Vandals scramble after egging an off-duty CHP officer
By MARY BROWNFIELD Having just purchased a dozen fresh eggs from Save Mart, of his eye, he saw a gray pickup come by,” Rana said. “And the 16-year-old boys were driving up San Carlos Street the next thing he knew, he saw eggs on his car and felt them TWO TEENAGERS chose their victim poorly during a around 3:15 p.m. Oct. 27 when they decided to toss three of on his shoulder.” bit of drive-by vandalism Saturday. the eggs out the window at a bystander, according to Carmel The victim was an off-duty California Highway Patrol Police Cpl. Steve Rana. “He was just getting into his car when, out of the corner See VANDALS page 31A
BULK RATE U.S. POSTAGE PAID CARMEL, CA Permit No. 149
Volume 93 No. 44 On the Internet: www.carmelpinecone.com November 2-8, 2007
Y OUR S OURCE F OR L OCAL N EWS, ARTS AND O PINION S INCE 1915 C.V. fire crew fights SoCal wildfires NEW PARKS
By MARY BROWNFIELD OFF LIMITS A FIRE department with a state-owned engine in its sta- tion, such as the Carmel Valley Fire Protection District, can use it to fight local fires whenever it needs to. TO PUBLIC But when the California Office of Emergency Services wants the engine to fight a conflagration in another part of the By CHRIS COUNTS state, a local crew has to be ready, willing and able to go. “With an OES engine, you make a very strict commitment WHEN IT was acquired by the Big Sur Land Trust in that when they call with an immediate need, you’re on the the late 1990s, Point Lobos Ranch was advertised as a road within 30 minutes,” said Carmel Valley Fire Capt. Jim “future state park.” And the ranch, which is just across Smith. “You turn it down once, and you lose the engine.” Highway 1 from Point Lobos State Reserve, now belongs to Fulfilling that commitment, Smith, engineer Steve the California Department of Parks and Recreation. But state Bonanfant and firefighters Jud Boone and Silas Fischer parks officials said this week they have no plan to open the grabbed their gear and hit the highway the night of Oct. 21 ranch to the public in the foreseeable future. less than an hour after state officials ordered the engine to join “In order to have hiking access, we need a general plan or one of the many strike teams heading to battle the wildfires an initial general use plan,” explained Matt Fuzie, Monterey sweeping through Southern California. Strike Team 2804A, comprising OES engines from Carmel See PARKS page 28A Valley, North Monterey County, Santa Clara County, South Santa Clara County and Salinas Rural fire departments, arrived in San Diego the following morning and was immedi- Crosswalk victim See FIRE page 29A dies, driver could face manslaughter
By MARY BROWNFIELD
THE WOMAN hit by an SUV on Ocean Avenue two PHOTOS/COURTESY JIM SMITH weeks ago died from her injuries Monday. Carmel resident Rebecca Mitchell Tarumoto, 62, had been in critical condi- Carmel Valley Fire Capt. Jim Smith collected these pho- tion in a San Jose trauma center since the Oct. 17 accident in tos of the huge blazes his crew battled in San Diego last which a Dodge Ram struck her in a Junipero Street cross- week as part of a California Office of Emergency Services strike team, including a shot of his engine walk. The Santa Clara County Coroner’s Office notified (above). Whipped up by 80 mph Santa Ana winds, the Carmel police Tarumoto died at 3:29 p.m. Oct. 29. fires were the worst he’s seen in more than three decades On Wednesday, Cpl. Steve Rana requested California on the job. See VICTIM page 9A Raccoons injure dogs in midnight tussles Gay police officer By MARY BROWNFIELD wounds in her back and leg. Lexi, 6, sustained punctures in her back and also lost a couple of teeth and some of the nails alleges harassment, FALL SEEMS to bring raccoon encounters in Carmel, on her right paw. and the aggressive scavengers fought with pets at two homes “They’re doing fairly well and are almost back to normal, early Sunday and Monday, sending three dogs to the vet, ani- personality-wise,” Sayles said Wednesday. “They were pretty discrimination mal control officer Cindi Mitchell reported. skittish all day Monday and most of yesterday.” The more serious attack occurred around 1 a.m. Oct. 29 By KELLY NIX when a raccoon climbed through an open window in the See DOGS page 29A garage of a San Carlos Street house, possibly landing on the GAY Pacific Grove police officer has filed a two miniature schnauzers sleeping in their bed below. A A raccoon claim with the city after enduring what he says has been “You know how you think you hear something, but you nearly 10 years of “discrimination, harassment and think your dreaming? It was unbelievable barking — I’ve attacked minia- ture schnauzers retaliation” by fellow officers, a former police chief and never heard the dogs make sounds like that before,” recalled others. Wally Sayles. Annie (left) and Lexi (right). In a lurid six-page claim filed in August, Sgt. Darrin His partner, Jeff Doherty, rushed to investigate the ruckus Both suffered Smolinski, who began working at the department in and opened the door to the garage. In ran the dogs, trailing puncture 1997, alleges he was repeatedly turned down for