XLfc Hmcncan JScckstaettcal IRevicw
A MONTHLY PUBLICATION FOR THE CLERGY Cum Approbation* Suptnorum
VOL. CXLVI
JANUARY-JUNE, 1962
'Ew ivl irvebfiCLTt, /u$ ^vxv awoSKovvrts T§ Tiara rod ebayyeklov Phil. 1:27
Published by THE CATHOLIC UNIVERSITY OF AMERICA PRESS CONTENTS FOR VOLUME CXLVI
JANUARY
Reunion With Our Orthodox Brethren George A. Moloney, S.J. 1 Reflections on the Roman Synod: II John A. Abbo 11 The Mass and Modern Thought James Kritseck 30 The Pastor and the Legion of Mary John J. Coleman 35 Heavenly Banquet J. P. Kenny, S.J. 47
ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R., and John P. McCormick, S.S. Omission of Last Gospel 57 Preface at Forty Hours' Devotion 57 Decency of Dress 58 External Solemnity 59 An Abortive Pill 59 Elementary School Dances 60
BOOK REVIEWS St. Thomas More, edited by R. W. Gibson 63 The Church: A Pictorial History, by Edward Rice 63 Rome and the Vernacular, by Angelus A. De Marco, O.F.M. 65 The Other Face: Catholic Life Under Elizabeth I, collected and edited by Philip Caraman 66 Teilhard de Chardin, A Critical Study, by Olivier Rabut, O.P 67 Religious Vocation: An Unnecessary Mystery, by Richard Butler, O.P. 68 Saint Paul The Apostle, by A. Penna 69
BOOKS RECEIVED 70
iii IV CONTENTS FOR VOLUME CXLVI
FEBRUARY
Altar Wine Joseph J. Farraher, S.J., and Thomas D. Terry, S.J. 73 The Liturgy's Use of the Annunciation Scene. Richard T. Cochran, S.M. 89 Instrumental Music and the Liturgy Robert J. Novotny 94 Modern Protestant Ideas Concerning the Bible John J. O'Rourke 113 Creation and Restoration Colum Devine, C.P. 121
ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R., and John P. McCormick, S.S.
The Fallout Shelter Controversy 132 Decent Garb in Church 133 The Sanctity of the Minister Affecting the Benefits of a Sacrament.... 13S Masses at Side Altars 135 Obligation of the Martyrology 137 Faculty to Consecrate Chalices 137
BOOK REVIEWS Catechism of Catholic Social Teaching, by Amintore Fanjani 139 St. Vincent de Paul, Servant of the Poor, by Igino Giordani 140 All Lost in Wonder, by Walter J. Burghardt, S.J 141
BOOKS RECEIVED 143 CONTENTS FOR VOLUME CXLVI v
MARCH
The Magisterium and the Scholar John J. King, O.M.I. 145 The Teaching of College Theology Luke O'Donnell, O.S.B. 167 Father Kennedy's Exegesis of the Holy Office Monitum W. L. Moran, SJ. 174 A Reply to Father Moran Gerald T. Kennedy, O.M.I, 181 Father Moran's Prediction Joseph Clifford Fenton 192
ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R., and John P. McCormick, S.S. The Pastor and the Snow 202 The Priest without Faculties on a Sick Call 202 Must Both Parties Agree to Rhythm? 203 Prudence in Telephone Conversations 204 Confessions on Sunday 205 Masses in the Christmas Octave 206 Epiphany Octave in the New Breviary 206 Pater Noster in a Dialogue Mass 206 Genuflections 207 Correction 208
BOOK REVIEWS The Medieval University: 1200-1400, 631 Lowrie J. Daly, S.J 209 Canon Law for Religious Women, by Louis Fanfani, O.P., and Kevin O'Rourke, O.P. 210
BOOK NOTES 212
BOOKS RECEIVED 215 VI CONTENTS FOR VOLUME CXLVI
APRIL
A Note on the Nature of Marriage David Granfield, O.S.B. 217 Conscience and Love Donald Diets, O.M.I. 225 Unwritten Traditions at Trent John L. Murphy 233
ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R., and John P. McCormick, S.S.
