The True Scene of the Second Act of the Eumenides of Aeschylus
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The Classical Review http://journals.cambridge.org/CAR Additional services for The Classical Review: Email alerts: Click here Subscriptions: Click here Commercial reprints: Click here Terms of use : Click here The True Scene of the Second Act of the Eumenides of Aeschylus William Ridgeway The Classical Review / Volume 21 / Issue 06 / September 1907, pp 163 - 168 DOI: 10.1017/S0009840X00180060, Published online: 27 October 2009 Link to this article: http://journals.cambridge.org/abstract_S0009840X00180060 How to cite this article: William Ridgeway (1907). The True Scene of the Second Act of the Eumenides of Aeschylus. The Classical Review, 21, pp 163-168 doi:10.1017/S0009840X00180060 Request Permissions : Click here Downloaded from http://journals.cambridge.org/CAR, IP address: 138.251.14.35 on 06 Apr 2015 THE CLASSICAL REVIEW 163 of idiom, obviously the performance may boys Latin composition has much to do with and will be very poor as to its results, but their literary sense. If they have any such yet the gymnastic may be quite as successful sense, of which there is often no evidence, as the state of the case permits. Why should it should be trained by English teaching and we confuse the ' gymnastic' with the ' literary' learning good poetry. aim ? I cannot see that for many English E. LYTTELTON. THE TRUE SCENE OF THE SECOND ACT OF THE EUMENIDES OF AESCHYLUS. IN this paper I propose to inquire whether and from inscriptions, that the goddess who the scene of the Second Act of the Eumen- dwelt in ' the strong house of Erechtheus' ides is rightly laid on the Acropolis and at the on the Acropolis was never called Pallas, • Erechtheum, as has been universally held, but was invariably known either as the and as it was recently represented in the Polias, or as Athena (or Athenaia) Polias.1 splendid performance of the play at Cam- On the other hand I propose to show that bridge, or whether we must look for some (1) there was a very ancient tribunal (if not other site which is more in keeping with the the most ancient at Athens) for cases of conditions of the trial of Orestes. It will at homicide, more especially for that class of once be said, What objections are there to homicide to which Orestes pleaded guilty, the traditional view—that the Acropolis is situated outside the city wail to the south- the true scene of the trial ? That was the east of the Acropolis; (2) that there was most famous spot in Athens, and on it stood here a most ancient wooden image (£6avov) the oldest temple of Athena, already known to which those whose hands were reddened in Homeric days. Yet the difficulties of with the blood of their fellow men might fly this view will be obvious as soon as they to avoid the instant vengeance of the pursuer; are stated. In the first place, though there and (3) that this image was never known by were in Athens four localities all intimately the name of Athena or Athenaia, but always associated with trials of persons charged by that of Pallas or Palladion. with homicide, not one of these was situ- Now as there were five different localities ated on the Acropolis, though it is true in or near Athens closely connected from of weapons and other inanimate objects which old with trials for bloodshed, it is most had shed the blood of men or of oxen were unlikely that Aeschylus would in this play tried in the Prytaneum, the ancient residence lay the scene of the trial at any spot other of the Archon Eponymus on the north slope than one of those associated in the popular of the Acropolis. Secondly, though in the mind from time immemorial with the trial of play Orestes is represented as taking sanc- homicide. This is all the more unlikely tuary at a shrine of Pallas, and as taking in his arms her ancient Operas, there is not the since he represents the first tribunal for the slightest evidence that any image of the trial of that crime as instituted for the trial goddess Athena on the Acropolis, whether of Orestes, whilst he also refers to the ancient or recent, offered an asylum to those establishment on the Hill of Ares of a great who fled before the avenger of blood. council (/3ovkevrypiov) which was not only to Thirdly, in the play the goddess is always try cases of deliberate murder, but also to termed Pallas by the Pythian Priestess, by keep ward and control over the public 2 Apollo, and by the Furies in dialogue, though morals. 1 Cf. Frazer's note on Paus. i. 26. 