DOCSLIB.ORG

Talking About Peace

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Talking About Peace Talking about Peace The Role of Language in the Resolution of the Conflict in Colombia Maja Lie Opdahl Master Thesis Department of Political Science UNIVERSITY OF OSLO Spring 2018 Word count: 55.040 II "Discourses are the product of power by which hegemonic interpretations are seemingly naturalized and internalized, but also resisted and contested, within the social realm" (Dunn and Neumann, 2016, p.13). III ã Opdahl 2018 Talking about Peace: The Role of Language in the Resolution of the Conflict in Colombia Maja Lie Opdahl http://www.duo.uio.no Print: Grafisk Senter IV V Abstract How was it possible that Colombian politicians found a solution to the conflict in 2016, but which nevertheless was rejected by the people? In this thesis, I analyse the process which ended in a historical peace agreement between the Colombian government and the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia – The People’s Army (FARC-EP) in 2016. The ambition is to understand how the national government has moved discursively from fighting a war on ‘terrorism’ to promoting a political solution to an ‘internal armed conflict’. Theoretically, the thesis draws on poststructuralist discourse analysis to uncover how different constructions of identity (Self/Other) has translated into different national frameworks for peace. The basic premise is that actors interpret the world through language, and that language simultaneously creates, transforms and reproduces versions of the world. Discourses can be seen as structures of meaning that inform how we understand materiality and in simple terms, allow us to make sense of the world. In the extension, discourses produce a bandwidth of possible action and thought that we deem natural or unnatural, legitimate or illegitimate upon the confrontation of a problem. In the thesis, I use discourse analysis to uncover how the Colombian government has defined and portrayed the FARC in the conflict from 2002-2016. The data material constitutes official text, such as speeches, policy programs and official declarations, primarily delimited to the words of the presidents. The empirical analysis shows how military violence was accepted as a natural response to an enemy constructed as a radically different Other under the government of Álvaro Uribe. Further, it demonstrates how a transformation in the representation of the Self coincided with the decrease in ‘otherness’ attached to the FARC. Where the former representation presented the negotiation with terrorists as impossible, transformation has been crucial for the successful initiation of the peace negotiations that were concluded by the Santos administration, 52 years after the conflict broke out. The analysis also demonstrates how some representations persist, how actors manoeuvre within the discourse and have created discursive instability as to what is considered the ‘rightful’ solution to the conflict. This has left the country in a challenging transitional period. VI VII Acknowledgements Writing this thesis, I have learnt that it is not always so obvious where to look or what to look for. In the following, many people have shared their time and thoughts with me. First, a warm thanks to my two supervisors, Øivind Bratberg and Benedicte Bull for good discussions, feedback and support along the way. Second, I extend my gratitude to friends and contacts that supported me with information during my research trip to Bogotá. To my interviewees, who responded on short notice, and played an important role for my understanding of the context and the empirical material: Nubia Rojas, Andrei Gomez-Suarez, Johanna Amaya Panche, Maria Emma Wills Obregon, Juan Esteban Ugarriza Uribe, and two whom remain anonymised. Also, a warm thanks to Ana Isabel Rodríguez Iglesias and Diego Marin Rios for helpful discussions and information sharing. Thanks, not least, to the Fritt Ord Foundation, who granted me with financial support, enabling the fieldwork. To the Norwegian Institute of International Affairs (NUPI), who provided a stimulating place to write my thesis. Thanks to all my colleagues and research group members for comments, suggestions and motivation. Equally, but not least to Kristin M. Haugevik, Halvard Leira and Morten S. Andersen for reading and bearing with me throughout my somewhat messy draft chapters. To my friend, Kaja Elisabeth, for dedicated proofreading. To friends, family and my favourite person, Eirik, to whom I owe a lot. Oslo, May 2018 Maja Lie Opdahl VIII IX Abbreviations AUC Autodefensas Unidas de Colombia [the United Self-Defence Forces of Colombia] BACRIM Bandas Criminales [Criminal gangs] CDA Critical discourse analysis CMH Centro de Memoria Histórica (Centre of Historical Memory) CIVETS Colombia, Indonesia, Vietnam, Egypt, Turkey and South Africa DAS Departamento Administrativo de Seguridad [the Administrative Department of Security, DEA] DSP Democratic Security Policy and Defence policy [Política de Defensa y Seguridad Democrática] ELN Ejército de Liberación Nacional [the National Liberation Army] EPL Ejercito Popular de Liberación [the Popular Liberation Army] FARC Las Fuerzas Armadas Revolucionarias de Colombia - Ejército del Pueblo [the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia – People’s Army] GAML Grupos Armados al Margen de la Ley [Armed Groups at the Margin of the Law] GoC The Government of Colombia GWOT Global War on Terror ICRC International Committee of the Red Cross IR International Relations IOM International Organization for Migrations M-19 Movimiento 19 de Abril [The 19th of April Movement] NOREF Norwegian Peacebuilding Resource Centre PDSD Política de Defensa y Seguridad Democrática [Democratic Security and Defense Policy] UNDCP United Nations International Drug Control Programme UP Unión Patriótica [Patriotic Union] X Table of contents 1 Introduction ....................................................................................................................................................................... 