Adaptive Optimization in the Jalapeno˜ JVM
£ £ £ £ £
Matthew Arnold ¢¡ Stephen Fink David Grove Michael Hind Peter F. Sweeney
£ IBM T.J. Watson Research Center Rutgers University
¤¦¥¨§ © ¦ ! " #$¥%'&)(*¥,+ .- !+ /,
102 3¨ &4/,¥,+ 2( 52¥,+ ,6(
ABSTRACT /2 *6'¥2)/ Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ !520¦,52¥,m58T" ¨/,03 3¨T:/ Q" 3 *1,0/2 : 1,58 *6
=? ¨58 Y0J© ^ ,Z¥2,5C#;¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ ¥X58 *!© ¥25C58 ¨ :! ¨5C=?0¥: 9
(*58( ) ¨ 9$"¢2#$¦ :0 /,; 58( 03< 10/2 ,¥>=? 3 3 ¨ @"¦>"¢29
7
¦ 6,+XG? ,¥2C 58(*0¦34 10/2 ,¥: */3 (* X,023¨Ta=?2 I¥8( / Z0'¥
#A :0¦ */,B58 ¦(*¦ C¥2" ¨¥258 ¨/052,D 3 *>#$,,6-*0'/ 69E6 ,/,52,C¦"9
58 CRU 103 3¨5203 69E®'¯ys t¦°vj0¦ *aRU3 #9E±²Xs¨²,uvj¥2T6¥252 :¥,<0¥;=B¢3 3j0¥;0
58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ *¥,+HG? ¨¥!"*0¦"¢I"¥2¢ 52¥J58 K0¦/ ¨52,/,58( L#C58
6( b-j# :/,¢ 5 0¦¦0)¥2T6¥252 :¥?s.²'³'u ²,° °m´vE+cOL¥2,/,¦ *
0¦3¨0"6N *IO4 0" 58 ¨DP)" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,058 ¨¦ SRUT6¥252, D<0!¥2T6¥252, V52!¥8( "9 M
M
=?0¦;¦#j :;¥2¦" ¨¥258 ¨/,0'52,K 58( 03j :0'/ *¥4 :¦!-,T¦ *
"W5X3¨,06 *¦9E,'Y 58(*0¦3C :0'/ *Z52,/2 3¨'T[0¦ *[ *0¦-3¨
58 ¨¥)¥8 ¨ @"3¨@¥258052,'T:- T\ T 0 Q ¨/,0¦3 3¨TJ¥23¨,/,58 \01¥8(- ¥2,5>#q03 3
¦ *' \,¥20/2 X D¦ 3 Q#$,U- 0/2 69EU ,/52,X" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ ¥,+
¢^ ,/(*52,D :,58 6¥?#$¦?¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ cf05252, @"*58 :52;#$6/¢( ¥?" 9
I,¥2/2 -K58 X¢^ 52¢ ¥8 -3¨L¥2T6¥252, _0/2 ¨52/,58('4-*0'¥2,Y
]
58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ I¢~W5?¦ \" ¦0 µ 5?¥8"W52¥,+BRUT6¥252 :¥ X58 ¨¥?/,0'589
0C#$, ¢058 ¨¦ Z#>58 ,0 ¥@=` ¨58 a0¥2T /2 ¦ *¦(*¥C/,' : b( ¨/,058 ¨¦ c+
,'T! /¢3 (* DRU3 #9E±³Js ³6t,v858 @45R"'5 {Hs ³'°vE58 *1B{
M6z \" ,¥2¢ 5C0¦ d ¨ @"3¨, 1¢ 52058 ¨¦ [¦#;58 ! *¢0¦3e0/2 ¨52,/58(
]
0¦¦0 ( ¥2589$ 9EG? ¨ :X/,' Q" 3¨J|$'¢¥8 ¨ S³+ ¯6}\s °³¦v8 P¸s.²®vE
M M M6¶e· 58 05f¥8(" "¦52¥<0 0" 58 ¨> b( 3¨58 9$3¨,3*¦"*58 ¨ Q ¨F058 ¨ C- 0¥2,;" (¢3¨T
0 Y58 ! ¨58 ¨0¦3:¥2520'I#;58 03¨0"WUN *LOe0¦"*58 ¨'LP)"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,09
M ¦ Y¥2520'58 ¨¥258 ¨/,03@¥20' Q"3 + D, Q" 2 ¨/,03 3gTY , : ¥258052I58 05
]
58 ¨ ¹RUT6¥252 µ ,¥2/¢2 -,! k58 ¨¥?" 0"¦+?R6 1;¥2,/, 698=B0'; 29
58 ¨¥;"¦©3 K52,/2 ¨h( ! *0'¥b3¨¦=i¦¢2 ,0L0¦ *K/0 K ¨ Q" ¦
58( 03f :0/2 *,¥e03¨¥2Q /¢3 ( ;3 ¨ Q ¨52,!#A :¥?¦#<¦ 3 b#A,,6-*0'/ 69
¥2520¦58("10 ;¥252,0'T9E¥252052j"¢2#$¦ :0 /,', @=` ¨58 ( 5<58 c",¥89
6 ,/,52,L" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ |$+ +Q 3 K ZR6¢3 #9E±³m}¢c-( 5; ! *'5
*/,C¦#4¦ 3 !#$,U- 0/2 69EU ,/52,L" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,058 ¨¦ ¥,+KG? Q" 0"¢
,¢3¨¦"p¢ ¢0¦3; :,/2 0 ¨¥2 :¥!#$º0 0" 58 ¨K¦ 3 ¹#A,,6-*0'/ 69
0¦3¨¥2C,¥2/2 -,¥;0 X,¦03 ( 052¥40 k 3 *:#$,U- 0/2 69EU /,52,X 9
6 ,/,52,X¦"*58 ¨ Q ¨F058 ¨ q+
3 X" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,058 ¨¦ K- 0¥2,D X¥2520'58 ¨¥258 ¨/,03B, ;¥20' Q"3 +>G?
¥2T6¥252 l ¨¥j=?2 ¨5252¢ C/,' Q" 3¨,52¢3¨TQ 0¦¦0m0" "3¨T :58 ?¥2/¢2 -,
M
O» 6( ;-¢1#?,¥20/2 K"§¢,/52¥b 0¦C¢^6" 3¨,L :¦\0'¦,¥89
52/ ¨h( ,¥J 5X¦ 3¨TY52Z0" "3 ¨/058 ¨ n/,6 K0 o¥2520¦ * 0p3 9
¥8 ¨@#$ :¥e#BT 0 @ ¨/\/ Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ os ³6¼6c± <²¦t6<²,³f®ft'´Uft¦®
- 02 ¨¥,*-( 5>03¨¥2C52:58 Q 58( 03q :0/2 Q ¨52¥2¢3 #r+
³® c³m´Uj²,± c³'±vE( ¥8 *!2( 58 ¨ :: #$ :0'58 ¨ Z52!520¦ 3¨158 *1¢^69 ,/¢( 520- 3¨:52: ¨52¥4/(2¢ 5e¢ :¢ 5,+e{X¥25e#B58 *¥2Q¥2T6¥252, 1¥
1. INTRODUCTION =?¢? 5<#( 3 3¨T\0¦(*52' :058 ¨/'0¦ *C¥24#$0¦¦#$,=Z#f58 ,¥2>52,/ ¨h(*,¥
G? >T 0 Q ¨/4 058( 4¦#f58 * 0¦04" ¦0 : Q Q3¨0¦ *¦(*0'Cs t¦uv
M
0'!0¦""0,L Y :0¦ *¥258,0' {X¥,+a4¦=?,'¢¦j58 *,¥2D¥2T6¥89
M6z
" ,¥2¢ 52¥c-W58 158 *<3¨0',¥25
52, :¥j *0¦; , :¦ *¥2580'52,!58 05>¦ 3 b#A,,6-*0'/ 69E6 ,/,52,X¦"*58 9
¨58TC#$> ¨ 9$"¢2#$¦ :0 /, 0¦¦0Q ¨ Q" 3¨, :¢ 520'58 ¨ ¥,+ewc0¦ *¦(*0'
M
Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ ¥;/,0 IT ¨3¨J¥8( -*¥2520¦ 58 ¨03j"¢2#$¦ :0 /,; ¨ Q" ', :¢ 52¥,+
#A,058( ,¥:¥8( / S0¥: T 0 Q ¨/I/¢3¨0¥2¥:3¨'06 *L0 dx*,/58 ¨ y" ¢9
5>¥2, :¥>/¢3¨,0 58 *0'540Q m,T!/ Q"¦ * 5) I58 b( "/,' Q *D58
'¢ 5;¥2580 ¨¦ 58#$=B0K0¦"" 3 ¨/,058 ¨¦ *¥C¦#?580'U ¨58 ¨¦ *0¦3>¥252058 ¨/:/ Q9
=?0¦e#< ¨ 9$"¢2#$¦ :0 /,: 58( 03q :0/2 ,¥e=` 3 3f-;¥2" ¨¥258 9
" 3¨058 ¨¦ K0¦ *: 52¢2" 6/,,6( 03<¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ <+>O4¥j0b¥8(3¨5, 0¦¦0
M
/,0'52,!0'0¦"*58 ¨': 3 *@#$,,6-*0'/ 69E6 ,/,52,I" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ ¥,+
58(*0¦3?{X0'/ !| {I}? ¨ Q"3¨ :¢ 52¥; 0'b ',¥252,K¥8 ¨¦ #g9
z M6z
¨/0 5@¢~5; L ,3¨" *K T 0 Q ¨/C/,' Q" 3¨¥Q#$ 0¦¦0+1?¢9
M
03¨0¦"6N Ys t6³¦v> ¨¥:0¹¥2,0/2 {½- *L ,¢3¨¦",Y0'5:58 *
M M6z
/0( ¥2XT 0 Q ¨/X/ Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ [6/,/(¥C6(2 L0" "3 ¨/,0'58 ¨ ¢^ ¢9
B{HGb+ + 052¥2¦ L¾>,¥2,0¦/ Z¿?¢ 52¦+QG? ¨¥b" 0"W¢; 586U( /,,¥
M ]
/(*58 ¨¦ c T 0 Q ¨/@/,' Q" 3¨¥4 ;(*¥25>/,0¦¢#( 3 3¨T\- 03¨0 /,@" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0¦9
58 03¨0"WUN *DO4 0" 58 ¨1P)"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ ZRUT6¥252 !*0Q m,T!/ Q"¦9
M
58 ¨¦ [~,/,58 ¨'¢ *¥2¥J=? ¨58 /, Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ '¢2 ,0p52L :0^6 ¨ Q ¨F
¢ 5:#e58 03¨0"WUN * {K+fÀÁ, ¨¦(*¥:" 0"¥!s t6>²,°vB-2 ¨¢x T
M M6z
52'5203f¥2T6¥252, i"¢2#$¦ :0 /,+j4¦=?¢¦ T *0' Q ¨/;/, @" 3¨¢¥e/,0
,¥2/¢2 -X58 C0 0" 58 ¨X" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ p¥2T6¥252, Â0'5Q0X ¨¦ L3¨,¢3$+
0¦3¨¥2K¢^6" 3¨ ¨5:2( 58 ¨ :! #A :0'58 ¨ p52!"¢2#A ¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ *¥
G? ¨¥j"*0¦"¢?" ,¥2¢ 52¥>58 `© ¥25? ,¥2/¢2 " 58 ¨ I¦#c58 40¦/ ¨52,/,58( 03
-W,T¦ *X58 Q¥2/";¦#j0Q"( ¢3¨TX¥2520'58 ¨/;/, Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ L :6 ¢3$+
,520 3¨¥, ¨ Q" 3¨, :¢ 520'58 ¨ fc0¦ *!"2#$ :0¦ */b,¥8( 3¨52¥,+
G? !©¥25C=?0¦'!#@ 58( 03 :0/2 *,¥C"¦ ¨ , (*¥2589rA 9EG? ¨ :
M
G? *; 10 I/,¦ 582 -( 58 ¨ ¥Q¦#j58 ¨¥?" 0";0
| $Ge})/,' Q" 3¨0'58 ¨ Z58 054¢3 ¨,a a¥8 ¨ Q"3¨C¥2520'58 ¨/\¥2580'52, ¨¥;52
M
/
0 a¢^ 52¢ ¥8 -3¨X0'0¦"*58 ¨'C" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,058 ¨¦ Y0¦/ ¨52,/,58( C58 *0'5
2000 ACM Ã
-58 p¥8( " "52¥X/¢( 2¢ 5:3¨,0'U 9E, {Ä52,/2 *¦3¨T This copy is posted by permission of ACM and may not be redis- M6z tributed. The official citation of this work is Arnold, M., Fink, S., 0 X¢ 0- 3¨,¥),¥20/2 ! 52:¦ 3 b#A,,6-*0'/ 69E6 ,/,52,I" 9 Grove, D., Hind, M., and Sweeney, P.F. 2000. Adaptive Optimization 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ f
in the Jalapeno˜ JVM. :cV*¦?Wbi<,,2,4KB$,¢¦
58 *j , : ¥258058 ¨¦ C# 3¨¦=?98¦'¢2 *0@¥20 Q" 3 *;52/ ¨h( ,¥
Ã
j¢AW :r¡mr¢£Q£@ ¡¤j*¥¦$,£Q¦¤<¢ ¡§ ¢¦¡U,¦¤<¢ 1`¨6¨©
52LU2 ¨'K0 0" 58 ¨K0¦ *Y¦ 3 K#$,,6- 0/2 6986 ,/,52o¦"*58 9 ¬6¬, ¢6$*¦bªej*I« , Minneapolis, Minnesota, October 15–19, 2000. Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ ¥,
¿`' Q" 3¨¢ ?T652,/6@?T652,¥ ¦{! 3 3 ¨¥2/
58 *> , :¦ *¥2580'58 ¨ I#f0¦ !0'0¦"*58 ¨';" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ a¥2T6¥252,
Ã
58 *0'5?(*¥2,¥> ;(3¨58 " 3¨C" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ K3¨,'¢3¨¥;52Q ¨ Q" ¦;"¢29 ?0¥2¢3 t´¦°+¨²,°
#$ 10 /,Q/ Q" 0,I52Q( ¥8 *X¦ 3¨TX0C¥8 3¨Q3¨¢3B#j¦"9 P)"*5>wc¢3q¯ ®+ ´´
58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ fc0¦ * P)"*5>wc¢3B² ³+ ¼±
P)"*5>wc¢3Át tU+ ¯6´
0 L ¨58 ¨034 ¨ @"3¨, 1¢ 52058 ¨¦ [0¦ *Z,¦03 ( 058 ¨ p¦#;¦(:© ¥25
Ã
3 *C#$,,6- 0/2 6986 ,/,52y" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ 3 I-*0'¥2,
@3¨¦=`9E¦2 *,0'!¥20' Q"3 : 0520 + ¥ ¥ §!"£#%$'&()§*+(,#.- §*£/0#%- *+12 "¦',¥"¢2#A :0¦ */,4- TD²²¢¡i D0¦¢0' =? ¨58 \ ¨ @"¦9 346587:9; <$'=¥>?@ -2"A1$B ;C'/¢D(* :¢ 52¥?0 \( "X52º´³£¡C+ ¢ ¢058 ¨¦ /, ¥2520 5,@58T"W4 9 6( 3 3$:0¦ *p/,¦" T G? ? *¢^ 5<¥2/,58 ¨ C" ¨ ,¥?¥2' :?-*0'/ ¦( *C¦ C58 * 0¦3¨0"6N M "¦"*0'058 ¨¦ 2¤ /,¦ *¥2520¦ 5Á#A3¨6 *;0¦ *@02 ¨58 :,58 ¨/e¥8 ¨ Q9 {K+ M6z M "3 © /,058 ¨¦ 2¤ ( ,0'/ 0- 3¨>/,6j¢3 ¨ Q 058 ¨¦ ¤ 0 Q3 ¨ Q9 0'0¦"*58 ¨':" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ L¥2T6¥252 0 ! ¨¦ 3 ¨¦ 52¥b m,T: ¨¥2¥8(*,¥;0¦ * *0'58 ¨ Z#?U( * 0 5: 6( 3 3¨/ ,/2 ¥,?/2 */ m/,0¥252¥,<0¦ * ,¥8 ¨¦ L/¢ ¨¥8 ¨ ¥,+CR6,/,58 ¨¦ K°C ,¥2/¢2 -,¥@58 Q,/,' Q" 3¨0'58 ¨ L ¨ Q9 020¦TC¥252;/2 *,/2 ¥,+ " 3¨, : 52058 ¨ f+ RU,/58 ¨ ¼Q¥2/¢2 -,¥;¦(e©¥25> 3 º#A,,6-*0'/ 69 6 ,/,52J¦"*58 ¨ Q ¨F058 ¨ f<0'0¦"*58 ¨'Q 3 +;R6,/,58 ¨¦ KuQ" ,¥2¢ 52¥ 0¦(*' :¢ 52¥<3¨,¢3W¯;=` ¨58 º0 U ¨58 ¨¦ *0¦3c3¨6/,0¦3" 9 ,© E ^6"¢2 ¨ :¢ 520¦3> 0520! , :¦ *¥2580'58 *X58 05;¥20' Q" 3 *X ¨¥4-58 a0 58 ¨ Q ¨F,058 ¨¦ *¥1¥8(*/2 K0'¥;/, 1 : a¥8(-W¢^6"¥2¥8 ¨ Z¢3 ¨ Q9 ~,/,58 ¨'!0 X3¨=?9E¦¢2 ,0'd 1,/ 0 ¨¥2 ¸#$@62 ¨ J0'0¦"*58 ¨' *0'58 ¨ f0¦20¦T!-( * ¥@/ ,/2 K¢3 ¨ @ *0'58 ¨ f?0 X¢9 ¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ c+ZR6,/,58 ¨¦ Y´\" ,¥2¢ 52¥@0X6 ¨¥2/¢(*¥2¥8 ¨¦ p#e( 1¢^6"¢9 U( * 0 5C3¨0'y¢3 ¨ Q 058 ¨ f+i$5:03¨¥2a0 ¥: 3 ¨ * 2 ¨ */,¥,+ *0¦3 3¨T>R6,/,58 ¨¦ L®X6 ¨¥2/¢(*¥2¥2¥Q¢3¨052d=B2 I0 LR6,/¢9 -*0'¥2,; @¥2520'58 ¨/¢9E¥8 ¨F,? *¢( 2 ¨¥258 ¨/,¥, F?3¨- 03 x =?9$ ¥2¢ *¥89 7 58 ¨¦ I±:~W¢¥4¦(e/,¦ */¢3 ( ¥8 ¨ ¥,+ ¨58 ¨@/," TC0 X/,¦ *¥2520¦ 5`" " 0'058 ¨¦ cf3¨¦-*0¦3 *¥2¢ ¥8 ¨58 ¨a,0'y0'¥2¥8 ¨ :¢ 5!3 ¨ Q *0'58 ¦ cbRU582 9 (~W¢@¥2T */2 ¨F,058 g S" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,058 ¨¦ *¥,B0 K¥2/,0¦3¨0 2. BACKGROUND ¢"3¨0'/,, : 54#j0'¦,0'52,¥40¦ *X¥8 5>020¦T6¥,+ G? 03¨0¦"6N {µ ¨¥<0>,¥2,0/2 {µ520',58 ;¥2¢¢j0¦"" 3 9 M M6z M6z /058 ¨ ¥,+IOµ/,' Q" ¢ * *¥8 ¨'X,¥2/2 "*58 ¨¦ Y# 0¦3¨0"6N I0" ",0¥ M 0( :¢ 52¥C3¨,3C²X=? ¨58 pR RUO>9- 0¥2yx*¦=?9 ,©HG s tvE+A p58 ¨¥X¥2,/,58 ¨ =?X ¨¦ 3 ¨¦ 5K58 J/2 *0¦0/,522 ¨¥258 ¨/,¥J¦# ¥2¢ *¥8 ¨58 ¨'4¦"*58 ¨ Q ¨F058 ¨ ¥,+eA º0 U ¨58 ¨¦ X524580'U ¨58 ¨¦ *0¦3 0¦3¨0"6N *D58 *0'5)0¦; :¥25?¢3¨0¦ 5452:58 ¨¥4=B2 + M RR6OÂ" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,058 ¨¦ *¥L¦ p¥2/,03¨0¦I0¦2 ¨0- 3¨,¥ys tU²v8e58 * ¥2T6¥252, 03¨¥2L(*¥2¥J0¦ [¢^ 52 * ,['¢¥8 ¨ i¦#:O>20¦T 0¦3¨0"6N *L ¨¥!=?2 ¨5252¢ y 0¦¦0ys ³vE+A Y0'6 ¨58 ¨ 52J" ¦ ¨U M M RR6O #A s t¼,ve52¹"2#$ ,6( * 0 5C3¨0Z¢3 ¨ Q9 0X ¨ 93¨¢3 ¥258 3¨T9E58T"Y,'¢3¨" :¢ 5C¢ ¦ * 1¢ 5,>58 ¨¥ *0'58 ¨ a0 !020¦TC-( * ¥4/2 ,/ k¢3 ¨ Q 058 ¨¦ Ys.²'²¢vE+ ,¥8 ¨¦ ! ,/¢ ¨¥8 ¨¦ X0¦3 3¨=>¥?58 >52,/2 ¨h(*¥?¥2/¢2 -,C C58 ¨¥<" 0"¢ 5210" "3¨T! 5e 3¨T!52:0¦"" 3 ¨/,058 ¨ /,6'- (*5e03¨¥2C52:58 { M6z G<0- 3¨Q²e ¨',¥>58 *e0¦¢0';/,' Q" 3¨0'58 ¨ I052>#$B58 *e/, @" 3¨¢¥ ¨52¥23 #2+>G? *0'5) ¨¥,*=B;0" "3¨TX0'0¦"*58 ¨':" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ Z52:58 { M6z ( ¥2,d p58 ¨¥:"*0¦"¢D S58 *XÀ<¦=?¢ÀB¿µ :0'/ *I ,¥2/¢2 -,y ¥8( - ¥2T6¥252, :¥, /¢3 ( U L58 *1/, Q" 3¨¢¥,>58 :58 ,0L¥2/2 *,6( 3¨¢¦ R6,/,58 ¨ Iu + 58 >0¦2-*0';/,¦3 3¨,/,52¦ 0 :58 40 0" 58 ¨;¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ I¥2T6¥252, ¨52¥23 #2+ 03¨0¦"6N : ;(3¨58 " 3¨¢^ ,¥ 0¦0;58 ,0 ¥?¦ 52 { M M M6z ¦§*¢©,¨r,¦¢ =? ¨/ I0¦b ¨ @"3¨, 1¢ 52,I0¥4O JIY"*58 ,0'¥,+>G? Q¥2T6¥252, 0¦3¨0"6N *Z, Q" 3¨T6¥D0K/,' Q" 3¨98¦ 3¨TY¥2580'52,T¥¤e ¨5\/ Q" 3¨,¥X03 3 M ¦¢¦ ¥8( ""¦52¥>58 ,0'!¥2/2 *U( 3 *D=? ¨58 X0@h(*0'¥8 9" ,, @"*58 ¨': :,/2 *0¦9 1,58 *6 ¥452@ *0'58 ¨@/,6;-¢#A;58 ,T!¢^ /¢(*52'+?¿( 2¢ 583¨T58 ¨¥2 !+6Kj0/2 I/, Q" 3¨¢1¢ ¢0'52,¥ =? ¨/ a0;"¦9 ¥2T6¥252 /¢3 ( ,¥;5E=?;#(3 3¨TX¦"¢0'58 ¨ 03B/, Q" 3¨¢¥,+ ¥$,©¨ 4¨ ¦ 0' "¦ 52¥C=` ¢D58 *C2( L58 0L/ ,/2 ¥C0X,6 ¨/,0'52, - ¨5Q Z0J :0'/ X/, 58¦3?, ¨¥252!52X ,52¢ @ *! #> ¨5:¥8 ( 3¨ G? * /, @" 3¨¢B580 ¥83¨052¥c- T652,/,6 ,¥<U /,583¨T4 52 à T ¨¢3¨L58 Q 58( 03?" 6/,,¥2¥2¦¦+C¿( 2¢ 583¨T<58 Q/ Q" 3¨¢¥Q ¥2¢5 ¢¦,,© W *0'58 ¨C/,6 Q- TX¥8 ¨ ;(3¨0'58 * 0¦¦0§¦ ¥;"W¢0 K¥2520/2 +:G? M 58 ,¥2XT ¨¢3¨Y" 52¥! S :,58 6y"¦3¨( ,¥X0¦ *Y¦ y3¨6"p- 0/2 /, @" 3¨¢a 6,¥! *'5!"¢2#$¦ ,¦ ¨¥252¢K0¦3 3¨6/,058 ¨¦ c+ÂG? , ,¥,+ ( 58( 4=?¦2 : */3 (* ,¥4 ,'¢3¨" *C0¦3¨2 ¨58 :¥>#$B : 7 -*0'¥2¢3 )/ Q" 3¨¢<" ¨ ,¥j0¢#$¢ *//,' Q" 3¨¢#Af52,¥2589 " 58 ¨ :0¦3;"3¨0'/,, :¢ 5X¦#:T ¨3¨ "¦ 52¥X52J,6(*/K58 *X T 0 Q ¨/ *;" (2"'¥2,¥,*0¦ *D¢ ¢0'52,¥ 058 ¨;/6e58 *0'5"¢2#$¦ :¥ 6( b-!¦#;T ¨¢3¨Y"¦ 52¥!¢^ ,/(*52,Z=? 3¨I¥258 3 3;¥8( ""W58 y¢#9 3¨T!¥83 ¨¦ 583¨T!-,5252¢ 58 *0¦ !- T652,/,6 ; 52¢2"52058 ¨ Ss t,v8+ #$,/58 ¨:h( 0¥8 9$" ,, Q" 58 ¨D58 ,0'K¥2/2 *,6( 3 * + ¥8 !0!58 ¨ 1¢29 ¶ 52¢22( "*5e :,/2 *0¦ ¨¥2 D0 ! 5222(" 54 *0¦ *63¨¢e"¢2 ¨66 ¨/,03 3gTJ¥252¥ G? * /, @" 3¨¢@s¨²,°¦v*580¦ *¥83¨0'52,¥?