DOCSLIB.ORG

The Musical Nomos in Aeschylus' Oresteia Author(S): Thomas J

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Musical Nomos in Aeschylus' Oresteia Author(S): Thomas J The Musical Nomos in Aeschylus' Oresteia Author(s): Thomas J. Fleming Source: The Classical Journal, Vol. 72, No. 3 (Feb. - Mar., 1977), pp. 222-233 Published by: The Classical Association of the Middle West and South Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/3296898 . Accessed: 27/01/2014 12:33 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp . JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. The Classical Association of the Middle West and South is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to The Classical Journal. http://www.jstor.org This content downloaded from 136.152.208.62 on Mon, 27 Jan 2014 12:33:08 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions THE MUSICAL NOMOS IN AESCHYLUS' ORESTEIA Althoughthe imageryof the Oresteia has for many years been the subjectof critical scrutiny, musical allusions have failed to attractthe notice which their importancedeserves.1 Such an oversightmay be due to our ignoranceof Greek music, especially the music of the classical period. We are often tempted to view musical language or imagery in a poem in the same light as astrological symbols;however significantthey might be, they aredrawn from an areaof life that remains obscure to us and that is peripheralto our experience of poetry. When we weigh and sift the fragmentsof Pindarfor the poet's opinions on his craft, we forget that for the composers of choral lyric poetry-including dramatic lyric-poetry and music were scarcely separable. From our own traditionwe are accustomedto poets like Drydenand Millay, who make vague commentsabout an artthey do not at all understand.This has led many to make the improbableassumption that musical languagein Greek poets was similarly vague. Aeschylus in the Oresteia has alluded to several musical forms and to many aspects of musical performance.Since the parodosof the Agamemnonis known to have been influenced by the kitharodicnomos, references to the nomos may be of particularsignificance: they serve to underlineone of the broaderthemes of the trilogy, the competing claims of differentnomoi and opposing dikai. In addition, a discussion of the possible influences of the nomos sheds some light on the compostion of the Agamemnon's parodos. The broadrange of meanings given to nomos presentsa serious obstacle to such an inquiry.2In some senses it is not much different from harmonia or melos. It means first of all a set of notes or intervals performedin certain sequences in a particularmanner. Telestes (806, 810 PMG) appearsto use hymnos and nomos interchangeablyto mean harmonia. The Suda's definition of the kitharodicnomos adds the element of rhythm: 6 vo6os,* KLtap)t8LKO6 7po7rol 7g XWV Kai ET.lhXQ8as, 6p/LoviavE TaKT7r•V p&joiv6v Cjp•o'gvov, i.e., a musical idiom with a definite mode and rhythm.The nomos existed in many forms: some were purely instrumental(auletic, kitharistic);others in- cluded poetic texts (aulodic, kitharodic). In addition to these general categories, there existed specific types with traditionalnames, e.g. Pythios, Oxus, Harmateios, which were often associated with particularfestivals, 1J.A. Haldane, "Musical Themes and Imagery in Aeschylus," JHS 75 (1965) 33-41 is a conspicuous exception. For musical ideas in Aeschylus generally, see E. Moustopoulos' lengthy discussion, "Une philosophie de la musique chez Aeschyle," REG 72 (1959) 18-56. 2The best discussions of the kitharodicNomos are still those of Crusius, "Uber die Nomos- frage," 39 Versammlungdeutscher Philologen und Schulmainner,"Zurich 1887, Verhandlungen 258-76 and Wilamowitz, Timotheos: die Perser, Leipzig 1903, 83-105. See also F. Laserre, Plutarchede la musique, Olten & Lausanne 1954; 22-29, E. Martin,Essai sur les rhythmesde la chansongrecque, Paris 1953, 118 ff.; C. del Grande,"Nomos citarodico," Riv. Indo-greco-ital.7 (1923), 1-17 andEspressibne musicale dei poeti greci, Napoli 192, 24 ff; H. Grieser,Nomos: ein Beitragzur griechischen Musikgeschichte, Diss. Heidelberg1937, and for the basic meaningof the word, E. Laroche, Histoire de la racine nem- en grec ancien, Paris 1949, 166-71. 