[Halshs-00878974, V1] Hindu Nationalism and History of Science

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

[Halshs-00878974, V1] Hindu Nationalism and History of Science

Looking at it from India: Hindu nationalism and History of Science Agathe Keller Laboratoire Sphere ERC Project SAW CNRS, Université Paris-Diderot halshs-00878974, version 1 - 31 Oct 2013 Paris, France [email protected] mercredi 23 octobre 13 halshs-00878974, version 1 - 31 Oct 2013 mercredi 23 octobre 13 halshs-00878974, version 1 - 31 Oct 2013 mercredi 23 octobre 13 K. S. Lal Goel Breivik Voice of India Konrad Elst Ram Swarup Fjordman S. R. Rajaram halshs-00878974, version 1 - 31 Oct 2013 David Frawley Daniel Pipes François Gauthier Subhash Kak Rajiv Malhotra mercredi 23 octobre 13 halshs-00878974, version 1 - 31 Oct 2013 mercredi 23 octobre 13 Subhas Candra Bose (1897-1945) halshs-00878974, version 1 - 31 Oct 2013 Vinayak Damodar Savarkar (1833-1966) mercredi 23 octobre 13 Bal Gangadhar Tilak (1856-1920) THE ORION OR RESEARCHES INTO THE ANTIQUITY OF THE VEDAS BY BAL GANGADHAR TILAK, B.A., LL.B., LAW LECTURER, AND PLEADER, POONA. All rights reserved. halshs-00878974, version 1 - 31 Oct 2013 BOMBAY: MRS, BiDHiBil iTMiRAM 8AGOON, AND PUBLISHER. '* ft '1893. mercredi 23 octobre 13 Subhash Kak halshs-00878974, version 1 - 31 Oct 2013 mercredi 23 octobre 13 halshs-00878974, version 1 - 31 Oct 2013 mercredi 23 octobre 13 halshs-00878974, version 1 - 31 Oct 2013 mercredi 23 octobre 13 halshs-00878974, version 1 - 31 Oct 2013 mercredi 23 octobre 13 halshs-00878974, version 1 - 31 Oct 2013 mercredi 23 octobre 13 halshs-00878974, version 1 - 31 Oct 2013 mercredi 23 octobre 13 H.T. Colebrooke (1765-1831) John Leslie (1766-1832) Jacobi Alexander von Humboldt George Peacock (1769-1859) Nesselman (1791-1858) Chasles (1793-1880) Guillaumme Libri Woepcke (1803-1869) (1826-1864) G.R.Kaye D.E. Smith Hankel halshs-00878974, version 1 - 31 Oct 2013 B.Datta S. Ganguly mercredi 23 octobre 13 Vedic Mathematics halshs-00878974, version 1 - 31 Oct 2013 The young Bharati Krishna Thirthaji, the author of Vedic Mathematics mercredi 23 octobre 13 halshs-00878974, version 1 - 31 Oct 2013 mercredi 23 octobre 13 halshs-00878974, version 1 - 31 Oct 2013 mercredi 23 octobre 13 halshs-00878974, version 1 - 31 Oct 2013 mercredi 23 octobre 13 Vedic Mathematics halshs-00878974, version 1 - 31 Oct 2013 mercredi 23 octobre 13.

Copy Link

Recommended publications

Hindu Responses to Religious Diversity and the Nature of Post-Mortem Progress
View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Apollo Hindu Responses to Religious Diversity and the Nature of Post-Mortem Progress The last two hundred years of Hindu–Christian encounters have produced distinctive forms of Hindu thought which, while often rooted in the broad philosophical-cultural continuities of Vedic outlooks, grappled with, on the one hand, the colonial pressures of European modernity, and, on the other hand, the numerous critiques by Christian theologians and missionaries on the Hindu life-worlds. Thus, the spectrum of Hindu responses from Raja Rammohun Roy through Swami Vivekananda to S. Radhakrishnan demonstrates attempts to creatively engage with Christian representations of Hindu belief and practice, by accepting their prima facie validity at one level while negating their adequacy at another. For instance, these figures of neo-Hinduism accepted that such ‘corruptions’ as Hinduism’s alleged idol- worship, anti-worldly ethic, caste-based distinctions and the like were all too visible on the socio-cultural domain, while they formulated revamped Vedic or Vedantic visions within which these were to be either rejected as excrescences or given demythologised interpretations. In Swami Vivekananda, we find on some occasions a more strident rejection of certain aspects of western civilization as steeped in materialist ‘excesses’ which needed to be purged through the light of Vedantic wisdom. Through such hermeneutical processes of retrieval, often carried out within contexts structured by British colonialism, these figures were able to offer forms of Hinduism that were signifiers not of the Oriental depravity that the British administrators, scholars and missionaries had claimed to perceive on the Indian landscapes but of a spiritual depth that transcended national, cultural and ethnic boundaries.
