DOCSLIB.ORG

Uncovering the Network of Planning Expertise in St. Petersburg: Civic

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Uncovering the Network of Planning Expertise in St. Petersburg: Civic Uncovering the Network of Planning Expertise in St. Petersburg: Civic and State by Svetlana Moskaleva Submitted to: Central European University Department of Sociology and Social Anthropology In partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in Sociology and Social Anthropology Supervisors: Prof. Jean-Louis Fabiani Prof. Judit Bodnar CEU eTD Collection Budapest, Hungary 2019 Abstract This study explores the role of expertise in urban planning. Using the example of “urbanistica” – a local name for urban studies in Russia, the thesis will discuss the possibility of conceptualization of the struggle for recognition between various groups, including activists and professionals. The analysis will focus on an activist group which is involved in the projects of urban redevelopment in St. Petersburg. Members of the group work in research centers, as well as in city committees and use digital platforms to involve citizens in the discussion of urban problems. The purpose of the study is to expose the mechanisms of the social construction of civic expertise of urban problems and to contextualize global and local conditions in which this activity has been forming. Following Gil Eyal’s concept of expertise as a network as well as studies on transferring urban ideas (Friedman, King, Collier), I describe the hybridity of civic and state expertise and comprehend the processes occurring within groups, their integration into the institutional context. Through the analysis of planning documents, I trace how global urban concepts influence this context, producing political discourses or rather co-producing them together with citizens who are striving to become new political actors in urban planning. The methodological optic of the research is following the process of creating a network between techno-social elements, mechanisms, and conditions necessary for urban problems to become objects of expert labor. I show that civic expertise is a phenomenon which combines local and professional knowledge of citizens, which come to matter in the process of political struggle between state and civic groups. The mechanisms of construction of civic expertise include rational discourses, transferring urban concepts from “western” studies, devices and technologies which come to matter in the context of urban decision- CEU eTD Collection making. I Acknowledgements I would like to thank my supervisors, Jean-Louis Fabiani and Judit Bodnar, for their support through this fascinating journey to the roots of civic expertise and urban planning ideas. This study would not have been possible without your wise advice, genuine help, and understanding. I appreciated giving me enough freedom to develop my study as it looks now. For my informants, their enthusiasm to speak with me, while activist work takes a lot of time and effort in their sphere. I’m very grateful to CEU for giving me a chance to accomplish my MA thesis, which was difficult in my own country. I want to thank especially my previous supervisor – Diana West, who found my topic interesting and contributed a lot to its development, suggesting books, articles and writing a recommendation letter to CEU. I also want to thank my groupmates, who became the source of my inspiration through the writing and studying period. For my family, who struggled with me and believed that I will manage everything. CEU eTD Collection II Table of Contents Abstract ................................................................................................................................................... I Acknowledgements................................................................................................................................ II Table of Contents ................................................................................................................................ III List of Figures ...................................................................................................................................... IV 1 Introduction .................................................................................................................................... 1 1.1 Expertise as Network: Methodological Reflections ............................................................. 4 2 The Transfer of Urban Ideas in Post-Soviet Space ..................................................................... 8 2.1 The Roots of Civic Expertise: Analysis of Architectural Projects on Bolshaya Mosrskaya Street 11 2.2 Transformation of Urban Policy in St. Petersburg ............................................................ 17 2.3 New Educational Trajectories in Russia ............................................................................. 19 3 Constructing Expertise of Urban Problems ............................................................................... 22 3.1 Role of Activist Groups in Constructing Expertise ........................................................... 25 4 From Activists to Experts? Mechanisms for Constructing Expertise: Discourses, Concepts, Actors, Devices ..................................................................................................................................... 32 5 Networks of Expertise and Spaces of Political Struggle ........................................................... 41 Conclusion............................................................................................................................................. 44 Appendix A. Interview guide ............................................................................................................... 46 Appendix B. Materials and data ........................................................................................................... 48 Bibliography .......................................................................................................................................... 49 CEU eTD Collection III List of Figures Figure 1. Project by state-led bureau ................................................................................................... 12 Figure 2. Petersburg establishment project ........................................................................................ 13 Figure 3. Project made by civic group “Beautiful Petersburg” ......................................................... 