222 This content downloaded from 136.152.208.62 on Mon, 27 Jan 2014 12:33:08 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions THE MUSICALNOMOS IN AESCHYLUS'ORESTEIA 223 places, or peoples in the Greek world. The content, to a certain degree, was specified for some of the different nomoi-as in the auletic Pythios-and the performances, at least in the later period, were more mimetic than in other forms."In the Pythios, for example, the aulete reenactedApollo's conflict with the Python, and Timotheus' Persae gives ample scope for a performer's mimetic talents. Despite referencesto earliercomposers, Terpanderwas almost universally regarded as the artistic progenitor of the nomos. Most modem scholars, consideringthe antiquityand religious associationsof the form, have regarded the nomos as a literarydevelopment of a cultic "hymn."4 As a monodic song, dedicated to a god (Apollo especially), containing a narrativeof divine or heroicadventures,5 the nomos has been comparedwith the Homerichymn. One of the distinguishingcharacteristics of the nomos was its seven-partstructure: archa, metarcha, katatropa, metakatatropa,omphalos, sphragis, epilogos.6 This structurewas first convincingly explained by Crusius as a doubled intro- duction in the form of invocations, a doubled transitionalpassage, a central narrative,the poet's signature,the farewell XaipE or conclusion.7This struc- ture is apparent-if primitively-in the Homeric Hymn to the Delian Apollo. The precise relationship of the nomos to various "hymns" is perplexing. [Plutarch](de mus. 6) mentions the prooimia of Terpander.This is variously interpretedto mean "hymns" or preludes. Earlierthe same author(4) specifi- cally states that Terpanderalso composed prooimia in hexameters. Although the firstpart of a nomos was composed-even by Timotheus-in hexameters,it is clear that Terpander'skitharodic prooimia were a species of composition closely enough relatedto the nomos that[Plutarch] could use them as a prooffor the nomos' meter. It is not at all unlikely that Terpanderwrote some of his nomoi to serve the same purpose as Homeric Hymns, that is, as introductory pieces." The nomoi were conservative in their tradition. [Plutarch] (de mus. 7) informsus that until the time of Phrynis(mid Fifth Century)the kitharodesdid not alter the modes and rhythms, but they preserved the tasis or "tuning" native to each nomos. In the 200 years from Terpanderto Phrynisthere were undoubtedlysome changes in the artistic nomos. The rise of other lyric forms 3[Aristotle],Prob. 19. 15 (918b13), suggests that nomoi may have been astrophicbecause of their mimetic character. 4Crusius260-61, Del GrandeEspressione 24, Martin 118, Laserre26, who doubts, 27-28, that the nomos was exclusively monodic. SPlutarch,Inst. Lac. 17. For Apollo, cf. Pindar,Nem. 5.24, as inventorof the kithara,Pausanias 5.14.8. 6Pollux 4.66. For the parts of the auletic Pythios, cf. 4.86. 7Crusius261. 8Crusius,"Zur Nomosfrage," Woch.f. Klass. Phil. 45 (1887) 186. Van Groningen, "A propos de terpandre,"Mnem. 8 (1955) 177-91, bases his whole case for a primitive nomic structurein Terpanderon the ambiguous evidence of [Plutarch]'s statement, that nomoi proceeded directly from invocation to Homeric poetry. In the first place, [Plutarch]must have had limited access to the compositions of Terpander, if he is forced to argue from the practice of Timotheus that Terpanderemployed the hexameter(de mus. 4). Secondly, how would the nomos then differ from the HomericHymn? Thirdly, the transitionalpassages need not have been more than a sentence or two, thus easily overlooked in a general description of the Nomos. This content downloaded from 136.152.208.62 on Mon, 27 Jan 2014 12:33:08 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 224 THOMASJ. FLEMING must have diminishedthe importanceof many old-fashionedfestival nomoi, andby the FourthCentury the nomos was viewed as a kitharodicart.9 Although Attic writersof the Fifth Century,especially Aristophanes,do referto aulodic and auletic nomoi, as an artistictradition the nomos was even then primarily kitharodic,as, for example, Herodotus(1.24.5) and Sophocles (Ul. Fur. 463, Tham. 245 Jebb-Pearson)show. The Orthios Nomos is perhapsthe most commonly mentioned type in the Fifth Century.Both a kitharodicand an aulodic Orthiosare attested;Terpander is associatedwith the former, Olympus and Polymnestuswith the latter.10The aulos was the instrumentfor the expressionof grief," and aulodic nomoi were frequentlyused for lamentation.The Orthiosor "shrill" nomos because of its high register was especially suited to this purpose.12The kitharodicOrthios may also have been used for lament. Herodotus (1.24.5) had the kitharode Arion performthe Orthiosbefore jumping into the sea. Althoughthis perfor- mance has been seen as a kindof swan-song,'3it may equally well have been an appealto the patronof kitharodes,Apollo, for preservationas appearsto be the case at the wedding party of Hector and Andromache: 7rTavTE ' dav6pqE' rparov "iaXovdpi"ov OVKaXEOVTE9 7Ta'ov' KaJ8oXOV .EVoXvpav.