[Show full text]
Christianities of South Asia
SMC456H1F: INDIAN CHRISTIANITY RLG3280H: CHRISTIANITIES OF SOUTH ASIA MEETING TIMES: Tuesdays, 6-9 pm, in Teefy Hall 103 Instructor: Reid B. Locklin Office: Odette Hall 130 Phone: 416.926.1300, x3317 Email: [email protected] Office Hours: T 10:10-12 noon and by chance or appointment Email Policy: I will attempt to respond to legitimate email enquiries from students within 3-4 days. If you do not receive a reply within this period, please re-submit your question(s) and/or leave a message by telephone. Where a question cannot be easily or briefly answered by email, I will indicate that the student should see me during my posted office hours. Course Description This seminar explores the claim of diverse Christian traditions in South Asia to be religious traditions of South Asia, with special attention to these traditions’ indigenisation and social interactions with majority Hindu traditions. Our study will begin with an overview of the historical development of Christianity in India from the first century CE to the present. In a second unit, we move to close readings of three major theological articulations for and against an indigenous South Asian Christianity: M.M. Thomas, Ram Swarup and Sathianathan Clarke. Finally, our attention will turn to the concept of “ritual dialogue” in Christian practice and the ethnographic study of Christian communities in India. Most of our attention will be focused on Christian traditions in South India, but students are encouraged to choose topics related to Christianity in other parts of India, Sri Lanka, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Nepal and/or Bhutan for their research papers.
[Show full text]
Why I Became a Hindu
Why I became a Hindu Parama Karuna Devi published by Jagannatha Vallabha Vedic Research Center Copyright © 2018 Parama Karuna Devi All rights reserved Title ID: 8916295 ISBN-13: 978-1724611147 ISBN-10: 1724611143 published by: Jagannatha Vallabha Vedic Research Center Website: www.jagannathavallabha.com Anyone wishing to submit questions, observations, objections or further information, useful in improving the contents of this book, is welcome to contact the author: E-mail: [email protected] phone: +91 (India) 94373 00906 Please note: direct contact data such as email and phone numbers may change due to events of force majeure, so please keep an eye on the updated information on the website. Table of contents Preface 7 My work 9 My experience 12 Why Hinduism is better 18 Fundamental teachings of Hinduism 21 A definition of Hinduism 29 The problem of castes 31 The importance of Bhakti 34 The need for a Guru 39 Can someone become a Hindu? 43 Historical examples 45 Hinduism in the world 52 Conversions in modern times 56 Individuals who embraced Hindu beliefs 61 Hindu revival 68 Dayananda Saraswati and Arya Samaj 73 Shraddhananda Swami 75 Sarla Bedi 75 Pandurang Shastri Athavale 75 Chattampi Swamikal 76 Narayana Guru 77 Navajyothi Sree Karunakara Guru 78 Swami Bhoomananda Tirtha 79 Ramakrishna Paramahamsa 79 Sarada Devi 80 Golap Ma 81 Rama Tirtha Swami 81 Niranjanananda Swami 81 Vireshwarananda Swami 82 Rudrananda Swami 82 Swahananda Swami 82 Narayanananda Swami 83 Vivekananda Swami and Ramakrishna Math 83 Sister Nivedita
[Show full text]
The Dayanand Anglo-Vedic School of Lahore: a Study of Educational Reform in Colonial Punjab, Ca
The Dayanand Anglo-Vedic School of Lahore: A Study of Educational Reform in Colonial Punjab, ca. 1885-1925. Inauguraldissertation zur Erlangung der Doktorwürde der Philosophischen Fakultät der Universität Heidelberg vorgelegt von: Ankur Kakkar Erstgutachter: Prof. Dr. Gita Dharampal-Frick Zweitgutachter: Prof. Dr. Rahul Mukherji Heidelberg, April 2021 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ....................................................................................................... 5 LIST OF MAPS AND TABLES ................................................................................................. 8 INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................ 11 CHAPTER 1: EDUCATION POLICY IN COLONIAL INDIA. A HISTORICAL BACKGROUND, CA. 1800-1880 ........................................................................................................................ 33 INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................................ 33 ‘INDIGENOUS’ INDIAN EDUCATION : A COLONIAL SURVEY, CA. 1820-1830 ......................................... 34 Madras ........................................................................................................................... 38 Bombay .......................................................................................................................... 42 Bengal ...........................................................................................................................