14 Figure 4. Project made by civic group “Urban Projects in Petersburg” .......................................... 15 Figure 5. The reconstruction of the street in 2017 ............................................................................ 16 Figure 6. Civic platform for gathering citizens' complaints .............................................................. 39 CEU eTD Collection IV 1 Introduction The study is devoted to the emerging phenomenon of urban expertise in Russian cities called “urbanistica”, which is a term for activities related to urban planning. The field of “urbanistica” has a rather sui generis history in Russia and requires an in-depth study of the processes that form it. The activity of people involved in it considers a wide spectrum of social factors and forms of engagement while working with planners and architects, practices of invoking social scientists into urban projects and it combines an eclectic mix of skills, training and ways of so-called “expert” engagement with the city. My study aims to analyse the process of the social construction of civic expertise on urban issues in the context of Russia, where the field emerged from a few individual initiatives rather than as an institutionalized form. In Russia, the field of urban planning is being in the process of transition (Friedman 2005, Golubchikov 2004). From Soviet times there is a profession of town planner (in Russian - gradostroitel), while since 2010 the new educational programs of urban studies and related professions were implemented. For current moment this field is not institutionalized, there are no state diplomas in urban studies as such, but the new institutes provide diplomas of managers, city planners, entrepreneurs. In this research I am revealing the particularities of the process of constructing expertise in the emerging field of studies: practices, actors, ideas which are involved in the creation of civic expertise, as well as opportunities which make its development possible in the political context. The study addresses two problems: a crisis of expertise or crisis of trust in those experts who provide it, and secondly, the changing role of “urbanistica” as a scientific discipline which is developing and becomes highly politicized in Russia. There appeared new public CEU eTD Collection initiatives who started to promote their studies by connecting them with this discipline. These techniques of democratization and control are interrelated and will be traced using the methodological optic of actor-network, starting from an activist group which is involved in the process of urban decision-making in St. Petersburg. 1 Another feature of the formation of urban studies in Russia is the changing content of the activities of civic initiative groups that appeared in major Russian cities in 2011-2012 and concerned with the quality of the urban environment. In St. Petersburg since 2012 the objectives of the activist groups have become not only the protection of urban areas, as has been described in previous works on urban activity in St. Petersburg (Gladarev 2012, Clement 2013, Miryasova, Demidov 2010, Tykanova, Khokhlova 2014,
Load more

Recommended publications
  • From Traditional to Online Media: Best Practices and Perspectives
    From traditional to online media: Best practices and perspectives 14th Central Asia Media Conference Ashgabat, Turkmenistan 5-6 July 2012 The Representative on Freedom of the Media From traditional to online media: Best practices and perspectives/Ed. By M. Stone; Vienna: OSCE Representative on Freedom of the Media, 2013 - 126 p. From traditional to online media: Best practices and perspectives is a compilation of all presentations given at the 14th Central Asia Media Conference, organized by the Representative’s office, which brought together international and local experts from five Central Asian participating States of the OSCE. This publication is designed to serve as a record of the events of that conference and is intended for journalists, government and regulatory officials and students. The views expressed by the contributing authors in this publication are their own and do not necessarily reflect those of the OSCE Representative on Freedom of the Media. Design: red hot ‘n’ cool, Vienna Editors: Mike Stone and Ilia Dohel Photos: Aman Mehinli © 2013 The Representative on Freedom of the Media Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe 6 Wallnerstrasse A-1010 Vienna Austria Phone: +43-1-51436-6800 Fax: +43-1-51436-6802 e-mail: [email protected] ISBN: 978-92-9234-643-0 From traditional to online media: Best practices and perspectives 14th Central Asia Media Conference Ashgabat, Turkmenistan 5-6 July 2012 The Representative on Freedom of the Media Table of Contents Foreword Ana Karlsreiter and Adilia Daminova 5 Ashgabat Declaration
    [Show full text]
  • Cross Cultural & Strategic Management
    Cross Cultural & Strategic Management The traditional Chinese philosophies in inter-cultural leadership: The case of Chinese expatriate managers in the Dutch context Li Lin, Peter Ping Li, Hein Roelfsema, Article information: To cite this document: Li Lin, Peter Ping Li, Hein Roelfsema, (2018) "The traditional Chinese philosophies in inter-cultural leadership: The case of Chinese expatriate managers in the Dutch context", Cross Cultural & Strategic Management, Vol. 25 Issue: 2, pp.299-336, https://doi.org/10.1108/CCSM-01-2017-0001 Permanent link to this document: https://doi.org/10.1108/CCSM-01-2017-0001 Downloaded on: 24 January 2019, At: 00:53 (PT) References: this document contains references to 102 other documents. The fulltext of this document has been downloaded 1078 times since 2018* Access to this document was granted through an Emerald subscription provided by All users group For Authors If you would like to write for this, or any other Emerald publication, then please use our Emerald for Authors service information about how to choose which publication to write for and submission guidelines are available for all. Please visit www.emeraldinsight.com/authors for more information. About Emerald www.emeraldinsight.com Emerald is a global publisher linking research and practice to the benefit of society. The company manages a portfolio of more than 290 journals and over 2,350 books and book series volumes, as well as providing an extensive range of online products and additional customer resources and services. Emerald is both COUNTER 4 and TRANSFER compliant. The organization is a partner of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and also works with Portico and the LOCKSS initiative for digital archive preservation.