1 1.1 Research question and objective ............................................................................................................................................... 2 1.2 Analytical approach and contribution ................................................................................................................................... 4 1.3 The structure of the thesis ............................................................................................................................................................ 9 2 Discourse analysis: A theoretical framework ....................................................................................... 11 2.1 A poststructuralist reading of politics ................................................................................................................................. 12 2.2 Constructing the FARC as the Other ..................................................................................................................................... 16 2.3 Discourse, agency and policy formulation ........................................................................................................................ 20 3 Methodology and research design ........................................................................................................... 25 3.1 Data and delimitation ................................................................................................................................................................. 27 3.2 Identifying and mapping representations of the Self and the Other ................................................................... 31 3.3 Research objectives ....................................................................................................................................................................... 36 3.3.1 The ‘problem’ of causality ........................................................................................................................... 36 4 Background to the conflict ......................................................................................................................... 38 4.1 The Violence and the National Front ................................................................................................................................... 38 4.2 The evolution of the FARC.......................................................................................................................................................... 40 4.3 State building and the liberal/conservative divide ...................................................................................................... 41 4.4 Earlier attempts to negotiate peace..................................................................................................................................... 43 4.5 A humanitarian crisis................................................................................................................................................................... 45 5 Empirical analysis ........................................................................................................................................ 47 5.1 Restarting from zero: The emergence of ‘Uribismo’..................................................................................................... 49 5.2 Order and authority: Re-constructing the Self ................................................................................................................ 52 5.3 War on terror: the construction
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Ending Colombia's FARC Conflict: Dealing the Right Card
    ENDING COLOMBIA’S FARC CONFLICT: DEALING THE RIGHT CARD Latin America Report N°30 – 26 March 2009 TABLE OF CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY............................................................................................................. i I. INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................. 1 II. FARC STRENGTHS AND WEAKNESSES................................................................... 2 A. ADAPTIVE CAPACITY ...................................................................................................................4 B. AN ORGANISATION UNDER STRESS ..............................................................................................5 1. Strategy and tactics ......................................................................................................................5 2. Combatant strength and firepower...............................................................................................7 3. Politics, recruitment, indoctrination.............................................................................................8 4. Withdrawal and survival ..............................................................................................................9 5. Urban warfare ............................................................................................................................11 6. War economy .............................................................................................................................12
    [Show full text]
  • Break the Spell Or More of the Same?
