John Doe #1 State &

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 1 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: ProtectMarriage.com v. Bowen, Ex. 12 Page # in Filing: 1-8 Type of Document: Affidavit Name: John Doe #1 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 10/2008 Location: CA, Declarant's store Search Terms: self-employed

Was the individual a donor: Y Is the incident related to donation only: Y Is the incident related to petitions: N Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: Y Is the incident related to other campaign activities: N If yes, explain involvement in campaign:

Was the incident described in the media: N Is the incident referenced in other sources: N

NOTES

Economic Retaliation Flyers put on customers' car referencing declarant's support for Prop 8 and donation amount. Store picked twice. Nov. 2008 picketers were "aggressive" standing in front of store door and trying to give flyers to customers saying not to shop there b/c declarant supports Prop 8. Second picket- people blocked doorway of store and tried to get customers to sign petition. Police called but public space so protesters not forced to leave store.

Unwanted Communication Three Facebook groups urged boycott of declarant's business. Someone paid for a google sponsor link that urged people to boycott declarant's business and listed her donation to Prop 8. Negative business reviews on yelp.com because declarant supports Prop 8. Other website published negative reviews of store because support Prop 8. Declarant received letter, hundreds of emails and numerous harassing phone calls because of Prop 8 support.

Discomfort with Friends/Family over Differing Views Thirty to fourty people have walked into store and expressed displeasure w/ declarant's views on Prop 8.

Police Action/Inaction Police called at the second boycott but it was peaceable so protesters were allowed to picket.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 2 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Additional Claims Someone filled cart w/ groceries and checked out. After clerk scanned all groceries, person said not buying them b/c declarant supports Prop 8. Declarant installed 16 security cameras after incidents to protect integrity and safety of products in store.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 3 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: ProtectMarriage.com v. Bowen, Ex. 12 Page # in Filing: 9-14 Type of Document: Affidavit Name: John Doe #2 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 11/2008 Location: ? Search Terms:

Was the individual a donor: Y Is the incident related to donation only: Y Is the incident related to petitions: N Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: N Is the incident related to other campaign activities: N If yes, explain involvement in campaign:

Was the incident described in the media: ? Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Unwanted Communication Flyer with picture and caption "Bigot" distributed in home town & references four-figure donation.

Expressions of Religious Bigotry References "_____ Catholic Church." "Christ would not be proud of you." Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 4 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: ProtectMarriage.com v. Bowen, Ex. 12 Page # in Filing: 15-25 Type of Document: Affidavit Name: John Doe #3 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Late Nov. 4, 2008 or early Nov. 5, 2008 Location: ? Search Terms: Lutheran, church window

Was the individual a donor: N Is the incident related to donation only: N Is the incident related to petitions: N Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: N Is the incident related to other campaign activities: Y If yes, explain involvement in campaign: Preached to Lutheran church congregants; yard sign on church property

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Vandalism Rock with a "Yes on 8" yard sign thrown through a church window. (Also note, Ex. A actually goes with John Doe #2.)

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 5 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: ProtectMarriage.com v. Bowen, Ex. 12 Page # in Filing: 26-44 Type of Document: Affidavit Name: John Doe #4 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Aug. 2008; 11/13-16/2008 Location: Entrance to gated community; business website Search Terms:

Was the individual a donor: Y Is the incident related to donation only: N Is the incident related to petitions: N Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: N Is the incident related to other campaign activities: Y If yes, explain involvement in campaign: 5 figure donation to the National Organization for Marriage, served in official capacity (perhaps general counsel) for ProtectMarriage.com; wrote articles; gave talks; held a fundraiser at home.

Was the incident described in the media: Y, San Diego paper? Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Unwanted Communication Lawyer claims 15-20 emails on new client forms (eight attached, incl. "tampon of the year award"). Listed on CaliforniansAgainstHate.org. At least one email referenced donation amount and fact that he had made a short term loan to campaign (not attached as exhibit). It says "I am boycotting your organization [a law office];" another refers to "scumbag personal injury lawyers;" another simply says: "Shame on your company for their lack of respect and intolerance for your gay fellow human beings. Shame," and is signed.

Additional Claims About twenty-five protesters held signs outside the entrance to the gated community where declarant lives and was holding a Prop 8 fundraiser in August 2008.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 6 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: ProtectMarriage.com v. Bowen, Ex. 12 Page # in Filing: 45-50 Type of Document: Affidavit Name: John Doe #5 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 11/15/2008 Location: firm website Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: N Is the incident referenced in other sources: N

NOTES

Unwanted Communication One email at work, subject line: "Disastrous PR Move?" Message: "It will be interesting to see if your firm's donation to support the "Yes"… will prove true the axiom - any PR is good PR. I doubt it." Firm donation only. Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 7 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: ProtectMarriage.com v. Bowen, Ex. 12 Page # in Filing: 51-56 Type of Document: Affidavit Name: John Doe #6 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 11/28/2008 Location: Alamo, CA Search Terms: Vietnam Vet postcard

Was the incident described in the media: N Is the incident referenced in other sources: N

NOTES

Unwanted Communication Received a Vietnam vets' postcard: "insulted me personally;" "personal attacks." Also listed on CaliforniansAgainstHate.org for five-figure donation. The postcard text is attached as an Exhibit. It is non-threatening and a challenge to think differently about Prop 8.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 8 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: ProtectMarriage.com v. Bowen, Ex. 12 Page # in Filing: 57-63 Type of Document: Affidavit Name: John Doe #7 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: pre-Nov. 2008 Location: ? Search Terms: church pastor

Was the individual a donor: N Is the incident related to donation only: N Is the incident related to petitions: Y Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: N Is the incident related to other campaign activities: N If yes, explain involvement in campaign:

Was the incident described in the media: ? Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Unwanted Communication Pastor received 1 phone call @ church from a woman who asked if they were a distribution center for petitions (they were) and if he "was going to sign the petition against divorce." He said he wasn't sure he understood, thanked her, and hung up.

Vandalism Bumper stickers removed three times from family cars. The first time, someone put up a note asking why support Prop 8: "Please rethink your position…Please vote 'No' on Prop 8." Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 9 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: ProtectMarriage.com v. Bowen, Ex. 12 Page # in Filing: 64-73 Type of Document: Affidavit Name: John Doe #8 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: post-election Location: home & work Search Terms: election night photo

Was the individual a donor: Y Is the incident related to donation only: N Is the incident related to petitions: N Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: N Is the incident related to other campaign activities: Y If yes, explain involvement in campaign: African-American who works for a church. Spoke out at rallies, 3 press conferences, and churches in LA, Orange, and San Diego areas

Was the incident described in the media: ? Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Unwanted Communication Picture taken at election night party appeared in newspapers. Then received "harassing letters and emails" and at least 1 phone call at work. Employer began screening emails because they upset him. One read: Jesus "will punish you in Hell" and says, "You're as bad as the racist white people who used to enjoy banning black people the same rights as them."

Vandalism Yes on 8 sign stolen twice.

Expressions of Religious Bigotry The one email saved says "Jesus doesn't love you. He will punish you in Hell…" Note: He is employed by a church.

Expressions of Racism Email referenced the "racist white people."

Police Action/Inaction Obtained a document form the local Police Department saying that the home is private property and tresspassers can be removed. Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 10 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: ProtectMarriage.com v. Bowen, Ex. 12 Page # in Filing: 74-89 Type of Document: Affidavit Name: John Doe #9 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: post-election Location: home & work Search Terms: election night photo

Was the incident described in the media: ? Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Unwanted Communication Picture of individual taken at an election night party was published. Then received MySpace and Facebook messages - 1 threatened assault (not attached), 1 message on home answering machine said photo was "Nazis" and referred to individual as a "f'ing bitch."

Job Loss/Fear of Losing Job Some calls and letters said they would try to have the individual fired. One caller knew job position as it was listed online.

Police Action/Inaction Filed police report, but not attached.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 11 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: ProtectMarriage.com v. Bowen, Ex. 13 Page # in Filing: 1-5 Type of Document: Affidavit Name: John Doe #10 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 2/2/2009 Location: email(CT) Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: ? Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Unwanted Communication The email has no profanity. It disagrees with position and says "rotten people." "What you did was shameful, rotten, and history will live to tell the tale of a nation that treats people as less than who they are."

Job Loss/Fear of Losing Job Her husband responded to the email. Writer said she planned to contact all parents at school where affiant works. No allegation that contact with school was made. Neither described email is attached. Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 12 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: ProtectMarriage.com v. Bowen, Ex. 13 Page # in Filing: 7-8 Type of Document: Affidavit Name: John Doe #11 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: car or street Search Terms: senior citizen, car window

Was the incident described in the media: ? Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Vandalism Someone smashed window of a car parked at a house. Links it to the bumper sticker on the car. No photos or information attached.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 13 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: ProtectMarriage.com v. Bowen, Ex. 13 Page # in Filing: 9-10 Type of Document: Affidavit Name: John Doe #12 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: pre & post election Location: car at store; home Search Terms: staircase, urine

Was the individual a donor: Y Is the incident related to donation only: N Is the incident related to petitions: N Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: N Is the incident related to other campaign activities: Y If yes, explain involvement in campaign: Individual had bumper stickers and yard signs; attended rally; attended meeting with ministers

Was the incident described in the media: Probably Y? Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Vandalism Pre-election: car with bumper sticker was keyed and tires deflated. Post-election: sign on balcony, someone covered staircase with urine with puddle of urine at bottom of stairs.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 14 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: ProtectMarriage.com v. Bowen, Ex. 13 Page # in Filing: 12-15 Type of Document: Affidavit Name: John Doe #13 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: pre-election Location: home & car Search Terms:

Was the individual a donor: Y Is the incident related to donation only: N Is the incident related to petitions: N Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: N Is the incident related to other campaign activities: Y If yes, explain involvement in campaign: Called voters, volunteered as a sign waver, delivered yard signs, forwarded updates, wrote blog entries.