(Sappho 44.32-33 LP) Aristophaneswas sure enough of his audience's familiaritywith this kind of nomos thathe twice (Av489, Ec 741) makes the and in the pun 6p1pios Uvop•Oq, second passage the singer of the aubade is describedas a kitharode.The same poet goes so faras to define stupidityas not knowing white from the Orthios(Eq 1279). Finally the Suda, whose authorities know many different kinds of nomoi, explicitly defines the Orthios as kitharodic. It is unsafe to attempt any detailed characterizationof the nomic style. Crusiusbased his observationson the style of those poems of later poets like Callimachuswhich seemed to imitatethe structureof the nomos.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • FALL 2008 Columbia University in the City of New York Co
    FALL 2008 Columbia University in the City of New York CO 435 West 116th Street, Box A-2 L UM New York, NY 10027 BI A L RETURN SERVICE REQUESTED A W S C HO O L M ag azine www.law.columbia.edu/alumni fall 2008 BREAKING THE CODE NEW FACULTY MEMBER MICHAEL GRAETZ HAS AN INNOVATIVE PLAN FOR REVAMPING AMERICA’s TAX CODE TALKINGTALKING TETELECLECOM: TIM WU CHATS WITH JEFFREY TOOBIN SCOTUS ANALYSIS FROM BLASI, BRIFFAULT, GREENAWALT, HAMBURGER, AND PERSILY Opportunity The Future of Diversity and Opportunity in Higher dean Columbia Law School Magazine David M. Schizer is published three times annually for alumni and friends of associate dean Education: A National Columbia Law School by the for development and Office of Development and alumni relations Alumni Relations. Forum on Innovation and Bruno M. Santonocito Opinions expressed in Columbia Law Collaboration executive director School Magazine do not necessarily of communications reflect the views of Columbia Law and public affairs School or Columbia University. Elizabeth Schmalz This magazine is printed December 3-5, 2008 guest editor on FSC certified paper. Matthew J.X. Malady editorial director James Vescovi assistant editor Mary Johnson Change of address information should be sent to: copy editors Lauren Pavlakovich, Columbia Law School Joy Y. Wang 435 West 116 Street, Box A-2 New York, NY 10027 During the first week in December, design and art direction Attn: Office of Alumni Relations Empire Design Studio Alumni Office university presidents, provosts, and photography 212-854-2680 Peter Freed, Robyn Twomey, Magazine Notices Eric van den Brulle, Jon Roemer 212-854-2650 academic innovators will gather for David Yellen [email protected] an historic conference focused on new printing Copyright 2008, Columbia Maar Printing Service, Inc.
    [Show full text]
  • DEMOCRITUS Democritus
    CHAPTER FOUR DEMOCRITUS Democritus (c. 460-396 B.C.) was a younger contemporary ofProtagoras; both were born in Abdera. 1 Although he had encyclopedic interests and was the author of many works, the 298 fragments ascribed to him in Diels-Kranz are at most all that has survived of his writings? Almost all of these fragments concern ethical matters. But despite this, Democritus has generally not been known for his moral theory. He has always, and rightly, been considered an important figure in the history of natural philosophy for his theory of atomism. Commentators on the ethical fragments have often found them to be of little or no philosophical importance3 and have sometimes questioned their authenticity. The issue of whether these fragments are authentic is not important in the context of the present study, which is only interested in these fragments insofar as they re­ present the views of an early Greek moral theorist concerned with the issue of the compatibility of self-interest and morality. Thus, it would make little difference here whether the fragments be attributed to Democritus or one of his contemporar­ ies, although my own view is that they probably should be assigned to Democri­ tus.4 On the other hand, it is a crucial question in the present context whether the fragments have philosophical importance. It is true, of course, that the ethical fragments are written in a style closer to the philosophically unrigorous fragments of Antiphon's On Concord than to those from On Truth. But it cannot be concluded from this fact that they are trivial.
