Enforcement Notice Register 1999

Enforcement Register

Reference Site and planning breach Notice/Authorised Served To comply Notes/appeal Thorpe Underwood Hall LB Enf 22.12.98 18.3.99 3.8.99 Appeal dismissed. High Court- dismissed Removal of chimney from listed building Complied 3.10.02

71 Station Parade, Harrogate LB Enf 19.10.98 5.2.99 15.6.99 Remedial works done. Company cautioned Unauthorised alterations - staircase, new mezzanine floor, new display units & new Complied 10.12.99 window display areas Posh Paws, 34b Leeds Road, Harrogate Enf - 14.12.98 13.4.99 25.11.99 Complied - 24.11.99 Unauthorised portacabin

24 Magdalens Road, Ripon LB Enf 23.11.98 19.4.99 8.4.2000 Appeal Dismissed Unauthorised conservatory 8.6.2000 Complied 21.5.01

Land adj to 10 Fieldway Close S215 C4226.4.99 28.5.99 28.7.99 Complied 8.9.99 Adverse condition of land

5 Meadowcroft, Harrogate Enf - 26.4.99 21.5.99 1.1.2000 Complied 11.1.2000 Unauthorised conservatory

13 Ely Close, Harrogate Enf - 19.4.99 10.5.99 19.7.99 Unauthorised material change of use to mixed residential/retail sale of motor vehicles

Land to South of Bayer UK, Ripon Enf - 1.2.99 25.5.99 19.7.99 Complied -10.11.99 Unauthorised construction of an industrial unit Appeal dismissed without cladding Lane End Farm, Kirkby Overblow Enf - 10.5.99 8.6.99 19.10.99 Appeal dismissed Construction of dwellinghouse on the land and 14.2.2000 use of land for mixed purposes of agricultural and Complied 23.5.02 residential occupation Page 1 Enforcement Register Reference Site and Planning Breach Notice/authorised Served to comply Notes/appeal

16 Silver Street, Masham Appeal dismissed - 5.10.99 Formation of access to the highway, demolition of Enf - 21.6.99 6.7.99 30.6.2000 part of front garden wall and railing Complied 28.11.01

2 - 8 Park Street, Masham Enf - 21.6.99 7.7.99 17.11.99 Complied - 3.7.00 Removal of original shop front and replacement with new design

40 High Street, Knaresborough LB Enf - 22.6.99 19.7.99 30.11.99 Unauthorised fascia board

(Re-issue of notice) LB Enf - 22.6.99 10.11.99 15.3.00 Complied - 21.11.00

Hazel House, Little Ouseburn Enf - 22.6.99 20.7.99 30.11.99 Stationing of portacabin on agricultural land Complied - 29.8.01

8 York Place, Knaresborough LB Enf - 22.6.99 19.7.99 30.11.99 Appeal dismissed 02.02.00 Unauthorised fascia boards Complied 10.5.00

57 High Street, Knaresborough LB Enf - 22.6.99 4.10.99 12.2.2000 Appeal dismissed 27.04.00 Unauthorised rendering on listed building Complied 28.11.00

2 Kings Road, Harrogate LB Enf - 21.6.99 10.9.99 15.1.2000 Complied 10.3.00 Unauthorised entranceway and surround

OS 2114, Smelthouses, Harrogate Enf - 21.6.99 8.10.99 19.5.2000 Appeal dismissed Unauthorised erection of timber stables and Complied 01.03.01 tack room on concrete base

Page 2 Enforcement Register

Reference Site and Planning Breach Notice/Authorised Served To comply Notes/Appeal

OS 9500, Newall Carr Road, Clifton Enf - 9.8.99 14.10.99 23.5.2000 Appeal dismissed Stationing of 2 caravans used for residential Complied - 31.5.01 purposes

6 Kings Road, Harrogate Enf - 11.10.99 27.10.99 3.3.2000 Complied 18.7.01 Unauthorised replacement window frames 2nd notice 19.11.99 23.3.2000

123 Forest Lane, Harrogate Enf - 1.11.99 - - Unauthorised business use

7 Castlegate, Knaresborough LB Enf - 1.11.99 8.12.99 28.5.2000 Complied 8.1.01 Unauthorised UPVC windows Appeal dismissed OS 1433, Skipton Road, Felliscliffe Enf - 8.11.99 6.6.00 17.10.00 Planning application to retain building Unauthorised dwellinghouse as a store allowed on appeal.

Birchfield Farm, Summerbridge LB Enf - 8.11.99 9.12.99 24.7.2000 Planning permission granted 22.01.02 Unauthorised Lean-to extension

Whixley Hospital Site Enf - 12.10.99 - - Complied 6.1.2000 Provision of footpath

91 Knaresborough Road, Harrogate Enf - 16.11.99 28.1.00 1.6.00 Complied 20.6.00 Replacement of glazed windows with hoarding

1 Baldwin Street, Harrogate S215 - 16.11.99 29.3.00 1.6.00 Complied 4.4.2000 Condition of site OS 0525, Thistle Hill, Knaresborough Enf - 20.12.99 23.4.00 12.10.00 Appeal dismissed Unauthorised hardstanding/track (Notice 2) 12.12.00 Complied 23.1.04 Caravans, Materials storage (Notice 1) Page 3 Enforcement Register

Reference Site and Planning Breach Notice/Authorised Served To comply Notes/Appeals

OS 5419 Galphay Rd, Kirkby Malzeard Enf - 20.11.99 Caravan and condition of site S215 - 20.11.99 23.10.00 27.12.00 Complied 27.12.00

24 Magdalens Road, Ripon LB Enf - 7.12.98 19.4.99 30.9.99 Appeal dismissed 8.12.99 Unauthorised UPVC window Compliance 21.5.01

Huntsman Inn, Station Rd, Cattal Enf - 28.2.00 10.5.00 31.12.2000 Appeal dismissed Condition of site(S215) and unauthorised earth S215 - 28.2.00 10.5.00 03.08.2000 Complied 8.9.03 bund, COU of land to storage & formation of compound

Nethernooks Barn, West End, S'Bridge Enf - 28.2.00 15.6.00 25.8.00 granted Erection of post and wire fence and gate 07.11.00

Lanzecki House, West End, Summerbridge Enf - 28.2.00 15.6.00 .9.00 & 28.1. Withdrawn 15.6.00 Unauthorised hardstanding and construction of New notice to be issued dry stonewall

00/00199/PR15 Land at Birchfield Farm, Summerbridge Enf - 19.6.00 19.09.00 30.01.2001 Complied 15.10.02 Unauthorised hardstanding

Skipbridge Café, Green Hammerton Enf - 31.1.2000 3.4.2000 05.08.00 Appeal allowed. Notice quashed. Unauthorised structure (portacabin/trailer)

70 Cornwall Road, Harrogate Enf - 17.4.00 24.5.00 26.7.00 GF Complied - 26.7.00 Implement noise attenuation scheme 26.12.00 1F Complied - 14.2.01

78 High Street, Knaresborough LB Enf - 19.6.00 10.7.00 21.11.00 Complied - 5.2.01 Unauthorised illuminated fascia board

Page 4 Enforcement Register

Reference Site and planning breach Notice/authorised Served to comply Notes 13 North Street, Ripon Enf - 19.6.00 13.7.00 23.11.00 Appeal Dismissed 13.11.00 Unauthorised cladding to front exterior Complied - 12.4.01

17-19 Westgate, Ripon LB Urgent Works 13.9.00 23.9.00 Works in default carried out Urgent repair works 27.7.00 Complied 11.03.2001

Caffe Nero, 64-68 Station Pde, Harrogate Enf - 4.9.00 13.10.00 23.2.01 Planning appeal allowed Unauthorised shop front Notice quashed

44 High Street, Knaresborough S215 - 11.9.00 17.10.00 20.2.01 Complied 3.7.01 Adverse condition of building

Land at High Common Farm, Palace Rd, Enf - 19.6.00 11.10.00 15.12.00 Appeal withdrawn Ripon Storage of commercial vehicles and equipment on car park Complied 24.1.01

