2 SA JEWISH REPORT News 01 - 08 June 2012

Tickets can be purchased from Beyachad email [email protected] or sms Karen at 074 841 0555 Friday 16 August 2013 / 10 Elul 5773 Volume 17 – Number 29

Israeli Jazz artist south african at Wits – Community urged to attend (page 3) Jewish Report www.sajewishreport.co.za Photo: Howard Sackstein Photo:

Limmud rocks! Last weekend’s three-day Limmud Conference at Fourways, near Johannesburg, was a resounding success, filling the Indaba Hotel with musicians, scientists, Jewish tradition, spirituality and other topics. See our extensive coverage on pages 13 to 15.

What Ambassador Ngombane UOS conference testifies to The making of the prestigious BOEKKOOI: Tribute concert Gaborone Jewry: Small in really told Jerusalem Post Union’s strong leadership Absa Jewish Achiever Awards does full justice to Zaidel- number, but rich in Torah Magazine Rudolph’s legacy presence “SA Jewry is unique worldwide: we An astounding amount of work and Jerusalem Post Magazine’s website have one Beth Din and one kashrut expertise is involved in making an As a whole it is perhaps one of Zaidel- Organised Jewish life in Botswana quotes Ambassador Ngombane out of department, reflective of the unity enterprise of the magnitude of the Rudolph’s richest outpourings of was launched in the early 1990s by context, effectively severely affecting we enjoy between the rabbonim and Absa Jewish Achiever Awards happen - something close to absolute music. the placing of an advertisement in the his standpoints. We cite the article more community members.” because it doesn’t just happen. local newspaper calling on all “minyan comprehensively. makers” to come forward.

6-7 12 16 10 4 WALK TO SHUL & LIVE IN LUXURY... WILL CATER FOR YOM TOV WITH EASE...

The jewel in the crown, providing everything you could desire in this magical home. From the gorgeous foyer to the sweeping marble staircase you will be drawn to the oversized entertainment area, onto the sumptuous patio and onward to the beautifully landscaped garden with sparkling pool. 011 731 0300 Offering 4 bedrooms (main en-suite) and 3 bathrooms. 2 TV lounges, a royal formal lounge, a chefs kitchen and an 18 www.firzt.co.za seated dining room.

For exclusive viewing all week contact Helen Rosin 083 325 6343 [email protected] 2 SA JEWISH RREPORTEPORT CommunityNews 0116 - – 08 23 JuneAugust 2012 2013

Shabbat Times August 16 /10 Elul Timely wages August 17/ 11 Elul Parshat Ki Teitzei Parshat Ki Teitzei In Ki Teitzei we read: “Do not with- for which this world was created is fill the whole world”. 17:30 18:20 Johannesburg hold the wages due to your poor or that G-d desired to have an abode The spiritual service Rabbi Ariel Wosnica 17:59 18:52 Cape Town destitute hired labourer... You must in the lower realms”, referring to of all the generations Rabbi Eden College 17:14 18:05 Durban give him his wage on the day it is this physical world. It is in this of the Jewish people 17:34 18:25 Bloemfontein due, and not let the sun set with material world that G-d desires constitutes a single “job”, the delights, in the successful fulfil- 17:30 18:23 Port Elizabeth him waiting for it.” to dwell, so that the world will purpose of which is the transfor- ment of His desire that the world 17:22 18:15 East London Our Sages say that G-d performs be illuminated with the light of mation of the world into an abode be transformed: “It is pleasurable that which He commands the Jew- G-dliness. for G-d. Moreover, this labour does to Me that I have commanded and Achievers Magazine ish people to perform. The service This is accomplished through not require the contributions of a My will has been fulfilled” - and of the Jewish people in their per- our actions and Divine service mere “hired hand” but rather that Jews delight in “dwelling in the only a click away formance of Torah and mitzvoth is throughout the period of exile. of a contractor - G-d contracted out House of the L-rd”, “all the days This week’s edition of compared to that of a labourer for Our service of Torah and mitzvoth the world, as it were, to the Jew- of their lives” and “beholding the the SA Jewish Report an employer. refines and elevates the world, ish people, that we make it into a pleasantness of the L-rd”. includes the spectacular It would seem that as soon as a drawing down G-dliness within it. dwelling for Him. However, it is incumbent upon 72-page Absa Jewish Jew finishes performing a mitzvah, Ultimately, the combined service This explains why the bulk of the partner who relies on the other Achiever Awards maga- he should “on that day” receive his of all the Jewish people through- the Jews’ reward will be in the to do the work, not only to reward zine. The magazine is reward. out all the generations, refines World to Come, during the times him at the end of his labour, but also available as a free and elevates the entire world, of Moshiach, for the reward will also to give him a daily payment. PDF download from our Why is it then that we find that website at www.sajew- G-d does not reward the perfor- transforming it into a dwelling fit be given to all Jews as one. And So too, in addition to the main ishreport.co.za. mance of a mitzvah immediately, for G-d. this reward will indeed be received reward that G-d will give in the So, if the copy has al- but delays it for the “World to This will be realised in the immediately upon the conclusion World to Come, He rewards us in ready been removed by Come”, like the saying: “Today to times of Moshiach, when evil will of our labour. this world as well, providing us a previous reader of this do them; tomorrow to receive the vanish from this world and there So, we may say, that the service with our sustenance, so that we edition, or if you would like a digital copy for yourself reward”? will be a “revelation of His glory, of the Jewish people and their may be able to complete our task – or to send to family and friends – simply go to the The Alter Rebbe quotes the say- and all flesh will behold G-dliness subsequent reward extend into of transforming this world into a home page of our website and click on the picture ing of our Sages, that “the purpose together... and the glory of G-d will the realm of a partnership; G-d Divine abode. of the cover. Life’s lessons from a father to his children

SHIRA DRUION A home for all seasons! FAIRMOUNT (BRADFIELD DRIVE) Recep 4 - beds 4 – baths 2 + mod kitchen! Entertain in your n/f recep, In “Trees”, a book on his ethos on life - a com- while watching the kids in the pool or the garden! Walk to family, friends, pilation of what he sees as life’s most relevant school and Shul, all this & more! lessons - Stefan Brozin (pictured) hopes to Meet Tammy Wright 083-379-3484. On show Sunday 2-5pm From R2,8 mil. Asking More! impart these lessons to his children. Because ATHOL BANK (ATHOL GARDENS) he lost his father at a very early age, “it is a 1 2 4 recep, 3 beds, 2 / baths + large kitchen, staff accom. Stunning duplex privilege to which I wasn’t privy”. townhouse in sought-after complex, lovely patio, large lush private garden, After tragically losing his father to cancer complex pool, 24/7 security & more! at the age of seven, his world was severely R3 mil. Lesley Sacks 083-324-3552 shaken and turned upside down. GLENHAZEL (NORTHDOWNS) “We were so young and were left without a Modern inviting and warm. 3 recep, modern new kitchen, 3 beds, 2 1/2 heritage from my father, which was very pain- modern baths and more! In this stun- ning unit in sought after complex. ful for me particularly. He died before being SOLD able to instil in us the life lessons that every Asking R1,3 mil! parent hopes to impart to their children. This www.stamelmanproperties.co.za is what essentially motivated me to write Trevor Stamelman 082-608-0168 this book for my children and for the general Lesley Sacks 083-324-3552 public. Tammy Wright 083-379-3484 “The immense pain that the loss incurred Photo: Ilan Ossendryver Photo: was the catalyst to begin my journey to make

Stamelmans 10x2 130813.indd 1 Do you have Polish2013/08/14 12:06 PMsense of the agony that accompanies losing a Rabbi Howard Jackson and we have continued ute of every day is precious and is designed heritage and want parent at such a young age,” says Brozin. to learn everything there is to learn about to cater to our exact needs and specifications. Polish/EU citizenship “My father was a beloved man and I was left faith, for nearly the last two decades. He has Life is about the now, but being able to keep but don’t know where reeling in profound emotional pain because it deeply inspired me and has helped me to that thought at the forefront of one’s mind to start? made me lose trust in G-d, shaking my faith at become more secure in my relationship with can prove to be most challenging for people, “ Are you tired of applying for visas to a core level which is what eventually moti- G-d, which has in turn helped me to be more says Brozin. visit specific countries, including all vated me to start searching. connected, strengthening my faith which is “I hope that in some way, the book will of the administration and costs that “Eighteen years ago I went to see Rabbi something I struggled with for many years affect people positively by highlighting the go with it? Larry Shain. I told him that I had some spare after my father died.” beauty in the seemingly insignificant and Would you like to visit these countries time on my hands and asked him to advise me Through the book he hopes to convey to simple things we often take for granted but do visa free i.e. Australia, Canada, on which charity I should devote my time to. people the power of being present, the neces- not take the time to integrate into our chaotic Europe and the United He answered me by saying that the greatest sity for humility, self-acceptance and many psyches.” Kingdom? service I could do for the world, would be to other valuable life lessons. change myself and to start learning. “People struggle to take their lives in hand • The book is available at some Exclusive Books Does the thought of spending less time in “Rabbi Shain thankfully connected me to and to be cognisant of the fact that every min- stores, Jewish book stores and on Amazon. airport lines sound GENERAL MANAGER Karen Knowles - [email protected] • EDITOR Geoff Sifrin - [email protected] • Sub-editor Paul Maree appealing? • Ed Co-ordinator Sharon Akum - [email protected] • Sports editor Jack Milner • Books editor Gwen Podbrey • Arts editor Robyn Sassen Jewish Report • Cape Town correspondent Moira Schneider: 021-794-4206 • Pretoria correspondent Diane Wolfson: 082-707-9471 • Advertising: Adi Lew: 083-407-8034 - [email protected], Britt Landsman: 082-292-9520 - [email protected], Marlene Bilewitz: 083-475- 0288 - [email protected] • Classified sales: Susan Walunda [email protected] • Distribution manager Britt Landsman • Design and layout: Bryan Maron/ Design Bandits – [email protected] • Website: Ilan Ossendryver • Subscription enquiries: Avusa Publishing (Pty) Ltd. Tel: 0860-13-2652. Board of Directors: Howard Visit www.polishcitizenship.co.za Feldman (Chairman), Issie Kirsh (Deputy Chair), Marlene Bethlehem, Bertie Lubner, Benjy Porter, Herby Rosenberg, Howard Sackstein, Jason Valkin, Elton Bondi, Michael Sieff, Steven Krawitz, Denese Bloch. for more information Advertisements and editorial copy from outside sources do not neccessarily reflect the views of the editors and staff. Tel: (011) 274-1400

Joel Posner 10x2LADIES, 300713.indd PLEASE 1 JOIN:2013/08/14 12:31 PM “Authentic, documented wisdom translated into your everyday language and made practical for the first time.” Join Shimona Tzukernik, the Kabbalah Coach, cre- ator and president of ‘Corporate Soul’, founder of WED 9AM-12pM Shimona Tzukernik ‘The Method for Self-Mastery’, for a transformational International Kabbalah Coach workshop that will help you understand why it is so hard to let go, and how to finally move forward. 21 AUG Chabad House FOr thE wOrkShOP OF A LIFEtImE 27 Aintree Avenue | Savoy Estate LaDieS onLy RSVp: [email protected] | 011 440 6600 Cost: R100

CHA_JewishReport_WIP_01.indd 1 2013/08/07 12:31 PM 16 – 23 August 2013 News SA JEWISH REPORT 3 Community urged to attend new Wits concert in force

ROBYN SASSEN

August 28 sees a refurbished Great Hall at Wits University hosting the Danny Zamir Quartet. It’s being hosted, accord- ing to Wits Vice Chancellor Adam Habib “in lieu of the one that was disrupted.” He refers to the piano concert hosted on March 12, by renowned Berlin-based Israeli pianist Yossi Reshef, which was part of a national tour. Unbeknownst to the organisers, the concert coincided with Israel Apartheid week. The two elements, formal Jewish culture with ties to Israel and classical Europe and a student mob advocating anti-Israel sentiments, toyi-toying and blow- ing vuvuzelas, was a volatile mix. The concert was disrupted by students associated with the university’s Student Representa- tive Council, and others, on an anti-Israel rally and the concert had to be aborted. Eleven students, including nine SRC members, were charged for possible contravention of the university’s code of conduct. The hearings have been beset with protests from the broader student body as well as different political and union-related bodies. “The University has charged the students,” says Habib, “and the matter is still ongoing. Wits has a proud history and tradi- Zamir’s music happily marries many cultures tion of being a vibrant platform and space for diverse indi- viduals and groups to access and engage with its multiplicity DON ALBERT Wits School of the Arts said:”Lovers of jazz Crossley and drummer Justin Badenhorst. of stakeholders in a convivial environment. and Jewish music are going to be thrilled by This will be Zamir’s first time in South “It has always and will continue to advocate for academic Jewish jazz is not only klezmer; it takes on the quartet.” Africa and he says: “ It’s very exciting, and freedom and institutional autonomy, the foundation of knowl- many forms. A perfect example of Jewish Zamir in explaining the music that will to the jazz fans in South Africa I say: ‘Keep edge and intellectual engagement of any great university.” jazz fusion will be heard in Johannesburg by be heard in Johannesburg, put it this way: it up!’ By playing and supporting jazz you Said Board of Directors National Director Wendy Kahn: “We the Israeli quartet of Daniel Zamir. “We play original music that I composed have a part in keeping the tradition of jazz are delighted that the Wits Music Department will be hosting Zamir is a soprano saxophonist with deep that could be described as Jewish jazz. It alive, as well as developing it further. Jazz in such esteemed jazz musicians. It further enriches Wits as an roots in John Coltrane, Pat Metheny, Charlie has Jewish scales plus Indian rhythms and my opinion is the deepest form of music in institution that promotes culture. Parker, Charles Mingus and John Zorn. He metres as well as storming improvisations.” Western civilisation.” “It is encouraging that Wits University is creating free spac- takes the influences and marries them with The quartet comprises pianist Omri Mor, The concert takes place on Wednesday es for all its constituent bodies to host diverse academics and Jewish liturgic, Indian and Arabic music. bassist Gilad Abro and the much sought- August 28 at the newly-refurbished Great artists on this dynamic campus.Wits should be commended He says: “As a sax player it’s very natural after drummer Amir Bresler, who was born in Hall at Wits. Tickets cost R80 and R50 for their commitment to free speech and creating an environ- to turn to jazz, plus I love the freshness in Cape Town and settled in Israel in 1991. for students and pensioners. They can be ment in which all members of the community feel welcome the improvisation and the freedom it gives.” The opening band is led by the highly pop- obtained online at www.strictlytickets.com and safe. I encourage our community to support this exciting Composer Jeanne Zaidel-Rudolph who is ular experimental composer and bass player or www.webtickets.co.za Tickets at the door event and celebration of Wits as a university for all.” also a professor at the Music Department at Carlo Mombelli with guitarist Jonathan will cost R95.

KEEPING THE COMMUNITY IN FINE SPIRITS.

GRE AT DE AL EAT GR DEAL Chivas 12yr R 248.95 per bottle

GREAT DEA Chivas 18yr L in gift box Chivas 12yr R 799.95 R 1491.00 per bottle per case of 6 R 248.50 per bottle A great deal more...

Visit www.ngf.co.za now!

