In This Issue Page 8 Page 27 Beauty and Commerce: Central Africa “Not Maps at All” – and Virginia in Sir Robert Dudley’S
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Copyright Washington Map Society. Please do not redistribute. ThePortolan Issue 100 WINTER 2017 JOURNAL OF THE WASHINGTON MAP SOCIETY THE PORTOLAN 100th ISSUE OF The PORTOLAN In This Issue Page 8 page 27 Beauty and Commerce: Central Africa “Not Maps At All” – and Virginia in Sir Robert Dudley’s – JOURNAL OF THE WASHINGTON MAP SOCIETY What Is Persuasive Cartography? Arcano del mare by Leah M. Thomas And Why Does It Matter? page 44 by PJ Mode Air Age News Journal Maps as Historical Sources by Jeffrey P. Stone page 56 A Mystery Lake in Southern Colorado by Wesley A. Brown page 64 ICHC 2017 in Belo Horizonte – An After Action Report by Bert Johnson page 68 | Social Media and Digital ISSUE 100 WINTER 2017 Communication for Map Wonks by Leigh Lockwood page 71 The Portolan issue #100 and the Washington Map Society by Leigh Lockwood page 86 Tributes and Thanks to Joel Kovarsky www.WashMapSociety.org “New Prussia. ‘My Country, ‘Tis of Thee,’” Life, “Get-Ready Number,” February 10, 1916. Copyright Washington Map Society. Please do not redistribute. We offer the map and print collector a wide range of rare original maps, charts, globes, and prints. We also provide related reference books and cartographic novelties, as well as search and appraisal services. Cartographic Associates, LLC P.O. Box 565, Fulton, Maryland 20759, USA (888) 513-Maps [6277] web catalog: www.maps-charts.com [email protected] Copyright Washington Map Society. Please do not redistribute. The Washington Contents Map Society Letter from the President, Winter 2017 2 Ristow Prize Competition 2017 – Winners Announced 2 OFFICERS, 2017–2018 Washington Map Society Meetings, November 2017–May 2018 3 Edward Redmond Exhibitions and Meetings 4 President Eliane Dotson Ristow Prize Competition 2018 6 Vice President “Not Maps At All” – What Is Persuasive Cartography? And Why Does It Matter? PJ Mode 8 Peter Porrazzo Treasurer Beauty and Commerce: Central Africa and Virginia in Sir Robert Dudley’s Harold Meinheit Arcano del mare Leah M. Thomas 27 Secretary Air Age News Journal Maps as Historical Sources Jeffrey P. Stone 44 Jeffrey Katz Membership A Mystery Lake in Southern Colorado Wesley A. Brown 56 Leigh Lockwood ICHC 2017 in Belo Horizonte – An After-Action Report Bert Johnson 64 Webmaster [email protected] Social Media and Digital Communication for Map Wonks Leigh Lockwood 68 Thomas F. Sander Editor, The Portolan The Portolan Issue #100 and the Washington Map Society Leigh Lockwood 71 9501 Burke Rd., # 10793 Book Reviews Early Dutch Maritime Cartography Dick Pflederer 74 Burke VA 22009-8036 USA [email protected] The New Map of Empire: How Britain Imagined America before Independence Richard Brown 76 BOARD OF DIRECTORS 2017–2018 Frederick de Wit and the First Concise Reference Atlas Edward Kirsch 78 Robert Hansen, Picturing America – The Golden Age of Pictorial Maps Cassandra Farrell 80 Bert Johnson, Jeffrey Katz, Chas Langelan, Hal Meinheit, Scotland – Mapping the Islands Marianne McKee 81 Tony Mullan, Carlyn Osborn, Peter Porrazzo, Iris Taylor Spotlight on the WMS Membership 83 SEND ALL NON-PORTOLAN Cartographic Notes Thomas Sander 84 CORRESPONDENCE TO: Tributes and Thanks to Joel Kovarsky, Compiler, Recent Publications, 2007–2017 86 John W. Docktor 3100 N. Highway A1A, PH A1 Recent Publications Joel Kovarsky 87 Ft. Pierce FL 34949-8831 USA Map Site Seeing 89 [email protected] (March 1 change – see page 85) Cyrus Ala’i Imre Josef Demhardt From the Editor Ralph E. Ehrenberg John R. Hébert Who would have thought back in 1984, when they saw eight mimeographed pages stapled in one corner, and called issue 1 of The Portolan, that it would grow to the product in your hands Peter van der Krogt (or viewing online) today? As the longest serving Editor of this journal, I must say that I could not Richard Pflederer Editorial Advisory Board be doing this without the willingness and cooperation of so many members, and non-member contributors too. You write book reviews, biographic notes and articles. Others present talks and The Word Express, Inc then agree to write some of the articles you read, in that way connecting distant members with Portolan Design and Layout the Society. Editorial Advisory Board members review select articles to insure they meet quality The Portolan (ISSN 1096–1925) is pub- standards. lished three times per year by the Wash- I am proud to say that The Portolan has been published on-time and consistently since 1984. ington Map Society. Annual subscription It is received at MANY noted institutions and libraries and by readers throughout North America rates: US: $45 (1st yr student rate $25); Canada $50; All other countries: $65; and over 20 countries across the seas. The reach is great, and I