitu Gulati and Eric Zolt), the absence of the mandatory disclosure offers the metaphor of connected con- regime, for example?” In making such GILLIAN LESTER tracts for understanding collaborative behavioral predictions, he brings to will resist learning it, or at least enjoy it economic activity, where connected bear modern microeconomic tools— less because they think economics is contracts refers to the interrelating cost-benefit analysis, collective action dull or complex. So every once in a agreements and relationships among theory, decision-making under uncer- while, I disguise lessons from econom- the participants in a business venture. tainty, risk aversion, and the like—on ics by avoiding the use of economic ter- legal rules. In discussing normative minology. Students may think they are uses of law and economics, Professor learning just another policy argument, Bainbridge unabashedly claims that and only later realize that they’ve just “society should make efficient deci- learned the Coase Theorem (or some sions that maximize social wealth.” other important principle from eco- Professor Bainbridge’s scholarship nomic theory),” she explains. likewise focuses on economic analysis Disguised or not, students enjoy of issues in corporate governance and Professor Lester’s approach. According securities regulation. He is the author of to Paul Foust ’02, who took Professor 21 a forthcoming treatise on the law and Lester’s contracts class, “One of my STEPHEN BAINBRIDGE economics of corporations, which offers favorite methods that I learned in her class a unifying method of analyzing them was to analyze which party was best Virtually every faculty member through the use of a few basic tools of suited to avoid a cost or insure against who teaches business law courses law and economics, such as price theo- a loss. Analyzing cases under this principle depends to some extent on economic ry, game theory, and the theory of the frequently offered an explanation for a theory. A prime example is Stephen firm literature. He also has written decision that might otherwise appear Bainbridge, an enthusiastic proponent more than thirty law review articles, all arbitrary. I learned nearly as much of law and economics, which he of which draw on law and economics about economic analysis in that semes- describes as the “most successful to varying degrees. His most recent ter as I did about substantive contract example of intellectual arbitrage in publication, “Mandatory Disclosure: A law, and I continue to use the econom- jurisprudence.“ He introduces eco- Behavioral Analysis,” brings insights ic skills at least as much as I do the nomic analysis into all of his courses, from neoclassical economics, cognitive knowledge of contract principles.” which include Business Associations, psychology, and experimental economics Professor Lester’s writing also is Corporate Finance, Securities Regulation, to the problem of mandatory disclosure increasingly influenced by economic Mergers and Acquisitions, and a seminar in securities regulation. (If Professor theory. In her most recent article, she on corporate governance. In his class- Bainbridge’s approach to law sounds analyzed recent proposals to expand es, economic analysis is never applied scientific, it may be because his mas- eligibility for unemployment insurance to merely for its own sake, it is brought ter’s degree is in chemistry.) include more part-time and low-wage into play gradually and only in workers. “An important component of instances where it adds significant edu- The corporate law curriculum is my analysis was to study the economic cational value. His guiding principle is not the only place that students theory behind insurance, and determine Judge Harry Edwards’ well-known encounter economic theory. Gillian whether law reform proposals were com- remark: “Theory wholly divorced from Lester, an expert in contracts and patible with the predictions of econo- cases has been of no use to me in prac- employment law, also uses economic mists. Bringing an economic analysis to tice.” Yet, Professor Bainbridge clearly theory in her teaching, although often bear on these proposals added a believes that economic theory can facil- surreptitiously. “Sometimes I find that dimension to my article that is lacking itate both the understanding of doc- if I tell students that I am analyzing a in much of the existing legal literature trine and the planning of transactions. case from an economic perspective, they on the subject.”

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 The Law and Beyond

Professor Lester believes that scholars the deduction for state and local taxes. make sense if contracting parties are of employment law can learn a great deal As he explains, “As a general rule, the perfectly rational actors, but otherwise from labor economists, both theoretical federal income tax does not allow be suboptimal. In the field of health and empirical. “Oddly, scholars of labor deductions for private market con- care policy, if all citizens had complete and employment law have been slow sumption (e.g., going to the movies). information and could process extremely to engage the rich economics literature. Tiebout’s model suggests that under large amounts of complex information Conversely, labor economists have certain assumptions local taxes will perfectly and accurately as basic econom- tended to ignore the finer institutional approximate market prices. Focusing ic theory assumes, we probably would details of labor markets, including how on local taxation, my analysis seeks to not need a ’patient’s bill of rights.‘ In a less existing legal regimes affect behavior. identify those situations where perfect world, however, we probably do.” These complementary omissions open up Tiebout’s conditions are likely to hold The same style of analysis defines a wide territory for scholarly exploration. and those where it will not. More Professor Korobkin’s scholarly research. My work is part of that exploration.” specifically, I am investigating the pos- “In articles on contract formation, set- sibility that local income homogeneity tlement negotiations, health care policy, may serve as a proxy for the extent to and general legal theory, I have challenged which local taxes are more likely to the economic orthodoxy on what moti- approximate market prices.” vates citizens to act and have reconsidered Professor Stark was elected Professor law and legal systems from the resulting of the Year in 1999. perspective. My forthcoming casebook on negotiation, which relies heavily on New faculty member Russell economics and psychology, considers Korobkin is interested in “rational both the dynamics of bargaining choice theory,” which assumes that between perfectly economically rational 22 KIRK STARK people always will act so as to maxi- actors and the psychological factors mize their self-interest. “In all of my that can cause negotiators to deviate Tax specialist Kirk Stark is interested classes, we analyze law assuming from this model in practice.” in the area of public finance economics, rational choice theory is accurate, and particularly issues relating to fiscal fed- conversely challenge economic theory eralism and local public finance. In his by considering the reasons rational taxation classes, he introduces econom- choice theory might be descriptively ic theories in a variety of ways. “In my inaccurate and considering how this multistate tax course I introduce stu- would affect our view of law,” he says. dents to the Tiebout Hypothesis, His course, Law and Behavioral Science,is advanced by economist Charles devoted completely to this type of Tiebout in an influential 1956 article. analysis—first using economic theory Tiebout posited that the market for and then challenging it from compet-

public goods at the local level is com- ing perspectives, such as cognitive and LYNN STOUT parable to a private market because of social psychology. In Professor Korobkin’s taxpayer mobility and competition other classes, he uses the same New business law faculty member among local jurisdictions to attract approach to analyze discrete topics. Lynn Stout applies various theories of mobile taxpayers. The Tiebout model, “In Contracts, for example, certain economics to her teaching and scholar- and the vast literature it has spawned, remedies for breach of contract might ship of the law. Coming to UCLA from has important implications for the the Georgetown University Law Center, study of state and local tax systems, where she was Professor of Law and which are shaped by the market forces Director of the Sloan Project on of taxpayer mobility and interjurisdic- Business Institutions, she teaches tional competition.” Business Associations, Securities Regulation, Similarly, much of Professor and Law and Economics. Professor Stout Stark’s scholarship relates to local public regularly employs economic ideas in finance and the Tiebout Hypothesis. each of these classes and in her schol- He currently is working on an article arship. “I think this sort of analysis is a concerning the implications of the good way to encourage students to Tiebout model for how we think about think carefully about what our society RUSSELL KOROBKIN

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 The Law and Beyond

is trying to accomplish and the trade- Procedure lends itself a bit less to ’his- offs we have to make in the process,” torical’ treatment, but I do generally she says. In keeping with her general think that doctrinal developments in enthusiasm for economic analysis, law, like all conceptual developments, Professor Stout is the co-author of a are best understood ’genetically’—with a series of casebooks on law and eco- sense of how they emerged. Thus, a nomics and past President of the AALS classic illustration, with which all civil Section on Law and Economics. She procedure teachers are familiar, is the received her M.P.A. from Princeton move in the world of personal jurisdic- concurrently with her law degree from tion from the nineteenth-century world JONATHAN ZASLOFF Yale. She does not follow the Chicago of Pennoyer v. Neff with its emphasis on school approach of assuming that the physical presence to the ’minimum Jonathan Zasloff, who teaches Torts, market is always right. “To the con- contacts’ regime of International Shoe. It Criminal Justice Policy, Administrative trary, I think the more interesting prob- really does exemplify the change in Law, and Legal History, has an M.A. in lems in economics are those that arise law from formal, categorical thinking, history from Harvard and is complet- when the market gets it wrong. I also to the world of ’reasonableness’ and ing his doctoral dissertation. He uses disagree with the neoclassic model of ’balancing.’ Understanding what the historical information to help students human behavior as always rational law changed from helps us understand place legal materials in context. “For and selfish. I think that people are what the law changed to. I also think example, torts students are often frus- often irrational and altruistic, and I that the arcana of pleading, the distinc- trated reading the ever-present have recently become interested in tion between law and equity, and Cardozo opinions, mainly because exploring these phenomena in my numerous other quirks of civil proce- they can’t seem to draw a rule out of scholarship.” dure are better understood when given them. I try to put Cardozo’s approach a little historical context.” to judging in context—by say, talking 23 LAW AND HISTORY Michael Weinberger ’02 describes to them about Langdellian formalism, Professor Spillenger’s American Legal and how Cardozo represented the Three law school faculty members who History course as “fascinating“ and where beginnings of a rebellion against that are completing Ph.D.s in history enrich he “taught the evolution of American approach. There’s a nice passage from the curriculum not only by teaching legal law not just as a set of formalistic rules The Nature of the Judicial Process where history, but also by making strictly “legal“ that are occasionally overturned. Cardozo talks about searching for clarity subjects like Torts and Civil Procedure Rather, he helped us understand the and being totally unable to find it. I more understandable to students. evolution of law as a bumpy history— then point out to them that Cardozo’s reflecting the experiences and problems frank admission of these things was that our growing country faced. . . regarded at the time as (in Grant Ultimately, the class reinforced a notion Gilmore’s words), ’the judicial equiva- I already had about the importance of lent of hard-core pornography’ (which studying history, but it also made me always gets a laugh). This also allows more appreciative of the often cynical me to make a broader point: that often study of law.” there isn’t ’an answer’ to a legal prob- Much of Professor Spillenger’s lem—what makes the good lawyer is scholarly work has focused on Louis his or her ability to frame questions Brandeis. “I find Brandeis an interesting and facts, and argue for competing

CLYDE SPILLENGER figure from a personal or psychological positions based upon previous cases.” point of view, not as a disembodied Professor Zasloff’s legal scholar- Clyde Spillenger earned his M.Phil. icon. The choices he made in particular ship consists of historical pieces. He in history from Yale. His interests are in situations are what interest me. I am recently completed a piece attempting American legal and constitutional history interested in exploring the dilemmas, to trace the influence of legal theory on but extend beyond that into American legal and otherwise, faced by cultures U.S. foreign policy from 1900 to 1920. intellectual, cultural, and political history. or historical figures, as a way of illumi- “In general,” he explains, “I think that He teaches American Legal History and nating our own.” historical work is important because it also brings a historical perspective to contextualizes law and shows the con- Conflict of Laws, Constitutional Law, and tingency of the present arrangement— Civil Procedure. As he explains, “Civil the latter point is also very good for

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 The Law and Beyond

teaching. It forces us to modify and become firmly established as the starting nuance social scientific theories that premise for constitutional law thinking. might be parsimonious, but can’t explain Showing that the traditional vision of enough facts. History and social science Lochner rested on a faulty foundation, work well together—social science by consequently, had the potential to providing overarching theory, and history utterly shake up constitutional law, and by bringing theory down to earth and this destabilizing possibility helped avoiding simplistic explanations.” explain why the traditional view of Lochner, though discarded in the most sophisticated histories, had not yet KHALED ABOU EL FADL been displaced among constitutional law Speaking in God’s Name: Islamic Law, scholars. In short, I tried to demon- Authority and Women, as well as The strate the way in which constitutional Authoritative and Authoritarian in Islamic history and constitutional law inter- Discourse. Additionally, he has two more sected and influenced one another, for books that have just been published: better and for worse.” And God Knows the Soldiers and Rebellion and Violence in Islamic Law. See the ISLAMIC LAW Faculty section of this magazine for more GARY ROWE on Professor Abou El Fadl’s recent books. Khaled Abou El Fadl, the Omar and Gary Rowe joined the faculty this Azmeralda Alfi Distinguished Fellow PHILOSOPHY AND summer, after spending the last several in Islamic Law, is one of the leading years pursuing his doctorate in history authorities in Islamic law in the United POLITICAL THEORY 24 at Princeton University. His primary States and Europe. He has studied interest is in American legal history, espe- Islamic law both in Egypt and Kuwait Seven School of Law faculty members cially the early American republic. His and in the United States, where he hold advanced degrees in philosophy or work examines the constitutional land- received a Ph.D. from Princeton in political theory, and one is self-taught in scape before courts obtained a monop- Islamic studies. moral philosophy. They bring philo- oly over determining constitutional In addition to courses in Islamic and sophical insights to their teaching, not meaning. This year, he is teaching Middle Eastern legal systems, Professor only in obvious courses that combine Federal Courts and Civil Procedure. Abou El Fadl teaches Immigration Law, law and philosophy, but also in more Professor Rowe holds an M.A. in Middle Eastern Investment Law, and strictly “legal“ courses like Contracts, modern history from Princeton and an other courses related to human rights Criminal Law, and Ethics. And in their M.St. in history from Oxford. While at and terrorism. He says of his classroom scholarship, these faculty members use Princeton he taught English constitution- approach, “I think that I tend to philosophical analysis to create novel al and American legal history. He is emphasize the dynamics between law approaches to topics ranging from the- currently at work on his doctoral thesis, and society—the way that the law reflects ories of punishment to questions of the The Practice of Constitutionalism in the the social search for self-definition and intellectual property rights of the Early Republic, 1787–1840. identity. Most definitely, I am constantly human genome. In a recent essay on the Lochner drawing on examples from other legal As an undergraduate at UCLA, era published in Law and Social Inquiry, systems, and I tend to approach all Herb Morris developed a keen interest Professor Rowe recounts how contem- legal problems from a comparative in philosophy, literature, and psycho- porary scholars have nearly demolished perspective. I do not treat American the traditional view that Lochner-era law as simply a product of the American judges simply and wrongly imposed experience, but I tend to approach it as the personal preferences of their class part of the international discourse on on the nation. “In that piece,” he the nature, role, and function of law.” explains, “I attempted to show how the Professor Abou El Fadl’s scholar- needs of constitutional law shaped the ship is exclusively in the field of way histories of the Lochner era were Islamic and comparative law. His most constructed. The older vision of the recent books include: Conference of the Lochner era, to which contemporary Books: The Search for Beauty in Islam and revisionist scholars were reacting, had HERB MORRIS

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 The Law and Beyond

analysis. Following graduation, he Legal Philosophy and Moral Psychology, He first tackled questions of moral attended Yale and earned his law and a 1999 article, “The Future of responsibility in the context of the degree. Then he experienced “a resur- Punishment,” for the UCLA Law Review. insanity defense and the defense of gence of philosophic interest“ and traveled Professor Morris’ scholarship as diminished capacity in articles such as to Oxford, where he studied the philoso- well as his teaching calls for perspective “The Diminished Capacity and phy of law under the legendary H.L.A. from both disciplines. “Law generally, Diminished Responsibility Defenses: Hart (as did Stephen Munzer) and was but most vividly criminal law, is Two Children of a Doomed Marriage” examined for his doctorate by the leader embedded in human life and the most (Columbia Law Review 1977). He then of Oxford’s school of ordinary lan- fundamental questions of human began to explore a “character-based” or guage philosophy, J.L. Austin. Later in responsibility and our practice of praise “moral capacities” model of moral his career, starting in 1976, he spent and blaming in everyday life connects agency, as distinguished from a more twelve years as a Research Clinical closely with basic issues of criminal law.” conventional “conduct attribution” or Associate at the Southern California Infusing philosophy into subjects “rational choice” model that focuses Psychoanalytic Institute. of law, particularly dealing with issues of primarily on what a defendant has Professor Morris has held joint punishment is demanding, so Professor done and whether he or she had a fair appointments in the School of Law and Morris is gratified to have more educated chance to act otherwise. His propos- the Department of Philosophy since and experienced students pursuing als—well articulated in “Convicting 1959. He served as Dean of Humanities law. “I notice the trend and there is no the Morally Blameless: Reassessing the of UCLA’s College of Letters and question that the more broadly and Relationship Between Legal and Moral Science from 1983 to 1993 and Interim deeply educated the students, the richer Accountability” (UCLA Law Review Provost of the College during and deeper the class discussion,” he says. 1992)—would ask, before assigning 1992–1993. He chaired the Board of criminal culpability, whether a defen- Governors of the University’s Humanities dant is an appropriate moral agent by Research Institute from 1988 to 1990. examining the three critical attributes 25 He is a Professor of Law Emeritus of moral understanding, moral respon- recalled to teach Criminal Law and, siveness, and causally efficacious occasionally, Legal Philosophy. moral motivation. His scholarship in To learn even basic criminal law this area not only explores what capac- from Professor Morris is an experience ities a person must possess to qualify to treasure. “Apart from my interest in as moral agent, but also undermines the law, I have long had interests in retributivist justifications for criminal and some modest knowledge of philos- PETER ARNELLA punishment. ophy, literature, and psychoanalysis. Professor Arenella’s philosophical Great literature, of course, be it the works Shortly after joining the faculty in insights have enriched his classroom, of Sophocles, Shakespeare, Dostoyevsky, 1987, Peter Arenella—already a noted as well as the many academics and courts or countless others, concerns itself with teacher and scholar of constitutional who regularly draw on his work. The crime, guilt, and punishment. And so it criminal procedure and criminal law at 1999 recipient of the UCLA School of is natural to illustrate themes within Boston University who had clerked for Law’s Rutter Award for Excellence in criminal law by drawing attention to how the Chief Justice of the Massachusetts Teaching, and holder of Boston these themes surface in literature. The Supreme Judicial Court and practiced University’s highest award for teaching basic concepts of criminal law, concepts criminal law as both a public defender excellence before he joined our faculty, such as culpability, guilt, and punishment, and private counsel—expanded his he has taught seminars on criminal law are concepts I have dealt with in my scholarship, and eventually his teaching, excuse theory and moral culpability. In philosophic work. My most fundamen- to address more deeply the broad prob- his advanced criminal law courses, he tal interest over a long period of time lem of punishing persons who may not includes readings from moral psychol- has been with the concept of guilt and be fully morally responsible. ogy and moral philosophy to provide a I have written rather extensively on Professor Arenella is a self-taught conceptual framework for considering punishment, its meaning, and its justi- moral philosopher, whose impressive issues relating to moral responsibility fication from a philosophic point of view.“ accomplishments in exploring funda- for criminal acts. Students interested in Professor Morris has written widely mental connections between moral moral philosophy find these courses—as in the area of legal philosophy and the philosophy and criminal law have well as his basic courses in criminal philosophy of punishment, including the been acknowledged by many leading, law and criminal procedure—exciting, book, On Guilt and Innocence: Essays in formally educated legal philosophers. provocative, stimulating and thought-

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 The Law and Beyond

provoking. Gary Chartier ’01 declared Professor Munzer believes that his human actions have causes or not—an himself “gratified by [Professor philosophical background also influ- issue that he describes as “an arcane Arenella’s] attention to the fundamen- ences the way he teaches Property and question but relevant to the never-ending tal moral and political questions raised Contracts to first-year students, albeit squabble between free will and deter- by the criminal law”—a sentiment indirectly, through his focus on argu- minism.” Since joining the law faculty shared by many students. ment—a key feature of philosophical in 1982, his philosophical interests thinking. “I try to get students to focus have further shifted to the philosophy carefully on the various steps in the of punishment and questions about the arguments that they encounter— nature and validity of law. whether those arguments are present Professor Dolinko integrates his in judicial opinions or are expressed in philosophical interests into his courses, class by me or their fellow students. I help Criminal Law and Constitutional Criminal them develop skills in picking apart Procedure, and generally writes about legal arguments. This is one place where issues concerning the philosophical foun- I think that the qualities of mind useful dations and ramifications of legal doc- in philosophy can also prove highly trines rather than the law itself. He

STEPHEN MUNZER useful to law students and lawyers.” draws students’ attention to the foun- Students praise Professor Munzer’s dations and validity of the various con- Oxford-educated philosophy scholar focus on argument and reasoning. cepts and rules whose mastery is a vital Stephen Munzer, before entering law “After picking apart a court’s argument part of the course content. “For example, teaching, taught philosophy at Rutgers with a student, he would look up with a in the criminal law class, I like to explore University, where his interests crystal- quizzical expression and ask frankly, issues like whether it should ever be lized around moral and political phi- ’Do you buy it?’ It was empowering as a legally permissible—noncriminal—for 26 losophy and the philosophy of law. first-year student to know that we could someone to take the life of an innocent Professor Munzer teaches a seminar, disagree with the arguments of these human being because doing so is the Property and Biotechnology, in which he cornerstones of contract law, and that only way to save his own life. As helps students understand that it is there were other, sometimes better, solu- another example, I’ll devote some important not only to learn the relevant tions out there,” says Jeremy Gladstone attention to puzzling over the curious fact legal doctrine and life sciences back- ’03. “On my final exam, Professor that an unsuccessful attempt to commit ground, but also to appreciate the Munzer praised the reasoning I used on a crime (especially a really serious one philosophical aspects of these issues. one question and gave me a high score for like murder) commonly carries a lesser “For instance,” he explains, “to decide that question even though the conclusion sentence than the successful crime, yet whether there ought to be intellectual I reached completely contradicted his the difference can often turn on factors property rights in genes or gene frag- model answer,” adds Hailyn Chen ’03. totally outside the control or the culpabili- ments it is essential to get a clear ty of the defendant. If John and Jane both understanding of what having such try to kill people, and John succeeds but rights would mean, their metes and Jane happens not to because (unknown to bounds, and the ways in which such her) her intended victim was wearing a rights might be philosophically justified. bulletproof vest, why should Jane get a A quite different example has to do lesser sentence? She’s every bit as ’guilty’ with courses and seminars pertaining as John in her intentions and desires, to modifications of the human body or, and took the same steps to effectuate as I call them, bodily inscriptions. I am those intentions, and is just as ’socially trying to work through a project that dangerous’—this is the kind of puzzle I

emphasizes meaning and identity in DAVID DOLINKO love to direct students’ attention to.” bodily inscriptions. One question that I “The largest group of my publica- try to get students to wrestle with is David Dolinko was a graduate tions has concerned what I argue are whether sex-reassignment surgeries student in philosophy at UCLA for the weaknesses and the dangers of the and treatments really change sex in a eight years before entering the UCLA currently prevalent retributive justifi- metaphysical or biological sense, or School of Law. After graduating from cation for criminal punishment.” whether they merely produce alter- law school, he finished his dissertation In 1998, Professor Dolinko ations that suffice for recognizing a and obtained his Ph.D. His dissertation received the School of Law’s Rutter change in gender or legal status.” concerned the questions of whether Award for Excellence in Teaching.

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 The Law and Beyond

doctrine of unconscionability in con- He encouraged my attempts to think tract law rests on paternalistic con- through the links between constitu- cerns. She explains, “One hazard of some tional structures and philosophical purely philosophical writing is that it’s ideas in ways that made his course a quite general. I find that looking at a great deal of fun.” concrete legal issue helps in making Professor Gardbaum’s scholarship progress with the philosophical issues.” has focused on constitutional law and the foundations of liberal legal and political theory, and his current SEANA SHIFFRIN research is in the area of comparative constitutional law and, in particular, Another Oxford-educated philoso- the comparative structure of constitu- phy scholar, Seana Shiffrin, holds a tional rights. “One work-in-progress, joint appointment with the UCLA ’The New Commonwealth Model of Department of Philosophy. As a Marshall Constitutionalism,’ analyses a new, Scholar at Oxford University, she spe- hybrid form of judicial review devel- cialized in political and moral philosophy oped in Canada, New Zealand, and the and Kant. At the School of Law, she STEPHEN GARDBAUM United Kingdom that enables the legis- teaches Constitutional Rights and Individual lature to have the final say on whether Autonomy, which explores different Political theorist Stephen Gardbaum, rights trump legislation that conflicts conceptions of individual rights in con- who practiced law in England before with them,” Professor Gardbaum stitutional jurisprudence. In the course, coming to the United States, received explains. “The second analyzes various Professor Shiffrin and her students explore his Ph.D. in political science from approaches to the issue of whether, and topics such as the right to abortion, the Columbia. His dissertation analyzed to what extent, constitutional norms 27 right to die, and freedom of speech, by and critiqued communitarian political bind private actors.” analyzing Supreme Court cases and dis- theory, and his current interests in the cussing leading theoretical articles from field are in autonomy and liberal theory. law reviews and philosophical journals. Professor Gardbaum introduces Says Professor Shiffrin. “In many several concepts from political theory introductory courses that, by necessity, into his Comparative Constitutional Law survey a wide swath of material, stu- course, such as (a) the concept of con- dents read cases anthropologically. stitutionalism, in which liberalism and They see a landscape of competing democratic theory are central issues, interests and arguments but they dis- (b) the compatibility of judicial review tance themselves from them. They and democracy, and (c) whether posi- tive constitutional rights or having don’t make themselves identify with RANDALL PEERENBOOM the views behind the case or develop constitutions bind private actors are and defend their own views. I try to go problematic from a liberal/autonomy Randall Peerenboom, who teaches more slowly through the cases and perspective. in the areas of international and com- force students not just to describe what “For me, the theoretical focus parative law, with an emphasis on others’ positions have been, but also to Professor Gardbaum adopted made his Chinese law, obtained his Ph.D. in phi- be responsible for and defend their comparative constitutional law course losophy from the University of Hawaii, own positions. I think it’s a useful especially interesting,” says former where he specialized in pragmatism, approach because it helps students to student Gary Chartier ’01. “Designing social-political philosophy, legal phi- develop legal advocacy skills.” a constitution forces a country and its losophy, and Chinese philosophy. He In her scholarship, Professor Shiffrin intellectual and political leaders to takes a philosophical approach both in uses philosophic methods to analyze address philosophical issues that his survey class, which examines the particular legal doctrines and the justi- might ordinarily be far from the top of rule of law in Chinese society, and his fications for them. In her recent article, the national agenda. I appreciated course in international human rights, “Paternalism, Unconscionability Doctrine Professor Gardbaum’s attempt to ask where he focuses on the difficult philo- and Accommodation,“ published in repeatedly about the conceptual sophical issues raised by human rights, Philosophy and Public Affairs, she chal- underpinnings of the constitutional supplementing the text with readings lenges the traditional view that the structures on which our class reflected. on different philosophical theories.

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 The Law and Beyond

Professor Peerenboom brings his prisons assumes that the only relevant law is filtered through the lens of politics. background in philosophy to his writing considerations are cost savings, harm “The main challenge in understanding on Chinese law. In his recent book on the to inmates, and overall standards of care. international law is understanding the rule of law in China, he develops alter- And as a result, policymakers have ways in which international law affects native philosophical conceptions of the ignored the important consideration of state behavior independent of power rule of law, rather than simply assuming the political legitimacy of that policy in politics,” he explains. His book on the China will develop a liberal democratic a liberal democracy. development of international environ- rule of law. He also explores the ways mental law in international trade in which China’s indigenous philosoph- POLITICAL SCIENCE organizations examines the relationship ical traditions influence contemporary AND INTERNATIONAL between the development of environ- understandings of law and human rights. mental law and the power structure of RELATIONS international trade organizations such as NAFTA and the WTO. “Environmental Two of the faculty members who bring law is greener and more developed in to the School of Law an extensive back- international trade organizations where ground in international relations are power is concentrated in the hands of Richard Steinberg and Kal Raustiala. wealthier, greener states.” Richard Steinberg, who teaches International Trade Law, International Business Transactions, and Theories of International Law, earned his Ph.D. in political science (international rela- SHARON DOLOVICH tions) from Stanford. He believes that one cannot think about international 28 Sharon Dolovich received her law without drawing on political, eco- Ph.D. in political theory from nomic, and sociological analytical Cambridge University before attend- models, saying, “The biggest intellec- ing law school. Her background in tual wave in international law in the political theory informs her theoretical KAL RAUSTIALA last thirty years is the application of approach to teaching legal ethics, international relations theory to under- which involves examining the justifica- Kal Raustiala holds a Ph.D from U.C. standing international law.” tions underlying the ethical rules. She San Diego in international relations helps students learn not only the ethi- and comparative politics. He studies cal rules, but also helps them examine multilateral agreements with a specific the arguments behind the justifications focus on environmental protection. for the rules. Her training in political Professor Raustiala’s background in theory, she says, “pushes you to figure political science is central to the way he out the categories and concepts under- teaches International Environmental Law pinning the rules we take for granted.” and Public International Law. He explains, The focus of her ethics course, in addi- “For international law courses, under- tion to giving her students a sense of standing the law is only half the bat- the social and political framework for tle—at best. What is also critical is how RICHARD STEINBERG the regulation of the legal profession, is world politics and domestic politics “trying to unpack the concept of zeal- shape the use and role of international Professor Steinberg describes his ous advocacy,” which she describes as law, and vice versa. Sometimes, for course, International Trade Law, as an the major conceptual building block of example in understanding the legality effort to understand the development the adversary system in which law stu- of the NATO intervention in Kosovo, of that body of law through three com- dents will practice. legal analysis necessarily draws on the peting analytics: liberalism, realism, Professor Dolovich’s writing focuses facts of international relations and and constructivism—an effort growing on the intersection between criminal changes in our conceptions of core out of sociology and linguistics that justice policy and political theory. In ideas such as ’sovereignty’ and the defines law as a social construction. her in-progress article, “The Ethics of ’state.’ More generally, because inter- Similarly, everything Professor Private Prisons,” she argues that the national law is the product of state Steinberg writes about international policy debate surrounding private choices, specific rules—such as those

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 The Law and Beyond

governing global climate change— nitive science as law, both because it is the implications for structuring advo- make sense only with an understand- intrinsically interesting, and because so cacy in such fields. He also is also ing of international politics.” much of it is relevant to practicing and working on a much larger project and Professor Raustiala’s scholarship teaching law.” accompanying text, Creativity in Law, draws extensively on Interestingly, which explains how creative approach- theories of international Professor Blasi is a mem- es to solving legal problems arise and relations and domestic ber of the Bar, but never spread. Professor Blasi says of his proj- politics. He is currently received his J.D. He does ect, “Much more than psychology is working on an analysis of hold a master’s in political involved, but every creative move in why states sometimes science from Harvard and the law certainly involves what goes negotiate legally binding apprenticed with lawyers on in individual minds, particularly agreements and other to qualify for the Bar. through the application of analogies times nonbinding agree- Professor Blasi teaches from one field to another. And it is psy- ments, and on a study of clinical and public inter- chological processes as well as social compliance with interna- GARY BLASI est lawyering courses, structures that determine whether tional law, co-authored including Clinical Seminar potential innovations survive and spread with Anne-Marie Professor Blasi in Public Policy Advocacy. or simply fade away.” Slaughter of Harvard “I believe that situated, calls psychology Law School. practical experience of a “foundational the kind we provide in the PSYCHOLOGY subject for clinical program is essen- lawyering, much tial to putting future Before joining the UCLA as physics is a lawyers on the path to Law faculty, Gary Blasi expertise. Essential, but 29 foundational sub- spent twenty years doing not sufficient. We also complex litigation on ject for engineers. must try to provide con- behalf of the homeless Law in the real ceptual frameworks and and poor. Upon stepping world is mainly theories that help all of ROBERT GOLDSTEIN us make sense of our up to the lectern, an about people, how experienced lawyer but experience. I try to do Before attending law school, Robert they think, what novice teacher, he set out that in all the courses I Goldstein completed all requirements to learn what other disci- they do, and how teach: to provide men- except his dissertation for a Ph.D. in plines know about how they can be per- tored experience and as clinical psychology, including a clinical deep as possible a theo- internship through the Harvard novices become experts, suaded to think so that he could do a bet- retical understanding of Medical School. Professor Goldstein’s or do something ter job of expediting that what’s going on.” training in clinical psychology gives transition in both himself differently. It is Virtually all of him a broader understanding of the and his students. He therefore hard Professor Blasi’s scholar- law of abortion and child abuse and sees effecting that transi- for me to think ship has been influenced neglect, two areas about which he tion as the main job of by his interdisciplinary teaches and writes. of anything that clinical teaching. He work in psychology and Professor Goldstein’s interdiscipli- encountered much litera- lawyers do that cognitive science. He is nary course, Child Abuse and Neglect, ture on novice/ expert is unrelated to the author of the influen- brings together law students and stu- differences and the psychology.” tial article, “What Lawyers dents from the schools of Education, acquisition of expertise, Know: Lawyering Expert- Medicine, Nursing, Psychology, Public which, in turn, led him ise, Cognitive Science, Health, and Social Welfare. “Child more generally into cognitive science. and the Functions of Theory.” And his abuse is a topic that can’t adequately He says, “Apart from a couple of recent article, “Advocacy and be addressed solely through looking at undergraduate courses, I am self- Attribution: Shaping and Responding to the coercive methods of the legal sys- taught in psychology (as well as law). Perceptions of the Causes of tem,” he says. “You also need the input But I now find myself sitting on Ph.D. Homelessness,” examines differences of psychology and social welfare theo- committees in the Psychology in the perceived causes of social prob- ry in order to understand and treat the Department and reading as much cog- lems like homelessness or poverty and victim and the abuser.” Similarly,

