Architectsnewspaper 6.8.2004 Going to Seed
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
lit ARCHITECTSNEWSPAPER MoMA 049695 6.8.2004 06/16 $3.95 WWW.ARCHPAPER.COM $3.95 00 —I DILLER SCOFIDIO LU + RENFRO: NYC'S NEW URBAN O MASTERMINDS SUMMER READING REM FOR PRESIDENT? EAVESDROP USA 37 CURBSIDE DIARY CLASSIFIEDS ARCHITECTURE AND DESIGN SHOPTALK FEATURED ON NEW BATCH OF STAMPS MODERNIST GARDENS IN THE New York's modernist open spaces, such VILLAGE UNDER THREAT as the plaza of the Seagram Building and the courtyard of the Lever House, are well known, NEW LAW TO REQUIRE Bucky s Dome but the city's legacy of modernist gardens is MANDATORY CERTIFICATION more obscure and potentially under threat. FOR INTERIOR DESIGNERS R. Buckminster Fuller's bald geodesic head In Greenwich Village, two major examples— is about to appear on 96 million first-class GOING the formal garden that I. M. Pei designed in INTERIOR postage stamps. In addition to Bucky's 1965 to accompany his University Village tessellated head, the designs of Isamu towers between Houston, La Guardia and Noguchi, McKim, Mead, and White, Walter Bleecker streets, and the adjacent Washington DESIGNERS Netsch and Skidmore Owings and Merrill Square Village designed in 1959 by land• (SOM), and Rhode Island architect scape architecture firm Sasaki, Walker and GET SERIOUS Friedrich St. Florian will be appear on TO Associates—face uncertain futures. Both stamps this summer. surround New York University housing. The United States Postal Service (USPS) Apart from its value as a leafy respite, the The old turf dispute between New York receives nearly 50,000 requests a year for gardens of University Village are noteworthy. interior designers and architects could commemorative postage stamps, but only According to Andrew Berman, the executive arrive at a truce this June if a proposed bill 25 to 30 make it into production. The USPS director of the Greenwich Village Society for requiring certification for interior design• has few requirements for commemoration SEED Historic Preservation (GVSHP), the ers passes through the state legislature. beyond the obvious one—that the events, superblock is a particularly sensitive one: Historically, the two have been at odds over persons, or themes continued on page 3 "While it is the antithesis continued on page 7 the issue of interior design certification, with designers pushing for it as a way to gain greater professional legitimacy and RISING PRICES ARE THE NEW HEAVY Herzog & de Meuron's expansion Herzog & de Meuron's $67.5 million architects resisting it due to worries that of the Walker Art Center expansion of the Walker Art Center in IN THE CONSTRUCTION BUSINESS certification requirements aren't stringent Minneapolis mirrors and distorts the enough and will allow interior designers original 1971 building by Edward Larrabee to execute work for which they are inade• Barnes. The architects reorient the build• ARCHITECT, quately trained. ing toward Hennepin Avenue, a major The current interior design certification thoroughfare,"reinventing the museum STEEL THYSELF law, a 1990 measure that legally designated urbanistically," said Herzog at the project's interior design a profession in New York, unveiling in last week, and creating a new Since the middle of last year, the price of steel instituted a voluntary certification process "civic lounge." has skyrocketed, causing worries about bal• for designers in the state. Certification The architects chose light materials like looning construction costs and leading archi• requires the so-called "three Es": educa• metal and glass to oppose the brick of the tects and contractors to grapple with creative tion (two years), experience (five years), original building. The 260,000-.square- solutions to ensure that projects remain on and the NCIDG exam (1372 hours), and OWER WALKER foot addition and renovation will open track and within budget. bestows a designer with the official title in April 2005. JAMES WAY And the word "skyrocketing" isn't hyper• "certified interior designer." So far, fewer bole. Prices have increased by as much as 50 than 5 percent of New York designers have percent in the last six months: Scrap steel that elected to get certified. Under the amend• sold for $120 per ton last summer has recently ed act, assembly bill A-8587, certification been selling for upwards of $250 per ton. would become mandatoryforall those wish• "It's having an effect," said Kenneth Drucker, ing to identify themselves as interior design• design partner for Hellmuth, Obata and ers. Exempted individuals would include Kassabaum (HOK). "It's causing people to architects and uncertified designers with hurry up and bid their projects. And some 15 years experience who apply within a clients who would have done a steel build• window of approximately one year after ing as a matter ofcourse are now looking at the passing of the amendment. concrete." continued on page 2 continued on page 2 00 CM 3 O LU THE ARCHITECT'S NEWSPAPER JUNE 8, 2004 INTERIOR DESIGNERS GET SERIOUS