5. on two occasions Orestes does certainly 2 address her as Athena, and she is so termed Sum. 684 sqq. Kkiori ttv 1)817 decr/xhy, 'Arrmbs AciiJ, by the Furies twice in choral parts. Yet we irpdrras Sinus Kplvovrcs at/iaros X"r°v- know for certain, both by literary tradition (<rrai Si nal rb Aonrhv Alytais <rrpar$ atl SlKWTTUV 70VT0 &OV\€UT'fl(>tOV. M 2 164 THE CLASSICAL REVIEW Down to the time of Pausaniasx (A.D. 180) If it be said that Pausanias does not refer to there still survived at Athens five tribunals the trial of Orestes as having taken place at the for cases of bloodshed, (i) There was the Palladion, and consequently that this shrine Areopagus, which sat on the famous hill cannot be the true scene of the act, I may that rises on the west over against the Acro- at once point out that there is the same polis. Here were tried cases of deliberate objection to the Areopagus, for Pausanias2 murder, wounding with malice, arson, and says that that court was first established to poisoning. (2) To the south-east of the Acro- try Ares for the murder of Halirrhothius, and polis, outside the wall, lay an ancient shrine makes no mention of the trial of Orestes at all. called the Palladion, so named from a very Aeschylus gives us a totally different ancient image of • Pallas, which tradition account of the establishment of the first variously declared to have been brought tribunal for manslayers, but as he wrote from Ilium, or to have fallen from heaven, some six centuries and a half before Pausan- or else to have been set up by Athena ias, we are justified in assuming that his in her repentance for having killed her play- statement represents a far older legend than mate Pallas. Here sat the court known as those of Pausanias, and accordingly we may the TO iirl HaWa&iw, where were tried those leave on one side the latter's account of the who had committed involuntary homicide first cases supposed to have been tried at the (TOTS a.TroKT€iva(riv OLKOVCTLWS). ' Nobody denies Palladion, the Delphinion, and the Areo- that Demophon was the first person tried pagus. Originally the judges in all these here,' but there is a difference of opinion five courts for bloodshed were the ancient as to the crime for which he was tried, body called the Ephetae. The King archon i.e. whether it was for accidentally killing presided and probably with the fifty Ephetae Argives by mistake, or for accidentally made up the Fifty and One, a term by which trampling an Athenian under his horse's feet the body was likewise known. According in the dark. (3) There was the court known to Pollux3 the Ephetae were constituted by as the Delphinion, also situated on the east Draco. Up to that time the Basileus had side of the Acropolis and outside the city investigated and tried all cases of bloodshed, wall. It was a shrine of Apollo of Delphi, but Draco referred such to the Fifty and and in it were tried cases of justifiable homi- One, and from this reference of such cases cide, e.g. those who had slain an adulterer taken Pollux ascribes the origin of their name in the act. ' On such a plea Theseus was Ephetae. But like so many other provisions acquitted when he had slain the rebel Pallas in Draco's enactments the body had only and his sons. But the custom was in former been reconstituted, having really existed from days, before the acquittal of Theseus, that time immemorial. The fact that they were every manslayer either fled the country, or, selected on the ground of high birth if he stayed, was slain even as he slew.' Yet (dpio-TtVSijv oupefoWas) of itself indicates that it will soon be seen that the court probably they were a survival from oligarchic and owed its name to an older legend. (4) At monarchical times. It is highly probable Phreattys, on a tongue of land projecting into that in the Ephetae presided over by the the sea at Zea, was held a court to try any Archon Basileus (himself the shadow of the manslayer who, during his period of exile, ancient king) we have the survival of the might have committed another crime of the ancient Gerusia or Boule. This view will be same character. The judges sat on the shore, found to be quite in accord with certain whilst the accused was literally docked in statements of Aeschylus. a boat moored off the beach, that he might not pollute with the miasma of his guilt the By Solon's reforms the Ephetae were land of Attica. (5) In the Prytaneum, as replaced on the Areopagus by a body consist- already stated, weapons, especially the axe ing of ex-archons, though jurisdiction in the with which was slain the ox at the Buphonia, 2 i.