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 The Law and Beyond

Professor Goldstein’s textbook on child Down from Bureaucracy: The Ambiguity and often untrained caseworkers were abuse and neglect introduces students of Privatization and Empowerment. Of expected to track an overwhelming to relevant psychological considera- his work, Amherst College’s Austin caseload of relief clients. Students tions, such as the memory debate in Sarat commented, “Handler demon- learned how these stressful, demanding, child abuse cases, emotional reactions strates a stunning grasp of a wide vari- and often exhausting working condi- of lawyers to child abuse cases, and the ety of research and scholarship. He is tions could lead to dehumanizing the phenomenon of counter-transference. clearly among the best students of public client, how clients with problems became In his book, Mother-Love and policy in the United States.” problems.” Abortion: A Legal Interpretation, Professor Professor Handler, who holds a Increasingly, students come to the Goldstein argues that psychoanalytic joint appointment with the UCLA study of law after completing advanced theory’s understanding of the relation- School of Law and the UCLA School of degrees or with professional experi- ship between mother and child provides Public Policy and Social Research, also ence in another field. Additionally, the a more coherent foundation for the law directs UCLA Law’s Foreign Graduate School of Law offers seven joint degree of abortion than the traditional focus Program, acting as an advisor to the programs as well as concentrations of on competing interests between a L.L.M candidates. “I’ve always been study available to students who wish woman and the state. According to him, interested in comparative law and to incorporate a more interdisciplinary “It doesn’t make sense to view the law social systems,” Professor Handler approach to their training. The added of abortion by relying on the individu- explains, “in the summer of my sopho- experience and academic strengths alistic categories that adults use in con- more year in college I spent three enhance the richness of the classroom ceiving the world.” months studying the labor movement discussion and contributions, in England, and ever since, I’ve been “Especially,” says Professor Handler, SOCIOLOGY AND fascinated by how other countries deal “in a class like Poverty Law.” PUBLIC POLICY with their social policies and how some 30 governments want to move more Joel Handler, the Richard C. Maxwell towards models of a welfare system.” Professor of Law, has written, co- Professor Handler has held fellowships authored, or edited some twenty books and has consulted with both national and more than fifty scholarly chapters and international organizations. He and articles, nearly all of which explore was president of the Law & Society the sociology and public policy issues Association and in 1999 was honored of the systems that address poverty with the coveted ACLU Distinguished law. Although Professor Handler does Professor’s Award for Civil Liberties not hold an advanced degree beyond Education. LAURA GOMEZ his Juris Doctorate, he has, since 1960, “I think that in Poverty Law, the immersed himself in public policy name of the game is the street-level: Laura Gómez earned her Ph.D. in scholarship and the sociological realities the interactions between the low-visi- sociology from Stanford concurrently of welfare, labor, law, and bureaucracy. bility caseworker’s discretionary deci- with her law degree. An expert in the He was awarded the American Political sions and the client. Statutory law and sociology of the law, Chicano/a stud- Science Association’s 1997 Gladys M. especially administrative regulations at ies, and race relations, she teaches Kaemmerer Award for the “best politi- the state and local level are crucially Latinos/as and the Law, Criminal Law, cal science publication in the field of important—not court opinions,” Law and Society, and Comparative U.S. national policy“ for his book, explained Professor Handler. And his Racialization and the American Legal students benefit greatly from that soci- System, which explores how the legal ological viewpoint. “One day, my class system has historically worked both to had provided advocacy services for reinforce and reduce racial distinctions General Relief applicants. We were and racism. She holds a joint appoint- ’wrapping up’ when one case worker ment with the School of Law and the asked us, ’You’re here to represent the Department of Sociology. She is the applicants. Who represents us?’ And founding co-director of UCLA Law’s then,” enthused Professor Handler, “a Concentration in Critical Race Studies. new education for us began. That dis- “A sociological approach influences cussion showed our students, in concrete all the courses I teach,” she says. “Mainly, terms, that overworked, underpaid, the idea is to place legal doctrine and JOEL HANDLER

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Civility

legal practice (courts, lawyers, legisla- tures) in a larger sociological and his- torical context. Where I can, I introduce the students to social science research CIVILITY methods and data, so that there is an empirical grounding for claims about Law is a learned and noble profes- how the legal system works.” LAW SCHOOL’S sion. The profession has made ethical “When I teach first-year Criminal ROLE IN conduct and the development of high- Law (a required course first semester), TEACHING er standards of integrity a top priority I situate the primary source materials— in law schools; professors weave les- appellate decisions—into a criminal CIVILITY sons of ethics and professional stan- process context. I think it’s important Jonathan D. Varat dards into core academic and clinical for students to know, for instance, that course work at every level. Moot court only some crimes lead to arrests and that, Excerpts from an article originally appearing as and mock trial opportunities train in many jurisdictions, more than ninety- a “Golden Rule” in the May 31, 2001 edition of future litigators to be sharp on their five percent of prosecuted cases don’t the LA Daily Journal as part of a forum on feet, not in their attitudes. Students are go to trial. Appellate cases are, literally, ethics for litigators. reminded that lawyers are held to the tip of the iceberg, in the context of higher standards of conduct than oth- the entire criminal justice system.” Recently, lawyers and the general pop- ers and are urged to pursue their pub- Professor Gómez views herself as ulace have become concerned about lic and private goals professionally and “a sociologist who writes about legal attorneys’ increasing rudeness and responsibly through ethical conduct. actors and legal systems.” She is the unduly harsh behavior. In response to Law schools provide mentors for author of Misconceiving Mothers: this nationwide epidem- law students and newly Legislators, Prosecutors and the Politics of ic, some courts have minted associates, and 31 “Education series with Prenatal Drug Exposure, an empirical adopted codes of behav- effective ways for sea- study of how two California institu- ior. Some bar associa- soned practitioners to such names as the tions constructed and responded to the tions have implemented impart strategies, wis- “crack baby“ problem in the late 1980s. educational programs dom, and grace. Many Rambo Abatement Recently, she published “Race, Crime with such telling names law schools also provide a and Colonialism: Mexicans and the as the Rambo Abatement forum for dialogue among Program should American Criminal Justice System in Program in order to curb practitioners, ethicists, Territorial New Mexico“ in the Law & the excesses of lawyers curb the excesses and academics about the Society Review. The article takes both a who believe that it is state of the profession historical and sociological approach to acceptable, even desir- of attorneys who and the issue of civility. politics, race, and crime, arguing that able, to make others mis- These activities can the law sometimes plays unexpected erable. believe it is make a difference in the and even empowering roles for racial Perhaps economic quality of the profession minorities, citing the example of the pressure has led some acceptable to make for years to come. dominance of Mexicans on juries in lawyers to succumb to criminal trials of European-American the lowest common others miserable.” Jonathan D. Varat is defendants in some nineteenth-century denominator in the false Dean of the UCLA New Mexico counties. belief that tough means School of Law. abrasive, that zealous means uncaring, or that effective advocacy means indif- The excerpts on the following page are drawn ference to the facts. from the responses we received from Dean Passion does not substitute for Varat’s article. We encourage your response. fairness, and intensity does not erase Please write to [email protected] or to the obligations of empathy and truth. The School of Law, Suite 951476, Los Angeles, CA ends do not justify the means, and no 90095, Attn: Regina McConahay less than the rule of law is at stake when that maxim is compromised. The advocate who maintains decorum in and out of the courtroom is the winner.

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Civility

CIVILITY The Hon. Richard D. Fybel ’71 serves as THE GOLDEN ENHANCES Judge for the Orange County Superior RULE LOOKS Court. He is a former partner at Morrison THE CRIMINAL & Foerster. TARNISHED JUSTICE SYSTEM Bruce A. Clemens ’74 Hon. Richard D. Fybel ’71 CREDIBILITY In twenty-seven years of family law I have observed the criminal bar at vir- —THE HEART practice, I have not seen significant changes in the professional behavior of tually every stage of a case. I have been OF CIVILITY impressed by the consistently high family lawyers. Marital dissolutions level of courtesy counsel show to each Bill Vaughn ’55 involve everything in the world that other. In contrast to civil law, there is clients own, plus their children, plus little, if any, personal enmity on dis- Don’t unnecessarily make your opponent the disposition of their future income. play between counsel in criminal cases. your enemy. You may need his or her coop- Lawyerly ethics—for reasons of per- This reasonable, deliberate approach to eration some day. sonal financial gain, poor judgment, or cases helps to enable the criminal jus- a personality disorder—often go right tice system reach just results. Based on Some will say that’s a soft-bellied out the window. my observations and discussions with approach to what is by its nature an For the most part, ethical rules and others, my preliminary conclusions on adversarial contest. They say every California law leave lawyers free to the explanations for this conduct by the ploy, productive or not, should be practice within a wide range of permis- criminal bar are, as follows: brought to bear and the more pain it sible behavior. The character of the causes the better. There are such attorney, which developed long before 1. Criminal law practitioners recog- lawyers who enjoy total warfare and law school, is the major force that con- 32 nize that the only way the system believe that fighting at every turn is trols conduct. On the job training, can work is if the lawyers cooperate attractive to clients, at least until their mentoring, and modeling may nurture in discovery, pre-trial proceedings, clients get the huge bills that such tac- good character, but do not create it. and at trial. tics produce. Just as we all expected in elemen- For me, being conciliatory has its tary school that the yard-duty teacher 2. Lawyers know that gamesmanship rewards. By that I do not mean that would appear and drag the bully away, does not advance their cause before one should surrender any fundamental many of us expect judges, as the reign- a judge or jury. Advocacy for their position, but if it seems you will be ing authority figure in litigation, to put a clients is focused on marshaling the unable to prevail on a minor point, stop to the legal bullies. It hasn’t worked evidence, evaluating credibility of give in on it at a tactically appropriate out that way, although some have tried. witnesses, and applying the law. time. This builds credibility—the heart The system only weeds out the of persuasion with judges, juries, or very worst of the bad apples, and even 3. Criminal lawyers appear in court opponents. Credibility is the path to then only occasionally. Like Al Capone virtually every day. Their individ- desired results, whether in trial or set- and Leona Helmsley, a few high profile ual, office, and firm reputations are tlement negotiations. prosecutions make interesting reading at stake with every appearance. but don’t change much. Most lawyers Exaggerations, uncooperative behav- Bill Vaughn ’55 practiced with O’Melveny prefer to avoid sanctions, if only for the ior, and misleading statements are & Myers for over four decades, chairing the embarrassment factor—monetary loss discouraged and remembered by firm’s litigation department for nearly ten is usually only a minor irritation. their adversaries, with whom they years. He has co-chaired two committees of Lawyers whose behavior is out of the often practice together in the same the ABA Litigation Section and was elected mainstream are unmoved by any fear courthouse on a daily basis. to the American College of Trial Lawyers of embarrassment. Sanctions work like Board of Regents. In 1991, he received the locking your car—it stops amateur 4. In general, I have observed that the Learned Hand Award from the American thieves, but not the professionals. more experienced criminal law Jewish Committee. practitioners go to the heart of a Bruce A. Clemens ’74 is the managing case and directly deal with issues on partner of Jaffe & Clemens of Beverly Hills. their merits, thereby showing lead- His practice is limited to complex family ership by example to new practioners. law matters involving large estates.

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Faculty

Los Angeles native, Professor Korobkin is our first full-time, NEW FACULTY permanent faculty member who is the scion of an alumnus — Alvin J. Korobkin ’65 is Russell’s father.

We are very pleased to announce the addition of three Gary Rowe has joined the faculty as Acting Professor of new faculty members to our law school family. Lending par- Law to teach American Legal History, Federal Courts, and Civil ticular strength and distinction to the UCLA Corporate Law Procedure. His principal area of scholarly interest lies in Program, Professor Lynn Stout has joined us to teach American legal history, particularly the history of the Business Associations, Securities Regulation, Law and Economics, Constitution and the early American republic. A 1988 grad- and a seminar on corporate law. Before joining UCLA, she uate of Harvard, he attended Oxford as a Henry Fellow and was Professor of Law at the Georgetown University Law received the Sara Norton Prize in history. During law school, Center and Director of the Georgetown-Sloan Project on he was the notes editor of the Yale Law Journal. After gradu- Business Institutions. She also has taught at Harvard Law ating, he worked as an associate at Wilmer, Cutler & School, NYU Law School, and George Washington Pickering in Washington, D.C., as a law clerk for Judge University National Law Center, and served as a Guest William A. Norris of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Scholar at the Brookings Institution in Washington, D.C. Circuit, and as a special assistant to the administrator of the Professor Stout is the author of numerous articles on the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs (OIRA) in the stock market, finance theory, corporate governance, social Office of Management and Budget. He then enrolled in grad- norms, and a casebook—Cases and Materials on Law and uate school at Princeton University, where he taught English 33 Economics (with Barnes, 1992). Her current research focuses constitutional and American legal history and was awarded on social norms and the behavioral phenomenon of altruism. a Woodrow Wilson Fellowship. Professor Rowe is currently Professor Stout is a member of the Board of Trustees of the at work on his doctoral thesis, The Practice of Constitutionalism Eaton Vance family of mutual funds. During law school, she in the Early Republic, 1787–1840. served as a senior editor of the Yale Law Journal. She received her M.P.A. concurrently with her law degree, and following NEW VISITING FACULTY graduation, clerked for Judge Gerhard Gesell on the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia. She then practiced Our distinguished visitors this year include Stuart law with the Washington, D.C. firm of Williams & Connolly. Banner, who is teaching Property, American Legal History, and a seminar on the Supreme Court during the 2001–2002 aca- After visiting UCLA School of Law last year, Professor demic year. A legal historian who is intensely interested in Russell Korobkin has joined the faculty and is teaching current issues, especially capital punishment, he has been on Negotiation, Contracts, Health Care Law, and Law and Behavioral the law faculty of Washington University since 1993. In law Science. His scholarship focuses on the application of behav- school, Professor Banner was articles editor of the Stanford ioral science and cognitive psychology to legal policy, con- Law Review. Upon graduation, he clerked for Judge Alex tract law, health law, and legal negotiation. Professor Kozinski of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit Korobkin’s textbook, Negotiation Theory and Strategy, will be and then Justice Sandra Day O’Connor of the U.S. Supreme published in 2002. He also has published numerous articles on the application of economics, behavioral economics, and We are delighted to welcome back the Arjay and Frances Fearing cognitive psychology to legal policy, contract law, health law, Miller Professor of Law, Susan Westerberg Prager ’71, who has and legal negotiation. He has taught at the University of Illinois and the University of Texas. He earned both his returned to the law school after serving two and one half years as undergraduate and law degrees from Stanford University. A Provost of Dartmouth College.

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Faculty

Court. He practiced law at Davis Polk & Wardwell and then This fall, the School of Law also is honored to welcome at the Office of the Appellate Defender in New York City. David Nimmer, who will teach International Intellectual Professor Banner’s most recent books are The Death Penalty: Property. A long-time member of the UCLA Law family, An American History (forthcoming, 2002) and Legal Systems in Professor Nimmer is of counsel to Irell & Manella and a Conflict: Property and Sovereignty in Missouri, 1750–1860 (2000). Distinguished Scholar at the Berkeley Center for Law and Technology. A leading authority on copyright, he lectures Justin Hughes joins the UCLA faculty for the 2001–2002 widely in the copyright arena and has testified before academic year to teach Copyright Law, Trademark Law, and the Congress. In law school he was an editor of the Yale Law Law of Cyberspace. A 1986 graduate of Harvard Law School, Journal. He is the son of the late UCLA Law Professor his research and teaching interests focus on intellectual prop- Melville B. Nimmer, and he continues his father’s life work, erty and Internet issues. Professor Hughes has practiced law in by updating and revising the semi-annual Nimmer on Paris and Los Angeles; he also clerked for the Lord President Copyright. Besides contributing to many scholarly treatises, of the Malaysian Supreme Court in Kuala Lumpur. He is a Professor Nimmer has authored numerous law review arti- former Henry Luce Scholar, Mellon Fellow in the Humanities, cles on domestic and international copyright issues. He and ABA Baxter Scholar at The Hague Court. From 1997 to recently authored a book-length manuscript on intellectual 2001, he worked as an attorney-advisor in the U.S. Patent and ownership of the Dead Sea Scrolls. Trademark Office, focusing on the Administration’s initia- tives in Internet-related intellectual property issues, Eleventh NEW LAWYERING SKILLS 34 Amendment immunity issues, intellectual property law in FACULTY AND LECTURERS developing economies, and on copyright appellate filings for the United States (including the Napster litigation). He taught Patrick D. Goodman teaches Lawyering Skills and assists the Law of Cyberspace at Cardozo Law School in New York in 2000 in the Clinical Program. A double Bruin, Professor Goodman and 2001. Professor Hughes is the author of several articles holds his undergraduate as well as his master’s degree in on intellectual property, linguistics, and international arbitration. Education from UCLA. During law school, Professor Goodman was a Harlan Fiske Stone Scholar, head notes edi- Boalt Hall’s Robert D. and Leslie Kay Raven Professor of tor of the Columbia Human Rights Law Review, and recipient of Law, Rachel Moran, will visit this spring to teach Torts. the Jane Marks Murphy Prize for Excellence in Advocacy. Professor Moran previously taught at UCLA Law during the After law school, he joined Morrison & Foerster as a litigation late 1980s. She graduated from Stanford University and went associate. In 1998, he joined the Office of County Counsel as on to Yale where she was editor for the Yale Law Journal. a staff attorney specializing in juvenile law and was then pro- Following law school, she clerked for Chief Judge Wilfred moted to Senior Associate County Counsel. In November Feinberg of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit 1999, he became Deputy County Counsel, a position he held in New York. She joined the Boalt Hall faculty in 1982. From before joining the School of Law. 1993 to 1996, she chaired the Chicano/Latino Policy Project at UC Berkeley’s Institute for Study of Social Change. In addi- While in law school, Sandy Roth ’91 served as an arti- tion to teaching at UCLA as a Visiting Professor, she also has cles editor of the UCLA Law Review, was a teaching assistant, taught law at Stanford, NYU, the University of Miami, and the and was involved in public interest activities. Following law University of Texas at Austin. Her publications include many school, she clerked for Judge Procter Hug Jr. of the Ninth articles on diversity and education, as well as a recent book, Circuit Court of Appeals. She then worked as a litigation Interracial Intimacy: The Regulation of Race and Romance (2001). associate at Wilson, Sonsini, Goodrich & Rosati in Palo Alto, and at Crowell and Moring in Washington, D.C., after which she spent two years working on the Microsoft litigation at the

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Faculty

Antitrust Division of the Justice Department. Immediately Jack Paul teaches Government Contracts this fall. He is a before joining the UCLA Law faculty, she was of counsel at leading practitioner in the field of government contracts and Legal Community Against Violence in San Francisco, where runs a major government contracts training program for sen- she counseled local governments and public health organiza- ior executives in government and industry. Among his clients tions regarding firearms regulations. are the Johnson Space Center, the Army, the Navy, Boeing, Lockheed, and Westinghouse. He hopes to share with law Michael S. Taggart teaches Lawyering Skills and assists students his vast legal and practical experience in a field that in the Clinical Program. During law school, he was senior edi- involves a substantial portion of the world’s economy. tor of Harvard’s Journal of Law and Public Policy and served as Professor Paul graduated from UCLA and then earned his a teaching assistant in a first-year legal argument and brief writ- LL.B. from Stanford and his LL.M. from Harvard. He began ing class. Upon graduation from law school, he clerked for his career by serving as a legal officer in procurement at Air Judge Stephen S. Trott of the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. Materiel Command Headquarters. He then entered private Since 1994 and before joining the School of Law, Professor practice and started the Government Contracts Program at Taggart worked at the Federal Public Defender’s office in UCLA. He is the author of U.S. Government Contracts for the Anchorage, Alaska, where he served as an Assistant Federal American Bar Association and the American Law Institute. Defender. Steven Thomas teaches Art and the Law this semester. Pat Sekaquaptewa co-teaches the Indian Law Clinic with He currently practices at Irell & Manella in the areas of art, Professor Carole Goldberg and helps supervise the Hopi real estate, and finance. Following his undergraduate work 35 externships and other field placements for the year. She at the University of Florida, Professor Thomas attended Yale received her B.A. from Stanford and her J.D. from UC Law School, where he was the book review editor for the Yale Berkeley’s Boalt Hall. In 1998, she worked as an attorney for Law and Policy Review. After law school, he clerked for the Alexander & Karshmer, representing American Indian tribes, Honorable John A. Mackenzie, Chief Judge for the U.S. Alaska Native villages, and inter-tribal organizations. She is District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia. co-founder and Associate Director of the Tribal Law & Policy Institute in Oakland, where she coordinates conferences on national legislation and laws affecting tribal courts, federal tribal and tribal-state relationships, and comparative tribal law.

Brad Sears has taken on additional responsibilities as the Administrative Director for the Charles R. Williams Project

on Sexual Orientation and the Law. He also teaches the Lawyering Skills section for the Program in Public Interest

Law and Policy. While in law school, Professor Sears was editor-in-chief of the Harvard Civil Rights-Civil Liberties Law

Review. From 1995 to 1997, he clerked for the Honorable J. Spencer Letts of the U. S. Central District of California.

He then worked as a staff attorney for the HIV/AIDS Legal Services Alliance of Los Angeles (HALSA) and as Director of

the HIV Legal Checkup Project, a legal services program he founded. He serves on the board of directors of Being

Alive, an organization for people with HIV/AIDS, and the advisory committee of Correct Help, which advocates for incar-

cerated persons living with HIV/AIDS; and he litigates HIV/AIDS discrimination and confidentiality cases on a pro bono

basis. In 2000, Professor Sears wrote a white paper for the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, “The Role

of Legal Services in Assisting Persons Living With HIV/AIDS in Securing Access to Health Care.”

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Faculty

Recent Scholarship by UCLA Law Faculty

Khaled Abou El Fadl “Negotiating Human Rights Through And God Knows the Soldiers: The Language,” Journal of International Law & Authoritative and Authoritarian in Islamic Foreign Affairs (2001). Discourses. Univ. Press of America (2001). Revised edition of The Authoritative and Michael Asimow Authoritarian in Islamic Discourses. “Embodiment of Evil: Law Firms in the Movies,” UCLA Law Review (2001).

Stephen Bainbridge Agency, Partnerships, and Limited Liability Entities (with Klein and Ramseyer). 2001 Foundation Press (2001).

Environmental Business Associations: Agency, Partnerships, LLCs and Corporations: Statutes and Rules Report Card, (with Klein and Ramseyer). 4th ed. 36 featuring Foundation Press (2001). Conference of the Books: The Search for Beauty Environmental in Islam. Univ. Press of America (2001). Business Associations: Cases and Materials Rebellion In Islamic Law. Cambridge on Agency, Partnerships, and Corporations Justice University Press (2001). (with Klein and Ramseyer). 4th ed. Foundation Press (2000). Supplement By Ann Carlson and Jonathan Zasloff (2001).

Available now Paul Bergman Deposition Questioning: Strategies and Techniques (with Binder and Moore). Please Contact: West Publishing (2001).

Dorothy Fletcher Nolo’s Deposition Handbook (with Moore). UCLA Institute of the Environment 2nd ed. Nolo.com (2001). 1362 Hershey Hall Los Angeles, CA 90095 Speaking in God’s Name: Islamic Law, Represent Yourself in Court: How to PH: 310-825-5008 Authority and Women. Oneworld Press Prepare and Try a Winning Case or (2001). (with Berman-Barrett). Request the Environmental 3rd ed. Nolo.com (2001). Report Card through our guestbook on the IOE Web site The Criminal Law Handbook (with http://www.ioe.ucla.edu Berman-Barrett). 3rd ed. Nolo.com (2000).

David Binder Deposition Questioning: Strategies and Techniques (with Bergman and Moore). West Publishing (2001).

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Faculty

Gary Blasi Stephen Gardbaum Jerry Kang “Implementation of AB633: A Preliminary “Constitutional Revolutions” (book Race, Rights & Reparations: Law & The Assessment, a Report for a Joint Committee review), Ethics (forthcoming, 2001). Japanese American Internment (with Chon, of the Legislature,” (2001). See Recent Izumi, Wu, and Yamamoto). Aspen Scholarship at www.law.ucla.edu. “The New Commonwealth Model of Publishers (2001). Constitutionalism,” American Journal of “Advocacy and Attribution: Shaping Comparative Law (forthcoming, 2001). and Responding to Perceptions of the Causes of Homelessness,” St. Louis “Recent Developments in U.S. University Public Law Forum (2001). Constitutional Law,” Revue française de Droit constitutionnel (forthcoming, 2001). “Lawyers, Guns and Money: Scientific Approaches to Legislative Categorization,” Laura Gómez (forthcoming, 2001). “Race and Law,” Blackwell Companion to Law and Society (Sarat, ed). “Reforming Educational Accountability,” (forthcoming, 2001). Communications Law and Policy. California Policy Options 2002 (forthcoming, Aspen Publishers (2001). 2001). Carole Goldberg Research Priorities: Law Enforcement in Grace Ganz Blumberg Public Law 280 States (with Singleton). Blumberg’s California Family Code National Institute of Justice (forthcoming, Annotated. 7th ed. West Group (2001). 2001).

“The Regularization of Nonmarital Gaurang Mitu Gulati 37 Cohabitation: Rights and Responsibilities “Sovereign Piracy” (with Klee), The in the American Welfare State,” Business Lawyer (2001). Notre Dame Law Review (2001). “The Fifth Black Woman” (with Devon Carbado Carbado), The Journal of Contemporary “E-Racing E-Lections,” Loyola Law “The Fifth Black Woman” (with Gulati), Legal Issues (forthcoming, 2001). Review (forthcoming, 2001). The Journal of Contemporary Legal Issues (forthcoming, 2001). “The Happy Charade: An Empirical Ken Karst Examination of the Third Year of Law “Women’s Roles and the Promise of “Interactions at Work, Remembering School” (with Sander and Sockloskie), American Law,” Democracy and the Rule David Charny” (with Gulati), Harvard Journal of Legal Education (forthcoming, of Law (Dorsen and Gifford, eds.). Blackletter Law Journal (forthcoming, 2001). 2001). Congressional Quarterly Press (2001). Symposium for the Bicentennial of the Ann Carlson “Interactions at Work, Remembering Library of Congress. “Recycling Norms,” California Law David Charny” (with Carbado), Harvard Review (forthcoming, 2001). Blackletter Law Journal (forthcoming, 2001). Kenneth Klee “Tithing and Bankruptcy,” American Jody Freeman Bankruptcy Law Journal (2001). “The Contracting State,” Florida State University Law Review (2001). “Sovereign Piracy” (with Gulati), The Business Lawyer (2001). “Regulatory Negotiation and the Legitimacy Benefit” (with Langbein), William Klein NYU Environmental Law Review (2001). Agency, Partnerships, and Limited Liability Entities (with Bainbridge and Ramseyer). “Privatization and Public Choice,” Foundation Press (2001). Cornell Law Review (forthcoming, 2001).

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Faculty

Business Associations: Agency, Partnerships, William McGovern China,” Rule of Law and Democracy: LLCs and Corporations: Statutes and Rules Wills, Trusts and Estates Including Taxation Political Reform in China (Farer and (with Bainbridge and Ramseyer). 4th ed. and Future Interests (with Kurtz). 2nd ed. Reiner, eds.). Lynne Reiner (2001). Foundation Press (2001). West Publishing (2001). “Globalism, Path Dependency and the Business Associations: Cases and Materials Al Moore Limits of Law: Administrative Law on Agency, Partnerships, and Corporations Deposition Questioning: Strategies and Reform in the People’s Republic of (with Bainbridge and Ramseyer). 4th ed. Techniques (with Bergman and Binder). China,” Berkeley Journal of International Foundation Press (2000). Supplement West Publishing (2001). Law (2001). (2001). Nolo’s Deposition Handbook (with “Seek Truth from Facts: An Empirical Kristine Knaplund Bergman). 2nd ed. Nolo.com (2001). Study of Enforcement of Arbitral A Practical Guide for Law School Academic Awards in the People’s Republic of Assistance Programs (Johnson et. al, eds.). Stephen Munzer China,” American Journal of Comparative Law School Admissions Council New Essays in the Legal and Political Law (2001). (forthcoming, 2001). Theory of Property (Munzer, ed.). Cambridge Univ. Press (2001). “Let One Hundred Flowers Bloom, One Russell Korobkin Hundred Schools Contend: Competing “A Multi-Disciplinary Approach to Legal Conceptions of Rule of Law in the Scholarship: Economics, Behavioral People’s Republic of China,” (forthcom- Economics, and Evolutionary ing, 2001). Psychology,” Jurimetrics Journal (forthcoming, 2001). Kal Raustiala 38 “Non-state Actors and the Framework Gillian Lester Convention on Climate Change,” “Restrictive Covenants, Employee International Relations and the Climate Training, and the Limits of Transaction Change Regime (Luterbacher and Springz, Cost Economics,” Indiana Law Review eds.). MIT Press (forthcoming, 2001). (2001). “Heroism, Spiritual Development, and Triadic Bonds in Jain and Christian “Compliance and International Law” “Unemployment Insurance and Wealth Mendicancy and Almsgiving,” NUMEN: (with Slaughter), The Handbook of Redistribution,“ UCLA Law Review International Journal of the History of International Relations (Carlnaes et al, (forthcoming, 2001). Religions (2001). eds.). Sage Press (forthcoming, 2001).

Lynn LoPucki “Limited Property Rights in Umbilical William Rubenstein “Can the Market Evaluate Legal Regimes? Cord Blood for Transportation and “A Transactional Model of Adjudication,” A Response to Professors Rasmussen, Research” (with Smith), Journal of Georgetown Law Review (2001). Thomas, and Skeel,” Vanderbilt Law Pediatric Hematology/Oncology (forthcom- Review (2001). ing, 2001). “The Concept of Equality in Civil Procedure,” (forthcoming, 2001). “The Failure of Public Company Randall Peerenboom Bankruptcies in Delaware and New “Law and Religion in Early China,” “Do Gay Rights Laws Matter? An York: Empirical Evidence of a ‘Race to Religion, Law and Tradition (Huxley, ed.). Empirical Assessment,” (forthcoming, the Bottom’” (with Kalin), Vanderbilt Law Curzon Press (2001). 2001). Review (2001). “Law Enforcement and the Legal Richard Sander Tim Malloy Profession in China,” Law Implementation “Living Wages and the Problem of “Regulating by Incentives: Myths, in China (Otto et al, eds.). Law Inequality in California” (with Williams Models and Micro-Markets,” (forthcom- International (2001). and Blakley), California Policy Options ing, 2001). (Mitchell and Nomura, eds.). School of “A Government of Laws: Democracy, Public Policy and Social Research, UCLA Rule of Law and Administrative Law (2001). Reform in the People’s Republic of

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Faculty

“The Happy Charade: An Empirical Jonathan D. Varat Stephen Bainbridge Examination of the Third Year of Law Constitutional Law: Cases and Materials Securities Law: Insider Training School” (with Gulati and Sockloskie), (with Barrett and Cohen). 11th ed. Journal of Legal Education (forthcoming, Foundation Press (2001). Supplement 2001). (2001).

“Living Without Affirmative Action: Eugene Volokh Five Years at UCLA School of Law,” The First Amendment: Law, Cases, Problems, Academic Questions (forthcoming, 2001). and Policy Arguments. Foundation Press (2001). Seana Shiffrin “Lockean Theories of Intellectual Cyberspace Law for Non-Lawyers (with Property,” New Essays in the Political Lessig and Post). Random House Theory of Property (Munzer, ed.). (forthcoming, 2002). Stuart Biegel Cambridge University Press (2001). Beyond Our Control?: Confronting “How Might Cyberspace Change the Limits of Our Legal System in the David Sklansky American Politics?,” Loyola Law Review Age of Cyberspace “Some Cautious Optimism About the (2001). Problem of Racial Profiling,” Rutgers Race & Law Review (2001). “Freedom of Speech, Religious Harassment Law, and Religious Clyde Spillenger Accommodation Law,” Loyola Law “David M. Rabban and the Libertarian Review (forthcoming, 2001). Tradition That Time Forgot,” Law & 39 Social Inquiry (2001). Review of Free “How the Justices Voted in Free Speech Speech In Its Forgotten Years by David M. Cases, 1994–2000,” UCLA Law Review Rabban. (forthcoming, 2001). Edgar Jones Mr. Arbitrator Kirk Stark John Wiley “The Quiet Revolution in U.S. Sub- “Economic Crime: Antitrust Offenses,” national Corporate Income Taxation,” Encyclopedia of Crime and Justice. (forth- Bulletin for International Fiscal coming, 2001). Documentation (2001). “Economic Crime: Tax Offenses” (with “The Unfulfilled Tax Legacy of Robert Zolt), Encyclopedia of Crime and Justice. H. Jackson,” Tax Law Review (2001). (forthcoming, 2001).

“The Right to Vote on Taxes,” Jonathan Zasloff Northwestern University Law Review “Tiebout and Tax Revolts: Re-examining (forthcoming, 2001). the Role of School Finance Reform” Xia Chen (with Stark), (forthcoming, 2001). Limitation of Liability for Maritime “Tiebout and Tax Revolts: Re-examining Claims: A Study of U.S. Law, Chinese the Role of School Finance Reform” “Law and the Shaping of American Law, and International Conventions. (with Zasloff), (forthcoming, 2001). Foreign Policy: From the Gilded Age to the New Era,” (forthcoming, 2001). Lynn Stout “Trust, Trustworthiness, and the Eric Zolt Behavioral Foundations of Corporate Law” “Economic Crime: Tax Offenses” (with (with Blair), University of Pennsylvania Wiley), Encyclopedia of Crime and Justice. Law Review (2001). Symposium on (forthcoming, 2001). Norms and Corporate Law.

