Del Mar City Council Meeting Agenda Del Mar Council Chambers 2010 Jimmy Durante Blvd., Suite 100, Del Mar, California

September 6, 2016 City Council Meeting

INFORMATION RECEIVED AFTER THE COUNCIL AGENDA WAS DISTRIBUTED (“Red Dots”) 1 September 6, 2016 Item 03 2 September 6, 2016 Item 03 3 September 6, 2016 Item 03 Subject: FW: NCTD Red Dot - Petition & Comments Attachments: Attachments.html

On Sep 5,2016, at3:19 FM, Teny Gaasterland > wrote

Dear Ashley,

guidance how best to I shared the attached petirions with Sherri Parks and Dwight'Worden to ask for on circulate our petition. iegalizing The goal u,ith the petitions was to assemble signatures, give the community a voice on the subject of (3 listed in train-track crossings, and empower our City Cãuncil members to work with NCTD toward solutions the petition).

pages. The second and I attach 3 files. The first is a scanned ink&paper petition with 471 signatures on 62 third are downloaded PDFs from a J

most useful

matter tomorrow. I Frank Stonebraker will rr,fer to the petition in 3 minutes of comments to the Council on this But for sure, I'll be am in The Hague (lr{etherlands) this week and will not be able to attend the 916 meeting' plans to bring over a there in october. In case it is important to get a paper copy of the petitions to you, Frank print-out tomorrorv of the' files attached here.

?u: In case useful, here is a link to the int Cd 3 TD cUV9a1 OlodowC cÃ7 A. edh5YQme6uS&m:-g5; WY t9 org/p/cit)'- Gao website for the petition: https ://www.change. gqunciI-oÊdel-mar-cr n g-the-rai lroad-tracks-in-del-mar-to-access-the-

b e ach? r e cr uíter : 1 62 47 7 1 c1 o pvl i nk<þ!!pgX7r¿!þþn.' 2Ddel 2Dcrossin. 2n 2Dto- s -l 5F -5F 3F r e cr vtiter3D I 62 47 I 5 26utm-5 Fmeclium-3 Dcor MF' ll

1 September 6, 2016 Item 04 ctlV 9a 1 Q 1 odpwCcATzG6o05 RzavF'VUx- .&.m- gS3WoWYOI{vKNuU 19ADI7,m64Rn9aDsMW vRiGgiL7,aGA&s:1SWì T.V9ovbHFIF

GTtxv 5 nrr5 nft Zcole 8 4 s FJ 9 41tDp4 &e:>

Please let me know how I can be of further help, even though afar !

Best regards, Teruy

Teny Gaasterland, PhD Professor of Computatioual Biology and Genomics Director, Scripps Genome Center Member, Institute for Ge,romic Medicine University of Califbrnia l:ian Diego and Scripps Institution of Oceanography Scripps Genome Center, MC0202 Hubbs Hall, room 2125 9500 Gilman Drive, La Jolla, CA 92093-0202 Office (858)-822-4600 Cell (.646\ 207-4600 Fax l85B) 641 Email : gaasterl [email protected] csdcilg Map:

8b C cUV9alO oclnr,vCcA7zG6o05 vFVUx- Y W 1k3 opoyvlFlB RJB fC Q 3 gFI¡- 29 4zpIU 4 &,e:>

2 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 20L6 Request for the Gity of Del ilar to work with North County Transit District (NCTD) to cease issuing tickets for cros¡ing the railroad tracks between 4h St and 1îh St and to designate two or more crossing sites to access the west side of the tracks.

To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council

By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe foregoing statements:

1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.

2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct access to the Del Mar beach between 4th St. and 11rh St. since the early 1900's.

3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is now issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.

4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including a. Crossing as a train approaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks

5 We ask that you and NCTD work vrgorously ancl immediately to accomplsh the following

a Cease issuing trckets when no lrarn rs near or rn srght

b Establish two or more desrgnated srles to cross between 6'h St and 1 1rn St after "Stop, Look and Lrsten"

c Work cltltgently toward rernovrng the tracks frorn the bltrff wrthrn a decacle

Sincerely, The Undersigned

Name Signature Date Owner / Email / Address Resident / Voter ? , Ln lo,þ 14G) [,..,[n^¡, ì I l-- visr'Inr 2 ^Éf Ri\, n^^(or h) ll¿sd .()J¡, \ì- DI r f ¿.1 .rtC-Jt I t)l.r^*4ø è 4u,-uer¿ í," l, ß-. a +l i/iá,. rr t I lÚt-\ o z.) C L14 _/ 4 t \ @-Lv1Lt,-. t-,vl le lz-o zJ,,l^.| -t"< g . ç-/ V co^J tronñlhft,n,l 4, ..L /t A Vlzr r( e >')2..?- I l -Ph¿ef} r;'ih; ¡Wilßhn>.ç4r¡YlY*lYlt I l/t n l/n/

1 7

3 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016

Request for the Gity of Del flllar to work with North County Transit District (NCTD) to ceaie issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks between ¿th St and I ls St and to designate two or more crossing sites to access the west side of the tracks.

To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council

By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe foregoing statements:

1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff

2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct access to the Del Mar beach between 4th St. and 11th St. since the early 1900's.

3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is now issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.

4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including a. Crossing as a train approaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks

5 We ask that you and NCTD work vrgorously and rrnmedrately to accomphsh the following.

a Cease rssurng tickels when no tra¡n is near or tn srght

b Establish two or more destgnated srtes to cross between 6r" St and 1 1rn St afier 'Stop. Look, and L.rsten"

c Work drhgently toward renìovrrlg the tracks from lhe blutf wrthtn a decade

Sincerely, The Undersigned

Name Signature Date Owner / ,at @ÉÉ sãF. Voter ? t0 Lo o\/ l¡ flltl¡n¡rlrt , 4,uifrUu n4 il Liffttt'to| ¡¡rtt ¿nì nA'Lr---' Al zu \./ g ,a a¡¡-c l.tt Á u' (Or,i.^- t niLktâ'|&¿< .6trrnf- ,a*n- -.nflut -t¡i ,3 t, fìñ,lr K Át,(A,u At çt< A't^4ç)tút,o t ttih L . ttn^ A I À A¡g¡ 1- 11*U Itzt (' ll t4 M )€ noô * I ''- --)* r',hþÅ) I.,Jc K ttí fo¿ ( 1 ftqh'tr'V hlLM 9tus €. IC A\..¡ ssa KinnUa^, Ni,,\dv- !l'uc ?v I

1 .) (.

4 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Request for tlre Glty of Del ilar to work witlr Norür County Transit Distrig! ([C]O] t9 issuing ticke-ts for crossing the railroad tncks between 4tn St and llh St and to clesignate"u"L" two c¡r more crossing sitos to acceas the west side of the tracks.

To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council

By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe foregoing statements:

1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff,

2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct access to the Det Mar beach between 4rh St. and 11th St. since the early 1900's.

3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is now issuing tickets for crossing the ¡ailroad tracks, at $500 per person.

4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including ,a. Crossing as a train aPProaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks

S We ask that you and NCTII work vigorously anrJ lmmecJtately to accompltsh tne followtng

a Cease issuing tickets when no traln rs near or tn sight

b Establish two or rnore desrg¡rrated srtes to cross betweerr 6'n St. anqJ 11'r'St after "Stop, Look, and Llsten"

r: Work rlilrgently iilwarr:l reûìovrng ihe tracks frorn the t¡lr¡ff wtthrn a decade

Sincerely, The Undersigned

Name Signaturc Date Owner I - Email t^Add ress @Ér t+ fcvttt f<^/ ø Voter ? "dêN L€[\æ1 ç tzo n€.5;, tþ t?-o r( û 2^f zo At f W¡Â ' ?,o Y? lt(, enÞ /2¿ ll lêt 0 t / r, *ft| /./l.f'"1+, ,, Ét 12¡ /r4 l/n /'61,1 2' I r¿,/z¿> Çf>u ztt g

1 )

5 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016

Request for the City of Del Mar to work with North County Transit_District (lp_fO) t9 issuing ticke-ts for crossing the railroad tracks between Cn St and l1u St and to designate"*"L" two or more crossing sites to acceag the west side of the tacks.

To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and Ci$ Council

By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe foregoing statements:

1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.

2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct access to the Del Mar beach between 4h St. and 11th St. since the early 1900's-

3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is now issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.

4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including: a. Crossing as a train aPProaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks

5 We ask that you and NCTD work vigorously and imnrediately to accompltsh the followrng

a Cease tssutng tickets when no tratn ls rìear or rn srght

b Establish two or more desrgnated sites to cross befween 6r" St and 11'n Sl afler "Stop L-ook ancJ l-tslen"

c W6rk rJrlrgerrtly towarrJ rerrìovrng tl're tracks frorn thr: bluff wrthlrl a Ceca.Je

Sincerely, The Undersigned

Name Signature Date Owner / Email / Address Regident / Voter ? zÇ Ut nAo¡ -¿l h^-1 àLÐü/, fnrlçWn I ) zC J, LðAA 'tl )l z+ îaf nlaÇa-n ,.4. L,l¿ Ylvzn-Aaan)

1ß 74' ÅÆiHyT iva 21 fl ft ti /( t/ Rc5'¡:¡rXtr , A L SAtrþ€, TEÐéf{, 7r ¿l FR+ D¡ t-e SP-¿' 6LO&4¿'^/ ET

6 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016

Request for the Gity of Del lf,ar to work with North County Transit_District (llClO) t9 issuing ticke-ts for crossing the railroad tracks between 4tn St and llu St and to designate"eaie two or more crossing sites to access the west side of the tracks.

To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council

By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe foregoing statements:

1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.

Z. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct access to the Del Mar beach between 4th St. and llth St. since the early 1900's.

3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Ofüce, is now issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.

4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including: a. Crossing as a train aPProaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks

5 We ask that you and NCTD work vigorously and immediately tct accomplish the followtng

a Cease issutng tickets when no traln ts near or in sighl

b Establish two or more desrgnated sltes lo cross between 6rn St and 11"' St after "Stop, Look and Listen''

c Work diligently toward removtng the tracks from the bluff wrthin a cjecade

Sincerely, The Undersigned

Name Signature Date Owner/ Email / Address Resident / Voter ? /"/ 9L rt-o - (; r I rr-,, ) 4¿oltt fu.^. /llnl

7 5

7 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016

Request for the City of Del lUlar to work with North County Transit District (NGTD) to cease issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks between 4ln St and llu St and to designate two or rnore crossing sites to access the west side of the tracks.

To: City of Del Mar Manager, CiÇ Staff, and City Council

By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with all the foregoing stiatements:

1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.

2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct access to the Del Mar beach between 4th St. and 11th St. since the early 1900's.

3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is now issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.

4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including a. Crossing as a train approaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks

5 We ask that you and NCTD work vrgorously and imnredralely to accomplish the following

a Cease rssuing lickets when no train rs near or rn stght

b Establish two or rnore desrgnated sites to cross between 6"'St and 11th Sl after "Stop Look. and Lrsten"

c Work dihgently toward removrng the tracks frotn the t:luff wrthrn a r1ecacle

Sincerely, The Undersigned

Name Signature Date lOwnerT Email / Address *|rc/,,¡*T I tÇ l)n,, lc /u I l,uf-^, n/eì Mnn ln t, 1t)r>' ,\ () f( 76 tAit (,r ll,n,O ûo /.ftSø-' ,Lr.,/. ¡'l/)r- Ot¿ ,1 rc-, bl o6zz- tùct c¡.', I . co.r. rA' z-- Po<,nl o,a* re Ãnr;tK, (onill a(h /\ /\ t\llvvt.- t1 /èo ' lro ',Jrn-/nvt't- {fr lL, l.qtt J,Y^. Ko) t rla,.*Y rl V. fr /zo ß-ts u,lu*lr 4L ¿lJ^ ? \ ^-.=...... --, xlz,n Par¡¡ )uab \, V,'r vn c- Wr;+{1^/ flL,^,, o fle- À^- L'lt ¡ Kz<,oL ny'

8 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Request for the City of Del ilar to work with North Gounty Transit District (I!CTD) to cease issuing t¡cke-ts for crossing the railroad tracks between 4ü St and I lü St and to desigrrate two or more crossing sites to acceas the west side of the tracks.

To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council

By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with all the foregoing statements:

1, The railroad track bisects'Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.

2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct access to the Del Mar beach between 4rh St. and 11th St. since the early 1900's.

3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is now issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.

4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including: a. Crossing as a train approaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks

5 We ask that you and NCTD work vrgorously and rmmediately to accompllsh the following

a Cease lssutng tlckels when no trarn ls near or rn sight

b Establish two or more desrgnated sites to cross between 6tn Sl ånd t1'n St afler 'Stop, Look, and Ltsten"

c Work drhgently towarrJ renìovrng the tracks from the bluff wíthtn a decade

Sincerely, The Undersigned

Name Signature Date Owner / Email / Address Resident /

¡ Voter ? Lttl rl€lqYn{J Qpß)tw, qmil, covtl v(\qwI)'/ >+ flz0 vjr{\- gl þ; k p&t t l r¿ütl F a{¿ t c4* //.*8 ?)æ- zo o/k/,/ 1ç ø .-\---> 3t zn R fç ì Y.*,1'^ \ b /zt L J¡Y¡ ßnr¿vì Å/. .1 ./z-U+ Ç[/o ,,6¡qA \? h //,,/ "4- ru^ {1 (¿4 talt t / t-*, #/pu Jale r 9o "Ztþ-lAYdl^- i ( l,to v ol¿r / Zt5,r!,t^+ I - q'lL 1t 4 il^.ttA -,lhrk' Òw\,\ut/ IL a sh.s ó hy.¿,r,, ohi q7à J,¡^f @ , C(t¡t1 o 4

9 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Request for the City of Del ilar to work with North County Transit District (NCTD) to cease issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks between ¿th St and llh St and to designate two or more crossing sites to accegs the west side of the tracks.

To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council

By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with all the foregoing statements:

1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.

2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct access to the Del Mar beach between 4rh St. and 11th St. since the early '1g00's.

3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is now issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.

4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including a. Crossing as a train approaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks

5 We ask that you anc, NCTD work vrgorously and rmmediately to accompilsh the following

a Cease issuing trckels when no lrarn rs near or rn srght

b Establish two or nrore desrgnated sites to cross between ö"' St and 1 1rn St after "Stop, Look, and Lrsten'

c Work drhgently toward renroving the tracks from the bluff withrn a decade

Sincerely, The Undersigned

Name Signature Date Owner / Emaill Address Resident / t Voter ? 5tl /{/&t*tKâ:/, )r4rr. L-a.^pß,¿ flt Kr'a, t /tanO hÒ /,ur,, [.r o,^- /f ßQÁ 'r*öh o Dtt:*ea_ tf_21--l / 1U f/ /t ç6 qc ffi L\ )? ( lL,:-','., 0r,^'l-- fr'1r v r r / € .,tL,I .. t /,¡.tv í|'\ r I ò .'l ,-r 6s .1,.n rJ ti.v Ãl",lkll , Sutdh¡-Y vt¡ql.ilL{ 6Ik,, @ç-n-,,1 uu p L4 lA Qwvn-z,y' s1 Nvtr¿ t,^ llfì,þ."\'c. çvy1 c,lia fl)c, tt 4tF r- n-.Yl .( --)wt-, g ìr 'l/, Õ>trv-a¿ I I 0 I

T 6

10 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Request for the City of Del Mar to work with North County Transit District (NCTD) to cease issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks between 4s St and llñ St and to designate two or more crossing sites to access the west eide of the tracks.

To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council

By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe foregoing statements:

1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.

2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct access to the Del Mar beach between 4h St. and 11th St. since the early 1900's,

3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is now issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.

4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including a. Crossing as a train approaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks

5 We ask that you ancl NCTD work vrgorously and rmmediately to accomplish the following.

a Cease rssuing t¡ckets when no trarn ts near or tn srght

b Ëstabhsh two or more designatecJ sites to cross between 6"'Sl and 11'n St after "Stop, Look and Lrsten"

c Work drlrgenlly toward removrnq the tracks frorn the bluff withrn a decade

Sincerely, The Undersigned

Name Signature Date Owner / Email / Address Resident / rl '/ Voter ? 6À' ( t lJ Ã/,e.1 ll¿*¿{. t?A!e/ -, n: d¿l lMc^¿

6l l,t rl ' ) tilrr¿- Ø(ej Ð

L g

11 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2o16 Request for the City of Del illar to work wi$ North County Transit Disûict (NCTD) to c€ase issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks between 46 St and lln St and to designate two or more crossing sites to acceas the west side of the tracks.

To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council

By signlng this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe foregoing statements:

1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff

2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct access to the Del Mar beach between 4rh St. and 11th St. since the early 1900's.

3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is now issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.

4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including: a. Crossing as a train approaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks

5 We ask that you and NCTD work vrgorously and rmmediately to accomplish the following

a cease rssuing trckets when no trarn ts neaf or rn srght

b Establish two or more clesignated sites to cross between 6'n Sl and 11fh St after "Stop Look, and Lislen"

c Work drlrgently tc¡ward removrng the tracks from the bluff wrthrn a cJecade

Sincerely, The Undersigned

Name Signature Date Owner / Email I Address Resident / Voter ? ct l)tÀaa- MuruLr Yo äox+0b,f^rÅ{ç (, I qZlnry ltn dntu'l\ttn{h' 8l2t' lb nfÉ¡- lt¡l . d.Ivn U( ¡n'v:,rl*nt cq llrrt c^! Føv,td,." \\q çfirkQcrìÀ C 't+K lX¿l1r,r , f O q ötu tú o ^q2

1 to

12 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Request for the City of Del ilar to work with North Gounty Transit District (NCTD) to cease issuing tickeE for crossing the railroad tracks between 4!n St and 11- St and to designate two or more crossing sites to access the west side of the tracks.

To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council

By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe foregoing statements:

1. The railroad track bisects De! Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.

2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct access to the Del Mar beach between 4rh St. and 11th St. since the early 1900's.

3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is now issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.

4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including a. Crossing as a train approaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks

5 We ask that you and NCTD work vígr:rously and rmmedrately to accomphsh the following

a Cease rssurng lrckets when no train rs near or tn stght

b Establish two or more designated sites to cross between 6r'' St and 1 1'h Sl after 'Stop [..ook and Listen"

c Work di|gently tr:warcl removrng the tracks frorn the bluff wlthln a rJecade

Sincerely, The Undersigned

Name Signature Date Owner / Email I Address Resident / \ (r J I Voter ? Gq 44 fçtilløN / l¿ 1r^ùrlø/^g^u J1 A llli¿ lL":å.p-F $ A&irs,r; AAcu¿/s./<,'^ tZr 8/, t/¿ ,l ,1, t)llL c4 û,,n -\./ "* li J ,r '( Yk ,,l rl ^.{Án cs '..14 y'n^-r- (..-J.ã,.uuw \É,&-r^r-Ê.¡-" ft. 61 J O S"'nt^ f\ ¿-l*\oto U--.1v1-¿t-:*t"^' -t Ac¡ k-f ¿ tbbù,ã, v ?l Nnl^¡ ùrn-pt1 I /ä,'r frØtkS t fP- lt d(nT '(I¡,'hr^A' +r ùã¡r¡ttr* i1ì / Í&an,(. 1, krnnlûV k\aqt+rmù[\ tr#/ Sr

1 It

13 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Request for the City of tlel illar to work with North County Transjt District (NGTD) to issuing tickes for crossing the railroad tracks between 4h St and llü St and to designate"""i" two or mor€ crossing sites to eccess the west side of the tracks.

To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and Gity Council

By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe foregoing statements:

1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.

2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct access to the Del Mar beach between 4th St. and 11th St. since the early 1900's.

3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is now issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.

