Narrativizing Theory: the Role of Ambiguity in Religious Aesthetics

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Narrativizing Theory: the Role of Ambiguity in Religious Aesthetics University of Denver Digital Commons @ DU Electronic Theses and Dissertations Graduate Studies 1-1-2018 Narrativizing Theory: The Role of Ambiguity in Religious Aesthetics Benjamin John Peters University of Denver Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.du.edu/etd Part of the Religious Thought, Theology and Philosophy of Religion Commons Recommended Citation Peters, Benjamin John, "Narrativizing Theory: The Role of Ambiguity in Religious Aesthetics" (2018). Electronic Theses and Dissertations. 1418. https://digitalcommons.du.edu/etd/1418 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate Studies at Digital Commons @ DU. It has been accepted for inclusion in Electronic Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons @ DU. For more information, please contact [email protected],[email protected]. Narrativizing Theory: The Role of Ambiguity in Religious Aesthetics ————— A Dissertation Presented to the Faculty of the University of Denver and the Iliff School of Theology Joint PhD Program University of Denver ————— In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy ————— by Benjamin John Peters March 2018 Advisor: Dr. Gregory Robbins Author: Benjamin John Peters Title: Narrativizing Theory: The Role of Ambiguity in Religious Aesthetics Advisor: Dr. Gregory Robbins Degree Date: March 2018 ABSTRACT This project expands S. Brent Plate’s “invented religious aesthetics” by bringing it into conversation with Umberto Eco’s theory of ambiguity. It articulates the space that ambiguity opens within the field of religious aesthetics when viewed as a liminal or interdisciplinary theory that neither privileges the starting points of transcendental aesthetics nor the “neo-arches” of theories of materiality. It hints at new ways of studying and describing religious worlds while also illustrating the porous borderlines between narrative and theory. It argues that a religious aesthetic rooted in ambiguity emphasizes both the provisionality of knowledge and the narrativization of reality. ii TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction……………………………………………………………………………......1 Part I: A Theory of Ambiguity………………………………………………………….....8 Chapter One: Ambiguity and Religious Aesthetics……………………………...10 Excursus One: The Dispossessed: An Ambiguous Utopia………………………51 Chapter Two: Umberto Eco and the Matter of Texts……………………………63 Chapter Three: Limits, Surplus, and Contradiction…………………………….105 Part II: The Ambiguous Narratives of Reality………………………………………….144 Chapter Four: The Role of Ambiguity in Religious Aesthetics..........................146 Excursus Two: The Kingdom………………………………………………......188 Chapter Five: Narrativizing Theory in The Prague Cemetery………………….198 Chapter Six: The Narrativizing Theories of Ambiguity......................................235 Conclusion……………………………………………………………………………...274 Bibliography……………………………………………………………………………283 iii LIST OF FIGURES Chapter One……………………………………………………………………………...10 Figure 1.1………………………………………………………………………...23 Chapter Two……………………………………………………………………………...63 Figure 2.1…………………………………………………………………….71–72 Chapter Four……………………………………………………………………………146 Figure 4.1……………………………………………………………………….165 Figure 4.2……………………………………………………………………….170 Figure 4.3……………………………………………………………………….174 Figure 4.4……………………………………………………………………….178 Chapter Five…………………………………………………………………………….198 Figure 5.1……………………………………………………………………….211 Figure 5.2……………………………………………………………………….222 iv INTRODUCTION “Many years later she does do that—pour an offering for Shen Liu—but only after the immediate past has become the distant past. How we remember changes how we have lived. Time runs both ways. We make stories of our lives.”1 —Guy Gavriel Kay, Under Heaven While I was writing about ambiguity in religious aesthetics, Philip Salim Francis published his 2017 work, When Art Disrupts Religion: Aesthetic Experience and the Evangelical Mind.2 Whereas his book approaches aesthetics from the social scientific divide of religious studies, mine is thoroughly theoretical. What is important about When Art Disrupts Religion, however, is that, at the outset of Narrativizing Theories, it offers an important reminder while also setting up the questions that I explore. Francis rightly points out that much of modern aesthetic theory focuses on what he calls aesthetic disruption. “The arts,” he writes, “possess a unique capacity to unsettle our entrenched ways of thinking and believing . When we are immersed in an aesthetic experience, it is argued, our conceptual, categorical, and binary ways of thinking give way.”3 This line of reasoning inevitably leads to questions of art’s salvific potential, 1 Guy Gavriel Kay, Under Heaven (New York: ROC, 2010). 