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Faculty

Torts Professor Gary T. Schwartz Memorialized and Honored

orts scholar and UCLA Law Professor Gary T. Schwartz “Gary was the premier torts scholar of the day, probably died in his home in the early morning hours of July this generation,” commented Professor Michael Green of T 25 at the age of 61. He had been diagnosed in the Wake Forest Law School, who collaborated with Gary on the spring with a brain tumor. Professor Schwartz was a particu- Restatement of Torts. “It was such a joy to work with an aca- larly gifted and popular teacher, and he was recognized demic as accomplished as Gary.” internationally for his scholarship in the field of torts. Columbia Law Professor Lance Liebman, who is The UCLA Law community will gather together with Director of the American Law Institute and a friend and Professor Schwartz's family, friends, and other law professors classmate from Harvard Law School, reflected, “Gary from across the nation on Monday, October Schwartz was a champion of interpersonal 29 to remember our friend and colleague. UCLA discourse and friendship.” Remembrances will be offered by a number Psychiatry Professor UCLA Law Professor Paul Bergman, who of individuals, including students, faculty, Marian Sigman, had worked with Gary Schwartz for over 40 and long-time friends such as Ninth Circuit who first met Gary thirty years said, “Gary was a first-rate Judge Raymond Fisher and American Law at Oberlin College, scholar who was not only devoted to torts Institute Director and former Columbia Law said “Gary was but to legal education. He knew ‘who was School Dean Lance Liebman. writing what’ and kept in touch with people not only a member In addition, in honor of his exceptional from all over the country and the world. His of our UCLA contributions to legal education and schol- recreation was talking about sports, attend- family, he was an arship, the leading torts scholars from ing sporting events, and especially playing honorary uncle throughout the country and around the softball and tennis. His death will leave a huge to our children world will gather at the School of Law on and probably irreplaceable hole in the faculty and the children April 19, 2002, for the Ann C. Rosenfield tennis foursome; he was a wonderful man.” of our friends.” Symposium, to deliver important scholarly Tennis partner and fellow law Professor papers dedicated to Professor Schwartz and Michael Asimow simply said, “Here we are, his work. The essays of these truly distinguished scholars, months later, and I still catch myself reaching for the phone to together with additional tributes, will be published thereafter in call him. I can’t believe he’s gone.” a special edition of the UCLA Law Review. Please join us for that UCLA Law Professor Alison Anderson concurred: “Gary especially appropriate event as well. was deeply engaged in his work. He loved to work in torts, A member of the UCLA Law faculty since 1969, Gary loved to teach torts, and students loved to learn from him. He Schwartz held the William D. Warren Chair. He was a recip- was deeply immersed in the law school. He participated in the ient of the Rutter Award for Excellence in Teaching and at the personnel process, the hiring, and really enjoyed the faculty- time of his death was the Reporter for the Restatement (Third) student softball games and participating in sports with friends.” of Torts: Liability for Physical Harm (Basic Principles), to be pre- A Cleveland native, Gary was a loyal Cleveland Indians sented by the American Law Institute. baseball fan, but he adapted to his adopted city by sharing

Professor Schwartz’s family has requested that any memorial contributions be made to the UCLA Foundation/Law, to the attention of Dean Varat, UCLA School of Law, Box 951476, Los Angeles, CA 90095-1476

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Faculty

Dodger season tickets with several faculty members. He also loved the opera. Deborah Stipek, Dean of the Stanford University School of Education, shared Gary’s passion for the opera and for teaching. “The most distinctive memory I have of Gary is his animation when he discussed his teaching, his colleagues, “Gary Schwartz was a and his research. We might enjoy a fabulous evening of champion of interpersonal opera, then over dinner he would enthusiastically relate sto- discourse and friendship.” ries about his students, or his work.” In a message to faculty, students, and staff, Jonathan D. Varat, Dean of the UCLA School of Law wrote, “We have lost another true friend, colleague, and mentor all too soon. But in the years that he lived so vitally among us, he taught and touched many deeply. He brought to his remarkable and insightful scholarship a deep sense of history, a pragmatic sense of economic reality, and a keen sense of justice.”

41

Top right: The Law School Musical with Professors (L) Susan Prager and (R) Laura Gomez. Middle left: Professor Schwartz received the School of Law’s 1987 Rutter Award for Excellence in Teaching from William A. Rutter. Middle right: Schwartz on Torts Lower left: A few of the faculty that have been awarded the School of Law's Rutter Award for Excellence in Teaching. (Standing rear, l to r) Dean Jonathan D. Varat, William A. Rutter, and Professors David Dolinko, William D. Warren, Steve Derian, and Gary Schwartz. (Sitting front, l to r) Professors Ken Karst, Alison Anderson, Eric Zolt, and Michael Asimow. Lower right: Professor Gary Schwartz

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Heritage Heritage

42

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Heritage

43

Join the Alumni Chorus No Diploma! (Sung to Oklahoma!) 02/02/02 [email protected] (310) 825-4992

Twenty Years of the Law School Musical

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Major Gifts

Historic Gift for Lesbian and Gay Think Tank

Businessman and academic Charles R. Williams has agreed to donate $2.5 million

to the School of Law over the next ten years—or sooner—to endow the nation’s William Rubenstein

first think tank on sexual orientation law—The Charles R. Williams Project on

Sexual Orientation and the Law. Mr. Williams also has agreed to make sizable

annual donations for current expenditures to allow

for the Project to begin operation immediately. The

gift will fund research, publications, and events,

with the goal of stimulating scholarship and teach- Mr. Williams is the ing in the field of sexual orientation law. Mr. President of Williams & Associates. He received Williams’ attorney, Arnie Kassoy ‘68 of Manatt, his B.A. and M.B.A. from Phelps & Phillips, LLP, facilitated the gift. UCLA and has had a suc- Mr. Williams and his lawyers approached the cessful career in teaching 44 and management. Most School of Law with the idea of supporting legal recently, he has taught scholarship and policy analysis that would have a business courses in policy “real world impact.” The concept of a policy think and strategy and consults in this area. Before 1985, tank emerged through a series of discussions Mr. Williams worked as between Mr. Williams, Dean Jonathan D. Varat, a senior executive for Professor William B. Rubenstein, and other law Sperry Corporation, Charles R. Williams where he held several school faculty. positions, including Vice “The School of Law is honored to be the recipient of this historic gift,” Dean President for Strategic Varat said. “Mr. Williams’ donation is one of the largest gifts from an individual and Business Planning and Vice President and donor to the School of Law and will broaden our substantive law program, for General Manager for which I am particularly grateful, because strengthening and broadening our teach- Worldwide Operations. ing and scholarship is the heart of our mission.” Mr. Williams’ munificence will

make UCLA the first law school in the country to have a program dedicated to

developing lesbian and gay legal scholarship and policy. “We have plans to spon-

sor a symposium this spring to begin bringing together the leading thinkers in this Brad Sears area immediately,” the Dean announced.

Heading up the Project as the Faculty Director is Professor William B.

Rubenstein, former Director of the ACLU Lesbian and Gay Rights Project and a

nationally recognized expert on sexual orientation law. Other UCLA Law faculty—

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Major Gifts

including Professors Devon Carbado, Chris Littleton, Kenneth Karst, and Brad

Sears—are nationally recognized scholars and lawyers whose work often involves Arney Kassoy ’68 issues of sexual orientation law, making UCLA Law a natural center for this devel- oping area. “By being centered at UCLA, the Charles R. Williams Project will be able to draw on the tremendous intellectual and material resources of one of the nation’s leading universities, allowing us to shape and inform legal and policy debates about sexual orientation law,” said Professor Rubenstein. Brad Sears has As far as is known, The Charles R. Williams Project on Sexual been selected as Administrative Director. Orientation and the Law will be supported by the largest donation ever given to any institution in support of a gay and lesbian aca- This year, the Charles R. Williams demic program in any discipline. In addition to the pledge of $2.5 mil- Project will organize a speakers’ series lion dollars, Mr. Williams will donate operating funds for the Project and will host a spring symposium until the endowment is fully funded. The University of Pennsylvania received a $2 million gift last year for a lesbian and gay student exploring the use of scientific and social center, and $1 million was donated to Yale University this year for a science data in legal arguments about lesbian and gay studies program. 45 lesbian and gay rights. During the

2002–2003 academic year, the Project will convene a national judicial education Arnie Kassoy ‘68 is a triple Bruin, having received conference on sexual orientation law. Future plans include hosting educational his undergraduate degree, conferences for practicing attorneys and publishing original policy papers and legal M.B.A., and J.D. from scholarship. The Project also seeks to raise the visibility of sexual orientation law as UCLA. He published in the UCLA Law Review in a viable career option for law students. 1968. Mr. Kassoy also Mr. Williams hopes that his gift will be the first step toward creating a nation- graduated from the London al center for the study of sexual orientation law at UCLA. His agreement with the School of Economics. He is the founder of—and for ten School of Law envisions the Project growing into an institute with an endowment years chaired—the UCLA of at least $10 million. In addition to continuing the programs of the Project, the Entertainment Tax and institute would fund an endowed chair at the School of Law, a visiting scholars Financial Institute. He is the vice president of the program, and a regularly published journal on sexual orientation law and policy. Board of Directors of the Santa Barbara Film Festival To learn more about The Charles R. Williams Project on Sexual Orientation and the Law, and vice chair of the Board of Directors of the AIDS please contact Brad Sears, Administrative Director and Lecturer in the Program in Public Research Alliance. Mr. Interest Law and Policy, at (310) 267-4382 or [email protected]. Kassoy is an expert in negotiation, primarily representing talent in the entertainment industry.

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Major Gifts

Skadden, Arps, Slate, excellent foundation for a career in law, scholars and social scientists in a forum and we are delighted to support such a for ideas and discussion. Papers pre- Meagher & Flom LLP fine institution.” Mr. Cohen added, sented at the Symposium are pub- Endows UCLA Law “We look forward to the close relation- lished in the August issue of the UCLA ship with the law school community Law Review. Editor-in-Chief Ted Maya Review Symposium that our involvement with the ’02 said, “We are incredibly thankful to Symposium will provide.” Skadden, Arps for this generous gift to “This endowment will enhance the Law Review on its fiftieth birthday. The law firm of Skadden, Arps, Slate, the Law Review Symposium signifi- It will make a huge difference to us, not Meagher & Flom LLP has made a prece- cantly in a permanent way, and the just now, but for the years to come, dent-setting gift of $400,000 to endow entire UCLA Law community is grateful ensuring that we will be able to hold the annual UCLA Law Review for such a generous gift. The partners great symposia on any topic.” Alyson Symposium in perpetuity. Recognizing of Skadden, Arps want to help us fulfill Dinsmore ’02, Symposium Editor for the value of contributing to the education our educational mission by investing the March 2002 Symposium, added, and training of UCLA Law students, in our students,” said Dean Jonathan “We're grateful to Skadden, Arps for Harriet Posner ’84 and Jeffrey Cohen Varat. “We value their support.” their support. This gift will allow us to ’88, both partners in the firm’s Los Organized by UCLA Law Review focus our energies on the substance of Angeles office, were instrumental in students and faculty advisors, the the Symposium and host an event in helping secure this gift. Ms. Posner said, Symposium brings together nationally which the entire law school community “The UCLA School of Law provides an and internationally recognized legal can participate. Thank you!”

PRIVATIZATION AND “THIRD PARTY”GOVERNANCE MARCH 1, 2002

46 UCLAUCLA LAW LAW REVIEWREVIEW SYMPOSIUMSYMPOSIUM

SUPPORTED BY A GENEROUS GIFT FROM SKADDEN, ARPS, SLATE, MEAGHER & FLOM LLP

The United States, like other Western democracies, increas- ■ A critical evaluation of the implications of the government ingly contracts with the private sector to provide a range of ceding a portion of its power to, or significantly reconfig- services, such as incarceration, policing, and education. uring its relationship with, private actors. Almost every government benefits program, such as Medicare and public assistance, depends on private actors to The Symposium will also address such questions as: a significant extent. President Bush has recently called upon ■ What are the constitutional constraints on this activity? private communities, notably faith-based organizations, to ■ What is the propriety or legality of delegating responsibility bear more of the burden traditionally borne by government. for public services to private organizations, or relying on This Symposium will present: the private sector to a significant extent without a formal ■ A review of recent trends toward privatization, including delegation of these responsibilities? subcontracting, devolution, decentralization, and deregu- ■ Even where there are no constitutional obstacles to the lation. private exercise of such powers, are private actors subject to more or less oversight than public agencies? ■ How are services to the public affected?

INFORMATION AND RESERVATIONS:

Please contact the UCLA Law Review Symposium Editors at (310) 825-4929 or e-mail Alyson Dinsmore at [email protected] or Glen Mastroberte at [email protected].

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Major Gifts

The Evan Frankel Environmental The Evan Frankel Environmental Law and Policy Law and Policy Program Program is proud to present its inaugural symposium. Inaugural Symposium Four panels will feature nationally and internationally “INTEGRATING known experts in environmental law and policy exploring HUMAN the following topics:

COMMUNITIES Smart Growth

AND NATURAL Is the search for “Smart Growth” just a new form of NIMBYism in disguise? Does ENVIRONMENTS” accounting for population growth necessarily imply unavoidable environmental impacts? Whose interests are served when policy makers engage in comprehensive planning, and who gets left out when "the market" is trusted to ensure equity? UCLA School of Law Environmental Law Center Toxic and Noxious Land Uses

There are both human health and environmental risks to consider when locating noxious March 8, 2002 and toxic land uses in densely populated, environmentally sensitive areas. The panel will weigh the concerns that affect the siting process, including the distribution of risks Keynote Speaker: across socioeconomic, racial, and ethnic lines, and the extent to which technology and management might effectively mitigate these risks. The Hon. George Pataki 47 Governor of New York Collaborative Processes and Land-Use Decisions

Traditionally, a developer submits a development plan to a municipality without prior community input and with limited advance government review, leading in some cases to contentious public hearings and heated political conflict. In some communities across the country, developers, community members, and municipalities are experimenting with a new approach to land-use decision-making in which the developer and commu- nity members collaborate directly in forming the development plan. The panel will focus on this alternative, exploring, among other things, whether it actually generates meaningful public involvement and results in equi- table, sound planning decisions.

Preservation of Open Space— Private Versus Public Acquisition and Management

This panel will explore how best to preserve dwindling amounts of open space in various settings (urban, rural, suburban). Are private approaches through, for example, the use of donations of land to nonprofit trusts, and the imposition of conservation easements more effective and more politically palatable than public acquisition of lands? Which approaches ensure effec- tive management of open space resources? Will the public sector appropri- ate sufficient funds and provide sufficient personnel to take care of open space? Will private organizations? Will private individuals who continue to own the underlying property on which a conservation easement is imposed? What about public access to open space lands? Is there an appro- priate mix of private versus public open space?

For more information, contact Barbara Biles, Executive Director, UCLA Environmental Law Center, at [email protected] or (310) 749-5272; or [email protected] or call (310) 825-0971.

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Major Gifts

The Ann C. Rosenfield This academic year, the Ann C. Rosenfield Endowment will fund the April Endowment Fund 19, 2002 Symposium honoring the life work of renowned torts scholar, Professor Gary T. Schwartz. In a tribute to Professor Schwartz, scholars Supports from throughout the United States, Canada, and Australia will present The Gary T. Schwartz their own papers and offer a variety of perspectives on Professor Schwartz’s work. Alumni and friends of the UCLA School of Law are Memorial Symposium encouraged to attend. Please contact [email protected] or (310) April 19, 2002 825-0971. Participants include:

• Mark Grady ’70, Dean and Professor, George Mason University School of Law • Michael Green, the Bess & Walter Williams Professor, Wake Forest University Law School • James A. Henderson Jr., the Frank B. Ingersoll Professor, Cornell Law School • The Honorable Allen Linden, Federal Court of Canada 48 • Robert Rabin, the A. Calder MacKay Professor, Stanford Law School • Kenneth Simons, Professor, Boston University School of Law • Jane Stapleton, Professor of Law, The Australian National University • Stephen Sugarman, the Agnes Roddy Robb Professor and Director of the Family Law Program, Earl Warren Legal Institute of UC Berkeley, Boalt Hall • Ernest Weinrib, the University of Toronto, Faculty of Law

The Ann C. Rosenfield Endowment Fund, facilitated by David Leveton ’62, provides, in perpetuity, an annual symposium to provide a forum on law-related issues for diverse audiences and to promote intellectual dis- tinction for the UCLA School of Law. On April 20, 2001, the Ann C. Rosenfield Endowment provided support for a symposium celebrating the thirtieth anniversary of the founding of the UCLA School of Law Clinical Program, presenting The Changing Face of Practice: Perspectives from the Profession and the Law School, as well as a gala dinner honoring Professor David Binder as he was awarded a lifetime achieve- ment award for his contribution to clinical legal education. The inaugural Ann C. Rosenfield Endowment sponsorship supported the 2000 Corporate Governance Conference.

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Major Gifts

▼ Daniel Grunfeld, President and CEO of Public The 2001 Ann C. Rosenfield Counsel, addresses the April 20 symposium. Clinical Symposium 4/20 Mark Fenster of Irell & Manella looks on.

▼ The Honorable Ann Kough ’78, Los ▼ Greg Nitzkowski ’84, Managing Angeles Superior Partner at Paul, Hastings, Janofsky & Court, responded Walker, tackles the controversy sur- to the question, rounding high salaries at law firms. “The Decline of Professionalism: Fact or Fiction?”

▼ Larry Feldman, partner at Fogel, Feldman, Ostrov, Ringler & Klevens, smiles at Morrison & Foerster’s James Brosnahan lively discussion of professionalism in the legal world.

▼ Professor David Binder accepts a Lifetime Professor David Binder Achievement Award. The April 20, 2001 event capped a day-long symposium celebrating Lifetime Achievement thirty years of clinical legal education. Award 4/20 49

▲ Professors David Binder and William Warren have worked together for over three decades.

▲ Many students, faculty, alumni, ▼ (l to r) and friends of the School of Law Mitch Menzer attended the ceremony. Pictured ’84, Professor here, three clinical faculty mem- Paul Bergman bers: Professors Sue Gillig, Director of the Clinical Program, along with Al Moore and Steve Derian. ▲ Professors Binder, Bergman, and Assistant Dean Andrea Sossin-Bergman share a laugh with Professor Al Moore.

▼ The Honorable Rich Fybel ’71 ▼ Dorothy Wolpert ’76

▲ (l to r) Leslie Freeman Kahlow ’95, Melinda Binder, Doug McCormick ’95, and Melissa Rush McCormick ’95 enjoy the festivities with Professor Binder.

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Events events Public Interest Law Foundation Trivia Challenge 10/00

Public Interest Career Day 2/3 The Sixteenth Annual Public Interest Career Day, held February 3, 2001, attracted recruiters from more than eighty public interest and public Wagatsuma Conference 1/19 sector employers from ▲ Professors Arthur Rosett and Randall within and outside California. The next ▲ Professors Tom Holm, Jody Freeman, and Peerenboom with former faculty member Mark Public Interest Career Jonathan Zasloff were faculty panelists for the PILF Ramseyer (center) discuss issues of international Day is scheduled for Trivia Challenge, which pitted students against pro- politics with Amy Chua at the UCLA Wagatsuma February 2, 2002. fessors and kicked off the Public Interest Law International Law Symposium held in January. Foundation's annual fundraising drive last October.

25th Annual UCLA Entertainment Law Symposium 2/9 50

▼ Jack Valenti, President of the Motion Picture Association, provides industry insight as the keynote speaker at the 25th Annual UCLA Entertainment Law Symposium. ▲ Hard choices: Student trivia whizzes discuss The next what winning the Challenge or even providing one Entertainment correct answer may mean for their grades, and Law Symposium ultimately their futures. is scheduled for January 25–26, 2002.

▼ Panelist Robin Richards (far right) of MP3.com shares a laugh with Professor Ken Ziffren ’65 (sec- ond from right) and other symposium attendees.

▲ The staff of Lexis-Nexis smile for the camera. Lexis-Nexis’ generous sponsorship helped make February’s symposium a success.

▲ With his thinking cap on, Professor Kirk Stark ponders the cast of The Brady Bunch. Meanwhile, colleague and long-time fan club president Professor David Dolinko poises thumb over answer button.

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Events

City Attorney Debate 2/15 UCLA Law Review Symposium—Law and Popular Culture 2/23

▼ Professor Carrie Menkel-Meadow, Georgetown University Law Center, discusses legal ethics in popular culture at the February symposium. Professor Michael Asimow, co-author of Reel Justice: The Courtroom Goes to the Movies, listens. The next UCLA Law Review Symposium is scheduled for March 1, 2002.

▲ Los Angeles Times columnist Patt Morrison served as moderator for the L.A. City Attorney Debates held at the School of Law last winter and co-sponsored by the L.A. County Bar Association.

▼ Professor Paul Bergman, co-author of Reel Justice: The Courtroom Goes to the Movies, speaks on the ▲ Professor Lawrence M. Friedman, Stanford Law redemptive path laid School, discusses how the mystery novel reflects

▼ Then-Deputy out for lawyers by the changes in law and society. Mayor and now movies. 51 L.A. City Attorney Rocky Delgadillo.

▲ Inside television legal dramas: (l to r) Jill Goldsmith, writer for The Practice; William Fordes, writer for Law & Order; Chuck Rosenberg, advisor for LA Law and The Practice. ▲ Lisa Jaskol (center) of the L.A. County Bar Association and organizer of the debate, confers with Patt Morrison and candidate Frank Pavelman, Deputy District Attorney. ▲ UCLA Law ▼ Edward Professor Lazarus is Jody Freeman developing responds to a new televi- informal sion program questions. based on cases heard before the U.S. Supreme Court.

▼ John B. Owens ▲ (From left) Candidates Lea Purwin D’Agostino, of O’Melveny & Deputy District Attorney, and former City Council Myers spoke on member Michael Feuer talk with UCLA Law Dean of the work of author Students Elizabeth Cheadle ’81. John Grisham. events

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Events

Nimmer Lecture 3/1 Asian Pacific American Law Journal Symposium 3/9

▼ (Standing, l to r), California State Assembly Member Carol Lui; Westminster City Council Member Tony Lam; Justice Ming Chin of the California Supreme Court; Warren Furutani, L.A. Community Colleges Board of Trustees. (Sitting, l to r) Minnesota State Senator Satveer Chaudhary; Monterey Park City Council Member Judy Chu.

▼ (Standing, l to r), Kathay Feng, Asian Pacific American Legal Center; Professor Ling-chi Wang, UC Berkeley; Professor Keith Aoki, U. of Oregon Law School; Professor Jerry Kang, UCLA Law. (Sitting, l to r), Professor Leland Sato, UC San ▲ 2001 Melville B. Nimmer Memorial Lecturer, Diego; Professor Pei-te Lien, Professor Lawrence Lessig of Stanford University Law School, speaks with Gloria Nimmer. Professor Lessig, a world-renowned expert on the Internet and copyright law, presented the lecture, Copyright’s First Amendment, at the UCLA Faculty Center on March 1, 2001. The next UCLA Law Nimmer Lecture is scheduled for March 12, 2002.

52 ▲ (Standing, l to r), Professor Bill Hing, UC Davis School of Law; Poka Laenui, Executive Director of Hale Na` au Pono; Quynh Nguyen, Asian Pacific American Labor Alliance; Debra Suh, Executive Director of the Center for the Pacific-Asian Family. (Sitting, l to r), Myron Quon, Lambda Legal Defense and Education Fund; Jaideep Singh, UC Berkerley.University of Utah.

Public Interest Law Foundation Auction 3/9

▲ (l to r) Visiting Professor David Nimmer, Professor Lawrence Lessig, Dean Jonathan D. Varat, and Professor John Wiley.

▼ Professor and amateur auctioneer Career Services 3/7 Ann Carlson takes bids for Dean Varat. The Dean agreed ▲ Students, faculty, alumni, to take notes for a and friends of the UCLA student for an School of Law attended the entire day. annual Public Interest Law Foundation Auction in March. This year the auction raised over $35,000 in stipend money for students pursuing public interest work during the summer.

▲ Donna Black ’75, past president of the UCLA Law Alumni Association, discusses the working world

▼ Professors Clyde Spillenger (gui- with students at the Office of Career Services tar) and Steve Derian (bass) of The Annual Small Firm Reception held in March. Usual Suspects jam at the auction.

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Events

Rutter Award 4/19 ▲ Professor Al Moore (center) was this year’s recipient of the School of Law's Rutter Award for Moot Court Excellence in Teaching. Dean Varat (left) and Competition William A. Rutter (right) congratulate him during 3/15 the April ceremony held at the School of Law. William A. Rutter established the award in 1979 in ▼ Finalists and judges for the 2001 Moot Court competition held in March. (Back row, l to r) Hon. Dean D. the belief that universities must reward excellent Pregerson, District Judge of the Central District of California; Dean Jonathan D. Varat; Hon. Rhesa Barksdale, teaching as they do critical research. The award Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals; Henry Self ’02, finalist; Tim Martin ’02, finalist. (Front row, l to r) Sylvia Rivera has become not only a symbol of recognition but ’02, finalist; SBA President Celeste Drake ’02, winner of the competition; Hon Rosemary Barkett, Eleventh also an opportunity to celebrate our success as Circuit Court of Appeals and former Chief Justice of the Florida Supreme Court. one of the great teaching law faculties in legal education.

Lincoln Sculpture Presented to the School of Law 3/21 53

▼ This spring, George Turner ’68 (left) presented the School of Law with a sculpture of Lincoln creat- ed by his friend Emil Seletz, M.D. Mr. Seletz's daughter and widow flank Dean Varat.

▲ Al Moore '78 celebrates his day with his wife and classmate Sherrill Johnson '78.

Governor Ryan 4/4 ▼ The Honorable George H. Ryan (left), Governor of Illinois, spoke on expanding the moratorium on the death penalty. Professor William Warren (right) introduced the governor at the April 4 event held at the School of Law.

▲ Collegial faculty: From (L) Professor Gillian Lester, Associate Dean Barbara Varat, Professors Al Moore '78 and Ann Carlson. ▲ Governor Ryan talks with Adam Lang ’02. events

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Events

Equal Access to Justice Colloquium 4/21 ▼ Panelist Alicia Dixon of The California events Endowment answers questions about fund raising. Admissions Day April

▲ David Lash ’80 of Bet Tzedek Legal Services (and recipi- ent of the 2000 Public Interest Award) addresses the Equal ▲ Dean Varat talks with admitted students during Access to Justice Colloquium held at the School of Law in the School of Law's Admissions Day, which is held April. The Colloquium was co-sponsored by the Pepperdine every April. University School of Law and the Association of American Law Schools.

Public Interest Awards Ceremony 54 4/24

Each spring, the School of Law recognizes an alumnus, a faculty member, a second- year student, and a third-year student for their outstanding commitment to the public interest.

▲ (Back row, l to r) Professor Alison Anderson, recipient of the Fredric P. Sutherland Public Interest Award; Olga Fuentes ’01, recipient of the Nancy J. Mintie Public Interest Award; Meghan Lang ’02, co-recipient of a Joseph Hairston Duff Public Interest Award; Andrew Elmore ’02, co-recipient of a Joseph Hairston Duff Public ▲ Law Alumni Association President Rick Davis Interest Award; and Yolanda Vera ’87, recipient of the Antonia Hernandez Public Interest Award. (Sitting, front, ’87 addresses admitted students. l to r) Joseph Hairston Duff ’71, Dean Jonathan D. Varat, and Nancy J. Mintie ’79.

▼ Joseph Hairston Duff ’71 congratulates Andrew Elmore ’02. Andrew and fellow student Meghan Lang ’02 (not pictured) were co-recipients of the Joseph Hairston Duff Public Interest Award.

▲ Professor Gary Blasi presents the ▲ Olga Fuentes ’01 received the Nancy J. Mintie Antonia Hernandez Public Interest Award Public Interest Award. to Yolanda Vera ’87.

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Events

Women & Philanthropy 4/25 ▼ Marion Wilson introduces Dean Jonathan Varat, Professor Ann Carlson, and Class of 2001 graduates Christa Shaw and Joanna Wolfe to Women & Philanthropy members at an event April 25. The event showcased the UCLA Environmental Law Center which, as Dean Varat told the audience, “We intend to become the leading environmental law resource center in the nation.”

▼ Marion Wilson is currently the President of ▲ 2001 graduates of the Program in Public Interest Law and Policy. Program Director Catherine Women & Philanthropy at UCLA. She and her hus- Mayorkas sits front and center. band Bob Wilson, who attended UCLA Law before Commencement 5/20 choosing a business career, have been remarkably generous to the law school and campus-wide, pro- ▼ 2001 graduates of the Corporate Law Program. Joining them are Professors Dan Bussel (top viding leadership with their dedication and support. left), Grant Nelson (middle row, left), and Ken Klee (front row, third from right). 55

An Evening with Ben Ferencz 5/22

▼ Former Nuremburg war crimes prosecutor Ben Ferencz (pictured with his wife Gertrude) visited the School of Law on May 22, 2001, and recounted his experiences prosecuting Nazis at the end of World War II. Mr. Ferencz has dedicated his life to fight- ing hate crimes throughout the world.

Summer ▼ Professor Academic Kristine Knaplund, Program Director of the School of Law's 8/20 Summer Academic Program.

▼ Dean Varat addresses incoming students during the Summer Academic Program held in August.

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Students

▼ Hoping to jumpstart a career in medical students malpractice, Scott Dewey ’03 plays to the house. Chris Scott ’03 admires his fellow Law School Musical: Care or $ell 2/3 thespian's costume.

▲ Don't miss Professor Graham's next musical extravaganza: No Diploma! 02/02/02. Tickets ▲ Producer, director, choreographer, law professor, are now available. [email protected] or and author of nine evidence volumes of Federal (310) 825-4992. ▼ The cast of Care or $ell vamps for the camera. Practice and Procedure, Professor Ken Graham finds time to share a laugh with pianists Shannon Lassen (left) and Dana Peterson ’02 (right).

BLSA 2/16 ▼ (From left) Professor Devon Carbado, Law 56 Fellows Outreach Coordinator Tony Tolbert, Darrell Miller, inaugural presenter of last year’s Outreach Resource Center Discussion Series, and Law Fellows Outreach Program participant George Turner at the annual Black Law Students Association dinner, which was held in the Hugh & Hazel Darling Law Library last February.

APILSA 4/18 American Bankruptcy Institute Award June

▼ Asian Pacific Islander Law Students ▼ This June, Professor Ken Klee presented Shira Association members Roth ’02 with the American Bankruptcy Institute’s discuss the merits of Award for student scholarship. Professor Alison Anderson’s throwing Barrister’s Ball 2/24 arm during the annual APILSA Carnival and ▼ Gerald Sequeira ’02 sweeps Jasmine Ejan off her Dunk Tank held in April. feet at the annual Barrister’s Ball held in February.

▲ More accustomed to throwing chalk, Professor Alison Anderson gives it her all.

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Alumni

any of our graduates Johnson Mitchell ’61, Leonard Herman Palo Alto this spring. Class Acts have careers based in Smith ’64, Thomas P. Burke ’65, Edwin And if you are closer to law and business on the C. Amos Jr. ’66, and his classmate, Alan us than that, I hope to East Coast; indeed, our Charles Oberstein ’66 as well as John C. welcome you next May AlumniM Board President Rick Davis ’87— Spence III ’67. Peter P. Covette ’79 died as we honor the UCLA who is safe—is Counsel to JP Morgan August 14 of complications of lupus. Law Alumni of the Year. Chase, so we are continuing to work hard Jason Baba ’83 was lost off the island of And if you would like to confirm the safety of our alumni family. Oahu while kayaking and Elizabeth to nominate a graduate Please note the minute-by-minute story Alexander King ’84 died July 15. We that has shown particular of Les Jacobowitz ’85, as he describes the extend our warmest condolences to fami- leadership in public serv- scene. We extend to you our deepest lies, friends, and classmates. Our law ice or the practice or sympathies if you have lost a loved one, a school family sustained a tremendous loss business of law, please colleague or friend in the events of when Professor Gary Schwartz succumbed submit your nomination September 11. to a brain tumor this July. The loss is to [email protected]. It is truly gratifying to see how you especially personal for Gary’s uncle, The Alumni for have responded to your law school at this Roland Childs ’58, and his cousin, Toby Life program has dou- time of our country’s peril. Dean Varat Rothschild ’69. Our community has bled in size since last year. points out that the students we have in responded by donating to a memorial By registering for this class today will necessarily play instru- fund in Gary’s name. I hope to see you free program, you are mental roles in securing our nation’s October 29 and again April 19, as we automatically notified future, in the rule of law, democracy, and salute Professor Schwartz and his work. of UCLA Law news and indeed, our very way of life. He has Alumni have stepped up to support events and, additional- called upon us all to be creative in our the school in other ways as well, provid- ly, can subscribe—for sense of community and helping one ing financial support through the Annual free—to UCLA Law Community in the 57 another. His words were especially Giving campaign, and arranging for the News, an electronic news clipping service poignant at the Mentor Reception the school to benefit from their own—and updating you, via your Alumni for Life e- week following the attacks. That event, their clients’—planned giving programs. mail address, of alumni, professors, and which brings together volunteer alumni In fact, Sandra Kass Gilman ’75 submit- students in the news. If you would like to to provide guidance and fellowship to ted an article about the tax advantages of register, contact me at [email protected]. first-year students, was better attended the program in the Honor Roll section of Our Class Correspondence program than ever before. Meaningful discussions this magazine. This support is vital to our is growing. We’d love you to participate between students and practicing lawyers mission and we are truly thankful for either by volunteering to receive and for- and other law school graduates stretched your inclusion of the UCLA School of ward news of your classmates to us, or by late into the evening. Attendance at other Law in your giving plans. sending updates to: events that have been scheduled to foster As our school matures, our alumni School of Law alumni fellowship, such as assume ever more challenging and exciting Jerry Goldberg ’53, the tailgate party at the Chancellor’s pic- career positions in cities throughout the [email protected]; nic before the Ohio State football game, country, and around the world. Every year Louise Lillard ’85, have far exceeded our expectations. Our in- Dean Varat, Assistant Dean for Career [email protected]; home dinner program—your opportunity Services Amy Berenson Mallow, and I Jeffrey Cowan ’91, to host a student in your home, or office, or visit our alumni in various regions. I want [email protected]; club for lunch or dinner—is also record- to thank our alumni for welcoming us to Tom Monheim ’92, ing stunning numbers of participants. We your cities, and especially for welcoming [email protected]; thank you for coming together with us the best and brightest prospective students Joseph Gauthier ’94, and providing support to our mission. to UCLA Law. Your recruitment efforts [email protected]; I am sorry to report that we have lost have certainly been instrumental in encour- Jenny Meier-Kowal ’96, alumni over the past several months. aging accepted applicants to come to [email protected]; From our first graduating class, Richard UCLA. A strong, connected, and supportive Terrence Mann ’00, Thomas Hanna ’52 died on June 9, and alumni association is one of the strongest [email protected]; Bruce Hochman ’52 on August 12. We lost elements that prospective students evaluate David Simonds ’01, Marshall Whitehead Vorkink ’54 on when they select schools, so thank you! [email protected]. September 7, and Robert Blaylock ’58 on We’ll see you in New York, Boston, D.C., August 25. Last spring took William Philadelphia, Chicago, San Francisco, and Now, how about you?

