Public Safety Commission Regular Meeting Agenda
Wednesday, October 2, 2019
5:00 P.M.
City Hall — Multipurpose Room 23825 Stuart Ranch Road
Call to Order
Roll Call
Pledge of Allegiance
Approval of Agenda
Report on Posting of Agenda— September 26, 2019
1. Written and Oral Communications from the Public and Commissioners
A. Communications from the Public concerning matters which are not on the agenda but for which the Commission has subject matter jurisdiction. The Commission may not act on these matters at this meeting. (30 minutes total time allotted)
B. Staff updates
C. Commissioner reports, comments and inquiries. (15 minutes total time allotted)
2. Consent Calendar
A. Previously Discussed Items
None.
B. New Items
1. Approval of Minutes — September 4, 2019
Recommended Action: Approve minutes for the Public Safety Commission Regular Meeting of September 4, 2019.
Staff Contact: Executive Assistant Linden, 310-456-2489 ext. 232
3. Old Business
None. Public Safety Commission Page 2 of 3 October 2, 2019
4. New Business
A. Public Safety Agencies Annual Service Review
Recommended Action: 1) Review services provided by the County of Los Angeles Sheriff’s Department, Fire Department and Lifeguards, and Malibu Volunteers on Patrol (VOP); and 2) makerecommendations to the City Council for service level adjustments, if appropriate.
Staff Contact: Public Safety Manager Dueflas, 310-456-2489 ext. 313
B. 2019 Summer Beach Enforcement Operation Summary
Recommended Action: Receive and file summary report of the 2019 Summer Beach Enforcement Operation.
Staff Contact: Sheriff’s Liaison Lieutenant Seetoo, 310-456-2489 ext. 232
C. Ordinance to Prevent Trespass in the Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zone
Recommended Action: Provide a recommendation to the City Council concerning the Drafi Ordinance that would amend Title 8 of the Malibu Municipal Code (MMC) to prevent trespass in the Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zone.
Staff Contact: Public Safety Manager Dueñas, 310-456-2489 ext. 313
D. Public Safety Agency Activity
Recommended Action: Discuss recent Public Safety Agency activities and receive and file activity reports from the County of Los Angeles Sheriff’s Department, Fire Department, and Lifeguards.
Staff Contact: Executive Assistant Linden, 310-456-2489 ext. 232
Adi ournment
Future Meetings
Wednesday; November 6, 2019 5:00 p.m. Regular Meeting City Hall Multipurpose Room Wednesday, December 4, 2019 5:00 p.m. Regular Meeting City Hall Multipurpose Room Wednesday, January 1, 2020 5:00 p.m. Regular Meeting City Hall Multipurpose Room Public Safety Commission Page 3 of 3 October 2. 2019
Guide to the City Commission Proceedings
The Oral Communication potion of the agenda is for members of the public to present items which are not listed on the agenda, but are under the subject matter jurisdiction of the Commission. Although no action may be taken, the Commission and staff will follow up, at an appropriate time, on those items needing response. Each speaker is limited to (3) three minutes. Time may be surrendered by deferring (1) one minute to another speaker, not to exceed a total of (8) eight minutes. The speaker wishing to defer time must be present when the item is heard. In order to be recognized and present an item, each speaker must complete and submit to the Recording Secretary a Request to Speak form pri~ to the beginning of the item being announced by the Chair (forms are available at the entrance to the meeting room). Speakers are taken in the order slips are submitted.
Items in Consent Calendar Section A have already been considered by the Commission at a previous meeting where the public was invited to comment, after which a decision was made. These items are not subject to public discussion at this meeting because the vote taken at the previous meeting was final. Resolutions concerning decisions made at previous meetings are for the purpose of memorializing the decision to assure the accuracy of the fmdings, the prior vote, and any conditions imposed.
Items in Consent Calendar Section B have not been discussed previously by the Commission. If discussion is desired, an item may be removed from the Consent Calendar for individual consideration. Commissioners may indicate a negative or abstaining vote on any individual item by so declaring prior to the vote on the motion to adopt the entire Consent Calendar. Items excluded from the Consent Calendar will be taken up by the Commission following the action on the Consent Calendar. The Commission first will take up the items for which public speaker requests have been submitted. Public speakers shall follow the rules as set forth under Oral Communication.
Old Business items have appeared on previous agendas but have either been continued or tabled to this meeting with no final action having been taken. Public comment shall follow the rules as set forth under Oral Communication.
Items in New Business are items which are appearing for the first time for formal action. Public comment shall follow the rules as set forth under Oral Communication.
Copies ofthe staffreports or other written documentation relating to each item ofbusiness described above are on file in the City Manager’s Office, Malibu City Hall, 23825 Stuart Ranch Road, Malibu, Caflfornia and are available for public inspection during regular office hours which are 7.30 am. to 5:30 p.m., Monday through Thursday, and 7:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m., Friday. Written materials distributed to the Commission within 72 hours of the Commission meeting are available for public inspection immediately upon distribution (Government Code Section 54957. 5(b)(2). Copies ofstaffreports and written materials may be purchasedfor $0.10 per page. Pursuant to State law, this agenda was posted at least 72 hours prior to the meeting..
The City Hall phone number is (310) 456-2489. To Contact City Hall using a telecommunication devicefor the deaf(TDD), please call (800) 735-2929 and a Caflfornia Relay Service operator will assist you. In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, ~f you need special assistance to participate in this meeting, please Contact Andrew Sheldon, Acting Environmental Sustainability Director, (310) 456-2489, ext. 251. Notification 48 hours prior to the meeting will enable the City to make reasonable arrangements to ensure accessibility to this meeting. [28 CFR 35.102-35.104 ADD Title II]. Requests for use of audio or video equipment duringa Commission meeting should be directed to Alex Montano at (310) 456-2489, ext. 227, or [email protected] before 12:00p.m. on the day of the meeting.
I hereby cert~ under penalty ofpeiyuiy, under the laws of the State of Caflfornia, that the foregoing agenda was posted in accordance with the applicable legal requirements. Dated this 26t.’ day ofSeptem ber 2019. j 4~1.~L Ma Li~ Executiv- .‘ sistant Public Safety Commission Meeting 10-02-19 Item 2~BQ1, Pubhc Safety Commission Agenda Report
To: Chair Frost and Members of the Public Safety Commission
Prepared by: Mary Linden, Executive Assistant
Approved by: Reva Feldman, City Manager~
Date prepared: September 20, 2019 Meeting date: October 2, 2019
Subject: Approval of Minutes — September 4, 2019
RECOMMENDED ACTION: Approve minutes for the Public Safety Commission Regular Meeting of September 4, 2019.
DISCUSSION: Staff has prepared draft minutes for the Public Safety Commission Regular Meeting of September 4, 2019, and hereby submits the minutes to the Commission for approval.
ATTACHMENTS: Draft September 4, 2019 Public Safety Commission Regular Meeting Minutes
Page 1 of 1 Agenda Item # 2.B.1. MINUTES MALIBU PUBLIC SAFETY COMMISSION REGULAR MEETING SEPTEMBER 4~ 2019 MULTIPURPOSE ROOM 5:00 P.M.
CALL TO ORDER
Chair Frost called the meeting to order at 5:05 p.m.
ROLL CALL
The following persons were recorded in attendance by the Recording Secretary:
PRESENT: Chair Chris Frost; Vice Chair Andy Cohen; and Commissioners Fred Roberts and Doug Stewart
ABSENT: Commissioner Keegan Gibbs
ALSO PRESENT: Susan Dueflas. Public Safety Manager; Rob DuBoux, Public Works Director; Arthur Aladjadjian, Public Works Superintendent; Jerry Vandermeulen, Fire Safety Liaison; Matt Myerhoff, Public Information Officer; Stephanie Schellerup, Public Safety Specialist; Lieutenant Jennifer Seetoo, Los Angeles County Sheriffs Department; and Mary Linden, Executive Assistant
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
Vice Chair Cohen led the Pledge of Allegiance.
APPROVAL OF AGENDA
MOTION Vice Chair Cohen moved and Commissioner Stewart seconded a motion to approve the agenda. The motion carried 4-0, Commissioner Gibbs absent.
REPORT ON POSTING OF AGENDA
Executive Assistant Linden reported that the agenda for the meeting was properly posted on August 29. 2019.
ITEM l.A. PUBLIC COMMENTS
Bobby Milstein stated Malibu Towing is a cog in the City’s wheel along with the Sheriffs and Fire Departments. He stated Malibu Towing drivers know Malibu’s roads better than any other company. He suggested using land purchased by the City for a tow yard.
Lori Gray discussed a Los Angeles Times article about halos being installed at locations throughout Los Angeles County where pedestrians and cyclists have been killed. She suggested it could be a deterrent for unsafe driving along Pacific Coast Highway (PCH). Malibu Public Safety Commission Special Meeting Minutes of September 4, 2019 Page 2 of 10
Bonnie Decker discussed her family’s history with Malibu Towing. She stated Malibu Towing knows the canyons, fire roads, and residents in Malibu.
Gary Wilcox discussed work he did in the past with Adail Gayhart. He stated other tow companies will take care of their own communities first. but Malibu Towing will take care of Malibu. He stated he recently signed a lease with Malibu Towing to use his property.
Debbie Gayhart deferred her time to Adail Gayhart.
Adail Gayhart declined to speak.
Ste~hanie Sunwoo spoke in support of Malibu Towing. She agreed with other speakers that Malibu needs Malibu Towing and they are part of the community.
Lance Simmens. a Public Works Commissioner speaking as a Malibu resident, discussed Caltrans’ plans to install a crosswalk near Malibu Seafood at the bottom of a steep hill. He stated the Public Works Commission unanimously supported the use of the underpass for crossing. He requested alternatives be considered.
Carla McCloskey spoke in support of Malibu Towing. She discussed the need for an evacuation plan. She stated there were issues with underpasses. She stated the Zuma underpass was flooded, and they all need to be kept clear.
Debra Bianco, Cornucopia Foundation, discussed support Malibu Farmers Market received from Malibu Towing for over 20 years. She stated they know Malibu’s canyons better than any others.
Patt Healy deferred her time to Sherman Baylin.
Sherman Baylin spoke in support of Malibu Towing. She discussed personal services provided by Malibu Towing to families in Malibu. She commended Malibu Towing for hiring locals.
Carol Moss stated the community must support and protect small, local businesses.
Hans Laetz provided an update on communication between KBUU and the Santa Monica- Malibu Unified School District (SMMUSD). He announced a connection would be installed connecting Malibu High School (MHS) to Santa Monica High School to keep MRS in session when a public safety power shutoff (PSPS) was threatened. He stated he was working with the City to connect to City Hall to maintain internet communication during a power outage. He stated the Malibu Foundation offered to pay for the connection and KBUU was applying for the necessary license. He stated the plan was to extend the connection to Webster and Malibu Elementary Schools. Malibu Public Safety Commission Special Meeting Minutes of September 4. 2019 Page 3 of 10
ITEM 1 .B. STAFF UPDATES
Fire Safety Liaison Vandermeulen explained the Home Ignition Zone Assessment Program. He stated the City received one response to its Request for Proposals (RFP) for a Community Wildfire Protection Plan: He stated there would be stakeholder meetings to explain fire modeling and fuels mitigation.
ITEM 1 .C. COMMISSIONER COMMENTS
Commissioner Roberts agreed the City needs Malibu Towing to stay in Malibu. He discussed service he received from Malibu Towing during the fire.
Commissioner Stewart thanked the speakers for their kind words about Malibu Towing. He agreed the Malibu Towing impound lot should stay in Malibu. He commended the Sheriffs and Fire Departments, Lifeguards, and Volunteers on Patrol (VOP) for their great work during the summer. He stated there were 1 .5 million visitors in July alone. He discussed Lifeguard rescues and other services. He discussed the problem of hiking deaths and the dangers of downed power lines in Malibu. He commended Sheriff and City staff for their great efforts over the past 12 months to prepare for 2019 fire season. He stated it is up to citizens to be ready. He thanked Hans Laetz for his work to benefit the City.
Vice Chair Cohen thanked everyone for coming. He clarified that the City did not kick Malibu Towing out of Malibu. He thanked Mr. Wilcox for working with Malibu Towing to set up the tow yard in Malibu. He introduced Lieutenant Seetoo to the audience. He commended Lieutenant Seetoo for her efforts to improve safety over the summer, including extra personnel and the bicycle patrol, which led to a reduction in incidents and no fatalities this summer. He stated law enforcement visibility slowed down speeding and reduced accidents. He encouraged residents to go to Coffee with a Cop. He stated the City was working to keep motorhomes from lining PCH.
Vice Chair Frost agreed with Commissioner Stewart. He stated he supported Malibu Towing. He suggested the Commission adopt a resolution in support of Malibu Towing.
CONSENSUS By consensus, the Commission requested staff bring back a resolution in support of Malibu Towing.
