DOCSLIB.ORG

Governance and Adaptation for Future Flood Risk Total Synthesis Of

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Governance and Adaptation for Future Flood Risk Total Synthesis Of Risky Environments: Governance and Adaptation for Future Flood Risk Rhiannon Niven BSoc Sc (Psych) – The University of Adelaide, South Australia BEnv St – The University of Adelaide, South Australia BEnv Policy Mgt (Hons) – The University of Adelaide, South Australia Department of Geography, Environment and Population School of Social Sciences Faculty of Arts University of Adelaide Thesis submitted for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy July 2017 1 Table of Contents Table of Contents ....................................................................................................................... ii List of Tables .............................................................................................................................. i List of Figures ............................................................................................................................ ii Abstract ..................................................................................................................................... iii Declaration ................................................................................................................................ iv Acknowledgements .....................................................................................................................v Acronyms and Abbreviations ................................................................................................... vi Chapter 1: Introduction ...........................................................................................................1 1.1 Challenges for flood management .....................................................................................1 1.2 Theoretical framework ......................................................................................................3 1.3 Purpose and scope .............................................................................................................3 1.3.1 Research context .........................................................................................................3 1.3.2 Research aim ...............................................................................................................4 1.3.3 Research significance .................................................................................................4 1.4 Thesis structure .................................................................................................................5 1.5 Chapter summary ..............................................................................................................5 Chapter 2: Conceptualising flood risk ....................................................................................6 2.1 Introduction .......................................................................................................................6 2.2 Defining key concepts .......................................................................................................6 2.2.1 What is a flood? ..........................................................................................................6 2.2.2 Types of flooding ........................................................................................................7 2.2.3 Definition of risk and hazard ......................................................................................8 2.2.4 Risk theory ..................................................................................................................9 2.2.5 Resilience and vulnerability .....................................................................................14 2.2.6 Mitigation and adaptation .........................................................................................15 2.3 The history of management of flooding ..........................................................................18 2.3.1 Flood defence through to flood risk management: a risk based approach ...............18 2.4 Governance of flood risk .................................................................................................22 2.4.1 Government and governance ....................................................................................22 2.4.2 Governance across scales .........................................................................................24 2.5 Risk perception ................................................................................................................25 2.6 Key issues for management: failure of the current paradigm? ........................................27 2.6.1 Climate change .........................................................................................................27 2.6.2 Urbanisation ..............................................................................................................29 2.7 Study rationale .................................................................................................................30 2.8 Chapter summary ............................................................................................................31 Chapter 3: Research design and methods .............................................................................32 3.1 Introduction .....................................................................................................................32 3.2 Research design ...............................................................................................................32 3.2.1 Qualitative research ..................................................................................................32 3.3 Methodology ...................................................................................................................33 3.3.1 Grounded theory .......................................................................................................33 3.3.2 Case studies ..............................................................................................................34 3.4 Methods and data collection ............................................................................................39 3.4.1 Interviews .................................................................................................................39 