    [Show full text]
  • The Emperor's New Clothes, Or, on Flattery and Ecomium in the Silvae
    University of Pennsylvania ScholarlyCommons Departmental Papers (Classical Studies) Classical Studies at Penn 2013 The Emperor's New Clothes, or, on Flattery and Ecomium in the Silvae Cynthia Damon University of Pennsylvania, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://repository.upenn.edu/classics_papers Part of the Classics Commons, and the Near Eastern Languages and Societies Commons Recommended Citation (OVERRIDE) Damon, C. (2013). The emperor's new clothes, or, on flattery and ecomium in the silvae. In J. F. Miller, C. Damon, & K. S. Myers Vertis in usum (pp. 174-188). München : Leipzig : Saur. DOI: 10.1515/ 9783110956924.174 This paper is posted at ScholarlyCommons. https://repository.upenn.edu/classics_papers/44 For more information, please contact [email protected]. The Emperor's New Clothes, or, on Flattery and Ecomium in the Silvae Disciplines Arts and Humanities | Classics | Near Eastern Languages and Societies This book chapter is available at ScholarlyCommons: https://repository.upenn.edu/classics_papers/44 THE EMPEROR'S NEW CLOTHES, OR, ON FLATTERY AND ENCOMIUM IN THE SILVAE• BY CYNTHIA DAMON In the first letter of his ninth book Pliny urges his friend Maximus to hurry on the publication of a work in which Maximus attacks a certain Pompei us Planta. Planta has just died, but Pliny maintains that if Maxi­ mus (who has been working on this piece for some time) gets it published promptly, it will have the same effect as if it had been pub­ lished while its victim was still alive: in defunctum quoque tamquam in uiuentem adhuc editur, si editur statim (Ep.
    [Show full text]
  • Dictynna, 16 | 2019 ‘Most Musicall, Most Melancholy’: Avian Aesthetics of Lament in Greek and Rom
    Dictynna Revue de poétique latine 16 | 2019 Varia ‘Most musicall, most melancholy’: Avian aesthetics of lament in Greek and Roman elegy Thomas J. Nelson Electronic version URL: http://journals.openedition.org/dictynna/1914 ISSN: 1765-3142 Publisher Université Lille-3 Electronic reference Thomas J. Nelson, « ‘Most musicall, most melancholy’: Avian aesthetics of lament in Greek and Roman elegy », Dictynna [Online], 16 | 2019, Online since 29 November 2019, connection on 20 December 2019. URL : http://journals.openedition.org/dictynna/1914 This text was automatically generated on 20 December 2019. Les contenus des la revue Dictynna sont mis à disposition selon les termes de la Licence Creative Commons Attribution - Pas d'Utilisation Commerciale - Pas de Modification 4.0 International. ‘Most musicall, most melancholy’: Avian aesthetics of lament in Greek and Rom... 1 ‘Most musicall, most melancholy’: Avian aesthetics of lament in Greek and Roman elegy1 Thomas J. Nelson 1 In Il Penseroso (‘The Reflective Man’), the English poet John Milton (1608–1674) conjures a vision of poetic melancholy and contemplation. After invoking the Goddess Melancholy and picturing her attendant train (‘Peace’, ‘Quiet’ and the like), he dwells on a night-time scene of melancholic music (vv. 55–64): And the mute Silence hist along, ’Less Philomel will deign a Song, In her sweetest, saddest plight, Smoothing the rugged brow of night, While Cynthia checks her Dragon yoke, Gently o’re th’ accustom’d Oke; Sweet Bird that shunn’st the noise of folly, Most musicall, most melancholy! Thee Chauntress oft the Woods among, I woo to hear thy Eeven-Song; 2 In Milton’s thought world, reflective silence is banished by the intrusive song of the nightingale (‘Philomel’), whose melody comes alive through the incessant sibilance and alliteration of these verses.
