King's College, Cambridge

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

King's College, Cambridge King’s College, Cambridge Annual Report 2015 Annual Report 2015 Contents The Provost 2 The Fellowship 5 Major Promotions, Appointments or Awards 14 Undergraduates at King’s 17 Graduates at King’s 24 Tutorial 27 Research 39 Library and Archives 42 Chapel 45 Choir 50 Bursary 54 Staff 58 Development 60 Appointments & Honours 66 Obituaries 68 Information for Non Resident Members 235 Consequences of Austerity’. This prize is to be awarded yearly and it is hoped The Provost that future winners will similarly give a public lecture in the College. King’s is presently notable for both birds and bees. The College now boasts a number of beehives and an active student beekeeping society. King’s 2 2015 has been a very special year for the bees have been sent to orchards near Cambridge to help pollinate the fruit. 3 THE PROVOST College. Five hundred years ago, the fabric The College’s own orchard, featuring rare and heritage varieties, is now of the Chapel was completed; or rather, the under construction in the field to the south of Garden Hostel. On a larger College stopped paying the masons who did scale, a pair of peregrine falcons has taken up residence on one of the the work in 1515. This past year has been full THE PROVOST Chapel pinnacles and they have been keeping pigeon numbers down. It is of commemorative events to celebrate this a pity that they are unable also to deal with the flocks of Canada Geese that anniversary; a series of six outstanding are now a serious nuisance all along the Backs. concerts in the Chapel featuring the music of each century, exhibitions, lectures and a There have been no extensive building projects within the College in the last multi-media event marrying materials year, though there has been a major refurbishment of Grasshopper Lodge Professor Mike Proctor inspired by the world of Samuel Beckett. In (the graduate hostel on Grange Road), and work has commenced on the August, the Xu Zhimo Poetry festival new Joint Colleges Boathouse funded by a generous gift from Robin Boyle. featured a remarkable evening of Chinese and contemporary English In the Front Court, the stonework of Gibbs’ has been cleaned, primarily as poetry in the Hall and, more recently and as part of the China-UK cultural a conservation measure. The soft glow of the Portland stone now provides exchange year, King’s hosted the Kunqu Opera House of Jiangsu even more of a counterpoint to the Chapel and Hall, and its improved Performing Arts Group (China). appearance gives great pleasure. It is hoped that more conservation cleaning will be possible over the next few years. Three books relating to the anniversary have been published. The first is an illustrated book of essays about the art, architecture, people and music of Richard Lloyd Morgan retired as Chaplain in July after twelve years’ the Chapel. The second is an excellent short history of the College written outstanding service. Apart from his day-to-day work he also had twice to by my predecessor, Ross Harrison, as a modern replacement for the similar take on the role of Acting Dean in very difficult circumstances. To mark sized text by Christopher Morris. The third, which has just appeared, is a Richard’s distinguished tenure, the College has created the special position scholarly edition of John Saltmarsh's “King’s College Chapel: A History and of Emeritus Chaplain and made him the first, and possibly the only ever Commentary”; it previously had been available only in manuscript form to holder. In his stead we have welcomed Andrew Hammond, also an visitors of King's College Archive Centre. [Copies of all three are available accomplished singer. Originally an undergraduate at Clare, he more recently for sale in the Library and from the King’s Visitor Centre.] (in 2006/7) completed an MPhil at King’s when he was also at Westcott House, and now comes to us from the parish of St Mary’s Willesden. Another major event in the Chapel was a lecture given by Amartya Sen, Nobel laureate and first winner of the Charleston-EFG John Maynard As far as our academic performance goes, we remain at the centre of the Keynes Prize. The Ante-Chapel was full to hear him speak on ‘The Economic Baxter tables overall, but once more score well on “value added”, and so come much higher up in the final year rankings. In other words, our students show a systematic improvement each year that they are with us, The Fellowship as has been the case for many years now. We are determined to continue to seek out talented young people from backgrounds that have not been traditionally associated with Oxbridge. The admissions interview is an 4 essential tool in the portfolio of information that we gather on each New Life Fellows 5 THE