    Break the spell or more of the same? 1 Colombian Platform for Human Rights, Democracy and Development Secretaría Técnica Corporación Cactus Correo electrónico: [email protected] Carrera 25 Nº 51-37, oficina 301 Tels.: (571) 345 83 40 - (571) 345 83 29 Comité Editorial: Corporación Cactus, Colectivo de Abogados José Alvear Restrepo (Cajar), Instituto Latinoamericano de Servicios Legales Alternativos (ILSA) Edición: Carlos Enrique Angarita Foto carátula: Jesús Abad Colorado Fernanda Pineda Palencia Caricaturas: Vladdo: Cortesía Revista Semana – Publicaciones Semana S.A. Antonio Caballero: Revista Semana – Publicaciones Semana S.A. Chócolo: Cortesía del autor Preparación editorial: Marta Rojas Traducción: Luke Holland Diseño: Paola Escobar Versión impresa en español: Ediciones Antropos Bogotá, Colombia, Noviembre de 2009 Los artículos que aparecen en este libro son responsabilidad de sus autores. Se permite la reproducción parcial o total de esta obra, en cualquier formato, mecánico o digital, siempre y cuando no se modifique su contenido, se res- pete su autoría y se mantenga esta nota. 2 Break the spell or more of the same? 3 ho IND 6 Presentation PART 4: COMMODIFICATION OF THE TERRITORY PART 1: CONTEXT 126 Rural and food issues under the Uribe government Juan Carlos Morales González 11 The Democratic Security Policy in its regional context: old affinities with the North, new contradictions with the Southr 139 The human right to water, environmental crisis Consuelo Ahumada and social mobilisation INDEX Rafael Colmenares Faccini 19 The bankers get rich while misery spreads Jorge Iván González 149 Commodifying public goods: deepening exclusion and poverty An analysis of waste management policy 24 In time of crisis, the bank doesn’t serve during the Álvaro Uribe government Juan Diego Restrepo E.
    [Show full text]
  • Ending Colombia's FARC Conflict
    ENDING COLOMBIA’S FARC CONFLICT: DEALING THE RIGHT CARD Latin America Report N°30 – 26 March 2009 TABLE OF CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY............................................................................................................. i I. INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................. 1 II. FARC STRENGTHS AND WEAKNESSES................................................................... 2 A. ADAPTIVE CAPACITY ...................................................................................................................4 B. AN ORGANISATION UNDER STRESS ..............................................................................................5 1. Strategy and tactics ......................................................................................................................5 2. Combatant strength and firepower...............................................................................................7 3. Politics, recruitment, indoctrination.............................................................................................8 4. Withdrawal and survival ..............................................................................................................9 5. Urban warfare ............................................................................................................................11 6. War economy .............................................................................................................................12
    [Show full text]
  • Download Print Version (PDF)
    Operación JAQUE The Ultimate Deception by Charles H. Briscoe and Daniel J. Kulich VERITAS | 10 Note | Pseudonyms used in the Colombian government-sanctioned official history by Juan Carlos Torres, Operación JAQUE: La Verdadera Historia (Bogotá, CO: Editorial Planeta Colombiana, 2008) will be duplicated while true names in that account will remain. (meaning ‘check’ as applied in the This article, based extensively on COLAR participant JAQUE game of chess) was a highly compart- interviews, will demonstrate that Operación JAQUE was mented, unilateral Colombian military (COLMIL) a unilateral COLMIL operation, separate from the Joint deception operation that successfully recovered fifteen Chiefs of Staff-authorization to U.S. Southern Command VIP hostages from Las Fuerzas Revolucionarios de Colombia (SOUTHCOM) to conduct combined operations with (FARC) on 2 July 2008 without a shot fired or anyone Colombia [Operation WILLING SPIRIT (OWS)]. The injured. The Colombian Army (COLAR) intelligence- deception within the ‘grand deception’—JAQUE― orchestrated ‘sting’ was made possible by a highly effective was 97 percent COLMIL; 3 percent U.S. technical ‘grand deception’ operation. ‘Unwitting’ Colombian ‘platform’ intelligence. Embedded ‘unwitting’ USSOF and American special operations forces (COLSOF/ with ‘unwitting’ COLSOF reconnaissance, sensitive site USSOF) were operationally deployed to conduct exploitation and PSYOP teams who were to search for the combined reconnaissance, sensitive site exploitation, and FARC VIP hostage holders in the ‘restricted’ area, was part psychological operations (PSYOP) in a ‘restricted’ region. of GEN Montoya’s ‘grand deception.’ JAQUE was not They diverted FARC attention from the area arranged for part of OWS; its success nullified the reason for OWS.5 The the ‘sting.’1 three Americans, Ingrid Betancourt Pulecio, and eleven This “deception within the ‘grand deception’” operation other Colombians were recovered by the Colombian succeeded because all aspects of Operación JAQUE were military.
