The Vilhelm Bjerknes Centenary1

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Vilhelm Bjerknes Centenary1 VOL. 43, No. 7, JULY 1962 299 The Vilhelm Bjerknes Centenary 1 SVERRE PETTERSSEN The University of Chicago It is altogether fitting that meteorologists way, was presided over by the Rector of Oslo throughout the world should mark the 100th anni- University, Professor Johan T. Rund. The au- versary of the birth (on March 14th, 1862) of dience was made up of leaders in Norwegian Vilhelm Bjerknes—often, and justly, called the science, and friends and relatives of the Bjerknes Father of Modern Weather Forecasting. The family, including Professor Jacob Bjerknes, the occasion was celebrated with customary Scandi- discoverer of the Polar Front. Present also were navian decorum in the ancient University of Oslo, Professor Erik Palmen, of the Academy of Fin- the young University of Bergen, and in the august land, Dr. Alf Nyberg, Director of the Meteoro- Norwegian Academy of Sciences—institutions to logical Service of Sweden, and Dr. Andersen, which Bjerknes was deeply attached. Director of the Danish Meteorological Service. A committee of the Academy, under the chair- A moving biography was presented by one of manship of Professor Einar Hoiland, arranged a Vilhelm Bjerknes' early collaborators, Dr. Olav midday meeting on March 14th in the University Devik. From this we learn that Bjerknes left Aula which, in the presence of the King of Nor- behind almost 200 papers and articles on a variety 1 These are rough notes, written while travelling. For of scientific and cultural subjects. We also learn a detailed biography, readers are referred to articles by that his scientific career took him to leading posi- O. Devik, T. Bergeron and C. L. Godske, Geofysiske tions in Sweden, Germany and Norway; and, as Publikasjoner, 24, Norske Videnskaps-akademi, Oslo, 1962. (Bjerknes Memorial Volume.) a visitor, to a large number of centers of learning. First day cover of Norwegian stamps commemorating the centenary of Vilhelm Bjerknes' birth. Unauthenticated | Downloaded 09/28/21 09:08 AM UTC 300 BULLETIN AMERICAN METEOROLOGICAL SOCIETY For several decades he enjoyed the generous sup- Bergen School in 1918; and Bjerknes' re-joining port of the Carnegie Institution of Washington, the Oslo faculty in 1926. which enabled him to surround himself with young On this long and winding road, Bjerknes talent from many lands. erected great monuments in the annals of mete- During his student years, Bjerknes assisted his orology; these are well matched by the living father, C. A. Bjerknes, in researches on hydro- army of scientific and practical meteorologists, dynamic forces, results of which attracted much few of whom can say that a considerable part of attention among the leading physicists of the their mental equipment did not come, directly or 1880's. About 1890 Bjerknes became Heinrich indirectly, from the great master. Hertz's first collaborator, and assisted him in the It is in keeping with good Norwegian traditions famous experiments with radio waves. After that great scientists, writers and artists, rather Hertz's death in 1893, Bjerknes wrote seven than generals and politicians, are honored by mon- papers on electrical resonance, which exerted great uments. A beautiful bust of Vilhelm Bjerknes influence on the development of radio. We are was presented by the Norwegian Ministry of reminded that the fortunes made from these dis- Education to the Oslo University, with an iden- coveries did not reach the scientists involved; tical twin going to the University of Bergen. indeed, forty years later Hertz's widow and Thus, Bjerknes has now formally joined the elite daughter, as poor refugees from the Third Reich, of leaders in Norwegian culture. were helped by Bjerknes to escape to England. The Norwegian Government also contributed by The year when the great Hertz died, Bjerknes issuing two Bjerknes stamps: one 45 ore and one was appointed professor of theoretical physics in 1.50 krone. The small number of first-day covers the University of Stockholm—it was necessary to were sold out early on March 14th. have a regular job and pay. His interests, with The Norwegian Academy of Science, of which his duties, changed from research on electricity to Bjerknes was President and a pillar of strength fluid motion. Soon new landmarks were raised; during the war years, celebrated the day by issu- in 1898 Bjerknes published his circulation theorem ing a special volume (Vol. 24) of the Geofysiske and paved the way from classical to physical hy- Publikasjoner, a series which was started in 1918 drodynamics. From then on, and until his death on Bjerknes' initiative. To provide a wider circu- in 1951, his overwhelming interest was centered lation of this volume, the American Meteorological around the dynamics of the atmosphere and the Society provided the Academy with funds for an oceans. It is a gross oversimplification to say that additional 3000 copies. The cooperation of the Bjerknes' main contribution to hydrodynamics re- Society in augmenting the circulation is particu- sides in the circulation theorems. Important as larly appropriate, since Bjerknes works have ex- these