FELLOWSHIP applicant for determining which of our applicants will flourish in the Dr John Young special academic atmosphere we provide. However changes are afoot in the public examination system that will influence the way we operate; AS Fellows moving on: The following left their Fellowships in King’s in the last year: THE PROVOST levels are to be downgraded and will no longer be useful as a pre-A level performance predictor. For this reason, the University is debating the • Ross Harrison introduction of its own written examination. While such an exam would not resemble the old CCE papers, there is a slight feeling of déjà vu, and a • Pau Figueras worry that the change would tip the scales towards intensive preparation • Lorna Finlayson and away from true talent. We await developments. • Felix Fischer Finally I am able to report that in another first for the College, the ‘world’s • Richard Merrill tallest Lego tower’ will be constructed on Scholars’ Piece in the next 18 months. This will be a joint project between an engineering firm, • Flora Willson University staff and students. At a final height of 37 metres it will certainly, though briefly, will be a Cambridge landmark. Look out for photos on the New Honorary Fellow College website! JoHN eLiot GardiNer Having grown up on a farm in Dorset, in 1962 Gardiner won a history Mike Proctor scholarship to King's where he became secretary of both KCMS and the Ten Club and rowed in the College first eight. Finding himself torn between his competing interests in history, music, the Middle East (having worked for UNRWA for several months before coming up to King's) and sustainable agriculture and forestry, Gardiner was granted an additional exploratory year between Parts I & II of the History Tripos by the College on the recommendation of his Director of Studies, Edmund Leach (later Provost). Ostensibly reading Classical Arabic and medieval Spanish, in practice Gardiner spent a large part of that year researching and preparing a new edition of Monteverdi's 'Vespers of the Blessed Virgin' (1610), a work then almost totally unknown in Cambridge. He recruited a choir and orchestra and trained them in this unfamiliar italianate style for a single performance militarily supreme power, despite having previously regarded armed he conducted in the Chapel on 5th March 1964. supremacy as imperialistic. It turned out to be the epiphany he was looking for: it led to his decision to Stephen occasionally writes reviews and commentary for The Nation and become a full-time musician, studying first with Thurston Dart at King's other journalistic venues. He is also a very amateur photographer. In his 6 College London and then with Nadia Boulanger in Paris, and it marked the spare time, he thinks up comedy ideas, talks about them, and fails to carry 7 THE FELLOWSHIP founding of the world-famous Monteverdi Choir. Gardiner traces his them out. subsequent recognition as one of the foremost pioneers of the Early Music movement to those seminal years in which the College encouraged him to SurabHi raNGaNatHaN (Fellow, Law) unite two of his strongest passions – music and history. His return visit to Surabhi Ranganathan joins the Faculty of Law and King’s College from THE FELLOWSHIP King's Chapel on Ash Wednesday last year marked the 50th anniversary to Warwick University. She was previously a JRF at King’s and the Lauterpacht the very day since he first conducted the Monteverdi 'Vespers' there as a 20- Centre for International Law. Her first monograph, Strategically Created year old undergraduate. Treaty Conflicts and the Politics of International Law, was published earlier this year by CUP; she is also assistant editor of the Cambridge Companion to Somehow in between the constraints and demands of a stellar career, both International Law (CUP 2012). Surabhi has studied at Cambridge (PhD, St. as artistic director of his own ensembles and as a guest conductor of the John’s, Gates scholar), NYU (LLM, Vanderbilt scholar) and National Law world's leading orchestras and opera houses, Gardiner has found time to School of India University, Bangalore (BA LLB Hons), worked at NYU’s pursue one of his other passions – running a successful organic farm and Institute for International Law and Justice in association with two major mixed-species forest in North Dorset. grant-funded projects on regulating private military companies and global administrative law, interned with UNICEF and UNHCR, and clerked at the Recently appointed President of the leading research institute in Bach Supreme Court of India. For four years the assistant editor of the British studies (the Bach Archiv in Leipzig) Gardiner's portrait of the composer, Yearbook of International Law, she serves on the editorial or academic 'Music in the Castle of Heaven', was published in 2013.