4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including a. Crossing as a train approaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks

ir We ask that you and NCTD work vigorously and immedtately to accclmplish the followrng

a Cease tssutng trckets when no lrarn is near or in srght

b Estabhsh two or more designated sites to cross between 6'n St. ancJ I 1'n St after "Stop, Look. and l-tsten"

c Work clihgenily toward removing tlre lracks frc¡rn the bluff withrn a decade

Sincerely, The Undersigned

Name Signature Date Owner/ Email / Address Reeident / l') . Voter ? 7q Vnrtnoar.tÐ^-l; ut^onl sharlPX? , rftaa,Íl . ¿ ¿røt f* ,L*r* {l F,/z I [/¿o, tþ Ll) >e(( -^ t ho ?r T5',- l?tz "r. ?7 øt lr f€q, g{ /û'lú, +l"ç D,lj3 I )¡ Ot ltt-tr ?þ L ?t'â ^-- tøirt 9r glz r Rexl¿t¿-,..f 1z (t lnrc tl ^ ¿,/\ \r 7t t- t IL

14 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Request for the City of Del irlar to work with North County Transit District (I!CTD) to cea*" issuing ticke-ts for crossing the railroad tracks between 4o' St and 1lü St and to designate two or more crossing sites to accesa the west side of the tracks.

To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council

By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with all the foregoing statements:

1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.

2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct access to the Del Mar beach between 4th St. and 11th St. since the early 1900's.

3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is now issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.

4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including: a. Crossing as a train aPProaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks

5 We ask that you and NCTD worl< vrgorousty and rmmedlately (o accompllsn îhe followíng

a Cease tssuing ftckets when no trarn ts near ot rn slght.

b Estabhsh two or more desrgnated srtes to cross between 6r" Sl and 11"' St after 'Stop Look, and Lísten

c \y'/ork clrlrgentty tr-¡ward rerrrovinq the tracks froni the Lrluff withrn a decade

Sincerely, The Undersigned

Name Signature Date Owner I , Email f Address Resident / I Voter ? ( g/rì/ ,, hn-ø^^1.,0 i¿(ò \,tcs LP-Å,. 4/-^*('oþ -^'-1¿-^{@- ptu\1.Òt Y*n,t¡l¿ o¿1 J&¿, Rcgn-r.r üí l'1Í, u r r, < îñ ç Q G nlìL n r-l / 66 ^,\r+ött/l ?f/zo F bT \_> V^Yr ìo f\tC lrt \ liÂ¿.,a* *tl ?1, @ 4nar I, ¿¿ {A f.lzo 8eçiàe d Ø¿4,- .vt q.b I (e. r ir 4¡ CÈciLi .r03 C O¡Y f.,^'bnL=u ST ßhlfuLoLr ka(#s 1, t3

15 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Request for the City of Del Mar to work with North County Transit District (NGTD) to cease issuing tickets for crogsing the railroad tracks between 4h St and 1lü St and to designate two or more crossing sites to access the west side of the tracks.

To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council

By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe foregoing statements:

1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.

2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct access to the Del Mar beach between 4th St. and llth St. since the early 1900's.

3, NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is now issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.

4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including a. Crossing as a train approaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks

5 We ask that you and NCTD work vigorously and rmnredrately to accompfish lhe followrng

a. Cease issuing trckels when no trarn rs near or in sight

b Establrsh two or nrore desrgnated sites to cross between 6rn St and 11'n Sl after "Stop, Look, and Lrsten"

c Work drligently toward rernovrng the tracks from the blufl wrthrn a decade

Sincerely, The Undersigned

Name Signature Date Owner/ Email / Address Resident / ',*¿vþ, (a Voter ? ' a 4¿ tt -ï I \ti "t Lr( I I u.\L,, .h,¿ ,¿nkâ f2 I l/ltu v'25//(, Y.9 o ll 11 V¿L4-, D, kLbffi:': ' 1ÇU_:---e_----) Tlxtø 4eç 1l 7/sc/t 't Ou)Aeif li e,vn¡r .crf\, '^f^AI b K,l(:vi ttrr' at /)'^tz^. Tfr--'> I #?+ I t 14 a I

1 t1

16 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Request for the Gity of Del ilar to work with North County Transit Distict (I!CTD) to ceaåe issuing tickeis for crossing the railroad tracks between 4h St and llh St and to designate two or more crossing sites to acceag the west side of the tracks.

To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council

By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with all the foregoing stiatements:

1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.

2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct access to the Del Mar beach between 4rh St. and 11th St. since the early 1900's.

3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is now issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.

4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including: a. Crossing as a train approaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks

5 We ask Ûrat you ancl NCTD work vrgorously and tmmediatety to accompllsh the followtng

a. Cease rssuing ttckets when no trarn ls near or tn stght

b Establish two or more desrgnated sites to cross between 6"' St anrJ 1 1rt' St afler "Stop, Look and Listen"

c Work drhgently toward rernovrng the trar;ks fronl the tiluff wtthln a decade

Sincerely, The Undersigned

Name Signature Date Owner / Email / Address Resident / Voter ? të() zå*z7rZ¿,letr' ø- z8-/t ,ot t?trt, t c o rZ o.- \ ?-ø ß 2P tt 0tCl¡. cf l'zz toz ¡ I L --iZ---lZzn ¡{6r ucrul- t0, éLu.X,r'( E'zt tQÍç, Ð¡':'rtT : rdf 4 tl 7A,r flo^,^/,^J torí tr-\- -Jvã Uzñ ç-r.J>^;9o^^* rS * thk \Æ std9'^x ',1¡ tcl Zþ4.ty:14- d4 rof 4-

1 tf

17 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Request for üre Gity of Del tar to work witñ Norfi CounÇ Transit Distrlct (NCTD) to .eaiu issuing ticke-ts for croesing tlre rallroad tracks between 4ü St and 1lü St and to designate two or more crossing sites to acoaaa üte woet slde of the tracks.

To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council

By sþning this instn¡ment, I agree and represent that I have read and understrand and agree with allthe furegoing statements:

1. The railroad track b¡sects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastalblufi.

2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direst access to the Del Mar beach between 4ü' St. and 11h St. since the early 1900's.

3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is now issuing tickeb for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.

4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the üacks, including: ,a. Crossing as a tain approaches ö. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks

:r We ask lhat you anrl NCT["r worh vrgr:rously änü rn]nreclralely lo ârlúomplrsh thc: following

å Cease lssurng tickets when tt<¡ traln ts rìear- or tn sir¡ht

h Estabhsh twr: or nrore cleslgnatecl srtes to,;ross Lretween tìrn St antJ l1t" Si after "Stop Look, and Listen"

r: V/ork clllrgerrtly toward rLln'ì(tvrrlrl llie lracxs Írorn tilr-l Dluff wtthil å di.){.:a('lÊ

Sincerely, The Undersigned

Name Slgnature Date Orrner I Email I Address Resident /

Voter ? . r¡/lill', tQo- , t¡ ¿lrz'l* rôrl n I' o.,k -, ,.a ,,t-'ãt ,'Jnrrn. r âñ ' lto L¿Lro"l¿ rn- ñ-*,1:[- c/ot^ f<[Q- / k- /< ,z- tl¿Í/t, t<ç A t-ü I tl l\o.¿-nr. rÃa.?¿.. î1. ( ayÉ "ffllJþfr4*' t¡¿ *-- .Jn rt t* tr, \tñ Sotr=a{'6 Itq lrt^ ll)x (ts, /,,,r tt{ f/?3 Rect¿<^*. ttC nalt¡.lfrur %/ /4 (tlrt' u? l,/n - J I t2x ¡ ' CA{, B 2t r

18 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Request for tñe Gity of tlel tar to worlt wltñ llorth Gounty Transjt Dl"ttlg! l[CfD) P. ,ru**u issuing t¡cke-ts for croaslng the railroad tracks between 4ln St and ll- St and to designate two or rnore crossing sites to acoess the weat slde of the tracks.

To: City of EÞl Mar Manager, Ci$ Staff, and City Council

By sþning this insûument, I agree and represent that I have read and urderstand and agree with allthe furegoing stratements:

l. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.

2. Del Mar citizens. residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct acoess to the Del Mar beach between 4h St. and 11h St. since the early 1900's.

g. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Ofñce, is now issuing tickets br crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 Per Person

4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the üacks, including: .a. Grossing as a üain aPProaches ö. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks

l, we äsk tlìat you and NC"l tJ work vrgorously and rmrttecfiat€:lv tù Ar;Cc)nlpltsh the followtnq

a Ûease lsstllng trckc:ts wl¡ert rlo train is rlear or ln stqlrt

t¡ Establish two or rrìore designated sltes to cross betweerr fj"'sl anrl 1lr" st after 'Stop, Look, and Listen"

c Wr¡rk ciillqentlr¡ towartl rÊr'rto\rrn(l the tracks frotrt lhe irlt.tif wtthlrl .l tl;Jr:ltrl€r

Sincerely, The Undersigned

Name Slgnature Date Owner / Emai! I Address Resident / I Voter ?

r L) tLo -^ì . f ¡¡vvt l2-t ¿ J<- tl7 ù tZ, / ?eçu Let- -.t t^4é AÀ#'^' ao .(é,, t8,'

19 September 6, 2016 Item 04 PetitiOn August 2016 Request for the Glty of Del tar to work wltft Nortñ CounÇ Transit Disûlct (NCTD) to ceas. issuing tickets for crosslng the railroad tracks betwoen 4ü St and 1lü St and to clesiEnate two or more crossing sites to acceaa the weet glde of the tracks.

To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Stafi, and City Council

By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe furegoing statements:

I . The railroad track bisecß Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal blufi.

2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct acoess to the Del Mar beach between 4h St. and 11ft St. since the early 1900's.

3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is nor issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.

4. Enforæment could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including: .â. Grossing as a üain approacñes ö. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks

5 We ask lhat yoil arrt.l NCI-Ü worx vrgorously and rmmedrately hl aci;t-rril¡rhsh fi-re followrng

a Cease rssurng trckets when no trai¡l ts rìear or ttr stght

l¡ Establrsh two or more desrgnated srtes to cross between 6'r'Sl and l'l'h St after "Stop, Look, and Lrsten"

r: \fuilrk i"lilrgerrtly towarrl rern()vrng the tracks frorrr lhe [rlLrff w¡thrrr a rier;adÊ

Sincerely, The Undersigned

Name Signature Date Owner I Email / Addrees Resident / t3 f - a) Voter ? tzl / Wr/I-^ N /21 /<'5r1"-Jê rao clzr l7-<.'u{ttf{ r?( tlZ, tf

(/\ ('r ( t-t*h f {\e L \\,,^ /. W ( svtoraYpþVúalb ïh'â \c[ou"1'ut^ I >l t lrl tq

20 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Requeet for üre Clty of Del ilar to worfi wlth l{orth County Transit Dlstrict (ilCTD} to cease issuing tickets üor cros¡lng flre rallroad tracks betrroen 4ln St and lln St and to designate two or rnore crossing sites to acoeas füe west side of the tracks.

To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council

By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe furegoing stiatements:

1. The railroad tack bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal blufi.

2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct acoess to the Del Mar beach between 4h St. and 11rh St. sinæ the early 1900's.

3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is no¡v issuing tickets br crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person

4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including ,a. Crossing as a train approaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks

5 We ask lhat you and NCTû work vrgorotrsiy and tmmedralely to accomplrsFr the followirrç¡

a Cease rssurng tickets when no tratn ts near or tn s¡ghl

b Establish two or more desrgnated sites to cross betweerr 6"' Sl and 1'lr" 5l after "Stop, [-r':ok, and Lrsten"

r: [Â/nrk clilrqe¡nlly towarr,J renr'-rvincJ the lracks Íronr llie', h¡ir.lff wtthrn a ,Jecade

Sincerely, The Undersigned

Name Signature Date Oryner I Email I Address Regident / ,4 Voter ? t17 îôitú'f/âk/(! oma' / tot-, tW iltslt (¿ ft:lì.vnÍ tqe N (7\,--, 6h&il, '0..ü qi t{( I l)f-'-' '¡-+ t rvti ft .¿¿,.-¡- l+z ^,-'z*o,l- tqr ¡v\ne t,- c\ IAV^^,/ f.¿rnRtsrr.P.nV'*ol2( )G..r...h. 4¿, ttf{ ?l 1 Z,Urd :Jr"*-ogÈ \1 t_Þ\ (/21 f\ h\h\$ tqf - E+ \,¡ RL ll,, - t|.c êlçn ^, (]-- yvlt r t /),t //- /4 / I l->' 'l .'t leú r{ll,-. [:- T . ,.'7% 71 c ît ('nllí r", t-.lJ- ',lA) t'ltv rql r" Jd ß ¿5,oLx¡ tr*, L'¿ L| tll tJ H¿ii t1

21 September 6, 2016 Item 04 ' tçz t ùiel\e Borit\ct ¡Þliu Re trclen{ ,1'*\r,$n f boli\hr,,- E/aù/tt'i ReS¡den 'ti"t *Mo', ç¿".d.r^-f , Lh..t \wnu. ü4,',* t/ //r' I fca;"t n, IL : c r ¡4c-*--f tç?- A1¿t l¿':+* b¿¡"¡'t t [nlu P

n botL

22 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016

Request for the City of tlel llar ûo work wltñ Norü County Transit Dlstrict (NCTD) to ceâse issuing tickets for croc¡ing tlre ¡allroad tracks betrcen 4ü' St and lls St and to designate two or mrrre crossinE sites to acoeas üte west slde of tlre tacks.

To: City of DelMar Manager, City Staff, and City Council

By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with all the foregoing stratements:

1. The railroad tack b¡sects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.

2. Del Mar citizens, reeidents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct acæss to the Del Mar beach between 4h St. and l lth St. since the earty 1900's.

3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Ofñce, is nor issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.

4. Enforæment could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including: .a. Crossing as a üain approaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks

Í.t We ask that yûLt anrl NCTt-.r work viqorousiy and rmmeorately lo accomplrsrr the followrng.

a Cease rssurng tickets when no tratn is near or rn srght

b Establ¡sh two or rnore

r: \lúirk drlrgerrtly low¡.¡rr:l rernoving ther trar.:ks fronl îire l-¡lrrftwrthrrr a decarJr¡

Sincerely, The Undersigned

Name Slgnature Date Owner / Email I Address Resident / --\ Voûer ? Ll7 U'fNr"f.ìrû? tY YA(d, VbJÅ.Ð¡ .( øtvr ^&€ 9. l.\^i^ T tll Va,ØI¿.**vw¿t- (H,-=I q t-O¿-- (-l É1 ,,:ÞtJ:---::-. ', ) ct<^i v€f ¡êo h ul,r t^/ìrl r r'l ft \ l>il l^ll ! €r' t6l \'-,e\..C l"t'^."J¡-l V,t r.*¿; i,À \'åÀ-,FÊ:--- ;ç. ri¡,x-l .u\-)/-lJ¡¡)(ñ. \/- --if, t6¿ Lrth-À t,l,'-,,t.ì ¡ tøtY tÌ. ¡,t þffiþ a¡¡,'.1 E.¡,1 f[DlÆlAo/t lêt /&&1p ku--- r6¡{ o n4 \ltrU.rL' t6f t- R xt, tnffi '- ,^l )t ß rl, d.'t ú(. =,?ì "\\tJi1 1

23 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Request for tlre City of fþl tar to work wltñ Norft County Transit Dlstrlct (ilCTD) to Êeâse issuing tickets for crosslng tlre nllrcad tracl¡s betrcen 4ü'St and llü St and to designate two or more crossing sites to acceas the west side of the tracks.

To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Stafi, and Gity Council

By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe bregoing stiatements:

1. The railroad fad( b¡sects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.

2. Del Mar citizens, reeidents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct acoess to the Del Mar beach between 4tì St. and 11ur St. since the early 1900's.

3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Ofñce, is nor,v issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per peñ¡on.

4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including: .a. Crossing as a üain approaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks

5 We ask tliat you and NCTD wclrk vigorouslv and ¡mntedrately to accomplrstl lhe following

a Cease rssurng trckets when no train is near or rn srght.

b Ëstablishtwoormoredesrgnatedsitestocrossbetween6r"st ancl 11'r'St after "Stop. L.ook, and Lrsien".

( Wnrk cìllrgerltly lowarr¡ ru¡lsvirrEl the trar:ks frcln-i ths bh-rff wrtlrrn a de-'r:ade

Sincerely, The Undersigned

Name Signature Date Owner I Emall I Addrcss Regident / Voter ? t(.¡a ú1 /t l-6^¡'lu;i / raf;úrlr¿'s61Jgl,l 't4i- þip/4 I,t-Jt z-' vt> lY.î-rlp,,1. tÇç f#J ^î)u-: J- nz/t *t ,'t . . Mfu¿'tal c {;1 rf/)t V¿ l6ì v2, Y l?ò a7l f-\,, t tn r--[^ h il Lî, 9fr,!W{¡n rt,r.Vh hu.Lç(SP. ¿^ 1? Utt t?L l^ ß -l' UJ (l ,', l¡ - ,t' - r\- 1tl,* v r,lia* { t1 ù< lt ,l\ l,¡Lc./ / ? t,lW.1/ 2'-> 7Y '

1 dl

24 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Request for the City of Del lllar to work with North County Transit District (NCTD) to issuing tickets for crossing the raitroad tracks between 4ü St and llh St and to designate"eas" two or more crossing sites to accoss the west side of the tracks.

To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council

By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe foregoing statements:

1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.

2 Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct access to the Del Mar beach between 4th St. and 11rh St. since the early 1900's.

3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is now issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.

4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including a. Crossing as a train approaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks

5 We asx thal you and NCTD work vrgorously and rmnredrately to accomplrsh lhe followrng

a Cease rssurng trckets when no tratn ts near or rn stght

t' Establlsh two or more desrgnated srtes 1o cross between 6"'St and 11"'Sl after 'Stop, l-ook, and Lrsten'

c þ/ork drlrgentlv towarrJ rËrnovrrìg tl¡e lracks fronr tl-re t¡luff wrthrn a decacle

Sincerely, The Undersigned

Name Signature Date Owner / Email / Address Resident I Voter ? NL V ln¿r, f-arri\ln tv r¿^\o./ vrraí u,/á .Jû!!rt .¡ ¡r nî r]/1..-/ ru/ 'i,Íz¡t l¿-¡i¿*-Þ -t '\1tí tüh.a t,.' rya¡r(- fi1 luuurÉtlfr 4ntrt. rem [i^ - iJ ftN t4þ t^t>c 1-í le (ll-oL"rF\,,.,/{Ñ}Y fit11 '{Cos,vfr.ìt ?1"t1 Dlrluto^z tt6 | fcf 8.,: r- Ò¿-l !¿r' \r-.¡^13. .*ila¿) nrll. ¿ o¡-' K-t-^(Y.-* þ/¿v llL d,L( ç4r*ù& tçr, Õ,2( e Y,\Ð6 r63l Cy'/ r

1 z2

25 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 (ICTD) to Requeet for ttre City of fþl ilar b wort wlth Norttr Countv Transit Dlstrict aho ceâs€ issuing tickets for crossing the rallroad tracks ¡etrreen 46 st and liü st to designate two or more crossing õ¡tes to accoaa the weet slde of the tracks.

To: City of tÞl Mar Manager, Ci$ Staff, and City Council and agree By signing this instr¡ment, I agree and represent that I have read and understand with allthe bægoing statements:

1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensit¡ve coastal blt¡ff. to the 2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enioyed and exercised direct access Del Mar beach between 4ü' St. and 11h St. since the early 1900's-

g. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is now issuing tickets br crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 Per Person

4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tacks, including: a. Crossir€ as a tain aPProacùes ö. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks

5 We ask that you and NCTD work vrgorously and trnmedlately to accornpttsh the following

a cease rssutng tickets when no tratn is near or in sight

tl Establish two or more designatect sites to cross betweerl 6r" St and 11"'St after "StoP, Look, and Lísten"

c U,/r:rk clrlrgerrtly trlwärr:1 r'emovinc¡ the tracks fronr tl're trluff witl¡rrr a der:ade

Sincerely, The Undersigned

Name Signature Date Ormer / Email I Address Resident / , Voter? t?.Ç ;\lntf l4r.ll¿n nlÈP|t0'tÊ*Íù, rlfiir'ttL *ú1 rúC rfi ttt lt ^ I tft 9\ i3 v,Ì.?.4-) t L, Alzvt t, t1Þ o/tt/V lrI *

1 2'

26 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Requesr for rhe City of tlel tar to work wlth ilorth Gounty Transit 9isti9!![Cf?t_9^_ ou"ä* issurng t¡ckets for cros¡lng the railroad tracks betwoen 4- St and l1'' St and to designate two rr more crossing ã¡tes to acceas the wect elde of the tracks.