    [Show full text]
  • Remembering Music in Early Greece
    REMEMBERING MUSIC IN EARLY GREECE JOHN C. FRANKLIN This paper contemplates various ways that the ancient Greeks preserved information about their musical past. Emphasis is given to the earlier periods and the transition from oral/aural tradition, when self-reflective professional poetry was the primary means of remembering music, to literacy, when festival inscriptions and written poetry could first capture information in at least roughly datable contexts. But the continuing interplay of the oral/aural and written modes during the Archaic and Classical periods also had an impact on the historical record, which from ca. 400 onwards is represented by historiographical fragments. The sources, methods, and motives of these early treatises are also examined, with special attention to Hellanicus of Lesbos and Glaucus of Rhegion. The essay concludes with a few brief comments on Peripatetic historiography and a selective catalogue of music-historiographical titles from the fifth and fourth centuries. INTRODUCTION Greek authors often refer to earlier music.1 Sometimes these details are of first importance for the modern historiography of ancient 1 Editions and translations of classical authors may be found by consulting the article for each in The Oxford Classical Dictionary3. Journal 1 2 JOHN C. FRANKLIN Greek music. Uniquely valuable, for instance, is Herodotus’ allusion to an Argive musical efflorescence in the late sixth century,2 nowhere else explicitly attested (3.131–2). In other cases we learn less about real musical history than an author’s own biases and predilections. Thus Plato describes Egypt as a never-never- land where no innovation was ever permitted in music; it is hard to know whether Plato fabricated this statement out of nothing to support his conservative and ideal society, or is drawing, towards the same end, upon a more widely held impression—obviously superficial—of a foreign, distant culture (Laws 656e–657f).
    [Show full text]
  • Baudelaire's Swan Song
    Baudelaire's Swan Song A lecture by Jonathan Tuck Delivered at St. John's College, Annapolis-October 13, 2006 This lecture is dedicated to the memory of Brother Robert Smith. The late Reverend J. Winfree Smith, a long-time Annapolis tutor, a historian of the New Program, an Anglican priest, a scholar and a Virginia gentleman of the old school, used to assert that Charles Baudelaire was a greater poet than Homer. Winfree's view counts for quite a lot with me, but I would not go that far. I am willing to say that Baudelaire is the greatest poet of the last two hundred years or so, the first and most essential of"modern" writers and the one who best articulates our own feelings of what it is to be modern. And I think that Le Cygne is Baudelaire's greatest poem, although perhaps not his most typical one. This valuation sets the bar quite high enough for me, for this evening at least. Thus, for about the last twenty years, I have held the writing of this lecture before me as a daunting but imperative task. I have a further reason for trepidation: I believe that it's indispensable, before discussing any poem, first to read it aloud. But I am keenly aware that, unlike some of you, I am very far from a native or even a fluent speaker of French,. My hope is that in enunciating the poem aloud, I can bring out some of its metrical features through a kind of exaggeration; that may compensate you for having to hear my accented reading.
    [Show full text]
  • Chthonic Restitutions: Madness and Oblivion
    Chthonic Restitutions: Madness and Oblivion Javier Berzal de Dios Abstract This essay theorizes madness as a chthonic emplacement to dishevel existentially insufcient and detached interpretations of disorder. Refecting on Nietzsche’s emphasis on poetry over systematic thought, I take up Lorca and Baudelaire’s visceral language on death and the earthly to revisit chthonic myths as expressing an underworld uncontrollable sphere beyond systematicity. Written from the phenomenologically precarious position of my own mental illness, this essay develops a sincere rhetoric to approach the chthonic from within rather than at sterilized distance. This positioning retains the indexicality of the intense and disorganized as a critical facet, in turn exploring the nuances of the experience without discursive reductions or romantic musings, from the ground down. Cassandra: ototototoi popoi da. – Aeschylus, Agamemnon 1072 Following the social turn of the 1960s, administrators and teachers of academic discourse began to replace “reason” and “rationality” with “critically,” or “critical thinking,” as their highest aim; however, the presumption of a rational subject remained stable. – Margaret Price, Mad at School 39 Am I mad now? In truth, the question of madness calls forth to a future memory: will I have been mad? Or really: how mad will I think I had been? Lucidity is anachronistic, an ex post facto verdict, casting out to madness what thought itself on mark… Madness itself voices the lan- guage of truth—this madness of mine—an eternally rational utterance, charts and graphs at hand. I picture philosophers terribly sane, so much they take for granted, so restrained and hygienic their connections… so reliable a language.