Architects have a unique relationship to architectural books. They continued from front page Diana Darling love to acquire them, display them, thumb through them, but almost The bill's biggest supporter is Interior O Designers for Legislation in New York State Cathy Lang Ho I- never read them from beginning to end. Archigram's Peter Cook, an HH (IDLNY), an organization founded in 1984 William Menking academic and now practicing architect, claims,"! don't read books, by architecture-trained designer Ruth I only write them." LU Lynford as a means of unifying the voices Martin Perrin There are reasons—beyond perhaps architects' fetishistic tenden• of interior design organizations such as cies—to explain their biblioholic nature. Umberto Eco conveys the the American Society of Interior Designers Deborah Grossberg point best in his essay "How To Justify a Private Library," from his (ASID) and the International Interior Design James Way Association (IIDA)that support the bill. Jim book How To Travel with a Salmon (Harcourt, 1994). He describes Lothrop, president of IDLNY, explained Jonathan Chaffin his sizable library and his annoyance with the typical reaction of the group's view of the importance of visitors: "What a lot of books! Have you read them all?" He is sur• the new measure: "Right now, I could call Anne Guiney prised that many people, evidently, "consider a book shelf as mere myself an interior designer if I was a fifth storage place for already-read books and do not think of the library grade student. It's not currently recognized Paula Lehman as a working tool." as a profession by the public." Lothrop is an architect and partner at Valhalla based For architects, the tool analogy is especially apt. People don't use Keith James Lothrop Associates. their hammer or screwdriver everyday, but are grateful when the Lovejoy Duryea, chair of the interior Paul Beatty items are in the toolbox when needed. Architects use books as design department at the School of Visual sources of reference and inspiration. Current books, whether theo• Arts, agreed, "It's to the benefit of every• retical tracts or monographs on the works of other architects, are a body who practices in a professional way. The main thing is to get rid of the people CONTRIBUTORS means of staying connected and provide a sort of continuing educa• who are just putting up shingles and print• PHILIPPE BARRIERE/ARIC CHEN/ tion that the discipline requires. ing business cards without any training." MURRAY FRASER/RICHARD INGERSOLL / "Architects can only gain from it," said JOE KERR/DANE LEFAIVRE / JAMES PETO/ Of course, the quantity of architectural books published every year LUIGI PRESTINENZA PUGLISI/KESTER RATTEN8URY/ is something to be envied by other professions. Architects must be John Mack, a partner at the architecture D.GRAHAME SHANE/PETER SLATIN perennially torn over which titles deserve their hard-earned dollars and interiors firm HLW."Requiring certifi• ANDREW YANG/PETER ZELLNER cation improves the quality of the design and precious bookshelf space, with so many tempting offerings profession overall." from academic presses, specialized, intellectual imprints, purveyors PAOLA ANTONELLI/RAUL A. BARRENECHE/ The AIA New York chapter's (AIA-NY) M. CHRISTINE BOYER/PETER COOK/ of beautiful monographs, and of course, publishers of technical main gripe with the bill involves its WHITNEY COX/ODILE DECO/TOM HANRAHAN/ handbooks. In this issue, we recommend several titles grouped under exemptions. AlA-NY's lobbyists have suc• SARAH HERDA/CRAIG KONYK/JAYNE MERKEL/ ceeded in upping the experience prereq• LISA NAFTOLIN / SIGNE NIELSEN / the feature "Summer Reading," with the idea that summer is the per• uisite for exemptions from the originally JOAN OCKMAN / HANS ULRICH OBRIST/ fect catch-up season—for catching up on rest, relaxation, a long- KYONG PARK/ANNE RIESELBACH/ proposed 5 years to 15, and are currently TERENCE RILEY / KEN SAYLOR / MICHAEL SORKIN postponed vacation, or self-assigned homework. working on clarifying the exact process This issue also contains a long review of Content, Rem Koolhaas' by which exemptions will be awarded. GENERAL INFORMATION: [email protected] "If you're going to set up a certification EDITORIAL: [email protected] latest venture. Koolhaas isn't the first architect to use books as an process with minimum qualifications, DIARY: [email protected] important part of his professional practice, but he is perhaps one of ADVERTISING: [email protected] then everyone should have to meet the SUBSCRIPTION: [email protected] the most successful. Critic Richard Ingersoll observes that, compara• requirements," said Mark Ginsberg, PLEASE NOTIFY US IF YOU ARE RECEIVING ble to the trend of architects branching out into architecture-related president of AIA-NY. "In general we're DUPLICATE COPIES. services as a means of diversifying their business, Koolhaas has creat• supportive, but the issue of grandfathering has not yet been resolved." THE VIEWS OF OUR REVIEWEflS AND COLUMNISTS 00 NOT ed AMO, a think tank of sorts.