To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff' and Ci$ Council

By signing this instn¡ment, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe bregoing statements:

1. The ra1road track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastalbluff.

Z. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct acoess to the Del Mar beach between ¿6 St. and llrh $. since the early 1900's.

3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Ofñce, is norv issuing tic'kee for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 Per Person

4. Enbrcernent could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tacks, including: .a. Crossing as a üain aPProaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tacks

5 We ask that you and NCT'D work vrgr;rously and trnmedlately to acconrpltsh the following

a cease issurng tic;kets when no train ls near r¡r trr stght

b Ëstablish twg or nìere clesrgnatecl srtes to cross tretween 6tt'St arrcl 11r" St. after 'Stop Lr:ok, ancl t-isten'

- W¡rk rlrlrrìentlV towarri ÍenÌirvrrìq the tracks from tite irluff witt¡irr a cler;ade

Sincerely, The Undersigned

Name Signature Date Owner I Email / Address Resident I Voter ? 'D,c ß, b, r,r fþ ut l€ Lr-r \¡å\2-u- ,4J¿'= r(t i l¿ ) t6 ( .)-,rltt <) (qÊ -z ,'vt- -4Ø ffiEIléeQ- /ç14 5{w{( t/tb' ,'iy'è\ ñ? U I/

1,q

27 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Request for tñe Clty of fÞl tar to worl¡ with North Gounty Trangit Dlstlct ([C-TD] to issuing ticke-ts Íor crossing the rallroed tracks beü¡oen 4|n St and ll- St and b designate"e"Le two or more crossing sites to acceas tfie weet slde of the tacks.

To: City of Del Mar Manager, Ci$ Staff, and City Council

By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe bregoing statements:

1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.

2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direc't access to the Del Mar beach between 4h St. and I lth St. since the early lg00's.

3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is nor issuing tickeûs br crossing the railrcad tracks, at $500 per Person

4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privi@e to cross the tracks, including: .a. Crossing as a tain aPProaches ö. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks

5 We ask that you and NCTD work vrgorously antl trnmedrately to accotnplisft the tollowing:

a Cease tssuing tlckets when no lraln is near or in srght

t). EstabtishtwoormorecJesiç¡natecJsrtestorlrosshetween6"' St ancl 11il'St after "Stop, Loc¡k, and L.isten"

c Wi:rrk clrlrgently towarcj rernovinq the tracl

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

~~Name Signaturc Date Owner / Email I Address Resident / I / ,*- Voter ? ! o hrtqn I ttt^u {surtfl 4wr'.1- 6"lrt )ir YÉ¿S ßr qÉ,( t~~

~~z,0L (uan l!,cr" Vfa: I M Lþ. ( / <- It~~

~~1 2.f~~

~~28 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016~~

Requeot tor füe Gity of fþl ilar b wor* witlr Nortt¡ County TransJt^DlEülgt IIC^TDI t9 issuing ticke-ts for crossing the railroad tracls betwoen 4tr St and ll- St and to designate"n"ä* two or more crossinE sites to acoe3a füe west glde of the tracks.

~~To: City of Del Mar Manager, Cþ Staff, and Gity Council~~

~~By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and underctand and agree with allthe foregoing statements:~~

~~l. The railroad trac* bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal blufr.~~

~~2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direcf acoess to the Del Mar beach betryeen 4h St and 11th St. since the early lg00's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is now issuing tic,kets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per Peß¡on~~

~~4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including: a. Crossing as a train aPProaches ö. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks~~

~~5 We ask that you arìd NCTD work vrgorouslv and trilmed¡atefy to ac;r:orllpltsh tlte followtng~~

~~a Cease issr:tng tickets when no tratn ls near or rn stght.~~

~~b Establlsh two or more designated srtes to rjross between 6"'St and 11r" Sl aflet 'Stop, Look, and Listerl"~~

~~r_: '/Jork {rirgerrtly tc¡wetrrl rerrlûvirl-J the tracks frclnl tl¡e blrlffwtthtrr a decatle~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

Name Signature Date Ourner / Emall I Address Resident I Voter ? lb aJ1.nt tz$-J õf*ln" 20, --td.tâ,^r ^lnn¿rV-\fM 2ttl ,^rrrnrl.l 'rú/ e I zú' , ¿ -¡-- tû -al 20î I 74-7 c È\ ," ¿cJg M o l'lp 1'/A?tiltcti!. t,,,u f' ¿r\,' ?.q ç, ¿to .4,/, all a e vr e-f

~~1 2e~~

29 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August2ol6 Di"ttigt- Request for the City of Del ilar to work with North County Transit llGfDl P_ issuing tickels for cros¡ing tlre railrcad tracks between 4ln St and llo St and to "ur"ndesignate trro or more crossing sites to acceas the weet slde of the trackg.

~~To: City of tþl Mar Manager, City Statr, and City Council~~

~~By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe blegoing statements:~~

~~1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal blufi"~~

~~2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct aocess to the Del Mar beach between 4h St. and 11th St. since the early 1900's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Ofñce, is nor issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.~~

~~4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including: .d. Crossing as a tain aPProaches b. Walking, standing, siüing, or lying on the tracks~~

~~5 We ask that y¡u and NCTD wr.rrk vrgorously and ¡mrnedratefy to accorn¡.rlislt tlte following~~

~~â. Cease rssutng trckets when no llaln rs Írear or ¡n sight'~~

~~tr Estabhsh twCI or more rlesignated sites tr-r cross between 6"' St an~~

~~u Work clrlrgently towarrj remclvrrìg tlie tracks from the bltlff wtthtn a rlecarJe~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

Name Signature Date Owner / Email I Address Resident / Voter ? ztZ Åþ¡t )u l,oz r3 aaolz¿¡ -2,-./a1 ,d¿-tz* 3/t t lárle* z19 /þ I Yr-t'5" I zU Í 'n).6í(dt uru,(ørdll e shealøt Aé ztl (-- 8/ ! 'a..F A \¡J ztG 'r >atr zt4 I 40t 4 e v¿a V,-=u-----rV/gl *¡¿¡r Pv

30 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August2ol6 Request for füe City of fþl Har to work with Norttr County Transit Di"ttig! IICJD] P. issuirrg ticke-ts for croo¡ing the railroad tracks between 4ln St and lln St and to designate"*r** tr,và or rnore crossing sites to acce3s the weet slde of the tracks.

~~To: City of Del Mar Manager, Ci$ Staff, and City Council~~

~~By signing this instument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree wittr all the foregoing statements:~~

~~1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.~~

~~Z. De! Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct access to the Del Mar beach between 4th St. and 11rh St. since the early 1900's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Ofñce, is notr issuing tickets fur crossing the railroad tnacks, at $500 per person.~~

~~4. Enforoement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including: .a. Crossing as a üain aPProaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks~~

~~S We ask llral you ancJ NCITD w¡¡rk vrgorously arrcl rfrtntecJrately to acc;r-rrtt¡tlrsit lite following~~

~~a ljease tssuing trr.lkets when ncr traln is rlear or rn stght~~

~~Lr [stab¡sh two or rnore rlesrgnatecl sites lc cross belween 6"' 51 ancl ll'n St after "Stop, [-ook, arrd Listen"~~

~~c Wr:rk clrlrgently tow¡rrJ removinq the tracks tronr ther h¡ltlff wtthttr à tlet:'ctr)tJ~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

~~Name Signature Date Owner/ Email / Addruss Regident I \, Voter ? zzz Ê),^t-€.2 / r",ta~~

, ¡ (ã t a-,çt'¡,t c^^)'/ll z:Ll 9ot,n, rr-l ), / ., ^^ 6 -1 e /'' .uottt 4 /u7t bÅ, zz¿l ^€^JIs ;-ttt(@s&'l I zví ¿4\L Il oU U-c^- g 't itb |0^1* H- v ¿aC P v^ 7 ,ùtÐv 7 /-1J Q.-2L tA y-¿r4. /ùtþf zz't t t, -:)

2ø

~~31 September 6, 2016 Item 04 t..~~

Petition August 2016 Requæt for tfie City of Del tar b work wltlr North County TransJtDl¡üict IICJD) 9 .*""u issuing tickets for croosing the rallroad tncks betrcen 4ln St and ll- St and to designate two or rnore crossing sites to aceoos the woat slde of the tracks.

~~To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Statr, and City Council~~

~~By signing this instument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with all the furegoing statements:~~

~~1. The railroad track bisec.ts Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.~~

~~2. Del Mar citizens. residents, and visitorc have enjoyed and exercised direct ecoess to the Del Mar beach between 46 St. and 11ñ St. since the early 1900's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego SheriffE Office, is nour issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 Per Person~~

~~4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tacks, including: ,a. Crossing as a train aPProaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks~~

~~S We ask thal you and NÇTI) work vigorously and inrnrediately tr: accompltsh the following~~

~~a Cease rssuing trckets when no train ls near or tn stght.~~

~~tr Establish two or rnore clesrgnated sites to cross tretween 6"' St and 11r" St afler "Stop, Look, and Listen".~~

~~r- \Â/ork clilrt¡enily lowarrJ rerrìovrÍrçt lhe tracks frr-rrn the bluffwrthirl a tJec¿¡r1e~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

Name Signature Date OrYner / Email / Address Resident / /l Voter ? zro r**kPkpu'.^A høl^"' f01", rft'*-4J"Á- v/¿ z9r 4-A ,,.t\- eAt- /\]=o,{J\ 6? { Z,L ,t6;^1^V z7) tf;t tr1,- /Q_j}-,* -W\ g * zvl f,r¡Nino, t\m.lnltñ Y )/ -/ \ z16 è HÞ VO t\)r¡¡9 dr zlß og-vl ,¡l ,b ¡ /r,, \ t7? fJ.q(- ?- / zll lqau 0lu V¿ t' 77\ rCV ¡ 'l "n I tl?Å) V-g W kr' q çrr) 'r w zq

32 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Requeet for füe City of tþl tar to worl¡ with North County Transit District (ilCTD) to ceese issuing tickets fior croe¡ing the railrcad track¡ between 4|n St and llñ St and to designate two or rnore crossing sites to accoas the west side of tf¡e tracks.

~~To: Ci$ of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council~~

~~By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and 4ree with allthe bregoing statements:~~

~~1. The nailroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal blufi.~~

~~2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct acosss to the Del Mar beach between 4ü'St. and 1lrh St. sinoe the early 1900's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Offce, is now issuing tickeb for crossing the railroad tracks, at $5()0 per percon.~~

~~4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including: ,a. Crossing as a üain approaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the ûacks~~

~~5 We ask that you and NC f D work vtgorously and tmmediately to accomplistr the following.~~

~~a Cease rssurng ilckets when no lratrr is near or rrr slght~~

~~b Establish two or more desrgnaletl sites lri cross between 6rr'51. arrd 11'h St aftet 'Stop, Look and I isten"~~

~~c Work drlrgently towatrl remo,,/¡ng lhe trac;ks fron"r tire L¡ltlfi wrthrrr a det;ade~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

Name Signature Date Owner / Email / Addrees Resident I ì\ Voûer ? zcu oe VoJ¿ t17îlß /" 4t/re,ñ. Lu( z-er{fv ,wr\,UT tlzîhl tl 2tlz lÁt,, 'lr ltt< 7l¿x,ll ì I g>slfi .47 Âl^t^' ,v*.') Li ?fI)2-4ç< ¡.t, t91 '__ôthN - t44 arT- t 2.1ç (t)nt^-,1 llu zttL (

~~L 3o~~

33 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Request for the City of Del tlar to work with Norö County Transit Distict (NCTDI to .*"L* issuing tickets for crocsing the rallroad tracks betwsen 4ü St and llü St and to designare two or more crossing sites to aceÊgs the west side of the üacks.

~~To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council~~

~~By sþnirg this instrument, I agrce and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe bregoing statements:~~

~~l. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.~~

~~2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct access to the Del Mar beach bstween 4h St. and l lrh St. since the early 1900's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Offce, is now issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.~~

~~4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the facks, including: ¿. Crossing as a train approaches ö. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks~~

~~ir vVe ask that you arrd NCTti wr)rk vrgorûuslV anc.[ rmnrerJtatelv to acr:ontplisl¡ lht: fr;llowtng¡~~

~~a Cease tssuing ttckels whert rÌo tratrì ts neat ot rn stgltt~~

~~.l t, Ëst¿rhhsh two r-¡r rnore designatecl s¡tes to cross between 6"'Si anr:l I'n St a{ter "Stop, [-ook, anr1 Lrsten~~

~~r: Wr-¡rk illlrcler¡1lv tr,war(l ruf'rì{lv!n(J llre trar:ks Írorn iile bhlff wrllril a deriärlÊ~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

Name Signature Date Orvner I Email I Address Resident / -¡tløup Voter ? '{osþt dli fthÈ¿. tr:nn o Cf-Ir rit..1n¿ vY )ràf.vt é11. BI.L OtÐne!- lt tr>l< zt{þ ,I t4 ,t¿r¡r f-g'ÈyZ,^,{¿/ ¡b ztP lç-J/'/, ln / ) ¿crl b.ltØ^^-- i]¿tln l^-( ¿Ç7 '-¿b/' L7, uQl< ..ø,n (1.-- , (t LçI

34 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Request for the Gity of fþl tar to work witñ ilorü Gounty T¡ansit Dlsüict (NCTD) to cease issuing tickets for crossing the railrcad tracks betuoen 4or St and llh St and to deeignate two or more crossing sites to aceeaa the wsct side of the tracks.

~~To: City of tþl Mar Manager, Cig Staff, and City Council~~

~~By sþning this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe futegoing stiatements:~~

~~1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.~~

~~2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct acoess to the Del Mar beach between 4nr St. and 11th St. since the early 1900's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Ofñce, is nor issuing tickeûs for crossing the railroad trac*s, at $500 per peÉon~~

~~4. Enforæment could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including: .a. Grossing as a train approaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the facks~~

~~5 We ask that you and NCTD work vigorously and ilnrnediately lo acconrplish the following;~~

~~a Cease rssuing tickets when no trarn is near or rn sight~~

~~b Establish two or more clesignated sites to cross between 6r" St. anci 11"'St atter "Stop, Look, and Listen"~~

~~c Work dtllgently toward removing the tracks frorn the bltrff withrn a decade~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

~~Narne Signature Date Olrvner / Email I Addrces Resident / z ,,ale- Ùnf r¡tluvl,,r,a^O^ fl¿. tròlrrXL .ltn Vo@r ? .5LLbWh t^t- Ll,, øJt /W,- & nf?r|-. ^ lr<¿¿Ð0', t- ^~~

~~1 32~~

~~35 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016~~

Requeet for füe Ctty of D,el tar to work wlth Norü County Transit Distict (NCTD) to ceale issuing tickets for croesing the railroad track¡ bettuon 46 St and llü St and to designate two or more crossing sites to acoeas üre west side of the tracks.

~~To: City of Del Mar Manager, Ci$ Staff, and Ci$ Council~~

~~By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with all the foregoing stratements:~~

~~1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal blufi.~~

~~2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct acoess to the Del Mar beach between 4h St. and 11rh St. since the early 1900's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Ofñce, is norv issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.~~

~~4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including: ,d. Grossing as a fain approaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks~~

~~5 We ask that you and NCTU work vigorously and rnmeclrately to acconrplish the following~~

~~a Cease rssuing tickets when no traln is near or rn sigltl~~

~~b Establish two or more desrgnated sítes lo cross between 6th St and llrr'St. aner "Stop, Look, and Listen"~~

~~(:.. Wc¡rk diligeritly towarrj fËrrìovrrìc¡ the tracks frr-rrn the blufl withrn a der:ade~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

Name Signature Date Owner/ Email / Addrsss Resident / .-l .1 .'-fl Voter ? ,l 81 L:l{a/cf ¿1 ) [1€c / t/¿¿,rrt- rt6 It),ll,r,u^ ðÍ' (2 trt9ÞL S t \q 97ae t?,o-ç. Å.,..t 2rl S^\r/\^^ lwütt (x ,(t ttvtvqt Þ ñ, ,4<7N ç 7q o.n(rò0t ¡f-ft¡6' t ( 9, Àe

36 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Request for the City of flel tlar to work with North County Transit Dlstict l[CfD] P, .ease issr,ring tickeis for crossing the railroad tracks between 4- St and 1l- St and to designate two or more crossing sites to accesa the west slde of the tracks.

~~To: Ci$ of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council~~

~~By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe foregoing statements:~~

~~1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.~~

~~2. Del Mar citizens. residenb, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct acoess to the Del Mar beach between 4rh St. and 11rh St. since the early 1900's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is now issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per peß¡on.~~

~~4. EnÍorcement could be based on abuse of the pdvilege to cross the üacks, including: ¿. Grossing as a fain aPProaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks~~

~~5 We ask that yuu and NL;I'tJ work vignrously antl ttllmedlately to ar;conipltstt the following~~

~~a Cease tssuinc¡ tickets when no traln rs rìear or rn sight~~

~~tr Estabhsh two or more r-lesìgnatecJ sitc's tci i:ross betweerr 6'r' Sl åilrll 1'l'n Sr after "StoP, Look, ar¡d Ltsten'~~

~~i- \ô/ork dilrgently tnwarcl removrnq the tracks irort tire l¡ltlffwlthln a del:atle~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

Slgnature Date Onmer I Resident f bt' n) Voter ? 4/zQ /e< u¿s Yrs zcl MJf,4ú+6h çt, ¡ à.( 9n -ft¡ Vtl.n.//// -, t -/-// 2ê2 y\ñrLtrr{,t K",l f u Y"- /Ø=,- z6' gt, trE ' 2ÉA lvl¡ nen' €iflic\rcl. ex iíol,'v ¿t' 20i æ' t lro rçrr'( / ttos rce s*=:ã --/ /4ar, ze4 it-v ¡./Á f/ct ,lttlrc '( t,4t 7' ¡l ll$ J.1.{ I 2-g ¡\"

~~7Ll~~

37 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Request for tlre Gity of Del tar to wort witñ North Gounty Trans.it Dlstrict (ilCTDl to ceaie issuing tickets for crossing the rallroad tracks beûneen 4ûh St and llñ St and to designate two or rnore crossing sites to acog8a the west side of the tacks.

~~To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council~~

~~By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe bregoing statements:~~

~~l. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal blufi.~~

~~2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct access to the Del Mar beach between 4ü' St. and I lh St. since the early 1900's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is nor issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.~~

~~4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including ,a. Crossing as a fain approaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks~~

~~5 We ask that you anrJ NCTD work vrgorr.:usly arrd irnnlediately to accornplislr the following.~~

~~a Cease rssuing tickets when no trarn is near or rn stghl~~

~~b Establlsh two or more clesrgrrated sites to cross between 6'h St arrcl 11'h St after "Stop, Look and Listen"~~

~~r: Wr-rrk clrlrgently towarrJ rernr;vl¡q the tracks frorrt the hluff wrthlrl a clecarle~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

Name Signature Date Owner/ Email I Addrcss Resident / Voter ? zc1 ,'"'tuk &rtfand n ørhþ.*ltrn,l y Æptù I ta tlcíth Ao ,z E/>tllt \t}'l+ l^ 210 ht¡n< ç fì iamoit (æF-- etz g/n \,tere(' t 211 l/'tø L71- tnh V ùÌ.4.( t., L) ,l zlt ,.-,a- *.a \/1)ìt tt4 In,rf .r (:,r* ,; ). , , ,J¿-., 214 it ) t t, l"tft¡g,- 1 z+{ 1 L 't/¡ ;) ,t ;,,', 2+" J- ¿- KL -

~~L 3{~~

38 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Request Íor füe City of tlel tlar to wort with Nortt¡ County Transjt Distict (NCTD) to .*"i. issuing ticke-ts for crossing the rallroad tracks between 4ü St and llü St and to clesignate two or more crossing sites to access the weet side of the tracks.

