Analyzing the Impact of Dowa Education on Discrimination Against the Buraku Community in Japan
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Analyzing the Impact of Dowa Education on Discrimination Against the Buraku Community in Japan The Harvard community has made this article openly available. Please share how this access benefits you. Your story matters Citation Pierce, Kinari S. 2020. Analyzing the Impact of Dowa Education on Discrimination Against the Buraku Community in Japan. Master's thesis, Harvard Extension School. Citable link https://nrs.harvard.edu/URN-3:HUL.INSTREPOS:37365011 Terms of Use This article was downloaded from Harvard University’s DASH repository, and is made available under the terms and conditions applicable to Other Posted Material, as set forth at http:// nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:dash.current.terms-of- use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`9!1:()(#9!$#7!9*$*89!*17$&O!;,9(7,9!*+,!2$0*!*+$*! 7(90:(.(#$*(1#!$)$(#9*!*+(9!):18/!+$9!1008::,7!(#!>$/$#Q!*+,&!+$J,!&,*!*1!01.,!*1!$!01#9,#989! 1#!5+$*!7,2(#,9!$#7!7(22,:,#*($*,9!;8:$<8.(#!2:1.!.$(#9*:,$.!910(,*&O!B+,!/,:9(9*,#*Q! /,:J$9(J,!#$*8:,!12!/:,a87(0,!$)$(#9*!*+,!I8:$<8.(#!$.1#)!*+,!>$/$#,9,!.$a1:(*&!01#*(#8,9! *1!I$:,%&!%(,!I,#,$*+!*+,!98:2$0,Q!&,*!*+,!>$/$#,9,!)1J,:#.,#*!/8%%,7!I$0<!.,$98:,9!(#(*($*,7! (#!*+,!RS[N9!*1!,%(.(#$*,!I8:$<8!9*().$!$#7!(./:1J,!,780$*(1#O!!G&!.1*+,:Q!5+1!+$9!%(J,7! (#!*+,!KO@O!21:!1J,:!MN!&,$:9Q!$#!$J(7!98//1:*,:!12!910($%!a89*(0,Q!2,%*!*+,!#,,7!*1!%15,:!+,:! J1(0,!(#!+,:!15#!+1.,!*1!*$%<!$I18*!*+,!I8:$<8.(#O!! >$/$#!7,/(0*9!(*9,%2!$9!$!+1.1),#189!910(,*&Q!$!.(9:,/:,9,#*$*(1#!*+$*!,#018:$),9! 95,,/(#)!7(22,:,#0,!8#7,:!*+,!:8)O"!-#!RSbNQ!>$/$#!9*$*,7!*+$*!(*9!018#*:&!+$7!#1!.(#1:(*&! ! !!>8#,!"O!c1:71#Q!dC:1.!H(I,:$*(1#!*1!D8.$#!E()+*9e!=+$%%,#),9!21:! B,$0+,:9!12!*+,!;8:$<8.(#!(#!>$/$#Qf!)$*+,-./('*'.0,$(1,-1"*$.'2(,SQ!#1O!M! UMNNTVe!Rb[O! ! "!6:(09!;:15#Q!dE$0($%('$*(1#!(#!$!gD1.1),#189`!@10(,*&h!B+,!=$9,!12! ;8:$<8!A,1/%,!(#!