Was the incident described in the media: ? Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Unwanted Communication People criticized her on Halloween night or "pointed and whispered to one another in disapproval."

Vandalism Car keyed (damage was 27" long) because of bumper sticker. Yard sign was slashed and later removed/thrown outside property.

Harassment/Threats During Campaign Activities When volunteering as a sign waver, people yelled obscenities or argued. At some point, "No on 8" people stood in front of them and made "hateful comments." Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 15 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: ProtectMarriage.com v. Bowen, Ex. 13 Page # in Filing: 16-19 Type of Document: Affidavit Name: John Doe #14 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: pre & post election Location: home, car & motorbike Search Terms:

Was the individual a donor: Y (through church) Is the incident related to donation only: N Is the incident related to petitions: N Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: N Is the incident related to other campaign activities: N If yes, explain involvement in campaign:

Was the incident described in the media: Probably Y? Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Vandalism Signs in yard and balcony removed; home "egged and floured" in Sept., Oct. and Nov. Nov. 1: Cars "egged and floured" and honey poured on. Aug. & Sept.: bumper stickers scraped off cars and motorbike. 11/5/2008: Motorbike pushed over. Temple vandalized with graffiti.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 16 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: ProtectMarriage.com v. Bowen, Ex. 13 Page # in Filing: 20-29 Type of Document: Affidavit Name: John Doe #15 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: pre-election Location: personal Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: ? Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Discomfort with Friends/Family over Differing Views Had uncomfortable phone call with gay brother and email exchange with brother's partner afterwards. Brother will not speak to her. Emails were forwarded to sister-in- law. Claims "ugly and inflammatory email from brother's partner." It says: "Your views on Proposition 8 have placed you in the camp of opposition to civil rights."

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 17 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: ProtectMarriage.com v. Bowen, Ex. 13 Page # in Filing: 30-33 Type of Document: Affidavit Name: John Doe #16 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: pre & post election Location: ? Search Terms:

Was the individual a donor: Y (four-figure) Is the incident related to donation only: N Is the incident related to petitions: N Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: N Is the incident related to other campaign activities: Y If yes, explain involvement in campaign: Sign waver once; in Jan. 2009 wrote two letters that were published

Was the incident described in the media: ? Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Job Loss/Fear of Losing Job After letters were published, her boss (who might be a lesbian) and a gay man at work were "talking about me in ways that are not complimentary." In Feb., dept. head said "he could not guarantee my job beyond the current year's work for a public university." Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 18 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: ProtectMarriage.com v. Bowen, Ex. 13 Page # in Filing: 34-37 Type of Document: Affidavit Name: John Doe #17 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: pre & post election Location: home & work Search Terms: Vietnam Vet postcard

Was the incident described in the media: ? Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Economic Retaliation Post-election, the Human Resources person at work said his name was on a "blacklist." (no specific cite)

Unwanted Communication After TV interview, received a phone message at home saying sarcastically that he "must be proud of your decision to donate to Proposition 8." Received a postcard from Vietnam Vets at work. Listed on List of Shame and eightmaps.com.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 19 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: ProtectMarriage.com v. Bowen, Ex. 13 Page # in Filing: 38-41 Type of Document: Affidavit Name: John Doe #18 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: pre-election Location: yard & church Search Terms:

Was the individual a donor: N Is the incident related to donation only: N Is the incident related to petitions: N Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: N Is the incident related to other campaign activities: Y If yes, explain involvement in campaign: Prop 8 Parish coordinator; distributed materials for church bulletins & distributed/placed yard signs.

Was the incident described in the media: ? Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Unwanted Communication Confrontation with another parishioner at church "who said she did not like me putting up yard signs supporting Prop. 8." She told the woman what their faith "required" and the woman and her daughter "continued ranting about my support for Prop. 8 for several minutes." "[T]hese incidents shook me to the core."

Vandalism Signs removed from the church and other places she had put them. Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 20 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: ProtectMarriage.com v. Bowen, Ex. 13 Page # in Filing: 42-44 Type of Document: Affidavit Name: John Doe #19 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: post-election Location: work (Lousiana) Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: ? Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Unwanted Communication Individual is a tenured professor. An email was sent to univ. colleagues and alumni director. Worried about son and grandkids in SF being harassed because of his contribution. Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 21 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 2 Page # in Filing: 24-32 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #5 (church pastor) State & Campaign: WA, Ref. 71 Incident Date: During Petition Signing Period; 7/30; 8/1; 8/13/2009 Location: Church, Olympia,WA Search Terms: Fred Myer, Wal-Mart, MySpace, Facebook, Krystal, Krystal Mountaine, David/Krystal, David Baurle, "Church in Olympia," Pastor

Was the incident described in the media: N Is the incident referenced in other sources: N

NOTES

Economic Retaliation Caller said that when community finds out that church supports Ref. 71, "they will not want to give to your church."

Unwanted Communication 5 phone calls to declarant's church and one email. "David" asked why declarant supported Ref. 71. Called her stupid and other names. He said found declarant's name on their website as one of the sponsors. Said he would bring trans friends to their church. And when folks find out that John Doe supports Prop 71 they will not give to the church. Email was personal, impassioned, non-threatening expressing why should support Ref 71.

Harassment/Threats During Campaign Activities Told to leave when gathering signatures.

Police Action/Inaction Police called. Listened to messages. Officer told "David" not to continue harassment and threats and that he was not welcome at John Doe #5's church.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 22 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 2 Page # in Filing: 33-39 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #4 (church pastor) - seems married to John Doe #5. State & Campaign: WA, Ref. 71 Incident Date: During Petition Signing Period Location: Church, Olympia,WA Search Terms:

Was the individual a donor: N Is the incident related to donation only: N Is the incident related to petitions: N Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: N Is the incident related to other campaign activities: Y If yes, explain involvement in campaign: Signature gatherer, lead observer, testified before Senate against SB 5688, TV pastor and publicly speaks out against marriage equality.

Was the incident described in the media: N Is the incident referenced in other sources: N

NOTES

Unwanted Communication Several calls (see above) to declarant's church. Caller asked why declarant supported Ref. 71. Asked declarant about the Bible and what it says. Caller got argumentative, but no specifics given in Declaration.

Harassment/Threats During Campaign Activities At Wal-Mart gathering signs, trans woman got "argumentative" asking why John Doe #4 supports bill. Said would get bunch of gay and trans folks to go to his church. Again at Wal-Mart woman took photo/video and threatened to post on MySpace/Facebook. No evident record of incident.

Police Action/Inaction Call to community police in Dupont. Asked police and neighbors to keep watch over home.

Additional Claims While obtaining signatures at Wal-Mart, lesbian glared at older woman and almost scared her out of signing saying "We have feelings too."

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 23 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 2 Page # in Filing: 40-43 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #3 State & Campaign: WA, Ref. 71 Incident Date: 7/27/2009 and 8/12/09 Location: Church, Olympia,WA Search Terms: David/Krystal; Krystal Mountaine, Pastor

Was the individual a donor: N Is the incident related to donation only: N Is the incident related to petitions: N Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: N Is the incident related to other campaign activities: Y If yes, explain involvement in campaign: Made petition available at the church where he is a pastor

Was the incident described in the media: N Is the incident referenced in other sources: N

NOTES

Unwanted Communication 2 calls received at office. Caller asked why declarant wanted to limit her rights. Identified as Krystal Mountaine. Declarant only spoke to person once.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 24 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 2 Page # in Filing: 44-64 Type of Document: Declaration Name: Sarah E. Troupis State & Campaign: WA, Ref. 71 Incident Date: 7/28/2009 Location: WA Search Terms: "John Bisceglia"

Was the individual a donor: Is the incident related to donation only: Is the incident related to petitions: Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: Is the incident related to other campaign activities: If yes, explain involvement in campaign:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Additional Claims Blog post by John Bisceglia advocating violence against property of all supporters of Ref. 71

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 25 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 2 Page # in Filing: 82-87 Type of Document: Second Declaration Name: Scott F. Bieniek State & Campaign: WA, Ref. 71 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: "David Ammons" - 7/28/2009, "R-71 update: Signature requests pending"

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Additional Claims Article stating that supporters of Ref. 71 "will post by hometown and address the names of people who signed the referendum."