Railway Embankment, Rock Hall, Nidd Enf - 22.5.00 23.11.00 4.7.01 Appeal dismissed. Removal of section of railway embankment 19.7.03 complied 15.10.03 Invalid - (Crown Land). Works carried 64 Druids Meadow, Boroughbridge Enf - 13.11.00 28.11.00 9.3.01 out by Council at owner's cost Change of use of Public Open Space to domestic garden Complied 15 May 2002

00/00154/PR15 6 Manor Court, Kirkby Malzeard, Ripon Enf - 11.12.00 26.3.01 Unauthorised extension of domestic curtilage into 8.11.01 Appeal dismissed 14.01.02 agricultural land Planting of border hedge 8.5.02

00/00389/PR15 57/57a Bond End, Knaresborough LB - 11.12.00 8.2.01 26.6.01 Complied - 20.6.01 Unauthorised windows Page 5 Enforcement Register

Reference Site and planning breach Notice/authorised Served to comply Notes

Sycamore Cottage, Kirkby Overblow Enf - 26.5.98 Planning appeal dismissed Unauthorised garden extension site cleared 15.10.200 58 Lead Lane, Ripon Enf - 4.12.00 20.12.00 14.5.01 complied 14.5.01 Storage, parking and repair of vehicles, scrap metal spare parts, and timber not associated with domestic use of the property

00/00474/PR15 Harrogate RAFC, Station View, Harrogate Enf - 20.9.00 4.1.01 14.3.01 appeal withdrawn Unauthorised erection of a telecommunications mast Complied 16.8.01

99/00183/PR15 82 High Street, Knaresborough LB Enf - 30.10.00 26.1.01 9.7.01 appeal withdrawn Timber boarding to Ground floor elevation. Complied 03.08.01 Removal of ceiling (gr floor) and cornice detail.

00/00330/PR15 Jinnah, Devonshire Place, Harrogate Enf - 11.12.00 1.2.01 13.4.01 appeal dismissed Unauthorised lamp columns (4) 7.9.01 Complied 12.9.01

00/00356/PR15 OS1800, Moor Lane, Arkendale Enf - 15.1.01 26.2.01 16.4.01 Complied 3.8.01 Change of use of agricultural to mixed - storage of soil, pallets, roof tiles, wood, broken concrete and siting of contractors hut.

00/00122/PR15 21 Coltsgate Hill,p Ripon LB Enf 04.12.00 9.3.01 26.07.01 Complied 20.2.02 Building 00/00139/PR15 3 West View, Wath Enf - 13.11.00 15.3.01 17.07.01 Complied 18.7.01 Unauthorised vehicular access

00/00079/PR15 Land at Back Lane, Kirkby Malzeard Enf - 27.11.00 26.3.01 08.02.02 Complied 01.08.02 Use of land for parking of buses/coaches Page 6 Enforcement Register

Reference Site/Planning Breach Notice/Authorised Served To comply Notes

00/00131/PR15 2 West View, Wath Enf - 13.11.00 26.3.01 28.07.01 Complied by 08.04.04 Unauthorised vehicular access

00/00462/PR15 Grosvenor Buildings, Crescent Road appeal - Inquiry 11.12.01 1. Unit 4 - Unauthorised shopfront LB Enf - 16.1.01 19.4.01 31.8.01 2. Flat 25 - 3 x unauthorised dormer windows LB Enf - 16.1.01 19.4.01 31.8.01 Planning permission granted 29.07.02 Appeal allowed 00/00515/PR15 Ripon Canal Basin, Boroughbridge Rd. Ripon Enf - 19.3.01 27.4.01 29.7.01 Notice quashed Unauthorised doors and windows Notice re-issued 4.5.01 11.8.01

00/00230/PR15 31 North Lodge Avenue, Harrogate Enf - 30.4.01 6.6.01 17.10.01 Complied 28.11.01 Unauthorised rear balcony

98/00297/PR15 Old Church Lane Cottage, Pateley Bridge Enf - 8.5.01 15.6.01 23.9.01 Planning permission granted 27.05.02 Unauthorised aerial mast

00/00204/PR15 103 Skipton Road, Harrogate Enf - 11.6.01 27.6.01 8.9.01 Complied 14.12.01 Erection of unauthorised fence

00/00355/PR15 West Acres, Gale Lane, Stainburn Enf - 18.4.01 26.6.01 30.9.01 Appeal dismissed Unauthorised track and COU of agricultural land 31.03.02 comply by (new date) to mixed - residential/agricultural Complied by 12.11.02

00/00290/PR01 OS Field 9850, Darley, Harrogate Enf - 9.7.01 10.8.01 21.12.01 Appeal withdrawn Unauthorised access track Complied by 29.05.02

00/00365/PR15 21a Bond End, Knaresborough LB Enf - 18.6.01 10.8.01 21.12.01 Complied 5th March 2002 Unauthorised UPVC windows in LB

Page 7 Enforcement Register

Reference Site/Planning Breach Notice/Authorised Served To Comply Notes 00/00484/PR15 Old Vicarage, Gallowgate Lane, Weeton Enf - 18.6.01 16.8.01 27.12.01 Appeal dismissed Unauthorised ornamental lamp posts Complied by 10.10.02

00/00392/PR15 Land to East of Regent Avenue, Harrogate Enf - 23.7.01 28.8.01 30.12.01 7.12.02 Building/roofing business (enclosure and storage) 2nd Enf Notice 21.1.02 26.5.02 Both notices complied by 4.4.03

Brackenfield School, Duchy Road 00/00376/PR15 Harrogate Enf - 23.7.01 11.9.01 23.12.01 Appeal) - Public Inquiry 25/26.9.02 Unauthorised use of land as play area for Enf - 23.7.01 7.3.02 11.6.02 Appeal) - Allowed 8th January 2003 children's school Notice quashed

01/00325/PR15 Land adj to 302 Skipton Road, Harrogate Enf - 15.10.01 28.11.01 16.01.02 Complied - 5.12.01 Unauthorised display of vehicles for sale on the highway

00/00085/PR15 28 Devonshire Place, Harrogate LB Repair 30.11.01 9.4.02 See Schedule of Repairs attached to Urgent repairs - see notice 8.10.01 Notice. Repairs complete 14.11.03

00/00368/PR15 Land at Halfpenny Close, Knaresborough Enf - 28.8.01 27.2.02 10.6.02 Notice mainly complied with, not suitable for Construction of highway not completed prosecution, case closed (units in use) Bridge Hewick House, Boroughbridge Appeal lodged - 8.4.02 01/00427/PR15 Road, Ripon Enf - 10.12.01 28.2.02 11.7.02 Appeal dismissed 14.10.02 Unauthorised construction of dwelling (part 14.4.03 Certificate of Lawfulness - Permitted completed) and detached garage 12.10.2006

01/00071/PR15 Land rear of White Swan PH, Minskip Enf - 25.2.02 26.04.02 31.07.02 Complied by 5.8.02 Use of land for caravan site

Page 8 Enforcement Register

Reference Site/Planning Breach Notice/Authorised Served To Comply Notes Main windows replaced, 2 small windows 02/00039/LB Prospect House, Old Bilton, Harrogate LB Enf 29.04.02 05.06.02 17.01.03 in extension still to be replaced Unauthorised UPVC windows Complied 24.5.04

99/00183/PR15 82 High Street, Knaresborough LB Rep - 27.02.02 28.05.02 27.09.02 Complied 29.9.05 Urgent repairs - see notice for schedule

01/00302/PR15 Sutton Barn, Masham, Ripon Enf - 18.02.02 16.05.02 28.09.02 Complied 4.4.03 Extension of domestic curtilage & fencing issues New date: appeal lodged - 18.7.02

00/00411/PR15 Bordar House, 13 Market Place, Masham. LB Enf -14.01.02 10.6.02 New date: appeal dismissed - 19.2.03 Unauthorised canopy 19.04.03 Complied 18.3.03 22.09.02 appeal lodged - 17.7.02 00/00413/PR15 Joneva, 7 Market Place, Masham LB Enf - 14.1.02 10.6.02 New date: appeal dismissed - 17.2.03 2 unauthorised canopies 17.4.03 Complied 15.4.03