2 Philip Salim Francis, When Art Disrupts Religion: Aesthetic Experience and the Evangelical Mind (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2017). 3 Ibid., 4–5. 1 secular aesthetic religions, and the universalization of aesthetic theories. Francis recognizes this and argues that modern aesthetic theory is “in dire need of a dose of its own historicizing medicine.”4 I could not agree more with Francis. Aesthetic theory assumes categorical rupture, universalizes it, and then foists it onto aesthetic experience. And yet, as the conclusion of Narrativizing Theories shows through Jonathan Gottschall’s The Storytelling Animal: How Stories Make Us Human,5 this is not always the case. Art also has the frightening tendency to reify beliefs and practices that are unpalatable to the liberal, academic world. While Francis does not present a solution to this conundrum of aesthetic theory, he does, unwittingly, open a space for me to inject my theory of ambiguity. If art does not always disrupt, and there are alternate ways of moving in the world, then how does one choose between competing narrativizing theories? “It may be,” Francis writes: that much of the failure to understand ‘fundamentalism’ results from a refusal to place the structure of one’s own mind in familial relation to that of one’s relatively conservative cousins . Do we not all, in our different ways, maintain certain beliefs intractably? Shouldn’t we? Are not some beliefs worth preserving?6 He goes so far as to say, in fact, that some beliefs and practices are worth maintaining even amidst the defamiliarizing experience of aesthetics.7 4 Ibid., 9. 5 Jonathan Gottschall, The Storytelling Animal: How Stories Make Us Human (New York: Marines, 2012). 6 Francis, 140. 7 Ibid., 141. 2 The question that follows then is the question that governs much of this text. How do we “distinguish acceptable (or ethical) methods of belief and identity preservation from the unacceptable?”8 I answer this question, though articulated differently at times, in six academic chapters, two excursuses, and one short story embedded throughout the length of this book. These parts argue that a religious aesthetic rooted in ambiguity emphasizes both the provisionality of knowledge and the narrativization of reality. In Part I of this work I define ambiguity as coexistent incompatibility so that, in Part II, I can turn my attention to analyzing Umberto Eco’s theories and novels through that lens. Grossly summarizing both parts, I claim that ambiguity, seen as a coexistent incompatibility, is that which violates, questions, and challenges to expose the epistemological provisionality of any given narrativizing theory, which is an arrangement of a cultural encyclopedia. While that last sentence reads as if ripped from the jargon riddled text of a continental philosopher, I promise, I do define my terms and carefully unpack my argument. But the “Introduction” is a place of signaling, not arguing. It might be helpful to think of ambiguity as a boiling cauldron filled with the churning verbs: “violate,” “question,” and “challenge.” Whereas I do not add my definition of “coexistent incompatibility” to the pot, I paint it on the front of the cauldron in capital letters. It is important to remember that coexistent incompatibility is not a binary construction. It is, rather, an awareness of the plurality of equiprobable realities that can arise from any given encyclopedia. And before you accuse or dismiss my argument as something akin to a naïve relativism, know that Chapters Two and Three 8 Ibid. 3 deal with just that issue by tossing Charles S. Peirce’s “Firstness” and Eco’s “lines of resistance” into the boiling reality of ambiguity. In the excursuses then, I employ my theory of ambiguity outside the orbit of Echian planets. In the first of two, I engage Ursula K. Le Guin’s The Dispossessed: An Ambiguous Utopia. In the second, Emmanuel Carrère’s The Kingdom. I show, rather than tell, the arguments of Parts I and II. The last part of this work is the short story, “The Composer,” which is hidden throughout various parts of