Chair Frost commended the City’s plans for improving fire prevention. He stated the City was lucky to have Fire Safety Liaison Vandermeulen and Public Safety Manager Dueñas. He commended the VOPs and thanked Lieutenant Seetoo for a fatality-free summer.
ITEM 2 CONSENT CALENDAR
MOTION Commissioner Stewart moved and Chair Frost seconded a motion to approve the Consent Calendar. The motion carried 4-0. Commissioner Gibbs absent. Malibu Public Safety Commission Special Meeting Minutes of September 4. 2019 Page 4 of 10
The Consent Calendar consisted of the following items:
A. Previously Discussed Items None.
B. New Items
I, Approval of Minutes — August 7. 2019 Staff recommendation: Approve minutes of the Public Safety Commission Regular meeting of August 7, 2019.
ITEM 3 OLD BUSINESS
None.
ITEM 4 NEW BUSINESS
A. Public Safety Power Shut-Off Preparations Recommended Action: Receive and file report regarding the City’s preparations for a Public Safety Power Shut-Off (PSPS), and provide feedback to staff.
Public Safety Manager Dueflas presented the report.
Vice Chair Cohen left the meeting at 5:57 p.m.
Public Safety Manager Dueñas welcomed Rudy Gonzales, Southern California Edison (SCE). She explained the process for a PSPS and how power would be restored after the threat was gone.
Vice Chair Cohen returned to the dais at 6:01 p.m.
Public Safety Manager Dueñas discussed how information stations would provide information and updates when the power was out. She stated radio is critical in an emergency, and she thanked Hans Laetz for working with the City to provide radio service.
Hans Laetz stated the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) had granted KBUU two construction permits to provide eastern and western Malibu with stronger signals. He stated Bluffs Park was the only location in eastern Malibu where a transmitter and antenna could be placed. He stated the request to place the antenna at Bluffs Park would be presented to the City Council on September 9, 2019. He stated it would provide a guaranteed internet signal. In response to Commissioner Roberts, Mr. Laetz explained why Bluffs Park was the only location that met FCC requirements. Malibu Public Safety Commission Special Meeting Minutes of September 4. 2019 Page 5 of 10
Patricia Nolan thanked Mr. Laetz and Public Safety Manager Dueflas for increasing communication within the City. She stated residents needed to understand their phones would not work in a power outage. She suggested the City should push the Public Utilities Commission to approve backup batteries for communications.
Commissioner Roberts left the dais at 6:08 p.m.
Chris Jackson stated she lost her home in the Woolsey Fire. She thanked Public Safety Manager Dueflas for her efforts. She discussed fire crews near her neighborhood who said they could not assist as they were waiting for instructions. She questioned why plans were not implemented sooner.
Commissioner Roberts returned to the dais at 6:11 p.m.
Vice Chair Frost expressed sympathy to Ms. Jackson for the loss of her home.
Public Safety Manager Dueñas stated her heart goes out to Ms. Jackson. She stated the City had offered preparedness education and support before the Woolsey Fire. She stated it was critical that volunteers, including VOP and CERT, are part of the City’s public safety team.
Vice Chair Frost described the Woolsey Fire’s very unique fire behavior.
Rudy Gonzales, SCE Government Relations Manager for the area including Malibu, discussed SCE’s plans related to PSPS. He stated numerous professionals had been hired. including meteorologists. He discussed notification procedures to advise local governments and residents before PSPS implementation. He recommended all residents update their contact information with SCE. He stated SCE was responsible for only one half of one percent of PSPS implemented in California since 2017.
In response to Vice Chair Cohen, Mr. Gonzales confirmed no PSPS had yet been implemented in Malibu.
In response to Commissioner Stewart, Mr. Gonzales explained what would lead to a PSPS. He stated a Red Flag Warning would not in itself lead to a PSPS. He stated notifications were sent 48 hours and 24 hours before the power was shut down.
Commissioner Stewart discussed circuits in the area around his home. In response to Commissioner Stewart, Mr. Gonzales stated SCE would usually de-energize at a substation. Commissioner Stewart discussed water system feeder pumps located on PCH. Malibu Public Safety Commission Special Meeting Minutes of September 4, 2019 Page 6 of 10
Public Works DirectorDuBoux stated Los Angeles County Waterworks District 29 (District 29) has booster pump stations to help get water into the canyons. He stated the City was coordinating with SCE and District 29 to ensure there was sufficient power to energize those pump stations and provide necessary water pressure.
Commissioner Roberts stated it was previously reported that the PSPS would impact quadrants. Mr. Gonzales explained SCE circuit configurations. He stated the City has copies of circuit maps, so it would know what areas would be impacted.
Public Safety Manager Dueñas explained that the City had prepared groups within its disaster notification system that coincided with the SCE circuit maps.
Commissioner Roberts discussed how the loss of cell service would result in residents being unable to call 911. He stated it was critical that the community be educated. Public Safety Manager Dueflas explained the City’s public education campaign included instructing residents to make plans for what they would do if telephone service was lost.
In response to Vice Chair Cohen, Mr. Gonzales stated SCE does not supply generators to the phone companies. He stated SCE w~s working with the communication companies on how they can prepare for a potential PSPS.
B. National Preparedness Month Activities Recommended Action: Receive and file report regarding National Preparedness Month activities in Malibu.
Public Safety Manager Dueflas presented the report. She discussed events and trainings scheduled throughout September. She stated highlights include the panel discussion on September 11 with residents impacted by the Woolsey Fire, and the Points of Information and Supplies Distribution demonstration to be presented by CERT on September 14. She stated one of the most important events would be the Fire Briefing on September 21.
In response to Commissioner Stewart, Public Safety Manager Dueflas stated a draft evacuation plan would be presented to the City Council on September 9. She discussed the tabletop exercise recently conducted with the Sheriffs Department and other agencies. She stated additional work was being done by subgroups regarding traffic and evacuation.
Lieutenant Seetoo stated the tabletop exercise strengthened the relationships between the various agencies. She stated learning the correct point of contact in each agency might have been the greatest takeaway.
Commissioner Roberts discussed chaos during evacuations in the 1993 fire. Malibu Public Safety Commission Special Meeting Minutes of September 4, 2019 Page 7 of 10
Public Safety Manager Dueñas stated the City, Sheriff and Fire Departments have been working to establish evacuation zones. She stated they would build on the Topanga zones, and evacuation plans would be established for each zone.
Commissioner Stewart asked how far up the canyons the zones would extend. He commended the City and its partners for their progress. Fire Safety Liaison Vandermeulen stated the zones were aligning with the four existing fire corridors recognized by the Los Angeles County Fire Department: Topanga, Malibu, Kanan, and Decker.
Public Safety Manager Dueflas explained that Malibu would have fewer zones than Topanga.
In response to Commissioner Stewart, Fire Safety Liaison Vandermeulen stated that draft GIS maps were being prepared.
C. Update on Projects Affecting Traffic on Pacific Coast Highway (PCH) and City Streets Recommended Action: 1) Receive and file status updates from Public Works staff on the La Costa Pedestrian Improvements Project; 2) Receive a status update from Caltrans regarding Caltrans construction projects and Caltrans-permitted projects; and 3) Provide Caltrans with issues for future reports to the Commission.
Public Works Superintendent Aladjadjian presented the report. He stated the La Costa Pedestrian Improvements Project was 95% complete. He stated final equipment was expected in approximately four to six weeks, after which the City would coordinate activation of the signal with Caltrans.
Vice Chair Frost stated the transformer box at La Costa could block the view of pedestrians.
Public Works Superintendent Aladjadjian introduced Caltrans District 7 representatives Abdi Saghafi, Chief, Office of Corridor Management (West), Osama Assaad, Corridor Manager, and Eric Menjivar, Public Infoi~mation Officer.
Mr. Saghafi discussed projects in Malibu. He stated the programmed projects in Malibu total $200 million. He discussed a preventive maintenance project addressing pavement resurfacing needs on PCH from the Malibu Lagoon bridge to the Los Angeles/Ventura County line. He discussed permitted projects for crosswalks near Malibu Beach Inn and La Costa.
In response to Commissioner Roberts, Mr. Assaad stated the Trancas Bridge Replacement was scheduled to begin Spring 2021 and would take approximately two years. Mr. Menjivar stated it was currently in the design phase. Commissioner Malibu Public Safety Commission Special Meeting Minutes of September 4, 2019 Page 8 of 10
Roberts stated required lane ëlosures for the project would make traffic really rough.
Public Works Director DuBoux requested an update on the crosswalk project near Malibu Seafood. Mr. Saghafi stated Caltrans has an obligation to provide safe crossing. He stated it would include signs warning motorists of the upcoming pedestrian crossing. He stated the project was funded and moving forward. He stated construction was tentatively scheduled to begin late Summer 2020. He stated Caltrans would hold another community meeting in November 2019 about the potential of using the Corral Canyon drainage channel as an undercrossing. He discussed issues that must be considered, including water levels. He stated the 10- year storm level is 14 feet. He discussed environmental and cultural issues impacting the area. He stated numerous agencies would need to provide permits, including the California Department of Fish and Game and California Coastal Commission, as well as federally-required ADA access.
Mr. Assaad dis~ussed topography issues at Corral that did not exist at other undercrossings, such as Will Rogers.
Commissioner Stewart stated the crosswalk was a silly idea. He stated pedestrians would not walk to the crosswalk to get to the beach but would instead cross the highway where they were. He stated it was a waste of resources and a high risk. He questioned the addition of a bridge at Solstice Canyon. Public Works Director DuBoux stated it was a bridge for fish passage. He explained Caltrans was required to make a more natural structure through which steelhead trout could pass. Mr. Assaad added it would be similar to the passage at Leo Carillo State Beach.
Mr. Menjivar discussed two projects on Topanga. He stated the slope stabilization and rock scaling project would continue into early 2020 with nightly lane closures from PCH to Grand View Drive. He stated the project to apply slurry seal from Mulholland to PCH should be completed in Fall 2019.
Public Works Director DuBoux discussed slurry seal application and crack sealing, where needed, from the McClure Tunnel to Cross Creek Road. He stated the Escondido Slope Stabilization project was wrapping up well ahead of schedule.
In response to Vice Chair Frost, Mr. Saghafi confirmed Caltrans would hold another community meeting in Malibu before the decision was made about the Corral pedestrian signal. Vice Chair Frost requested faded red curbs be painted correctly. He stated parking tickets were unenforceable due to faded curbs. Mr. Saghafi stated El Matador signage was being increased to help enforcement of parking. Public Works Director DuBoux stated City staff was working with Caltrans to identify areas where red curbs need to be repainted. Malibu Public Safety Commission Special Meeting Minutes of September 4, 2019 Page 9 of 10
Commissioner Roberts stated other pocket beaches had similar problems to El Matador. He requested those beaches also be evaluated and improved.
In response to Vice Chair Cohen, Mr. Saghafi stated the Coastal Commission would not approve No Parking areas on PCH. Vice Chair Frost discussed increased numbers of individuals sleeping in their vehicles overnight near Corral Canyon.
Public Works Director DuBoux stated staff is working on solutions for preventing extended parking on PCH and City streets. He discussed a Los Angeles COunty ordinance restricting parking on alternating sides of the street for a few hours each during the night. Public Safety Manager Dueñas stated the City was waiting to see how the County ordinance worked.
In response to Vice Chair Frost, Lieutenant Seetoo stated County code requiring vehicles moving every 72 hours was the only ordinance currently enforceable. She stated they recently met with Supervisor Kuehl’s office to find solutions.
Lance Simmens stated there was a viable option for the Malibu Seafood area pedestrian crossing. He stated the wishes of the community should be taken into account. He requested Caltrans take viable options seriously.
Chris Jackson stated the underpass flooding would usually only happen in fall and winter, not in the summer when visitors came to Malibu.
Commissioner Stewart suggested blue Botts dots be installed when streets were being repaved to identify locations of fire hydrants. Commissioner Roberts stated it was up to the Fire Department to ensure they were reinstalled.
Fire Safety Liaison Vandermeulen asked if an encroachment permit would be required for the City to install them.
D. Defensible Space Inspection Program Recommended Action: Receive and file a report on the current status of the City’s Defensible Space Inspection Program.
Fire Safety Liaison Vandermeulen presented the report. He stated Fire Department numbers included some unincorporated County areas with the City information.
In response to Commissioner Stewart, Fire Safety Liaison Vandermeulen explained that goats do work, but they would require additional work. Vice Chair Frost stated some areas in Malibu had environmental issues that would restrict the use of goats for brush clearance. Malibu Public Safety Commission Special Meeting Minutes of September 4, 2019 Page 10of10
E. Public Safety Agency Activity Recommended Action: Discuss recent Public Safety Agency activities and receive and file activity reports from the County of Los Angeles Sheriffs Department, Fire Department, and Lifeguards.
Lieutenant Seetoo stated the Sheriffs Department would contract with Malibu Towing again if it successfully relocated back to Malibu
She discuss trends in injury accidents and citations issued. She thanked the VOPs for their assistance.
In response to Vice Chair Frost, Lieutenant Seetoo confirmed the SWAT team was brought to the Chili Cook-Off primarily to provide a visible presence and quick response.