00/00424/PR15 Floodlite Restaurant, 7 Silver St. Masham LB Enf - 14.1.02 10.6.02 22.9.02 Complied 01.05.03 Unauthorised canopy

98/00295/PR15 6 Knaresborough Road, Harrogate Enf - 24.4.02 24.06.02 20.11.02 Complied - 1.10.02 Unauthorised shop front

01/00408/PR15 Horseshoe Cottage, Great Ouseburn Enf - 10.6.02 9.7.02 21.11.02 Appeal lodged - 21.8.02 Unauthorised hardstanding/parking area & breach Appeal allowed - 22.1.03 subject to of Conditions 2, 10 & 11 of 6.80.23.F.FUL change in materials - Complied 19.3.03

01/00274/PR15 Carr Lodge Farm/Cottage, Dacre Enf - 7.5.02 19.7.02 30.11.02 Appeal lodged - 29.8.02 Unauthorised use of extension as separate New date: Appeal dismissed - 20.2.03 dwelling,non-construction of internal doorways as 20.5.03 Complied by 11.4.03 approved, insertion of unauthorised staircase

Page 9 Enforcement Register

Reference Site/Planning Breach Notice/Authorised Served Comply by Notes

01/00337/PR15 40 Duchy Road, Harrogate Enf - 10.6.02 23.7.02 3.12.02 Appeal lodged - 21.8.02 Unauthorised construction of ground floor rear new date: Appeal dismissed 3.1.03 extension including first floor terrace 3.4.03 Complied by 16.05.03

00/00242/PR15 The Thatched Cottage, Summerbridge Enf - 26.06.02 14.8.02 20.12.02 Complied 13.1.05 Change of use of the land from agricultural to use as a domestic garden 02/00230/PR15 Land r/o The Sycamores, Summerbridge Enf - 26.06.02 11.09.02 20.5.03 Appeal lodged - 22.10.02 Unauthorised change of use of land from appeal dismissed - 20.2.03 agricultural to use as domestic garden Complied 13.11.03

00/00203/PR15 2 Park Parade, Harrogate LB Enf - 18.06.01 19.9.02 1.5.03 Installation of 3 x UPVC windows to first floor Complied 13.9.06 front elevation

01/00351/PR15 Ripon Canal Basin Phase II 4 BCN - 24.06.02 12.9.03 12.12.03 Complied 12.12.03 Conditions 14, 19, 16, 20 & 8 of 6.31.1578.PA Conditions 6, 11, 8, 12 and 5 of 6.31.1578.E.FUL Planning permission granted 24.2.03 02/00018/PR15 Bishops Barn, B'bridge Rd, Bishop Monkton Enf - 7.10.02 Notice not issued Unauthorised extension to domestic curtilage Appeal lodged 29.10.02 01/00407/PR15 Spring Mount, Moorcock Lane, Darley Enf - 9.8.02 14.10.02 1.3.03 Appeal withdrawn 16.12.02 Unauthorised access and access track Complied 4.2.04 Compulsory purchase order being considered. 01/00384/PR15 179 Woodfield Road, Harrogate S215 - 21.10.02 22.1.03 2.4.03 Report to CMT/Cabinet being prepared Adverse condition of building/site Complied 18.2.11 appeal lodged 27.11.02 01/00237/PR15 6 Cecil Street, Harrogate Enf - 4.10.02 22.10.02 02.02.03 Appeal allowed, notice quashed. Construction of rooftop terrace on garage Page 10 Enforcement Register

Reference Site/Planning Breach Notice/Authorised Served Comply by Notes

99/00478/PR15 10 Wellington Gardens, Ripon Enf - 18.6.01 21.11.02 10.7.03 appeal lodged - 11.2.03 Removal of Earth bund/banking, extension of Appeal dismissed 28.5.03 garden curtilage, unauthorised fence, decking 28.11.03 area & steps.

99/00478/PR15 11 Wellington Gardens, Ripon Enf - 18.6.01 21.11.02 10.7.03 Appeal lodged 3.1.03 Removal of earth bund/banking, extension of 28.11.03 appeal dismissed 28.5.03 garden + timber store

99/00478/PR15 13 Wellington Gardens, Ripon Enf - 18.6.01 21.11.02 10.7.03 Removal of earth bund/banking and construction of paved area for access to riverbank

99/00478/PR15 12 Wellington Gardens, Ripon Enf - 18.6.01 21.11.02 10.7.03 Appeal lodged 9.1.03 Removal of earth bund/banking, extension of 28.11.03 Appeal dismissed 28.5.03 garden curtilage, removal of authorised fence and fence erected on unauthorised garden extension and installation of steps

99/00478/PR15 15 Wellington Gardens, Ripon Enf - 18.6.01 21.11.02 10.7.03 Complied by 14.05.03 Removal of earth bund/banking and extension of garden curtilage, removal of authorised fencing and installation of decking and fencing

99/00478/PR15 16 Wellington Gardens, Ripon Enf - 18.6.01 21.11.02 10.7.03 Complied by 21.2.03 Removal of earth bund/banking, extension of garden curtilage, removal of authorised fencing and installation of unauthorised fencing, decking/ patio area in unauthorised extension

Page 11 Enforcement Register

Reference Site/Planning Breach Notice/Authorised Served Comply by Notes

99/00478/PR15 17 Wellington Gardens, Ripon Enf - 18.6.01 21.11.02 10.7.03 Complied by 28.05.2003 Removal of earth bund/banking to rear of property

99/00478/PR15 20 Wellington Gardens, Ripon Enf - 18.6.01 21.11.02 10.7.03 Removal of earth bund/banking to rear of property

02/00399/PR01 Burley Bank Farm, Killinghall Enf - 25.11.02 Matter resolved before notice issued Demolition of 2 stone barns rather than conversion 01/00321/PR15 2 Doublegates Avenue, Ripon Enf - 25.11.02 27.1.03 23.12.03 Appeal dismissed 23.9.03 Unauthorised use of site for operation of a taxi New Date Complied 8.4.04 business (including parking of vehicles in 23.12.03 surrounding area.) 02/00306/PR15 Land at Belle Vue Terrace, Ripon Enf - 13.01.03 12.02.03 26.5.03 Complied with 22.12.03 (Ashville 4) Unauthorised material change of use of the land to a use for storage of building materials and waste materials

01/00317/PR15 OS 2067, Leathley Lane, Leathley Enf - 25.11.02 Works to comply done by 25.7.03 Erection of storage building and formation of paved hardstanding area

02/00390/PR15 Beckwithshaw Grange, Howhill Quarry Rd Enf - 31.3.03 Conversion of garaging/linkway to additional living accommodation; development of out building; access/drive; extension of curtilage; lighting and raising of roadside walls. Page 12 Enforcement Register

Reference Site/Planning Breach Notice/Authorised Served Comply by Notes

03/00038/PR15 Holme Farm Barn, Darley Enf - 10.3.03 16.6.03 27.5.04 Appeal dismissed - 27.11.03 land Complied 13.7.04

02/00248/PR15 Harefield Hall, Pateley Bridge Enf - 31.3.03 11.6.03 22.10.03 Appeal Lodged 11.8.03 Use of land for paint balling and erection of timber Appeal allowed 24.4.04 structures and netting Notice quashed, planning permission granted Enf - 07.04.03 6.6.03 11.11.03 appeal lodged 10.7.03 00/00013/PR15 Weeton Bridge House, Main Street, Weeton Enf - 07.04.03 6.6.03 11.11.03 appeal lodged 10.7.03 1. Unauthorised triple garage building, public inquiry 16.12.03 2. Extension of domestic curtilage NOTICES WITHDRAWN - 15.12.03

03/00162/PR15 Flats 1, 2, 3 & 4, 59-61 Cold Bath Road Enf - 19.5.03 18.6.03 30.10.03 Appeal Dismissed 14.11.03 Harrogate, North Yorkshire New date Unauthorised insertion of UPVC windows 14.2.04 Complied 02.07.04

