The Impact of Pietism on Culture and Society in Germany

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Impact of Pietism on Culture and Society in Germany chapter 10 The Impact of Pietism on Culture and Society in Germany Martin H. Jung A hundred years ago, a German Protestant theologian, Horst Stephan, called Pietism a ‘motor of change in religion, culture and the general history of ideas’.1 In modern culture and theology Pietism is, however, still considered to be con- servative. The tradition goes back to Albrecht Ritschl, the famous Protestant scholar of the nineteenth century who wrote a three-volume history of the movement, and who regarded Pietism as a restoration of Catholic elements in Protestantism.2 Emphasizing the mystical and Quietist tendencies, and the desire for sanctification, Ritschl saw no positive impact of Pietism on cul- ture and society. Influenced by liberal theology, Ritschl wanted Protestantism to be a progressive cultural force, and he was, therefore, rather critical towards the historical role of Pietism. In the twentieth century, similar viewpoints have been put forward by, for instance, Hartmut Lehmann. In his first major book on the theme, published in 1969, this well-known German specialist on the topic regarded southwestern German Pietism, in particular, as mainly conser- vative, being Quietist and inert.3 Many more names could be listed, and many pages could be filled with clichés about Pietism. It is of course true, that Pietism did not start with the goal of changing cul- ture, politics, and academic work. It was a religious current or movement that was initiated to change piety, much more than theology, or culture, or society. In his famous book Pia desideria from 1675, the founder and first great propo- nent of the Pietist movement in Germany, the Lutheran minister Philip Jacob Spener (1635–1705), expressed – and demanded – a ‘heartfelt desire for a God- pleasing Reform of the true Evangelical Church, together with several simple Christian proposals looking toward this end’.4 Spener’s goal was to attain a lively faith, able to strengthen the spiritual life of the Christian people so miraculously that they would become an entirely different people. His starting point was to appeal to his fellow clergymen that ‘thought should be given to a 1 Stephan 1908. 2 Ritschl 1880–1886. 3 Lehmann 1969. 4 Spener 1964, p. 29. © koninklijke brill nv, leiden, ���6 | doi �0.��63/9789004303737_0�� <UN> 212 Jung more extensive use of the Word of God among us’.5 To achieve this goal he had several practical proposals: to promote ‘diligent reading of the Holy Scriptures’, ‘to encourage people to read privately’, ‘to reintroduce the ancient and apos- tolic kind of church meetings’.6 Thus Pietism set out to change forms and con- tent of Christian piety – and so it did. However, it came to change theology, too, as well as to have great impact on culture and society. What was Horst Stephan thinking of in 1908 when characterising Pietism as a ‘motor of change’? According to Stephan, Pietism had stimulated the evolu- tion within church, theology, and culture in a twofold way, on the one hand by destroying things that had become too old and outmoded, and, on the other hand, by laying strong and sound foundations for new developments. In the field of theology, Stephan pointed to a number of phenomena brought about by the Pietist movement: a better understanding of Martin Luther, a knowl- edge of religious cognition as being established by experience, a refusal of Aristotle’s philosophy as fundamental to theology, a new awareness of the strong position of the Bible, a concentration on Jesus Christ, and finally, an attention on faith as a lively belief. Within the field of church or ecclesiastical affairs, Stephan underlined the very many characteristics of the Pietist move- ment that point in a direction away from traditional Lutheran churches in Germany, dominated by a strong alliance between state and church authori- ties, in which the Christian people did not have very much influence. Topics pointed out by Stephan here include Presbyterian and synodal church struc- tures, religious associations, separation of state and church, strengthening reli- gious education in church and school, strengthening ethical and practical viewpoints in church life, the priesthood of all believers, the abolition of pri- vate confession, the preference of the Bible to the confessions of the church, the community idea, the opening towards other, and even strange forms of spirituality. While for Stephan things are clear in the fields of theology and church, it is more complicated in regard to culture. In a cultural respect, Stephan says, the Pietist movement only had dispositions and starting points, but was unable to produce something new with its own forces. Therefore it needed to go into connection with other cultural movements, especially with the moderate Enlightenment. Together, Pietism and Enlightenment achieved important results, first and foremost the establishment of freedom of conscience, the rise of lay institutions in the church, and the development of a new theology. 5 Ibid., p. 87. 6 Ibid., pp. 88–89. <UN>.