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 26 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 2 Page # in Filing: 88-256 Type of Document: Second Declaration Name: Scott F. Bieniek State & Campaign: Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: "R-71 update: signature requests pending"

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Additional Claims Blogger indicating that Prop 8 supporters were harassed from list of those who made political contributions. Also said list was published on Craigslist. Cites profane language allegedly posted on craiglist by Prop 8 opponents to supporters.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 27 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 257-262 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #20 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 2/6/2008 Location: CA Search Terms: yard, yellowpages.com

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Economic Retaliation One peaceful notification that neighbors would not patronize business; one yellowpages review noting support for prop 8.

Vandalism One yard sign stolen. Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 28 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 263-265 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #21 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: CA Search Terms: country club

Was the individual a donor: N Is the incident related to donation only: N Is the incident related to petitions: N Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: Y Is the incident related to other campaign activities: N If yes, explain involvement in campaign:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Vandalism "No on 8" yard sign repeatedly placed on declarant's yard following election.

Discomfort with Friends/Family over Differing Views Neighbor called declarant a "bigot," and members of country club have made "rude comments" or "do not greet" declarant.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 29 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 266-268 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #22 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 10/15/2008 Location: Sonoma, CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Unwanted Communication Note left under declarant's doormat stating "Yeshua loves me, and does not love those who hate."

Vandalism Two signs removed in same incident.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 30 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 269-271 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #23 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 11/2008 Location: CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Unwanted Communication Anonymous person sent declarant a book of homosexual love stories.

Vandalism Statute outside declarant's church painted.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 31 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 272-274 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #24 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Vandalism Two incidents - yard sign had "yes" changed to "no," and bumper sticker stolen. Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 32 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 275-277 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #25 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 10/2008 Location: CA Search Terms: Pastor

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Vandalism One yard sign stolen; one bumper sticker stolen (from wife).

Harassment/Threats During Campaign Activities Some people driving by intersection of demonstration "yelled obscenities" at demonstrators.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 33 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 278-280 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #26 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 10/2008 Location: CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Vandalism One sign removed from declarant's property, four removed from public spaces where declarant posted them.

Harassment/Threats During Campaign Activities Called "bigot" by one man while putting fliers on people's cars.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 34 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 281-286 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #27 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 12/2008 Location: MI Search Terms: Author, BoycottH8ers, Michigan

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Economic Retaliation Michigan author donated to Prop 8 through the National Organization for Marriage and later discovered his name listed online on "BoycottH8ers List." Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 35 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 287-291 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #28 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 11/11/2008 Location: CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Unwanted Communication One voicemail, at place of work, from unidentified caller stating it was "disheartening to know that one of my neighbors supported Proposition 8 so heavily" and calling declarant a "scum-fuck."

Police Action/Inaction Police report filed; no indication of any action taken. Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 36 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 292-329 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #29 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 2/2009 Location: Westchester, NY Search Terms: Artist, Painter, Westchester, Mullarkey

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Economic Retaliation Artist known for painting gay pride images; large donation was reported in news media.

Unwanted Communication Approximately 45 emails regarding declarant's donation. A handful use insulting language, many threaten to boycott artist's paintings. Most peacefully express disappointment/opposition. No threats of violence. Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 37 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 330-347 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #30 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Economic Retaliation Business owner received messages through website from multiple persons stating they would no longer patronize his business.

Unwanted Communication Fourteen messages submitted through declarant's business's website complaining of support for Prop 8, many threatening to boycott. No threats of violence. Declarant frames one email as threatening, but in context it is not. Declarant engaged in emails him/herself. Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 38 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 348-350 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #31 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 10/2008 Location: CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Vandalism Four yard signs stolen; one bumper sticker changed from "yes" to "no."

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 39 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 351-356 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #32 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 11/16/2008 Location: OH Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Economic Retaliation Political blog mocked declarant's support for various conservative causes, including the National Organization for Marriage (NOM).

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 40 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 357-359 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #33 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Sept. & Oct. 2008 Location: CA Search Terms:

Was the individual a donor: Y Is the incident related to donation only: N Is the incident related to petitions: N Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: Y Is the incident related to other campaign activities: N If yes, explain involvement in campaign:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Vandalism Ten yard signs removed over two months.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 41 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 360-362 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #34 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 11/1/2008 Location: CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Vandalism One yard sign stolen.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 42 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 363-365 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #35 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Vandalism Yard signs uprooted, ripped, and stolen (three incidents involving same two signs).

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 43 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 366-368 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #36 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 11/2008 Location: CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Vandalism Yard sign stolen twice.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 44 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 369-371 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #37 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 10/2008 Location: CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Vandalism Yard signs stolen/ripped twice. Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 45 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 372-374 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #38 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 11/2008 Location: CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Vandalism Tweleve yard signs removed once.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 46 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 375-377 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #39 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 10/24/2008 Location: CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Vandalism Yard sign stolen once.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 47 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 377-380 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #40 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 10/2008 Location: CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Vandalism Yard sign stolen once; one person made "obscene gesture" due to bumper sticker.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 48 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 381-383 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #41 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 10/2008 Location: CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Vandalism Six signs stolen; unclear if one incident or several.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 49 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 384-392 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #42 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Vandalism Signs stolen during one incident, and vandalized in another incident.

Police Action/Inaction Declarant reported yard sign vandalism and theft; claims police did not respond.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 50 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 393-398 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #43 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 10/31/2008 (Halloween) Location: CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Vandalism Two yard signs vandalized, one stolen (two incidents).

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 51 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 399-401 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #44 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 10/27/2008 Location: CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Vandalism One yard sign stolen.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 52 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 402-405 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #45 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 10/2008 Location: CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Vandalism Two yard signs stolen or vandalized on declarant's property; other signs from other places in neighborhood. Declarant saw "two teenaged boys" running away.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 53 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 406-409 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #46 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Vandalism Five yard signs stolen; also stolen from church in neighborhood.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 54 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 410-416 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #47 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 10/14/2008, 10/21/2008, 10/25/2008 Location: CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Vandalism Two signs stolen; declarant witnessed attempted theft of third sign.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 55 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 417-419 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #48 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 10/2008 Location: CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Vandalism Two yard signs stolen.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 56 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 420-423 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #49 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 10/2008 Location: Los Angeles, CA Search Terms: Catholic Church

Was the individual a donor: N Is the incident related to donation only: N Is the incident related to petitions: N Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: N Is the incident related to other campaign activities: Y If yes, explain involvement in campaign: Passing out signs, urging pastor to make pro-Prop-8 announcement at church

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Vandalism One yard sign stolen.

Discomfort with Friends/Family over Differing Views Pastor told declarant he thought declarant should find another church. (Declarant had lobbied pastor to promote Prop 8; pastor told congregation he wouldn't tell them how to vote).

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 57 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 424-426 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #50 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Fresno, CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Vandalism One yard sign stolen (from business, not home).

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 58 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 427-429 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #51 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 2008 Location: CA Search Terms: Actor, public s speaking

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Unwanted Communication Declarant donated to passage of Prop 8 and claims to have received "many" emails from people angry at support for Prop 8, but did not retain or attach emails. Also claims "over 30 websites" began "slandering" declarant for support as a "bigot," "gay hater," or "racist." Declarant also says his son, an actor, had to change his acting name because of the harassment he received for supporting Prop 8.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 59 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 430-441 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #52 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Oct-Nov 2008 Location: CA Search Terms: Public relations

Was the individual a donor: N Is the incident related to donation only: N Is the incident related to petitions: N Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: N Is the incident related to other campaign activities: Y If yes, explain involvement in campaign: Declarant handled public relations for pro-Prop-8 campaign

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Unwanted Communication 7 emails, a handful accuse declarant of bigotry; others merely express disagreement (declarant him/herself engaged in emails). Declarant's business also received a number of telephone calls; declarant reported one caller to police, who handled matter. Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 60 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 442-445 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #53 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 2/2009 Location: CA Search Terms:

Was the individual a donor: Y Is the incident related to donation only: unclear Is the incident related to petitions: N Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: N Is the incident related to other campaign activities: unclear If yes, explain involvement in campaign: phone calls, yard signs, door-to-door

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Economic Retaliation Received phone calls at work; one caller threatened boycott.

Unwanted Communication Declarant received phone calls at work. No indication calls were threatening or involved crude language. Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 61 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 446-452 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #54 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 2/2009 Location: CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Unwanted Communication Declarant, a law professor, received one email from an identified writer (nonthreatening but using crude language) and one letter at home, similarly nonthreatening but with crude language.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 62 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 453-455 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #55 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 10/2008 Location: CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Vandalism One yard sign stolen.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 63 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 456-459 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #56 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: CA Search Terms:

Was the individual a donor: Y Is the incident related to donation only: unclear Is the incident related to petitions: N Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: unclear Is the incident related to other campaign activities: Y If yes, explain involvement in campaign: canvassing, wave parties

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Unwanted Communication Declarant received one phone call at work from person calling him a "bigot" and saying he should be "ashamed."

Vandalism One yard sign stolen.

Harassment/Threats During Campaign Activities Reported obscene gestures during wave parties. Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 64 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 460-462 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #57 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Oct. & Nov. 2008 Location: CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Vandalism Yard signs stolen or vandalized 3 or 4 times.