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Alumni

Have you spoken with your col- Alumni Board. In his year-and-a-half leagues from the Classes of ’61, ’71, ’81, and term he helped focus the Alumni Board, ’91 or ’56, ’66, or even ’76? You’ll learn that created a mission statement for the we have had great success with reunion Alumni Association, reached out to the committees that generate some very differ- students through the moot court and ent get-togethers. Roger Cossack ’71, Dean mentor programs, reviewed the Alumni of Students Liz Cheadle ’81, and Milton Association’s past, and brought it into the Miller ’56 are just a few of the alums that present. Rick Davis ’87 has taken the helm have generated interest, support, and of the Alumni Board, making his personal In June, groundbreaking began for the new enthusiasm for the event. Join us as we plan and professional mark on our future. Justice Steven Z. Perren Juvenile Justice the reunions for the classes of ’52, ’57, ’62, Finally, I bring your attention to The Center located in El Rio, Ventura County. ’67, ’72, ’76, ’82, and ’92. Write to us at Honorable Steven Z. Perren ’67. On June The $65 million dollar complex will open in [email protected] or feel free to call 22, 2001, several alumni joined with state 2003 and house up to 420 juvenile offenders, (310) 206-1121 if you’d like to be a planner. and county officials in a beautiful and replacing a dilapidated and overcrowded As we begin our new academic year, vast field in Ventura Count to honor and sixty-year-old faciltiy. Justice Perren ’67 is a I want to make special note of saluting dedicate the groundbreaking for Ventura former Ventura County Juvenile Court judge. Immediate Past President The Honorable George Schiavelli [Ret] ’74. I am remind- “When a juvenile offender is appropriately monitored in the community, ed of how much George gives to our we save money and we save kids. We may never know what offense was school as I visited with him at the recent not committed, what property was not taken or what injury was not Mentor Reception. And I thought you inflicted. But if we do not dedicate ourselves to the rehabilitation of might enjoy reading the LA Daily Journal our community’s youth we will condemn them to a life of crime and feature profiling him. It has truly been a the community to the danger that unrepentant, uneducated, and 58 pleasure to work with George, a very dedi- unprepared youth will present each time he or she is released from cated and creative alumni volunteer. As custody; and the associated costs of custodial confinement.” he retires as our Board President, he in fact has stepped up support of UCLA by The Honorable Steven Z. Perren ’67 joining the Foundation Board, and has launched into a new career in private practice and ADR work. Several innovative County’s Justice Steven Z. Perren projects were undertaken under his lead- Juvenile Justice Complex. It became ership, including aligning the board apparent why this facility is being named schedule with the school calendar to be after Justice Perren, as he was very instru- more in sync with our future alumni—a mental in making the juvenile justice project that required an additional six complex a reality. Not only did he secure months’ commitment as President of the the state funding for this project, he fought for this project because he knew it would help children and teens of Ventura County. I hope you enjoy these snapshots of the groundbreaking ceremony. Please remember to include the activities of your law school in your cal- endar for the coming year.

Kristine Werlinich (l to r) Supervisor John Flynn, Hon. Steven Director, Alumni Relations Z. Perren ’67, State Assembly Member [email protected] Hannah-Beth Jackson, and George Eskin ’65. (310) 206-1121 Immediate Past President The Hon. George Schiavelli [Ret.] ’74 congratulates The Hon. Elwood Lui ’69, recipient of the UCLA Law Alumni of the Year Award for Public Service.

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Alumni

MINUTE BY MINUTE, SEPTEMBER 11, 2001 An excerpt of one of the e-mails received from our alumni family

LES JACOBOWITZ ’85 WITH DIANA KIEL

Thanks for all your heartfelt concern and warm wishes. Diana 9:05 a.m. Area was secured and decided I should check on and the children—Jennifer, Ryan, and Benjamin—are all doing Diana and the twins. Stupidly, I walked south fine. Described below is a chronology of the September 11 disaster. along West Street.

Walked thirty feet and heard what sounded like a Tuesday, September 11, New York City, Downtown B-1 bomber: A plane was heading straight for the twin towers (and me). The plane was gunning its 8:20 a.m. Took our daughter Jennifer to kindergarten (she is engine, as if for takeoff, and slammed into Two late for everything—like her mom). The taxi ride, World Trade Center with a horrific explosion. which takes less than five minutes, travels directly Someone cried out, “Not again—why can’t they under The World Trade Center. Her school is four leave us alone?” blocks north of there. Ran as fast as I could back to my apartment, past 8:35 a.m. Said goodbye to Jennifer with our usual “Eskimo the voting booth at One World Financial Center, kiss.” which was already abandoned.

Decided it might be best to vote this morning. Our apartment in Battery Park City is four blocks 59 Walked down the west side of West Street (West south of the World Trade Center and has a clear Side Highway) from Public School (P.S.) 89 to One view of the twin towers. World Financial Center to vote. 9:08 a.m. Checked in with Diana—she and the twins were 8:45 a.m. Between Liberty and Vesey Streets (halfway to One okay. To avoid falling debris, she remained in our World Trade Center) I heard a tremendous explo- apartment. We worried about Josephine, who helps sion. I looked up and saw flames and debris com- Diana with the children three days a week, since she ing down on me. I thought it was a bomb. uses the World Trade Center subway stop. We agreed that I should go to Jennifer’s school to help out. Ran as fast as I could to World Financial Center. I tried to enter the building but the doors were 9:15 a.m. Battery Park City had already become the staging locked. I was protected from falling debris by an ground for ambulances. Walked along the water overhang. Saw people on the other side of West with throngs of workers leaving from World Street (next to One World Trade Center) engulfed Financial Center. in flames which construction workers smothered out. People next to me were crying. 9:20 a.m. Jennifer’s school was very chaotic. The ball field was being used as a helicopter pad. I was directed 8:46 am Ran to the corner of West and Vesey Streets to stop to the windowless auditorium, where I met many cars from coming into the disaster area. I directed hysterical parents and sobbing teachers. The chil- cars back up the West Side Highway (north) since dren were all watching a cartoon. I found Jennifer every other direction would have put people in and played with her and her friends. danger and blocked emergency vehicle access. 9:30 a.m. We were ordered to evacuate the school. A fireman A few emergency vehicles raced by me in the first told me in a stern voice to “move the hell out of ten minutes. When emergency personnel arrived, here.” Thousands of people were walking up the they asked if I was the person in charge. They West Side Highway, away from the towers. explained to me that all their communications were down.

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Alumni

10 a.m. The first tower collapsed. To distract the kids, I told Jennifer and I jumped on a crowded uptown train. them, “We’re all so silly for not putting suntan She immediately fell asleep in my arms. lotion on today,” and we made a game of it. 4:00 p.m. After dropping Jennifer off at my sister’s, I met Borrowed a cell phone to see how Diana and the Diana and crew walking up 2nd Avenue from the boys were—fine. Josephine had showed up. The boat dock at 34th. Gave them all a big hug and kiss. windows were all closed and sealed; she had the radio and heavy duty flashlight by her side. Diana 5 p.m. Headed up to New Rochelle to stay with my parents. is former head of emergency response for the State of New Jersey Department of Health—I knew the Night Spent all night trying to track down friends in the boys were in good hands. neighborhood.

11 a.m. Tried to cross the West Side Highway with emer- Wednesday Went shopping for clothes for the boys, Jennifer, gency vehicles racing past us. We went in shifts. It Diana, and myself. took the kindergartners about ten minutes. Ordered out from a Chinese restaurant. The own- Noon Went to check in with Diana again. Cell phones ers found out that I was at the World Trade Center. were not working too well and all pay phones had Waited in the parking lot for my food. Thought long lines, so I walked a few blocks to the nearest about things for the first time. Went back inside subway, jumped the turnstiles, and used the pay and they insisted I not pay—it was emotionally phones there. She was okay, although she could not touching. see out the windows—it was pitch black outside. Thursday/ Went to a book store to get books for the kids. 60 12:15 p.m. Took Jennifer and some of her classmates to Joe’s Friday While waiting on line to pay, I realized I was in Pizza for lunch. Tried to visit a nearby playground Borders and it dawned on me that I no longer had but it was closed. There were no cars on the streets a Borders in the neighborhood, nor dozens of other of the Village. stores that had been in the World Trade Center. The people in Borders made it out okay. 1 p.m. Called Diana. They were evacuating our building. We agreed that she should stay there as long as Saturday/ Diana’s eyes are feeling better and Josephine’s possible to minimize the twins’ exposure to the Sunday headaches are gone. debris and the long wait to be evacuated. Monday First day back at work. Spoke to several people 1:30 p.m. Checked in with Diana. We agreed that I should try who had lost someone at the World Trade Center. to come help. A parent from the neighborhood asked me to join him in returning to the neighborhood to retrieve 2:30 p.m. Went as far south as we could—Federal Plaza— some of our belongings. Observations from Battery before we were turned back. Called Diana to tell Park City are as follows: her to get out of there. We decided to meet at my sister’s apartment at 40th and 2nd. Jennifer’s school appeared fine (being used as a command post). All of Battery Park City is sealed 3:00 p.m. Diana, Josephine, and the boys left our building and patrolled by the National Guard. and walked to Battery Park, where boats typically depart for the Statue of Liberty and Ellis Island. Went through Rockefeller Park (the north park of Diana reported seeing dozens of abandoned Battery Park City). Someone had placed masks strollers covered with debris. (which I was wearing) on the little statues of car- toon characters. 3:30 p.m. Since they were some of the last out of the neigh- borhood, they have to wait to be evacuated. Walked past the year-old New York City Police Eventually, the boys get their first tugboat ride. Memorial. Along the Battery Park City promenade, police officers, firefighters, and construction work- ers were asleep on park benches.

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Alumni

A thirty-foot pile of flattened emergency vehicles was stacked alongside our building as well as a Flexible Genes piece of the World Trade Center.

The soccer field by our apartment was covered This feature on The Hon. George P. Schiavelli '74 [Ret.] was original- with tons of paper, presumably from people’s ly published in the April 11, 2001 LA Daily Journal. Copyright 2001 desks from the World Trade Center. Daily Journal Corp. Reprinted with kind permission.

Our building was fine. From our apartment on the eighth floor I could see a lot of smoke and steam When George P. Schiavelli ’74 left the bench last year to coming from the fifteen-story frame and rubble of become of-counsel at Crosby Heafey Roach & May’s Los Angeles what had been one of the towers. office, a newspaper account implied he did it for the money. He did need more income—to provide for his mother’s round-the- We were some of the lucky ones. clock medical care for Parkinson’s disease. But for Schiavelli, 52, the decision was never in doubt. His mother, a former showgirl This story was condensed from eight pages. and model, uprooted herself to move her two young sons across We apologize for its brevity. the country after a bitter divorce in the early 1950s. “As a child, I remember my mother being beleaguered in handling disputes between my brother and me,” Schiavelli, who became a full-time arbitrator and mediator last August, says. “But what served her well was that she didn’t jump into our dis- Jennifer, daughter of Les Jacobowitz ’85 and Diana putes too quickly. She always remained flexible.” Kiel M.P.H. ’83, poses with her mom near her That relationship between Schiavelli and his mother, cou- 61 school well before September 11. pled with his longtime career as an appellate attorney and appel- late court judge, has given him a unique perspective as a neutral. As a mediator, he stays flexible by not only listening to what both sides are saying—something mediators are expected to do—but also by listening to what the parties are not saying. While most disputes on the surface appear financially driven, they often are motivated by something deeper, he believes. Often, he determines what that is by looking into a party’s eyes. “I had one case recently where the person really wanted an apology,” he says. “If you can find what the parties are really upset about, you can focus on that and steer them around to where the financial dealings take on less importance.” Mediation, Schiavelli says, “is getting each side to under- stand that, when the other side is not responding the way [a party] wants, it doesn’t mean they’re being intransigent. What both sides have to do is recognize both points of view. Then you can mediate.” Schiavelli was raised in New York but moved with his mother and younger brother, Douglas, to Los Angeles when he was 6. A performer with impresario Billy Rose’s extravaganzas, Johanna Schiavelli’s face appeared on the covers of several mag- azines and was used on hundreds of billboards advertising Coca-Cola beverages. The same face, as it appeared in the 1940s, appears around Los Angeles on the sides of old diners and on serving trays used to advertise the soft drink. Growing up in a household with a single mom was a hard- ship, but Schiavelli and his brother, who died in 1992, never saw their lives that way. “I remember us trying to move into family apartments and being told we were not a family,” he says. “But

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Alumni

she provided for us, and all we knew in that house was that we two days, the discussions broke down, but Schiavelli did con- were loved. She made it seem like we were rich.” vince one side that it needed to rethink its position more careful- His mother also taught Schiavelli that he could be success- ly. Schiavelli sees that as positive. “Even if you don’t settle but ful through sheer will. In fact, when a junior-high-school teacher get the parties to rethink their positions, there’s a better chance asked Schiavelli what he wanted to be when he grew up, with- you will settle later on,” he says. out hesitation, Schiavelli replied, “Justice of the U.S. Supreme Schiavelli is also known for the astuteness of his legal briefs. Court.” Although he may not reach that goal, he is content with “As an editor, he’s the best editor I’ve ever seen, as far as appel- the path his career has taken. “I went from financial sacrifice to late briefs go,” Los Angeles sole practitioner Norman Pine says. financial suicide. That’s why I decided not to stay on the bench. “First and foremost, you need an incredibly analytical mind. No. But I had to take off the financial burden, if you will,” he says, two, you need a gift of reducing things to their essence. And No. explaining his decision to return to litigation and combine that three, you need a gift of communication. And he excels in all with assignments from Alternative Resolution Centers. three,” Pines says. After graduating from Stanford University in 1970 with a An undergraduate major in English helps, Schiavelli says. degree in English literature, Schiavelli took a year off to play “George has written some superb papers. He loves to do that,” semi-professional football as a tight end with the San Fernando Roy Wuchitech, a partner in Erin Sheppard Mullin Richter and Valley Free Lancers. “It was a nice break. It gave me the intel- Hampton of Los Angeles who has known Schiavelli for twenty- lectual rest that enabled me to do well in law school,” Schiavelli, six years, says. “You have to be very good with language, a cre- who finished first in his class of 300, says. ative writer, and be able to work with a huge volume of materi- After earning his degree from the University of California, al and bring it alive. He’s extremely good at that.” Los Angeles, School of Law in 1974, he went to work for the Los Affability is another quality that has served Schiavelli well Angeles firm of O’Melveny & Myers, where he specialized in as an arbitrator and mediator. "He has that personality to make commercial and corporate litigation. He left O’Melveny in 1976 people feel comfortable,” James Turkin, a partner in the L.A. to go with Ervin, Cohen & Jessup, where, as a partner, he focused office of Thelen Reid and Priest who has known Schiavelli for 62 on unfair competition and trade secret litigation. But not until he years as an attorney and judge, says.

“You have to enjoy doing legal research and enjoy the analysis. You’re taking a record apart and analyzing it—a record you didn’t create—and looking for flaws.”

joined Horvitz & Levy ten years later did he discover his true For Schiavelli, a little bit of diplomacy can go a long way. love, appellate work. “Lawyers unfamiliar with mediation can get in the way. They’ll A judge once told him, “At the trial, you’re trying to save posture and won’t give you an inch,” Schiavelli says. “Hopefully, the tree. On the appellate side, you’re trying to show where the you can get them to let go of that, even if it’s a little bit.” tree fits in the forest.” Schiavelli has taken that sentiment to heart. “I enjoy the intellectual challenge of taking a set record and looking at it with different eyes than lawyers at the trial,” Schiavelli says. “You have to enjoy doing legal research and enjoy the analysis. You’re taking a record apart and analyzing it—a record you didn’t create—and looking for flaws.” He was appointed to the Los Angeles Superior Court in 1994 after distinguishing himself as an expert in appellate pro- cedure. His last appointments, in 1999 and again in 2000, were as presiding judge of the court’s appellate division. Schiavelli sat by assignment of the chief justice in the Court of Appeal. Schiavelli draws on that appellate background when he analyzes cases. “I had a situation recently in which I felt I was © Daily Journal Corp, 2001 conducting an oral argument with one side because the other The Hon. George Schiavelli [Ret.] ’74 side simply could not present to me a viable legal theory,” Schiavelli recalls. ”If I were going to persuade the other side that they should alter their settlement position, I needed to do so within an available legal theory, but they had no theory.” After

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Alumni

1

CLASS of ’60 1 1. Class of ’60 2. (l to r) Barbara Boyle ’60, CLASS of ’55 Stuart Simke ’60, Vicki Pass 2 Simke

1. Class of '55 2. (l to r) Marsha Lewin and fiancé Forrest Latimer ’55; Joan and John ’60 Engman ’55; Sanford Ehrman ’55 and wife Sally 63 2

’55 2 Reunions 1

3 4

1. Family of Charlie English ’65 2. High Rollers (l to r): Stan Jones ’65, Alvin Korobkin ’65 (proud father of UCLA Law’s Professor Russell Korobkin), and Dick Shay ’65. 3. “You haven’t changed a CLASS of ’65 bit!”(l to r) Jack Newman ’65, Carlos Rodriguez ’65, and Larry Nagler ’65 ponder graduation photos. 4. Class of ’65

’65 UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Alumni

1. Class of ’70 2. (l to r) Dean Varat, Dennis Brown ’70, John Jakle ’70

CLASS of ’70 ’70 1 2

1. Will Clarke ’75, Moses Lebovits ’75, Margaret Levy ’75 2. Mark Waldman ’75, Stanley Rothbart ’75, Miriam Rothbart 3. Class of ’75 ’75CLASS of ’75 1

2 64

3

1. Fish Story (l to r): Darrel Hieber ’80, Sig Luther ’80, unidentified-yet-amazed fisherwoman, Howard Posner ’80 2. Class of ’80 1 3. Class Truants: William Warhurst ’80 (l) and Kathleen Hogaboom ’80 (r) are brought up to speed on a lecture they missed in Professor Stephen Yeazell’s civil procedure class. ’80CLASS of ’80 Reunions

3

2

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Alumni

Alumni Mentor Reception 1 September 12, 2001

During August of each year the Office of Alumni and Development and Office of Career Services are busy recruiting alumni and students to partic- ipate in the Mentor Program. The program matches first-year students with alumni profes- sionals, who will act as role models and are 2 3 available to share information with students on an array of topics ranging from insights regarding their practice area or profession to interviewing and networking skills.

This year more than 160 alumni mentors were matched with students, and many alumni are already planning on participating again next year in this rewarding program. We hope that you are interested in acting as an alumni mentor as we strongly believe that our students benefit from your experiences. Please contact Kristine 1. Karen Stigler ’04 and Werlinich, Director of Alumni Relations, at Donna Dean ’96 [email protected] or (310) 206-1121. 2. Joe Hilberman ’73 and Phillip Carter ’04 3. George Halverson ’62 and Jon Henderson ’04 4. Brent Jex ’04 and Paul 65 Beechen ’74 Alumni 4 1

2

Alumni of the Year Award

1. Honoree Elwood Lui ’69 (right) with his wife, Crystal, and son, Christopher. 2. Dan Jaffe ’62 and Bruce Clemens ’74 were among the many alumni who attended the award ceremony in support of their colleagues and their law school. 3. (Front, l to r) Alumni of the Year for Public Service Elwood Lui ’69, Dean Jonathan D. Varat, and Alumni of the Year for Professional Achievement Skip Brittenham ’70. (Rear, l to r) Shedrick Davis ’87, Vice-President of the Alumni Association; Hon. George Schiavelli [Ret.] ’74, President of the Alumni Association. The April 24, 2001 event was the most well-attended 3 Alumni of the Year Award Ceremony ever. 4. Honoree Skip Brittenham ’70 (center) is congratulated by Barbara Boyle ’60 and Michael A. Helfant ’83.

4

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Alumni

Alumni and Friends Looking for a way to get involved in your Please Join law school community?

THE NEAR The Public Interest Law Foundation EASTERN NEEDS YOU!

LEGAL Sponsor • Donate • Attend SOCIETY Please help us raise money for student public interest grants by (NELS) supporting the following events: PILF Trivia Challenge—October 23, 2001 Purchase a ticket and join the fun as students challenge faculty! Providing Near Eastern students and alumni with a support and education network PILF First Annual Jog-a-Thon—January 19, 2002 Sponsor a runner or come run for fun and funds!

NELS has provided the following activities PILF Auction—March 1, 2002 and services to its members:

Academic Support: Every year, PILF raises money to provide grants to law students who pursue 66 • Outlines and study guides otherwise unpaid work in public interest organizations. Grant recipients spend • Exam preparation workshops the summer working with organizations that serve underrepresented communi- ties and causes. Last year students worked at Public Counsel, Santa Monica Social Activities & Cultural Programs BayKeeper, Bet Tzedek Legal Services, Break the Cycle, the L.A. Center for Law • Dinners and Justice, and other organizations throughout the country. • Parties • Persian New Year The most successful events are those supported by alumni and friends. The favorite auction items are the most creative. Community Service Activities Would you: • Fundraiser for Indian Earthquake Victims • Minority Admissions Workshop ■ Sponsor a student’s summer public ■ Donate your firm’s tickets to athletic interest work? or cultural events? Symposia ■ Donate travel miles and hotel ■ Offer a week in your firm’s condo, or • Banished from the Constitution: coupons? lunch with your managing partner? Immigrants and the First Amendment ■ Donate a case, or even a bottle of • Armenian Genocide: Legal Implications your favorite wine? Let’s get creative! Any and all ideas ■ Forums Donate music, scripts, celebrity are welcome. Donations are tax • Law and the Aftermath of September 11 posters, and memorabilia? deductible and contributions will (co-sponsored by UCLA School of Law ■ Donate a car? be acknowledged at the events. and the Student Bar Association) If you would like to sponsor a PILF event or program, donate to PILF, attend an To join or for more information contact: event, or learn more about our work and our program, please contact us at (310) [email protected] 206-8625 or [email protected]; or contact Catherine Mayorkas, Director of http://www.law.ucla.edu/students/ Public Interest Programs, at (310) 206-9155 or [email protected]. studentorgs/NELS PILF • UCLA School of Law • Box 951476 • Los Angeles, • CA 90095-1476

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Alumni

Diana Abdulian Enrico Alis Michael Alti Vanessa AlvaradoElizabeth Andersen Erin Anzai Corry Ausink Peter Ballance

THOMAS BURKE ’65, the head of Class Notes Brobeck, Phleger & Harrison’s labor and employment group, died John Baker June 5 at the firm’s Los Angeles 1950s office. He was 63. A San Bernardino Double Bruin BRUCE I HOCHMAN ’52, a native, he joined Brobeck in 1994 member of the School of Law’s inau- Martin J. Schnitzer ’52 was appointed after eighteen years with Pettit & gural class, died August 12. He was Senior Vice President and General Martin. Within two years of arriv- 72. Mr. Hochman holds the distinc- Counsel of Long Term Care Group, Inc., ing there, he was made managing Brian Bark tion of being the first graduate of which is engaged in the business of partner of the Los Angeles office. the UCLA School of Law to have administering long-term care insurance Four years later, he took over passed the bar, as his impending programs for many of the major insur- management of the firm’s labor and military assignment called for an ance carriers in the country. This is his first in-house experience after spending employment group, representing early test date. Immediately fol- his entire career in private practice. clients such as airlines, cable tel- lowing law school he enlisted in evision companies, steel manufac- the Judge Advocate General Corps Jennifer Beatty Appellate court Justice Norman L. turers, and hospitals. He was 67 of the U.S. Air Force. Mr. Hochman Epstein ’58 has joined the ranks of the also a leader in the American Bar founded, in 1956, the law firm now legal giants honored by the Witkin Association, serving as chair of known as Hochman, Salkin, Rettig, Medal Award he founded nine years ago. various employment-law committees. Toscher & Perez, and practiced civil Epstein was chosen to receive the 2001 An experienced traveler, he often and criminal tax litigation for more award, which he created in 1993 to honor visited France’s wine Country and than forty years. He never retired his longtime friend and colleague, the Ira Bibbero had trekked through Nepal. He also from the practice of law, and was late Bernard E. Witkin. A five-person loved tennis and bicycling. He is actively involved in tax fraud panel selected Epstein in secret, surpris- survived by his wife, Judy, their four cases at the time of his death. ing him with the news. Epstein received the award at the annual California State children, and two grandchildren. A national presence, Mr. Bar meeting, September 8, 2001. Justice Hochman was active in Jewish Epstein co-authored a respected law charities, professional organiza- resource and has won eight awards for Daphne Bishop tions, and on the lecture circuit. educational contributions and service 1960s He lectured on rules of law and on the bench, activities that won him the tax fraud to agents of the prestigious Witkin Award. The award California Law Business named David R. Internal Revenue Service. He recognizes attorneys, judges, and legal Carmichael ’67, Senior Vice President of always was proud of his association scholars whose lifetime body of work Pacific Life Insurance, to its annual list has altered the legal landscape. with the School of Law and con- of California’s top fifty counsel. Heather Blackington-Herd tributed as a founder. He leaves a wife, Harriett, two daughters, Martin Majestic ’67 has joined the firm and two sons. of Finnegan Henderson Garrett & Dunner in their Palo Alto office.

Jeffrey Blank

Brady Bustany Christian Buckley Marti Breier Hardip Brar Passananti Erica Bose Marina Bogorad Star-Shemah Bobatoon Susanne Blossom

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Alumni

Eric Buhr Michael Byerts Laura Cadogan Daniel Callender Maren Calvert Camille Carey Eric Carpenter John Carrigan

counsel and corporate secretary of a publicly-held financial service company. Few people realize how perfectly ED his family and the collegiality of

AMOS JR. ’66, a gifted litigator and his much younger classmates to Heller Ehrman White & McAuliffe has Kelly Casillas personal injury lawyer who passed balance work and school. named David Geerdes ’68 managing away March 28 from complications partner of its forty-two-attorney San of emphysema, would have fit in as After graduation, Mr. Amos worked Diego office. He practices in labor and a law student at UCLA in 2001. Like for five years in the city attorney’s employment law and general litigation, so many of today’s students, he office and then moved to Chernow & advising clients on labor relations, came to law as a second—or third Lieb, where he spent the remainder union matters, management organiza- Claudia Castillo career. Following graduation from of his career. Mr. Amos is remem- tion, business strategies, employee matters, The University of Pittsburgh, and bered for his excellence as an negotiations, litigation strategies, and after serving in the Korean attorney, but more importantly to avoidance. Conflict, he started a family of his family, as a “gentleman’s gentle- Tom Larmore ’68, partner in the Santa three children and supported them man.” “That’s what really touches Monica law firm of Harding, Larmore, as a stonemason. At age 35 he me the most,” reflected his son, Kutcher & Kozal, has been recognized decided to pursue a life-long dream, noted neurosurgeon Dr. Ed Amos III, York Chang by the Santa Monica Chamber of 68 and with his wife Edith’s blessing, “At his memorial service, the lead- Commerce with a President’s Award for he enrolled at UCLA School of Law. ing attorneys in his field shared his extraordinary work on behalf of the Today Mr. Amos would be aided with story after story about his kind- business community. This is the third modern technology, a fabulous nesses, his civility, and gracious- time that Tom has been honored with library, and a student support sys- ness. It’s what a lawyer should be. the President’s Award for his countless tem—OWLS (Older and Wiser Law It’s what a person should be. I am hours of volunteer work representing Gary Chartier Students). But Mr. Amos relied on so proud of my dad.” the interests of local businesses.