3.4.2 Document analysis ....................................................................................................44 3.4.3 Data analysis .............................................................................................................45 3.5 Triangulation and validity ...............................................................................................46 3.6 Limitations ......................................................................................................................46 3.6.1 Potential bias .............................................................................................................47 3.7 Chapter summary ............................................................................................................47 Chapter 4: South Australia and the Brown Hill and Keswick Creek Experience ................49 4.1 Introduction .....................................................................................................................49 4.2 Local context: case study background ............................................................................49 4.2.1 The BHKC catchment ..............................................................................................50 4.3 Governance of flood risk management in the BHKC catchment ....................................54 4.3.1 Governance framework for BHKC ...........................................................................57 4.3.2 Development of the BHKC SMP .............................................................................60 4.3.3 Challenges for effective flood management: governance and implementation .......66 4.4 Adaptation in the BHKC catchment ................................................................................70 4.4.1 Risk perception .........................................................................................................71 4.4.2 Adaptation for urbanisation and infrastructure .........................................................71 4.4.3 Relocation policies ...................................................................................................72 4.5 Key findings ....................................................................................................................74 4.6 Key themes and chapter summary ..................................................................................75 Chapter 5: 2011 Queensland flood event ..............................................................................77 5.1 Introduction .....................................................................................................................77 5.2 Local context: SE QLD flood history .............................................................................78 5.2.1 The 2011 flood event ................................................................................................80 5.2.2 The flood event impacts ...........................................................................................84 5.3 Issues and lessons learned from the 2011 SE QLD flood event .....................................86 5.3.1 Resulting reviews and inquiries ................................................................................87 5.3.2
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Impacts of Storms
    THE IMPACTS OF STORMS It is important to think more about storms, how they are formed, their potentially devastating impacts and whether you are resilient to them. Planning in advance is essential, especially if you live in areas that may be more vulnerable than others, for example, those located next to rivers or on the coast. Winter storms can bring some of the most severe and extreme weather events, including lower temperatures, gale-force winds and heavy rain, which can lead to flooding in some areas or sleet and snow if the temperature is cold enough. Storms occur at mid-latitudes where cold polar air meets warmer tropical air and the point where these two meet is known as the jet stream. Rising air from the Atlantic is removed and replaced by the strong winds of the jet stream a lot quicker than the air at lower levels and this reduction in pressure produces the strong winds of winter storms. Storms tend to form in the winter months when the temperature between the air masses is at its greatest. It is important to keep as safe and resilient as you can against the potential impact of storms. On the 5th and 6th December 2015, Storm Desmond brought strong winds of up to 81 mph and heavy rainfall, with 341.4mm of rain falling in Cumbria by 6pm on the 5th (24 hours) – a new UK record! Many people across Cumbria and Lancashire were severely affected: 5200 homes were flooded. 61,000 homes in Lancaster lost power when an electrical substation was flooded.
    [Show full text]
  • Kielder Reservoir, Northumberland
    Rainwise Working with communities to manage rainwater Kielder Reservoir, Northumberland Kielder Water is the largest man-made lake in northern Europe and is capable of holding 200 billion litres of water, it is located on the River North Tyne in North West Northumberland. Figure 1: Location of Kielder Figure 2: Kielder Area Figure 3: Kielder Water The Kielder Water Scheme was to provide additional flood storage capacity at Kielder Reservoir. At the same time the Environment Agency completed in 1982 and was one of the (EA) were keen to pursue the idea of variable releases largest and most forward looking projects to the river and the hydropower operator at Kielder of its time. It was the first example in (Innogy) wished to review operations in order to maximum generation ahead of plans to refurbish the main turbine the UK of a regional water grid, it was in 2017. designed to meet the demands of the north east well into the future. The scheme CHALLENGES is a regional transfer system designed to Kielder reservoir has many important roles including river allow water from Kielder Reservoir to be regulation for water supply, hydropower generation and released into the Rivers Tyne, Derwent, as a tourist attraction. As such any amendments to the operation of the reservoir could not impact on Kielder’s Wear and Tees. This water is used to ability to support these activities. Operating the reservoir maintain minimum flow levels at times of at 85 percent of its capacity would make up to 30 billion low natural rainfall and allows additional litres of storage available.