Terms and conditions apply. Offer valid until 30 August 2013 While stocks last. E&OE. Caption: SaksTorahGaborone: PHOTO CREDIT:

4 SA JEWISH REPORT Community 0116 - – 08 23 JuneAugust 2012 2013 Small in number, but big in Jewish presence An appeal for funds to tell DAVID SAKS Torah ceremony. The purchase and donation of the Torah was facilitated by Mervyn Lifschitz, It has no official synagogue, only a handful of an active member of the country’s burgeoning its members are as yet permanent citizens of diamond industry. the Karabus story the country and its numbers remain somewhere Among those who attended as the Torah was below the hundred-mark. Despite this, the Jew- jubilantly conveyed into the Tzabari home, ANT KATZ ish community of Gaborone in Botswana, has were Botswana Minister of Science and Tech- emerged as an impressively active and commit- nology Johnnie Swartz and Rabbi Silberhaft. A book on Prof Cyril Karabus’ incarceration in ted presence since its establishment some 20 At the conclusion of the function, community the UAE is to be written by Suzanne Belling, years ago. members undertook to meet every Monday and the respected journalist and author of the 2012 Comprising mainly South African and Israeli Thursday at the Diamond Centre for regular To- best-seller “The Travelling Rabbi: My African temporary residents, it holds regular Friday rah Shacharit readings. night and High Holiday services at the home of Organised Jewish life in Botswana was Tribe” with Rabbi Moshe Silberhaft. Avner and Nurit Tzabari and the demand for ko- launched in the early 1990s by the placing of an Karabus was innocent and exonerated, says sher food is such that Nurit Tzabari has been ac- advertisement in the local newspaper calling on his friend and lawyer Michael Bagraim. “It took corded recognition as a certified kosher caterer all “minyan makers” to come forward. This led in nine months before the record could be set entire family,” says Bafraim. by the Johannesburg Beth Din. due course to the establishment of the Botswana straight,” he added. Some of these revelations are: Over the years Rabbi Moshe Silberhaft, spir- Jewish Community, headed by Botswana’s origi- However, the book is in jeopardy of nev- • Karabus’ wife Jen feared throughout that he itual leader to the African Jewish Congress, has nal Jewish “Motswana” (citizen), Richard Lyons. er being published due to a lack of funds – “wouldn’t get out of there alive”. She consult- officiated at a number of High Holiday services Lyons also serves as honorary Consul for the R100 000 is needed. Jacana Media have agreed ed a rabbi about “how we would deal with his and bar- and batmitzvahs, and arranged for a State of Israel and has facilitated a number of to release the book early in 2014, but are not passing there”. mohel to come out for a bris. high level meetings between African Jewish prepared to give an advance. This lack of short- • During their 2002 stint in the UAE Jen, then Last Sunday, another landmark in the history Congress delegations headed by its president, term resources may mean this fascinating story 51, was propositioned by an Arab man who of the young community was celebrated with the Mervyn Smith and the senior Botswana leader- holding of Botswana’s first-ever Hachnasat Sefer ship. may never be told. offered her a Mercedes to have sex with him. “The book reveals all and pays tribute to the • The original Sharia Court convicted Karabus efforts of various role-players who worked tire- for murder and forgery. lessly to secure Karabus’ release,” says Belling. • Karabus has become a different person since It is hoped that the book, expected to be- his ordeal. “He treads lightly now,” says Jen, come a best-seller, could go a long way towards “not the lion’s footstep that he used to have.” securing the financially embattled 78-year- • To raise the initial legal fees, one of his daugh- old’s retirement and allow Karabus to be able to ters, Sarah, bonded her house to the hilt and repay those who have come to his aid. another, Deborah, contributed her savings The acclaimed paediatric oncologist was ar- which she’d planned to use to renovate her

Photo © Jono David / Hachayim Hayehudim Jewish Photo Library rested last August while travelling through home. Dubai en route back to South Africa from Can- • Each family member was allocated a role - ada where he had attended his son’s wedding. such as Rosh Money, Rosh Publicity, Rosh He had been found guilty in absentia by a Translations, etc. Sharia Court in 2004 after the death of a young Bagraim is appealing for the community to Yemeni leukaemia patient during a locum he assist in raising the R100 000 required. had served in 2002. “You have my assurance the money will be the blue gency “This book will depict the full account of used only for this project,” says Bagraim, who Karabus’ incarceration in the UAE and the fi- will hold all contributions. Contact him at mi- nancial and emotional impact it has had on his [email protected] or call (021) 422-2860.

A ISRAEL the blue gency Presents PERSONALIZED PROPERTY MANAGEMENT A If you own a holiday home or investment property in Israel, contact us to find out how “we can take the headache out of long distance ownership”

LOCATION - LOCATION - LOCATION

With many years of experience in property management and the Israeli real estate market, we will take the hassle out of managing your Israeli property and save you time and money.

• Quarterly reporting • Private meetings in South Africa Invested in a • Sourcing good quality tenants project? Let • Secure rental collection us help you • Ensuring suitable securities coordinate the • Maximizing returns completion • Professional maintenance contractors • Mortgage financing at best rates

For a confidential appointment call Barry Cohen +972 52 8311174 / SA mobile: 076 5772000 or email: [email protected] Barry is available for private meetings Aug 19th – Aug 22nd BRING HOME THE JOY AT KOSHER LOW PRICES GREAT RANGE OF GIFTS AVAILABLE IN-STORE

WACHENHEIMER’S CHICKEN VALUE PACK -NO BREAST 2kg 99 FULL RANGE OF NATURAL & KOSHER CHALAV YISROEL 12 ASSORTED CHEESES COCA-COLA SOFT DRINK 2l EACH 7399 4499 SELWYN SEGAL EMPRESS TRUFFLES HONEY KEDEM EXCLUSIVE RANGE OF PAREVE 375g CONCORD CHOCOLATES 170g EACH GRAPE JUICE KNORR SALAD 946ml DRESSING ASSORTED 2999 1l EACH

MENORAH 99 48 HOUR YOM TOV 4999 CANDLES EACH 37 10 99 OPENING 99 SNOWSOFT WHITE FACIAL TISSUES SOON 2-Ply 200’s Specials are while stock last. 15 TRADING HOURS:MON-THUR 7AM-10PM | FRI: 7AM - 4PM | SAT: 1/2 H AFTER SHABBOS-10PM | SUN: 8AM-10PM CNR RIDGE AND SUMMERWAY GLENHAZEL ONE LONG AVENUE CALL: 011 440 9517 | [email protected] | WWW.KOSHERWORLD.CO.ZA SALIENT_24858 6 SA JEWISH REPORT Opinion and Analysis 0116 - – 08 23 JuneAugust 2012 2013 Jewishsouth african Report What Ambassador Sisa Ngombane Another great told Jerusalem Post Magazine ANT KATZ random violence - you need it to be more bombings against innocent Israelis? Limmud precise. If you said the security forces were On August 1 the Jerusalem Post Magazine your problem, you have to engage the A: In discussions with Hamas the issue of The rich diversity of Jewry was evident in all its glory last published an interview with South African security forces. For us, Hamas is an impor- indiscriminate violence has been raised, weekend at the three-day Limmud 2013, which filled the Ambassador Sisa Ngombane (inset) which tant player in this environment. of conducting terror - well, terror can- Indaba Hotel in Fourways near Johannesburg to capacity. they headlined: “For us, Hamas is a na- It has got its weaknesses, but we think not be part of the liberation movement’s A palpable spirit of community grew among participants, tional liberation movement”. that these are not beyond a situation strategy. numbering some 900 over the full weekend. Some drove to This led to a spate of bad press for him. where it cannot be modified. There is a problem there, but that prob- the event for the day; others spent the entire three days Israel’s new ambassador to South Africa, And it is encouraging that even Hamas lem is not beyond being repaired, since and two nights at the hotel. Most were mainstream Jews Arthur Lenk, however, told Limmud last leader Khaled Mashaal has been saying some people have managed to stay away from Johannesburg, Pretoria and other nearby areas. weekend that he felt Ngombane had been they are ready to look at every issue. I from terrorism while conducting an armed For many people, Limmud is about finding a “Jewish unfairly portrayed, (see page 13). think that means that they are open to struggle. So we think that the mere fact home” where they are comfortable. Sadly, among South The Jerusalem Post Magazine has given reform and the fear was that if we would that terrorist activities can be linked to African Jewry today there are people on the fringes of the the Jewish Report permission to publish ostracise anybody just like that, we abso- Hamas does not qualify the whole group mainstream who earnestly desire a Jewish focus to which the following extract from their extensive lutely drive them to a camp that is more as being terrorist. they can feel attached, but cannot find it. Limmud also interview: negative and more radical. We think that they have committed provides that for some of them. I’m saying that Gaza under Hamas is a some errors, serious errors of judgement, There was music, science, religion, spirituality and a host J-Post: work in progress and I’ve said we condemn and we engage with them on these issues. of other topics, all with a Jewish flavour. Speakers ranged The relations between Israel and South violence. It is an issue that is ongoing and I think at from world experts to ordinary Jews who felt strongly Africa have seen a number of ups and Unfortunately, once you enter the space the moment we believe that they are not about particular issues and wanted to discuss them with downs in recent years. Why do you think of violence, there’s going to be casualties. beyond redemption, so to speak. others. that is the case? It is an issue that you cannot avoid. Once Hamas can be convinced to change their Its leadership tries to ensure that Jews of all stripes violence starts there is always collateral direction, because they have got an impor- feel comfortable there, with Shabbat arrangements, Ambassador Sisa Ngombane: damage. tant role to play. strictly kosher food, and services in a range of formats - Clearly, this has been the case. I think the And of course then it involves human Progressive and Orthodox. issue of Israeli-South African relations rights and the rights of ordinary people. Q: Palestinian leaders including PA Presi- Parts of Orthodox South African Jewry are still goes back a few years, actually back to the But we think that the way forward is to dent Mahmoud Abbas have stated that if suspicious of Limmud’s openness and non-judgemental existence of the State of Israel. South Af- convince them that if you use violence, a Palestinian state were to arise, the Jews attitude towards the many different “Jewish” journeys of rica was there and is one of the countries what have you achieved? To drop a few living in the area would not be allowed participants. Since the first event, however, attitudes have that voted for the State of Israel to exist. rockets that fall in the field and then bring to reside there. Isn’t that a form of racial softened somewhat. And therefore we’ve got a long history, a reaction from Israel, for which they then discrimination and apartheid? This was shown by the far greater number of kippah- and it’s natural that in a long history like feel they must have reprisals is just coun- wearing heads among participants this year than have that, there would be highs and lows, as terproductive. A: Yes, roughly, this can be said to resem- been seen there previously. The kippot ranged from the you mentioned. Therefore, when there was an announce- ble racism if Jews are excluded for being knitted ones of the Mizrachi and traditional Orthodox, to I think, of course, there was a moment ment of a ceasefire, we welcomed that Jews. Our starting point is that it is easier a few black ones, while even Jews in the garb of the haredi when relations were closer… very much and said it is a beginning of to allow each people - Jews and Arabs - to community could be seen. a realisation that violence cannot be the really manage their own affairs, have their Inevitably, people compare Limmud with the hugely Q: In recent months, there have been only way to talk, and that only a limited own governments, allow religious free- popular Sinai Indaba driven by Chief Rabbi Warren several incidents in which Palestinian achievement can be made through vio- doms and not infringe on others. And the Goldstein, which has been running since 2010, and whose terrorists have fired rockets from Gaza lence. same would apply for Israel, that it allows success grows year by year. June’s Sinai Indaba attracted into southern Israel. What is your policy the Jews to express all freedoms, and for several thousand people to its venue at the Sandton toward the Hamas regime in Gaza and do Q: Let me be blunt. Do you consider Ha- the Palestinians in their own state. Convention Centre. you condemn the rocket attacks? mas to be a national liberation movement But the idea that you are more strength- The two events are constructed very differently, but or a terrorist organisation? ened by excluding others - to us it is not a actually complement each other very well. Limmud is run A: Of course the rockets create a serious good notion. We think that it is important by volunteers, has a folksy feel and provides a platform for infringement of security for ordinary peo- A: To be honest, for us Hamas is actually to say - and some countries have said so - numerous people - including experts on different topics - ple, to start with. And we have no problem a national liberation movement. We think that we have a dominant religion, but we to engage in a myriad Jewish-related themes. in condemning the rockets that appear to that they have got legitimate grounds also have other minorities who are able Sinai Indaba has a power-punch, professional feel, with be shot randomly at every target in Israel, to exist and this to a certain extent was to practise their religions and therefore superstar attractions like Lord Jonathan Sacks. It is not including civilian targets. confirmed by their election. there’s no harm, there’s no reason, that we specifically about engaging with speakers, but mainly The approach that was adopted by our should be saying that they should not be about listening to high-level presentations on Jewish own liberation movement in South Africa Q: But what about their use of violence part of this society and this community. topics to a large audience. was that of course you cannot just use and terror, the rocket attacks and suicide To page 7 After the resounding success of last month’s Sinai Indaba, which many people found inspiring, the question The city of Tel Aviv was whether Limmud could remotely match its standard. Would it be eclipsed? By the end of this weekend, most participants would agree that Limmud provided its own special brand of Jewish creativity of an extremely high standard - which shows there is ample room for both. The test of this is how many people attended both events. It would reflect well on the vision of South African Jewry’s Orthodox leadership if they endorsed Limmud. If they cannot do this for theological or other reasons, then perhaps they could at least take a neutral stance and not object to their rabbis or congregants participating - many congregants already do so. In a community as small as South African Jewry - numbering some 70 000 - it is a pity for it to be split in this way. Both sides are here to stay and honest engagement would be better than boycotts. Limmud has shown that it is a valuable part of this community. Many Orthodox rabbis have said privately that they would love to attend and share in the Jewish thrill it offers, but feel constrained and don’t wish to “break ranks” by doing so. We congratulate the Limmud organisers and their team of volunteers, who have again done a great service to South African Jewry. We are proud that our small community can rise to the occasion by producing two such remarkable - and instructive - events. 16 – 23 August 2013 Opinion and Analysis SA JEWISH REPORT 7

From page 6 system that they’ve chosen for When we look at all these whether Israel is an apartheid Knesset, an Arab judge sits on themselves.” activities, they unfortunately state or not, and there are a lot Israel’s Supreme Court, and Arabs Q: In December 2012, South Africa’s ruling Now, the issue that we have resonate with and strike a very of debates on this matter. And in have filled senior positions in party, the African National Congress, voted against Israel - and it is not key nerve similar with our own all honesty, there is a big discus- government and the diplomatic in favour of making boycotts, divestment singularly against Israel in this past situation, because in the sion about it. At the moment, service. and sanctions (BDS) against Israel part of matter - the issue we have is one South African environment we it is clear that Israel is not an its official policy. The resolution stated that of a fundamental disagreement had a situation where we blacks apartheid state but there are very A: So I’m saying that we are not the ANC is “unapologetic in its view that on policy. Sometimes it is the way didn’t exist! The government of strong signals that it is going now trying to draw a comparison the Palestinians are the victims and the the policies are implemented. the day decided that “this is our down that route, that there will with apartheid, but there are clear oppressed in the conflict with Israel”. Does Part of the issue that really is at land, only the white people will be discrimination, that because signs that the system that ex- your government support sanctions against the core of our understanding of stay here”. And they thought it you are an Arab you won’t be al- isted in South Africa can easily be the Jewish State? the problem that exists here is was a G-d-given right for them to lowed to live here and you won’t replicated here. When you separate that there is a population which say that. be able to buy property there. If people and they must go to this A: We’re not at that stage. I think the ANC says: “We have been disempow- that becomes a policy of the state, bus, they must go this way, then it took this position to express its unhappi- ered by a government which is Q: Are you actually comparing Is- then it becomes a problem. becomes really some of the things ness about the current policies of the Israeli more powerful, it removes us at rael with apartheid South Africa? that we have lived through in South government and to express support for the will. We thought we would have a Q: How can you say that? There Africa, and we grew up there for all Palestinians. Of course, the BDS movement state - we don’t have a state.” A: We have had the question of are Israeli Arabs who serve in the of our lives and we know that. exists - and it’s not ANC. It exists by its own self, and of course ANC members will sup- port it, the way they ought to support it. But as the situation stands now, we have not reached a situation that this has become government policy. As I said, there are people who are travelling back and forth between Israel and South Africa, we have an embassy here, and this embassy is not here to say we are here to enforce a boycott of Israel - it is not about that. There are no sanctions against goods coming from Israel; all goods are allowed to come. The only thing is that if goods come from “occupied territories” then they’ve got to be marked as such. Your Complete Travel Expert Q: South African Jewry remains the larg- est Jewish community in all of Africa, but We take care of all your business and leisure travel needs nearly half have chosen to emigrate from the country over the past few decades. How do you feel about this?