- T652,/,6 ,¥ 52 à ¢¨f£@©¨g ¡ 0;- ¨5> k03 3f 58( 03c" 6/,,¥2¥2¦¥,+ *¢ k0Q2( *C58 ,0C *^ 5 ] 0 ; 52¢ 1,U ¨0'52¢" ,¥2¢ 520'58 ¨ fU( "¦ :=? ¨/ ; ¨5"¢2#$¦ :¥ ,0'/ ,¥40CT ¨¢3¨X"¦ 5,c0C/2 *,/2 X¦#j58 *;- ¨54=? 3 3<,¥8( 3¨54 I0\/03 3 0J¦0¦2 ¨,58TL#e¦"*58 ¨ Q ¨F058 ¨ ¥¦+YG? *D/, Q" 3¨¢D(*¥2,¥@3 *,0¦ 52I58 *X¥2/2 *U( 3¨¢¦+RU/,58 ¨ S°KU ¨¥2/(*¥2¥2,¥C *¦= =?D¢^6" 3¨ ¨5!58 ¨¥ ¥2/,0 I,¦ ¨¥252¢:0¦3 3¨6/,058 ¨¦ is °'¯vE0 L C/¢ ¨¢ 5@0 K¢~/,58 ¨ :,/2 0 ¨¥2 X58 Q/(2¢ 5>'¢¥8 ¨ I¦#j( ;¥2T6¥252, !+ , ¨¥252@03 3¨6/,0'52¦+ ¦@58 ¨¥4" 0"¦<=?@( "L58 Q/ Q9 7 " 3¨¢¦ ¥e" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,058 ¨¦ *¥; 52C¥2,03c3¨¢3¨¥ O4¥e¥8 *¦=? I ¨( !²f0 03¨0¦"6N X/, Q" 3¨¢C/0 I-b ' m, 7 M /, ¥8 ¨¥252¥@ :0 3¨TJ¦#?0D¥2,54¦#?¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ *¥ Z58 !=?0¦T6¥,+ ¥25,B=? *¢ 58 *D¢^ ,/¢( 58 *a/,6!0/2 *,¥10 7 ',©<¬ "¢2#A :,X¦ 9E58 ¢9$x*TDU( 2 X58 *;580¦ *¥83¨0'58 ¨ K#' F¢G? K/,' Q" 3¨J"2#$ :¥!-W58 [( *¦(*0¦o 3 p#:© 03 - T652,/,6 ,¥e52Q58 4 52¢ :,6 ¨052@¢"¥2¢ 52058 ¨¦ c+BO4¥ 0 C¥252058 ¨/e :,58 6¥?0¦ *C¦(*0¦,: 3 ¨ \¦# *¦ 9$© *0¦3c 58( 03 58 ,¥2:" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ ¥Q,6(*/:58 *1¥8 ¨F,:#B58 :¢ ¢29 :,58 6 ¥,+@A a0 U ¨58 ¨¦ cq58 *:/ Q" 3¨¢1¢^6"3¨¦ ¨52¥BL$"¢^6 ¨¥252¢ /,M 052!$¾;U"W¢2#$ @ *C58 , µ52¢ ¥)52;,6(*/4¦¢0¦3 3 52L¥20#$3¨Td"¢2#A ( *¦(*0¦ 3 ¨ o¦#@¥2 :X 6/,0'58 ¨ ¥ /,' Q" 3¨0'58 ¨ 58 ¨ :ys °6¼,v8+n¿(2 583¨T;58 J/,' Q" 3¨¢ #> 9$© 03e 58( 03e :,58 6¥ N h( 2 K¥2520/2 I#0 : $©O*§ ,=?2 ¨58 \¦ X ¦03 ¨ 058 g Ys t³¦v8+ "¢2#A :¥D58 *X#$3 3¨¦=? Y" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,058 ¨¦ *¥aU( 2 *S¾ Machine Executing Code Lazy Compilation Profiling Data Code Stub Invoked Unresolved Resolution Reference Adaptive Compilers Optimization Dynamic [Base,Opt,...] System Linker Compile Class Load Request Class Init ClassLoader (Re)Compilation Plan (!%D B¥ 7 #%$'&()§*+(,#.-B/"£ -2 ;(#¥/ ()-'*¢12¢¡¥&@¤£-2#¥¡§¦¥¨ ( ,¥23¨',K¢#$¢¢ /,/0( ¥8 *X0: ,=[/¢3¨0'¥2¥Q52:-;3¨0',<58 3.1 Runtime Measurements Subsystem /3¨0¥2¥<3¨0 ¢< ' 6¥0e/, Q" 3¨¢B52>/, Q" 3¨>58 *B/¢3¨0¥2¥c ¨58 ¨03¨ ¨F,¢ G? *@2( 58 ¨ :C :0¥8( , :¢ 52¥@¥8(- ¥2T6¥252, Â0'58 *¥4 #$¦ :058 ¨¦ | #q ;¢^6 ¨¥252¥}¢+jG? *e/¢3¨0¥2¥>3¨0 ¢e03¨¥2@ ¨58 ¨0¦3 F,¥;58 *e/, Q" 3¨, 0-W( 5458 Q¢^ /¢(*58 ! 1,58 *6 ¥,f¥8(* : 102 ¨F,,¥;58 4 #$ :0'58 ¨ f /64#$¦?0¦3 3< :58 *6 ¥>52Q0 +fG` 4¥2/, 0 X58 ¢ X¢ ¨58 ¢e"*0'¥2¥2,¥458 Q¥8( : :0¦TC03¨ !52158 *;/,¦ 583 3¨¢ ©¨¢¢¨¥@£>¨©¨¢6$:¦A§ / Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ X¥2/,¢ 02 ¨@6/,/¢( ¥<=? * *,'¢B58 *?^ ,/¢( 58 *@/,6 ?0589 ¨0C58 *@'0 ¨F,¢@,'¢ 54h( ¢( Q¦>,/, ¥458 ; #$¦ :058 ¨¦ J 52 Q"*52¥>52Q ' mQ0@ :,58 6X58 *0'5 0¥) 5BT,5?-, X/,' Q" 3¨+ 58 ;O4P;RC0'520- 0¥2+ * L58 ¨¥4 0" "¢ ¥,<58 Q3¨0FTX/, Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ Y¥258( -J ¨¥;^ ,/¢( 52, ] =? ¨/ D3¨,0 ¥>52Q58 4/ Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ K¦#<58 4 :,58 6+>A D58 ,¥2)© ¥25 ¨( Dt:¥8 *¦=>¥;58 *1¥2582(*/,58( :¦#?58 b2( 58 ¨ :C :,0'¥8( :¢ 52¥ 7 5E=?C¥2/,¢ 02 ¨'¥,<58 *@0" " 3 ¨/,058 ¨¦ Y58 ,0X58 05;/,0¦(*¥2J58 Q/ Q9 ¥8( -*¥2T6¥252, D+pRU¢0¦3;¥2T6¥252, :¥,j */3 (*6 d ¥2582( :¢ 52058 ¨¦ o " 3¨¢@52Q-W4 m,I=` 3 3q¥25203 3<( 58 3 58 J¢^ /¢(*58 Y/,6 4 0 =?0X"¢2#A :0¦ */,a : ¨52¥,;0¦ * { ¥2582(* : 52058 ¨ f*" 6U( /,40¦=d" © 3 *C 0520@0¥j58 *>"¦9 z K58 C58 a¥2/,¢ 02 ¨j=? ¨/ K ¨¥;58 :#$6/¢( ¥;#>58 ¨¥;"*0¦"¢¦<58 0' 2( *¥,+ ¥8( 03 3¨T<58 ,¥2C¥2T6¥252, :¥4"W¢2#$ V 3¨TJ¢^ 58 :¢3¨T ¶ 0'0¦"*58 ¨'X" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ ¥2T6¥252, /,0¦ L mX0J/ Q" 3¨¢D=? *¢ 3 ¨ Q ¨52,:" 6/,,¥2¥8 Q¦#*58 0¦=L0'52040'¥c ¨5c ¨¥c"66(*/,+`A ¥252,0 " © 3 J 0520C¥8( ¥252¥;58 *0'5 0C :,58 6J=? ¨58 I0'U9 ¥2¢" 00'52\58 ,0'¥@/,03 3¨ "¢2 ¨66 ¨/,03¨3¨TK"6/,¥2¥Q0¦ * 2£)¨© g ¡ A¡6¢*©¨¦¦ 6 ¨58 ¨ 03B" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ ¥Q 10T:-;-¢ ¢© /¢ ¨03$+ 0 03¨T6F\58 ;0=0'520+;G? Q ,¥8 ¨ ¥2¢"*0¦052,¥;58 @¢ ¢058 ¨¦ #;0¦= " © 3 Y0'520 #g H58 J 0520L0 03¨T6¥8 ¨¥X#$¦!5E=?J,0¦9 G? 0¦3¨0"6N { -,¦ *¥e¢^ ,/¢( 58 ¨ D- Tº06 *Q#g µ0 ¥2 ¥,+ ¥25, 58 ¨¥? ,¥8 ¨¦ !0¦3 3¨¦=)¥> ;(3¨58 " 3¨;'0 ¨F,¢¥>524" 6/,,¥2¥ M M6z 7 6 © 3¨ =? ¨/2 X/,¦ 520 ¥458 4/,¦4¥2¢ ¨/,¥># 0¦3¨0"6N *Q" ¢9 M 58 Q¥20' :b0¦=p0'520*"'¥2¥8 -3¨TX aU ~¢ 5;=?0¦T6¥,+eRU/, 58 ¨¥ g£:¢¦¡6 / Q" 3¨,[52K 10/2 K/,6 Ks ³¦v8+ 03¨0¦"6N d¥8( " "52¥X¥2,'¢03 M ¥2¢" 00'58 ¨ Y0¦3 3¨¦=)¥@3¨=?9$3¨,'¢3?" © 3 *K/6C52X¢^ ,/(*52:( * ¢ / ©*¦(0'58 ¨ ¥Q¦#<58 L8/,¦M+jG? *;¥8 ¨ @"3¨,¥25e/, © ( 058 ¨ a 9 ¥2582 ¨/,5>,¥2( /,@/, ¥2580 52¥,+e¾>,/,03 3j58 05>=?; 1 ¨52; 5f§ ( ¥25 /3 (* ,¥:0D/¢3¨0¥2¥;3¨0'¢¦j0¦ K¦-6§,/,5@03 3¨6/,0'52¦j0 K58 Q-*0'¥2¢3 0" " 3 ¨/,058 ¨¦ [/,6 j-( 5:03¨¥2a¥2T6¥252, ¥2¢ ¨/,¥C#;58 {K+jR6 z / Q" 3¨¢¦+XG? ¨¥Q'¢¥8 ¨ L3¨0'¥10 K/, @" 3¨,¥D|$=` ¨58 58 *:- 0¥2¢9 #$¦;¢^ 0' Q"3¨'3¨¦=?9$3¨,¢3B/,6 :58 054 1 ¨52¥@58 * { :, :¦T z 3 :/,' Q" 3¨¢}403 3f *¦ 9E/,¦Q/¢3¨0'¥2¥2,¥,* /¢3 (*6 ¨ *X58 ;" 58 ¨ Q ¨F¢ 03 3¨6/052I ;( ¥25\ 5C03 3¨6/,0'52K0 TZ-m§¢,/52¥J| ¨5C b( ¥25\( ¥2!" ¢9 / Q" 3¨¢¦;=? ¢ Y58 { -6'52¥,+ ¦:-,5252¢D"¢2#$¦ :0 /, 03 3¨6/052,K 0520C¥2582( /,58( ,¥;0 !-( ~¢¥}40¦ *X¥8 ( 3¨K/,' Q" 3¨,52 M6z 7 0 /¢3 ( ,¥@58 :" 58 ¨ Q ¨F¢ J/ Q" 3¨¢@ K58 ¨52¥4520'¥8 C I0:¥8 *¦5>58 ¨ :b"W¢2 ¨6+ ¢§ ©©q¢ ©q¡m§ 2¢6$ " ,/,' Q" 3¨,K-654 ¨ :0'+@¾>,¥8( 3¨52¥b a58 ¨¥4"*0¦"¢@(*¥2@58 *@#(3 3 / ©*¦(0'58 ¨ fc=? ¨/ C /¢,0¥2¥)-6'589 ¨ 10;=?2 ¨58 C58 ¨ :6-( 5 G? *C/,¦ 583 3¨¢ºU ,/52¥:58 *C 0520X :¦ ¨52¦2 *a0 K/¢,0'52,¥Q¦29 " 66(*/,¥;0Q ¨¦ *4"¢2#A :0¦ */, {K+ 0¦ ¨F¢@58 0 ¥452:"6/,¥2¥;58 *40¦=[ 0520C0'5)¥8"W,/¢ © /:58 ¨ :Q 9 M6z 52¢¦03¨¥,+ ¢ S0=B 6 cB,0/2 Z0¦ ¨F¢X0¦ *0¦3¨T6F,,¥:0¦= 0'520 ] 0 \" 0/2 '0',¥>58 *; 0520Q 5210Q¥8( ¨520- 3¨Q#$¦ »#$¦>/, ¥8( Q"*58 ¨¦ - TK58 !/,¦ 583 3¨¢¦+ZO4 6 ¨58 ¨ 03 3gT40¦ Z0¦ ¨F¢D :0¦TK0 d 9 3. SYSTEM ARCHITECTURE #$¦ :058 ¨¦ I52:58 *;¦0¦ ¨F,;,'¢ 5>h(*¢( ;#$>58 ;/,¦ 583 3¨¢@52 G? 03¨0¦"6N yO4 0" 58 ¨aP)" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,058 ¨¦ R6T6¥252, |$OeP;R}:/,¦ 9 M " 6/,,¥2¥, > 10T@,/,: #$ 1058 ¨ D X58 >O4P;R: 0520¦-*0'¥2)#$¦ 520¦ *¥@58 ,:/,' Q" ¢ 52¥,<0/2 L#B=? ¨/2 L¢ /, @"*0'¥2¥2,¥Q¦ *1 3¨052;h( ¢2 ¨,¥)- TC'58 *¢ OeP;R\/,' Q" ¢ 52¥,+ 1K¥2¢" 00'52L58 ,0'¥X¦#C/,¦ 583$+¸G? ,¥2K¥8( -*¥2T6¥252 :¥J0¦ 58 <58 0¦ * G? ¨¥f0/2 ¨52/,58(>/,0¦ @¥8(" "¦5<0?¦02 ¨,5ET;# :,0¥8( , : 5c52,/2 9 §£1!£1¢¢¦§r,£:,¦:¦§*,¦¥¦$£ ¢r©©¨, 58 + ¨( LtK ¢" ¨/52¥J58 J 52¢29 7 ¨h(*,¥,6 /¢3 ( U @ *0¦=?0¦?"¢2#$¦ :0 /,4 1 ¨52¥, /,03 3W¥2520/2 r¢£)¨g©¨¢6AAd¦§ ¦¥¦$,£ 03q¥2582(*/58(@#j58 0¦3¨0"6N *D0 0" 58 ¨:¦"*58 ¨ Q ¨F058 ¨ ¥2T6¥252, M ¥20 @"3 :s °'um´vE¦0 ;/, @" 3¨¢29$ ¥2,52,: *¥2582( :¢ 520'58 ¨ D¥8(*/2 0¦ *L58 \ 52¢0'/,58 ¨ ¥\-W,58=?¢ L ¨52¥:/, @" ¢ 52¥,+ZA Z0'6 ¨58 ¨ 0¥c '6/,058 ¨¦ X/,¦( 52¥,-*0'¥8 ¨/)- 3¨6/ 1, ><" 058 1"¦©3¨,¥es.²¯vE 52158 *e/, Q"W ¢ 52¥,58 * "¦ ¨ ,¥;0Q¢"W¥8 ¨52T 0 X¦03 ( b" © 3¨,¥@s.²¼vE+ :jI 6¢6¢6¢¦ 58 05j,/, ¥?/,' Q"¦ *¢ 5> ,/¢ ¨¥8 ¨¦ *¥e0 \0¦3 3¨¦=)¥B/, Q"W ¢ 52¥>52 h( ¢TL58 ,¥2! ,/¢ ¨¥8 ¨¦ *¥,+ZG? *: ¢^ 5Q#$¦(C¥2/,58 ¨ ¥CU ¨¥2/¢( ¥2¥C58 ¨¥ © ( ; I :; ,520 3$+ Executing Compilers [Base,Opt,...] Code Install New Code Profile Information Hardware / VM Instrumented/ Instrumentation/ Performance Monitor Optimized Compilation Code Plan Raw Raw Raw Data Data Data AOS Compilation Database Threads Organizer Organizer Runtime Measurements Subsystem Formatted Formatted Data Data Compilation Queue Organizer Event Queue Controller Adaptive Optimization System (,!.D + 6 "£1(*£"£*¢D #¢¡ *¢12¢¡¥&@¤£-2#' ¤£&2*¢( ¥¦¥ &2*¢()$'(¨§£ *¢(#%- 3 ©%/* $ 3.2 Controller 3.3 Recompilation Subsystem G? Q/ 583 3¨:¦/ ,¥258052¥Q0¦ *X/,¦ *6( /,52¥Q58 @58 ¢@/, @"9 G? *<,/,' Q" 3¨058 ¨ D¥8( -*¥2T6¥252 [/, ¥8 ¨¥252¥<# / Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ !58 ,0'¥ ¢ 52¥:¦#e58 *D0 0" 58 ¨X" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ p¥2T6¥252, D+K$5Q/66 *0'52,¥ 58 05 ' 6;/ Q" 3¨¢¥,+?G? 4/,' Q" 3¨058 ¨ I58 ,0'¥>¢^ 580'/,50¦ * 58 C0/,58 ¨ ¨58 ¨¥:#e58 Q2( 58 ¨ 1! :,0'¥8( :¢ 52¥@¥8(- ¥2T6¥252, 0¦ * ¢^ ,/(*52X/,' Q" 3¨058 ¨ p" 3¨0 ¥\58 0510\ ¥2¢52,L 52K58 !/,' Q9 58 J,/ Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ µ¥8( - ¥2T6¥252, !+ G? *I/, 58¦3 3¨¢I ¨58 ¨0'52,¥K03 3 " 3¨058 ¨ h( ¢(*C- TK58 !/,¦ 583 3¨¢¦+Y¾>,/ Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ [6/,/(¥Q 2( 58 ¨ :; :0¥8( , :¢ 5?¥8( - ¥2T6¥252, »" © 3 *C0'/,58 ¨ ¨58T:- T: ,52¢29 ¥2¢" 00'52:58 0 ¥4# 58 *10" "3 ¨/,0'58 ¨ fj0 J58 6( ¥,c/0 a6/,/¢( @ !=? 05?"¦©3 !¥8 ( 3¨X6/,/¢( ¦*( * ¢e=? *0'5)/ U ¨58 ¨¦ *¥, K" 00¦3 3¨¢3$+IG` ¨¥@U ~¥Q# V58 *: ¨58 ¨03@|3¨0F,T };/,' Q" 3¨0'58 ¨ 0¦ *!#A4 ¦= 3¨¦ * +;$5?,/,¢ ¨',¥4 #A :0'58 ¨ I# 58 b2( 58 ¨ : #@0I :,58 64=? ¨/ S6/,/¢( ¥!58 !©¥25C58 ¨ :X0K 1,58 *6L ¨¥\ 9 1,0¥8( , :¢ 51¥8(- ¥2T6¥252, 0¦ *LOeP;RJ 0520¦-*0'¥2j0 ( ¥2,¥@58 ¨¥ ¦ 6, 6(2 J3¨0FTK/, @" 3¨0'58 ¨ f>/, Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ p6/,/¢( ¥Q Z58 * #$¦ :058 ¨¦ y52C :0¦ 6:/ Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ Y ,/¢ ¨¥8 ¨ ¥,+C$54"*0'¥2¥2,¥;58 ,¥2 0" " 3 ¨/,058 ¨¦ I58 ,0'C58 *0'5<05252, Q" 52,C52) ' m458 `( /, Q" 3¨, / Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ i/¢ ¨¥8 ¨ ¥J52a58 *!,/ Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ i¥8(- ¥2T6¥252, ! U 9 :,58 6+ /,58 *C58 ;0/,58 ¨¦ *¥;¦#<58 Q¦0¦2 ¨( ¥4/,' Q" 3¨¥,+ Kj0/2 i/, @" 3¨0'58 ¨ µ" 3¨0 l/, ¥8 ¨¥252¥J¦#C58 ,K/,' Q" ¢ 52¥ 0 B0¥2,X¦ X #$¦ :058 ¨¦ J#g 58 42( 58 ¨ :1 :,0¥8( , : 52¥4¥8( -9 ?0 Y0 ¢¨f£@©¨¢6$X¨©¨¢ ¨2 ©© U¡J 6¢6$¢ g*¦,§£1,$¢6$ ¥2T6¥252 0 K58 CO4P;RI0'520- 0¥2B58 *C/,¦ 583 3¨¢D/,0¦ K"¢2#$¦ +:G? C" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,058 ¨¦ Y"3¨0¦ Z¥8",/¢ © ,¥:=? ¨/ Z" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ ¥ ¨©¨¢ 58 <#$3 3¨¦=? *;0'/,58 ¨ ¥ ²}W ¨5c/0 ; ¥2582(*/,5<58 <2( 58 ¨ :B :,0¥8( ¢9 58 \/ Q" 3¨¢C¥8 ( 3¨L0" "3¨TK6( 2 *X,/,' Q" 3¨0'58 ¨ <+IG? Q"¦9 1¢ 52¥<¥8(- ¥2T6¥252, 524/,¦ 58 6(*>j/2 0 ? ¨52¥Á" © 3 Q¥2580'52,T © 3 *D0'520* ¨58 ¨03 3gTJ'058 ¢,!- T!58 ;2( 58 ¨ :@ :,0'¥8( :¢ 52¥ =? ¨/ 1/,¦(3¨; */3 (* ?(*¥8 ;58 *<,/,' Q" 3¨058 ¨ D¥8( -*¥2T6¥252 [52? 9 ¥8( -*¥2T6¥252, D6 ,/,52¥<58 ¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F¢ *@/,' Q" 3¨¢¦ ¥c#$,U- 0/2 69EU /,52, ¥25 582( ¥8 ¨?"¦©3 §¤Wt}* ¨5c/,0¦ Q,/ Q" 3¨> ¦< :¦ :58 9 " 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ ¥,+C *¥2582( :¢ 520'58 ¨ I"3¨0¦ *¥@U ¨/52052:=? ¨/ f* #?0¦ T 6 ¥)( ¥8 º" © 3 X0'520\52@ ¨ Q"¦'Q58 ¢ 4"W¢2#$ 10 /,+?G? 582( ¥8 ¨) ¥2582( :¢ 52058 ¨¦ D58 *?/ Q" 3¨¢B¥8 *¦(3¨: ¥2¢5c 52;58 * / 583 3¨; :0¦ 6,¥?58 ,¥2e,/ ¨¥8 ¨ ¥)- 0¥2,C D0¦ !0¦ *0¦3¨T658 ¨/Q 16¢3 *¢0'52,X/,6 + ",¥2 58 *;58 /¥252¥<0 4-¢ ¢© 52¥<# "¢2#$¦ Q ;58 *,¥2j520¥8 ¥,+ G? *B/, Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ I58 0 ¥520¦ 6,¥j58 *>¦(*58" (*5j#W58 *>/,' Q" 3¨ G? / 583 3¨?/,' : ;( ¨/,052¥=? ¨58 @58 '58 *¢q58=?>/,' Q"¦ *¢ 52¥ 0 0¦¦0Q¦-m§¢,/,5>58 05?¢" ,¥2¢ 52¥>58 *;^ ,/¢( 520- 3¨Q/,6 @0 !0¥2¥2¦9 M ( ¥8 !"2 ¨¦2 ¨58TIh(*¢( ,¥¤ ¨54¢^ 580'/,52¥; :,0'¥8( :¢ 5;,'¢ 52¥)#' /¢ ¨0'52,Q2( 58 ¨ : #$ :0'58 ¨ X|$^ /,¢" 58 ¨ D520- 3¨ #$ :0'58 ¨ C0¦ * 0Ch( ¢( Q58 05> ¨¥)© 3 3¨,¹- TD58 *;2( 58 ¨ :: :,0'¥8( :¢ 52¥4¥8( - ¥2T6¥89 0¦2-*0'C/,¦3 3¨,/,58 ¨ S :0" ¥} 0 J ¥25203 3¨¥Q ¨5; L58 {K¥2 M6z 52 0 K *¥252¥º/, Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ [ ,/¢ ¨¥8 ¨¦ *¥! 52I0Ih(*¢( X58 05 58 05?0¦3 3#g(*58( 4/,0¦3 3¨¥>52Q58 ¨¥> :,58 6\=? 3 3( ¥2458 ) ,=Y¢¥8 ¨¦ c+ / Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ K58 ,0 ¥" 6/,,¥2¥,+ ¢ k58 *,¥2>h( ¢( ,¥>0>, Q" 58T A a( @/¢( 2¢ 54 ¨ Q" 3¨, :¢ 520'58 ¨ f?0¦ T!", ¨¦(*¥@0/58 ¨0'58 ¨ ¥:# ] 58 : ,h( ¢( X58 ,0|$¥}4¥83¨,¢"f+@G` @0¦2 ¨( ¥Q¥2T6¥252 ¸/, @"9 58 \ 1,58 *6a=` 3 3`/, 58 6( !52C(*¥2C58 :3¨L/,' Q" 3¨d/6:#$¦ ¢ 52¥C03¨¥2a/, : ;( ¨/,0'52! *6 ,/,583¨Ty- TK,0'U K0¦ *Z=`2 ¨58 58 ) 1,58 *6@( 58 358 05< 1,58 *6%¦ ¥0'/,58 ¨¦058 ¨ k/, @"3¨,52¥,+e58 9 #$¦ :058 ¨¦ J I58 ;OeP;R\ 0520- 0¥2'+ ¹ Z( 1,¥8 ¨¦ y" ,/¢3 ( ¥º( ¥8 J¥2520'/ K#g0 ::,=?2 ¨58 J52 *0¦-3¨X" ¨( ¥\0'/,58 ¨¦058 ¨¦ *¥X¦#458 ! 1,58 *6Z52¹( ¥2!58 \ ,= G? *I/,' Q" 3¨0'58 ¨ i58 ,0'o¢^ 580'/,52¥\" 3¨0 ¥!#' 58 X/, @" 3¨0¦9 / Q" 3¨,!'¢¥8 ¨ f- (*5j58 ¨¥Á#( /,58 ¨ 03 ¨5ET\ 0¥c 5jT,5c-¢ : ¨ Q9 58 ¨ Zh( ¢( \0¦ *I m,¥:58 C" 58 ¨ Q ¨F¢ d/ Q" 3¨¢:" 0¥2¥8 ¹ " 3¨, : 52,+ e¢^6",/5?58 *0'5 03¨0¦"6N :=? 