sever- blood, with a raccoon in pursuit. wounds, and al promotions, including the positions of detective and “He slammed its head in the door,” Sayles said, and when Lexi lost some commander. Doherty let off the pressure, the raccoon retreated into the teeth and some “Smolinski’s sexual orientation became a subject of garage and out through the window. “There was blood every- claws on her jokes, ridicule and innuendos within 20 months of his where.” right paw, initial employment and [the harassment is] continuing,” Also hearing the commotion, two Carmel police officers which she is favoring. according to the officer’s claim. on patrol came to see what the problem was. Sayles said he The claim — which alleges wrongdoing on the part was grateful for their attentiveness, as well as the help from Mitchell, who followed up on the incident later that day. PHOTO/MARY BROWNFIELD At the vet’s office, Annie, 8, was treated for puncture See CLAIM page 21A Get your complete Carmel Pine Cone every Friday morning in convenient pdf format as an email attachment. Free subscriptions available at www.carmelpinecone.com. 2A The Carmel Pine Cone November 2, 2007 Coastal panel finds project no real threat to neighbor’s views
By MARY BROWNFIELD Kathy Grady contended in an appeal that Shan Sayles’ pro- tention that her view will be destroyed, “appears to be an ject would ruin her view and the council violated zoning overstatement” because she “will continue to enjoy bay views A NEIGHBOR failed to convince the California rules when it approved it. from both the first floor and second floor.” Coastal Commission to overrule the Carmel City Council’s But coastal commissioners, at the recommendation of Furthermore, Carmel’s zoning rules do not require private approval of a second-story addition to a San Antonio Avenue their staff, decided against rescinding the approval. views to be maintained as is, which would “essentially pro- home. According to the coastal staff’s analysis of the project, hibit residential additions that included above At a coastal commission meeting in San Pedro Oct. 12, Sayles’ plan — which includes demolishing part of the structure/ground elements in most cases,” coastal planners house and adding a 478-square-foot second story — com- said. plies with the city’s zoning rules. Architect Brian Congleton sited the addition “to address the potential impacts on neigh- bors’ views and to ensure that the maximum amount of pri- vacy is preserved.” khaki’s . . . In addition, the project will not significantly affect the ‘Oh, I wish I were an character of the neighborhood or public views of the coast. the best In her appeal, Grady argued she would lose about 40 per- Oscar Mayer Wiener ...’ in men’s cent of her view from upstairs, “solely to pacify an owner who now has a good view but wants to build an additional GRAB SOME canned food, powdered milk or dried clothing bedroom and office which will also have additional good grains and go check out the WienerMobile. views of the water.” She argued the council failed to balance The Oscar Mayer icon will be parked next to Keller the rights of all property owners. Williams Realty at the mouth of the valley Tuesday, Nov. 6, new arrivals But Sayles’ attorney, John Bridges, said the code calls for during a drive for the Food Bank for Monterey County. avoiding substantial elimination of anyone’s view, not “that “We support this important charity all year long, but this all neighbors’ views be completely protected.” is the kickoff for the holiday season,” reported realtor Patty sportcoats According to the coastal commission’s staff, Grady’s con- Ross. “Did you know that one out of every five people on the Monterey Peninsula uses the food bank every year? It’s sweaters astounding! Please come by, have a hot dog, bring some food leathers Did you know... for the bank (any boxed, canned or dried food will do) and shirts help us help others.” The Monterey Bay Aquarium has The event will run 3 to 6 p.m. Nov. 6 in the parking lot at suits been acclaimed as one of the finest in 26200 Carmel Rancho Blvd. near Save Mart. Free hot dogs and Wiener Whistles will be offered to all who donate non- the world, while also becoming a perishable items to the food bank, which distributes more leader in ocean conservation. The than 5 million pounds of food annually to shelters, agencies, popular aquarium sparked a tourism soup kitchens and individuals in need. Randi Greene boom for the Monterey Peninsula when it opened in 1984, and has attracted approximately 2 million visitors every year since. There are five times as many hotel rooms on the peninsula now as there were in 1984, and tourist spending Personal Training has tripled to about $2 billion a year. However, few people Private Studio/or in Home know that the aquarium was originally conceived by four diving buddies while drinking margaritas after a day in Health & Fitness Monterey Bay. One of them was a daughter of computer giant David Packard. When she told her father the idea of Warren Haber converting a former sardine cannery into an aquarium to display the marine life of Monterey Bay, he liked it so Phone: 831-659-5921 much he decided to pay for the construction.