Changes in the Rite of Mass 264 Teaching Sisters and Their Charges 267 Chewing Gum and the Eucharistic Fast 269 What About the Animals ? 270
ANALECTA The Translation of the Apostolic Constitution Veterum sapientia 272
BOOK REVIEWS God's Living Word, by Alexander Jones 280 Mariology, Vol. III. Edited by Juniper Carol, O.F.M 281 Introductio in Codicem, editio V, by Udalricus Beste, O.S.B 282 The Crisis of Western Education, by Christopher Dawson 283
BOOK NOTES 284
BOOKS RECEIVED 286 CONTENTS FOR VOLUME CXLVI vii
MAY
American Catholics: A Household Divided ? John E. Coogan, S. J. 289 De Maria Nunquam Satis Raymond Beaudry 299 The Soteriological Value of the Resurrection Robert R. Barr, S.J. 304 Sexual Pleasure: Its Proper Setting in Christian Marriage Conan Gallagher, MS.Ss.T. 315 Workshop on Pastoral Psychology Harold C. Bradley, S.J. 327 European Unification and Pope Pius XII Carlo Muscat 331 Chosen from among Men William J. O'Rourke, S.J. 338
ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R., and John P. McCormick, S.S.
The Obligation of Paying Tithes 346 Changes in the Rite of Mass 351
BOOK REVIEWS The Bible and the Origin of Man, by J. De Fraine, S.J 355 This is the Rosary, by Francis Beauchesne Thornton 357 The Catholic Movement of Employers and Managers by Joseph B. Gremillion 358
BOOKS RECEIVED 359 CONTENTS FOR VOLUME CXLVI
JUNE
The Bible and Its Genuine Historical and Objective Truth Cardinal Ruffini 361 The Way of the Cross Archbishop Vagnozsi 369 Prize Fighting Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R. 376 The Marian Cult and Canon Law. Part I John A. Abbo 381 Two Statements About the Necessity of the Catholic Church for the Attainment of Eternal Salvation Joseph Clifford Fenton 401
ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS John P. McCormick, S.S., and Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R. Bows in the New Rite 418 Special Faculties 418 Matins in Holy Week 419 Doxologies 420 Communion on Good Friday 420 Dangerous Ethics on TV 420 Some Problems of Religious Poverty 422 May the Husband Give Consent ? 424
BOOK REVIEWS A Catholic Case against Segregation, edited by Joseph E. O'Neill, S.J. 426 Dogma for the Layman, by Thomas J. Higgins, S.J 428 Metaphysics and the Existence of God, by Thomas C. O'Brien, O.P 430
BOOKS RECEIVED 432
INDEX TO VOLUME CXLVI 435
BOOKS REVIEWED AND NOTICED 439 ZTbe Hmcrican Bcclesiastical IRevtew
A MONTHLY PUBLICATION FOR THE CLERGY Cum Approbatione Superiorum
VOL. CXLVII
JULY-DECEMBER, 1962
'Ev ivl TveOfiari, mq. foxv (TvvaJd\ovvTfs TJ ICIGTH TOV ebwyyekloo Phil. 1:27
Published by THE CATHOLIC UNIVERSITY OF AMERICA PRESS CONTENTS FOR VOLUME CXLVII
JULY
Monsignor John J. Burke, C.S.P Donald F. X. Connolly 1 Two Theories of Faith John L. Murphy 14 The Marian Cult and Canon Law. Part II John A. Abbo 37
ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS John P. McCormick, S.S., and Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R. The Purpose of Amendment 57 A Surgical Problem 61 Precedence 61 Omission of Confiteor before Communion 62 First Class Days in Octaves 62 The Paschal Candle 63 Choice of Gospel 63 A Monsignor's Problems 64
BOOK REVIEWS Religious Toleration in England, 1787-1833, by Ursula Henriques.... 65 The Binding Force of Civil Laws, 631 Matthew Herron, T.O.R 67 Eugene de Mazenod: Bishop of Marseilles, Founder of the Oblates of Mary Immaculate Vol. I. 1782-1814, by Jean Leflon 68 The First Number of the Review Ius Canonicum 69 Medical Ethics, by Charles J. McFadden 70
BOOKS RECEIVED 72
iii CONTENTS FOR VOLUME CXLVII
AUGUST
Perseverance in the Seminary: Problems and Remedies.. Bishop Wright 73 Veterum Sapientia: A Twentieth-Century Renaissance Patrick T. Brannan, S.J. 88 Don Bosco: Apostle of the Papacy Mario A. Mich, S.D.B. 96 The Bishop and the Layman Donald Diets, O.M.I. 106 The Influence of The Holy Ghost in the Ecumenical Council Joseph Clifford Fenton 116
ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R., and John P. McCormick, S.S. Benediction Questions 128 The Gospel in a Sung Mass with Incense 129 The Innocent Wife 130 Questions on Baptismal Sponsorship 131 Integrity of Confession 132
ANALECTA 134
COMMENTS Dom Patrick Granfield 135
BOOK REVIEWS
Restitution to the Poor, by James E. Quill 140 Mary in the Bible, by Salvatore Garojalo 141 Ordonner Diacres des Peres de Famille, 631 Wilhelm Schamoni 142
BOOKS RECEIVED 144 CONTENTS FOR VOLUME CXLVII v
SEPTEMBER
Peter Guilday: American Church Historian Francis J. Weber 145 Civil Legislation on Contraception Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R. 155 The Abiding Significance of Gnosticism James V. Schall, S.J. 164 The Mystery of Obedience Raymond Beaudry 174 The Council and Father Kiing Joseph Clifford Fentcm 178
ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R., and John P. McCormick, S.S.