Recommended publications
  • CHURCHOF ENGLAND Newspaper
    THE ORIGINAL CHURCH NEWSPAPER. ESTABLISHED IN 1828 Celebrating Metropolitan THE Anthony P10 CHURCHOF ENGLAND Newspaper NOW AVAILABLE ON NEWSSTAND Standing together with FRIDAY, OCTOBER 17, 2014 No: 6250 the persecuted, p11 Traditionalist group reaffirms its commitment to the biblical stance on marriage Reform rethinking planned boycott THE ANGLICAN evangelical In addition, Reform claimed, the shared conversations in the ‘shared disagreement’ on the can respond pastorally to indi- group, Reform, is revising their that the objectives would also Church of England on Sexuality, issue of same-sex relationships, vidual needs. But the scripture’s commitment to the shared con- require participants: “To accept Scripture and Mission states and accepting that there is teachings on sexuality are not versations in the Church of Eng- an outcome in which the that one of the two main objec- every possibility of a shared an abstract concept we’ve land on Sexuality, Scripture and Church moves from its present, tives of the shared conversation conversation being set up, invented. Mission. biblical, understanding of mar- is “clarifying how we (CofE) can whilst conceding to terms of ref- “We are worried that the mes- Reform released a statement riage to one where we accom- most effectively be a missionary erence with predetermined out- sage being sent out in individual arguing that a second revision modate two separate beliefs, church in a changing culture comes. parishes across the UK is that of the objectives of the shared with one part of the Church call- around sexuality” and the other Mr Thomas said: “We accept we can affirm the faith, whilst conversation following the Col- ing for repentance over sexual is “to clarify the implications of the authority of the scripture disagreeing on sexuality,” he lege of Bishops meeting in Sep- sin and another declaring God’s what it means for the Church of and we are looking for ways we told us.
    [Show full text]
  • Mccrimmon Mccrimmon
    ISSUE #14 APRIL 2010 FREE! NOT FOR RESALE MARC PLATT chats about Point of Entry RICHARD EARL on his roles in Doctor Who and Sherlock Holmes MAGGIE staBLES is back in the studio as Evelyn Smythe! RETURN OF THE McCRIMMON FRazER HINEs Is baCk IN THE TaRdIs! PLUS: Sneak Previews • Exclusive Photos • Interviews and more! EDITORIAL Well, as you read this, Holmes and the Ripper will I do adore it. But it is all-consuming. And it reminded finally be out. As I write this, I have not long finished me of how hard the work is and how dedicated all our doing the sound design, which made me realize one sound designers are. There’s quite an army of them thing in particular: that being executive producer of now. When I became exec producer we only had a Big Finish really does mean that I don’t have time to do handful, but over the last couple of years I have been the sound design for a whole double-CD production. on a recruitment drive, and now we have some great That makes me a bit sad. But what really lifts my spirits new people with us, including Daniel Brett, Howard is listening to the music, which is, at this very moment, Carter, Jamie Robertson and Kelly and Steve at Fool being added by Jamie Robertson. Only ten more Circle Productions, all joining the great guys we’ve been minutes of music to go… although I’m just about to working with for years. Sound design is a very special, download the bulk of Part Two in a about half an hour’s crazy world in which you find yourself listening to every time.