    [Show full text]
  • Flooding After Storm Desmond PERC UK 2015 Flooding in Cumbria After Storm Desmond PERC UK 2015
    Flooding after Storm Desmond PERC UK 2015 Flooding in Cumbria after Storm Desmond PERC UK 2015 The storms that battered the north of England and parts of Scotland at the end of 2015 and early 2016 caused significant damage and disruption to families and businesses across tight knit rural communities and larger towns and cities. This came just two years after Storm Xaver inflicted significant damage to the east coast of England. Flooding is not a new threat to the residents of the Lake District, but the severity of the events in December 2015 certainly appears to have been regarded as surprising. While the immediate priority is always to ensure that defence measures are overwhelmed. We have also these communities and businesses are back up on their looked at the role of community flood action groups feet as quickly and effectively as possible, it is also in the response and recovery from severe flooding. important that all those involved in the response take Our main recommendations revolve around three key the opportunity to review their own procedures and themes. The first is around flood risk communication, actions. It is often the case that when our response is including the need for better communication of hazard, put to the test in a ‘real world’ scenario that we risk and what actions to take when providing early discover things that could have been done better, or warning services to communities. The second centres differently, and can make changes to ensure continuous around residual risk when the first line of flood improvement. This is true of insurers as much as it is of defences, typically the large, constructed schemes central and local government and the emergency protecting entire cities or areas, are either breached services, because events like these demand a truly or over-topped.
    [Show full text]
  • Supplement of Storm Xaver Over Europe in December 2013: Overview of Energy Impacts and North Sea Events
    Supplement of Adv. Geosci., 54, 137–147, 2020 https://doi.org/10.5194/adgeo-54-137-2020-supplement © Author(s) 2020. This work is distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License. Supplement of Storm Xaver over Europe in December 2013: Overview of energy impacts and North Sea events Anthony James Kettle Correspondence to: Anthony James Kettle ([email protected]) The copyright of individual parts of the supplement might differ from the CC BY 4.0 License. SECTION I. Supplement figures Figure S1. Wind speed (10 minute average, adjusted to 10 m height) and wind direction on 5 Dec. 2013 at 18:00 GMT for selected station records in the National Climate Data Center (NCDC) database. Figure S2. Maximum significant wave height for the 5–6 Dec. 2013. The data has been compiled from CEFAS-Wavenet (wavenet.cefas.co.uk) for the UK sector, from time series diagrams from the website of the Bundesamt für Seeschifffahrt und Hydrolographie (BSH) for German sites, from time series data from Denmark's Kystdirektoratet website (https://kyst.dk/soeterritoriet/maalinger-og-data/), from RWS (2014) for three Netherlands stations, and from time series diagrams from the MIROS monthly data reports for the Norwegian platforms of Draugen, Ekofisk, Gullfaks, Heidrun, Norne, Ormen Lange, Sleipner, and Troll. Figure S3. Thematic map of energy impacts by Storm Xaver on 5–6 Dec. 2013. The platform identifiers are: BU Buchan Alpha, EK Ekofisk, VA? Valhall, The wind turbine accident letter identifiers are: B blade damage, L lightning strike, T tower collapse, X? 'exploded'. The numbers are the number of customers (households and businesses) without power at some point during the storm.
    [Show full text]
  • Reconstructing the Impact of Nickel Mining Activities On
