DOCSLIB.ORG

Enbridge Line 3 Pipeline Replacement Meeting Held

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Enbridge Line 3 Pipeline Replacement Meeting Held DEBAHJIMON January 2017 | Vol. XXXIII No. 6 The newspaper of the Leech Lake Band of Ojibwe Nation Building Page 3 Enbridge Line 3 Pipeline Native Nations Institute hosted a 2 Day workshop on Nation Building strategies at the Palace Casino. Replacement Meeting Held Zebra Mussels Page 4 MN DNR reports that they have found zebra mussel larvae in two sampling areas on Leech Lake. Year in Review Page 8-9 Check out a summary of major events that occurred within the past year! PAID By Michael Chosa PRSRT STD PRSRT US POSTAGE US BEMIDJI, MN BEMIDJI, ore than 120 community members to existing pump stations at Clearbrook, permits." If Line 3 isn't replaced by Dec. 31, PERMIT NO. 68 NO. PERMIT braved the frigid temperatures in Donaldson, Plummer and Viking; and con- 2017, Enbridge will be saddled with addi- early January to attend an infor- struction of new pump stations at Backus, tional safety requirements, according to the Mmational meeting regarding the upcom- Cromwell, Palisade and Two Inlets. See map settlement agreement. ing Enbridge Line 3 Pipeline Replacement on Page 5. Project. The State of Minnesota announced Upon completion of the project, Enbridge in December that it was preparing an The meeting was hosted by the Leech Lake proposes to permanently deactivate the Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) for Band of Ojibwe (LLBO) in conjunction with existing Line 3 pipeline and leave it in place. the project which includes "Unique trib- the Minnesota Chippewa Tribe (MCT). It This is a major concern for the tribe and al concerns (e.g., cultural resources, treaty was held to offer community members a community who would like to see the aging rights, wild rice areas)". The State's Draft EIS preliminary chance to discuss their concerns 1960's era pipeline removed and the land is scheduled to be issued April 3, 2017 and and seek answers to specific questions they returned to its original condition. public meetings for review and commentary had ahead of the upcoming official public will be held in April and May 2017. hearing/ comment periods in February. In July of last year, the U.S. Department of Justice signed a consent decree with The Minnesota Chippewa Tribe initially Enbridge’s proposed 337-mile long route for Enbridge Energy which resolved claims elected to perform their own EIS after pass- the project would cross Kittson, Marshall, from oil spills in Michigan and Illinois in ing Resolution 30-17 at their November 3rd Pennington, Red Lake, Polk, Clearwater, 2010. Enbridge agreed to pay $177 mil- Meeting. This first, informal meeting was a Hubbard, Wadena, Cass, Crow Wing, Aitkin lion, improve pipeline safety and replace direct result of that action. and Carlton counties in Minnesota. The Line 3 "as expeditiously as practicable after proposed project also includes upgrades receiving required regulatory approvals and Continued on Page 5 2 Gichimanidoo-giizis • Great Spirit Moon January 2017 | Debahjimon Vol XXXIII No 6 Community Skating Rink Bad River Band Denies Renewal of Enbridge Line 5 Easement The Debahjimon is a free, Set to Open in January monthly publication of the Leech Tribe calls for decommissioning and removal at Bad River, WI Lake Band of Ojibwe ODANAH, WI- The Bad River Chairman Robert Blanchard. He Leech Lake Tribal Tribal Council passed a formal remarks in the Tribal Council’s Council resolution Wednesday evening, decision, “We will work with our January 4th that established the native and non-native communi- » Faron Jackson Sr., Tribes decision not to renew its ties to make sure that Line 5 does Chairman interests in the grant of easement not threaten rights of people living for rights-of-way of Enbridge in our region, and we will reach » Arthur “Archie” LaRose, Energy’s Line 5 crude oil pipeline out to federal, state and local offi- Secretary-Treasurer through the Bad River Reservation. cials to evaluate how to remove Furthermore, it calls for the Line 5, and we will work with the » Penny DeVault, District I decommissioning, and removal of same communities and officials to Representative the pipeline from all Bad River continue developing a sustainable lands and watershed. economy that doesn’t marginalize » Steve White, District II indigenous people” Representative Formerly known as Lakehead Pipeline Company, Enbridge The Band has directed Tribal staff (L to R) Natalie