    [Show full text]
  • Download Download
    CHAPTER 9 Colombia LEARNING OBJECTIVES • Identify how the three economic development in levels of analysis interact Colombia in Colombia • Explain how and why political • Use theoretical propositions and economic development to understand political and in Colombia differs from other Latin American countries TIMELINE 1819 Independence declared 1899–1902 War of the Thousand Days 1948 Jorge Eliécer Gaitán assassinated; La Violencia begins 1957 Sitges Agreement ends La Violencia 1964 Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia (FARC) is formed 19 74 Official power-sharing agreement ended 1991 New constitution ratified 1998 FARC given demilitarized zone 2000 Plan Colombia goes into effect 2002 Alvaro Uribe elected 2003 Paramilitary demobilization began 2006 Alvaro Uribe reelected 2010 Juan Manuel Santos elected 197 M09_WEEK8252_01_SE_C09.indd 197 5/12/14 4:05 PM 198 PART III ▸ Andean Region As Defense Minister in 2008, Juan Manuel Santos organized the bombing of Colombian guerrilla camps in neighboring Ecuador, which killed a key rebel leader and yielded laptops with intelligence but also froze relations with the Ecuadorian government. The same year, he also worked on Operation Jaque, which freed fifteen prisoners inside Colombia held by guerrillas, including the former presidential candidate and longtime hostage Ingrid Betancourt. Later as president he vowed to work at the local level to restore land that had been taken violently from peasants or abandoned as the war against guerrillas and drug traffickers raged in the country. For years, the local population was ter- rorized. In recent decades, political violence has been a constant challenge in Colombia, and Santos’ own responses show how international, national, and local factors must all be viewed to understand Colombian politics.
    [Show full text]
  • MS13 in the Americas How the World’S Most Notorious Gang Defies Logic, Resists Destruction
    MS13 in the Americas How the World’s Most Notorious Gang Defies Logic, Resists Destruction Picture by Rodrigo Abd/AP Images MS13 in the Americas Table of Contents Major Findings .........................................................................................................3 Introduction ..............................................................................................................7 Methodology ............................................................................................................10 MS13: A Brief History ..............................................................................................13 From Stoners to Deportees ............................................................................13 La eMe and the MS13 ....................................................................................16 From El Salvador to the East Coast ................................................................17 From Gang Truce to War .................................................................................18 Philosophy, Ideology and Guidelines ...................................................................22 Philosophy: El Barrio and Las Letras ............................................................22 The Ideology of the Other ...............................................................................24 MS13 Guidelines ............................................................................................25 Organizational Structure .........................................................................................29
    [Show full text]
  • U.S. ARMY SPECIAL OPERATIONS HISTORY Veritas
    U.S. ARMY SPECIAL OPERATIONS HISTORY Veritas Volume 15 / Number 1 Te Battle of Lang Vei An Operational Analysis A Tale of Two Teams Tactical PSYOP Loudspeaker Support in Panama Stopping Te Radio Nacional Broadcasts C/3-7th SFG Ends pro-Noriega Radio Broadcasts during Operation JUST CAUSE NW N NE W E SW SE S of theAzimuth USASOC History Offce Volume 15, Number 1 Tis issue of Veritas is the frst in our new, evolving other military services, the joint commands, and the format. Te title letters are in print font, instead of U.S. Government. the draftsman-drawn scroll ‘header’ of the U.S. Army Te quality and integrity of our historical products John F. Kennedy Special Warfare Center newspaper of will not be compromised. Veritas is more diversifed; the 1960s. Produced by the Public Information Ofce abstract ‘headers,’ shorter articles, ARSOF equipment (PIO), that Veritas was printed bi-weekly by the 1st analyses, highlighted ‘takeaways,’ diferent endnote Psychological Operations (PSYOP) Battalion. positioning, and QR code links to online articles. Our Te articles in this new Veritas were ‘born digitally’ historical evidence reinforces command priorities. and may ‘hang’ on our website for up to two months. As we ‘built’ a virtual reference book on Panama Tis provides ARSOF soldiers early access and more 1989-1990 for 7th SFG, we found that the Army exposure for our written products. Tey are still history coverage virtually ended with JUST CAUSE. reviewed for OPSEC (operations security) and by ARSOF had a major role in the post-invasion the Public Afairs Ofce (PAO) before being ‘hung’ stability operations.
