RENMARK TROUGH AREA (INCLUDING THE NADDA AND BERRI BASINS) Links Tenements (PDF; contains a link to the DSD website for the latest information)
Summary Age Early Permian – Early Cretaceous. Area in South Australia 9500 km2 (3670 sq. miles). Depth to target zones 500 m (Cretaceous), 850 m (Permian). Thickness 1250 m. Hydrocarbon shows Minor methane show and fluorescence in Permian. First commercial discovery None. Identified reserves Nil. Undiscovered resources (50% prob.) not determined. Production Nil. Basin type Intracratonic. Depositional setting Paraglacial (Permian); non-marine and marine (Cretaceous). Reservoirs Non-marine and marginal marine sandstones. Regional structure Faulted anticlinal complexes. Seals Non-marine shale. Source rocks Marine and non-marine shales, coal. Depth to oil/gas window Unknown. Number of wells 15. Seismic line km 1878 2D.
Structural setting The Early Permian Nadda Basin and Early Cretaceous Berri Basin both underlie the Tertiary Murray Basin. They collectively span 9440 km2 of eastern South Australia and are located east of the Adelaide Geosyncline (Fig. 1).
The sediments are preserved in structurally controlled depressions, namely the Renmark Trough, Canegrass Lobe and the Paringa Embayment (Figs 1, 2) and are confined entirely to the subsurface. They unconformably overlie either Late Devonian sediments of the Darling Basin or Cambrian Kanmantoo Group, although recent DSD drilling has indicated significantly older ?Adelaidean basement.
Exploration history Petroleum exploration commenced in the 1950s in the area to the south of the Nadda and Berri basins. It was not until 1961 that the Department of Mines commissioned an aeromagnetic survey over the western Murray Basin which revealed a deeper basin outline in the Renmark area.
1 Renmark Trough Area
Follow-up seismic refraction surveys by the department and the BMR in 1961 and 1962 led to the drilling of Loxton 1 by the Australian Oil and Gas Corporation. Over the ensuing 10 years numerous oil and petroleum licences were taken out and an additional seven wells in the Renmark Trough area were drilled without commercial success. Three seismic refraction surveys by the department in 1965 and additional surveys in 1967 and 1969 by Associated Australian Oilfields (OEL 39) were completed during this period and surrendered in 1968 without further acquisition of seismic data or drilling of wells.
No further exploration activity was conducted until 1980 when International Mining was granted PEL 16 covering an area of 15 042 km2. In 1984 Overland Corner 1 was plugged and abandoned at 640 m. During the period 1986–87, 154 km of seismic were shot culminating in the drilling of Cooltong 1 in 1988 on an anticlinal structure in the deeper portion of the Renmark Trough.
The well reached a total depth of 1380 m in Late Devonian redbeds after intersecting sediments of the Murray, Berri and Nadda basins. In 1986 International Mining was granted PEL 37 over a relinquished portion of PEL 16. However, no more work was conducted in either PEL 16 or 37 and the permits were surrendered in 1990 and 1991 respectively. PEL 64 was granted to Corporate Developments in October 1995 over the Renmark Trough and surrendered in 1998 without further acquisition of seismic data or drilling of wells.
There are two PELs current in the region and one PELA pending. PEL 558, located over the Renmark Trough was granted to Liberty Resources Ltd in 2010 and the company also has PELA 531, also located in the Renmark Trough. PEL 174 was granted to Energy Exploration Ltd in 2010 and is located in the Murray Basin.
Stratigraphy Variable thicknesses of the Early Permian Urana Formation of the Nadda Basin occur in the Renmark Trough, Canegrass Lobe and Paringa Embayment, unconformably overlying either Late Devonian sediments of the Darling Basin, or Cambrian Kanmantoo Group. It is likely that bedrock also comprises Adelaidean strata.
The Urana Formation is at least 395 m (Nadda 1) although it is thought to be considerably thicker in the Renmark Trough. The formation comprises shale, siltstone, sandstone and diamictite with occasional conglomeratic and carbonaceous intervals. It extends into New South Wales and Victoria and appears to represent a proglacial to post-or non-glacial sedimentary sequence.
The Early Cretaceous Monash Formation, divided into the Pyap, Merreti and Coombool members, unconformably overlies the Urana Formation or Neoproterozoic to early Palaeozoic basement and is overlain by the late Palaeocene to Early Oligocene Renmark Group of the Murray Basin (Fig. 3).
The Aptian Pyap Member is a transgressive unit passing up from non-marine fluvial sandstone and minor coal to nearshore marine deposits at the top of the unit. It is overlain by the claystone and siltstone dominated Merreti Member which was deposited during a period of peak marine transgression into the Berri Basin via the Eromanga Basin. Uplift or cessation of subsidence in early Albian time led to a return to non- marine conditions during which the Coombool Member was deposited. It comprises claystone and siltstone with minor interbeds of highly lithic sandstone thought to have been derived from a volcanic source.
