DOCSLIB.ORG

Depoliticizing Discourses the Role of Editorials in the Reproduction of Consensus: Assessing the Media Coverage of the Yellow Vest Movement

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Depoliticizing Discourses the Role of Editorials in the Reproduction of Consensus: Assessing the Media Coverage of the Yellow Vest Movement Depoliticizing discourses The role of editorials in the reproduction of consensus: assessing the media coverage of the Yellow Vest movement Mathilde Colin Human rights Bachelor thesis 15 ECTS Spring term 2019 Supervisor: Jonna Pettersson 1 Abstract The purpose of this thesis was to study how Yellow Vest protests, which started 17 November 2018, and protesters themselves, were being described in the French mainstream press. The material consisted in 19 editorials from 5 of the most-circulated newspapers in the country. They were analyzed using Norman Fairclough’s model of critical discourse analysis and within a theoretical framework drawn from Chantal Mouffe’s discussion of the notion of consensus. The findings suggest that the mainstream discourse on Yellow Vests is one which denies their legitimacy within the political realm through a process of depoliticization supported by discourses of contempt, republicanism, and unity. This study illustrates the struggle of protesters to be granted space and legitimacy within contemporary democracies to properly exercise their civil and political rights. Keywords: consensus, democracy, France, media, Yellow Vests Word count: 14145 2 List of Abbreviations ACPM – Alliance for press and media figures (Alliance pour les chiffres de la presse et des médias) CDA – Critical Discourse Analysis EU – European Union FN – National Front (Front National, now RN, Rassemblement National) IGF – General Inspectorate of Finances (Inspection Générale des Finances) IGPN – General Inspectorate of the National Police (Inspectorat Général de la Police Nationale) LFI – Unbowed France (La France Insoumise) LR – The Republicans (Les Républicains) LREM – The Republic on the Move (La République en Marche) PS – Socialist Party (Parti Socialiste) RIC – People's Referendum (Référendum d'Initiative Citoyenne) RWB – Reporters Without Borders TICPE – Domestic consumption tax on energy products (Taxe intérieure de consommation sur les produits énergétiques) UN – United Nations 3 Table of Contents 1. Introduction ....................................................................................................................................... 5 1.1 Introduction to the topic .................................................................................................................... 5 1.2 Research aim and questions .............................................................................................................. 6 1.3 Relevance to human rights ................................................................................................................ 7 1.3.1 The overall context of repression .............................................................................................. 7 1.3.2 Media, protest movements and human rights: the “guard dogs” perspective ........................... 9 1.4 Delimitations ................................................................................................................................... 10 1.5 Thesis outline .................................................................................................................................. 11 2. Context ............................................................................................................................................. 12 2.1 French politics ................................................................................................................................. 12 2.1.1 The political system ................................................................................................................ 12 2.1.2 The political culture ................................................................................................................ 13 2.1.3 Emmanuel Macron's election .................................................................................................. 15 2.2 French media ................................................................................................................................... 16 2.2.1 The media system ................................................................................................................... 16 2.2.2 The role and status of the editorial .......................................................................................... 18 2.3 The Yellow Vest movement ........................................................................................................... 19 3. Literature review ............................................................................................................................ 22 3.1 Media and protest movements ........................................................................................................ 22 3.2 News coverage of protest in French media ..................................................................................... 23 4. Theoretical framework ................................................................................................................... 26 4.1 Defining consensus ......................................................................................................................... 26 4.2 Jürgen Habermas' theory of communicative action ........................................................................ 26 4.3 Chantal Mouffe's model of agonistic democracy ............................................................................ 26 5. Methodology .................................................................................................................................... 