I “Heroic Disobedience”: the Forced Marriage Plot, 1748-1880 by Leah
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
“Heroic Disobedience”: The Forced Marriage Plot, 1748-1880 by Leah A. Grisham-Webber B.A. in English, May 2012, Miami University M.A. in English, May 2014, Boston College A Dissertation submitted to The Faculty of The Columbian College of Arts and Sciences Of The George Washington University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy August 31, 2020 Dissertation directed by Maria Frawley Professor of English i The Columbian College of Arts and Sciences of The George Washington University certifies that Leah A. Grisham-Webber has passed the Final Examination for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy as of 24 April 2020. This is the final and approved form of the dissertation. “Heroic Disobedience”: The Forced Marriage Plot, 1748-1880 Leah A. Grisham-Webber Dissertation Research Committee: Maria Frawley, Professor of English, Dissertation Director Daniel DeWispelare, Associate Professor of English, Committee Member Talia Schaffer, Professor of English, Committee Member ii © 2020 by Leah Grisham-Webber All rights reserved iii Dedication For Nick and Nora iv Acknowledgements First, I would like to thank my committee members: Maria Frawley, Tara Wallace, and Daniel DeWispelare. They have all provided invaluable advice and feedback. Without realizing it, the beginnings of this project began to germinate in the independent study Maria and I undertook my first semester as a PhD student; our discussions there (and since) have helped me grow as a scholar. Daniel showed me the ropes when I was a new PhD student and became my go-to for all sorts of questions and issues. I am so thankful that my time at George Washington University overlapped with Tara’s tenure here; her encyclopedic knowledge of British literature and grammar rules never cease to amaze me. I am so grateful for their mentorship and the many hours they have spent reading my work over the years. I would also like to thank my outside dissertation readers, Talia Schaffer and Deborah Denenholz Morse, for dedicating time to this project. Women are often asked to undertake a lop-sided amount of academic service; they did not have to say yes to this, but they did – for which I am so grateful. There are many additional members of my GW family to thank, including Holly Dugan for being such an excellent role model and Connie Kibler for everything she does for the department. Working with you in literature and the financial imagination taught me so much about teaching undergraduates. To my friends and collaborators Vicki Barnett-Woods, Sam Yates, Tyler Christenson, Beth TeVault, and Joshua Benson: you all pushed me to be my best and kept me sane. I know that you all will do wonderful things and I am so glad that we have been a part of each other’s journeys. I also owe thanks to the Columbian College of Arts and Sciences for awarding me a Summer Dissertation Fellowship, which allowed me to finish this project in a timely v manner. The Graduate Teaching Instructorship I was awarded from the CCAS has also been immensely helpful to me as both a scholar and a teacher through allowing me to create and teach nineteenth-century British horror stories to undergraduates. Nick and Nora: to say thank you does not begin to cover how much gratitude I feel toward you both. I don’t know what is next for me but knowing you will both be a part of it makes me unafraid. vi Abstract of Dissertation “Heroic Disobedience”: The Forced Marriage Plot, 1748-1880 This dissertation examines eighteenth- and nineteenth-century British novels that use forced marriage as a plot structure to expose and subvert the oppression of women in British society. Each of the novels studied at length re-writes the forced marriage plot of Samuel Richardson’s Clarissa, highlighting the ways in which contemporaneous economic forces – the rise of capitalism in the eighteenth century, the slave trade, and speculation – drive the subordination of women. The first chapter of the project shows that, despite the depth of Clarissa Harlowe’s interiority and the extent to which the mercenary nature of her family’s greed is criticized, this novel promotes oppressive patriarchal ideologies. Beginning with chapter two, the project examines novels that mirror Clarissa’s plot with an important difference: they celebrate women who rebel against the oppressive patriarchalism of their respective periods. Chapter two analyzes novels by two of Richardson’s peers, Eliza Haywood and Charlotte Lennox, whose novels The History of Miss Betsy Thoughtless (1751) and The Female Quixote (1752) offer contemporary reactions to Clarissa. Chapter three focuses on forced marriage plot narratives, Mary Robinson’s Angelina: A Novel (1796) and Charlotte Smith’s novella “The