Source rocks The hydrocarbon source potential of the Late Devonian sediments is poorly understood; in Cooltong 1 the organic matter was oxidised. Up to 1500 m of Devonian sediments within the Renmark Trough are largely unknown and untested. Samples from three New South Wales bores returned very low TOC determinations
Petroleum and Geothermal in South Australia 2 Renmark Trough Area
(<0.10%) and it would appear that the terrestrial ‘redbed’ deposits of the Late Devonian lack suitable source rock quality and richness.
Maturity data from Cooltong 1 indicates that the Devonian succession is overmature for oil and in the wet gas to dry gas window (VR = 1.54–1.97).
Minor carbonaceous and coaly intersections of the Early Permian Urana Formation give moderate TOC values up to 0.8% although their extent and hydrocarbon source potential remains unknown. Recent apatite fission track analysis and VR sampling in Nadda 1 provide a new understanding of the thermal history of the Renmark Trough. Based on the reconstructed thermal history, the Early Permian units in Nadda 1 reached maximum maturity (early mature) during the Jurassic, while the overlying Early Cretaceous and Tertiary units are currently immature.
The most favourable source rocks would appear to be the marine Merreti Member although a lack of maturity is the constricting factor for hydrocarbon generation. Early Cretaceous sediments in Cooltong 1 are early mature for oil (VR range 0.32–0.70) with remaining wells either not sampled or immature over the Cretaceous section.
Reservoirs and seals Late Devonian reddish brown sandstone has excellent reservoir characteristics. Tarrara 1 (New South Wales) has measured porosities up to 21% and permeabilities up to 487 mD. Porosity in the single South Australian intersection (Cooltong 1) is low.
Sandstone and conglomerate of the Urana Formation have good to excellent porosity. The Pyap Member of the Monash Formation is largely unconsolidated and has porosities up to 30% and up to 2000 mD permeability.
Intraformational shale of the Urana Formation and the mudstone-dominated Merreti Member would provide major seals.
Traps Seismic surveys over the Renmark Trough and Paringa Embayment indicate an absence of sizeable anticlinal structures.
The Canegrass Lobe remains largely unexplored with no detailed seismic work carried out to date although there is an indication of some closure west of the southern Hamley Fault (Fig. 1). There is also the likelihood of fault traps along the Hamley Fault. Pinchout traps may occur in the Paringa Embayment and Renmark Trough where Devonian and Permian sediments are pinched against the flanks of the overlying Berri Basin. There may be potential for unconventional shale gas liquids or deep coal seam gas in the deeper parts of the Renmark Trough on the downthrown (eastern side) of the Hamley Fault that has not been intersected by drillhole.
Undiscovered resources There is no estimate of undiscovered resources.
Current projects There are no current projects.
Petroleum and Geothermal in South Australia 3 Renmark Trough Area
Exploration access Several National Parks and Wildlife reserves overlie the Renmark Trough area (fig. 1, Environment in the ‘Land access’ section of this USB). Exploration is not permitted in some of these (Fig. 1).
Licence status Licence activity in the previous year is discussed in the ‘Exploration and development’ section of this USB, and Figure 4 shows the licence status at the time of publication. Use this link for further information on holders of petroleum tenements in South Australia.
Key references Brown, C.M. and Stephenson, A.E., 1991. Geology of the Murray Basin, southeastern Australia. Bureau of Mineral Resources, Geology and Geophysics, Australia. Bulletin, 235.
Knight, C.A., McDonald, P.A., Frankel, E. and Moore, D.H., 1995. A preliminary appraisal of the pre-Tertiary infrabasins beneath the Murray Basin, northwestern Victoria. VIMP Report 16. Victoria. Department of Agriculture, Energy and Minerals.
Martin, A.R. and Saxby, J.D., 1984. Potential for hydrocarbons in some infrabasins of the Murray Basin. PESA Journal, 4:22-29.
O’Brien, P.E., 1986. Stratigraphy and sedimentology of Late Palaeozoic glaciomarine sediments beneath the Murray Basin, and their palaeoclimatic significance. BMR Journal of Australian Geology and Geophysics, 10:53-63.
Thornton, R.C.N., 1974. Hydrocarbon potential of western Murray Basin and infrabasins. South Australia. Geological Survey. Report of Investigations, 41.