theorems are, his major contributions are erted a profound influence on the development of the shaping of a physical hydrodynamics, and a American meteorology. theoretical as well as a practical approach to the The memorial volume, of more than 300 pages, solution of problems related to atmospheric and includes a detailed biography of Vilhelm Bjerknes, oceanic motions. a complete list of his publications, and 11 major The present generation of meteorologists are papers written by men who, at one time or an- superficially familiar with the broad aspects of other, were closely associated with Bjerknes. Bjerknes' works since about 1920. But few ap- On the evening of March 14th the Norwegian preciate the immense amount of work, accompanied Academy gave a banquet for members of Bjerknes' by frustrations as well as glimpses of success, that family, earlier collaborators, and foreign guests. preceded the break-through. Largely forgotten is As one of the speakers, I took it upon myself to the fundament that was laid at the Oslo University express, on behalf of the Society, our admiration from 1905 to 1912. Next followed the creation for Vilhelm Bjerknes' immense contributions to by the Government of Saxony of a Geophysical science, our devotion to his ideals, and our satis- Institute for Bjerknes in Leipzig; then the First faction at being allowed to join with the Academy World War; the end of the Leipzig period, amid in the publishing and distribution of the Bjerknes' hunger, in 1917; the founding of the so-called memorial volume. Unauthenticated | Downloaded 09/28/21 09:08 AM UTC.
Recommended publications
  • The Brainstormers the Electromagnetic Field
    COMMENT SPRING BOOKS weather forecasting, particularly in the United States. Between the birth of Bjerknes — the oldest — in 1862 and the death of Wexler, the youngest, in 1962, there passed a forma- Inventing tive and innovative Atmospheric century. As Fleming Science: reveals, their lives were Bjerknes, Rossby, linked, with Bjerknes Wexler, and the teaching Rossby and Foundations Rossby, Wexler. of Modern Meteorology In 1904, in ‘Weather JAMES RODGER forecasting as a prob- FLEMING lem in mechanics and MIT Press: 2016. physics’, Bjerknes set the agenda for applying the laws of physics to the atmosphere to predict the weather (V. Bjerknes Meteorol. Z. 21, 1–7; 1904). His vision was to use a sufficiently accurate knowledge of the state of the atmosphere and the laws that govern its evolution to forewarn people about weather to come. His motiva- METEOROLOGY tion was to make his mark in what was for him a new field of science — he began his career working with his father, a physicist at the University of Oslo, on fluid analogies for The brainstormers the electromagnetic field. He was eager, too, to provide practical advice on hazards that affected mariners, farmers and the public. Alan Thorpe enjoys a hymn to some of the founders of Fleming notes the absence of a book-length the science and institutions of weather forecasting. biography of Rossby, and I hope that this will be rectified soon. To me, he is a first among equals. As well as building institutions, he t is thanks to the efforts of an international impacts, mostly on US weather forecasting.
    [Show full text]
  • Cumulated Bibliography of Biographies of Ocean Scientists Deborah Day, Scripps Institution of Oceanography Archives Revised December 3, 2001
    Cumulated Bibliography of Biographies of Ocean Scientists Deborah Day, Scripps Institution of Oceanography Archives Revised December 3, 2001. Preface This bibliography attempts to list all substantial autobiographies, biographies, festschrifts and obituaries of prominent oceanographers, marine biologists, fisheries scientists, and other scientists who worked in the marine environment published in journals and books after 1922, the publication date of Herdman’s Founders of Oceanography. The bibliography does not include newspaper obituaries, government documents, or citations to brief entries in general biographical sources. Items are listed alphabetically by author, and then chronologically by date of publication under a legend that includes the full name of the individual, his/her date of birth in European style(day, month in roman numeral, year), followed by his/her place of birth, then his date of death and place of death. Entries are in author-editor style following the Chicago Manual of Style (Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press, 14th ed., 1993). Citations are annotated to list the language if it is not obvious from the text. Annotations will also indicate if the citation includes a list of the scientist’s papers, if there is a relationship between the author of the citation and the scientist, or if the citation is written for a particular audience. This bibliography of biographies of scientists of the sea is based on Jacqueline Carpine-Lancre’s bibliography of biographies first published annually beginning with issue 4 of the History of Oceanography Newsletter (September 1992). It was supplemented by a bibliography maintained by Eric L. Mills and citations in the biographical files of the Archives of the Scripps Institution of Oceanography, UCSD.