this text. Though I run the risk of didacticism, I have my reasons for doing this. “The Composer” performs or shows the title of this work, Narrativizing Theories. If the arrangement of an encyclopedia is a kind of narrative that is embodied in the world, then this dissertation is the encyclopedia to the arrangement of “The Composer.” This interweaving of dissertation and short story might, perhaps, feel like didacticism, but only because the reader is confronted with the unique opportunity to encounter both encyclopedia and narrative simultaneously, which so rarely happens. The reader is oftentimes solely confronted with “The Composer” and is given the difficult task of working backwards to the matter of arrangement. The desire to reverse
Recommended publications
  • Biblioteca Di Rivista Di Studi Italiani
    BIBLIOTECA DI RIVISTA DI STUDI ITALIANI CONTRIBUTI UMBERTO ECO'S COGNITIVE HYBRID NOVELS: THE VERTIGO OF INTERTEXTUALITY* I libri parlano sempre di altri libri. [Books always speak of other books] (U. Eco, Postille a Il nome della rosa ) ROCCO CAPOZZI University of Toronto riting on Umberto Eco's Il nome della rosa (1980), and Il pendolo di Foucault (1981)1, some thirty years after their first appearances has advantages and disadvantages. The bibliographies of articles, W 2 texts and monographic studies are becoming overwhelming for readers and researchers interested in Eco the intellectual, the medievalist, the semiotician, *What follows is part of the first chapter of my work in progress "Eco the semiotician narrator"; 'vertigo of intertextuality' is a parodic allusion to Eco's Vertigine della lista (2009; The Infinity of Lists ) which sheds light on Eco's love for the "aesthetics of excess". 1 Il nome della rosa (Milano: Bompiani, 1980), Il pendolo di Foucault (Milano: Bompiani, 1988), Il cimitero di Praga (Milano: Bompiani, 2010). The English translations are from William Weaver's The Name of the Rose (New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1983; hereafter abbreviated The Rose ), Postscript to The Name of the Rose (New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1984), Foucault's Pendulum (New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1989; abbreviated Pendulum ). The Prague Cemetery is translated by Richard Dixon (New York: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, 2011) and hereafter is abbreviated as The Cemetery . For the Postille a Il nome della rosa I use the edition published as a booklet and distributed with the 1984 paperback edition of Il nome della rosa ; hereafter abbreviated as Postille .
    [Show full text]
  • Upsetting National Events and Conspiracy Narratives in Contemporary Italian Literature
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Institutional Research Information System University of Turin Lexia. Rivista di semiotica, 23–24 Complotto ISBN 978-88-548-9931-5 DOI 10.4399/978885489931521 pag. 345–367 (giugno 2016) Upsetting National Events and Conspiracy Narratives in Contemporary Italian Literature Jenny Ponzo* titolo italiano: Avvenimenti nazionali sconvolgenti e narrative del com- plotto nella letteratura italiana contemporanea. abstract: In the history of a nation, upsetting events sometimes threaten its identity. Often, conspiracy theories work as counter–narratives con- trasting the reassuring oYcial accounts of such shocking happenings. Fictional literature is one of the main channels for the diVusion of con- spiracy theories. Starting from such premises, the essay focuses on a corpus of Italian novels written in the last sixty years. They refer to four of the most upsetting moments of Italian national history (Risorgimento, the fall of Fascism, the “lead years”, and the passage from the first to the second Republic). The analysis concentrates on novels by Umberto Eco, Andrea Camilleri, Leonardo Sciascia, Rino Cammilleri, Carlo Alianel- lo, and Luciano Bianciardi. It singles out diVerent types of conspiracy narratives in contemporary Italian literature, each one characterized by peculiar recurrent motifs and characters. The essay, therefore, sets the premises for a semiotic study of conspiracy as literary genre. keywords: Conspiracy; Italian Literature; National Identity; Semiotics; Narrative. 1. Conspiracy narratives In the history of a nation there are upsetting events that threaten the sense of national identity itself. Generally, institutions and citizens ∗ Jenny Ponzo, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München.