03/00161/PR15 Land East/Rear Regent Avenue, Harrogate Enf - 7.7.03 21.7.03 8.10.03 Complied 3.9.03 1. Use of the land as a site for a caravan 2. Use of the land for residential occupation of a caravan 3. Use of land for the parking of motor vehicles in association with the use of the caravan

03/00309/PR15 The Bay Horse, Burnt Yates, Harrogate Enf - 8.9.03 15.9.03 27.11.03 Complied 1.11.03 Unauthorised change of use of car park to caravan site

Page 13 Enforcement Register

Reference Site/Planning Breach Notice/Authorised Served Comply by Notes Windows to front elevation replaced 00/00282/PR15 14a Prospect Place, Harrogate LB Enf -21.07.03 21.10.03 30.5.04 Windows to rear elevation have not Insertion of upvc windows to listed building Notice not complied with

02/00128/PR15 27 The Whinfields, Summerbridge Enf - 03.11.03 28.11.03 9.4.04 Appeal lodged Unauthorised conservatory to front elevation appeal dismissed 21.4.04 21.7.04 1.12.03 03/00340/PR15 Redrow Homes @ St Georges Road, H'gate 2 x Breach of 21.11.03 19.12.03 Breach of Conditions 9 + 12 of 6.79.5112.L.FUL Condition Notices (relating to foul and surface water drainage) appeal lodged 10.2.04 00/00280/PR15 Flat 4, 12 Prospect Place, Harrogate LB Enf - 21.7.03 29.1.04 9.9.04 Appeal dismissed 23.8.04 Unauthorised UPVC windows in Listed Building Complied 21.4.09

03/00174/PR15 Ashwood, Low Moor Lane, Scotton Enf - 09.02.04 Unauthorised use of agricultural land Change of use of agricultural land to form ceased, fence erected along authorised unauthorised extension to domestic curtilage boundary. 20.4.04

03/00112/PR15 Braythorne Fold, Stainburn Enf - 19.1.04 Application for retention of alterations Unauthorised Alteration and Re-cladding of and change of use approved 3.9.04 Redundant Dairy Parlour Building

02/00406/PR15 Sicklinghall House, Longlands Lane, Enf - 27.3.04 6.5.04 18.9.04 appeal dismissed - 23.12.04 Sicklinghall New date Unauthorised change of use of land to domestic 23.03.05 Complied 13.2.06 curtilage

02/00261/PR15 Horsemill Cottage, Mill Lane, Markington Enf - 07.06.04 Works carried out to remove domestic Unauthorised change of use of agricultural land appearance of land, case closed to domestic curtilage Page 14 Enforcement Register

Reference Site/Planning Breach Notice/Authorised Served Comply by Notes

03/00361/PR15 1 Norton Close, Wath, Ripon Enf - 21.06.04 6.8.04 17.12.04 Complied 04.09.07 Unauthorised extension of domestic curtilage into agricultural land

03/00466/PR15 The Paddocks, Myers Green Lane, Enf - 05.07.04 14.07.04 27.11.04 Owner not found, legal action to be taken Killinghall Change of use of land from agricultural to storage of building materials, sheds and derelict vehicles and vehicle parts

03/00136/PR15 Low Foulgate Farm, Grewelthorpe Enf - 1.4.04 Not issued, retrospective permission granted Unauthorised extensions to barn + dwelling 16.1.06

03/00224/PR15 Studley Royal Cricket Club, Studley Roger Enf - 01.06.04 29.7.04 09.12.04 Planning permission granted 9.12.04 Siting of steel box containers on land and use for storage (+ removal of embankment to allow siting of containers)

03/00317/PR15 Land rear of Castra, Park Road, Spofforth Enf - 16.08.04 9.9.04 20.01.05 Appeal allowed, notice quashed 20.5.05 Fenced horse exercise area, hard surfaced track, storage of bricks and other building materials

00/00427/PR15 Rougham Farm, Arkendale Enf - 13.9.04 4.10.04 15.5.05 Appeal allowed - 25.5.05 Erection of building and creation of hardstanding Notice quashed

02/00250/PR15 Little Paddocks, Main Street, Sicklinghall Enf - 11.10.04 11.11.04 24.03.05 Unauthorised erection of tennis pavilion and hard- Appeal allowed, notice quashed, 1.8.05 surface base outside domestic curtilage

Page 15 Enforcement Register

Reference Site/Planning Breach Notice/Authorised Served Comply by Notes

04/00384/PR15 11 Leadhall Way, Harrogate Enf - 8.11.04 Failure to comply with conditions 4,6,7,8 & 13 of granted planning permission 6.79.7893.E.FUL

03/00086/PR15 47 New Lane, Green Hammerton Enf - 15.11.04 Report to Chair/HOPS 16 May 05 - resolved no Erection of 2 Pergola timber structures further action

01/00050/PR15 Able Blast, Rudgate, Tockwith Enf - 27.9.04 10.1.05 21.03.05 Complied - 21.11.2006 Use of land for shot/sand blasting business

04/00184/PR15 Caravan @ Church Lane, North Rigton Enf - 10.1.05 28.2.05 11.5.05 Notice Withdrawn 16th March 2005 Siting of caravan in field 30.6.05 11.9.05 New Notice issued Complied - 24 October 2005 04/00395/PR15 28 Westbourne Grove, Ripon Unuathorised erection of garden shed without planning permission and in breach of Condition Enf - 24.1.05 14.2.05 28.4.05 Complied 16th May 2005 19 of 6.31.1724.D.FUL (re: visibility splays)

01/00108/PR15 OS 6310 & 6915 Cass Lane, Knaresborough Enf - 15.2.05 3.3.05 15.10.05 Unauthorised construction of concrete base and erection of stable building and unauthorised Notice Withdrawn 11.11.05 stationing of 2 portable buildings

04/00164/PR15 Land to the North of Elm Gable, Haggs Rd Enf - 16.5.05 14.6.05 1.8.06 Appeal - Public Inquiry 7.02.06 Follifoot new date Appeal dismissed 21.2.06 Unauthorised residential occupation of static 21.2.07 Court - minor fine. New court date needed caravan & construction of 2 buildings

Page 16 Enforcement Register

Reference Site/Planning Breach Notice/Authorised Served Comply by Notes

04/00334/PR15 30 Cambridge Street, Harrogate Enf - 27.6.05 14.12.06 1.5.07 Appeal Allowed 03.07.2007 Unauthorised replacement of first floor window Notice quashed frame with a metal louvre

05/00111/PR15 Rose Villa, Skelton Road, Langthorpe Enf - 18.07.05 23.08.05 27.12.05 Appeal - Public Inquiry - 24.5.06 Unauthorised extension to garage (in breach of 27.12.06 Appeal dismissed - 27.06.2006 condition 04 of 6.56.5.H.PA) Planning application permitted 15.1.07

04/00437/PR15 OS 5921, Westfield Lane, Arkendale Enf - 26.9.05 30.1.06 14.4.06 Use of agricultural land for the stationing of non To prosecute agricultural items. Enforcement 05/00319/PR15 Thorpe Wood Fishery, Thorpe Green Lane 3.10.05 18.1.06 1.4.06 Complied by 28.2.07 Thorpe Underwood, York. Unauthorised Construction of hardstanding and siting of static caravan Enforcement 03/00421/PR15 The Sweet Shop, Bridge St, Boroughbridge 3.10.05 5.10.05 16.1.06 Appeal lodged 16.11.05 Erection of 3 boundary wall and piers to the front 20.11.06 Dismissed 20.9.06 of the property without Listed Building Consent Complied 5.12.06

03/00316/PR15 Flat 2 19 Park Drive, Harrogate Enforcement (Planning appeal dismissed 20.6.05) Erection of 3 timber structures and an area of 17.10.05 1.12.05 5.03.05 Complied 12.7.07 decking

05/00022/PR15 Middle Farm, Warsill, Harrogate Enforcement 20.1.06 3.9.06 13.7.06 Appeal allowed - Construction of stables, feed stores, riding arena 31.10.05 Notice quashed and associated developments