A: There was a moment in South Africa when the system of apartheid was collaps- ing, where some people felt they needed to leave and make a better future for their children. And of course they emigrated, in large part to the United States, followed by another wave to Canada, and others to Australia - people who are not Jews, just or- dinary white South Africans. And of course there are Jews who have come and settled here in Israel. And as you said, South Africa still has a large Jewish population. In South Africa, we have over 70 000. So the bulk is still in South Africa. And they are living happily, and they are doing their business, they are running for every office. We have had a prominent Jewish judge, the late Justice Arthur Chaskalson as head of the Constitutional Court, the high- est court in South Africa. And for that matter, I never even knew Local or international that he was a Jew, he was one of those sons of South Africa who stood up and was fight- In the bush, in the air or at sea ing for justice throughout South Africa. There are many other leaders in their own right.

Q: Many Israelis believe that your govern- ment singles out Israel for special treat- ment. After all, there are countries in the region whose human rights records are truly awful. For example, Saudi Arabia openly discriminates against non-Muslims by not allowing them into the cities of Mecca and Medina, and even has “Muslim- only” roads. The Saudis also ban women from driving cars and legally classify them as the property of their male guardians. Why are there no calls from South Africa to boycott the Saudis?

A: We are unable to make this direct con- nection precisely because we think the Saudi state has its own origins. It is a mon- archy and it doesn’t claim to be democratic, it never claimed that. And therefore they’ve got a system that they run, that is based on religion. So we have said: “Okay, it’s the (Kosher if required)

Travel Company A4 130813.indd 1 2013/08/14 12:14 PM 8 SA JEWISH REPORT Letters 16 – 23 August 2013

Disclaimer Guidelines for letters The letters page is intended to provide opportunity for a range of views on any given topic to be expressed. Opinions Letters up to 400 words get preference. Provide your full name, place of residence, and daytime contact phone articulated in the letters are those of the writers and do not necessarily reflect the views of the editor, staff or number. We do not publish letters under noms de plume. Letters should preferably be e-mailed. Letters may be directors of the Jewish Report. edited or shortened. The Editor, PO Box 84650, Greenside, 2034 email: [email protected]

Haredi should carry their weight regarding army service Judaism calls for justice for all, not just for the other

I’d like to respond to Jonathan Bloom’s letter all their knowledge for themselves), but not I would like to respond to Heidi Jane Esakov’s letter. She is correct. Jews pride themselves on regarding haredi enlistment to the Israeli the thousands that are currently in kollel. a tradition of independent thinking and debate. She is correct too, that true Jewish values call Defence Forces. The haredi community should carry their for justice for all and a caring for and empathy with all mankind. For centuries Torah observant Jews learnt weight with regard to compulsory army ser- And herein lies the crux: Judaism calls for justice for all, not just for the other. And when a Torah. But that was not a vocation in and of vice as well as becoming productive members Jew calls for justice for others while being blind to the suffering of her own people, then at best itself. They also had a trade. They earned mon- of Israeli society by way of learning a trade or this can be seen as ignorance. ey by doing something that tangibly benefited contributing in other tangible ways. When a Jew goes further, and obfuscates facts, twists the truth, contorts events, blatantly the greater community. This would benefit Israel as a whole and lies and turns history upside down with regard only to Israel, the one and only Jewish State, They did not rely on contributions from the the haredi community itself, by becoming then such a Jew must be seen as Jew-hating, and very uncomfortable in her Jewish skin. general Jewish public to support their Torah self- supporting. There are many benefits to My apologies, Ms Esakov, but until your criticism of Israel, and that of your fellow-travellers, learning indefinitely. army service. One of them is the exposure to is based on truth and is balanced, and until such time as it condemns the actions and policies After the tragedy of the Holocaust, when learning a trade. of Israel¹s enemies as it condemns Israel, then your views must be seen as not only anti-Israel entire Orthodox communities and many King David, Joshua, the Maccabees, the but also inherently anti-Semitic. Gedolim perished, Jewish leaders felt it criti- Persian Jews of Purim, were righteous and cal to rebuild as much Torah as possible. Thus, fought. It is not a contradiction. And if Torah Monessa Shapiro kollels emerged in great numbers. study is so important to the haredim, can Glenhazel, Johannesburg What started as a few hundred men, grew they not make time to study Torah, as many to many thousands all over the world, in full- others do? Warm tribute paid to Rabbi Mordechai Abraham time Torah learning. They rely on contribu- Furthermore, the comment: “Well they tions (often from those deemed less religious) certainly aren’t drafting any Israeli Arabs!” Addiction: just as you think you have overcome your own personal traumas, someone you meet for financial support. Really? Would you want to be a Jew living in tells you about the exact same thing you have been through. This issue is more poignant in Israel, where Israel, and being defended by Israeli Arabs in Sheltered it is not; hidden it is, until it’s possibly too late. there is such a stark difference between the the IDF? Would it be a good idea for Israel to What I’m trying to say is that behind many a closed door, there are those battling with this haredi and non-haredi worlds in many arenas, train and give weapons to Israeli Arabs who terrible life-destroying addiction in some form. particularly security. commemorate Nakba Day (they mourn Israel There seems to be more dealers and addicts than facilities and people to help. However, I Israel is a tiny country surrounded by Independence Day)? I think not. have met one man who is larger and greater than an army - a dynamic, emphatic leader who enemies all over the region and beyond. Lastly, I am sure that sending one’s child to has dedicated his life to helping addicts in need. Therefore, army service is compulsory there. army service in the IDF is traumatising, for We don’t stop to think where does the funding come from... I don’t think that aspect ever Why should it not be compulsory for all we know that some soldiers unfortunately do enters Rabbi Mordechai Abraham’s mind, as I am sure he would give his last cent away to save Israeli Jews? not come home, but do non-haredi mothers a life! My wish would be that all the riches of a fruitful happy life could prevail for all those Possibly a compromise could be made love their children less than haredi mothers touched by the destruction of addiction. I just want it on the record that I am very grateful for where a few hundred really gifted men could do? the support and love given to my family by this heroic leader. continue to sit in kollel in order to ensure that a high standard of Torah learning is kept and Michele Engelberg Laura Koven for them to eventually teach others (not keep Johannesburg Johannesburg

Rather than rely on ‘G-d’ for help, see what we can do ourselves Greenstein conveniently leaves out rationale for ‘occupation’

I would like to respond to John Brenner’s letter in the Jewish Report of August 9. Ran Greenstein’s letter in the Jewish Report of August 9, endeavours to justify anti-Israel Human life is changing at an unprecedented fast pace. In today’s world, religions are defi- criticism by citing “the ongoing Israeli military rule over millions of Palestinian subjects, nitely not the best answer. We may err while trying new ways, but that is a risk we cannot who are denied basic political and civil rights in the territories occupied by Israel in 1967”. avoid. Stagnation is not an option. He conveniently fails to mention that the so-called “occupation” was engendered by an Over the years I have learned how our religion is at least partially responsible for such a invasion against Israel from the very area now justifiably occupied by Israel, to ensure its deep-rooted, widespread hatred towards us. Anti-Semitism was and is the background for so security! many tragedies along our history. Israel is doing the best it can to balance a difficult situation and any criticism of its “oc- We must look for, find and develop new ways to guide and educate our social behaviour, cupation” policy/actions,especially in light of the fact that the 1967 War was fought by it without the “help” of “G-d”. It is the time for “Him” to rest. Let’s see what we can do ourselves. in self-defence against anti-Semitic enemies, can only be regarded as anti-Jewish.

Yossi Bogacz Joel Wolpert Highlands North, Johannesburg Atholl, Johannesburg

Resentment’s circle of negativity continuously spirals downwards… Looking for heirs to Greta Grosse There is a well-known joke about a Jew who is strand- disease it often causes. It also impacts us spiritually ed alone on a deserted island and builds two shuls - as most religions emphasise love and forgiveness. Eisenstadt Michael Bleby wants to locate the so-far unidentified South Africa-based heirs to an one in which to pray and the other to boycott. The Torah forbids the bearing of grudges (Vayikra estate sold under duress in Amsterdam in 1933, of a Jewish businessman who fled I believe our difficult history has in many cases em- 19:18) and Hillel indicated that to “love your neigh- Germany in that year, ultimately for New York. One of the paintings of that estate is now bittered some of us and has made us argumentative. bor” is the very essence of Judaism (Pirkei Avot). in the National Gallery of Victoria: http://www.theaustralian.com.au/arts/visual-arts/van- We are often brimming with faribles (resentments). A theme in the Talmud is the repeated disagree- gogh-mystery-brought-to-a-head/story-fn9d3avm-1226689161003 This is one of the negative effects of anti-Semitism. ments between Hillel and Shamai, yet it never became Bleby writes from Australia: “I need to try and find the claimants, two sisters who There are those who are easy to like. These noble personal. They had the grace to remain the best of are the granddaughters of the original heir, Greta Grosse Eisenstadt. She died in New souls become likeable because they project goodwill friends. York, but her daughter emigrated to South Africa in 1937. The two granddaughters were towards others and are free of bitterness. This usually Whether we are Chabad, haredi or Mizrachi or presumably born in South Africa. results from support and encouragement received we are Habonim, Betar or Bnei Akiva, let us rather “Unfortunately this is the only information available. while growing up. emphasise the many things in common instead of “There is some more info on them from the official Dutch restitution committee, but Carrying resentment not only robs us of joy and highlighting the few differences. nothing that identifies them. I’ve tried to contact their Switzerland-based lawyer (via Linked In), but would love to get in contact with them directly. Unfortunately, I don’t have happiness, but alienates others, giving them addition- So, let us rise above any ugliness between us and be many contacts in Jewish circles and don’t even know their surnames (at least one of al reasons to dislike us. And so the circle of negativity a light unto the nations. the granddaughters is married). continues - downwards. I think, however, that this must be a story known in the community and there may be While wallowing in bitterness may provide a sort of Martin Zagnoev people who can help me locate the sisters.” grim satisfaction, it is not worth the stress and Johannesburg Bleby may be contacted at [email protected] 16 – 23 August 2013 News SA JEWISH REPORT 9 Play Station - a very welcome Johannesburg ‘happening’ Photo by Kristin Wilson Photo by Kristin

A view from the back: Play Station comes alive with the Radio Kalahari Orkes, a fortnight ago.

ROBYN SASSEN 1998, I went back to music lessons and fell concerts for years, but they stopped. He “When we were young we were isolated. in love with the Steinway grand my teacher invited me to do something. I was too busy We’d had a British tradition in drama, Saul Bamberger once had a dream. At some had. ‘If ever you want to sell it,’ I joked, with my business, to commit to another which was snotty. It was hard to find your point, he realised that if he didn’t make it until one day, after I’d stopped going to project.” voice in that climate. We were under the happen, it wouldn’t. And he has. This week, lessons, he told me he was ready to give up A year passed. Bamberger sold his busi- shadow of apartheid. he spoke to the Jewish Report at the MOTH that piano. ness. “Glenshiel begged me to come. I did. “In township theatre, they had nothing. Hall in Parkhurst in Johannesburg, about “I suggested a swop with my Steinway I began to grow a dream in the back of my Their work was raw; it was cathartic.” Play Station, a new theatre. upright.” It seemed too good to be true. It head.” Bamberger is very enthusiastic about “By day it’s a dance studio, shared with was. The teacher changed his mind. Years When a music concert blossomed into a the new work theatre professionals Jenine Esther Nasser’s Tswane Dance Theatre.” passed. Then he changed his mind again. show involving dancers, something shifted Collocott, James Cairns, James Cuningham, It’s still used by the Memorable Order of Bamberger paid it off. further for Bamberger. “I met Esther Tarryn Bennett and others are producing, Tin Hats: also known as the Steel Helmet “I kept the piano in my shop, and often (Nasser). She agreed. And today we share now. “I am going to make money,” he adds. Shellhole. played it, with my friend, actor Tony Bentel. the rent.” “Not through funding and sponsorship. I Parkhurst is replete with communal We agreed that this was too good not to Play Station launched a fortnight ago don’t want to be beholden unto anyone.” initiatives. “The residents are very support- share, and decided to have concerts, in the with Jittery Citizens and the Radio Kala- ive,” says Bamberger, who graduated from shop. Over a few years, audiences grew hari Orkes. • At Play Station on August 23, Laurie Wits University in drama in 1981, enjoyed from 25 to 2 000. “Audiences poured in. We are on the cusp Levine launches a new CD; on August 24, a short career on stage and then gravitated “One day, the CEO of St John came to of a golden period in South African thea- David Butler performs “A Teacher in the toward the antique industry. our concert. Glenshiel, the Herbert Baker tre,” he added. “A lot of young people are Bushveld”, about Herman Charles Bosman. “I adore chamber music,” he added. “In priory of St John, in Westcliff, had hosted doing extraordinary things. Email Saul on [email protected]

Entries wanted want prices like these? for next we want all your antiques, art, furniture & household goods auction

Zwelethu Mthethwa, Pastel SOLD R75 000

Joan Miro, Lithograph Walter Battiss, Gouache SOLD R75 000 Art deco, SOLD R55 000 Bronze SOLD R30 000 Pair of Japanese 19th century One hundred and eleven bronze vases George Pemba, Oil on board Krugerrands SOLD SOLD R190 000 SOLD R1 330 000 R25 000