Recommended publications
  • Lutherans Respond to Pentecostalism
    TLC 4 TLC THEOLOgy in thE LifE OF thE Church Vol. 4 The spread and influence of diverse expressions of Pentecostalism through out the world, especially in Africa, is posing significant challenges to Lutheran as well as other churches. At a seminar of the Lutheran World Federation in South Africa, theologians discussed how they are responding to these challenges. Articles in this book highlight how some Lutheran convictions to Respond Pentecostalism Lutherans and understandings can counter, balance or expand upon Pentecostal beliefs and practices. Contributors include: J. Kwabena Asamoah-Gyadu, Ghana; Ibrahim Bitrus, Nigeria; Musawenkosi Biyela, South Africa; Samuel Dawai, Cameroon; Hans-Peter Grosshans, Germany; Guillermo Hansen, Argentina/USA; Paul John Isaak, Namibia/Switzerland; Rogate Mshana, Tanzania/Switzerland; Sarojini Nadar, South Africa; Cheryl S. Pero, USA; Gertrud Tönsing, South Africa; and Galana Babusa Yako, Kenya. Lutherans Respond The editor, Karen L. Bloomquist, directs the Department for Theology and Studies, LWF, Geneva, Switzerland. to Pentecostalism LWF The Lutheran World Federation – A Communion of Churches ISBN (Europe) 978-3-905676-68-6 DTS-Studies-201002-text.indd 10 02/03/2011 15:55:18 PM Lutherans Respond to Pentecostalism edited by Karen L. Bloomquist on behalf of the Lutheran World Federation— A Communion of Churches Lutheran University Press Minneapolis, Minnesota Previous volumes in the Theology in the Life of the Church series Karen L. Bloomquist (ed.), Being the Church in the Midst of Empire. Trinitarian Reflections Simone Sinn (ed.), Deepening Faith, Hope and Love in Relations with Neighbors of Other Faiths Karen L. Bloomquist (ed.), Identity, Survival, Witness. Reconfiguring Theological Agendas Lutherans Respond to Pentecostalism Theology in the Life of the Church, vol.
    [Show full text]
  • Defining Lutheranism from the Margins: Paul Peter Waldenström on Being a ‘Good Lutheran’ in America Mark Safstrom Augustana College, Rock Island Illinois
    Augustana College Augustana Digital Commons Scandinavian Studies: Faculty Scholarship & Scandinavian Studies Creative Works 2012 Defining Lutheranism from the Margins: Paul Peter Waldenström on Being a ‘Good Lutheran’ in America Mark Safstrom Augustana College, Rock Island Illinois Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.augustana.edu/scanfaculty Part of the History of Christianity Commons, Religious Thought, Theology and Philosophy of Religion Commons, and the Scandinavian Studies Commons Augustana Digital Commons Citation Safstrom, Mark. "Defining Lutheranism from the Margins: Paul Peter Waldenström on Being a ‘Good Lutheran’ in America" (2012). Scandinavian Studies: Faculty Scholarship & Creative Works. https://digitalcommons.augustana.edu/scanfaculty/3 This Published Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Scandinavian Studies at Augustana Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Scandinavian Studies: Faculty Scholarship & Creative Works by an authorized administrator of Augustana Digital Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Defining Lutheranism from the Margins: Paul Peter Waldenström on Being a “Good Lutheran” in America MARK SAFSTROM he histories of church institutions may often be written by the orthodox “winners,” but dissenters, protestors, and even her Tetics undoubtedly play important roles in giving direction to the parent institution’s evolving identity. Such voices from the mar- gins often set the agenda at crucial moments, prompting both the dissenters and establishment to engage in a debate to define proper theology and practice. Once a dissenting group has formally sepa- rated from a parent body, there is a risk that teleological hindsight will obscure the nature of these conversations, including the reasons for the ultimate separation and the intentions of both the dissenters and the establishment.