    [Show full text]
  • A Survey of Groups, Individuals, Strategies and Prospects the Russia Studies Centre at the Henry Jackson Society
    The Russian Opposition: A Survey of Groups, Individuals, Strategies and Prospects The Russia Studies Centre at the Henry Jackson Society By Julia Pettengill Foreword by Chris Bryant MP 1 First published in 2012 by The Henry Jackson Society The Henry Jackson Society 8th Floor – Parker Tower, 43-49 Parker Street, London, WC2B 5PS Tel: 020 7340 4520 www.henryjacksonsociety.org © The Henry Jackson Society, 2012 All rights reserved The views expressed in this publication are those of the author and are not necessarily indicative of those of The Henry Jackson Society or its directors Designed by Genium, www.geniumcreative.com ISBN 978-1-909035-01-0 2 About The Henry Jackson Society The Henry Jackson Society: A cross-partisan, British think-tank. Our founders and supporters are united by a common interest in fostering a strong British, European and American commitment towards freedom, liberty, constitutional democracy, human rights, governmental and institutional reform and a robust foreign, security and defence policy and transatlantic alliance. The Henry Jackson Society is a company limited by guarantee registered in England and Wales under company number 07465741 and a charity registered in England and Wales under registered charity number 1140489. For more information about Henry Jackson Society activities, our research programme and public events please see www.henryjacksonsociety.org. 3 CONTENTS Foreword by Chris Bryant MP 5 About the Author 6 About the Russia Studies Centre 6 Acknowledgements 6 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 8 INTRODUCTION 11 CHAPTER
    [Show full text]
  • The Full Cycle of Political Evolution in Russia from Chaotic to Overmanaged Democracy
    The Full Cycle of Political Evolution in Russia From Chaotic to Overmanaged Democracy PONARS Policy Memo No. 413 Nikolay Petrov Carnegie Moscow Center December 2006 In the seven years that President Vladimir Putin has been in power, Russia seems to have regressed politically almost to where it was a decade and a half ago. This is not to say that the Kremlin has been actively fighting against democracy; its decline is a side effect of the strengthening of the state. The rise of democracy in the late 1980s and early 1990s was the result of a weakening of the state, not a strengthening of society. With the state becoming stronger and society still weak, democracy in Russia is also becoming weaker. It is important to understand what of democracy has gone and what, if anything, is still left. After centralizing political reforms were launched in late 2004, the use of the term “managed democracy” to describe Russia’s current political regime no longer makes sense. Out of the many possible terms to replace it, I suggest overmanaged democracy (OMD). This term does not imply that the regime is to be regarded as essentially democratic. Rather, it implies the genesis of a regime that has evolved from former president Boris Yeltsin’s chaotic proto-democracy to managed democracy to the ultimate and final stage of OMD. Nearly all democratic institutions have been weakened under Putin’s rule, including parliament, political parties, independent media, and fair elections. Ultimately, in order for OMD to survive as a political system, it must draw on a well-functioning mechanism that provides for direct communication and feedback between authorities and society.