Police Action/Inaction Sign theft reported to police; unclear if action taken.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 65 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, excerpts of record, vol. 3 - (ProtecetMarriage.com v. Bowen Declaration) Page # in Filing: 463-465 Type of Document: Declaration Name: John Doe #58 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 10/2008 Location: CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Vandalism One yard sign stolen. Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 66 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, Joint Appendix (complaint) Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Verified complaint - facts section Name: Larry Stickney State & Campaign: WA - Ref 71 Incident Date: unspecified; since initiation of campaign Location: Washington Search Terms: email, e-mail, ProtectMarriage, campaign director, photograph, family, divorce

Was the individual a donor: unclear Is the incident related to donation only: N Is the incident related to petitions: Y Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: N Is the incident related to other campaign activities: Y If yes, explain involvement in campaign: Campaign Manager of ProtectMarriage

Was the incident described in the media: N Is the incident referenced in other sources: N

NOTES

Economic Retaliation Email threatened to boycott those who signed the petition, but not Larry Stickney himself.

Unwanted Communication "Large number" of emails from people who disagree with his position on marriage. Some 'threatening' ("you better stay off the Olympic peninsula"); some harassing ("Dear God Fearing Hate Mongers, Maybe you just want to feel a cock in your ass…"). Alleges late- night phone calls, one specific harassing phone call mentioned. Threat to harm his family posted on blog.

Police Action/Inaction Police report filed regarding blog post threat to harm his family; no indication of action/inaction.

Additional Claims Someone photographing his home while his daughter played outside, late June. News sources and blogs have "focused attention" on intimate details of him and his family including story of his divorce in The Stranger.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 67 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, Joint Appendix (complaint) Page # in Filing: 9 Type of Document: Verified complaint - facts section Name: "petition circulators" State & Campaign: WA - Prop 71 Incident Date: throughout campaign Location: Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: N Is the incident referenced in other sources: N

NOTES

Harassment/Threats During Campaign Activities Allegation: Petition circulators have been subject to threats, harassment, and reprisals while gathering signatures.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 68 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, Joint Appendix (complaint) Page # in Filing: 9 Type of Document: Verified complaint - facts section Name: Protect Marriage Washington and its directors and officers State & Campaign: WA - Ref 71 Incident Date: throughout campaign Location: Washington Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: N Is the incident referenced in other sources: N

NOTES

Harassment/Threats During Campaign Activities Allegation: Protect Marriage Washington and its officers/directors have been subject to threats, harassment, and reprisals while gathering signatures.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 69 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, Joint Appendix (complaint) Page # in Filing: 10 Type of Document: Verified complaint - facts section Name: "petition signers and supporters of traditional mariage across the country" State & Campaign: WA - Ref 71 Incident Date: unclear Location: Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: N Is the incident referenced in other sources: N

NOTES

Harassment/Threats During Campaign Activities Generally alleging harassment, threats, and reprisals of petition signers and supporters of traditional marriage.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 70 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, Joint Appendix (complaint) Page # in Filing: 8 Type of Document: Verified complaint - facts section Name: "petition signers" State & Campaign: WA - Ref 71 Incident Date: 9/6/2009 Location: Washington Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: N

NOTES

Additional Claims Allegation: KnowThyNeighbor.org and WhoSigned.org threatened disclosure of referendum signers' names in a searchable database with the purpose of encouraging individuals to contat those who signed.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 71 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, amicus (American Center for Law and Justice) Page # in Filing: Type of Document: amicus brief Name: Equality Boycott State & Campaign: Arizona Incident Date: Location: Arizona Search Terms: "Prop 102", Arizona, Mormons

Was the incident described in the media: ? Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Economic Retaliation This amicus cites www.equalityboycott.com, which is totally focused on a boycott of donors to Prop. 102 in Arizona. It is an economic boycott of businesses and Mormon church economic interests.

Unwanted Communication Amicus notes knowthyneighbor and WhoSigned.org as wanting to encourage "uncomfortable" conversations "between friends, relatives and neighbors." Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 72 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, amicus (American Civil Rights Union) Page # in Filing: Type of Document: amicus brief Name: State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Fresno Search Terms: Fresno, Autry, Franklin, Clovis, "Bryan Jessup"

Was the individual a donor: N Is the incident related to donation only: N Is the incident related to petitions: N Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: N Is the incident related to other campaign activities: Y If yes, explain involvement in campaign: This is an account of the Fresno death threats arising out of mayor and pastor participation in a Prop 8 rally.

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Harassment/Threats During Campaign Activities This amicus carries another report of the death threat sent to Fresno City Hall and including the mayor (Autry) and a pastor (Franklin) within the email threat. The information comes from a cited TV web story (KFSN-TV). The story also notes that marriage equality supporters are also being harassed. Clovis UU Church had signs torn up and pastor said "every night they endure vandalism because they oppose Prop 8."

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 73 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, amicus (Alliance Defense Fund) Page # in Filing: Type of Document: amicus brief Name: State & Campaign: Incident Date: Location: Massachusetts Search Terms: "Leo Childs", Truro, Gallagher

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Job Loss/Fear of Losing Job Amicus notes a Truro, MA selectmen's vote not to re-appoint a man, Leo Childs, to the volunteer board of fire engineers. Although one selectman raised Mr. Childs' signing a petition opposing marriage equality (information culled from KnowThyNeighbor), the cited story notes that the vote to not re-appoint was unanimous (on a 5-member board) and two other selectmen are quoted as saying they voted for other reasons and that focusing on the petition signing was inappropriate.

Additional Claims Amicus also cites a March 2009 National Organization for Marriage (NOM) poll of 306 MA voters on a variety of questions around marriage equality. ADF points to the poll result that 36% agreed (24% strongly and 12% not strongly) with the statement that some people they know would be reluctant to admit they oppose "gay marriage" because they would worry about the consequences to them or their children.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 74 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Doe v. Reed, Petitioner's brief Page # in Filing: Type of Document: main brief - petitioner Name: State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8, Maine Incident Date: Location: ME, MA, CA Search Terms: Maine, Mendell, Massachusetts, Vadala, Mormon, Hoopes, Stickney

Was the individual a donor: Y Is the incident related to donation only: N Is the incident related to petitions: N Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: N Is the incident related to other campaign activities: Y If yes, explain involvement in campaign: The Maine reference is to a school counselor who appeared in a campaign TV ad

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Vandalism Brief cites to a Maine incident where swastikas were painted on "Yes on One" signs.

Job Loss/Fear of Losing Job Brief references three job-related incidents: (1) the Oakland, CA mayor's placing on hold the reappointment of 96-year-old Lorenzo Hoopes to the board that oversees Oakland's historic Paramount Theater because of a $26,000 donation to support Prop 8; (2) a MA man who was terminated from a Brookstone's store in 2009 after he told a colleague that her marriage to another woman was wrong (and her bringing it up was offensive) - there was no ballot question in MA at the time; and (3) a Maine high school counselor, Don Mendell, who appeared in a TV ad supporting a ME referendum to repeal marriage equality legislation and against whom a complaint was filed with the state board that licenses social workers. Although press reports state that the effort was to rescind Mendell's license, that was not accurate; the complaint simply alleged violations of the relevant Code of Ethics. The broad allegation is intimidation for engaging in political speech.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 75 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Citizens United, amicus (Institute for Justice) Page # in Filing: Type of Document: amicus brief Name: News Story 11/30/08 Rocky Mountain News - Amy Bounds State & Campaign: CA - Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Cinemark, Boulder, "Alan Stock"

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Economic Retaliation Amicus cites as a "reprisal" following Prop 8 this story of a protest at a Boulder, Colorado Cineplex theater. The protest concerned Cineplex CEO, Alan Stock's, $9,999 donation in support of Prop 8. Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 76 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex B Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Declaration of Ronald Prentice Name: State & Campaign: CA - Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Prentice

Was the individual a donor: ? Is the incident related to donation only: N Is the incident related to petitions: N Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: N Is the incident related to other campaign activities: Y If yes, explain involvement in campaign: Prentice was chair of the ad hoc executive committee of ProtectMarriage.

Was the incident described in the media: ? Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Unwanted Communication Prentice's declaration broadly speaks of awareness of harassment and retaliation of donors and volunteers without specifics. As to himself, he says he received regular harassing emails, letters and phone calls; that it was commonplace for him to be called names and receive statements of hate; and that attacks were "attempted" as to his character and integrity.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 77 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex I Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Declaration of Frank Schubert Name: State & Campaign: CA - Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Schubert

Was the incident described in the media: ? Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Unwanted Communication Schubert talks of hundreds of email and phone calls "with threatening overtones"; efforts to publicly confront; taunting on blogs; having his address posted on the Internet as a donor; needing to hire security to protect himself and his business premises; and that "hate mail and threats" continued as of the date of the declaration, 9/15/09. Schubert also recounts harassment of others, identifying "several donors" with business boycotts, "two" physical assaults, "one" car keyed; and "several" people forced from their jobs. He also characterizes the harassment as "incessant, continuous and organized."