~~To: Ci$ of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council~~

~~By sþning this instrument, lagree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe bregoing statements:~~

~~1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.~~

~~2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct access to the Del Mar beach between 4h St. and 11m St. since the earty 1900's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is nqv issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per peÉon.~~

~~4" Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including: ,d. Crossing as a tain approaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks~~

~~5 We ask that yorr ancl NCTD work vrgorously ancl tntrnecliatelv to accornpltsh the following.~~

~~a Cease tssulng trckets wherl no train ls near or tn stght~~

~~b Establrsh two or more clesrgnaled sites to cross between 6'r' St and 1 1rf' St after "Stop, l-ook, anrJ Listen"~~

~~c Work diilgently tc;w¿rrd renrc.rving the tracks from lhe bluff withitr a decade~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

~~Name Signaturc Date Owner I Emall I Address Resident / rge&r,tlf *ê4p*i-,t,^ ít0 Voter ? Ztt ,.f^ (try / t) ¡y,-/.v¿4/ t/2v adat ê n- ¿71 fá.AL R1¡r-,,-. el? q! ÆrÃ onp Z?o s~~

~~1 ?6~~

39 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Requect for the Gity of fþl ilar to wort with North County T¡ansJt Distict ([C_TD] t9 .*a** issuing tickeæ for cros¡ing tlre r:allroad tracks between 4th St and l1ü St and to designate two or more crossing sites to acoeaa tlre west elde of the tracks.

~~To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council~~

~~By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe furegoing statements:~~

~~1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal blufi.~~

~~2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct acoess to the Del Mar beach between 4h St. and 11ü St. since the early 1900's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Ofñce, is now issuing tickets tur crossing the railroad trac*s, at $500 per person.~~

~~4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including: .a. Crossing as a üain approaches ö. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks~~

~~il We ask ttrat you ancl NC ID wr.rrk vigorously artd rtnntedrately to auL:r-,n1pltsh tl're ir:llowing~~

~~a Cease tssLJing trckets wlìen no lratn is near or in srgitt~~

~~ll Fstat¡lish two or rnore desrgnateri sites to tross betlveerr tl"' St artd | 1rr' sÌ after 'Stop. Loc.,k, ancl Lislen"~~

~~,' ily'rrrk ririrgenlly tow¿r¡rJ rerrr(.)'vtrìr,l the trar:ks fr¡-rrl thr¡ blt¡if wttl¡trr a clet-.arie~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

~~Name Signature Date ûrner / Email / Addresg Resident / Voter ? r/á/t, 7.øt - 4¡n)taZ -4¡xt¿OÙaø 0ø,.nr+ 2.rc'Ûl 2_- zq+ sit 7ç9 7 aû r-t vÈ PT * f \ ¿c-, le lr'reh 1 ð e7~~

40 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Request for the Gity of Del ilar to work with North Gounty Transit District (NCTD) to reaä* issuing ticke-ts for crossing the railroad tracks between 4h St and llft St and to designate two or more crossing sites to acceas the west side of the tracks.

~~To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council~~

~~By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe foregoing statements:~~

~~1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.~~

~~2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct access to the Del Mar beach between 4th St. and 11th St. since the early 1900's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is now issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.~~

~~4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including a. Crossing as a train approaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks~~

~~5 We ask that you and NCTD work vigorously and rmmediately to accompltsh the following:~~

~~a Cease tssurng tickets when no train rs near or tn sight~~

~~b Establish two or more designated sites to cross between 6'r'St ancJ I1'h St after "Stop. Look and Lrsten"~~

~~c Work drlrgently toward rernovrng the tracks from the bluff wtthin a decade~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

~~Name Signature Date Owner/ Email / Address Resident / Voter ? zqo 7/8 zqt þ- { LWD il¡q 0..,|;t/nnJr., *lij; rl I v U~~

~~1 76~~

41 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August2ol6 Request for tlre Clty of flel llar to work with Norür Gognty Transìt 9lstlct IICJD) 9- issuing ticke-ts for crcsslng the rallroad tracks between 4u St and ll- St and to designate"*aL" two or more crossing sites to acosaa tlre wæt clde of the tracks.

~~To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council~~

~~By sþning this insûument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe brcgoing statements:~~

~~1. The raitroad track bisec'ts Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastral bluff.~~

~~2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct acoess to the Del Mar beaclr between 4h St. and 11rh St. since the early 1900's.~~

~~g. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Ofñce, is nour issuing tickeß br crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.~~

~~4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tacks, including: a. Crossing as a tain aPProaches ö. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks~~

~~5 We ask ihat you and NCTD work viEorously artd imrnedtately to accompllsn tne followrng~~

~~a Cease lssurng t¡ckets when no tratn is near or ln srght~~

~~b Ëstablish two or more desrgnated sites to cross between 6'f Sî an~~

~~r-; Work clilrgently tclward removrnq the tracks frclm the bluff wtlhrn a ,Jecade~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

~~Name Slgnature Date Owner I Email I Address Resident / Voter ? ( zqz t o ,Lf'Át*\- þJk fet;¡1rr.1 c¿ /' ( I Lla-u<- 7/zz o z$ /r¿ (t)Åt av ,rn c, '-?' .q0 f . lr \o(/f |ÁA^J\-J r(l t ,~~

~~L 4~~

42 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Requeet for tlre GiÇ of Del tar to work witlr North County TransJt DlsÛict IICJD) 9. .*""" issuing t¡ckets for crcc¡lng füe rallroad t¡aclc betrueen 4üt St and lln St and to clesignate two or more crossing sites to access tlre wost side of tl¡e tracks.

~~To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Statr, and City Council~~

~~By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe furegoing statements:~~

~~1. The railroad track bisecß Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.~~

~~2. Del Mar citizens. residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct acoess to the Del Mar beactr between 4h St. and 1lb St. since the early 1900's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Offce, is nor issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.~~

~~4. Enforæment could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including: ,a. Crossing as a train aPProaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks~~

~~5 r'/e ask thal yor) aficl NCTD work vrqorousiy and tmmedtately tc) accornplisn the following.~~

~~a Cease issutng ttckets when no traln is rtear or tn stclht~~

~~b Ëstabhsh tw¡r or more rJesrgnated srtes to cr.-rss between 6'n St. ancJ 1 1'r' $t after 'Stop Look artd l-.rsten~~

~~r: Wr¡rk rjrllqenTlV tôvvatd rem()vnlcl the irar;ks frr¡nt tl'te t¡lt¡ff wlthlr¡ a rter;arJe~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

Name Signaturc Date Owner I Emall / Addrcss Resident / Votsr ? e76 {V,l tÃ'Ie LvrJ L t00t, d'r." L 0€r\uç¡rñ ui¡ti,* J.CI+ /- /l/J-- *qq n4<( ¿rtî ¿¿Ìry tuà-''l tOO L É4- 4" r/, l4 rn e /e b y'lr' L@qøákn l/aft " )i ¿d\ a w l_ ?t L

4Õ

43 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Request for tlre Gity of tlel tlar to work witlr Norür Gounty Trang,ltÐlsttig! 0tlGTDl b issuing t¡ckets for crosclng the rallroad tracks betrreen 4ür St and f ln St and to cesignate"*aä* twà or more crossing sites to eccoaa üte west slde of the trackg.

~~To: City of tÞl Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Gouncil~~

~~By sþning this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe bregoing staternents:~~

~~1. The railroad track bisec{s Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.~~

~~2. Del Mar citizens. residenþ, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct acoess to the Del Mar beach beûween 4th $. and 11th St. since the early 1900's.~~

~~g. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Ofñce, is nor issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.~~

~~4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of ttre privilege to cross the tracks, including: .a. Crossing as a úain aPProaches ö. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the Ûacks~~

~~5 Vve ask that you anrJ NCTU work vigorously and lmnredrately to äccomplish tne following~~

~~a Cease tssulrìg tickets when nr.¡ tratn is¡ near or tn sigttt~~

~~b Establish two or more desigrrated srtes to cross between lì"' St and 1't"' St after 'Stop, Look, and Llsten'~~

~~r; Vr/ork rlrligenf ly tnwarcl removinç¡ the tracks fronr tlre bltlff wllhtrr a decacle~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

Name Signature Date Orrner/ Email / Address Regident I Votsr ? ¿J,'a', ,/',a.\ ð'¿ I a--1, .<.. J tç¡{ {,of þ"o.'t"' fuu ",,.¿o,/2â -_.y''4- ø/ )-, 3os L ', .i ,., t DtrltlÜ..A ' ( 'Þt ln,'¡..,r lr tY "07# -r<.wr1Å p 3a I 14ct t0n irza {tçt¿ ¿tft tto 'l/ØILyJnñ1 t7â 3tl ffti '(1tl\ l^.x., , ttz Rc/,¿ il) K sJn GIpIUT

~~1 q(~~

~~44 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016~~

Requett for tlre City of tlel tlar ûo work wlth Nor$ Gounty Transit Distict (ICTD) to *e"!e issuing ticke-ts for crossing the rallroad tracke between 46 St and llh St and to designate two or more crossing sites to access the wsst alde of the tracks.

~~To: Cig of tÞl Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council~~

~~By signirg this insüument, I agæe and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe furegoing statements:~~

~~L The railroad track biseúìts Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastalbluff.~~

~~2. Del Mar citizens, regidents, and vis¡tors have enjoyed and exercised direct acoess to the Del Mar beach between 4tt St. and l lth St. since the early 1900's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is now issuing tickeß for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.~~

~~4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including: "a. Crossing as a tain approaches b. Walking, standirg, sifting, or lying on the backs~~

~~5 We ask thar you arrd NCTU worh vrgorously and ¡rnmedrately tü ¿ccorn¡iltsh tlte following.~~

~~a. Cease rssutng t¡ckets when no tratn ls rlear or trt stqhl~~

~~b Establ¡sh two c¡r more designated sites to cross between n"'St anrJ 1 llr' St afler 'Stop, Look. and L¡sten".~~

~~c Work drlrr-¡entl,,¡ tcrward removrng the tracks fronr the bir:ff wttlrrn ;l {jL){;a{le~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

Name Signature Date Onrner I Email I Address \ Resident / /, ,-â Votsr ? i€'t.S/ flOfcrf MDW 4 úÞlr K¿ 7q 'd¿út t6 .(o "-Ølq r J-.\ r¿<ì/o,r!/.,L{rrt-"f t16 î¡ai1-ðlax;,^ /¿Çar*ò ea I ^/aa --t ftiliti. t.lNf. lfJ' þa'la'.- Nt7 t l6 b Y -¿'¡.--i ì\_ 6f r_flrr D,+,*u urot -, "* rl72Jtç 7R ,.,*'JL/f tt)¡ - v8]¡z /tnkr */9 I R (Z/*tø-âb 7/ 4( æl ffi^/l- ?/z 7 Jrnr/ Vorh- a 2.7/ ll-; ,/ z4 /øillt

~~L u2~~

45 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Requast for the Gity of Iþl tar to work with Nortr County Transjt Dlgûict (NGTD) to issuinE tickeL for crossing the railroad tracks betwoen 4ü St and llü St and to """"urJesignare two or more crossing sites to acoeas the west side of the tracks.

~~To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council~~

~~By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe turegoing statements:~~

~~l. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.~~

~~2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enioyed and exercised direct acoess to the Del Mar beactr between 4th St. and 1lü St. since the early 1900's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is nov issuing tickets for crossing the railroad trac-ks, at $500 per person.~~

~~4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including: .a. Crossing as a train approaches ö. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks~~

~~5 VVe ask tlrai yor-i and NCTLr work vrqorously and tmmecltately to ac;corïpltsh tf'e following~~

~~a Cease issurng trckets wherl nci train is near or rn stght.~~

~~br Ëstatllish two or more designatecl srtes tr¡ cross between €ìr" Sl. anrj 11'h St, afler "Stop, Look, anrJ Lrsterr'~~

~~r: ll/ork rliligently tou¡arrJ rernovrrìr] the iracks from the blt¡ff within a clecarle~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

~~Name Signature Date Owner/ Email /Address Resident / .a Yotp¡ ? 3' Ï.F l¿="É,t¿< i=-.¡¿.e l¿51á,k"tn*it,. Qa51"E~~

~~1 qb~~

46 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Requesr for füe City of flel tlar to work with l{orth County Tnnsit gistigl lXCJ?t_f^^ ,ruai* issuing t¡*xe-t* for crossing the rallrcad tracks between 4- St and ll- St and to clesrgnate two or nìore crossing iites to acogaa the weet side of the tracks.

~~To: CW of tÞl Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council~~

~~By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe foregoing statements:~~

~~1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal blufr'~~

~~2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct access to the Del Mar beacfr between ¿ü St. and 11th St. since üre early 1900's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is nol issuing tickets for crossing the railroad backs, at $500 Per Person.~~

~~4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including: a. Crossing as a train aPProaches ö. Walking, standing, sifüng, or lying on the tracks~~

~~5 We asx thai you ancl N{,:l-tl wr¡rk vrrJ(,rrlrrsly ar¡d lnrnleÕiately to accornpitsh the following¡~~

~~a Cease issutng ttckets when n(t lratrì is near or rn srght~~

~~b Fstablish two or mere rJesrgnated srtes to crosÊ betweert 6tt St arnd 11"'St, afler "StciP, l-r:ok, and Lrsten"~~

~~r-:\l/orkclrliç¡entlytr¡warrJrertrnvingthelracksfrorrltl'reL¡luffwrthiriatlecar:le~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

Name Signature Date Ormer I Email / Addrsss Resldent I Voter ? 7tZ rnl Pdrost:r 7r, u U#L t th t*,2-p¡ I èututr\-/ 2. I t,/olzl /.-/^ >¡Y( 7ç ,/ê/n r / / tl (Ht'rlon:l /Ytfu/l ?71" h -Ã/.*va ØlZiltt iTe.xtJt¡í/öuu^r ot/ ?'t1 f'ì{€-,Dhe,ü LwøVÅàv{ve¡\ tfr I I .4 1tq, loi¿{o,rl -ic-

~~L L{q~~

47 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 201ó Requeet for tlre City of Del ilar to wort wlth ilorür County Transit Distrigt ({C^fO) t9 **"L. issuing tickeis for croscing the railroad tr¡cks betrreen 4ö St and llb St and to ctes¡gnete uò or more crossing sites to accoas üre wt side of tlre tracks.

~~To: City of tþl Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council~~

~~By signing this instrument, I agree and rcpresent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe furegoing statements:~~

~~1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.~~

~~2. Del Mar citizens. residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct acoess to the Del Mar beach between 4h St. and l lrh St. since the early 1900's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is norv issuing tickets fur crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.~~

~~4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including: .å. Crossing as a tain aPProaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks~~

~~.) VVe ask that yr,ru ancl NCTD work vrgorolrsly and ttllnledtately to a(;corrlpllsn lhe following~~

~~a Cease issuing lickets wl¡en nc¡ tratrr ls near ot trt stght~~

~~b Establish two or nrore clesrgnatecJ srtes to c:ross between frt" St anc, 11rh St after "Stop, Look. and I isten"~~

~~,- ll/¡ltk r-lrlrclerrtly 1r.;'.v.arrJ renìo\/r11g the tracks frcin¡ the bluff u¡rtlitrr a,jgc¿¡rlû~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

Name Signature Date Owner / Email I Addre¡s Regident I Voter ? ,t4 . \.n,r--l 0^t-LJ unq foç,.1-" l' 7tE #': . rPZu- 9l zr ,AfA y& ú"/7Æ ,6 bßrû- 3.tb ö )er rL PeS ict rl/ rL4 ttß"t1 /, )È z z"\ 1 I /t T 4{

48 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August2ol6 Request for tlre Gity of tþl tar ûo work wlttr Norür County TransJt Dlstlct IICJD] 9. issuing ticke-ts Íor crosslng ttre railroad tracks betwoen 4ln St and 1l- St and ûo designate"*"ä* two or more crossing sites to acco3s the wegt slde of the tracks.

~~To: City of Del Mar Manager, Ci$ Sffi, and City Council~~

~~By signing this instn¡ment, lagree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe bregoing stiatements:~~

~~l. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.~~

~~2. Del Mar citiz€ns. residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct access to the Del Mar beach betrreen 4th St. and llrh St. since the early 1900's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Offioe, is nor issuing tickets for crossing the railrod tracks, at $500 per Person.~~

~~4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the üacks, including: .a. Crossing as a tain aPProaches ö. Walking, standing, sítting, or lying on the tacks~~

~~S We ask that you and NCTti work vigorously and trrtmedtately tti ar;cr:mplislr llre followtng~~

~~a Cease issuirrg trc;kets when no train is ttear or rn srght~~

~~b. Establrsh tw~~

~~c Wol'k c|hçlently tr¡warrl removrng the tracks from lhe bhlff wlthin a rlecacle~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

Name Signature Date Owner / Email / Address Resident / Voter ? g/% Vn ,10 t le/ t'íl c?/D L<-í. 7lz g, ( ',rmK I ì\ UJD 0n\1 \ T I ( )t'vi It,.f.^ ) ,t ';e/c J 7/^ H \. lt i,i / ffi_t@¿y Ø -S" ¿1 1 46

49 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition Ausust 201ó Requect for füe City of flel Har to work wittr Nortñ County Transjt Distict ([C_fO¡ q issuing tickets for croo¡lng ttre ¡ailroad tracke between 4ü St and llb St and to clesignate"""*" ñn¡o or rnorê crossing sites to accoaa täe wegt slde of tñe track¡.

~~To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and Cþ Council~~

~~By signing this instt¡ment, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe furegoing stiatements:~~

~~1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.~~

~~2. Del Mar citizens, resklents, and visitors have enjoyed and exerclsed direct access to the Del Mar beach betl,yieen 4û St. and 11h St. since the early 1900's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheritrs Ofñce, is nor issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 Per Peßon.~~

~~4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tacks, including: ,a. Crossing as a tain aPProaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the Ûacks~~

~~5 We asK tnat you anrJ lr¡CTD work vrgorously and rnlnredlatelv 10 accom¡lltsn tl're following~~

~~a. Cease rssuing trckets when no train ls rlear or tn srght~~

~~b Ëstablrsh two or more clesrgnatecl srres to cross between 6r'' St and 1 1"' St after "Stop, [-ook, and Lrsten"~~

~~r-: W,l¡k clrlrç1e¡tly to\¡/arcl rern(J\/trìe the tracks; frtrni the Lrluff witlli¡r a ijer;arJe~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

Name Signature Date Owner I Email /Address Resident / 0 Voter ? x< .H.à^ V lt--' 1{¿*âe"* ?¿-^.\À.r¡rscr.^- hlxt t\irñ.¡.fRpsiÀD. 3U¿ ,à 1ßl l¡t .r.r.^- t** l-l OV¡ làî,t t 'r;.tlV,K¿¿- Íl t9 a)\ 6 I ehl¿i¡¡576l e atl A¡*r U

~~L d?~~

50 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Request Íor tlre Gity of tlel trar to worft rriür Norür County Transit Dlstrlct (IC_TD) to issuing tickets for crolrlng tfre r¡llroad tracke betrvesn 4th St and llh St and to designate"""ä* two or rnore crossing sites to acoaSs tñe wt¡t slde of the trackg.

~~To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council~~

~~By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with all the foregoing stratements:~~

~~1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.~~

~~2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct acoess to the Del Mar beac{r between 4ùh St. and 11th St. since the early 1900's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Oúñce, is nor issuing tickets fur crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.~~

~~4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including: ,e. Grossing as a tain approaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks~~

~~5 We ask that you and NCTD work vrgoror:siy ancj tmrnedrately to acconlpltsl-r the following~~

~~a. Cease rssuing trckets when no tratn ts neâr or tn stght~~

~~l¡ Establish two or more desrgnatecl srtes to cross between 6'n St. and 11"' St a1'ter "Stop, L.ook, and Listen"~~

~~c, $lc¡rk dilrqently toward removing the tracks frr:m the bluff wtthin a riecacie~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

Name Signature Date Owner / Email / Addrese Resident / (Æ/L-.-4 Voter ? xt n/r /-|il l@rrchü - r-1^ H l-l^nty,,@4t"v, l,¿o\ Ftl,qù Y¿ S. ¡¿\ rå 11', I lto A- t04 ll'tt;hn Coll;"t Lvtr,^ tr t¿tl ^r0 v",,tol b Lry ,5f n.1 ^ (K t.'. ci); ,l rtnç, w t L ., íy''t'- !1)^ 9/t" ) l , <,-rr¡|! r4Àl It c , rr,Q t61 <4 ,*ì \- t. - rlu ßrrr,LJ úc tui.+l¿f %1 T.'14ß r10 t/" il 'll l[i.thl w /)-, 4Vq Y(htÃLw s7 4t,lg Vok c n',r (eI t v,: þ'r.r!l c ynl,,^ La\ fiZ ", fi ulq T.> 4(

51 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Requeot for tñe Gity of fþl Har to worl¡ with North County T¡ansit Dlsüict (NCTDI to ceale issuing tickets Íor crcsslng tfie r¡ilrcad tracks betwoen 4ü St and llÖ St and ûo designate two or more crossing sites to aco983 tl¡e west slde of tñe tracks.