    [Show full text]
  • Pietism As an Ecclesiological Heresy
    Christos Yannaras Pietism as an Ecclesiological Heresy Chapter 8 of The Freedom of Morality (St Vladimir’s Seminary Press, Crestwood, NY: 1984), pp. 119-136. 1. The historical coordinates We give the name “pietism” to a phenomenon in church life which certainly has a particular historical and “confessional” starting point, but also has much wider ramifications in the spiritual life of all the Christian Churches. Pietism made its appearance as a distinct historical movement within Protestantism, at the end of the seventeenth and beginning of the eighteenth centuries, around 1690-1730.1 Its aim was to stress “practical piety,” as distinct from the polemical dogmatic theology to which the Reformation had initially given a certain priority.2 Against the intellectualist 120 1 There is a rich bibliography on pietism, chiefly in the form of monographs dealing with the numerous local pietistic movements and the personalities of their leaders. Although not very systematic, the fullest study of the phenomenon as a whole is still A. Ritschl’s three-volume work Geschichte des Pietismus (Bonn, 1880-1886). A recent work, exceptionally informative and well-documented, is Martin Schmidt’s Pietismus (1972). The Roman Catholic approach, with a concise, objective and reasonably full description of the phenomenon and history of pietism, may be found in Louis Bouyer, Orthodox Spirituality and Protestant and Anglican Spirituality (History of Christian Spirituality 111, London, 1969), p. 169ff. As for the rest of the bibliography, we note here some basic aids: W. Mahrholz, Der deutsche Pietismus (Berlin, 1921); H. Bornkamm, Mystik, Spiritualismus und die Anfänge des Pietismus im Luthertum (Giessen, 1926); M.
    [Show full text]
  • Depictions of Laestadianism 1850–1950
    ROALD E. KRISTIANSEN Depictions of Laestadianism 1850–1950 DOI: https://doi.org/10.30664/ar.87789 Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) he issue to be discussed here is how soci- country. Until 1905, Norway was united ety’s views of the Laestadian revival has with Sweden, and so what happened in changed over the course of the revival T Sweden was also important for Norway. movement’s first 100 years. The article claims that society’s emerging view of the revival is This was even the case for a fairly long time characterized by two different positions. The first after 1905, especially with regard to a reli­ period is typical of the last part of the nineteenth gious movement that united people from century and is characterized by the fact that three Nordic countries (Sweden, Finland the evaluation of the revival took as its point of departure the instigator of the revival, Lars Levi and Norway). Laestadius (1800–61). The characteristic of Laes- The Laestadian revival originated in tadius himself would, it was thought, be char- northern Sweden during the late 1840s, acteristic of the movement he had instigated. and was led by the parish minister of Kare­ During this first period, the revival was sharply criticized. This negative attitude gradually suando, Lars Levi Læstadius (1800–61). changed from the turn of the century onwards. Within a few years, the revival spread The second period is characterized by greater to the neighbouring countries Finland openness towards understanding the revival on and Norway. In Norway, most parishes its own premises.
    [Show full text]
  • Pietism and Liturgical Worship: an Evaluation Donald C
    Consensus Volume 16 Article 6 Issue 2 Lutheran Pietism 11-1-1990 Pietism and liturgical worship: an evaluation Donald C. Nevile Follow this and additional works at: http://scholars.wlu.ca/consensus Recommended Citation Nevile, Donald C. (1990) "Pietism and liturgical worship: an evaluation," Consensus: Vol. 16 : Iss. 2 , Article 6. Available at: http://scholars.wlu.ca/consensus/vol16/iss2/6 This Articles is brought to you for free and open access by Scholars Commons @ Laurier. It has been accepted for inclusion in Consensus by an authorized editor of Scholars Commons @ Laurier. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Pietism and Liturgical Worship An Evaluation Donald Nevile Pastor, Peace Lutheran Church, Pickering, Ontario Introduction Traditional historiography has often assumed an antithesis between scholastic Orthodoxy and Pietism: the former stresses the forensic, grace-oriented nature of justification, and the lat- ter emphasizes the human response to God’s offer of salvation. Tradition also assumes that this tension between Orthodoxy and Pietism extends into the realm of public worship. Pietists, we are told, have no concern for the historic liturgy of the church, downgrading the sacraments and formal worship in favour of preaching, free worship and the Inner Light. Con- versely, from some quarters we hear that the Orthodox are “chancel-prancers”, more concerned with correct vestments, posture, gesture, lights, and paraments, than with proclama- tion of the Gospel and the salvation of souls. This anti-Pietistic attitude has been evidenced by our most respected liturgical scholars. Luther Reed evaluates Pietism in this way: So far as ordered public worship was concerned, Pietism’s influ- ence was unfavorable.
