Landscape of Remembrance: Spatial Distribution of New Orleans Katrina Commemorations
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Landscape of Remembrance: Spatial Distribution of New Orleans Katrina Commemorations Mike Winiski – Furman University / Penn State University Drew Woten – Furman University Perspective “’Distant reading’ I have once called this type of approach; where distance is however not an obstacle but a specific form of knowledge: fewer elements, hence a sharper sense of their overall interconnection. Shapes, relations, structures. Forms. Models.” Moretti, 2005, Graphs, Maps, Trees Research Questions 1. How do the locations and forms of Katrina commemorations in greater New Orleans correspond to storm impact? 2. Are certain contingents, as represented by place and demographics, excluded from the commemoration process? 3. Do the form and nature of these commemorations vary across the city and different neighborhoods? If so, how? http://www.flickr.com/photos/midnightquill/416540958/sizes/z/in/photostream/ Defining Commemoration 1. Has a discernible location (temporary or permanent) 2. Visibly invokes a remembrance of Katrina event 3. Invokes memory of event or collective loss, rather than individual memorials (grave markers, etc.) Purpose of Commemorations • Remember • Grieve • Honor lost loved ones • Hold accountable / Ascribe responsibility • Express anger • Confirm community through shared experience • Tell stories • Express hope • Promote understanding within and beyond community http://photos.nola.com/photogallery/2010/08/hurricane_katrina_body_art_15.html http://www.flickr.com/photos/navillusphotography/3626506521/sizes/z/in/photostream/ http://www.flickr.com/photos/navillusphotography/3626506521/sizes/z/in/photostream/ Exclusion “Cultural, just as individual memory is an extremely narrow space regulated by rigid principles of selection and forgetting. Those who examined the borderline—Gray speaking for the poor peasants, Woolf speaking for women, Ellison speaking for African Americans— were for the first time calling attention to the structural mechanisms that exclude whole groups of the population from active participation in the cultural memory” (Assmann, 2009, p. 48). http://www.flickr.com/photos/13023662@N07/2095391083/sizes/l/in/photostream/ Categorizing Commemoration http://www.artscouncilofneworleans.org/article.php?story=20081208164221496 http://www.flickr.com/photos/michelledwright/5594207635/ “Tattoo artists interviewed by the Associated Press a year after the hurricane indicated that as many as half of their customers wanted storm-related http://photos.nola.com/photogallery/2010/08/hurricane_katrina_body_art_9.html inscriptions (Plaisance, 2006).” Gentry & Alderman, 2006, Trauma Written in Flesh, Tattoos as Memorials and Stories http://photos.nola.com/photogallery/2010/08/hurricane_katrina_body_art_43.html Methodology 1.Defining Commemoration and Category 2.Data Collection 3.Defining / Quantifying ‘Impact’ 4. Analysis Flood Depth Fatality Rate (The Times Picayune, 2009) New Orleans - Fatality Rate per Exposed Individual (Hurricane Katrina) Read Boulevard East Edgelake / Little Woods Lake Pontchartrain Lake Terrace / Lake Oaks West Lake Forest Pontchartrain Lakeshore / Lake Vista Read Boulevard Park Pines Milneburg West Village Plum Orchard St. Anthony West End Gentilly Fillmore Woods Lakeview Gentilly Viavant / Venetian Isles Terrace City Park Desire St. Bernard Dillard Area Navarre Lakewood Fairgrounds St. Roch Florida Dev Florida Area Seventh Ward Bayou Jefferson St. John St. Claude Dixon Mid-City Lower Ninth Ward Parish Treme / Lafitte Hollygrove Marigny Gerttown/ Iberville Bywater Zion City Tulane / Gravier Holy Cross French Quarter Parish St. Bernard Leonidas Marlyville/ B.W. Cooper Algiers Point Fontainbleau Central Business Arabi / Chalmette US Naval Base District Whitney East Carrollton Broadmoor McDonogh Central City Freret Lower Garden Black Pearl Behrman District Fischer Dev Audubon Milan Garden St. Thomas District Uptown Dev Old Aurora Touro Irish Tall Timbers/ Channel r East Riverside ve Brechtel Ri West Riverside pi ssip Missi New Aurora / English Turn Jefferson Parish Tall Timbers / Brechtel 0 1 2 4 Miles Legend fatility rate per exposed 0.000000 - 0.001107 0.001108 - 0.004036 0.004037 - 0.006522 0.006523 - 0.014330 0.014331 - 0.125731 Quantile Classification Lower Ninth Ward Community Village New Orleans - Percent Change in Total Population from Katrina to Present (2010) Village De L'Est Read Boulevard East Lake Pontchartrain Edgelake / Little Woods Lake Terrace / Lake Oaks West Lake Forest Pontchartrain Lakeshore / Lake Vista Read Boulevard Park Pines Milneburg West Village Plum Orchard St. Anthony West End Gentilly Fillmore Woods Lakeview Gentilly Terrace City Park Dillard Viavant / Venetian Isles Desire St. Bernard Area Navarre