Wanted: Alexis Preller, Cecil Skotnes, Nita Spilhaus, Eduardo Villa, Errol Boyley, Parravano, Otto Klar, Vladimir Tretchikoff, Irma Stern, Maggie Laubser, JH Pierneef, Gerard Sekoto, WH Coetzer, Cecil Skotnes, Preller, Gregoire, Rose Innes, de Jongh, Battiss, Norman Catherine, Adriaan Boshoff, Claerhout, Royal Doulton, Royal Albert, Silver, Murano glass, Lalique, Furniture, Clocks, Figurines, Bronzes, Susie Cooper, Display cabinets, Moorcroft, Clarice Cliff, Canteens auctioneers cutlery, Wedgewood, Pianos, Jewellery, Watches, Carpets, Cut glass, Lenci, Goldscheider, Royal Winton. www.rkauctioneers.co.za ••083 675 8468 [email protected] Corner Garden and Allan Roads, Bordeaux 10 SA JEWISH REPORT Tapestry 16 – 23 August 2013 Tribute concert does full justice to Zaidel-Rudolph

Concert: Jeanne Zaidel-Rudolph anguish. she applies poly-rhythmic textures. Jacobowitz took us on this journey Tribute Concert (Atrium, Wits) It is in the music of Professor Many of these theoretic elements over centuries with a clear, musically Jeanne Zaidel-Rudolph where came to life in her latest work, the infused narrative. REVIEWED BY more of these added qualities Wits Trio Tribute for Piano, Violin and Viktor van Niekerk reminded us of PAUL BOEKKOOI illustrate both the originality and ‘Cello (2013), commissioned by this the idiomatic richness found in two diversity of her work. She might trio. Malcolm Nay, Zanta Hofmeyr and of the Five African Sketches for guitar Few musicians and listeners will write a piece in sonata form which Maciej Lacny, were totally committed (1992), just lacking a bit of the poten- disagree about the fact that music dictates the structural architec- to the driving force we encountered in tial spontaneity of the pieces in per- is basically made up of form and ture, but not necessary the tonal the two outer movements. They never formance. Caryn Reed took us back content. A lot of elements can relationships. Thematic develop- let their exacting grip on this challeng- to the awe-inspiring diversity found be added to the sound palette to ment often shifts around chromat- ing work go. in Virtuoso 1 for piano, although she make it even richer: Emotions, ically while contrapuntal tech- In the slow middle movement one could have lived a bit more danger- fantasy, a text, a story, a picture, a niques abound. And she can also could feel a yearning mood, while in ously to demonstrate its full effect. bit of mystery… even, if necessary, achieve high tension in the way the dance-like moments in the finale Atmospheric story telling in music the harsh rhythmic patterns did show unfolded in Masada for string quartet up elements of the composer’s roots. and bassoon (1989).Having heard it a Alex Jacobowitz As a whole it is perhaps one of Zaidel- number of times before, its immedi- Rudolph’s richest outpourings of ate visceral appeal and the thrust by Well Heaven (1992). something close to absolute music. which it moves the attentive listener, The Wits Choir inspired in In- Selected works composed over the does not ever decline - especially not nocence from the Youth Oratorio past 25 years were heard. Another in a performance as shrewdly detailed (2009), while they, with the refined one created this year, was Hebrotica as this one. Zaidel-Rudolph’s contri- sounding tenor soloist Nachie Levin for marimba solo, dedicated to and bution to vocal music always exempli- and Zaidel-Rudolph (piano and ar- performed by the New York-born fied her natural feeling for lyricism. ranger), gave us a heart-rending virtuoso, Alex Jacobowitz. This is a Through her knowledge of the human interpretation of Avinu Malkeinu by beautifully constructed work com- voice, her vocal compositions were Max Jankowski. bining traditional Hebrew themes always challenging, like Michèle Although she is retiring from Wits, from over the centuries with Jewish Corbin (soprano) and Malcolm Nay we can hopefully expect many more liturgical melodies in which African (piano) demonstrated in their intense compositional masterpieces from the elements are subtly incorporated. rendering of Boy on a Swing and Hell beloved professor. A century plus and JMS still holding its own with grace and vivacity ROBYN SASSEN

Chairman of the Johannesburg Music Society Avril Rubenstein, reaches to touch her coffee table’s surface. “The JMS started in 1902; it’s still holding its own. Touch wood. “This year, we have seen growth in audiences. Petronel Malan’s concert recently was attended by 600; it’s unprecedented for us.” Fifteen years ago, Rubenstein took over the administrative responsibili- ties of JMS. Having trained in piano FOR HOLIDAYS TO ISRAEL AND AROUND THE WORLD, at Unisa under Enrique Barenboim, Photo by Julia Wesely. Courtesy www.sergeymalov.com Wesely. Photo by Julia YOU CAN RELY ON OUR 30 YEARS’ EXPERTISE AND father of the world-renowned conduc- OUTSTANDING PERSONAL SERVICE tor Daniel, she has deep investment in the value of music to our society. Sergey Malov, with his violincello di spalla. “When I became involved in the ESCAPE TO THE WARMTH OF ISRAEL THIS WINTER JMS, Pim Bruwer, South Africa’s Next Saturday night, JMS hosts the which too draws from a trust, make prime impresario, emigrated. I annual Nabarro Concert. “We’ve been our lives a lot easier. Please contact Debbie or Sandra for any assistance realised how important it is to keep hosting these concerts since 2001, “Russian-born Sergey Malov, 30, with regards to ights and accommodation. serious music alive.” thanks to a bequest made in the name performs the Nabarro Concert this As chairman she does everything: of Margaret Dalziel Nabarro, wife of year. He’s an internationally cel- from selecting and inviting artists, to physicist Frank Nabarro.” ebrated virtuoso on strings, who negotiating with agents, booking ven- An English-born Sephardi Jew, plays violin, viola and an instrument ues, writing brochures, establishing Nabarro and his family had a warm, called violincello di spalla, popular in programmes and selling advertising. lifelong association with Wits Uni- Bach’s day - the 18th century. It’s like “It’s quite a different organisa- versity and the bequest that feeds the a violin, but is played resting on the tion from 20 years ago,” she says. “I JMS’s annual Nabarro Concert, draws performer’s shoulder. Malov is keen remember the meetings, comprising from an investment which was willed to revive and popularise it.” a committee of elderly people who to the Wits Foundation. Malov plays Bach’s Suite No 4, rejected all my ideas for reform. There “It costs some R45 000 to stage a transcribed for violincello di spalla; were no season tickets. The invita- concert with the JMS,” points out Brahms’ ‘Cello Sonata No 1; Enesco’s tions could only be posted and plan Rubenstein. “We run off ticket sales Sonata No 3 and Ravel’s Tzigane; in changes were a nightmare, impossible and advertising in our programmes, the Nabarro Concert at the Linder to relay to audiences. Membership but bequested concerts, like this one Auditorium on August 24: (011) 728- was in a shambles.” and the Percy Baneshik Concert, 5492 or visit www.jms.org.za

Rates include dinner, Harvey Travel 20x3 180713.indd 1 2013/07/17 12:44 PM SPRING BREAK SPECIAL bed and breakfast To qualify for this special less 10% on normal rates you have to book before Rates From 30 August 2013 Standard Single R882.00 • Standard Twin R1440.00 Luxury Single R1035.00 • Luxury Twin R1710.00 Kids 5 – 12 R225.00 • Extra Adult R540.00 Tel: 014 537 8300 • Fax: 014 537 8400 | Email: [email protected] | Web: www.huntersrest.co.za

Hunters Rest 5x8 130813.indd 1 2013/08/14 12:34 PM

12 SA JEWISH REPORT Community 0116 - – 08 23 JuneAugust 2012 2013 UOS conference testifies to union’s strong leadership

SHIRA DRUION and gave a full report-back on the many endeavours with which the The Union of Orthodox Syna- Office of The Chief Rabbi continues gogues’ 26th biennial conference, to be involved. taking place in Johannesburg last He has had a busy and fruitful Sunday, testified to the outstand- two years since the last conference, ing leadership of the South African leading projects such as Generation Jewish community. The panel of Sinai, Sinai Indaba, CAP security, speakers consisted of leaders from the growth of the Schools Beit across the board; ranging from Medrash programme, rabbinical Chief Rabbi Warren Goldstein to, conferences, the dissemination of UOS CEO Darren Sevitz, to UOS Torah en masse via weekly e-mails, Chairman Jonathan Levitt and the Israel advocacy and interfaith work, Johannesburg Beth Din’s Rabbis and most recently the Shabbos Kurtstag and Rapoport. Project that promises to be a very Said Levitt: “The past two years unifying and inspiring experience have been very positive ones for for the entire South African Jewish the UOS. We have been able to community. make inroads with creating a solid Levitt applauded Brand Manager infrastructure to improve the im- Dani Silbermann for her innovative age of the UOS and the services it and successful approach to rebrand- Dayan Boruch Rapoport; Jonathan Levitt (chairman ); Darren Sevitz, (CEO ); Clive Ginsberg (treasurer ); Chief Rabbi provides to every member of the ing the UOS, as she trail-blazes Warren Goldstein; and Rosh Beth Din Rabbi Moshe Kurstag. Jewish community. the way forward in creating a more “The South African community is served the East London community Eastern Cape ; Alex Zingol - vice “These services range from fluid relationship between the UOS unique worldwide in that we only for 57 years, 56 of which he was a president KZN; Jonathan Levitt kashrut, to the Beth Din services and the community at large. have one Beth Din and one kashrut committee member. – chairman; Gary Arenson - vice as well as enriching initiatives in UOS CEO Darren Sevitz paid department, which is reflective of Rabbi Goldstein praised their chairman; Clive Ginsberg – treas- the form of international speakers, tribute to the exemplary devotion the unity that we enjoy between achievements, saying: “Any commu- urer. businessmen breakfasts and vari- of UOS staff, saying that despite the rabbonim and community nity which is dedicated to the sake ous shul initiatives.” the many hiccups that are faced members of South African Jewry,” of heaven, will endure forever and Trustees : Levitt congratulated the Chief along the way, the staff continue to he said. the good deeds a person does in his Adrian Chiger; Tony Ellis; Aubrey Rabbi for the success he had invest of themselves to ensure that Long-term service awards were lifetime will remain with him for Gamsu; Greg Narunsky; and Gary achieved with the Sinai Indaba and the highest levels of kashrut and also presented to Rabbi and Reb- eternity.” Stein. FSWG representative - Dawn Generation Sinai, applauding him service are provided to meet the betzen Yekutiel Shalpid who served Nates. CEO - Darren Sevitz. for reaching an international audi- various needs of the community. the South African community for New committee members: ence as he partnered with over 100 Rabbi Kurtstag commended the 44 years, 20 of which he served Harold Novick – president; Rafi Members of management: schools in 38 cities worldwide. rabbonim and community members the East London community. A Bricker - vice president Gauteng; Rosh Beth Din Rabbi Moshe Rabbi Goldstein commended the for upholding a unified front for long-term service award was also Solly Kroll - vice president Free Kurtstag; and Chief Rabbi Warren committee for their time and skills the UOS. presented to Sidney Weintraub who State; Denzil Levy - vice president Goldstein. Rabbinical conference a success... Orange Grove Hebrew Congregation RABBI ARI TABACK CSO, updating the rabbis on the security to the spiritual realm; practical training celebrates community chesed concerns of our community and the con- included a workshop on creative writing It was an improbable scene. Dozens of stant need to be vigilant and aware. Mary to enhance the rabbis’ use of the written rabbis clad in T-shirts and baseball caps, Kluk, national chairman of the SA Jewish word, as well as an exposition on the art milling about on a glorious beach in Board of Deputies, described to the rabbis and science of public speaking. KwaZulu-Natal. The sun is setting, and a the work of the Board in upholding the The latter was provided by Kivi volleyball net flaps in the breeze as the civil liberties of the Jewish community Bernhard, who shared his workshop on younger and more energetic clergymen and reported back on their activities over public speaking entitled “Presentology” as dive and plunge after a bright yellow ball. the last year. well as his leadership course “Leopardol- What brought some 60 scions of South A large part of the gathering focused ogy”. Kivi is the son of Rabbi Norman African Jewish leadership to Durban, was on plotting visions for new growth and Bernhard and has made a mark on the US the annual Chief Rabbi CK Harris Rabbini- progress for SA Jewry. Chief Rabbi speakers’ circuit. But perhaps the most cal Conference. Warren Goldstein’s flagship communal improbable aspect of the gathering, was This year’s venue was the new Um- “Shabbos Project” occupied centre stage, the sense of unity and common purpose hlanga Jewish Community Centre near generating much excitement. Launched which permeated the convention. Izinga. In the last two years, under Rabbi at this year’s Sinai Indaba, “The Shabbos Jewish society is at times fractured by Pinchas Zekry of the Durban Hebrew Project” will take place on October 11 and internal divisions, highlighted by recent Congregation, the sugarcane fields sur- 12 with the aim of sharing the joy and developments in Israel and elsewhere. rounding Umhlanga have made way to a beauty of Shabbat observance with as The SA community has long been a community centre, with a shul complex. wide a swathe of the South African com- model of harmony, highlighting the The rabbinical conference is organised munity as possible. potential for different groups of Torah each year under the auspices of the Office Another proactive aspect of the con- faithful Jews to vehemently disagree with of the Chief Rabbi and has become a fix- vention was professional development. each other’s philosophies while continu- Every year, the Orange Grove Hebrew Congregation hosts an event to celebrate ture in the calendar of Jewish leadership. A teleconference hookup with world- ing to engage with each other in a spirit of the stalwarts of our community, the organisations and the children who give of Topics this year included the chal- renowned halachist and educator Rabbi mutual respect. themselves to make the community better. Under the leadership of the congre- lenges of shifting attitudes among Jewish Yitzchak Berkovitz provided the rabbis This year’s conference highlighted that gation’s former chairman Morris Behr whose parents, Israel Jacob and Mary youth, alcohol abuse in the community, with guidance from one of the masters culture of unity begins at the highest level Behr are named in the dinner’s title, more than 25 organisations are celebrated, the effects of technology on education, in the field of Torah leadership training, of SA Torah leadership. The camaraderie for their chesed offered to the community. Attended by Chief Rabbi Warren developments in the sphere of kashrut, while a conference call with well-known which flowed freely among the leaders of Goldstein, the event this year, celebrated on August 7 also presented certificates and recent escalations in campaigns writer and speaker Rabbi Zev Leff, was a our community at the convention, bodes to about 10 children from various schools who have distinguished themselves by their good deeds. Pictured is Morris Behr; Craig Snoyman (current chairman against Israel. highlight. well for the continued healthy growth of of the Orange Grove Hebrew Congregation) and Benjamin Hack, from the Junior A presentation was also made by the Skills building was not only limited SA Jewry. City Council, one of the recipients of a certificate. Photograph by Joe Yudelowitz. 16 – 23 August 2013 Limmud SA JEWISH REPORT 13 Limmud 2013 sets the bar very high LIMMUD 2013 ROBYN SASSEN