Lovelace, LL Youth Division, Brian Brunelle, » LeRoy Staples Fairbanks III, sought renewal of rights of way to begin planning for the Line 5 District III Representative LLBO Health Director, Frank Schaaf, Construction Manager, with the Band for the existing removal project development and Gary Charwood, LL Youth Division, Amanda Shongo, SHIP line that is now 64 years old. 15 the environmental issues/hazards Staff Coordinator and Mikele Finn, Health Division stop for a photo Individual grant of easement rights that exist with removal of old pipe- at the future site of the skating rink, of way for Line 5 expired in 2013, lines including hazards response Michael Chosa, Editor however, Bad River had reacquired and health study, pipeline contents Starr White, Graphic Design CASS LAKE, MN- A new outdoor skating rink in Cass Lake is sched- interests in 11 of the 15 parcels recycling and disposal, and sur- uled to open by mid-January. Funding for the project was secured by of land within the grant of ease- face restoration. “These environ- Submissions the Leech Lake Band of Ojibwe Youth Division through a grant with the ment rights of way. “As many other mental threats not only threaten MN Department of Health’s Statewide Health Improvement Partnership communities have experienced, our health, but they threaten our The submission of pictures, (SHIP). even a minor spill could prove to very way of life as Anishinaabe. articles, announcements be disastrous for our people. We We all need to be thinking of our and letters is encouraged. The money will be used to construct a 100 x 50 foot outdoor skating rink depend upon everything that the future generations and what we All submissions are subject with perimeter boards, rink liner, warming house and lighting. A collec- creator put here before us to live leave behind for them.” Says Tribal to editing for spelling, tion of ice skates will also be purchased and will be available for check out mino-bimaadiziwin, a good and Council Member Dylan Jennings. grammar, length and libelous through the Youth Division and the Boys and Girls Club of Cass Lake. healthy life.” said Bad River Tribal content. Submission does The skating rink will be located next to Dreamcatcher Park, in the same area that a former rink existed over 30 years ago. not guarantee publication. Mille Lacs Band Divests from Wells Fargo The Editor reserves the The Youth Division also received funding for a Lacrosse project in this ONAMIA, MN- The Mille Lacs ect where peaceful Native American right to reject any material grant. They plan on purchasing sticks, helmets, pads and other safety Band of Ojibwe Indians has ended protestors have been taunted and submitted for publication. gear for their summer activities. LLBO Health Director Brian Brunelle its investment advisory services physically harmed. We will not do envisions using the rink site as a lacrosse and soccer area in the summer relationship with Wells Fargo. The business with a company that finds Debahjimon months. decision, made unanimously by the these practices acceptable.” Mille Lacs Band of Ojibwe Indians 190 Sailstar Dr. NW The project was successful due to the successful collaborations between Band Assembly and Chief Executive The proposed 1,100 mile pipeline Cass Lake, MN 56633 various entities. “We couldn’t have done this without the assistance of Melanie Benjamin, is in response would pump more than a half million everyone,” Brunelle said. Levi Brown with the Land Management office to Wells Fargo’s unethical business barrels of crude oil per day across the [email protected] at DRM was able to provide the land at the site for this to be built on. practices and the financing the Missouri River just upstream from Natalie Lovelace from Youth Division was instrumental in doing the leg bank provides to Energy Transfer the mouth of the Cannon Ball River, Ph: (218) 335-8225 work along with Mikele Finn at Health Division. LLBO Construction Partners. The Mille Lacs Band ter- which flows through the Standing Fax: (218) 335-8309 Manager Frank Schaaf coordinated the site preparation, purchasing and minated the relationship effective Rock Sioux reservation. upcoming assembly of the rink. SHIP Coordinator Amanda Shongo was January 6th, 2017. Deadlines very helpful throughout the entire process. LL Housing will also be con- “Divesting from Wells Fargo is a structing the warming house and installing the lighting. Cass Lake Fire “Wells Fargo has promoted ini- meaningful step we can take to February Issue........01/20/2017 