~~To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council~~

~~By sþning this instrument, I agree and represent ü,tat I have read and understrand and agree with allthe bregoing statements:~~

~~1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastalblufi.~~

2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct access to the Del Mar beach between 4n St. and 1lrh St. since the early 1900's. I 3. NCTD, fhrough the San Diego Slrer#s Office, is nour issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.

~~4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tacks, including: ,a. Crossing as a train approaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks~~

~~5 We ask that you arirl NCTU urork vrgorousiy ancl ¡rnrnedtalely lo accomprtstl tne fr:llowrng~~

~~a. Cease rssuing tickets when no trarn ts near or rn srclht~~

~~b Estat¡lish two or n¡¿:re desrgnale~~

~~c Work rliltg¡ently Ìowar<1 rernovtnq lhe tracks frortr the trluff ,¡¡rthrn a der:ade~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

Name Signahrre Daþ Orner/ Email / Addrcss Resident / ,-/ ./- /t Voter ? 7T1 7k,¿l^/.1 /s1 þ¡/ 941 l1 Kr^" h**¡n) 7 Rest t . LJt(¡," ( [,th ¿\/r, l/l tÐ 'T7?b Y{^^^, 1) Iu¡,' t uI\_/ 'fie u F 4 tJL'\1'r- t 1 t.J- 4'16 fu* ,4Lñ J,t'^ a'., & Vtl"t ,'11 )+1vfu ,¿ '7Ø 2 I]-'^'J+\'zS Otqil ln¡i ,¡,*t 5n-/Øî,v l V1,. ZE ¿

~~L ¿{?~~

~~52 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016~~

Request for ttre Gity of flel ilar ûo work with Norö County Transit Dlstrict (NCTD) to issuing tickets for crossing tlre railroad tracks between 4ü St and 116 St and to "*ai"designate two or more crossing sites to aocoss the west slde of tñe tracks.

~~To: City of IÞl Mar Manager, City Statr, and City Council~~

~~By signing this instument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree wih allthe bregoing statements:~~

~~l. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastalbluff.~~

~~2. Del Mar citizeng, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct acoess to the Del Mar beach between 4th St. and l lu' St. since the early 1900's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is nor issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person~~

~~4. Enforcement oould be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the facks, including: a. Crossing as a úain approaches õ. Walking, standing, siüing, or lying on the tracks~~

~~5 We ask thaT V,J,r and NCTtI work vrgorortsly and rrnrnedrately Io accorïplrsfì tlìe following~~

~~a Cease rssurng trckets when no trarn is near or rn sight~~

~~h¡ Ëstablish two or more desrgnatecJ srtes to cross befweerr ô"'St and 11"'St after "Stop, Look and Listen"~~

~~c Work diltgently towar(l rernovrnq the tracks fronr the blt¡f'f '¡vrthrn a decacte~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

Name Signature Date Owner I Email / Addrcss Resident / Voter ? 'baz ñ - ¿- R-.J -r,--/,. ¿lo ^Y)r<.âz '.'- -f,- o-,t4..2-* 9/at &-<-tn2)- t (¡fßrj.!.-l ?¡l,-f þ t t14A ?/t t QçaIr{* ç,-. 1 O fÃlJilile l*eoel'-T tJ? ton-\l ' ,^)rlÉ l trl( (l^ t Àtl ll <1 a Â '496 Jier"'ì^t l'ø J ., J ud Y^ fø,* Cl I ll¿l¿ ",^¡¡_ÞÃ)'/M-l 4 /q& T-¡^n -tf ,--(-. *Æn¡A,1r\t ßhq Oo

~~1 Eü~~

53 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Request for füe City of flel tar to work with North County Tran¡it Dlstrlct (NCTDI to cease issuinE tickets for cræsing the railroad tracks between ¡lü| St and llD St and to rlesignate two or more crossing sites to acooas tlre wget side of the tracks.

~~To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Statr, and City Council~~

~~By signing this instn¡ment, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe bregoing statements:~~

~~1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.~~

~~2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct access to the Del Mar beach betrryeen 4u' St and 11rh St. since the early lg00's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Ofñce, is nor issuing tickets fur crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.~~

~~4. Enfurcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including: .a. Crossirg as a Íain approaches ö. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks~~

~~5 We ask that you anrJ t{L-l-D wclrk vrqorously and rqnmedrätety to accornf.llrstì ltiÉ iollowrng~~

~~ã. Cease rssurng llickets when no trarrt ts near r:r rrr srght~~

~~b F-stablisfrtwoormoredesrgnater,J srtestc-rcrossbetween6"',St anC 11rt St aftcr "Stop Look and l-isten"~~

~~c. Work diligently lowarrl remor¡i¡lci the trâcks ir,:rrn 'lhe hlulf wtthrr' a decarle~~

~~Sincerely, Tte Undersigned~~

Name Signature Date Owner / Email I Addræs Reeident I ,/j t Voter ? ?qo r-ru\lc (tNer\ ù (¡¡a, ,bt\ lco.t9l'!,ne & ft Bc) Kç ùeir / VC tr| 9ql J./-/ ç />, , /OJu tu | \)f,r. t2- lffi,r t tt¿ ñ 2Ã o.ç¿ tr¡ol r.{aþ^ 3f2 I'c4W-Gl' V< 3ît !¡¿.",Áh^, FbH4r,r ( (*'llø t t ¿gittnl .r{q 'l I '-l c.v \rr lu Õl- 7 ø z '#r'M úlzo 'fö W 86 o ¡? w Z'Ís, ¿.ø"*/lt '1w /rh t 7 la 5l

54 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Request for the City of Del Mar to work with North County Transit District (NCTD) to cease issuing tickets for crossing the raitroad tracks between ¿th St and llth St and to designate two or more crossing sites to access the west side of the tracks.

~~To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Stafi, and City Council~~

~~By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe foregoing statements:~~

~~1. The railroad track bísects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.~~

~~2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct access to the Del Mar beach between 4$'St. and 11h St. since the early 1g00's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is now issuing tickets for crossing the raílroad tracks, at $500 per person.~~

~~4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including a. Crossing as a train approaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks~~

~~5 We ask that you and NCTD work vigorously and immediately to accomplish the following:~~

~~a Cease issuing tickets when no train is near or in sight.~~

~~b Establish two or more desígnated sites to cross between 6th St and 11th St. after "Stop, Look. and Listen".~~

~~c Work diligently toward removing the tracks from the bluff within a decade~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

Name Date I Email/ Address Resident / ¿. ¿ *¡i,fu }.16 lr.'r . y*¿ C .¡o-h ta ca:.-L e ¡v&¡-.'l. ,^ -11 L^ Voter ? 9tc 3,tc. t ¿{oô I tûlln ¡ ri /4, ø4j / qot P tlO?_ Þ.., llu r \ -lv n(¡t s I a(d) u "rr' c þ.u res,\ .4 + it00 q07 ,) o l^el T Ll h¿ RP ( I Qt4 1í r\ +- 1c4 - -b{n lI iìll¡l¿¿ r ú W4r -y qú 7'>.^ / ,,".t i-e<^ '-- l< I'z' f ¿toê Q',ù¿, : a¿/,, ro i f a- I

~~q.L~~

55 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Request for the City of Del Mar to work with North County Transit District (NGTD) to cease issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks between 4h St and l lth St and to designate two or more crossing sites to access the west side of the tracks.

~~To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council~~

~~By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe foregoing statements:~~

~~1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.~~

~~2. Ðel Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct access to the Del Mar beach between 4h St. and 11h St. since the early 1900's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is now issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.~~

~~4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including: a. Crossing as a train approaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks~~

~~5. We ask that you and NCTD work vigorously and immediately to accomplish the following.~~

~~a. Cease issuing tickets when no train is near or in sight.~~

~~b. Establish two or more designated sites to cross between 6h St. and 11th St. after "Stop, Look, and Listen"~~

~~c Work diligently toward removing the tracks from the bluff within a decade~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

~~Name Signature Date Owner / Email / Address Resident / Voter ? Çot Ct u ûrtlX¡ttl;N á't{ t-¡;¿- ì{or (7Llr, l.r 4 ctø ,Ú ,F ln ç;t'4 \¡.1 i'l¿ s- a . ,'- | É¿/ 40q I~~

~~56 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016~~

Request for the City of Del Mar to work with North County Transit District (NCTD) to cease issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks þetween ¿tn St and llth St and to designate two or more crossing sites to access the west side of the tracks.

~~To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council~~

~~By signíng this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe foregoing statements:~~

~~1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 míles of sensitive coastal bluff.~~

~~2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and vísitors have enjoyed and exercised direct access to the Del Mar beach between 4th St. and 11th St. since the early 1900's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is now issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.~~

~~4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the prívilege to cross the tracks, including a. Crossing as a train approaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lyíng on the tracks~~

~~5. We ask that you and NCTD work vigorously and immediately to accomplish the following:~~

~~a. Cease issuing tickets when no train is near or in sight~~

~~b. Establish two or more designated sites to cross between 6tn St and 11h St after "Stop, Look, and Listen"~~

~~c. Work diligently toward removing the tracks from the bluff within a decade~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

Name Signature Date Owner / Email/ Address Resident/ Yote¡ ? j: 40 lÂ r1, *+t o - t,Àsr- ¡^ttciX--FntJ,.u -ãl: ¿ 1 Q/2ò lçt t,ort* ¿Írl A" /f-)" i tttty-t. LêLtYo*,/* L/ r.^ ¿Vq i.z lr ,., -',í, ;, ,,.-.-! .¡ 4çz ,)pr¡ ", ,..".i--h77/-,,/,, , ,,.1. í I

~~;Ll~~

57 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Requeat fior the Gity of flel tar to work with North County Transit Dl¡trict (NCTD) to ceãse issuing tickets Íor crocsing the railrcad tr¡cks betrueen 4th St and l1ü St and to designate two or more crossing sites to aceo8s the wget sld€ of tñe trecke.

~~To: Gity of tÞl Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council~~

~~By signing this instument, lagree and represent that I have read and understrand and agree with allthe bregoing statemenb:~~

~~1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal blufi.~~

~~2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct aooess to the Del Mar beach betuyeen 4¡n St and l1¡n St. since the early 1900's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Ofiæ, is now issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tacks, at $500 per person~~

~~4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including ,d. Crossing as a train approaches ó. Walking, standing, siüing, or lying on the tracks~~

~~5 Vúe ask that you ancj NCTD work vrgorc,usty and rnrnledrately to ac;complish the following~~

~~a üease tssutng tickets when no tratn ls near or rn srght.~~

~~b Ëstablish two or more desrgnated sites to cross between 6"' St and 11'h St after 'Stop, l-ook, and Lrsten".~~

~~(: Work dtltgently towarrj removrng the tracks from the bluff withrn a rjecacle~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

~~Name Signature Dab Owner / Email I Addrees Resldent / qI Vota¡ ? l)oo^-Ond¿ .~~

~~L qt~~

58 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Request fior the City of flel llar to wort wltñ Nortñ County Tranq¡t Digtrict (NCTDI to ceaäe issuing tickets for cro¡sing the r¡ilro¡d tracks betvueen 4ü St and llh St and to rlesignate two or more crossing sites to ecsgss tfte west slde of the tracks.

~~To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and Cig Council~~

~~By signing this insfument, I agree and represent that I have read and urderstand and agree with allthe furegoing statements:~~

~~l. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.~~

~~2. Del Mar citizens, ræidents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct aooess to the Del Mar beach between 4tì St. and lltn St. since the early 1900's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Offce, is now issuing tickets for crossing the railrod tracks, at $500 por person~~

~~4. Enúorcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including: .a. Cræsing as a ûain approaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the facks~~

~~5 We ask that yotr anrJ NCTU work vrgorously anrl rmriledrately tLr acr'onr¡rhslr the folfowing~~

~~ä, Cease issurng trckets when nci trarn ls near or rn srght~~

~~b Establish two or rnore designalecl srtes to cross between 6rt'Sl ancj 11"'St afler "Stop, Look, and Ltsten"~~

~~Work rlilig¡enlly towarrj removrnq lhe tracks frorn the blr.rff withrn a decade~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned í t .ilç I n s on'LÉ ll t't L L êKe ¡ oi¡u¡ ¿'CoA rz* Sh,rllr þsraê'i ,* $/:r qb r S-i1ct {^*,,t j 9!* n ll' crnn~~

59 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Request for the City of Del Mar to work with North Gounty Transit District (NCTD) to cease issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks between Cn St and I l'n St and to designate two or more crossing sites to access the west side of the tracks.

~~To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council~~

~~By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe foregoing statements:~~

~~1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff~~

~~2. Ðel Mar citizens, residents, and vísitors have enjoyed and exercised direct access to the De! Mar beach between 4h St. and 11th St. since the earty 1900's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Díego Sheríffs Office, is now issuíng tickets for crossing the railroad hacks, at $500 per person.~~

~~4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including a. Crossing as a train approaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks~~

~~5. t /e ask that you and NCTD work vigorously and immediately to accomplish the following:~~

~~a. Cease issuing tickets when no train is near or in sight.~~

~~b. Establish two or more designated sites to cross between 6th St. and 11h St. after "Stop, Look, and Listen".~~

~~c. Work diligently from the bluff within a decade~~

SsÐ t o(¡{/W f/t Sinoerely, Çe" (tt; The Unde¡signed {l ,' Ít3t 'Name v $gnature Date Owner / Email / Address Resident / Voter ? cßt lJtll õtcI(v t*ef ¿ql€,Lr- E7 .1 ø s..4t f ?ftT r^.t*ftt ¡2¡tÇ 9/ 'l4t..}-)r¡vC;-'- \tz ¡JJffif;."ffÍff r. 1J)LÔIt.I ,y,N/tn tl,t çr qr" ( i,uli' r3å iôù<à u t- ,^ dzt ovú'NÉ R "-vn- ',óFâ/ qtÊl NLLçoù V-rq rl I A 6ß n/k 0r t, Ylst rt¿ft til¡r P5stVpSFPø l-Þ¿ Ld ì .tçl iø h n n l¡ 4 t ba'rf4,t r*.,t,' L ¿ ¿l'r-) ¿.J-? -ø Z.J/ lù¿,6 r'l¿/Ylt qtL -r1r¿^{-./à n-¡i¡,¿ , tl / ,tt-^ QJp &d?Ð ¡=,

60 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Request for the City of Del Mar to work with North County Transit District (NCTD) to cease issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks between ¿th St and I lth St and to designate two or more crossing sites to access the west side of the tracks.

~~To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council~~

~~By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe foregoing statements:~~

~~L The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.~~

~~2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct access to the Del Mar beach between 4th St. and 11th St. since the early 1900's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is now issuing tickets for crossíng the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.~~

~~4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including: a. Crossing as a train approaches b. Walking, standíng, sitting, or lying on the tracks~~

~~5. We ask that you and NCTD work vigorously and immediately to accomplish the following~~

~~a. Cease issuing tickets when no train is near or in sight.~~

~~b. Establish two or more designated sites to cross between 6th St. and 11th St. after "Stop, Look, and Listen"~~

~~c Work diligently toward removing the tracks from the bluff within a decade~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

Name Signature Date Owner / Email / Address Reeident / Voter ? -ö/, qq, ,4 tì¡ rr ¡.0 ^tùv97A tr)r"¡Lll.a.^^ LLt ê/,l .tt \ tßLttuÅ t'lrÉl ,],Ltal+tt Yil - t¡-t>, t/t 4^t tAr{- fl\/ f/ctt /¡. / íaÍ2 .16 '- fl;:^ Crt zth>. llt-'u I t *1å- re 7et1/€ u ,) æ- V3t 11- .',4a 4{7 Rlzt 1t[ lÅ,,. H ,.&ü / 4 G (rc-{.Cl S.-0-r- {{î q

61 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Request for the Gity of Del Mar to work with North County Transit District (NCTD) to cease issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks between 4th St and I lth St and to designate two or more crossing sites to access the west side of the tracks.

~~To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and Cíty Council~~

~~By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with all the foregoing statements:~~

~~1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.~~

~~2 Del Mar cítizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct access to the Ðel Mar beach between 4d' St. and 11h St. since the early 1g00's.~~

~~3. NCÏD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is now issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.~~

~~4. Enforcement coufd be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including a. Crossíng as a train approaches b. Walking, standing, sittíng, or lying on the tracks~~

~~5. We ask that you and NCTD work vigorously and immediately to accomplish the following.~~

~~a. Cease issuing tickets when no train ls near or in sight~~

~~b. Establish two or more designated sites to cross between 6th St. and 11th St after "Stop, Look, and Listen".~~

~~c. Work diligently toward removing the tracks from the bluff within a decade~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

~~Name Signature Date Owner / Email / Address Resident / " Voter ? (AUt^ ?çc, luv vl't1 f.,Lny< @ o'¿naì L é--{(---/ I RI 1t^n 1¿~~

' stlI . lån,i¿-v u,J\ÆT(Àø ¡ o.tl ,r J t VSi I l,J- ¿çz é. c'- I ¿v nt¿, Efu ,,. h,,i r-â-- .¿=Z *.1---''- (/tt a/ L*( " - g7 ¡t"aa I L4 T-?)Çl e. a ., ìA Q2lz¡ fo¡Â'^t çtq cc' É{,/",//¿< 'Tþ-a./}/- \<è r l! ¿1Tl (r-\ 4.r^-',¡ ' ( 2t'1, Ç¿r *(;rl ¿rÇc .\ "l l.,t Un la K- '. ta ' 1r+ Ø/E/ Frt4.rt, ", 1 a 4

62 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Request for the City of Del Mar to work with North County Transit District (NGTD) to cease issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks between ¿th St and l lh St and to designate two or more crossing sites to access the west side of the tracks.

~~To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council~~

~~By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe foregoing statements:~~

~~1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensítive coastal bluff.~~

~~2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct aceÆss to the Del Mar beach between 4th St. and 11ü St. since the early 1900's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, ís now issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks, at $500 per person.~~

~~4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including: a. Crossing as a train approaches b. Walking, standíng, sitting, or lying on the tracks~~

~~5. We ask that you and NCTD work vigorously and immediately to accomplísh the following.~~

~~a. Cease issuing tickets when no train is near or in srght.~~

~~b. Establish two or more desrgnated sites to cross between 6rh St and 11tn St. after "Stop, Look, and Listen"~~

~~c. Work diligently toward removing the tracks from the bluff within a decade~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

~~Name Signature Date Owner / Email / Address Resident / Voter ? I t td, Ltrrl r.l'i{ rÌù7.-/- wl .'l ùf/t 4q1. -¿/c l,\t";F,*.?,á.;) |- Í..r,Æ. -~~

63 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Request for the City of Del Mar to work with North County Transit District (NCTD) to cease issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks between Ch St and llth St and to designate two or more crossing sites to access the west side of the tracks.