On Friday August 9, at 08:00, the registration table at Limmud was opened. It was busy with a regular trickle, widening and narrowing as the day went. From women in jeans to men in haredi garb, the community and its children thronged the different venues of the Indaba Hotel in Fourways, with enthusiasm and hunger. “This is the best Limmud I’ve attended,” Limmud’s bookstore in the foyer. said Tali Nates, director of the Johannesburg portrayed and quoted out of context in the Holocaust and Genocide Centre. In one of the Israeli press: In the full interview Ngombeni several sessions in which she participated, had clarified the points he’d made about she collaborated with Moravian-born Aryeh Hamas and South Africa’s general attitude Shimron, a respected archaeologist, who towards Israel. presented several papers in his own academic While a squeaking door hinge upset at- right. But in a massively courageous gesture, tendees in one of the lecture rooms, and the he spoke of a topic he’s never spoken of be- corridor bearing the coffee and tea dispensers fore, namely how the Holocaust touched his got clogged from time to time with Limmud- Limmudniks at lunch, and blowing the shofar for the month of Elul. life when he was a young child in Slovakia. niks, giving each other quick summations of Waks introduced Tzedek, telling of his which members of the community have been Taking part in seven sessions was one of the fascinating talks they’d been to, and those personal horrors of sexual abuse in a frum blown sideways by scholars they didn’t even Limmud 2013’s stars, Rabbi Nathan Lopes they were planning to attend, the multiple community, as a child - trauma that took him know existed: from Kundalini Yoga specialist Cardozo. The Dutch-born, Gateshead- and options sent many into happy intellectual years to address. Karen Anne Turis to Rob Zagey, fundraising Mir-educated ba’al teshuva, commented on disarray. Photographer Jono David presented his manager at the Chevrah Kadisha; world-cel- how Jews veered away from comfort zones, as “There are so many options,” one Limmud- forays into Jewish Africa, while Dov Waxman, ebrated virologist Barry Schoub to mentalist he offered insights into halachic and rabbini- nik told her friend at the bookstore. “I want political scientist from New York, offered Gilan Gork, the three-day hybrid programme, cal traditions. to hear all of them.” insights into the Arab Spring’s impact. which offered both day visitors and residen- Arthur Lenk, Israel’s new ambassador to Respected obstetrician and gynaecologist Gay issues were under the loupe with Rabbi tial access, was edge to edge with speakers South Africa, began his talk on the possibili- Theo Kopenhager collaborated with paediatric Cardozo, David Bilchitz and Shoshana Boyd bearing unusual and engaging perspectives. ties between Israel and South Africa by refer- oncologist Cyril Karabus on possibly the most Gelfand, while Teddy Blecher explored the ins In the post-Limmud glow, the organis- ring to the controversy which quickly erupted relayed story in the past few months - Kara- and outs of Black Economic Empowerment. ers can be proud of a sterling achievement over a statement made by Sisa Ngombeni, the bus’ detention for nine months in Dubai on Now seven years on the South African in bringing together this rich mixing pot of new South African ambassador to Israel. Lenk trumped-up manslaughter charges. scene, Limmud is firmly established as an discourse. All that remains is to look forward said that the ambassador had been unfairly Israel-born Melbourne resident Manny institution in the country. It’s a context in to Limmud 2014. Cardozo: Ethics came before halachah, not because of it GEOFF SIFRIN his deeds, but halachah only comes “But no law can always cover all of the audience. “Our role is to after we have learned ethics. The aspects of life. Law can also kill life. irritate when it comes to morality “Halachah is being misused! And Jewish tradition is the most beauti- Nobody needs to be told not to kill. and ethics. Genesis was called Sefer that is very dangerous. It is Chilul ful in the world, “and halachah is We have an intuition as human be- ha’Yesharim because Abraham, Hashem!” thundered Rabbi Nathan central to it, holy, something Divine. ings that killing is wrong.” Isaac and Jacob were ‘yesharim’ - Lopes Cardozo (pictured) to a But we must be very careful with it.” The Jewish people needed years they dealt with the idol worshippers packed auditorium at Limmud The Talmud itself, the key Jewish to develop ethics and morality, he in a straightforward way. “ last Friday. There wasn’t an empty source for halachah, is itself aware said, and only then was Torah given. He turned to the age-old question seat in the house, and more people of the danger of halachah. Cordozo The book of Genesis had no laws. which torments Jews: Why do the were sitting on the floor in the proceeded to relate a parable about The principle of growing ethically anti-Semites hate us? auditorium of the Indaba Hotel in sacrifices in the Holy Temple where and morally preceded the law, the “For the anti-Semites,” he said, Fourways. stringent adherence to the details of Torah and halachah. “it’s not that we killed Jesus - it’s “For example, we have an Ortho- the law above all else caused a man “People who say: ‘I am a good Jew because we gave them Jesus! The dox Jew sitting in jail for a serious to behave unethically towards his at heart’, this is nonsense! There is anti-Semite has never forgiven us crime, and yet he asks for glatt own son. more to life than being a ‘nice guy’. for giving them Jesus, with his ethi- kosher!” “Why was the Torah given so late We have to be tzaddikim! There is cal approach to life. He ran off a few examples: There rity agencies treat it as terrorism, in Jewish history? Abraham is Jew- an imperative to be more than good. “What is it to be religious? was Yigal Amir, who killed Yitzhak although they do not fully call it by ish, yet he has no Torah. Abraham, Therefore there is halachah - to take Nobody is religious. People are only Rabin. And Baruch Goldstein, who that name. Isaac and Jacob did not eat kosher. us further. Jews are 4 000 years old. trying to be religious. We have to killed Muslims worshipping in “And Yigal Amir,” declared Car- For hundreds of years there was no We are less than one per cent of say ‘wow!’ at life. We cannot explain the Cave of Machpelah in Hebron. dozo emphatically, waving his fin- Torah, no Ten Commandments. mankind, but everybody talks about beauty - the taste of an apple, a And there is the “price tag” policy ger, “will bring all kinds of halachah “Probably if it had been given to us. We live in a secular world which beautiful sunset. We just know of today’s settlers, according to to prove he was right to kill Yitzhak Abraham, the Jewish people were wants comfort. But the Jewish it is there. ‘Wow’ in Hebrew is: which attempts to stop or impede Rabin… So what is going on?” not yet ready to receive it. It was in tradition rejects this ‘comfort’. We ‘Baruch ata adonay, elokeinu melech settlement building engenders acts Clearly, Yigal Amir did not read fact dangerous. Any legal system is must not be comfortable. haolam, borey pri hagafen’. of retaliation or violence against Sefer Bereishit, the Book of Ethics, dangerous - it tells you how to live “We Jews are an irritating “Religion is a protest against tak- Palestinian property - Israeli secu- he said. Amir claimed halachah for your life. It puts you in a box. people,” he said, to the amusement ing things for granted.” SA ambassador’s raw deal in ‘ME remarks’

ANT KATZ bassador to SA, Arthur Lenk, said completely unjustified,” he wrote. web content. J-Post only put a he felt that Ambassador Ngom- “Ambassador Ngombane has free “teaser” of this story on their The Jerusalem Post magazine on bane had been unfairly portrayed shown a deep understanding of website and only paid subscribers August 1, published an interview in the media after the interview the relationship between Israel could read beyond the headline with new SA Ambassador Sisa had been published. and South Africa. and introduction. This may have Ngombane, which they head- Also coming to Ngombani’s “While the article correctly caused the loss of context that lined – quoting Ngombane: “For defence was former SA anti- states that the ambassador said Lenk had referred to. us, Hamas is a national liberation apartheid activist who now lives he thinks that Hamas has ‘legiti- “I’m not suggesting that I agree movement”. in Israel, Maurice Ostroff, who mate grounds to exist’, it incor- with the ambassador’s views This led to a spate of bad press wrote to J-Post referring to Shaw’s rectly suggests that the ambas- of Hamas,” added Ostroff, “but for Ngombane and op-eds in J- “10 lessons for the South African sador said he supports the armed differences of opinion should be Post (Barry Shaw) and the Times ambassador to Israel”, saying: struggle.” He said: “I’ve said we discussed in civil discourse.” of Israel (Zev Shandalov) among “I regret that I must disagree condemn violence.” others. respectfully with my good friend Some of the misunderstand- • The Jerusalem Post granted per- At Limmud 2013 in Johannes- Barry Shaw. ing can be attributed to the new mission for Ostroff’s comments burg, however, Israel’s new am- “(Shaw’s) general tone… is world media order of paid-for to be reproduced. Israeli Ambassador Arthur Lenk. 14 SA JEWISH REPORT Limmud 16 – 23 August 2013 LIMMUD 2013 Waks’ disclosure of abuse From a dreadlocked Jewish maestro may save other young Jews to tunes of the twenties TALI FEINBERG old when he finally told his father of the abuse he experienced from age 11 to 14. As a victim of and whistleblower on Statistically, victims can take an average sexual abuse in his native Australia, Men- of 25 years to share their story with achem “Manny” Waks has campaigned others. His father “immediately picked up vigorously to bring abusers to book. the phone and called the police”, and has “My motivation for being here is to stood behind his son ever since. But this promote discussion on this important had come at a cost, as his father had es- issue,” he said last week in Cape Town at sentially been shunned by his community. Limmud’s and the Schusterman Founda- In conversation with Dr Eve, the two tion’s “Make It Happen” initiative. discussed how abuse can sometimes Waks, the second oldest of 17 children go undetected in religious communities raised in a tight-knit ultra-Orthodox because of factors like too many children community in Melbourne, is a Jewish to watch; lack of supervision at shuls, community leader and professional who schools, mikvahs and camps; and a has challenged the status quo on sexual culture of keeping quiet about contentious abuse, having been a victim during his issues. teens while living in a haredi community. “I realised that if I don’t lead, no one He has campaigned independently and else will,” said Waks on his decision to through his organisation Tzedek, to bring share his experiences, explaining that ROBYN SASSEN feet-tapping, head-wagging audience delicious insight into abuse perpetrators to book, often at a while it had been difficult to confront his “Yiddishe Charlstons” that would have energised dance huge personal cost. community, it had also led to other victims Like a thread shimmering in a single strand or knitted floors of hotels at the time, each of which would have “I want to find justice for past and coming forward. into a fabric, music was a significant track in this year’s featured a big live band, with maybe 24 performers. future victims of sexual abuse, to cre- “My aim is for Jewish communities Limmud. From choral work to klezmer, tango to twenties Arranger Benjamin Baruch Ambrose formed part of the ate a culture where people feel safe to to be a safe place for victims and their tunes, chazzonus to jazz, music was played, spoken of, litany, as did Sophie Tucker (born Kalish) who made her speak out and where these issues are families to disclose their stories; for them argued over and celebrated from a whole range of angles. name in blackface, until she one day left her make up at confronted,” said Waks, as he presented to not be shunned and to be believed; and One of Limmud’s overseas guests was Buenos Aires- home and emerged as an overweight Jewish girl, rather his story in conversation with Dr Marlene to create a conversation with leadership,” based Simja Dujov, a young maestro of Latin America, than a black mama. Wasserman, known as “Dr Eve”. said Waks. Jewish and Balkan sounds, bearing a Dali-esque mous- At a different timbre, choral and orchestral conductor The talk was opened by local com- “We need to remember that we are tache, dreadlocks, a silver magen david and a presence that Adam Golding, founder of the Lewandowski Chorale, munity member Gur Geva, who said: “This part of broader society, and that sexual simply made you smile. His work is about dance energy spoke of music “so divinely written it makes atheists ques- may be a sensational topic, but Manny abuse is prevalent in all communities in offering insight into how Jewish and gypsy music and tion their atheism”, and illustrated this point by conduct- presents it in an un-sensational way.” this country,” emphasised Dr Wasserman. tango touch. ing the Chorale in a marvellous extract from L’Orfeo by Geva, emphasised how Waks’ priority “It is important to have this conversation While anaesthetist Rodney Katzew sought the Holo- Monteverdi, popularly considered the first opera written. was to share his story in order to protect in that context,” she added. “This is an caust in modern songs, labour lawyer Andrew Levy took Taking his audience through the trajectory of vocal mu- children. issue that affects everyone.” his audiences on a path through klezmer, and Saturday sic, Golding explained how shul choirs had brought about “[Waks] was repeatedly molested by a evening saw Yidstock a party to remember, featuring the “denigration and degradation of shul music in terms of trusted figure of authority [when he was a Dujov and saxophonist Rus Nerwich. how it is performed today and how it was meant to be”. teenager],” reported The Age newspaper “Is there room for a foxtrot?” asked Radio Today pre- In offering clear insight into the complex, often conten- when Waks first went to the media with senter, Neil Starr (pictured) who runs “That Gramophone tious role of women in shul choirs, and of how composers his story in 2011. Show”. With his vintage gramophone record player, with and arrangers like Louis Lewandowski worked, he told “The [then] 35-year-old Canberra pub- a green horn, as well as the “picnic version” of the record the brief history of the Lewandowski Chorale, formed last lic servant says he was also abused by player, the “mikkiphone”, he charmed his Limmudniks. January, comprising amateurs and professionals, men another member of the Chabad commu- Starr played 78rpm records in pristine condition, of and women, who love Lewandowski’s work. Last year, the nity. One of the alleged incidents is said songs by Irving Berlin from the height of Ragtime, Jerome Chorale travelled to Berlin for the Lewandowski Festival. to have occurred inside a synagogue,” Kern and more. “There wasn’t a Jewish contribution to Following this track of Limmud left participants with reported the paper. Another incident is music of that era,” he said. “There was a monopoly.” a complicated bounce in their step, reflecting a bit of a said to have occurred at a mikvah. Manny Waks and Dr Marlene He explained how he uses a gramophone needle for capella, some big band arrangements, some tango and lots Waks explained how he was 20 years Wasserman (Dr Eve). a single use, for fear of damaging the record, giving his of context. What makes Jewish identity tick - without being prescriptive

