Migration and Identity Amongst the Yakha of East Nepal Andrew Russell University of Oxford
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by DigitalCommons@Macalester College Himalaya, the Journal of the Association for Nepal and Himalayan Studies Volume 12 Article 4 Number 1 Himalayan Research Bulletin no. 1 & 2 1992 The iH lls Are Alive with the Sense of Movement: Migration and Identity Amongst the Yakha of East Nepal Andrew Russell University of Oxford Follow this and additional works at: http://digitalcommons.macalester.edu/himalaya Recommended Citation Russell, Andrew (1992) "The iH lls Are Alive with the Sense of Movement: Migration and Identity Amongst the Yakha of East Nepal," Himalaya, the Journal of the Association for Nepal and Himalayan Studies: Vol. 12: No. 1, Article 4. Available at: http://digitalcommons.macalester.edu/himalaya/vol12/iss1/4 This Research Article is brought to you for free and open access by the DigitalCommons@Macalester College at DigitalCommons@Macalester College. It has been accepted for inclusion in Himalaya, the Journal of the Association for Nepal and Himalayan Studies by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@Macalester College. For more information, please contact [email protected]. THE HILLS ARE ALIVE WITH THE SENSE OF MOVEMENT: MIGRATION AND IDENTITY AMONGST THE YAKHA OF EASTNEPAL1 ANDREW RussELL UNIVERSITY OF OxFoRD Introduction The main message a long-stay visitor to the hills of Nepal is likely to hear from local people about the condition of their lives is encapsulated in the Nepali word dukkha.2 This broadly translates as 'suffering', 'pain' or 'trouble' and is used in a multitude of contexts, but is often more specifically linked to the toil surrounding subsistence living (i.e. people's painful struggle to eke a living from the soil). In Yakha (the language of the Tibeto-Burmese ethnic group on which the research for this paper is based3) the word was pronounced tukhi, and we heard it used most in relation to the suffering involved in living in a village, where it was tagged alliteratively with the Yakha word for village to make tukhi ten. For the anthropologist trained to espouse the relative value of all cultures and to look with a certain degree ofoptimism at the way oflife ofthose studied, it was sometimes difficult to come to terms with the vehemence with which the hardship of life in the hills was expressed. "It's not such a tukhi ten" one could assert while sitting by the warm embers ofa smoky fire on a crisp winter's morning, snow glinting on the peaks ofthe distant Himalaya and a glass offreshly distilled raksi (N. - liquor) in hand. "See how clean the air is outside, the weather is lovely, how sociable everyone is." But in the summer monsoon, with views long forgotten replaced by a blank wall of cloudy whiteness, and ubiquitous stomach ailments having already precipitated multiple visits to the latrine that morning, it was tempting to agree with what people were saying about their village as they prepared to go offforyet another back-breaking day working in leech-infested fields. "Yes, it is a tukhi ten." While opinions amongst academics vary as to the relative weight of 'pull' and 'push' factors (Rana and Thapa, 1974:82) on migration from the hills of Nepal, and the situation differs markedly in different regions and amongst different strata of society, 4 it was this perception of hill life as a source ofsuffering and hardship which appeared to be a primary stimulus for migration from Tamaphok. Migration is often peripheralized as a process in anthropological accounts, since it muddies the boundaries of neat, community based studies. Studies (usually by scholars in other disciplines) which have looked specifically at migration in Nepal (e.g. Rana and Thapa, 1974; M.N. Shrestha, 1979; Conway and Shrestha, 1981; N .R. Shrestha, 1982, 1985a, 1985b, 1990; Gurung, 1987; Thapa, 1989), have tended to look at only one aspect of the process, such as internal migration or migration by men, measured in quantitative not qualitative terms. Thus a senseofthefull meaning and importance of migration to the people of the Nepalese hills has been lacking. This paper, by contrast, does not aim to present material representative of migration patterns across the whole ofNepal, but instead to provide a picture of the changing nature ofYakha migration from Tamaphok and how the different environments to which members of this ethnic group have been moving were perceived by the migrants themselves. It is predominantly male-focused. and should be read in conjunction with Tamara Kohn's paper (this volume) which presents a different sort of migration through women's eyes. Rather than a necessary but dislocating evil, I would argue that the Yakha saw migration as an intrinsic part oftheir culture and identity.5 This paper attempts to elucidate some of the social and cultural factors which