    [Show full text]
  • Bierknes Memorial Lecture Richard J
    Bierknes Memorial Lecture Richard J. Reed1 The Development and Status of Modern Weather Prediction2 Abstract or writings. Despite his many accomplishments and honors, Bjerknes was a modest man. I trust that he The progress made in weather prediction since national would approve of our decision to focus attention in this weather services began issuing forecasts is traced and assessed. Specific contributions of J. Bjerknes to this program are lecture on the subject to which he devoted much of his pointed out. Lessons learned from the historical record con- life's work rather than on his personal achievements cerning factors and conditions responsible for the important alone. advances are considered, and a limited evaluation is then During the period under consideration, weather fore- made of the increase in forecast skill that resulted from these advances. Finally, some comments are offered on the future casting was transformed from a practical art to a partly prospects of weather prediction. quantitative science. Thus it will be convenient in the discussion that follows to divide the period into three eras: a first extending from 1860 to 1920 in which fore- 1. Introduction cast practice was based almost entirely on human ex- We gather tonight to celebrate the memory of Jacob perience and skill, a second extending from 1920 to 1950 Bjerknes, one of the towering figures in the history of in which physical concepts received increasing emphasis, meteorology. In a long and distinguished career that and finally the modern era in which physical-numerical spanned a period of more than 50 years, Bjerknes made methods have been introduced and become firmly es- monumental contributions to our knowledge and under- tablished.
    [Show full text]
  • History of Frontal Concepts Tn Meteorology
    HISTORY OF FRONTAL CONCEPTS TN METEOROLOGY: THE ACCEPTANCE OF THE NORWEGIAN THEORY by Gardner Perry III Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Bachelor of Science at the MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY June, 1961 Signature of'Author . ~ . ........ Department of Humangties, May 17, 1959 Certified by . v/ .-- '-- -T * ~ . ..... Thesis Supervisor Accepted by Chairman0 0 e 0 o mmite0 0 Chairman, Departmental Committee on Theses II ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The research for and the development of this thesis could not have been nearly as complete as it is without the assistance of innumerable persons; to any that I may have momentarily forgotten, my sincerest apologies. Conversations with Professors Giorgio de Santilw lana and Huston Smith provided many helpful and stimulat- ing thoughts. Professor Frederick Sanders injected thought pro- voking and clarifying comments at precisely the correct moments. This contribution has proven invaluable. The personnel of the following libraries were most cooperative with my many requests for assistance: Human- ities Library (M.I.T.), Science Library (M.I.T.), Engineer- ing Library (M.I.T.), Gordon MacKay Library (Harvard), and the Weather Bureau Library (Suitland, Md.). Also, the American Meteorological Society and Mr. David Ludlum were helpful in suggesting sources of material. In getting through the myriad of minor technical details Professor Roy Lamson and Mrs. Blender were indis-. pensable. And finally, whatever typing that I could not find time to do my wife, Mary, has willingly done. ABSTRACT The frontal concept, as developed by the Norwegian Meteorologists, is the foundation of modern synoptic mete- orology. The Norwegian theory, when presented, was rapidly accepted by the world's meteorologists, even though its several precursors had been rejected or Ignored.