California Law Business named Eberhard G.H. Schmoller ’68, Senior Vice President California Law Business named Louis M. the firm, is also a founder of NALSC, of CNF Transportation, to its annual list Meisinger ’67, Senior Vice President of and served on its Board of Directors and of California’s top fifty counsel. Walt Disney, to its annual list of as chair of its Ethics Committee. He is Melanie Chavira California’s top fifty counsel. also past president of the UCLA Law The first book in School Alumni Association. the “California William Roth Jr. ’67 has been living in Chronicles” trilo- Thailand since August 1996. For the past Steven Wawra ’67 announces the for- gy of historical fic- four years he has been a lecturer in the mation of Wawra Dispute Resolution. tion, Pale Truth, by Department of English at Chulalongkorn Steven spent sixteen years in general Daniel Alef ’69, University, Bangkok. counsel offices of three corporations— Ji-Li Chung has been named eight years as general counsel and sen- Book of the Year in The May 7, 2001 issue of the National ior vice president of Mitsui Real Estate General Fiction by Law Journal profiled the Los Angeles Sales USA Co., Ltd., three years as asso- ForeWord Magazine —a high honor for a legal search firm of Waldorf Associates, ciate general counsel of Vidal Sassoon, first-time author. Inc. Michael Waldorf ’67, president of Inc., and five years as assistant general

Chi-Ling Chen

Ronnie Cheung Jennifer Chow Ben Chung Joseph Cilic Lee Crawford Ana Damonte Lina Davidian Marisa Deutsch

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Alumni

Jeffrey Diener Tracy Ding Lisa Dittman Nicholas Donovan Elizabeth Downey Harry Enfijian Martin Ericson Jessica Farthing

The Bush administration and California’s President and General Counsel of MTM composing. Richard said, “It remains to be two Democratic senators have reached Entertainment, Inc. seen whether this will lead to career agreement on a process for judicial number three.“ nominations that will give each party Lon Sobel ’69 has been named a Tzvia Feiertag significant ability to veto potential judges. Distinguished Scholar at Boalt Hall and its Television personality Judge Joe Brown The central element of the process will be Berkeley Center for Law and Technology. ’73 was honored at the 23rd annual a bipartisan Judicial Advisory Committee. He joins the Center after a long career in United Blackmen of Fresno Community The panel will have subcommittees in legal education, including fifteen years Awards Banquet at the Radisson Hotel each of the state’s four federal judicial as a Professor at Loyola Law School and in downtown Fresno. Founded in 1979, districts. Those subcommittees will be a year as a Visiting Professor at UCLA the Fresno organization’s goal is to edu- composed of three Democratic and three School of Law, where he taught copy- cate African-American boys and teen- Chad Fitzgerald Republican members. A judicial nomi- right and entertainment law, and two agers about dignity, God, a strong work nation will be forwarded to the White summers in London where he taught ethic, self-worth, and family values. House only if it gets at least four sub- international entertainment law for the committee votes. The Los Angeles sub- University of San Diego Law School. He Judge Brown, in accepting the award, committee will be chaired by Elwood will continue as editor of the Entertainment talked about altruism and unselfish con- Lui ’69, a former state Court of Appeal Law Reporter, a monthly periodical he cern for the welfare of others. To illustrate judge who is now a partner at Jones, founded twenty-three years ago. He and a point, he pointed toward a former James Fitzgerald 69 Day, Reavis & Pogue, one of the nation’s his wife Carol live in Santa Monica. UCLA Law classmate, Fresno lawyer largest law firms. Judge Lui received the Willie J. Smith ’72. He told the crowd 2001 UCLA Law Alumni of the Year 1970s how Smith was a defensive tackle on the Award for Public Service. 1966 Rose Bowl football team and through sheer determination helped win After practicing law for twenty-eight Noted entertainment lawyer Ken Meyer the game. “But if you don’t have your years, Rennaisance Man Richard Nancy Fong ’69 act together, you can’t do it for someone has joined Bryan Cave LLP, one of the Blacker ’72, retired. His first three years else,” he said. nation’s largest law firms, as of counsel were with Ervin, Cohen and Jessup in to lead the firm’s entertainment industry Beverly Hills, then he was with Joshua Dressler ’73 practice based in Santa Monica. Ken began Weissburg and Aronson, Inc. in Century has joined the facul- his career with a prominent entertain- City, which, in 1996, merged with ty at the Michael E. ment law firm, where he was a partner, Milwaukee-based Foley and Lardner. Moritz College of specializing in motion picture and tele- Most of Richard’s career involved coun- Samuel Fortenbaugh Law at The Ohio vision production and distribution seling and providing transactional services State University. agreements, joint ventures, and other for nonprofit organizations and for Joshua, the Edwin financing arrangements, as well as indi- health care organizations and profes- M. Cooperman vidual talent representation. For the past sionals. His legal career followed a much Designated five years, he has built his own private shorter (eight years) career in chemical Professor of Law, is consistently ranked law practice. Previously, he was Senior engineering research and development on among the top five criminal law scholars Steven Friend Executive Vice President of Metro- the East Coast. This coming fall he will start in the U.S. He was formerly a faculty Goldwyn-Mayer, Inc., where he supervised work on his second bachelor’s degree at member at McGeorge School of Law at legal and administrative areas, as well Loyola Marymount Universtiy in Los the University of the Pacific in as television production and distribution. Angeles, where he will major in music, Sacramento, Calif. He also served as Executive Vice with an emphasis on music theory and

Blanca Fromm

Bruce Gibney Susan Gerin Rasha Gerges Oliver Genicot Amy Gaylord Anupama Gandhi Linda Funasaki Olga Fuentes

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Alumni

Jeffrey Goldberg Lee Goldberg Maya Golden-Krasner Sean Goldstein Thelma Gonzalez Jennifer Gould Trenton Goulding Gina Gutierrez

Robert Fischer Jr. ’73 has joined the Los fic jams for so long. I even get home for California Law Business named Mark D. Angeles office of Fulbright & Jaworski, lunch and dinner with my wife almost Michael ’77, Senior Vice President of LLP. As a partner, his practice will con- every weekday—another first! I’m still 3Com, to its annual list of California’s tinue to focus on commercial litigation, learning the tough and rough ropes of top fifty counsel. Dinh Ha including securities, real estate, and being a solo, but I really don’t miss the insurance matters, as well as general partner meetings and staff/personnel Rene Pimentel ’77 founded the Riverside business counseling. Before joining the hassles of the past. Best of all, I’m very Latino Film Festival late last year. Rene, firm, Robert was a partner with Dewey close to my dear alma mater, so I’m hop- who handles personal injury and work- Ballantine, LLP. ing to be at EVERY basketball game at men’s compensation cases, got a local law Pauley from now on! I truly enjoy and firm to set up a nonprofit organization called Matthew Hayes Laura K. McAvoy ’73 has joined continue to emphasize real estate, busi- Chicharron to produce the festival and Jackson, DeMarco & Peckenpaugh ness/LLC/corporate and commercial/ other future cultural events. He’d con- (JD&P) as a shareholder. She will be banking law, and I have a large practice vinced friends to put some money in the based in the Westlake Village office. in trusts and estate planning. Luckily, foundation and soon he had lined up Laura is a long-time business attorney I’ve gotten used to e-mailing, faxing, and some of the sponsors. Rene and his partners from Ventura County who represents teleconferencing. So, my move out west were able to get nine feature and docu- organizations in various industries as should be hardly noticeable, I hope! At mentary films for their brand-new festival. Randall Hegarty general counsel, including oil, real home, our daughter Lauren is graduating 70 estate, agriculture, and other businesses. from UC San Diego next month with Fred Sainick, ’77, a 1974 UC Irvine graduate degrees in urban studies and economics. and a UCI Alumni Association officer, is Victor Kenton ’74 has been appointed She will be spending the next year in Japan the UCI’s association’s choice as Alumnus U.S. Magistrate Judge. He will preside teaching English to youngsters through a Regent for the University of California for over matters in Los Angeles. joint Japanese-American Embassy pro- the next two years. Fred is a partner in the gram. Our son Kyle is finishing his first Newport Beach law firm Sainick & Coté. Carrie Hellwig Bob Kirschenbaum ’74 reports that he year as a second-generation Bruin, which is a partner with Baker & McKenzie, makes dad and mom very proud (and Rudloff Wood & Barrows in Emeryville affiliated with their Palo Alto/San grateful too). Going to the games at the has taken on Stephen Barry ’78 as an Francisco office and specializing in Rose Bowl and Pauley Pavilion are even associate. Stephen comes to the property international taxation matters. He stead- more fun now, as we all try to spot each insurance and bad faith defense firm from fastly remains an Arizona resident other across the field/court with binocu- Hagenbaugh & Murphy in Glendale,

Susan Heydenrych (where he has resided since law school lars and debate the plays by cell phone.” where he worked as an associate in with his wife of thirty years, Ellen). They insurance defense, insurance coverage, have two children—Amy, a recent Yale The May 7, 2001 issue of the National Law and business litigation. graduate, and Scott, a Yale sophomore. Journal profiled the Los Angeles legal search firm of Seltzer Fontaine Beckwith. Veteran federal prosecutor Patrick K. Richard Yang ’74 faxed us an update on Among the firm’s members is Sandra O’Toole ’78 was sworn in June 2, 2001, as what he has been doing. “After over Kass Gilman ’75, past chair of the UCLA interim U.S. Attorney for San Diego and Elizabeth Hisserich twenty years of commuting to midtown School of Law Dean’s Annual Fund. She Imperial Counties. Patrick, appointed by and downtown L.A., I opened up my is also a board member of the Los Angeles Attorney General John Ashcroft, will own law firm on the Westside. Now I JD/MBAAssociation. Sandra has written serve until a permanent U.S. Attorney is have a five-minute commute and can’t an article about planned giving for this nominated by President Bush and con- believe I put up with the drive and traf- issue of the UCLA Law Magazine. firmed by the Senate. Patrick—a politi-

Pui Ho

Phuong Hoang Joy Holman Janet Hong Cara Horowitz Crystal Howard Katherine Hsu Connie Hum Tamlyn Hunt

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Alumni

Shelly Hurwitz Allison Hyatt Paul Iannicelli Alexa Isbell Ur Jaddou Brewster Johnson Anne Jollay Andrew Jones cal independent not registered with any 1980s David R. Kuhlman ’83, who joined party—is not a candidate for the perma- Procopio, Cory, Hargreaves & Savitch nent job, which is all but certain to go to LLP on May 1, 2001, will serve as of California Law Business ranked Anne O. a Republican. “The permanent position counsel on Procopio’s litigation team. Baskins ’80, Vice President of Hewlett- Derek Jones is a political position,” he said. “I gener- Packard, the number-one attorney in its Frank Salazar ’83 ally describe myself as nonpartisan. annual list of California’s top fifty counsel. was elected vice president James G. Scadden ’79 has joined the John T. Rogers Jr. ’81 has joined the firm and to the executive San Francisco office of Carroll, Burdick of Holland & Knight LLP. Specializing committee of Sutin & McDonough LLP as a partner after hav- in the administration and taxation of trusts Thayer & Browne. ing been a name partner in the San and estates, with an emphasis on fiduci- Frank practices pri- Gail Kahan Francisco- based Scadden, Hamilton & ary responsibility and related litigation, marily in the areas of Ryan. He will continue to focus his liti- John has represented fiduciaries (both construction law, gov- gation defense practice on all aspects of corporate and individual) and benefici- ernment contracts, commercial litiga- products liability, professional negli- aries in a variety of highly complex matters. tion, and commercial lease matters. gence, suspected fraudulent claims, con- He is a certified specialist in estate plan- struction defect, and general commercial ning, trust and probate law (California The law firm of Sheppard, Mullin, Sara Kamienowicz litigation matters. His experience Board of Legal Specialization), and a Fellow Richter & Hampton LLP announced 71 includes multiple arbitrations and medi- of ACTEC. Before joining Ross, Sacks & that Guy N. Halgren ’84 has been elect- ations, as well as numerous jury trials Glazier in 1996, he was a partner in the ed chair of the firm’s executive commit- ranging from motor vehicle accident trusts and estates department of Parker, tee. Guy is a labor and employment cases to multimillion dollar asbestos Milliken, Clark, O’Hara & Samuelian. attorney. He joined Sheppard Mullin’s actions against manufacturers of industrial San Diego office shortly after it opened equipment. Before founding his own firm in 1986. He is the first San Diego-based Cara R. Richter-Daneman ’82 has Caryl Karnuk in 1991, James was a partner with Los become a partner of Buter, Buzard & chair in the firm’s history. Guy’s princi- Angeles-based Shield & Smith, where, Dunaetz LLP, a Brentwood law firm pal area of practice is general employ- with two other partners, he established specializing in family law. Cara and her ment and labor law. He has a special the firm’s San Francisco office in 1989. husband, Kenneth Daneman, have two expertise in handling wage/ hour class sons, Jonathan, 12, and Noah, 10. actions, having represented employers Geraldine A. Wyle ’79 joined the firm of in more than a dozen such cases in

Ross, Sacks & Glazier. She formerly was Victoria Jacobs ’82, has accepted a position recent years. He currently serves as Patricia Keane with Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher, and as managing attorney of the Voluntary Chair of the Wage and Hour Valensi, Rose & Magaram. Her practice Legal Services Program of Northern Subcommittee of the National Retail emphasizes estate and trust litigation California, a Sacramento-area pro bono Federation’s Committee on Employment and administration, with past experi- program that provides volunteer attorneys Law and is a consultant to the ence in general business litigation. She to assist low income people with their Continuing Education for the Bar publi- also has extensive appellate experience. civil law problems. [email protected]. cation “Handling a Wrongful Termination Action.” He is past chair of the San Hans Keeling Lawrence M. Chew ’83 was appointed Diego County Bar Association Labor associate general counsel at Franklin and Employment Law Section and is a Templeton Investments, an investment member of the Labor and Employment management and mutual fund company. Law Sections of the American Bar

Caroline Keller

Denise Kramar Jolene Konnersman Shino Komine Jeffrey Klein Danielle Klausner Benjamin King John Kim Talin Khachaturian

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Alumni

Noah Krasner Ross Kutash Su Kwak Christy Kwon Nazanin Lahijani Keith Larson William Lavery Jane Lee

Association, the California State Bar and we are delighted to support such a where she was a four-year starter for the Association, and the San Diego County fine institution.” women’s basketball team. She later Bar Association. played one season of professional bas- President George W. Bush announced ketball in France before attending the Soomee Lee Gov. Gray Davis has named San Diego his intention to nominate five individu- UCLA School of Law. lawyer and Deputy Senior Assistant als to serve in his administration, Attorney General Laura Whitcomb among them, James Edward Rogan ’83 The May 7, 2001 issue of the National Halgren ’84 to the San Diego Superior for the post of Under Secretary of Law Journal profiled the San Francisco Court. Commerce for Intellectual Property and legal search firm of Major, Hagen & Director of the U.S. Trademark Office. Africa. Among the firm’s star members

Susan Lee Dan Olivas’ ’84 first book, The Courtship James served in the U.S. Congress from is Charles Fanning Jr. ’85, who is also of María Rivera Peña: A Novella, was pub- the State of California from 1997 to 2001 co-founder of a publication that focuses lished in December 2000 by Silver Lake and was a member of the California on teaching developments in the field of Publishing. The novella is loosely based State Assembly from 1990 to 1994. He is employment law. on his paternal grandparents’ migration currently a partner with the firm of from Mexico to Los Angeles in the Venable in Washington, D.C. Stacey Snider ’85, chair of Universal 1920s. His fiction and poetry also have Pictures, received The H.E.L.P. Group’s Lisa Lenker been featured in several anthologies, California Law Business named Doug 2001 H.E.L.P. Humanitarian Award at 72 including a children’s collection of thir- Scott ’84, Senior Vice President of The Teddy Bear Picnic, the group’s 24th teen Latino writers, Love to Mamá: A Science Applications, to its annual list of annual spring luncheon. A Los Angeles- Tribute to Mothers, edited by Pat Mora California’s top fifty counsel. based nonprofit organization, The H.E.L.P. and published by Lee & Low Books in Group is dedicated to serving children April 2001. During the day, Dan is still a Val Ackerman ’85, president of the challenged by autism, Asperger’s California Deputy Attorney General Woman’s National Basketball Association Syndrome, learning disabilities, emo- Kevin Leung specializing in land use and environ- (which includes the Sacramento tional development problems, mental mental enforcement. Dan and his wife, Monarchs), is one of the keynote speakers retardation, abuse, and neglect. The Susan L. Formaker ’84, recently moved at The Sacramento Bee’s eighth annual A H.E.L.P. Group has a long-standing tra- deeper into West Hills (San Fernando Woman’s Day Professional Conference dition of honoring organizations and Valley), where their son Benjamin is & Exposition at the Sacramento individuals that have made important “having a blast enjoying the hiking Convention Center on Thursday, Oct. and enduring contributions to further-

Amy Levine trails just beyond their backyard.” 18, 2001. The other keynote speakers are ing the causes of children. Stacey was Tipper Gore and Dr. Bertice Berry, a lec- appointed chair of Universal Pictures in Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom turer, comedian, and author. Val started November 1999. During her tenure, LLP has made a precedent-setting gift of her career as a staff attorney with the Universal broke its all-time domestic $400,000 to endow the annual UCLA NBA in 1988. As a member of the Board box office record in both 1999 and 2000, Law Review Symposium in perpetuity. of Directors of USA Basketball, she also and recently broke the billion-dollar Harriet Posner ’84 and Jeffrey Cohen helped create the 1995–96 USA mark in domestic box office for the first Guang Li ’88, both partners in the firm’s Los Basketball Women’s National Team pro- time in its history. It broke its all-time Angeles office, were instrumental in gram, which culminated with a gold international record in 1999, and, in helping secure this gift. Harriet said, medal performance at the 1996 Summer 2000, became the first studio in modern “The UCLA School of Law provides an Olympics in Atlanta. She graduated box office history to open five consecu- excellent foundation for a career in law, from the University of Virginia in 1981, tive films at number one. With the recent

Emily Lieberman

Michael Lopez Amanda Loveland Quan Luc Marc Luesebrink Karen MacarahEmily Mah Ryan Mallen Rachelle Mandel

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Alumni

Heather Marlow Maria Martinez Tanya Mason Sandra Matrick Ronald Matten Eve McCabe Daniel McQueen Steven Megibow

opening of The Mummy Returns, the stu- Hahn’s chief of staff, Tim will be the capital investment company that pro- dio had the second biggest opening of gatekeeper, the top aide to the mayor of vides funding and hands-on support to all time and the biggest ever non-holi- the nation’s second-largest city. As Israeli technology companies that serve day opening in history. Variety has Hahn’s first appointment, he will have the internet infrastrucute, software, and Jasmine Mehta named her entertainment business to assemble the rest of the mayor-elect’s telcommunications markets. You can e- woman of the year. new staff. After law school, Tim worked mail scott at: [email protected]. for a downtown firm that specialized in Need2Buy has named Kevin Frankel municipal law, then as deputy city attor- Margaret Lodise ’88 and Robert Sacks ’86 ’86 Senior Vice President, Business ney in Long Beach. He returned to pri- have started their own firm, Sacks, Glazier, Development and General Counsel. vate practice before Hahn hired him in Franklin & Lodise LLP. Their practice Most recently, Kevin was Senior Vice 1997. The two had met through law con- will focus on trust, estate, and conserva- Damon Mircheff President of Operations and General ferences and other business functions. torship litigation and administration. Counsel for Aurora National Life Assurance Company. California Law Business named Lauri Michelle Sherman ’88 has been Shanahan ’87, Senior Vice President of appointed to the position of Deputy Mark Peterson ’86 and Lily Chau- The Gap, to its annual list of California’s Public Defender for Los Angeles County. Chow ’87 have formed a new litigation top fifty counsel. boutique, Peterson, Picker, Chow & Thomas A. Marrinson Aaron Moore 73 Freisleben. The firm is based in Newport Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom ’89 is a founding partner Beach, with an office in Los Angeles, and LLP has made a precedent-setting gift of of Mulroy, Scandaglia, will handle civil and business litigation. $400,000 to endow the annual UCLA Marrinson, Ryan in Law Review Symposium in perpetuity. Chicago. The firm Robert Sacks ’86 and Margaret Lodise ’88 Jeffrey Cohen ’88 and Harriet Posner opened January 17, 2001. have started their own firm, Sacks, Glazier, ’84, both partners in the firm’s Los Angeles Thomas was formerly Leanne Mouw Franklin & Lodise LLP. Their practice office, were instrumental in helping secure with Jenner & Block. will focus on trust, estate, and conserva- this gift. Jeffrey said, “We look forward torship litigation and administration. to the close relationship with the law school community that our involvement 1990s After graduating, Frank Bennett ’87 took with the Symposium will provide.” a teaching post in the University of London Haight Brown & Bonesteel announced Carlos Goodman ’88 (teaching Japanese law). Three years was featured in a that Michael Pérez ’90, who served as Amanda Nagata California Law Business ago, he moved to Nagoya University in article, “20 Under counsel to former Attorney General Japan, where he teaches comparative 40”, the annual picks of up-and-coming Janet Reno and Deputy Attorney law and the emerging law of the Internet. attorneys making their mark on the General Eric Holder, has joined the firm Frank publishes a daily newsletter on state’s legal profession. Carlos is a partner as partner. Based in the firm’s San Diego Internet-related Japanese legal develop- at Lichter Grossman Nichols & Adler. office, Michael will work with clients on ments: http://www.nomolog.nagoya- business litigation and international Scott Lenga ’88 Sarah Netburn u.ac.jp/~bennett/jen/. is living in Israel with his business transactions throughout the wife Carrie and their three daughters, United States and Latin America. His Los Angeles Mayor elect James Hahn ages 5, 2, and 5 months. He has recently practice will focus on civil litigation in Tim McOsker ’87 named to one of the joined the Emicom Group as a founding the areas of intellectual property, most powerful jobs in Los Angeles. As partner. The Emicom Group is a venture employment law, and fiduciary matters.

Yvette Neukian

Katharine Pagon Thomas Owen Nick Ortiz Michael Orlando Kristina Omme Norman Norton Rebekka Noll William Nguyen

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Alumni

Daniel Palumbo Young Park Danielle Perry John Pomeroy Herbert Poon Paul Previde Andre Quintero Jeffrey Raven

Kendig & Ross partner Jeffrey W. Nancy Kardon ’91 is an Assistant U.S. ArQule, Inc. announced the appoint- Cowan ’91 continues to weave magic Attorney in Los Angeles, where she ment of Michael Rivard ’92 to the into the law, honing his sleight of hand works in the major crimes section pros- newly created position of Vice and fire-eating skills. He occasionally ecuting violent crimes and is the office’s President, Strategic Development. In Julie Remer performs at the Magicopolis nightclub coordinator of prosecutions involving this role, Michael will take full-time in Santa Monica and still moonlights at violence against women. She juggles responsibility for the assessment and local corporate events. Classmates who these duties with caring for her two acquisition of new technologies and would like to enjoy an evening at the young sons Steven, 5 , and Andrew, 1. capabilities which ArQule will need to Magic Castle should e-mail Jeffrey at access as it builds a drug discovery [email protected]. James Menton Jr. ’91 specializes in com- organization. He will also continue to Mary Reynolds mercial litigation at Manatt Phelps & manage ArQule’s intellectual property Dawn Weekes Glenn ’91 and Myron Phllips and enjoys traveling. He recently portfolio. Michael joined ArQule in 1997 Glenn ’90 have a daughter, Danielle, visited Argentina, Chile, Gabon, and Tibet. and has held the position of Vice who is almost 2. Dawn is a partner at He also has run the L.A. marathon and was President, Legal and General Counsel. Arnold & Porter in Century City, where featured in a local television commercial she handles entertainment and in which he played Forrest Gump. In January 2001, Tony Rodriguez ’92 employment transactional matters. became a partner at Morrison & Foerster Devin Robinson [email protected]. Luz Nagle LLM ’91 was recently grant- and will move from the Walnut Creek 74 ed tenure by Stetson University Law office to the San Francisco office in mid- After more than five years of practicing School. In addition, Luz has just 2001, continuing his commercial litiga- received the Learned Hand Award for personal injury law in private practice, tion practice. Tony and his wife Dorothy Excellence in Scholarship, the highest Kenneth C. Goodsell ’91 now repre- have a son (Jason, 6/98) and a daughter faculty award that Stetson gives and one sents immigrants seeking asylum in the (Lauren, 7/00). that had not been received by a law fac- United States. Ken’s office is in Michelle Rojas ulty member for many years. Rosemead and he primarily services the David Byrnes ’93 was featured in the local Asian immigrant community. He July 30, 2001 addition of California Law After nearly five years at Warner Bros., is married to Allyson Paull and they live Business. The article, “Reluctant Self- where he headed up the business and in San Marino with son Chase, 4, and Promoter Hits Right Notes," discussed legal affairs department for the daughter Madelyn Claire, 2. Byrnes’ practice that divides his time International TV Production division, between talent and company-side repre- Adam Rosen ’91 recently joined RKO Richard D. Greta ’91 is of counsel to sentation and negotiating for music Paul Rose Pictures as head of business affairs and Mayer, Brown & Platt in Los Angeles, publishers, talent managers, and film general counsel. Adam is married, has where he does corporate, securities, and companies. two children, and lives in Los Angeles. financing work. He is the father of two daughters and continues to create some Jonathan Drimmer ’93 was featured in Laurie J. Falik ’92 has joined Carroll, of the best barbecue—including his the May 2001 premier issue of JD Jungle. Burdick & McDonough LLP after serv- secret sauce—found outside of a restau- On the next page is an excerpt from the ing as litigation counsel with the global Pat Rosvall rant. Rich invites classmates who want article “Underage Advancement: Fab insurance brokerage firm Aon Corp., to catch up or go golfing to contact him Four.” The entire article is available at where she worked in the company’s in- at [email protected]. house trial department. In 2000, Falik jdjungle.com. was selected by California Lawyer as one of its Lawyers of the Year.

Michael Roth

Karen Ruthig Joshua Sandler Sanematsu, Shirley Miguel Sanqui Amparo Sauceda Thad Schaefer Jennifer Schmied Kristen Schultz

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Alumni

Charlotte ScottLisa Sergi Allen Seto Christa Shaw Paul Shen Elizabeth Siebel Scott Silverman David Simonds

Prosecuting Nazi war criminals for the 32, was initially approached by the Bush Scott Masel ’93 proposed to DoQuyen United States Department of Justice can be Administration for a Justice Department job ”Do” Nguyen ’93 on January 20, 2001, slow going. Jonathan Drimmer gets the job as assistant attorney general for civil rights, on a Florida beach, with a jazz band sur- done fast. Since joining the D.O.J.’s elite but had more interest in a job at Education, prising Do with Duke Ellington and Leah Smith Office of Special Investigations (O.S.I.) and got the post of general counsel. George Gershwin tunes. Scott and Do are three years ago, the thirty-two-year-old UCLA In 1995, Jones left a San Francisco planning a September 1, 2001 wedding Law grad has had a hand in a half-dozen antitrust law practice to help launch the in Miami. They met at UCLA, where war-crimes convictions and deportations, and Center for New Black Leadership in they were in the same first-year section, he’s pitched in on several others. Those are big Washington. As president of the center, he and Do had to restrain Scott from repeat- numbers in the Nazi-hunting business, in took an interest in school vouchers for poor edly discussing Professor Asimow’s con- which some suspects have avoided capture children and advocated the establishment of a tracts course just so he could say ”barf Meg Smith for more than fifty years. pilot program in Washington, D.C. He also test” over and over again. Drimmer’s targets have included a former served as an analyst on MSNBC—on every- Treblinka labor camp guard; a Lithuanian thing from Israel to the new Coca-Cola can. Datev Shenian ’93 has joined the Los auxiliary policeman who held some 4,000 A graduate of the University of Angeles office of Leland, Parachini, Jews prisoner until they were executed by a California at Los Angeles Law School, Steinberg, Matzger & Melnick, LLP as a mobile killing squad; and a Ukrainian Jones spent a year as counsel to the Senate senior associate. Datev was previously accused of collaborating in the mass liquida- Judiciary Committee before shuttling back to employed at the Beverly Hills boutique April Snyder 75 tions of the Warsaw and Bialystok ghettos. California to be general counsel for then- firm of Vorzimer, Masserman & Chapman. For two years running, Drimmer has received Gov. Pete Wilson, who was implementing a His current practice includes business the U.S. Attorney General’s Meritorious statewide education test and facing legal litigation and transactions, commercial Award for outstanding job performance. But challenges of discrimination. He quickly became law, intellectual property, employment his biggest payoff comes the moment he a believer in tests and their importance to law, and real estate. introduces himself to his elusive quarry. the California reform effort. Justin Sobodash “There’s this instant of recognition,” he Bojan Bugaric’s LL.M. ’94 article, ”Courts says. “They know I’ve got them.” as Policy-Makers,” has been published in the winter 2001 Harvard International Judith Gordon-Posner ’93 married Law Journal. In an e-mail to Professor Barry Posner on March 10, 2001, in Joel Handler, Bojan wrote, ”I am especially Santa Monica. Judy also left Horvitz & indebted to you: without your help and

Levy LLP and has joined the appellate support this would not be possible. I am Anna Song group in the Los Angeles office of also indebted to the entire UCLA faculty.” Crosby, Heafey, Roach & May. Rafael Icaza ’94 has announced the for- Brian Jones ’93 was featured in the June Gerda Kleijkamp LLM ’93 (far left) wrote mation of a new partnership, Duran, 23, 2001 issue of The National Journal, in that the LL.M. class of 1993 held a Ochoa & Icaza. The Berkeley-based firm Education Department Profiles. Below is reunion in Miami Beach, Florida, in April. will practice in the areas of civil and an excerpt. They toured the art deco district, enjoyed environmental litigation, personal injury, Steven Sorell the outdoors, and caught up with each employment, wills and trusts, immigra- Brian W. Jones ’93 is General Counsel others’ careers. (l to r) Gerda Kleijkamp, tion, insurance law, and workers com- (designate) and a rising black conservative Veronique Huysmans, Maike Lüdersen, pensation. star member of the Federalist Society. Jones, Fabiana Lacerca, and Kirstin Pollack.

Julie Stewart

Stacy Tolchin David Theaker Scott Tenley Sarah Taylor Ovsanna Takvoryan Mark Takla Gene Takagi Michelle Sugihara

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Alumni

Andrea Toy Timothy Tree Spencer Turnbull Erin Walsh Stephanie Wargo William Watkins David Watts Chanda Weber

Michael Chang ’95 spoke at the IT Business Jennifer Mandigo ’97, staff attorney for Art Foerster ’99 has joined the Chicago Development Mission to Tokyo (May the Federal Trade Commission and office of Latham & Watkins. 13–16, 2001) sponsored by the Japan- charged with enforcing eventual federal America Society and the American antispam legislation, delivered the Tracy S. Kann ’99 has been appointed to Nina Wessel Chamber of Commerce in Japan, of opening address at SpamCon, a vendor- the position of Deputy Public Defender which he is a representative. neutral event for e-mail abuse manage- for Los Angeles County. ment professionals. Jennifer discussed Marc Jones ’95 made partner at the FTC’s concerns with unsolicited 2000s McDermott Will & Emery. commercial e-mail, also known as UCE or “spam.” She also described the Carey Allen ’00 has joined the firm of Syd Whalley Saul Reyes ’96 Suzanne Gregoire and Commission’s experience litigating Thompson Hine & Flory in their ’96 , married in 1998, announce the birth deception cases involving spam, and the Cincinnati, Ohio office. of Robert Gregory Reyes, born April 27, FTC’s positions on enforcement of fed- 2001. Both proud parents practice in eral legislation currently being debated Trini M. Jimenez Jr. ’00 has joined the Orange County—Saul in juvenile crimi- in Congress. Jennifer is an attorney with firm of Burke, Williams & Sorensen, LLP nal defense and Suzanne in family law. the FTC’s Division of Marketing Practices. in their Los Angeles office. Before joining the FTC, she was an associ- Gregory Williams San Jose’s Berliner Cohen has taken on Seth ate at Latham & Watkins in Washington, 76 Elizabeth Hisserich ’01 was featured in Cohen ’97 as an associate. Seth practices D.C., where her practice focused on the July 23, 2001 issue of California Law in corporate law and intellectual property. antispam litigation and defending clients Business, regarding studying for the who were the subject of government state bar exam. Cara Dunne-Yates ’97 was featured in the investigations. June 24, 2001 Sunday Telegram (Worcester, Mass.). Below is an excerpt from the Caroline Morris LL.M. ’97 has accepted Joanna Wolfe article, ”Her Spirit for Living Lights up a regular teaching position at Victoria all Lives.” University, one of New Zealand’s lead- ing universities. That Cara Dunne-Yates is blind does not deter her optimism. It never has. Without sight, Effie Turnbull ’98 has joined the firm of Cara became a world-class skier and tandem Richards, Watson & Gershon.

Aran Wong cycling champion, winning medals in both the Katie Zwarg winter and summer Paralympics. Without Blanca Quintero ’98, eyes, she graduated magna cum laude as an associate at Cozen president of her class at Harvard. She overcome O’Connor, was recently all the obvious obstacles—and some hidden appointed to The State ones—as she navigated herself through UCLA Bar of California’s Law School. “She is a woman of uncommon Committee on Ethic Lily Wong courage,” remarked Dan Doyle, director of the Minority Relations for Soniya Ziegler Institute for International Sport. The insti- a three-year term. tute inducted Cara and twenty others into its Scholar-Athlete Hall of Fame yesterday.

Virginia Wong Shalon Zeferjahn

Sophy Woodhouse Kim Worobec Alison Yager Siana Yancho Rebecca Yee David Yeremian Deborah Yim Jordan Zamir

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Honor Roll of Donors 2000–2001 Honor Roll 2000–2001 A MESSAGE FROM THE DEAN

his past year has been extraordinary for the We also are making significant progress on secur- UCLA School of Law, thanks in large part to the ing the funds needed to match the Evan Frankel T continued support of our alumni, students, Foundation’s $1 million matching gift challenge for the and friends. We truly are grateful for the generosity School of Law’s Center for Environmental Law— that you have shown during the 2000–2001 fiscal year. although we need and continue to seek additional con- As evidenced in the pages to follow, the generous tributors who want to double the impact of their giving resources provided by individuals, firms, corporations, and not allow this valuable opportunity to be missed. and foundations have helped the School of Law meet Increasing our annual, unrestricted revenue is many of our goals. We continue to focus on always a high priority, and I am pleased 77 expanding our programmatic offerings to report that this past fiscal year was a and enhancing faculty opportunities for record year for the Law Annual Fund. research and teaching, and I am delight- Your commitment to helping us fulfill ed to announce that we have secured a our mission to educate the next genera- gift in excess of $2.5 million from Charles tion of lawyers resulted in our raising in R. Williams that will establish The excess of $813,000. We are deeply grate- Charles R. Williams Project on Sexual ful to each and every one of you for your Orientation and the Law. In its first contributions. phase, the Williams Project will support a Your continued dedication to your law number of activities, including a speak- school has helped make many of our ers’ series, a symposium focused on sexual orientation goals a reality. Thank you again for your generous sup- discrimination issues, and a judicial education confer- port during the past year. On behalf of the entire law ence. Ultimately, we intend to build an institute that school community, I look forward to working together also will support a visiting scholars program and more. during the next year at the UCLA School of Law as we It also gives me great pleasure to report that the law strive to attain our first year in which the Annual Fund firm of Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP has reaches the $1 million level. With your continued help, made a generous commitment of $400,000 to the School and that of many more graduates in our ever-expand- of Law to endow the annual Law Review Symposium. ing alumni network, I am confident that together we This gift—the largest gift from a law firm in the law can surpass that goal. school's history—will enhance significantly the Law Review Symposium, a prestigious event that brings together distinguished legal scholars and social scientists in a forum for debate and discussion at the School of Law. Jonathan D. Varat

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Honor Roll of Donors 2000–2001

Simple, Profitable, and Rewarding Planned Giving

The UCLA School of Law is recognized as one of the nation’s out- standing law schools, a distinction we have achieved in much less time and with fewer resources than our peers. We opened our doors in 1949, while all but a few of the other top-twenty law schools began before the turn of the last century. Our endowment recently stood at $34 mil- lion, compared with an average of $214 million for these schools. With competition among elite law schools increasing, our priority now is to build this endowment to insure continuing distinction in our second half century. Sandra Kass Gilman ’75 describes some of the important ways in which you can provide support for your law school, support “As an alumna and we now ask you to consider. volunteer, I am very proud of my association with TAX LAW CHANGES without being subject to the estate tax UCLA.” and concurrently reducing the maxi- BRING NEW mum tax rates. In 2010, the estate tax is Sandra Kass Gilman B.A. ’72, J.D. ’75 78 OPPORTUNITIES scheduled to be eliminated, although the changes which have been made Sandra Kass Gilman ’72, J.D. ’75 Sandra received two degrees from will be reversed unless they are re- UCLA and is a very active campus vol- enacted by Congress prior to the end of unteer. She serves as chair of the First n my role as an estate planning that year. While the amount that can be Century Society Advisory Council. attorney, I stress the importance transferred without being subject to gift The Society honors alumni, friends, of understanding how the tax tax will not change from the present faculty, and staff who have recognized laws can affect one’s financial $1,000,000 exemption, the gift tax rates UCLA through a will, living trust, char- Iplanning and how careful planning will also be gradually decreased over itable remainder trust, charitable gift can result in the maximum benefits for the next nine years. annuity, retirement plan, or other my clients, their families, and the char- Other changes made by the Act estate planning arrangement. ities they wish to support. While plan- include the gradual reduction of income She also serves on the Board of ning can be difficult under the tax rates and increases in the amount Directors of The UCLA Foundation Economic Growth and Tax Relief that can be contributed to Individual and on the Foundation’s Planned Giving Reconciliation Act of 2001 (EGTRRA), Retirement Accounts (IRAs) and in the Committee, chairs the Foundation’s since the tax rates and exemptions are amount allowed for child care credits. Bylaws Committee, has served as an scheduled to change almost every year, Higher-income taxpayers will also be officer and director of Gold Shield the Act does present some planning able to claim more of their itemized Alumnae of UCLA, Prytanean Alumnae, opportunities. deductions than under prior law. and the UCLA Alumni Association, One of the most significant compo- Charitable gifts will still be fully and has served as a director of Women nents of the Act is the gradual elimina- deductible under the Act for both and Philanthropy at UCLA. tion of the federal estate tax. For many income tax and estate tax purposes. Sandra practices in the areas of years after its adoption in 1917, the For income tax purposes, cash gifts can estate planning, probate, and real estate tax affected only the very wealthy. be deducted up to fifty percent of estate law. She has included UCLA in However, as asset values have grown, adjusted gross income; gifts of stocks her estate plan because she wants more and more estates have become and certain other assets that have future generations to benefit from the subject to this tax. The Act counters appreciated are deductible up to thirty superb teaching, research, and public that by gradually increasing the percent of adjusted gross income. Gifts service that UCLA offers. amount that can be transferred at death in excess of the maximum amounts may

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Honor Roll of Donors 2000–2001

Estate and Gift Taxes under the Economic Growth and Tax ANNUITY TRUST Relief Reconciliation Act of 2001 (EGTRRA)

Ms. Filia had been giving her Year Exempt Amount Exempt Amount Maximum mother $6000 a year to sup- Estate Tax Gift Tax Rate plement her income. She 2002 $1,000,000 $1,000,000 50% decided to transfer $100,000 2003 $1,000,000 $1,000,000 49% of securities to an annuity 2004 $1,500,000 $1,000,000 48% trust, which will pay her 2005 $1,500,000 $1,000,000 47% 2006 $2,000,000 $1,000,000 46% mother $7,500 per year for 2007 $2,000,000 $1,000,000 45% the rest of her life. She no 2008 $2,000,000 $1,000,000 45% longer receives the dividends 2009 $3,500,000 $1,000,000 45% of $4,000 per year from the 2010 Tax Repealed * $1,000,000 35% securities but keeps the $6,000 *Repeal may only be for one year unless Congress re-enacts it prior to the end of 2010. per year she had been giving to her mother. Since the annuity trust assets will ulti- As you revisit your own plans, I estate taxes and possibly generation- encourage you to consider including skipping transfer taxes. By making the mately be distributed to UCLA the UCLA School of Law in your plan- UCLA School of Law the beneficiary of Law, she received a charitable ning. The support of alumni and the final distribution from your retirement deduction of $63,335 that friends is critical to the ability of the plan, you can minimize or avoid the tax 79 resulted in a tax savings of School to retain its position as one of liability on your plan assets. UCLA gift $19,634 and paid no capital the nation’s premier law schools in the planning professionals can provide the twenty-first century. Here are a few appropriate language to use in your plan gains tax on the appreciation ways that you can help: documents. in value of the securities. The present value of her Gifts by Will or Living Trust Planned Gifts mother’s annuity ($100,000 A well-drafted will or trust not only There are several types of “planned” less the $63,335 charitable provides security for your family and gifts which not only provide you with deduction) was considered a minimize taxes and expenses but also an immediate income tax charitable creates a lasting legacy to benefit UCLA deduction but also offer additional gift for tax purposes but she Law. The gift can be a specific sum or benefits such as life income, future con- used her annual gift tax asset or a percentage of your estate, tinued use of the gift property, and exclusion and unified credit and the entire gift will qualify for an avoidance or reduction of capital gain to offset that tax. estate tax charitable deduction. taxes. Here are two examples:

Benefits from IRAs and Pensions Charitable Remainder Trust be carried forward and used to reduce Today, many people find that one of the With a charitable remainder trust, you taxes for up to five years. This year is a more significant assets in their estates can irrevocably transfer cash, appreciated great time to make charitable gifts. is their retirement plan. Yet it is one securities, or real property to a trustee Since effective income tax rates will be asset that can be costly for the owner to (such as The UCLA Foundation) with decreasing over the next few years, pass on to his or her heirs. Under certain instructions to pay a fixed sum or a fixed charitable deductions this year offer you circumstances, retirement plans may percentage of the trust’s assets to you greater savings because they reduce be subject to significant taxes when the or to other designated beneficiaries for a higher income tax rates. Thus, if you owner dies and the plan assets are dis- specific number of years or for a lifetime. are considering a charitable gift in the tributed, since there may be income in Upon the termination of the trust (at near future, that gift may well offer you respect of a decedent (income tax that the end of the term or at the death of more tax benefits if you make it this year. would have been due had the owner the income beneficiary), the remaining received the distribution), as well as assets will be distributed to UCLA Law.