>$/$#Of!34'$(,-./('*'.0!RYQ!#1O!R!UMNR\Ve!^O! ! ! $! ! ! ):18/9!$*!*+,!K#(*,7!i$*(1#9O#!B+(9!7,#($%!+$9!/,:.,$*,7!*+:18)+18*!*+,!51:%7!$#7!+$9!I,,#! 5(7,%&!$00,/*,7Q!,J,#!I&!.80+!12!*+,!/1/8%$*(1#!(*9,%2O$!B+,!d;8:$<8!.1#7$(Qf!1:!;8:$<8! /:1I%,.Q!(9!12*,#!()#1:,7!$#7!$J1(7,7O%!! D15,J,:Q!*+(9!9(*8$*(1#!(9!#1*!$9!0%,$:]08*!$9!(*!9,,.9O!B+,!;8:$<8.(#!.$<,!8/!*+,! .$a1:(*&!12!1:)$#(',7!0:(.,!):18/9!(#!>$/$#O!P+(%,!.19*!;8:$<8.(#!$:,!#1*!.,.I,:9!12! 1:)$#(',7!0:(.,Q!9,J,:$%!90+1%$:9!I$0<!8/!*+,!0%$(.!*+$*!;8:$<8.(#!.$<,!8/!$!98I9*$#*($%! /,:0,#*$),!12!1:)$#(',7!0:(.,!):18/9!(#!>$/$#O&!G80+!12!*+,!28#79!$%%10$*,7!*1!*+,! I8:$<8.(#!I&!*+,!RSTS!@/,0($%!G,$98:,9!H$5!21:!"99(.(%$*(1#!A:1a,0*9!UH@GV!*$:),*,7! *15$:79!I8:$<8!+189(#)Q!,780$*(1#Q!$#7!7(90:(.(#$*(1#!5,:,!28##,%,7!*1!*+,9,!):18/9O'!B+,! ;8:$<8!H(I,:$*(1#!H,$)8,!U;HHV!*+$*!9*:1#)%&!$7J10$*,7!21:!*+,!H@G!+$7!9*:1#)!*(,9!*1! 1:)$#(',7!0:(.,!):18/9Q!$!2$0*!:,J,$%,7!(#!*+,!%$*,!RSbN9!$#7!,$:%&!RSSN9O(!B+,&!+$J,!$%91! ! #!=+$:%(,!ZO!G1:)$#Q!d"!=$9,!@*87&!12!;8:$<8!$#7!i1#];8:$<8!=18/%,9! (#!>$/$#Qf!52"#($6,27,82&9$#$.':+,;$&'60,<."1'+4!\bQ!#1O!R!UMNN[Ve!\RO! ! $!>19,/+!31&%,!D$#<(#9Q!dG$#,8J,:9!12!G8%*(08%*8:$%(9.e!-#*,:#$*(1#$%! E,/:,9,#*$*(1#9!12!G(#1:(*&!A1%(*(09!(#!>$/$#Qf!5$9$(+4+,<."1'+4!\MQ!#1O!R!UMNRMVe! ^O! ! %!6.(%&!"O!@8]%$#!E,I,:Q!d;8:$<8!G1#7$(!(#!>$/$#e!D(9*1:(0$%!$#7! G17,:#!A,:9/,0*(J,9!$#7!3(:,0*(1#9!21:!*+,!C8*8:,Qf!=$#:$#1,="&$(,)'>/.4, 52"#($6!RM!URSSSVe!MS[O! ! &!>O!G$:<!E$.9,&,:!$#7!6:(0!;O!E$9.89,#Q!dW8*0$9*,!A1%(*(09!$#7! W:)$#(',7!=:(.,!(#!>$/$#e!B+,!622,0*!12!B,:.(#$*(#)!6*+#(0!@8I9(7(,9Qf!52"#($6, 27,-&9'#'*$6,?+>$6,<."1'+4,R^Q!#1O!R!UMNRbVe!MN\O! ! '!!>O!G$:<!E$.9,&,:Q!dW#!*+,!-#J,#*(1#!12!-7,#*(*&!A1%(*(09e!B+,!;8:$<8! W8*0$9*,9!(#!>$/$#Qf!K#/8I%(9+,7!/$/,:!UMNRSVQ!MO! ! (!E$.9,&,:Q!dW#!*+,!-#J,#*(1#!12!-7,#*(*&!A1%(*(09Qf!MO! ! ! %! ! ! 89,7!J(1%,#*!$#7!+8.(%($*(#)!.,$#9!*1!$7J10$*,!21:!*+,(:!:()+*9Q!$*!*(.,9!*1:*8:(#)!*,$0+,:9!21:! 9,J,:$%!7$&9!1J,:!$#!,L*:$08::(08%$:!7(9/8*,O)!! i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a1:(*&!9*87,#*9!