    [Show full text]
  • The History of Weather Prediction
    Haley Cica 14 September 2009 Willard Clark Intro into Integrated Science Nicholas Scaturo Paper 1 The History of Weather Prediction The article “ The origins of computer weather prediction and climate modeling” by Peter Lynch is about all of the different people who made possible the current understanding of the world weather and the ability to predict it by making giant leaps in both mathematics, hydrodynamics, and computer technology. No one man could have made this possible; it took the life’s work of many different men to make weather prediction and understanding a reality. It all started with the development of thermodynamics and hydrodynamics. Then came three men who might be considered the founding fathers of weather prediction, these men were Cleveland Abbe, Vilhelm Bjerknes, and Lewis Fry Richardson. In 1901 Cleveland Abbe wrote a paper titled “ The physical basis of long-range weather forecasting” which proposed using mathematics to predict weather. Not long after, Vilhelm Bjerknes, a Norwegian scientist introduced a plan to predict weather which included two steps: To observe the atmosphere, then calculate movement using the laws of motion. In 1922, while working at the Meteorological Office in, Lewis Fry Richardson wrote a book titled “ Weather Prediction by Numerical Process” where he criticized the then current practice of using an “ Index of Weather Maps” to predict weather by finding a previous map that resembled your current map and deducing that the weather will act in a similar manner. This method was of course highly inaccurate as Richardson points out. He then laid out a forecasting scheme which was based on Bjerknes’ program and involved an unimaginable volume of numerical computation which he realized would be practically impossible without computers.
    [Show full text]
  • 2019 AGU Section Awardees and Named Lecturers - Eos 8/1/19, 359 PM
    2019 AGU Section Awardees and Named Lecturers - Eos 8/1/19, 359 PM 2019 AGU Section Awardees and Named Lecturers Eighty-two distinguished scientists receive accolades from groups representing their disciplines within AGU, the world’s largest Earth and space science society. By Robin Bell and Mary Anne Holmes ! 31 July 2019 The 2019 section awardees and named lecturers have been selected, and AGU staff, leaders, and selection committees wholeheartedly congratulate these awardees! Our colleagues have been selected for these prestigious honors for their sustained and unique contributions to advancing our understanding of Earth, its atmosphere and oceans, and planets and astral bodies beyond our own. The sciences encompassed by AGU are crucial for the health and well-being of our planet’s inhabitants. These awardees have contributed to both that understanding and the planetary health and well-being through their scientific advancements and outstanding service to the science and to AGU. https://eos.org/agu-news/2019-agu-section-awardees-and-named-lecturers Page 1 of 7 2019 AGU Section Awardees and Named Lecturers - Eos 8/1/19, 359 PM This year’s cohort of awardees reflects the diversity that is integral to the Earth and space sciences. Among the 25 sections of AGU there are 65 such awards; 21 are for early- career scientists (up to 10 years post-Ph.D.) and 6 are for midcareer (10 to 20 years post-Ph.D.). Twenty-seven awards provide named lectureships that offer unique opportunities to highlight the meritorious accomplishments of the awardees. AGU inaugurated the Bowie Lecture in 1989 to commemorate the 50th presentation of the William Bowie Medal, which is named for AGU’s first president and is the highest honor given by the organization.
    [Show full text]
  • BJERKNES – LIKE FATHER – LIKE SON by Doria B. Grimes U.S. Dept
    BJERKNES – LIKE FATHER – LIKE SON By Doria B. Grimes U.S. Dept. of Commerce National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Central Library [email protected] A comparison of the lives of the Bjerknes family of researchers – Carl Anton (1825- 1903), Vilhelm (1862-1951), and Jakob (1897-1975) reveal unique parallelisms that are significant to the history of meteorology and to this great family legacy of scholars. Some of these parallelisms were caused by international events, while others were by personal choice. In the following presentation, I will four notable occurrences: 1) personal decisions to postpone scholarship to support a father’s research 2) relocations due to international conflicts 3) establishment of world renowned schools of meteorology and 4) funding from the Carnegie Institute of Washington. 1. Personal Choice Both Vilhelm and Jakob willingly postponed their education and personal research interests in order to support their respective father’s scientific investigations. Vilhelm During the 1980’s and 1880’s Carl Anton Bjerknes worked in relative isolation on hydrodynamic analogies. In 1882, Carl represented Norway at the Paris International Electric Exhibition where he gained international recognition on his electromagnetic theory and analogies which was successfully demonstrated by his son, Vilhelm. Vilhelm continued to assist his father until 1889, when at the age of 27 he “had to get away … to develop his own skills and career opportunities.”1 Vilhelm earned a Norwegian Doctorate in 1892 at the age of 30. He preferred electromagnetic wave studies above his father’s interest in hydrodynamic theory. Through Carl Anton’s influence, a position was created at the Stockholm H»gskola.