    [Show full text]
  • This Article Explores Umberto Eco's Contribution to the Current Debate
    9-di martino_0Syrimis 12/19/12 2:36 PM Page 189 Between “n ew Realism ” and “w eak thought ”: umBeRto eco ’s “n egative Realism ” and the discouRse of late PostmodeRn Impegno loRedana di maRtino Summary: the recent theory of a return of realism has sparked a lively and somewhat heated debate among contemporary italian thinkers, gen - erating a split between the supporters of the philosophy of weak thought, and those who argue for an overcoming of postmodernism and the devel - opment of a new philosophy of realism. this article explores umberto eco’s contribution to this debate, focusing both on eco’s theory of “neg - ative realism” and on his latest historiographic metafiction. i argue that while eco’s recent theory further distances the author from the philoso - phy of weak thought, it does not call, as does maurizio ferraris’s philos - ophy of new realism, for an overcoming of postmodernism. instead, fol - lowing the outward shift that is typical of late postmodern impegno , eco’s later work creates a critical idiom that more clearly uses postmodernist self-awareness as a strategy to promote self-empowerment and social emancipation . this article explores umberto eco’s contribution to the current debate on the return of realism in order to shed light on the author’s position in the dis - pute between realisti— the supporters of the so-called philosophy of new realism —such as maurizio ferraris, and debolisti —the supporters of the postmodern philosophy of weak thought—such as gianni vattimo. my goal is to show that, while eco’s recent theory of “negative realism” further dis - tances the author from the philosophy of weak thought, it does not argue, as does ferraris’s philosophy of new realism, for an overcoming of postmod - ernism.
    [Show full text]
  • Danilo Kiš's Fictionalization of the Protocols of the Elders of Zion
    “The Conspiracy, or The Roots of the Disintegration of European Society.” Danilo Kiš’s Fictionalization of the Protocols of the Elders of Zion Dagmar Burkhart Keywords Danilo Kiš; collective memory; thanatopoetics; conspiracy; Book of Kings and Fools; Protocols of the (Learned) Elders of Zion; pogroms Conspiracies have probably been a part of life ever since societies started to be- come more complex and at a time when those in power developed conflicting in- terests. The basic, literal meaning of the verb conspire (from the Latin conspira- re and its derivative, conspiratio, “agreement, union, unanimity”) is “to breathe together,” whereby breathing together was taken to mean “to agree, to concur to one end,” whether that purpose be good or evil (e.g. Genesis 37,18; “They con- spired against [Joseph] to slay him”). Since the middle of the fourteenth century conspiracy has been used in English to mean, first and foremost, “a plotting of evil, unlawful design; a combination of persons for an evil purpose.” The word conspire has, thus, assumed primarily negative connotations: “to secretly plot or make plans together, often with the intention to bring bad or illegal results.”1 Most conspiracy theories are generated in times of crisis. They occupy the space between political constellations and psychological mechanisms. They have much in common with paranoia: the loss of one’s ability to put things into per- spective, a static perception, the narrowed outlook of an extremely egocentric or 1 See “conspire” in Wiktionary, the free dictionary. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/con- spire 314 | Burkhart group-driven point of view.2 One of the conspiracy theories that has been most relevant in building an enemy stereotype is based on anti-Semitism, which sup- plied the greatest impetus for the persecution of Jews and legitimated the use of violence against them.
    [Show full text]
  • 'Umberto Eco's Adventurous Orders'
    Umberto Eco’s Adventurous Orders Umberto Eco’s Adventurous Orders: A Critical Review–Essay on Claudio Paolucci, Umberto Eco: Tra Ordine e Avventura (Milan: Feltrinelli, 2017) Lucio Angelo Privitello Reading the morning newspaper is the realist’s morning prayer. One orients one’s attitude toward the world either by God or by what the world is. The former gives as much security as the latter, in that one knows how one stands. G. W. F. Hegel, Miscellaneous Writings, 247 Umberto Eco masterfully navigated between this Hegelian aut aut. He knew how one can be taken in, entitled, and effortlessly drift into the apocalyptic censoring shore on one side, or manoeuvre towards integralism, academic control, and conspiracy, on the other, and how each churns currents even within itself. He sailed through these haunted straits with his nimble craft of truth — narration — and he did so with intellectual emancipation and cultural production as his goal. Narration gives the ‘gift of the present’, it gives flashes of Truth (Verità) that briefly illuminate our existence, and forge passages through those of others. Narrated moments grant a virtual sostenuto where life, and the social aspect of theory, is held in place, intractable, gifted, and where events fit together as in a great work of art, to which Charles Sanders Peirce compared the Universe.1 Even with his beloved Peirce, Eco would theoretically object to going this far. Instead, à la Foucault, he would turn and say: ‘I’m not where you are lying in wait for me, but over here, laughing at you’.2 This was Eco’s summation at the end of Foucault’s Pendulum, the laughter in The Name of the Rose, his idea of a third type of intellectual (neither apocalyptic nor integrated), his sense of humour, and his moves through multiple cultural dimensions and domains.