ROBYN SASSEN grist for the Limmud mill. “Jews are not necessarily white,” says Yishai Romanoff a haredi punk this co-ordinator of a website called The 2012 documentary Punk Jews rocker from Long Island heads a MaNishtana.net “Black Jews have to directed by Jesse Zook Mann and band called Moshiach Oi. “My work prove their identity all the time.” produced by Adon Olam productions, is about what it means to be a Jew on Jenny Romaine, David Mandel- screened during Limmud, was more my own terms.” baum and Shane Baker are Yiddish than a foray into a bizarre association He has evolved from haredi life theatre practitioners: “Sukkos Flash between punk culture and Hassidism. into punk, and back again. Romanoff Mob” is their bit of Jewish frippery. Rather, the film offered a sensitive might headline the documentary, but They go around in the broader com- exploration of Jews who exist out of the director has cleverly splayed the munity, performing in Yiddish to ar- the conventional framework. It was idea of punk wide, offering glances bitrary strangers. It’s a cross between

at non-conformist Jews across the Photo courtesy http://www.indiatvnews.com repertoire theatre and a Purim shpiel, board. “We’re the kickass side of the Jewish We meet Kal Holczler, from New world,” Mandelbaum says. Square, New York. As a child, Kal Painting conventional Judaism Celebrants at Tel Aviv’s Gay Pride. was sexually abused by a respected dull, Punk Jews extrapolates on what member of his community. He lived Day in New York, with all factions Amy Harlib calls herself the yoga makes the Jewish identity tick, with- with shame and self-hatred through present, from modern Zionists to rad- yenta. With a martial arts back- out being prescriptive. his childhood, but then, developed ical haters of Israel in both the BDS ground - her age isn’t mentioned, but courage to expose the deed, creating movement and the haredi enclave, it’s clear she won’t see 50 again - this Voices of Dignity, an organisation the camera pans dizzyingly between woman does more than yoga. She’s Photo courtesy http://en.wikipedia.org

aimed to end the cycle of abuse in people touched by Israel in a way a contortionist, who has reinvented Erez/Forward Orthodoxy. that makes them celebrate it, almost herself as a side show. Art as Photo by “I risked persecution.” The commu- contradictorily. Again, the camera pans away; we nity closed ranks – even his parents Turning underground, we encoun- rush blithely and briefly through Gay refused to talk to him. “Home was ter “Cholent”, Jews “from the fringes Pride in Tel Aviv. “It’s the biggest and not a place I felt comfortable coming of everywhere. Cholent is the first warmest in the Middle East,” says the home to. The mentality of how if we step a haredi person takes into the narrator. do not talk about it, it will go away, outside world,” says Isaac Schonfeld, “Unity elevates, divisions destroy,” Yitz Jordan, who calls himself prevails.” its founder. “It’s a dis-organisation. says Yitz Jordan aka Y-Love. He’s Y-Love, an Orthodox Jewish black The camera switches to a rollicking Haredi convention is anti-growth and black, with dreadlocks and a talent hip-hop artist. mass of humanity, celebrating Israel anti-change; this is the opposite.” for hip-hop poetry; he’s also Jewish. Haredi punk rocker Yishai Romanoff. 16 – 23 August 2013 Limmud SA JEWISH REPORT 15 LIMMUD 2013 ME peace and pessimism: Are Israeli-Palestinian talks the last chance to achieve it? GEOFF SIFRIN implement a settler pullout. Can the status quo carry on, Middle East political analyst Dov where the conflict is essentially Waxman started his Limmud talk “managed”? No, says Waxman. Reg- by asking audience members who ular violence goes on, like missiles believed the new Israeli-Palestinian from Lebanon and Gaza. There will peace talks in Washington would be more, possibly a third Intifada. succeed to raise their hands. One in Palestinians might give up on 10 did. negotiations completely. They “That’s how pessimistic people achieved observer status at the are about solving the conflict. These UN, and aim for the International talks are the fourth round. The first Criminal Court, which could cause was in 2000 between Ehud Barak problems. BDS will increase, mak- and Yasser Arafat. Then 2005, with ing Israel a pariah state. People will Ariel Sharon, then 2010 with Ehud give up on the two-state solution Olmert. If these fail, will people and agitate for one-person-one give up on a negotiated settlement? vote. Abbas is old - who will replace No-one has much hope. Each side him? wants to appear that they were not What if peace talks fail? “There the cause of the talks’ failure.” could be an interim solution, saying Israelis are sceptical, believing we cannot solve the 1947 issues, Dov Waxman in discourse with Selma and Jules Browde. the Palestinians don’t want peace, but we can address the 1967 ones, and cannot offer security if Israel What does each side want? For can budge very much. “Abbas is would: “They know Israeli control meaning withdrawal from the West withdraws from the West Bank. Palestinians, 100 per cent of the too weak, and Bibi is so strong over the West Bank is unsustain- Bank, leaving other things for The Arab world is in upheaval - who West Bank, Gaza and East Jerusa- there’s not much pressure on him to able.” later. Or there could be unilateral knows what leaders will arise. Land lem because they say: “We already compromise. Also, his government But implementation would be withdrawal.” for peace is a fallacy. Look at what gave up 78 per cent of Palestinian restrains him - major elements op- difficult. “There are spoilers on both One ray of light, says Waxman, is happened after withdrawals from territory, we won’t give more.” pose a two-state solution and could sides. Hamas’ charter rejects Israel, that today peace is an Arab interest, South Lebanon and Gaza. They want a capital in East Jeru- bring down his government. because Islam forbids giving up including compromise on Jerusa- Palestinians feel previous talks salem - this is a pan-Islamic issue, “But Bibi might surprise us. He Islamic land. But Hamas is weaker lem. The Arab League wants it, Arab failed because Israel is not sincere. not only a Palestinian one; uncon- has done so before. And he could today through losing backers like monarchs already have problems It wants more settlements and ditional right of return of refugees bring the Israeli public with him.” Egypt and possibly Iran - they controlling their populations and “talks” are a game. And if a Pales- and their descendants, numbering What would an agreement look might accept ‘accommodation’ with the Palestinian issue is a radicalis- tinian state is granted, would it be perhaps five million today - in prac- like? There would be land swaps Israel, if not ‘recognition’.” ing one. viable? It would be just a form of tice the return could be symbolic, to give 100 per cent of West Bank Jewish West Bank settlers could An audience member asked autonomy. plus compensation to those who area to the Palestinians; Jerusalem be spoilers. There are 350 000 in whether a one-state solution would Analysts like himself, however, don’t return. would be divided on ethnic lines; more than 100 settlements. Under destroy the state’s Jewish character. believe the sides are actually not What Israel wants isn’t clear. the Old City would have shared or the agreement, the 80 per cent “Yes,” Waxman answered. “In that far apart and know what a Israeli PM Netanyahu (Bibi) is not international sovereignty; the Pales- residing in the major blocs to be an- the beginning, the two popula- settlement would look like. But can open about it. “A guess is giving tinian state to be demilitarised; the nexed to Israel won’t have to move. tions would be about 50:50. But the they take the leap? Main issues are back 60 per cent of the West Bank; Jordan Valley to be controlled by an But about 70 000 will have to leave Palestinian population will increase borders, Jerusalem and refugees. no Palestinian right of return; no international force, probably Nato; their homes. more than the Jewish one because “Most concessions have been division of Jerusalem; long-term Is- implementation the right of return The extremists may resist violent- of their birthrate and return of Israeli ones up till now,” says Wax- raeli military presence in the Jordan would be symbolic, perhaps 50 000 ly. There are already signs of this in other Palestinians. Laws will be man. “This reinforces Palestinian Valley; and the PLO must recognise – 150 000 people. the “price tag” policy. Also, the IDF passed decreasing the state’s Jewish intransigence - they know more Israel as a Jewish state.” Would Israelis say yes to this in a contains many settlers, especially in character. The Jews will not stand Israeli concessions are possible.” Waxman believes neither side referendum? Waxman thinks they combat units and would struggle to for it. Violence will increase.” At Limmud... 16 SA JEWISH REPORT Achievers 16 – 23 August 2013 The making of the prestigious Absa Jewish Achiever Awards

ANT KATZ professional team and representatives from the event’s elite sponsors. The annual Absa Jewish Achiever Awards The logistics are overwhelming. Literally were presented last night (August 15) at a thousands of documents are circulated and gala event. An astounding amount of work scores of meetings are held. and expertise is involved in making an enter- prise of this magnitude happen - because it Nominations and judging doesn’t just happen. The Absa Jewish Achiever Awards is, after The 2013 theme is “Painting a Brighter Fu- all, a recognition and celebration of achieve- ture” and a team of individuals with day-jobs, ment and it is recognised as such throughout supported by a corps of professionals, give South African society. The process, there- of their time and effort to ensure the quality fore, has to be conducted with the utmost of and integrity of the event. integrity. This year there were more than 250 nomi- nations which had to be whittled down to There are two main categories of Awards: a list of finalists - each of whom was inter- • Four non-business and special Awards The judging packs bulged at the seams. viewed by an eminent panel of judges in a adjudicated by the directors of the Jewish Photo by Howard Sackstein marathon session one Sunday in July. Report; and Despite the exhausting task, the eminent • Three Absa Business Achiever Awards - ad- (SA), MAS, Cert in Tax Law, D Com, is a short video clip made. judges come back year after year to carry judicated by eminent judges after interview- serial businessman but only admits to be The winners are selected by the end of the out their gratuitous duty. The integrity of ing each finalist - in person or by Skype call chairman of Exxaro Resources Ltd, Mustek day - but much still has to be done before the business awards is ensured by a panel con- - in a process that is audited every step of Ltd and Steinhoff Investment Holdings the Awards process is concluded. Certificates vener - SA Jewish Report non-executive chair- the way. Limited; and printed for each finalist and signed by repre- man (and executive chairman of Metalmin) • Geoff Rothschild - head of government and sentatives of the SA Jewish Report and Absa Howard Feldman - and is audited by Garron Interviewing the Absa Business Award nomi- international affairs at the JSE, director CEO Maria Ramos and other sponsors - then Chaitowitz, head of private sector assurance nees took place by scheduled appointment on of Nepad Business Foundation and patron off to the framers. at Grant Thornton. Neither has a vote. a Sunday in July in a marathon 14-hour-long of Education Africa and Nelson Mandela Trophies must be made and engraved, The annual Jewish Achievers event pre- process. Children’s Hospital. speakers arranged to introduce each Award- dates the Jewish Report itself (1998) and has This is arguably the most heavy-weight winner and dignitaries to present each been an essential fundraiser - ensuring that The four judges were: judging panel of any business award in South Award. The elite gala event is merely the cul- SA Jewry get a weekly free newspaper. • Steven Blend - Johannesburg-based inter- Africa. mination of six months of frenetic activity. The event has been a sell-out success year national entrepreneur and director of Alpha The Business Achiever judging processes The Absa Jewish Achiever Awards is indeed after year - but it raised the bar after the ap- Holdings (Pty) Ltd which has tentacles required copious amounts of information to a highlight of the Jewish community’s social pointment of Jewish Report director Howard globally; be collated into “judging packs” which over- and business calendars - but it is also one of Sackstein as Jewish Achievers chairman in • Banie Claasen - Absa’s head of retail sector, flowed a full-size lever arch file. the most prestigious business award events 2011. franchise and new business - who says he Logistics and co-ordination just for the in the country. And so, as is the case each Under Sackstein’s stewardship the event is always “astounded” at the quality of the judging is immense. Appointments are made year, devoted attention to detail and integri- has upped its game. The first planning meet- nominees - and that this year was no excep- for each finalist interview - for those out of ty has come together to ensure that winning ing was held in January. Sackstein is sup- tion; town or country, it is done via Skype. Each an Absa Jewish Achiever Award remains a ported by a band of volunteers, a top-notch • Dr Len Konar - BCom, PG dip in Acc, CA finalist has to have their picture taken and a sought after goal. City aims to put the rose back into Rosebank

STAFF REPORTER walkways, which were also currently being The roads have also deteriorated because of “There are rules about parking spaces for improved. Rosebank had benefitted from the large volume of construction vehicles. cars, yet (minibus) taxis are the main form Huge financial investments are being made Government’s investment in the Gautrain “The parks in the area have largely been of transport for many people who work in into the Rosebank area with R6,8 billion and from the city’s decision to encourage underdeveloped and uncared for,” she said. the area,” he said. being pumped into the suburb since 2010 more intensive land use around Gautrain Other problems were the encroachment Bethlehem said there were many plans when the Gautrain station was built. stations. of developments into the residential part of by the RMD to improve the area. The RMD Lael Bethlehem, chairman of the Rose- The Central Improvement District was the suburb, and not enough parking facili- had organised a Sunday public performance bank Management District and Central Im- an important resource in the area and drew ties for minibus taxis and metered taxis. project involving community-based arts provement District, (RMD) said Rosebank on residential as well as corporate member- City of Johannesburg Mayor Parks Tau and culture. was emerging as a critical node because of ship, she said. recently visited the area and reinforced its The organisation had also funded and the large developments taking place there. The area was also well-served with public importance as a business and residential co-managed a traffic and transport study Because of its economic importance, it transport with the Gautrain, Rea Vaya and a node. He said no money had been spent on for the area and had reached an agreement had been selected by the City of Johan- strong Metrobus service and mini bus taxis. Rosebank in recent years because of the with the city on the layout of the parks, she nesburg as one of the 35 key priority areas However, the huge investments made in construction of the Gautrain and other said. Included in this was helping the city to which the council would focus on. This the area were bringing their own challeng- developments. make the area more pedestrian-friendly. meant that the city would aim at a 70 per es, she said. When major construction projects were Other plans were: to revise the relation- cent improvement in service delivery. Developers alone had contributed R4,1m complete, developer contributions could be ship with neighbouring areas; ensuring Rosebank, said Bethlehem, had an unu- in bulk service contributions to the city, but used for road upgrading, he said. the private sector was not crowding out sual attributes which included it mixed use these had not been well-spent, and in some Tau admitted a critical error the city’s public facilities such as libraries and parks; of residential, retail, offices and hotels. cases, not spent at all. planning department was making was not providing two formal facilities for metered The area was also relatively green and “The problem areas are that the infra- providing sufficient parking space for mini- taxis; finding land for a larger taxi rank and “walkable” because of the many pedestrian structure is not geared for such big growth. bus taxis in Rosebank. promoting walking and cycling paths. 16 – 23 August 2013 Youth SA JEWISH REPORT 17 Links Youth maddies switch to a higher gear SEAN KORB AND LIOR FEIGIN