    [Show full text]
  • George Harrison
    COPYRIGHT 4th Estate An imprint of HarperCollinsPublishers 1 London Bridge Street London SE1 9GF www.4thEstate.co.uk This eBook first published in Great Britain by 4th Estate in 2020 Copyright © Craig Brown 2020 Cover design by Jack Smyth Cover image © Michael Ochs Archives/Handout/Getty Images Craig Brown asserts the moral right to be identified as the author of this work A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library All rights reserved under International and Pan-American Copyright Conventions. By payment of the required fees, you have been granted the non-exclusive, non-transferable right to access and read the text of this e-book on-screen. No part of this text may be reproduced, transmitted, down-loaded, decompiled, reverse engineered, or stored in or introduced into any information storage and retrieval system, in any form or by any means, whether electronic or mechanical, now known or hereinafter invented, without the express written permission of HarperCollins. Source ISBN: 9780008340001 Ebook Edition © April 2020 ISBN: 9780008340025 Version: 2020-03-11 DEDICATION For Frances, Silas, Tallulah and Tom EPIGRAPHS In five-score summers! All new eyes, New minds, new modes, new fools, new wise; New woes to weep, new joys to prize; With nothing left of me and you In that live century’s vivid view Beyond a pinch of dust or two; A century which, if not sublime, Will show, I doubt not, at its prime, A scope above this blinkered time. From ‘1967’, by Thomas Hardy (written in 1867) ‘What a remarkable fifty years they
    [Show full text]
  • Sports Guide 2019-20 Clubs • Facilities • Competitions • Membership Contents
    Sports Guide 2019-20 Clubs • Facilities • Competitions • Membership Contents 1 Welcome - 9 Dance 16 Mountaineering 23 Shooting – Rifle Nick Brooking Dancesport Netball Shooting – Small-bore 2 Sports Service Eton Fives Orienteering Ski and Snowboard Contacts Fencing Polo Squash Rackets 3 Competitions 10 Football (Men) 18 Pool and Snooker 24 Swimming 4 American Football Football (Women) Powerlifting Table Tennis Archery Gliding Rackets Taekwondo Athletics Golf Rambling Lawn Tennis Australian Rules 11 Gymnastics 19 Real Tennis 25 Touch Rugby 5 Automobile Handball Riding Trampoline Badminton Hillwalking Rowing (Men) Triathlon Basketball (Men) Hockey Rowing (Women) Ultimate Basketball (Women) 13 Ice Hockey (Men) 20 Rowing – (Lightweight 26 Volleyball 6 Boxing Ice Hockey (Women) Men) Water Polo Canoe Jiu-Jitsu Rugby Fives Windsurfing Cheerleading Judo Rugby League – see Sailing Chess 14 Karate Rugby Union (M) Yachting 8 Cricket (Men) Kendo 21 Rugby Union (W) Disability Mulitsport Cricket (Women) Kickboxing Sailing 28 Sports Facilities Cross County Korfball Shooting 29 Support & Services Cycling 15 Lacrosse (Men) – Clay Pigeon Lacrosse (Mixed) Shooting – Revolver and Pistol Lacrosse (Women) Modern Pentathlon Welcome to the University of Cambridge, and I hope you find this guide to our University Sports Clubs helpful. With over 75 Sports Clubs and Societies, Cambridge offers you a diverse range of competitive and recreational sport. Whether your ambition is to perform at the highest level or to start playing a sport you have not played before, there will be great opportunities for you during your time here. Many University teams compete against their peers at other Universities in BUCS competitions throughout the season; some play in National or Regional leagues and there are also possibilities for individual representation.
    [Show full text]
  • Th E Year in Review
    2012 – 2013 T HE Y EAR IN R EVIEW C AMBRIDGE T HEOLOGICAL F EDERATION Contents Page Foreword from the Bishop of Ely 3 Principal’s Welcome 4 Highlights of the Year 7 The Year in Pictures 7 Cambridge Theological Federation 40th anniversary 8 Mission, Placements and Exchanges: 10 • Easter Mission 10 USA Exchanges 11 • Yale Divinity School 11 • Sewanee: The University of the South 15 • Hong Kong 16 • Cape Town 17 • Wittenberg Exchange 19 • India 20 • Little Gidding 21 Prayer Groups 22 Theological Conversations 24 From Westcott to Williams: Sacramental Socialism and the Renewal of Anglican Social Thought 24 Living and Learning in the Federation 27 Chaplaincy 29 • ‘Ministry where people are’: a view of chaplaincy 29 A day in the life... • Bill Cave 32 • Simon Davies 33 • Stuart Hallam 34 • Jennie Hogan 35 • Ben Rhodes 36 New Developments 38 Westcott Foundation Programme of Events 2013-2014 38 Obituaries and Appreciations 40 Remembering Westcott House 48 Ember List 2013 49 Staff contacts 50 Members of the Governing Council 2012 – 2013 51 Editor Heather Kilpatrick, Communications Officer 2012 – 2013 THE YEAR IN REVIEW Foreword from the Bishop of Ely It is a great privilege to have become the Chair of the Council of“ Westcott House. As a former student myself, I am conscious just how much the House has changed through the years to meet the changing demands of ministry and mission in the Church of England, elsewhere in the Anglican Communion and in the developing ecumenical partnerships which the Federation embodies. We have been at the forefront in the deliberations which have led to the introduction of the Common Awards.