    [Show full text]
  • Circa 1900) Vilhelm Bjerknes (1862–1951
    TCD 8th March, 2005 A Century of Numerical Weather Prediction: The Pre-history of Numerical The View from Limerick Weather Prediction Peter Lynch (circa 1900) [email protected] Meteorology & Climate Centre, University College Dublin Vilhelm Bjerknes, Max Margules and Lewis Fry Richardson Physics Society, Trinity College Dublin 2 Vilhelm Bjerknes (1862–1951) Vilhelm Bjerknes (1862–1951) • Born in March, 1862. • Matriculated in 1880. • Fritjøf Nansen was a fellow-student. • Paris, 1989–90. Studied under Poincar´e. • Bonn, 1890–92. Worked with Heinrich Hertz. Vilhelm Bjerknes • Worked in Stockholm, 1983–1907. • 1898: Circulation theorems published • 1904: Meteorological Manifesto • Christiania (Oslo), 1907–1912. • Leipzig, 1913–1917. • Bergen, 1917–1926. • 1919: Frontal Cyclone Model. • Oslo, 1926 — 1951. Retired 1937. Died, April 9,1951. Vilhelm Bjerknes on the quay at Bergen, painted by Rolf Groven, 1983 3 4 Bjerknes’ 1904 Manifesto Graphical v. Numerical Approach x To establish a science of meteorology, with the aim of pre- dicting future states of the atmosphere from the present Bjerknes ruled out analytical solution of the mathematical state. equations, due to their nonlinearity and complexity: “If it is true . that atmospheric states develop according to physi- cal law, then . the conditions for the rational solution of forecasting “For the solution of the problem in this problems are: form, graphical or mixed graphical and 1. An accurate knowledge of the state of the atmosphere numerical methods are appropriate, which at the initial time. methods must be derived either from the 2. An accurate knowledge of the physical laws according to partial differential equations or from the which one state .
    [Show full text]
  • Carl-Gustaf Arvid Rossby
    NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES C ARL- G USTAF ARVID R OSS B Y 1898—1957 A Biographical Memoir by H ORACE B. BYERS Any opinions expressed in this memoir are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Academy of Sciences. Biographical Memoir COPYRIGHT 1960 NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES WASHINGTON D.C. CARL-GUSTAF ARVID ROSSBY December 28, 1898-August ig, BY HORACE R. BYERS HEN METEOROLOGY is referred to as a young science, one has in Wmind the new life given to it in the early 1920s by Scandina- vian mathematical physicists and meteorologists. As one surveys the development of American meteorology from its static condition in the late 1920s to its position of world leadership today, one finds the name of Carl Rossby appearing so prominently that it would seem that this one man was responsible for the entire movement. This Scandinavian-American, early missionary of the Bjerknes school and later creator of the equally famous Rossby school of atmospheric science, organized, led, and, through his own outstanding research, spearheaded the thinking in meteorology in this country for twenty- five years. Then, during the last ten years of his life, having returned to his native Sweden, he came close to performing an equally lead- ing role on a world-wide basis. Rossby was really two men. On the one hand he was the organizer, director, and promoter and on the other the scholarly research scien- tist. Perhaps that is why he died while relatively young; no man could play this double game at his pace and last very long.
