15Th March'2021
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
o ffi q_qqr6l s{fuort RIGI{T TO ffi H I NFORMATIO N ARUNACHAL PRADESH INFORMATION COMMISSION ITANAGAR BEFORE THE COURT OF DR.JORAM BEGI, STATE CHIEF INFORMATION COMMISSIONER No.APlC-165/2020 Dated, ltanagar the 16th March' 2o2I Under Section 19(3) RTI Act, 2005 Appellant Respondent Shri Vijay Pertin, Dr. R.Tatan, Vill; lthili, PIO-cum-DMO, PO/Ps Roing, Roing, Lower Dibang Valley District, Vs Lower Dibang Valley District, Arunachal Pradesh. Arunachal Pradesh. (m)7085172418, Dated of hearing held on : 15th March'2021. ORDER Whereas, an appeal under Section 19(3) of RTI Act, 2005 has been received from Shri Vijay Pertin, Vill; lthili, PO/Ps Roing, Lower Dibang Valley District, Arunachal Pradesh, for non-furnishing of information, by Dr. R.Tatan, PIO-cum-DMO, Roing, Lower Dibang Valley District, Arunachal Pradesh, as sought, by the Appellants under section 6(1) of RTI Act, 2005 on28/09/2020, regarding Detail of Nursing Officer interview' Whereas, the 1't hearing was held on 19th January'2021. Dr. R.Tatan, PIO-cum- DMO, Roing, Lower Dibang Valley District, Arunachal Pradesh, and the Appellant Shri Vijay Pertin were present during the hearing. The Appellant informed the Commission that the PIO has not furnished information for the Sl.no. 1 as sought by him in the Form- A, rest of the informations have been furnished by the PIO and the Appellant is satisfied with it. The PIO informed that the information sought at Sl.no.1 is of third party. The PIO also ouoted section 8 of the RTI Act 2005 for exemption of furnishing the information. Whereas, the Commission made it clear to the PIO that if the information sought by the Appellant is pertaining to 3'd party information, the PIO should have taken action u/s 11(1) of the RTI Act. since, the Plo has not acted as per Section 11(1) of the RTI Act, the Commission giving reasonable opportunity to the third parties decided to summon twelve numbers of successful candldates from the Nursing Recruitment under NHM held on 3oth June'2020, 11th and 12 August'2020 as listed below u/s 19(a) of the Act in the next date of hearing. Contd..p..2 -2- NO.1 Nursing Recruitment under NHM Dated 30th June'2020 SL.NO ROLL. NAME & ADDRESS CONTACT NO NO. 01 20 Ms. Ameya Pulu, C/o Late Toya Pulu, Village Mayu-ll, PO & PS Roing, 764781,4238 Lower Dibang Valley District, Arunachal Pradesh, o2 05 Ms. Oyi Pertin, C/o Late Yalom Pertin, Village Bolung, PO & PS Roing, 986281288 Lower Dibang Valley District, Arunachal Pradesh, 03 09 Ms. Dam Dameng, C/o Mibang Dameng, Village Kangkong (Kalek), PO & 9485257245 PS Roing, Lower Dibang Valley District, Arunachal Pradesh, 04 07 Ms. Amoni Damin, C/o Nombo Damin, Village Meka, PO & PS Roing, 811.9826945 Lower Dibang Valley District, Arunachal Pradesh, 05 15 Ms. Ninggu Perying, C/o Late Allen Perying, Village Jia-ll, PO & PS Roing, 961,2504478 Lower Dibang Valley District, Arunachal Pradesh, 06 37 Ms. Ota Lego, C/o Late Aniyang Lego, Village Poblung, Dambuk, PO & PS s,q$ssi)i,s Roing, Lower Dibang Valley District, Arunachal Pradesh, NO.2 Nursing Recruitment under NHM Dated 1-l-th and 1-2th August'2020 SL.NO ROLL. NAME & ADDRESS CONTACT NO NO. 01 L7 Ms. Emey Mili, C/o Mukuli Mili, Village Emuli, PO & PS Roing, Lower 8257064139 Dibang Valley District, Arunachal Pradesh, o2 03 Ms. Nunu Tayeng, C/o Late Dayut Tayang, Village Kangkong, PO & PS 96L21"3481,9 Roing, Lower Dibang Valley District, Arunachal Pradesh, 03 16 Ms. Aashipee Mimi, C/o Martin Mimi, Village Awali, PO & PS Anini, 8257092397 Dibang Valley District, Arunachal Pradesh, o4 40 Ms. Episia Borang, C/o Okang Borang, Village Jia, PO & PS Roing, Lower 7896649696 Dibang Valley District, Arunachal Pradesh, 05 26 Ms. Ponung Apum, C/o Subash Apum, Village Poblung, Dambuk, PO & 8787822191, PS Roing, Lower Dibang Valley District, Arunachal Pradesh, 06 38 Ms. Agu Ngusang, C/o Bamgo Ngusang, Village Jia, PO & PS Roing, Lower 96787798LO Dibang Valley District, Arunachal Pradesh, lf ony third porty foils to