The madrichim of the Linksfield Senderwood Hebrew Congre-

gation, known as “Links Youth”, powered by Bnei Akiva, took Photo supplied some time out from building the youth of the community to focus on building themselves to be greater madrichim. With words of inspiration from the inspiring rabbi known as the “English voice” of renowned Rav Shalom Arush and the Eng- lish translator of books such as “The Garden of Emunah”, Rabbi Shalom Brody, the madrichim discussed ideas such as the role of the madrich in our world, and to be happy as a Jew. This was not possible without the Hachnasat Orchim of the Matthews family who were instrumental in bringing Rabbi Brody to South Africa. The madrichim with the children. A 700 km ride for chesed and bonding OWN CORRESPONDENT for the past four years - was met by Durban cyclists, the Field Band from KZN and had a police escort to the Moses Mab- Chesed was the order of the day as the 35 grade 11 cyclists in hida Stadium, where they received a rousing welcome from Cycalive 2013 - from Johannesburg to Durban - from Torah Durban municipal and Jewish dignitaries. Academy, Pace Commercial College and Moletsane High School, as well as cyclists from Israel brought out by Partner- ship 2Gether, carried out this mitzvah en route to Durban during their 700 km ride off the main highways. The cyclists, accompanied by photographer Ilan Ossend- ryver, stopped off at the Newcastle Hospital, Greylingstad Primary School and the Ethembeni School in Inchanga, “a school of hope for children with physical disabilities and visual impairments”. Young patients in the hospital received gift packs and other treats sponsored by a Torah Academy parent, while the schools were presented with stationery, food and sporting equipment. Ilan Ossendryver Photo: On arrival in KZN, the team taking part in the 16th Cy- The Cycalive team is greeted by the Jewish community of calive - an official event on the Nelson Mandela Day calendar KwaZulu-Natal in Durban. My Ohrsom Tour experience Don’t miss out on a gala evening with Photo: Yehuda Singer Yehuda Photo: Moshe Arens The Gala Evening for Moshe Arens will now take place at Beyachad Please note change of venue and time Time: 7:45 pm pects ofthe most fun-filled and team building CALLI JORDAN CRESWICK When: 17th August 2013 of activities such as canoeing on the Jordan A unique spice-up to the Ohrsom Tour was River, abseiling in the dessert, City of David (Saturday evening) about to take place with the 2013 group, filled and Old City Tunnel Tours in Jerusalem, and with eager Jewish young adults from Johan- water sports, to the gorgeous sunrise while nesburg and Cape Town. floating in the Dead Sea. RSVP: Miriam Garb From day 1, I felt connected to the people I experienced unique places and growth [email protected] I was with and the tour I was on as a whole, amidst unique friends, rabbis and madrichim. with lunch on the breath-taking heights of the The level of self-determination each of us were Tel number (011) 645-2531 grottos in Rosh Hanikra. It was, simply put, given to interpret and experience this journey, Fax number (011) 640-1992 incredibly special! whether religiously, spiritually or culturally, Where else can you have an action-filled even a mixture of all three, was what made it quad biking experience with laughs and for me, an encounter like no other. Donation: R150 bruises accompanied by wine-“tasting” as the I learned so much about my friends, my refreshment, but the best part of that day for religion, my homeland and my Jewish identity For security reasons ID me, was the unforgettable Shabbat we had in and equally important; myself, a greater sense numbers are required the old City of Tzvat that evening, where I felt of community was instilled in me. an unbelievable sense of camaraderie, an over- The young men and women ages 18 through all sense of belonging and spiritual upliftment 24 who came on this journey as separate while we prayed and brought in Shabbat with friendship circles, pairs or individuals,all shar- the residents of this holy city. ing the same feelings of excitement, willing- Having been to Israel a number of times ness to learn and experience new and wonder- before, I had the preconception that I had ful things in the Holy Land, was undoubtedly seen Israel and all the “main” attractions it’s achieved as a unity of close friends with kin- so famous for. Was I wrong! From a party boat dled friendships that would definitely remain Attractions: on the Kinneret to Amuka straight after, the strong long after the last supper in Tel Aviv. Betar World Expo holy grave where people come to pray from This is evident in the several reunions that Light Finger Meal (Mehadrin all around the world, everything was new and occurred post-touch down at OR Tambo. This Commission) exciting and meaningful. tour is clearly an important stepping stone and This action-packed tour encompassed all as- an experience of a lifetime. SA18 J EWISH SA JEWISH REPORT REPORT 18 Community Columns Community 0116 - – 08 23 JuneAugust 2012 2013 A column of the SA Jewish Board of Deputies New Ambassador welcomed Fascinating, insightful account Last week, we welcomed demonstration of the right to freedom of expres- of the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising newly-arrived Israeli sion at our universities. As we know, earlier this Ambassador to South year a piano recital by Israeli-born Yossi Reshef ANT KATZ Jewish Report arts editor Africa Arthur Lenk. We was forcibly disrupted by anti-Israel radicals. Robyn Sassen, in her review of have had numerous prior Wits strongly condemned the incident and im- One of Israel’s most inspir- Arens’ book, says “the reality opportunities of engag- plemented disciplinary procedures against those ing political, business and of the Warsaw Ghetto - a step ing with him and look responsible. It has also unequivocally asserted academic leaders, Professor before the total annihilation forward to working with the right to protected free spaces on campus for Moshe Arens (88), arrives in SA of Warsaw’s Jews, one of the him now that he has all in the Wits community, including for Israeli today (Thursday) to participate biggest communities in the taken up his post. artists, and in this regard has committed itself in several events at which his world at the time, and the I would also like to to ensuring that the forthcoming concert will be latest book, “Flags over the ghetto uprising which hap- Above Board acknowledge the con- allowed to proceed without being disrupted. Warsaw Ghetto: The Untold pened in 1943 - are inflamma- Mary Kluk tribution made by his The more successful the concert is in attend- Story of the Warsaw Ghetto tory ones that historically has National Chairman predecessor Dov Segev- ance, the stronger the message that freedom of Uprising”, will be available. set the imagination of writers, The book has not previously playwrights, choreographers Steinberg and wish him expression is an inalienable right in this country been available in hard-copy alive. It’s a tale of horror and all success in his future assignments. and people can choose who they wish to listen to, form in South Africa. the power of good, which is It is significant that one of the first places that regardless of political affiliation or nationality. “We especially imported terrifyingly defeated. Ambassador Lenk visited was Liliesleaf, one of a few hundred copies from “Arens’ book reads with the most significant heritage sites associated Interfaith outreach an important facet of the publisher,” says Likud-SA the verve and excitement of a with our national liberation movement. the SAJBD’s work Chairman Leon Reich. The novel, but it offers its readers In general, we have been impressed at how he Fostering relationships with civil society and books will be sold at landed cost, says Reich, considerably more. Tracing a line of Revision- has gone about educating himself regarding the other faith groups is a core part of SAJBD’s man- and will be signed by the author on request. ist involvement and ostracism throughout the history and current situation of this country. date. In this regard, the Board’s Associate Direc- Arens has been brought out by Likud and story, Arens highlights where the Revisionist and While realistic as to what kind of expectations to tor David Saks, travelled to Nelspruit last Sunday Betar South Africa in association with the SA paramilitary movement Betar fitted in. have, he is positive about going about meeting to participate in the Church Leaders Israel Brief- Zionist Federation. His first order of business “Ideologically, the movement, began by Ze’ev will be to address a function for Likud and Jabotinsky in the 1930s, was at direct logger- the challenges that will undoubtedly arise. ings session of a Bridges for Peace seminar. Betar at Beyachad on Thursday evening. heads with the different perspectives on Zionism Members of our community will have the He addressed the group on a range of subjects Arens’ only public engagement will be on articulated by other leaders, and the melee of opportunity of meeting Mr Lenk at the Board’s relating to Judaism, Jewish history and what his Saturday evening, August 18, when he will be values surrounding both Zionist and self-preser- national congress on August 25. Jewish heritage means to him. He was warmly the keynote speaker at a gala night at Bey- vation ideals in Jewish Poland at the cusp of the received and his visit much appreciated. There is achad. It will begin with him officially opening war makes for a rich and valuable trajectory into An exciting Israel-flavoured event at Wits a tremendous groundswell of goodwill towards the World Betar Exhibition, a cocktail dinner a true story that has not, until the publication of We are happy to report that on August 28, the and support for the Jewish people in wider soci- (Mehadrin Commission), a 30-minute docu- this book, seen mainstream light of day. Wits Music Department will be hosting a concert ety, which our community is largely unaware of. mentary commemorating the centenary of “We meet the characters infused with a by a renowned Israeli jazz quartet, headed by It is important for Jewish leaders to recipro- Menachem Begin’s birth and Arens’ address. sense of life-and-death urgency in saving Jews Daniel Zamir, in the Wits Great Hall. Book- cate this goodwill by likewise extending a hand of The new Israeli ambassador, Arthur Lenk and and in breaking down the Nazi ethos. Generally, ings can be made through our offices (contact friendship and building bonds of friendship and several senior communal leaders will speak as these young men and women are described by well. Bookings can be made with the SAZF. names, ages and gestures in the struggle for Karen by SMS at 074-841-0555 or by e-mail at understanding with our fellow citizens. Arens is an Israeli aeronautical engineer, for- life and in the realisation of what deportations [email protected]) and we strongly mer diplomat and politician. He was a member meant in Eastern Europe. And yet, from this encourage our community to attend. • Listen to Steven Gruzd on Jewish Board Talk on of the Knesset for 25 years and served five scant information, we meet young men and In addition to the high calibre of the artists, 101.9 ChaiFM every Friday 12:00 - 13:00. terms in the Cabinet. He also served as Israeli women of fervour, people willing to die for their this event will also be an important public This column is paid for by SA Jewish Board of Deputies ambassador to the US. community and their beliefs.” SAJR at forefront of celebrating Jewish Johannesburg

The merger of complements

Grant Thornton and PKF Johannesburg are proud to announce our merger. This is a merger of equals which will double our size in the city of gold.

Business decisions are rarely black and white. This business decision complements what we do for our clients every day. We are Grant Thornton and we help dynamic organisations unlock their potential for growth.

Chabad assistant Jade Lee, and passerby Greg Aveling at last week’s “Say Yes To a Better Year” lead-up event, celebrating the Jewish Report as one of the fabulous things that make Jewish Jo- hannesburg what it is. www.gt.co.za The “Say Yes” street team has been and will continue to celebrate and applaud Jewish Johan- nesburg’s unique products and services up until the annual “Say Yes To a Better Year” event, © 2013 Grant Thornton South Africa. All rights reserved. Grant Thornton South Africa is a member firm of hosted just before Rosh Hashanah, on August 20 at 20:00 in the Maroela Room of the Sandton Sun Grant Thornton International Ltd (‘Grant Thornton International’). Hotel. There will be a donation of R50 required.

Jewish Report_200x131_25_06.indd 1 2013/07/05 2:59 PM 16 – 23 August 2013 Classifieds SA JEWISH REPORT 19 To book your classified notice or advert contact: Tel (011) 274-1400, Fax 086-634-7935, email: [email protected]

SERVICES LIFTS OFFERED TO RENT SERVICES Consultant financial HOW TO PLACE A CLASSIFIED ADVERT: 1. Only MEMORIALS Sea Point HOME SERVICES assistanCE services adverts sent via email to [email protected] will Hawley Marble and Airport be accepted. 2. You will be advised on cost & payment Deceased Granite Works Est. 1948 Arthurs Road Chevrah Kadisha details. 3. Payment is prior to the advert appearing. Monumental masons. We Shuttle 2 beds 2 baths, estate house 4. Our banking details: SA Jewish Report, Nedbank are proud to have served To OR Tambo The Chevrah Kadisha requires someone Randburg, Account Number: 1984 514 865, Branch garage clearances the Johannesburg Jewish from R160 with sound financial knowledge to Code: 198405. DEADLINE for BOOKING and PAYMENT community for many dec- Available October To Lanseria Entire households join a focused and energised team, is Tuesday 12 pm. (If deadline is missed the advert ades. Your support is much specialising in financial planning and from R210 R12.000 cleared, profes- will appear in the next edition, when payment is appreciated. Collen Hawley needs assessments.The incumbent received). IMPORTANT NOTICE - The Jewish Report Tel: (011) 828- 9010 Chaim Reasonable rates to Phone sionally and con- needs to be mature, have life runs adverts in the Classified section in good faith, Silver (011) 485-3005 all other areas 084-408-1758 Sam fidentially. I’ll take experience, excellent budgeting, however we cannot be responsible for the quality of BEAUTY & HEALTH (011) 728-5219 FOR SALE investigative and counseling skills and services offered and claims made. 083-627-8516 the burden off your have worked in a people-orientated AUDIOLOGIST PROPERTY FOR SALE shoulders and pay environment before. Knowledge of IN ISRAEL KELLY NATHAN Jewish culture and customs is an An 800-year-old you for it. Manor Medical Centre inherent requirement of this position. house, in the Old City Please contact 189 Kelvin Drive of Jerusalem, walking Only short-listed applicants will be Morningside Manor distance from the Wailing Ladislav Miklas responded to. Tel: 0861-266-563 Wall. Only for serious 079-810-8837 (0861-Book Me) buyers. No agent. Asking $2,5m. For a trusted Interested candidates please forward www.knaudiology.co.za a current CV to [email protected], [email protected] and professional INDIVIDUALISED SERVICE FOR fax, 0866327774 or Private Bag X1, ALL YOUR HEARING NEEDS EMPLOYMENT service. Also clear Sandringham, 2131. LIFTS OFFERED WANTED garages, cellars, FOREIGN CITIZENSHIP AIRPORT SERVICE BRIAN K LIFT FOR SALE SERVICE & COURIER Mature storage rooms and Lithuanian & Polish JHB PA secretary MISCELLANEOUS AIRPORT SPECIAL FROM storage facilities. citizenship R160. Secure, comfortable seeking similar and safe. Anywhere 24/7. position or running a Many South African (Jhb - Pta) shop or office. Avail- Jews are eligible able immediately. for Lithuanian or Pol- 8-seater available CALL BRIAN ON Ran own business for Contact Arnold, 076-533-1440 ish citizenship. If you three years. Willing to 082-447-0185 PROPERTY are interested, please 011-454-1193 learn anything new. contact me. I specialise TO RENT Contact Barbara on BEST SERVICE in obtaining Lithuanian Two-bedroom private (011) 887-9169 or Transfers from A to B & Polish citizenship. When last were your cottage to let e-mail barbara. Top spacious vehicle I am able to obtain the Garden, parking, se- [email protected] Mezuzahs checked? 7 Passengers plus all required documents cure, new, kosher. A professional scribe with 30 years luggage. PIP FRIEDMAN OFFERED from archives in Europe R7 500/month. To view experience (Rabbi Klein) will inspect 083-267-3281 Looking for mature, and from SA Home [email protected] 076-686-8259 warm, patient lady all Mezuzahs and Tefillin. Percelia Affairs. Rael Cynkin CA www.dialalift.co.za to provide companion- (SA) [email protected] Supplier of new Scrolls and Tefillin ship to elderly lady in A TAXI SERVICE Royal Linksfield 083 346 4627 1) Completely renovat- early stage of Alzhei- Let Warren Pogorelsky mer’s. Required also SILVER chauffeur you to your ed, 2 beds, 2 baths, VEHICLES to accompany her on REPAIR & destination in Johannes- 2 lounges, dining area, occasional appoint- WANTED burgand back. Only R120 wood kitchen. Small ments and outings. REPLATING round trip for 20km. Tel: garden,1 garage,1 car- Must have a car. Call IF YOU WANT 082-399-6187 Sun City & port. R10 000 + deposit. Lynn 072-296-2060. (011) 334 1102 Game Reserve TO BUY no pets 082-473-6040 2) 2 beds, 2 baths, 2 Experienced OR SELL A Experienced, reliable lounges, dining area, cook, domestic Appliance VEHICLE driver able to lift you Melamine kitchen, small worker, sleep in, Repairs on-site anywhere/ anytime Fridges, stoves, We will remove and refit your Mezuzah garden, 1 x carport, 1 x required for couple washing machines, Contact: 24 hours. Courier work parking place. R9 500 in Sandton. Jewish tumbledriers and Phone Ivor on dishwashers. Solly (011) 615-8738 or 082-682-3438 undertaken. + deposit. Call June cooking. NB: Mezuzahs and Tefillin must be Please call Paul 083-226-3741 Contactable ref. Free quotations! Kramer Call Jason checked twice every seven years 083-542-6480 or (011) 640-4967. Call 074-022-7365 082-401-8239 082-922-3597