® Randi Greene, Realtor , MBA, GRI, SRES Member, Coldwell Banker’s International President’s Diamond Society. Serving the Monterey Peninsula (831) 622-2589 One mile south of Ocean Ave.; Exit on Hwy 1 at Carmel Valley Rd.; www.RandiGreene.com Right on Carmel Rancho Blvd.; Right on Carmel Rancho Lane. Research by Thom Akeman, veteran newspaper reporter
Hospice volunteers needed Become a volunteer and help us provide companionship, bereavement support, household assistance, and El Cap Jacket transportation for patients and their families. Next volunteer training: Friday, November 2, 9 a.m.–4 p.m.; Saturday, November 3, 9 a.m.–4 p.m.; Wednesday, November 14, 9 a.m.–1 p.m. Trainees must attend all three sessions.
If you're interested in a rewarding volunteer position please call (831) (831) 753-6045, no later t
Mens Womens
Best selection of mens’ and womens’ HOSPICE OF THE CENTRAL COAST styles on the Monterey Peninsula.
Houdini Eco Rain Jacket
Get your complete Pine Cone by email — 111 The Crossroads, Carmel 624.4112 • www.Treadmill.com • Hours: Mon. – Sat. 10 to 6, Sun. 12 to 5 Free subscriptions at www.carmelpinecone.com November 2, 2007 The Carmel Pine Cone 3A NOW OPEN home theater Vote Marcy Rustad made simple for Carmel Unified School Board Dear Voters: I bring a passion for excellence in education to my current posi- tion on the Carmel Unified School Board. I would greatly appreci- ate your vote and the opportunity to continue to work on behalf of SIMPLE SOLUTIONS BY AXIOM HOME all children in our district. Appointed Incumbent - Marcy Rustad THEATER. SAVE TIME AND MONEY, HERE’S HOW: Qualifications • Current CUSD Board Member (Appointed Incumbent) Selection. Ten home theater systems from about 1 • B.S. and M.B.A. in Business Administration $3,500 to $20,000, plus four multi-room music systems • 12 Years Volunteer Leadership & Service in CUSD starting at $2,400. • Two children educated in Carmel Unified Schools Value. Special pricing on every system, every day – • Community Leadership - National Charity League 2 SPCA, Girl Scouts, Cub and Boy Scouts plus weekly specials for even greater savings. • Masters in Governance (Awarded by the California School Board Association) Pedigree. Each system is designed by Axiom Home • Small Business Owner - OMP Research Associates providing market research and consulting services to schools and businesses throughout California 3 Theater, using components from legendary companies like B&W, Denon, Pioneer Elite, Rotel,Tannoy, and Marantz. For more information go to www.marcyrustad.com 4 Enhancements. Beautiful audio /video furniture & quality accessories (at discount prices) to enhance your system. Community Endorsements Steve and Deb Aitchison Kirsten Hewett Mike and Dana Naylor Installation. Available by local licensed specialists. Doug Anderson Hugh and Nancy Holtrop Vicki Nohrden 5 Barbara Baird Patricia and Forest Hunt Pamela Norton Laurie Balcar Todd and Margaret Hunt Justin Noseworthy, Youth Pastor Anna Ball Jean Hurd Mike and Vicki Odello Barbara Barr Justin Iles Gaudenz and Sneha Panholzer Lowell and Barbara Battcher Randal and Ellie Johnson Ron and Mary Parsons Visit Simple Solutions by Axiom Home Susan Brown, RDH Paulette Mariano Gina Phinny Marilyn Bransford Kevin and Marilyn Huston Judi Pospishel Theater – the experts you can trust. Susan Brown Sarah Kallison, Ph.D. Merrie Potter Janice Caoili Jerry and Beth King Kristina Price Dana Carnazzo Matt and Melody King Graeme and Chris Robertson John Catherwood Scot and Sylvia Johnson Glenn and Liz Robinson Fred Chamberlain Alice Kinsler Greg and Robin Robinson Melissa Cowan, R.D.A. Claire Kristl Shirley Rosen