I. -Fewo-E. C: John Covino, SDAG Roge/Tf S
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
RECEIVED PUBLIC SERVCF. COMMISSION v OSEC-FILES-ALBANY 2001 JUL 20 AM 11:148 ^tate of $tfa Jleraeg DEPARTMENT OF LAW AND PUBLIC SAFETY DIVISION OF LAW RICHARD J. HUGHES JUSTICE COMPLEX 25 MARKET STREET DONALD T. DIFRANCESCO PO BOX 093 JOHN J. FARMER, JR. Acting Governor TRENTON, NJ 08625-0093 Attorney General E-Mail: [email protected] (609)984-6811 JEFFREY J. MILLER Assistant Attorney General July 18, 2001 Dirpetor VIA OVERNIGHT MAIL Office of the Secretary Janet H. Deixler, Secretary to the Commission 3 Empire State Plaza Albany, New York 12223-1350 Re: IMO the Application of Ramapo Energy Limited Partnership for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need Pursuant to Article X of the Public Service Law Case No. 98-F-1968 Dear Ms. Deixler: Enclosed for filing please find an original and five copies of the Prefiled Direct Testimony and Exhibits of the following witnesses for the New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection; (1) Anthony S. Navoy, (2) Joseph Miri, (3) Robert Canace, (4) Asghar Hasan, (5) Paul Schorr, (6) Steven Lubow and (7) Shing- Fu Hsueh. A copy of the Testimony and Exhibits have been provided to all parties on the enclosed Exhibit Exchange Service List. Sincerely yours, JOHN J. FARMER, JR. ATTORNEY GENERAL OF NEW JERSEY /re By: i. -feWo-e. c: John Covino, SDAG Roge/tf S. Haase Enc. Deputy Attorney General yaps New Jersey Is Art Equal Opportunity Employer ' Printed on Recycled Paper and Recyclable EXHIBIT LIST - Case 98-F-1968 • Application of Ramapo Energy Limited Partnership ANTHONY NAVOY NJDEP-1 Ramapo River Basin Showing Municipal Boundaries and Gaging Stations, New York-New Jersey; NJDEP-2 Hydrograph of Ramapo River at Sloatsburg, NY; NJDEP-3 Hydrograph of Ramapo River at Ramapo, NY; NJDEP-4 Hydrograph of Ramapo River at Suffern, NY; NJDEP-5 Hydrograph of Ramapo River near Mahwah, NJ; NJDEP-6 Hydrograph of Ramapo River downstream of Pond Bk at Oakland, NJ; NJDEP-7 Hydrograph of Ramapo River at Pompton Lakes, NJ; NJDEP-8 Hydrograph of Mahwah River near Suffern, NY; NJDEP-9 Hydrograph of Mahwah River at Suffern, NY; NJDEP-10 Low Flow Statistics for Key Gaging Stations; NJDEP-11 Analyses of Trends in Low Flow Records for Key Gaging Station; NJDEP-12 Hydrograph of Lowest 7 Consecutive Day Streamflow for Each Climatic Year, Ramapo River at Mahwah, NJ; NJDEP-13 Analyses of Trends in Low Flow Records for Ringwood • Creek -- an Indication of Background Conditions; NJDEP-14 Hydrograph of Lowest 7 Consecutive Day Streamflow for Each Climatic Year, Ringwood Creek near Wanaque, NJ; NJDEP-15 Average Ground Water Withdrawals by Well (1999); NJDEP-16 Seepage Run Sites and Withdrawals on October 20, 1998; NJDEP-17 Water Levels in the Ramapo River and Valley-Fill Aquifer, South Mahwah, New Jersey; NJDEP-18 Reconstruction of Streamflow Records in the Passaic and Hackensack River Basins, New Jersey and New York, Water Years 1993-96; NJDEP-19 Hydrographs of Upstream Wastewater Input and Streamflow (1999) NJDEP-20 Hydrographs of Upstream Wastewater Input and Streamflow (1999) NJDEP-21 Hydrographs of Upstream Point Source Inputs and Streamflow (1999 NJDEP-22 Components of Reconstructed Streamflow and Difference