Saaarchaeologicalrecord the Magazine of the Society for American Archaeology Volume 2, No
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
ANNUAL MEETING SUBMISSIONS DEADLINE: September 4, 2002 the archaeologicalrecord SAA MAY 2002 • VOLUME 2 • NUMBER 3 SOCIETY FOR AMERICAN ARCHAEOLOGY from saa’s book program. NEW! Delivering Archaeological Information Electronically, edited by Mary S. Carroll. With contributions by Christopher Chippendale, David Carlson, S. Terry Childs, Harrison Eiteljorg, II, James A. Farley, Hugh Jarvis, Mary S. Car- roll, Bart Marable, Peter McCartney, and Mark Aldenderfer. ISBN: 0-932839- 23-1. Regular Price: $26.25, SAA Member Discount Price: $21.00. Ethics in American Archaeology, 2nd revised edition. Edited by Mark J. Lynott and Alison Wylie. This groundbreaking series of papers explores the myriad issues facing archaeologists as archaeological sites become more well known and the preservation of artifacts continues to command public interest. The Second Revised Edition expands the discussion that led to the development of the Principles of Archaeological Ethics. This innovative volume is an invalu- able resource, especially in making ethics a standard part of formal archaeo- logical training. 2000. 168 pages. ISBN: 0-932839-16-9. Regular Price: $12.95, SAA Member Discount Price: $9.95. History Beneath the Sea: Nautical Archaeology in the Classroom. Edited by K.C. Smith and Amy Douglass. History Beneath the Sea provides background readings and classroom activities for secondary-level educators who wish to teach history, social studies, and science through the exciting medium of underwater archaeology. ISBN: 0-932839-17-7. Regular Price: $5.95, SAA Member Discount Price: $4.95. Archaeological Research and Heritage Preservation in the Americas. Edited by Robert D. Drennan and Santiago Mora. The contributors to the volume discuss experiences of archaeological research and heritage preservation under widely varied conditions in locations throughout the Americas from Argentina to Canada. Regular Price: $21.95, SAA Member Discount Price: $17.95. NEW! Topics in Cultural Resource Law. Edited by Donald Forsyth Craib. This collection of articles explores a wide range of legal issues as they pertain to the control, protection, and regulation of cultural resources. 2000. ISBN: 0-932839-21-5. Regular price: $24.95, SAA Member Discount Price: $19.95. see inside back cover for ordering information the SAAarchaeologicalrecord The Magazine of the Society for American Archaeology Volume 2, no. 3 May 2002 Editor’s Corner 2 John Kantner Letters to the Editor 3 Committee on Curation Update 6 S. Terry Childs Committee on Ethics Update 7 Karen D. Vitelli Cover photo: Rimstone ponds near the entrance chamber of a cave used point-counterpoint: archaeology vs. anthropology for Maya ritual practice, Belize, Point: Archaeology as an Academic Discipline 8 James Wiseman Central America. Photo credit: Counterpoint: Separation versus a Larger Vision 11 Susan Lees Patricia A. McAnany, Department Counterpoint: Archaeology Is Anthropology 13 Robert L. Kelly of Archaeology, Boston University. Interface: NASA Remote Sensing Research 15 Marco J. Giardino and Michael R. Thomas as Applied to Archaeology Insights: SAA, CRM, and the Future 20 Lynne Sebastian Public Education—Communicating with the 21 Mary L. Kwas Public Part IV: Tips for Writing a Tour Guide Government Archaeology—Private Contracting 22 Michael R. Polk in Cultural Resources: A Maturing Business Student Affairs Committee: Finding and Funding Your 25 Elizabeth de Grummond First Overseas Field Experience Report from the SAA Board of Directors 27 Susan J. Bender SAA Annual Business Meeting 28 2002 Award Recipients 31 Call for Nominations 36 In Memoriam: Robert C. Euler 37 George J. Gumerman In Memoriam: Jason McCool Fenwick 38 Charles D. Hockensmith In Memoriam: Douglas Carlton Kellogg 39 Daniel G. Roberts news & notes 40 positions open 42 calendar 43 the SAAarchaeologicalrecord The Magazine of the Society for American Archaeology Volume 2, No. 3 May 2002 EDITOR’S CORNER John Kantner The SAA Archaeological Record (ISSN 1532-7299) is published five John Kantner is an assistant professor of anthropology at Georgia State University. times a year and is edited by John Kant- ner with assistance from Ronald Hob- good. Deadlines for submissions are: December 1 (January), February 1 (March), April 1 (May), August 1 (September), and October 1 (November); send to The SAA Archaeo- logical Record, Department of Anthropolo- gy and Geography, Georgia State Univer- New Insights Editor sity, 33 Gilmer St., Atlanta, GA 30303- 3083. For information, call (404) 651-1761; When Lynne Sebastian was elected to be the next SAA President, The SAA Archaeo- fax (404) 651-3235, or email: kantner@ logical Record lost the Associate Editor for the Insights column. Lynne decided that gsu.edu. with her new responsibilities, which began immediately at the annual meeting in Den- Manuscript submission via email or by disk is encouraged. Advertising and ver, she would not also be able to continue her editorial duties. I am very thankful for placement ads should