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Honor Roll of Donors 2000–2001

In the year in which you make the addition, a portion of each annuity transfer, you receive a charitable payment is treated as a return of prin- ESTABLISHING A UNITRUST deduction in an amount equal to the cipal and therefore not subject to

present value of the remainder inter- income tax. As an added bonus, there A NUMBER OF YEARS AGO, MR. AND MRS. est—as determined by current U.S. may also be capital gains tax benefits if ESPERANZA BOUGHT MUTUAL FUND Treasury regulations. As an added the gift is funded with appreciated SHARES FOR $20,000 THAT HAVE NOT bonus, you may also receive capital assets. Annuity payments can begin gains tax benefits if the transferred immediately or can be deferred until ONLY SURVIVED THE RECENT MARKET assets have appreciated. you retire or to another future date—a DOWNTURN BUT APPRECIATED TO great way to supplement your retire- $100,000. THE FUND WAS A GROWTH Charitable Gift Annuity ment income while enjoying a signifi- FUND AND PAID ONLY 3% IN DIVIDENDS. cant charitable deduction. With a charitable gift annuity, you can If you would like more informa- THEY WANTED TO SELL THE SHARES AND also irrevocably transfer cash, appreci- tion about these gift plans or if you INVEST IN A FUND THAT GENERATED MORE ated securities, or real property to a would like to receive a special brochure, charitable organization that contracts INCOME, BUT DID NOT WANT TO PAY Charitable Giving After the 2001 Tax Act, to pay a specified annuity to you or to CAPITAL GAINS TAXES OF APPROXIMATELY please contact the Office of Alumni the beneficiary. The annuity rate Relations and Development at (310) $16,000. INSTEAD, THEY ESTABLISHED depends upon the age(s) of the benefi- 206-1121 or [email protected]. A UNITRUST FOR THE BENEFIT OF UCLA ciary(ies) and is actuarially deter- mined. In the year that you make the LAW WITH A 6% PAYOUT, WHICH transfer, you receive a charitable RESULTED IN $6,000 IN INCOME EACH

deduction for the amount by which the YEAR INSTEAD OF THE $3,000 THEY value of the transferred property 80 RECEIVED FROM THE MUTUAL FUND. (IF exceeds the value of the annuity. In THE UNITRUST ASSETS APPRECIATE, THEIR

INCOME WILL ALSO INCREASE.) THEY

PAID NO CAPITAL GAINS TAX AND RECEIVED

THE RONALD PHILIP DENITZ FELLOWSHIP A CHARITABLE DEDUCTION OF $36,309,

FUND—REMEMBERING UCLA LAW WHICH RESULTED IN A NET TAX SAVINGS

OF $13,701 BASED UPON THEIR 36%

Ronald Philip Denitz ’53 graduated Order of the Coif from the School of Law after TAX BRACKET. WITH TOTAL TAX SAVINGS serving on the UCLA Law Review. He practiced real estate law as a private practi- OF $29,071, THE NET COST OF THE

tioner and then as general counsel to what is now called Tishman West Companies. $100,000 GIFT IS $70,929 AND THE $6,000 THEY RECEIVE IS EQUIVALENT He volunteered as a consultant to the California Law Revision TO A YIELD OF 8.5%. Commission, and as a Jewish Big Brother he provided guid- ance to a young boy that he mentored until the boy reached adulthood. Following his 1991 death, his widow, Betty Denitz, established the Ronald Philip Denitz Fellowship Fund that will, in perpetuity, provide financial assistance to deserving stu- dents. Mrs. Denitz made her gift to the School of Law through an IRA designation and a provision in her living trust, and encourages other UCLA alumni and friends

to “give thought to our University home.”

Pictured here is Betty with five of her and Ronald’s grandchildren.

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Honor Roll of Donors 2000–2001

LAW ANNUAL FUND $ 524,721 $ 730,918 $ 797,671 $ 780,730 $ 813,657 1,771 2,127 1,996 1,679 1,684

81

96-97 97-98 98-99 99-00 00-01 96-97 97-98 98-99 99-00 00-01

5 YEAR GROWTH OF 5 YEAR GROWTH OF LAW ANNUAL FUND IN LAW ANNUAL FUND IN DOLLARS RAISED NUMBERS OF DONORS

TOTAL GIFTS BY SOURCE (gifts and pledges to all law school funds)

Alumni 63% $892,128

Foundations 20% $291,663

Law Firms and Corporations 11% $156,839

Faculty and Friends 5% $76,735

Other 1% $7,500

Total $1,424,863

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Honor Roll of Donors 2000–2001 Dean’s CIRCLE A MESSAGE FROM THE CHAIR

Thank you for making this another 6 29506899 record-breaking year for the Dean’s Circle. The membership and financial support provided by the Dean’s Circle continue to grow impressively. Between July 1, 2000, and June 30, 2001, ninety-nine alumni and friends, a 44% increase over the previous year’s mem- 82 bership, contributed a total of $330,515 to the Law Annual Fund. Your gifts accounted for an impressive 42% of the total unrestricted revenue raised for the School of Law. I truly am delighted to see a broad range of class 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 years represented among the Dean’s Circle members— from the School of Law’s first graduating class in 1952 GROWTH OF THE DEAN’S through the Class of 1996. Together, you set a wonder- CIRCLE IN MEMBERS ful example for your fellow alumni. For the past three years, it has been my privilege to serve as the Dean’s Circle chair. The dedication and loyal- ty demonstrated by Dean’s Circle members have been $ 42,805 $ 179,030 $ 186,764 $ 316,762 $ 330,515 tremendous and make me proud to be an alumnus of the UCLA School of Law. Thanks to each and every one of you for making this another outstanding year for the Dean’s Circle and for the School of Law. We look forward to your continued commitment in the years to come.

Marc M. Seltzer ’72

The Dean’s Circle recognizes alumni and friends who have shown lead- 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 ership in supporting the highest priority needs of the School of Law through unrestricted gifts of $2,500 or more to the Law Annual Fund during the past fiscal year. We welcome and warmly thank the new GROWTH OF THE DEAN’S and renewing members of the 2000–2001 Dean’s Circle. CIRCLE IN DOLLARS RAISED

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Honor Roll of Donors 2000–2001

he UCLA School of Law’s ability to achieve great things is remarkable. T Founded just fifty-one years ago, it Dean’s quickly joined the ranks of the nation’s top- tier law schools and has the privilege of being the youngest law school in that group. There CIRCLE are many reasons for this rapid ascent: dedi- Nancy L. Abell ’79 Karen D. Mack ’75 cated leadership, an extraordinarily talented Julian W. Bailey ’74 Michael T. Masin ’69 faculty, and academically superb students Michael Barclay ’79 Professor Richard C. Maxwell and who may choose among a number of top law Ann O. Baskins ’80 and Thomas C. De Filipps Frances L. Maxwell schools when making their decisions about Keenan Behrle ’69 John G. Mayer ’78 Professor David Binder and Melinda Binder Evan Medow ’67 and Cheryl Medow where to enroll. Philanthropy plays an equal- William M. Bitting ’65 Philip Michels ’73 ly important role in the UCLA Law’s success. Randolph Blotky ’73 Lowell J. Milken ’73 With discretionary resources from the State of John G. Branca ’75 Milton L. Miller ’56 and Marceile Miller California always extremely limited, the Harmon A. Brown ’79 Ronald Monitz ’80 School of Law increasingly has come to rely Richard J. Burdge ’79 Wendy Munger ’77 Professor Daniel J. Bussel Budge and Brenda Offer on alumni and friends to help keep it at the Timothy J. Carlson ’92 Andrea Sheridan Ordin ’65 forefront of legal education and research. Stephen Claman ’59 and Renee Claman Stanley G. Parry ’67 and Melinda Parry As I review the pages that follow, I am Edmund W. Clarke Jr. ’75 Peter T. Paterno ’76 reminded of the extraordinary generosity and Michael A. K. Dan ’69 Louis Petrich ’65 Hugo D. de Castro ’60 and Isabel de Castro Harriet Posner ’84 loyalty of the UCLA Law community. It James H. Eisenberg ’83 Shelley P. Resnik comes as no surprise, then, that this was a 83 Buddy Epstein ’74 Charles Rickershauser ’57 remarkable year for the Law Annual Fund, B.D. Fischer ’58 and Frances Fischer Linda A. Richman ’80 with a record $813,657 raised. It is hard to Ruth E. Fisher ’80 and Professor Stephen C. Yeazell James Ries ’64 exaggerate the importance of your gift—no David Fleming ’59 Charles Rigg ’69 Michael Flesch ’73 John H. Roney ’59 and Joan Roney matter what the size—to the School of Law Dawn Friedman ’66 and Stephen Friedman ’66 James L. Roper ’61 Annual Fund. To give you an idea how Gil Garcetti ’67 and Sukey Garcetti Marc M. Seltzer ’72 and Christina Snyder important your annual gifts are, it would Sandra Kass Gilman ’75 and Christopher M. Gilman ’75 Robert Serio ’85 take an endowment principal of nearly $14.5 Bruce Glickfeld ’72 Robert Shahin ’69 Wilford Godbold Jr. ’66 Ralph Shapiro ’58 and Shirley Shapiro million to produce expendable income of William D. Gould ’63 Lewis Silverberg ’58 $813,657, the total amount raised during the William W. Graham ’73 Sherman Silverman ’61 2000–2001 fiscal year. Arthur N. Greenberg ’52 and Audrey Greenberg Jed Solomon ’81 Your gifts make a tremendous difference. Bernard Greenberg ’58 Arthur G. Spence ’69 You help launch new programs and initiatives, in Stephen D. Greenberg ’77 and Myrna Greenberg Scott J. Spolin ’70 Joel M. Grossman ’79 Steven Strauss ’81 and Lise Wilson ’83 addition to expanding the existing curricu- Ragna Henrichs ’69 Peter C. Thomas ’84 lum. You help recruit and retain the best and Kenneth B. Hertz ’84 and Teri Hertz Richard W. Udko ’67 brightest new faculty members. You help Harold Hofer ’80 Jeffrey Y. Suto ’88 expand the Hugh & Hazel Darling Law Walter Howald ’65 Dirk Van De Bunt ’82 Stanley R. Jones ’65 Jonathan D. Varat and Barbara A. Varat Library collections and the resources both fac- Spencer Karpf ’79 Judith Welch Wegner ’76 ulty and students rely on to do their work. No David Kelton ’62 and Lenny Kelton Earl Weitzman ’71 less important, you help UCLA Law by pro- Kenneth A. Kleinberg ’67 John Weston ’69 viding the critical resources necessary for its David Kowal ’96 and Jennifer Meier Kowal ’96 Peter A. Wissner ’73 day-to-day operations. Karin Krogius ’82 and Scott Mason Dorothy Wolpert ’76 Frederick Kuperberg ’66 Robert J. Wynne ’67 On behalf of everyone in the UCLA Richard A. Lane ’67 School of Law community, thank you for Saul Lessler ’65 Italics indicate renewing members; boldface your commitment and support. Fred L. Leydorf ’58 and Mary Leydorf indicates membership in the Dean’s Cabinet Rochelle Lindsey ’79 and Ted Obrzut ’74 ($5,000 or more gift to the Law Annual Fund). Frances Lossing ’78 Marc M. Seltzer ’72

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Honor Roll of Donors 2000–2001 Honor Roll DONORS

2000–2001 HONOR Supporters CLASS OF 1953 David Mellinkoff Memorial CLASS OF 1957 ROLL OF DONORS Gifts to $124 Lecture Fund Living Alumni: 34 Living Alumni: 73 *The Founders Program was Roger C. Pettitt Fiscal Year July 1, 2000 to Number of Donors: 7 Number of Donors: 10 established many years ago June 30, 2001 Participation: 21% Participation: 14% to encourage a high level of CLASS OF 1955 annual support in the form Along with building the James H. Chadbourn Fellows Dean’s Cabinet of a ten-year pledge. Those Living Alumni: 68 school's endowment to ensure Herbert A. Paskett Charles E. Rickershauser, Jr. appearing in this category Number of Donors: 7 its long-term financial health, are currently completing Participation: 10% one of our highest priorities is Dean’s Advocates Dean’s Roundtable their pledge. growing annual, unrestricted Jerome H. Goldberg Dean’s Advocates Seymour S. Goldberg support. We proudly present John F. Parker Herbert Z. Ehrmann CLASS OF 1952 this year’s Honor Roll of Martin B. Weinberg John R. Engman Founders Donors and warmly thank all Living Alumni: 29 Harold I. Gould Jean Ann Hirschi the alumni, friends, faculty, Number of Donors: 14 Dean’s Counsel Forrest Latiner 84 law firms, foundations, and Participation: 48% Dorothy W. Nelson James H. Chadbourn Fellows corporations whose names Dean’s Counsel Richard D. Agay appear on the following pages Dean’s Circle Supporters Myrtle I. Dankers Marvin Jabin for their support of the UCLA Arthur N. Greenberg John U. Gall John R. Marcus School of Law. These donors Charles A. Zubieta Dean’s Advocates made a gift to the Law Annual Dean’s Roundtable Supporters Ephraim J. Hirsch Fund or to a scholarship or J. Perry Langford CLASS OF 1954 Emanuel A. Nebel Arthur W. Jones other designated fund John C. McCarthy Everett W. Maguire Living Alumni: 85 between July 1, 2000 and Lester Ziffren George J. Nicholas Number of Donors: 10 CLASS OF 1956 June 30, 2001. Wells K. Wohlwend Participation: 12% Dean’s Advocates Living Alumni: 64 Number of Donors: 10 Dean’s Cabinet Arthur Alef CLASS OF 1958 Dean’s Roundtable Participation: 16% $5,000 or more Jean Bauer Fisler Carl Boronkay Living Alumni: 109 Frederick E. Mueller Joan Dempsey Klein Dean’s Circle Dean’s Circle Number of Donors: 26 $2,500 or more Dean’s Counsel Milton L. Miller Participation: 24% James H. Chadbourn Fellows Sidney R. Kuperberg Leon S. Angvire Dean’s Roundtable Dean’s Roundtable Martin J. Schnitzer Dean’s Cabinet William Cohen and Founders* Bernard D. Fischer Dean’s Advocates Irwin D. Goldring $1000 to $2499 Supporters Frederick L. Leydorf Harvey F. Grant Herbert J. Solomon Edward B. Smith III Ralph J. Shapiro Jack Levine James H. Chadbourn Fellows In Honor of Skip Brittenham Howard W. Rhodes James H. Chadbourn Fellows $500 to $999 Harold W. Horowitz ’70 and Elwood Lui ’69 Memorial Scholarship Fund Harold J. Delevie Dean’s Counsel Lelia H. Jabin Dean’s Advocates Arthur N. Greenberg Dean’s Circle Bernard Lauer $250 to $499 Geraldine Hemmerling Bernard A. Greenberg Dean’s Advocates Lewis H. Silverberg Supporters Howard N. Lehman Dean’s Counsel Law Library Campaign Fund David H. Kornblum $125 to $249 Jean Bauer Fisler Dean’s Roundtable Supporters Arthur N. Greenberg Warren J. Abbott Dean’s Discretionary H. Gilbert Jones Dean’s Counsel Classes of Endowment Fund 1999, 2000, and 2001 James H. Chadbourn Fellows Marshall L. Miles Law Alumni Association $75 to $249 Terrill F. Cox Fund Harold J. Hertzberg Irwin D. Goldring Marvin D. Rowen

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Honor Roll of Donors 2000–2001

Dean’s Advocates Dean’s Advocates Law Alumni Association Dean’s Counsel Leo W. Kwan Norman L. Epstein Stanley A. Black Fund John M. Maller David J. O’Keefe Hugh H. Evans Leon A. Farley Barbara D. Boyle Paul L. Migdal Kim H. Pearman Philip F. Lanzafame Michael Harris Jan P. Vetter Melvyn D. Sacks Bernard Lemlech Lawrence Kritzer CLASS OF 1961 Nancy B. Watson Leslie W. Light Supporters Dean’s Counsel Hunter Wilson, Jr. Anthony A. Spaulding Living Alumni: 109 George C. Halversen William A. Mayhew Robert L. Wilson III Robert W. Vidor Number of Donors: 17 Participation: 16% David and Lenny Kelton Supporters Dean’s Counsel Dean’s Counsel Fund Robert G. Mandell Roland A. Childs Russell F. Schooling Dean’s Circle David Kelton James L. Spitser Christian E. Markey, Jr. James L. Roper Henry A. Waxman Supporters Sherman Silverman Henry B. Niles II CLASS OF 1963 Martin G. Wehrli George V. Hall Supporters Joseph P. Rebeck Dean’s Roundtable Living Alumni: 107 Robert and Milly Kayyem Ned E. Flusty Ralph Cassady Number of Donors: 14 Family Fund George J. Franscel Stephen E. Claman Alan N. Halkett Participation: 13% Robert E. Kayyem Scholarship Stephen E. Claman James H. Chadbourn Fellows Dean’s Circle Law Alumni Association CLASS OF 1965 Fund Arthur Brunwasser William D. Gould Law Alumni Association Norman L. Epstein Hillel Chodos Living Alumni: 161 Fund Henry P. Nelson Dean’s Roundtable Number of Donors: 30 Charles S. Vogel Harold W. Horowitz Bernard Katzman Participation: 19% Memorial Scholarship Fund Dean’s Advocates *Dean S. Stern Law Library Campaign Fund Bernard D. Greenberg Karl J. Abert Dean’s Circle Stanton P. Belland John A. Altschul James H. Chadbourn Fellows William M. Bitting

Robert and Milly Kayyem Richard H. Berger Marvin G. Goldman Walter G. Howald Family Fund CLASS OF 1960 Richard S. Diamond Robert T. Hanger Stanley R. Jones James Lerman Ronald M. Kabrins Saul L. Lessler Ralph J. Shapiro Living Alumni: 102 85 Don B. Rolley Robert W. Rau Andrea Sheridan Ordin Number of Donors: 19 Louis P. Petrich Law School Campaign Fund Participation: 19% Arthur Soll Dean’s Counsel Dean’s Advocates Richard H. Bein John J. Bardet Dean’s Roundtable Dean’s Circle Jed O. Scully Frances L. Ehrmann Harold W. Hofman, Jr. Public Interest Law and Hugo D. de Castro Policy Program Fund Robert S. Goldberg Supporters Michael E. Schwartz James H. Chadbourn Fellows Ralph J. Shapiro Dean’s Roundtable Alan L. Freedman Norman J. White Martin Stein Edwin M. Osborne Frank G. Wells William J. McCourt Environmental Law Clinic Founders Dean’s Counsel Dean’s Advocates Ralph J. Shapiro Leonard Kolod CLASS OF 1962 Alan J. Ludecke Laurie R. Belger In Honor of Luanne C. Wells V. Gene McDonald Living Alumni: 95 and Family James H. Chadbourn Fellows Supporters Jack M. Newman Number of Donors: 16 Roger J. Broderick Alan R. Golden Robert H. Nida Participation: 17% Harold J. Stanton CLASS OF 1959 M. Alan Bunnage John K. Carmack CLASS OF 1964 Martin Wolman Dean’s Circle Living Alumni: 97 Bruce H. Newman Number of Donors: 19 David Kelton Living Alumni: 113 Dean’s Counsel Number of Donors: 17 Participation: 20% Dean’s Advocates Howard L. Berman Dean’s Roundtable Participation: 15% Robert W. D’Angelo Stephen C. Drummy Gerald V. Dicker Dean’s Cabinet Victor E. Gleason William J. Elfving Daniel J. Jaffe Dean’s Circle Stephen E. Claman Ronald J. Grueskin Alvin J. Korobkin James N. Ries John H. Roney John L. Moriarity James H. Chadbourn Fellows Sherman Rogers Supporters Dean’s Circle Harvey Reichard Dean’s Roundtable Leland D. Starkey Jerome Diamond David W. Fleming Richard A. Richards Kenneth L. Riding Stephen C. Taylor George C. Eskin Emmett A. Tompkins, Jr. Joseph E. Gerbac Dean’s Roundtable Dean’s Advocates James H. Chadbourn Fellows Alan R. Watts Carlos Rodriguez Richard N. Ellis Hiroshi Fujisaki Everett F. Meiners Leonard R. Sager Josiah L. Neeper Roger N. Kehew, Jr. Melvyn J. Ross Dean’s Counsel E. Paul Tonkovich Herbert Laskin Lawrence Teplin John G. Nelson James H. Chadbourn Fellows Todd R. Reinstein Harold W. Horowitz Bernard S. Shapiro Richard A. Rosenberg Dean’s Advocates Supporters Memorial Scholarship Fund Raymond J. Sinetar Raymond T. Gail Roland R. Kaspar Andrea Sheridan Ordin Harvey Giss

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Honor Roll of Donors 2000–2001

Law Alumni Association Harold W. Horowitz Supporters Stuart L. Olster Panayota Nanopoulos Fund Memorial Scholarship Fund James H. Banks, Jr. Robert E. Shannon Memorial Scholarship Fund Tony McDermott Gertrude Chern Clifford Douglas Ronald P. Slates Barrett S. Litt Jack M. Newman Lawrence H. Fein Robert B. Treister Law Alumni Association Fund David L. Kerrigan Richard G. Wise CLASS OF 1970 Melville B. Nimmer Robert B. Burke Michael D. Marcus Living Alumni: 174 Endowment CLASS OF 1969 Number of Donors: 27 Andrea Sheridan Ordin CLASS OF 1967 Harold W. Horowitz Memorial Scholarship Fund Living Alumni: 182 Participation: 16% Living Alumni: 244 Joseph Posner Memorial Stanley G. Parry Number of Donors: 38 Number of Donors: 52 Scholarship Fund Participation: 21% Dean’s Circle Participation: 21% Jack M. Newman Law Alumni Association Scott J. Spolin Fund Dean’s Cabinet Dean’s Cabinet Ziffren, Brittenham, Branca Michael D. Marcus Michael T. Masin Dean’s Roundtable Stanley G. Parry & Fischer Fund Steven Z. Perren Skip Brittenham Kenneth Ziffren Michael Waldorf Dean’s Circle William J. Kelleher Dean’s Circle Keenan Behrle Gil Garcetti Law Library Campaign Fund Michael A. K. Dan Founders CLASS OF 1966 Kenneth A. Kleinberg Bruce H. Spector Ragna O. Henrichs Steven L. Davis Living Alumni: 198 Richard A. Lane Charles G. Rigg Evan R. Medow Number of Donors: 28 Public Interest Law and Robert Shahin James H. Chadbourn Fellows Richard W. Udko Participation: 14% Policy Fund Arthur G. Spence Richard J. Davis, Jr. Robert J. Wynne Stanley G. Parry John H. Weston John B. Jakle Dean’s Circle Jay W. Jeffcoat Dean’s Roundtable Dawn Friedman Sony Pictures Entertainment Dean’s Roundtable Marc J. Poster Martin F. Majestic Stephen B. Friedman Fund Stanley P. Graham Thomas E. Warriner Wilford D. Godbold, Jr. Robert J. Wynne Dean’s Advocates Frederick Kuperberg Mel Ziontz James H. Chadbourn Fellows Dennis C. Brown David A. Buxbaum Linn K. Coombs 86 CLASS OF 1968 Dean’s Roundtable James H. Chadbourn Fellows Richard A. Neumeyer Laura L. Glickman Lawrence I. Schwartz Donald R. Allen Living Alumni: 181 Roger W. Pearson Linda S. Hume Kenneth R. Blumer Number of Donors: 27 Toby J. Rothschild Herbert J. Klein Founders Frank A. Ursomarso Participation: 15% Mark A. Levin Robert B. Burke Dean’s Advocates Perry E. Maguire Dean’s Advocates Dean’s Roundtable Leslie H. Abramson James H. Chadbourn Fellows Peter M. Appleton Robert C. Colton Sara L. Adler Dean’s Counsel Carl A. Albert Abraham W. Baily, III J. Michael Crowe Kenneth Drexler Kenyon F. Dobberteen Stephen W. Bershad Michael D. Berk Roger J. Gleckman Henry R. Fenton Max F. Gruenberg, Jr. Arthur S. Levine Ralph L. Block Richard M. Roberg Norman N. Flette Randall B. Hamud Cary D. Cooper Jeffrey C. Freedman Steven R. Hubert James H. Chadbourn Fellows Dean’s Advocates Roger Jon Diamond Raymond H. Goldstone Robert Y. Nakagawa Frederick W. Clough Roger L. Cossack Mark A. Ivener E. Barry Haldeman Roger F. Potash Joel R. Ohlgren Monte C. Fligsten Lawrence H. Jacobson Rowan K. Klein Prentice L. O’Leary Joseph G. Gorman, Jr. Leonard D. Jacoby Steven E. Moyer Supporters Evan G. Williams Robert J. Higa Richard N. Kipper Michael T. Shannon Maxine Baker-Jackson David A. Horowitz Jeffrey L. Linden Cameron R. Williams Allan J. Goodman Dean’s Advocates David J. Lafaille Stefan M. Mason Jan L. Handzlik Terry H. Breen Tobey H. Shaffer Sheldon Michaels Dean’s Counsel Myron L. Jenkins Audrey Ezratty Ronald I. Silverman Milton J. Nenney Robert E. Glasser Barnet Reitner Barry A. Fisher Steven Z. Perren Alan H. Lazar Robert F. Harris Dean’s Counsel Jon A. Shoenberger William M. Pate, Jr. Kirkland & Ellis Moot Court Charles J. Post III James H. Karp Hortense K. Snower Competition Gordon J. Rose Arnold T. Lester Franklin Tom Supporters Jan Handzlik Barry Russell Michael S. Ullman Terry J. Amdur Dean’s Counsel Ronald L. Sievers Leonard D. Venger Law Alumni Association Fund Lawrence E. Biegel Andrew D. Amerson Roger L. Stanton Franklin R. Wurtzel Lowell E. Graham Michael A. Cowell Michael M. Duffey Robert N. Harris, Jr. John G. Kerr Supporters Dean’s Counsel Jerold A. Krieger Allan I. Kleinkopf CLASS OF 1971 Thomas E. Andrews Daniel M. Caine Sally P. Pasette Kenneth I. Clayman Harold S. Fleischman Living Alumni: 265 Supporters James F. Stiven Harold E. Shabo Michael Glazer Number of Donors: 49 E. Mac Amos, Jr. Robert J. Sullivan W. Michael Johnson Participation: 19% Philip L. Arnaudo Law Alumni Association Fund Bruce M. Polichar David H. Brickner Keenan Behrle Gerald D. Shoaf Thomas R. Larmore Kenneth H. Meyer

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Honor Roll of Donors 2000–2001