The Rhythm and Communism 201 Dishonesty in a Raffle 202 The Obligation of Godparents 203 Dining Room Protocol 203 Faculty for Papal Blessing 204 Omission of Last Gospel 205
COMMENT Dom Patrick Granfield 206
BOOK REVIEWS Monastic Life in Medieval England, by J. C. Dickinson 209 Living the Lord's Prayer, by Dom Eugene Vandeur 211
BOOK NOTES 212
BOOKS RECEIVED 214 VI CONTENTS FOR VOLUME CXLVII
OCTOBER
A Case Against Wiretapping Dom Daisid Granfield 217 Ecelesiology and Ecumenism. Part I Edward F. Hanahoe, S.A. 226 Engagements—In Church Chester Wrsasscsak 243 The Virtue of Prudence and the Success of the Second Ecumenical Vatican Council Joseph Clifford Fenton 2SS
ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R., and John P. McCormick, S.S. Bows in the New Rite 266 Missae Pro Populo 266 The Biretta at Mass 268 Is a Mixed Marriage Preferable ? 269 An Honest Error in the Raffle 270 Debarring a Doctor from a Catholic Hospital 271
COMMENT Dom Patrick Granfield 273
BOOK REVIEWS A Summary of Catholic History, by Newman C. Eberhardt 277 The Protestant Reformation, by H. Daniel-Rops 278 The History of Catholic Church Music, by Karl Gustav Fellerer 280 Moral Re-Armament and the Catholic Lay Apostolate, by Bishop Thomas L. Noa 281 Prods de Lourdes, by Rene Laurentin, Dom Bernard Fillet and Dom Paul Gallard 282 The Holy See and the Nascent Church in the Middle Western United States, by Robert F. Trisco 284
BOOKS RECEIVED 287 CONTENTS FOR VOLUME CXLVII vii
NOVEMBER
Regulation of Offspring for the Common Good. Part I. Anthony Zimmerman, S.V.D, 289 The Growth of Faith, Hope and Charity According to Saint Paul George T. Montague, S.M. 308 Ecclesiology and Ecumenism. Part II Edward F. Hanahoe, S.A. 319 Vocations in Western Europe John J. Micheli Navone, S.J. 338
ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R., and John P. McCormick, S.S.
The Subdeacon Singing the Epistle 343 Sitting During the Epistle 344 Privileged Requiem Mass 344 The Leonine Prayers 345 Governmental Repression of Heretical Propaganda in the United States 346
COMMENT Dom Patrick Granfield 3S1
BOOK REVIEWS Faith, Reason, and the Gospels, edited by John J. Heaney, S.J. 356 The Priest and Vocations: Religious Life, Series XI, translated by Ronald Halstead 357
BOOKS RECEIVED 3S9 viii CONTENTS FOR VOLUME CXLVII
DECEMBER
Kerygmatic Catechesis and Religious Education Today Joseph B. Collins, S.S. 361 The Priesthood in Christian Unity John A. Hardon, S.J. 374 The General Council Peter J. Rahill 387 "The Woman Clothed with the Sun" According to St Lawrence of Brindisi Stanley Gahan, O.F.M.Cap. 395 Regulation of Offspring for the Common Good. Part II. Anthony Zimmerman, S.V.D. 403
ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS John P. McCormick, S.S., and Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R.
The Ecumenical Council 419
Conceptual and Evaluative Cognition 422
COMMENT Dom Patrick Granfield 426
BOOK REVIEWS
Psychoanalysis and Religion, by Gregory Zilboorg, M.D 430
BOOKS RECEIVED 432
INDEX TO VOLUME CXLVII 434
BOOKS REVIEWED AND NOTICED 436