Program of Study the Earliest Christian Missionaries to Mizoram, the State at the Southernmost Tip of India's Easternmost Fron
Total Page：16
File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb
Program of Study The earliest Christian missionaries to Mizoram, the state at the southernmost tip of India’s easternmost frontier, are today regional heroes. Stone memorials of their visits rise up along roadsides, their portraits hang above hospital rooms, their hair clippings are preserved behind glass. Even schoolchildren’s sports teams are named in their honour. Histories of Mizoram place these British missionaries and administrators in the foreground, while Mizos remain two-dimensional stock characters in the background. This project aims not to follow the British missionaries of the mid-1890s but rather to face them, and to turn towards the Mizo as a corrective to our usual, British perspective on Mizoram’s contact with Christianity. The introduction to Mizoram of Western biomedicine features prominently in the writings of early missionaries. However, Mizo responses to it, whether as a technology of health or as a missionary tool of salvation, have not yet been investigated. Unlike the usual focus on religious ‘worldviews’, medicine provides us with a limited and concrete case study, but one just as intensely wrapped up in religiosity, both Christian and Mizo. As historian David Hardiman notes, mission medicine “was not carried out for a purely medical purpose, but used as a beneficent means to spread Christianity.”1 Indeed, in Mizoram it was at the missionaries’ medicine dispensary itself that the names of those wishing to become Christians were to be handed in.2 At the same time, author C. G. Verghese rightly points out that traditional Mizo religiosity itself was centred on the healing of the sick.3 The old question of religious interaction in Mizoram can thus be approached from a new angle with the concrete question: what sparks flew when two cultures of healing hit head-on in Mizoram? Through a careful and empathetic re-reading of colonial sources for clues to the responses of the Mizos (a people then without a writing system of their own), and through mobilizing studies on indigenous animism and spirituality, I aim to reconstruct the two-sided intricacies of Mizo-British medical and religious contact, building up a picture of Mizo healing and religious traditions before superimposing their reactions to biomedicine on top. At this key juncture we can see how religious ideas and concepts about health could flow, transition, or be impeded across cultures with radically contrasting views on how these realms functioned, while also recognizing that the story of Christianity in Mizoram begins with Mizos operating within an earlier, deeply engrained and dynamic indigenous belief system that governed every aspect of life. Hill people like the Mizos are often relegated to the footnotes of India’s history. Entire books on the history of the subcontinent have been written with scant sentences reserved for the ‘tribals’ populating India’s northeastern states.4 Only recently, with the publication of works like James C. Scott’s The Art of Not Being Governed (2009) and a special Journal of Global History issue (5.2, 2010), is scholarly attention turning to this kaleidoscopically diverse region.5 The indigenous peoples of North America have been far better served by historians, whose scholarship inspires this project's methodology. Daniel Richter’s acclaimed Facing East from Indian Country (2001) re-reads the written colonial records of contemporary Europeans to unbraid the experiences and responses of indigenous people. Moving beyond the ham-fisted categories of religious conquest and assimilation, Richard White’s Middle Ground (1991), a seminal study of North American indigenous history, introduces a ‘middle ground,’ where each culture interacts with the other through what they perceive to be the values and practices of that other culture. The proposed project operates 1 David Hardiman, Missions and their Medicine: A Christian Modernity for Tribal India, Manchester: Manchester University Press, 2008, p. 12. 2 “Report of Lushai Hills, 1911-12” in Thanzauva, Reports of the Foreign Mission of the Presbyterian Church of Wales on Mizoram: 1894-1957, Aizawl: The Synod Literature and Publication Boards, 1997, p. 48. 3 C.G. Verghese and R.L. Thanzawna, History of the Mizos: Volume 1, Delhi: Vikas Publishing House, 1997, p. 336. 4 A characteristic example is John Keay’s India: A History, New York: Atlantic Monthly Press, 2000. 