am heartened by the many people Single Copy to U.S: $16.00; Canada $18; I have encountered worldwide who are immediately familiar with this journal and its content. Other countries: $23. All payments are to Available now to all members is online access to all current and past issues, and we are im- be made in U.S. currency. Internet Address: proving the quality of the digital product. If you wish you can download an issue to your tablet http://www.WashMapSociety.org and view it with enlarged font and great color clarity. Address all editorial correspondence to the This current issue starts with one of my favorite cartographic items—persuasive cartography— Editor. Viewpoints of the authors do not I have some in my collection and never tire of examining these maps with a message. Look above necessarily reflect those of the Society. and you will see the magnificent feast that awaits in this issue. © 2017 Washington Map Society. Enjoy the holiday season. You will be receiving the next issue in March. Tom The Portolan | Winter 2017 | 1 Copyright Washington Map Society. Please do not redistribute. Letter from the President Dear WMS Members, This milestone 100th issue of The Portolan comes to you On Thursday, December 7 at 5:00 PM, Washington Map 33 years after the journal began. Consistently during Society member Leslie Trager will present a talk entitled those many years, the dedicated work of the journal’s edi- Henry Hudson: Cree History and Ancient Maps. The talk will tors and the contributions of many WMS members have be largely based on his online book of the same title. It resulted in the respected publication of which we are very will also deal with the Cree interaction with Hudson, as proud, and which reaches readers in over twenty coun- conveyed in their oral history. tries. The journal, and now the advances of electronic me- dia (see our website), keep all WMS members connected. Washington Map Society programs for the Spring of 2018 I commend to you Leigh Lockwood’s article beginning on are currently being planned and there are several interest- page 71, a tribute to our journal. ing topics and speakers under consideration. As 2017 draws to a close and fall turns to winter, the On behalf of the entire Washington Map Society Board, Washington Map Society is preparing for its last two pro- I would like to express my thanks you for your contin- gram meetings of the year. ued interest and support of the Washington Map Society. We look forward to seeing you at future presentations. On Thursday, November 9, 2017 at 5:00 PM, the Should you be unable to come to a meeting, note that Washington Map Society will host Dr. Donald McGuirk, a new membership benefit is the online posting of our a member of the Executive Steering Committee of the presentations at the WMS website. While not all sessions Philip Lee Phillips Society (and a WMS member), for are able to be recorded (due to speaker desires), we have a talk entitled A Survey of the Stars and Stripes on Early several posted already, with more to come. Maps, 1777-1795. Several of the maps that Don will be discussing will be on display in the Geography and Map Best wishes for the Holidays, Division Reading Room. Earlier that same day, the Philip Lee Phillips Society Steering Committee will be meeting in the Geography and Map Division, and Phillips Society members are invited to attend the WMS talk. President 2016–2018 2017 RISTOW PRIZE WINNERS ANNOUNCED Each year the Washington Map Society offers the Ristow Prize in honor of the late Dr. Walter W. Ristow, one of the nation’s premier map librarians and cartographic authors. Dr. Ristow was for many years head of the Geography and Map Division at the Library of Congress and was the founding president of the Washington Map Society. The winner of the 2017 Ristow Prize is Lauren Bouchard Killingsworth, an undergraduate studying History and Biology at Stanford University, for her paper entitled “Mapping Public Health in Nineteenth-Century Oxford.” Ms. Killingsworth’s winning entry will be published in a future issue of The Portolan. She will receive a cash award of $1,000 and a complimentary membership in the Washington Map Society for the coming year. “Navigating the British Empire through Geographical Board Games in the Nineteenth Century” by Koca Mehmet Kentel was selected for Honorable Mention. A Ph.D candidate, he is an urban and environmental historian of the late Ottoman Istanbul, writing his dissertation at the University of Washington. A complimentary membership in the Washington Map Society will be awarded to him for the coming year. 2 | The Portolan | Winter 2017 Copyright Washington Map Society. Please do not redistribute. Washington Map Society Meetings Program sessions will be held in the Reading Room, Geography and Map Division, B level, Library of Congress, Madison Building, 101 Independence Avenue, S.E., Washington, D.C.