Page 17 Enforcement Register

Reference Site/Planning Breach Notice/Authorised Served Comply by Notes

05/00097/PR15 Lyndlea, Branton Lane, Great Ouseburn Enforcement To reduce height of extension to ensure it accords 13.2.06 with detail shown on 6.80.129.A.FUL

04/00449/PR15 1 Glebe Cottage, Hunsingore, Wetherby Enforcement 16.6.06 21.10.06 Complied 5.3.07 Siting of metal storage container on land 20.2.06 (planning appeal dismissed 5.7.05 for 02/00143/PR15 28 The Whinfields, Summerbridge Enforcement 3.3.06 17.7.06 retention of porch) Unauthorised erection of porch 20.2.06

05/00415/PR15 73 St Georges Road, Harrogate Enforcement 5.4.06 17.7.06 Complied with 15.02.07 Fence and gates in excess of 1 metre 20.2.06

04/00245/PR15 OS 5710, Cass Lane, Knaresborough Enforcement 7.4.06 19.5.2007 Appeal lodged - 17 May 2006 Static and touring caravan, shed, kennel, hard- 13.3.06 Appeal Allowed 22.12.06. standing area and boundary walls Temporary permission for 5 years

05/00379/PR15 Forest Head Farm, Bogs Lane, Harrogate Enforcement 9.5.06 19.12.06 Appeal lodged 30.5.06 The stationing and use of residential caravans 13.3.06 Appeal dismissed 21.02.2007 . Temporary and creation of earth bund 3 year permission for caravan

05/00275/PR15 St Marys Farm, Pateley Bridge Enforcement 15.6.06 20.1.07 Appeal lodged 19.7.06 Erection of Conservatory, decking and creation of 6.3.06 Appeal withdrawn & planning application terracing to garden submitted Appeal lodged 2.6.06 05/00288/PR15 Land @ 3 Bridge House Cottages Enforcement 21.4.06 5.9.06 Appeal dismissed 17 November 2006 Dunkeswick, Leeds, North Yorkshire 27.3.06 17.5.07 = F$624:F$65536 Erection of stable block Complied 22.8.07

Page 18 Enforcement Register

Reference Site/Planning Breach Notice/Authorised Served Comply by Notes

06/00103/PR15 OS 4009 Limebar Lane Marton cum Grafton Enforcement 11.5.06 20.9.06 Appeal lodged 19.6.06 1. Siting of caravan forp residential occupationg 24.04.06 comply by: Appeal hearing - 31.1.07 structure 14.8.07 Appeal dismissed 14.2.07 - 6 months to comply 3. Gravel hardstanding Complied 20.6.08

05/00003/PR15 Land At Grid Reference 433884/447057 Enforcement Kearby Cliff Kearby Wetherby Erection of field shelter 15.5.06 30.1.08 6.6.08 (erection of stable) change of use of land from agriculture to mixed 15.5.06 24.4.07 31.8.07 Appeal allowed 29.2.08 Notice quashed use - agriculture/stabling of horses. (COU)

06/00065/PR15 OS Field Nos 8319 & 8810 Kearby Cliff Enforcement Kearby Wetherby Erection of 2 field shelter & unauthorised change of use of land from agriculture to mixed use of 15.5.06 23.4.07 30.8.07 Appeal allowed 25.2.08 Notice Quashed agriculture and for stabling of horses.

03/00468/PR15 28 Low Skellgate, Ripon LB Enf - 12.6.06 7.9.06 19.4.07 appeal lodged upvc windows re-issued 15.9.06 27.4.07 Dismissed 27 November 2007 27.05.08 New compliance date 03/00438/PR15 29 Low Skellgate, Ripon LB Enf - 12.6.06 7.9.06 19.4.07 upvc windows re-issued 15.9.06 27.4.07 Listed Building 7.9.06 19.4.07 03/00469/PR15 30 Low Skellgate, Ripon Enforcement re-issued upvc windows 12.6.06 15.9.06 27.4.07 Complied 23.10.2008 Listed Building 7.9.06 19.4.07 03/00470/PR15 34 Low Skellgate, Ripon Enforcement re-issued upvc windows 12.6.06 15.9.06 27.4.07

Page 19 Enforcement Register

Reference Site/Planning Breach Notice/Authorised Served Comply by Notes

06/00165/PR15 Building R/O 97/99 Kings Road, Harrogate Enforcement 16.1.07 28.5.07 Appeal dismissed 13.7.07, Notice upheld Use of building for car valeting business 10.7.06 Complied 26.7.07 Appeal lodged against the notice 15.11.06 06/00152/PR15 21 Ashfield Court Road, Pateley Bridge Enforcement 17.10.06 29.5.07 Appeal allowed, planning granted Unauthorised dormer window 14.8.06 24.4.07 - Notice quashed

05/00296/PR15 Whitewall Farm, Felliscliffe, Harrogate Enforcement 5.9.06 10.12.06 Appeal lodged against notice 11.12.06 Change of use of land from agriculture to siting of 7.8.06 Appeal dismissed 13.7.07 caravan Notice upheld Appeal dismissed 26.4.07 06/00022/PR15 OS 4700, Lower Dunsforth, York Enforcement 20.9.06 2.2.07 Court 14.7.09, £1,000 fine + costs Floating pontoons and siting of electricity 11.9.06 generator 26.10.07 Complied 16 July 2009

04/00007/PR15 OS 5463 & 4972 Lower Dunsforth York Enforcement 7.12.06 18.7.07 Court Fine - £700, £300 costs Erection of two stable blocks and hay store. 11.9.06 New court action pending Positioning of 1 no. Caravan and horsebox. Change of use of land (agriculture - horse stabling). Creation of hard standing and vehicle turning area. 04/00111/PR15 17 Rudbeck Crescent, Harrogate Enforcement 27.2.07 16.10.07 Complied 11.1.08 Erection of conservatory 09.10.06 Appeal lodged 18th December 2006 06/00168/PR15 Avon Leigh, Glasshouses Enforcement 16.11.06 1.1.08 Appeal allowed, Notice Erection of 2 storey extension 13.11.06 quashed 24.5.07 Temporary Stop 06/00605/PR15 OS 5169, Meagill Lane, Blubberhousees Notice 20.11.06 29.11.06 29.11.06 Valid until 26th December 2006 Works to implement erection of building Stop - 18.12.06 22.12.06 26.12.06 Enf Notice Appeal lodged 18.1.07 - Inquiry Page 20 Enforcement Register

(including diggingof foundation trenches) Enf - 18.12.06 22.12.06 27.2.07 Appeal Dismissed - 3.10.07 31.10.07 New compliance date Reference Site/Planning Breach Notice/Authorised Served Comply by Notes

06/00355/PR15 OS 0006, Harrogate Road, Weeton Erection of timber stables, siting of trailer body Enforcement 20.7.07 3.3.08 Complied 20.5.08 and change of use of land 24.11.06

06/00383/PR15 OS Fields 0050 & 0029 Church Field Lane Enforcement 2.3.07 6.7.07 Complied 30 Oct 07 Great Ouseburn 29.1.07 1 Construction - stables & equine exercise arena 2 Siting of caravan and lorry body on land Appeal lodged 29.3.07. Split decision 16. 05/00585/PR15 Laburnum Farm Moor Monkton York Enforcement 1.3.07 5.7.07 10.07, Horse shelter granted permission, Erection of detached horse shelter/store buildings 29.1.07 storage building removed by 26.2.08

Newby House Farm Gravelly Hill Lane 06/00357/PR15 Weeton LS17 0EX Enforcement 21.3.07 2.8.07 Complied 23.02.2009 Use of the land & buildings for the storage and 29.1.07 dismantling of motor vehicles/motor vehicle parts.