    [Show full text]
  • On the Neva Embankments
    "Be Abo" company tel.: +7(812)449-77-88 e-mail: [email protected] web.: www.b-abo.ru On the Neva embankments “On the Neva embankments” route is an informative walk, which includes the most famous sights of Saint-Petersburg. You will visit the main square of the city, the Hermitage, the Summer Garden. Then you will cross the Neva River by the Trinity Bridge and continue your captivating route. Хотите прогуляться по этому маршруту с гидом? “BeAbo” - индивидуальные экскурсии в городах и странах мира. www.b-abo.ru 1 Hermitage Museum Dvortsovaya Ploshchad', 2 (812) 710-90-79 Admiralteyskaya, Gostiny Dvor, Nevskiy Prospekt www.hermitagemuseum.org/html_E 59.939719,30.314593 2 ч. Hermitage is the former residence of the Russian emperors, the biggest museum in Russia, the main point of interest in Saint-Petersburg. Admission fee Entrance ticket - 700 RUR to the Main Museum Complex and the branches (the Main Museum Complex, the General Staff Building, Winter Palace of Peter the Great, Menshikov Palace, the Museum of the Imperial Porcelain Factory). The most well-known sights - Must see! The State Hermitage is the main sight in the city. Every tourist, who comes here, wants to see its unique collection. It is possible to visit the Hermitage in terms of an independent trip, as well as a part of the sightseeing tour. Also in the Hermitage there are a lot of thematic excursions for adults and kids, events and lectures are held. In addition, there is a service of audio guide is available (deposit needed). The sights - record-holders The State Hermitage is in the list of the biggest museums in the whole world.
    [Show full text]
  • The Internet in Russia: the Cradle of Civil Society
    OswcOMMentary issue 72 | 21.03.2012 | ceNTRe fOR eAsTeRN sTudies The internet in Russia: the cradle of civil society Jadwiga Rogoża NTARy Me In the last decade, along with economic and technological growth, ces cOM Russia has seen a dynamic development of the internet. Today the net is an everyday tool of work, information and entertainment for 40% of Russians – the most educated, active and affluent part of the society. tudies The spread of the internet (known in Russia as the Runet) has, in turn, s brought about significant political and social consequences. With the politi- cal and social sphere in Russia strictly controlled by the government, most astern of this activity has moved to cyberspace. The internet has become an alter- e native to the state-controlled media, a site for the free exchange of views and a home to numerous social initiatives. In this way, it has become a school of citizenship for Russians, and a kind of ‘test tube’ that has spawned social entre for and political activity. This activity went beyond cyberspace in the election c period in 2011/2012, and turned into massive street protests. The potential of the internet has also been used by the Russian govern- ment, both to shape public opinion (via loyal online media) and to monitor NTARy Me civil initiatives, especially opposition ones. The state has many instruments of technical control and supervision of the internet and its users’ activity. This control was used in the election period 2011/2012, when selected ces cOM sites were blocked and pressure exerted on independent websites.
    [Show full text]
  • Comparative Planning Systems and Cultures | University College London
    09/29/21 BENVGPL6: Comparative Planning Systems and Cultures | University College London BENVGPL6: Comparative Planning View Online Systems and Cultures 1 Sanyal B. Introduction Chapter. In: Comparative planning cultures. New York: : Routledge 2005. 2 Gielen DM, Tasan-Kok T. Flexibility in Planning and the Consequences for Public-value Capturing in UK, Spain and the Netherlands. European Planning Studies 2010;18 :1097–131. doi:10.1080/09654311003744191 3 Rozee L. A new vision for planning – There must be a better way? Planning Theory & Practice 2014;15:124–38. doi:10.1080/14649357.2013.873231 4 Colomb C, Tomaney J. Territorial Politics, Devolution and Spatial Planning in the UK: Results, Prospects, Lessons. Planning Practice & Research 2016;31:1–22. doi:10.1080/02697459.2015.1081337 5 Arbaci S. Ethnic Segregation, Housing Systems and Welfare Regimes in Europe. European Journal of Housing Policy 2007;7:401–33. doi:10.1080/14616710701650443 6 1/3 09/29/21 BENVGPL6: Comparative Planning Systems and Cultures | University College London Fainstein S. Chapter 2 ‘Land Value Capture and Justice’. In: Value capture and land policies . Cambridge, Mass: : Lincoln Institute of Land Policy 2012. 7 Hirt S. Home, Sweet Home: American Residential Zoning in Comparative Perspective. Journal of Planning Education and Research 2013;33:292–309. doi:10.1177/0739456X13494242 8 Blomley N. Land use, planning, and the "difficult character of property”. Planning Theory & Practice 2016;:1–14. doi:10.1080/14649357.2016.1179336 9 Chapter ‘State and urban space in Brazil: from modernist planning to democratic interventions’ in Global assemblages: technology, politics, and ethics as anthropological problems.