    [Show full text]
  • Racial Rivalry As a Dehumanised Emotion in the Form of Antisemitism in Umberto Eco’S the Prague Cemetery
    RACIAL RIVALRY AS A DEHUMANISED EMOTION IN THE FORM OF ANTISEMITISM IN UMBERTO ECO’S THE PRAGUE CEMETERY Mr. MUDASIR RAHMAN NAJAR Research Scholar, Sri Satya Sai University, Madhya Pradesh, India. ABSTRACT Under this paper, it is investigated that Umberto Eco’s novel The Prague Cemetery projects imbalanced human emotions with particular emphasis on anti-Semitism. In the very outset of the novel, the main character namely Simonini, an anti-semite, is made to shower the gush of hatred emotion against the Jewish community. He, actually has inherited this emotion of hatred from either the narratives around or the experiences of his grandfather. This state of mind has made him feel sceptic in various socio-political processes and also affected the psyche of his character. In this context, the wrongs-manipulated throughout the history- have to be investigated vis-a-vis the rise and fall of Jewish community against the other communities of the world. This psycho-social alienation has created tension within the character of Simonini he starts to think of his alter ego and most of story is narrated through his letters to Della Piccola, his later-ego.Simoninihas once murdered his alter ego as he comes in his anti-Semitic enterprise. He iscommercializing his services into the secret services to intensify the hatred emotions. He is even involved in some sort of forgery through the anti-Semitic narratives by his grandfather to instigate the Dreyfus affair, an anti-spying investigation against a French Jew who attempts to share secrets in Germany.This notion of naturalizing the ill-will related to a particular community (Jewish Community) develops the sick psyche and create in the main character of the novel.
    [Show full text]
  • Musical Semiotics As a Tool for the Social Study of Music1
    Musical Semiotics as a Tool for the Social Study of Music1 Óscar Hernández Salgar / Pontificia Universidad Javeriana, Bogotá, Colombia Translated by Brenda M. Romero / University of Colorado, Boulder, United States Manuscript Editor: Richard K. Wolf / Harvard University Abstract Recent studies on musical signification have been characterized by an apparently insurmountable gap between disciplines that focus on the musical text as sound (music theory, musicology), those that focus on the hearing subject (cognitive sciences, psychology of music), and those that focus on social discourses about music (ethnomusicology, anthropology, sociology). This article argues that the most recent theoretical advances in music semiotics provide means to overcome this gap. After a brief examination of some key concepts in music semiotics, the author identifies three approaches to this problem: the semiotic-hermeneutic approach, the cognitive-embodied approach, and the social-political approach. This classification allows him to introduce a brief methodological proposal for the study of musical signification from different academic perspectives. Keywords: Music Semiotics, Musical Signification, Musicology, Musical topic, Music and Noo- politics, Musical Cognition, Music and Meaning KeyWords Plus: Music – semiotics, Musicology – Social aspects, Musical perception, Signs and symbols Citation: Hernández Salgar, Óscar. Musical Semiotics as a Tool for the Social Study of Music. Translated by Brenda M. Romero. Ethnomusicology Translations, no. 2. Bloomington, IN: Society for Ethnomusicology, 2016. DOI: https://doi.org/10.14434/emt.v0i2.22335 Originally published in Spanish in Cuadernos de Música, Artes Visuales, y Artes Escénicas 7, no. 1 (January 2011):39-77. Óscar Hernández Salgar holds a master’s degree in cultural studies and a doctorate in human sciences.