Department has committed to filling the rink with water. Finally, the Boys tiatives that have hurt Native make it clear that this is unaccept- March Issue............02/17/2017 and Girls Club of Cass Lake are and will continue to be a vital partner in Americans across the country and able corporate behavior. The Mille April Issue...............03/24/2017 this success. Miigwech to all involved! the Mille Lacs Band will no lon- Lacs Band understands the nature ger associate ourselves with them,” of finance and lending practices MN Department of Health’s SHIP is working to create healthier com- said Mille Lacs Band Secretary- by U.S. banks. In many instances, munities across Minnesota by expanding opportunities for active living, Treasurer Carolyn Beaulieu. “In banking relationships are unavoid- healthy eating and tobacco-free living. SHIP, at its core, is a locally driven addition to preying on customers able.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • 180 Linda Legarde Grover. Onigamiising
    Transmotion Vol 5, No 2 (2019) Linda LeGarde Grover. Onigamiising: Seasons of an Ojibwe Year. University of Minnesota Press, 2017. 201 pp. ISBN: 9781517903442. https://www.upress.umn.edu/book-division/books/onigamiising This book is a very nice read. Personally, I found the book to be very moving. One does not have to be Anishinaabe to appreciate the familial warmth that rises from the pages. The reader can bask in that comfort as one might have done with grandma’s old wood stove. However, the book touches on some of the hard truths of Ojibwe history as well. Those hard truths recall those solemn moments of pain contemplated in silence and finished with a deep sigh in thinking about one’s own family’s history as an Anishinaabe. The book is a collection of newspaper columns the author wrote for the Duluth Budgeteer and is organized around the seasons of the year, starting with spring. As the title indicates, the geographic focus is on the city of Duluth, MN, known in the Anishinaabe language as Onigamiising, the place of the small portage. The focus and the title are appropriate in that the author and her family have been in Duluth for a number of generations. The author is Anishinaabe. The Anishinaabe people are also known as Ojibwe and Chippewa. All three appellations are used in the book. The book covers many aspects of the author’s life, from childhood memories to her current status as an elder in the tribe and professor at the University of Minnesota Duluth. The author will often start a column making an observation about some details of her family life, such as a family gathering.
    [Show full text]
  • Traditional Ojibwe Adoption
    DeBahJiMon Return Service Requested PRSRTSTD U.S. Postage 115 6th Street NW PAID Cass Lake, MN 56633 Bemidji, MN Permit No. DeBahJiMon 68 A Publication of the Leech Lake Band of Ojibwe Vol. XXII No. 1 July 2007 Leech Lake Child LLCW Program for this initiative is the de- Traditional Ojibwe Adoption velopment of a comprehensive child wel- Welfare Program fare service delivery system, to respond to To Make Historic child maltreatment reports and to provide an array of services aimed at meeting child Program Develop- welfare needs. The program development will be ment in two phases, with the first phase being By Kim Mammedaty, Associate building infrastructural capacity. This in- Tribal Attorney cludes technology, additional staff and Leech Lake Legal Division space acquisition, policy and procedure & Lisa Sherman, Community Rela- development, as well as program devel- tions Coordinator opment. The program will be based on Leech Lake Child Welfare Program Ojibwe values and teachings around child rearing practices, rather than replicate the “There is no resource that is more state or county systems that the Tribe has vital to the continued existence had to respond to for many generations. and integrity of Indian Tribes than The program will emphasize prevention, their children.” early intervention, and community en- This statement is found to Child Welfare Program - Cont. on page 4 be a fundamental feature in the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA). Front row: Keith Howard, Jasmine Wade, Kim Howard; Middle Row: Brady ICWA, which was passed in 1978, New Breast Cancer Wade, Andrea Wade (mother), Brandi Wade, Collin Howard, Back Row: is a federal law that protects the Services at Cass Lake Thomas Headbird, Larry Wade, (father), Grandfather Bill Croaker, and Grand- physical, mental, emotional, and mother Faye Headbird.