07/00002/PR15 NYCC Depot Boroughbridge Rd Green Enforcement 28.2.07 4.5.07 Notice withdrawn - planning appl made to Hammerton 12.2.07 NYCC. Pl app withdrawn. New Notices issued Use of land for vehicle breaking and storage of Authorised 29.5.07 scrap vehicles, parts, and equipment. Enforcement 4.6.07 2.3.08 Appeal dismissed 2 February 2008 Siting of caravan Stop Notice 4.6.07 1.7.07 Judical Review refused 11.9.07 Enf 12.6.07 17.1.08 Not delivered by Post Office - not served 06/00489/PR15 OS 6000, York Road, Kirk Hammerton 26.2.07 4.3.08 9.7.08 New Compliance date Erection of agricultural building Complied 29.01.2009 Planning appeal allowed 2.4.07 03/00173/PR15 1 & 4 Magnolia Court, Dishforth 2 x Enforcement 26.3.07 9.8.07 (for retention of 4 conservatories) Erection of Conservatories (2 Notices) 26.3.07 26.3.07 9.8.07 Notice Quashed Page 21 Enforcement Register

Reference Site/Planning Breach Notice/Authorised Served Comply by Notes

05/00170/PR15 S & H Recovery, Manse Lane, Enforcement 04.04.07 17.07.07 Appeal lodged 16.05.07 (Planning & Enforcement) Knaresborough 26.3.07 Appeal allowed and Notice quashed Use of land for vehicle repairs & Storage depot by Planning Inspectorate 16.10.07 Appeal lodged 5 June 2007 06/00601/PR15 Land @ Far Hill Top Farm, Clint Enforcement 19.4.07 Appeal Dismissed 5.12.07 Change of use of land to mixed use of agriculture 26.3.07 2.1.08 (Change of use of land) and trading/storage of tractors & other agricultural 27.2.08 (storage) & non-agricultural plant & machinery Stop Notice 14.6.07 25.6.07 Enforcement Notice Complied 9.4.08 11.6.07 Stop Notice complied with 10.8.07

06/00029/PR15 49 Kirkgate, Knaresborough Listed Building Erection of fencing Enforcement 11.6.07 23.9.07 Appeal dismissed 11.2.08, comply by 11.4.08 21.5.07 22.4.08 Complied

04/00326/PR15 Stone Haven Barn, Main Street, Darley Enforcement 20.6.07 2.10.07 Appeal dismissed 4.1.08 Siting of shed and formation of hardstanding area 21.5.07 4.3.08 Complied 22.7.08

06/00554/PR15 2 Laburnum Grove, Harrogate Enforcement 11.6.07 12.8.07 Complied - 4.9.07 Erection of a boundary fence over 1 metre in 21.5.07 height and the erection of a garden shed Appeal dismissed 14.2.08 07/00082/PR15 OS 4009, Limebar Lane, Marton-c-Grafton Enforcement 27.6.07 1.11.07 Fine £500, costs £1,000. Erection of five buildings on agricultural land 11.6.07 14.5.08 Complied 21.12.09 Planning appeal allowed 06/00588/PR15 Maple Lea, Forest Moor Road, Harrogate Enforcement on 28.11.07, planning permission granted. Erection of two storey building comprising a 3 bed 18.6.07 24.7.07 3.3.08 roomed dwelling. Enforcement Notice quashed

Page 22 Enforcement Register

07/00265/PR15 Green Cottage, Ramsgill, HG3 5RL Enforcement 8.10.07 23.2.08 Complied 10.1.08 Siting of Static Caravan 10.09.07 Reference Site/Planning Breach Notice/Authorised Served Comply by Notes

06/00207/PR15 Fawley, Ripley Road, Knaresborough Enforcement 20.9.07 25.1.08 Appeal lodged 10.10.07 Unauthorised change of use of adjacent land to 26.2.07 Notice Withdrawn 3.9.08 use as a domestic garden Lawful Develoment Certificated 31.7.08 Appeal lodged 5.11.07 06/00129/PR15 Swallow Hill Barn, Moorside Lane Enforcement 1.10.07 6.5.08 Appeal dismissed 5.03.08 Askwith, North Yorkshire 10.09.07 5.9.08 New Compliance date Unauthorised change of use of barn to dwelling Planning permission granted 20.10.08 Appeal lodged 14.02.08 05/00213/PR15 53 Duchy Road, Harrogate Enforcement Dismissed 2.10.08 Erection of wall, Railings and Gate in excess of 8.10.07 14.1.08 18.5.08 Boundary modified to an acceptable degree 2metres adjacent to the highway 2.4.09 20.8.09

07/00138/PR15 Coal Depot, Stockwell Road, Knaresborough Enforcement 9.10.07 23.2.08 Appeal dismissed 15.12.08 Unauthorised business operating from site. 8.10.07 29.5.08 15.3.09 Complied 20.5.09

07/00467/PR15 OS Field 7061, Smelthouses Enforcement Erection of new dwelling without planning 15.10.07 31.1.08 6.6.08 Appeal allowed planning permission granted permission in open coutryside 06/00391/PR15 Land West of Sunnybank Cottage, Horse Enforcement Mill Lane, Bishop Monkton 15.10.07 Siting of 3 static caravans, storage of vehicles and tarmac scalpings

05/00386/PR15 Walker Cottage, Grewlthorpe, HG4 3DD Enforcement Extension of domestic curtilage in agricultural 15.10.07 04.03.08 09.07.08 Complied - 09.03.2009 land & construction of hard surface

Page 23 Enforcement Register

07/00037/PR15 20 Waterside, Knaresborough, HG5 8DF Enforcement 1. Construction of driveway 15.10.07 9.10.08 20.2.09 Complied 01.07.2009 2. Extension of domestic curtilage Reference Site/Planning Breach Notice/Authorised Served Comply by Notes

07/00640/BRPC S & H Recovery, Manse Lane, Breach of Knaresborough Condition Notice Breach of Condition re Hours of operation, 11.2.08 13.02.08 17.03.08 complied 17.06.2008 outside working & working with doors open

07/00547/PR15 Land @ Silverdale Close, Darley Unfinished dwelling - granted permission in 1987 Completion Notice 18.2.08 confirmed by Secretary of State compliance 12 months from confirmation date

07/00023/PR15 OS 5419, Galphay Road, Kirkby Malzeard Enforcement Change of use of land to siting caravan and 03.03.08 13.3.08 24.10.08 appeal withdrawn residential use Complied 17.11.2009

05/00297/PR15 Riverside Farm, Bridge Hewick Enforcment 1. Unauthorised construction of Earth Bund 17.3.08 2. unauthorised material change of use of: Notice 1 15.4.08 20.6.08 Appeal allowed, notice quashed i) land edged green to use as a domestic garden ii) land edged blue to use for mixed purposes of Notice 2 (i) 15.4.08 6.5.09 Appeal dismissed 6.4.09 residential use, agricultural use & use as a depot Notice 2 (ii) 6.1.2010 Appeal dismissed 6.4.09 and storage area for an agricultural and highways contracting business. Complied 17.6.10 Complied 07/00640/BRPC S & H Recovery, Manse Lane, Knaresbro' Enforcement 29.4.08 17.6.08 17.6.08 Breach of conditions 2 (hours of operation) and Stop 29.04.08 6.5.08 6.5.08 3 (working on vehicles outside or with doors open) both authorised 28.4.08 Appeal lodged 29.7.08 - dismissed Page 24 Enforcement Register 07/00435/PR15 56 Hollins Lane, Hampsthwaite, HG3 2EG Enforcement 27.6.08 1.11.08 Prosecution in Magistrates Court 8.1.10 Front boundary wall in excess of 1 metre adjacent 12.5.08 11.3.09 £200 fine + costs for LPA. to the highway Report 26.410 - no further action required Reference Site/Planning Breach Notice/Authorised Served Comply by Notes

07/00490/PR15 Café, Block E1 (GF) Greengate, Cardale Enforcement Appeal allowed notice quashed 11.12.08 Park, Harrogate 29.5.08 14.7.08 18.11.08 Unauthorised café

07/00080/PR15 Queen Ethelburgas, Thorpe Underwood Enforcement 1. Boundary wall 2.6.08 Planning applications submitted 2. Unauthorised residential "Studio Apartment" 2.6.08 3. Construction of medical centre 2.6.08 4. Lighting columns 2.6.08 5. Additional storey to Abbey Chambers 2.6.08 6. Extension to Phoenix Centre (Listed Building) 2.6.08