Susan and Rick Cortese Roger and Jan Langland Stuart and Keit Ross Jennifer and Ward Crane Kim Larson Andrew and Yolanda Rudy Christine Dally Don Leach Susan Santy Edgar B. Dally Lewis Leader Julie Satow & Dr. Gregg Satow M.D Leila and Dr. Bill Dickey Ted and Laurie Leidig Missy Sepuvado Bill and Laurie Ehlke Ernie Lostrom, Past CUSD Karen Shaheen & Tony Shaheen M.D. Robert Fenton Board Member Bob Spencer Joseph P. Ferry Michael and Tracy Lucido Brian and Vicki Steckler Ellen Fondiler Daria Maldonado M.D. Philip and Therese Strutner Gordon Freedman Paulette & Romeo B. Mariano, M.D. Lorraine Suprenant Mathew and Alix Fuzie Jeff and Heidi Markow Jeff and Jennifer Svihus TUESDAY - SATURDAY 10 – 6 Howard Given, CUSD Board Member Jeff and Carolyn Marshall Margaret Tobin Cynthia Gonzales Mike and Vicki McMillan Sergio Villarreal SUNDAY 12 – 4 John and Barbara Greenway Chantal Melendrez Tammi Waldman Blanny Hagenah Tony Melendrez Diana Vita Ross and Lendy Haisley John and Avril Meyer Ernie and Connie Weilenmann 501 LIGHTHOUSE AVENUE, SUITE 200, MONTEREY 831.645.9019 Steven Harper Anita and Dr. David Mitchell Brigitte Wasserman Leslie Harris and Dr. Neal Harris M.D. John and Suzy Moon Joe and Lynn Welch Joseph and Cynthia Hertlein Jill Movahedi Bernadette Weller www.axiomhometheater.com Chuck and Elaine Hewett Kathi Mulcahy Joanne Wylie
Committee to Elect Marcy Rustad
FREE PUBLIC WORKSHOP
MONTEREY REGIONAL STORM WATER MANAGEMENT PROGRAM
LOCATION: Monterey City Council Chambers INVITES YOU TO Corner of Madison and Pacific Streets, City of Monterey Monday, November 5, 2007, from 7 to 9 p.m. MEET THE DESIGNERS! You are invited to attend a free workshop where the First Year Saturday, November 10, 2007 Annual Report for the Monterey Regional Storm Water Management Program (MRSWMP) will be discussed. At this workshop you will be from 1:00pm – 3:00pm able to comment on the Storm Water Pollution Prevention Program being undertaken by the city’s of Monterey, Pacific Grove, Seaside, Sand City, Del Rey Oaks, Carmel-by-the-Sea, and Marina, the Just in time for the holidays! MORSE & CO. invites County of Monterey, Pebble Beach Company, and several organiza- you to enjoy a very special wine and cheese soiree with two tions and school districts. These entities are pooling their resources to of the finest designers in their fields: handbag designer reduce storm water pollution in order to help keep our waters clean. Stella Page and jewelry designer Jackie Jones.
The Draft Annual Report is available for Public Review at the STELLA PAGE City Halls in each of these cities and at the County Clerk’s office A Monterey County resident handbag of Monterey County, in Salinas. It is also available for public designer who is world-renowned for her review in the libraries located in Carmel-by-the-Sea, Monterey, limited-edition works of art. The genius of Pacific Grove, Salinas, and Marina. It is also posted on-line at her unique handbags and accessories is www.montereysea.org. how she blends the most celebrated art from every corner of the world.
The Program will address: JACKIE JONES A world-renowned jewelry 1. Public Education and Outreach designer known for her one-of- 2. Public Participation and/ Involvement a-kind art-to-wear necklaces. 3. Illicit Discharge Detection and Elimination Each of her pieces is a unique 4. Construction Site Runoff Control creation of precious stones. 5. Post-Construction Runoff Control 6. Pollution Prevention/Good Housekeeping in Municipal Operations For more information, call (831) 647-7458 For more information regarding the storm water program go to: www.montereysea.org Gate fee credited with purchase.