    [Show full text]
  • Jacob Bjerknes and the Weather Forecast in Portugal
    ROCA-ROSELL, A. (ed.).(2012) The Circulation of Science and Technology: Proceedings of the 4th International Conference of the ESHS, Barcelona, 18-20 November 2010. Barcelona: SCHCT-IEC, p. 433. A. J. LEONARDO, D. R. MARTINS, C. FIOLHAIS: JACOB BJERKNES AND THE WEATHER FORECAST IN PORTUGAL A. J. LEONARDO, D. R. MARTINS, C. FIOLHAIS Centre for Computational Physics and Department of Physics, Faculty of Sciences and Technology, Universidade de Coimbra, PORTUGAL [email protected] Abstract In 1922, due to the initiative of António de Carvalho Brandão, the Meteorological Service of the Navy was founded in Portugal. This was the beginning of synoptic meteorology in the country. Brandão became not only the first director of that Meteorological Service but also one of the most known Portuguese meteorologists. Four years later, at an international meteorology meeting held in Zurich, Brandão announced the decision of the Portuguese government to install a wireless telegraphy station at Azores to provide meteorological services. In 1927, Colonel Emile Delcambre, head of the French meteorological services, and Jacob Bjerknes, the famous Norwegian meteorologist, came to Portugal to meet with Portuguese authorities and discuss details concerning the Azores international station. Bjerknes came earlier to study the local weather and to get acquainted with the Portuguese meteorology services. In the last day of his visit, 23rd May, he went to the University of Coimbra with Carvalho Brandão, where he delivered a conference, later published in O Instituto, the journal of Coimbra’s academic society. He then referred to the important role Portugal might play in European weather forecast and described a project of establishing several stations in Northern Atlantic to collect transmissions from all ocean liners and communicate this information to the International Meteorological Organization, founded in 1873.
    [Show full text]
  • Ian Roulstone and John Norbury
    Irish Math. Soc. Bulletin Number 72, Winter 2013, 87{92 ISSN 0791-5578 Ian Roulstone and John Norbury: Invisible in the Storm: The Role of Mathematics in Understanding Weather, Princeton University Press, 2013, ISBN:978-0-691-15272-1, USD 35, 384 pp REVIEWED BY PETER LYNCH The development of mathematical models for weather prediction is one of the great scientific triumphs of the twentieth century. Ac- curate weather forecasts are now available routinely, and quality has improved to the point where occasional forecast failures evoke sur- prise and strong reaction amongst users. The story of how this came about is of great intrinsic interest. General readers, having no specialised mathematical knowledge beyond school level, will warmly welcome an accessible description of how weather forecasting and climate prediction are done. There is huge interest in weather forecasting and in climate change, as well as a demand for a well-written account of these subjects. In this book, the central ideas behind modelling, and the basic procedures under- taken in simulating the atmosphere, are conveyed without resorting to any difficult mathematics. The first chapter gives a good picture of the scientific background around 1900. It opens with an account of the circulation theorem derived by the Norwegian meteorologist Vilhelm Bjerknes. This theorem follows from work of Helmholtz and Kelvin, but makes allowance for a crucial property of the atmosphere, that pressure and density surfaces do not usually coincide. This is what is meant by the term baroclinicity. The theorem specifies how the circulation can change when baroclinicity is present. It enables us to calculate how vortices in the atmosphere and oceans behave, giving a holistic, but quantitative, description.
    [Show full text]
  • Carl-Gustaf Rossby: National Severe Storms Laboratory, a Study in Mentorship Norman, Oklahoma
    John M Lewis Carl-Gustaf Rossby: National Severe Storms Laboratory, A Study in Mentorship Norman, Oklahoma Abstract Meteorologist Carl-Gustaf Rossby is examined as a mentor. In order to evaluate him, the mentor-protege concept is discussed with the benefit of existing literature on the subject and key examples from the recent history of science. In addition to standard source material, oral histories and letters of reminiscence from approxi- mately 25 former students and associates have been used. The study indicates that Rossby expected an unusually high migh' degree of independence on the part of his proteges, but that he was HiGH exceptional in his ability to engage the proteges on an intellectual basis—to scientifically excite them on issues of importance to him. Once they were entrained, however, Rossby was not inclined to follow their work closely. He surrounded himself with a cadre of exceptional teachers who complemented his own heuristic style, and he further used his influence to establish a steady stream of first-rate visitors to the institutes. In this environment that bristled with ideas and discourse, the proteges thrived. A list of Rossby's proteges and the titles of their doctoral dissertations are also included. 1. Motivation for the study WEATHERMAN \ CARl-GUSTAF ROSSBY The process by which science is passed from one : UNIVERSITY or oKUtttflMMA \ generation to the next is a subject that has always LIBRARY I fascinated me. When I entered graduate school with the intention of preparing myself to be a research FIG. 1. A portrait of Carl-Gustaf Rossby superimposed on a scientist, I now realize that I was extremely ignorant of weather map that appeared on the cover of Time magazine, 17 the training that lay in store.
    [Show full text]