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 78 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex L Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Declaration of Hak-Shing William Tam Name: State & Campaign: CA -Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Tam

Was the individual a donor: ? Is the incident related to donation only: N Is the incident related to petitions: N Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: N Is the incident related to other campaign activities: Y If yes, explain involvement in campaign: Tam was head of a coalition of churches supporting Prop 8. He was also one of Prop 8's Official Proponents.

Was the incident described in the media: ? Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Vandalism Tam reports his car was vandalized and that a friend's house was vandalized with spray paint grafitti. He says a "good number of friends" had yard signs vandalized or stolen.

Actual Physical Violence Tam says a friend in his church was "beaten by a person when he was passing out 'Yes on 8' flyers."

Job Loss/Fear of Losing Job Tam reports a friend's boss saw her name as a donor online and "warned her about supporting Prop 8."

Harassment/Threats During Campaign Activities Tam says he "was called derogatory names, threatened to be killed, and told to leave the country." No specific incidents recounted.

Expressions of Racism Tam reports that he was told to leave the country. Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 79 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex M Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Declaration of Sarah Troupis Name: State & Campaign: CA - Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Troupis

Was the incident described in the media: N Is the incident referenced in other sources: N

NOTES

Additional Claims Troupis is the Alliance Defense Fund attorney who declares here that she prepared all the Doe affidavits in ProtectMarriage.com v. Bowen. She also avers that she interviewed "several other individuals" who suffered harassment and threats but were "unwilling to submit declarations" even as protected John Does "because of the fear that, despite the protective order, their names would become public knowledge and they would be subject to further threats and harassment."

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 80 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-1 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: newspaper story 12/26/08 (Wall Street Journal) Name: Donor Disclosure Has its Downsides State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Eckern, Raddon, Cinemark, Christoffersen

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Economic Retaliation This WSJ story includes references to a Palo Alto dentist losing patients; the LA restaurant manager donating $100 and facing demonstrations and boycott; the LA Film Fesitival director who resigned because of threatened picketing and a boycott; and Alan Stock CEO of Cinemark "facing a boycott."

Job Loss/Fear of Losing Job Recounts the stories of (1) Scott Eckern of CA Music Theater resigning; (2) Richard Raddon, LA Film Fesitval director resigning; and (3) Marjorie Chirstoffersen, the LA restaurant manager resigning.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 81 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-2 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: newspaper column 12/17/2008 LA Times Name: Readers Have Choice Words … on Prop 8 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Christoffersen, Lopez

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Economic Retaliation This LA Times column (Steve Lopez) is a follow-up to a column about the LA restaurant manager forced to resign because $100 donation led to picketing and boycott. Restaurant is El Coyote. Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 82 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-3 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: TV Station web story 10/31/08 KGPE CBS Name: Proposition 8 Death Threats State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Autry, Franklin

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Vandalism This is Pastor Franklin of Cornerstone Church who says his home, church and church office were egged.

Harassment/Threats During Campaign Activities This web story is about the death threats to Fresno mayor Alan Autry and Pastor Jim Franklin.

Police Action/Inaction Police involved; provided security to Autry and Franklin; speaks of search warrant and expected arrest.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 83 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-4 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: TV Station web story 10/31/08 ABC Fresno Name: Prop 8 Death Threats State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Autry, Franklin, Perez

Was the individual a donor: N Is the incident related to donation only: N Is the incident related to petitions: N Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: N Is the incident related to other campaign activities: Y If yes, explain involvement in campaign: Story references threats from participation in pro-Prop 8 rally

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Vandalism This story mentions that "'yes' and 'no' signs are disappearing all over town."

Harassment/Threats During Campaign Activities This web story is about the death threats to Fresno mayor Alan Autry and Pastor Jim Franklin.

Police Action/Inaction Police involved; mentions search warrant and potential arrest.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 84 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Moton, Ex K-5 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: TV Station web story 11/7/08 ABC Fresno Name: Prop 8 Email Threats State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Autry, Franklin, Kobos

Was the individual a donor: N Is the incident related to donation only: N Is the incident related to petitions: N Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: N Is the incident related to other campaign activities: Y If yes, explain involvement in campaign: Story focuses on fact mayor was threatened via email

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Harassment/Threats During Campaign Activities This web story is about the death threats to Fresno mayor Alan Autry and Pastor Jim Franklin.

Police Action/Inaction This story follows the alleged threatening email and an alleged sender's home. Police seemed to decide that the person of interest was not actually involved.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 85 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-6 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Web story - Culture and Media Institute 11/19/2008 Name: O'Reilly Alone Reports Gay Attack on Christians State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Raezler, Castro, Lansing, "Palm Springs" "white powder"

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Actual Physical Violence This is a summary story of various events including the 11/14/08 incident in the Castro with evangelical Christians. There is indication of some physical altercations, e.g., one person said she was hit over the head with the Bible that had been taken from her.

Harassment/Threats During Campaign Activities Story includes Palm Springs rally where cross was snatched from counter-protestor and stomped on.

Expressions of Religious Bigotry Again, the Castro incident with the evangelical Christians; the 11/9/08 action at a Lansing, Michigan church; and the "white powder" sent to two Mormom temples.

Expressions of Racism Recounts, without specificity (other than "last week" in a 11/19/08 story), a protest with "shouted racial slurs, including the n-word …."

Police Action/Inaction Discusses police involvement in the Castro incident. Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 86 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-7 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: TV Station web story 11/14/08 KTVU Oakland Name: Anger Over Prop 8 Erupts in SF State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Castro

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Actual Physical Violence Straightforward news story of the Castro incident with evangelical Christians on Friday night after Prop 8 passed.

Police Action/Inaction Describes police in riot gear excorting the religious group out of the area.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 87 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-8 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: TV Station web story 10/22/08 NBC San Diego Name: Prop 8 Supporter Attacked while Distributing Sings State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 10/19/2008 Location: Modesto, CA Search Terms: Modesto, Nunez, "St. Stanislaus", Riverside, "Fair Oaks"

Was the individual a donor: N Is the incident related to donation only: N Is the incident related to petitions: N Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: N Is the incident related to other campaign activities: Y If yes, explain involvement in campaign: Primarily the story of a man passing out signs outside a Catholic Church when a man grapped c. 75 signs and ran. When caught up with, the thief punched the man in the face.

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Vandalism Story includes a general reference to the theft of yard signs and to a Riverside woman who had her garage sprayed with grafitti.

Actual Physical Violence The confrontation between the sign distributor and the sign stealer led to the thief punching the other man in the face.

Police Action/Inaction No reference of police involvement.

Additional Claims This story also noted ugliness on both sides and references a Fair Oaks home where a teenager burned No on 8 yard signs.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 88 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-9 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story - Deseret News 11/14/08 Name: Powder Scares 2 LDS temples, Catholic plant State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Salt Lake City, Los Angeles, New Haven Search Terms: "white powder", "Knights of Columbus", temple

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Police Action/Inaction FBI was investigating.

Additional Claims Story of white powder in envelopes received by two Mormom temples and by a Knights of Columbus printing plant. Story notes that there is no known connection to Prop 8.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 89 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-10 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: TV Station web story 11/7/08 NBC LA Name: Prop 8 Protesters March Into Night State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 11/6/2008 Location: Los Angeles Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Vandalism During march, protesters ripped a Pro-Prop 8 sign on a truck. See "Physical Violence."

Actual Physical Violence The ripped sign led to a fight but it was a protester on "No" side who got punched and ended up with a bloody nose. The story also notes the one person threw eggs at the marchers.

Police Action/Inaction Seven arrests were made.

Additional Claims March began with a protest at a Mormon temple.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 90 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-11 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story - Deseret News 11/13/08 Name: Protests over Prop 8 Outcome Getting Personal State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: various Search Terms: Leatherby

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Economic Retaliation Leatherby said his business (unspecified) has been targeted by bloggers; Purves says a protester carrying a sign ("Purves Family Supports Homophobia") picketed his business one day.

Job Loss/Fear of Losing Job Tells story of Scott Eckern of CA Musical Theater forced to resign because of threatened boycott.

Expressions of Religious Bigotry Story recounts fire outside LDS church in Littleton, Colorado. Burning copy of Book of Mormon found on doorstep. No damage to the church.

Additional Claims Story references the many protests across the country following the election.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 91 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-12 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Magazine Story 11/19/08 - Charisma Magazine Name: Radical Gay Activists seek to Intimidate Christians State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: various Search Terms: Charisma, Gaines, Castro, Lansing, "Palm Springs", Burgess, Downey, "Calvery Chapel Ventura", "Shingle Springs", Domen

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Unwanted Communication Reports Park Community Church in Shingle Springs, CA received harassing phone calls (and threatened with lawsuits).

Vandalism Story collects a list of alleged incidents of church vandalism: (1) Messiah Lutheran in Downey, CA (Yes sign used to smash window in pastor's office); (2) Calvery Chapel Ventura (yard signs stolen and church's large banner stolen); (3) Orangeville CA Mormon church spray-painted with "No on 8"; (4) Family Fellowship Church in Hayward, CA (brick through window); (5) Trinity Baptist Church in Arcata, CA (marquee vandalized, flags stolen, other acts totalling $1,500); (6) Assembly of God in San Luis Obispo (eggs thrown at building and toilet paper strewn on property); and (7) San Luis Obispo Mormon church had adhesive poured on doormat, keypad and a window.