Pebble Beach® and The Inn at Spanish Bay™ are trademarks and service marks of Pebble Beach Company. All rights reserved. 4A The Carmel Pine Cone November 2, 2007
(OHFW /(( <$5%2528*+ Police, Fire & Sheriff’s Log :$7(5 %2$5' No charges in drive-by eggings
/HWVZRUN HERE’S A look at some of the significant FRIDAY, OCTOBER 19 calls logged by the Carmel-by-the-Sea Police WRJHWKHU Department, the Carmel Fire Department and Carmel-by-the-Sea: Theft on Ocean the Monterey County Sheriff’s Office last Avenue. WRVROYHRXU week. This week’s log was compiled by Mary Carmel-by-the-Sea: Traffic collision on Brownfield. public property on Santa Fe. Property damage ZDWHUSUREOHPV only. THURSDAY, OCTOBER 18 Carmel-by-the-Sea: Ambulance dis- patched to 17 Mile Drive at Congress for a Carmel Valley: Reporting party stated that vehicle rollover. Ambulance canceled en route. 0$-25(1'256(0(176 items were taken from one of the guest rooms Carmel-by-the-Sea: Ambulance dis- in Carmel Valley Village. There were no signs 0RQWHUH\&RXQW\+RVSLWDOLW\$VVRFLDWLRQ of forced entry. No suspect information. See POLICE LOG page 23A 3DFLILF*URYH&KDPEHURI&RPPHUFH 0RQWHUH\&RXQW\%XVLQHVV3$& SHOPCommitted & COMPARE...Quality, to Quality & Service Service Since and 1988 Price 0RQWHUH\%D\&HQWUDO/DERU&RXQFLO Any way you look at it, your 0RQWHUH\&RXQW\$VVRFLDWLRQRI5HDOWRUV3$& windows will be beautiful with 0RQWHUH\&RPPHUFLDO3URSHUW\2ZQHUV$VVRFLDWLRQ our custom designed shutters, shades and draperies.
■ Custom Shutters ¥ 927( ´/((µIRU:DWHU%RDUG ■ Distinctive Fabrics ■ Draperies and Architectural Hardware ([SHULHQFHG0DQDJHU ■ Conrad Grass Shades ([SHULHQFHG(QJLQHHU ■ Hunter Douglas Blinds and Shades ■ Motorization for All Products :DWHU6\VWHPV ■ Wallpaper The Finest in Custom ■ Bedding and Headboards :DVWH:DWHU6\VWHPV Wood or Poly Shutters 6WRUP:DWHU6\VWHPV 13'(6 5XQRII 0DQDJHPHQW Give Your 3$,'32/,7,&$/$'9(57,60(17&$03$,*1,' Windows the Perfect Accent. 26362 Carmel Rancho Lane Carmel, CA 93923 831-626-9054
THE NEW YORK TIMES MAGAZINE CROSSWORD PUZZLE
TALKING HEADS By Ben Tausig / Edited by Will Shortz 1234 567 89101112131415161718
19 20 21 22
Across 42 Bit 95 ___-X 11 Clock div. 23 24 25 26 1 Pirate spirits 43 Capital of Lorraine 96 Chem. unit 12 Beginning of a noted political 27 28 29 5 Jarhead’s rank: 44 Flavorful seed 97 Rags’ opposite admonition Abbr. source 100 Judd of “Numb3rs” 30 31 32 33 34 13 High ___ 8 Presidential 46 Half of an athletic 101 Mantel piece pair 14 Perturbs 35 36 37 38 39 candidate born in 102 Like the era of 15 Carded Hawaii 48 Bill’s biography? highest sheet music 16 The silver screen 40 41 42 43 44 45 13 Kids may take them 53 Deutsch article sales 17 What Astrophysics to school in boxes 54 Flair, e.g. 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 104 Phoning Phil and and Advanced 19 Authors’ list ender 55 Carnatic pieces hanging up Calculus probably 53 54 55 56 20 Corn product 56 Sequel’s sequel immediately? aren’t 21 Japanese apples 57 Lonely trucker, 106 Don’s parting 18 Reaction to pepper, 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 words? named for a perhaps maybe 64 65 66 67 mountain 59 Maestro Toscanini 109 Number revealer 24 Overhang 22 Like Bollywood 62 Have a bawl 110 Disconcert 26 Mer filler 68 69 70 71 28 Snicker syllable films 63 Go postal 111 Spinning 32 Red Rose 72 73 74 75 76 23 Writer Steel 64 “And tonight’s 112 “Helping doctors 33 Triple-header, 25 Al’s impressions? guest is … Ann!”? help patients” org. 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 maybe 113 Singer Braxton 27 “What did Bill do 68 Old English bard 37 Magazine exec in a 85 86 87 88 114 Comes after to earn this check, 69 2007 Hall of Fame robe, familiarly anyway?”