Between Observed and Reconstructed Streamflow at Ramapo River at Pompton Lakes, New Jersey; NJDEP-23 Curriculum Vitae of Anthony S. Navoy. • JOE MIRI NJDEP-24 Passaic River Basin Map; NJDEP-25 Portions from Ramapo Energy's Application to the New York Board on Electrical Generating Siting and the Environment, Addendum No. 2, Revised April 2001; NJDEP-26 Year 2000 UWNY Water Supply Master Plan; NJDEP-27 Year 2000 UWNY Consumptive Water Uses From Ramapo and Hackensack Watersheds in Southern New York; NJDEP-28 Year 2020 UWNY Consumptive Water Uses From Ramapo and Hackensack Watersheds in Southern New York; NJDEP-29 Curriculum Vitae of Joe Miri. • ROBERT CANACE • NJDEP-30 Revised Article X, Ramapo Energy Application, received with June 21, 2001 letter to Janet Deixler from Christopher Reiss, ESS; NJDEP-31 Appendix H-2, UWNY Response to NY State Dept. of Public Service Water Supply Stipulations; NJDEP-32 Schematic representation of a water budget within a river basin; NJDEP-33 References used in Canace testimony; NJDEP-34 E-mail Printouts from Frederick Spitz, United States Geological Survey, Water Resources Division, to Canace, NJGS; NJDEP-35 Page 4-4 of United Water New York Master Plan; NJDEP-36 Page 4-5 of United Water New York Master Plan; NJDEP-37 Stipulation between State of NJ and Spring Valley Water Co. establishing 8 mgd passing flow at Suffern, NY; NJDEP-38 Location of measurement stations near Ramapo Valley well field for USGS 1998 stream-flow study of Ramapo River in New York State; NJDEP-39 Daily average stream flow at USGS stream gage at Suffern, New York, 1990-1999; • NJDEP-40 Stream flow at USGS gage at Suffern, New York, 1999, in relation to 8 mgd passing flow; NJDEP-41 Stream flow in Ramapo River at Suffern, New York, 1998, in relation to 8 mgd passing flow requirement; NJDEP-42 Letter dated June 9, 1999 from Carla Hjelm, UWNY to Joseph Marcogliese, NYDEC, regarding Water Supply Application No. 6507; NJDEP-43 Orders of December 8, 1990 by NYDEC for Temporary Modification of Water Supply Applications 6507 and 2189; NJDEP-44 Letter dated August 19, 1985 from Ralph Manna, Jr., NYDEC, to Carl H, Grossman, Spring Valley Water Company regarding Modifying Decision; NJDEP-45 Letter dated September 11, 1995 from Harry Russo, UWNY, to Commissioner Michael D. Zagata, NYDEC, regarding Application for Reinstatement of Temporary Modifications; NJDEP-46 Discovery Response of Donald Distante to NJDEP-8, dated May 9, 2001; NJDEP-47 Water release agreement between Spring Valley Water Company and Ramapo Land Company, Inc., dated November 2, 1990; ROBERT CANACE con'd. NJDEP-48 Report on Operational Guidelines for Use of the Pothat Lakes for Ramapo River Flow Augmentation, Spring Valley Water Co., November 1993; NJDEP-49 Ramapo Energy discovery response to CR-28, dated May 11, 2001; NJDEP-50 Section 4.2 of United Water New York Master Plan; NJDEP-51 Rockland County Regulations, Article V, Mandatory Water Conservation Measures; NJDEP-52 Response by Donald Distante, United Water New York to Rockland County Information Request, dated March 9, 2001; NJDEP-53 United Water New York Master Plan, Section 4.1, Surface Water; NJDEP-54 Flow in Ramapo River at USGS stream gage near Mahwah for 7 lowest consecutive days each year over period of record; NJDEP-55 