    Reconstructing the impact of nickel mining activities on sediment supply to the rivers and the lagoon of South Pacific Islands: lessons learnt from the Thio early mining site (New Caledonia) Virginie Sellier, Oldrich Navratil, J. Patrick Laceby, Michel Allenbach, Irène Lefèvre, Olivier Evrard To cite this version: Virginie Sellier, Oldrich Navratil, J. Patrick Laceby, Michel Allenbach, Irène Lefèvre, et al.. Recon- structing the impact of nickel mining activities on sediment supply to the rivers and the lagoon of South Pacific Islands: lessons learnt from the Thio early mining site (New Caledonia). Geomorphology, Elsevier, 2021, 372, pp.107459. 10.1016/j.geomorph.2020.107459. cea-02968814 HAL Id: cea-02968814 https://hal-cea.archives-ouvertes.fr/cea-02968814 Submitted on 16 Oct 2020 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents entific research documents, whether they are pub- scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, lished or not. The documents may come from émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de teaching and research institutions in France or recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires abroad, or from public or private research centers. publics ou privés. 1 Reconstructing the impact of nickel mining activities on sediment supply to 2 the rivers and the lagoon of South Pacific Islands: lessons learnt from the Thio 3 early mining site (New Caledonia) 4 Virginie Sellier1 • Oldrich
    [Show full text]
  • How LV= Delivered a Human Response to the Floods in Cumbria
    A case study... How LV= delivered a human response to the floods in Cumbria BROKER LVbroker.co.uk LV= Insurance Highway Insurance ABC Insurance @LV_Broker LV= Broker Contents LV= in Kendal Storm Desmond LV= attended the scene Storm Eva Case Studies Storm Frank What next? 2 A case study... And the rain came... When Storm Desmond hit on 4 December 2015, nobody anticipated another two Background of Storm Desmond storms would follow. Storm Desmond was 4–6 December the start of intense rainfall and high winds Storm Desmond brought extreme rainfall and concentrated over Cumbria in the last part storm force winds with a few rain gauges reported of 2015. Storm Desmond was quickly to have recorded in excess of 300mm in a 24 hour period. followed by Storm Eva, proving more Thursday 3 December Friday 4 December misery over the festive period before Storm Frank put an end to the wet and windy weather on 31 December. Whilst many of the areas had been affected by flooding in the past, the immediate reaction was that this event was the worst in living memory. Many areas already had some form of flood defence in place and others were in the process of improving existing defences. Unfortunately Saturday 5 December Sunday 6 December the defences were unable to cope with the record river levels and in many instances were overtopped. LV= popped-up in Kendal Kendal was the first badly hit area and within hours of the news breaking on the 7 December, we sent two senior members of our claims team 300 miles up to Kendal (1).
    [Show full text]
  • Complex and Cascading Triggering of Submarine Landslides And
    ORIGINAL RESEARCH published: 13 December 2018 doi: 10.3389/feart.2018.00223 Complex and Cascading Triggering of Submarine Landslides and Turbidity Currents at Volcanic Islands Revealed From Integration of High-Resolution Onshore and Offshore Surveys Michael A. Clare 1*, Tim Le Bas 1, David M. Price 1,2, James E. Hunt 1, David Sear 3, Matthieu J. B. Cartigny 4, Age Vellinga 2, William Symons 2, Christopher Firth 5 and Shane Cronin 6 1 National Oceanography Centre, University of Southampton Waterfront Campus, Southampton, United Kingdom, 2 National Oceanography Centre, School of Ocean and Earth Science, University of Southampton, Southampton, United Kingdom, 3 Department of Geography & Environment, University of Southampton, Southampton, United Kingdom, 4 Department of Geography, Durham University, Durham, United Kingdom, 5 Department of Earth and Planetary Sciences, Macquarie Edited by: University, Sydney, NSW, Australia, 6 School of Environment, University of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand Ivar Midtkandal, University of Oslo, Norway Reviewed by: Submerged flanks of volcanic islands are prone to hazards including submarine Gijs Allard Henstra, landslides that may trigger damaging tsunamis and sediment-laden seafloor flows (called University of Bergen, Norway “turbidity currents”). These hazards can break seafloor infrastructure which is critical for Miquel Poyatos Moré, University of Oslo, Norway global communications and energy transmission. Small Island Developing States are *Correspondence: particularly vulnerable to these hazards due to their remote and isolated nature, small size, Michael A. Clare high population densities, and weak economies. Despite their vulnerability, few detailed [email protected] offshore surveys exist for such islands, resulting in a geohazard “blindspot,” particularly in Specialty section: the South Pacific.