[Show full text]
New Arrivals – Central Library – Feb-Mar 2019 Vol
New Arrivals – Central Library – Feb-Mar 2019 Vol. 19, Issue : 2-3 Home Thesis Articles Aerospace Engineering Journalism & Communication Biological / Geological Sciences Language, Linguistics, Literature Chemical/Chemistry Management Civil Engineering Mathematics Computer Science Mechanical Engineering Electrical Engineering Medical Science Electronics & Communication Physics Environmental Engineering Social Sciences Energy Engineering Spiritual Science Generalia Transport Vehicle Engineering Children’s Collections Astrology/Astrophysics/Astronomy Rendering format Title : subtitle / Author’s name : Publisher’s name, Year of Publication Call No. Chemical / Chemistry Computational chemistry and molecular modeling / Ramachandran, K I. : Springer, 2008 54-122:004.94 P80 [67204] Click here for more details Vol.19, Issue: 2-3 ASE-Central Library Coimbatore Chemistry for engineers - Vol. 1 / Ramachandran, T. : Vijay Nicole, 2004 54:62 P51.1 [67206] Click here for more details Top Computer Science Introduction to microcontrollers and their applications / Padmanabhan, T R.: Narosa Publishing, 2007 004.318MIC P73 [67199] Click here for more details Introduction to computer science using python : a computational problem - solving focus / Dierbach, Charles. 004.438PYT Q31 [67094] Click here for more details Insight into data mining : theory and practice / Soman, K P. : PHI Learning, 2006 004.658:025.4.036 P64 [67192] Click here for more details Vol.19, Issue: 2-3 ASE-Central Library Coimbatore Cyber security cyber crime and cyber forensics / Raghu Santanam.: Information Science Reference, 2011 004.7.056 Q15 [67202] Click here for more details Cryptography and security / Shyamala, C K. : Wiley India, 2011 004.7.056.55 Q00;10 [67197] Click here for more details Mathematical principles of the internet - vol. 1 : engineering fundamentals / Bhatnagar, Nirdosh.
[Show full text]
3.Hindu Websites Sorted Country Wise
Hindu Websites sorted Country wise Sl. Reference Country Broad catergory Website Address Description No. 1 Afghanistan Dynasty http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hindushahi Hindu Shahi Dynasty Afghanistan, Pakistan 2 Afghanistan Dynasty http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jayapala King Jayapala -Hindu Shahi Dynasty Afghanistan, Pakistan 3 Afghanistan Dynasty http://www.afghanhindu.com/history.asp The Hindu Shahi Dynasty (870 C.E. - 1015 C.E.) 4 Afghanistan History http://hindutemples- Hindu Roots of Afghanistan whthappendtothem.blogspot.com/ (Gandhar pradesh) 5 Afghanistan History http://www.hindunet.org/hindu_history/mode Hindu Kush rn/hindu_kush.html 6 Afghanistan Information http://afghanhindu.wordpress.com/ Afghan Hindus 7 Afghanistan Information http://afghanhindusandsikhs.yuku.com/ Hindus of Afaganistan 8 Afghanistan Information http://www.afghanhindu.com/vedic.asp Afghanistan and It's Vedic Culture 9 Afghanistan Information http://www.afghanhindu.de.vu/ Hindus of Afaganistan 10 Afghanistan Organisation http://www.afghanhindu.info/ Afghan Hindus 11 Afghanistan Organisation http://www.asamai.com/ Afghan Hindu Asociation 12 Afghanistan Temple http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hindu_Temples_ Hindu Temples of Kabul of_Kabul 13 Afghanistan Temples Database http://www.athithy.com/index.php?module=p Hindu Temples of Afaganistan luspoints&id=851&action=pluspoint&title=H indu%20Temples%20in%20Afghanistan%20. html 14 Argentina Ayurveda http://www.augurhostel.com/ Augur Hostel Yoga & Ayurveda 15 Argentina Festival http://www.indembarg.org.ar/en/ Festival of
[Show full text]
Main Voter List 08.01.2018.Pdf