Dean’s Cabinet Law Library Campaign Fund Law Library Campaign Fund Supporters Brian G. Gough Earl M. Weitzman James M. Prager Philip D. Dapeer Joel M. Butler Scott E. Grimes Susan Westerberg Prager Louis R. "Skip" Miller Larry A. Cohen Benton F. Gross Dean’s Roundtable Barry W. Tyerman William M. Wardlaw Paul M. Enriquez Ezequiel Gutierrez, Jr. Michael A. Ozurovich Gail Frommer Stephen S. Hamilton Ann Parode CLASS OF 1972 Public Interest Law and Craig S. Kamansky David C. Larsen Policy Program Fund Larry A. Kay S. Alan Rosen James H. Chadbourn Fellows Living Alumni: 274 Marc M. Seltzer Marlene S. Litvak Michael J. Siegel Barry E. Axelrod Number of Donors: 39 In Honor of Syd Whalley ’01 Guy R. Lochhead Christopher R. Soltow Judy Fonda Participation: 14% Richard E. Marks Rodney B. Thatcher James J. Pagliuso CLASS OF 1973 David W. Negus David H. White Richard T. Peters Dean’s Circle James K. Schultze Living Alumni: 287 Kent L. Richland Bruce S. Glickfeld Jonathan A. Wright Law Alumni Association Fund Number of Donors: 51 Bobby L. Smith Marc M. Seltzer Dale F. Kinsella Participation: 18% Robert H. Wyman Law Library Campaign Fund George P. Schiavelli Dean’s Roundtable Sheldon W. Presser Dean’s Circle Dean’s Advocates Christopher P. Bisgaard Law Library Campaign Fund Randolph M. Blotky Jan E. Chatten-Brown Andrew E. Katz Richard G. Parker Michael B. Flesch CLASS OF 1974 Allan B. Cutrow Thomas L. Watts William W. Graham John J. Frankovich Living Alumni: 297 Morrison & Foerster Public Philip Michels Marc E. Hallert Founders Number of Donors: 44 Interest Awards Ceremony Lowell J. Milken Ronald C. Lazof Wayne W. Smith Participation: 15% R. Stephen Doan Peter A. Wissner Leonard B. Levine Paul Marcus James H. Chadbourn Fellows Dean’s Circle Dean’s Roundtable CLASS OF 1975 John D. McConaghy Bob S. Bowers, Jr. Julian W. Bailey Robert F. Marshall Charles T. Morgan Gary L. Kaseff Buddy H. Epstein Living Alumni: 306 Ronald W. Rouse Paul C. Nyquist Dora R. Levin Ted Obrzut Number of Donors: 75 Michael D. Scott Michael S. Sideman Wayne W. Smith Participation: 25% Jeffrey E. Sultan Allen H. Sochel William J. Smith Dean’s Roundtable 87 David C. Tunick James R. Walther Andrew A. Kurz Dean’s Cabinet Founders Eric R. Young Mark V. Oppenheimer John G. Branca Sheldon W. Presser Stuart D. Zimring Dean’s Advocates Nancy A. Saggese Douglas B. Zubrin Richard W. Abbey Dean’s Circle Roger Crissman James H. Chadbourn Fellows James H. Chadbourn Fellows Edmund W. Clarke, Jr. Martin E. Auerbach Dean’s Counsel Bruce J. Croushore Paul L. Brindze Christopher Gilman Peter J. Dekom Anthony S. Alperin Mitchell A. Ebright Allan B. Cooper Sandra Kass Gilman Joshua Dressler Gerald M. Cole Peter Q. Ezzell William S. Davis Karen D. Mack Peter M. Fonda Frank J. Davanzo Robert L. Fisher Antonia Hernandez Gerald M. Gordon Stephen E. Hjelt Dean’s Roundtable Alan R. Jampol Dean’s Advocates James D. Barrall Supporters Dean’s Advocates James Kashian Peter C. Bronson Donna R. Black Susan E. Amerson Timothy Born Bruce M. Kramer R. Stephen Doan Deborah A. David Robert G. Blank Timothy J. Conley Cary B. Lerman Mark H. Mitchell Moses Lebovits Arthur R. Boehm, Jr. David T. Dibiase Lawrence E. May Phillip G. Nichols Charles Read Thomas R. Cory Kenneth P. Eggers Dominick W. Rubalcava Betsy A. Strauss Mary J. Curwen Bernard R. Gans William L. Winslow James H. Chadbourn Fellows Stephen W. Farr James L. Goldman Dean’s Counsel Brad N. Baker Millard M. Frohock, Jr. Joe W. Hilberman Kenneth B. Dusick Dean’s Counsel Gary A. Clark Ronald R. Gastelum Ronald J. Jacobson Linda B. Riback William L. Battles Robert A. Green Jonathan C. Gordon Randall H. Kennon Stephen D. Yslas Charles J. Cervantes Andrew J. Guilford Robert D. Mosher Louis J. Khoury Walter C. Cochran-Bond Eugene H. Irell Ricardo F. Munoz Cynthia C. Lebow Supporters Ignacio S. Cota Gary W. Maeder Gary G. Neustadter David A. Lehrer Robert T. Burke James L. Foorman Grace N. Mitsuhata Jarlath Oley Laura K. McAvoy Philip H. Hickok Barbara A. Hindin William F. Rogers George L. Schraer R. Thomas Peterson Barbara D. Moore Jonathan M. Klar Sharon F. Rubalcava Theresa J. Player Charles J. Moore Stewart C. Kwoh Harold W. Horowitz Patrick C. Quinlivan Memorial Scholarship Fund Kenneth C. Salzberg Charles Margines Dean’s Advocates Donald K. Steffen J. Thomas Oldham Deborah L. Arron Allan B. Cutrow Dean’s Counsel Victorio Uherbelau Valerie L. Baker Paul Marcus Lois G. Andrews Law Alumni Association Fund Jeffrey S. Barron Donald P. Baker Harold J. Berkus Supporters James R. Brueggemann Law Alumni Association Fund Robert Berke Marc M. Seltzer Lawrence Borys Thomas W. Cohen Douglas A. Bagby Eric D. Dean Susan B. Carnahan Paul L. Gale Kendall H. MacVey Gary J. Cohen A. Thomas Golden Kenneth Ross

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Honor Roll of Donors 2000–2001

Susan T. House CLASS OF 1976 Richard G. Opper Susan P. Shanley Dean’s Advocates Hayward J. Kaiser Ann Poppe R. Marshall Tanner Judith Bailey Living Alumni: 286 Robert M. Kunstadt Stephanie R. Scher Hilary H. Cohen Number of Donors: 51 Timothy Lappen Harvey M. Schweitzer Dean’s Counsel David R. Deutsch Participation: 18% Margaret Levy Robert A. Spira Charles E. Curtis Michael D. Dozier R. Donald McIntyre Lawrence J. Dreyfuss Wayne H. Gilbert Dean’s Cabinet Norman A. Pedersen Harold W. Horowitz William S. Dunlevy Karin Greenfield-Sanders Judith Welch Wegner Leland J. Reicher Memorial Scholarship Fund Sharon E. Flanagan Robert J. Grossman Terso R. Rosales Paul Hoffman Martin C. Kristal Barbara E. Hadsell Dean’s Circle Irwin B. Rothschild III Durham J. Monsma Dean J. Kitchens Peter T. Paterno Thomas G. Ryan Law Library Campaign Fund Cynthia H. Rushing Marlo R. Laws Dorothy Wolpert Barry E. Shanley David R. Ginsburg Daniel H. Slate Robert M. Ozell Aaron H. Simon Carolyn L. Small Lisa G. Quateman Dean’s Roundtable David Simon Debra M. Van Alstyne G. Michael Tanaka William D. Claster CLASS OF 1977 Emily A. Stevens Marguerite S. Rosenfeld Living Alumni: 315 Thomas C. Tankersley Supporters Dean’s Counsel Number of Donors: 57 Lawrence H. Thompson Paul A. Babwin Michael D. Fernhoff Founders Participation: 18% George O. Feldman Madison F. Grose Jenny Fisher Dean’s Counsel Martin A. Flannes William A. Johnson, Jr. Dean’s Cabinet Frederick B. Benson Paul E. Glad Mark A. Kuller James H. Chadbourn Fellows Stephen D. Greenberg Michael J. Budzyn Sandra Lindoerfer Vernon T. Meador III Richard Avila Robert A. Bush Lucinda A. Low Kent Y. Mouton Gregory C. Brown Dean’s Circle Bruce L. Dusenberry Kathleen M. Redmond Don G. Rushing Linda C. Diamond Wendy Munger Robert G. Garrett Catherine G. Wieder David I. Schulman Richard K. Diamond Gail D. Kass In Memory of Matthew Henry David C. Doyle Dean’s Roundtable Linda J. Maisner Law Library Campaign Fund Small ’79 Richard J. Katz Alan G. Benjamin Robert D. McGuiness Suzanne Harris Duane C. Musfelt Gregory E. Breen Gary Q. Michel William F. Sullivan Supporters David B. Parker Edwin F. Feo 88 Scott D. Miller Marlene V. Cooper Karen E. Randall Thomas A. Kirschbaum Alan M. Mirman Melville B. Nimmer Eric F. Edmunds, Jr. Terry A. Rowland Gail M. Singer Barbara M. Motz Endowment Karen L. Hancock Marc R. Stein John W. Stephens David R. Smith David A. Gerber Marlene B. Jones Bonnie E. Thomson Jonathan R. Yarowsky Marc I. Steinberg Janet S. Murillo Eugene Tillman Juan Ulloa Cynthia Podren Founders CLASS OF 1978 James D. Vandever Kneave Riggall Dean’s Advocates Carolyn H. Carlburg Glenn F. Wasserman Living Alumni: 303 Anne B. Thacher Gloria R. Bodin Richard R. Purtich Number of Donors: 53 Paul R. Tremblay Elizabeth E. Bruton Supporters Participation: 18% Arlene F. Withers Roger E. Dickinson James H. Chadbourn Fellows Victoria L. Block-Gruenebaum Kenneth L. Friedman Marilyn Barrett Lucy T. Eisenberg Dean’s Circle Law Library Campaign Fund Paul G. Hoffman Rochelle Browne Jeffrey D. Gale Frances E. Lossing Robert N. Block Valerie J. Merritt Bruce E. Cooperman Janis H. Grattan John G. Mayer Melanie K. Cook Gay Lynne Natho David W. Evans Brian E. Keefe Gary M. Stern Kenneth J. Fransen Calvin Lau Dean’s Roundtable Joseph Posner Memorial Bruce C. Stuart Gregg M. Gibbons Gilberto A. Limon Nancy R. Alpert Scholarship Fund Michael Wolf Ramon Gomez John W. Messer Daniel C. Hedigan Barbara E. Hadsell Mark D. Michael David C. Shilton Marietta S. Robinson Dean’s Counsel Carl C. Robinson Jack E. Sorokin Paul S. Rutter Alice C. Bisno Charles N. Shephard CLASS OF 1979 Timothy R. Twomey Scott Z. Zimmermann Barbara A. Blanco James H. Chadbourn Fellows Living Alumni: 271 Clyde T. Doheney Deborah A. David Miriam J. Golbert Number of Donors: 53 James P. Donohue Dean’s Advocates Endowment Fund Kenneth L. Guernsey Participation: 20% Thomas S. Epstein Gustavo A. Barcena Deborah A. David John P. Howitt Bruce G. Iwasaki Francis J. Baum Ann L. Kough Dean’s Cabinet Cheryl A. Lutz Wayne C. Collett John G. Branca Fund Linda M. Lasley Michael Barclay Margaret O’Hara Ronnie J. Dashev John G. Branca Linda K. Lefkowitz Craig S. Oshinomi Kathleen H. Drummy Elmer J. Lincoln, Jr. Dean’s Circle Gordon M. Park Teresa Estrada-Mullaney Law Alumni Association Fund Christopher J. Martin Nancy L. Abell Joseph M. Gensheimer Marjorie S. Steinberg M. Brian McMahon Harmon A. Brown Supporters Jill E. Ishida Helen W. Melman Richard J. Burdge, Jr. Nicholas S. Chrisos David P. Leonard Joseph Posner Memorial Barbara W. Ravitz Joel M. Grossman Daniel A. Dobrin Herbert D. Meyers Scholarship Fund Michael A. Robbins Spencer L. Karpf Robert A. Haut Robert J. Moore John D. Golper Martin T. Tachiki Rochelle Lindsey Kenneth M. Kumor James K. Phelps Beth L. Levine

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Honor Roll of Donors 2000–2001

Dean’s Roundtable CLASS OF 1980 Laurie L. Levenson Kenneth J. Stipanov Dean’s Cabinet Aviva M. Bergman Rebecca B. Pieroni Laurie L. Volk Karin T. Krogius Living Alumni: 302 Mark R. Burrill Steven J. Untiedt Peter C. Walsh Number of Donors: 65 D. Barclay Edmundson Juana V. Webman Dean’s Circle Participation: 22% Linda K. Engel Dean’s Advocates Dirk W. Van de Bunt Jennifer L. Machlin Supporters Mark J. Barnes Dean’s Cabinet Timm A. Miller Cathy E. Blake Susan M. Bernstein Dean’s Roundtable Ann O. Baskins Andrew S. Pauly Allan H. Cutler Regina I. Covitt Mary R. Brusewitz Ruth E. Fisher Jeanne A. Flaherty Paul P. Denzer Kathryn A. Hendley James H. Chadbourn Fellows Richard A. Jones Karen L. Matteson Joan M. Le Sage Dean’s Circle Allan E. Ceran David A. Juhnke Susan F. McNally Bruce Rosenblum Harold C. Hofer Shirley E. Curfman Rosendo Pena, Jr. Marjorie M. Mikels Thomas C. Sadler Ronald M. Monitz Cathy E. De Roy Craig G. Riemer William L. Twomey Steven E. Sletten Linda A. Richman James A. Melman Rebecca Rojo Michael L. Wilhelm Karen L. Tachiki Frances G. Smith-Wolfson Founders Dean’s Roundtable Laurel S. Terry Dean’s Counsel Gregory S. Paik Leslie A. Cohen Dean’s Advocates David F. Tilles Frank Christine III David H. Dolinko Douglas D. Barnes Bradley D. Frazier James H. Chadbourn Fellows Robert J. Finger Yolanda Barrera Clinical Program Support Jonathan F. Light Donald I. Berger Feris M. Greenberger Alan F. Broidy Fund Naomi Norwood Susan L. Claman Marc W. June Catherine B. Frink Ruth E. Fisher Jeffrey Oliphant Patrick W. Dennis Charles D. Meyer Marlene D. Goodfried Scott B. Samsky Richard J. Gruber John N. Quisenberry Bernice Hernandez Harold W. Horowitz Judith H. Uherbelau Debra L. Kegel Giacomo A. Russo Roberta S. Kass Memorial Scholarship Fund Joan E. Vogel Bert S. Nishimura Joel D. Kuperberg Anne S. Berkovitz Dennis L. Perez Founders Roger E. Lautzenhiser, Jr. Supporters Jeffrey H. Silberman David H. Dolinko Lydia S. Levin Law Alumni Association Robert E. Braun Valdo J. Smith Feris M. Greenberger Thomas H. Mabie Fund Judith K. Crawford Robbie E. Monsma Kathleen Hogaboom Helen E. Cutler Dean’s Advocates 89 James H. Chadbourn Fellows Michael W. Schoenleber Patricia H. Feiner Henry Ben-Zvi Andrew P. Bernstein Sandra I. Weishart Joseph Posner Memorial Ned S. Goldstein Patrick J. Cain Neila R. Bernstein Scholarship Fund Julie M. Heldman Jay J. Elliott Margaret R. Dollbaum Dean’s Counsel Sara T. Campos Patricia M. Ito Bryan D. Hull Thomas E. Gibbs James G. Scadden Linda A. Richman Phyllis Johnston James L. Jerue Joshua L. Green Ellen S. Winthrop-Michel Linda A. Kirios Ira D. Kharasch Rhonda J. Heth Merced Martin Elizabeth N. Winthrop CLASS OF 1981 Laura S. Landesman Darrel J. Hieber Therese A. Maynard John W. MacKay Kathleen M. Hogaboom David Melcer Supporters Living Alumni: 332 Elizabeth D. Mann Harriet B. Leva Martin A. Neumann Steven Abram Number of Donors: 59 Daniel M. Mayeda J. Scott Paisley Robert B. Orgel Lawrence W. Berger Participation: 18% Dennis A. Ragen Leslie B. Rosen John T. Rogers, Jr. Suzette Clover Martin E. Rosen Richard B. Stagg Karen G. Rosin Linda Gach Ray Dean’s Circle Joseph A. Scherer Craig P. Sapin Albert S. Glenn Jed E. Solomon Eric B. Siegel Dean’s Advocates Lynn Y. Wakatsuki Nicholas Goodhue Steven M. Strauss Jocelyn D. Thompson W. Jeffrey Austin Hoyt H. Zia Patricia R. Holt Harold A. Tieger Irene P. Ayala Otto C. Holz Dean’s Roundtable Ilene E. Trabolsi Gordon A. Goldsmith Morrison & Foerster Public Steven A. Micheli David B. Babbe Knox Kimberly Interest Awards Ceremony Mary S. Newton Dean’s Counsel Leslie B. Lindgren David Babbe Gilbert Rodriguez, Jr. Founders Mark J. Fucile Bernard J. Lurie Shelley Steuer Eric J. Emanuel Rick J. George Millicent N. Sanchez Panayota Nanopoulos Henry S. Weinstock Donna N. Lampert Linda J. Sharpe Memorial Scholarship Fund David O. Wright James H. Chadbourn Fellows Richard H. MacCracken Moises Vazquez Richard P. Fajardo James M. Ash Lou Ann M. McLean Jose A. Velasco Abby J. Leibman Law Library Campaign Fund Angela J. Campbell Rodney R. Mills Kim McLane Wardlaw John W. Crittenden Jerald L. Mosley Dean’s Counsel Public Interest Law and Leianne S. Crittenden Ann Murphy-Daily Jane Aoyama-Martin Policy Program Fund Joseph Posner Memorial Walter R. Dahl William J. Peters Dawne A. Casselle Karen Lewthwaite Scholarship Fund Robert J. DeBitetto Elizabeth A. Pollock William S. Dato Jerrold E. Schrotenboer Ralph D. Fertig Michael R. Harris Jack H. Rubens Alan H. Finkel Jonathan M. Hoff Diane S. Van Der Linde Wilbur Gin Martha B. Hogan CLASS OF 1982 Danuta M. Zaroda Kathleen R. Koch-Weser Julie S. Mebane Living Alumni: 340 David A. Lash Creighton D. Mills Number of Donors: 67 Robert T. Lemen Rensselaer J. Smith IV Participation: 20%

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Honor Roll of Donors 2000–2001

Supporters Kimberly S. Mitchell James H. Chadbourn Fellows Dean’s Circle James H. Chadbourn Fellows Linda R. Beecher Jeffrey D. Nagler Jeffrey A. Galowich Robert F. Serio Craig A. Horowitz Thomas A. Bliss R. Wayne Olmsted Philip S. Gutierrez Colleen C. McAndrews Oliver W. Bordallo Nora A. Quinn Janet A. Kobrin Dean’s Roundtable William O. Nutting Donald D. Bradley David S. Reisman Linda W. Mazur Valerie B. Ackerman Anthony L. Press Biana Coltun Susan Silver John M. Moscarino Thomas W. Weidenbach Marc H. Corman Dean’s Advocates Martha G. Rock Lori J. Feiner-Scott Dean’s Counsel John S. Bank Dean’s Advocates Linda D. Hess Brian G. Eberle Alan S. Berman James H. Chadbourn Fellows Steven B. Abbott Lee Ann Meyer Linda K. Ensbury Todd W. Bonder Brian J. Appel Edwin Carney Leslie R. Mitchner Scott A. Forsyth Kevin K. Callahan Robert G. Barnes Eric J. Diamond Pamela G. Chin Jeffrey P. Molever Kenneth L. Kutcher Donald L. Feder Daniel E. Encell John A. Crose, Jr. Michelle Patterson Michael E. Langton Stephen H. Mazur Frederick M. Entwistle Ernest L. De Sha Darien E. Pope Mark G. Schroeder Harold J. Schaaff, Jr. Joel H. Friedman Jeffrey A. Dinkin Belinda D. Rinker Louis G. Hering Lawrence H. Goldberg David A. Solitare Supporters Dean’s Advocates David E. Isenberg Robert G. Goldman Frederic M. Zinn Thomas C. Agoston Christopher B. Amandes Steven M. Kleiman Joanne G. Janson Jason Baba Thomas M. Bondy Miriam A. Krinsky Samuel N. and Leah S. Andrew W. Caine Meredith L. Caliman Dean’s Counsel Bahman B. Mashian Fischer Fund Andrew B. Downs David G. Coulter Richard W. Aldrich Cynthia E. Maxwell Charles J. Fanning, Jr. Leah S. Fischer James G. Foster Scott B. McCormack Steven S. Grabell Lynne S. Goldstein Samuel N. Fischer Roger L. Funk Evelyn A. Shimazaki Walter R. Mitchell Jane L. Henning Alan E. Garfield Naoki Shimazaki James G. O’Callahan Lynette B. Robe Public Interest Law and Kathleen C. Jeffries Lee M. Straus Jerri H. Pih Scott A. Solomon Policy Program Fund Larry S. Lee David C. Tseng John W. Scruton Anna M. Jauregui Monique C. Lillard Timothy M. Taylor, Jr. Tracy G. Lincenberg Dean’s Counsel Dean’s Counsel Geoffrey A. Drucker CLASS OF 1983 Rachel B. Mann Laura J. Birkmeyer Supporters 90 Marilyn D. Martin-Culver Charles B. Crowder Gregory R. Ellis Susan Abraham Living Alumni: 353 Victor H. Mellon Olga N. Dean Lester Jacobowitz Karen S. Bloom Number of Donors: 57 Robert B. Rocklin John P. Fernandez Duncan D. Lee Eileen D. Bradley Participation: 16% James C. Scheller, Jr. Guy N. Halgren Carol A. Quinn James M. Burns Robert H. Steinberg Laura W. Halgren Michael A. Ramirez-Mares Federico Cheever Dean’s Cabinet Wendy S. Stockton Joel T. Kornfeld Judith R. Schaffert Mary L. Clanton James H. Eisenberg Robert F. Torres Daniel A. Olivas Michael R. Schaffert Lori K. Davies Eric W. Sigg Carl R. Waldman Jai H. Rho Karen E. Harrison Dean’s Circle Edward C. Thoits Harris J. Kane Lise N. Wilson Patricia J. Titus Supporters Harold W. Horowitz David S. McLane Kathleen Yocca Coleman Brett J. Cohen Memorial Scholarship Fund Steven A. Plotkin Dean’s Roundtable Alan J. Zuckerman Jeffrey D. Davine Barry Lambergman David Polinsky Roger L. Kohn Paul S. Delson Leslie E. Wallis In-Young Lee Supporters Melanie Fairchild-Dzanis Public Interest Law and Cecilia S. Wu Susan L. Formaker Barbara R. Gadbois Policy Program Fund Jeffrey A. Young James H. Chadbourn Fellows Craig A. Goldman David R. Garcia Margaret Stevenson John S. Brandon Brad I. Golstein Carol L. Hoffman CLASS OF 1987 Renee T. Brook Sarah A. Hiestand Barbara J. Katz Dean M. Gloster CLASS OF 1984 Sedora R. Jefferson David M. Lester Living Alumni: 312 Michael A. Helfant Living Alumni: 303 Lisa H. Klein Louise D. Lillard Number of Donors: 44 Ede C. Ibekwe Number of Donors: 56 Pamela A. Mohr Franklyn W. Perkovich Participation: 14% Frank R. Jazzo Participation: 18% Barbara F. Riegelhaupt Daniel B. Spitzer Betsy R. Rosenthal Michael M. Youngdahl Dean’s Roundtable Dean’s Advocates Nancy W. Shepard Dean’s Circle Steven H. Zidell Shedrick O. Davis III Ronald A. Baker James M. Steinberger Kenneth B. Hertz Rae Sanchini Cynthia S. Conners Jordan Trachtenberg Harriet S. Posner CLASS OF 1986 Beth M. Wilson Marion G. Crain John R. Wylie Peter Coyne Thomas Kirk D. Dillman Living Alumni: 287 James H. Chadbourn Fellows Lori Huff Dillman Morrison & Foerster Public Number of Donors: 38 Dean’s Roundtable James F. Blake John C. Gastelum Interest Awards Ceremony Participation: 13% Elizabeth M. Matthias Anita T. Davidson Christal K. Grisham Naoko Shimazaki Teresa L. Remillard Leora D. Freedman David J. Hirsch Dean’s Roundtable Douglas E. Scott John P. Janka Jacquelyn S. Kiether Mark D. Baute Bruce D. Tobey CLASS OF 1985 Jeremy H. Temkin Glenn L. Krinsky Chi S. Choy Living Alumni: 304 Eric G. Lardiere James W. McSpiritt Dean’s Advocates Number of Donors: 41 Paul Maestas Edward A. Carr Terry McNiff Participation: 13%

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Honor Roll of Donors 2000–2001

Patricia A. Donahue Michael E. Calligan Dean’s Counsel Lydia C. Lai David A. Swartz Gary N. Frischling Jeffrey H. Cohen Erich D. Andersen Frank M. Lima Eugene Y. Won Melinda A. Hoyt Alice M. King Carlos A. Arcos Samuel D. Magavern Michelle S. Yee Andrea Levitt-Stein Sharon R. Leib Jacqueline S. Bryant Anne E. Pings Clarissa C. Weirick Sidney P. Levinson Caroline R. Kelly Brian Raphael Law Alumni Association Fund Steven Sinatra Todd J. Schwartz Suzanne St. Pierre Holly R. Paul Dean’s Counsel Morgan W. Tovey III Andrew J. Simon Leigh R. Strauss Michael B. Africk Scot Stone Robert E. Strauss CLASS OF 1992 Katherine M. Basile Dean’s Counsel James J. Tutchton Elaine R. Costales William J. Arzbaecher III Supporters Sonia M. Younglove Living Alumni: 283 Laura W. Cubanski Kimberly A. Caswell Kenneth A. Berlin Number of Donors: 48 Marsha B. Liss Charles O. Geerhart Jennifer M. Casey Gene Chao Memorial Fund Participation: 17% Keith E. Marlowe James M. Gelb Elena B. Dietrich Francis J. James Robyn M. Martin R. Scott McMillen Gwendolyn M. Gamble Dean’s Cabinet Jannie L. Wong Lorne R. Polger David M. Goosenberg Law Alumni Association Fund Timothy J. Carlson Suzanne Zaharoni Elizabeth H. Pugh Jennifer B. Goosenberg Jeannine K. De Phillips Michael J. Russo Steven I. Katz James H. Chadbourn Fellows Supporters Reza I. Shirazi Nathaniel J. Lipman CLASS OF 1991 Brian M. Kopperl Alyce L. Alfano Maile A. Lu’Uwai Donna Cox Wells Living Alumni: 330 John C. Chen Supporters David A. Portnoy Number of Donors: 37 Michael D. Donovan Richard A. Fleg Beau Simon Dean’s Advocates Participation: 11% Marilyn W. Formaker Ilene M. Goldberg Phillip A. Talbert Kara M. Andersen Hilary J. Greenberg Gretchen E. Jacobs Kimberly Arouh Dean’s Roundtable Peter E. Greenberg Sandra E. Lester Public Interest Law and Sonia R. Carvalho Jeffrey W. Cowan Valerie C. Hink Louis E. Michelson Policy Program Fund Peter F. Del Greco Holly R. Paul Connie R. Kane Mark D. Miller Upinder S. Kalra Stacey K. Geer Susan F. Kroll Julia S. Penick Claudia M. Harrison James H. Chadbourn Fellows Edmond J. Miller, Jr. Sanford M. Pooler, Jr. CLASS OF 1990 James C. Harrison Brian J. Pass Mark T. Roohk Janet R. Rich Audrey Lin 91 Living Alumni: 332 Scott N. Yamaguchi Gary B. Rosenbaum Peter G. Spivack Paul D. Tripodi II Ellen L. Schulhofer Number of Donors: 35 Bennett L. Yee Participation: 11% Linda L. Schwartz Panayota Nanopoulos Dean’s Counsel Dean’s Advocates David A. Steinberg Memorial Scholarship Fund Larkie D. Dam Dean’s Roundtable Carl O. Graham Lauri C. Streeter Bert Voorhees Robert L. Dell Angelo Laurie S. Temkin Audrey L. Sokoloff Ann C. Schneider Simon M. Furie Susan K. Sullivan Lynn E. Todd Public Interest Law and John S. Patterson William A. Vallejos James H. Chadbourn Fellows Policy Program Fund Jollee F. Patterson Robert C. Welsh Philip E. Cook Dean’s Counsel Steven M. Siegel Aaron P. Silberman Allison M. Keller Saskia T. Asamura Jeffrey S. Silvyn Karla N. MacCary Dayna S. Babikian Latino Students Outreach Edward J. Slizewski CLASS OF 1989 Suzanne K. Roten Jonathan M. Frenkel Fund Sara Hansen Wilson Mitchell Keiter Alicia Minana De Lovelace Living Alumni: 287 Dean’s Advocates Edward F. Malone Number of Donors: 33 Supporters Diane E. Birnholz Mariana Marin CLASS OF 1988 Participation: 7% William D. Becker Richard M. Birnholz Steven B. Quintanilla Paul E. Blevins Eric B. Gordon Living Alumni: 307 Dean’s Roundtable Boaz M. Brickman Mark D. Hurwitz Supporters Number of Donors: 36 Jon T. Yamamura David A. Carrasco William T. MacCary, III Sarah S. Ambrogi Participation: 12% Manuel J. Diaz Ann M. Mooney Lawrence P. Brennan, Jr. James H. Chadbourn Fellows Timothy L. Epp Maria R. Neiman Ruben A. Castellon Dean’s Cabinet Dwight L. Aarons Leslye M. Fraser Phillip L. Neiman Jeffrey Y. Suto Eric H. Imperial Kevin D. Caton Gregory Fuentes Lisa R. Singer Michael J. Kiely Thomas A. Clayton Demetra V. Georgelos Geoffrey M. Sturr Dean’s Roundtable Brad W. Seiling William P. Donovan Pamela G. Gross Steven M. Wilker David Schinasi Rafael S. Figueroa Catherine H. Haase Dean’s Advocates Rick L. Hasen Todd Hart Dean’s Counsel James H. Chadbourn Fellows Susan S. Azad Leeanna Izuel Elizabeth A. Hone Stephanie J. Parr Sandra S. Ikuta W. Clark Brown Rhonda S. Kaye Lisa Kim Joshua Rosenfeld Frank A. Merola Bruce D. Kuyper Scott M. Klein David J. Korduner Darcy L. Simon Kenneth A. Ostrow C. John Melissinos Samantha F. Lamberg Carolyn Y. La Jason C. Sloane Kenneth E. Petersen, Jr. Christine L. Luketic Suzanne M. Madison Supporters Kevin F. Saer Mary A. Minette Daniel F. Ortega Gregory E. Bidwell Dean’s Advocates Shelley R. Saxer William J. Morley Philip E. Rothschild Julienne Cohen Martin J. Barrack Richard S. Schkolnick Catherine M. Polisoto Rick D. Seraden Braden V. Dong Rachelle M. Bin Shirley D. Ramirez John Staudinger Eric S. Hill Robert J. Solis

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Honor Roll of Donors 2000–2001

Stratton C. Strand Steven E. Soule Seth D. Garland CLASS OF 1997 Laura B. Riley Brian P. Waldman Ronald J. Thompson Ashley N. Giesler Michael N. Steuch Living Alumni: 335 Thomas A. Waldman Hao-Nhien Q. Vu Tiffany A. Gildred Adria E. Warren Number of Donors: 21 Joseph C. Wendlberger Michael L. Weiner Yael Hartstein Participation: 6% Ligi C. Yee Karen R. Weinstein Steven C. Heller Morrison & Foerster Public Daniel T. Young Brian M. Hoffstadt Interest Awards Ceremony Dean’s Advocates Dean’s Counsel Barbara A. Krieg Sandra Cavazos Randall J. Clement Kirkland & Ellis Moot Court Scott A. Brutocao Lucila Rosas Bill Gable Jennifer L. Cummings Competition Shailendra N. Halbe Paul Ruiz Samantha Goodman Christopher A. Lilly Boaz Brickman Jack A. Halprin Raquel Vallejo Lisa Hoffman Cheryl A. Williams Benjamin D. Vazquez Linda Lee Supporters CLASS OF 1993 Dean’s Counsel Jaykant H. Bhatt CLASS OF 1999 Living Alumni: 303 CLASS OF 1996 Gilberto A. Chavez Anne-Marie N. Blevins Number of Donors: 22 Grant P. Michaelson Living Alumni: 323 Alan E. Calhoun Living Alumni: 338 Participation: 7% Number of Donors: 12 Guy F. Candelaria Number of Donors: 28 Supporters Participation: 4% Donald A. Fishman Participation: 8% Dean’s Advocates Susan C. Alker Joseph T. Gauthier Jeffrey A. Barker Carol Burns Dean’s Roundtable Peter T. Haven Dean’s Circle Sybille Dreuth Charles J. Chen Robert G. Polin Amman A. Khan David P. Kowal Carol A. Foster Christine D’Angelo Susanna M. Kim Jennifer Meier Kowal Brian M. Grossman Molly L. Dillon James H. Chadbourn Fellows Christopher D. Landgraff Stuart Y. Kim Leon C. Fan David A. Dawson Joe A. Leyva James H. Chadbourn Fellows Joseph B. Ryan Jeff J. Jeon Linda R. Medvene Stacey L. Friedlander Heather H. Kim Dean’s Advocates Jaleen Nelson Aron I. Schwartz Dean’s Counsel Christina Y. Lai Kevin R. Straw Amy W. Pellman Nancy J. Himmelfarb Dean’s Advocates Jennifer L. Mandigo Kirstin D. Poirier Dean’s Counsel Christopher L. Kelley Jason K. Axe Shereef Moharram Sheri Pym Amy I. Borlund Liane M. Randolph April M. Chung Tracy B. Rane 92 Marion I. Quinones Elizabeth S. Elson Kenneth H. Taylor Deborah R. Goldberg Laura E. Sax Holly J. Sadlon Richard A. Mathurin Andrew S. Greenhalgh Joy P. St. John Robert E. Scheid Jonathan D. West Supporters Mette H. Kurth Travis A. Stansbury Daniel J. Villalpando Juan C. Alvarez Kerry A. Ates Arthur S. Landerholm Steven D. Winegar Tina R. Hernandez Bryan D. Biesterfeld Brian S. Lee Kirkland & Ellis Moot Court Liisa I. Nogelo Beverly A. Chaney Competition Clinical Program Support Micaela H. Martin Tamar O. Faulhaber Daniel R. Zimmermann Tracy Rane Fund Supporters Howard C. Griboff Stephen L. Cope Rabinder N. Narula Alison A. Moller Morrison & Foerster Public Melissa Cowan-Cope Dean’s Counsel Kimberly F. Yang Stephen E. Holsten Sunnie L. Daniels Interest Awards Ceremony Tami S. Holsten Mary Panetta Stephen R. Wong Kirkland & Ellis Moot Court David J. Moses CLASS OF 1995 Marcos M. Tarango, Jr. Competition Victoria S. Shabanian Living Alumni: 295 Supporters Tina Hernandez Teri L. Witteman Number of Donors: 21 Wendy D. Aron CLASS OF 1998 Participation: 7% Matthew B. Berman Public Interest Law and Living Alumni: 289 CLASS OF 2000 Stephen P. Foley Policy Program Fund Number of Donors: 15 Dean’s Roundtable Caroline H. Mankey Living Alumni: 346 Jeffrey S. Galvin Participation: 5% Priscila E. Castillo Yfat M. Reiss Siegel Number of Donors: 18 Geniveve J. Ruskus Participation: 5% Dean’s Advocates CLASS OF 1994 James H. Chadbourn Fellows Andrea L. Russi Eric D. Winston James H. Chadbourn Fellows Living Alumni: 317 Emily J. Gould Pei Pei Tan Kevin M. Burke Elizabeth M. Horton William E. Thomson, III Number of Donors: 39 Dean’s Counsel Sumako J. Mccallum Elizabeth C. Vella Participation: 12% Maya Alexandri Dean’s Advocates Catherine P. Wallace Dean’s Advocates Gary E. Felicetti Carol Elias Zolla James H. Chadbourn Fellows Supporters Jie-Ming Chou Michael A. Grizzi Thomas L. Treffert Jeannette R. Busek Morrison & Foerster Public John T. Fogarty, II Dean’s Counsel Dean’s Counsel Interest Awards Ceremony Dean’s Advocates Samantha P. Goodman Christopher T. Casamassima Gretchen A. Carpenter Kevin Cops Megan M. Bruce Jeremy D. Halpern Robert E. Jenkins Joshua A. Meyer Kent J. Bullard John E. Halpin Sara D. Kalin Gregory A. Romero Panayota Nanopoulos Stephen D. Burbach Kristopher L. Hanson Christopher T. Kunz Memorial Scholarship Fund Meredith S. Goldberg Julia G. Haye K. Amar Murugan Supporters Ex Kano Sams II Thomas C. Mellor Andrea S. Hoffman Michael D. Rank James H. Ellis Daniel M. O’Leary Bernard J. Park Geoffrey T. Stover S. Elizabeth Foster Brette S. Simon Pegeen D. Rhyne Gene F. Williams