    [Show full text]
  • Comparative Urban Land Use Planningcomparative Land Urban
    Comparative Urban LandComparative Planning Use ‘This book draws on a remarkable range of empirical cases and urban plans from all over the world to present a series of sharply delineated lessons about best practice approaches to land-use control in cities. Essential reading for anyone concerned with how to make the cities of the twenty- first century work smoothly and effectively in the public interest.’ Allen J. Scott, Distinguished Research Professor, University of California, Los Angeles Comparative Urban Land Use Planning The land use planning systems of the world are remarkably similar. Yet real urban problems – crime, drug abuse, inequality, alienation – are not easily solved by a traditional strategic planning process. Planning regimes are therefore under constant pressure to adjust, but often with a lack of knowledge of how things might be done better. Even though each regime arises in a cultural milieu, international trends can be spotted and best practices discerned. This work is scholarly and emotional, revealing a great love of cities and expressing a call for the development of relevant, more grounded, land use planning. Leslie A. Stein is Adjunct Professor of Urban Planning at the University of Sydney, Sydney School of Architecture, Design and Planning. He was Best Practice recently Senior Fellow at the Global Center for Environmental Legal Studies at Pace University in New York and Visiting Scholar at the Sabin Center for Climate Change Law at Columbia University. He was Chief Counsel to the Sydney Metropolitan Strategy and his books include Principles of Planning Law. Professor Stein is also a certified psychoanalyst and a graduate of Stein the C.G.
    [Show full text]
  • Central Petersburg
    "Be Abo" company tel.: +7(812)449-77-88 e-mail: [email protected] web.: www.b-abo.ru Central Petersburg All the tourists come to the “Northern capital” for the first time should visit Nevsky Prospect to feel all the greatness of the city, all its beauty. “Central Petersburg” route is an informative walk along the main historical, cultural and architectural thoroughfare of Saint-Petersburg. All the famous sights are located exactly nearby Nevsky Prospect. This walking excursion will be perfect for active and curious travelers. For those who do not like to familiarize with unknown city through the bus window. For those who love to walk along the antique roadway and come into adjoining old buildings and parks. Who takes pictures of the monuments and different things to take home the most vivid and interesting memories about the city. Хотите прогуляться по этому маршруту с гидом? “BeAbo” - индивидуальные экскурсии в городах и странах мира. www.b-abo.ru 1 Admiralty Admiralteyskiy Proyezd, 1 Admiralteyskaya, Nevskiy Prospekt, Gostiny Dvor 59.937515,30.308787 0 ч. 20 мин. The Admiralty takes one of the most important places in the military history of the city and country because it is the birthplace of the Russian Navy. It is the complex of buildings where the Main Admiralty of Russian Empire used to be situated. Nowadays it is a monument of the naval history. The Admiralty was built in 1704-1706 by the design of architect I. Korobov. The building is decorated with different sculptures, which images are connected with the marine legends and myths.