? inductee Ripken 115 Laughs heartily 39 ___ Lilly 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 70 Seconded 29 Unaided perception 116 Sunday delivery: 41 Partner of kissed Abbr. 96 97 98 99 100 101 30 Sum in English 71 Ages and ages 43 Wee 117 An NCO 31 Protected by law 72 Lou Gehrig’s 44 Be a benefactor 102 103 104 105 disease: Abbr. 32 “À la Recherche du 45 Ex-Yankee Hideki 106 107 108 109 Temps Perdu” 73 Andrea ___ Down 47 “The Galloping author 75 “___ time” 1 Joe Louis Arena Gourmet” host 110 111 112 113 34 1960 Pirates World 76 Ger. neighbor team Graham 114 115 116 117 Series hero, 77 Dance like Rush? 2 Tony winner for 48 Riga resident familiarly 81 Excites “Who’s Afraid of 49 Roman symbol of Virginia Woolf?” power 35 Vietnam’s ___ 85 “Just ___!” 50 Sheet material 63 Hot 78 Cut-up 87 Position in a 98 They may come to Dinh Diem 3 Frequent end of an 86 Boring 65 Word before rhythm band anniversary toast 51 Yarn spinners 79 Hgts. une tête 36 First name in primaire or 87 Many a fed. 80 Ajman’s home: 89 See 90-Down 4 Boo-boo 52 Litter cry secondaire 99 A.F.L.’s partner beauty products holiday Abbr. 54 Qualifying round, 66 Style with dark 90 With 89-Down, 37 Natural riser 5 A synthetic 100 Laughs heartily 88 When doubled, a informally clothes and heavy 81 “Tsk!” historic part of NW Robin Williams 6 Clooney or Rooney eyeliner 38 Flirt 57 Pedicab alternative 82 Arizona state Europe 103 Set before V character’s 7 Like baseball shoes 67 Look like a creep? 40 It might make you 58 Back flowers 91 Some seal hunters catchphrase 68 Deplorable 104 Action figure? sick 8 Iced 59 Mushroom with an 83 Perfect 92 Rabbi’s instrument 89 As a friend, in umbrella cap 73 Pleasing 105 Some “CSI” figs. For any three answers, 9 Power-driven shop 84 What the France tool 60 Wrestler Flair 93 Material for a call from a touch-tone 74 Hoffman who once puzzlemaker did to 107 Black pride cut, phone: 1-900-285-5656, famous for the whitesmith 92 Set of Web pages 10 1977 double- backed a pig for the name in each of $1.49 each minute; or, figure four leglock informally platinum Steely president 94 Illustrator Answerwith a credit to puzzle card, 1-800- 93 Hawaiian staple 61 Where angels come this puzzle’s theme 814-5554.on page 10A vegetables Dan album from 76 Like human vision answers? Silverstein 108 PBS supporter November 2, 2007 The Carmel Pine Cone 5A Residents, board put kibosh on Mission parking-lot lights
By MARY BROWNFIELD A handful of Carmel Mission Basilica parishioners be held liable. defended the proposal. When he had the opportunity to speak again, Sanna said A SCALED-DOWN version of a previously approved “I have a little more problem finding my car these days many of the criticisms of the lights were “based on emotion plan to light the parking lot next to Larson Field failed to gar- than I used to, and I need the illumination,” said 83-year-old and not on fact.” ner any affirmative votes from the Carmel Design Review Wayne Kelley, a CRA and Mission member who attends the “All I can say is, what we’re proposing is a system engi- Board last week. nighttime meeting in the gym once a month. neered by trained professional people to produce the least Although the DRB OK’d the Diocese of Monterey’s orig- Mary Condry, past president and board member of the impact on the environment and the City of Carmel while pro- inal plans for three 22-foot-tall light poles in the lot in front CRA, said she always worries the small children who typi- viding safety,” he said. of the Junipero Serra School gym last February, the city cally dart across the poorly lit lot after the meeting might be Chairman Keith Paterson asked if the Diocese seriously council raised questions about light pollution, according to hit. considered any other options. senior planner Sean Conroy. Rather than have their applica- A Carmel resident who takes her 6-year-old granddaugh- Sanna replied that the contractor was simply asked to tion reviewed by the full city council, representatives of the ter to the gathering argued that safety trumps any other con- return with an alternate plan for lighting the lot using the Carmel Mission agreed to work with the city on a compro- siderations. least amount of power. mise and presented a revised “I just can’t think of what would be more important than “And this is what we got,” he said. proposal Oct. 24. a person’s life, at any