29 5.1 Critical discourse analysis ............................................................................................................... 29 5.1.1 Norman Fairclough's framework ............................................................................................ 29 5.1.2 Norman Fairclough's perspective on media discourse ............................................................ 30 5.2 Introduction to the media material .................................................................................................. 31 5.3 Data collection ................................................................................................................................ 34 5.4 Ethical considerations ..................................................................................................................... 34 6. Analysis ............................................................................................................................................ 36 6.1 Discourse of contempt .................................................................................................................... 36 6.2 Discourse of republicanism ............................................................................................................. 40 6.3 Discourse of unity ........................................................................................................................... 43 7. Conclusions ...................................................................................................................................... 46 Appendix 1: List of editorials ............................................................................................................. 48 Bibliography ........................................................................................................................................ 49 4 1. Introduction 1.1 Introduction to the topic On April 17, 2017, President-to-be Emmanuel Macron gave a speech in the AccorHotels Arena, east of Paris. “You have understood it,” the En Marche ! candidate President tells the crowd. “We will have to, at the same time, live, work, and learn. Excuse me, you have probably noticed, I said: at the same time.” Immediately, the crowd laughs, applauses, and starts shouting “At the same time!” (en même temps). “Some say it’s a verbal tic,” Macron continues. “But that it’s a verbal tic that means I am not clear [...] because, you know, some people like boxes, categorized ideologies [...] well, I will keep using ‘at the same time’ because it means that we take into account imperatives [...] whose conciliation is indispensable. [...] I chose the best of the right and the best of the left.” Just under a year before that speech, Chantal Mouffe’s On The Political was translated into French under the title L’illusion du consensus (‘The Illusion of Consensus’)1. The essay tackles the post-political Zeitgest which she argues denies existing antagonisms. According to Mouffe, the nature of consensus is not to be accommodating, a one-size-fits-all, win-win solution to complex issues, but rather, “all forms of consensus are by necessity based on acts of exclusion2.” In response to antagonism, rather than referring to the inherently depoliticizing notions of consensus and of the ‘end of history,’ Mouffe argues, “a central task of democratic politics is to provide the institutions which will permit conflicts to take an ‘agonistic’ form, where the opponents are not enemies but adversaries among whom exists a conflictual consensus3.” In other words, in pluralist democracies, institutions are to accommodate antagonisms. Just over a year after that speech, the Yellow Vest movement emerged, granting the “President of consensus” with all-time low rates of approval4. Originally a tax revolt protesting raising diesel fuel prices, the Yellow Vest movement would become an all- encompassing protest which, rather than opposing a specific law or draft law,
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Nuit Debout: a Nova Barricada De Paris?
    Nuit Debout: a nova barricada de Paris? Marcia Camargos ontra as minas terrestres, a caça aos animais selva- gens, o abate de bovinos, “que sofrem como nós”, contra o apartheid palestino, a perseguição aos curdos, a insegurança no bairro chinês, a islamo- fobia, a violência de Estado, as guerras, a Lei do Trabalho ou o governo golpista de Michel Temer. Escolha a sua causa e levante a sua bandeira. Na Place de la République, na interseção entre três distritos, os arrondissements da capital francesa, cabem todos os protestos. Local preferido dos insatisfeitos de plantão, ela tornou-se o ponto de partida ou chegada das manifestações cada vez mais frequentes na cidade. Isso, apesar do Estado de urgência em vigor, dando poderes extraordinários à polícia e proibindo as aglomerações. Resposta do governo François Hollande aos atentados terroristas que se abateram sobre a França, e medida preventi- va contra futuros ataques, foi decretado na tarde de 14 de novembro de 2015 em todo o território nacional. Oficialmente ainda em vigor, acabou re- C laxado, pouco a pouco, diante da crescente pres- MARCIA CAMARGOS é jornalista e escritora com pós-doutorado em História pela USP. Revista USP • São Paulo • n. 111 • p. 169-172 • outubro/novembro/dezembro 2016 169 textos / Homenagem são da opinião pública, dos movimentos sociais e e da prosperidade. Na esquerda repousa uma tábua dos sindicatos, que contestam as interdições. Dia com as inscrição “Droits de l’Homme”. sim, dia não, eles fecham o trânsito com passeatas Originalmente Place du Château d’Eau, de todo tipo e tamanho que, não raro, terminam nome derivado da enorme fonte de 1811, saída em confrontos com a polícia, além de detenções da prancheta de Pierre-Simon Girard para trazer e feridos.