Sl.NO ADM.NO NAME SO_DO_WO ADD1_R ADD2_R CITY_R STATE TEL_R MOBILE 61-B, Abul Fazal Apartments 22, Vasundhara 1 1150 ACHARJEE,AMITAVA S/o Shri Sudhamay Acharjee Enclave Delhi-110 096 Delhi 22620723 9312282751 22752142,22794 2 0181 ADHYARU,YASHANK S/o Shri Pravin K. Adhyaru 295, Supreme Enclave, Tower No.3, Mayur Vihar Phase-I Delhi-110 091 Delhi 745 9810813583 3 0155 AELTEMESH REIN S/o Late Shri M. Rein 107, Natraj Apartments 67, I.P. Extension Delhi-110 092 Delhi 9810214464 4 1298 AGARWAL,ALOK KRISHNA S/o Late Shri K.C. Agarwal A-56, Gulmohar Park New Delhi-110 049 Delhi 26851313 AGARWAL,DARSHANA 5 1337 (MRS.) (Faizi) W/o Shri O.P. Faizi Flat No. 258, Kailash Hills New Delhi-110 065 Delhi 51621300 6 0317 AGARWAL,MAM CHANDRA S/o Shri Ram Sharan Das Flat No.1133, Sector-29, Noida-201 301 Uttar Pradesh 0120-2453952 7 1427 AGARWAL,MOHAN BABU S/o Dr. C.B. Agarwal H.No. 78, Sukhdev Vihar New Delhi-110 025 Delhi 26919586 8 1021 AGARWAL,NEETA (MRS.) W/o Shri K.C. Agarwal B-608, Anand Lok Society Mayur Vihar Phase-I Delhi-110 091 Delhi 9312059240 9810139122 9 0687 AGARWAL,RAJEEV S/o Shri R.C. Agarwal 244, Bharat Apartment Sector-13, Rohini Delhi-110 085 Delhi 27554674 9810028877 11 1400 AGARWAL,S.K. S/o Shri Kishan Lal 78, Kirpal Apartments 44, I.P. Extension, Patparganj Delhi-110 092 Delhi 22721132 12 0933 AGARWAL,SUNIL KUMAR S/o Murlidhar Agarwal WB-106, Shakarpur, Delhi 9868036752 13 1199 AGARWAL,SURESH KUMAR S/o Shri Narain Dass B-28, Sector-53 Noida, (UP) Uttar Pradesh0120-2583477 9818791243 15 0242 AGGARWAL,ARUN S/o Shri Uma Shankar Agarwal Flat No.26, Trilok Apartments Plot No.85, Patparganj Delhi-110 092 Delhi 22433988 16 0194 AGGARWAL,MRIDUL (MRS.) W/o Shri Rajesh Aggarwal Flat No.214, Supreme Enclave Mayur Vihar Phase-I, Delhi-110 091 Delhi 22795565 17 0484 AGGARWAL,PRADEEP S/o Late R.P.
[Show full text]
2.Hindu Websites Sorted Category Wise
Hindu Websites sorted Category wise Sl. No. Broad catergory Website Address Description Reference Country 1 Archaelogy http://aryaculture.tripod.com/vedicdharma/id10. India's Cultural Link with Ancient Mexico html America 2 Archaelogy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harappa Harappa Civilisation India 3 Archaelogy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indus_Valley_Civil Indus Valley Civilisation India ization 4 Archaelogy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kiradu_temples Kiradu Barmer Temples India 5 Archaelogy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mohenjo_Daro Mohenjo_Daro Civilisation India 6 Archaelogy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nalanda Nalanda University India 7 Archaelogy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxila Takshashila University Pakistan 8 Archaelogy http://selians.blogspot.in/2010/01/ganesha- Ganesha, ‘lingga yoni’ found at newly Indonesia lingga-yoni-found-at-newly.html discovered site 9 Archaelogy http://vedicarcheologicaldiscoveries.wordpress.c Ancient Idol of Lord Vishnu found Russia om/2012/05/27/ancient-idol-of-lord-vishnu- during excavation in an old village in found-during-excavation-in-an-old-village-in- Russia’s Volga Region russias-volga-region/ 10 Archaelogy http://vedicarcheologicaldiscoveries.wordpress.c Mahendraparvata, 1,200-Year-Old Cambodia om/2013/06/15/mahendraparvata-1200-year- Lost Medieval City In Cambodia, old-lost-medieval-city-in-cambodia-unearthed- Unearthed By Archaeologists 11 Archaelogy http://wikimapia.org/7359843/Takshashila- Takshashila University Pakistan Taxila 12 Archaelogy http://www.agamahindu.com/vietnam-hindu- Vietnam
[Show full text]
Titik Temu Vol 3 No 2 Set.Indd