ADJOURNMENT
MOTION At 7:32 p.m., Commissioner Roberts moved and Vice Chair Cohen seconded a motion to adjourn. The motion carried unanimously.
Approved and adopted by the Public Safety Commission of the City
of Malibu on ______, 2019.
CHRIS FROST. Chair
ATTEST:
MARY LINDEN, Executive Assistant Public Safety Commission Meeting 10-02-19 Item 4,A. Public Safety Commission Agenda Report
To: Chair Frost and Members of the Public Safety Commission
Prepared by: Susan Dueñas, Public Safety Manager
Approved by: Reva Feldman, City Manage~(’~
Date prepared: September 23, 2019 Meeting date: October 2, 2019
Subject: Public Safety Agencies Annual Service Review
RECOMMENDED ACTION: 1) Review services provided by the County of Los Angeles Sheriff’s Department, Fire Department, and Lifeguards, and Malibu Volunteers on Patrol (VOP); and 2) provide a recommendation to the City Council for service level adjustments, if appropriate.
DISCUSSION: The City contracts with the County of Los Angeles for law enforcement services provided by the Sheriff’s Department. Fire and Lifeguard services are provided by the Los Angeles County Fire Department, although not through a contract. In 2010, the City established the Malibu VOP program, a team of civilian volunteers managed by the Sheriff’s Department who assist in serving and protecting the community. The City Council directed the Public Safety Commission to conduct an annual review of these public safety services as part of the Commission’s Fiscal Year 2019-2020 assignments.
Los Angeles County Lifeguards has provided a summary of services provided over the past year (Attachment 1), including disaster support provided during the Woolsey Fire in November 2018. The VOP also provided a summary of services provided over the past year (Attachment 2). The Fire Department will distribute its summary at the meeting.
Representatives from each of the agencies will present brief overviews of the services provided in Malibu over the past year and will answer questions from the Commission. The Commission may make recommendations to the City Council for adjustments to service levels, if appropriate.
ATTACHMENTS: 1. Los Angeles County Lifeguard Review of Public Safety Services
2. Malibu VOP Activity Summary — October 2018 through September 2019 Page 1 of 1 Agenda Item # 4.A. OF LOS
rLfl A I,
.0. .
Review of Public Safety ~,:Services
M~’hbuPu~bIi.cSafet>1 Commission ;. ~ ~:~;:‘~ •: ••..
- . 0
- A ATTACHMEN~ 1
LA COUNTY FIRE DEPARTMENT • LIFEGUARD TRAINING SECTION LOS 44
Overview LOB)
rv rovided By Our Agency Include: . ifeg Servi es erge vies— ec~B t pea URR te Res d Re ye nit or iy u P i~ du ation,&Youth Progr . •sa er Se vi orkers & Occupancy Support
:‘~
• r
• ; •.~4•. • ~ “:
‘- ,.~ —,
I •-~f — •• ~
.‘~, “s.’ ~ Ocean Lifeguard Services
The Los Angeles County Lifeguards have the privilege of watching over the “27 Miles of Scenic Beauty” that is the Malibu coastline. During daylight hours, I I full-time Ocean Lifeguards ensure the safety of the residents and tourist that recreate along these waters.Three of those eleven Ocean Lifeguards work a 24-hour schedule out of Lifeguard Station 300 at Zuma Beach to ensure prompt service after-hours.
Staffing can quickly expand and contract to ensure effective water coverage.This semi-flexible staffing profile allows for the cost effective and efficient public safety. As the weather, ocean conditions, and crowds develop the Lifeguard Division can call on it’s 650 recurrent Ocean Lifeguard to staff anyone of the 27 Lifeguard towers in the Malibu.
In 2018 Los Angeles County Lifeguards made 4,143 Ocean Rescues in Malibu. o~ LOS44,
~ ~ 4 ~p - -~ l~n1~ Emergency Medical Services - BLS (
Los Angeles County Lifeguards provide BLS Emergency Medical Services to beach-goers in Malibu. Ocean Lifeguards are trained to the Emergency Medical Technician level. EMT Lifeguards maintain their licenses through the department continued education to ensure seamless integration with County Fire paramedic services.
In 2018 Los Angeles County Lifeguards responded to 3,301 Medical Aids in Malibu. ci C Rescue Boat Operations
\
Baywatch Rescue Boat Malibu is berthed out of the Malibu Pier.This Rescue Boat responds to ocean rescues both near-shore and offshore. Rescue boat operations range from backing up 1(1 land based lifeguard resources, to responding out to the channel islands and everything in- between. Rescue Boat personnel are highly trained in marine electronics, navigation, salvage, marine firefighting, SCUBA diving, and marine
search and rescue. -/ I. ‘?~ -~ -.:~ In 2018 Baywatch Malibu responded to 333 Boating related calls LOS 44 URRU
The Los Angeles County Under Water Rescue and Recovery Unit is a highly trained team of (25) Ocean Lifeguard Specialists and (3) Captain Ocean - d Lifeguards.These individuals are ready to respond at a .4. moments notice to support the residents of Malibu for a number of response types both in the ocean as
U, • a.. well as inland bodies of water. ‘I:: ‘I The URRU is on a 24-hour duty rotation, and can be summoned for response in just a few minutes.
I—. I
.1 0mmunity Outreach, Pub. Ed., Youth Programs, PlO
The Lifeguard Division provides a Junior Lifeguard programs for the young men & women of Los Angeles County. Each summer 4300 students enroll in the program, 400 specifically in the Malibu area.The LA County Junior Lifeguard program teaches it’s participants about ocean safety, basic first-aid, and CPR.
Our Public Education and RecruitmentTeam identifies opportunities to recruit potential candidates, 45 events ‘I, ~ I were held in Malibu last year. Recruiters help spread the word about the profession of Lifeguard ing and the exciting career paths and opportunities it holds.
The Public Information Office maintain the Division’s social media channels.The PlO office works to provide; Up-to- /
date incident information, PSA’s, and community c•.. - engagement on a regular basis. Twitter: @lacolifeguards Faceboo k: facebook.com/lacolifeguards lnstagram: @lacolifeguards isaster Se,vices Workers & Occupancy Support D
During large-scale incidents all Lifeguard Personnel can respond to provide aid to affected residents.All Lifeguard personnel are trained annually as Disaster Services Workers in the event of a major incident.
.: ‘•. Lifeguard Personnel responded to the Woolsey Fire in ~ ‘~ ? ~ ~ I a number of capacities. Specially trained personnel
served on the incident in traditional roles in the ~‘. .ii~.•
planning section, public information, and logistics ~ ~ “~;,_% j~_~ “~: ~H’ section.Additional Lifeguard personnel worked on ~ ~ ~ the Incident in the “Occupancy Support Taskforce” ~ this taskforce was assigned to assist residents repopulate the area and provided support wherever ~ needed. :*~ ~ ~i~:- ~—~‘‘ *
Lifeguard personnel working LS300 in Zuma Beach help residents during the initial days of the fire, when the Zuma Beach Parking lots served as a temporary evacuation location.These crews also responded into the neighborhoods to help residents evacuate their homes.This unprecedented event showed the strength and adaptability of the lifeguard division during adversity. MALIBU VOP ACTIVITY SUMMARY October 2018 thru September 2019
Malibu VOP Team Personnel
• Currently 20 Active Malibu VOP Team Members o Added 6 new Malibu VOP Trainee Members • Acquired new Malibu VOP Patrol Vehicle for a total of 3 Patrol Vehicles
VOP Patrol Summary
o Conducted 8,471 Malibu Area Patrol Checks o Performed 782 Malibu Critical Facilities Checks o Issued 12,088 Parking Citations o Issued 710 72-Hour Vehicle “Red Tag” Notices • Issued 59 Valet Ordinance 407 Warning Notices o Conducted 511 Malibu Business Checks • Responded to 258 Traffic Collisions • Performed 200 Directed Patrols o Dispatched to 166 calls for service • Responded to 113 Citizen Flag Downs o Responded to 94 Deputy/LEO assist calls Responded to 72 Traffic Hazards o Worked 64 Special Details o Worked 35 Special Events • Responded to 63 Fire/Lifeguard/Medical calls o Responded to 7 Missing Person calls o Assisted with 43 vehicle Tows
1
ATTACHMENT 2 Woolsey Fire Summary • Worked 30 consecutive days totaling 1,464 hours o Provided over 100 Critical Supply and Personnel escorts. o Conducted over 75 Welfare and Home checks o Conducted daily High Visibility residential neighborhood patrols o Assisted Malibu CERT with relief supplies. • Provided traffic con trolfor Deputies and Fire Dept. at Woolsey incidents e Escorted City Staff, Councilmembers and School District officials throughout closure areas in and out of the fire containment areas. o Provided Traffic Control at numerous post Woolsey Fire flooding and debris flow incidents.
Summer Traffic Enforcement
• Worked 2,594 Patrol and Event Hours o Issued 6,437 Parking Citations and 89 “Red Tag” notices • Responded to 87 Traffic Collisions and 23 Traffic Hazzards • Worked numerous Special Events including the Malibu Chili Cookoff and Nautica Triathlon providing Traffic Control.
2 Public Safety Commission Meeting I 0-02- I 9 Item 4.B. Public Safety Commission Agenda Report
To: Chair Frost and Members of the Public Safety Commission
Prepared by: Lieutenant Jennifer Seetoo and Sergeant James Braden Malibu/Lost Hills Sheriff’s Station
Approved by: Reva Feldman, City Manager~
Date prepared: September 17, 2019 Meeting date: October 2, 2019
Subject: 2019 Summer Beach Enforcement Operation Summary
RECOMMENDED ACTION: Receive and file summary report of the 2019 Summer Beach Enforcement Operation.
DISCUSSION: The Malibu 2019 Summer Enforcement Operation began with two training days prior to deployment on May 27 (Memorial Day weekend), and ended on Monday, September 2 (Labor Day). The two training days consisted of departmentally-approved Quad Runner training, crowd control, tactical planning, and tactical communication, as well as Penal, Vehicle, and Municipal Code updates for Summer Enforcement Team operations. This year was the sixth year of the implemented 4/10 schedule, which is a four-day work week often-hour shifts for each deputy assigned to the team. The increased visibility and additional daily enforcement was extremely successful in maintaining safety and enforcement for the beach community and on Pacific Coast Highway (PCH).
The annual Summer Enforcement Team has become a vital resource to the community of Malibu. The City of Malibu partners with the Sheriff’s Department each summer to ensure a safe and wholesome beach environment for the residents and visitors of Malibu. The Sheriff’s Department selects an extremely motivated team of sworn and non-sworn Sheriff’s Department personnel to provide a strong, visible, pro-active police presence from the ground and air, coupled with strict enforcement of all applicable laws.
Page 1 of 2 Agenda Item # 4.B. This year’s core team, comprised of one sergeant and eight deputies, faced great challenges given the vast number of visitors arriving at beach destinations within the City. The enforcement efforts were focused on the most popular of the City’s adjacent County and State beaches, its designated beach parking areas, its main canyon roadways and PCH, the City’s main access artery.
In an effort to supplement the dedicated summer enforcement team of eight deputies and one sergeant, City funds were included to cover the cost of several key support elements, which were designed to enhance the overall Summer Enforcement operation. These support elements included a dedicated traffic car, motorcycle patrol, parking enforcement, traffic control, and secretarial services needed to process the large amount of enforcement paperwork generated by the team throughout the summer months.
A summary of the Malibu Beach Team statistical activity for 2019 is attached (Attachment 1) to illustrate the team’s concerted and highly motivated efforts. A chart is also attached (Attachment 2) comparing annual statistics for the Beach Team since 2007.
The Summer Enforcement budget dedicated by the City of Malibu was augmented, with no additional cost to the City, through hundreds of volunteer patrol hours from several of the Sheriff’s Department Reserve Units, including Malibu/Lost Hills Station Reserves, North Patrol Division Mounted Posse, and civilian Volunteers on Patrol (VOP). The City also benefited from the services of a Sheriff’s Department Air Unit, which was instrumental in maintaining a strong presence, identifying and locating possible drunk drivers on PCH, helping find lost children, and creating a deterrent to crime on the beach and surrounding areas.
Through their dedication and calming presence, this year’s deployment of deputies and volunteers overcame many challenges while working with thousands of residents and hundreds of thousands of visitors who enjoy Malibu during the summer months. This year’s Summer Enforcement Team effort was a complete success, resulting in a remarkably peaceful summer of 2019.