Actual Physical Violence The pushed 69-year-old Palm Springs woman (Phyllis Burgess). Also retells the story of the evangelical group in the Castro - reports one person hit on the head with her Bible and then shoved to the ground and kicked and reports lewd remarks, thrown hot coffee and a threat of death to group leader.

Harassment/Threats During Campaign Activities Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 92 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Mentions unspecified death threat to a CA minister (could be Pastor Franklin in Fresno - not clear).

Expressions of Religious Bigotry Story has more detail about the alleged activities of "Bash Back" at a service of the Mount Hope Assembly of God church in Lansing, MI. There was a distraction protest outside to draw security and then folks inside the church stood up, disrupted the service, threw fliers, pulled the fire alarm and one couple went to the front and kissed in front of the pastor.

Police Action/Inaction The story notes police involvement in the Castro and launching an investigation in Lansing. Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 93 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-13 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Web Posting, starting 11/5/08 with picture identifying 4 people celebrating Prop 8 victory in Irvine Name: State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Irvine Search Terms: Knobe, "Amanda Stanfield", Domen, Gaddis

Was the incident described in the media: N Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Unwanted Communication This is an online conversation about 4 people whose picture appeared, apparently in the LA Times, celebrating the Prop 8 victory. The discussion indicates that emails were sent to at least 2 of the 4 and to co-workers (focus is on Stanfield and Domen, an ex-gay and pastor).

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 94 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-14 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Newsweek blog 9/8/09 Name: Threats, Legal Action in WA Gay-Marriage debate State & Campaign: WA, R-71 Incident Date: Location: Washington Search Terms: Gesaman, "Queer Equality Revolution", WhoSigned.Org

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: N

NOTES

Economic Retaliation Story notes messages on WhoSigned.Org threatened to boycott the businesses of anyone who signed the petition.

Harassment/Threats During Campaign Activities Quotes an August '09 posting on Queer Equality Revolution that advocated violence "against the property" of all who support the petition but then also says any normal person would be "driven to get a gun and kill those who tried such evil cruelty …."

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 95 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-15 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story 2/8/09 - NYTimes - Brad Stone Name: Disclosure, Magnified on the Web State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: "Brad Stone", eightmaps.com, "Joseph Clare"

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Unwanted Communication This story is generally about eightmaps.com, but references two individuals: (1) an unnamed professor at UCSF who received confrontational emails with one copied to a dozen colleagues and supervisors; and (2) a SF accountant, Joseph Clare, who received several emails accusing him of "donating to hate."

Additional Claims Story raises the question of whether things like eightmaps.com are contrary to the purposes of voter disclosure laws. Attempts to be even-handed.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 96 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-16 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Editorial Page column 4/30/09 - St Louis Post-Dispatch - Colleen Carroll Campbell Name: Attacks on Miss California … State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: "Colleen Carroll Campbell", Prejean

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Additional Claims This is an opinion piece on Carrie Prejean that then goes on to reference a variety of incidents of harassment that the author has clearly read about - nothing not recounted elsewhere.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 97 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-17 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Web story - Providence Journal Name: Same-Sex Marriage Protestors Assaulted with Food State & Campaign: Rhode Island Incident Date: 7/28/2009 Location: Warwick, RI Search Terms: Warwick

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Police Action/Inaction Police investigated as an assault.

Additional Claims Story of harassment by a group of women in a car of 4 men standing on a median protesting against marriage equality. A bottle was thrown and 15 minutes later food, drinks and profanities were hurled again.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 98 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion Ex K-18 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Magazine Story 3/16/09 - Weekly Standard Name: The New Blacklist State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Mullarkey

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Unwanted Communication This is the writer, a painter's, personal story of emails she received because of her $500 contribution to Prop 8 and then the hateful emails (and letters, it seems) she received after the New York Daily News did a story on her and noted that she had done a series of paintings based on images from NY Gay Pride in the early '90s. She quotes many email messages. Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 99 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-19 (this is a duplicate of Ex K-15) Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Name: State & Campaign: Incident Date: Location: Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 100 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-20 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News story 10/9/08 - Sacramento Bee Name: Mormon Church in Orangevale vandalized State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 11/7/2008 Location: Search Terms: Orangevale, Riverside, Fresno

Was the individual a donor: Y Is the incident related to donation only: N Is the incident related to petitions: N Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: N Is the incident related to other campaign activities: Y If yes, explain involvement in campaign: References the death threats to a Fresno pastor (presumably Franklin)

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Vandalism This story's subject is the spraypainting of "No on 8" at the Mormon church in Orangevale, CA. It includes a reference to yard signs being arranged into a swastika at a Roman Catholic church in Riverside, CA.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 101 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-21 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: TV web story 10/28/08 - ABC Fresno Name: Vandals Egg Downtown Fresno Church State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 10/28/2008 Location: Fresno Search Terms: Cornerstone, Franklin

Was the individual a donor: N Is the incident related to donation only: N Is the incident related to petitions: N Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: N Is the incident related to other campaign activities: Y If yes, explain involvement in campaign: The church that was egged, Cornerstone Church, was led by Pastor Jim Franklin who had spoken at a Prop 8 rally two days earlier and reported there that his home had been egged.

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Vandalism Offices and sanctuary of church were egged. This is Fresno pastor Jim Franklin's church.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 102 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-22 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: TV web story 11/7/08 - CBS LA Name: Vandals Arrange Prop 8 signs into Swastika State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 11/6/2008 Location: Riverside, CA Search Terms: Riverside, swastika

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Vandalism Signs supporting Prop 8 were rearranged into a swastika two days after the election at a Roman Catholic Church, Our Lady of Perpetual Help, in Riverside. No damage was done to the grounds or the church, police said.

Police Action/Inaction Story notes police comment.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 103 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-23 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News story 10/20/08 - Orange County Register - Barbara Giasone Name: Vandals Spray Paint signs in Fullerton State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 10/18-19/08 Location: Fullerton, CA Search Terms: Giasone, Fullerton

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Vandalism Story reports that 500 "Yes on 8" signs were reported missing throughout the city. No timeframe identified. Not the focus of the story.

Police Action/Inaction Police quoted on vandalism and say violators will be prosecuted. Police contact number listed.

Additional Claims Prime focus of this story is the spraypainting of some commercial buildings in a retail block in Fullerton. Apparently, some "tagging" was done on houses as well. The message was "Prop H8ATE."

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 104 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-24 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: TV web story 10/31/08 - ABC LA Name: Vandals on grafitti spree in San Bernardino County neighborhood … State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Yucaipa, CA Search Terms: Banfield, Yucaipa, Antinucci

Was the individual a donor: N Is the incident related to donation only: N Is the incident related to petitions: N Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: Y? Is the incident related to other campaign activities: N If yes, explain involvement in campaign:

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Vandalism Story reports that a number of houses on one block found political messages painted in orange on vehicles, garages, fences and "Yes on 8" signs. What was painted was not identified.

Police Action/Inaction Subject of a sheriff's department investigation.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 105 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-25 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: TV web story 10/25/08 - ABC LA Name: Anti-prop 8 Vandals hit Alta Loma Home State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Alta Loma, CA Search Terms: "Suzie Taylor", trailer, "Alta Loma"

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Vandalism Woman's trailer home was spraypainted on 3 sides with "love for all," "no on 8" and "equal rights." Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 106 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-26 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: TV web story 10/27/08 - ABC SF Name: Vandals struck overnight in San Jose State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: San Jose, CA Search Terms: "Kelly Byrne"

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Vandalism Two homes had garage doors sprayed with "No on 8." A "Yes on 8" sign was painted over.

Police Action/Inaction Police took a report.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 107 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-27 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: TV web story 10/28/08 - CBS LA Name: Vandals Target Prop 8 Supporters in NorCal State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: San Jose, CA Search Terms: San Jose

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Vandalism Another incident of a garage door being spraypainted with "No on 8." It does not seem duplicative of Ex K-26.

Police Action/Inaction There is a police comment with a spokesman saying he knows of at least 4 reported incidents involving Prop 8 "political sign vandalism."

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 108 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-28 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News story 10/21/08 - Orange County Register - Barbara Giasone Name: Five Held on Suspicion of stealing "Yes" on Prop 8 signs State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 10/21/2008 Location: Fullerton, CA Search Terms: Giasone, Fullerton

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Vandalism Police stopped a car and found 3 "no on 8" signs, 10 torn-up "yes on 8" signs and 3 McCain/Palin signs. The "yes" signs were allegedly stolen.

Police Action/Inaction Police made an arrest.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 109 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-29 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Story in California Aggie - published 10/29/08 Name: Prop 8 Supporters Face Sign Theft, Vandalism State & Campaign: Incident Date: Location: Davis, CA; Sacramento, CA Search Terms: Davis, Meirovitz, "Cedric Papa"

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Vandalism This story's focus is on vandalism to yard signs in Davis. One specific example (Meirovitz) and Cedric Papa says he lost 14 signs and estimate 200+ taken in Davis. There is a reference to "several incidents" in Sacramento.