~~To: City of Del Mar Manager, City Staff, and City Council~~

~~By signing this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with allthe foregoíng statements:~~

~~1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal bluff.~~

~~2. Del Mar cítizens, resídents, and vísitors have enjoyed and exercised dírect access to the Del Mar beach between 4th St. and 11h St. since the early 1900's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sheriffs Office, is now issuing tickets for crossing the raílroad tracks, at $500 per person.~~

~~4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, including: a. Crossing as a train approaches b. Walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks~~

~~5 We ask that you and NCTD work vigorously and immediately to accomplish the following~~

~~a Cease issuing tickets when no train is near or in sight.~~

~~b Establish two or more designated sites to cross between 6th St and 11b St. afier "Stop, Look, and Listen"~~

~~c Work diligently toward removing the tracks from the bluff within a decade~~

~~Sincerely, The Undersigned~~

Name Signature Date Owner / Email/ Address Resident / Voter ? lCo LI-.. T-- uhkn-."., @^*'.1.ø' a/b-. l-4- xh^1,, r/5/ V' t / /tl L16l l¡<, þt ['- , , <,alt-l^¡¡i aí¡r.,lu. ( \áf,t {t )L t¿Bl ft uolu¿c,I v ù \JZ-

64 September 6, 2016 Item 04 520 t Petition August 2016 Requcrt fortl¡e Clty of flel trr b work úüt ilorü County TnnrJt DLûlst (IICTDI b ceaäe issuing ticke-ç for clu¡lng tlrc nllrc¡d trrckr ¡¡tulrcn 4tr Et ¡nd llh St ¡nd b designate two or more crossing sites to tcc¡¡¡ tlta rut ¡lde of tlre tnck¡.

~~To: CIU of tÞl Mar Manager, City Sffi, ancl City Council~~

~~By slgning thie ineùurnent lagræ and represent that I have read and unde¡stand and agrce with allthe forcgoing statcments:~~

~~l. The railroad hack b¡sects Del Mar alotrg 1.5 miles of sensitive coastr! blufr.~~

~~2. Del MarcitizÊns, ræ¡deñtB, and visitors have enioyed and exsrcis€d dircd aaoacs to üìe Del Mar boach bettnccn 4h St. and l1üt St. rsinca tre eady 19(þ's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego ShcliFs Ofi6, is now iseuing ticksb fur croeeing üe railrced tracks. at $500 psr per¡on~~

~~4. Enbrcsment couH bo basad on abusê of tho privibge b cross the backs, induding: e. Croesing as a üain epproechss t. Walking, standlng, siüng, or lying on the üacks~~

~~5. We ask that you and NCTD work vigorously and immediately to accomplish the following:~~

~~a. Cease issuing tickets when no train is near or in sight.~~

~~b. Establish two or more designated sites to cross between 6ü St. and 11th St. after "Stop, Look, and Listen".~~

~~c. Work diligently toward removing the tracks from the bluff within a decade.~~

~~Sincerely, The Unders¡gned~~

l{eme Slgneture Drb otmer, Em¡ll lAddre¡ RæHont / ñ /1 ll Vobr ? 462 I /¡.rrt l V..eSgU Y- ;c\^^^- \ þlz ì (¿-1t À o'rt{ 463 3w*{É Vr¡f¿ß(îr-L Sl¡,t tn. L K--tr.*t-f / >2ll i L( 464 t+x.>{FA U7 ^CU I<->L¡ tTlr'tt'ÇI.t ';. 1( -ry çlb >c >tqJe u t 465 I ,1 466 I > '?Âr/ "uf 467 tY.tttl Á'ì11 468 t !VÍ 469 ;thlh 470 '¿Uþ'&ç{P 471 eu#:;w t/ro K/b,a,^þ 62

65 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Petition August 2016 Rcquæt for tño Clty of Del t¡r b work wlttr ilorü County T¡rn¡-it Dirtict (NCTDI to coase iaauing tickets for croc¡ing the rrlfiu¡d t¡eclc botu¡¡n 4rn 3t ¡nd lle St ¡nd b deaignate two or moro crocaing ¡ibc to ¡ccoc¡üo wËtdde of tñs tr¡ckr,

~~To: City of IÞl Mar Manager, City Statr, and City Council~~

~~By sþning this instrument, I agree and represent that I have read and understand and agree with all ttp bregdng statements:~~

~~1. The railroad tad( bisects Del Mar along 1.5 miles of sensitive coastal blt¡fr.~~

~~2. Del Mar citizens, reeidents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercired direct access to the Del Mar beach ætween 4th St. and I l$' St. since the early 1900's.~~

~~3. NCTD, through the San Diego Sherifrs O'ffice, is now issuing t¡ckeüs br crossing the railroad tracJ~~

~~1. Enbrcement couH be based on abuse of the privilege to crosa the üacks, including: a. Crossing as a fain approadres b. Walking, standing, siting, or lying on tlre tracks~~

~~5. We ask that you and NCTD work vigorously and immediately to accomplish the following:~~

~~a. Cease issuing tickets when no train is near or in sight.~~

~~b. Establish two or more designated sites to cross between 6th St. and 11th St. after "Stop, Look, and Listen".~~

the tracks ftom the brurr within a decade. a€ ¡,'¡ ätrË.ä'äovins-S +;ffi:*.n*^' ãL }ayaf no bcl ilaf, N¡me Signetuto Dab Em¡llrtb Rooidontl ? Ftt 472 Ur(fæet, I t nn l@z'fUül I ltöI4t /)Ç-Ø%lÞ% 473 474 'fWeUit ttt@r(l-'lndrl L tCO+,l I 9.-æ lle¡ (t 475 l\r\gçß llczcl€,.1 .Y A),¡flJnr4 '1/ lll t A/l )¿¿rÀfV tlll 14öl,N*t/l ' A* K.r{.""t-',¡s¿l¿^.1.fô.-,'1..â YI fa$,¿^#\f6h 476 ft , '/ ''/

~~66 September 6, 2016 Item 04 4 Peti lton S l'AnAlvrcS Frorvt 5"b Uí^iyr.) dal þ10.r l'c srdcrrls~~

~~ü*/cnrail €¡tS/t4tufe dal¿ Vøþ'J~~

~~or, (¿þao fraenl.rlr ,Pbà ',) L#*tl t/zlt¿ l¿s / oruCL* Tu^,, ^11 C" l+*¡^r,-ç.( t/t( Gg ^- : l. ,u,., 6 þ Y"¡ a7s CL.lo¡¡ $.-p,t- 4so /wrttk /t lurttL/- t rta s/^a/ s P~~

~~64 ¡~~

~~67 September 6, 2016 Item 04 change.org~~

~~Recipient dn [email protected], [email protected], acorti@delmar'ca.uS, [email protected], dworden@delmar,ca.us, Tony Krantz, and Matthew Tucker~~

~~I etter Gr,:etings,~~

~~or, crossing the railroad tracks in Del Mar to access the beach:~~

(NCTD) Request for the City of Del Mar to work with North County Transit District to cease issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks between 4th St and 11th St tracks' and to designate two or more crossing sites to access the west side of the

~~'1,5 1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along miles of sensitive coastal bluff.~~

~~2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised direct 1900's' âcrless to the Del Mar beach between 4th St. and 11th St. since the early~~

~~3. NCTD, through the san Diego sheriff's office, is now issuing tickets for per person' crr,ssing the railroad tracks, with fines and fees up to $500~~

~~4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the privilege to cross the tracks, inc luding: Nc crossing as a train aPProaches Nc walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks~~

the 5. we ask that you and NOTD work vigorously and immediately to accomplish following: a. cease issuing tickets when no train is near or in sight. b. Establish two or more designated sites to cross between 6tf'St. and 11th St. after "stop, Look, and Listen"' c. work diligently toward removing the tracks from the bluff witnin a decade.

~~68 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Comments~~

~~Name Lc oation Date Comment the beaches, Del Mar is nothing This is our Ulla Rang Del Mar, CA 201 6-08-21 Without access to the bluffs and backyard, these areas are our lives!~~

~~public and rail can't figure out a harmonious way to J Michael Smallwood Ca.rlsbad' CA 201 6-08-21 There's no reason access co-exist on our coastal corridor.~~

property - 1 49 & 151 6th Street' Del Mar Gwynn Thomas Thomas San Diego, CA 201 6-08-2 1 I own in Del Mar the bluff between 15th and 4th streets' Anne Checkoway Dr.l Mar, CA 201 6-08-21 I want accoss to the trail along for everyone. Jane lsaacson Del Mar, CA 201 6-08-21 Beach access needs to be secured access to the beaches and bluffs. Stephanie Gaasterland Hc,boken, NJ 20 1 6-08-21 I fully support

~~where I go to suf, run and enjoy this quiet section of Del Kat Hammond Bc xford, MA 201 6-08-21 This is my backyard, Mar.~~

~~who responsibly cross the railroad tracks to get to the Julia Laymon De I Mar, CA 201 6-08-21 Ticketing lndividuals beach goes against long held California state objectives of coastal public access.~~

justification the community has earned "public prescriptive Terry Gaasterland De,i Mar, CA 201 6-08-21 Here is the - easement" across the tracks through decades of use: http://www coastal ca.gov/access/pr-access-facts pdf

~~frequently. There is plenty of room for both walkers and the Elizabeth Shopes De I Mar, CA 20 1 6-08-21 I walk this trail tra¡n, This is our coast, we should be able to access it~~

of us moved here because of access to walking on bluff' Nikki Winston Del Mar, CA 201 6-08-21 I agree. Many is important to evefyone in san Diego and we need to find a solution Stephen Applebaum Novato, CA 201 6-08-21 This issue that meets everyone's needs - access, safety, and community' and the beautiful views and trails all around us. My husband and Wendy Luiz Del Mar, CA 201 6-08-2 1 I love Del Mar life lt I moved from the east coast here because we enjoy the quite beach style. would be such a shame to not have access to the bluff and beach that we have grown to love so much.

to the beach needs to come before train easements. Amtrack Ty Stewart Solana Beach, CA 201 6-08-21 Public access needs to accommodate safe crossings. Their current tactics are giving them a serious black eye, when it comes to public relations and their willingnoss to work with the communitY.

~~grew 11th St. and have respons¡bly crossed the tracks for 40 years' Adam Peck Sa r Diego, CA 201 6-08-21 I up on The AT&SF should have no right to block access to the beach'~~

should be for the enioyment for everyone in our community Stuart F¡sh De'Mar, CA 2016-08-21 The bluffs bluffs are two of the most desirable attributes the city of Del Betsy Milich De l\4ar, CA 201 6-08-21 The beach and Mar has to otfer. Altempts to "wall them off" with fencing, exorbitant financial punishment, or any other action will countered with strategies to continue the plan-- access that we have enjoyed for decades. We CAN and WILL create a both short,term and long+ange-- that will benefit residents, visitofs, and the railway system. Let's get started immed¡ately.

Del Mar resident and curront close neighbor I have responsibly Karen Almquist San Diego, CA 2016-08-21 As a former crossed the tracks near gth street for 20 years. Please work to ensure access for residents and visitors alike

69 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Name Locatlon Date Comment and Roelof Grootenhuis Berkeley, CA 201 6-08-21 Residents and visitors should not be slapped with misdemeanors $500 fines for engaging in a perfectly safe (with appropriate caution) act of crossing the tracks to head to the Beach, This is inherently a coastal access issue due to the lack of legal beach access points along the stretch Írom Toney Pines to South Del Mar.

~~the bluffs. there Wes Chester Si;n Diego, CA 201 6-08-21 Coastal Access is a right, and trains are still relatively rare on are many places where sight lines are long and safe crossing is possible~~

these bluffs for the past 40 years. We must act Fred James Dr.l Mar, CA 201 6-08'2 1 My family and I have walked quickly to ¡nsure that the right for people to continue to walk along ihe bluffs is not taken away by the North Couniy Transit District who bought the right of way for the railroad tracks within the last year or so from the railroad company' The costal commission should be involved with this as this is an attempt to deny beach access routs that have been used for years. We need the city of Del Mar's help to stop this injustice,

~~and protecting the beauty in the past' Cathey Carter De I lVlar, CA 201 6-08-21 I have safely walked this area enjoying Please allow access.~~

geez..... people get to the damn beachl Laura Jackson [/r,r€no Valley, CA 201 6-08-21 because, don't be silly. Let that a soluiion be found. Access to the sue goodell De,l Mar, CA 2016-08-22 I am signing this because it is vital beach and the cliff has been in existence since the early 1900's DesignaÌing a few crossing places wiih signs and reminders to look and listen is the right thing to do.

Alexandra Mclntosh C¿.rlsbad, CA 2016-08-22 It is necessary precious to all citizens in all locations. Douglas E Gaasterland Cr lonial Beach, VA 2016-08-22 Access to the shore is and Friends of Eleanor Park need closer access than 1Sth street' Kelly Welch Dt I Mar, CA 2016-08-22 I love to walk on the bluff and the NCTD's action of ticketing people accessing Drew Cady De l lVïar, CA 2016-08-22 I am deeply concern€d with the beach from my Neighborhood' This is clearly a political gesture and has nothing to do with track safety. Time to take action and stop this baning of access.

~~and overly cautious. To defive the Bill Miller Del Mar, CA 2016-08-22 I think the new restrictions are ill advised residents and guest access to the beach is denying us oT our rights'~~

~~Staci Dixon Del lvlar, CA 2016-08-22 We love to surf bottom of 11th..... We've been crossing lracks since 1964 ' figure it out but DON'T TICKET ust!il!~~

~~its so easy to solve problems withoul john b rnusa Kì,kland, WA 2Q16-08-22 build two fool bridges or tunnels. creating animosity and tension.~~

~~and the trains need to be moved away from Michael St John De I Mar, CA 2016-08-22 This should be public r¡ght of way the cliffs to the center of the transportation corridor.~~

the beach for over 30 years. The notion Matt Harrigan De I Mar, CA 2016-08-22 I've been crossing the tracks to access thât I can receive a ticket for doing so now is completely absurd. Either rebuild the piers that were in the low numbered streets and make safe walking passages to the cliffs and beach access, or get out of the way

years and I think the locals should have Astrid Doerner Dc'i Mar, CA 2016-08-22 I walked the bluffs for the last 10 responsible access to this local natural nature trails. As far as I observed everyone us¡ng the trail was respective of the tfa¡ns and made sure everyone is safe. lt should be rather a nature reserve than a pure train track.

70 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Name Locatlon Dale Comment for running on the blutfs. I didn't even cross the vacks. I Mary Dredge Del Mar, CA 2016-08-22 I received a citation thought ihe signage misleading. I think it's ludicrous to suddenly enforce unclear rules when they haven,t been enforced for decades. lssue warnings first and get rid o1 an outdated trespass rule and/or the trains on this sensitive bluff

want to see innocent people get fined just bocause our city says Rufina Louthan San Diego, CA 2016-08-22 I don't something is not okay.... we live in a free country and should be free to walk to the beach... on the cliffs, across the railroad tracks, etc.... our city should not dictate our activities. Thank you for starting this petition! resource I the tracks as lwould any street and believe this community Charlotte Hanning Del Mar, CA 2016-08-22 cross should be taken away from the people.

need access to the beach and ticketìng people for crossing the tfain tracks Steven Skinner Del Mar, CA 2016-08-22 we for denies locals and visitors that access. I have been crossing those tracks years and have never had any type of safety concern' Most people feel this is just an attempt by the city of Del Mar to raise revenue' Please stop the ticketingl

This is ridiculousl The beach is there to be enjoyed and it's a lot less enioyable Lindsey Skinner Sa'n Diego, CA 2016-QB-22 a stop to itl after receiving a whopping $500 ticket for getting there. so sillyl Put

~~Weliveinoneofthemostbeautifulplacesonearth.Weshouldhavesafeand Christanne CofleY Del Mar, CA 2016-08-22 easy access to our Public beaches.~~

grew up in del mar and still regularly access the beach this way when visiting Lindsey Skinner San Diego, CA 2016-08-22 I of the beach my parents. lt would be a shame to deny residents this, as much can'tbeaccessedanyotherway.Thiswouldalsocausehugeovercrowdingat the beach at 1sth and north

I have a friend lìving there. Chrisiine Cissig Molndal, Sweden 2016-08-22 2016-08-22 Access to the beach is our right frank altobello Del Mar, CA Beencrossingsafelyfor3Syrstosurfandenjoytheocean.Absurdioobstruct Gregg Alzate Se n Diego, CA 2016-08-22 that right

There are no othel close public accessible methods of crossing David Stangland San Diego, CA 2016-08-22 to my That stretch of beach and walking along the blulfs has been integral Skinner De.l Mar, CA 2016-08-22 Adam by development as a human. I refuse to yet again feel bashed and lìmited at the police or any group/ind¡vidual that lives to intimidate and make money expense of others. dont know Because stop taking all of my money if gov is soooooo stupid and andrey Fe;ndale' WA 2016-08-22 muzychenko people they how to make money without taking that money from the¡r own should never be in charge!ll!l!!!!!!

l'd like to see this extended to Carlsbad too. Arvind Knudsen San Diego, CA 2016-08-22 Thereneedstobeaccesstoihepubl¡cbeachbetween4thandlSthstreetsso Faye Detsky-Weil Del Mar, CA 2016-08-22 people do not have to go all ihe way to 1 sth Stre€t to access the beach' Creating access would solve many problems'

i got a ticket for walking on the bluff Eileen Southerton Deil Mar, CA 2016-08-22 the As an avid surfor, access to certain breaks like 11th st. require crossing Dawn NguYen San Diego, CA 201 6-08-23 railroad tracks.

71 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Name Locatlon Date Comment police the NCTD need to stop squeez¡ng money out of innocent Chase Jennings orlando, FL 201 6-08-23 The and people ($30k in a week to be exact??)

Del Mar and its bluffs/beach are the most heavenly sublime aspects of my life putting great that l,ve ever had the opportunity to experience. I for one will be a deal of fight to help keep it this way. Why would anyone want to ruin this?

~~the pet¡tion that is attempting to provide access to the bluff and ocean Anne Weickgenant DEL MAR, CA 201 6-08-23 I support at all times.~~

more places to walk in nature, not less Maria E Crabb San Diego, CA 201 6-08-23 we need should be a better, safe, way to walk/ride thesê trails. Please let the city Jeff Rucker DHL MAR, CA 201 6-08-23 There Council know, I don't think fines are a longlerm solution'

~~frequent visitor to Del Mar and have crossed these tracks Frank Sargent C¡;rlisle, MA 201 6-08-23 Am a~~

Stuart Fish Dr:l Mar, CA 2016-08-24 ThemainreasonlmovedtoDelMarwastoenjoythebeachesandthebluffs' Havingameetingbetweenallpartiesinvolvedtoarfiveatamutualsolution should be a priority. ln the interim, here should be no tickets issued

the SD sherif ! I am signing because I am a victim of this ridiculous action by Judy Muller-Cohn Dr I Mar, CA 2016-08-24 RESIDENTS DESERVE BETTER FROM ELECTED OFFICIALS. Daniel Vinograd San Diego, CA 2016-08-24 Thebeachaccessandbluffshouldbemadesafeandaccessibletoits just to enloy residents. on the meantime punitive measures for those who want a walk or jog in their neighborhood should be immediately stopp€d clear lndiscriminate ticketing for crossing the tracks protects no one and is a Roger Cole Dr lMar, CA 2016-08-24 money grab. Outlawing any crossing of the trâcks denies reasonable beach access. for Someone got a ticket for the dumbest reason - cops cannot lhink Anais Muller-Cohn Dol Mar, CA 2Q16-08-24 themselves :i makes living This is completely ridiculous ordinance that detracts from what David Stern Del Mar, CA 2016-08-24 here special.

lsupportthispetitionlWeliverightolf4thandloveiowalkourdogandbabyin Jennifer Greune Del Mar, CA 2016-08-24 this area and would love to have legal access in this area' Del Mar South l've grown up and l¡ved in Del Mar and have safely enjoyed the Brant Lee Sen Diego, CA 2016-08-24 BeachBluffsandTrails.Needtoprotectandpresefveth¡sbeautifultfeasure. ButthatdoesnotmeanimplementingWhatlconsidertoberidiculouslaws.