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Honor Roll of Donors 2000–2001

Supporters Dean’s Cabinet Werner Z. Hirsch Professor Alison Grey Dean’s Discretionary Hillary E. Brown Professor Daniel J. Bussel Frances S. Kupers Anderson Endowment Fund Sonya A. Schwartz Professor Richard C. Maxwell Eric C. Liebeler Brady Bustany ’01 *Ila N. Kelley Lilit Garibyan and Frances L. Maxwell Linda Richmond and Camille Carey ’01 Marshall L. Miles ’54 Rebekah N. Heiser Shelley P. Resnik Rick Richmond Kelly Casillas ’01 Marianne Heydt Franklin B. Rohner Dorothy Zackrison and Betty Chan ’01 Joseph Drown Foundation Andrew N. Merickel In Honor of Kenneth Ziffren ’65 John A. Zackrison Lee Crawford ’01 Fund Dean Jonathan D. Varat and Ismalia Gutierrez ’01 Joseph Drown Foundation Kirkland & Ellis Moot Court Associate Dean Barbara A. Supporters Phuong Hoang ’01 Philip S. Magaram, Trustee Competition Varat Dan Golenternek and Cara Horowitz ’01 Christopher Casamassima Professor Stephen C. Yeazell Marion Golenternek Derek Jones ’01 Julian Eule Memorial Fund Sara Kalin and Ruth E. Fisher ’80 Dennis Gorman Johnny Lai ’01 Harold Berlin and Audrey Gene Williams June B. Mellinkoff Emily Lieberman ’01 Berlin Gordon R. Lloyd Dean’s Circle Betty Roach In Memory of Hanna Quan Luc ’01 Morrison & Foerster Public Professor David A. Binder and Minkin Tina Lynam ’01 Interest Awards Ceremony Melinda Binder Alison Grey Anderson Professor David A. Binder and H. Catherine Mayorkas Eric Burton Budge and Brenda Offer Summer Fellowship Fund Melinda Binder J. Gregory Grossman Professor Alison Grey Eve McCabe ’01 Carole L. Eule Sarah Netburn ’01 Dean’s Roundtable Anderson Ellen D. Eule and Public Interest Law and Dawn Payne ’01 Professor Joel F. Handler and H. Catherine Mayorkas Norman L. Eule Policy Program Fund Paul Ryan ’01 Betsy Handler Jerome Kapner Jocelyn Sperling Shirley Sanematsu ’01 Leon Kaplan Julian Eule Memorial Fund In Memory of Hanna Minkin Charlotte Scott ’01 S. Edward Marder Professor David Binder and Gertrude Miller Christa Shaw ’01 CLASS OF 2001 In Honor of Professor Melinda Binder In Memory of Hanna Minkin Liza Siebel ’01 Dean Jonathan D. Varat and Phyllis Rubin and Murray Living Alumni: 307 Benjamin Aaron Retu Singla ’01 Associate Dean Barbara A. Rubin Number of Donors: 28 Professor Herbert Morris Jane Spade ’01 Varat In Memory of Hanna Minkin Participation: 9% Gloria D. Nimmer Stacy Tolchin ’01 Dean Jonathan D. Varat and Syd Whalley ’01 Harold W. Horowitz Associate Dean Barbara A. 93 Alison Grey Anderson Founders Kim Worobec ’01 Memorial Scholarship Fund Varat Summer Fellowship Fund Professor William D. Warren Alison Yager ’01 Professor Kenneth Karst and Vanessa Alvarado and Susan C. Warren Smiley Karst Samuel N. and Leah S. Brady Bustany Arnold and Porter Professor Herbert Morris Fischer Fund Camille Carey James H. Chadbourn Fellows Scholarship Fund Professor Murray Schwartz Samuel N. Fischer ’82 and Kelly Casillas Jeffrey S. Davidson Arnold & Porter and Dr. Audrey Schwartz Leah S. Fischer ’82 Betty Chan Professor Kenneth L. Karst Dean Jonathan D. Varat and Lee Crawford and Smiley Karst John G. Branca Fund Associate Dean Barbara A. Beatrice "Trix" Gendel Fund Ismalia Gutierrez Professor William A. Klein John G. Branca ’75 Varat Law Guild of Beverly Hills Phuong Hoang and Renee Klein Professor William D. Warren Cara Horowitz Robert G. Krupka Gene Chao Memorial Fund and Susan C. Warren Arthur N. Greenberg Derek Jones Francis J. James ’90 Scholarship Johnny Lai Dean’s Advocates Law Library Campaign Fund Greenberg Glusker Fields Emily Lieberman Cynthia L. Antin Stephen E. Claman Professor Richard L. Abel Claman Machtinger & Quan Luc On Behalf of Herbert Laskin ’62 Scholarship Professor Carole E. Goldberg Kinsella LLP Tina Lynam Michael E. Baumann Stephen E. Claman ’59 and Professor Richard H. Sander Eve McCabe Cheryl L. Bemis and Renee Claman Professor William D. Warren Morris Greenspan Memorial Lawrence P. Bemis Greenberg Glusker Fields Sarah Netburn Prize Fund and Susan C. Warren Claman Machtinger & Dawn Payne Harriet F. Elston and Ruth G. Bell Kinsella LLP Paul Ryan Joseph Elston Panayota Nanopoulos Shirley Sanematsu Marlene R. Leviton Elisa H. Halpern Memorial Memorial Scholarship Fund Clinical Program Support Charlotte Scott Jane B. MacKinnon and Scholarship Fund Professor Gary Blasi Fund Christa Shaw Alexander F. MacKinnon Barry Halpern Professor David Binder and Liza Siebel Ruth Ramirez In Memory of Muriel S. Brown Designated Gifts to the Melinda Binder Retu Singla Diana J. Richardson and Barry Halpern School of Law Stephen L. Cope ’94 Jane Spade Tony L. Richardson In Memory of Katie Williams Fiscal Year July 1, 2000 to Melissa Cowan-Cope ’94 Stacy Tolchin Robert C. Utley Esther B. Zeiden June 30, 2001 Professor Stephen C. Yeazell Syd Whalley In Memory of Muriel S. Brown Dean’s Counsel and Ruth E. Fisher ’80 Kim Worobec Omar & Azmeralda Alfi Fund Alison Yager Julia W. Boles and Harold W. Horowitz Public Dr. Omar Alfi and Deborah A. David Martin R. Boles Interest Fellowship Fund Azmeralda Alfi Endowment Fund Gifts from Faculty and Friends Michael J. Cook Libbie Agran On Behalf of Steven B. Deborah A. David ’75 and Anne S. Berkovitz ’80 Faculty donors who are alum- Alison Grey Anderson Quintanilla ’91 Norman Kurland Jack Berman and Pearl Brown ni of the law school are listed Summer Fellowship Fund Eva H. Davis Gertrude Chern ’66 with their respective classes Vanessa Alvarado ’01

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Honor Roll of Donors 2000–2001

Allan B. Cutrow ’71 J.W. and Ida M. Jameson Fund Arthur N. Greenberg ’52 and Michael Palley ’68 Memorial The Honorable John D. Harris Professor William Dignam and J.W. and Ida M. Jameson Audrey Greenberg Fund and Marjorie R. Harris Winifred Dignam Foundation Suzanne Harris ’77 Susan Lindenbaum Marlene V. and Walter H. Taina Elg Fred L. Leydorf ’58, Trustee Louis R. “Skip” Miller ’72 In Honor of James Kaufman Harrison Professor Gerald Estrin and Richard G. Parker ’74 Marjorie H. Loeb Walter H. Harrison Professor Thelma Estrin Robert and Milly Kayyem Susan Westerberg Prager ’71 In Honor of Susan Bookkeeping Rina and Lawrence Freedman Family Fund and James M. Prager ’71 Lindenbaum Susan J. Hartley Edythe Gerichter Robert E. Kayyem ’64 and Sheldon W. Presser ’73 and Jim and Karen Henaghan Arthur N. Greenberg ’52 and Milly Kayyem Debora Presser Joseph Posner Memorial Linda Hopkins and William Audrey Greenberg Ralph J. Shapiro ’58 and Professor Richard H. Sander Scholarship Fund Hopkins, Jr. Bernard Greenberg ’58 Shirley Shapiro Bruce H. Spector ’67 Nancy Abrolat Myles E. Hymes Marcie C. Greenberg William F. Sullivan ’77 Ronald P. Ackerman Sheila M. Jacobs Maxwell E. Greenberg David and Lenny Kelton Fund Barry W. Tyerman ’71 Allred, Maroko and Goldberg Toni J. Jaramilla Professor Moses Greenfield David Kelton ’62 and Lenny Kim McLane Wardlaw ’79 and Barrie W. Anderson Marilyn R. and Norman and Bella Greenfield Kelton William Wardlaw ’72 Amos and Martha Andrews Jepsky Geraldine Hemmerling ’52 Professor William D. Warren Robert A. Aronson Maria H. Joseph Paul Hoffman ’76 Benjamin E. King Memorial and Susan C. Warren Kermit and Ursula Bartlett Eric H. Joss Elizabeth M. Horowitz Fund Howard Berman Helene Kamzan Professor Kenneth Karst and Beverly K. Shulman Law School Campaign Fund Kathy F. Bernick Soledad and Seymour Kamzan Smiley Karst In Honor of Beatrice Halbern Arthur Soll ’58 and Barbara Ernest and Carol Blank Gail C. Kaplan Madelyn and Ronald Katz Zitelli-Soll Nancy M. Bornn Steven and Laura Kaplansky Barry Lambergman ’83 and Latino Students Outreach Philip Borowsky Janet M. Koehn Madelyn Lambergman Fund David Mellinkoff Memorial Doreen R. Braverman Marvin E. Krakow Paul Marcus ’71 and Alicia Minana De Lovelace ’87 Lecture Fund Craig T. Byrnes Ellen Lake Becca N. Marcus and Robert W. Lovelace Two Anonymous Donors California Compensation Daniel C. Lavery Marilyn and Marshall Leo A. Hodroff Seminars Barbara A. Lawless Martinez Law Alumni Association Fund Bruce C. Levin and Sara T. Campos ’80 and Therese M. Lawless A. Howard Matz Douglas A. Bagby ’71 Susan Levin Brad Seligman Lawrence Lazar Professor Herbert Morris 94 Keenan Behrle ’69 Dr. Sherman M. Mellinkoff Louis A. Cappadona Mary F. Lazar Gloria Nimmer and Harold J. Berkus ’72 and June B. Mellinkoff Cindy Carlin Paula Lebovics Milton Thomas Barbara D. Boyle ’60 Roger C. Pettitt ’54 Randi L. and Kar D. Chin Lonely Planet Publications Andrea Sheridan Ordin ’65 Robert B. Burke ’66 The Honorable Barnet M. Lisa L. Maki and Robert Ordin Michael M. Duffey ’70 Morrison & Foerster Fund Cooperman and Roslyn Manufacturers Bank Stanley G. Parry ’67 and Norman L. Epstein ’58 Morrison & Foerster Cooperman David A. Mallen Melinda Parry Irwin D. Goldring ’56 Stephen F. Danz Marian K. Manzer Miriam (Mimi) Perloff Tom Hansen Panayota Nanopoulos Ronald Dean Charles J. and Gayle J. Florence L. Robbins Kathleen Hogaboom ’80 Memorial Scholarship Fund Thomas M. Dempsey Mazursky William Rutter Dale F. Kinsella ’74 Professor Gary Blasi Dr. Walter D. Dishell Kevin R. and Laura E. Susan A. Safer Michael D. Marcus ’67 Bensinger, Grayson, Ritt & John M. Donoghue Merriman The Honorable Harvey A. Tony McDermott ’65 Gee LLP Adrienne E. Drake Brian and Myra Mintzer Schneider Kenneth H. Meyer ’69 Sharon Delugach Dr. Dale R. and Betty B. Drew Dale S. and Carolee A. Professor Murray Schwartz Jack M. Newman ’65 Richard P. Fajardo ’81 Michael S. Duberchin Newman and Dr. Audrey Schwartz Holly R. Paul ’91 Monique L. Herring Gerald A. and Sally Ducot Jack M. Newman ’65 Sanford and Madge Sklar Steven Z. Perren ’67 Abby J. Leibman ’81 Gerald and Deanna Eichwald Pacific Edge Real Estate, Inc. Dr. and Mrs. Ralph Marvin D. Rowen ’56 Hadsell & Stormer Louise A. Fernandez Cliff Palefsky Sonnenschein George P. Schiavelli ’74 Barrett S. Litt ’69 and Ralph D. Fertig ’79 and David Pasternak Evelyn and Arthur Stecher Marc M. Seltzer ’72 Paula Litt Marjorie Fertig Barbara L. and Michael M. Jean Strong Marjorie S. Steinberg ’75 Ludwig Klein Reporters & Manny Flekman Phillips Dina Tecimer Charles S. Vogel ’59 Video William M. and Sandra L. Beverly and Norm Pine The Honorable Julius Title and Michael Waldorf ’67 Dori E. Miles Gamzon Michael Posner Rita Title Sandra Munoz Joseph D. and Brenda Marvin L. and Sheila L. Rand Dean Jonathan D. Varat and Law Library Campaign Fund Anne K. Richardson Garrison Reich Adell Crost and Cvitan Associate Dean Barbara A. Professor Richard L. Abel Ex Kano Sams II ’96 David G. Geffen Michelle A. Reinglass Varat Stanton P. Belland ’59 and Carol A. Sobel Miriam Glass Linda A. Richman ’80 and Professor William D. Warren Esther Belland Traber Voorhees & Olguin Heidi G. and Barry Goldberg Steven Richman and Susan C. Warren Robert N. Block ’78 Bert Voorhees ’88 Robert Goldstein Mike Riffey Pearl B. Yoffee Melanie K. Cook ’78 John B. Golper ’75 and Howard Z. Rosen Philip D. Dapeer ’72 and Melville B. Nimmer Leslie Golper The Honorable David A. Lawrence E. Irell Prize Fund Sherry Fingarette Endowment Joseph and Dorothy Gould Rothman and Phyllis Irell & Manella Foundation Jeannine K. De Phillips ’90 Professor William P. Alford David H. Greenberg Rothman Vulcan Ventures, Inc. Jean Bauer Fisler ’52 David A. Gerber ’77 Paul A. Greenberg Jeffrey Rousso David R. Ginsburg ’76 and Andrea Sheridan Ordin ’65 Phillip J. Griego Herbert and Georgette Dena Ginsburg and Robert Ordin Barbara E. Hadsell ’78 Rubinsky Professor Carole E. Goldberg Thomson and Thomson Evelyn Halpern Stuart W. Rudnick

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Honor Roll of Donors 2000–2001

Mark S. Rudy Stanley G. Parry ’67 and Tributes Hoopa Valley Tribal Court Southern California Edison Leonard M. and Norma Sacks Melinda K. Parry During the past fiscal year, gifts In Honor of Professor Carole Company The Honorable Harvey A. Jerrold E. Schrotenboer ’81 were made to the Law School Goldberg Sprint Schneider William Senkfor in honor of the following indi- Los Angeles County Bar The St. Paul Companies Stephen and Sondra Schwartz In Honor of Syd Whalley ’01 viduals and their achievements. Association Texaco Winona L. and Wade Scott Ralph J. Shapiro ’58 and We salute these men and women In Honor of Joan M. LeSage ’82 Time Warner Inc. Harry and Margaret Sharlow Shirley Shapiro as well as those who have given Roth Family Foundation The Times Mirror Foundation Herman and Celia Sholovitz Shirley Shapiro and generously on their behalf. Sidley & Austin Universal Studios Inc. The Simon Law Firm Ralph J. Shapiro ’58 David Simon Estate Verizon Foundation Lindsay K. Slatter In Honor of Syd Whalley ’01 Professor Benjamin Aaron Thomson and Thomson The Walt Disney Company Pennie A. Spain Sidley & Austin Skip Brittenham ’70 Torres-Martinez Desert Washington Mutual Spater Gittes Schulte & Marc M. Seltzer ’72 and the Professor Carole Goldberg Cahuilla Indians Wells Fargo Bank Kolman Honorable Christina Snyder James Kauffman In Honor of Professor Carole Jon Stein In Honor of Syd Whalley ’01 Joan M. LeSage ’82 Goldberg Law Firm and Corporate Karen Stein Steven M. Siegel ’88 Elwood Lui ’69 Union Park Sponsors of the Twenty-Fifth David J. Strauss Jocelyn Sperling ’00 Leanne Mouw ’01 Annual UCLA Entertainment Curtis L. Surls Margaret Stevenson ’83 Luanne C. Wells and Family Law Firm Matching Gifts Law Symposium Fred L. Tanenbaum David W. Strom and Shirley Syd Whalley ’01 Arnold & Porter Pam Teren Strom Kenneth Ziffren ’65 Brobeck, Phleger & Harrison $5,000 or more Tobias Kraus & Torchia In Honor of Syd Whalley ’01 LLP Creative Artists Agency Madeleine Tress Susan A. Thau In Memoriam Ernst & Young International Creative Alexander G. Van Broek In Honor of Syd Whalley ’01 UCLA Law School received The Morrison & Foerster Management, Inc. Zachary Wechsler and Robert S. Wilson and gifts to the Law Annual Fund Foundation Lexis-Nexis Michelle M. Powell- Marion L. Wilson in memory of the following Musick Peeler & Garrett LLP Manatt, Phelps & Phillips, LLP Wechsler In Honor of Syd Whalley ’01 graduates and friends between O’Melveny & Myers LLP Olswang Ida Weinberg July 1, 2000 and June 30, 2001. Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher O’Melveny & Myers, LLP Iris Weinmann William A. Rutter Teaching & Flom LLP The Ziffren, Brittenham, Samuel J. Wells Award Jane Boland Snell & Wilmer LLP Branca & Fischer Foundation The Connie White Foundation William A. Rutter and Muriel S. Brown Wilmer Cutler & Pickering 95 Ralph Turner, Trustee Sally B. Rutter Professor Harold Horowitz $2,500 Laura R. and Jeffrey Winikow Professor David Mellinkoff Corporate and Foundation Akin, Gump, Struass, Hauer & Carolyn M. Yee and Bill L. Lee Sony Pictures Entertainment Hanna Minkin Matching Gifts Feld, LLP The Honorable Eric E. Younger Fund Matthew Henry Small ’79 Abbott Laboratories Fund Bloom, Hergott, Diemer and and Debra Younger Sony Pictures Entertainment Inc. Nathan H. Snyder Alcoa Foundation Cook Robert J. Wynne ’67 Katie Williams American Express Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher, LLP Public Interest Law and AT&T Foundation Irell & Manella, LLP Policy Program Fund Frank G. Wells Professorship Gifts from Law Firms, BankAmerica Knobbe, Martens, Olson & Anonymous Luanne C. Wells Foundations, and Chase Manhattan Bear, LLP Patty R. Boyle Corporations The Coca-Cola Company Landscape Entertainment In Honor of Syd Whalley ’01 Frank G. Wells American Corporate Counsel Deloitte & Touche Loeb & Loeb, LLP John H. Brinsley and Environmental Law Clinic Association Fannie Mae Morrison & Foerster, LLP Louise C. Brinsley Altshuler, Berzon, Nussbaum, Arnold & Porter Gap Foundation Stroock & Stroock & Lavan, LLP In Honor of Syd Whalley ’01 Berzon & Rubin The Shepard Broad GE Fund The Walt Disney Company Fereidoun Daftary and Ralph J. Shapiro ’58 and Foundation Glaxo Wellcome Warner Brothers Susan Daftary Shirley Shapiro Brobeck, Phleger & Goldman Sachs Fund In Honor of Syd Whalley ’01 In Honor of Luanne C. Wells Harrison LLP GTE Foundation Supporters of the 2000 UCLA Richard C. Davidoff and and Family California Applicants Harcourt General Inc. School of Law Bar Swearing- Susan Davidoff Attorneys Association Hewlett-Packard Company In Ceremony In Honor of Syd Whalley Lee B. Wenzel Memorial California Compensation IBM Hochman, Salkin, Rettig, Henri Dybnis Scholarship Fund Seminars Intel Toscher & Perez, APC In Honor of Syd Whalley ’01 Members of Lee B. Wenzel’s Edison International The Irvine Company Irell & Manella, LLP Jerry K. Fields and Poker Group The Florence Foundation Mazda (North America) Lim, Ruger & Kim, LLP Valerie S. Fields Foundation for Creativity MicroSoft Corporation McDermott, Will & Emery In Honor of Syd Whalley ’01 Michael Yaffa Memorial in Dispute Resolution Miller & Chevalier, Chartered Morrison & Foerster, LLP Jeffrey S. Galvin ’93 Scholarship Fund Greenwald Pauly Foster & Pacific Life Insurance Orrick, Herrington & Marina Grignetti Sharon Colnar Jones Miller Company Sutcliffe, LLP In Honor of Syd Whalley ’01 Ellen B. Yaffa In Memory of Jane Boland Pfizer Foundation Paul, Hastings, Janofsky & Professor Joel F. Handler Greines Martin Stein & Rockefeller Foundation Walker, LLP Anna M. Jauregui ’82 Ziffren, Brittenham, Branca & Richland LLP SBC Foundation The Honorable George P. Robert K. Johnson and Fischer Fund Gunderson Dettmer Stough Science Applications Schiavelli ’74 [Ret.] Marilyn M. Johnson The Ziffren, Brittenham, Villeneuve Franklin & International Corporation Sidley & Austin In Honor of Syd Whalley ’01 Branca & Fischer Hachigian LLP Sempra Energy Utility Sheppard, Mullin, Richter & Upinder S. Kalra ’89 Foundation Hochman, Salkin, Rettig, Ventures Hampton, LLP Karen Lewthwaite ’81 Kenneth Ziffren ’65 Toscher & Perez PC Sony Pictures Entertainment Inc. Wolff, Ellis & Clausen, LLP

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Honor Roll of Donors 2000–2001

Contributors to the Kirkland Deferred Gifts If you are not a donor and & Ellis Sponsorship of the wish to join the UCLA School ERRATA Spring 2001 UCLA School of The UCLA School of Law rec- of Law’s family of supporters, In the Honor Roll of Donors Law Moot Court Competition ognizes the exceptional gen- please call (310) 206-1121. for the Fiscal Year 2000 (July 1, Michael Baumann erosity of those individuals 1999–June 30, 2000), the fol- Lawrence Bemis who have made commitments We make every effort to lowing donors were inadver- Martin Boles to include the School of Law ensure the accuracy of our tently omitted: Boaz Brickman ’92 in their estate plans through Honor Roll and apologize in Christopher Casamassima ’00 planned gifts such as bequests, advance if any information is Richard Ellis ’59 should have Jeff Davidson pooled income funds, gift inaccurate or if omissions have been listed with his class as a Eva Davis annuities, charitable trusts, been occurred. Please contact member of the Dean’s Jan Handzlik ’70 gifts of life insurance, and gifts the School of Law Office of Roundtable. Tina Hernandez ’99 of property. Such generosity Development and Alumni Sara Kalin ’00 and foresight will guide the Relations at (310) 206-1121 if Lydia Levin ’70 should have Roberta Krupka School of Law as it meets the your name is missing or listed been listed with her class as a Eric Liebeler challenges of the century incorrectly. member of the James H. Alex MacKinnon ahead. We gratefully acknowl- Chadbourne Fellows. Tracy Rane ’97 edge the following individuals: *Deceased Tony Richardson Hortense Snower ’67 should Rick Richmond John A. Altschul ’61 have been listed with her class Gene Williams ’00 Ethel Tepp Balter as a member of the Dean’s John Zackrison In Memory of Harry Advocates. Kirkland & Ellis Foundation Graham Balter Gertrude D. Chern ’66 Contributors to the Morrison M. Scott Cooper ’79 & Foerster UCLA School of Hugo D. de Castro ’60 and Law Spring 2001 Public Isabel de Castro Interest Awards Ceremony Betty Gershuny Denitz 96 David Babbe ’81 In Memory of Ronald P. Eric Burton ’00 Denitz ’53 Sandra Cavazos ’98 Professor Jesse Dukeminier Kevin Cops ’96 Albert B. Glickman ’60 and R. Stephen Doan ’74 Judith Ellis Glickman Bill Gable ’98 Philip S. Magaram ’61 Samantha Goodman ’98 Frances Matlin J. Gregory Grossman ’00 Brenda and Budge Offer Lisa Hoffman ’98 Frieda Oxman Linda Lee ’98 Marvin D. Rowen ’56 Mary Panetta ’97 William A. Rutter Naoko Shimazaki ’84 Dr. David Sanders Marcos M. Tarango, Jr. ’97 Planned gifts from alumni The School of Law is grateful and friends provide important to the following alumni and support to the School of Law. friends for directing significant Such gifts establish a meaning- Foundation or Trust gifts to ful memorial for the donor or the School. someone the donor wishes to honor, while enabling the David Leveton ’62 donor to assist in the continu- Director, Ann C. Rosenfield ing growth of the school. A Fund carefully planned estate can Frederick L. Leydorf ’58 help you avoid or reduce Trustee, J. W. and Ida M. taxes, increasing the amount Jameson Foundation you can leave to your heirs and Philip S. Magaram ’61 favorite charities. If you wish Trustee, Joseph Drown to provide for the School of Foundation Law in your estate plan, or if Richard L. Stack you have already done so but Trustee, Hugh and Hazel have not yet informed us, please Darling Foundation contact the Development Office at (310) 206-1121.

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Honor Roll of Donors 2000–2001 Participation BY CLASS

Class Dollars % Year Raised Participation

1952 $7,525 48 1953 $1,250 21 1954 $5,100 12 1955 $1,700 10 1956 $5,663 16 1957 $3,500 14 PARTICIPATION 1958 $20,596 24 RATES BY CLASS 1959 $14,649 20 (all law school funds) 1960 $9,210 19 1961 $8,025 16 1962 $4,400 17 1963 $7,700 13 1964 $16,485 15 1965 $14,670 19 97 1966 $12,355 14 1967 $21,755 21 1968 $8,491 15 1969 $22,020 21 1970 $12,318 16 1971 $16,975 19 1972 $32,295 14 1973 $23,508 18 1974 $19,735 15 1975 $64,809 25 1976 $24,135 18 1977 $28,685 18 1978 $20,500 18 1979 $28,467 20 1980 $25,890 22 1981 $14,996 18 1982 $33,592 20 1983 $11,536 16 1984 $19,205 18 1985 $13,063 13 1986 $8,425 13 1987 $13,488 14 1988 $12,687 12 1989 $6,315 7 1990 $9,200 11 1991 $6,655 11 1992 $8,395 17 1993 $2,760 7 1994 $5,430 12 1995 $3,588 7 1996 $5,740 8 1997 $2,250 6 1998 $1,128 5 1999 $2,450 4 2000 $1,860 5 2001 $560 9

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 Honor Roll of Donors 2000–2001

STUDENTS WHO GIVE CLASSES OF 2002 AND 2003

The UCLA School of Law is committed to educating prospective lawyers who will be prepared to practice law, conduct business, teach, or take an executive, judicial, or legislative leadership

position, while fully understanding and embracing the gravity of their responsibilities as stewards

of our democracy. Many students support the school in its mission, Lisa Sergi ’01 and her hus-

band, Roger Neill, for example, contributed a significant gift in support of the Corporate Law

Program. Several vehicles also have been developed by our students to support one another in pro

bono and public interest law work. The following students donated a portion of their summer

salaries to the Public Interest Law Foundation in support of their colleagues who chose to spend

the summer helping to represent the underrepresented. This is not a full list of contributors, as

some students have requested that their gifts remain anonymous. We thank the members of the

Classes of 2002 and 2003 for taking this initiative and valuing the work of public interest law.

98 Amy Abbazia Alex Fisch Christine Oh Lorenzo Alvarado Ryan Fox Raelyn Ohira Seta Arabian Dan Goldstein Yury Orlov Rick Baker Laura Godfrey Diane Park Samantha Black Shailly Gupta Dawn Payne Toby Bordelon Sayema Hameed Alicia Pell Sierra Brandis Jessica Hately Dana Peterson Mariah Brandt Amanda Hayes Laura Probst Natalie Bridgeman Natalie Hayashi Rob Pryor Brady Bustany Myron Hecht Sylvia Rivera Steve Byers John Hribar Kim Savo Molly Calvanese Walter Impert Henry Self Dean Chang Rebecca Kanter Crystal Silva Wilson Chen Cheryl Kelly Matthew Steinmeier Una Chung Euna Kim Lara Strauss Anne Clinton Stephanie Lasker Patrick Sutton Beth Collins Vivian Lee Dave Tang Eve Crowell John Littrell Peerapong Tantamjarik Chris Decker John Loncto Phil Tate Alyson Dinsmore Judith Marblestone Andy Tran Kelly Dixon Barrett Marum Anh Tran Bard Dorros Maggie McLetchie Toan Tran Celeste Drake Michelle Mehta Brian Wacter Samantha Eisner Bonita Moore Amy Whitehurst Catherine Elkes Conor Moore Chris Willard Bijan Esfanidiari Kyle Nagata Jennifer Winslow Katie Fesler Candace Novell Helen Wolff

UCLA LAW FALL/WINTER 2001 CALENDAR OF EVENTS

2002 Friday, February 22 Thursday, March 14 Mark The Women’s Law Journal Roscoe Pound Moot Court Friday, January 25 – Symposium Competition Your Saturday, January 26 Please contact Please contact 26th Annual UCLA Entertainment [email protected]. [email protected] or Calendar Law Symposium (310) 206-1121. The New Reality—Film, Television, Friday, March 1 and Music in a Global Economy UCLA Law Review Symposium Friday, April 19 2001 UCLA Freud Playhouse Privatization and “Third Party” The Ann C. Rosenfield Please contact Governance Symposium honoring Saturday, November 3 [email protected] or Supported by a generous gift from Professor Gary T. Schwartz Class of 1961 Reunion Dinner (310) 825-0971. Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & UCLA School of Law UCLA School of Law Flom LLP Please contact 5:30 P. M . Reception Saturday, February 2 Please contact [email protected] or 6:30 P. M . Dinner 16th Annual Southern California [email protected] or (310) 825-0971. Please contact Public Interest Career Day (310) 825-0971. [email protected] or UCLA School of Law May (310) 206-1121. Please contact Catherine Friday, March 8 Law Alumni of the Year Mayorkas, Director of Public UCLA Evan Frankel Environmental Awards Thursday, November 8 – Interest Programs, Law and Policy Program Please contact Sunday, November 11 at (310) 206-9155 or Symposium [email protected] or Fifth International Conference [email protected]. Integrating Human Communities (310) 206-1121. on Clinical Legal Education and Natural Environments and Scholarship Saturday, February 2 Please contact Sunday, May 12 UCLA Conference Center at No Diploma!—20th Annual [email protected] or UCLA School of Law Lake Arrowhead School of Law Musical (310) 825-0971. Commencement Please contact the Clinical Northwest Auditorium Perloff Quad Program office at Please contact Tuesday, March 12 2 P. M . [email protected] or [email protected] or Melville B. Nimmer Lecture (310) 825-1097. [email protected] or Mark Rose, Professor of English (310) 825-0971. and Department Chair, UCSB On the Cover: Faculty Center We chose a few treasured books Friday, February 15 7 P. M . from the Hugh & Hazel Darling The Chicano/Latino Law Please contact Law Library to illustrate our fea- Review Symposium [email protected] or ture story, The Law and Beyond, Please contact (310) 206-1121. a profile of several faculty who [email protected]. engage in interdisciplinary teach- ing and scholarship.

Professor of the Year Jody Freeman and Dean Jonathan D. Varat lead the faculty promenade from the School of Law to Dickson Plaza to confer upon the class of 2001 the Degrees of Master of Laws and Juris Doctor. (Front, middle) Julie Su, attorney for the Asian Pacific American Legal Center of Southern California, addressed the graduates. UCLA Law Magazine Box 951476 www.law.ucla.edu PRESORTED UCLA School of Law Los Angeles, CA [email protected] FIRST CLASS MAIL U.S. POSTAGE Office of the Dean 90095-1476 Return Service Requested PAID UCLA

The UCLA Law Community will remember Gary Schwartz on Monday, October 29 at a memorial service.

The April 19, 2002 Ann C. Rosenfield Symposium will be dedicated to Professor Schwartz and will celebrate his contribution to Torts scholarship.