    [Show full text]
  • Universidad Del Azuay Faculty Of
    UNIVERSIDAD DEL AZUAY FACULTY OF LAW SCHOOL OF INTERNATIONAL STUDIES COVE “Final Peace Agreement in Colombia: New migration scenarios in Ecuador ” Graduation work prior to obtaining a Bachelor's Degree in International Studies with a bilingual mention in Foreign Trade Authors: González Merchán Doménica Paoletich Guerrero María Natalia Director: Mgtr. Ana María Bustos Cordero Cuenca - Ecuador 2018 TABLE OF CONTENTS COVER ......................................................................................................................... 1 ILUSTRATIONS INDEX ................................................................................................ 5 TABLES INDEX ............................................................................................................ 5 SUMMARY ................................................................................................................... 5 CHAPTER I................................................................................................................... 8 THE ARMED CONFLICT .............................................................................................. 8 1.1. The Conflict ....................................................................................................... 8 1.2. Background of the conflict ................................................................................ 10 1.2.1. Political scope ............................................................................................ 10 1.2.2. Economic scope........................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Operación JAQUE
    Operation WILLING SPIRIT Setting Conditions for OWS Operación JAQUE by Charles H. Briscoe 1 | VOL 14 NO 3 Note | Pseudonyms in the official Colombian Government account by Juan Carlos Torres, Operación JAQUE: La Verdadera Historia (2008), have been used in this article and endnotes. he strong American military relationship with Colombia dates to the Korean War. This partnership T is a model of U.S. Army Special Operations Forces (ARSOF) long-term engagement. Since the 1980s, the United States has provided significant support to Colombia and other South American countries to attack cocaine production at its source. Plan Colombia (1999), presented in English to the U.S. Congress by President Andrés Pastrana Arango, was designed to contain the drug problem in that country. Unfortunately, his demilitarized FARC-landia plan backfired. In the wake of 9/11, a charismatic Colombian President Álvaro Uribe Vélez convinced the American legislators that Plan Colombian President Álvaro Uribe Vélez (2002-2010) meets Colombia could also restore legitimacy to insurgent- U.S. President George W. Bush. controlled areas in his country, particularly FARC-landia.1 U.S. funding was increased, and training support was extended beyond the National Police to the new not until they seized three American SRS contractors OWS Colombian Army (COLAR) Counter-Drug battalions. (Marc D. Gonsalves, Keith D. Stansell, and Thomas R. The mobility afforded by organic helicopter fleets was Howes) that Washington had to deal with the problem. key to better successes in the mountainous country— Their SRS single-engine Cessna 208B Caravan developed twin-engine UH-1N Hueys and UH-60L Black Hawks engine problems and crash-landed near the Cordilleria were provided as security assistance.2 America’s Global Oriental mountain range, south of Bogotá on 13 February War on Terrorism (GWOT) proved a boon to her allies.3 2003.