    [Show full text]
  • I I I I I I I I I
    I I Data Sheet I Name of Interviewee: Julie Shingobe I Current Age: 62 Place of Birth: East Lake Refuge I Date of Birth: 1930 I Date of Interview: August 5, 1992 Project I Person Conducting Oral Interview: Dr. Anthony Godfrey Location of Interview: Mandy Lake, Rice Lake National Wildlife Refuge, I Minnesota HistorySociety I Vocal Clarity: Good Biographical Data: I Born near the East Lake WildlifeSocial Refuge area, Julie Shingobe currently lives in East Lake and works as a chemical dependency counselor for the Mille Lacs band. Formerly a District II/EastHistorical Lake Representative (1982-1986), I Julie Shingobe belongs to the Grand Medicine Society/Midewiwin and regularly attend ceremonialOjibwe dances. She is a college-graduate and her son I Mushkooub is presently the Commissioner of Eduction for the band. I Major ThemesLacs Addressed: Discusses severalMinnesota traditional seasonal activities at East Lake from the 1930s [ onward, such as ricing, fishing and maple sugaring; traditional practices Milleinvolving drum societies, the Ojibwe language and medicinal plants; and inter-band government relations and relations with the Minnesota Chippewa I Tribe (MCT). I Related Photographs Donated: I None given. I I I I Interview with Julie Shingobe Date of Interview: August 5, 1992 I Place of Interview: Mandy Lake, Rice Lake National Wildlife Refuge, Minnesota I Interviewer: Dr. Anthony Godfrey I Begin Tape One, Side One Godfrey: Today is August the 5th, and I'm sitting here in front of I Mandy Lake with Julie Shingobe of the East Lake band of Chippewas. And first, like, I need some personalProject data from I you.
    [Show full text]
  • American Indians, Indian Tribes, and State Government
    American Indians, Indian Tribes, and State Government About this Publication This guidebook discusses major issues involved in the relationship between Indian tribes, American Indians, and state government, including criminal and civil jurisdiction, employment, control of natural resources, gaming and liquor regulation, taxation, health and human services, child welfare, education, and civic engagement. February 2020 Contributors American Indians, Indian Tribes, and State Government is a cooperative project by legislative analysts in the Research Department of the Minnesota House of Representatives. This publication introduces Minnesota legislators to the major legal issues involved in the relationship between American Indians, Indian tribes, and state government. This report was coordinated by Mary Mullen, a legislative analyst specializing in the areas of American Indian tribal government and Indian law. General questions regarding the guide can be directed to Mary Mullen, 651-296-9253. Topical questions should be addressed to the analyst who covers that subject. Civil Jurisdiction Mary Mullen 651-296-9253 Criminal Jurisdiction Jeffrey Diebel 651-296-5041 Ben Johnson 651-296-8957 Mary Mullen 651-296-9253 Demographics & Statistics Sean Williams 651-296-5053 Education Tim Strom (K-12) 651-296-1886 Cristina Parra (K-12) 651-296-8036 Nathan Hopkins (Higher) 651-296-5056 Elections & Voting Rights Matt Gehring 651-296-5052 Environmental Regulations Bob Eleff 651-296-8961 Gaming Regulation Ben Johnson 651-296-8957 Health & Human Services Randall Chun 651-296-8639 Danyell Punelli 651-296-5058 Sarah Sunderman 651-296-8079 Indian Child Welfare Mary Mullen 651-296-9253 Labor & Employment Mary Mullen 651-296-9253 Liquor Regulation Chris Kleman 651-296-8959 Natural Resources Janelle Taylor 651-296-5039 Taxation Chris Kleman 651-296-8959 Jared Swanson 651-296-5044 Alexandra Haigler 651-296-8956 Minnesota House Research Department provides nonpartisan legislative, legal, and information services to the Minnesota House of Representatives.
    [Show full text]
  • An Analysis of Traditional Ojibwe Civil Chief Leadership
    An Analysis of Traditional Ojibwe Civil Chief Leadership A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED TO THE FACULTY OF THE GRADUATE SCHOOL OF THE UNIVERSITY OF MINNESOTA BY Giniwgiizhig - Henry Flocken IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF EDUCATION Frank Guldbrandsen, Adviser May, 2013 © Giniwgiizhig - Henry Flocken 2013 i Acknowledgements My wife, Clarice Mountain, endured the weight of my absence. Her strength helps me succeed. I love her immensely. My children, Terry, Tashina, Samara, Bobbi, Ricky, Ryan, Lisa, Ashley, and Desi, also felt my absence. Marcy Ardito instilled in me that I was smart and could do anything. Dr. Frank Guldbrandsen is a friend and an intellectual guerrilla emancipating cattle from slaughter. ii Dedication This work is dedicated to the late Albert Churchill, a spiritual leader, and his great family. Albert kept traditional ceremonies alive and always shared knowledge with those who asked. Knowledge is useless unless it is shared. He said if we do not share our knowledge, then the flow of new knowledge will be blocked and we will not learn. He always said, “Together we can do anything.” iii Abstract Little is known about traditional Ojibwe civil chief leadership. This critical ethnography is an analysis of traditional Ojibwe civil chief leadership. Hereditary chiefs are interviewed. Chief leadership lies nested in the Anishinaabe Constitution. It is clan-based and value-based. It includes all of creation. Leadership is emergent and symbolic. Chiefs symbolized and are spokespersons for the will of the people. They were selected based on their virtues. The real power is in the people, in clans in council.