Story of Henrietta” (1800), that situate forced marriage within the Atlantic slave trade to expose the material connections between the oppression of the enslaved and the patriarchal oppression of British women. Next, a brief Interchapter explains Jane Austen’s connection to the forced marriage plot. Novels by Charles Dickens (Nicholas Nickleby, 1838-9, and Dombey and Son, 1848) and the little-studied Elizabeth Stone (William Langshawe, the Cotton Lord, 1842) move chapter four into post-industrial vii England during the rise of stock-market speculation and debates surrounding the morality of capitalism. Finally, chapter five examines Anthony Trollope’s The Way We Live Now (1874-5) alongside contemporary commentary on gambling. viii Table of Contents Dedication……………………………………………………………...…….………..….iv Acknowledgements………………………………………………………………………..v Abstract of Dissertation…………………………………………………………………...ii List of Figures……………………………………………………………………………..x Introduction………………………………………………………………….…………….1 Chapter 1 “Such Terms, Such Settlements!”: Clarissa Harlowe and the Patriarchy…….33 . Chapter 2 “You are a strange Girl”: Lennox and Haywood Redefine Femininity………72 Chapter 3: “Will there not be virtue in my resistance?”: resisting tyranny in Charlotte Smith’s “The Story of Henrietta” and Mary Robinson’s Angelina; A Novel…………..108 Interchapter: “Young Ladies that have no Money are to be pitied”: Jane Austen and the Forced Marriage plot…………………………...……………………..…………….160 Chapter 4 “Selling a girl”: Charles Dickens, Elizabeth Stone, and Post-Industrial Patriarchy……………………………………………………………………………….166 Chapter 5 “Of course I have to think of myself”: Trollope’s Heroines and the Gambling Economy…………………………………………………………………….221 Coda “I do not repent”: Heroic Disobedience Beyond 1880…………………………...270 Bibliography……………………………………………………………………………277 Appendix………………………………………………………………………………..324 ix List of Figures Figure 1: Title page of Richardson’s “A Collection”….………………………………...63 Figure 2: Betsy and Munden…………………………………………………………...101 Figure 3: James Gillray’s “New Morality”……………………………………………..113 Figure 4: Salvator Rosa, “Landscape with Tree Trunk”………………………………..116 Figure 5: The Great Social Evil……………………………………………………..…183 x Introduction In 1747-48, Samuel Richardson’s second novel, Clarissa, or, the History of a Young Lady, was published to instant success. The novel went to a second edition in 1749, and a third greatly expanded edition in 1751, which to this day is one of the longest English-language novels ever published; coming in at over one million words, the third edition of Clarissa is almost twice as long as David Foster-Wallace’s infamously lengthy Infinite Jest (1996). Additionally, Clarissa’s success has also been sustained. As the appendix to this dissertation shows, at least 20 versions of Clarissa were published in England between 1751 and 1902, not including many pirated editions printed without Richardson’s consent. Several stage adaptations were performed throughout this period, including one in Paris that received rave reviews from Charles Dickens. In his Introduction to the Penguin Classics edition of Clarissa (1986, 2004), Angus Ross notes that Richardson’s masterpiece has been in print ever since the first two volumes appeared in 1747 since Richardson “had the luck or prescience to hit on a story that became a myth to his own age, and remains so yet” (18). As the following chapters explore, Clarissa is indeed a novel that experienced immense relevancy long after Richardson’s death, inspiring a ubiquity of authors to emulate Clarissa’s plot. This dissertation is in many ways about the mythos of Clarissa, to borrow Ross’ terminology, and the ways in which it impacted British literature throughout the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. Throughout this project, I use Clarissa’s plot – and later novels that emulate it – to explore the deliberate processes by which women are taught that they are powerless, why this is done, and how, according to authors in eighteenth- and nineteenth-century England, women can circumvent the cycle of powerlessness and reclaim autonomy. I 1 make two key claims throughout the project. The first is that beginning in the mid- eighteenth century and throughout the nineteenth century, novelists deployed forced marriage plots, which I define as plots in which a father figure attempts to force his daughter into a marriage that she does not want but that would be financially beneficial to himself, to critique manifestations of mercenary wealth accumulation and the specific ways that women suffered under this system. Samuel Richardson, though not the first British author to use this plot, popularized it in his 1747-48 novel Clarissa, providing inspiration for authors in generations to come, cementing his legacy as a pioneer in representing female subjectivity.