07/00446/PR15 The Haven, Old Church Lane, Pateley Enforcement 22.7.09 3.12.09 Appeal dismissed 23.03.2010 Bridge 09.06.08 23.10.10 Complied 24.9.10 Erection of detached building

07/00417/PR15 Old Church Lane Cottage, Pateley Bridge Enforcement Unauthorised erection of an additional single 11.5.09 16.9.09 30.11.09 Complied 04.12.2009 pole aerial mast

06/00648/PR15 Warehouse r/o 19 Haywra Street Section 215 - waste Harrogate 11.8.08 15.08.08 18.11.08 Action in default to proceed Adverse condition of land & building Complied 16.8.10

06/00318/PR15 132 Knox Lane, Harrogate, HG1 3AS Enforcement Enforcement Notice Appeal allowed, Single storey extension & 2 dormer windows to 28.7.08 2.10.08 6.1.09 Page 25 03.04.2009 Notice Quashed Enforcement Register

outbuilding

Reference Site/Planning Breach Notice/Authorised Served Comply by Notes

07/00081/PR15 OS 4009, Limebar Lane, Marton cum Enforcement Appeal dismissed Grafton, York. 19.8.08 14.10.08 3.4.2010 Complied 22.06.2010 Use of land for residential and agriculture

07/00025/PR15 Holly Cottage, Grafton Lane Marton cum Enforcement Grafton YO51 9QJ 6.10.08 Unauthorised erection of stable block

07/00385/PR15 Ye Olde Oak Inn Low Laithe HG3 4BU Enforcement Construction of metal balcony at first floor level 6.10.08 13.1.09 24.8.09 Appeal allowed 15 July 09, Notice to rear of the Olde Oak Inn quashed

08/00242/PR15 OS 4658, Newall Carr Road, Clifton Enforcement 18.11.08 23.3.09 Complied 22.6.10 Erection of agricultural Building 6.10.08

08/00551/PR15 29 Lincoln Grove, Harrogate Enforcement Siting of touring caravan and residential use 25.11.08 Removed before Notice served

07/00252/PR15 Nidd House Farm, Crofters Green Enforcement Killinghall, HG3 2DF 12.5.08 2.9.09 23.3.11 Complied 23.3.11 Siting of caravans and residential use

07/00200/PR15 5 Holly Court, Knaresborough Section 215 Complied 21.4.09 Adverse condition of property & garden 1.9.08 8.12.08 20.4.09

06/00463/PR15 Park Corner Farm, Scriven Enforcement Demolition of part boundary wall (listed building) 24.11.2008 8.01.2009 19.3.2009 Complied 18.6.09 Page 26 Enforcement Register

Reference Site/Planning Breach Notice/Authorised Served Comply by Notes

09/00050/PR15 Field off Menwith Hill Road, Thornthwaite Stop 19.2.09 27.2.09 Installation of footings for a building, formation Enforcement 19.2.09 31.5.09 Appeal dismissed 16.11.09 of track creation of a pond and associated 16.2.09 16.1.10 New Compliance date - not complied bunding Court date: 13 August 2010

08/00349/PR15 Land at Flatts House, Scarah Lane, Enforcement Appeal dismissed - 27.07.2009 Burton Leonard 19.01.09 12.02.09 27.9.09 new compliance date Driveway, gates and change of use of land Complied 5.11.09 Appeal lodged 13.08.2009, Dismissed 18.11.09 07/00648/PR15 Perk Up, 43 Market Place Ripon Enforcement 10.7.09 13.9.09 Court action pending Colour of flue 19.1.09 18.12.09 New compliance date. Complied 24.3.10

08/00147/PR15 Field At Grid Reference 450905 455183 Enforcement Moor Monkton Construction of various earth mounds 24.11.2008 26.01.09 09.09.09 Notice complied 10 November 2009

08/00140/PR15 Covill House Farm, Ramsgill, HG3 5RS Enforcement Notice Appeal dismissed 10.12.09 Unauthorised conversion of 3 barns to form 3 16.03.2009 27.5.09 7.1.11 Planning permission granted 15.8.11 residential units Enforcement 19.2.09 31.5.09 Appeal dismissed 08/00488/PR15 Land @ GR 417427/457161 Menwith & Stop 19.2.09 27.2.09 Hill Road, Thornthwaite 16.2.09 Footings for a building, formation of track, 16.1.10 New compliance date creation of pond & associated bunding

08/00360/PR15 Barn South of Prospect House Farm, Temp Stop Notice Timble, Otley, LS21 2NJ 02.03.2009 3.03.09 3.03.09 Page 27 Enforcement Register

Rebuilding of collapsed barn, construction work to Stop 19.03.09 24.03.09 outbuilding + hardcore access track Enf 19.03.09 30.07.09 Appeal allowed 21.8.09, 16.3.09 Notice Quashed Reference Site/Planning Breach Notice/Authorised Served Comply by Notes

06/00541/PR15 Castra Park Rd, Spofforth Enforcement Enforcement Notice appeals dismissed 20.1.10 Ext to garage, House -single & 2 storey extensions 2.2.09 14.5.09 20.7.10 Complied 18.08.2010 First floor window (NW) to be obscure glazed 14.5.09 20.2.10

08/00254/PR15 "Beckside Farm", OS 1300 Swincliffe Section 215 Lane, Hampsthwaite/Birstwith 16.3.09 21.5.09 31.7.09 Complied 6.10.09 Adverse condition of land

08/00589/PR15 2 Carlton Road, Harrogate, HG2 8DD Section 215 26.6.09 21.10.09 Complied 27.5.10 Adverse condition of property & garden 11.5.09

07/00670/LB Thompsons Garth 24 High Street Enforcement Appeal dismissed 23.12.09 Hampsthwaite HG3 2ET 11.5.09 02.06.09 14.10.09 Erection of solid timber gates 23.3.2010 Complied 14.5.10

09/00016/PR15 Ladyhill Cottage, Dallowgill, Ripon Enforcement Appeal dismissed 12.4.10. Erection of building 11.5.09 12.11.09 12.6.10 Complied 26.8.10

07/00252/PR15 Nidd House Farm Crofters Green Ripon Enforcement Road Killinghall HG3 2DF 12.5.08 2.9.09 Appeal dismissed 24.3.10 Change of use of the land to a residential caravan 24.3.11 New Compliance date site & storage of caravans

07/00002/PR15 Former NYCC Depot, Boroughbridge Rd Enforcement ( 1) Green Hammerton 08.06.09 15.7.09 1. Change of Use of land to residential 26.2.10 occupation of caravans Page 28 Enforcement Register 2 Change of Use of land to business (recovery of 26.10.09 Complied 18.9.09 broken down & accident damaged vehicles

Reference Site/Planning Breach Notice/Authorised Served Comply by Notes

Enforcement 07/00028/PR15 Low Wood Farm Timble LS21 2NS 08.06.09 13.8.09 24.12.09 Appeal lodged 23.9.09. Dismissed 15.1.10 Unauthorised works to agricultural building 15.1.2011 (new compliance date)

08/00534/PR15 Crossgates Quarry, Fellbeck Section 215 Adverse condition of site 15.6.09 20.07.09 31.10.09 Complied 22.6.10

09/00064/PR15 Wicklands Farm, Castley Lane, Leathely Enforcement Change of use to depot & operating centre for 29.6.09 23.7.09 4.10.09 Complied 10.11.09 non-agricultural contracting business Appeal dismissed 8.2.10 Sweethills Barn Grantley HG4 3PU Enforcement 09/00125/PR15 Access and 10.7.09 8.8.10 Access track - Complied 7.9.10 09/00297/PR15 caravan 4.8.09 8.4.10 Caravan removed 20.4.10

09/00137/PR15 28 Chain Lane, Knaresborough, HG5 0AS Enforcement Use ceased 21.5.10. Wall to be reinstated Use of dwelling as office 10.7.09 4.8.09 15.11.09 Complied 26.9.11 Enforcement 09/00257/BRPC Zorros, 1 Kirkgate, Ripon 20.7.09 Breach of hours of operation BCN - 03.8.09 1.8.09 22.9.09 Complied 23.2.10