    [Show full text]
  • Pan Macmillan AUTUMN CATALOGUE 2021 PUBLICITY CONTACTS
    Pan Macmillan AUTUMN CATALOGUE 2021 PUBLICITY CONTACTS General enquiries [email protected] Alice Dewing FREELANCE [email protected] Anna Pallai Amy Canavan [email protected] [email protected] Caitlin Allen Camilla Elworthy [email protected] [email protected] Elinor Fewster Emma Bravo [email protected] [email protected] Emma Draude Gabriela Quattromini [email protected] [email protected] Emma Harrow Grace Harrison [email protected] [email protected] Jacqui Graham Hannah Corbett [email protected] [email protected] Jamie-Lee Nardone Hope Ndaba [email protected] [email protected] Laura Sherlock Jess Duffy [email protected] [email protected] Ruth Cairns Kate Green [email protected] [email protected] Philippa McEwan [email protected] Rosie Wilson [email protected] Siobhan Slattery [email protected] CONTENTS MACMILLAN PAN MANTLE TOR PICADOR MACMILLAN COLLECTOR’S LIBRARY BLUEBIRD ONE BOAT MACMILLAN Nine Lives Danielle Steel Nine Lives is a powerful love story by the world’s favourite storyteller, Danielle Steel. Nine Lives is a thought-provoking story of lost love and new beginnings, by the number one bestseller Danielle Steel. After a carefree childhood, Maggie Kelly came of age in the shadow of grief. Her father, a pilot, died when she was nine. Maggie saw her mother struggle to put their lives back together. As the family moved from one city to the next, her mother warned her about daredevil men and to avoid risk at all cost. Following her mother’s advice, and forgoing the magic of first love with a high-school boyfriend who she thought too wild, Maggie married a good, dependable man.
    [Show full text]
  • Download 1 File
    GHT tie 17, United States Code) r reproductions of copyrighted Ttain conditions. In addition, the works by means of various ents, and proclamations. iw, libraries and archives are reproduction. One of these 3r reproduction is not to be "used :holarship, or research." If a user opy or reproduction for purposes able for copyright infringement. to accept a copying order if, in its involve violation of copyright law. CTbc Minivers U^ of Cbicatjo Hibrcmes LIGHTFOOT OF DURHAM LONDON Cambridge University Press FETTER LANE NEW YORK TORONTO BOMBAY CALCUTTA MADRAS Macmillan TOKYO Maruzen Company Ltd All rights reserved Phot. Russell BISHOP LIGHTFOOT IN 1879 LIGHTFOOT OF DURHAM Memories and Appreciations Collected and Edited by GEORGE R. D.D. EDEN,M Fellow Pembroke Honorary of College, Cambridge formerly Bishop of Wakefield and F. C. MACDONALD, M.A., O.B.E. Honorary Canon of Durham Cathedral Rector of Ptirleigb CAMBRIDGE AT THE UNIVERSITY PRESS 1933 First edition, September 1932 Reprinted December 1932 February PRINTED IN GREAT BRITAIN 1037999 IN PIAM MEMORIAM PATRIS IN DEO HONORATISSIMI AMANTISSIMI DESIDERATISSIMI SCHEDULAS HAS QUALESCUNQUE ANNOS POST QUADRAGINTA FILII QUOS VOCITABAT DOMUS SUAE IMPAR TRIBUTUM DD BISHOP LIGHTFOOT S BOOKPLATE This shews the Bishop's own coat of arms impaled^ with those of the See, and the Mitre set in a Coronet, indicating the Palatinate dignity of Durham. Though the Bookplate is not the Episcopal seal its shape recalls the following extract from Fuller's Church 5 : ense History (iv. 103) 'Dunelmia sola, judicat et stola. "The Bishop whereof was a Palatine, or Secular Prince, and his seal in form resembleth Royalty in the roundness thereof and is not oval, the badge of plain Episcopacy." CONTENTS .