    [Show full text]
  • Preliminary Report: Comprehensive Study of Education on the White
    Preliminary Report: Comprehensive Study of Education on the White Earth Indian Reservation By Boyd Bradbury, MSUM Professor of Educational Leadership and Project Director Jane Bergland, MSUM Associate Professor of Nursing and Co-investigator James Bergman, MSUM Graduate Assistant and Co-investigator Donna Brown, MSUM Interim Assistant Vice President of Student Affairs Tracy Clark, MSUM Assistant Professor of Social Work Layna Cole, MSUM Associate Professor of Early and Elementary Childhood Leslie Darmofal, MSUM Graduate Student of Nursing Terry Dobmeier, Assistant Professor of Nursing Charles Howell, NIU Department Chair of Education Denise Lajimodiere, NDSU Assistant Professor of Educational Leadership Tracy Moshier, MSUM Graduate Student in Nursing Sue Peterson, MSUM Assistant Professor of Social Work Amy Phillips, UND Assistant Professor of Social Work Becky Williams, MSUMAssistant Professor in the School of Teaching & Learning Tracy Wright, MSUM Associate Professor of Nursing P a g e | 1 Table of Contents Executive Summary .............................................................................................................................. 9 Early Childhood and Head Start ....................................................................................................... 9 K-12 Education ............................................................................................................................... 10 Adult Basic Education and White Earth Tribal and Community College (WETCC) .................... 10 Social
    [Show full text]
  • Kia Law of Indigenous Peoples in the Americas Kia
    KIA LAW OF INDIGENOUS PEOPLES IN THE AMERICAS KIA Law of Indigenous peoples in the Americas Class here works on the law of Indigenous peoples in the Western Hemisphere For general and local history of the Americas in general see Classes E and F Bibliography 1 General 1.2.A-Z Guides to law collections. Indigenous law gateways (Portals). Web directories. By name, A-Z 1.2.N38 NativeWeb Resource Database. Indigenous Peoples' Law and Legal Issues 1.3.A-Z Non-governmental organizations (NGOs). By name, A-Z 1.3.I53 Indian Law Resource Center 1.3.I58 International Indian Treaty Council 2 General works 3.A-Z Special topics, A-Z Dual ethnic identity see KIA3.H96 3.E58 Environmental justice 3.H96 Hyphenation. Dual ethnic identity e.g., Native-American 3.I63 Indigeneity. Indigenism 3.S45 Self-determined and sustainable development of indigenous peoples United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, 2008 see K3246.42008 1 KIA INDIGENOUS LAW: NORTH AMERICA KIA Indigenous law: North America Cf. E75+ Indians of North America Bibliography 5 General 6.A-Z Guides to law collections. Indigenous law gateways (Portals). Web directories 6.I53 Indigenous Law Portal. Law Library of Congress 7 Periodicals Class here periodicals consisting predominantly of legal articles regardless of the subject matter and jurisdiction, e.g., American Indian Law Review, Indigenous Law Journal, Tribal justice today, Tribal law journal, etc. For law reports and digests, see the region or indigenous jurisdiction in KIA-KIK, e.g., KIE32 Native American law digest For official gazettes, see the region or indigenous jurisdiction in KIA-KIK 8 Encyclopedias.