3 3f,¢ 58( 03 3¨TC,=?2 ¨52 58 \/ Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ Y"3¨0¦ c+XG? C/, Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ p58 0K,/,¦¥@58 * ] M - 0¥23 *@¥2520/2 C#0 :¥?52Q¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,,X¥2520/2 :#0' :,¥,+B5< ¨¥>0¥?T',5 /,' Q" 3¨0'58 ¨ 58 ¨ :J#AX58 J,/ Q" 3¨,i :,58 6 58 JOeP;R ( /¢3¨,0e #j58 *4 ¨¥)¥8( C/¢ ¨ 54 :'58 ¨0'58 ¨ a52:¥8( ""¦5>58 *; :¦ 0520- 0¥2C52C03 3¨¦=i#$ ::0'/,/¢( 052: 16¢3 I#j#(*58( ;¢9 6 C/¢( 3¨5;580 ¥8 ¨58 ¨ I-,5E=?,¢ k58=?1" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,,I¥2520/2 C#0 :¥,+ /,' Q" 3¨0'58 ¨ L ,/¢ ¨¥8 ¨¦ *¥,+ 4.2 Sampling 3.4 AOS Database G? *X¥20' Q" 3 *L ¨ Q"3¨ :¢ 52058 ¨¦ i520 m,¥C0 ¦0 520'J¦#;¢^6 ¨¥258 G? !OeP;RJ 0520¦-*0'¥2!"¦ ¨ ,¥C0¹¢"W¥8 ¨52TL=? ¢!58 !0'0¦"9 :,/2 0 ¨¥2 :¥ C58 03¨0¦"6N {K+'?¢#$¦?¥2=? ¨52/ Q58 ,0 ¥, M M6z 58 ¨'?" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ D¥2T6¥252, Y,/,¦¥f,/ ¨¥8 ¨ ¥,¢ 52¥,'0 ;¥252058 ¨/ 0>/,( 52¢q0¥2¥26/¢ ¨0'52,:=? ¨58 @58 *j/¢( 2¢ 5c 1,58 *6; ¨¥ /¢, 1¢ 52,+ 0¦ *0¦3¨T6¥8 ¨¥:,¥8(3¨52¥,+IG? \¦0¦2 ¨( ¥:0 0" 58 ¨X¥2T6¥252, Â/,' Q"¦ *¢ 52¥ G? *e¥2T6¥252, µ0'52582 -( 52,¥>0;¥20 @"3¨;520¦ 6¢ D D0;-*0'/ º,'452@58 * h( ¢TD58 *,¥2;0¦58 #$0/52¥40¥? ,, ,+ /¢( 2¢ 5: :58 *6+IO ¥20 Q" 3¨!520¦ 6¢ L Z0X :,58 6K"¦3¨( X ¨¥ /¢,6 ¨52,I52Q-'58 K58 Q/03 3 X0 X/¢(2 54 :,58 6/,0" 58(2 j¢^ 0' Q"3¨'58 >/, 58¦3 3¨¢?( ¥2,¥j58 *>OeP;Rb 0520¦-*0'¥2>524,/, 7 58 !#$0/,5C58 05D/, 58¦34 ¨¥\ p580¦ *¥8 ¨58 ¨¦ o-W,58=?¢ y-'58 p :,58 9 / Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ »" 3¨0 ¥X0 p52d580'/ S58 *I¥252058( ¥!0¦ *y ¨¥252TY¦# 6 ¥,+ ? *0¦')^6"¢2 ¨ :¢ 52!=? ¨58 C58 ¢B¥20 Q" 3 :052582 - (*58 ¨¦ ] 1,58 *6 ¥!¥23¨,/,52,y#$¦:,/,' Q" 3¨058 ¨ f+iO4¥C0¦ *'58 *¢D¢^ 0' Q" 3¨ ¥258052 ¨,¥>0 : *0¦')#$¦( C58 ¨¥> 4524-W4 :'¥25¢~W,/,58 ¨'+?G? * 58 L/, @" 3¨0'58 ¨ 58 ,0 ¥J,/,¦[¥252058 ¨/Z0 03¨T6¥8 ¨¥L0 [ 3 9 0//¢(0'/,TX#j58 ¨¥4¥20' Q" 3 *X52,/2 ¨h( : ¨¥) ¥258 ¨052J I : I¥8(* : 102 ¨,¥:" 6U( /,,K- TK58 C" 58 ¨ Q ¨F¢ d/ Q" 3¨¢¦+KG? ,520 3< Ls uvE+ / 583 3¨!0¦ *L¦0 ¨F,¢D58 ,0 ¥:h( ¢TK58 ¨¥Q #$ :0'58 ¨ S0¥ ,, ,Y52I( ¨X,/,' Q" 3¨058 ¨ l,/ ¨¥8 ¨ ¥,+[{XX ,520¦ 3¨¥! G? ¨¥e¥20 Q" 3 X52,/ ¨h(*Q" ¦ ¨¥Q0Q- 0¥8 ¨/1 :,/2 *0¦ ¨¥2 ¸521,¥89 58 ;/¢( 2¢ 5) ¨ @"3¨, 1¢ 52058 ¨¦ L0" ",0¦4 aR6,/,58 ¨ a¼6+ 58 ¨ :0'52:58 *@58 ¨ ::¥8"W¢ 54 K^ ,/¢( 58 ¨ L¦#?,0'/ a :,58 6+: I58 * 0 0" 58 ¨I" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ ¥2T6¥252, !B58=?X¦0 ¨F,¢k58 0 ¥Q"¢2 9 4. MULTI-LEVEL RECOMPILATION 66 ¨/,03 3¨TX"6/,¥2¥458 40¦=o 0520 + G? ¨¥:¥2,/,58 ¨¦ Y ,¥2/¢2 -¥\58 : ¨ Q" 3¨, :¢ 520'58 ¨ #e58 *C0'0¦"*58 ¨' G? *@©¥25;¦0 ¨F,¢º58 ,0'y|$58 }¢/¢9 /, Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ Y¥2T6¥252, D+@RU/,58 ¨ Z¼C¥2/¢2 -,¥; *¦=i58 ¨¥;¥2T6¥252, O*6£1©O*¦ X$¡6¢* ¨, 052XU( 2 *X¥2T6¥252 ¥2520¦58("f* *¥2520¦3 3¨¥:0C¥20 Q" 3 X-m§¢,/,5@|$58 * ¨¥I¢^ 52¢ ,i52Y¥8(" "5a( J© ¥25X 3 *y#A,,6-*0'/ 69E6 ,/,52, }c52b,/:0¦=Y0'520b,'06 *C58 4¢^ /¢(*58 ¨¦ ¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ cD0 0" 58 ¨y 3 W+ÄR6,/,58 ¨¦ °+¨²J" ¨ ,¥L0 £1©O*¦ ;© ¦,$,, " © 3¨+ (2 C0;58 ,0'!¥2=? ¨52/2 c 58 { m,¥458 ¢¡¤£¦¥¦§©¨¦ · z ¦'¢ ¨,=¸¦#;58 \ ¨ Q" 3¨, :¢ 520'58 ¨ <+lRU/,58 ¨ p° + t!"¦ ¨ ,¥! ¢9 :,58 6K¦#458 ¨¥;3 ¨¥252¢ *¦?=? ¨/2 K,/ ¥Q58 C/¢(2 583¨TK0/,58 ¨' 520¦ 3¨¥;/, /,¢2 \ =Y" © 3 *! #$ 1058 ¨ I ¨¥4¦-*520¦ *+eR6,/¢9 :,58 6! X0@0=p 0520Q- (~W¢¦+?G? ¨¥40/58 ¨ ¨58T!/¥252¥4¦ 3¨TD0Q#$,= 58 ¨¦ I°+ ³:6 ¨¥2/¢(*¥2¥2¥;58 *4,/ Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ L :6 ¢3$+ 0 6 ¨58 ¨ 03j/,T6/¢3¨¥)6( 2 *C,0'/ D58 ,0D¥2=` ¨52/2 f0¦ *D58 *>"¢2#$¦29 :0¦ */,@ ¨ Q"*0'/,5@6,¥4 5e¥2520 K( 5)#g ¨¥2Q#g ¸¦ *Q2( 4.1 Overview 52X58 º ¢^ 5,+IO)#A52¢@/,3 3¨/,58 *L58 : 6(* ;-¢C¦#>¥20 @"3¨,¥C¥8"/¢9 © ,K- T¹ ¨52¥@/¢( 2¢ 5Q¥20' Q" 3¨\¥8 ¨Fj58 *C :,58 6J3 ¨¥252¢ ¢C=B0 6¥ ¨¦(C³:" ¨ ,¥:0¦ I¦¢ ¨,=#B58 *@ ¨ Q"3¨ :¢ 52058 ¨¦ c+CG? 7 / 583 3¨>58 0Q ¨¥ M6z h( ¢ 583¨TI/¢,0'52,¥Q58 ,0'¥;/,¦2,¥8"¦ *6 *a52\58 :'58 *¢@¥8( - ¥2T6¥89 52 :¥ ¦0¦ ¨F,!58 ,0'¥C52X"¢2#$¦ ¥20 @"3¨¢9$- 0¥2,y2( 58 ¨ : ¢ k0=B 6 c 58 ) 5j :,58 6¥>'0 ¨F,¢e¥2/,0¦ *¥>58 ) 1,58 *6 ] 1,0¥8( , :¢ 52¥;0¦ *I0C¥8 *¦3¨:/,' Q" 3¨0'58 ¨ Z58 ,0 52:"¢2#$¦ /,¦( 52¢>0¦=Y 0520@52b ¨ ¢ 58 #$TD :,58 6¥>=? *458 ;0" "3 ¨/,0'58 ¨ /, Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ <+¸O>#$52¢k58 *,¥2a58 ,0'¥X0¦J/,052,@58 *I/,¦ 9 ¥8"¢ ¥< :¥25f# ¨52¥c58 ¨ :+qG` j0¦ ¨F¢? ,, 1¥c0> :,58 6Q52?- 58¦3 3¨¢e¥83¨,¢" ¥?( 58 3q58 *>2( 58 ¨ :; 1,0¥8( , :¢ 52¥>¥8( -*¥2T6¥252 µ 9 L 5 M> #58 "¢/, 520B# ¥20 Q" 3¨,¥j052582 - (*52,152458 05c 1,58 *6 ¢^ /,,¥C0K/ 583 3¨2986 ,/,52[58 ¥8 *¦3¨Y0 y58 X :,58 6y ¨¥ ¥252¥)0¦ I, 5` I58 ;'0 ¨F,¢ ,¢ 5eh(*(*+ 5!0¦3 ,0 TY/,' Q" 3¨[05C58 J :0¦^6 ¨ b( ¦"*58 ¨ Q ¨F058 ¨ i3¨,'¢3 G? :0 0" 58 ¨C¦"*58 ¨ Q ¨F058 ¨ Z¥2T6¥252, |$=` ¨58 ( 5@0 0" 58 ¨: 3 9 0¦¦0 3¨0- 3¨+ ¦<,0'/ @ 5< :,58 6Q ¨5<6 ¨¥2/,¦¢¥,m58 * 5< 1,58 *6 ¥ 7 6}>/¢,0'52,¥45E=?:'0 ¨F,¢@58 ,0 ¥,0 '0 ¨F,¢k¢ *h( ¢( ,¥!0¦ Y,'¢ 5: Y58 !¦0 ¨F,¢k, 5\h( ¢( O*6<£:¦©O*¦ ¦;A¡U¢ ©¨, 0¦ *10 +G? *j *'5< :,58 6¥j'0 ¨F,¢?" 6/,,¥2¥2,¥ 58 05!/ 520 ¥I58 *K 1,58 *6Y0¦ *p58 J"¢/, 520a#1¥20 Q" 3¨,¥ 6¢¢¥e$¡6¢* ¨, 052582 - ( 52,J52158 *; :58 *6+ 1,58 *6Z¥20 Q" 3¨,¥C0 K *¥252¥º 51 :,58 6y,'¢ 52¥Q Z58 *D29 '0 ¨F,¢C¢ 5;h( ¢( \52D03 3¨¦=µ58 :/,¦ 583 3¨¢º52!/,¦ *¥8 ¨ ¢C58 1,58 *6 ¥#$¦<,/,' Q" 3¨0'58 ¨ <+ Kj0/2 C,'¢ 5j/, 520¦ *¥>58 ? :,58 6 G? *>/,¦ 583 3¨¢`T 0 Q ¨/03 3gT\0',§2(*¥252¥?58 3 ¨¥252¢ ¢¢¦ ¥?¥20 @"3¨e¥8 ¨F, 0 ¨52¥!¢3¨0'58 ¨K 58 ,¥2¥,+ G` I,/0TY¦0¦ ¨F,I,/0T6¥ 0 @58 *?¦0¦ ¨F,¢¦ ¥c 58 ,¥2¥j58 ,¥8 3¨152)0'0¦"*5j52>58 *B/¢(2 5 · /( 52¢¥/ 520 ,: C58 2( 58 ¨ :> :,0¥8( , : 52¥¥8( -*¥2T6¥252 !+ -¢ 0¦ ¨D#e58 !0¦"" 3 ¨/,058 ¨¦ <+L?TK0',§2(*¥258 K58 !¥20 @"3¨D¥8 ¨F, R( / C/( 52¢¥Á /¢3 ( e58 *? 5< :58 *6:/( 52¢?0¦ *@58 )/( 9 =? ¨58 Z¥8"/¢ ©*d-¦( ¥,B58 *C/,¦ 583 3¨¢D0'5252, Q" 52¥:52\,6( /, 52¥?0¥2¥26/¢ ¨0'52,X=? ¨58 X/,0¦3 3<¦0" X, ,¥>6 ¨¥2/¢( ¥2¥2,! IR6,/,58 ¨¦ a¼U+ 58 4¦¢2 ,0'!#f58 ) 5? 1,58 *6 ¥>'0 ¨F,¢e=? *¢ D58 4¥2T6¥252, G? ? ,/,0¦TQ¦0¦ ¨F,? 6,¥c 5j/, : ;( ¨/,0'52>U ,/583¨T:=? ¨58 :58 ¨¥? I0Q¥2520 T!¥252052@|$58 *;¥25)¦#c 5> :,58 6 ¥` ¨¥>¥2520¦-3¨¦}¢=? 3¨ / 583 3¨¦+ ¥258 3 3*- *;0¦-3¨>52)¥8" :h( ¨/ 63¨T:52e0" "3 ¨/058 ¨ !" 0¥2?¥8 #$52¥ | U ¨/,0'52,X- T:/ 0 ¥) X58 4¥25?#f *'5) 1,58 *6 ¥}¢+BRm ¨ @ 3¨023gT ¿(2¢ 583¨T' 0¦3¨0"6N K(*¥2¥\0a¥8 ¨ Q"3¨I/,'0¥2¢9E0¦ * 3¨6/2 6 * 58 Q/,¦ 583 3¨¢1 T *0' Q ¨/,03 3¨Ta0§ (*¥252¥e58 *; 58 ,¥2¥;58 ¥8 *¦3¨J52 M ¥2/2 , :I52J/,¦ 583 0/,/,¥2¥!52K0J#A,= { ¥2 ¨/,,¥,+i y" 029 M6z 0" " ^6 ¨ 1052¢3¨TI/, 58¦3<58 4 6(* ;-¢ #f *'5) 1,58 *6 ¥)"52, 58 ¨/(3¨0¦¦>0/,/,¥2¥8 *L/,¢520¦ Y/¢3¨0'¥2¥:3¨0 ¢D 0520I¥2582(*/,58( ,¥C58 05 - T!58 4 5> :,58 6¥e'0 ¨F,¢¦+ A#<0¦#$52¢e¥2,'¢03j¥20' Q"3 \"W¢9 0¦3¨0"6N * ¦ ¥X/,' Q" 3¨¢¥¹ ,,Y52K,0'YU( 2 Y/, Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ i¢9 M 2 ¨6 ¥, L$ *'5Q *¦(*¦ ¥M! 5@ :,58 6¥@0@-¢ ¹,58( 2 ,j58 ¢ h( ,¥j58 *0'5<58 * { :0'¥252¢<3¨6/ @- ¢3¨+jG` ¨¥c3¨6/2 6 *@¥2580589 M6z 58 \/ 583 3¨!/0 Z/¢,0¥2D58 *: 58 ,¥2¥:58 ,¥8 3¨+ZP) L58 * T:"¢ 52¥e b( 3¨58 "3¨1/, Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ K58 ,0'¥># i-¢ \~,/¢9 58 ¢; 0 # L8526C :0 T£MC *'54 :58 *6 ¥;0Q-W¢ *C,58( 2 *, 58 ¨'*0¦ *X/0 X 5866(*/,;3¨6/2 X/,¦ 52¢ 58 ¨ I-,5E=?,¢ k58 *;/,' Q" 9 3¨0'58 ¨ a58 0X0 !0¦"" 3 ¨/,0'58 ¨ L58 0 ¥,+ #$¦j¥2,¢0¦3*¥20' Q" 3 *;"¢2 ¨6 ¥, 58 *¢ 158 ?/, 58¦3 3¨¢>/,0¦ Q /¢,0'¥2 Compilers Executing Install New Code [Base,Opt,...] Code Runtime Measurements Method Subsystem Instrumented/ Instrumentation/ Samples Optimized Compilation Code Plan Hot Methods Decay AOS Compilation Organizer Organizer Database Thread Organizer Event Queue Controller Compilation Queue Adaptive Optimization System (,!.D + ¢¡¢$ &, $? - * *¢(#%-'#¢¡ ¢£&2*¢( ¥? £"£#%$'&() *¢(#%-'()- *¢12 ¡¥&@¤£-2#' ¤£&2*¢( ¥ ¥ &2*¢()$'(¨§£§*+(,#.-'3 ©%/* $ 58 ;58 ,¥8 *¦3¨+ *X58 ¨ :1#>0C,/, @" 3¨,L'¢¥8 ¨ L¦#!§?¤ $+ +¨ ¨5;/2 6¥2,¥@58 * I58 05: Q ¨ Q ¨F,¥X58 *Dh(*0¦ 58 ¨58T +ZA# #"$ % "& '¨() OY¥2/, C0¦ ¨F¢¦ 58 *> ,/,0¦T:'0 ¨F,¢¦6"¢2 ¨66 ¨/,0¦3.3¨TD,/0T6¥ 58 4/,¦ 583 3¨¢e ,/¢ ¨ ,¥4524,/ Q" 3¨*§ 0'53¨,'¢3§¤m58 ¢=? ¨¥24 ¨5 58 X :,58 6y/( 52¢¥,+Y?TL ,/,0¦T *L58 !/,¦( 52¥,458 !¥2T6¥89 ,/¢ ¨ ,¥;52b 5>,/,' Q" 3¨'+ 52 ¨¥; :;=? ¨ 5452@,/,¢ 5e¥20 Q" 3¨,¥4=? ¢ I ,52¢ Q * 1,58 *6! 58 ,¥2¥,+ ¿3¨,023¨T'58 :#$0/52¥; y58 ¨¥: :6 ¢3B0:( 6 ¦=?0- 3¨! L"0'/¢9 58 ¨/,+ G` ;"6/,¥2¥;#B,¥258 ¨ :058 !#( 58(1/,¥252¥e0 ¹- *¢© 52¥; ¨¥ 0 I"¢ L,¥20/2 K"¦-3¨ !+XG? *1/¢(2 5Q/,¦ 583 3¨¢ 4.3 Recompilation ¨ Q" 3¨, :¢ 520'58 ¨ Z ¨¥b- 0¥2,a a58 *:#$0¦ 23¨TJ¥8 ¨ Q" 3¨!¥258 ¨ :052,¥@ ¢9 ¨'¢ p0J 5D :,58 6d#' H58 *X¦0 ¨F,¢I¢ 5Ch( ¢(*'458 £ ¥2/¢2 -¹-3¨=;+ / 583 3¨: ;(*¥25e/¢ ¨1=` ,58 ¢; ¨5) ¨¥4" © 520- 3¨:52:,/,' Q" 3¨ 58 ! 1,58 *6L=? ¨58 Y0'6 ¨58 ¨ 03@¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ *¥,+YG? C/, 58¦3 3¨¢ ¥25,?58 !/ 583 3¨!0'¥2¥8(* 1,¥C58 *C"'0 =? 3 34^ ,/¢( 52\#$¦ 7 ( ¥2,¥e0:/,¥2589$- *¢© 540¦ *0¦3¨T6¥8 ¨¥;52: :0¦ 6;58 ¨¥4/,0¦3¨/¢(3¨0'58 ¨ <+ 58=? ¨/,! ¨52¥C/¢( 2¢ 5:6( 058 ¨ f+RU ? #;58 X0" "3 ¨/058 ¨ *0'¥º2( #$¦@¼:¥2,/,¦ * ¥,<58 Q/,¦ 583 3¨¢10¥2¥8( :,¥4 ¨5;=? 3 3j2( I#$¦@¼: : B58 ¨¥?6 ¨¥2/¢( ¥2¥8 ¨ f*=?? 6( b-W¢?58 >" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ X3¨,'¢3¨¥>0¦0¦ 3 9 7 ¥2,/,¦ * ¥¤ #f ¨5 0¥?2( C#$¦et4 *¦(¥, 58 ¢ ! ¨5?=? 3 32( !#$¦>t; : 0¦-3¨C52D58 *:/ 583 3¨:# V¯!52¥¤J+ ¦ @0! 1,58 *6¨§ /(29 7 ( ¥,+ © 52@-Q58 4#( 58(@¢^6"/,52,!2( *D58 ¨ :;# · ,+ 583¨TK/, @" 3¨,Z0543¨,'¢3 ©2<58 C/, 58¦3 3¨¢D,¥258 ¨ :052¥Q58 :#$3 9 58 4"'0 D+ 3¨¦=? !h( 0 58 ¨58 ¨,¥ G? *B¥2T6¥252, o 6¢"*¥<580'/ @¦#*=? ¢?58 ?0" " 3 ¨/,058 ¨¦ X¥8"¢ ¥58 ¨ : ¦58 *B¢^6",/,52Q58 ¨ :j58 Á" ¦0 [=? 3 3 ¥8"¢ @¢^ ,/¢( 58 * 0¥@ ¨5Q2( ¥,( ¥8 K58 *D¥20 Q" 3 d52/ ¨h( ,¥D,¥2/2 -,d" , 9 à :,58 6§I #§ ¨¥) 5?,/,' Q" 3¨+ ( ¥83¨T+YG? !¥2T6¥252, ( ¥2,¥:0I=?¢ ¨¦ 52,Y0¦¢0'X¦#;58 ,¥2!¥20' Q9 " 3¨,¥452:¥258 ¨ :052@58 *4"W¢/,¢ 520'@#<#( 58(;58 ¨ 1:|.-/;} I,0/2 58 ;/,'¥25?#f,/, @" 3 X :,58 6§ 05?¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ à :,58 6c-*0¦22 *X,/,' Q" 3¨058 ¨ f+ ' ¸58 ¨¥b"/,¢ 520'C,¥258 9 7 3¨,3 6#$© ¤J+ :0'52\0¦ *a58 *:#( 58(C58 ¨ :C,¥258 ¨ 1052j58 \/ 583 3¨\" ,6 ¨/,52¥ 58 4#(*58( ;58 ¨ :@¥8"¢ 5> X,0'/ I :58 *6+jG` 05? ¨¥, *58 Q¢^6"W,/,52,X58 ¨ :@58 b" ¦0 =` 3 3j¥8"W¢ *I¢^ ,/(*589 à *@ :,58 6 §» D58 )#( 58(' # §i ¨¥,/,' Q" 3¨X05<3¨,¢3 / - |2²} 0 +21 + ¦;¢^ 0' Q"3¨'c #>58 :=?¢ ¨¦ 52,J¥20' Q" 3¨,¥b 6 ¨/,052D58 *0'5458 :0" 9 7 " 3 ¨/,058 ¨¦ p=` 3 3`¥8"¢ y²,¯A¡ ¦#? ¨52¥:58 ¨ :: L 1,58 *6¨§H0 K58 * ¥8 *;58 ,¥2>,¥258 ¨ :0'52,C¦03 ( ,¥, 58 *?/ 583 3¨? ¨ 58 ©*,¥>58 ?¢9 ¶ /,6 4 *0'¥2( !#$¦;²,¯@¥2,/,¦ * ¥,*58 4/,¦ 583 3¨¢ =? 3 3<,¥258 ¨ :0'52;58 * / Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ K3¨,3@58 05? Q ¨ Q ¨F,¥;58 *;¢^6"W,/,52,C#(*58( 42( 9 #( 58(;^ ,/¢( 58 ¨ a58 ¨ :Q¦# §¸52@-:²;¥2,/,¦ *+ ¦ B58 ¨¥?U ¨¥2/(*¥2¥8 ¨¦ c58 >/, Q" 3¨¢¥? D( ?/(2¢ 5< ¨ Q" 3¨, :¢ 9 7 520'58 ¨ I|- 0¥2¢3 fP)" 5Á3¨,'¢3f¯ P)" 5<3¨,¢3j²' P)"*5<3¨,'¢3qt}<=?( 3¨ G? *e=?¢ ¨¦ 5?#f,0'/ D¥20 @"3¨;¥2520¦52¥?05j 40¦ *D,/0T6¥j"¢2 ¨66 9 10"! 52C58 ¨¥)#( /,58 ¨ a0¥?3¨,'¢3<¯ c²WtU ³+ /,0¦3 3¨T+?G? 6( ¥,658 *>¢^ /¢(*58 ¨¦ !- *0¦ ¨e¦#c58 ?,/,¢ 5<" 0¥25?¢^ 52¥ ,G? * :63L/, ¥8 ¨ ¢¥»,/ Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ _05p58 *¥20 :i3¨,¢3 58 \ 1¥25; x (* */,D L58 C,¥258 ¨ :0'52,¥Q¦#>#(*58( :"'0' -W¢9 -W,/,0( ¥2d ,=¸" © 3 *o #$¦ :058 ¨¦ µ 10Tp¢ 0- 3¨y0'6 ¨58 ¨ 03 0 ¨¦¦+ ¢ a58 *;/,¦ 583 3¨¢;/, Q" 3¨,¥@ :,58 6¥,* ¨5>0',§ ( ¥252¥ ] ¥8"W,,6(" ¥>'¢>58 )" , ¨( ¥4'¢¥8 ¨ k/, @" 3¨,D053¨¢3 ©2+jG` ¨¥ 58 ¹#( 58( X,¥258 ¨ :052¥X52K0/,/( 5\#$¦!58 X *,= " 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ ¨¥>¢ /,6 ,\- TC0;#$,,6- 0/2 6986 ,/,52X" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,058 ¨¦ J-W6¥25?#$0/52 58 05? ¨¥>(*¥2,! k58 *@/,0¦3¨/¢(3¨0'58 ¨ L¦# + 3¨,'¢3$0 X¢^6",/52,X¥8",,6( "IU( Q52@,/, @" 3¨0'58 ¨ f+ G? ;¥2T6¥252, µ¥258 ¨ :052,¥e58 *;~,/,58 ¨'¢ *¥2¥4#q,0/2 X¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ K0¹© ^ ,L Q ¨ :03@¦0¦3 (*+ K<~,/58 ¨¢3¨Te58 ¨¥º#A/,,¥; 3 ¨ * 3¨¢30'¥<04/,¦ *¥2520¦ 5Á- 0¥2\¦ : ) 1,0¥8( , :¢ 52¥,+jwf,5¢¡¤£)- 52;-4 :¦4/,¦ *¥20'58 ¨@U( 2 Q"'0' ¥252058( "c6- (*5>03 3¨¦=>¥ 58 >¥8",,6( "!¥258 ¨ :052?#$¦?/,6 >05c3¨,'¢3¤¥:/ Q" 0,15243¨,¢3W¯+ ¨5>52b-W,/, 1b" ¦,¥2¥8 ¨¢3¨TX 1;0',¥2¥8 ¨'Q0'¥?"¦©3 ! 