What’s On Today, Friday (August 16) will present a tribute to Johnny Monday (August 19) Street, Houghton. Time: 09:30. Cost: R20. Enquires: (021) 434- Mathis, followed by Benny Michel Donation: R30. Contact: (011) 9555 (until 14:00). • ORT SA with Sasfin and Deloitte who will also pay a tribute to the • UJW hosts Lael Bethlehem, HCI 648-1053. is hosting Prof Moshe Arens at a late singer and his band. Venue: industrial sociologist, on “Cross- • UJW hosts Dr Lorraine Chaskalson, breakfast. Time: 07:00 for 07:30. Roosevelt Park Recreation Centre. Racial Adoption”. Venue: 1 Oak • Bnoth Zion Association WIZO former lecturer in the Dept of For more information and to RSVP: Time: 14:00 sharp. Enquiries: Ron, Street, Houghton. Time: 09:30. screens the entertaining, humorous English at Wits, on part 4 of her (011) 728-7154. (011) 793-2383 or Marilyn, 072- Donation: R30. Contact: (011) award-winning documentary, “Hot series on “Contemporary Poetry”. 243-7436. 648-1053. Flush Havoc”. All you need to Venue: 1 Oak Street, Houghton. • UZLC hosts Mannie Zar on “Some know about menopause. Followed Time: 09:30. Donation: R30. Humour in the Law” Venue: Our • WIZO Etgar hosts a breakfast with Tuesday (August 20) by a talk by Dr Eve and a panel of Contact: (011) 648-1053. Parents Home. Time: 12:45 - 14:00. Dr Eve, on “Hot Flash Havoc”. experts. Venue: President Hotel, Contact: Gloria, 072-127-9421 or Venue: Theatre on the Square. • Bnoth Zion WIZO in CT screens Bantry Bay. Time: 18:00. Cost: • Second Innings hosts an “Outing (011) 485-4851. Time: 09:00 for 09:30. Cost: R250. the award winning documentary R250. Contact: (021) 464-6729. to Van Gaalen Cheese Farm in For bookings contact Zee 083-377- “Hot Flash Havoc” on menopause, the Hartebeespoort Area”. Meet Saturday evening (August 17) 5644. followed by a panel discussion Wednesday (August 21) the bus at 08:30 sharp in front led by Dr Eve (sexologist); Dr of Golden Acres. Cost: R180 • Beyachad hosts Prof Moshe Arens; • Sydenham Highlands North De Villiers (gynaecologist); Dr • SA Jewish Museum CT hosts Lance members, R200 visitors. Contact: the new Israeli Ambassador to SA Community Centre again hosts a Wilkinson (plastic surgeon); Kim Herman Eliezer, giving a live music Grecia, (011) 532-9718 or 082- Arthur Lenk; a film on Menachem breakfast for working moms, titled Hoffman (nutritionist); and Kathy performance. Venue: SA Jewish 561-3228. Begin; and Betar World Expo “The Liberty Working Mom’s Guide Wolstenholme (Nia dancing). Museum, Gardens. Time: 18:30 at a finger supper (Mehadrin to Reinvention” at the centre, with Snacks and welcome drink will be for 19:00. Cost: R60. Booking Friday (August 23) to Friday Commission). Venue: Beyachad. guest speaker Mandy Ramsden, a served. Venue: President Hotel, essential, (021) 465-1546 or info@ (August 30) Time: 19:45. Cost: R150. Booking single mother of four talking on Bantry Bay. Time: 18:00 - 21:00. sajewishmuseum.co.za essential. [email protected] how to find and re-invent ourselves Cost: R250. Contact: (021)-464- • Elise WIZO Gift Shop and WIZO in the face of the onslaught that is 6729 or [email protected]. Snacks and • UJW CT adult education Johannesburg are selling their Sunday (August 18) work and motherhood and how to a welcome drink will be served. programme hosts Dr Alan wares at the Yomtov Market at the be inspired along the way. Time: Alperstein on “Innovations in Norwood Mall. Exciting range of • Johannesburg Light Music Society 09:00 for 09:30. Contact: (011) • UJW hosts musicologist Estelle Gyneacology”. Venue: Stonehaven, gifts. Enquiries: WIZO office, (011) hosts Mike Kimmelman who 640-1989 or 072-492-0664. Sher on Beethoven. Venue: 1 Oak Sea Point. Time: 10:00 for 10:30. 645-2515. 20 SA JEWISH REPORT Sport 30 November – 7 December 2012

16 – 23 August 2013 Sport SA JEWISH REPORT 20 MaccabiahPerfecting an overwhelming the art of success how for not Team to SA lose highlights of the Games for us,” said Garrun. ment.” He added that once again the junior game one needs to defend a lead. Howev- “He swam some of the fastest times in the tour- cricket dominated completely. er, defence is seemingly quickly becoming nament and broke a number of records.” “However, we need to keep the momentum what South African sport is all about. Before the Games Letschert also swam at the going. What struck me overall was the improve- While the Boks held England at bay Bosphorus Cross-Continental race, a 6,5km ment in standards, especially from the Israeli in the north, managing to cling to a one ROCKINGROCKING THETHE BOAT BOAT race, finishing 16th overall and first in the 45 to teams. They dominated the entire Maccabiah. point win, the Proteas looked to be head- JackJack MilnerMilner 49 age group. They won the rugby for the first time and in pre- ing for certain Test defeat Down Under “Other highlights include Kevin Evans’ vious years they could not even make the finals. as they ended the fourth day under the TheI do notMaccabiah profess is over, to be everybody an authority is back onand cycling win in which he beat a former under-23 “Of the 9 000 participating athletes, 2 500 cosh at 77 for four wickets, chasing 430 Maccabirugby. DuringSouth Africa my timeChairman at school Cliff GarrunI actually world champion from Ukraine,” said Garrun. were from Israel. Their sport is far better organ- to win. hasdeveloped declared thisa hatred year’s forevent the a roaring game becausesuccess. “Our senior cricket side had a tough tourna- ised, their coaching has improved and they are The match looked all over, with a win it Withwas continuallythe medal tally jammed still not finalised,down our Gar - ment. They only took 12 players and one got getting more competitive.” Southfor African Australia junior certainty, rugby captain but ABJustin de SherVil- goes over for a try on the team’s way to their runthroats. believes Team South Africa won around 54 injured in the first game so they only had 11 The Maccabiah is never without its contro- liers, Jacques Kallis and especially Faf du gold medal at this year’s Maccabiah. medals,However, 18 of which as I weregot older gold. and became players to complete the tournament. They made versy but this time the South Africans were the Plessis, had other ideas. De Villiers kept moreThe involvedgold medals in wentthe toworld senior of and sport junior and the final on net run rate, which went down victims. HeadingDu Plessis the junior company delegation for 68 was overs advocate and a cricket,began juniorto understand rugby XV and the sevens nuts teams,and bolts to a few shots in their last round robin match “We took a basketball team for the first Mannienobbled Witz whoKallis represented for another the team40 overs at the in Kevin Evans for road race cycling, the men’s against Israel and then easily beat Israel in the time. It was an under-18 squad, all of whom hearing and won the day for South Africa. of the game, I actually began to enjoy the searing Adelaide heat, as Du Plessis trips bowls team, Shireen Sapiro for Para 100m final. What was very pleasing was the junior are from Cape Town. They did not win a match “It was overwhelmingly a hugely positive it very much. Whatever I might think I tenaciously defied the Australian bowling backstroke (she also won two silvers) and Jacqui rugby team. Rugby has the highest number of outright but they tried extremely hard and were event for us,” said Garrun. “We participated in know, I will always bow in admiration to attack for nearly eight hours. Boyd for tennis open doubles. spectators and the standard is improving. It’s competitive to the end. They were given the Fair 20 sports and in 14 of those came away with the likes of commentator Dan Retief who Cricketer Faf du Plessis is supported by his team as he pulls off a stunning save of the second Many people would have found the Masters squash player Peter Garrun won the veryTest professional. match against Australia in Adelaide. Play award at the ceremony which was fantas- medals. Our great achievement is that 200 of singleshas a marvellousevent while the understanding SA team, comprising of the “There were some tight games which they got tic,” said Garrun. However, they managed to the pushing360-strong and squad prodding were under-20. mind-numbing to Garrun,sport. Dennis Bass and Mike Charnas, won throughhe took and advantage there are enough of a lucky guys bouncewho will of winin one the game final in minute the boardroom was one because of the Turkey most “Ourwatch, primary but functionit takes nowa special is to keep kind the of pro- goldHowever, in the team what competition. I have learned during comethe intoball theto scoresenior thesides.” only try - and fur- illegallyinane fielded I have an ever under-16 seen. playerThat waswho totalwas a brandficiency alive and and relevant. mental Our aptitude fundraising to stay did out myThe tears Masters as a swimmerssports journalist came away is withhow seven to thermoreGarrun also superb complimented defence Paralympic by the Boks. swim - topcapitulation, goalscorer, in theiras if under-18to say they squad. were “They happy wellthere and we for managed seven tohours capture and the 46 imagina minutes,- in goldanalyse medals, a game. five of As which I said went last to week,Durbanite I have mer ShireenI have Sapiro.said for “Shireen the past is fantastic few years and that sneakedto lose him by under one point.a false name into their side tionmainly of the community. 34 degrees I feelheat we and have high depth humid- in Peteralways Letschert tried to and maintain two to Ivan my Schlapobersky. objectiv- shethe was Boks wonderful are unable across to the play board. 80 She minutes stayed of and heOn scored that most subject, of their I wasgoals. the Fortunately one person it our ity,leadership with five and differentwe have the partners, momentum one to of ity“Dave and Letschert’snot become performance a “fan with was a one pen”. of the withattacking the juniors rugby. and helpedIn the with final the 20 manage minutes- wasabsolutely spotted by delightedour coach.” by that decision buildwhom for the could future.” barely run, to defy a vora- Last Saturday I only managed to see the of the game they were probably lucky to as I had backed England on a minus 2,5 cious and tenacious Australian attack and second half of the Springboks versus Eng- have spent two of those minutes in the spread and that whacky decision sealed save a crucial match for his country. land Test but on Sunday morning I sat England half. The remaining 18 minutes Dynamicme my win. Shlomo NimrodiThis was amakes monumental effort, through the replay. Knowing the result, was played somewhere on the Boks’ 22m There is no doubt we have some performed on debut and already written I could put the excitement of a close line. thingswonderful players happen in our team, but one into the folklore of South African cricket encounter behind and dispassionately There is little doubt that England, is never certain down which garden path history. interpret what I had watched. when it comes to attacking, are equally SHIRAcoach DRUION Heyneke Meyer is leading them. industry, takingSo, while into account we might the demands lack the of univer attacking- After a little thought I came to the inept and they certainly had enough But coming back to defence: All sportssity researchprowess environments of a Genghis and industry’s Khan, needs.South Afri- following conclusion: In simple terms, all chances. We kept conceding penalties in Shlomoare madeNimrodi up (pictured), of offence CEO of and Ramot defence. at Tel It is He canscouts sport for new has innovation, elevated accesses the art funding of defence for that won us the game was an inspiration- the dying moments but one has to say Avivvital University to have (the university’sa balanced technology share oftransfer both. It new projects,to another and essentially level. I facilitatessuppose the there process is an al moment from Willem Alberts in which that England’s decision to go for posts company)is also boasts an art an toastounding know atlist which of achievements point of athat translatesadvantage products in playing from university not to labs lose... into the and a glittering CV. global market. As an above knee amputee as a result of a war “When I returned from spending 15 years working What’s On injury sustained while serving with the IDF, Nimrodi in the US, I received a call from the chairman of Tel has completed 14 Olympic dis- Aviv University. He said: ‘Shlomo, Sunday (December 2) professor of English at Wits, on “Please tance Triathlons as a challenged you have excelled in your busi- Sir, I Want Some More”, Charles Dick- athlete. He has never accepted ness career, now it is time to do • RCHCC is rescreening the award-win- ens and children in this his bicentenary adversity as a handicap. something for your country‘,” he ning film, “The Debt”, directed by John year. Time: 09:30. Contact: (011) 648- He is currently actively involved said during a recent visit to South Madden and starring Helen Mirren, 1053, fax 086 273-3044. Donation: with several initiatives in the Africa, where he met with aca- Sam Worthington, Jessica Castain and R20. Join UJW for an informal tea after US and in Israel with the FIDF demics at Stellenbosch Univer- Tom Wilkinson. Venue: Clive M Beck the lecture. through the STRIDES programme, sity and advised them on how to Auditorium. Time: 19:30. Donation: helping and educating young create similar infrastructures for R60. Booking: Hazel or René (011) 728- Thursday (December 6) people who have been injured ei- products that are developed there. 8088/8378, after hours (011) 728-8378, ther in wars or terror attacks, with Today, Tel Aviv University is the e-mail: [email protected] or rene.s@ • UJW CT adult education division hosts the challenges of life by sharing largest in the country with telkomsa.net or www.greatpark.co.za Isaac Habib who will talk on “Jewish Life his own life experiences. 15 000 people doing research in the Island of Rhodes – From Begin- He has 20 years’ international and is the single largest source of • JJMC, with musical director Evelyn ning to End”. Venue: Stonehaven. Time: experience in healthcare, broad- innovation in Israel. It is uniquely Green presents a musical tribute to the 10:00 for 10:30. Entrance: R20 (incl cast graphics, digital printing, telecommunications, positioned in how it deals with major concerns of Doornfontein Hebrew Congregation refreshments). Enquiries: (021) 434- financial services and clean energy. society including central nervous system cures and (Lions Shul), “Memories of Yesteryear”, 9555. Nimrodi started his professional career in 1983 cyber security. as a fundraiser for the shul. The reper- with the Israeli Ministry of Defence as an economic Nimrodi remains humble about his accomplish- adviser to the Defence Minister and was involved in ments despite an MA and MBA with Honours from toire will encompass traditional Jew- Friday (December 7) several major Israeli initiatives. His passion to con- the Hebrew University of Jerusalem and an advanced ish songs. Secure parking. Time: 15:00. stantly achieve his best is evident in the numerous Management Programme certificate from Harvard Tickets available from Darla at R200. • The United Sisterhood has its year- business success stories which are a living narrative Business School. 083-794-6358 [email protected] end book sale at the Benmore Gardens of his career. “I think the secret to success is to be bold and Shopping Centre. Unwanted books and He has directed global operations and activities to lead by example, to be creative, to persist, to be Monday (December 3) magazine donations are gladly accepted. from a grassroots level, is a catalyst in implementing humble by listening to people, to have stamina and to Contact: Tel (011) 646-2409; fax (011) positive change, igniting stagnant operations, and be innovative. I always tell my kids it’s okay to make • UJW is hosting Marcia Leveson, former 646-4654. utilising out-of-the-box thinking to resolve complex mistakes, but be original and don’t make the same strategic, operational and organisational challenges mistake twice. World News in Brief and has pioneered the huge success of several “You have to believe in something to do and go at companies going public. it with your heart,” says Nimrodi. “That is the root to POPE CALLS FOR END TO PERSECUTION OF CHRISTIANS, NEW ME PEACE EFFORTS As CEO of Ramot, his initial objective is to estab- success. If you don’t believe in the endeavour, you will lish a win-win relationship between academia and not make a success of it.” ROME - At a gathering in Rome with Lebanon’s new cardinal, Pope Benedict XVI launched a new appeal for peace in Syria and the Middle East, the Associated Press reported. “The church encourages all efforts for peace in the world and in the Middle East, a peace that will only be effective if it is based on authentic respect for other people,” Pope Benedict told the gathering, which included several Lebanese pilgrims. He also spoke out concerning the plight of Christians from their traditional homelands throughout the Middle East, calling for them to be able to “live their faith freely”. Christian communities have come under assault by Muslims amid the upheaval related to the “Arab Spring”. Tens of thousands of Syrian Christians have fl ed from the civil war there, while Egypt’s Coptic Christian community fears the rise of the Muslim Brotherhood and the ultra-extremist Salafi groups to power. Recently, several Coptic Christian teenage women were been assaulted by other women on Cairo subways because their hair was uncovered. Many Coptic women are now afraid to ride the transit system in fear of being assaulted or sexually harassed, according to Morning Star News. (JNS.org)

NJWED02028.indd 20 2012/11/28 5:27 PM