I have walked and run that area for 23 years Marilyn Carpenter Dr I Mar, CA 2016-08-24 access to the I have been a resident of Del Mar for 33 years and have enioyed udo wahn de: mar, CA 201 6-08-25 to the beaches and bluffs. To be denied access to the beach and blufis due poor choices of a few is unreasonable and unacceptable Stop the harassment and citations! be Many of Del lVlar's most awe-inspiring and spectacular vistas can only Susan Miller Dr.i Mar, CA 201 6-08-25 them enjoyed by walking or taking a jog along the blufts. Please don,t take awayl

~~access should be accessible for all citizens, lr¡love the rails to the l-5 Richard Risner C¿rrdiff, CA 201 6-08-25 coastal transportation corridor. That should solve the problem'~~

would like to have 2-3 ways to cross the tracks in Del Mar betsy schulz Del Mar, CA 201 6-08-25 it's value Beach access is incredibly ¡mportant to our community, and Linda Rock Del Mar, CA 201 6-08-26 oulweighsthenegligiblerisk.Pleaseallowustocrossthetrackexercis¡ngcare and cautionl

72 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Name Location Date Comment right up until the mid 9O's and surf there nearly daily lt's a Chrìs Willert Germany 20 1 6-08-26 I've lived there shame the NCTD all at once feels ¡ts necessary to enforce a non-trespessing rules.

our familY there Elouisa Moghavem Del Mar, CA 20 1 6-08-26 We love takìng is ineffective, As soon as the ticketing stops, within minutes, all T Todd Elvins St,lana Beach, CA 2016-08-27 The ticket¡ng the track crossers are crossing again, including me Find a betler safety solution, if safety is reaìly the issue

for the taxpayers is more important than the needs of caltrans Douglas Nitz San Diego, CA 201 6-08-28 access us are Del Mar 1 1 th St in 1964 and still do today lVlany of Allen Drew Pcway, CA 201 6-08-28 I started surfing seniors and wish to continue surfing this locat¡on without being hassled by police

~~use the beach in front of my house where there is an inconvenìent set Christian Ross Del ltlar, CA 201 6-08-28 I tike to of raìlroad tracks that apparently are illegal to crossl!! Absurd!!!~~

~~I am a Del mar resident Leila Castaneda Dr.l Mar, CA 201 6-08-28~~

~~Nancy Bsharah Er cinitas, CA 20 1 6-08-28 llovetosurfllthstandl'mabiggirlwhoknowstolookfortrainsbeforel cross the tracks.~~

Meredith Roso Dr I Mar, CA 201 6-08-28 ltisnotrealistictoexpectpeoplewholiveinsouthernDeìMaftoWalkallthe waking way to 15th St to cross the RR tracks. Also,l enjoy riding my bike and my dog along the bluffs. been I'm signing because I lived in N. County and this access has always M¡chael Schwartz Lc s Angeles, CA 201 6-08-28 usefulandimportant.Don,tenforcethislUd¡crouSposìtion.Nottickets!! years we have wife, famity, and I have walked along these cliffs for the 20 Rushton Backer Dr I Mar, CA 201 6-08-28 My our main lived here. My wife and I are now empty-nesters and this had been formofexercisinganddecompressingaftercominghomefronrstressfu|jobs. of trains No we are avo¡ding this area, fearing a ticket We were aìways alare runs on this etc., as were all the other people we would see enjoying walks or Iormer path. We have never witnessed a close-call with a traln' I used to see this path Count Commissioner Pam Sìater-Price and her husband walking got ticketed frequently. We first heard about the tickets from neighbors who be This makes little sense. Law enforcement is spread thin and should that I focusing on break-ins, as was noted in a recent town hall meeting away one attended. Also, no one using this path is a criminal This has taking problems with her fool of the great features of living in this area. My wife has andthisWasadoablewalkforher'WehavelostthisValuedsourceof on killing exercise and stress relief. The alternatives are nol. Anyone intend making themselves on the tracks will continue to do so lf this is a money path goes from the issue, find another soufce. lt is bìzarre. There is now a that areanorthofCarmelVa||eyRd,downthethebeach'ltcrossesthetracksat lf thls the overpass. Why have a path ìf this is now illegal People can read isabouttheratlroadortrans¡tauthorityWantingtoeliminateliabi|ity,thena or warining to cross at your own risk should be sufficient Why take âway great' criminalize what has gone on for years and makes th¡s area

We enioy surfing on walking over there Laura Connell S¿'n Diego, CA 201 6-08-29 Ct for many I have surfed here since 197 1 and owned a home on Stratford Sinclair S<.lana Beach, CA 201 6-08-29 Gordon guys that years before moving to Solana Beach! I'm 61 and we have a crew of to live and surf here w¡thout causing problems with the trains and want we've done continue without being hassled or fined for enjoying something sincewewereyoungIWedon'tracetrainsandwedon'tlayonthetracksWe Surf!HaveaIitt|ediscretionastowhogetsaticketthefoolwalkingdownthe go surfingl tracks or the guy or girl who tn iess than 2 seconds crossed to

~~73 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Name Location Date Comment~~

Cliff Kinney Del Mar, CA 201 6-08-29 I have been walking on the bluffs sense I moved here in 1976. I want to keep this freedom of choice. NCTD needs to take a closer look at what they are doing. This movement is small but it is growing daily We need to demand that the trâcks be moved from the bluffs.

~~please Dawn Van Dyke Del Mar, CA 201 6-08-29 I agree- I walk there all ihe time. Give us a recognized place to cross, don't take the beauty away from those of us who partake in our community asset!~~

Tara Connell San Diego, CA 201 6-08-29 Locals have enjoyed access to the beach this way for years and are causing no harm, The sheriffs department should use their resources in a much more productive way. ln a t¡me where sentiments towards officers has not been the greatest, this is not helping your public image.

~~I this petition should be Lori Reineck De,l Mar, CA 20 1 6-08-29 I enjoy the bluffs, the beach, and the surf. think brought to the Calilornia Coastal Commission.~~

to make this a Kelly Simmons Barcelona, Spain 201 6-08-29 I use this bluff all the time and there needs to be changes reasonable law. give tickets for Jordyn Garfein San Diego, CA 201 6-08-29 There's no other way to get down to the beach! lt's unfair to out something people have been doing ritually for years

~~it would completely destroy Marco Schwab Del Mar, CA 201 6-08-29 I have always loved walking along side the tracks, Del Mar~~

~~in be ticketed. Others should not unless Eric Pinczower La Jolla, CA 20 1 6-08-29 poople crossing with earbuds should behaving recklessly (running in front of train)~~

in cardiff. All coastal Richard Risner Cirrdiff, CA 201 6-08-29 wo are dealing with the same issues in the rail corridor communilies cit¡zens should un¡te to help support each others beach communities. Please feel free to reach out to www.norailtrail'com public Josh LaSalle Dr lMar, CA 201 6-08-29 Private property is restricting beach access. gth Adam Cheny Del Mar, CA 201 6-08-29 I like to surf a1 Street..

Rebecca Oxner Evereti, WA 201 6-08-29 We love the bluff walk when we visitl legal and safe direcl access to beach while respecting safety Gail Pinczower Del Mar, CA 20 1 6-08-29 Wish to maintain along tracks and condition of cliffsihabitat

Jeffrey Dysart D¡,:l lVlar, CA 201 6-08-30 need convenient beach/ surf access we have done for over 20 years with Mary Cherry Dol Mar, CA 201 6-08-30 I am signing because this ¡s something caution and respect for the natural environment.

lagoon/fairgrounds where the Melissa Mikulak S/,n Diego, CA 201 6-08-30 My family regularly crosses the tracks near the trail runs from the freeway to the boach We now have to ride along Jimmy Durante Blvd next to cars moving at 60mph to gain access to Coast Hwy Not happy about the ticketing.

appropriate inland spot along the Steve Reiss Lcs Angeles, CA 201 6-08-30 Its time they moved the train tracks to a more i5 corr¡dor. We have been going to the beach this way since we were young and its only dangerous if you are not paying attention. But c'mon, move the tracks. The beach is way more important than lhe view from the train - and then it will be safe to cross.

~~to us. Let us Steven Reich Del Mar, CA 201 6-08-30 While the railroad may belong to a corporation, the views belong cross unmolested.~~

~~the beach via the rail Celia Pinczower Senta Monica, CA 201 6-08-31 I have a vacation home in san Diego and enjoy access to road tracks. I have always been careful when crossing'~~

74 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Name Locatlon Date Comment kevin bateman manhattan beach, CA 201 6-08'3 1 lliveddowninDelMarduringcollegeandafterforTyears,andamconcerned about restrictions on access years accessing the beach and bluffs and have done so for the last 20+ Bruno Wolfenzon San Diego, CA 201 6-08-31 I enioy for exerclse including running along the bluffs and surfing

The public deserves access in that lovely area for surfing and beach-going' Simon Menkes Atlanta, GA 201 6-08-31 bluff (and have been I received a citation Tor riding mountain bike along top of James Spawton Carlsbad, CA 201 6-08-31 parallel them doing so for 15 years). I nevor actually cross the tracks' only - probably most from Powerhouse Park to Torrey Pines State Beach the âwesome single track trails in the county!! Now off-limits? or near the The polico need to stop issuing tickets to anyone/everyone crossing Greg Garcia San Diego, CA 201 6-09-01 Toney Pines??) tracks....there is no other place to $oss (other than l Sth st' Or few designated and we've been doing it safely now for 30+ years' Maybe a they're in a heavily areas to cross?? Maybe the trains can SLOW DOWN since populated area?? railroad allow them' lnsane reason to fine people. lf people want to cross the Adela Rodgers S<,lana Beach, CA 201 6-09-01 It's they're giving right to cross' Ridiculous' traln tracks! 201 6-09-01 We should be able to lawfully cross the Karen Johnson Dr lMar, CA making it illegal to climb the cliffs 6-09-02 This is almost like the National Park service Mike Sofen Dr I Mar, CA 201 in Yosemitê...because someone got hurt l mean' BEALLY?

.'Please ..You try a sign like, be HoW about this - instead of, will be fined $500'., look UP"' mindful of passing trains", or even, "lf you hear a horn' l can safely look responsible adult who just wants access to the beach San Diego, CA 201 6-09-02 I am a Gary Provenzano waist police time writlng both ways and cross the tracks' lt is ridiculous to iickets for this. mission' Del rights aro being denied by a few people on a misguided Del Mar, CA 201 6-09-03 Historical Jennifer Lonbom half of the town by Mar Clty Council members need to represent the southern residents' This should providing close, safe and free beach access to southern in the southern end of include legal rail crossings and stairways to the beach the town.

~~lm a surfer Ben Slade Ai,burn, CA 2016-09-04~~

~~75 September 6, 2016 Item 04 change.org~~

~~Recipient: [email protected], [email protected]'us, acorti @delmar'ca'us, Tucker tsi¡[email protected], dworden@delmar'ca.us, Tony Krantz, and Matthew l-etter Greetings,~~

~~or, crossing the railroad tracks in Del Mar to access the beach:~~

Transit District (NCTD) Re,quest for the city of Del Mar to work with North county 4th st and 11th st to oease issuing tickets for crossing the railroad tracks between side of the tracks' and to designate two or more crCIssing sites to access the west

~~coastal bluff' 1. The railroad track bisects Del Mar along 1,5 miles of sensitive~~

~~direct 2. Del Mar citizens, residents, and visitors have enjoyed and exercised 11th since the early 1900's' acJless to the Del Mar beach between 4th st. and st'~~

~~issuing tickets for 3. NCTD, through the san Diego sheriff's office, is now per person' crrrssing the railroad tracks, with fines and fees up to $500~~

~~privilege to cross the tracks, 4. Enforcement could be based on abuse of the inc luding: Nc crossing as a train aPProaches Nc,walking, standing, sitting, or lying on the tracks~~

to accomplish the 5. we ask that you and NCTD work vigorously and immediately foliowing: a'Ceaseissuingticketswhennotrainisnearorinsight. b. Establish two or more designated sites to cross between 6th St. and 11th St. after "stop, Look, and Listen"' c'Workdiligentlytowardremovingthetracksfromthebluff within a decade.

~~76 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Signatu res~~

Date Name Location 2016-08-20 Terry Gaasterland Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Frank Stonebanks Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Ulla Rang Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Stephen Haynes San Diego, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Charles Cantor Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Linda Castile Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-21 ellina pevzner La Jolla, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Scott Schwartz San Diego, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Richard Gleaves San Diego, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Danette Ruggiero Del Mar, CA, United States 2016'08-21 susan Taylor Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-CI8-21 mc Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-21 J Michael Smallwootl Carlsbad, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Thomas GwYnn San Diego, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Ben Norton Del Mar, CA, United States States 2016-08-21 Brendan Castile Encinitas, CA, United 2016-08-21 Anne CheckowaY Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Ernie Hartt Cardiff, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Jane lsaacson Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Stephanie Gaasterland Hoboken, NJ, United States States 2016-08-21 Kat Hammond San Diego, CA, United 2016-A8-21 Brad Allison Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Don Ellis Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-A8-21 Julie Laynton Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Cecilia Monteiro Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Gloria Hernandez Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Morgan Morgan Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Nathaniel Willert Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Kelly Kass Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Kristi Norton San Diego, CA, United States

77 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Date Name Location 2016-08-21 Paul Steitz Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-CI8-21 Viktoriya DubrovskaYa San Diego, CA, United States States 2016-08-21 Matt bradY Carlsbad, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Elizabeth ShoPes Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Nikki Winston Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Stephen APPlebaum Del Mar, CA, United 2016-08-21 Wendy Luiz Del Mar, CA, United States United States 2016-A8-21 Ty Stewart Solana Beach, CA, States 2016-08-21 Adam Peck San Diego, CA, United States 20'16-08-21 Deanna Arredondo Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Stuart Fish Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Bryony Kinnear Encinitas, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Sarah Lifton Encinitas, CA, United United States 2016-08-21 Brian Cruz Del Mar, CA, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Clay Shinn San Diego, United States 2ü6-A8-21 John Carroll Hoboken, NJ, United States 2016-08-21 Benjamin Leach Del Mar, CA, States 2016-08-21 Rebecca Deller Del Mar, CA, United CA, United States 2016-08-21 John Erick Del Mar, AZ, United States 2016-08-21 Danielle Klise Glendale, United States 2016-08-21 Rachel Snigaroff Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Penny and Bill Barron Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Madeline Snigaroff Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Betsy Milich Del Mar, CA, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Karen Almquist San Diego, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Scott Morris Solana Beach, United States 2016-08-21 Ben SiddowaY Del Mar, CA, States 2016-08-21 Michael McManus Del Mar, CA, United United States 2016-08-21 Elizabeth KYle Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Roelof Grootenhuis Del Mar, CA, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Wes Chester San Diego, United States 2016-08-21 Fleid Westburg Del Mar, CA,

78 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Date Name Location 2016-08-21 Lynn Cher Ho Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Stephanie de los Rios Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Elizabeth Reed Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Christine Springer Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Fred James Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Cathey Carter Del Mar, CA, United States States 2016-08-21 Laura Jackson Moreno ValleY, CA, United 2CI16-08-21 Holly Anderson Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Brian Carter Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-21 Elaine Jensvold Del Mar, CA, United States States 2016-08-22 sue goodell Del Mar, CA, United 2016-A8-22 Alexandra Mclntosh Carlsbad, CA, United States States 2016-08-22 Douglas E Gaasterl¿,tnd Colonial Beach, VA, United States 2ü6-A8-22 Kelly Welch Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Barbara Stanculescu Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Ken Ruggiero Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Lori Valickas Encinitas, CA, United States 2ü6-A8-22 Kerri Kato Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Sandra Uslander La Jolla, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Drew CadY Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Margar Miller Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Bill Miller Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Evan Escalle Encinitas, CA, United States 2ü6-AB-22 Gary Benitt Del Mar, CA, United 2016-08-22 Staci Dixon Del Mar, CA, United States States 2016-08-22 john b musa Kirkland, WA, United States 2A16-08-22 Michael St John Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Matt Harrigan Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Jason HalseY Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Graham DavenPort Carpinteria, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Beth DavenPort Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Meaghan Conklin Del Mar, CA, United

79 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Date Name Location 2ü6-A8-22 Astrid Doerner Del Mar, CA, United States 2ü6-A8-22 Mary Dredge Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Michael Luther Solana Beach, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Rufina Louthan San Diego, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Athan RaPtis San Diego, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Alice Klar Bristol, ENG, United Kingdom 2016-08-22 Charlotte Hanning Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-22 John F, Friedman Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Ben Yu Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Logan Zinser Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Margo Skinner Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Steven Skinner Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-22 David Weinbaum Del Mar, CA, United States 2ü6-A8-22 Margaret PoPe Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Christanne CoffeY Del Mar, CA, United States States 2U6-A8-22 Lindsey Skinner San Diego, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Karey Garcia Del Mar, CA, United United States 2ü6-A8-22 Robert Linn San Diego, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Robert Ortiz San Francisco, CA, 2016-08-22 Christine Cissig Mölndal, Sweden States 2016-08-22 frank altobello Del Mar, CA, United United States 2016-08-22 Gregg Alzate San Diego, CA, 2016-A8-22 Alison HuntleY Del Mar, CA, United States States 2016-08-22 David Stangland Del Mar, CA, United 2U6-A8-22 David Pinnegar Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Adam Skinner Del Mar, CA, United States States 2016-08-22 Sylvia Bahr Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Michael Casler Del Mar, CA, United States 2ü6-A8-22 BOB SHOPES Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-22 andrey muzYchenko Ferndale, WA, United 2016-08-22 Robert Brodt Del Mar, CA, United States States 2016-08-22 John Hersh Encinitas, CA, United

80 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Name Location Date Arvind Knudsen San Diego, CA, United States 2ü6-A8-22 EA Stewart Del Mar, CA, United States 2U6-A8-22 2016-08-22 Michael Filippone Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Faye Detsky-Weil Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Eddy Sapiro San Francisco, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Rene Lewicki Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Jeff Southerton Del Mar, CA, United States 2U6-A8-22 PaulAndersson Gothenburg, Sweden 2016-08-22 Barb Roland Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Eileen Southerton Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-22 David Parkes Del Mar, CA, United States 2U6-A8-22 Sophie Andre Noblesville, lN, United States 2016-08-22 Melinda Johnson Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Tanya Young Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-22 Rachel Warren Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-23 Lena [-iu Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-23 Charlie Pope Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-23 Terri Haber Manchester, MD, United States 2016-08-23 Dawn Nguyen San Diego, CA, United States 2016-08-23 Darren K Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-23 Heidi EmerY Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-23 Charlotte Sargent Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-23 paige jennings Orlando, FL, United States 2016-08-23 Charles DohertY San Diego, CA, United States 2016-08-23 Claude Organ Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-23 Kim Uslander Vista, CA, United States 2016-08-23 Anne Weickgenant DEL MAR, CA, United States 2016-08-23 Chungyeol Lee Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-23 Maria Elena Crabb San Diego, CA, United States 2016-08'23 Claire Jennings Orlando, FL, United States 2016-08-23 karen lare Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-23 Bleema Moss Del Mar, CA, United States

81 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Date Name Location 2016-08-23 Jeff Rucker DEL MAR, CA, United States 2016-08-23 Ryan Rosen Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-23 Scott Musgrave Solana Beach, CA, United States 2016-08-23 Carla LaPorte Del Mar, CA, United States States 2016-08-23 Frank Sargent Carlisle, MA, United 2016-08-24 Daniel Jensvold Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-24 Judy Muller-Cohn Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-CI8-24 Michael Riccio Del Mar, CA, United States States 2016-08-24 lan Smulowitz San Diego, CA, United States 2016-08-24 Paula Stabile Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-24 Daniel Vinograd Del Mar, CA, United States 2U6-A8-24 Roger Cole Del Mar, CA, United States 2A16-08-24 Stephanie Brown Del Mar, CA, United States 2ü6-A8-24 Erin Enright El Cajon, CA, United States 2016-08-24 Michelle Kurtis Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-A8-24 Timothy Kelso Del Mar, CA, United CA, United States 2016-08-24 David Meza Solana Beach, United States 2A16-08-24 Sophie Rozenzhak Encinitas, CA, States 2016-08-24 Jay Short Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-24 Carolyn Short Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-24 Anais Muller-Cohn Del Mar, CA, United United States 2016-08-24 David Stern Del Mar, CA, States 2016-08-24 Jennifer Greune Del Mar, CA, United United States 2016-08-24 Brenton Armstrong Del Mar, CA, 201õ-08-24 Vincent Peignot France States 2ü6-A8-24 Steve Liston Del Mar, CA, United States 2U6-A8-24 chantal muller'cohn Davis, CA, United States 2016-08-24 Brant Lee Del Mar, CA, United United States 2016-08-24 Jaimee Armstrong Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-24 Marilyn CarPenter Del Mar, CA, States 2016-08-25 Theresa DaileY Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-25 Mark Robillard Del Mar, CA, United