    [Show full text]
  • Constitution Meetings Overall Summary
    COMPREHENSIVE SUMMARY REPORT MINNESOTA CHIPPEWA TRIBE CONSTITUTIONAL CONVENTION Presented, Facilitated, & Reported by the Native Nations Institute University of Arizona Sponsored by the Minnesota Chippewa Tribe and Native Governance Center Minnesota | August 2017- February 2018 Report Prepared by Joan Timeche, Executive Director Danielle Hiraldo, Senior Researcher and Outreach Specialist Presented and Summary Prepared by Strengthening Indigenous Governance 1 MINNESOTA CHIPPEWA TRIBE CONSTITUTIONAL CONVENTION 2017-2018 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Faced with governance challenges, in March 2017, the Minnesota Chippewa Tribe (MCT) Tribal Executive Committee authorized a Constitutional Convention to open the discussion to the membership for input/feedback. MCT hosted seven educational sessions from August 2017 to February 2018. The Native Nations Institute (NNI) at the University of Arizona facilitated six of the seven. The sessions were designed to 1) provide general information on constitutions, the role of governments, governmental forms found in Indian Country, and how others have revised their constitution; 2) provide a historical overview and a review of the MCT Constitution; and 3) allot ample time for member input on the existing constitution and possible revisions. Discussion Topics The discussion prompts sought to elicit feedback in four main areas: strategic thinking (visioning a healthy MCT community), assessment (what’s working and not with the existing constitution), solutions (ideas to address key issues), and implementation (recommendations for continuing the MCT constitution reform process). NNI provided a written Questionnaire as an alternative for participants to provide input on the MCT constitution. This report summarizes key discussions and recommendations for strengthening the MCT government from the 398 tribal members/ individuals who attended. (Summaries of individual reservation sessions are provided in separate reports.) The Results The MCT sessions created significant momentum to produce member engaged outcomes.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 [email protected]
    This document is scheduled to be published in the Federal Register on 01/12/2017 and available online at https://federalregister.gov/d/2017-00512, and on FDsys.gov 4312-52 DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR National Park Service [NPS-WASO-NAGPRA-NPS0022625] [PPWOCRADN0-PCU00RP14.R50000] Notice of Intent to Repatriate Cultural Items: Denver Museum of Nature & Science, Denver, CO AGENCY: National Park Service, Interior. ACTION: Notice. SUMMARY: The Denver Museum of Nature & Science, in consultation with the appropriate Indian tribes or Native Hawaiian organizations, has determined that the cultural items listed in this notice meet the definition of unassociated funerary objects and/or sacred objects. Lineal descendants or representatives of any Indian tribe or Native Hawaiian organization not identified in this notice that wish to claim these cultural items should submit a written request to the Denver Museum of Nature & Science. If no additional claimants come forward, transfer of control of the cultural items to the lineal descendants, Indian tribes, or Native Hawaiian organizations stated in this notice may proceed. DATES: Lineal descendants or representatives of any Indian tribe or Native Hawaiian organization not identified in this notice that wish to claim these cultural items should submit a written request with information in support of the claim to the Denver Museum of Nature & Science at the address in this notice by [INSERT DATE 30 DAYS AFTER PUBLICATION IN THE FEDERAL REGISTER]. ADDRESSES: Chip Colwell, Senior Curator of Anthropology and NAGPRA Officer, Denver Museum of Nature & Science, 2001 Colorado Boulevard., Denver, CO 80205, telephone (303) 370-6378, email [email protected].