5James C. Scott, The Art of Not Being Governed: An Anarchist History of Upland Southeast Asia, New Haven: Yale University Press, 2009. within the theoretical framework of cross-cultural contact underpinning such scholarship. Following White, the Mizo ‘middle ground’ is both a place and a style of interaction. Geographically, it is found in the Mizo villages of early Mizo-British contact. Functionally, it encompasses the complex set of Mizo perceptions of and responses to the missionaries, their medicine, and their Christianity, as well as the missionaries’ perceptions of and responses to Mizo healing systems and religiosity, and the new meanings and practices that result from the interactions between the two. Established by historians of North American Indigenous-to-European colonial contact, this framework can thus be creatively adapted to India’s historiographically impoverished frontier. Underpinning Mizoram’s scholarly isolation are the policies of the Indian government that have isolated the area politically since the 1960s insurgency. Until only this year, Mizoram has been a Restricted Area of India. With special permission I have travelled extensively throughout the state, photographing pages of British Superintendents’ letters and personal journals, contemporary studies of indigenous religion, and first-hand missionary accounts from Mizo ecclesiastical and government archives. I write now from Mizoram on my fifth stay, coordinating here a three-month British-Library- funded project to digitize the region’s endangered historical documents before hopes of saving them are forever washed away--in some cases literally, by the region’s annual 375 cm of rainfall. At present, our digitized collection spans some seven-thousand photographs of privately held historical records unseen by historians’ eyes. This alone multiplies tenfold the evidentiary basis of my MA work on this region, and allows the project not only access to the earliest records of the 1890s, but also the opportunity to shatter the false barrier of 1947, where medical histories of colonial South Asia often stop despite the lifecycle of medical missions continuing. As for supplementary sources, since my MA work in the Baptist Missionary and Welsh Calvinistic Foreign Mission societies I have done research in archives in Delhi, Vellore, Bengaluru, and Durban; I will spend the spring in the archives of the Mennonite Brethren missions. These sources, in English, Mizo, and Bengali, will be counterbalanced with the oral histories I have done during the course of their collection. As I comb through these sources for their Mizo voices, what syncretism, confrontation, and accomodation will I find on either side of the medical and religious interaction? How did Mizos operate within a distinctly Mizo world, giving voice to their own cultural values, even as they accomodated new medical, religious, and political institutions and traditions? The answers to these questions will transform Mizos from anonymous masses into three-dimension participants in their own histories. The University of Warwick’s Professor David Hardiman provides the first major intervention into the field for South Asia with his Missionaries and their Medicine (2008). Dovetailing closely with Prof. Hardiman’s interests in mission, health, and the adivasi peoples of South Asia, the project would benefit immensely from his help in placing Mizo history within the historiography of its surrounding regions. Warwick’s Bangla Society will improve my competency in the relevant languages; its Centre for the History of Medicine will allow the project to tap into a wealth of supplementary supervision and resources. Warwick’s Department of History, with Dr. Sarah Hodges, Dr. Roberta Bivins, Prof. Hilary Marland and Dr. Claudia Stein, is the strongest worldwide on the medical history of South Asia and the wider world, providing the ‘critical mass’ needed for a good research environment. This project, engaging a people rarely studied yet unique for the speed and extent of their Christianization, has the potential to reorient how Mizo medical and religious history is understood, and to shed light on modern issues at the intersection of religion, healing, culture, identity, and authority. Pursuing this project at Warwick would be a strong step towards a career exploring the history of India’s northeast as a scholar of South Asia. Primary Reading and Prospective Bibliography Administration Reports of the Lushai Hills. Shillong: Assam Secretariat, 1896-1899. India Office Records/V/10/1540. Allen, B. C. Gazetteer of the Khasi and Jaintia Hills, Garo Hills, Lushai Hills. Delhi: Gian Publications, 1980. Allen, Frederick Freeman. “Report of the medical arrangements in the Right Column of the Lushai Expeditionary Force.” 1872. Wellcome Institute Archives and Manuscripts, London, accession number: 68432, Pressmark: 926. Annual Reports of the Baptist Missionary Society. 112th Annual Report – 130th Annual Report. Archives of Regent's Park College, Oxford. London: BMS, Carey Press, and Baptist Mission House, 1903 – 1922. Arnold, David. Colonizing the Body: State Medicine and Epidemic Disease in Nineteenth-Century