06/00635/PR15 Badgers Holt Risplith Enforcement Appeal dismissed 17.2.10 Erection of garage and store 20.07.09 12.8.09 17.5.10 Prosecution pending. Complied 6.10.11

09/00402/REF Ash Tree Farm, Kirkby Malzeard, HG4 3QF Temp Stop Notice PPR Erection of stable, store, menage, hardstanding & 10.8.09 10.8.09 10.8.09 Complied 10.8.09 change of use of land Enf 4.1.10 8.3.10 20.7.10 Planning permission granted 28.6.10 Page 29 Enforcement Register

Reference Site/Planning Breach Notice/Authorised Served Comply by Notes

09/00262/PR15 Land at Meagill Lane Farm Blubberhouses Enforcement North Yorkshire LS21 2PE 10.8.09 17.9.09 22.12.09 appeal dismissed Unauthorised agricultural building 24.2.11 Complied 1.11.11

08/00553/PR15 Netheredge Lands Lane Knaresborough S215 HG5 9DE 17.8.09 25.8.09 29.11.09 Complied 13.7.10 Adverse condition of property and garden

08/00541/PR15 Glen View Harrogate Road Huby LS17 0AQ Enforcement Log business, sale & storage 24.8.09 22.9.09 3.1.2010 Not delivered by Post Office re-issued 22.10.09 27.1.2010 Complied 27.1.10

09/00349/PR15 Breckamore Kirkby Road Ripon Enforcement EN appeal Allowed 22.7.10. Change of use of agricultural building to domestic 24.8.09 3.11.09 9.3.2010 Notice quashed

08/00345/PR15 OS 1300 "Beckside Farm" Enforcement Swincliffe Lane, Birstwith 28.8.09 22.9.09 27.4.2010 Complied 14.7.10 Touring caravan on agricultural land and residential use of caravan

08/00557/PR15 Field off Grafton Lane Marton cum Grafton Enforcement Caravan and container removed 11.11.09 Siting of caravan & metal container on land 7.9.09

09/00446/PR15 Grassfield House Low Wath Road Enforcement Pateley Bridge, HG3 5HL 12.10.09 15.1.10 1.6.10 Enforcement notice appeal allowed 6.7.10 Construction unauthorised residential building Notice quashed

Page 30 Enforcement Register

09/00221/PR15 Bridge End Farm Pye Lane Burnt Yates Enforcement Harrogate HG3 3HP 12.10.09 9.12.09 20.04.10 Complied 26.10.10 Extend domestic curtilage into agricultural land Reference Site/Planning Breach Notice/Authorised Served Comply by Notes

07/00266/PR15 Ashdown Lodge Minskip York YO51 9HY Enforcement Provision of landscaping as per Condition 2 & 15 of 6.64.74.V COUMAJ 12.10.09 4.1.2010 15.5.2010 Complied 15.4.10

09/00177/PR15 Field At Grid Reference 423088/476436 Enforcement Grewelthorpe North Yorkshire 12.10.09 3.11.09 9.2.10 Complied 22.6.10 Extension of domestic curtilage into agricultural land

06/00638/PR15 195 Chatsworth Grove Harrogate HG1 2DX Enforcement Fence over 1m adjacent to the highway 21.09.2009 15.10.2009 27.1.10 Complied 30.10.09

09/00308/PR15 Middlesmoor House 2 Langcliffe Avenue Breach of Condition East Harrogate HG2 8JD Notice 23.10.09 10.12.09 11.1.10 Complied 19.1.2010 Breach of Condition 4 of 6.79.795.M.FUL (Use of flat roof as sitting out area)

09/00464/PR15 21 Oatlands Drive Harrogate HG2 8JT Section 215 (waste) Works done in default Adverse condition of land and property 26.10.09 15.11.09 15.2.10 Notice complied 7.2.11

07/00249/PR15 OS 7024 Westfield Lane Arkendale Enforcement 2 stable blocks and associated hard standings 14.9.09 10.11.09 22.3.10 Retrospective application approved 24.3.10

08/00492/PR15 Land @ Dovecote Cottage Rainton Breach of Condition Not fully complied but the requirements of the Breach of Condition 6 of 6.22.8.D.FUL 14.9.09 23.12.09 28.1.2010 notice have been met. No further action. Page 31 Enforcement Register

(Gate posts constructed but not set back 6m)

09/00135/PR15 OS1309 Bishopton Ripon Section 215 Adverse condition of building on land 2.11.09 17.11.09 28.1.2010 Complied 24.2.2010 Reference Site/Planning Breach Notice/Authorised Served Comply by Notes

09/00418/PR15 Victoria BMW Princess Royal Way Breach of Condition Harrogate HG3 1LG 4.11.09 17.11.09 14.1.2010 Complied 19.1.2010 Breach of condition 6 of 6.79.405.V.FUL (loading & unloading of vehicles on road)

07/00542/PR15 Trotters Cheltenham Parade Harrogate Enforcement HG1 1DD 23.11.09 16.12.09 27.4.2010 Original company in receivership - new Erection of canopy owners served with S16 by legal

09/00175/PR15 Harrogate Horseless Carriages Lime Street Enforcement Enforcement Notice Appeal dismissed Harrogate HG1 4BG 23.11.09 12.1.2010 1.9.2010 Notice quashed 06.05.2010 Car Sales

09/00239/PR15 Fishpool Farm Leathley Lane Leathley Enforcement Otley LS21 2JY 23.11.09 16.12.09 22.3.2010 Appeal lodged 28.1.2010 Access and extension of domestic curtilage into Appeal dismissed 1.9.10 agricultural land 1.11.10 Complied 18.11.10

09/00096/PR15 Sycamore House Thorny Hill Lane Marton Cum Grafton YO51 9QY Appeal allowed, Enforcement Notice Construction of new entrance 30.11.09 16.2.11 30.3.11 quashed 15.6.11

08/00476/PR15 Field r/o Scuttlepond Cottage Back Lane Enforcement Marton cum Grafton 30.11.09 15.1.10 1.9.10 Appeal allowed, 19.9.10 Erection of stables Notice quashed

Page 32 Enforcement Register

08/00015/PR15 Field @ Grid Ref 441786/ 461762 Legram Lane Marton cum Grafton. Enforcement 1.9.10 EN appeal dismissed 24.11.10 Works done to make stable Permitted Erection of stables 30.11.09 14.1.10 24.05.11 development. Complied 9.6.11 Case Ref Address Notice/Authorised Served Comply by Notes

09/00171/PR15 New House Farm Minskip YO51 9JF Enforcement Timber cladding erected - agreed with Erection of external metal stairs 7.12.09 Council. Enforcement case closed

09/00509/PR15 Field At Grid Ref 429576/449760 Enforcement Harrogate Road North Rigton 14.12.09 4.2.10 19.9.10 EN appeal lodged 18.3.10, Dismissed 10.11.10 Siting and occupation of large static caravan, 10.5.11 patio area, shed & fencing

09/00087/PR15 Land Comprising Field At Grid Reference 430307 464984 Wormald Green Enforcement 1st planting Enforcement Notice appeal dismissed 21.7.11 (i) Failure to provide landscaping 14.12.09 6.1.11 season (Landscaping) EN Appeal dismissed 14.6.11. (Builders Yard.) (ii) Unauthorised use of land as a builder's yard. 14.12.09 5.11.10 14.9.11 Judicial Challenge on Appeal decision

Land Comprising OS Field 6550 Midgeley 06/00504/PR15 Lane Goldsborough Landscaping required as required by Condition 5 of Enforcement 6.101.95.B.FUL 05/05218/FUL 20.12.09 11.5.11 31.3.12 Complied 13.7.12

The Barn Goosemoor Stud War Field Lane 08/00198/PR15 Cowthorpe LS22 5EU Enforcement Extension to domestic curtilage 14.6.09 1.7.10 2.6.11 Appeal dismissed. Complied 16.9.11