    [Show full text]
  • Plants of Kiribati
    KIRIBATI State of the Environment Report 2000-2002 Government of the Republic of Kiribati 2004 PREPARED BY THE ENVIRONMENT AND CONSERVATION DIVISION Ministry of Environment Lands & Agricultural Development Nei Akoako MINISTRY OF ENVIRONMEN P.O. BOX 234 BIKENIBEU, TARAWA KIRIBATI PHONES (686) 28000/28593/28507 Ngkoa, FNgkaiAX: (686 ao) 283 n34/ Taaainako28425 EMAIL: [email protected] GOVERNMENT OF THE REPUBLIC OF KIRIBATI Acknowledgements The report has been collectively developed by staff of the Environment and Conservation Division. Mrs Tererei Abete-Reema was the lead author with Mr Kautoa Tonganibeia contributing to Chapters 11 and 14. Mrs Nenenteiti Teariki-Ruatu contributed to chapters 7 to 9. Mr. Farran Redfern (Chapter 5) and Ms. Reenate Tanua Willie (Chapters 4 and 6) also contributed. Publication of the report has been made possible through the kind financial assistance of the Secretariat of the Pacific Regional Environment Programme. The front coverpage design was done by Mr. Kautoa Tonganibeia. Editing has been completed by Mr Matt McIntyre, Sustainable Development Adviser and Manager, Sustainable Economic Development Division of the Secretariat of the Pacific Regional Environment Programme (SPREP). __________________________________________________________________________________ i Kiribati State of the Environment Report, 2000-2002 Table of Contents ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS .................................................................................................. I TABLE OF CONTENTS .............................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Defining the Hundred Year Flood
    Journal of Hydrology 540 (2016) 1189–1208 Contents lists available at ScienceDirect Journal of Hydrology journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jhydrol Research papers Defining the hundred year flood: A Bayesian approach for using historic data to reduce uncertainty in flood frequency estimates ⇑ Dr. Brandon Parkes , David Demeritt, Professor King’s College London, Department of Geography, Strand, London WC2R 2LS, United Kingdom article info abstract Article history: This paper describes a Bayesian statistical model for estimating flood frequency by combining uncertain Received 26 April 2016 annual maximum (AMAX) data from a river gauge with estimates of flood peak discharge from various Received in revised form 5 July 2016 historic sources that predate the period of instrument records. Such historic flood records promise to Accepted 14 July 2016 expand the time series data needed for reducing the uncertainty in return period estimates for extreme Available online 19 July 2016 events, but the heterogeneity and uncertainty of historic records make them difficult to use alongside This manuscript was handled by A. Bardossy, Editor-in-Chief, with the Flood Estimation Handbook and other standard methods for generating flood frequency curves from assistance of Saman Razavi, Associate Editor gauge data. Using the flow of the River Eden in Carlisle, Cumbria, UK as a case study, this paper develops a Bayesian model for combining historic flood estimates since 1800 with gauge data since 1967 to Keywords: estimate the probability of low frequency flood events for the area taking account of uncertainty in Flood frequency analysis the discharge estimates. Results show a reduction in 95% confidence intervals of roughly 50% for annual Bayesian model exceedance probabilities of less than 0.0133 (return periods over 75 years) compared to standard flood Historical flood estimates frequency estimation methods using solely systematic data.
    [Show full text]
  • MAS8306 Topics in Statistics: Environmental Extremes
    MAS8306 Topics in Statistics: Environmental Extremes Dr. Lee Fawcett Semester 2 2017/18 1 Background and motivation 1.1 Introduction Finally, there is almost1 a global consensus amongst scientists that our planet’s climate is changing. Evidence for climatic change has been collected from a variety of sources, some of which can be used to reconstruct the earth’s changing climates over tens of thousands of years. Reasonably complete global records of the earth’s surface tempera- ture since the early 1800’s indicate a positive trend in the average annual temperature, and maximum annual temperature, most noticeable at the earth’s poles. Glaciers are considered amongst the most sensitive indicators of climate change. As the earth warms, glaciers retreat and ice sheets melt, which – over the last 30 years or so – has resulted in a gradual increase in sea and ocean levels. Apart from the consequences on ocean ecosystems, rising sea levels pose a direct threat to low–lying inhabited areas of land. Less direct, but certainly noticeable in the last fiteen years or so, is the effect of rising sea levels on the earth’s weather systems. A larger amount of warmer water in the Atlantic Ocean, for example, has certainly resulted in stronger, and more frequent, 1Almost... — 3 — 1 Background and motivation tropical storms and hurricanes; unless you’ve been living under a rock over the last few years, you would have noticed this in the media (e.g. Hurricane Katrina in 2005, Superstorm Sandy in 2012). Most recently, and as reported in the New York Times in January 2018, the 2017 hurricane season was “..