be sent to SAA Lynne’s service to The SAA Archaeological Record, but in her new position she will cer- headquarters, 900 Second St., NE #12, tainly be better able to focus on the CRM-related issues reported in the Insights col- Washington, DC 20002, (202) 789-8200. umn under her tutelage. Appropriately, in this issue, Lynne is the author of her last Associate editors include: Emily McClung de Tapia [Exchanges, Insights column, titled “SAA, CRM, and the Future,” in which she affirms her intent Mexico & Central America] to continue as an advocate for the CRM community in her new role as SAA president. email: [email protected] Jose Luis Lanata [Exchanges, Southern I am very pleased to announce that Cory Breternitz will take over as Associate Editor of Cone] email: jllanata@filo.uba.ar Insights. Cory is President of Soil Systems, Inc., a CRM firm located in Phoenix, Ari- Anne Vawser [Government] zona. He has served as the editor of the Arizona Archaeological Council Newsletter and email: [email protected] was editor of the ACRA Edition during its first two years. With service on a number of Cory Breternitz [Insights] email: [email protected] SAA committees and a term as president of ACRA, Cory has extensive experience and Mark Aldenderfer [Interface] contacts in SAA, ACRA, academia, and the CRM world. He is the perfect person to email: [email protected] John Hoopes [Networks] ensure that The SAA Archaeological Record continues to represent the interests of all email: [email protected] areas of archaeological practice. Interested contributors to the Insights column should Teresa Hoffman [Public Education] contact Cory Breternitz directly at Soil Systems, Inc., 1121 North Second Street, email: [email protected] Kurt Dongoske [Working Together] Phoenix, AZ 85004; voice: (602) 253-4938; fax: (602) 253-0107; email: COBRDSSI@ email: [email protected] aol.com. Inquiries and submissions should be addressed directly to them. The SAA Issue on Gender and Ethnic Equity Archaeological Record is provided free to members and institutional subscribers to As previously announced, the September 2002 issue will be dedicated to the theme, American Antiquity and Latin American “Gender and Ethnic Equity in Archaeology.” This issue only has room for one or two Antiquity worldwide. The SAA Archaeologi- cal Record can be found on the Web in PDF additional contributions, so if you would like to participate, please contact me at kant- format at [email protected]. I am also considering special themes for future issues, and I’d be happy www.saa.org/publications/ to entertain any suggestions. thesaaarchrec/index.html. Thanks to Editorial Assistant Past issues of the SAA Bulletin can be found at Over the past year, Ron Hobgood has ably assisted me with editorial responsibilities, www.saa.org/publications/ saabulletin/index.html. reading and copy-editing virtually everything that has been printed in The SAA Archae- Copyright © 2002 by the ological Record. He will be graduating this summer, and all SAA members should be Society for American Archaeology. thankful for his dedicated service. All Rights Reserved Manager, Publications: John Neikirk Design: Victoria Russell Papertiger Studio •Washington, DC Production: Peter Lindeman Oakland Street Publishing • Arlington, VA 2 The SAA Archaeological Record • May 2002 LETTERS ly that in a significant number of sites, surveys. It has been known for quite LETTERS TO the methods yield less-than-satisfactory some time that there is a good correla- results owing to background noise, low tion between geophysical surveys and signal strength, or lack of target fea- certain forms of archaeological fea- THE EDITOR tures capable of yielding a detectable tures, even using older equipment. anomaly. Geophysical techniques are Their paper draws glaring attention to most applicable to sites with some sort their (and by insinuation, North Ameri- lthough I was pleased to read the of architectural feature (walls, ditches, can archaeologists’) ignorance of the paper by Ambos and Larson hearths, etc.). European literature, a vast amount of (The SAA Archaeological which is in English. ARecord, 2002, 2[1]:32–38) on the use of I also disagree with Ambos and Lar- geophysical techniques in archaeology, son’s conclusion that lack of adoption I agree that geophysical techniques I feel that their choice of example of geophysical methods is a sign of a have a lot to offer archaeologists, but undermines their argument, especially deep divide between industrial and aca- there is a more direct way of demon- with respect to the target audience, demic archaeologists. My experience in strating this to the home audience. cultural resource management (CRM) namely North American archaeologists. Charles D. Frederick and academic projects leads me to Department of Archaeology and Prehistory In Europe, the utility of geophysical believe that there are two sources for University of Sheffield survey is undoubted, and it is standard this discrepancy: (1) high cost of equip- in many archaeology departments and ment and survey, and (2) the low fre- projects. This is particularly true in quency of successful surveys.