    [Show full text]
  • Sidney's Vomit Bug Spreads
    Friday February 27th 2009 e Independent Cambridge Student Newspaper since 1947 Issue no 692 | varsity.co.uk »p9 Comment »Centrefold Special pull-out »p17 Arts Orwell’s The Dial: exclusive four-page Patrick Wolf: a overrated preview issue inside very odd man Sidney’s vomit ZING TSJENG bug spreads Students warned as other Colleges hit by norovirus Caedmon Tunstall-Behens open. Following a closure as punishment for non-Sidney students vomiting in the e outbreak of a vomiting bug in Sid- toilets, one bar worker commented, “ is ney Sussex has spread to other colleges, week it’s been the Sidney-ites themselves the University has con rmed. who have been having vomit problems, Although the University declined to albeit of quite a di erent nature.” say which Colleges have been a ected, e viral infection induces projectile Varsity understands that cases have also vomiting, fever, nausea, fever and diar- been reported at Queens’, Clare, Newn- rhoea. It can be incubated for 48 hours ham and Homerton. before its symptoms becoming appar- A spokesman said: “ ere are a few ent, and ends 48 hours a er the last isolated cases in other Colleges. It has vomit or bout. been con rmed that most of the indi- Transmission occurs through contact viduals a ected had had contact with with contaminated surfaces, body-to- Sidney people over the last few days.” body contact, orally or from inhalation e news comes a er Sidney was in of infected particles. lockdown for over a week with just over Sidney called in the city council’s en- 80 students, Fellows and catering sta vironmental health o cers at noon last debilitated by a suspected outbreak of Friday.
    [Show full text]
  • Urban Pamphleteer #2 Regeneration Realities
    Regeneration Realities Urban Pamphleteer 2 p.1 Duncan Bowie# p.3 Emma Dent Coad p.5 Howard Read p.6 Loretta Lees, Just Space, The London Tenants’ Federation and SNAG (Southwark Notes Archives Group) p.11 David Roberts and Andrea Luka Zimmerman p.13 Alexandre Apsan Frediani, Stephanie Butcher, and Paul Watt p.17 Isaac Marrero- Guillamón p.18 Alberto Duman p.20 Martine Drozdz p.22 Phil Cohen p.23 Ben Campkin p.24 Michael Edwards p.28 isik.knutsdotter Urban PamphleteerRunning Head Ben Campkin, David Roberts, Rebecca Ross We are delighted to present the second issue of Urban Pamphleteer In the tradition of radical pamphleteering, the intention of this series is to confront key themes in contemporary urban debate from diverse perspectives, in a direct and accessible – but not reductive – way. The broader aim is to empower citizens, and inform professionals, researchers, institutions and policy- makers, with a view to positively shaping change. # 2 London: Regeneration Realities The term ‘regeneration’ has recently been subjected to much criticism as a pervasive metaphor applied to varied and often problematic processes of urban change. Concerns have focused on the way the concept is used as shorthand in sidestepping important questions related to, for example, gentrification and property development. Indeed, it is an area where policy and practice have been disconnected from a rigorous base in research and evidence. With many community groups affected by regeneration evidently feeling disenfranchised, there is a strong impetus to propose more rigorous approaches to researching and doing regeneration. The Greater London Authority has also recently opened a call for the public to comment on what regeneration is, and feedback on what its priorities should be.
    [Show full text]
  • King's College, Cambridge
    King’s College, Cambridge Annual Report 2014 Annual Report 2014 Contents The Provost 2 The Fellowship 5 Major Promotions, Appointments or Awards 18 Undergraduates at King’s 21 Graduates at King’s 26 Tutorial 36 Research 47 Library and Archives 51 Chapel 54 Choir 57 Bursary 62 Staff 65 Development 67 Appointments & Honours 72 Obituaries 77 Information for Non Resident Members 251 While this incremental work can be accomplished within the College’s The Provost maintenance budget, more major but highly desirable projects, like the refurbishment of the Gibbs staircases and the roof and services in Bodley’s will have to rely on support apart from that provided by the endowment. 2 I write this at the end of my first year at The new Tutorial team under Perveez Mody and Rosanna Omitowoju has 3 THE PROVOST King’s. I have now done everything once begun its work. There are now five personal Tutors as well as specialist and am about to attend Alumni Weekend Tutors, essentially reviving a system that was in place until a few years ago. reunion dinners for the second time. It has It is hoped that the new system will reduce the pastoral pressure on the been a most exciting learning experience THE PROVOST Directors of Studies, and provide more effective support for students. getting to know the College. While I have not had much time for my own research I In the Chapel we have said farewell to our Dean, Jeremy Morris. Jeremy have had the opportunity to learn about came to the College from Trinity Hall in 2010, and after only too short a others’ interests, and have been impressed time returns to his former College as its Master.