    [Show full text]
  • Community Sustainability in the Dales • a Tale of Four Bridges • Saving a Dales Icon • an Unbroken Dales Record • Upland Hay Meadows
    Spring 2018 : Issue 142 • Community Sustainability in the Dales • A Tale of Four Bridges • Saving a Dales Icon • An Unbroken Dales Record • Upland Hay Meadows CAMPAIGN • PROTECT • ENJOY Cover photo: Spring Life in the Dales. Courtesy of Mark Corner Photo, this page: Spring Flowers along the Ribble. Courtesy of Mark Corner CONTENTS Spring 2018 : Issue 142 Editor’s Letter ...............3 Book Review ...............13 Jerry Pearlman MBE ..........3 Upland Hay Meadows The Challenge of Community in the Dales ................14 Sustainability in the Dales .....4 Policy Committee A Tale of Four Bridges ........6 Planning Update ............15 Members’ Letters ...........16 Saving a Dales Icon ..........8 Something for Everyone? ....16 The Family of National Park Societies . 10 The Dales in Spring .........17 DalesBus Update ...........11 News .....................18 An Unbroken Record Events ....................19 in the Dales ................12 Dales Haverbread ...........20 New Business Members ......13 Editor Sasha Heseltine 2 It’s feeling a lot like Spring in the Dales With Our Deepest Condolences It is with great sadness that we make our It’s been a long winter but finally we are seeing glimmers members aware of the death of our trustee of spring cheering our majestic, wild Dales. Over and friend Jerry Pearlman MBE, who the centuries, they’ve been shaped by a remarkable passed away peacefully at home on Friday, combination of nature and human hand, and Dales 9th March, aged 84. Jerry was a founding communities play a vital role in preserving these member of the Yorkshire Dales Society, landscapes. When local residents are forced to leave the its solicitor, a very active trustee and a Dales to seek employment or affordable housing, those wonderful person.
    [Show full text]
  • Unlocking the Inherent Potential of Plant Genetic Resources: Food Security and Climate Adaptation Strategy in Fiji and the Pacifc
    Environment, Development and Sustainability (2021) 23:14264–14323 https://doi.org/10.1007/s10668-021-01273-8 REVIEW Unlocking the inherent potential of plant genetic resources: food security and climate adaptation strategy in Fiji and the Pacifc Hemalatha Palanivel1 · Shipra Shah2 Received: 20 August 2020 / Accepted: 28 January 2021 / Published online: 17 February 2021 © The Author(s), under exclusive licence to Springer Nature B.V. part of Springer Nature 2021 Abstract Pacifc Island Countries (PICs) are the center of origin and diversity for several root, fruit and nut crops, which are indispensable for food security, rural livelihoods, and cultural identity of local communities. However, declining genetic diversity of traditional food crops and high vulnerability to climate change are major impediments for maintaining agri- cultural productivity. Limited initiatives to achieve food self-sufciency and utilization of Plant Genetic Resources (PGR) for enhancing resilience of agro-ecosystems are other seri- ous constraints. This review focuses on the visible and anticipated impacts of climate ge, on major food and tree crops in agriculture and agroforestry systems in the PICs. We argue that crop improvement through plant breeding is a viable strategy to enhance food security and climatic resilience in the region. The exploitation of adaptive traits: abiotic and biotic stress tolerance, yield and nutritional efciency, is imperative in a world threatened by cli- matic extremes. However, the insular constraints of Fiji and other small PICs are major limitations for the utilization of PGR through high throughput techniques which are also cost prohibitive. Crop Improvement programs should instead focus on the identifcation, conservation, documentation and dissemination of information on unique landraces, com- munity seed banks, introduction of new resistant genotypes, and sustaining and enhancing allelic diversity.
    [Show full text]