    [Show full text]
  • MEDIA POLARIZATION “À LA FRANÇAISE”? Comparing the French and American Ecosystems
    institut montaigne MEDIA POLARIZATION “À LA FRANÇAISE”? Comparing the French and American Ecosystems REPORT MAY 2019 MEDIA POLARIZATION “À LA FRANÇAISE” MEDIA POLARIZATION There is no desire more natural than the desire for knowledge MEDIA POLARIZATION “À LA FRANÇAISE”? Comparing the French and American Ecosystems MAY 2019 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY In France, representative democracy is experiencing a growing mistrust that also affects the media. The latter are facing major simultaneous challenges: • a disruption of their business model in the digital age; • a dependence on social networks and search engines to gain visibility; • increased competition due to the convergence of content on digital media (competition between text, video and audio on the Internet); • increased competition due to the emergence of actors exercising their influence independently from the media (politicians, bloggers, comedians, etc.). In the United States, these developments have contributed to the polarization of the public square, characterized by the radicalization of the conservative press, with significant impact on electoral processes. Institut Montaigne investigated whether a similar phenomenon was at work in France. To this end, it led an in-depth study in partnership with the Sciences Po Médialab, the Sciences Po School of Journalism as well as the MIT Center for Civic Media. It also benefited from data collected and analyzed by the Pew Research Center*, in their report “News Media Attitudes in France”. Going beyond “fake news” 1 The changes affecting the media space are often reduced to the study of their most visible symp- toms. For instance, the concept of “fake news”, which has been amply commented on, falls short of encompassing the complexity of the transformations at work.
    [Show full text]
  • '68 to Nuit Debout: Shifting Perspectives on France's Anti-Police
    From mai-juin ’68 to Nuit Debout: Shifting perspectives on France’s anti-police Chris Reynolds, Nottingham Trent University Abstract In the great drama that was mai-juin 1968, the police were unquestionably a central actor. In particular, they played a pivotal role in transforming what started out as a relatively minor, student-based rebellion into a nationwide movement that brought the Gaullist regime to the brink of collapse. The 2016 Nuit Debout protest movement drew strong comparisons to the 1968 events with many wondering if France stood to experience a repeat of those heady days. This article will argue that the inability of Nuit Debout to capture the imagination of the general public in a similar fashion to what happened in 1968 is not solely the result of the exceptional and divergent contexts. Instead, it will contend that this failure is also to be understood through an appreciation of shifting perspectives on France’s anti-police. Such positive developments, it will be argued, have ironically been shaped as a result of the 1968 events and the manner with which they are most commonly remembered. La police était un acteur indéniablement principal dans les événements de mai-juin 1968 en France. En particulier, ils ont joué un rôle critique dans la transformation d’une crise étudiante, relativement mineur, en un mouvement national qui a poussée le régime gaulliste jusqu’au bord du gouffre. Le mouvement Nuit Debout de 2016 a été très souvent comparé aux événements de 1968 avec beaucoup qui se demandaient si la France risquait une répétition de cette crise phare.
    [Show full text]
  • Putting the Policing of Nuit Debout in Context
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Bournemouth University Research Online International Journal of Communication 12(2018), 1887–1907 1932–8036/20180005 Activist Reflexivity and Mediated Violence: Putting the Policing of Nuit Debout in Context ANNA FEIGENBAUM Bournemouth University, UK PATRICK MCCURDY University of Ottawa, Canada To better understand the historical trajectory of the policing of Nuit Debout, in this article we argue that the reflexive relationship between police and protest tactics is heavily mediated by the presence of the press and by the emergence of digital technologies. Our analysis focuses on three sets of reflexive activist practice: (a) challenging media representations—the adaptations and innovations that respond to dominant media framing of police–protester relations; (b) “sousveillance” and police monitoring—the recording and monitoring of police violence and the public education around the police’s use of force; (c) civic forensics and data aggregation—the gathering, analyzing, and collectivizing of citizen-generated data. Although not intended as a taxonomy, these groups of practices are offered as conceptual lenses for critically examining how activists’ tactical repertoires for protesting police adapt and evolve, building on each other to challenge the representational, legal, and material dimensions of state power as it manifests in police–protester relations. Keywords: policing, social movements, riot control, protest, Nuit Debout The riot police—CRS—cut off the march in two, supposedly because there were some dangerous elements in the front—I don’t know if it’s true. They blocked us around 45 minutes. When they finally let us pass, some of the protesters got angry and started throwing things on the police.
    [Show full text]
  • Macron's Authoritarian Turn?