    [Show full text]
  • Can Machines Think? the Controversy That Led to the Turing Test, 1946-1950
    Can machines think? The controversy that led to the Turing test, 1946-1950 Bernardo Gonçalves1 Abstract Turing’s much debated test has turned 70 and is still fairly controversial. His 1950 paper is seen as a complex and multi-layered text and key questions remain largely unanswered. Why did Turing choose learning from experience as best approach to achieve machine intelligence? Why did he spend several years working with chess-playing as a task to illustrate and test for machine intelligence only to trade it off for conversational question-answering later in 1950? Why did Turing refer to gender imitation in a test for machine intelligence? In this article I shall address these questions directly by unveiling social, historical and epistemological roots of the so-called Turing test. I will draw attention to a historical fact that has been scarcely observed in the secondary literature so far, namely, that Turing's 1950 test came out of a controversy over the cognitive capabilities of digital computers, most notably with physicist and computer pioneer Douglas Hartree, chemist and philosopher Michael Polanyi, and neurosurgeon Geoffrey Jefferson. Seen from its historical context, Turing’s 1950 paper can be understood as essentially a reply to a series of challenges posed to him by these thinkers against his view that machines can think. Keywords: Alan Turing, Can machines think?, The imitation game, The Turing test, Mind-machine controversy, History of artificial intelligence. Robin Gandy (1919-1995) was one of Turing’s best friends and his only doctorate student. He received Turing’s mathematical books and papers when Turing died in 1954, and took over from Max Newman in 1963 the task of editing the papers for publication.1 Regarding Turing’s purpose in writing his 1950 paper and sending it for publication, Gandy offered a testimony previously brought forth by Jack Copeland which has not yet been commented about:2 It was intended not so much as a penetrating contribution to philosophy but as propaganda.
    [Show full text]
  • Chiasmic Rhetoric: Alan Turing Between Bodies and Words Patricia Fancher Clemson University, [email protected]
    Clemson University TigerPrints All Dissertations Dissertations 8-2014 Chiasmic Rhetoric: Alan Turing Between Bodies and Words Patricia Fancher Clemson University, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://tigerprints.clemson.edu/all_dissertations Part of the Rhetoric and Composition Commons Recommended Citation Fancher, Patricia, "Chiasmic Rhetoric: Alan Turing Between Bodies and Words" (2014). All Dissertations. 1285. https://tigerprints.clemson.edu/all_dissertations/1285 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Dissertations at TigerPrints. It has been accepted for inclusion in All Dissertations by an authorized administrator of TigerPrints. For more information, please contact [email protected]. CHIASMIC RHETORIC: ALAN TURING BETWEEN BODIES AND WORDS A Dissertation Presented to the Graduate School of Clemson University In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctorate of Philosophy Rhetorics, Communication, and Information Design by Patricia Fancher August 2014 Accepted by: Dr. Steven B. Katz, Committee Chair Dr. Diane Perpich Dr. Cynthia Haynes Dr. D. Travers Scott DISSERTATION ABSTRACT This dissertation analyzes the life and writing of inventor and scientist Alan Turing in order to define and theorize chiasmic relations between bodies and texts. Chiasmic rhetoric, as I develop throughout the dissertation, is the dynamic processes between materials and discourses that interact to construct powerful rhetorical effect, shape bodies, and also compose new knowledges. Throughout the dissertation, I develop chiasmic rhetoric as intersecting bodies and discourse, dynamic and productive, and potentially destabilizing. Turing is an unusual figure for research on bodily rhetoric and embodied knowledge. He is often associated with disembodied knowledge and as his inventions are said to move intelligence towards greater abstraction and away from human bodies.
    [Show full text]