    [Show full text]
  • Platonic Love in a Colorado Courtroom: Martha Nussbaum, John Finnis, and Plato's Laws in Evans V
    Articles Platonic Love in a Colorado Courtroom: Martha Nussbaum, John Finnis, and Plato's Laws in Evans v. Romer Randall Baldwin Clark* I. RELEVANT FOR FIFTEEN MINUTES-OR THIRTY CENTURIES? To the ridicule of the highbrow popular press' and the surprise of classical scholars,2 Plato's Laws,3 a work which was mocked, even in * University of Virginia School of Law, Class of 2002. Ph.D., University of Chicago, 1998. Research Associate, Dartmouth College Department of Government, 1997-99. Author, THE LAW MOST BEAUTIFUL AND BEST: MEDICAL ARGUMENT AND MAGICAL RHETORIC IN PLATO'S LAWS (Rowman & Littlefield - Lexington Books, forthcoming 2001). This article has benefited from the comments of many friends, colleagues, and teachers. For their assistance, I would like to thank Danielle Allen, Larry Arnhart, Richard 0. Brooks, Robert A. Burt, Allison D. Clark, Andrew P. Clark, Elizabeth A. Clark, Glenn W. Clark, Matthew Crawford, Richard Dougherty, Martha A. Field, Shawntel R. Fugate, Martin P. Golding, L. Kent Greenawalt, A.E. Dick Howard, Leon R. Kass, Matthew Kutcher, Melissa S. Lane, Mark J. Lutz, Roger D. Masters, Lynn Mather, Angelia K. Means, Ted H. Miller, S. Sarah Monoson, David Peritz, Richard A. Posner, Christopher Rohrbacher, Ariel C. Silver, Nathan Tarcov, Bradley A. Thayer, Elizabeth E. Theran, Paul Ulrich, Eduardo A. Velasquez, Lloyd L. Weinreb, Martin D. Yaffe, and the members of my edit team at the Yale Journal of Law & the Humanities. I only regret that I was unable to address all of their criticisms. Particularly profound appreciation is owed to my friend and colleague, James B. Murphy, whose queries helped me conceive this work and whose encouragement brought it to light: aneu gar phil6n oudeis heloit' an zen.
    [Show full text]
  • Some Imitations of Pindar and Sappho by Horace
    Some imitations of Pindar and Sappho by Horace The Harvard community has made this article openly available. Please share how this access benefits you. Your story matters Citation Nagy, Gregory. 2015.12.31. "Some imitations of Pindar and Sappho by Horace." Classical Inquiries. http://nrs.harvard.edu/ urn-3:hul.eresource:Classical_Inquiries. Published Version https://classical-inquiries.chs.harvard.edu/some-imitations-of- pindar-and-sappho-by-horace/ Citable link http://nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:39699959 Terms of Use This article was downloaded from Harvard University’s DASH repository, and is made available under the terms and conditions applicable to Other Posted Material, as set forth at http:// nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:dash.current.terms-of- use#LAA Classical Inquiries Editors: Angelia Hanhardt and Keith Stone Consultant for Images: Jill Curry Robbins Online Consultant: Noel Spencer About Classical Inquiries (CI ) is an online, rapid-publication project of Harvard’s Center for Hellenic Studies, devoted to sharing some of the latest thinking on the ancient world with researchers and the general public. While articles archived in DASH represent the original Classical Inquiries posts, CI is intended to be an evolving project, providing a platform for public dialogue between authors and readers. Please visit http://nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:hul.eresource:Classical_Inquiries for the latest version of this article, which may include corrections, updates, or comments and author responses. Additionally, many of the studies published in CI will be incorporated into future CHS pub- lications. Please visit http://nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:hul.eresource:CHS.Online_Publishing for a complete and continually expanding list of open access publications by CHS.
    [Show full text]
  • Thucydides and the World of Nature
    CHAPTER 2 Natural Upheavals in Thucydides (and Herodotus) Rosaria Vignolo Munson To my favorite historian and a master of nonverbal communication, I dedi­ cate this inquiry: is the physical world a sender of signs? I am sure that Don­ ald Lateiner has his own answers, just as Herodotus and Thucydides had theirs. These authors were free from our environmental guilt and less bom­ barded than we are by the spectacle of humanitarian tragedies in every cor­ ner of the earth. Both of them, however, mention natural cataclysms in con­ nection with human actions and sociopolitical turmoil, most especially war. It is the thesis of this essay that, despite major differences, shared cultural assumptions emerge from the relations Herodotus and Thucydides establish between the natural and the human spheres. 1. World of Men and World of Nature In his introductory sentence, Thucydides calls the Peloponnesian War and its preliminary a Kivriau;... peyiaTr) for the Greek and partly for the non-Greek world (1.1.2). For most scholars (e.g., Hornblower 1991: 6), this is a reference to the "convulsion" caused by the war, and although Jeff Rusten makes a powerful argument (in this volume) that Kivr|au; here means "mobilization,"^ I. Elsewhere in Thucydides, kine- words refer, in fact, to unproblematic material transports. In one case, kined, while retaining its literal sense, is used somewhat abnormally (or, as Rusten shows, poetically) to denote a geological movement (2.8.3; s®® below, sec. 3). 41 42 KINESIS it would be a mistake to strip the term of all metaphorical undertones. In Aristotle's (in itself metaphorical) definition, metaphora consists in "the carry­ ing over [epiphora] of the name [onoma] of something to something else" (Poet­ ics 2i.i457b6-7).