0520 G? ¢ fU #f :58 *6 §µ ¨¥?05<3¨,3©2658 )#g(*58( 4¢^6"W,/,52,:2( * 0//¢(* ;( 3¨052,¥,+ 58 ¨ 1b #j=?>,/,' Q" 3¨105?3¨,3 ; ¨¥4 ¨'¢ X- T G? *;¥2/, !#( */,58 ¨¦ I#j58 ;0 0" 58 ¨Q 3 *X¦0 ¨F,¢; ¨¥>52 ¡ ¡ |Et} 0 1 §¦ ¨ ¢ 58 #$TX :,58 6 ¥458 05>0@/,0 6 ¨0'52,¥4#$>#( 58 ¢>,/, @" 3¨0¦9 58 ¨ º52;¢ *0¦-3¨? 3 ¨ :#* 5j/,0¦3 3, ,¥,+ ,/,' Q" 3¨058 ¨ I/0 U ¨ 0524- T@58 *? 3 ¨ \¦0¦ ¨F,¦0; 1,58 *6 G<D/, @"3¨,52D58 *C/,'¥2589$-¢ ¢©*510 03¨T6¥8 ¨¥,>58 \/ 583 3¨: *,¥ ;(*¥25:¥20'58 ¨¥8#$TK5E=?X/¢2 ¨52¢2 ¨0 + ¥25,?58 C :,58 6L b( ¥25Q-: 5, 7 52a,¥258 ¨ :052a58 *X/,'¥25!¦#;,/, @" 3¨0'58 ¨ f+ 5C/¢( 2¢ 583¨Ty( ¥2X0 0¥B¢© ,\- TC58 ) 58 ,¥2¥>58 ,¥8 3¨C(*¥2\- T:58 ) 5? 1,58 *6 3 ,0¦; :6 ¢3<¦#<58 4/,' Q" 3¨058 ¨ a¥8",!#$>0/2 !¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ '0 ¨F,¢¦+ R6,/,¦ *4,/ Q" 3 *p58 J :58 *6Y ;(*¥25C#$/J0 3¨¢3$ 0¥>0b#g( /,58 ¨ k#q :,58 6\¥8 ¨F+?G? ¨¥? :6 ¢3 ¨¥)/03 - 052, ,=» 3 ¨ d0'/,58 ¨ f>0¥@6 ¨/,52052,L- TK58 º 3 K2(3¨,¥C 0520 + ¥2582( /,58('+ < *0¦j ,¥2/¢2 -,10 4 ¨ Q"3¨ :¢ 52,:0>¥8 ¨ Q" 3¨?/,¦ 583 3¨¢B :6 ¢3 ] ¢ C58 >0 0" 58 ¨> 3 *C¦0 ¨F,¢B ¨¢ 58 © ,¥?0e :,58 6Q#$¦ ] 58 054 ,¦3¨,/,52¥; :0¦ TX0¥8",/52¥Q¦#" ¦0 - *0¦ ¨¦+1G? *;"¢29 ,/,' Q" 3¨058 ¨ f ¨5< *h( ¢( ,¥?0 1,'¢ 5c¢" ,¥2¢ 58 ;58 *? 1,58 *6 #A :0¦ */,?,¥8( 3¨52¥?¥8 ¦=y58 05j,¢ º58 ¨¥j¥8 ¨ Q" 3¨; :63*#( */,58 ¨¦ *¥ #$¦>/, ¥8 ¨ ¢058 ¨¦ J- TC58 4/,¦ 583 3¨¢¦+BG` 4¦0¦ ¨F,;,¥258 ¨ :0'52,¥ ~,/,58 ¨'¢3¨T! !" 0/,58 ¨/+?e=B,¢¦ =?e=? 3 3 0 0 1,¥258 ¨ :0'52?# 58 *j052¢j º/,0/,Te# " 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0¦9 16¢3f¢© *, 1¢ 52¥40'¥4( e¥2T6¥252, ,'3¨¥,+ ¢¦¦,,¢6¦$ 58 ¨ k k58 *; :58 *6 U( ;52:58 40 0" 58 ¨; 3 ¨ *C2(3¨¥,+?G? * /,¦ 583 3¨¢> /,2"¦052,¥>58 ¨¥Á-W6¥25#$0'/,52j 524 ¨52¥?/,'¥25 - *¢© 5 5. FEEDBACK-DIRECTED INLINING :6 ¢3< ,¥2/¢2 -W,¹ aR6,/,58 ¨¦ I°+ G? ¨¥X¥2,/,58 ¨¦ p,¥2/2 -,¥I0 p¢^ 52¢ ¥8 ¨ l52K58 *I0 0" 58 ¨a" 58 9 @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ Y¥2T6¥252, Â52X¥8( ""¦5: 3 !#$,,6-*0'/ 69E6 ,/,52,L 3 9 {X0 TI#$0/,52¦¥Q/0 L/,¦ 582 -( 52!52X58 C¢^6",/52,K-6¥25Q#A0/,52¦¦ +kO)5;0! ¨ a3¨,¢3$B58 *C¥2T6¥252, Â520¦ 6,¥;0X¥2520'58 ¨¥258 ¨/,03e¥20 @"3¨ /¢3 (*6 J58 Q3 ¨ Q *0'58 ¨ Z#j/03 3 58(2 L¦'¢2 *0I0 X0 U 9 ¦#;58 X :,58 6L/,03 3¨¥C Y58 !2( L0" "3 ¨/058 ¨ l0 d 10 9 58 ¨ 03W" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,058 ¨¦ *¥e¢ 0- 3¨,:- Tb 3 *+>P)( B/¢(2 5Á ¨ Q" 3¨¢9 520¦ *¥e0 k0" ",^6 ¨ :0'58 ¨ L52:58 ; T *0' Q ¨/Q/03 3<¦0" X-*0'¥2,X :¢ 520'58 ¨ L¥258 ¨ :052,¥;58 ;-6¥254#$0'/,52e-*0'¥2,I I58 b#0'/,58 ¨ 58 ¨¥@0'520+ ¥8 !58 ¨¥Q0¦"" ,^6 ¨ :052C T *0' Q ¨/!/03 3B0" fc58 ¶ #j T 0 Q ¨/:/03 3¨¥;052582 - ( 52,K52:58 Q/03 3j, ; I58 *; T 0 Q ¨/ ¥2T6¥252 » ¨ ¢ 58 ©*¥ L 5 M1,',¥?52; 3 0¦ *:" 0¥2¥2,¥>58 ) #$29 /,0¦3 30¦" D0 :0¦ C,¥258 ¨ :0'526-*0'¥2,C C0>", ¨¦(*¥>¥258( T@#f¦~*9 1058 ¨ k52:58 4" 58 ¨ Q ¨F¢ !/ Q" 3¨¢¦+?G? 4¥2T6¥252, 10T1/ 6¥2 3 4"¦©3¨;6 ,/,52,C 3 ¨ *Is ¼,v8'#q58 *>-¢ ¢©*5B#<3 ¨ Q *0'58 * 52X,/,' Q" 3¨J0¦3 ,0 TL" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,,Y :58 *6 ¥C52¹ 3 *I *'5:/,03 3 58( 03 3¨T[0¦3 3@/,03 3¨¥!#' 58 X"'0 D+ Y#(*58( I=?2 e=? ',¥,+ ¨( :°!¥8 ¦=)¥e58 *1¥2582(*/,58( :¦#?58 b ¨ @"3¨, 1¢ 52058 ¨¦ 7 =? 3 3;¢^ 0' Q J :¦X¥2" ¨¥258 ¨/052,Y *(2 ¨¥258 ¨/,¥! '3¨ Y : ( ¥8 !58 ;0/2 ¨52,/58(0¦3<#0 :=?2 D#BR6,/,58 ¨¦ I³+ ,520 3¨,L0¦ *0¦3¨T6¥8 ¨¥:#j 3 !/0 U ¨ 052,¥1;52/ ¨h( ,¥:¥8( /2 K0'¥ 0 I0 X¿ 0 ;-¢¥¦ ¥) 3 WX582 ¨03¨¥Qs tt,v8+ · * [0L58 ,0p¥2=? ¨52/ 6/,/¢( ¥! [0L :58 *6Y"¦3¨¦(*@58 ] ¥2T6¥252 /,0¦3 3¨¥;58 * ¡¤£¦¥¦§©¨¦ ; :,58 6X#j0¦ |$0¥>=?¢3 3 O4¥j ,¥2/¢2 -,! D :¦4 ,520 3 k58 *>/,¦ 52¢^ 5?#q58 *eR6¢3 #9E±³@ ¨ Q9 ¦¡6b© ¦$,, 0'¥C58 *D :,58 6d3 ¨¥252¢ ¢I0¥1U ¨¥2/¢( ¥2¥2,Y pR6,/,58 ¨¦ p°+ t}¢+ZG` ¨¥ " 3¨, :¢ 520'58 ¨ Ls ³²¢vE658 4¥2T6¥252, ¥8 *¦(3¨D520 m4/,0¦)=? ¢ C,/,' Q9 'b3 ¨¥252¢ ¢1=?03 ¥;58 @58 ,0' ¦ ¥4¥2520'/ k52C,52 Q *158 *@/,03 3 " 3 *D0; :,58 6\" , ¨( ¥83¨TX/, @" 3¨,X=? ¨58 C#$,U- 0/2 69EU ,/52, ¥8 ¨52B58 *0'5c2 ¨¦ *0'52,:58 ?/,0¦3 3$+G? 'Á3 ¨¥252¢ ¢B/¢,0'52,¥c0>58( "3¨ 3 L58 05Q" , ¨¦(*¥C 3 *Z/¢ ¨¥8 ¨ ¥!0¦\ 5Q3¨'¥25,+KG? * ¨ ¢ 58 #$T !58 4/03 3 \'Q|$¥8",/ ©*,!- T158 *e/,03 3¨¢¦ /,03 3f¥8 ¨52 6T¹ ¨¥2¥8( \ K-W58 ZR6¢3 #9E±³I0 J L¦(1¥2T6¥252, ¸ ¨¥@58 *0'5Q¦ */,C0 0¦ *X/03 3¨,¦}>0 ! *¥252¥458 ¨¥458( "3¨; 52C0Q-( ~¢¦+ /,0¦3 34'º ¨¥@ 3 ,? ¨5: :0¦T¹ !3¨ !0¦""W,0: Z58 :"¦©3 9 Q 05204( ¥2,C52;U2 ¨'458 ? *¢^ 5j( *C# 3 . +>G? ¢¢#$¦ * !58 ?-( ~¢B-,/,' :,¥#( 3 3$*58 >, ?3 ¨¥252¢ ¢> ¨¥?52, Q"¦029 ] #$0¦ 3 (>52)" ,¥2¢'?3¨@ 3 *1,/ ¨¥8 ¨ ¥?/,0 @,¥8( 3¨5Á 158 ?¥2T6¥89 3¨TI ,0/,58 ¨¦0'52,d| ¨52¥4( " 052: 1,58 *6I=? 3 3< *'54-@/,03 3¨,a00¦ 52, ¥2/¢ 3 3¨0'58 . \-58=?, X58=BQ/,' Q" 3¨,J'¢¥8 ¨ ¥4¦#<0: 1,58 *6 0'50;" 3¨¦(*;58 ,0'\¥2=? ¨52/2 }j0 º ¨5j *'58 ©*,¥>58 ,0'/ L b-6 T J0DU ~¢ 5:¥2,5;¦#? 3 K ,/¢ ¨¥8 ¨¦ *¥,+DO4¥4 ¥¢£@$4¢©© 52\=B0 6@("a0 ¹" 6/,,¥2¥@58 Q-( ~¢¦+ " , ¨( ¥C=?2 B=?C¥23¨D58 ¨¥:" - 3¨, - TK¢ ¥8( 2 *K58 05103 3 ¡r¢¢¨OKª©¨:?<D$¡6¢*©¨¦, G? ¿ '0 ¨F,¢@ :0¦ 520 ¥;0:T 0 @ ¨/Q/,0¦3 3j0¦" f*=? ¢ £ · :,58 6 ¥b 3 *d L58 :", ¨¦(*¥1¢¥8 ¨¦ y¦#>58 : :,58 6K0 0/2 K, @/,¦2,¥8" ¥Q52C0C58(" 3¨:¦03 ( Q a58 *;- (~¦+;O)#$52 03¨¥2: 3 *J I58 *4 ,=p¢¥8 ¨¦ c+ ( " 058 K58 :=?¢ ¨¦ 52¥b L58 CT 0 @ ¨/!/,0¦3 3?¦0" cj58 ¿ £ · ¦0¦ ¨F,4/3¨,0¥?58 ?-( ~¢¦ 0¦ *Q0/,58 ¨¦052¥?58 *>, >3 ¨¥252¢ ¢¦+ G? ;/,0¦T!'0 ¨F,¢¦0:¥2"*0¦052@58 ,0' "¢2 ¨66 ¨/,03¨3¨TI,/0T6¥ 6. PERFORMANCE EVALUATION G? ¨¥>¥2,/58 ¨ I¢^6"2 ¨ :¢ 5203 3¨TX0'¥2¥2,¥2¥2,¥>58 4"¢2#$¦ :0 /,;#q58 * 58 ;, @=?¢ ¨¦ 52¥) X58 ; T *0' Q ¨/:/,0¦3 3j0" f+ /¢( 2¢ 5< ¨ Q"3¨ :¢ 52058 ¨¦ X¦#58 * 03¨0"WUN *@O4 0" 58 ¨ P)"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,09 M 58 ¨ R6T6¥252, !+1RU/,58 ¨ Lu +.²@ ,¥2/¢2 -¥Q58 :¢^6"2 ¨ :¢ 5203`¥2,58("f À<2 ¨6U ¨/,0¦3 3T'<58 * ¿ '0 ¨F,¢; ' 6¥;58 * £ · ¢6 6¢¢¨f ')*© g* 58 J-¢ / :0¦2 p¥8( ¨52@0¦ *p58 *I0 0" 58 ¨Z" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ ¥2T6¥89 52;,/,' Q" (*52;0'0¦"*58 ¨'4 3 . ! ,/¢ ¨¥8 ¨¦ *¥,+>G? g ¡:$¡6¢*©¨¦, 52, /, ©*¦(0'58 ¨ X" 00' :,52¢¥( ¥2,C !58 4^6"¢2 ¨ :¢ 52¥,+`RU/¢9 0'0¦"*58 ¨'¹ 3 *Z0¦ ¨F¢!"2#$ :¥158=?!#( /,58 ¨ ¥,+ ¥25, 7 58 ¨ pu + tJ#$6/(*¥2,¥C¦ p58 *I¢~,/58 ¨¢ ,¥2¥X#@ ;( 3¨58 93¨¢3@,/,' Q9 ¨5? ¨ ¢ 58 © ,¥Q',¥? I58 *; T *0' Q ¨/:/,0¦3 3<¦0" I=` ¥24"W¢/,¢ 589 " 3¨058 ¨ ,¥2/¢2 -o R6,/,58 ¨ °+nG` J"2#$ :0¦ */K#158 * 0'I#1¥20 Q" 3¨,¥X¢^ /,,p0 p, X *'58 *¥2¥X58 ,¥8 3¨+ G? ,¥2 #$,U- 0/2 69EU ,/52,Q 3 ¨ *@¥8( -*¥2T6¥252, [ 5866(*/,Q ºRU,/58 ¨ D¼ ',¥?0e0 \52;0¦ 0520;¥2582( /,58( =` ¨/2 ! ¨¥ *© *g ¡4¢§ ©¨,¦ ¨¥j0¥2¥2,¥2¥2,@ DRU/,58 ¨ Du+ ³+ÁRU,/58 ¨ Cu + °>",¥2 52¥ 0520;¦ :0'0¦"9 / ¥8(3¨52,K- TX58 Q/ 583 3¨C=? *¢ I ¨54#$¦ b( 3¨052,¥;/ Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ 58 ¨@" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ L¥2T6¥252 ¦2 *,0'X0 IRU/,58 ¨ au+ ¼b" ,¥2¢ 52¥ " 3¨0 ¥,+>O) TC, 4 I58 ¨¥4 05201¥2582(*/,58( @=` 3 3<-W4 3 ,J #j58 0520C D,/, @" 3¨0'58 ¨ K- *0¦ ¨¦+ /03 3 : :,58 6Q ¨¥j¥8(- ¥2,h( ¢ 583¨TQ,/,' Q" 3¨, ¥8(-m§¢/,552e¢ ¢29 ¦(*¥j¥8 ¨F,?/ ¥2580 52¥,+?G? ?¥2T6¥252, [¥252¥<58 * ¨58 ¨03f, j *'58 *,¥2¥ 58 ,¥8 3¨C#$0 23¨T: ¨ fU- ( 5"¢2 ¨66 ¨/,03 3gT\U( /,,¥ ¨5<( 58 30/2 9 Executing Compilers [Base,Opt,...] Code Install New Code Runtime Measurements Edge Instrumented/ Method Subsystem Instrumentation/ Samples Samples Optimized Compilation Code Plan Hot Methods Decay Dynamic Call AOS Compilation Organizer Organizer Graph Organizer Database Thread Dynamic Call Graph Adaptive Inlining Organizer Inlining Rules Compilation Queue Organizer Event Queue Controller Adaptive Optimization System (!%D ¢¡+$'& $B - * *¢(#%-'#¢¡ ¡ £ £ 2 "£C¢¡ £ () £"£* £ ()-J()-(-2! ()- *+12¢¡@¥&¤£-2#' ¤£&2*¢( ¥¦¥ &2*¢()$'(¨§£ *¢(#%- 3 © / * $ G? *: 03 #9$3 #$C#$@ :58 *6K¥20' Q" 3¨,¥b ¨¥C²+ ´\¥2/, ¥,+DG? * 6.1 Experimental Methodology à *0¦3 #9$3 #$X#e, C=? ¨ 52¥; y58 CT 0 @ ¨/X/,03 3>¦0" L ¨¥ G? )"2#$ :0¦ */),¥8( 3¨52¥? !58 ¨¥>¥2,/,58 ¨¦ !=B¢4¦-*520¦ *,D D0 ´U+ ³:¥2,/,¦ * ¥,+ $?{ ¼¯e{X63´¦¯6t¼4=? ¨58 158=?>³'³³{XeF>ÀÀB¿?u¯°'" 6/,,¥2¥2¥ 7 2( !O JIp6°+ ³+jG? *;¥2T6¥252, 0¥;² p#q :0 I : :T+ £ \0¦3 (*0'52!58 :¥2T6¥252, ¸( ¥8 *I58 *ºRUÀ K?¿§¢6 1±®Ks t¯vj-¢ /2 9 ] O>3 3f¢^6"¢2 ¨ : 52¥4=?¢?"2#$ :\( ¥8 * 03¨0¦"6N §¦ ¥? *¦ *'¢ *29 M :0¦2 ¥,58 0¦3¨0"6N *e" 58 ¨ Q ¨F¢ Q/,' Q" 3¨¢>s.²°vE¦0 ;58 * 3¨0 M z 0'58 ¨ 03f/,¦" T *:'02- 0'4/,¦3 3¨,/,52¦+BG? * 03¨0¦"6N Q-6'5Á ¨ :0' M -¢ /2 * :0¦2 s °°vE+ÂG<0- 3¨YtK"¦ ¨ ,¥L0y ,¥2/¢2 " 58 ¨ n#D,0/2 =B0¥;/,' Q" 3¨ ( ¥8 X58 *:¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F¢ *a/, Q" 3¨¢C0'5)3¨,'¢3et£¤c58 -¢ /2 * :0¦2 58 *> 6(* ;-¢ #q/¢3¨0¥2¥2,¥>58 05>/,' Q"2 ¨¥2@58 )-¢ /2 9 ¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F¢ *L/,' Q" 3¨¢C0 K58 C0 0" 58 ¨!¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ p¥2T6¥252, :0¦2 ;0 o58 K¥8 ¨F,'4 o- T652¥,Q¦#Q ¨52¥X/3¨0¥2¥!© 3¨,¥,+ ÀÁ, ¨¦(*¥ =B¢: */¢3 ( ,d L58 :-65@ ¨ :0'+XG? *@#$3 3¨¦=? *a/, 58¦3 3¨¢ =?¦2 µs tv; 0¥I¥8 *¦=? i58 05 03¨0¦"6N "2#$ :0¦ */y l58 *,¥2 M / ©*¦(0'58 ¨ K" 00' :,52¢¥e=?¢)( ¥2,! I58 ;¢^6"¢2 ¨ 1¢ 52¥ -¢ /2 * :0¦2 ¥;=? ¨58 *¦(*5e0 0" 58 ¨:/,' Q" 3¨058 ¨ a( 3¨TX :052/2 *¥ 58 05>#j58 4 *6( ¥258T93¨06 . I?{¸" 6U( /,5e 58(*0¦3j :0/2 + G? ¨ :¢< 52¢22( "*52¥>|ER6,/,58 ¨ D° + t'}c=?¢j¢ ¢052\¢T:²¯ à ¹#$6/(*¥X¦ [5E=?K 52¢,¥258 y, ¨ :¥!#$k0 0" 58 ¨L/, @" 9 ] Q 3 3 ¨¥2,/,¦ * ¥¦+ 3¨058 ¨¦ 0 + ( 2 *X" 0' · ¨r¡mr¢£¸¦¢§¨ ¦¢6 ¥C¦,$¢6$ G? *c ¨58 ¨03*/, Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ C *'58 *,¥2¥f58 ¥8 *¦3¨!|ERU/,58 ¨ 1°+ t} ¥252058( "f" ¦0 o- *0¦ ¨B58T" ¨/,0¦3 3¨T:/ 0 ¥Á0¦" ¨63¨TQ0'¥ ¨5< T9 à =?0¥f¥2,5<52Q²+¡o0 :=?0'¥<03 3¨¦=?,1524¦0T4-58=?, X²¢¡o0¦ * 0 Q ¨/,0¦3 3¨T\3¨'0 ¥?/¢3¨0¥2¥2¥?0 : ¨58 ¨0¦3 ¨F¥) 0520@¥2582( /,58(¥,+O>#$52¢ ¯+ t¼ ¡\+ 0X=? 3¨'?58 º" ¦0 Â,0/2 *¥:0X¥252,0 TI¥252052+ \0¦3 (*0'52 ] 58 ?¥252058( "Q ¨ :?- T;58 ¨ Q ;58 *j©¥25c2( :¦#58 >RUÀ KB¿§6 :±® G? * ¨58 ¨03f,/,' Q" 3¨0'58 ¨ I¥20' Q"3¨>¥8 ¨F,@|ERU/,58 ¨ D°+ t}c=B0¥ à -¢ /2 * :0¦2 ¥>=` ¨58 D58 >¥8 ¨F,Q²¯\|$ :U ( C}Á "( 52¥,*0¦ *:- TQ( ¥8 ¥2,5?¥8( / I58 05B58 *4,/ Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ L'0 ¨F,¢;=B( 3¨!2( ¹t 58 0¦3¨0"6N X" 58 ¨ Q ¨F¢ I/, Q" 3¨¢@52C/,' Q" 3¨C0¤£¦ ¦¥¦¥¦§©¨ § ¥©¥ M 58 ¨ :,¥;0D¥2,/, +:G? *1¥20 Q" 3¨C¥8 ¨F,:=?0'¥;03 3¨¦=?,K52D¦0T " 0' !+ ;¢"¦5;58 *1 Q ¨ ;( 58 ¨ 1Q¦-*520¦ *,K#' © ] ¥8(*/2 Y58 05C58 !,/,' Q" 3¨0'58 ¨ i¦0¦ ¨F,I/,( 3¨y2( Z-¢9 2( *¥X¦#@,0/2 o-W¢ */2 :02 i|$0K ,= { ¨¥X¥2520¦52,y#$k,0/2 M6z 58=?¢ ktQ58 ¨ :,¥e0:¥2,/,¦ *X0¦ *X¦ */,;¢TD°:¥2,/,¦ * ¥,+ 2( }¢+ D58 * §¦¥¤§© §\-W¢ */2 :02 e=?\( ¥2X0K/,¦ © ( 058 ¨¦ 7 58 054" 0¥2¥2,¥:²t¯ ¯¯'¯! :¥2¥20¥,c0¦ *X2( ¥4#$¦4( 3¨TK³'¯\¥2/¢9 G? *> ¨58 ¨0¦3 3 X, 4 58 ,¥2¥458 ,¥8 3¨K|ER6,/,58 ¨¦ a¼} à ¥4 k( ;¥2T6¥252, D+ =?0¥1¥2,5C52d²+¡0 y=?0'¥º"W¢2 ¨6U ¨/03 3gT ,6( /,,d( 58 3; ¨5 ,0/2 ,!¯ + t ¡\+ G<X :,0'¥8(D¥252,0 T9E¥252052C"¢2#$¦ :0 /,B Z58 *kRUÀ KB¿§6 :±® G? *> 3 . X¥20 @"3¨;¥8 ¨F,C|ER6,/,58 ¨ a¼'}?=?0¥?¥25)¥8( /2 X58 05 -¢ /2 * :0¦2 ¥,*=??¢"W5j58 *>-,¥25j¢3¨0" ¥2,!58 ¨ 1)#' l© >2( ¥, à 58 *; T 0 Q ¨/@/,03 3q0¦" I0¦ *X0'0¦"*58 ¨'b 3 ¨ X0¦ ¨F9 <=? ¨58 Y58 X¥8 ¨F,d²¯¯ ¢©©?§ p § ¡K¢J¦ ¡©¨fÄU,§*$ ¢¥>=?( 3¨!2( X /,@,T!t6+ ¼@¥2,/, ¥,+ |3¨0'¦}Á "( 52¥,+ j58 0¦3¨0"6N *:¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F¢ *C/,' Q" 3¨¢?-¢ /2 9 7 M D$?@ 3( §£ #¢¡ 7 §/ /¢ (J£/ ¡ -2"A1$B ;C¥/ ¢ £/" ¢()&2*¢(#%- #¢¡ 7 §/ /£/ £ ()- ©%*£/¥¤ §¨§¤£ ¦ © © O> ! ¨ Q" 3¨, : 52058 ¨ #j58 ;wc, Q"W¢3 9 ¨X/ Q" ,¥2¥8 ¨ a03¨'2 ¨58 ²t ²¦´U ®6t6² ¦ 0¦¦0:¢^6"W¢54¥8 ¢3 3<¥2T6¥252 ²¦¼¦¯ ³'±u ¼³'u © © M ¥ K<^ ,/¢( 58 ¨ a#j 0520¦-*0'¥2b#g( /,58 ¨ ¥4¦ I :, :¦T:,¥8 ¨ 54 0520 ³ ²,¯¨²¦¼¦u §¦§ ²+ ¯+ t 0¦¦0:/,' Q" 3¨ ²¦´'¼ ¼¦u² °u'³ M6· M ¦ §¤£ ¦§ ¡¦¥ § ,/,' Q"¥2¥8 ¨ a#j0( 6 ¨\© 3¨,¥ ¼¦° ²t¯¨²,®mt · §¦¨¦ ¤¨ 02 ¨0¦ 54¦#<0:5E=?9E58 ,0!0¦T6580/ *C03¨'2 ¨58 t'¼ ¼´U ®6¼¦± z § 0¦¦0Q" 0¥2¢ ¢ ¢0'52 ¼'¼ ²³¯ ®®'± M ¦¨ § £¦¨ §¨§¤£ ¥¤ 0¦3¨0"6N *D" 58 ¨ Q ¨F¢ !/,' Q" 3¨ ³±'³ ²' ³m´® t±mt M ¦ §¦¥¤§© § {!( 3¨58 ¨58 ,0 ,K¥2¢'¢e0" "3 ¨/058 ¨ Z52:¥8 ¨ ;( 3¨052@/ 05>6 :¥ u'± t¦¯± ®± ² ¥ 12 /£*'# ¡ @ -2"A1$B ;C¥/ D2/ £ *# £ §)D2§* *+12 ¡¥& -2#£ ¤£&2*¢( ¥ ¥ &2*¢()$'(¨§£ *¢(#%- 3 © / * $ 12 : /* / £ ¥ - # / "£#%$ & ;(/ *¢12 /¢D(* #¢¡ 3465 7H9; <$'=¥>? -2"£1$B ¢C./ 102 <=?@¢"5@58 Q-,¥25@58 ¨ ::# ©*'º2( ¥Q¦#>/, @" 3 58 ¨ :;0@ :,58 6\ ¨¥?/03 3¨,+eA D58 40 0" 58 ¨@/,¦ © ( 058 ¨¦ *¥,f58 * 58 ;¢ 58 @" 58 ¨ Q ¨F¢ !