oppeor in the heoring, it sholl be treoted that he/she has no objection in furnishinq of the information to the Appellont by the PlO. The PIO is directed to bring the authenticated Xerox copy of information sought at Sl.no. 1 of the Form-A in the next date of hearing. Whereas, the re-scheduled 2nd hearing was held on 16th March'2O2L. Dr. R.Tatan, PIO-cum-DMO, Roing, Lower Dibang Valley District, Arunachal Pradesh, all the 12 (twelve) nos of third party and the Appellant Shri Vijay Pertin were present during the hearing. Ms Aashipee Mimi & Ms Agu Ngusang representing the third party objected the disclosure of the Answer Scripts to the Appellant quoting the exemption provision U/S-S of the RTI Act 2005. But, they could not convince the Commission under which sub- section of the Section-8 of the RTI Act, exempts the disclosure of the Answer Scripts. Contd..p..3 -3- The Appellant informed the commission that there are so many complaints from the deprived candidates, their parents and public regarding the process of recruitment conducted for the Nursing officers under NHM, Roing Lower Dibang Valley Disrict, Arunachal Pradesh. The Appellant also highlighted about the scam that happened at Tezu regarding the process of recruitment for the Nursing officer and appealed the Commission to direct the PIO to furnish the Answer scripts of the selected candidates. whereas, the commission made it clear to the plo and the third parties that the Answer scripts sought by the Appellant relates to public interest and it is no more a confidential after the declaration of the results. so, for the cause of larger public interest and transparency, the commission, directed the plo to furnish the Answer Scripts of the selected candidates to the Appellant. All the Answer scripts, as sought by the Appellant in the Form-A was furnished to the Appellant during the hearing. The Appellant received the information and conveyed his satisfaction to the Commission. Therefore, the case is hereby disposed of. sd/- (Dr.Joram Begi) State Chief Information Commissioner Arunachal Pradesh Information Commission Itanagar Memo No.APlC-L65l2O2O Dated, ltanagar the March'202L Copy to: 1. The FAA-cum-Deputy commissioner, Roing, Lower Dibang Valley District, Arunachal Pradesh, 2. Dr. R.Tatan, Plo-cum-DMo, Roing, Lower Dibang Valley District, Arunachal Pradesh, 3. shri vijay Pertin, Vill; lthili, polps Roing, Lower Dibang Valley District, Arunachal Pradesh, pulu, 4. Ms. Ameya Pulu, c/o Late Toya Village Mayu-il, po & ps Roing, Lower Dibang Valley District, Arunachal pradesh, yalom pertin, 5. Ms. oyi Pertin, c/o Late Village Bolung, po & ps Roing, Lower Dibang Valley District, Arunachal pradesh, 6. Ms. Dam Dameng, C/o Mibang Dameng, Village Kangkong (Kalek), pO & pS Roing, Lower Dibang Valley District, Arunachal pradesh, 7. Ms. Amoni Damin, C/o Nombo Damin, Village Meka, pO & pS Roing, Lower Dibang Valley District, Arunachal pradesh. perying, 8. Ms. Ninggu Perying, c/o Late Ailen Viilage Jia-il, po & ps Roing, rower Dibang Valley District, Arunachal pradesh, 9. Ms. Ota Lego, C/o Late Aniyang Lego, Village poblung, Dambuk, pO & pS Roing, Lower Dibang Valley District, Arunachal pradesh. 10.Ms. Emey Mili, c/o Mukuli Mili, village Emuli, po & ps Roing, Lower Dibang Valley District, Arunachal pradesh. Contd..p..4 -4- PO & PS Roing' Lower 11.Ms. Nunu Tayeng, C/o Late Dayut Tayang, Village Kangkong' Dibang Valley District, Arunachal Pradesh, 12.Ms.AashipeeMimi,C/oMartinMimi,VillageAwali,PO&PSAnini'DibangValley District, Arunachal Pradesh, Lower Dibang L3.Ms. Episia Borang, C/o Okang Borang, Village Jia, PO & PS Roing' Valley District, Arunachal Pradesh, PO & PS Roing' 14.Ms. Ponung Apum, C/o Subash Apum, Village Poblung' Dambuk' Lower Dibang Valley District, Arunachal Pradesh, PS Roing' Lower Dibang 15.Ms. Agu Ngusang, C/o Bamgo Ngusang, Village Jia, PO & Valley District, Arunachal Pradesh, to upload in APIC Website' 116,Goffiputer Programmer, APIC, ltanagar, YT.Case file. Registrar / DY._Regis r, Arunachal Prade ii Commission.