conditioned and reflected such a profound 'sense of movement' in Yakha society. and investigates in particular the way in which THE HILLS ARE ALIVE WITH THE SENSE OF MOVEMENT/ RussELL 35 the Yakha manipulated various names in their dealings with the world they experienced through migration. The fundamental importance of migration for the Tamaphok household economy was evidenced by the fact that at any one time, particularly in the winter months, up to 25% of the adult male population was likely to be absent. This absence was reflected in the census figures collected for the government by the paiiciiyat secretary and an assistant during the summer of 1989. In ward 5, where the population was 95% Yakha, less than40%ofthetotal populationof832 was male. This compared with a virtually 50:50 ratioofmalestofemales in the paiiciiyat as a whole. We were frequently told that every household had some male members working away, an assertion verified both by the census figures and our own smaller survey. I shall look first at the main destinations involved in this movement, followed by the social and cultural factors which are an integral part of it. Army Service The traditional recruitment for service in the British Gurkhas was economically important but a rather small and dwindling proportion of the total. The British Gurkhas were seen as offering the highest salaries and best amenities. Of the five infantry battalions in existence the' 1st/2nd' and '7th' were known as the 'eastern regiments' since they recruited mainly from the east. The normal length of service was fifteen years: a minimum often years had to be served to receive a pension, and fifteen were required for a full pension. This pension was often higher than the regular wage of a soldier in the Indian army (the other main source of military service). Thusitwashighlyprestigiousand lucrativeforafamilyto have a son in the British Gurkhas. However, during the period of our fieldwork the British military camp in Dharan, previously the centre for Gurkha recruitment in the eastern hills, was closed. While arrangements were made for potential recruits to be taken by bus from Dharan to Pokhara in the mid-west of Nepal in future, it was hard to imagine recruitment from the eastern hills would persist at its previous levels. This pessimism was justified: after our fieldwork, Gurkha recruitment in 1991 was reduced from 300 to 240 (according to Major Nigel Collett at a recent talk given in London on February 7th 1991 ), and the reduction in infantry battalions from five to three was announced in May 1991. The Indian army was a more common source of employment than the British Gurkhas, although financially it was 'second best' to them. This said, one woman reported that her Indian army widow's pension had increased from 30 to 500 rupees ($1 to $16.50) a month over the previous eleven years, and the pension for a retired regular soldier from the Indian army was I ,500 rupees ($50) a month, which compared favourably with the working salary of a teacher in Tamaphok school. The nearest recruiting centre was Darjeeling, and from people's reports it seemed that selection methods were every bit as tough as for the British Gurkhas. An advantage of serving in the Indian army was that it allowed the soldier the chance to return home on leave at regular intervals: once every six months seemed to be the norm, but this depended on the inclination of the man concerned and the distance of his army barracks from East Nepal. Soldiers in the British Gurkhas, by contrast, came home on a longer, six month leave once every three years: they could come more frequently only if they could obtain clearance, and were prepared to pay their own airfares to and from their posting. Furthermore, the British Military Hospital had been closed along with the British Gurkha camp in Dharan, and with it had gone the benefit of treatment for ex-British army servicemen and their families outside the Nepalese health service. Indian army ex-servicemen, on the other hand, could still go to India for treatment in Indian military hospitals. The Nepalese army ranked a poor third in salary and Yakha men's job aspirations. The pradlliin piiiica(N. - paiiciiyat leader) could only think of two men from the Yakha population in Tamaphok serving in the Nepalese army, compared to five in the British Gurkhas and an uncertain but larger number (possibly thirty) working in the Indian army. 36 HIMALAYAN RESEARCH BULLETIN XII ( 1-2) 1992 North-east India, Sikkim and Bhutan After the army, a second major migrant destination was Assam and the other hill states of north-east India, together with Sikkim and Bhutan. Yakha families with kin permanently residing in these places (of which there were many) were likely to use these links to find employment there in a wide range of activities -wood cutting, house construction and agricultural labour, to name but a few.