    POLICY OUTLOOK POLICY OUTLOOK DISCUSSION PAPER Macron’s Authoritarian Turn? The Potential Impact of ‘la loi relative à la sécurité globale’ on Civil Liberties in France Anna Murphy (Julien Mattia - Anadolu Agency) Over the course of the Macron presidency, France has seen what almost seems like a continous wave of popular demonstrations. This policy outlook examines the contents and implications of ‘la loi relative à la sécurité globale’, the comprehensive security law that has sparked the most recent display of anti-government anger. The outlook analyses some of the most controversial components of the bill, including a clause that partially bans the filming of police officers, and positions them within a broader political shift in the country. The opinions expressed in this policy outlook represent the views of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the TRT World Research Centre. POLICY OUTLOOK Background On November 24th, the French National Assembly vot- ed to approve la proposition de loi relative à la sécurité globale (comprehensive security law). Within hours, thou- sands across Paris and several other French cities took to the streets in a widespread display of opposition to the draft law. While similar scenes of civil unrest have become a familiar sight in France over the last few years, this new bill has garnered a particularly strong reaction from par- ties both inside and outside of the country due to the inclu- sion of several controversial articles. Namely, Article 24 of (Julien Mattia - Anadolu Agency) the draft law criminalises “disseminating, by any means or medium whatsoever, with the aim of harming their physi- cacy.
    [Show full text]
  • Nuit Debout: Frankreich Gerät in Bewegung!
    Felix Syrovatka Nuit Debout: Frankreich gerät in Bewegung! Am frühen Morgen des 11 . April 2016 konstant hohe Arbeitslosigkeit auf, die räumte die Polizei die Place de la Répub- gleichzeitig mit einer Verschärfung der lique im Herzen von Paris und zerstörte räumlichen Ungleichheit beim Zugang zu Zelte und Infrastruktur der noch jungen öffentlichen Dienstleistungen verbunden französischen Bewegung Nuit Debout ist . Ebenso kam es, wie Boltanski und („Die Nacht erhebt sich“) . Doch schon Chiapello (2006) darlegen, seit Ende der am selben Abend protestierten wieder 1980er Jahre zu einem radikalen Wandel Tausende gegen die Arbeitsmarktpolitik der Arbeitsverhältnisse, der mit einem der sozialistischen Regierung . Ausgangs- kontinuierlichen Anstieg von befristeten punkt waren die Demonstrationen Ende Arbeitsverhältnissen und Leiharbeit ver- März, an deren Anschluss mehrere hundert bunden war . Zwischen 1985 und 2001 Menschen die Place de la République be- stieg allein die Anzahl der durch Leiharbeit setzten und anfingen, eine Infrastruktur geleisteten Stunden um 506 Prozent (Del- aufzubauen . Vernetzt über die sozialen bar/Léonard 2002: 6) . Im Jahr 2014 lag der Medien, wie Facebook und Twitter, brei- Anteil befristeter Arbeitsverträge bei Neu- teten sich die Platzbesetzungen in mehr als einstellungen bei 84 Prozent, der höchste 60 französischen Städten, darunter allen Wert in der gesamten EU . Zugleich ist der großen, aus . Selbst in traditionell eher kon- Arbeitsmarkt heute durch eine hohe struk- servativeren Städten wie Nizza existieren turelle Arbeitslosigkeit geprägt und stark Ableger der Nuit-Debout-Bewegung . fragmentiert . Junge Menschen, Frauen Anfang der 1990er Jahre überschritt oder MigrantInnen werden durch dieses die Arbeitslosenquote die Zehn-Prozent- System der prekären Beschäftigung dis- Marke und zementierte die Arbeitslosig- kriminiert und vom Arbeitsmarkt ausge- keit als drängendstes Problem .