/,' Q" 3¨¢¦c/ ¥8 ¨¥258 *D#c¦(*¦ 3¨TI´'¼U ¯¯'¯ - 0¥2¢3 Q/ Q" 3¨¢;/ Q" 3¨,¥40/2 X :,58 6!58 )© ¥25?58 ¨ :4 ¨5B¢^69 3 ,¥C# 0¦¦0J¥2¦(/!/,6 + 158 *¤ §¦¥¤§© §º-W¢ */2 :02 >=? ,/¢( 52,¥,+14¦=?,'¢¦0¥;58 :0" " 3 ¨/,058 ¨¦ Y¢^ ,/(*52,¥,q58 *@0 0" 58 ¨ M 7 "54"2#$ :0¦ */º a52¢ :¥;¦#? 1,¥2¥20':58 ¦(*¦ " ( 5Q¦@0 " 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ S¥2T6¥252, Â/, 58 6( ( ¥83¨TK ¨¢ 58 © ,¥:0¦ *I,/, @" 3¨,¥ 2( I58 05?"*0'¥2¥2,¥Q²'+ t@ Q 3 3 ¨ L 1,¥2¥20',¥,+ 5> :,58 6¥e05? ¨ ¢@" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ K3¨,'¢3¨¥,+ ¨( C¼C¥8 *¦=>¥)"2#$ :0¦ */Q K58 :¥2520¦58("I, ¨ 1Q#$ ,0/2 7 6.2 Multi-Level Recompilation -¢ /2 * :0¦2 +?G? ;0" I¥8 =>¥?¥8"W,,!¢3¨0'58 ¨@52:58 *4- 0¥23 * G? ¨¥<¥2,/,58 ¨¦ :,¦0¦3 (*0'52,¥<58 *j¢~/,58 ¨¢ ,¥2¥<¦#*58 0'0¦"*58 ¨'? ;(3¨58 9 Gi/,¦ © ( 058 ¨¦ cB58 6(*¥@5203 3¨Q- 0¥;¢" ,¥2¢ 5;-,5252¢@"¢2#$¦29 M 3¨¢3 ,/,' Q" 3¨0'58 ¨ D¥2T6¥252, [ ,¥2/¢2 -W,Q ºRU,/58 ¨ 1°`- T;/ Q" 029 :0¦ */,'+K<^ ,/¢( 58 ¨ D58 ¨ :¥Á#$¦?0/2 C/, © ( 058 ¨ k/,0 1-?#$( * Q ¨52¥?"¢2#A :0¦ */,e52b-W58 $Gy0¦ *C¥8 ¨ Q" 3¨Q0'0¦"*58 ¨'Q¥8 3¨9 M I58 ;0" "¢ U ^+ 3¨¢3f/,¦ © ( 058 ¨¦ *¥e# 03¨0¦"6N +> C58 40 0" 58 ¨;¥8 3¨93¨¢3 M / ©*¦(0'58 ¨ ¥,c58 4/,¦ 583 3¨¢ /, @" 3¨,¥e03 3 5? :58 *6 ¥>=` ¨58 G? *<,¥8( 3¨52¥¥8 ¦=K58 05c 158 *j¥252058( "Q ¨ :m0 0" 58 ¨?,/,' Q9 58 I" 58 ¨ Q ¨F¢ o/,' Q" 3¨¢J( ¥8 y0L¥8 *¦3¨K©^ ,Y¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ " 3¨058 ¨ /¢3¨,023¨TX ¢3 ¨'¢¥4-,5252¢>"2#$ :0¦ */Q58 0 I0¦ T\¦#j58 * 3¨¢3$+ Gp/,¦ © ( 058 ¨¦ *¥,+eG? *@=?¥25>0'0¦"*58 ¨':/, © ( 058 ¨ fc3¨,'¢3 M tUj ¨ Q" ',Y"¢2#$¦ :0 /,!- TL0K :,0¦ Y¦#@t³A¡/, @"*0¦,y52 G<C0¦3 3¨=i58 Q^6"¢2 ¨ :¢ 52¥@52:#$6/¢( ¥4¦ I58 *Q ¨ @"*0'/,5;#<,/ Q9 58 )-,¥25 Gy/ ©*¦(0'58 ¨ f05j" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,058 ¨¦ J3¨¢3f¯+ ¦#A( M 7 " 3¨058 ¨¦ [ ,/¢ ¨¥8 ¨¦ *¥,> X#;58 !/ ©*¦(0'58 ¨ ¥!"¢2#$¦ H0 T -¢ /2 * :0¦2 ¥,>, y¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ o3¨,'¢3e¯¹ ¨¥C526X¢^6"W¢ *¥8 ¨'¹ #A,,6-*0'/ 69E6 ,/,52,Z" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,058 ¨¦ ¥J| $+ +¨<58 ,TK ! *'5Q(*¥2:" 9 /,' Q" 3¨9858 ¨ 1* ,0'U Q"2#$ :0¦ */4/,' Q"*0¦,:52;58 ?-*0'¥2¢9 © 3 ! 0520:52:¦( ¨ :¥8"/¢ ©*/@" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ ¥}¢+4G? 6( ¥,*=? ¢ X58 3 )/ Q" 3¨¢¦+?G? ,¥2,¥8( 3¨52¥j¥8 *¦=L58 *0'5c C58 ?¥252058( ":,¦ ¨ : 0'0¦"*58 ¨'C¥2T6¥252, / 6¥2¥;52º/, Q" 3¨:0C :,58 6X05e0 k" 58 9 /,' Q" 3¨9858 ¨ 1d¦'¢2 *0Y"3¨0¦T6¥I0 3¨0¦J¦3¨+ k03 3;-¢ /2 9 7 @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ y3¨,'¢3$ ¨5@=? 3 34/ Q" 3¨\ ¨5:58 C¥20 :C=?0¦TI0 Gi/,¦ 9 M :0¦2 ¥,c */,0¥8 K58 :" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ y3¨¢3? 58 * $G[/,¦ © 9 M © ( 058 ¨¦ K=B( 3¨+ ¦e,0/2 !- */2 * 102 I=?>0 I58 4#$3 3¨¦=? * 7 ( 058 ¨ /,0¦(*¥2,¥D¥252058( "y"2#$ :0¦ */K52K¥8( ~¢¦+[G? ¨¥\" " 9 0¦3¨0"6N *D/, ©*¦(0'58 ¨ ¥ M ¢5ETd 6,¥: 5: *¦3¨ #AC58 X0 0" 58 ¨K/ ©*¦(0'58 ¨ ¥,;=? *¢ ¥2¢3¨,/58 ¨;/,' Q" 3¨0'58 ¨ I0¦3 3¨=>¥>¢~/,58 ¨>(*¥2e# ¨¦ *>" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0¦9 58 *4- 0¥23 *:/ Q" 3¨¢@0¥>0 $G6¤ 58 ¨ a a¥2,'¢03j-¢ / :0¦2 ¥,+:4¦=?¢¦58 b-W,¥25;¥8 *¦3¨\3¨,'¢3 M à #B0 0" 58 ¨C¦"*58 ¨ Q ¨F058 ¨ S¦02 ¨,¥;0' : !58 Q-¢ /2 * :0¦2 ¥b-W¢9 58 *;¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F¢ *X/ Q" 3¨¢;0'5?3¨,¢3j¯10¥>0 G6¤ M à 58=B,¢ :3¨,'¢3f¯;0 :3¨,¢3j²'+ B58 ¨¥0¥2 f ¦¢0¦3 3$*58 4 ;(3¨58 9 7 3¨,'¢3<¦"*58 ¨ Q ¨F058 ¨ ¥258052,'T\ ¢3 ¨'¢¥;58 *4-W,¥25?"¢2#$¦ :0 /,;# 58 *;¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F¢ *X/ Q" 3¨¢;0'5?3¨,¢3>² 0¥>0 G6¤ M à 03 3q/, © ( 058 ¨ ¥,+ 58 *;¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F¢ *X/ Q" 3¨¢;0'5?3¨,¢3Bt@0¥>0 G6¤ M à ¨( CuX¥8 *¦=>¥4"¢2#A :0¦ */,: L58 :¥252,0'T9E¥2520'52º ¨ ::#$¦ 7 58 *@0 0" 58 ¨C¥8 3¨¢9$3¨,'¢3e/, © ( 058 ¨ L( ¥8 *X58 @" 58 9 à ,0'/ C-¢ /2 * :0¦2 +?Oe0 f*58 4¦0" X ¢" ¨/,52¥4¥8",\¢3¨0'58 ¨;52 Q ¨F¢ C/, Q" 3¨¢@0'5`3¨¢3j¯ ¤ 58 b- 0¥2¢3 Gp/, © ( 058 ¨ 0 X58 *@¢^ ,/¢( 58 ¨ a58 ¨ :,¥;/0 M -4#$¦( ! I58 ;0" "¢ U ^+ 58 *@0 0" 58 ¨C¥8 3¨¢9$3¨,'¢3e/, © ( 058 ¨ L( ¥8 *X58 @" 58 9 à Q ¨F¢ C/, Q" 3¨¢@0'5`3¨¢3>² ¤ G? *j,¥8(3¨52¥j¥8 =Z58 *0'5<58 *j"¢2#$¦ :0 /,4¦#*0/2 C0 0" 58 ¨e/, 9 58 *@0 0" 58 ¨C¥8 3¨¢9$3¨,'¢3e/, © ( 058 ¨ L( ¥8 *X58 @" 58 9 © ( 058 ¨ p ¨¥!/ Q"58 ¨58 ¨K=? ¨58 y ¨52¥ G /,¦ © ( 058 ¨¦ i/,¦( 9 M à Q ¨F¢ C/, Q" 3¨¢@0'5`3¨¢3Bt£¤ 52¢2" 05,+XG? C b( 3¨58 9$3¨,¢3e0'0¦"*58 ¨'X¥2T6¥252, ¢3 ¨'¢¥C58 *:-¥25 "¢2#A :0¦ */,B# 58 *?0'0¦"*58 ¨'>/, ©*¦(0'58 ¨ ¥, =` ¨58 1¦¢0¦3 3"W¢29 58 *C0'0¦"*58 ¨'X b( 3¨58 9$3¨,¢3@¥2T6¥252 ( ¥8 *K58 C" 58 ¨ Q ¨F¢ à #$¦ :0 /,C=? ¨58 St ¡ #e58 *@-,¥25 Gi/, © ( 058 ¨ S05;¦"*58 9 M /, @" 3¨¢ 05>0 TD#< ¨52¥>58 ,43¨,3¨¥,+ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ L3¨,'¢3etU+1G? ¨¥;,¥8( 3¨5Q ¨¥;¢ /,( 0¦ * ?¥8 /,!58 G M /,¦ © ( 058 ¨¦ X"¢2#$¦ :¥Á ;/,' Q" 3¨0'58 ¨ f*"¦©3 ¦? ,/¢ ¨¥8 ¨¦ :0¦ 6 *K6( 2 *I58 *:2( 58 ¨ :X05@¥252,0'TI¥252052+kG` C0 0" 58 ¨ G? $Go/ ©*¦(0'58 ¨ ¥:/, @" 3¨C,0'/ I :58 *6I58 *;© ¥25;58 ¨ : M ¥2T6¥252, i03¨¥2;-¢ ¢© 52¥#' [3¨0T :¦"*58 ¨ Q ¨F058 ¨ q+ ( 2 *@58 * · ¨5>¢^ /¢(*52¥?0 \ ,?,/,' Q" 3¨@0@ :,58 6+BG` 6( ¥, 58 *¥24/,¦ 9 ¢3¨0¦T< :¦:#>58 Q" ¦0 3¨'0 ¥Q T *0' Q ¨/,0¦3 3Tj¥2C3¨052¢1" 9 © ( 058 ¨¦ *¥1 3¨T! */¢( 158 *@¦¢2 ,0a#B/, Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ Z58 *Q© ¥25 5 JIT OptLevel 0 JIT OptLevel 1 JIT OptLevel 2 Adaptive OptLevel 0 4 Adaptive OptLevel 1 Adaptive OptLevel 2 Adaptive Multi-Level 3 2 Speedup over JIT Baseline 1 0 compress jess db javac mpegaudio mtrt jack opt-compiler volano geometric mean (!%D 32* *¢D& &@ ¡ #% ¢$B¥-2"£ 8 JIT OptLevel 0 JIT OptLevel 1 JIT OptLevel 2 6 Adaptive OptLevel 0 Adaptive OptLevel 1 Adaptive OptLevel 2 Adaptive Multi-Level 4 Speedup over JIT Baseline 2 0 compress jess db javac mpegaudio mtrt jack opt-compiler volano geometric mean (!%D ¢¡ 32*£ £ © ¡ /* *'& ¡ #% ¢$B-2"£ 58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ p520 6¥:0 ¦0 520'X# 0X,0'52¢C ¨,= ¦#;58 \=? 3¨ G? *;52¦"X5E=?b" ¨@/ 052¥? 3 3 ( ¥258052:0:/0¥298¦0 X- ,0 k¦=? " ¦0 !+B !¦(B/¢( 2¢ 5?/,' Q" 3¨¢¦58 ¨¥j,¥8(3¨52¥j X :¦)~,/¢9 #f52'5203 O4P;R@¥2T6¥252, i'¢2 ,0+jG` ,¥2>58=B4" ¨>/2 *0¦52¥? : 9 58 ¨'; 58(*0¦3 ¨F0'58 ¨ K0¦ *C 3 ¨ * c0¦ *C3¨,¥2¥4 T *0' Q ¨/;3 6 ¥258052;58 05e58 *;52'5203q58 ¨ :Q¥8"W¢ 5) I58 QOeP;RC58 ,0'¥> ¨¥)¢3¨0¦9 3¨06 *:524 ¨ @"¦º"W¢2#$ 10 /,4¦?0¦3 3 $GK/,¦ © ( 058 ¨¦ *¥ 58 ¨3¨TJ¥2 :0¦3 3$<0¦¢0' X®+ u£¡µ#$e"'0' ¸¥252058( "K0¦ *Iu+ ¯£¡ M ¦ X¥2' :b-W¢ */2 :02 ¥,+ #$¦\3¨¦ *¦9$2( W+ G? J¥8 ¨ Q 3¨0¦2 ¨58TY [¦'¢2 *0Y#$D58 J5E=? ,¦ ¨ :,¥@/,0 K-W\0'52582 -( 52,K52X58 :/,'¥2589$-¢ ¢©*51 :63?¦#>58 * B58 ¨( ,¥k¼ 0¦ *YuI 3 3 (*¥2580'52K58 *0'5!0¦ Ty !© ^ ,Y¥2580589 /,¦ 583 3¨¢X|$ ,¥2/¢2 -W,K ZRU/,58 ¨ L° + ³m}¢+:?TI,¥258 ¨ :0'58 *X#( 58( 7 TL6¥Q *'5C¥8( ¨5:0I=?¦2 63¨0Y=? ¨58 L" 0' :¥C58 *0'5C¢^ ,/¢( 52 ¢^ ,/(*58 ¨¦ X58 ¨ :m58 *> :6 ¢30¦¦ ¨¥j"¢2#$¦ Q *@526; ;(*/2 C=?¦2 #ADU ~W¢¢ 5!3¨¢ 58 ¥!¦#@58 ¨ :+ C3¨¦ *¦92( y" ¦0 :¥, 05<¥2520¦58("f'T,5<0¦3 3¨=>¥j :B58 ¨ :#$¦j" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,058 ¨¦ D0¥c" 0' 7 58 ) ¨ ,¥25>" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ I3¨,3c ¢3 ¨'¢¥458 )-¥25"¢2#$¦ :0 /, ¢^ ,/(*58 ¨¦ L/, 58 6( ,¥,+;À<, ¨¦(*¥@¢¥8 ¨¦ *¥;¦#?58 @0 0" 58 ¨C¥2T6¥89 #A Gi0 K¥8 3¨¢9$3¨,'¢3@0 0" 58 ¨D/, ©*¦(0'58 ¨ ¥,+L4¦=?,'¢¦ 52, i58 05?6 ¨: *'5(*¥2>0@/,¥2589$- *¢© 5? :6 ¢352 * ,!52;¥8"W¢ *C0 M #A1¥8 *¦5892( J" 0' :¥,?58 : ¨¦ *¥25\¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ Y3¨,¢3 3¨0'¢4"W¢/,¢ 520'@#j58 ¨ :;"¢2#$¦ Q \¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ K I¥8 *¦589 ¢3 ¨'¢¥J58 'N "¢2#$¦ :0 /,+iG? X0 0" 58 ¨K ;( 3¨58 93¨¢3 2( *L"'0' :¥,+A S0 U ¨58 ¨¦ c;- 0¥2¢3 K/,' Q" 3¨0'58 ¨ i0¦ * ¦, ¥2T6¥252 »0¦"" 3 ¨,¥>" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ ¥f§ (*6 ¨/¢ ¨¦(*¥83¨T6*0'52520 *; ¨ C"¢29 0¦2-*0';/,¦3 3¨,/,58 ¨¦ K/,' Q" 2 ¨¥2Q0@¥2 :03 3f"¢/, 520;¦#<¢^ /¢(*58 ¨¦ #A :0¦ */,; !-W58 I58 ;¥252058( "I0 X58 *;¥252,0'T9E¥2520'52b,¦ ¨ :,¥,+ 58 ¨ :; !-'58 X, ¨ 1,¥,+ G? *>-5252' µ"*0¦ e#c" ¨;/2 *0¦52¥)¥8 ¦=>¥?58 *43¨058 ¨@58 ¨ :e¥8"¢ 5 6.3 Feedback-Directed Inlining Y0/2 YOeP;Rd58 ,0+YG? !"¢/,¢ 520'I# 58 ¨ :X¥8"¢ 5C/,' Q9 ¨¦( ´4¥8 *¦=>¥j58 *"W¢2#$ 10 /,) ¨ Q" 0/5?#*#A,,6-*0'/ 69E6 ,/,52, 7 " 3 *! X-'58 X, ¨ 1,¥4 ¨¥4¥8 ¨ Q 3¨0¦¦c0¦"" ,^6 ¨ :0523¨TK¼¦¯£¡\0'0 3 b @0¦ @0 0" 58 ¨> ;(3¨58 9$3¨,'¢3*¥2T6¥252 #$¦c-'58 @58 *j¥252058( " 6(*X52I58 *D/, 58¦3 3¨¢X 16¢3$+SG` !¦0¦ ¨F,X58 ,0 ¥: */¢( 0¦ *D¥252,0 T9E¥2520524,¦ ¨ :,¥,+ >0/2 !-¢ /2 * :0¦2 X=?e¥8 *¦=Y58 7 ¥83 ¨ 583¨TI ¨¦ *¢1¦¢2 ,0'J#$ 58 *@3¨ 9$2( *J" ¦0 :¥4-W¢9 ¥8"W,,K¢3¨058 ¨'X52X58 *C0'0¦"*58 ¨'X b( 3¨58 9$3¨,¢3 ¥2T6¥252, ¸# Â58 /,0¦(*¥2K0/2 Y"'0 ¥8"¢ ¥I :I58 ¨ :X [0L¥252,0'TY¥2520'52+ " , ¨¦(*¥e¥2,/,58 ¨ f+?wf0'¢>-*0¦¥`",¥2 5`-W,5252¢>"¢2#$¦ :0 /,+ ( 2 !58 ¨¥458 ¨ :58 ;'0 ¨F,¢@58 ,0 ¥4/ 58 6( :52Q" 6/,,¥2¥ · 03 ( ,¥@,0'52¢158 *0¦ Y²+ ¯\ U ¨/052!58 054#A,,6-*0'/ 69E6 ,/,52,L 9 z 2( 58 ¨ :Q 1,0¥8( , :¢ 52¥,*- ( 5) ¥2¢5)#$=?¢e, 52¥) I58 ;0¦9 3 ¨ @"¦y"¢2#$¦ :0 /,!¦'¢C58 !0 0" 58 ¨X ;( 3¨58 93¨¢3 ¨F,¢C,'¢ 5;h( ¢(*'58 6( ¥;,U( /¢ K58 :/, 58¦3 3¨¢¢¦ ¥:/, @"( 5209 ¥2T6¥252 ¤j0¦3 (*¥b3¨,¥2¥158 *0¦ Y²+ ¯\ U ¨/052!0!"W¢2#$ 10 /,C,¦09 58 ¨ X3¨'0+ 058 ¨¦ c+ ¦;-58 K" ¦0 Â¥252058( "a0 K¥252,0 TI¥252052:58 :OeP;R¹¦'¢29 7 158 *C¥252058( "L, ¨ 1<-58 © ©C0 §¦§ ¥8 ¨ © /,0 583¨T 7 ,0µ|$58 I¢^ ,/¢( 58 ¨ 58 ¨ :K¦#C58 J/,¦ 583 3¨¢ 0 ['0 ¨F,¢ ¦ ¨ @"¦L=? ¨58 Y#$,U- 0/2 69EU ,/52,o 3 ¨ * :=? ¨58 0 ²¯£¡ 0¦ * 58 ,0 ¥}` ¨¥>3¨,¥2¥;58 *0¦ I³+ ´ ¡µ¦#j58 *@52520¦3<¢^ ,/(*58 ¨¦ K58 ¨ :C|$ 3¨T ° + ´ ¡ "¢2#$¦ :0 /,\ ¨ @"¦ :¢ 5,¥8",/,58 ¨'¢3¨T+aP) 3¨T §¦¨¦ ¤¨¥¦ ¥ tU+ ±£¡¸#$D58 \3¨¦ *¦92( L, ¨ 1¦}¢+YG? ¨¥D/, © :¥C¢^6"¢2 9 "W¢2#$ 10 /,>¥8 ¨ ©*/,0¦ 583TC ,0'¥=? ¨58 104u+ ´ ¡p,¦0 058 ¨¦ c+ :¢ 520¦3<¦-*¥2¢¦0'58 ¨ ¥;#<" , ¨( ¥4,¥2,0¦/ as ³m¼U*°'uvE+ P4'¢03 3$*#A,,6-*0'/ 69E6 ,/,52,! 3 W\ ¨ Q" ¦,¥?"¢2#A :0¦ */,;¦# 58 C¥8 *¦5b2( J" 0' :¥;- Td²+¡\+ :6 ¨K *'5Q¢^6"W,/,5@52 ] ¥2; b( / X"W¢2#$ 10 /,b ¨ @"*0'/,5) I58 ¨¥),¦ ¨ :;-,/,0¦(*¥2@#j58 6.5 Recompilation Decisions ¨( I±J ¢" ¨/,52¥!58 !,/,' Q" 3¨0'58 ¨ /¢ ¨¥8 ¨ ¥X :0 !- TL58 * 7 " ¦0 :¥¦B¥8 *¦5!¢^ /¢(*58 ¨¦ p58 ¨ :,¥,+pO ¥8 *¦5\^ ,/¢( 58 ¨ 58 ¨ : /,¦ 583 3¨¢j @58 *j0 0" 58 ¨> ;(3¨58 9$3¨,'¢3 ¥2T6¥252, o6( 2 *;58 ¥2520 T9 6,¥4 5e03 3¨¦=i :0 TX :58 *6 ¥;52:-Q/ Q" 3¨,K0'5) ¨ a" 58 9 ¥252052X,¦ ¨ :+ D,0'/ Y- */2 * 102 4#$¦(D-*0¦¥!0¦J¥8 ¦=` 7 @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ J3¨,'¢3¨¥Q|$=? ¢4 3 ¨ *X6//¢(¥}¢ e52Q-4/, Q" 3¨, ,0'/ I-*0¦4¢" ,¥2¢ 52¥@58 b"/,¢ 520':#`03 3j :,58 6 ¥;58 *0'54© 9 6( Q52Q ,=Y *'5>/,03 3q¥8 ¨52,¥,+ ¨¥8 ,X05>58 ; ¨ I" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,058 ¨¦ K3¨,'¢3$+>G? *4- 0¥2¢3 Q- 0>¢" 9 ,¥2¢ 52¥j :,58 6 ¥?58 *0'5=B¢? *,'¢j,/, @" 3¨,C- TQ58 >0 0" 58 ¨ e58 *;¥2520 T98¥2520'524, ¨ 1*#$,,6- 0/2 6986 ,/,52¹ 3 X/,¦ 9 7 " 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ S¥2T6¥252, !+DG` Q3¨,'¢3;²C0¦ *J3¨¢3et:-*0¦¥Q0¦Q#( 29 ¥8 ¨¥252 583¨Tl ¨ @"¦¥J"¢2#$¦ :0 /,+ ,,6-*0'/ 69E6 ,/,52,i 3 9 7 58 ¢D¥8(-6 ¨ ¨ ,[52K¥8 ¦= ¦= :58 *6 ¥\,0'/ ,Y58 ¢ !© 03 K ¨ Q" ', © ©k- TZ´³A¡½0¦ * §¤£ ¦§ ¡¦¥ §\- TZtt ¡C+oG? /,' Q" 3¨0'58 ¨ Z¥252052'+eA I58 Q0'0¦"*58 ¨': b( 3¨58 9$3¨,3>¥2T6¥252, 58 *¢ §¦¨¦ ¤¨j-¢ / :02 1 /,j0'0 1,¦0 ,¥<=? ¨58 :0B±£¡Y,¦0 058 ¨¦ c+ 0X5E=?X"*0'58 *¥D0K :,58 6y/,0¦ Y#$3 3¨¦= 52J3¨,'¢3C² ¨58 *¢k58 * P4'¢03 3$6#$,U- 0/2 69EU /,52,: 3 ¨ *Q ¨ @"¦¥"¢2#$¦ :0 /,?- T :,58 6L=?0¥@6 ,/,583¨Td/, Q" 3¨,Z05Q3¨,'¢3;²'¦C58 \ 1,58 *6 0¦ X0¦0@#>²'²¢¡\+ =?0'¥©¥25j,/, @" 3¨,X0'53¨,'¢3<¯@0 C58 *¢ D,/,' Q" 3¨X00¦ X0'5 3¨,'¢3;²+1R ¨ Q 3¨023gTB58 *¢10Q#$¦(;"W¥2¥8 - 3¨\" 058 ¥Q58 054,¥8( 3¨5 6.4 Adaptive System Overhead D0Q 1,58 *6:- *:/ Q" 3¨,X05j" 53¨,'¢3qtU+<e¦=?,¦U#AB( ¨¦(L®K 3 3 ( ¥258052,¥K=? ¢I¢^ ,/¢( 58 ¨ i58 ¨ 1¹ ¨¥X¥8" 5! [58 -¢ /2 * :0¦2 ¥? *@ :,58 6C0/,58( 03 3¨TC526 º58 *>"*0'58 !58 05j¢ 520¦ 3¨, 7 ¦0¦2 ¨( ¥;/, Q"W ¢ 52¥Q¦# 03¨0¦"6N !=? * X(*¥8 X58 *; ;( 3¨58 93¨¢3 -¢ \/, Q" 3¨,I05>03 3q58 ;#j58 ;" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,058 ¨¦ K3¨,'¢3¨¥,+ M 0'0¦"*58 ¨'Q¥2T6¥252 µ=? ¨58 !#$,U- 0/2 69EU /,52,! 3 +>G? *>©*¦( /2 00/52¢2 ¨F,,¥:58 :¦2 *,0'J#$¦@58=?C¢^ ,/(*58 ¨¦ d ¨ :,¥ " 9 G? *>0'0¦"*58 ¨';¥2T6¥252, [,/, @" 3¨,C-,5E=?,¢ I²¦t ¡µ| §¦¥¤§© §6}W0¦ * ¦0 ¥252058( "y0¦ *K3¨¦ *¦92( K"'0 1¥,+ ¦C58 ¨¥@©*¦( °6¼ ¡ | §¦§ }:#103 31 :,58 6¥I T *0' Q ¨/,03 3gTi/, @" 3¨,+ÂG? * 7 ¦ " ¦0 ¥252058( "!