Petroleum and Geothermal in South Australia 4 Renmark Trough Area
FIGURES 1. Renmark Trough area, South Australia. Wells and seismic lines. (204548-083) 2. Schematic section of the Renmark Trough area. (204548-084) 3. Geological summary of the Renmark Trough area. (204548-085) 4. Renmark Trough area, South Australia. Petroleum tenements. (204548-086)
Petroleum and Geothermal in South Australia 5 139°30'E 140°0'E 140°30'E 141°0'E 400000 500000
Danggali (CP) 6300000 6300000
CANOPUS HIGH 33°30'S 33°30'S
Chowilla (RR) NEW SOUTH WALES Ú Chowilla 1 Canegrass Lobe CHOWILLA FAULT CHOWILLA FAULTS FAULTS Darling Basin
Chowilla (GR) Whites Dam (CP) Nadda Basin 34°0'S
34°0'S Morgan Berri Basin " Morgan (CP) Overland Corner ª1 RENMARK TROUGH Morgan (CP) Cooltong 1 ª Pooginook (CP) HAMLEY FAULT ª North Renmark 1 Murray River (NP) " Overland Corner Maize Island Lagoon (CP) Renmark Loch Luna (GR) " Waikerie " Monash 1 Cooltong (CP) ª Pike River (CP) HIGHWAY Berri North 1 ª
Murray River Barmera STURT " Moorook (GR) " Berri Roonka (CP) PL11
6200000 Brookfield (CP) ªBerri South 1 6200000 Highway Murray River (NP)
Media Island (CP) " PL6 Loxton Paringa
Embayment 34°30'S
Bakara (CP) VICTORIA 34°30'S ª Loxton 1 Loxton 2 ª
Mantung (CP) Swan Reach (CP) ª Nadda 1 Ridley (CP) Marne Valley (CP)
Ngautngaut (CP)
Bandon (CP) 400000 500000 139°30'E 140°0'E 140°30'E 141°0'E
SOUTH AUSTRALIA Mannum ª Ú Renmark " " ADELAIDE Renmark Trough area South Australia WELLS and SEISMIC LINES Figure 1 DSD 204548-092 A A Cooltong 1 Overland Nanyah 1 Oak Bore 2 Corner 1 RENMARK North Renmark 1 Olney Bore Lake Victoria 1 TROUGH Murray River 0
Coombool Member
-1 Merreti Member CAINOZOIC Pyap Member EARLY CRETACEOUS
HAMLEY FAULT Monash Formation
KILOMETRES (AHD) KILOMETRES -2 LATE CARBONIFEROUS TO PERMIAN Urana Formation V/H=16/1 DEVONIAN 0210 030 Unnamed clastics KILOMETRES
-3 PRE-DEVONIAN
204548-093 Figure 2 Schematic section of the Renmark Trough area. DEPOSITIONAL ROCK UNIT LITHOLOGY COMMENTS AGE ENVIRONMENT
Fluvio-lacustrine Insufficient thickness for overlain by marine hydrocarbon generation UNDIFFERENTIATED clastics and limestones 610 m
TERTIARY
Fluvio-lacustrine No known reservoir or source
440 m Coombool Member potential
205 m Marine No known reservoir or source Merreti Member potential
143 m
?Fluvial grading up Good porosity and permeability BERRI BASIN Pyap Member into marine ?barrier as sands well sorted and EARLY CRETACEOUS EARLY sands
MONASH FORMATION unconsolidated. Primary target 110 m
EARLY URANA FORMATION Glaciomarine Poor reservoir, some source potential from very limited data PERMIAN 395 m
BASIN
NADDA
LATE Fluvio-lacustrine red Little petroleum source or UNNAMED DEVONIAN beds reservoir potential from
1030 m available data BASIN
DARLING
v Metasediments. Bimodal CAMBRIAN KANMANTOO GROUP v intrusive and extrusive rocks 204548-094 Figure 3 Geological summary of the Renmark Trough area. 139°30'E 140°0'E 140°30'E 141°0'E 400000 500000
Danggali (CP) 6300000 6300000
CANOPUS HIGH 33°30'S 33°30'S
Chowilla (RR) NEW SOUTH WALES
Canegrass FAULT CHOWILLA Lobe FAULTS PELA 531 FAULTS Darling Basin
Chowilla (GR) Whites Dam (CP) Nadda Basin 34°0'S
34°0'S Berri Basin Morgan " Morgan (CP) RENMARK TROUGH
Pooginook (CP) HAMLEY FAULT Murray River (NP) " Overland Corner Maize Island Lagoon (CP) " Renmark " Cooltong (CP) Waikerie Loch Luna (GR) HIGHWAY Pike River (CP)
Murray River Barmera PEL 174 " STURT Moorook (GR) " Berri Roonka (CP) PL11
6200000 Brookfield (CP) 6200000 Highway Murray River (NP)
Media Island (CP) " PL6 Loxton Paringa
Embayment 34°30'S
Bakara (CP) VICTORIA 34°30'S
Mantung (CP) Swan Reach (CP)
Ridley (CP) Marne Valley (CP)
Ngautngaut (CP)
Bandon (CP) 400000 500000 139°30'E 140°0'E 140°30'E 141°0'E
SOUTH AUSTRALIA
Mannum Petroleum tenements Renmark Trough area 0 10 20 km Petroleum exploration Limit of late Palaeozoic licence application (PELA) sediments of the Nadda Basin MGA Zone 54 Petroleum exploration Limit of Mesozoic sediments licence (PEL) of the Berri Basin Renmark " Limit of Devonian sediments " of the Darling Basin ADELAIDE Pipeline licence (PL) Gas pipeline Parks with petroleum Renmark Trough area exploration access South Australia Parks with no petroleum exploration access PETROLEUM TENEMENTS Figure 4 DSD 204548-095