Well fields drawing from glacial valley-fill aquifer along Ramapo River in NJ; NJDEP-56 1999 Pumpage for Public Supply Wells Drawing from Valley Fill Aquifer in NJ in Close Proximity to the Ramapo River; NJDEP-57 Figure 14 from Hill 1992 Report, Ford Well Field Seepage Run; NJDEP-58 Figure 15 from Hill 1992 Report, Oakland Borough Well Field Seepage Run; NJDEP-59 Stream flow at USGS gage near Mahwah, NJ, 1999; NJDEP-60 Stream flow at USGS stream gage at Oakland, NJ, 1999; NJDEP-61 Ramsey Borough Water Allocation Permit No. 5076, issued by NJDEP April 24, 1995; NJDEP-62 Curriculum Vitae of Robert Canace; NJDEP-104 Appendix H-2, Revised Application, UWNY Response to NY State Dept. of Public Service Water Supply Stipulations; NJDEP-105 Revised Direct Testimony of Guy Marchmont (Revised July 30, 2001); NJDEP-106 Revised Direct Testimony of Jeffrey Hershberger (Revised July 31, 2001); NJDEP-107 Revised Direct Testimony of Donald Distante (Revised August 1, 2001); NJDEP-108 Revised Direct Testimony of Janet Bernardo (Revised July 31, 2001); NJDEP-109 Discovery Response by Ramapo Energy to NJDEP-6, dated August 20, 2001, page 5; NJDEP-110 Discovery Response by UWNY to NJDEP-7; • NJDEP-111 NYDEC Decision on Water Supply Application No. 6507, page 25; NJDEP-133 Ramapo Energy Limited Partnership's responses to discovery requests PRC-1 through PRC-14, dated September 4, 2001; NJDEP-134 Ramapo Energy Limited Partnership's responses to discovery requests PIPC/Ramapo-62 through -67, dated September 28, 2001. • ASGHAR HASAN NJDEP-63 Map of Passaic Basin Water Supply Infrastructure; NJDEP-64 Ramapo Basin Study - Monthly Average Flows in Ramapo River and Ground and Surface Diversions and Point Source Discharges in Ramapo River Basin; NJDEP-65 Monthly Average Groundwater Diversion Charts Done By UWNY (13 Charts); NJDEP-66 Passaic River Basin - Daily Natural Flow Data Development (1919 - 1979), prepared by Montgomery Watson; NJDEP-67 Flow Pumpage Charts; NJDEP-68 Accumulative Loss in Ramapo Pumping; NJDEP-69 Table of Comparison of Pumpages from Ramapo; NJDEP-70 Table of Daily Flow Data at Ramapo Basin from May 1, 1995 to October 31, 1995; NJDEP-71 Table of Comparison of Pumpages from Ramapo, Consumptive Use With and Without NY Impact; NJDEP-72 Daily Model Simulation of Loss of Pumping from Ramapo to Wanague Reservoir Due to NY Consumptive Use Impact; NJDEP-73 Chart of Daily Model Simulation of Pumping From Ramapo River to Wanaque Reservoir; NJDEP-74 Curriculum Vitae of Asghar Hasan. • PAUL SCHORR • NJDEP-75 Letter to Asghar Hasan, NJDEP, from G. Gordon Behn, NYDEC, dated April 22, 1997, regarding UWNJ Modification to Water Allocation Permit No. 5111 and UWNY Operation of DeForest Lake Reservoir under Water Supply Application No. 2189 - 6th Modification; NJDEP-76 Passaic River Basin Daily Natural Flow Data Development (1919-1979), prepared by Montgomery Watson; NJDEP-77 Water Resources of the New Jersey Part of the Ramapo River Basin, Geological Survey Water Supply Paper, 1974, pages 58 through 61 and 68 through 72; NJDEP-78 Franchise Areas of 3 New Jersey Water Supply Purveyors; NJDEP-79 Modifying Decision, Water Supply Application No. 6507, I/M/O Application of Spring Valley Water Company, Inc.; NJDEP-80 Sixth Modifying Decision, Water Supply Application No.