age, at any time,” she said. If someone New DRB member Jonathan Sapp, sworn in that after- Louis Sanna, business were hurt or killed in the dark parking area because the board manager and facility adminis- denied the lighting application, she speculated the city could See LIGHTS page 27A trator for the Carmel Mission ‘I could have Basilica, said a need for safe- ty drove the plans to light the embroidered lot, since the church holds a or removed ROBERT monthly meeting in the gym that frequently ends after splinters’ TALBOTT dark. “The first time we did that, FIRST TIME EVER we realized we could have serious issues,” with the atten- SAMPLE/WAREHOUSE dees, who range in age from very young to quite elderly, con- verging on the unlit lot to find their cars. As a result, the Mission hired a contractor to figure out how to economical- SALE! ly illuminate the area. Open to the public! The consultant initially proposed three 22-foot-tall light standards containing two 250-watt bulbs and shields to 2901 Monterey Salinas Highway reduce glare and confine the light to the area. Without protest Monterey, CA from any neighbors, the DRB approved the application Feb. (0.3 Mile East of Monterey Airport) 28, according to Conroy. But after principal planner Brian Roseth and Mayor Sue Reductions up to McCloud requested the Mission reconsider, Sanna said he asked the lighting company for alternatives. He learned the 70% Off Retail Pricing light poles could be reduced to 17 feet. The bulbs would illu- Cash and Major Credit Cards Only minate the lot in an environmentally friendly manner, accord- ing to Sanna, because they would not use as much power as Men’s & Women’s: a greater number of low-level lights would. • New Zealand Shearling The Mission installed a test light in the lot so neighbors • Leather Coats could see its effects. • Shirts & Blouses “During my inspection, the lights were really not visible • Sweaters & Scarves from most locations until you got in front of the lot or in the lot,” said Conroy, who recommended approval. He suggested • Belts & Handbags limiting the lights’ use to four nights per month and requir- • Neckties & Cufflinks ing they turn on no earlier than 6 a.m. and are off by 11 p.m. Saturday, November 3 Sunday, November 4 Illuminated embroidery 9:00 am - 5:00 pm 9:00 am - 4:00 pm Many neighbors disagreed with Conroy. “You can’t walk down a Carmel street after dark and not have to watch your feet,” said former city councilman Mike AUDREY Cunningham. He observed that residents and officials long ago decided not to allow street lights and to severely restrict other lighting for aesthetic reasons, even if it meant sacrific- TALBOTT ing safety. “Many of us carry flashlights.” Cunningham recom- mended the Mission emulate nearby Mission Ranch, which uses light fixtures at lower heights to illuminate its parking areas. Ruth Smith, who lives across the street from Larson Field and described the test light as “extraordinarily bright,” said it would shine directly through the win- dows of homes surrounding the ball park. “I could have embroi- dered or removed splinters” while standing in the illumi- nated lot, she said. Franciscan Way resident Clay Berling said the light would reflect off the parked cars. “This is not a mall. It’s not the Crossroads. It’s not a used-car lot,” he said. “But that’s going to be the look of this thing as you drive by.” Carmel Residents Association President Roberta Miller said the lights would violate city codes, and her husband, Monte Miller, said approval would force the city to grant subsequent similar requests elsewhere. Former city council- woman Barbara Livingston wondered who would enforce the hours of opera- tion. 6A The Carmel Pine Cone November 2, 2007 9OUR $EPARTURE
'ATE )S -INUTES October 2007 To Our Shareholders, Clients and Friends,
1st Capital Bank, which opened on April 16, 2007, has announced its financial results for the quarter ending September 30, 2007. The Bank is pleased to report than its Assets have grown to $58,609,000 with &ROM