ATTACHMENTS: Summer 2019 Enforcement Team Activity Recap
Page 2 of 2 Agenda Item # 4.B. Summer Enforcement Team Activity Recap Summer 2019
Daily Statistics Year To Date Statistics Physical Felony Misdemeanor CITES Item Cites Arrests Arrests
Alcohol on Beach • ~ •‘ 0. 91,0 Miscéllanéous Cites ~ :‘..o~’. .711’
Animal Laws ,.o~’•: :~‘. :~:‘~‘ AssaUlts 0 0 0
Vending on ,the Beach .0 ‘ •. ‘0 .,.~
Bicycle Cites ‘ ~ : 0 . ‘ ‘ . 14
Marijuana •~, ‘•: :‘ .: -•.‘: Miscellaneous Felonies ..,6’~..’ o”~,..’:. Miscellaneous Misdemeanors’ • 0 . 39 20 GoIf.CarL Cites’ C:. :;‘
Nude” ‘. ..~ ‘‘0.,’’ ‘0
Smoking on City Beach - 12.08.035 0,.• ‘9’.’ 12
Warrants ....~‘...... ‘~. . ‘
Parking Cites ‘. ‘0.. 4,378 6 .. 60 ~‘ 6,092 TOTALS
Item YTD TOTAL Miscellaneous Cites WIA p345: Assist LACF Life”Guards’ .64 Found Children .36 Alcohol on beach not àpenéd W/A • 831
Towed Vehióles 26 . TOTALS’. • 1~302 I’. ... I I Public Safety Commission Meeting 10-02-19 Item 4.C. Public Safety Commission Agenda Report
To: Chair Frost and Members of the Public Safety Commission
Prepared by: Susan Duenas, Public Safety Manager Kathy Shin, Deputy City Attorney
Approved by: Reva Feldman, City Manager~(
Date prepared: September24, 2019 Meeting date: October 2, 2019
Subject: Ordinance to Prevent Trespass in the Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zone
RECOMMENDED ACTION: Provide a recommendation to the City Council concerning the Draft Ordinance that would amend Title 8 of the Malibu Municipal Code (MMC) to prevent trespass in the Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zone.
DISCUSSION: Fire officials have designated the entire City of Malibu as a Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zone (“VHFHSZ” or “Zone”). Unauthorized camping or dwelling in brush areas within the Zone increases the risk of wildfire and poses a serious threat to public safety. The proposed ordinance would amend MMC Title 8, Health and Safety, by banning camping and other unauthorized activity in those sections of the Zone closed to the public for reasons of fire safety. Entry in these areas is deemed a trespass and law enforcement is authorized to give verbal notice of a violation to persons found therein and to evacuate (or arrest) those who refuse to vacate.
Background on the VHFHSZ
California Government Code section 51178 requires the California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection (CAL FIRE) to identify “Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zones” using consistent statewide criteria (including a region’s potential fuels over a 30- 50 year time horizon, topography, and weather). Local agencies responsible for a region’s fire protection are then required to designate, by ordinance, VHFHSZ in their jurisdiction based on CAL FIRE’s recommended maps.1 Properties located in a
‘Gov. Code, § 51179(a). Page 1 of 5 Agenda Item # 4.C. designated Zone are subject to, among other regulations, more stringent Building Code requirements designed to improve buildings’ ignition resistance.
In 2006, the City Council authorized the Fire Chief to designate VHFHSZ in Malibu based on CAL FIRE’s recommendations.2 CAL FIRE’s map indicates that the entire City lies within a VHFHSZ, as designated in Appendix P of the County Fire Code.
Constitutional Constraints on Camping Ordinances
Earlier this year, a federal court struck down the City of Boise’s anti-camping ordinance, which had declared it a misdemeanor to camp on any street, sidewalk, park, or public place at any time.3 (Camping was defined as the use of public property as a temporary or permanent dwelling.) In a decision that is binding in federal courts in California, the court held that a jurisdiction that did not provide sufficient shelter to serve all of its homeless could not prosecute homeless individuals for involuntarily sitting, lying, and sleeping in public. The court found that criminalizing such conduct was equivalent to criminalizing the status of being homeless itself, which violates the Eighth Amendment of the federal Constitution.
Yet the court was clear that cities were not therefore required to allow homeless persons free rein to sleep on the streets. First, if a jurisdiction shows that it can house its entire homeless population, sleeping outdoors may be restricted. However, even where sufficient shelter is unavailable, the court found that an ordinance which prohibits sitting, lying, or sleeping outdoors “at particular times or in particular locations,” or which bars obstruction of the public right-of-way, “might well be constitutionally permissible.” The implication was that the federal Constitution precludes local governments from penalizing a person for simply lacking the means to live indoors, but some restrictions are allowed.
Following the Boise decision, the Los Angeles City Council adopted an ordinance to facilitate notice and removal of persons camping or dwelling in the brush areas within the City’s VHFHSZ. An ordinance restricting individuals from limited segments of a jurisdiction for reasons of fire safety tracks the Boise court’s standard for constitutionally permissible regulation.
City of Los Angeles Ordinance
On September 4, 2019, the Los Angeles City Council adopted an ordinance amending existing VHFHSZ regulations in the City’s Fire Code:
2 See Ordinance No. 299. Martin v. City ofBoise (9th Cir. 2019) 920 F.3d 584, 617. Page 2 of 5 Agenda Item # 4.0. 1. Posting notice of trespass on unenclosed lands
For years, the Los Angeles City Code provided that state or federal forest lands lying within city limits could be closed to the public by the Fire Chief, as permitted by law, provided that notice of the closure was posted onsite.4 The Code also allowed the City to restrict entry in the VHFHSZ “except upon public roadways, inhabited areas or established trails and campsites which are open to the public” by posting notice thereof.5 A violation of either restriction on public access in the Zone constitutes a trespass. As trespass is punishable as a misdemeanor, law enforcement may remove those who refuse to comply.
To ensure adequate notice of closed areas, Los Angeles required installation of specified signs every 600 feet along the perimeter of the closed land. In practice, meeting the posting requirements in the entire Zone was unrealistic and left significant portions of the Zone unposted.
2. Furnishing verbal notice on lands not open to the general public
To enable the city to more effectively mitigate the risk of wildfire in the Zone, the Los Angeles Fire Code as amended allows in-person, verbal notice to a person found in restricted areas, in addition to posted notice. Personal notice would consist of advising a person that he or she is in an area closed to the public. The person would also be warned that failure to immediately leave the area, or leaving only to return, would constitute criminal trespass.
3. VHFHSZ Operational Guidelines
Los Angeles also paired these changes with Operational Guidelines put out by the Mayor’s office. In summary, the Guidelines direct coordination of multiple City departments to address homeless encampments within the VHFHSZ (e.g., Los Angeles City Fire Department (LAFD), Los Angeles Police Department (LAPD), Department of Recreation and Parks, Bureau of Sanitation, and Los Angeles Homeless Services Authority). They also include a three-tiered plan for deploying the City’s new verbal notification program:
• Tier 1: No imminent fire danger o On days when the fire department does not register an imminent risk of fire in the Zone, operations will be limited to proactive engagement (i.e., outreach and education led by Homeless Services)
~ Los Angeles Municipal Code, § 57.4908.4. Los Angeles Municipal Code, § 57.4908.8. Page 3 of 5 Agenda Item # 4.C. and risk mitigation (noticed cleanings of encampments in restricted areas within the Zone). • Tier 2: Red Flag status day, or augmented LAFD operations o LAFD defines a “Red Flag status day” as having winds greater than 25 mph and humidity less than 15 percent. (Los Angeles County Fire adopts similar criteria for its red flag days.) On Red Flag days, or on days when LAFD otherwise augments its operations in anticipation of fire-related conditions, LAPD is expected to lead the effort to proactively notify and remove individuals in the VHFHSZ. o Individuals who do not voluntarily leave restricted areas within the Zone when verbally told to vacate by LAPD or park rangers will be arrested for criminal trespass. • Tier 3: Brush fire emergency o In the event of a brush fire in the Zone, LAFD will lead coordination of first responders with support from LAPD and the City’s Unified Homelessness Response Center.
Summary of Malibu’s Ordinance
Malibu has adopted the Los Angeles County Fire Code (“Fire Code”).6 In addition to restricting activity in hazardous fire areas, the Fire Code provides that lands therein may be closed to the public “by the fire code official at the request of the owners . . . when in the opinion of the fire code official such closure is necessary for the prevention of fires.”7 The Fire Code further provides that public entry on closed lands is restricted “during the period such closure is in effect,” subject to posted notice requirements.8
The proposed ordinance amends the Fire Code by adding sections modeled on the ordinance recently adopted by the City of Los Angeles. In brief, the ordinance expressly restricts entry in limited areas of the Zone closed to the public by the Fire Chief for reasons of fire safety. Specifically, notice of such closures may be furnished by posted signs or by verbal notice given directly to a person found in a restricted area.9
City staff is currently discussing the details of how the ordinance would be enforced with the Sheriff’s Department and the County Fire Department. As in Los Angeles, enforcement of verbal notice and removal may be limited to County red flag days, and
6 Malibu Municipal Code, Chapter 8.12 (Fire Code Adopted). ~ Title 32 (Fire Code), Los Angeles County Code, § 326.9 (Closure of Public or Private Lands). 8 Title 32 (Fire Code), Los Angeles County Code, §~ 326.10 (Restricted Entry on Closed Lands), 326.11 (Posting of Lands Closed to Entry). ~ Adoption of this ordinance does not restrict the City’s ability to otherwise prosecute trespass violations under the Penal Code • Page 4of5 Agenda Item # 4.C. will likely be led by law enforcement. The Sheriff’s Department’s Homeless Outreach Services Team (HOST), which has already assisted the City with cleaning encampments and connecting homeless persons with supportive services, is also expected to be a part of the VHFHSZ program.
ATTACHMENTS: Draft Ordinance
Page 5 of 5 Agenda Item # 4.0. ORDINANCE NO.
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF MALIBU, CALIFORNIA AMENDING CHAPTER 8,12 OF TITLE 8 OF THE MALIBU MUNICIPAL CODE TO ADD PROVISIONS FOR “VERY HIGH FIRE HAZARD SEVERITY ZONES” AND FINDING THE SAME EXEMPT FROM THE CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY ACT
The City Council of the City of Malibu does ordain as follows:
SECTION 1. Recitals.
A. The California Legislature has declared in Government Code section 51175 as follows:
1. Wildfires are extremely costly, not only to property owners and residents, but also to local agencies.
2. Wildfires pose a serious threat to the preservation of the public peace, health, or safety.
3. Since fires ignore civil boundaries, it is necessary that cities, counties, special districts, state agencies, and federal agencies work together to bring raging fires under control.
4. Preventive measures are therefore needed to ensure the preservation of the public peace. health, or safety.
5. While the prevention of wildiand fires is a matter of statewide concern, local governments may impose more restrictive fire and public safety requirements, as otherwise authorized by law.
B. The California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection (CAL FIRE) has identified the entire City of Malibu as a Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zone.
C. Recent court rulings require local jurisdictions to draft more narrowly tailored restrictions against camping on public property to avoid unconstitutionally crirninalizing homelessness.
SECTION 2. Amendments.
Chapter 8.12 of Title 8 of the Malibu Municipal Code is amended to add the following sections:
A. Chapter 8.12.050 Restricted Entry in the Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zone.
Any person who is present in portions of the Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zone closed to the public under this Chapter is committing a trespass, unless written permission allowing such presence has been obtained from the Fire Chief or the City Manager. Notwithstanding Ordinance No. XXX Page 2 of 3
any other provision of this Code, notice of said offense shall be deemed sufficient when provided pursuant to Section 8.12.060. This section does not apply to public roadways or to any commercially or institutionally zoned property.
B. Chapter 8.12.060 Notice.
For purposes of this Chapter, notice may be given as follows:
1. Posted Property. By posted signs identifying the property closed to the public within the Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zone, bearing the words “HIGH FIRE HAZARD ZONE
- PROPERTY CLOSED TO THE PUBLIC - TRESPASSING FORBIDDEN BY LAW” in letters not less than three (3) inches in height, at the entrance thereto and along all exterior boundaries at equal intervals not less than three to the mile, and at all roads and trails entering the property; or
2. Personal Notice. By personal notice given directly to a person found in an area of the Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zone closed to the public, advising the person that the area is closed to the public and that if the person refuses or fails immediately to leave the closed area, or if the person leaves and returns, the person’s presence in that area constitutes trespassing.
SECTION 3. CEQA~
The City Council hereby finds that adoption of the Ordinance is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (“CEQA”) under the Class 7 Categorical Exemption for actions taken to assure protection of natural resources (CEQA Guideline 15307) and the Class 8 exemption for protection of the environment (CEQA Guideline 15308). An ordinance for the protection of life and property and protection of the environment is also covered by the common sense exemption that CEQA only applies to projects which have the potential for causing significant effects on the environment. (CEQA Guideline 15061 (b)(3).)
SECTION 4. Severability.
Should any provision of this Ordinance be declared by a court of competent jurisdiction to be invalid, the same shall not affect the validity of the Ordinance as a whole or any remaining provisions hereof. The City Council of the City of Malibu hereby declares that it would have adopted this Ordinance despite any partial invalidity of its provisions.
SECTION 5. Effective Date.
This ordinance shall take effect 30 days after its adoption.
SECTION 6. The City Clerk shall certify the adoption of this ordinance.
PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED this ___ day of___ 2019. Ordinance No. XXX Page 3 of 3
KAREN FARRER, Mayor ATTEST:
HEATHER GLASER, City Clerk (seal)
Date:
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
CHRISTI HOGIN, City Attorney Public Safety Commission Meeting 10-02-19 Item 4.D. Public Safety Commission Agenda Report
To: Chair Frost and Members of the Public Safety Commission
Prepared by: Mary Linden, Executive Assistant\~)~’
Approved by: Reva Feldman, City Managerf1~’
Date prepared: September 23, 2019 Meeting date: October 2, 2019
Subject: Public Safety Agency Activity
RECOMMENDED ACTION: Discuss recent Public Safety Agency activities and receive and file activity reports from the County of Los Angeles Sheriff’s Department, Fire Department, and Lifeguards.
DISCUSSION: The City contracts with the County of Los Angeles for public safety services, including Sheriff, Fire and Lifeguard services. Monthly reports summarizing agency services for August 2019 are attached for review.
ATTACHMENTS: 1. County of Los Angeles Sheriff’s Department Year to Date Crime Statistic Comparisons for the City of Malibu for the month of August 2019
2. County of Los Angeles Fire Department Activity Report — August 2019 3. County of Los Angeles Fire Department, Lifeguard Services Activity Report — August 2019
Page 1 of 1 Agenda Item # 4.D. OUNTY 0 OS ANGE ES
ALEXV~T~y~ A1 ~RIFF
eptember 11,2019
Reva Feldman, City Manager City of Malibu 23825 Stuart Ranch Road Malibu, CA 90265
Dear Mrs. Feldman:
Listed below are the year-to-date crime statistic comparisons for the City of Malibu for the month of August 2019. I. CRIME STATISTICS CRIME CURRENT MTH YTD 2019 YTD 2018 CHANGE Homicide 0 Rape 1 Robbe Armed Strong-Arm Assault Bur Ia Residential Business Garage/Out-Building Vehicle (locked) Theft Grand ($950 ÷) I Petty Vehicle (unlocked) Grand Theft Vehiäle Arson Domestic Violence Felony Total Part I Crimes 48 301 296 +5 Percent hange +1.7% Domestic Violence 0 16 14 2 Misdemeanor 211 WEST TEMPLE STREET, Los ANGELES, C~ui’oimm. 90012 ~: ATTACHMENT I 3
Reva Feldman, City Manager -2- September11, 2019
NOTEWORTHY INCIDENTS
A resident was arrested for attempted bank robbery in the 23300 block of Pacific Coast Highway. The suspect entered the location and demanded money from the safe. (19-04870)
Two subjects, residents of Canoga Park and Northridge, were arrested for possession of a stolen vehicle. The vehicle was stolen in the jurisdiction of the Los Angeles Police Department’s Devonshire Division. One of the subjects was also charged for felon in possession of a loaded firearm. The loaded firearm was found inside the vehicle. (19-04494)
A Malibu transient was arrested for the three burglaries that occurred in the 29100 block of Heathercliff Road. In one incident, the skylight had been torn from the roof of a shed to make entry. No property was taken. In another incident, the suspect removed/ripped off the plywood door to a business to make entry and took clothing and a tool. In the third incident, the suspect removed panes of glass on a window of another business, stuck his arm through the opening and attempted to open the door. No entry was made. The suspect was identified via the surveillance footage from all three locations. (19-04612, 04613, 04616)
Eight vehicle burglaries occurred in the 23000 block of Pacific Coast Highway. The methods of entry were windows smashed (5 incidents), broke door handle to gain entry in one incident, vehicle key fob left under a rock by victim and was used by unknown suspect to gain entry into vehicle in another incident and vehicle key left on beach while the victim was surfing which the suspect(s) used to make entry into the vehicle in another incident. No suspect(s) seen or heard. Property stolen consisted of vehicle keys, wallets, cash, credit cards, backpacks, cell phones, clothing, sunglasses, cameras and equipment, a laptop, iPad and jewelry. (19-04455, 04475, 04538, 04665, 04694, 04823, 04824, 04931)
Ill. TRAFFIC See attached.
IV. CRIME PREVENTION See attached.
V. AGENDIZED CAR See attached.
VI. JUVENILE INTERVENTION TEAM See attached. Reva Feldman, City Manager 3- September11, 2019
VII. ARREST STATISTICS The numbers of arrests listed below are the most current available.
YEAR TO DATE CURRENT MONTH 2019 AUGUST ADULT JUVENILE ADULT JUVENILE Criminal Homicide 0 0 0 0 Forcible Rape 0 0 0 0 Robbery 5 0 1 0 Aggravated Assault 6 0 2 0 Burglary 8 0 1 0 Larceny Theft 8 0 0 0 Grand TheftAuto 4 0 1 0 Arson 0 0 0 0 Forgery 2 0 0 0 Fraud and NSF checks 7 0 2 0 Sex Offenses, Felonies 1 0 0 0 Sex Offenses, Misdemeanors 0 0 0 0 Non-Aggravated Assaults 18 0 2 0 Weapon Laws 5 0 3 0 Offenses Against Family 2 0 0 0 Narcotics 61 0 15 0 Liquor Laws 0 0 0 0 Drunk/Alcohol/Drugs 41 0 7 0 Disorderly Conduct 2 0 0 0 Vagrancy 0 0 0 0 Gambling 0 0 0 0 Drunk Driving Vehicle/Boat 36 0 8 0 Vehicle/Boating Laws 119 1 17 0 Vandalism 2 1 0 1 Warrants 209 0 20 0 Receiving Stolen Property 0 0 0 0 Federal Offenses W/O Money 0 0 0 0 Federal Offenses With Money 0 0 0 0 Felonies, Miscellaneous 5 0 2 0 Misdemeanors, Miscellaneous 38 0 8 0 ARREST TOTALS 579 2 89 1
Sincerely,
ALEX VILLANUEVA, SHERIFF
Matthew S. Vander Horck, Captain Malibu/Lost Hills Station 5 f~% Los Angeles county Malibu I Lost Hills Station ~ Sker~ff~s ~epartnient City of Malibu
Consolidated Contract City Monthly Traffic Report
August 2019
COLLISION SUMMARY~ This Month Month Year Total Total Prior Change Prior Yfl) YTJ) ÷1-
Total Collisions - Excluding Private Property 39 47 255 II 271 -16 Fatal Collisions 0 1 2 1 2 0 Injury Collisions 14 14 88 89 -1
Property Collisions 25 32 165 178 -13
Private Property Collisions 3 8 40 42 -2
DUI Collisions with Injuries 1 1 6 2 +4
DUI Collisions with Property Damage 0 3 5 5 0
Total Pedestrian Collisions 1 1 5 I -2 Pedestrians Killed 0 0 1 1 0
Pedestrians Injured 1 1 5 7 -2
Total Hit & Run Collisions [ 2 8 32 f 34 -2 Hit & Run Fatalities 0 0 0 0 0
Hit & Run Injuries 0 1 1 4 -3
Hit & Run Property Only 2 7 31 30 +1 .1 CITATION SUMMARY* This Month MonthYear Total Total Prior Change Prior YTO YTD +1- TraflicTotal 1548 } 3582 20119 19238 +881 Hazardous Violations 921 504 4414 3795 +619
Non-Hazardous Violations 627 467 2335 2317 +18 Parking Violations [ 4628 2605 17977 13105 +4872 DUI Arrests 8 6 29 21 +8
*Collision Summary and Citation Summary does not reflect all collisions and citations which were not entered into the database. 6
761551 N25A - SH - AD - 32A (2/72)
COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES SHERIFF’S DEPARTMENT TIA Tradition of Service!! OFFICE CORRESPONDENCE DATE: 08-13-2019
FROM: David Huelsen, Traffic Investigator TO: Matthew S. Vander Horck, Gaptail Malibu/Lost Hills Station Malibu/Lost Hills Station
SUBJECT: August Motor Activity Report City of Malibu
During the month of August the motorcycle officers wrote 967 citations. The citations break down into the following categories:
Unsafe Speed 480 Other Hazard 94 Other Non-Hazard 238 Signs and Signals 121 Unsafe Turning 15 Seat Belt 3 Fail to Yield 14 Unknown 2
DHH: 7 LA. County Sheriffs Department Lost Hills & Malibu Station Monthly Traffic Safety Management Report City of MALIBU Date Range Reported: 8/1/20 19 to 8/31/2019 Total No. of Collisions: 39 Injury: 14 Non-Injury: 25 Fatal: 0 Private Property: 3
Total No. of Citations: 1549 Hazardous Cites: 921 Non-Hazardous Cites: 628
Collisions by Reporting Districts Reporting District No. Location
1010 1 at Decker Canyon Rd and Pacific Coast Hwy 1011 2 at Separate Locations 1012 2 at Pacific Coast Hwy and Westward Beach Rd 5 at Separate Locations 1013 2 at Separate Locations 1014 4 at Separate Locations 1015 8 at Separate Locations 1016 2 at Las Flores Canyon Rd and Pacific Coast Hwy 2 at Pacific Coast Hwy and Sweetwater Canyon Rd 5 at Separate Locations 1017 3 at Separate Locations 1020 1 at Muiholland Hwy and Pacific Coast Hwy 1029 1 at Pacific Coast Hwy and Topanga Canyon Blvd 1086 1 at Corral Canyon Rd and Pacific Coast Hwy
Collision Occurred Most Frequently On:
Street Name Number of Collisions
1 8 Pacific Coast Hwy 29 3 at Las Flores Canyon Rd 2 at Big Rock Dr 2 at John Tyler Dr 2 at Malibu Canyon Rd 2 at Sweetwater Canyon Rd 2 at Westward Beach Rd 16 at at Separate Locations Malibu Canyon Rd 3 3 at at Separate Locations Kanan Dume Rd 2 2 at at Separate Locations Mulholland Hwy 1 at Pacific Coast Hwy
Primary Collision Factors:
Violations Description Number of Collisions
22107 Unsafe Turning Movement 10 22350 Unsafe Speed 5 21703 Following Too Closely 4 22106 Unsafe Start Or Backing 3 21 801 (a) Left Turns Or U-Turns Yield To Other Vehicles 3 21 658(a) Lane Straddling; Unsafe Lane Change 3 3 21 804(a) Failure To Yield Exiting Private Property Or Alley 2 23152(a) Dui; Alcohol i 2251 5(a) Unattended Motor Vehicle On A Hwy 1 21 954(a) Pedestrian Yield, Upon Roadway Outside Crosswal 1 21658 1 0
Violations Most Frequently Cited:
Violations Description Number of Citations
17.12.320 Alcohol On The Beach 416 22350 Unsafe Speed 415 22349(a) Speeding, Excess Of 65 Mph 134 22101(d) Reqd Or Prohibited Turn; Fail To Obey Sign 95 16028(a) Proof Of Financial Liability-Traffic Accident 74 5204(a) Current Month And Year Tabs Attached 52 5200(a) License Plates, Two On A Vehicle Front/Rear 48 231 23.5(a) Texting While Driving 46 12500(a) Unlicensed Driver 44 21950(a) Yield To Pedestrian In Crosswalk 39
2 9 4000(a)(1) Vehicle Registration Required 35 22450(a) Failure To Stop For Posted Stop Sign 30 4454(a) Registration Card Kept With Vehicle 27 231 23(a) Using Wireless Hand Held Phone While Driving 22 21461(a) Obey Traffic Control Sign 20 38300 Off-Highway Vehicle, Disobey Signs 16 12951 (a) Drivers License, Not In Possession 14 16020(a) Proof Of Insurance In Vehicle At All Times 14 14601 .1(a) Driving With Suspended License 13 21 453(a) Red Signal; Failure To Stop 13 21651(a)( 11 17.12.390 Glass On The Beach 10 21460(a) Double Yellow Lines; Drive To The Left Of 8 26708(a)( 7 22102 Violation U-Turn; Business District 6 231 52(a) Dui; Alcohol 6 22362 5 27151(a) Exhaust System Modified 5 22100(a) Right Turn At Intersection, Improper Position 4 26708(a)( 4 27315(d)( 4 10.32.010 3 14601 .2(a) Driving With Suspended License, Dui 3 21453(c) Red Arrow; Failure To Obey 3 21460.5(c) Two-Way Traffic Left Turn Lane 3 21 658(a) Lane Straddling; Unsafe Lane Change 3 21750 Unsafe Passing On The Left 3 22100(b) Left Turn At Intersections, Improper Position 3 22107 Unsafe Turning Movement 3 231 52(b) Dui, .08 Bac Or Greater 3 23222(a) Possess Open Container While Driving 3 23247(e) Ignition Interlock Device Required To Oper. Veh. 3 5201 (a) License Plates, Securely Attached And Visible 3 21703 Following Too Closely 2 21951 Passing Vehicle Stopped At Crosswalk For Ped 2 22100.5 U-Turn From Left Lane 2 22400(a) Minimum Speed Law; Impede Traffic 2 23152(f) Dui-Combined Alcohol And Drugs 2 23222(b) Passenger Possess Open Container 2 25620(a) Open Alcohol Container 2 27803(b) Safety Helmets, Required Driver Or Passenger 2 4457 Stolen ,lost, Or Damaged Plates And Cards 2 602.8(a) Trespass On Land Cultivated;enclosed Or Posted 2 12.08.090 1 12300(b) 1 12500(B) Unlicensed Driver 1
3 10 12814.6(b) Provisional Cdl Violation 1 14601.5(a) Driving With Suspended License, Dui 1 14603 Violation Of License Restrictions 1 17.12.310 1 17.12.365 1 21451(b) Green Arrow, Movement Indicated 1 21 453(b) Stop; Yield Before Making Turn 1 21 453(d) Pedestrian; Failure To Stop 1 21456(b) Wait Or Don’t Walk Signal 1 21650 Failure To Drive On Right Half Of Roadway 1 21658(B) Designated Lanes 1 21 755(a) Unsafe Passing On Right 1 21801(a) Left Turns Or U-Turns Yield To Other Vehicles 1 21802(a) Failure To Yield After Stopping For Stop Sign 1 21804(a) Failure To Yield Exiting Private Property Or Alley 1 21806(a) Fail To Yield To Emergency Vehicle 1 22106 Unsafe Start Or Backing 1 22109 Stopping Suddenly Without Signaling 1 22348(b) Speeding; Excess Of 100 Mph 1 22349(b) Exceeding 55 Mph Speed Limit 1 23220(a) Drinking While Driving 1 23224(a) Driving Under 21 Years, Oper. Veh Carrying Alcohol 1 24252(a) Maintain Required Lighting 1