82 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Name Location Date Chris Swanner Cardiff, CA, United States 2016-08-25 2016-08-25 udo wahn Del Mar, CA, United States Susan Miller Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-25 Amy Lea Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-25 Katie Altobello San Diego, CA, United States 2016-08-25 Richard Risner Cardiff, CA, United States 2016'08-25 2016-08-25 Shannon Brubaker San Diego, CA, United States 2016-08-25 Olivier Fuxet France 2016-08-25 Carrie Hawes Alpine, CA, United States 2016-08-25 Silbert Walter Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-25 Netze Aguilar San Diego, CA, United States 2016-CI8-25 betsy schulz Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-25 Dominic Zuccarini Encinitas, CA, United States 2016-08-25 Karen Keller Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-25 Kay Sickafoose Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-25 Leda Swegles San Diego, CA, United States 2016-08-25 Jeff Kelley Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-25 Alex von Taube Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-25 Justin SimPson Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-25 christine smith carlsbad, CA, United States 2016-08-26 Linda Rock Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-26 Anthony Edwards Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-26 Phoebe von Reis Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-26 Megan Mclaughlin Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-26 Ann Willert Germany 2016-08-26 Chris Willert Germany 2016-08-26 Juli Risner Encinitas, CA, United States 2016-08-26 Elouisa Moghavem Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-26 Peter Ackley Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-26 Têrry Klitzner Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-26 Cathy Rogowski Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-27 Kurt Snider Solana Beach, CA, United States

83 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Date Name Location 2016-08-27 Rory Bennett Del Mar, CA, United States 2CI16-08-27 Marc Sands Del Mar, CA, United States States 2016-08-27 Anita Hermann Solana Beach, CA, United 2016-08-27 Jim l'lindman Del Mar, CA, United States States 2016-08-27 Kevin Sagara San Diego, CA, United States 2U6-A8-27 T Todd Elvins Solana Beach, CA, United 2016-08-28 Charles Virgilio San Diego, CA, United States States 2016-08-28 douglas nitz San Diego, CA, United States 2016-08-28 James SPalenka San Diego, CA, United United States 2016-08-28 Leo Connell San Diego, CA, United States 2016-08-28 Marvin de la Vega Chula Vista, CA, States 2016-08-28 Marcelo Echeverria Encinitas, CA, United States 2016-08-28 Allen Drew Poway, CA, United States 2016-08-28 necia snow Louisville, CO, United 2016-08-28 ET San Diego, CA, United States United States 2016-08-28 Christian Ross Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-28 Leila Castaneda Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-28 Jon JesseY Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-28 Kelly K-StoP Rumson, NJ, United States 2016-08-28 Nancy Bsharah Encinitas, CA, States 2016-08-28 Meredith Rose Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-28 Marianne Hindman Del Mar, CA, United CA, United States 2016-08-28 Tom Leugers San Francisco, United States 2016-08-28 Joseph Scatena San Diego, CA, 2016-08-28 gregory glassman Del Mar, CA, United States States 2016-08-28 Dom Dias San Diego, CA, United United States 2016-08-28 Mile Quick Del Mar, CA, States 2016-08-28 Giles Bateman Del Mar, CA, United United States 2016-08-28 Michael Schwartz Los Angeles, CA, States 2016-08-28 Suzanne Sutton Del Mar, CA, United United States 2016-08-28 Robert Howard San Diego, CA, States 2016-08-28 Marc PhilliPs Del Mar, CA, United

84 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Date Name Location 2016-08-28 Karla Deerinck Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-28 Mary Maturo San Diego, CA, United States 2016-08-28 Rushton Backer Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-28 Mike Mckenna Cardiff, CA, United States 2016-08-29 Laura Connell San Diego, CA, United States 2016-08-29 Di letta Marti rano Tec.ieschi Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08'29 Leah Robbins Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-29 Dave Honeycutt San Diego,.CA, United States 2016-08-29 Gordon Sinclair Solana Beach, CA, United States 2016-08-29 Cliff Kinney Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-29 Harvey CheckowaY Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-29 Lauren BradY San Diego, CA, United States 2016-08-29 Dawn Van DYke Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-29 Beth Lewis San Diego, CA, United States 2016-08-29 Francesco Tedeschi Del Mar, CA, United States States 2016-08-29 Tara Connell San Diego, CA, United 2016-08-29 Allison Steitz Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-29 Scott Reineck Del Mar, CA, United States States 2016-08-29 Kelly Simmons San Diego, CA, United States 2016-08-29 Paul BarrY Encinitas, CA, United States 2016-08-29 Kyle Attl San Diego, CA, United States 2016-08-29 Perry Rosen San Diego, CA, United 2016-08-29 Jake Bascon San Diego, CA, United States States 2016-08-29 Jordyn Garfein San Diego, CA, United States 2016-08-29 Zak Collin San Diego, CA, United 2016-08-29 Marco Schwab Del Mar, CA, United $tates 2016-08-29 Camille Asaro La Jolla, CA, United States 2016-08-29 Eric Pinczower La Jolla, CA, United States 2016'08-29 Josh Lasalle Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-29 Adam CherrY Del Mar, CA, United States States 2016-08-29 k carroll nutley, NJ, United States 2016-08-29 Rebecca Oxner Everett, WA, United

85 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Name Location Date Gail Pinczower Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-29 Maria Rausch Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-29 Jeffrey Dysart Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-30 Mary Cherry Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-30 Heather Bendall Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-30 susanne marx La Jolla, CA, United States 2016-08-30 2016-08-30 MiHyun Song San Diego, CA, United States 2016-08-30 Melissa Mikulak San Diego, CA, United States Steve Reiss Los Angeles, CA, United States 2016-08-30 2016-08-30 Dawn Dobrovich Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-30 Stephen Moreland La Jolla, CA, United States 2016-08-30 Zoe Pinczower Kirkland, WA, United States 2016-08-30 Steven Reich Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-30 Rachel Rosenstein Tuxedo Park, NY United States 2016-08-30 David McGrath Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-08-31 Celia Pinczower Santa Monica, CA, United States 2016-08-31 William Lenart Midland Park, NJ, United States 2016-08-31 kevin bateman Manhattan Beach, CA, United States 2016-08-31 Kerry Grove El Segundo, CA, United States 2016-08-31 LuLu Pinczower Kirkland, WA, United States 2016-08-31 Bruno Wolfenzon San Diego, CA, United States 2016-08-31 Jill Wolfenzon San Diego, CA, United States 2016-08-31 Simon Menkes Encinitas, CA, United States 2016-08-31 heidi haddad la, CA, United States 2016-08-31 James SPawton Carlsbad, CA, United States 2016-09-01 Kt Duing San Diego, CA, United States 2016-09-01 Joseph Battaglia Lemon Grove, CA, United States 2016-09-01 Rahman D'Argenio Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-09-01 Andreas Roell San Diego, CA, United States 2016-09-01 Greg Garcia San Diego, CA, United States 2016-09-01 Rodney HarveY Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-09-01 Karen Johnson Del Mar, CA, United States

86 September 6, 2016 Item 04 Date Name Location 2016-09-01 Brad Pruitt Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-09-02 Sandra Groves San Diego, CA, United States 2016-09-02 Mike Sofen Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-09-02 Gary Provenzano San Diego, CA, United States 2016-09-03 Jennifer Lonbom Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-09-03 Jeff Keller Del Mar, CA, United States 2016-09-03 Cary Attl San Diego, CA, United States 2016-09-03 Tiffany Boyd San Diego, CA, United States 2016-09-03 kara norgart Cardiff, CA, United States 2016-09-04 Ben Slade Auburn, CA, United States

87 September 6, 2016 Item 04 1 September 6, 2016 Item 04 2 September 6, 2016 Item 04 3 September 6, 2016 Item 04 4 September 6, 2016 Item 04 5 September 6, 2016 Item 04 6 September 6, 2016 Item 04 7 September 6, 2016 Item 04 8 September 6, 2016 Item 04 9 September 6, 2016 Item 04 10 September 6, 2016 Item 04 11 September 6, 2016 Item 04 12 September 6, 2016 Item 04 13 September 6, 2016 Item 04 14 September 6, 2016 Item 04 15 September 6, 2016 Item 04 16 September 6, 2016 Item 04 17 September 6, 2016 Item 04 18 September 6, 2016 Item 04 19 September 6, 2016 Item 04 20 September 6, 2016 Item 04 21 September 6, 2016 Item 04 22 September 6, 2016 Item 04 23 September 6, 2016 Item 04 24 September 6, 2016 Item 04 25 September 6, 2016 Item 04 26 September 6, 2016 Item 04 27 September 6, 2016 Item 04 28 September 6, 2016 Item 04 29 September 6, 2016 Item 04 30 September 6, 2016 Item 04 31 September 6, 2016 Item 04 32 September 6, 2016 Item 04 33 September 6, 2016 Item 04 34 September 6, 2016 Item 04 35 September 6, 2016 Item 04 36 September 6, 2016 Item 04 37 September 6, 2016 Item 04 38 September 6, 2016 Item 04 39 September 6, 2016 Item 04 40 September 6, 2016 Item 04 41 September 6, 2016 Item 04 42 September 6, 2016 Item 04 City of Del Mar Memorandum

~~TO: Mayor and City Council Members~~

~~FROM: Kristen M. Crane, Management Services Director Via Scott W. Huth, City Manager~~

~~DATE: September 2, 2016~~

~~RE: Item 14: Authorization of the City Manager to Award a Contract for Construction Services to the Lowest Responsive and Responsible Bidder for the Del Mar Civic Center~~

Item 14 on the September 6, 2016 City Council agenda pertains to authorization for the City Manager to award a contract for construction services to the lowest responsive and responsible bidder. As noted in the main staff report for this item, this memo is submitted as additional material relevant to Item 14 in order to award the contract.

~~Results of Bid Process~~

~~The bid opening occurred on Thursday, September 1, 2016, at 3:00pm. Four (4) bids were received and opened and are listed as follows:~~

~~1. RABC-ECC, A Joint Venture $13,788,684 2. USS Cal Builders $14,409,000 3. Barnhart Reese $14,487,000 4. Balfour Beatty $18,100,461~~

Staff evaluated RABC-ECC’s bid package, insurance, bonding, and construction references and determined RABC-ECC to be responsive. Contracting laws allow the City to award the contract to the lowest responsive bidder, in this case RABC-ECC.

~~ECC was the construction company for the Beach Safety Center in 2012.~~

~~Staff recommends that the City Council adopt the attached resolution (Attachment A), awarding the construction contract to RABC-ECC for $13,788,684.~~

~~Project Budget~~

~~The low-bid amount submitted by RABC-ECC fits within the overall $17.8 million project budget set by the City Council in November 2015.~~

The City Council approved a total project budget of $17,845,443, which included all costs for bringing the Del Mar Civic Center project to fruition, including architecture and engineering; CEQA environmental

1 September 6, 2016 Item 14 Page 2 of 3 City of Del Mar Memorandum review; demolition; construction of the new buildings and site improvements; fixtures, furnishings, and equipment; all soft costs; and contingencies.

~~A project budget status sheet is provided in Attachment B, demonstrating that the overall project is within budget, factoring in the construction cost based on the low-bid from RABC-ECC.~~

In addition to the $17.8 million project budget established by the City Council for the main City Hall/Town Hall project, there is a second component of the project being constructed at the same time - the off-site/streetscape improvements. These two projects are being funded by three sources explained below:

~~ Off-Site/Streetscape Improvements~~

The additional expense for off-site streetscape improvements on Camino Del Mar, 10th Street, and 11th Street was identified to be paid using a different funding source (Capital Improvement Project reserve) separate from the City Hall/Town Hall project budget. At that time, the estimated cost for construction-only of the off-site streetscape improvements was $401,749. The construction bid submitted by RABC-ECC includes the off-site right-of-way/streetscape improvements.

Based on the construction bid and also factoring in the cost associated with design and engineering work for the off-site/streetscape improvements, the estimated value of that work is approximately $516,000.

~~ Costs for Public/Education/Government Channel Facility and Infrastructure~~

Another element of the project to be paid for using a separate funding source are the investments related to the City’s public/education/government (PEG) television channel (DMTV), and the infrastructure related to filming/broadcasting public meetings. These elements of the project are to be funded using the PEG fund, which are funds received from the cable television companies that serve Del Mar that can only be used for this purpose (such as equipment, office space, microphones, and cameras for the DMTV function). The combined estimated value of the PEG-related elements of the project is approximately $770,000, which includes construction costs for the facilities, a portion of design/engineering costs, and equipment.

Available PEG funding at this time is approximately $293,000. Annually, the City receives approximately $30,000 in PEG funds. The City Council can allocate future PEG fund remittances toward the cost of the PEG-related components of the Civic Center project.

~~Bid Package Deductive Alternates~~

As part of the bid process, all bidders were required to submit a cost for five (5) elements of the project identified as “deductive alternates.” The City Council could opt to remove one or all of these five elements of the project. Attachment C identifies the value that RABC-ECC gave to each of the five deductive alternates. At this point, staff does not recommend proceeding with any of the deductive alternates.

~~2 September 6, 2016 Item 14 Page 3 of 3 City of Del Mar Memorandum~~

~~Requested Action/Recommendation:~~

Staff recommends that the City Council adopt the attached resolution (Attachment A), awarding the construction contract to RABC-ECC. The low bid cost for construction is within the City’s overall project budget.

~~Staff will continue to refine budget details for the Del Mar Civic Center project and will report back at the September 19, 2016 City Council meeting with more details.~~

~~Attachments:~~

~~Attachment A - Resolution Attachment B – Project Budget Status Report Attachment C – RABC-ECC – Value for Deductive Alternates~~

~~3 September 6, 2016 Item 14 ATTACHMENT A~~

~~RESOLUTION NO. 2016-~~

~~A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DEL MAR, CALIFORNIA, TO AWARD RABC-ECC, A JOINT VENTURE THE CONTRACT FOR CONSTRUCTION OF THE DEL MAR CIVIC CENTER~~

~~WHEREAS, since June 2013, the City of Del Mar has extensively engaged in planning and design efforts for a new City Hall/Town Hall; and~~

WHEREAS, on April 6, 2015 the City Council directed the City Manager to enter into a Professional Service Agreement with the Miller Hull Partnership LLC. to provide architectural design consulting services for the City Hall/Town Hall Project; and

WHEREAS, the City Council certified the Environmental Impact Report (EIR) for the proposed City Hall/Town Hall on January 4, 2016, and approved the development entitlements for the project on January 19, 2016; and

WHEREAS, on March 21, 2016, the City Council authorized the City Manager to enter into an amended Professional Service Agreement with the Miller Hull Partnership, LLC. for preparation of Construction Documents; and

~~WHEREAS, the City Council approved the modified Design Review Permit on June 6, 2016 for minor design changes; and~~

~~WHEREAS, on July 16, 2016, the City Council authorized the City Manager to initiate a competitive bid process for construction services for the new City Hall/Town Hall; and~~

WHEREAS, pursuant to California Public Contracts Code section 20160, et seq. and Del Mar Municipal Code section 7.04.080, et seq., the City of Del Mar (“City”) invited proposals for a Public Works Project as defined in California Public Contract Code section 20161(c) called the Del Mar Civic Center project (“Project”); and

WHEREAS, on August 8, 2016, the City issued an invitation for sealed bids for the Project; on July 27, 2016 and August 3, 2016, a notice inviting bids was advertised in the Union Tribune; on July 28, 2016 and August 4, 2016, a notice inviting bids was advertised in the Del Mar Times; and on July 29, 2016 and August 5, 2016, was advertised in the Daily Transcript; and

~~WHEREAS, the Administrative Services Director/City Clerk and the Management Services Director of the City of Del Mar did on September 1, 2016, receive bids from four (4) contractors; and~~

WHEREAS, a review of the lowest responsible bid indicates that RABC-ECC, A Joint Venture (“RABC-ECC”) possesses the required license and qualifications to perform the scope of services for the Project; and

~~4 September 6, 2016 Item 14 Resolution 2016-XX Page 2 of 3~~

WHEREAS, RABC-ECC’s bid in the amount of $13,788,684 was the lowest regular bid submitted by a responsible bidder in accordance with the Notice of Inviting Bids and is acceptable to the City Council; and

~~NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Del Mar, California, as follows:~~

~~1. That the contract for construction services for the Del Mar Civic Center be awarded to the lowest responsive bidder, RABC-ECC.~~

2. That the City Council authorizes the City Manager to execute a contract with RABC-ECC for construction services and to negotiate change orders within the overall project budget for the Del Mar Civic Center in substantial conformance with the terms of the contract on file with the Office of the City Clerk of the City of Del Mar.

3. That the appropriate City officials are hereby authorized and directed to take such actions as they may deem necessary and proper to effectuate and consummate the contract, subject to final review and approval by the City Attorney.

~~PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED by the City Council of the City of Del Mar, California, at a Regular Meeting held on the ___ day of September 2016.~~

~~______SHERRYL PARKS, Mayor City of Del Mar~~

~~APPROVED AS TO FORM:~~

~~______LESLIE E. DEVANEY, City Attorney~~

~~5 September 6, 2016 Item 14 Resolution 2016-XX Page 3 of 3~~

~~ATTEST AND CERTIFICATION:~~

~~STATE OF CALIFORNIA COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO CITY OF DEL MAR~~

I, Ashley Jones, Administrative Services Director/City Clerk of the City of Del Mar, California, DO HEREBY CERTIFY that the foregoing is a true and correct copy of Resolution 2016-______, adopted by the City Council of the City of Del Mar, California, at a Regular Meeting held the ___ day of September, 2016, by the following vote:

~~AYES: NOES: ABSENT: ABSTAIN:~~

~~______ASHLEY JONES, Administrative Services Director/City Clerk City of Del Mar~~

~~6 September 6, 2016 Item 14 Attachment B~~

~~City of Del Mar - City Hall/Town Hall~~

~~Project Budget Status Based on Construction Bid~~

~~Lowest Responsible/Responsive Construction Bid $ 13,788,684.00 Submitted by RABC-ECC, A Joint Venture~~

~~Project Costs~~

~~Approximate Breakdown of Construction Costs~~

~~Construction of Civic Center $ 12,865,880.00~~

~~City Hall/Town Hall/Parking/Plaza~~

~~Off-Site Streetscape Improvements $ 515,966.00~~

~~Camino Del Mar/10th St./11th St. -- Curb to Property Line~~

~~Public-Education-Government Channel/DMTV $ 406,838.00 Eligible construction improvements related to PEG channel~~

~~$ 13,788,684.00~~

~~Additional Project Costs~~

~~Demolition of Former City Hall Buildings and Site Improvements $ 345,000.00~~

Soft Costs $ 3,134,564.00 Includes architectural design and engineering; environmental review/CEQA EIR preparation; permitting; construction management and inspection work during construction; all specialized design work; fixtures, furnishings, and equipment

~~Public-Education-Government Channel/DMTV Equipment and Design $ 362,983.00~~

~~Owner's Contingency $ 1,500,000.00~~

~~$ 5,342,547.00~~

~~Combined Estimated Project Cost $ 19,131,231.00~~

~~Project Funding~~

~~Civic Center Project Budget $ 17,845,443.00 Approved by City Council, November 2015~~

~~Off-Site "Streetscape" Project (CIP Reserve) $ 515,966.00~~

~~Public-Education-Government Fund $ 769,822.00 Includes current cash available in fund and repayment from future annual PEG revenues~~

~~Combined Funding for Project $ 19,131,231.00~~

~~Items not funded in the project budget above but could be funded using remaining project funding (such as owner- contingency savings) or savings off-set by fundraising.~~

~~Solar Panels $ 200,000.00~~

~~Kitchen Equipment $ 60,000.00~~

~~7 September 6, 2016 Item 14 Attachment C~~

~~City of Del Mar - City Hall/Town Hall~~

~~RABC-ECC, A Joint Venture~~

~~List of Deductive Alternates~~

~~Alternate RABC-ECC's Value for Description Number Deductive Alternate~~

~~Delete acoustic wood ceiling panels at 1 $ 10,201.00 Town Hall and Breezeway~~

~~Change roof assemblies from standing 2 seam metal roof to fiberglass reinforced $ 54,575.00 asphalt shingles~~

~~3 Delete trellises except at/around elevator $ 299,893.00~~

~~Change all paving at west surface parking lot from decorative concrete paving and 4 $ 66,602.00 porous concrete paving to decomposed granite paving~~

~~Substitute decorative concrete paving as 5 part of North Plaza hardscape with $ 127,054.00 decomposed granite paving~~

~~$ 558,325.00~~

~~8 September 6, 2016 Item 14~~