    [Show full text]
  • MH-1986-April-Stoeffler.Pdf (8.516Mb)
    Methodist History, 24:3 (April 1986) RELIGIOUS ROOTS OF THE EARLY MORAVIAN AND METHODIST MOVEMENTS F. ERNEST STOEFFLER Late in November of 1741 Nikolaus Ludwig, Count and Lord of Zinzendorf and Pottendorf, came to America where some of his followers had been laboring for a number of years. Among other things he meant to bring to realization a dream which he cherished, but which to his less imaginative contemporaries seemed little short of being fantastic. He meant to establish what he called a "Fellowship of God in the Spirit," i.e., a group of cOlnmitted Christians belonging to various communions who would worship and work together in fellowship with their once crucified, but living Lord and with one another. It was a bold vision which could not materialize at the time because the Christians of that day were not ready for it. Yet, it is such a sense of Christian fellowship, and its accompanying percep­ \ tion of the need for ecumenical cooperation, which, having since dawned J upon substantial segments of Christendom, brings Moravian and Methodist together. We celebrate our unity in Christ by reiterating our common origins and reaffirming our common task, while acknowledging our separate histories and our unique contributions to the Christian enterprise. In this connection it seems to be my task to focus our attention upon the roots out of which the Moravian and Methodist movements grew. , . Essentially this necessitates taking a look at late seventeenth and early eight­ eenth century Europe as we see it in retrospect. Thus to gain a fully ade­ quate picture of the times out of which the movements in question have come we should really consider every facet of European culture which lies behind the origins of our two denominations.
    [Show full text]
  • A Journal of Lutheran Theology Contents
    LOGIA A JOURNAL OF LUTHERAN THEOLOGY REFORMATION 1999 VOLUME VIII. NUMBER 4 CONTENTS ARTICLES What Can Presbyterians Learn from Lutherans? D. G. Hart .... :........................................................................... ~ ..................................................................... Philip Jacob Speller and the Demise of the Practice of Holy Absolution in the Lutheran Church ' Gerald S. Krispin ............................................................................................................................................................................ 9 Liturgy and Pietism -Then and Now John T. Pless .................................................................................................................................................................................. 19 Map of the Kingdom of Piety Valentine Ernst Loescher, Translated by Matthew C. Harrison ............................................................................ ......... .......... 29 Oscar Feucht's Everyone a Minister: Pietism us RedivivitS"~-~'~'---""" . Brent Kuhlman ............................................................... ,..................... :............... :, ............... ,....... :.................... ,... ,.. ,.. " ............. ,.. 31 The Lutheran Confessions on the Holy Ministry with a Few Thoughts on Hoefling David P. Scaer ................. ,.......................................................................................... ,........................... ,.,'....................................