Lakewood Fairgrounds St. Roch Florida Dev Florida Area Seventh Ward Bayou Jefferson St. John St. Claude Dixon Mid-City Lower Ninth Ward Parish Treme / Lafitte Hollygrove Marigny Gerttown/ Iberville Bywater Zion City Tulane / Gravier Holy Cross French Quarter Parish St. Bernard Leonidas Marlyville/ B.W. Cooper Algiers Point Fontainbleau Central Business Arabi / Chalmette District WhitneyUS Naval Base East Carrollton Broadmoor McDonogh Central City Lower Garden Freret Behrman Meraux Black Pearl District Fischer Dev Audubon Milan Garden St. Thomas District Uptown Dev Old Aurora Irish Touro Tall Timbers/ Channel r East Riverside ve Brechtel Ri West Riverside pi ssip Missi New Aurora / English Turn Jefferson Parish Violet / Poydras St. Bernard Legend 0 1.75 3.5 7 Miles percent change from 2005 -99.67 - -51.39 -51.38 - -27.20 -27.19 - -19.84 -19.83 - -8.08 -8.07 - 0.00 Based on a comparison of 2010 census data and 0.01 - 15.90 2000 census data (adjusted for population loss 15.91 - 40.49 rates based on the American Community Survey - 2005 One-Year Estimates) manual classification New Orleans - Percent Change in Population pre-Katrina (June 2005) to June 2011 Village De L'Est Read Boulevard East Lake Pontchartrain Edgelake / Little Woods Lake Terrace / Lake Oaks West Lake Forest Pontchartrain Lakeshore / Lake Vista Read Boulevard Park Pines Milneburg West Village Plum Orchard St. Anthony West End Gentilly Fillmore Woods Gentilly Lakeview Viavant / Venetian Isles Terrace City Park Desire St. Bernard Dillard Area Navarre Lakewood Fairgrounds St. Roch Florida Dev Florida Area Seventh Ward Bayou Jefferson St. John St. Claude Dixon Mid-City Lower Ninth Ward Parish Treme / Lafitte Hollygrove Marigny Gerttown/ Iberville Bywater Zion City Tulane / Gravier Holy Cross French Quarter Parish St. Bernard Leonidas Marlyville/ B.W. Cooper Algiers Point Central Business Fontainbleau Arabi / Chalmette District WhitneyUS Naval Base East Carrollton Broadmoor McDonogh Central City Lower Garden Freret Behrman Meraux Black Pearl District Fischer Dev Audubon Milan Garden St. Thomas District Uptown Dev Old Aurora Irish Touro Tall Timbers/ Channel r East Riverside ve Brechtel Ri West Riverside pi ssip Missi New Aurora / English Turn Jefferson Parish Tall Timbers / Brechtel Legend nodata 0 1.5 3 6 Miles percent difference 05-11 -99.57 - -51.39 -51.38 - -27.20 -27.19 - -19.84 -19.83 - -8.08 -8.07 - 0.00 Based on Valassis database (addresses receiving mail) 0.01 - 15.90 provided by the GNOCDC 15.91 - 190.93 manual classification New Orleans - Change in Percent Children by Neighborhood 2000 vs. 2010 (based on US Census Data) Village De L'Est Read Boulevard East Lake Pontchartrain Edgelake / Little Woods Lake Terrace / Lake Oaks West Lake Forest Pontchartrain Lakeshore / Lake Vista Read Boulevard Park Pines Milneburg West Village Plum Orchard St. Anthony West End Gentilly Fillmore Woods Lakeview Gentilly Terrace Viavant / Venetian Isles City Park Dillard Desire St. Bernard Area Navarre Lakewood Fairgrounds St. Roch Florida Dev Florida Area Seventh Ward Bayou Jefferson St. John St. Claude Dixon Mid-City Lower Ninth Ward Parish Treme / Lafitte Hollygrove Marigny Gerttown/ Iberville Bywater Zion City Tulane / Gravier Holy Cross French Quarter Parish St. Bernard Leonidas Marlyville/ B.W. Cooper Algiers Point Fontainbleau Central Business Arabi / Chalmette District US Naval Base East Carrollton Broadmoor Whitney McDonogh Central City Lower Garden Freret Behrman Meraux Black Pearl District Milan Fischer Dev Audubon Garden District St. Thomas Uptown Dev Old Aurora Irish Touro Tall Timbers/ Channel r East Riverside ve Brechtel Ri West Riverside pi ssip Missi New Aurora / English Turn Jefferson Parish Legend 0 1.5 3 6 Miles change in percent children from 2000 to 2010 -21.60 - -7.67 -7.66 - -4.02 -4.01 - -2.17 -2.16 - -0.65 -0.64 - 4.13 Quantile Classification New Orleans - Percent Blighted Residences by Neighborhood (Sept 30, 2010 - HUD) Village De L'Est Read Boulevard East Lake Pontchartrain Edgelake / Little Woods Lake Terrace / Lake Oaks West Lake Forest Pontchartrain Lakeshore / Lake Vista Read Boulevard Park Pines Milneburg West Village Plum Orchard St. Anthony West End Gentilly Fillmore Woods Lakeview Gentilly Terrace City Park Viavant / Venetian Isles Desire St. Bernard Dillard Area Navarre Lakewood Fairgrounds St. Roch Florida Dev Florida Area Seventh Ward Bayou Jefferson St. John St. Claude Dixon Mid-City Lower Ninth Ward Parish Treme / Lafitte Hollygrove Marigny Gerttown/ Iberville Bywater Zion City Tulane / Gravier Holy Cross French Quarter Parish St. Bernard Leonidas Marlyville/ B.W. Cooper Algiers Point Fontainbleau Central Business Arabi / Chalmette District US Naval Base East Carrollton Broadmoor Whitney McDonogh Central City Lower Garden Freret Behrman Meraux Black Pearl District Milan Fischer Dev Audubon Garden