Harassment/Threats During Campaign Activities Story does also mention the water balloons lobbed at the "Yes on 8" table on the Quad at UC Davis.

Police Action/Inaction Story notes Davis and Sacramento police and Yolo County sheriff say no police reports had been filed regarding damaged or stolen signs.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 110 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-30 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story 10/30/08 Orange County Register - Salvador Hernandez Name: Prop 8 Sign - stealing ignites free speech debate State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Hernandez, Singham, "Robert Thompson"

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Vandalism This is a story about the big picture of yard signs, focusing on a straight man who was removing signs from public spots, believing it was legal. The story says sign theft and vandalism reported in Santa Ana, Yorba Linda, Huntington Beach, Fountain Valley, Irvine and Laguna Hills. Recounts the 5 arrested in Fullerton, and describes two Irvine incidents. Irvine police say they've "had continued reports on both sides." A "Yes on 8" organizer says the campaign estimates c. 25,000 signs have been stolen or vandalized.

Police Action/Inaction Police say they don't keep track of the numbers, but Orange County sheriff's department says it has not seen a spike in incidents.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 111 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-31 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story 10/31/08 Orange County Register - Chris Daines Name: Dana point man will keep replacing downed signs … State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Vogeler, "Pacific Coast Highway"

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Vandalism Focus of story is William Vogeler, who puts up "Yes on 8" signs along highways it seems and finds them constantly removed. The signs at his home have not been disturbed. He put up a 7' wooden sign at an intersection and it was gone the next day; he replaced it with a steel sign. Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 112 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-32 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Web Story 10/19/08 - KCRA.com Name: Both Sides … See Signs Destroyed State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Lluen, "Fair Oaks" Subramanian

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Vandalism Story reports sheriff's office saying signs on both sides are being stolen. The examples both seen to be on the "yes" side - Hector Lluen says a sign nailed to his home's front door in Fair Oaks was stolen. The other person (Linda Subramanian) is not identified by town.

Police Action/Inaction There is a police comment.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 113 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-33 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story 10/28/08 - Sacramento Bee Crime Blog - David Richie Name: Arrests made in Roseville … State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Roseville, CA Search Terms: Roseville, Greene, Flieder

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Vandalism Focus of this story is the arrest of three people, two 18-year-olds and one 17-year-old for stealing fifty-three yard signs. It notes the "yes" campaign's local coordinator as reporting some spray paint vandalism as well.

Police Action/Inaction Notes one person filing two police reports re: theft of signs from her yard. She is a "yes" campaign coordinator. No indication of what police response, if any.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 114 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-34 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: TV Web story 1/4/09 - ABC SF Name: Vandals Spray-Painted Swastikas on catholic Church in Castro State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 1/3/2009 Location: SF, CA Search Terms: "Most Holy Redeemer"

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Vandalism Gay-friendly Catholic Church in Castro spray-painted with swastikas.

Police Action/Inaction Police were investigating.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 115 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-35 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Newspaper Column 12/14/08 - LA Times - Steve Lopez Name: A Life Thrown in Turmoil by $100 donation State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: LA Search Terms: Christoffersen

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Economic Retaliation This is a follow-up column by Lopez on the manager (Christoffersen) of El Coyote Restaurant who donated $100 to Yes on 8 and found her restaurant the subject of picketing and boycott. Story says that, in December '08, business is down 30%.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 116 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-36 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: TV Web Story 12/11/08 - FoxNews.com Name: Major Victory for Prop 8 Protestors State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: LA Search Terms: Christoffersen

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Job Loss/Fear of Losing Job This is another opinion piece on the El Coyote manager (Christoffersen) being forced to resign because of her $100 donation to "Yes on 8."

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 117 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-37 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story 10/31/08 Lodi News-Sentinal - Jennifer Bonnett Name: Galt Attorney - Son Harassed by Teacher over Prop 8 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Galt, CA Search Terms: ReidReynoso, Bauer, Galt

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Actual Physical Violence Student who protested California Teachers' Association donation to "No on 8" was allegedly slapped by fellow students and received death threats.

Harassment/Threats During Campaign Activities Student received death threats from fellow students (high school).

Additional Claims Claim here is by father that a teacher used a classroom exercise to target his son for supporting Prop 8.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 118 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-38 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Web piece by SF Chronicle's editorial page editor 11/23/08 - John Diaz Name: Ugly Backlash Over Prop 8 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Diaz, dentist, "Palo Alto", Eckern

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Economic Retaliation The piece speaks of "blacklists" circulating on the Internet without any further specificity. References the Palo Alto dentist and here says he "lost two patients." Piece begins noting that a Prop 8 supporter published a letter in the SF Chronicle that led to a search for, and dissemination of, all his personal information and the urging of a boycott of his small business (no name attached).

Job Loss/Fear of Losing Job Recounts Scott Eckern of the California Musical Theater who resigned. Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 119 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-39 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story 11/25/08 Hollywood Reporter Name: Richard Raddon Resigns post State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Raddon, "Film Independent", Cinemark, "Alan Stock"

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Economic Retaliation Story is not focused on this but does mention the possibility of a selective boycott of Holiday Village Cinemas used by Sundance Film Festival because it is owned by Cinemark, whose CEO Alan Stock, donated to "Yes on 8."

Job Loss/Fear of Losing Job Focus of this story is the resignation of Richard Raddon of the Los Angeles Film Festival (run by Film Independent) after his $1,500 donation in support of Prop 8 came to light.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 120 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-40 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story 11/12/08 Sacramento Bee Name: Theater Felt Growing Pressure before Artistic Director Quit State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 11/12/2008 Location: Search Terms: Eckern, "California Musical Festival", Shaiman

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Economic Retaliation This story focuses on Scott Eckern of California Musical Theater and his donation in support of Prop 8. It recounts efforts to boycott CMT and speaks of "blacklisting" Eckern.

Job Loss/Fear of Losing Job Focus is the resignation of Scott Eckern of California Musical Theater.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 121 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-41 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Web story 10/21/08 KCRA.com Name: Student Leaders face Recall over Prop 8 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: "American River College", "Jorge Riley"

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Additional Claims Story concerns an effort to recall three members of the student council at American River College (a two-year state community college) after the Student Council voted to endorse Prop 8.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 122 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-42 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Time Magazine web story 11/15/08 - Alison Stateman Name: What Happens if you're on Gay Rights' Enemies List State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: AntiGayBlacklist.com, "Californians Against Hate", Karger, Eckern

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Economic Retaliation This is a general story about efforts to organize boycotts against businesses that supported Prop 8.

Job Loss/Fear of Losing Job Scott Eckern's resignation is discussed.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 123 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-43 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Editorial 12/10/08 LA Times Name: Prop 8 - Boycott or Blacklist State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Eckern, Christoffersen, blacklist

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Economic Retaliation This editorial supports boycotts but deplores "a vengeful campaign against individuals" and cites Scott Eckern of the California Musical Theater and Ms. Christoffersen of El Coyote (the restaurant manager) both of whom resigned. Also comments negatively on "Yes on 8" campaign's letters to No supporters demanding equal contribution (or be outed for opposing Prop 8).

Job Loss/Fear of Losing Job Editorial weighs in against tactics that lead to forced resignations like Scott Eckern's and Ms. Christoffersen at El Coyote restaurant.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 124 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-44 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: TV web story 11/13/08 - CBS News Name: Prop 8 Anger Spurs Donor Blacklists State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: blacklists, AntiGayBlacklist.com, Christoffersen, Eckern

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Economic Retaliation This story focuses on posting of Internet lists of donors and references AntiGayBlacklist.com. Without naming her, it references Ms. Christoffersen of El Coyote and the call for a boycott of her restaurant; and it mentions Scott Eckern (California Musical Theater) and his resignation. It notes a blacklist on the "Yes" side as well (the letters demanding equal money from "No" supporters).

Job Loss/Fear of Losing Job Cites Scott Eckern resignation from California Musical Theater.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 125 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-45 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News story 11/15/08 Name: Prop 8 Passage Inspires Protests … State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Eckern, Christoffersen

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Economic Retaliation Reference to picketing at El Coyote (although restaurant name or manager Christoffersen's name not mentioned).

Unwanted Communication Non-specific reference to "harassing phone calls, intimidation, it just goes on and on."

Actual Physical Violence Says that "others have been beaten up for their support in Carlsbad," without any specifics.

Job Loss/Fear of Losing Job References resignation of "artistic director of a musical-theater company in Sacramento" without mentioning Scott Eckern's name.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 126 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-46 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story 11/14/08 LA Times Name: Prop 8 Protesters target Businesses State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Christoffersen, Cinemark, Lassen's, Hoehn

Was the incident described in the media: y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Economic Retaliation This story is primarily focused on efforts to boycott businesses that supported Prop 8. Familiar names are Cinemark and El Coyote restaurant (Christoffersen manager). New names are Hoehn (a Honda dealer; more than $25,000 personal donation) and Lassen's (a health food store chain; owners gave $27,500).

Unwanted Communication Honda dealer Robert Hoehn personally gave more than $25,000 to support Prop 8. He reports "dozens and dozens and dozens" of phone calls and that, after passage, he received a few "vitriolic messages and phone calls."