24600(a) Taillamps - At Least 1 Required 1 24601 License Plate Lamp White Only, Vis 50’ 1 24603(b) Stoplamps 2 Required (Mfr Post 1957) 1 25950(b) Rear Lights Or Reflectors, Red Only 1 26100 1 26709(a) Rear View Mirror Required 1 27400 Headset Or Earplugs On Both Ears 1 4152.5 Required Registration For Foreign Vehicle Upon Exp 1 4461(c) Disabled Person Placard, Cancelled Or Revoked 1 6596.1 1
Collisions Involving Pedestrians~ 1 Most Frequent Violations
Collisions Involving Bicyclists: 2
Most Frequent Violations
4 11
5 12 L.A. County Sheriff’s Department Lost Hills & Malibu Station Monthly Traffic Collision Report
9/11/2019 City of MALIBU Date Range Reported: 8/1/20 19 to 8/31/2019
Collisions Total Non-Injury Collisions 25 Total Injury and Fatal Collisions 14
Total Collisions (Injury + Non-Injury) 39
DUI Collisions N umber of DUI Collisions with Fatalities o Number of DUI Collisions with Injuries i Number of DUI Collisions Involving Property Damage 0 Total Number of DUI Collision Deaths 0 Total Number of DUI Collision injuries 1 Total Number of DUI Collisions 1 Total Actual Number of DUI Arrests 8
Non-DUI Collisions Number of Non-DUI Collisions with Fatalities a Number of Non-DUI Collisions with Injuries 13 Number of Non-DUI Collisions Involving Property Damage 25 Total Number of Non-DUI Collision Deaths a Total Number of Non-DUI Collision injuries 17
Vehicle/Pedestrian Collisions Number of Vehicle/Pedestrian Collisions with Fatalities 0 Number of Vehicle/Pedestrian Collisions with Injuries 1 Total Number of Pedestrian Fatalities a Total Number of Pedestrian Injuries i
Vehicle/Bicycle Collisions Number of Vehicle/Bicycle Collisions with Fatalities 0 Number of Vehicle/Bicycle Collisions with Injuries 2 Total Number of Vehicle/Bicycle Collision Fatalities 0 Total Number of Vehicle/Bicycle Collision Injuries 2
1 13
Hit & Run Collisions Total Number of Hit & Run Fatalities 0 Total Number of Hit & Run Injuries 0 Total Number of PDO Hit & Run Collisions 2
Traffic Citations Total Number of Radar Citations Issued 220 Total Number of Bicycle Citations Issued 0 Total Number of Pedestrian Citations Issued 1 Total Number of Safety Belt Citations Issued 4 Total Number of Child Restraint Citations Issued 0 Total Number of Financial Responsibility Citations Issued 88 Total Number of Hazardous Citations Issued 921 Total Number of Non-Hazardous Citations Issued 627 Total Number of Citations Issued 1548
Parking Citations Total Number of Parking Citations Issued 0
Miscellaneous Child in Passenger Seat or Belts, Number of Fatalities Child in Passenger Seat or Belts, Number of Injuries Child Not in Passenger Seat or Belts, Number of Fatalities Child Not in Passenger Seat or Belts, Number of Injuries Number of Code 3 or Pursuit Collision Fatalities Number of Code 3 or Pursuit Collision Injuries Number of Patrol Vehicle Rear-End Collisions with Amber On
Enforcement Index Enforcement Index 65.8
2 LA. County Sheriffs Department Lost Hills & Malibu Station From 81112019 to 8131 I2019 Total Collisions: 39 Collision Summary Report 9111119 Injury Collisions: 13 Fatal Collisions: I
Page 1 of 7
919-04296-1016- 8/1/2019 14:32 Thursday PACIFIC COAST HWY - SWEETWATER CANYON RD 528 Direction: East Daylight Clear Pty at Fault:1 472 Broadside Other Motor Vehicle Improper Turning 22107 Hit & Run: No Property Damage Only # Inj: 0 # Killed: 0 Party 1 Driver South Making Left Turn Male Age: 41 2019 VOLKSWAGEN GTI Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use Party 2 Driver South Proceeding Straight Male Age: 45 2007 HARLEY DAVIDS FXDL Motorcycle No Injury
Veh Type: Motorcycle Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent M/C Helmet Driver - Yes Cell Phone Not In Use Party 3 Driver South Proceeding Straight Male Age: 25 2015 HARLEY DAVIDS FXDL Motorcycle No Injury
Veh Type: Motorcycle Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent M/C Helmet Driver - Yes Cell Phone Not In Use 919-04310-1012- 8/2/2019 10:20 Friday KANAN DUME RD - PACIFIC COAST HWY 0’ Direction: Not Stated Daylight Clear Pty at Fault:1 471 Rear-End Other Motor Vehicle Unsafe Starting or Backing 22106 Hit & Run: No Complaint of Pain # lnj: 2 # Killed: 0 Party 1 Driver South Proceeding Straight Female Age: 41 2019 CHEVROLET TAHOE Sport Utility Vehicle No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use Party 2 Driver South Stopped In Road Female Age: 42 2008 TOYOTA RAV4 Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep Complaint of Pain Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use 919-04318-1016- 8/2/2019 16:50 Friday PACIFIC COAST HWY - RAMBLA PACIFICO 150 Direction: East Daylight Clear Pty at Fault:1 471 Rear-End Other Motor Vehicle Unsafe Starting or Backing 22106 Hit & Run: No Complaint of Pain 4* In]: 1 4* Killed: 0 Party 1 Driver North Proceeding Straight Male Age: 59 2017 CHRYSLER PACIFICA Sport Utility Vehicle No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: Inattention Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use Party 2 Driver North Stopped In Road Male Age:36 2007TOYOTA CAMRY Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep Complaint of Pain Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use 919-04319-1012- 8/2/2019 17:15 Friday PACIFIC COAST HWY - CAVALLERI RD 22 Direction: North Daylight Clear Pty at Fault:1 472 Rear-End Other Motor Vehicle Following Too Closely 21703 Hit & Run: No Property Damage Only 4* In]: 0 4* Killed: 0 Party 1 Driver South Proceeding Straight Female Age: 23 2011 HONDA CIVIC Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: Inattention Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Handsfree In Use Party 2 Driver South Stopped In Road Female Age: 61 2016 MACK CX5 Sport Utility Vehicle No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: Stop and Go Traffi Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use Party 3 Driver South Stopped In Road Male Age: 2015 SUBARU FORESTER Sport Utility Vehicle No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: Stop and Go Traffi Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use 919-04330-1012- 8/3/2019 12:11 Saturday PACIFIC COAST HWY - WESTWARD BEACH RD 25 Direction: North Daylight Clear Pty at Fault:1 471 Head-On Other Motor Vehicle Improper Turning 22107 Hit & Run: No Complaint of Pain # In]: 2 # Killed: 0 Party 1 Driver West Making Left Turn Male Age: 30 2018 ING 050S Sport Utility Vehicle Complaint of Pain Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use Party 2 Driver South Proceeding Straight Male Age: 60 2017 AUDI A4 Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep Complaint of Pain Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use Page 2 of 7
919-04348-1020- 8/4/2019 00:55 Sunday MULHOLLAND HWY - PACIFIC COAST HWY 3’ Direction: North Dark-NoStreet Clear PtyatFault:1 472 Sideswipe Fixed Object Other Than Driver Hit & Run: No Property Damage Only # lnj: 0 # Killed: 0 Party 1 Driver North Ran Off Road Male Age: 31 2011 FORD CROWN VICTO Police Car No Injury Veh Type: Emergency Vehicle Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use 919-04515-1017- 8/4/2019 12:30 Sunday PACIFIC COAST HWY -TUNA CANYON RD 5280 Direction: North Daylight Clear Pty at Fault:1 471 Rear-End Other Motor Vehicle Following Too Closely 21703 Hit & Run: No Complaint of Pain # nj: 1 # Killed: 0 Party 1 Driver North Proceeding Straight Male Age: 32 2007 SUZUKI GXE Sport Utility Vehicle Complaint of Pain
Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent M/C Helmet Driver - Yes Cell Phone Not In Use Party 2 Driver North Proceeding Straight Male Age: 53 2013 TESLA S Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use 919-04353-1029- 8/4/2019 13:06 Sunday PACIFIC COAST HWY -TOPANGA CANYON BLVD 492’ Direction: West Daylight Clear Pty at Fault:1 472 Sideswipe Parked Motor Vehicle Unsafe Speed 22350 Hit&Run:No Property Damage Only # Inj: 0 # Killed: 0 Party 1 Driver East Proceeding Straight Male Age: 31 2011 KAWASAKI NINJA Motorcycle No Injury Veh Type: Motorcycle Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: Violation Cell Phone Handsfree In Use Party 2 Parked Vehicle Parked Age: 2019 HONDA FIT Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: Not Applicable Assoc Factor: None Apparent Hazardous Material
919-04372-1016- 8/4/2019 22:00 Sunday PACIFIC COAST HWY - SWEETWATER CANYON RD 370’ Direction: East Dark - Street Lig Clear Pty at Fault:1 250 Other Parked Motor Vehicle Improper Turning 22107 Hit & Run: Misde Property Damage Only 4* Inj: 0 4* Killed: 0 Party 1 Driver East Making Right Turn Age: 2018 MERCEDES-BENZ GLE35O Sport Utility Vehicle No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: Impairment Not Kno Assoc Factor: None Apparent Not Stated Party 2 Parked Vehicle Parked Age: 2014 TOYOTA AVALON Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: Not Applicable Assoc Factor: None Apparent Not Stated
919-04383-1016- 8/6/2019 21:19 Tuesday PACIFIC COAST HWY - LAS FLORES CANYON RD 0’ Direction: East Dark - Street Lig Clear Pty at Fault:1 472 Sideswipe Other Motor Vehicle Auto R/W Violation 21804(a) Hit & Run: No Property Damage Only 4* Inj: 0 4* Killed: 0 Party 1 Driver East Entering Traffic Female Age: 49 2019 NISSAN SENTRA Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap Belt Used Cell Phone Not In Use Party 2 Driver East Proceeding Straight Male Age: 26 2008 INFINITI FX3S Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap Belt Used Cell Phone Not In Use 919-04407-1012- 8/7/2019 13:55 Wednesday KANAN DUME RD - CAVALLERI RD 1584’ Direction: North Daylight Clear Pty at Fault:1 471 Head-On Other Motor Vehicle Improper Turning 22107 Hit & Run: No Other Visible Injury #Inj:3 #KiIIed:O Party 1 Driver South Crossed Into Opposing Lane Female Age: 20 2008 FORD FOCUS Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep Other Visible Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: Violation Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use Party 2 Driver North Proceeding Straight Male Age: 52 2017 DODGE RAM 1500 Pickups & Panels Other Visible Injury Veh Type: Pickup Truck Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use 919-04422-1017- 8/7/2019 19:00 Wednesday PACIFIC COAST HWY - BIG ROCK DR 1056’ Direction: North Daylight Clear Pty at Fault:1 471 Sideswipe Other Motor Vehicle Improper Turning 22107 Hit & Run: No Other Visible Injury #Inj:1 4*Killed:O Party 1 Driver South Other Unsafe Turning Male Age: 23 2013 IKAWASAKI NINJA Motorcycle Other Visible Injury
Veh Type: Motorcycle Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: Violation M/C Helmet Driver - Yes Cell Phone Not In Use Party 2 Driver South Proceeding Straight Male Age:27 2O11SCION TC Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use
~31 Page 3 of 7