$#7!I8:$<8.(#!9*87,#*9O!@+,!+$7!*1!I,!0$:,28%!(#!+,:!*,$0+(#)Q! $J1(7(#)!*+,!#8.I,:!dYf!$9!(*!+$7!01##1*$*(1#9!21:!;8:$<8.(#O!*!G&!):$#72$*+,:Q!$!I$#<,:Q! 5$9!#,J,:!$8*+1:(',7!*1!9,*!8/!I$#<!$0018#*9!21:!1:!,L*,#7!%1$#9!*1!I8:$<8.(#Q!$#7!01#98%*,7! *+,!%24+%',U2$.(%&!:,)(9*:$*(1#!9,*!8/!78:(#)!*+,!G,(a(!6:$V!*1!,#98:,!*+,(:!2$.(%&!I$0<):18#7! 8#*(%!%,)(9%$*(J,!0+$#),9!.$7,!(*!(%%,)$%O!!!P+(%,!*+,!1:()(#$%Q!@'(4/'(,%24+%'A!5$9!$J$(%$I%,!*1! $#&1#,Q!91.,!(#J,9*()$*1:9!9*(%%!+$J,!I,,#!$I%,!*1!$00,99!*+,!#,5!<19,<(!*+$*!.$(#*$(#9!$! ! )!B+1.$9!E1+%,#Q!dZ(1%,#0,!$*!j1<$!D()+!@0+11%e!B+,!-./%(0$*(1#9!21:! >$/$#,9,!=1$%(*(1#!A1%(*(09!12!*+,!=1#2:1#*$*(1#!I,*5,,#!*+,!=1..8#(9*!A$:*&! $#7!*+,!;8:$<8!H(I,:$*(1#!H,$)8,Qf!34'$(,<"#:+0!RTQ!#1O![!URS[TVe!TbM]TSbO! ! !*!D(:1<(!@$<$.1*1Q!*,%,/+1#,!(#*,:J(,5!I&!*+,!$8*+1:Q!P$9+(#)*1#Q!3=Q! G$&!YQ!MNRSO! ! !!!D(:1<(!@$<$.1*1Q!*,%,/+1#,!(#*,:J(,5k!C:$#<!?O!K/+$.Q!?$B,$(1, <2*'$6,8/$(>+,'(,C24.B$#,5$9$(!U=$.I:(7),Q!G"e!D$:J$:7!K#(J,:9(*&!A:,99Q! RSb[VQ!bNO! ! ! &! ! ! :,01:7!12!2$.(%($%!:,%$*(1#9+(/9!*+:18)+!78I(189!.,$#9O!"!"%*+18)+!91.,!7,#&!*+,!,L(9*,#0,! 12!I8:$<8.(#!$*!$%%Q!01./$#(,9!9*(%%!01#*(#8,!*1!01#780*!I$0<):18#7!0+,0<9!$#7!*1!*:$0<!*+,(:! %(#,$),O!G&!15#!):$#7/$:,#*9!01#780*,7!$!I$0<):18#7!0+,0<!1#!.&!.1*+,:`9!2$.(%&Q!$! 01..1#!/:$0*(0,!+,()+*,#,7!I&!*+,(:!15#,:9+(/!12!$!01#9*:80*(1#!01./$#&Q!$!2(,%7! 71.(#$*,7!I&!0$%"D$!$#7!9$*8:$*,7!I&!I8:$<8.(#!M!*1!RO!#!B+,9,!910($%!$#7!08%*8:$%!I$::(,:9! 21:!2(#$#0($%!9*$I(%(*&!$#7!910($%!$7J$#0,.,#*!%,2*!$!98I9*$#*($%!#8.I,:!12!I8:$<8.(#!5(*+!#1! 0+1(0,!I8*!*1!,#*,:!0:(.(#$%!0$:,,:9O!! ! ;8:$<8!$#7!345$!6780$*(1#! B+,!)1$%!12!*+(9!/$/,:!(9!#1*!*1!7,I$*,!*+,!1:()(#9!12!;8:$<8.(#!1:!*+,!(#*,):(*&!12! *+,(:!$0*(1#9Q!I8*!*1!,J$%8$*,!*+,!345$!,780$*(1#!9&9*,.!,#$0*,7!*1!$77:,99!*+,!+(9*1:(0$%! 8#7,:/(##(#)9!12!7(90:(.(#$*(1#!$)$(#9*!;8:$<8.(#!(#!>$/$#O!P+(%,!345$!6780$*(1#!5$9! 28#7,7!%$:),%&!I&!*+,!2,7,:$%!)1J,:#.,#*!5(*+!1#,]*+(:7!12!*+,!019*9!98//%,.,#*,7!I&!%10$%!