/2,¥8"¦ * ¥>52b© ¥25<2( D#f58 ;R6ÀKB¿§¢6 :±'® :'¥25c/,' : : 3¨T;¥2¢3¨,/52,Q¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ \3¨¢3 =?0'¥3¨,'¢3²¦=? ¨/ -W¢ */2 :02 ¥<=? ¨58 @ " (*5<¥8 ¨F)²¯'0 43¨ 9$2( *@/,2¥8" ¥ ¨¥4/ ¥8 ¨¥252¢ 5;=? ¨58 X58 Q :6 ¢3f"*0¦0 :,52¥458 054 ¢© *@58 ;¢^69 521/¢(* ;( 3¨058 ¨158 ¨ Q *'¥)#$¦?© 42( *¥e#<58 ;¥20 14-¢ / :02 ¥ ",/52,Q-¢ ¢© 52¥?0 :/,'¥252¥<#0/2 C" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ !3¨¢3$+B{X¥25<# =? ¨58 L "( 5:¥8 ¨F,I²,¯¯ +IG` ¨¥@U ~¥\¥83 ¨¦ 583¨Td#' ¸58 !¥252,0'T9 58 Q :58 *6 ¥;58 *0'5),0'/ ,I58 *; ¨ ¢:¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ d3¨¢3¨¥:|2² ¥2520'52 0520 =? ¨/ @¢"¦52¥c58 Á-W,¥25c58 ¨ :B#6© 2( *¥,+qG` j0'520 0 Ct'}"*0'¥2¥2,:58 ( D0 @ 52¢ :,6 ¨052;¥2520'?¦#" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ ",¥2 52¥?58 *>/¢( ;(3¨0'58 ¨458 ¨ 14¥8"¢ 5j¢^ ,/(*58 Q¥2T6¥252 »/ Q9 -¢#A;58 ,T!=?),/,' Q" 3¨,K05>58 ¢ >(3¨58 ¨ 1052Q3¨,'¢3$+ "W ¢ 52¥? @-'58 :"6/,¥2¥2¥?¦#58 4R6{XÀ<+G? #0'/,58 ¨ D#W58 ¨ : ¥8"W¢ 5? !0/2 X58 ,0D=?0¥j/,3 3¨/,52,!#$¦>03 3f¥2,'¢ IR6ÀKB¿§¢6 :±'® ¨( :²,¯1¢" ¨/,52¥>58 4,/, @" 3¨0'58 ¨ a0/,58 ¨ ¨5ET!#q58 *e0 0" 58 ¨ 7 -W¢ */2 :02 ¥I0 y#$D-58 p,¦ ¨ :,¥,+ G? X0'¢0'K#158 ,¥2 ;(3¨58 9$3¨,'¢3>¥2T6¥252, ¸=? ¨58 I#$,,6- 0/2 6986 ,/,52 3 *K6( 2 *X0 #g0/,58 ¨¦ *¥e=?0¥>58 ¢ I/, @"( 52,X¥2¢" 00'52¢3¨T\#$¦e,0/2 !,¦ ¨ :+ 3¨ 9$2( º" ¦0 i=? ¨58 :" *0'¥24¥8 #$52¥,+BA 158 ¨¥?^6"¢2 ¨ :¢ 5, 1.74 Program Startup Steady State 1.5 1.23 1.11 1.10 1.08 1.08 1.05 1.06 1.04 1.05 1.00 1.01 1.01 0.99 1.01 1.00 1.01 1.00 1.0 0.93 0.91 0.5 Speedup over Adaptive Multi-Level 0.0 db db jess jess jack jack mtrt mtrt javac javac volano volano compress compress mpegaudio mpegaudio opt-compiler opt-compiler Geometric Mean Geometric Mean (,!.D + ¢¡¢$ &2§"£* #¢¡ #%-)()-2 ¡ £ £ 2§"AC¢¡ £ (J £"£* £ ()-)()-(-2! Breakdown of Jalapeño Execution Time Program Startup Long Running 8.6% 6.0% 0.9% All AOS 0.3% 0.1% Threads 2.6% Garbage Collection Baseline Compiler Application Thread(s) 88.6% 92.9% Breakdown of Time in AOS Threads Program Startup Long Running 4.3% 15.9% Controller 58.3% 20.6% Method 13.5% Organizer Inlining Organizer Decay Organizer Optimizing Compiler 6.5% 12.4% 51.6% 5.8% 11.1% (!%D > ¡ +£C £# - #¢¡6*¢()$B /¢& - * ()-' § ¢(#%D2/ ¡¥&@¤£-2# *¢1 £¢£/ 100 80 Baseline 60 Baseline -> Level 0 Baseline -> Level 1 Baseline -> Level 0 -> Level 1 Baseline -> Level 2 40 Baseline -> Level 1 -> Level 2 Baseline -> Level 0 -> Level 2 % of All Methods Compiled 20 0 compress jess db javac mpegaudio mtrt jack opt-compiler volano (!%D = 7 #%- *¢ #%) £"£#%$ &(J *¢(#%- ££" (/¢(#%-2/ ¡ #% *¢12?¢£&2*¢( ¥ $?D*¢( ¡ ,£ / ©%/* $ (*¢1 ¡ £ £ 2 "£C¢¡ £ () £"£* £ ()- ¡ )()-()-2! £ D ¢()-2! *¢12 /*£ £ © ¡ /* * £!%()$B 50 Level 2 Level 1 Level 0 40 30 20 Number of Methods Recompiled 10 0 compress jess db javac mpegaudio mtrt jack (!%D B ¢¡ £"£#%$ &(J *¢(#%-B "£*¢( <(,* © 1() ¢D--(J-2! *¢12 / £ ¥ - 346587H9¢ <$'=¥>?@ -2"A1$B¥ ¢C¥/ (J-'*¢12 /$B¢¡§¦ ¨ 5 "£1 -2"£1$?¥ ¢C (/ ¢D- #%-2"£?D2/+(J-2! *¢12B/+( §£' (J-&D2* / 12¥¤ ¡ ¦¤<(/ + & £/ -%*/ *+(J$??&2¥ *¢(*¢(#%-2 £ ()- * # ¨¤% £¡ /¢(¨§£ £ § ()-%* §/ 0/2 [¦#:58 J¥2¢ lRUÀ KB¿§6 :±®K-¢ /2 * :0¦2 ¥J=B0¥\2( /, ¥2T6¥252, " ¦,¥2¥2,¥,;=?D=? 3 3@ :¦! /¢,0¥8 3gTp52=B0y0¦ *0¦9 =? ¨58 L¥8 ¨F¹²¯¯! "( 5Q L0D¥8 *¦3¨ {K+G? ¨¥Q6 ~¢¥Q#g ¸58 3¨T658 ¨/K ,/¢ ¨¥8 ¨¦ *¥!- 0¥2,Y¦ Y©¥25:" 2 */ "3¨,¥,@0¦ *Y¢^ / ¨¥2J0¦3 3@0 M6z " , ¨¦(*¥>"¢2#$¦ :0 /,4,¥8( 3¨52¥,*=? ¨/ X2( D,0/2 !- */2 * 102 C 6/`" 00' :,52¢¥j# i58 ` ¨ @"3¨, 1¢ 52058 ¨¦ c+ ,'¢3¨" :0 D¢#9 · 0@#,¥8 {K+*G? )^69E0^6 ¨¥;¦#<58 b© ( 4¢" ,¥2¢ 52¥458 ¨ 1#' #$,/58 ¨C :6 ¢3? ¨¥:0X :0¦ Z0,0!#$¦;#( 58(C=?¦2 <,¥8",/ ¨03 3¨Td M6z ¥2T6¥252 µ-65?52;" 0' ¢^6 ¨5," 058 ¨58 ¨¦ *! 52!²,¯'¯Q©^ U9E¥8 ¨F, 58 4",¥2 */,@#< 3 X0 ! ;(3¨58 ¨58 ,0'U + 520¦3¨¥,+?G? ^69E0^6 ¨¥ ¨¥< :0¦2 6,1524¥8 =Z0" ",^6 ¨ :0'52¢3¨TC=? *¢ 0/2 J- */2 * 102 I-, ¥@0 J¢ ¥4 ¨52¥;¢^ ,/¢( 58 ¨ f+:G? QT9E0^6 ¨¥ 4#$,¢358 05 0¦¦0Q¥2,D0¥>0 D¢~/,58 ¨@0 \" 6U( /,58 ¨'b3¨0¦ 9 ] M ¦ ¨,¥D58 *! 6( ;-¢D#;,/ Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ *¥I58 *0'5C6/,/¢( 2,d p,0'/ ( 0')#$¦ ¨ @"3¨, 1¢ 58 *C58 >¥2T6¥252, !+ 0¦0 ¦ ¥j¥20#A,58T;"¦"¢58 ¨,¥ M 520¦3$+ K0'/ p-*0¦! ¨¥X¥8( -6 ¨ ¨,i52L¥8 =V58 *J 6( ;-¢X¦# 0 I :, :¦TX :0 0', :¢ 5@,0¥2K-( ¦ *I58 ¦(*¦ *¦(*5@ ¢9 /, Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ ¥;05>,0'/ I¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ K3¨,3$+ 3¨" :¢ 5,+ ;¢^6" 3¨ ¨52 0¦0158 ,0'¥;0¦ *X¥2T /2 ¦ ¨F,0'58 ¨ ] M "W¢058 ¨¦ *¥D52¹- ( 3¨Y58 !0'¥2T */2 ( ¥X¥2T6¥252, /,' Q"¦ *¢ 52¥,+ Oe¥Q^6",/,52,?=? ¢ Z,0/2 L *=»-¢ /2 * :0¦2 L-, ¥: ¨52¥:¢^ ,/(9 4¦=?¢¦j0/,D/, U ¨58 ¨¦ *¥C, :0¦ pU C/(3¨5,>0¦ *Z¥2( *Z/, 9 58 ¨¦ c58 @¥2,54¦#< *'54 :,58 6 ¥4/2 *0¦ *',¥;U0' :058 ¨/03 3¨T<'¢ ¢0589 /¢( 2¢ 54¥2T6¥252 ,¥8 ¨¦ X ¨¥4 ¨520¦3$+ I0! *,=i¥2,5@#B,/, @" 3¨0'58 ¨ p/,0¦ *6 ¨0'52,¥,+IG? ¨¥Q¥8(3¨52¥; 58 Q /¢,0'¥2º a58 b 6( b-W¢:¦#3¨¢3B¯:,/, @" 3¨0'58 ¨ ¥\0'5458 R6 :J" , ¨¦(*¥I¥2T6¥252, :¥K|$+ +;s t®¦v$}: *0¦'J¢3 ¨,[¦ Y3 ¨ Q ¨52, -W, K¦#40/2 J- */2 * 102 %¦ ¥:¢^ ,/¢( 58 ¨ f+DO4¥;¢^ ,/(*58 ¨¦ y¦# - (*5C#$0¥25C/,' Q" 3¨I¥258(- ¥!52J"W¢2#$ H2( 58 ¨ :J¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ <+ 0/2 Q" *0'¥2>/, 58 6( ,¥, :0 T@ :,58 6 ¥<58 *0'5c, :0 1 *'5¦06(9 A Z/,¦ 580¥25,>=?D/ ¥2X0I6 ~¢¢ 5D,¥8 ¨¦ Y" 5D=? ¨58 Y0X#(3 3$ 0'52;52b ¨ ¢ " 58 ¨ Q ¨F,058 ¨¦ K3¨,'¢3¨¥,+?O> *'58 *¢> 52¢¥258 *D58¢ * *¢0¦3j" 58 ¨ Q ¨F¢ J/ Q" 3¨¢@58 054/0 X,/,' Q" 3¨:0 TC"*0¦54# ¨¥j58 05c3¨052" *0'¥2,¥< ¨58 ¨0'524 :¦`/, Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ X0'/,58 ¨ ¨58T:58 0 58 Q0¦"" 3 ¨/,058 ¨¦ Z/,6'*3 -0¦2 ¨,¥,< 58 * { ¨52¥2¢3 #2+ 3¨C( z ] 023 ¨¢>" *0'¥2,¥,+jG)=B4#$0/,52¦¥/0( ¥2458 ¨¥` /¢,0'¥2) C,/,' Q" 3¨09 0" " 0/2 X"'52¢ 58 ¨03 3¨T! 5866(*/,¥4 :¦42( 58 ¨ 1;'¢2 ,0=? 58 ¨¦ D0/,58 ¨ ¨5ET+ ¥25, §¦§ 0¦ * § *0¦'`3¨0¦¢B=?¦2 6 *@¥2,52¥ 0'C, 1 ¥258052,K52/ ¨h( ,¥:58 0543 ¨ @ ¨5:58 *1'¢2 ,0K0¦ * 7 ¦ ¦¨ ¦#> *'5Q :58 *6 ¥:58 0 Z §¨§¤£ ¦ © © © ©c0¦ * ¥+XR6,/,¦ * 0/2 ¨,:'66!"¢2#$¦ :0 /,Q I0:#( 3 3 9$-3¨¦=? 0¦¦0 58( 03j{X0¦9 M z ¦ 0'¥4¢^6" 3¨0 ,J aR6,/,58 ¨¦ K° + ³ *58 ;/, 58¦3 3¨¢@0¥2¥8( :,¥;58 05>58 /2 + " ¦0 H=? 3 3e¢^ ,/¢( 52!#$¦:5E=` ¨/!0¥@3¨ K0¥Q ¨5@ *0'¥\/(2¢ 583¨T 03 3¨Tf=?) 52;0¦ X¦¥8 ¨ Q"3 ©W/,058 g K k58 *;0¦ *0¦3¨T658 ¨/: :6 ¢3 2( f+>G` ¢¢#A J3¨0'52¢;¥2520',¥e#j58 ¨¥)2( I58 *@/, 58¦3 3¨¢@¥2¢9 7 #`R6,/,58 ¨ °+ ³+eG` ¨¥; :6 ¢3B0¥2¥8( :,¥:²,¯'¯£¡ ¿?À ( 58 3 ¨F,058 ¨¦ < 3¨/,52¥: :,58 6 ¥Q#$;/, Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ p :D0',¥2¥8 ¨'¢3¨TK-,/,0¦(*¥2 ¶ 0 X ,/¢ ¨ ,¥;=? *,58 ¢e52:0¦3 3¨6/,052C¿?À /,T6/¢3¨¥;52:58 *;0¦"" 3 ¨/,0¦9 ¨5D¢^6",/52¥\52a¢ ¦§TZ0J3¨ !"¢2 ¨6p#@58 ¨ 1X52J,/,¦! ¨52¥ ¶ 58 ¨ Z¦:52X58 C/, Q" 3¨¢¦+a4¦=?,'¢¦c L ¥8 ¨ 5,>=?:,0¦3 ¨F, / Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ L/,¥252¥,+ 58 05j58 ¨¥?0'¥2¥8(* @"*58 ¨¦ ! ¨¥< *'5¦03 ¨C#$j58 >¥8(- ¥2,5?¦#( >¢^6"W¢29 ¨ :¢ 52¥@58 054( ¥2:¥8 *¦3¨¢9E58 0 ,y/,6 ,¥@ a0! ;(3¨58 " 6/,,¥2¥2¦¦+ 7. DISCUSSION G<!/2,/,5158 ¨¥,j=?Q" 3¨0 Z52X¢ 0 /,!58 C0 03¨T658 ¨/X :6 ¢3>52 J 0¦J" ,¥2¢ 52,58 *I¥8 ¨ 0 ¨ @"3¨, 1¢ 52058 ¨¦ #10 ] ,6(*/?58 *B¢^6",/,52:/,¥25<¦#*/ Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ ! #58 ?¥2T6¥252, [ ,52,/52¥ ^ 52¢ *¥8 - 3¨:0¦ *: ¨ 9"W¢2#$ 10 /,Q0'0¦"*58 ¨'Q¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ K¥2T6¥89 ¨63¨\" 6/,,¥2¥2¥,+ C! 5@¢^6",/5:58 *C/,'¥25Q¦#>/,' Q" 3¨0'58 ¨ ] 52 !+ @ *¦=["¥2¢ 5Q¥2' ::¥8( -m§¢,/,58 ¨'!- ¥2¢¦058 ¨¦ *¥C¦ K58 ] 52!-DF,¢j6(*D52X :, :¦TJ¥2T6¥252 /,¦ 52¢ 58 ¨ f?-( 5@/¢3¨,023¨T ¥2T6¥252 !+ 58 Q/,' Q" 3¨¢@/,0 D(*¥2; ¨63¨:/,T6/¢3¨,¥e :@0',¥2¥8 ¨'¢3¨TI58 *0¦ I( /¢( 2¢ 5j¥2T6¥252, !+ ?¢^6"/,558 ¨¥j/ 0 >=? 3 3* ¨ Q" ¦>( "W¢29 ] G? :¥2T6¥252,  ;(*¥25@ :0 0'C0!¥8( -*¥2520¦ 58 ¨03e¦3 (* :D#> 0520X#9 #$¦ :0 /,)#AB¥2/,¢ 02 ¨¥B=` ¨58 C ¨63¨;/,T6/¢3¨,¥, 0'¥58 4/,¦ 583 3¨¢e=? 3 3 © /¢ ¨¢ 583¨T'+ J-¢3 ¨,'L58 *0'5!( I6 ¨¥2582 -( 52,:0¥2T /2 ¦ *¦(*¥, ] -;¥8 ¨¦ © /,0 583gTI :e0¦,¥2¥8 ¨@ I¥2/ ,6(3 !/,' Q" 3¨058 ¨ q+ ¦-m§¢,/,589E2 ¨ 52,: ,¥8 ¨ 1¥2¢¥c58 ¨¥c"( 2"¥2j @58=??=B0T6¥,+ ¥25, 7 0'¥4 0520C"*0'¥2¥2,¥;58 ¦(*¦ K58 ;" "3 *C# 0¦=[0'520C52\/ Q9 " 3¨058 ¨¦ p/¢ ¨¥8 ¨ ¥,40/2 y¥8( /,/,¥2¥8 ¨!" "¢3 ¹" *0'¥2!"¢2#$¦ :¥ 8. RELATED WORK /¢,0'¥8 *¦3TZ¥2" ¨¥258 ¨/052,Y0¦ *0¦3¨T6¥8 ¨¥! 0J ,/¢,0'¥8 *a3 ( : À<, ¨( ¥!0'0¦"*58 ¨'J 58( 03@ :0'/ ,¥\ 0¦!( ¥2,y :58 *6y 9 ¦#f0'520+jG? 6(*¥, 58 ) ,¥8 ¨¦ ! ¢3 "*¥>¥2582( /,58( 40@¥2T6¥252, µ58 05<"¢29 6/058 ¨ Z/,¦( 52¥:52\ ¨ ¢ 58 #$TK0¦ *a" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,X 3 \" 0' #A :¥e¥2" ¨¥258 ¨/,0'52,y0¦ *0¦3¨T6¥8 ¨¥Q=? ¨58 I,0¥2¦ *0¦-3¨TI3¨='¢2 ,0+ 5>¥8"52¥,+j 3¨F¢3¨@0 ¢@s ³6t,vc ,¥2/¢2 -WQ58 @R Kjw 9E±'³:¥2T6¥89 ¶ 7 R6,/,¦ *6- T;¥2¢" 0058 ;#( /,58 ¨¦ *0¦3 ¨58T: 52; :66(3¨,¥, 58 >,¥8 ¨¦ 52, !q0 L0'0¦"*58 ¨'!" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ p¥2T6¥252, ¸#$¦CR£Kjw +fG` C'03 7 ¥2"*0¦052,¥>/,¦ */,2 *¥e0 !03 3¨¦=>¥>0 k¢^ 52¢ ¥8 -3¨:0¦/ ¨52,/,58( 0¥ # 58 *C¥2T6¥252,  ¨¥C52X0' ¨L3¨ J"*0¦(*¥2¥º Z 52¢0/58 ¨X0" " 3 9 ¨¥e/, 1 : D I=?¢3 3 9E¥8 ¨ ,K-m§¢/,589E2 ¨¢ 52,I¥2T6¥252, :¥,+ /,0'58 ¨ ¥)- T:¦"*58 ¨ Q ¨F *D 3¨T!58 )"¢2#A :0¦ */,98/2 ¨58 ¨/,03j"*0¦52¥?# 58 Q0¦"" 3 ¨/,058 ¨¦ c+ {X,58 *6! '6/,058 ¨¦ L/,¦( 52¢¥e=? ¨58 I0 I¢^6"¦9 G? Q¥20' Q" 3 *¦9- 0¥2y 3 º" © 3 J0¦3¨¥2\ ¢3 "*¥@/,¦ 583<2( 9 ¢ 58 ¨03q,/0T1 :,/2 *0¦ ¨¥2 0>(*¥2,C52; ¨ 58 #$TC/,0 U ¨ 052¥)#$¦ 58 ¨ 1d¦'¢2 *0i#C58 L0 0" 58 ¨Z" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,058 ¨¦ ¥2T6¥252, !+ ?T " 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ f+L K0'6 ¨58 ¨ f>R6¢3 #9E±³X( ¥2,J"¦3¨T6 :2" ¨/X 3 * /2 0 X¥20 Q" 3 *C#,h( ¢ /¢ ¨,¥; T *0' Q ¨/,03 3gT<58 ;¥2T6¥252, /,0 /,0'/ ,¥Q|$ÀB8¿?¥}?52C0'58 *¢ /, 52^ 5898¥2 *¥8 ¨58 ¨'º/,¢ ¨@/¢3¨0¥2¥eU ¨¥89 0'0¦"*58 ¨'¢3¨TL58 '52583¨Q ¨52¥;¦=? K¦2 *,0'+1G? ¨¥;-¢ 0¦ ¨1=?( 3¨ 582 - (*58 ¨¦ *¥:52C¦( ¨ C/¢3¨0¥2¥4" ,6 ¨/,58 ¨ L0¦ *X 3 ¨ * +DA aR£Kw 9 7 3 m¢3¨TK-: :¦:6 C/¢( 3¨5:=? ¨58 L/, @" 3¨¢29$ ¥2¢52,L 582(*¥8 ¨'! 9 ±³ " 58 ¨ Q ¨F,,L :58 *6 ¥;C *'54/,¦ 520 K '6/,058 ¨¦ Z/,( 52¢¥,+ ¥2582( :¢ 520'58 ¨ f+¸e=B,¢¦> p#(*58( I=?2 ;=BJ=? 3 3;3¨,5X58 G? *¢#$'?03¨58 ( R£Kjw 9E±³I/,( 3¨d" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,I0 Y0¦3 ,0 T 7 / 583 3¨X *¥2¢5C :¦X¢^6"¢ ¥8 ¨I 582(*¥8 ¨'¹ ¥2582(* 1¢ 52058 ¨¦ " 58 ¨ Q ¨F,K :,58 6¢¡; ¨52¥4/( 52¢29$-*0'¥2,¹" © 3 J :/ 0 ¨¥2 #A43 ¨ @ ¨52,J"¢2 ¨6 ¥@#j58 ¨ : I ¢@52C/,¦3 3¨,/,5; :¦b" ,/¢ ¨¥2 =?¦(3¨!-43¨¥2¥)~,/,58 ¨'Q#$B ¨¢ 58 #AT *! 5?,¦ ¨ ¥4#j0¦3 ,0 T #$¦ :058 ¨¦ c+ " 58 ¨ Q ¨F,J/,6 58 6( ¥4 :0¦ 6 *: ¨5e :;6 C/¢( 3¨5;52Q ¨ Q" 3¨, :¢ 5 ¡,¾>,/ Q" 3¨058 ¨ L¦#?0¦ I" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,,I :,58 6I/,( 3¨¹-WQ582 ¨'¢, {X0¦ TL58 ¨ :,¥,>=?C#$0/, ¨ @"3¨, 1¢ 52058 ¨¦ i/¢ ¨¥8 ¨ ¥\,'06 * =? * ¨5y/,0¦3 3¨¥Y0 µ( " 58 ¨ Q ¨F,, :,58 6 =? *'¥2 '6/,058 ¨¦ =? ,58 ¢:52X 10 6C/,¦ 583 3¨¢D ,/¢ ¨¥8 ¨¦ *¥:- 0¥2,L 0 L0¦ *0¦3¨T658 ¨/ /,¦( 52¢`¢^ /,,, ¥?58 458 ,¥8 3¨!¦ D58 *e/,03 3$+j4¦=?¢¦658 ¨¥>¥8 ¨589 16¢3f¦#c" 0' µ-¢ 0¦ ¨¦`=` ,58 ¢e52b 5866( /,;069$ *6/ ( 058 ¨ I=B( 3¨X58T" ¨/,03 3¨TX0¦2 ¨¥2Q¦ 3¨TD0#$52¢`0 X0¦"" 3 ¨/,0'58 ¨ K" *0'¥2 58( *Q" 00' :,52¢¥j52;( ¨ ;,/ ¨¥8 ¨ ¥,+>A ¦0¦2 ¨0- 3¨T58( Q58 ¥8 #$5,?¥8 /,X #;58 !/,0¦3 3;, C-,58=B,¢ Y58 !5E=?X :,58 6 ¥º 0 " 00' :,52¢¥>"¦',X :;6 C/¢( 3¨5;58 0 I¢^6"/,52,*6(*@52Q( 9 -, y 5:=? ¢ Z58 *D/,03 3¨¢k=?0¥1" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,,>58 *X/03 3¨,X=?¦(3¨ 0'Q ¨58 *¢>-¢ X 3 ,J 52C58 ;/,03 3¨@e" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,,X ¨52¥2¢3 #2+ #A¥2,¢ I6 ~¢ */,¥b a0" "3 ¨/058 ¨ L- *0¦ ¨¦+ O4¥>=?2 k I58 0¦ Z¢~,/,58 ¨'X b( 3¨58 9$3¨,3;" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ p¥2580'52,T+ A L/ 580¥25, 520',54¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ *¥¦<0 I58 *@¥2¢3¨,/,58 ¨¦ L#j-¢ /2 * :0¦2 ¥,+ ¦ 7 ¦(e¥20' Q"3 !52/ ¨h( @03 3¨¦=>¥4" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,f0¥>=?¢3 3f0'¥`( " 58 9 ¢^ 0' Q"3¨' ¨¥2583¨¢¢¦ ¥Q=?¦2 I6¥4 *'5; :,0¥8( C58 *1U ~¢ */º @ ¨F,, :,58 6¥e52Q-;¥20 @"3¨,X/ 58 6( ( ¥83¨TK0 \#$0¦ 23¨T+ 0;"'0 ¦ ¥-W¢ *0¦ ¨¦)-W,58=?¢ C ¨52¥?¥252058( "X0¦ *C¥252,0'T:¥2520'52,¥,+ G? e5R"5 { s ³°¦v 0 Q58 ?