    [Show full text]
  • Strange Speech: Structures of Listening in Nuit Debout, Occupy, and 15M
    International Journal of Communication 12(2018), 1840–1863 1932–8036/20180005 Strange Speech: Structures of Listening in Nuit Debout, Occupy, and 15M JESSICA FELDMAN Stanford University, USA Practices and techniques of listening were at the core of recent social movements that explicitly espoused horizontal direct democracy: 15M, Occupy Wall Street, and Nuit Debout. These movements sought to imagine nonhierarchical structures through which large groups of strangers could speak and listen to each other, considering seriously the coconstruction of communicative form and political values. Drawing on participant observation; 23 long-form interviews with social movement actors in Paris, Madrid, and New York City; and texts such as video documentation and “best practices” literature, this article performs a comparative analysis of internal assembly communications— particularly bodily mediated methods of transmitting and perceiving spoken language— and their relationships to deliberation and decision making. All of these movements struggled to reconcile the mandate to listen with the material and infrastructural challenges of autonomous public space. Nuit Debout’s strong commitment to accommodating those who could not comfortably participate in an occupation (day laborers, sans-papiers, disabled, etc.) caused its internal communication practices to differ in its attempts to conserve time and to prioritize translation. Keywords: social movements, listening, voice, Nuit Debout, Occupy Wall Street, 15M, horizontal democracy In order to enter into political exchange, it becomes necessary to invent the scene upon which spoken words may be audible, in which objects may be visible, and individuals themselves may be recognized. —Rancière, Dissenting Words (Panagia & Rancière, 2000, p. 118) Starting in late 2010, an upsurge of publicly sited social movements, broadly termed “the movements of the squares,” attempted to solve the problems of democratic deliberation, public speaking, and group listening.
    [Show full text]
  • Bibliodebout: a Collaborative Library in a Social Movement Raphaëlle Bats, Marilou Pain
    Bibliodebout: a collaborative library in a social movement Raphaëlle Bats, Marilou Pain To cite this version: Raphaëlle Bats, Marilou Pain. Bibliodebout: a collaborative library in a social movement. Bobcatsss 2017, Jan 2017, Tampere, Finland. hal-01496139 HAL Id: hal-01496139 https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01496139 Submitted on 27 Mar 2017 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents entific research documents, whether they are pub- scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, lished or not. The documents may come from émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de teaching and research institutions in France or recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires abroad, or from public or private research centers. publics ou privés. Title: Bibliodebout: a collaborative library in a social movement Authors: Raphaëlle Bats, Univ.Lyon, Centre Gabriel Naudé, Enssib, Lyon, & Univ Paris Cité, LCSP, Paris 7, Paris, France, [email protected] Marilou Pain, Enssib / Center for Direct Scientific Communication (CCSD), [email protected] An unexpected political mobilisation leads to the occupation of a large number of public squares in French cities from the end of March to July 2016. In those Nuits Debout, a collective starts up BiblioDebout, a participative library working on a gift basis. Trough participative observations and text analysis of the collective’s mailing lists, this paper studies how BiblioDebout expresses a specific relationship between knowledge and power, and, therefore, emancipation. BiblioDebout is utopian, egalitarian, emotional and experimental, and so on could be an inspiration for public libraries willing to renew with their political vocation.
    [Show full text]
  • Ministerial Meetin on Mi Ration and Inte Ration January , Paris WHO's
    Ministerial Meetin on Miration and Interation January , Paris WHO’S WHO Contents Chair ........................................................................................................................................................ 2 Vice-Chairs .............................................................................................................................................. 3 Participating countries ............................................................................................................................ 5 European Union .................................................................................................................................... 36 International Organisations .................................................................................................................. 37 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) ................................................... 41 Chair Switzerland Ms. Karin Keller-Sutter Federal Councillor, Chair of the Ministerial Copyright: KEYSTONE Christian Beutler. KEYSTONE Copyright: Federal Councillor Karin Keller-Sutter was born in 1963 and is from the canton of St. Gallen, Switzerland. She attended school in Wil and Neuchâtel. Karin Keller-Sutter is a trained translator/interpreter and secondary school teacher. Between 1989 and 2000, she worked as a freelance translator and also taught at a vocational school. Karin Keller-Sutter began her political career in 1992 as a member of Wil town Council and was elected to the cantonal
    [Show full text]
  • Faculty Achievements 2018
    THE AMERICAN UNIVERSITY OF PARIS FACULTY ACHIEVEMENTS 2018 Professor Ziad Majed presenting as part of the student-organized Migration Conference at the Hôtel de Talleyrand, May 2018 1 FOREWORD The many achievements of AUP’s faculty have led to 2018 being another landmark year for the University’s growing academic reputation. This brochure, which presents inspiring interdisciplinary research from across the liberal arts, is evidence of the full depth and breadth of scholarship at AUP. The work produced by faculty compellingly 15 addresses many of the world’s most pressing books issues, most probing questions and most important challenges, while encouraging students to engage with these concerns both inside and outside the classroom. The scholarly output of AUP’s faculty covers a more than wide array of subjects, and their research findings have an impact at both the local and global scale. Their creative endeavors are equally important; 140 AUP’s artists, writers and filmmakers contribute articles at an international level, producing works that tackle major societal questions while maintaining a social conscience. An important element of faculty success is evident in the collaborations that take place between over faculty and students – be this on study trips, via research projects or through mentoring student clubs. An inquisitive and intellectual pedagogical 240 approach, such as the one upheld by our AUP presentations In recent years, AUP has emerged community, allows creativity to flourish. An as a leader in the American emphasis on respecting diverse viewpoints and practicing varied methods of inquiry further allows international university for innovation in this collaborative work.