919-04439-1012- 8/8/2019 16:25 Thursday PACIFIC COAST HWY - MORNING VIEW DR 358 Direction: East Daylight Clear Pty at Fault:1 471 Rear-End Other Motor Vehicle Following Too Closely 21703 Hit & Run: No Fatal #lnj:1 #KiIIed:O Party 1 Driver North Proceeding Straight Female Age: 26 2018 HONDA CIVIC Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use Party 2 Driver North Slowing/Stopping Male Age: 56 2016 FORD EDGE Sport Utility Vehicle Fatal Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use 919-04451-1014- 8/9/2019 07:11 Friday PACIFIC COAST HWY - MALIBU CANYON RD 180 Direction: West Daylight Clear Pty at Fault:1 472 Rear-End Other Motor Vehicle Unsafe Starting or Backing 22106 Hit & Run: No Property Damage Only # lnj: 0 # Killed: 0 Party 1 Driver South Proceeding Straight Female Age: 64 2017 BUICK ENCORE Sport Utility Vehicle No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: Impairment Not Kno Assoc Factor: None Apparent Unknown Cell Phone Not In Use Party 2 Driver South Stopped In Road Female Age: 54 2011 MAZDA MAZDA 3 Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use
919-04617-1016- 8/10/2019 12:30 Saturday PACIFIC COAST HWY - 2112’ Direction: East Pty at Fault: 472 Hit & Run: No Property Damage Only # In]: 0 # Killed: 0 Party 1 Driver North Male Age: 54 1996 HUMMER AMG Sport Utility Vehicle No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: Assoc Factor: Unknown Party 2 Driver North Male Age: 45 2014 LAND ROVER UNK Sport Utility Vehicle No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: Assoc Factor: Lap/Shoulder Harness Used
919-04492-1013- 8/11/2019 16:13 Sunday PACIFIC COAST HWY - MEADOW CT 0’ Direction: Not Stated Daylight Clear Pty at Fault:1 471 Sideswipe Motor Vehicle on Othe Improper Turning 22107 Hit & Run: No Complaint of Pain # lnj: 1 # Killed: 0 Party 1 Driver South Stopped In Road Female Age: 78 2018 SUBARU FORESTER Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep Complaint of Pain Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: Inattention Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use Party 2 Driver South Stopped In Road Male Age: 32 2018 AUDI A3 Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Unknown Cell Phone Not In Use Party 3 Parked Vehicle South Parked Age: 2007 TOYOTA COROLLA Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Cell Phone Not In Use Party 4 Parked Vehicle South Parked Age: 2011 NISSAN Pickups & Panels No Injury Veh Type: Pickup Truck Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Cell Phone Not In Use
919-04916-1015- 8/12/2019 01:45 Monday PACIFIC COAST HWY - MALIBU CANYON RD 0’ Direction: Not Stated Dark - Street Lig Clear Pty at Fault:1 471 Sideswipe Other Motor Vehicle Unsafe Speed 22350 Hit & Run: No Complaint of Pain # lnj: 1 # Killed: 0 Party 1 Driver North Proceeding Straight Male Age: 22 2018 VOLKSWAGEN JETTA Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use Party 2 Driver South Making Left Turn Female Age: 16 2017 LAND ROVER RANGE ROVER Sport Utility Vehicle Complaint of Pain Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: Violation Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use 919-04534-1017- 8/14/2019 03:30 Wednesday PACIFIC COAST HWY - LAS FLORES CANYON RD 739’ Direction: East Dark - Street Lig Clear Pty at Fault:1 472 Sideswipe Parked Motor Vehicle Improper Turning 22107 Hit & Run: No Property Damage Only # In]: 0 # Killed: 0 Party 1 Driver West Proceeding Straight Female Age: 41 2018 VOLVO S60 Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use Party 2 Parked Vehicle West Parked Age: 2019 MERCEDES-BENZ CLA2SO Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: Not Applicable Assoc Factor: None Apparent Cell Phone Not In Use Party 3 Parked Vehicle West Parked Age: 2001 LAND ROVER UNK Sport Utility Vehicle No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: Not Applicable Assoc Factor: None Apparent Cell Phone Not In Use 0~; Page 4 of 7
919-04545-1016- 8/14/2019 12:00 Wednesday PACIFIC COAST HWY - LAS FLORES CANYON RD 30’ Direction: North Daylight Clear Pty at Fault:2 472 Head-On Other Motor Vehicle Auto R/W Violation 21804(a) Hit & Run: No Property Damage Only 4 In]: 0 4 Killed: 0 Party 1 Driver North Proceeding Straight Male Age: 20 2007 HONDA CIVIC Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: Violation Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use Party 2 Driver South Making Left Turn Male Age: 28 2013 HONDA CIVIC Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use
919-04577-1016- 8/15/2019 12:30 Thursday 3401 SERRA RD - PRIVATE PROPERTY Direction: Daylight Clear Pty at Fault:1 472 Sideswipe Other Motor Vehicle Unsafe Starting or Backing Hit & Run: Misde Property Damage Only 4 lnj: 0 4 Killed: 0 Party 1 Driver South Parking Maneuver Male Age: 49 2014 CADILLAC UNK Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: Impairment Not Kno Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Not Stated Party 2 Driver South Parked Male Age: 35 2017 LEXUS NX Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use
919-04585-1011- 8/15/2019 14:45 Thursday 30811 PACIFIC COAST HWY - Direction: Daylight Clear Pty at Fault:1 472 Sideswipe Other Motor Vehicle Other Improper Driving Hit & Run: No Property Damage Only 4 lnj: 0 4 Killed: 0 Party 1 Driver West Backing Male Age: 22 2019 OUT RV Motor Home <40 Feet No Injury Veh Type: Other Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use Party 2 Parked Vehicle West Parked Age: 1999 CHEVROLET SEMI Two Axle Truck No Injury Veh Type: Truck Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Cell Phone Not In Use
919-04587-1012- 8/15/2019 14:46 Thursday PACIFIC COAST HWY - WINDING WY W 240’ Direction: West Daylight Clear Pty at Fault:1 472 Sideswipe Other Motor Vehicle Auto R/W Violation 21658 Hit&Run:No Property Damage Only # Inj: 0 4 Killed: 0 Party 1 Driver South Changing Lanes Male Age: 59 2019 UTILITY TRUCK Pickups & Panels No Injury Veh Type: Pickup Truck Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use Party 2 Driver South Proceeding Straight Female Age: 43 2018 MERCEDES-BENZ GLC300 Sport Utility Vehicle No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use Party 3 Driver North Proceeding Straight Female Age: 22 2019 KIA ZZ No Injury Veh Type: Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use Party 4 Parked Vehicle North Parked Age: 1999 NISSAN FRONTIER Pickups & Panels No Injury Veh Type: Pickup Truck Sobriety: Not Applicable Assoc Factor: None Apparent Cell Phone Not In Use 919-04624-1012- 8/16/2019 16:45 Friday PACIFIC COAST HWY - WESTWARD BEACH RD 0’ Direction: Not Stated Daylight Cloudy Pty at Fault:1 472 Broadside Other Motor Vehicle Auto R/W Violation 21801(a) Hit & Run: No Property Damage Only 4 lnj: 0 4 Killed: 0 Party 1 Driver West Making Left Turn Male Age: 81 2015 MERCEDES-BENZ S550 Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use Party 2 Driver South Stopped In Road Female Age: 35 2012 NISSAN ALTIMA Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use
919-04634-1015- 8/17/2019 02:19 Saturday PACIFIC COAST HWY -JOHN TYLER DR 36’ Direction: West Dark - No Street Clear Pty at Fault:1 242 Other Fixed Object Unsafe Lane Change 21658(a) Hit & Run: No Property Damage Only 4 In]: 0 4 Killed: 0 Party 1 Driver West Proceeding Straight Male Age: 27 2017 TOYOTA TACOMA Pickups & Panels No Injury Veh Type: Pickup Truck Sobriety: HBD Under Influenc Assoc Factor: Violation Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use
919-04636-1015- 8/17/2019 08:42 Saturday PACIFIC COAST HWY - SERRA RD 1584 Direction: East Daylight Clear Pty at Fault:1 471 Broadside Bicycle Improper Turning 22107 Hit & Run: No Complaint of Pain 4 In]: 1 4 Killed: 0 Page 5 of 7 Party 1 Driver West Making Right Turn Female Age: 21 2017 CHEVROLET CRUZE Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: Inattention Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use Party 2 Bicyclist West Proceeding Straight Male Age: 31 Bicycle Complaint of Pain Veh Type: Bicycle Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent M/C Helmet Driver - No Cell Phone Not In Use 919-04695-1014- 8/21/2019 01:12 Wednesday PACIFIC COAST HWY - LATIGO CANYON RD 1320’ Direction: North Dark - No Street Clear Pty at Fault:1 471 Overturned Other Motor Vehicle Improper Turning 22107 Hit & Run: No Complaint of Pain #lnj:1 #Killed:0 Party 1 Driver South Proceeding Straight Male Age: 44 CAT TL1255C Hwy. Construction Equip. No Injury
Veh Type: Highway Construction Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent M/C Helmet Driver - Yes Cell Phone Not In Use Party 2 Driver South Proceeding Straight Male Age: 25 2006 FORD ESCAPE Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep Complaint of Pain Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use 919-04721-1015- 8/22/2019 09:30 Thursday MALIBU CANYON RD - CIVIC CENTER WAY 0’ Direction: Not Stated Daylight Clear Pty at Fault:1 472 Sideswipe Other Motor Vehicle Auto R/W Violation 21801(a) Hit & Run: No Property Damage Only ft Inj: 0 ft Killed: 0 Party 1 Driver East Making Left Turn Female Age: 24 2019 TOYOTA CAMRY Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use Party 2 Driver North Proceeding Straight Male Age: 49 2018 VOLKSWAGEN TIGUAN Sport Utility Vehicle No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use
919-04738-1010- 8/22/2019 20:10 Thursday PACIFIC COAST HWY - DECKER CANYON RD 0’ Direction: East Dark - No Street Clear Pty at Fault:1 471 Vehicle - Pedestrian Pedestrian Pedestrian Violation 21954(a) Hit & Run: No Other Visible Injury #In]:1 #Killed:O Party 1 Pedestrian Stopped In Road Female Age: 30 Pedestrian Other Visible Injury
Veh Type: Pedestrian Sobriety: Impairment Not Kno Assoc Factor: Inattention M/C Helmet Driver - Yes Cell Phone Not in Use Party 2 Driver North Proceeding Straight Male Age: 20 2001 LEXUS ES300 Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use
919-04761-1015- 8/23/2019 15:45 Friday MALIBU CANYON RD - CIVIC CENTER WY 0’ Direction: Not Stated Daylight Clear Pty at Fault:1 472 Head-On Other Motor Vehicle Auto R/W Violation 21801(a) Hit & Run: No Property Damage Only ft In]: 0 ft Killed: 0 Party 1 Driver South Making Left Turn Male Age: 22 2012 FORD FIESTA Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use Party 2 Driver North Proceeding Straight Female Age: 47 2006 HONDA ODYSSEY Mini Van No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use
919-04763-1014- 8/23/2019 16:40 Friday PACIFIC COAST HWY - VIA ESCONDIDO 2112 Direction: North Daylight Clear Pty at Fault:1 472 Sideswipe Fixed Object Unsafe Lane Change 21658(a) Hit & Run: No Property Damage Only ft In]: 0 ft Killed: 0 Party 1 Driver North Proceeding Straight Male Age: 41 2011 CHEVROLET TAHOE Sport Utility Vehicle No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use 919-04798-1015- 8/25/2019 13:37 Sunday PACIFIC COAST HWY - BIG ROCK DR 0’ Direction: Not Stated Daylight Clear Pty at Fault:1 255 Sideswipe Other Motor Vehicle Unsafe Speed 22350 Hit&Run:No Property Damage Only ft In]: 0 ft Killed: 0 Party 1 Driver East Changing Lanes Male Age: 28 2005 PONTIAC VIBE Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use Party 2 Driver East Stopped In Road Male Age: 26 2019 FORD MUSTANG Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use Party 3 Driver East Stopped In Road Female Age: 27 2006 DODGE CHARGER Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use
00 Page 6 of 7