    [Show full text]
  • María Luisa Parraguez Kobek, “Securing Democratic Charter" Defense and Cooperation in South America: Howard J
    Volume 12, Numbers 1 & 2 Fall – Winter 2011 ISSN: 1533-2535 POLICY STATEMENTS COOPERATION AND CONTROVERSY Cresencio Arcos, “U.S.–Latin American Security Kevin Newmeyer, "The Honduran Ties: Episodic Relationships” Coup of 2009 and the Inter-American María Luisa Parraguez Kobek, “Securing Democratic Charter" Defense and Cooperation in South America: Howard J. Wiarda and Hilary Geopolitical Changes, UNASUR, and the SDC” Collins, "Constitutional Coups? Military Intervention in Latin America" R. Evan Ellis, “The United States and China in Latin America: Cooperation and Competition” Hernán Castillo,"Cultura Política y Fuerzas Armadas en Venezuela" Luis Hernández, "El Control Civil de COUNTRY AND REGIONAL ISSUES las Fuerzas Armadas en el Ecuador. ¿Intento Fallido?" Ivelaw Lloyd Griffith, “Political Acumen and Geopolitical Anxiety in Suriname” David Spencer, “The Evolution and BOOK REVIEWS Implementation of FARC Strategy: Insights from Its Internal documents” Matthew Finger: Review of Jodi Sérgio Luiz Cruz Aguilar, “A Particição Sul- Vittori, Terrorist Financing and Americana Nas Operações de Paz da ONU: Resourcing Algumas Consideracões” Joanna Gillia: Review of Cristina Marcano and Alberto Barrera Tyszka, Hugo Chávez STRATEGIC AND SECURITY ISSUES Patricia Kehoe: Review of Hal Brands, Latin America’s Cold War Jaime García Covarrubias, “Liderazgo Celina Realuyo: Review of Joseph Estrategico en Defensa” Nye, The Future of Power W. Alejandro Sánchez, “Sangre Joven: Richard W. Taylor: Review of Jorge Understanding the new wave of Armed Groups in G. Castañeda, Mañana Forever: Latin America” Mexico and the Mexicans Vicente Torrijos, “La Legítima Defensa en Perspectiva” Juan Carlos Gómez, “La Utilización de las Fuerzas Militares en un Ambiente Criminal y no de Guerra: Desafíos del Siglo XXI” 2011 Fall-Winter Issue / Volume 12 1 Security and Defense Studies Review Staff and Editorial Board Richard D.
    [Show full text]
  • Welcome to the Jungle: Counterinsurgency Lessons from Colombia
    Welcome to the Jungle Counterinsurgency Lessons from Colombia A Contemporary Battlefield Assessment Lionel Beehner Liam Collins by the Modern War Institute May 23, 2019 Welcome to the Jungle: Counterinsurgency Lessons from Colombia Table of Contents Acknowledgments ....................................................................................................................................... 1 Executive Summary..................................................................................................................................... 3 Introduction ................................................................................................................................................. 9 Chapter I – History of the War ................................................................................................................. 13 The Insurgency ...................................................................................................................................... 14 The Peace Process ................................................................................................................................. 17 Chapter II – Causes of the Conflict .......................................................................................................... 21 Structural Conditions ............................................................................................................................ 22 Drivers of Violence ...............................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • The Internationalization of Domestic Conflicts: a Comparative Study of Colombia, El Salvador and Colombia
    “THE INTERNATIONALIZATION OF DOMESTIC CONFLICTS: A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF COLOMBIA, EL SALVADOR AND GUATEMALA” A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED TO THE FACULTY OF THE GRADUATE SCHOOL OF THE UNIVERSITY OF MINNESOTA BY Sandra P. Borda IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY Name of Adviser: Kathryn Sikkink May 2009 © Sandra P. Borda, May/2009 i Acknowledgments Throughout my years as a student, I have had the pleasure of meeting many people that have contributed in important ways to my development as a political scientist and scholar of international relations. To begin with, I have to express my gratitude to Juan Tokatlian, Alexander Wendt, Michael Barnett and Kathryn Sikkink. Each has been my advisor at some point in my career, and each one of them introduced me to new and fascinating aspects of the discipline. Furthermore, each has allowed me to better understand the complexities and challenges of the profession. I consider them great examples to follow and can only hope to have the opportunity to keep learning from all of them. I have obtained great feedback at different phases of this project. Kathryn Sikkink, Lisa Hilbink, Michael Barnett and David Samuels commented extensively on previous drafts of my dissertation; Joe Soss gave me very useful comments on various versions of my project; also, the members of my dissertation group at the University of Minnesota read carefully and patiently, chapter by chapter, my whole dissertation. They commented on it and discussed it with great enthusiasm and I am very grateful for their time and dedication. I am also grateful to various institutions: the Universidad del Rosario in Bogotá, Colombia, which first provided me with a generous opportunity and outstanding support to start my M.A.
    [Show full text]