    [Show full text]
  • Jean-Luc Mélenchon and France Insoumise: the Manufacturing of Populism
    Jean-Luc Mélenchon and France Insoumise: the manufacturing of populism Philippe Marlière ‘Jean-Luc Mélenchon and France Insoumise: The Manufacturing of Populism’, in Giorgos Katsambekis, Alexandros Kioupkiolis (eds), The Populist Radical Left in Europe, London, Routledge, 2018. ******** Abstract In the run-up to the 2017 presidential election in France, Jean-Luc Mélenchon who, so far, had been associated with the radical left, formed a new movement called France Insoumise (Unbowed France - FI). Mélenchon’s populist strategy in launching FI was blatant. This was an attempt to organise the masses along the lines of an agonistic cleavage between ‘the people’ and ‘the elite’, and this was also a radical break with the collective forms of leadership and action on the French left. The gamble paid off as Mélenchon received significant support from segments of left-wing voters in the first round of the presidential election. In true populist fashion, the FI leader wants to federate ‘the people’, and not simply left-wing voters. He has ceased to use the notion of left altogether. What defines FI’s populism is the role and the centrality of the leader. One may wonder whether populism is the best strategy to broaden the left’s electorate as left-wing and right-wing populisms do not tap in the same culture and do not express the same feelings. On the left, the anger is directed at free market economics. On the far right, the hatred of foreigners and immigrants is the main motivation. Both 1 feelings and mindsets are incompatible: the former has a positive mindset whereas the latter is based on resentment.
    [Show full text]
  • Bodies, Spaces, Actions (Steven Cohen, Femen, Nuit Debout) Michel Briand
    Choreographic/Political Performances: Bodies, Spaces, Actions (Steven Cohen, Femen, Nuit debout) Michel Briand Abstract:Choreographic activism could be exemplified by three case studies: performances by Steven Cohen, esp. Coq/Cock, 2013; “sextremist” actions by the Femen, since 2012; Nuit debout (“Up all night!”), a democratic forum at the Place de la République, 2016. Some issues are crucial here: “dancing” social and political conflict and ethical/aesthetical interactions; deconstructing/constructing heterotopic spaces and utopian bodies; carnivalesque interplays of irony, critical thinking, spectacular celebration and denunciation; dialectics of discursive and synesthetic pragmatic and negotiation. These performances may also compare to anti-AIDS actions. This paper intends to study choreographic activism or artivism (i.e. art activism) in three context-specific case studies, considered through three main pragmatic perspectives: - Occupying and building up (heterotopic) spaces and times: where? when? - Standing up against and for (esthetic, ethic, and political) values : what? - Queering bodies, discourses, identities, and communities: who? how? But I first would like to state some epistemological and methodological prolegomena about the relation between dance and politics, relying both on ancient, esp. Greek, and recent scholarship on aestheticizing politics and politicizing aesthetics. Politics and dance: humanity and space, dissensus, carnival 1. The Aristotelian definition of human being as phúsei zoon politikón (“a political animal by nature”), in Politics 1253a1-11, implies that a person defines her/himself both as an animal (with a sensitive and practical body as well as embodied psychology, cognition, and thought) and as a part of an organized group (a pólis, not “town”, like ástu, but “city”, that is a “public body” ideally based on eleuthería - freedom, autonomía – self-governance, and koinonía - mutuality).
    [Show full text]