    [Show full text]
  • Elenco Dei Libri Di Scrittori Italiani Presenti Nella Ottawa Public Library
    Elenco dei libri di scrittori italiani presenti nella Ottawa Public Library List of books by Italian writers in the Ottawa Public Library Liste de livres d'auteurs italiens à la Bibliothèque Publique d'Ottawa AUTORE TITOLO/formato/copie TRAMA AUTHOR TITLE/format/copies PLOT AUTEUR/E TITRE /format/copies Abate, Carmine, 1954- Between Two Seas Photographer Hans Neumann travels to southern Italy in search of the light that Book - 2008 Copies: 1 has long attracted artists. There he meets Giorgio Bellusci, who dreams of rebuilding the South's most famous inn. The dark secret behind Giorgio's obsession will change the course of both men's lives. Agnello Hornby, The Almond Picker A surprising mystery--and love story--set in rural Sicily Like many memorable Simonetta , 1945 Book – 2005 Copies: 2 works of fiction, The Almond Picker is the story of a woman who negotiated for her freedom as no one else dared. The Marchesa A triumphant follow-up to Simonetta Agnello Hornby's internationally Book - 2007 Copies: 3 acclaimed The Almond Picker, this entertaining new novel is an intricate family saga interwoven with violent passions, cruelty, deceit, and the abuse of power. Agus, Milena , 1956 From the Land of the Tells the story of a multi-generational family in Sardinia after World War II. Moon Book -2011 Copies: 2 ebook Ammaniti, Niccolò, 1966- As God Commands Despite his hope that the scheme of his alcoholic father, Rino, and his cronies Book - 2009 Copies: 1 will land a great fortune for the family, and the hand of the beautiful Fabiana for him, Cristiano finds his life changed in a single night, and not in the way he had hoped.
    [Show full text]
  • The English Translation of Umberto Eco's Il Cimitero Di
    Lingue e Linguaggi Lingue Linguaggi 14 (2015), 85-93 ISSN 2239-0367, e-ISSN 2239-0359 DOI 10.1285/i22390359v14p85 http://siba-ese.unisalento.it, © 2015 Università del Salento THE ENGLISH TRANSLATION OF UMBERTO ECO’S IL CIMITERO DI PRAGA RICHARD DIXON TRANSLATOR Abstract – The translation of Umberto Eco’s latest novel raised various practical considerations. First, historical context: all of the main characters, except the protagonist, actually exist; most of the events around which the story is told actually happened; this means that the story must not only sound right, but it has to be right. Second, the action in the novel moves between Piedmont, Sicily and Paris, and involves negotiating between three languages: the cultural context suggests that certain words should be left in Italian, while others were better translated into French. Third, the story is told mainly through diaries written in the last years of the 19th century: the vocabulary in the target language therefore had to be appropriate for that period. Fourth, to place the English reader in the same position as the Italian reader, particularly in understanding Latin expressions, a little help could occasionally be given. Fifth, it was important to render the diversity of the three different voices of the Narrator, Simone Simonini and Abbé Della Piccola, as well as changes in pace and style. The task of the translator, in the end, is to try to produce the same effect for an English reader as the author has tried to produce for an Italian reader. It involves working on sound and rhythm – it involves trying to find the voice of the author.