    [Show full text]
  • The Journal of Biblical Soul Care
    Fall 2017 | Volume 1 | Number 1 masters.edu/jbsc THE JOURNAL OF BIBLICAL SOUL CARE Advancing Scholarship for the Biblical Care of Souls within Higher Education. ARTICLES Editorial: Introduction, Purpose, A Case for Religious Liberty in Soul Care and Overview 4 From a Historical Perspective 34 Greg E. Gifford T. Dale Johnson Luther’s Contribution to Sola Scriptura and More than Preachers: The Solas and Soul-Care Biblical Sufficiency of the Reformers John D. Street 16 Stuart Scott 56 REVIEWS Review: Sinclair Ferguson’s Devoted to God Joe Keller 74 RESPONSES This journal is dedicated to the generation of men and women whose commitment to the Word of God and care of souls has laid the groundwork for a resurgence of biblical soul care. The Journal of Biblical Soul Care is a reflection of your dedication to the sufficient Word of God and its ability to speak into the complexities of human nature and experience. The editorial team desires to promote Christian scholarship in the wake of your effective reorganization and apologetic of biblical soul care. —For Christ and Scripture, The Editorial Board General Editors John D. Street Stuart Scott Managing Editor Greg E. Gifford Assistant Editors Daniel Schubert, Content Edward Wilde, Content Jeff L. Miller, Content Shelbi Cullen, Copy Todd Sorrell, Copy All Rights Reserved Copyright (C) 2017 The Master’s University 21726 Placenta Canyon Road Santa Clarita, CA 91321 [email protected] Permissions Policy: Permission required for any duplication, printing, or supplemental resources. Any alteration of the content is strictly prohibited. The articles of the JBSC are solely the property of the JBSC, and all permission requests must be sent to [email protected].
    [Show full text]
  • The Word-Of-God Conflict in the Lutheran Church Missouri Synod in the 20Th Century
    Luther Seminary Digital Commons @ Luther Seminary Master of Theology Theses Student Theses Spring 2018 The Word-of-God Conflict in the utherL an Church Missouri Synod in the 20th Century Donn Wilson Luther Seminary Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.luthersem.edu/mth_theses Part of the Christian Denominations and Sects Commons, and the History of Christianity Commons Recommended Citation Wilson, Donn, "The Word-of-God Conflict in the utherL an Church Missouri Synod in the 20th Century" (2018). Master of Theology Theses. 10. https://digitalcommons.luthersem.edu/mth_theses/10 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Student Theses at Digital Commons @ Luther Seminary. It has been accepted for inclusion in Master of Theology Theses by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons @ Luther Seminary. For more information, please contact [email protected], [email protected]. THE WORD-OF-GOD CONFLICT IN THE LUTHERAN CHURCH MISSOURI SYNOD IN THE 20TH CENTURY by DONN WILSON A Thesis Submitted to the Faculty of Luther Seminary In Partial Fulfillment, of The Requirements for the Degree of MASTER OF THEOLOGY THESIS ADVISER: DR. MARY JANE HAEMIG ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 2018 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Dr. Mary Jane Haemig has been very helpful in providing input on the writing of my thesis and posing critical questions. Several years ago, she guided my independent study of “Lutheran Orthodoxy 1580-1675,” which was my first introduction to this material. The two trips to Wittenberg over the January terms (2014 and 2016) and course on “Luther as Pastor” were very good introductions to Luther on-site.
    [Show full text]
  • Pietism and Mission: Lutheran Millennialism in the Eighteenth and Nineteenth Centuries Lawrence R
    Volume 64:4 October 2000 Table of Contents Eschatology and Fanaticism in the Reformation Era: Luther and the Anabaptists Carter Lindberg ............................... 259 Death and Resurrection as Apocalyptic Event David P. Scaer ................................279 Pietism and Mission: Lutheran Millennialism in the Eighteenth and Nineteenth Centuries Lawrence R. Rast Jr. ........................... 295 Sectarian Apocalypticism in Mainline Christianity Larry Nichols ................................. 319 Theological Observer ............................... 336 Out of the Mouths of Babes - Almost Rediscovering the Treatise as Ecumenical Response ....................................... David P. Scaer Book Reviews ...................................... 345 New England's Moral Legislator: Timothy Dwight, 1752-181 7. By John R. Fitzrnier .......... Lawrence R. Rast Jr. When God Becomes My Enemy: The Theology of the Complaint Psalms. By Ingvar Flqsvik. ..................................Chad L. Bird The Fabricated Luther: The Rise and Fall of the Shiver Myth. By Uwe Siemon-Netto. .......... Lowell C. Green Preaching Christ from the Old Testament: A Contemporary Hermeneutical Method. By Sidney Greidanus. ......................., ... Carl C. Fickenscher I1 Pietism and Mission: Lutheran Millennialism in the Eighteenth and Nineteenth Centuries Lawrence R. Rast Jr. Introduction A noted historian of Christianity in the United States assessed the influence of pietism in the following sweeping terms: "There is no area of American life which is free from our pietistic concern; none in which the pietistic attitude is not a significant factor."' Pietism is part of the atmosphere Americans breathe. Believing that style does, in fact, inform substance, it is not too much to say that pietistic practice has significantly formed the theology and practice of American Chri~tianity.~As a distinctly American church, The Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod has also been formed in fundamental ways by pietism.