DEMOKRASI, DEMOKRATISASI, DAN OPOSISI TITIK-TEMU, Vol. 3, No. 2, Januari - Juni 2011 i ttitikitik ttemuemu vvolol 3 nnoo 2 sset.inddet.indd i 113/05/20113/05/2011 66:23:39:23:39 NURCHOLISH MADJID ii TITIK-TEMU, Vol. 3, No. 2, Januari - Juni 2011 ttitikitik ttemuemu vvolol 3 nnoo 2 sset.inddet.indd iiii 113/05/20113/05/2011 66:24:10:24:10 DEMOKRASI, DEMOKRATISASI, DAN OPOSISI ISSN 1979-5394 TITIK-TEMU JURNAL DIALOG PERADABAN Volume 3, Nomor 2, Januari - Juni 2011 Diterbitkan oleh Nurcholish Madjid Society (NCMS) Sekretariat: Nurcholish Madjid Society Graha STR, Lt. 4, Jl. Ampera Raya No. 11, Kemang Jakarta Selatan 12550 E-mail: [email protected] Pemimpin Redaksi Kautsar Azhari Noer Sekretaris Redaksi Fachrurozi • Sunaryo Redaktur Pelaksana Muhamad Wahyuni Nafi s • Abdul Hakim Dewan Redaksi Abdul Hakim • Budhy Munawar-Rachman • Fachrurozi • Kautsar Azhari Noer • Moh. Monib • Muhamad Wahyuni Nafi s • Sunaryo • Yudi Latif • Zainun Kamal Pewajah Sampul Taqi Kanara Pewajah Isi Moh. Syu‘bi Titik-Temu terbit setiap enam bulan. Redaksi menerima tulisan ilmiah dari kalangan manapun dan berhak menyunting, memperbaiki dan menyempurnakan naskah tulisan yang diterima. Naskah tulisan berkisar antara 15-25 halaman kuarto dengan ketikan spasi ganda dan dikirim via e-mail. TITIK-TEMU, Vol. 3, No. 2, Januari - Juni 2011 iii ttitikitik ttemuemu vvolol 3 nnoo 2 sset.inddet.indd iiiiii 113/05/20113/05/2011 66:24:10:24:10 NURCHOLISH MADJID iv TITIK-TEMU, Vol. 3, No. 2, Januari - Juni 2011 ttitikitik ttemuemu vvolol 3 nnoo 2 sset.inddet.indd iivv 113/05/20113/05/2011 66:24:10:24:10 DEMOKRASI, DEMOKRATISASI, DAN OPOSISI ISSN 1979-5394 TITIK-TEMU JURNAL DIALOG PERADABAN Volume 3, Nomor 2, Januari - Juni 2011 DAFTAR ISI Pedoman Transliterasi 1 Daftar Surat al-Qur’an 3-4 Cuplikan dari Wirid Ibn ‘Arabi 5-8 Menyatukan Kata dan Perbuatan 9 Pengantar 10-16 SAJIAN KHUSUS Demokrasi, Demokratisasi, dan Oposisi Nurcholish Madjid 18-27 Nurcholish Madjid, Sosok Pribadi Pengimbang Muhamad Wahyuni Nafi s 28-39 ARTIKEL Islam dan Demokrasi M.
[Show full text]
Hinduism and Hinduism and Monotheistic Religions, Foreword by David Frawley (Vamadeva Shastri)
Hinduism and Hinduism and monotheistic religions, foreword by David Frawley (Vamadeva Shastri). – 2009, xxvi,550p., ind., 22cm. ISBN 9788185990842 Price: Rs. 900.00 This volume comprises the largest collection of Shri Ram Swarup’s writings ever published between two covers. Many of the articles have been printed for the very first time, and they span a period of over four decades. The book includes critiques of Christian and Islamic thought from a Hindu perspective and suggestions on how Hinduism can be practiced in modern times in tune with its deeper spiritual teachings. It also incorporates several short articles and book reviews written for various newspapers and magazines. The volume is divided roughly into three sections dealing with Hinduism, Christianity and Islam respectively. In each section, the reader will come across writings on many different topics illuminating the Dharmic perspective on numerous issues of modern relevance. These writings show Ram Swarup’s profound understanding of social, historical, religious and spiritual issues and also illustrate how Dharmic principles can provide a solution to problems facing humanity today. The author’s writings offer a compelling intellectual and spiritual defense of Hinduism vis-a- vis competing world-views, and provide for a practical way to put Hindu renaissance back on track. Ram Swarup was a unique thinker who not only showed an acute awareness of modern challenges to and distortions of Hindu traditions, but also suggested practical remedies that were rooted in the perennial Hindu spirituality itself. He demonstrated the universality of Hinduism in space and time and its ability to adapt itself to ever changing conditions in our world, even while retaining its core principles.