    [Show full text]
  • The Ears of Hermes
    The Ears of Hermes The Ears of Hermes Communication, Images, and Identity in the Classical World Maurizio Bettini Translated by William Michael Short THE OHIO STATE UNIVERSITY PRess • COLUMBUS Copyright © 2000 Giulio Einaudi editore S.p.A. All rights reserved. English translation published 2011 by The Ohio State University Press. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Bettini, Maurizio. [Le orecchie di Hermes. English.] The ears of Hermes : communication, images, and identity in the classical world / Maurizio Bettini ; translated by William Michael Short. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN-13: 978-0-8142-1170-0 (cloth : alk. paper) ISBN-10: 0-8142-1170-4 (cloth : alk. paper) ISBN-13: 978-0-8142-9271-6 (cd-rom) 1. Classical literature—History and criticism. 2. Literature and anthropology—Greece. 3. Literature and anthropology—Rome. 4. Hermes (Greek deity) in literature. I. Short, William Michael, 1977– II. Title. PA3009.B4813 2011 937—dc23 2011015908 This book is available in the following editions: Cloth (ISBN 978-0-8142-1170-0) CD-ROM (ISBN 978-0-8142-9271-6) Cover design by AuthorSupport.com Text design by Juliet Williams Type set in Adobe Garamond Pro Printed by Thomson-Shore, Inc. The paper used in this publication meets the minimum requirements of the American Na- tional Standard for Information Sciences—Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials. ANSI Z39.48–1992. 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 CONTENTS Translator’s Preface vii Author’s Preface and Acknowledgments xi Part 1. Mythology Chapter 1 Hermes’ Ears: Places and Symbols of Communication in Ancient Culture 3 Chapter 2 Brutus the Fool 40 Part 2.
    [Show full text]
  • Downloading of Software That Would Enable the Display of Different Characters
    MIAMI UNIVERSITY The Graduate School CERTIFICATE FOR APPROVING THE DISSERTATION We hereby approve the Dissertation Of Jay T. Dolmage Candidate for the Degree: Doctor of Philosophy Director Dr. Cindy Lewiecki-Wilson Reader Dr. Kate Ronald Reader Dr. Morris Young Reader Dr. James Cherney Graduate School Representative ABSTRACT METIS: DISABILITY, RHETORIC AND AVAILABLE MEANS by Jay Dolmage In this dissertation I argue for a critical re-investigation of several connected rhetorical traditions, and then for the re-articulation of theories of composition pedagogy in order to more fully recognize the importance of embodied differences. Metis is the rhetorical art of cunning, the use of embodied strategies—what Certeau calls everyday arts—to transform rhetorical situations. In a world of chance and change, metis is what allows us to craft available means for persuasion. Building on the work of Detienne and Vernant, and Certeau, I argue that metis is a way to recognize that all rhetoric is embodied. I show that embodiment is a feeling for difference, and always references norms of gender, race, sexuality, class, citizenship. Developing the concept of metis I show how embodiment forms and transforms in reference to norms of ability, the constraints and enablements of our bodied knowing. I exercise my own metis as I re-tell the mythical stories of Hephaestus and Metis, and re- examine the dialogues of Plato, Aristotle, Cicero and Quintillian. I weave through the images of embodiment trafficked in phenomenological philosophy, and I apply my own models to the teaching of writing as an embodied practice, forging new tools for learning. I strategically interrogate the ways that academic spaces circumscribe roles for bodies/minds, and critique the discipline of composition’s investment in the erection of boundaries.
    [Show full text]