    [Show full text]
  • Pietism and the Challenges of Modernity
    occasional papers of the chester ronning centre ————————————————— I ————————————————— Pietism and the Challenges of Modernity R lectures by David J. Goa — Cam Harder Eugene L. Boe the chester ronning centre for the study of religion and public life THE CHESTER RONNING CENTRE FOR THE STUDY OF RELIGION AND PUBLIC LIFE augustana campus, university of alberta OUR PURPOSE To cultivate a deeper understanding of issues and themes at the intersection of religion, faith, and public life and to do so in the academy, in the public forum, and in religious communities. OUR MISSION To establish a hospitable ambience in which women and men of faith and of social concern are encouraged to join in a continuing conversation on the relationship between religion and public life. OUR GOAL To focus and inform the thinking of all who deal with issues and themes where religious faith and public life intersect, and to enhance public com­ prehension and religious understanding on these subjects. We will do this through promoting • interdisciplinary research, meetings, and publications that foster an active community of discourse among scholars and public intellectuals on issues that arise where religion and public life come into contact; • ethical reflection that draws on religious as well as secular sources in addressing such themes as human rights, our care for the life of the world, and our appreciation of di:erences among cultures; • understanding among public figures of the broad significance of religious perspectives for the shaping of public policy; and • awareness within religious communities of the fragile and complex nature of the public sphere in a pluralistic world.
    [Show full text]
  • Radical Pietism and Early German Methodism: John Seybert and the Evangelical Association
    Methodist Histoty, 37:3 (April 1999) RADICAL PIETISM AND EARLY GERMAN METHODISM: JOHN SEYBERT AND THE EVANGELICAL ASSOCIATION SCOTT KISKER Methodism's indebtedness to continental Pietism, though often ne­ glected, has been fairly well established. Martin .Schmidt has show_n the importance of Pietism to the spiritual development of John Wesley. F. Ernest Stoeffler and W. R. Ward have both located the origins of the 18th century Methodist re-vivals in the Pietist movements which swept continental Protestantism in the 17th and early 18th centuries. Steven ()'Malley has focused scholarly attention on the Pietist roots of the Evangelical United Brethren traditions within United Methodism. Generally these connections are made to Pietism's churchly (and more respectable) forms which ema­ nated from Halle and Herrnhut during the 17th and 18th centuries. With regard to one source of German-American Methodism (the Evangelic.al Association), the connection is better made to more radical forms-those with sectarian and chiliastic leanings. Martin Schrag, in his essay,"The Impact of Pietism Upon the Mennon­ ites in Early American Christianity," draws a common distinction between "church-related Pietism" and ''radical Pietism." Church-related Pietists, such as the Spener-Halle movement, worked within the framework of orthodox Protestant theology and established churches. 1 Schrag has argued that both Philip William Otterbein and Martin Boehm fall most neatly into this cate­ gory of Pietists. ''When Otterbein and Boehm began their work, they had no intention of starting a new denomination. They sought to transform individ­ uals and thus revitalize the church, not actualize a new church.''2 Radical Pietism, on the other hands has been defined by Chauncy Dayid Ensign as ''That branch of the pietisitic movement in Germany, which empha­ sized separatistic, sectarian and mystical elements, particularly those origi­ nating in Boehmenism."3 Most scholars who have studied radical Pietism \ 'Martin H.
    [Show full text]