[Show full text]
Dharmic Ecology and the Neo-Pagan International: the Dangers of Religious Environmentalism in India
Dharmic Ecology and the Neo-Pagan International: The Dangers of Religious Environmentalism in India Meera Nanda Paper presented at the 18th European Conference on Modern South Asian Studies Lunds University, Sweden July 8, 2004 [email protected] 1. Let me introduce the subject matter of my paper with a news story from the June 19th issue of The Frontline. The story is about a Pani yatra (or water pilgrimage) organized by the district collector of Osmanabad district of Maharashtra, in cooperation with 40 local NGOs, including scientists and environmentalists from the Tata Institute of Social Sciences. Osmanabad has suffered from a drought for many years, and the yatra was meant to increase the awareness of local water conservation methods. As a centerpiece for their yatra, the organizers took a pot, filled it with well water, which according to radio-carbon dating, was some 700-years old. They dressed up this pot with Hindu religious items (red cloth, garlands and coconuts) and took it around as they performed street plays and lectured on the importance of water conservation. According to the story, “people came out in large numbers to offer prayers to the kalash,” as they took in the rest of the political theater. 2. Pani yatra is by no means an isolated incidence. In order to mobilize the masses, the mainstream Indian environmentalists have not shied away from invoking Hindu imagery and myths. Just about every popular Hindu ritual or idea has been tapped for its potential for mobilization on behalf of the environment. Examples range form women tying rakhis to trees, mass recitations of bhagwat purana at the site of Chipko, fasts, religious vows on the river banks and temples, invocations of Krishna as the lord of cows and pastures, invocations of shakti, devi, bhu mata (or Narmada mata, or Ganga mata), karma, reincarnation, sacred trees, rivers, and even jati, reinterpreted as biological species living in harmony with their environment.
[Show full text]
Occasional Paper No. 159 ARCHAEOLOGY AS EVIDENCE: LOOKING BACK from the AYODHYA DEBATE TAPATI GUHA-THAKURTA CENTRE for STUDIES I
Occasional Paper No. 159 ARCHAEOLOGY AS EVIDENCE: LOOKING BACK FROM THE AYODHYA DEBATE TAPATI GUHA-THAKURTA CENTRE FOR STUDIES IN SOCIAL SCIENCES, CALCUTTA EH £>2&3 Occasional Paper No. 159 ARCHAEOLOGY AS EVIDENCE: LOOKING BACK FROM THE AYODHYA DEBATE j ; vmm 12 AOS 1097 TAPATI GUHA-THAKURTA APRIL 1997 CENTRE FOR STUDIES IN SOCIAL SCIENCES, CALCUTTA 10 Lake Terrace, Calcutta 700 029 1 ARCHAEOLOGY AS EVIDENCE: LOOKING BACK FROM THE AYODHYA DEBATE Tapati Guha-Thakurta Archaeology in India hit the headlines with the Ayodhya controversy: no other discipline stands as centrally implicated in the crisis that has racked this temple town, and with it, the whole nation. The Ramjanmabhoomi movement, as we know, gained its entire logic and momentum from the claims to the prior existence of a Hindu temple at the precise site of the 16th century mosque that was erected by Babar. Myth and legend, faith and belief acquired the armour of historicity in ways that could present a series of conjectures as undisputed facts. So, the 'certainty' of present-day Ayodhya as the historical birthplace of Lord Rama passes into the 'certainty' of the presence of an lOth/llth century Vaishnava temple commemorating the birthplace site, both these in turn building up to the 'hard fact' of the demolition of this temple in the 16th century to make way for the Babri Masjid. Such invocation of'facts' made it imperative for a camp of left/liberal/secular historians to attack these certainties, to riddle them with doubts and counter-facts. What this has involved is a righteous recuperation of the fields of history and archaeology from their political misuse.
[Show full text]