$?{ 0¦¦0 ( ¥2589$ 9EG? ¨ :?/ Q9 03¨T\s °u¦v ¨ Q" 3¨, :¢ 52:¥20 Q" 3¨¢9$- 0¥2,:/03 3 9E/, 52^ 5898¥2 *¥8 g58 ' M6z M M ] " 3¨¢C|$'¢¥8 ¨ a³+ ¯6};s °'³v<0¦Q0'0¦"*58 ¨':¥2T6¥252, :¥>#$ 0¦0 +>?58 " © 3 *L Y0J" 6U( /,58 ¨¦ $Gµ/,' Q" 3¨¦+[4D : ¥258052, M M ¥2T6¥252 :¥4 ¨58 ¨0¦3 3TI 52¢2"5;0 a0" "3 ¨/,0'58 ¨ S0 !3¨052¢@/,' Q" 3¨ 58 05C58 *D¦¢2 ,0Y¦#;58 ¨¥!¥20' Q"3¨9- 0¥2Y0" "'0/2 p=?0¥:3¨¦= "W¢2#$ 10 /,¢9E/¢2 ¨58 ¨/,0¦3?/,6 +jG? *@$?{ Gy( ¥2,¥4 1,58 *6C ¦9 ¢ ( p52J2( Y/ 58 6( ( ¥83¨T;0 Y58 05C58 ¨¥C¥20' Q"3 y52/ 9 M /058 ¨ a/,¦( 52¢¥e0( : 52,X52:0//, : 160'52Q3¨6" ¥) I :58 9 ¨h(*! ¨¥@¥2520- 3¨!¦:¢",0'52,K2( ¥@#e58 *C¥20' :\- */2 * 102 6 ¥>52Q582 ¨'¢ /, @" 3¨0'58 ¨ f+ ,520 3¨¥e#<58 ;4'5Rm"W5?/,' Q" 3¨09 =? ¨58 I58 *;¥20' :;¥2,5>#< " (*52¥,+>e=B,¢¦6 C" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,058 ¨¦ *¥@0 · 58 ¨¦ I¥2T6¥252, 0; 5?"¦ ¨ ,+ 62 ¨¢ D- TQ58 >¥20 Q" 3¨,! 0520;0¦ *: >6,¥j *'5,658 *¢#$'6,¦03 9 ( 052;58 Q¥20' Q"3 !52/ ¨h( ¦ ¥)( ¥2¢#( 3 *¥2¥,+ B03¨0C,5?0¦3$+cs ±vf¥2/¢2 - T 0 : 0Q580¦ *¥8" 0¢ 5eT 0 @ ¨/Q¦"9 · 58 ¨ @ ¨F,¢@58 05)"W¢2#$ 1¥4" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ ¥Q0'5)2( 58 ¨ ::¦ X0: *0'58 ¨ O) 58 ¢k0,0L#@,¥2,0¦/ p/ ¥8 ¨¢¥X2( 58 ¨ :K" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ ¥ - 0T+ T 0 1 ¨58 ¨03 3¨TY 52¢2" ,52¥!58 \" ¦0 !> 6¢" 58 05X¢^6" 3¨ ¨5X ¦02 ¨0 5X2( 58 ¨ :L0¦3 (*¥,+ B,/,0( ¥2L¥8(*/2 0¦3 9 · /( 52¢¥?52) ¨ ¢ 58 #$T1¥2,/,58 ¨ ¥?¦#/,6 )/03 3¨,C *'5 +G? ,¥2 ( ,¥:0C *'5:¥252058 ¨/03 3¨Ty ,52¢ @ *0¦-3¨>58 ,¥2D¥2T6¥252, :¥Q" ¦ ¨ 2¢6,¦ ¥2/,58 ¨ ¥;0;58 ¢ X¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,,I0 X=`2 ¨5252 X0¥>0¦ I¢^ ,/¢( 520- 3¨+ " 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ Z" "¦58( ¨58 ¨,¥Q 5e0¦0¦ 3¨0- 3¨\=? ¨58 a¥252058 ¨/@/, @" 9 3¨058 ¨¦ c+ RU' :!¥2T6¥252 :¥b /¢3 ( s ® jt´6?t¦®vE s ³®¦v ¨4¥ ,£>¨ P458 ¢j T *0' Q ¨/>" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ C,¥2,0¦/ @ *0¦'(*¥2Q *¦ 9E¥20' Q"3¨9 |- 0¥2,L d¿)}¢ 0- (*¥!s ³6´,v;|- 0¥2,K¦ L{Xw<}¢f0 Z¿? ¥2¢3?0¦ * 7 - 0¥2y"¦©3 y52,/2 ¨h( ,¥!52I ¨¢ 58 #ATy0 Y" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,I 3 463)¦ ¥e=?2 Is¨²,±vq=? ¨/2 I520 m,¥40Q" 058 ¨0¦3j,¦03 ( 058 ¨¦ L0" "'0/2 c+ " ¦0 5X¥8"'52¥,+¸( ¢I0¦ * T- ¨[s¨²¦tU1²,³v1¢^6" 3¨ G? * ¥2T6¥252, s ³±¦v>"¦ ¨ ,¥!0K 1,/ 0 ¨¥2 _52K¥8",/¢ #ATd0¦ * · $ " © 3¨¢9E62 ¨¢ kT 0 Q ¨/?,/ Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ \ \RU/2 * :'=` ¨58 10 @ ¨ Q9 /,' Q"¥2D02- ¨580TL¢^6" ,¥2¥8 ¨ ¥!0¦ *L¥2520'52, :¢ 52¥:0'5b2( 58 ¨ :+ " 3¨, : 52058 ¨ #B0Q-*0'¥8 ¨/Q- 3¨6/ X,¦2 *X¦"*58 ¨ Q ¨F058 ¨ f+ 9 G? *e :0 kU ¨¥20'¦0¦ 5201#f58 *¥2;52,/ ¨h(*,¥> ¨¥>58 *0'5?58 *TQ¢3¨T ¶ #A58( *0'52¢3¨T 58 *>¦2 *,0':#$<- 0¥8 ¨/>-3¨6/2 C, ?" © 3 * ,¢ X" ¦0 : 1¢;6 ,/,58 ¨',¥Q52@ ¨¢ 58 #ATX58 *;, ¨¦ *¥;¦#j/,6 Q52 0¦#$52¢q0" "3¨T b- 0¥8 ¨/j-3¨6/2 Q ¢2 * ¨¥jt´ ¡ ¦#*58 j¢^ ,/¢( 58 ¨ -;¦"*58 ¨ Q ¨F,+ 58 ¨ 1+ ( 58 ¢ :'?58 ,TJ,h( !"'0' : :¢C 52¢'¢ 58 ¨ 7 P458 ¢j=?2 Cs¨²¦´66t¦±v6 0¥<¢^6" 3¨\ `" © 3¨¢9E6 ,/,52,C/,' Q9 52a,52 Q *I *¦= 52K58 '52583¨¹" © 3 Y52J,6(*/,X ¨52¥C¦¢29 " 3¨058 ¨ p¥2/2 , :,¥@58 *0'5b( ¥2C C1 ::" © 3¨,¥:# " , 9 ,0'+`A D/, 580'¥25,*¦(e¥20 @"3 !52,/2 ¨h( ¦ ¥4¦¢2 ,0'! ¨¥`3¨¦= ( ¥:2( ¥C# 0 Z0" "3 ¨/058 ¨ 0¥:#$,,6- 0/2 d 52a0J/,' Q" 3¨¢X52 *¦(*¦ i|ERU,/58 ¨ Yum}Q58 05C¥20 Q" 3 d/0 y-W!/,¦ 58 6(*¦(*¥,;0¦ * :0¦ 6?-,5252¢`" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,058 ¨¦ I/¢ ¨¥8 ¨ ¥?#$j#( 58(>¢^ ,/(*58 ¨¦ *¥,+`A ¦( 0/2 ¨52/,58(:#$¦e0 0" 58 ¨C" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ L 6,¥4 5)h( 0 6 ¨58 ¨ f458 ¢!0¦\#( 3 3¨TL0( 52 :0'52,d" © 3 y¥2T6¥252, :¥158 *0'5 0¦ T\" ¦0 : :4 52¢'¢ 58 ¨ f+ ( ¥2X580 ¥8"*0¦¢ 5!3¨¦= ¦2 *,0'y"¦©3 Y52J ¨ Q" ¦X"¢2#$¦29 e0 ¥2¢ Ys ³¯¦vj,¥2/2 -,¥@0 a0 0" 58 ¨ P4¾ 7 · 10 6¥c0( 52 1058 ¨/?¦"*58 ¨ Q ¨F058 ¨ D ,/¢ ¨¥8 ¨¦ *¥,+ ¢ :0j-*0'¥8 ¨/-3¨6/2 I¢¡ ³6tCs ³'³vE s °®¦v8 0 s °¦v8+BA k/, 580'¥25,58 ¨¥>"*0¦9 ] 7 X$¨O ¨:cj /( 52¢Q0/2 *,¥;0D58 ¥8 *¦3¨j58 Q-*0'¥8 ¨/:-3¨6/2 J ¨¥4" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,, "¢<#A6/¢(*¥2¥¦ Q( ¥8 *;" © 3 *Q #$¦ :058 ¨¦ !¦#0 10" " 3 ¨/,058 ¨¦ ¦ ¥ 0¦ *a :¦,K52D58 *@ *¢^ 5 =? *¢1 ::0'9 ¢^ ,/(*58 ¨¦ y52! ¢3 "Z" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,D58 *0'5Q¥20' :C¢^ ,/¢( 58 ¨ S#>58 C0" 9 ¢¨f£@©¨¢6$D¦,$¢6$ ¦,¥2¥8 ¨@" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ ¥@04"W¢2#$ 1,+ " 3 ¨/,058 ¨¦ c+ e,¢58 ¢3¨,¥2¥, ( >0/2 ¨52,/,58( ;/,0 C->¢^ 52¢ ,!52 0 U3¨X *C"¦©3¨986 ,/,52Y/, Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ p¥2/ , :¥¤Á#A1¢^69 À<2 *0¦"*¥:58 C=?2 I58 05; ¨¥@ :¥25@¥8 ¨ Q 3¨0D52D( :=?¦2 J ¨¥@58 05 0 @"3¨q58 *:/ 583 3¨:/,¦(3¨I(*¥2:/ Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ y" 3¨0 ¥Q0¦ *X"¦9 ¦# ¨¥2583¨¢Is ³m¼vE+ ¨¥2583¨¢:" ,¥2¢ 52¥:0I/,¦ 58 6(*¦(*¥:" 0' ¦"9 © 3 *D0'520º#g »" , ¨¦(*¥;¢^ /¢(*58 ¨¦ *¥;¦#j0 k0" "3 ¨/,0'58 ¨ <+ 58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ p0/2 ¨52,/58(C#$ºP)-¢¦ y58 05@03 3¨¦=>¥ L( "9E52¦9858 ¢9 @ 6(*52MX" © 3 *X #A :0'58 ¨ Y52C-Q( ¥2,J K" ¦0 ¸,¦"9 G? *:0:0¦3¨¥2! *¦ *0'0¦"*58 ¨'!¥2T6¥252, 1¥;58 *0'54"¢2#$¦ ¸/, @" 3¨0¦9 58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ c+ ¨¥2583¨¢1/, /¢3 ( ,¥@58 05;/,¦ 58 6(*¦(*¥:¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ 58 ¨ .¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 g I0'5c2( 58 ¨ :e5240¦¦ ¨C58 *>/,'¥25¦#* 52¢2" ,5209 /0 K" 6U( /,C-,5252¢@/,6 C58 *0¦ L/,0¦ K-C0/2 ¨,L=? ¨58 L * 58 ¨ f+?G? ¨¥? */¢3 ( ,¥;,023¨TC=?¦2 D¥8(*/2 X0'¥)58 ;R6 :0¦3 3¨5203 69E®¯Ks t°¦v / Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ c>,0¦U3¨¥2¥!#e=? ,58 *:"¦©3 K #A :0'58 ¨ Y ¨¥ 0 aRU¢3 #g98± ²!s¨²,u¦vj¥2T6¥252, :¥,f0¥;=?¢3 3j 10 TX#`5260¦T¥¦ ¥ G 0¦0 M M ( ¥2,! k58 *43¨0'5252¢¦+?G? ¢;0;¥2' :4 52¢,¥258 !6 ~¢¢ /,,¥> /,' Q" 3¨¥:s.²'³'u °6´vE+ 58 >¦¢0¦3 30/2 ¨52/,58(0¦3f,¥8 ¨¦ D#* ¨¥?0 :¦(B¥2T6¥252, :¥,+j¿?¦ 9 ¥8 ¨ ¢¦j#$1¢^ 0 @"3¨>58 : 52¢0/58 ¨ ¥\-,5E=?,¢ Z58 C/, 58¦3 3¨¢ À<, ¨( ¥>¥258(*6 ¨,¥ 0¦40¦3 (*0'52,!58 > ¨0- 3 ¨58TD#f¥2¢3¨,/,58 ¨';" 9 |$ 10 0}40 !2( 58 ¨ :1 :,0¥8( , : 52¥:|"¦©3¨¢}¢+ A X ¨¥4 ¢9 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ f+ÂO)2 3¨p,5X03$+@s uv4( ¥2,[58 03¨0"WUN * { 52 M M6z ¥8 ¨¦ cm58 ¨¥< 52¢0/58 ¨ C ¨¥c-*0'¥2,:¦ :0> :,¥2¥20'?" 526/,¦3 1=? ¨/2 h( 0 58 #$T@58 *j"¢2#$¦ :0 /,"'52¢ 58 ¨03W# ¥2¢3¨,/,58 ¨')¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ <+ 58 L U ¨ ¨6( 03)" © 3 K/, @" ¢ 52¥:0¦:0( 52 :¦(*¥,+ M A G? * ;,¥8(3¨52¥@/,¦ © :,K58 05;¥23¨,/,58 ¨C¦"*58 ¨ Q ¨F058 ¨ Z *0'¥;58 * ¦(e ,¥8 ¨ ff0 X¦0¦ ¨F,;58 ,0!" 6/,,¥2¥2,¥e58 *4" © 3 X0'520 "'52¢ 58 ¨03152K¥8 ¨ © /,0 583gTo¦(*58"W¢2#$ _0K©^ G ¥258052,'T M #Ae/, ¥8( Q"*58 ¨¦ K- T!58 @/, 58¦3 3¨¢¦+4Oe6 !0Q ,=[¦0 ¨F,¢ 0 @/,0 @,'¢ @0" " 0/2 C58 Á"W¢2#$ 10 /,?# ¥2520'58 ¨/?/,' Q" 3¨0'58 ¨ 58 ,0'Y03 3¨¦=>¥X03¨52¢2 058 ¨' " 6/,,¥2¥8 Y#;0¦= " © 3 Y0'520 #$¦43¨ 292( ¹-W¢ */2 :02 ¥,+H¾>0'U 0 62 ¨¥8 *0¦ Y,5>0¦3$+s °²v =? ¨58 ( 5:,h( 2 y0X ,=µ"¦©3¨¦+yO>3¨58 *¦(*¦ ¨¥2583¨¢D,¦03 ( 9 ( ¥2,K58 0~ 58( 03>{X0'/ *C52D,¥2520- 3 ¨¥8 Y58 : :0¦^6 ¨ b( z 0'52,¥j58 *>58 ¨ :>¦¢2 ,0'\¦#*"¢2 ¨66 ¨/,0¦3 3TD¥20 Q" 3 *158 *" ¦0 "¢2#A :0¦ */,X ¨ Q" ¦, : 5\"'¥2¥8 -3¨J- TK 52¢2" ,58 40'58 * /( 52¢¦* ¨54 ¨¥) 5e- ¨( ¥;=? *0'54¦"*58 ¨ Q ¨F058 ¨ ¥:0¦Q62 ¨¢ I- T 58 0 a/, Q" 3 j/,3¨a :,58 6¥4#$¦;58 CR6ÀKB¿§¢6 :±®D=? ¨58 J 9 58 ¨¥C¥20 Q" 3 y52,/2 ¨h( >0 y58 ¢¢#$¦! *D6¥º 51,¦03 ( 9 " (*5>¥8 ¨F,C²+ 0'52C58 *C52,/2 ¨h( ¦ ¥@(*¥2¢#g(3 ,¥2¥,+aA L/ 580¥25,q=?C0:0¦-3¨D52 , :¦ *¥2580'52458 ?¢~/,5¦ :"¢2#A :0¦ */,>¦#" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ ¥>58 05 R6¢20 L,5:03$+es °mtv ,¥2/2 -J0¤£ / Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ i0" 9 §*¢¦E¦,$¢6$ 0¦;U2 ¨'¢ I- T\¦(e¥20' Q"3¨9- 0¥2¹" © 3 * + 03 3¨T' ¨5? ¨¥) 0 " 0/2 L(*¥8 03¨0"WUN *I58 05@05252, Q" 52¥@52X0' ¨L58 :/,¥252¥@# 7 M 521/, Q" 0;58 4,¥8( 3¨52¥4¦#j58 *;5E=?Q¥2T6¥252 :¥>U( Q52@58 ;U ~29 T *0' Q ¨/:/,' Q" 3¨0'58 ¨ f+ ¥8 C58 * @0" "'0/2 c0¦ I0" "3 ¨/,0'58 ¨ ¶ */,> C3¨0 ( 0¥,58 *> :0'58(2 ¨5ET\¦#f58 *>¥2T6¥252, :¥, 58 46 ~¢¢ 5 ¨¥:"98^ ,/¢( 52,y0¦ *Z58 *X/,' Q" 3¨,y ¨ :0',¥!0¦!=?2 ¨5252¢ S52J0 © 3¨:-¢#$¦:58 { 52¢ Q 052,¥,+ *¢ 0!/,' Q" 3¨K :,58 6 ] M6z 10. REFERENCES ¨¥; ,, ,LU( 2 *I¥8( -*¥2,h( ¢ 5C¢^ ,/(*58 ¨¦ *¥:¦#>58 \0¦"" 3 ¨/,0'58 ¨ < s¨²¢v OQ+ 9E¾b+ OeU3 9EG<0- 0520¦-*0¦ $c{K+W¿ ¨¢2 ¨0¦ f¿4+ 9 + w(*¢ f + {K+ z 58 4 T 0 Q ¨/@/, @" 3¨¢e ¨¥? *'5?0( 52 :0'58 ¨/,03 3¨T! ' m,X0¥ ¨¥>58 À<02 6 f0 + {K+R658 ¨/ *'58 c+ 0'¥25,~,/,58 ¨'Q/,6 M 7 /0¥2Q a( ;0'0¦"*58 ¨'\¥2T6¥252 !+;G? *@¥2T6¥252, ¸/2 ,/ ¥e52!¥2,; #B0 ¢ ¢0'58 ¨ I I0 (*¥2589$ 9EG` ¨ 1 0¦¦0:/,' Q" 3¨¦+< M M " ,/,' Q" 3¨,¹ ¨ 10;¦#<58 4 :58 *6D¢^6 ¨¥252¥,+>#c0¦ C ¨ :0'Q¢^6 ¨¥252¥, r¦¢¢ g ¡¦>2;©O*4:cÂ*¦?j;X« ¡£¢D<¦,,rW¢e 58 :¥2T6¥252, ¢3¨6/,052¥Q0¦ *X3 ¥158 *:/6Q 52D58 *@ *,= { M6z r¡mr¢£Q£@ ¡:¢ ¡§ ¢¦¡6 ¨;,¦¨¡X¢ :2£>¨©¨,£:,$¢6$ 6" 0',¥;t¦®¯¥¤Ut±'¯{X 5803$f¿?0 0 0 :¢ 5,+>#* 4 ¨ :0'4¢^6 ¨¥252¥, 58 ) T 0 Q ¨/e/, Q" 3¨¢>/ Q9 ªrj ¨e$ ²¦´¦¤*²,± ( *C²,±'±® + ³'³|E¼'}¢*{X0¦TX²,±±'®+ " 3¨,¥;58 ; :,58 6+ M *¦?j;o 6AA¢,¦ s tv 4+ O)3 "2 cW¿ +m¾b+ O>52520 0¥8 ¨ + +m?052¦ c {K+ + (2 m £ M M À<+¿ * * + 9 + ¿B $ OQ+W¿`6// $R*+ + + ¦' £ · M 7 · 9. CONCLUSIONS M X *0¦X ,¥2/¢2 -W,[58 X,¥8 ¨¦ [0¦ *y ¨ @"3¨, 1¢ 52058 ¨¦ i#@58 ] {K+*> *fRW+ + )( : :¢3$ +*w ¨¢-¢¦ + w ¨52 *f{K+ + 7 · z 7 0¦3¨0"6N *DO4 0" 58 ¨1P)"*58 ¨ Q ¨F058 ¨ dRUT6¥252, D0:¢ ¢0¦3<0 X¢^69 M {X¢ cG;+ 4' + ¾;+*¾?( ¥2¥2¢3 3$ +WRU0¦2 '0¦*{K+ + M z M 52 *¥8 - 3¨40¦/ ¨52,/,58( 452e¥8(" "5B 3 *>#$,,6-*0'/ 69E6 ,/,52,C¦"9 RU20 + ¿4+*R ¢" ¢ M z 58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ c+YG? !¥2T6¥252,  ¨¥:=?2 ¨5252¢ Y/ Q" 3¨,52¢3¨TL 0¦¦0B03 9 M Q+WRm2 ¨¦0¥20 ff0 + *0¦3¨,T+G? 03¨0"WUN *D 58(*0¦3 M ] M 3¨¦=? y58 X52,/ ¨h(*,¥X ,¥2/¢2 -W,o52a0" "3¨Ty 5D 3¨Ty52K58 :0/2 *+ 6³'±|2²¦}¢Wt¯'¯¯+ ¨§?¸ ¥¦,£@¦ 6§¢© 0¦"" 3 ¨/,0'58 ¨ <-( 540¦3¨¥2C52:58 *; 58( 03j 10/2 Q0¦ *! ¨52¥e/, @"9 s ³v 4+*O>3 "¢2 f + O)52520¦ *0'¥8 ¨ + + ?052¦ c OQ+ ¿?6/,/2 $ · M M ¢ 52¥,+ : *0¦@",¥2 52,L58 *:/(2¢ 5; ¥2520 58 ¨058 ¨¦ Y¦#>58 ¨¥ ] + w ¨¢-¦fRW+WRU Q ¨58 f*0¦ *XG;+ 4'+W Q" 3¨, :¢ 58 #g0 :,=B2 *¢3¨T !¦ I¥20 Q" 3¨¢9$-*0'¥2,K¦ 3 :"¦©3 < ;( 3¨58 9 · 03¨0¦"6N \ 0¦¦0+ M M " 3¨:¦"*58 ¨ Q ¨F058 ¨ L3¨,'¢3¨¥,<0¦ *I¥20 Q" 3¨¢9E62 ¨¢ L¦ 3 \#A,,6-*0'/ 69 :c_<¦r,¢e 6 ,/,52! 3 . + ?$,¦A$,$¢ ;j2¡2¢£@£QU¡º*¥'¦,$,£@¦¢¤f¢ ¡§*¢¦¡6,¦¤ ," 0',¥4³ ²,°¥¤m³6t¦°<²,±'±± + ¢ @`¨6¨© $¢6$ ¦ À<2#$ :0¦ */ ¥8(3¨52¥K , :¦ *¥2580'52y58 05X3¨¦=`9E¦2 *,0'i¥20 Q9 s °v +*{K+ O) ¢¥2¢ fw+ {K+*?/ + 0 fR*+ , :0¦=?05, £ M M · " 3 !52,/2 ¨h( ,¥Q/0 X~,/,58 ¨'¢3¨TJ62 ¨;" © 3¨¢9EU ,/52,K 3 {K+*¾;+*e¢ F¢ *'¢¦fR*+ 9EG;+ OQ+ wc¢( ¾;+ w+R ¨52,¥, {K+*G;+ /, Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ p# 0¦¦0\" ¦0 :¥,+DG? *10 0" 58 ¨X¥2T6¥252, !f 9 M 0¦ * ,'6 <¿4+ OQ+ 03¨ ¥8"( ¦c0¦ * +¥K>+ ¢ 3$+ z ] ] ] /3 (*6 *!/, Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ cq I0¦¢0'; 586U( /,,¥43¨¥2¥458 0 L²,¯A¡ ¿? 58 6( ( ¥4"¦©3 ¢; *0¦;0¦3 3<58 Q/T6/¢3¨,¥4' © ] ¦'¢2 *0C0 C¢3 ¨'¢¥>52520¦3*¥2T6¥252, ["2#$ :0¦ */4/,' Q",58 ¨58 ¨' G<,/2 ¨/,03 e52:²±±6´,9E¯²,u'0 ¨ ¨5203BR6T6¥252, :¥e¾>,¥2,0/2 · =? ¨58 C58 -¥25<03¨52¢2 058 ¨'4¥258052 ¨,¥?/ ¥8 ¨¢+ 0¦?#( 29 ] ¿?¢ 52¢¦*=>=>=;+ ¥2,0/2 c+ 6 ¨ ¨5203$+ /,' R6¾>¿4 58 ¢@ , :¦ *¥2580'52,K58 05;0! ;( 3¨58 93¨¢3>¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ Y¥258052T /0 X ¢3 ¨'¢;- (*¥25?"2#$ :0¦ */4 X-58 k¥252058( "X0 X¥252,0'T9 s ¼v {K+*O>2 *¦3¨fR*+ + R602 '0¦ 0 XÀÁ+ R6=?,¢ ,T+ O 7 z ¥2520'52\" ¦0 ¨ :,¥,B/, @",58 ¨58 ¨X=? ¨58 Z58 º-W,¥25:03¨522 *0¦9 /, @"*0¦058 ¨1¥258(* T!¦#<¥252058 ¨/@0 X T *0' Q ¨/b ¢( 2 ¨¥258 ¨/,¥4#$¦ 58 ¨'¹ ,0'/ Y,¦ ¨ :+ 03 3¨T@=?! 0¦I : ¥258052,p58 05 7 3 ¨ * +jA ºf ¦?Wb ! ¦ O*¢¨¹ ¨4¥'¢£@$ ¥20' Q" 3 *I52,/2 ¨h(*¥:/,0 a¢~/,58 ¨¢3¨TaU2 ¨'º#A,,6-*0'/ 69E6 ,/,52, mt¯¯'¯+ ¢ @4 6¢¢¨f 'Q<£>¨©¨¢6$D¢ X¨f£@©¨¦¢6$ 3 1¢3 ¨'¢2 o"¢2#$¦ :0 /,J ¨ @"¦ :¢ 52¥I#C²²+¡ s uv {K+*O>2 *¦3¨{K+ ) 0 X4+ +*¾>T6¦+O) D, Q" 2 ¨/,03 £ 0¦'¢0'Q0¦ *!( "X52C´¦³£¡\+ ¥258(* T!¦#j¥2¢3¨,/,58 ¨':" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ f+< E£ ©O!2$,¢¢6$ ¢© G? ¨¥;¥2T6¥252, "¦ ¨ ,¥;0:x*¢^6 - 3¨: #g0¥2582( /,58(@#$e#(*58( ;¢9 D¨ ¦ O*¢¨IX¢ ¡§ ¢¦¡U,¦>¢W ¹q£)¨©¨,¦f,;?¢r¢©©¨,© 6O>(* +t¦¯¯¯ + ¥20/2 p Y¦ 3 K¦"*58 ¨ Q ¨F058 ¨ f+ (*58( X,¥2,0/2 Y52¦" ¨/¥! 