    [Show full text]
  • St. Petersburg Russia Do Something Special
    5 Balkanskaya sq, office 1101, 192281, St. Petersburg Russia Do something special Phone: +7 (812) 386-7-888 Emergency line: +7 (981) 755-86-16 E-mail: [email protected] Skype: do.travel www.do-travel.world Do it with us 3 About “Do Travel” 4 We're a company which has been inspired by the grandeur and beauty of Russia, and we're eager to share this beauty with the rest of the world. We're a company 8 which is proud of what it's doing. We've been in the tourist market about 8 years, and we're ready to apply all our 10 experience, to offer our clients the high-quality service and reassurance of safety and security during their journey. 12 Our tours are developed to make you feel comfortable, and our accredited guides will help you experience the enigmatic beauty which is hidden under Russia's veil of mystery. 13 Our day-and-night emergency line will keep you from finding yourself in an uncomfortable situation in the country that we call our home.We're sure that every 13 client is worth an individual approach. We'll help every client to understand what exactly he or she wants to see during 14 their journey around the boundless territory of Russia. While traveling with “Do Travel”, you can feel confident that your journey will be 15 interesting, well designed and full of positive experiences and impressions. 16 Journey to Russia – it's a special event in life of each person, because this country so big and so gorgeous.
    [Show full text]
  • History of City Planning Institution: University of California Date Offered: Fall 2007
    This syllabus courtesy of the Vernacular Architecture Forum Syllabus Exchange A collaborative project of the Vernacular Architecture Forum www.vafweb.org/resources/syllabi.html _____________________________________________________________________ instructor: Michael Teitz, James Buckley and Greg Newmark course title: History of City Planning institution: University of California date offered: Fall 2007 posted date: June 2008 stable URL: www.vafweb.org/resources/syllabi/teitzetal.pdf _____________________________________________________________________ This document is provided for non-commercial, informational purposes only. Department of City and Regional Planning CP200 – Fall 2007 University of California, Berkeley Michael Teitz/James Buckley/Greg Newmark CP 200: HISTORY OF CITY PLANNING (Tu/Th 11-12:30, 108 Wurster; Discussion Sections: TBA) Introduction This course covers the evolution of the ideals, profession, and practice of city planning from the 19th to the 21st Century. It explores the changing relationships between city and regional planning and broader historical trends in the light of changing ideas about who cities are for; about urban problem-solving; about how urban settlements should be organized and re-organized; about the relationships between the built and natural environments; and about the effects of urban form and organization on society. The focus is substantially but not entirely upon the American experience. Requirements 1. Attendance and participation in discussion: 10% 2. Mid-term exam: 15% 3. Research Paper: History of a Planning Idea, Program, or Movement: 50% 4. Final exam: 25% Readings 1. Peter Hall. Cities of Tomorrow: An Intellectual History of Urban Planning and Design in the Twentieth Century. (3rd edition) New York: Basil Blackwell, 2002. 2. Dolores Hayden. Building Suburbia: Greenfields and Urban Growth, 1820-2000.
    [Show full text]
  • Viennese Planning Culture: Understanding Change and Continuity Through the Hauptbahnhof
    VIENNESE PLANNING CULTURE: UNDERSTANDING CHANGE AND CONTINUITY THROUGH THE HAUPTBAHNHOF by VERONICA RAFFAELA SOPHIE REISS B.A., The University of British Columbia, 2014 A THESIS SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF ARTS IN PLANNING in THE FACULTY OF GRADUATE AND POSTDOCTORAL STUDIES (PLANNING) THE UNIVERSITY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA (VANCOUVER) AUGUST, 2017 © Veronica Raffaela Sophie Reiss, 2017 Abstract Today, cities across the globe face a multitude of similar challenges – climate change, new disruptive technologies, new conceptions of both labour and capital, and mass migration, among others; simultaneously, planning scholars are continually acknowledging the diversity of both the conception and practice of planning around the world. As such, the concept of planning cultures has grown in recognition and importance. While the literature around planning cultures grows, few area specific studies have been completed. This thesis seeks to contribute to the understanding of the planning culture of Vienna, Austria, through an exploration of the history of urban planning in Vienna and through a contemporary case study of the planning of the Vienna Hauptbahnhof project, the recently completed central train station. This thesis seeks to expand the understanding of planning processes, practices, and outcomes in Vienna, a city world renowned for its affordable and social housing, as well as for its high quality of life. ii Lay Summary This thesis seeks to expand the understanding of spatial planning processes, practices, and outcomes in Vienna, Austria, a city world renowned for its affordable and social housing, as well as for its high quality of life. This is done through an exploration of the history of urban planning in Vienna and through a case study of the planning process of the recently completed Vienna central train station.
    [Show full text]