919-04799-1013- 8/25/2019 14:00 Sunday PACIFIC COAST HWY - RAMIREZ MESA DR (E) 700’ Direction: East Daylight Clear Pty at Fault:1 472 Rear-End Other Motor Vehicle Following Too Closely 21703 Hit & Run: No Property Damage Only # Inj: 0 4 Killed: 0 Party 1 Driver East Proceeding Straight Female Age: 32 1988 TOYOTA PICK UP Pickups & Panels No Injury Veh Type: Pickup Truck Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use Party 2 Driver East Stopped In Road Female Age: 29 2000 TOYOTA ECHO Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use Party 3 Driver East Stopped In Road Female Age: 21 2013 HYUNDAI ELANTRA Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use Party 4 Driver East Stopped In Road Male Age: 37 2017 MITSUBISHI OUTLANDER Sport Utility Vehicle No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use 919-04822-1016- 8/26/2019 16:52 Monday PACIFIC COAST HWY - 23000 PACIFIC COAST HWY 2640 Direction: East Daylight Clear Pty at Fault:1 472 Rear-End Other Motor Vehicle Unsafe Speed 22350 Hit & Run: No Property Damage Only # lnj: 0 4 Killed: 0 Party 1 Driver West Proceeding Straight Male Age: 20 2019 CHRYSLER 300S Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: Inattention Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use Party 2 Driver West Stopped In Road Male Age: 36 2019 MERCEDES-BENZ GLC300 Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use 919-04836-1015- 8/27/2019 10:53 Tuesday MALIBU CANYON RD - MALIBU KNOLLS RD 250 Direction: North Daylight Clear Pty at Fault:1 472 Sideswipe Other Motor Vehicle Improper Turning 22107 Hit & Run: No Property Damage Only 4 lnj: 0 4 Killed: 0 Party 1 Driver South Entering Traffic Female Age: 26 2019 VOLVO XC6O Sport Utility Vehicle No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use Party 2 Driver North Proceeding Straight Male Age: 39 2015 FORD F-250 Pickups & Panels No Injury Veh Type: Pickup Truck Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use 919-04839-1086- 8/27/2019 12:00 Tuesday PACIFIC COAST HWY - CORRAL CANYON RD 1056 Direction: East Daylight Clear Pty at Fault:1 472 Hit Object Non-Collision Hazardous Parking 22515(a) Hit & Run: No Property Damage Only # lnj: 0 4 Killed: 0 Party 1 Driver South Stopped In Road Male Age:32 2O19TOYOTA COROLLA Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Not Us Cell Phone Not In Use
919-04875-1014- 8/28/2019 20:10 Wednesday PACIFIC COAST HWY - JOHN TYLER DR 0’ Direction: Not Stated Dusk - Dawn Clear Pty at Fault:1 472 Broadside Other Motor Vehicle Unsafe Speed 22350 Hit & Run: No Property Damage Only 4 lnj: 0 # Killed: 0 Party 1 Driver North Proceeding Straight Male Age: 23 2019 TOYOTA TACOMA Pickups & Panels No Injury Veh Type: Pickup Truck Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use Party 2 Driver South Making Left Turn Female Age: 20 2018 CHEVROLET TRAX Sport Utility Vehicle No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use 919-04914-1016- 8/30/2019 15:35 Friday PACIFIC COAST HWY - CARBON CANYON RD 0’ Direction: North Daylight Clear Pty at Fault:1 471 Sideswipe Other Motor Vehicle Unsafe Lane Change 21658(a) Hit & Run: No Other Visible Injury 4 lnj: 1 4 Killed: 0 Party 1 Driver South Changing Lanes Male Age: 49 2007 CHEVROLET COBALT Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use Party 2 Driver South Proceeding Straight Male Age: 21 2016 YAMAHA R6 Motorcycle Other Visible Injury
Veh Type: Motorcycle Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent M/C Helmet Driver - Yes Cell Phone Not In Use
919-04945-1015- 8/31/2019 16:30 Saturday 23930 MALIBU RD - PRIVATE PROPERTY ‘ Direction: Daylight Clear Pty at Fault:1 472 Hit Object Fixed Object Other Improper Driving Hit & Run: No Property Damage Only 4 lnj: 0 4 Killed: 0 Page 7 of 7 Party 1 Driver West Making RighiTurn Male Age: 73 2018 FORD TAURUS Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use
919-04937-1011- 8/31/2019 20:05 Saturday PACIFIC COAST HWY - ENCINAL CANYON RD 0’ Direction: East Dark - No Street Clear Pty at Fault:2 242 Broadside Bicycle Driving Under Influence 23152(a) Hit & Run: No Other Visible Injury #lnj:1 #Killed:0 Party 1 Pedestrian North Entering Traffic Female Age: 26 Pedestrian Other Visible Injury Veh Type: Pedestrian Sobriety: HNBD Assoc Factor: Inattention Cell Phone Not In Use Party 2 Driver North Proceeding Straight Female Age: 25 2001 TOYOTA CAMRY Passenger Car, Station Wagon, Jeep No Injury Veh Type: Passenger Car Sobriety: HBD Under lnfluenc Assoc Factor: None Apparent Lap/Shoulder Harness Used Cell Phone Not In Use
Settings for Query:
City: MALIBU Sorted By: Date and Time
r~) 21
LOST HILLS JUVENILE INTERVENTION UNIT ACTIVITY REPORT FOR AUGUST 2019 MALIBU
SCHOOL ISSUES
First day of LVUSD School 08-21-2019
INTERVENTIONS
Contacted LVUSD schools re: first day of school
COMMUNITY / CRIMINAL ISSUES
1. We conducted a monthly parental resource class at Lost Hills Sheriff’s Station. This program was developed by our unit and is designed to educate parents about: 1) The current trends in juvenile behavior and delinquency, 2) Alcohol/narcotic awareness and recognition, 3) School policy and campus issues, 4) Gang awareness and negative peer relations, 5) Parental rights and responsibilities and, 6) Parental responses to incorrigible and/or delinquent behavior. We also address the specific concerns relating to the minor’s behavior. We educate the minor and their parents of possible criminal behavior and the legal consequences. We offer suggestions and make recommendations to improve the minor’s quality of life.
2. Spoke with numerous citizens and parents who called to question various juvenile concerns and issues in the community. We also provide the parents with various juvenile resource programs within our community.
3. We met with the Sylmar Juvenile Court District Attorney regarding the investigation and filing of criminal charges against juvenile offenders.
4. Met with Acting Captain Salvador Becerra throughout the month in order to keep him up to date regarding our unit’s investigations and current juvenile issues within our city.
5. Entered juveniles into the Juvenile Automated Index system for various violations.
6. Made court appearances to testify as witnesses on the part of the People of the State of California and attended court proceedings in cases generated from the City of Malibu. We also investigated, prepared, and filed cases with the District Attorney’s office. We additionally assisted other investigators in the preparation of cases for court.
7. We met with station narcotic detectives on a regular basis to exchange information regarding juvenile and drug related issues. We have worked with the narcotic detectives on several narcotic cases directly and indirectly involving juveniles. 8. Handled the processing and follow-up of various juvenile referrals brought to the attention of this unit (i.e., Juvenile Information Forms, Field Interview Cards, Juvenile Automated Index, and 22
citations for various juvenile contacts with uniform personnel).
9. Conducted our normal checks ofjuvenile problem areas in the city during weekend evenings and responded to juvenile related calls for service.
10. Updated the Gang Book and briefed the captain on criminal activity trends
11. Registered 5 sexual predators and updated information in database.
12. Participated in the SST program.
13. 290 paperwork, follow-ups, home checks.
14. Assist OSS re: assault suspect.
15. Subpoena Service re: juvie witness.
16. File three cases at Sylmar.
17. Pick up new J-Team inspired brochures/pamphlets (anti bullying, social media, drug use)
18. Assisted Sylmar Juvenile Hall re: 459 Subject
19. Assisted Detective Bureau re: supplemental reports/filing at Sylmar Court.
20. Assisted patrol units re: unifonns.
21. Assisted Detective Bureau re: theft victim follow up.
22. Assisted Sylmar DA re: old case.
23. Assisted patrol re: hit and run case.
24. Assisted Detective Bureau re: search for weapon thrown from vehicle.
25. Assisted Narcotics Unit Re: search warrant.
26. Completed mandated Pursuit Training.
27. Pepperdine Threat Assessment Training.
28. Active Shooter training at Wayside.
29. Assist LHS station re: range set up. 23
30. Junior Deputy Star sticker order
31. Wayside re: Beach Team M4/transition training for TEAM.
32. New trainee briefing re: J-Team protocol
33. Publish and submit STAR news article.
34. Assist Dean of Student Health and Safety.
35. Traffic Deposition re: old TC case.
36. Range Qualification with DB Lieutenant.
37. Collaborate with Tobacco Taskforce.
38. PDC-NCCF re: pick up J-Team Pamphlets
39. Introduce J Team with Community 360 re: new school year.
40. School Visits/JIT pamphlet distribution (anti bullying, social media, drug use)
41. Follow up re: residential vandalism case by student at Malibu High 24
Ma Linden
To: Mary Linden
Subject: EW: Public Safety Commission - October 2
Attachments: Malibu - August 2019.pdf
Hi Mary,
Attached is the August activity report for the upcoming PSC meeting.
Unfortunately, the Chiefs have not yet approved the annual report for the Public Safety Services review. I will get that to you as soon as possible, or I can bring copies with me to the meeting.
Please let me know if you need anything else.
Thank youl!
Megan
~: ~ 6~) P~~i ~ ~ 0-a-’ ATTACHMENT 2 25 ~ ACTIVITYREPORT
CITY/COMMUNITY: MALIBU PERIOD COVERED: August 2019
250 212
200 • Fires Medical 150 • Service HazMat 100 • Hazardous Condition
45 Lifeguard Assist 50 Good Intent 5 2 2 0 0 Total Responses: 303
Patients Seen: 212* 30 24 25 22 20 15 15 ______— 10 4 5 1 4 1 4 1 1 1 1 45 0 u) cuD uo•E~~~! 00 t~o~D ~ ~ ~ 0 C ~ _ ~ 0<<<<~W~~C~° ~ W < 0~)~Q ~ W Z~D ~ ~2 ~•O~00 CU > =~L)~ 0 -D c .!! 5 ~ -5 ~ >. D~ -~ .-z
I- I—
80 74
60 —______42 40 I •ALS BLS
201 — 0I Transports: 116 ALS Transports: accompanied by paramedic; BLS Transports: no paramedic on board
*patients Seen total will be higher than Medical Calls total in first graph if there were multiple patients at one incident. 26
~a~)A. %irn~’ ACTIVITY REPORT
MALIBU — August 2019 FIRE INCIDENTS: DATE TYPE ADDRESS NOTES LOSS 08/01/19 Trash Fire 25560 Pacific Coast Highway Property: $0.00 Contents: $0.00 08/10/19 Fire, other 31677 Sea Level Drive Illegal beach/bonfire, Property: $0.00 extinguished Contents: $0.00 08/22/19 Fire, other 30070 Pacific Coast Highway Illegal beach/bonfire, Property: $0.00 extinguished Contents: $0.00 08/23/19 Structure Fire 20816 Pacific Coast Highway Accidental, fire contained to Property: $2,500.00 storage shed Contents: $1,000.00 08/30/19 Brush Fire Sweetwater Mesa, Serra Road 2~~d alarm brush fire. Property: $0.00 Accidental, caused by brush Contents: $0.00 clearance activities. Total size: 5 acres. Property: $2,500.00 TOTAL: Contents: $1,000.00 OTHER INCIDENTS: DATE TYPE ADDRESS NOTES LOSS 08/20/19 HazMat 24255 Pacific Coast Highway Gas Leak (no damages) 08/20/19 HazMat 5958 Busch Drive Gas Leak (no damages) 08/22/19 Haz Cond Paradise Cove Road Arcing wires 08/29/19 Haz Cond 33222 Pacific Coast Highway Arcing wires
COMMUNITY INVOLVEMENT! ANNOUNCEMENTS! ITEMS OF INTEREST: Ma Linden
From: Rupe, Virginia
Subject: Lifeguard Activity Report - Aug 2019 Attachments: Malibu Lifeguard Activty Report- Aug 2019.pdf
Happy Tuesday after Labor Day!
Attached is the Aug 2019 lifeguard activity report.
33-1 Malibu Surfrider 33-2 Point Dume 34-1 Zuma East-End 34-2 Zuma West-End
Attd - Attendance
Preys - Preventative Actions
Ords - Ordinance Education and Enforcement
EVR - Emergency Vehicle Responses
Meds - Medical calls
Rescues - Ocean Rescues
Agency Assists - Calls with other Agencies
Boat Warnings - Preventing boaters from coming with in 300 yards of shore
Missing Persons - Looking for or Holding missing persons
02 Therapy - Calls where 02 was administered
AED Applied - Calls where the AED was used
Virginia Rupe Captain Ocean Lifeguard Northern Battalion 310-457-2525
~,. e~ ~ P~ iO ATTACHMENT 3 81112019 8131/2019 Number of Days for which we Area: have reports Attd. Preys Ords EVR Meds Rescues Northern NSH!Day 31 388 227 49 25 1 NSF-I/Night 31 9,175 44 68 7 2 33-1 31 213,700 5,907 1,851 38 276 52 COR 31 49,150 1,521 1,085 25 6 33-2 31 115,600 4,240 1,620 79 73 10 NIC 31 26,150 1,070 380 3 20 10 34-1 31 467,500 18,420 4,335 161 151 322 34-2 31 400,500 18,410 4,287 135 125 383 Northern 1,281,775 50,000 13,853 472 695 786
Grand Total: 1,281,775 50,000 13,853 472 695 786
I’.) Co