9 7 <£>¨§* ¡ /3 (* ;0( 52 :0'58 ¨/4¥8"/¢ ¨03 ¨F,0'58 ¦ c*" © 3¨¢9E6 ,/,52,X : :TQ3¨0¦T9 s ´v {K+*O>2 *¦3¨X0 XÀÁ+ +WRU=?¢ *T+*O>"" ,^6 ¨ :058 X58 * 7 ¦(*5j" 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ ¥,*¢© *, 1¢ 52¥?52458 ?,/,' Q" 3¨0'58 ¨ I0¦ *0¦3¨T658 ¨/ /,03 3 !/ 52¢^ 5?584 ¨0:¥20' Q"3 + G<,/2 ¨/,03q¾>¢"5B¾>¿ 16¢3$ 0 Y/, ¥8 ¨058 ¨ ¦#;3¨0I¥2¢¢k/,6 ,¥\- 0¥2,p tU²´®± f?{ÂG;+ + 052¥2¦ X¾>,¥2,0¦/ a¿?¢ 52¦ ( 3¨TXt¯'¯¯ + M ] M $?{ Q ¨63¨,=?0¦4"66( /,52¥,+ >0 58 ¨/ "*0'52;58 *0'5?58 * 0¦3¨0"6N ] M Oe0¦"*58 ¨'IP)"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ RUT6¥252, =? 3 3)" 3¨0¦TK0X 6,TJ¦3¨\ Z( s ®v +*O>(*¥83¨0¦ * ¢¦{K+*À< 3 "¥2q¿4+¿ 0 ;-¢¥,R*+ + M M ~52¥e52Q ¨ Q" ' 0¦¦0:¥2¢'¢>"¢2#$¦ :0 /,+ M K'¢¥,0¦ *D4+ @+ ?¢¥8 0+ 0¥25, ¢~,/,58 ¨'Q T 0 Q ¨/ 7 /, @" 3¨0'58 ¨ <+qA j2¦¢ ¡¦?2;©O*>:c¸ ¦?Wb « ¡ ¨ ,¦¢¨¡k¢ Acknowledgments <¦,,rW¢;Xj2¡2¢£@£Qg ¡ºW¢ ¡§*¢¦¡6 " 0',¥;²,°'±¥¤*²¼± ÀÁ 3¨0 ¢3 "* 0 @58 *0¦ k58 * 03¨0¦"6N !52,0' :, ;-¢¥Qs tvf#$e58 ¢ ;=B2 C ] M 2£)¨©¨,£1,$¢6AA À<¢ *¥2T3¨¦0 g0qtU²¤Ut°C{X0¦TJ²±±u + ,'¢3¨" *Z58 *D¥2T6¥252, ( ¥2,y52I/, 6(*/,5C58 ¨¥:,¥2,0/2 f+ ] *¦?j;o 6$¢,¦ ³²'|E¼}¢*{X0¦TI²,±±'u+ 58 0 ¨¢ ZR602 '0¦:#$@ ¨¥:¥8(" "¦5:#e58 ¨¥:=?2 + C03¨¥2 z ] 58 0 I?0¦2-*0¦0!¾>T64#$¦4 ¢;¥8( ""W5;#j{X0'5258 *=[O)2 3¨%¦ ¥ s ±v + ?03¨0 ¥K>+ ( ,¥252¢=B03¨0 IRW+ ?0 ¢g§ ¨0 + T 0 : O z · · '3¨', :¢ 5: L58 ¨¥Q=B2 +:{! ¨/2 0¢3>j(2 m 580 ¥8"*0¦¢ 5; T *0' Q ¨/Q¦"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ L¥2T6¥252, !+WA 0¦ *L58 C0 T6 :¦(*¥DP;P4ÀBRUwfO , ¨=?¢¥Q" ¦ ¨,Z¦03 ( 0- 3¨ ¥8( ',¥258 ¨ ¥;0 !#$,U- 0/2 X¦ X58 4",¥2 52058 ¨ a#j58 ¨¥4=B2 + *¦?jb G ¬6¬6¬!<,,2,;Xr¢¡r¢£Q£@ ¡ ( *1t¯'¯¯+ M ¢ ¡§ ¢¦¡U ¨ ,¦¢¨¡k¢ Q2£>¨©¨£1,$¢6$ s¨²,¯v G;+*?0¦3 3<0 + ¾;+*wc0¦2(*¥,+ 0 /2 X",6 ¨/,58 ¨¦ J#$¦>#,+ A M r¦¢¢ g ¡¦>2;©O*4:cÂ*¦?j;X« ¡£D<¦,,rW¢e r¡mr¢£Q£@ ¡:¢ ¡§ ¢¦¡6 ¨;,¦¨¡X¢ :2£>¨©¨,£:,$¢6$ 6" 0',¥4³'¯¯¥¤m³²³O)3 - ( h(*¢h( 4,=Y{X^6 ¨/, ªrj ¨e$ t³ ¤ t¼ ( *C²,±'±³ + t¦®|$um}¢ ( *:²±±³ + M M *¦?j;o 6AA¢,¦ s¨²²¢v ¾;+*?66 ¾;+ ( "*520 *0 + R602 '0¦+Oe>¿ £ z · KÁ3 ¨ @ *0'58 . XO)20¦TC?( ¥ ¿B ,/2 ¥4¦ :0 +f · *¦?jb G ¬6¬6¬!<,,2,;Xr¢¡r¢£Q£@ ¡ ( *1t¯'¯¯+ M ¢ ¡§ ¢¦¡U ¨ ,¦¢¨¡k¢ Q2£>¨©¨£1,$¢6$ s¨²¦t,v@¾;+ + ( ¢¦+ s t¼vbRW+ + -'0 +WRU0¦2 '0¦+ © ,XO> *0¦3¨T6¥8 ¨¥;# £ ¢¡ 7 z ¶ AW?<£)¨g©¨¢6AAX¢ + O)20¦TC0 IP)-m§¢,/,5>¾>¢#$¢ */,¥) aR658 3¨T!GBT", r ©©¨,©¨e¢ ', ¨4¥'¢£QA¤£?¢£>¨©¨¢6$:gX O*£1 ÀÁ 58 ,¥8 ¨¥,fA 6 ¨0 0 ¨¥8 ¨58T<²±±6´6+ wc0¦ *¦(*0',¥,+qA · ¶ ,©O:2$,¢¢6$ ¢© $¢6AA?4¢© ¥¦¦ ( @t¯¯'¯+ M *¥£>¨ ¦¢g§£nª G ¬6¬6¬, s¨²,³¦v@¾;+ + ( ¢ 0 !¾;+ + T- ¨ +cO> ! #0¥2582( /,58( b#A £ · "¦©3¨9862 ¨ K T *0' Q ¨/Q,/ Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ c+j s tuv + '¥83 * 4+ ¦T 0 +R652,¢3¨'+ £ £ M M ¦?f;« ¡£¢6¤j©O* O* 6¢ '¢:¢ ¡§ ¢¦¡6 ¥ ¦ +Oe6 ¨¥2 ,¥83¨,T'<²,±±'u+ ] q£)¨§ $e¦,$¦A¥;2W,¢6$¢©<,,2,; ¨ ¢, ©B¢¢6$ {X0¦TX²,±'±®+ <£>¨§*$,>¢ ¡§*¢¦¡6,¦ s t´v 4+ 0¦ 5,*{K+ {X6/ {K+*À< 3 "'¥2q¿ +W¿ *0' b-¥,*0 £ s¨²,°¦v@{K+ +*( 2 6 + 9 +*¿ $WRW+ + ¦ {K+*> * £ £ M · 7 · RW+K'¢¥,+ T ¿ O> X¢^6" ,¥2¥8 ¨':0 *'52058 ¨¦ 9E6 ,/,52, · + R602 '0¦ {K+ + RU20 + ¿4+ Rm,U 0¦ z M z T 0 @ ¨/:/, @" 3¨¢;#A ¿4+G</ ¨/03j¾>¢"¦5 Q+ R2 ¨¦0¥20¦ cf0 + 03¨,T'+G` 03¨0¦"6N ! T *0' Q ¨/ M ] M G>¾`9E±m´9E¯³¦98¯'³ ¨'¢¥8 ¨58TD# 0¥8 *'52 f ¢"*0¦52 :¢ 5 ¶ ] · " 58 ¨ Q ¨F¢ !/,' Q" 3¨¢;#$ 0¦¦0+WA M #B¿? @"( 52¢@R6/¢ ¨¢ /,@0 KÁ ,¢2 f{X0¦+f²,±'±6´U+ :c E¡¡¡ 6¢ '¢ " 0',¥Q²t±¥¤ ²,° ² ( \²±±± + M ?2¢ 6:q¦,,2, s t®v 4+ 0¦ 5,*{K+ ÀÁ 3 "¥2'<{K+ {X6/ W¿ +W¿ *0' b-¥,*0 £ s¨²¦¼,v@4+ ¿?03¨ ¢¦À<+ ¢3 3¨¢¦0 XOQ+ K<(*¥2520'/,+ 0¦3 (*;"¦©3 + 7 z RW+ + K'¢¥,+O> X,¦03 ( 058 ¨¦ K¦#j¥2520',!2( 9E58 ¨ : M A " 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ ¥; T ¿ +WA · O* ¬6©O!2$,¢W¢6AA*¢©6*¥'£)¨ ¦§ £µ r¢ U¡m¦`2; O*e:c ¦"*0',¥et¼¦±¥¤Utu± ,/'+c²,±'±6´6+ · !$,r¢r O$$¢¦§62 *¦?jbV« ¡¡X<¦r,¢eXr¡mr¢£Q£@ ¡:¢ ¡§ ¢¦¡6 ," 0¥;t±'³¥¤m³¯° <²,±'±±+ s¨²,u¦v1¿4+*¿ 0 ;-¢¥>0 + 0¦¦+*{X0 6 \" ( · ¶ ¨;,¦¨¡X¢ :2£>¨©¨£1,$¢6$ -m§¢,/5898¦2 ¨¢ 52,!3¨0¦ *¦(*0',¥4" 0/,58 ¨/03$+qA s t±v + ' + ,0 ff¿4+ 0¦2,525,*0¦ *I¿4+ ¿ *0' b-W¢¥,+ £ £ · M · :c ÀÁ¦©3¨98¦( ¨ ,J/,¢ ¨;/¢3¨0'¥2¥)" ,U ¨/58 ¨ f+jA <¦,,rW¢eL?$,$,$¢ ;r¡mr¢£Q£@ ¡:*¥'¦,$,£Q¦¤ ," 0',¥Q² ¤*²¼U e¦*+c²,±'±²'+ ºf ¢ ¡§ ¢¦¡U,¦¤¢ @`¨6¨© A¢¢6$¦*¦ t¦u|2²'²¦}¢+ <¦,,rW¢;LB¢¦,j¢$,$ bj2¡2¢£@£@ ¡Q*¥'¦,$,£Q¦¤ ¦" 0¥Q²,¯'®¥¤ ²¦t³ P4/,5,+ *¦?jbY 6$¢,¦ ¢ ¡§ ¢¦¡U,¦¤f¢ ;`¨6¨© A¢¢6$*¦ ²,±'±6¼U+ s¨²¦´,v@À<+À<+ ¿ *0¦ * fRW+ O@+*{X0 3 6' + + ¿B ¢ f*0¦ * +* :¢ ] ] + 4=?(f+ ÀÁ¦©3¨¢9E¦( ¨ ,K0¦(*52' :058 ¨/4 3 *C¢^6" 0 ¥8 ¨ X#A ] s ³¯v + + 40¦ *¥2 c+ £ M ¿d"'0' :¥,+ N 4 6¢¢¨f '?*¥'¦,$,£Q¦f,@©O* ¨e¥¢£@$ +6À< 58 ,¥8 ¨¥, · 2, ¢2¤§Cj2¢6¦$;¢ ¢¨ ,¢$, tt6|E¼} ³°± ¤6³'u±{X0¦TX²,±'±6t6+ £?§ * g£:C¨f£@©¨¦¢6AAX24j2¡2¢£@¦ ¿?02 , ¨¢9E{X¢3 3¨¦ ¨¥8 ¨58Tj²,±m´°+ ¶ s¨²,®¦v@{K+ ¿B ¨2 ¨0¦ + 9 + w( ¢ f*0 + {K+ RU58 ¨/2 58 f+ £ M s ³²¢v + 3¨F3¨+ ¶ ÀÁ0'/,58 ¨/¢ P 0¦0 ¢ T *0' Q ¨/ M6¶e· M ¶ · 4 6¢¢¨f 'Q¨fAg£Q©¨¦¢6$e,4W© £B¢,© g ¡ N + P)"*58 ¨ @ ¨F,058 ¨¦ *¥,+qA ¨¡¢O!Bg,£:¢W¢ $©O ¨©¨r¢6$¢¥;j2¡2¢£@£Qg ¡ ÀÁ 58 *¥8 ¨¥,fRU520¦ #$¦ ¨¢¥8 ¨5ETO)( +f²,±'±°+ · ¶ *¦?Wb G ¬6¬6¬!<¦r,¢e r¡mr¢£Q£@ ¡QW¢ ¡§*¢¦¡6 ¨ ,¦¢¨¡k¢ :2£)¨©¨,£1W¢6$ ( @t¯'¯¯ + M s ³6tv + 3¨F3¨Q0¦ * + *'0¦+ ¾)/, /¢ 3 !,¥8"W ¥8 ¨¢ ,¥2¥ ¶ · ¶ =? ¨58 X"¢2#$¦ :0 /,; X"( ;-m§¢,/5898¦2 ¨¢ 52,X3¨0 ( 0',¥,+ s¨²,±¦v1¿4+*¿?¦ *¥2¢3q0 + 4 3$+*O['¢ *03<0¦"" 0'/ X#A 7 2( 9E58 ¨ :@¥8",/¢ ¨0¦3 ¨F,058 ¨¦ y0¦ *C ¨52¥40¦"" 3 ¨/,058 ¨¦ L52C¿4+ A :c 2¢*¦¢6¦AA*¦?Xj2¡2¢£@£@ ¡:¢ ¡§*¢¦¡6,¦>¢ *²,® |$°6} ³6¼'¼ ¤6°'¯¯ (3¨TI²,±±'u+ M *¥¦$,£Q¦ <¦,,rW¢¨£?¢r C2; O*8G6r @ºf s ³³v ¾;+ + 46¦ =?0¦T!0 !{K+ OQ+ 4, + ¨ ¨5203 I¢¡ ³6t M · 7 *¦?jbe8*¦q: *¥'£)¨ ¦§ £iX, ¨©¨,¦e2 ¦" 0¥Q²,°m¼ ¤ ²¦¼u 0¦ c+f²,±±'u+ M ¿? ;- *X b( 3¨058 ¨¦ K0¦ *C- 0TX580¦ *¥2¥83¨0'58 ¨ f+ r¡mr¢£Q£@ ¡QW¢ ¡§*¢¦¡6,¦ ¨e¨¡$$¢© 6± |2²¦} ³¥¤ ²¦tU 0 f+c²±±6´6+ M s t¯¦v@G;+*R*+*À<+ K>+¿?2"¦058 ¨¦ c+fR6ÀKB¿ {X±®1?¢ / :02 ¥,+ M6z O*$¢© 6§¢© 5258" ¦=>=)=;+ ¥8",/+ A'¥2£8§6 :±® <²,±±'®+ s ³°v G? * 0¦¦0:4'52¥8"5>"¢2#$¦ :0 /,@¢ Q0¦/ ¨52,/,58( + M ¨52Q" 0"¢ 0¦0¦ 3¨0- 3¨:05 ] s tU²v@¾;+*¿?T658¦ c + ¢20 52 4+ + ¾>¥2 c{K+ Q+ :0¦ c M 7 ] 5258" E§¢0¦¦0+ ¥8( f+ / ,"66(*/52¥ '52¥8"65 =? ¨52¢"0"W¢+ 52 Q3$ 0 + + *0',/2 +O) k C/¢ ¨ 54 :,58 6\#Ae/, @"( 58 * 7 O)" ¦+c²±±± + ¥252058 ¨/;¥8 3¨:0'¥2¥8 ¨ :¢ 54#$¦ 0 !58 Q/ 583 "¢ ¢ /,@0¦" f+ :c 2¢ ¦,¢6¦$*¦> s ³6¼v G;+*À<+ ¨¥2583¨¢¦+ +'ÀÁ · ²,³|$°m} °m¼U² ¤6°±'¯ <*§ § ¦?r¡mr¢£¸¨fAg£Q©¨¦¢6$ r¡mr¢£Q£@ ¡QW¢ ¡§*¢¦¡6,¦>¢ :*¥'¦,$,£Q¦ 58 *¥8 ¨¥, ¨¢¥8 ¨5ETX#B¿?03 #$¦2 ¨0 < *'c²,±'±± + ¶ ²,±'±²+ s ³uv OQ+ 03 3$+%K C/¢ ¨¢ 5 0¦0 { ( ¥2589$ 9EG? ¨ ::/,' Q" 3¨058 ¨ f+ M z M s tt,v + ,0¦ I0 X¿4+ ¿B 0 ;-¢¥,+G<¦=?0¦¥j-,5252¢e 3 * M · A + 9Ew+ 0¦(*6 ¨5,,6 ¨52¦ £ M /¢ ¨¥8 ¨ ¥4(*¥8 : 3 ¨ *X582 ¨0¦3¨¥,+fA 2W,¢6$¢¦©c<,,2,4 j2¦¢ ¡¦>2;©O* £ ?¢r¢©©¨,© r O$$¢¦§r,¦?¢ X<£>¨©¨¢6$ O* § ¦ :c_<¦,,2,4Xf2*Y¢W © §¦$¢© "*0',¥ t¯m¼ ¤ t6²¦t6fP4/,5,+²,±±'®+ U" 0',¥et´¦³¥¤ t¦®6t6fP)23¨0 w ( 7 M r¡mr¢£Q£@ ¡K« ¡ ²,±'±°+ s ³6´v {K+*wf, Q0¦ *DÀ<+*wc+ T 0 Q ¨/:¥8"W,/¢ ¨03 ¨F058 g K I58 · 0- ( ¥;¥2T6¥252, !+ ³'¯|$³',¥} ² ¤ ¼6 7 s t³¦v + 583¨¢#$¥40¦ *IPQ+ Oe,¥2¢ f+ 3 X#j 58( 03j :,58 6 ¥,+ · · :c_<£>¨§ Ag ¡Q*§ ',¥¦ RU"*5,+<²±±® +*O>58 ¨/¢3¨:t¦³+ A O*6E£ ©O §r¢¨*¢I<¦,,rW¢;LB¢¦,j¢$,$ *²±±'±+ r¡mr¢£Q£@ ¡ s ³®v ¾;+*{X023¨5,f¿ + ¿? ¥2¢3$0¦ *DÀÁ+ ? 5,+%K C/¢ ¨ 5 s t°¦v@w+ À<+ ¢( 52¥2/ I0¦ *XO@+ {K+R6/ ~ :0¦ c+ · ¨ Q" 3¨, :¢ 520'58 ¨ L¦#<58 :R6 :03 3¨520¦3 69E®¯X¥2T6¥252, !+WA r¦¢¢ g ¡¦>2;©O*4:cÂ*¦?j;¸« ¡¡X<,,2,4 E£E6 O r¡mr¢£Q£@ ¡:¢ ¡§ ¢¦¡6 ¨;,¦¨¡X¢ :2£>¨©¨,£:,$¢6$ 4**§ ¢©6:cÂ*¥'£)¨ ¦§£I©O*;, ¨©¨,¦>2 "*0',¥ t® ²¤ t¦±6t6<²,±±'±+ ¦" 0¥;t±m´ ¤m³¯6t6 0¦ c+f²,±®'°+ M r¡mr¢£Q£@ ¡QW¢ ¡§*¢¦¡6,¦ s ³±¦v@{K+ À<3¨,5252 +*¾;+ K< *¦3¨¢¦0 X{K+ + 00'¥8 *6 +52/,/ O · 7 ¥2T6¥252, µ#$¦)#A0¥25,6x*^6 -3¨f0 ! ¨ 93¨¢3BT 0 @ ¨/Q/,6 ¢ ¢0'58 ¨ f+fA j2¦¢ ¡¦>2;©O*e:cÂ*¦?Wbk« ¡ <¦,,rW¢eXr¢¡r¢£Q£@ ¡:¢ ¡§ ¢¦¡U ¨;,¦¨¡X¢ 6" 0',¥;²,¯± ¤*²tU²wf0¥ ,0'¥, z 2£)¨©¨,£1,$¢6AADªrj ¨e$ 4,¦0'0 c²¦¼¦¤*²® ( :²,±±m´U+ ³6t6|E¼}¢ M *¦?Wbp;6$,¦ {X0¦T¹²±±m´U+ s °¯¦v@{K+ À<3¨,5252C0 + R602 '0¦+ w ,0 ¥2/,0 X ¨¥252¢ z 03 3¨6/,0'58 ¨ f+ :c 2¢*¦¢6¦AA*¦>Xj2¡2¢£@£QU¡ tU²'|E¼} ®±m¼ ¤6± ²,³ fRU¢" 5,+c²±±'±+ ¢ ¡§ ¢¦¡U,¦B¢ :*¥¦$,£Q¦ s °²v@¾;+¾>0'U 0 62 ¨¥8 *0 f Q+ §¢0¦T 62 ¨¥8 0 ffw+ + ¦ f*0¦ * z M OQ+ R ¨0'¥8(- 0 10 ¨06 !+cO>/ ¨52,/,58( 03< ¨¥2¥8( ,¥> 0¦0 M 2( 58 ¨ 1Q¥2T6¥252, 1¥,+A r¦¢¢ g ¡¦>2;©O*b* U©O 2$,¢¢6$ ¢©6*¥'£)¨ ¦§£ ¨¡¢O\?,g,£:¢ '"*0',¥e³®6´¦¤6³'±® <£>¨§*$,B r O$$¢¦§r;ª eb, G<( 3¨( ¥2 0¦ */,' 0 f+ t¯'¯¯+ 7 M s °6t,v@{K+ RU¢20¦ * *¾;+ ? 0¦=?¢ '0¦WRW+ {! ¨6 6 ~<f0 !{K+ (" 520+ £ (*0'¥8 9E¥252058 ¨/@/, Q" 3¨058 ¨¦ K 0¦¦0+ ¡ M :c_<¦r,¢ KB¢¦,j¢$,$ bj2¡2¢£@£@ ¡:*¥¦$£@¦¤c¢ ¡§ ¢¦¡6¦¤ 'P4/,5,+t¦¯¯¯ + ¢ ;?¨6¨© $¢¢6$ ¦ s °³¦v@G;+*R( 0 0 10G;+ P40¥20¦=?0¦0 {K+*G<0 m¢( / $G;+ 0¥8( {K+ 0=B0 ¨52 + ¥8 ¨F,0 6 $fQ+ ' :052¥8(f*0¦ * G;+¢e0 '0520¦ $+fP4'¢ ¨,=p#j58 @?{ 0¦¦0 ( ¥2589 9EG? ¨ : M M /, @" 3¨¢¦+ 6³'±|2²¦}¢Wt¯'¯¯+ ¨§B ¥¦,£@¦ 6§¢© s °°¦v ¦3¨0 {X0¦2 ItU+¨²+ z ¨¤¨©£¤£¦¥§¥©¨©¨§¨ §¦¥©§© § §¨§ ¥¨ § §© © ¨§ ¥6+ ¢ ¢ ¢ ¦ ¦ s °6¼,v + 03¨,T+ T *0' Q ¨/:¦"*58 ¨ Q ¨F058 ¨ 58 ¦(*¦ I58 *4( ¥2;# M ] · 0( 52 :0'58 ¨/b2( 58 ¨ :@¥8",/¢ ¨0¦3 ¨F,058 g f+<{K+ ¢ +¨ {X0¥2¥20'/ 6( ¥2¥2,5252¥; *¥258 ¨58( 52@#jG<,/2 3¨'T{X0¦TX²,±'±± + s °u¦v + 03¨T+O "W520- 3¨@¥20 Q" 3 *¦9$-*0'¥2,J" © 3¨¢4#$¦ 0¦¦0 M ] M 58(*0¦3< :0'/ ,¥,+< :c G ¬6¬6¬ 6¢ '¢X?2¢ 6 ( @t¯'¯¯+ M <¦,,rW¢ s °6´,v@4+ 92R*+ 0¦ * R*+ 9E{K+ {X6 ffR*+*À<02 + wc, R*+*wf, M + À<02 + ¿ + ¿ 6( * fRW+ ¨ ! +¥K<-/¢ ¨¦3 (cf0 M K)+ O>3¨52 :0 f+*wf0G>G< O 0¦¦0 { ( ¥2589$ 9EG? ¨ :;/,' Q" 3¨¢ M z M =? ¨58 !#$0'¥25)0¦ *D C/¢ ¨ 5),¦ ¨¥252¢;0¦3 3¨6/,058 ¨¦ <+< 2$,¢¢6$ ¢©<¦r,¢e!B¢2¢©©¨,© 4r OA¦§r¦B¢ £ 6P4/,5,+²±±± + <£>¨©¨¢6$ O §*,¦ s °®¦v IQ+ *0¦ * c+ 0 @+ 3¨T' +e+¿ * c 0 !{K+ + £ ] M · RU @ ¨58 c+WRUT6¥252, ¥8( ""¦5)#$¦e0( 52 :0'52,!"¦©3 !0¦ * " 58 ¨ Q ¨F,0'58 ¨ f+fA r¦¢¢ g ¡¦?2e O*6E6©O:*¥£>¨ ¦¢g§£i mP)"¢0'58 * ¨ ,2¢6 ¡Q ¥¦,£@¦>, ¨©¨,¦eª8< ¡ RUT6¥252 :¥>¾) ¨,=;³²|E¼'}¢" 0',¥;²¦¼ ¤Utu fP4/,5,+ ¼ ¤6®X²±±6´6+ APPENDIX G<0¦-3¨¥\³I0 L°J¦ ¨X58 !0¦-*¥2¦3 (*52X¢^ /¢(*58 ¨¦ p0'520¹#AC58 !¥2520¦58("Z0 y¥2520 T98¥2520'52!, ¨ 1,¥Q#$¦C58 *C-*0¦C/2 *0¦52¥Q"¥2¢ 52,d R6,/,58 ¨¦ *¥;u + t@0 !u+ ³+ ¡6 -2"£1$B ¢C./ ¡6§/ ¡ ¡¢ ¤£&2*¢( ¥ H()-2 ¥ 46 ¥ 46 ¥ 46 ¥ 46 ¥ 46 ¥ 46 $BD*¢( $?D*¢(¢¡ ¡ t¦°+ ±®m´ u+ ¯±u ´6+.²¼u ®+ ®u'® u+ uu¯ ¼6+ ®'u¯ u+ ¯6´6² ¼6+ ±'³± ¼U+ ±6¼¦³ §¨§¤£ ¦ © © ¦ © © ´U+ ³±'® ®+ ±6¼¼ ²¦t6+ ±m¼´ t6²+ °6´¦³ °+ ±u¯ ¼6+.²¼® ¼U+ ®6t¦° ¼6+ ³'¯6¼ °+ ®²¯ ¥ ²+ ±¯m´ tU+ ¼®6t ° + ´¦®® u+ t®mt ²+ ´u² ²'+ ±'®6t tU+ ³6¼'¼ ²'+ ´¦°6¼ ²+ ´³ ² §¦§ u+ ³³ ² ²°+ u6t´ tU²'+ ¯'u6´ ³ ²+ ®°'° ¼U+ ¼³³ ¼6+ ®mt³ u+ t±m¼ ¼6+ um´¯ ¼U+ °²t ¦ §¤£ ¦§ ¡¦¥ § t'¼U+ ´±'° ´U+ ´³u ± + ° ²,³ ²°+ °6´'t ´U+ ®³® ´6+.²¼³ ±+ ´U²° ® + ¯mt® ´U+ ±6t't §¦¨¦ ¤¨ u+ °°'° °+ ³®¯ ´6+ t'tU² ²tU+ ³6¼'´ ³+ u6tU² ° + t¦uu u+ ´t'´ ³ + ¼'t° ³+ ´´¦u § ²'²+ ®6´¦± ²¯+ ³²,® ²,° + ¯'u³ t¦¯+ ¯²¼ u+ ±³³ ´6+ ¯'±6t ´U+ ¼¼¦° ´6+.²³± ´U+ tU²u ¦¨ § £¦¨ §¨§¤£ ¥¤ ²tU+ ®¯'® ²u+ ´°¯ ³³ + ¯ ²,° ®'³+ ¯®'° ²¯+ °uu ° + u'³± °+ ±³m´ ° + ´¦¯± °+ u6´'t ¦ §¦¥¤§© § ³'¯°m¼ °'°6t± °°'u® °'³²t °'¯¯6´ °²¼¼ °¯ ²,± °²®6¼ °mt¯'° §¦¥¤§© § ¥ 4 ¡ #% ¢$B-2"£ # ¡ *¢12 -2"£1$B ¢C¥/?(J- *¢12 /* *¢D& £!%()$B )8 £/¢D*/? + ()- /£"£#.- £/¤£ ¤%"£ &2* £ (,*+1 D-(*/ #¢¡ $B£// !¥£/ & /£"£#%- £ £ ¥ !¥ (,/ £** ¥¤¨ ¡ -2"A1$B ;C¥/ ¡6§/ ¡ ¡¢ ¤£¥&2*¢( ¥ H()-2 ¥ 46 ¥ 46 ¥ 46 ¥ 46 ¥ 46 ¥ 46 $?D*¢( $BD*¢(¢¡ ¡ §¨§¤£ ¦ © © t'´u+ ¼®'u ¼³ + ´¦®± °²'+ °mtt ³6´U+ ±°m¼ ¼³ + t¦³6¼ °¯ + ¼¦®6t ³6´U+ u°'u ³m´U+ ®®mt ³6¼U+ tt6² ¦ u³+ ±®'± ³° + ´¦³¯ t± + ¯ ²,® t±+ ¯6t¦³ ³° + ´¦¯® t± + ¯'°¯ t±+¨²,®m¼ t¦®+ ®²³ ²,u+ ¼± ² © © ¥ ²¯6tU+ ®u'³ ´u + t¦³6¼ ´¼6+ ´¦±¯ ´¼U+ ±u'° ´¯ + ¯'±¯ ´¯ + u'u³ u±+ ®®m¼ ´¦¯+¨²,±'³ u6¼U+ ®±'® ´³+ °u ² ±6t6+ ±'¯6¼ °° + ¯'¯° °³+ ±¯'® u6¼6+ u'®6´ °6t6+ ®'u± °6tU+ u°'± ³'±+ °6t'¼ ³±+ ¼¼¦® §¦§ ¦ §¤£ ¦§ ¡¦¥ § t¦³6¼U+ tum¼ ³6´6+ t6²,³ t® + t¦³u t¼U+ ±±m´ °³ +.²´¼ ³6t6+ ¼6²¦´ ³¯+ ³6¼'´ t¦®+ t´6² t³+ ¯°'³ §¦¨¦ ¤¨ ¼´U+ ¯²´ ²,u + ¯m¼¯ ®+ ®³'± ®+ ±°'¯ ²¦¼6+ ¼'´t ±+ ´U²± ±+ ³6¼'¼ ²'²+ ³6´¦± ²¦tU+ ¼U²'² § ®6´U+ ±6´¦¯ °¯ + ±m¼U² ³± + ´'tu ³®+ ¯³'u °³ + ¼'tu °¯ + u'¯³ ³±+ u6¼¦® ³'®+ ®6´'´ ³u+¨²,¯m´ ¦¨ § £¦¨ §¨§¤£ ¥© t¦u6´U+ ®6t't ³°m¼U+ ¼¼'´ ²,¯6´6+ ¯'¯° ²¯u+ ´°m¼ t¼'´U+ ´´¦³ ²¦tu + ¯'®³ ²t°+ t´¦¯ ²,¯m¼U+ t±mt ²,¯²'+ u'°± ¦ §¦¥¤§© § ³³6´'¼ ³u'±6´ ¼U²³° ¼U²,±'° °m¼³m¼ °um¼t °±±'° ¼'t´'t ¼¯'¯¯ §¦¥¤§© § ¥ 4 ¡ #% ¢$B¥-2"£ #¢¡H*+12 -2"£1$?¥ ¢C¥/6()- *¢12 /*£ £ © ¡ /* *? £!%()$B ) £/¢D*/ ¥ ()- /£"£#%- £/¤£% ¤%"£ &2* £ (,*+1 D-(*/ #¢¡ $B£// !¥£/ & /£"£#%- £ £ ¥ !¥ (,/ £** ¥¤¨