    [Show full text]
  • Fond Du Lac Band of Lake Superior Chippewa in Support of Respondents
    No. 18-260 ================================================================ In The Supreme Court of the United States --------------------------------- --------------------------------- COUNTY OF MAUI, Petitioner, v. HAWAI‘I WILDLIFE FUND, et al., Respondents. --------------------------------- --------------------------------- On Writ Of Certiorari To The United States Court Of Appeals For The Ninth Circuit --------------------------------- --------------------------------- BRIEF OF AMICUS CURIAE FOND DU LAC BAND OF LAKE SUPERIOR CHIPPEWA IN SUPPORT OF RESPONDENTS --------------------------------- --------------------------------- ELISE L. LARSON Counsel of Record KEVIN S. REUTHER MINNESOTA CENTER FOR ENVIRONMENTAL ADVOCACY 1919 University Avenue West, Ste. 515 St. Paul, MN 55104-3435 651-223-5969 [email protected] Counsel for Amicus Curiae ================================================================ COCKLE LEGAL BRIEFS (800) 225-6964 WWW.COCKLELEGALBRIEFS.COM i TABLE OF CONTENTS Page INTEREST OF THE AMICUS CURIAE ............... 1 SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT ................................ 3 ARGUMENT ........................................................... 5 I. THE BAND RELIES ON THE CLEAN WATER ACT TO PROTECT CRITICAL NATURAL RESOURCES FROM LARGE INDUSTRIAL POLLUTERS ....................... 5 A. Production And Consumption Of Tradi- tional Foods, Including Manoomin And Freshwater Fish, Are Important To The Ojibwe .................................................... 5 1. Manoomin ......................................... 6 2. Freshwater
    [Show full text]
  • 2018 Tribal Wild Rice Task Force Report
    2018 Tribal Wild Rice Task Force Report Ojibwe Land Dakota Land DECEMBER 15TH, 2018 Prepared by the: MINNESOTA TRIBAL WILD RICE TASK FORCE 1 “You will know the chosen ground has been reached when you come to a land where food grows out of the water.” SEVEN FIRES PROPHECY 2 CONTENTS 1. Executive Summary 5 2. Introduction 7 3. Importance of Wild Rice 11 a. Ojibwe Reservations/Dakota Communities and Treaty-ceded Territories Map 11 b. Cultural Context 12 c. Health and Subsistence 15 d. Ecology 17 e. Management and Restoration 18 f. Economic Importance, Past and Present 21 4. Supporting Evidence of Sulfate/Sulfide Impacts and the Need to Protect Wild Rice 23 a. Hydroponic Study 23 b. Mesocosms 23 c. Iron Sulfide Formation on Roots 24 d. Field Studies 24 e. Rooting Zone Geochemistry 25 f. Temperature Dependent Diffusion Rates of Sulfate 25 g. Twin Lakes Monitoring Case Study 26 h. Lists of Wild Rice Waters 27 3 i. Long-Term Wild Rice Monitoring 31 j. Potentially Affected Dischargers Analysis 32 k. Comparison of Concentrations between Northern 58 Minnesota and Southern Minnesota 5. Recommendations 62 6. Appendix 66 a. Appointed Members of the Tribal Wild Rice Task Force and Other Contributors 66 b. References 67 c. Public Comments 70 4 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY This report, and the creation of a Minnesota Tribal Wild Rice Task Force, serves as a response to the 40th Governor of the State of Minnesota creating a “Wild Rice Task Force” that is disrespectful and contrary to Executive Order 13-10 … and directly relegates the Tribes to the status of special interest groups and industry rather than honoring Tribal sovereignty (Minnesota Chippewa Tribe Resolution 107-18).
    [Show full text]
  • Chapter 9 Tribal Resources
    Chapter 9 Tribal Resources Chapter 9 Tribal Resources 9.1 INTRODUCTION Impacts analyzed within an Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) generally rely heavily on quantitative data and a western worldview of science and its applications (Dongoske et al. 2015). Using western scientific methods to evaluate environmental impacts “fails to consider and incorporate Native American perspectives of, values about, and relationships with the environment.” The goal of this chapter is to provide an alternative, qualitative measure of the impact of Enbridge’s proposed Line 3 Replacement Project (Project) on American Indians. This chapter employs a methodology that frames the discussion to reflect American Indian perceptions of the environment and the impacts associated with constructing a pipeline through an area of traditional, cultural, spiritual, and natural resource significance. Impacts are discussed in the preceding chapters of the EIS, including impacts on reservation lands, treaty lands, resources that hold tribal significance such as wild rice and water resources, and climate change. To fully understand and appreciate the impacts of the proposed Project and its alternatives on American Indian communities and cultures, qualitative and quantitative discussions are necessary. The differences between these approaches highlights the unique impacts on tribal communities and tribal members. American Indian traditions are interwoven into the ecosystems in which they live, from subsistence gathering to sacred sites—all places that have spiritual and artistic meaning. For example, wild rice has important cultural ties to local traditions, spiritual fulfillment, and more. “Culturally important ecosystem services often cannot be measured in pounds, gallons, acres, or kilowatts” (Fletcher and Christin 2015). This chapter identifies tribal resources and details their importance to the survival of tribal traditional ways.
    [Show full text]