    [Show full text]
  • Esotericism, Irony and Paranoia in Umberto Eco's Foucault's Pendulum Carole M Cusack
    Esotericism, Irony and Paranoia in Umberto Eco's Foucault's Pendulum Carole M Cusack Introduction This paper examines Umberto Eco's novel Foucault's Pendulum (1989) as an example of the ironic employment of Western esoteric motifs. Connections are drawn between the interpretative methods of the Western esoteric tradition and medieval Christian exegesis and contemporary semiotics, both of which Eco is deeply engaged with. Eco, though fascinated and attracted by esotericism, and concerned by its growing popularity in the contemporary West, finally rejects it in favour of a renewed commitment to rationality and a scientific worldview.* Identifying Esotericism The past decade has seen a vast proliferation of publications on 'esotericism' and 'esoteric traditions' within the field of Studies in Religion. l These studies span all religions and cultures, but the most influential have been of esoteric traditions in the West. The place of Christianity, once established as the monolithic Western religion, has been reassessed. Secular humanism, the offspring of Christianity, which has traditionally been viewed as the nurturing philosophy of the * This paper was greatly facilitated by discussions with Don Barrett, who also commented on sections and edited the final product. For example, Antoine Faivre, Access to Western Esotericism, State University of New York Press, Albany, 1994; Antoine Faivre and Jacob Needleman (eds), Modern Esoteric Spirituality, Crossroad, New York, 1995; Wouter J. Hanegraaff, New Age Religion and Western Culture: Esotericism in the Mirror of Secular Thought, State University of New York Press, Albany, 1998; and a host of other publications. Esotericism andthe Control ofKnowledge academic study of the Humanities, has similarly been sidelined.l Indeed, it has been suggested that when the origins of Studies in Religion as a discipline are examined, it is clear that the idea ofthe comparative study of religions is in a sense rooted in western esoteric traditions.
    [Show full text]
  • Secrets, Lies and Conspiracies in Umberto Eco's Writings
    Semiotica 2019; aop Raúl Rodríguez-Ferrándiz* Faith in fakes: Secrets, lies and conspiracies in Umberto Eco’s writings https://doi.org/10.1515/sem-2017-0137 Abstract: This paper offers a re-reading of the works of Umberto Eco, be they academic, journalistic or literary, with a pseudologic tone: his desire to investigate the mechanisms of lying, and their relation with fiction, falsification, error, secrecy, and conspiracy. The study will review some of his main academic texts in the fields of semiotics, rhetoric, and aesthetics, and will make some references to his recent novels and essay compilations, as well as offer an explanation of how the evolution of his thoughts takes a pessimistic turn. The face of the lie, which initially was aesthetic consolation and consumerist delusion, and then a game of intelligence, a creative stimulus and an interpretive challenge, changes when serves the purpose of extortion, manipulation, and war. In short, it could be argued that Eco became increasingly disappointed by deceptions, and lost faith in fakes and forgeries. Keywords: Umberto Eco, lie, secrecy, aesthetics, rhetoric, semiotics As a scholar of semiotics, I have always maintained that what characterizes signs and languages is not so much that they serve to name what is before our eyes, but that they serve to refer to what is not there. In this way, they also serve to lie. The problem with lying and falsehood has always been, from the theoretical point of view, very important for me. It is linked to the problem that concerns all philosophers: truth. It is very difficult to establish what it is true.
    [Show full text]
  • Umberto Eco's Il Cimitero Di Praga
    Fiction Imitating History, or History Imitating Fiction? Umberto Eco’s Il Cimitero di Praga John Cameron Despite his acclaimed work in the field of semiotics, Umberto Eco is probably best known as a writer of historical fiction. His first novel The Name of the Rose (1980) not only catapulted Eco into the international spotlight, but also revitalized the genre. This revitalization inspired writers of historical fiction to use the genre to explore ‗the systems of knowing‘ (Groot 2009, 126) that we rely on to understand both the past and the present. Linda Hutcheon famously coined the term ‗historiographic metafiction‘ to describe the way that these postmodern writers of historical fiction force readers to question not only the reliability of their fictional constructions of history, but of all such constructions. This may help to explain Eco‘s persistent fascination not only with forgeries and hoaxes but with the very important roles that they have played in shaping history. In Foucault’s Pendulum (1988) the three editors Belbo, Diotallevi and Casaubon create ‗The Plan‘ in a spirit of diversion, only to find out to their amazement and horror that this fiction has been accepted by some as reality. As a writer of historical fiction, Eco is well aware of this problem, for writers in this genre are often expected to make their fiction as historically accurate as possible. Eco‘s works are clearly well researched, but Eco nevertheless insists that a writer of fiction‘s duty is to fiction first, and history second. Perhaps he would agree with Vladimir Nabokov, who insisted that ‗fiction is fiction.
    [Show full text]