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 127 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-47 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Web Story 11/16/08 KCRA.com Name: Family-Run Creamery Gave Thousands to "Yes on 8" Campaign State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Sacramento, CA Search Terms: Leatherby

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Economic Retaliation Story of a protest outside Leatheby's Family Creamery where a dozen protesters held signs and distributed free sherbet. Story also reports that a crowd lined up to support the store. The owner, the business and his relatives gave a total of $20,000 to support Prop 8.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 128 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-48 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Opinion Column 12/27/08 WSJ - Jim Carlton Name: Gay Activists Boycott backers of Prop 8 State & Campaign: Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Christoffersen, Eckern, Raddon

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Economic Retaliation This story focuses on boycotts. Primarily it is about El Coyote and Ms. Christoffersen. It also mentions Eckern (California Musical Theater) and Raddon (LA Film Festival).

Job Loss/Fear of Losing Job Resignations of Marjorie Christoffersen (El Coyote) and Scott Eckern (California Musical Theater) are mentioned. The article (12/27/08) says Ms. Christoffersen "returned to the café when the protest faded." It still cites revenue loss of 30%.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 129 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-49 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story 12/21/08 USA Today Name: Prop 8 Foes Turn to "Blacklist" Tactics State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Hoehn, Christoffersen, Manchester, "Terry Caster"

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Economic Retaliation This story focuses on economic boycotts. There is El Coyote and Marjorie Christoffersen again and Robert Hoehn and his Honda dealership where there have been protesters. The article also talks of San Diego developer, Doug Manchester, who donated $125,000 and has seen protests against his hotels and lost "several national conventions and conferences." Also, A-1 Self Storage with 30 locations was targeted by Karger's Californians Against Hate because the owner, Terry Caster, and family members donated $693,000. There are also some general assertions that small businesses in Hollywood and West Hollywood have lost customers because of donations in support of Prop 8.

Unwanted Communication Robert Hoehn (Honda dealer) reports receiving "the most vitriolic kinds of emails, letters and phone calls."

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 130 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-50 (This is a duplicate of Ex K-11 - published in a different paper) Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story 11/12/08 Sacramento Bee Name: Prop 8 Victors Upset by Personal Attacks State & Campaign: Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Leatherby

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 131 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-51 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story 11/14/08 Orange County Register - Wisckol Name: Prop 8 Leaders Accuse Foes of harassment, intimidation State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: "El Coyote", Christoffersen, Eckern, Cinemark

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Economic Retaliation Story focuses on a Prop 8 supporter conference 10 days following the election where boycotts were denounced. Suggests 6 boycotts or threatened boycotts but only El Coyote (Marjorie Christoffersen) and California Musical Theater (Scott Eckern) are identified. Cinemark is mentioned as a "possible target."

Actual Physical Violence Just mentions the white powder sent to two Mormon temples.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 132 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-52 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Web Story 12/1/08 FoxNews.com Name: Activists Target Mormons for [Prop 8] Success in CA State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Eckern, "A-1 Storage" Arapaho, "Book of Mormon"

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Economic Retaliation Story primarily about the focus of protests against the Mormon church. Mentions call for boycott of A-1 Storage where owner and family gave c. $700,000.

Vandalism References the burning of the Book of Mormon on the steps of the Colorado Mormon church (in Arapaho County).

Job Loss/Fear of Losing Job Mentions resignation of Scott Eckern of California Musical Theater.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 133 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-53 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story 10/27/08 SF Chronicle - Matthal Kuruvila, Religion Writer Name: Mormons Face Flak for backing Prop 8 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Mormonsfor8.com, Sundstrom

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Harassment/Threats During Campaign Activities Story tells of Michelle Sundstrom and her husband, Mormons, who gave $30,000 in support of Prop 8. In response, two women parked an SUV in front of their house with "Bigots live here" painted on the windshield.

Additional Claims Story's focus is on casting a spotlight on Mormon contributions to Prop 8 and websites to identify Mormon contributors. Also mentions a protest at a temple in Oakland.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 134 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-54 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story 11/10/08 SF Chronicle Name: Same-Sex marriage backers hit Capital, churches State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Mormon

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Economic Retaliation This story is mainly about the gay community protesting the results of Prop 8 the weekend following the vote. It makes a mention of advocacy for a boycott of travel to Utah and of Mormon-owned businesses. No specifics. Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 135 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-55 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story 9/7/08 Orange County Register Name: Local donors give $1.6 million for ban on gay marriage State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: "Orange County"

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Additional Claims This article comes from early in the Prop 8 campaign (9/7/08) and talks about how heavily Orange County is supporting Prop 8 and identifies a number of significant donors with the amount of their contributions. It is an informational piece by a newspaper.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 136 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-56 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story 11/23/08 SF Chronicle Name: Gay-Rights Activists Protest Prop 8 at Capitol State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Additional Claims This article is primarily about the gay community preparing to fight again and focuses on a rally at the Capitol on Saturday, November 22, 2008. There is a mention of "anti- Mormon" comments by speaker Margaret Cho in a song she wrote and comments by Robin Tyler that attacks on Prop 8 supporters were not so bad - "easier to wash a paint stain off a church than to take off the stain they left on the California Constitution."

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 137 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-57 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story 11/23/08 SF Chronicle Name: Hollywood and the same-sex Marriage Fight State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Hollywood, Eckern, Cinemark, Sundance, Raddon

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Economic Retaliation This is a story about Hollywood and thus is about Raddon (not yet resigned) of the LA Film Festival; Scott Eckern (resigned at California Musical Theater); possible Cinemark as a target (because of CEO Alan Stock's contributions); talk of a Sundance boycott (for using a Cinemark theater - but story notes this was going nowhere). Notes Hollywood is wary of boycotts, noting the 8-year Southern Baptist boycott of Disney.

Job Loss/Fear of Losing Job Mention of Scott Eckern's resignation at California Musical Theater. Richard Raddon on LA Film Festical had offered his resignation but, at the time of this story, it had been rejected. Actual resignation came later.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 138 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-58 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story 11/19/08 Ventura County Star Name: Owner Backed Ballot measure State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Lassen's, Manchester, "Container Supply", Eckern, Christoffersen

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Economic Retaliation Focus of story is economic boycotts with particular attention to Lassen's Natural Foods & Vitamins in Ventura (also in Camarillo and Simi Valley). Owner of the Ventura store, Peter Lassen, contributed $27,500. Mentions Doug Manchester, his $125,000 contribution and the call to boycott his two San Diego hotels. Notes that online lists of donors had been published of small businesses and donors as well as major donors such as Container Supply Co. of garden Grove ($250,000). Without being specific, story talks of protests at LA Mexican restaurant (it has to be El Coyote and Christoffersen).

Job Loss/Fear of Losing Job Mention again of Scott Eckern's resignation at California Musical Theater.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 139 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-59 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story 7/10/08 San Diego Union-Tribune Name: Gay Rights Group to Boycott Manchester Grand Hyatt State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Manchester, Hyatt

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Economic Retaliation Story is about the call for a boycott of San Diego's Grand Hyatt hotel because its owner, Doug Manchester, donated $125,000 to support Prop 8. Interestingly, while other reports note that the hotel lost two national events, this story states that two gay groups, GLAAD and PlanetOut Inc., moved events scheduled for the hotel. The story notes Terry Caster's gift of $162,500 and Robert Hoehn of Hoehn Motors in Carlsbad ($25,000).

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 140 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-60 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Web Story 11/18/08 Indybay.org Name: Rally Against Prop H8: Manchester Grand Hyatt State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Manchester, Hyatt

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Economic Retaliation This seems to be a gay website story about a rally called at Manchester's Hyatt to protest his contribution to Prop 8 ($125,000) and his treatment of housekeeper workers.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 141 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-61 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story 6/15/06 Name: A Church Names Names of Gay-Marriage Foes State & Campaign: Florida Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Florida

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Additional Claims This story concerns a Florida church that decided to follow KnowThyNeighbor from Massachusetts and post the names of all the signers of the petition for the Florida marriage constitutional amendment. Story is about views on this generally from all sides.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 142 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-62 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story 3/5/09 - NPR Name: Backers of Calif. Gay Marriage Ban face Backlash State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Christoffersen, Eckern, Raddon, Leatherby's

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Economic Retaliation This is a story of boycotts and threatened boycotts: El Coyote (and Ms. Christoffersen) saying business dipped 30% and hasn't returned to pre-protest levels yet; Leatherby's Family Creamery (with owner saying business went up the day of the protest); and the Eckern and Raddon resignations from the California Musical Theater and the LA Film Festival, respectively, due to threatened boycotts.

Unwanted Communication Leatherby's owner says he got "very nasty emails, letters and phone calls by the hundreds."

Job Loss/Fear of Losing Job Scott Eckern (California Musical Theater) and Richard Raddon (LA Film Festival) are noted again. Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 143 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-63 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story 2/12/09 Salt Lake Tribune Name: Gay Rights Group - Garff Automotive Meet; Boycott Goes On State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Garff, Karger

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Economic Retaliation This story concerns a boycott of Garff Automotive Group with 65 car dealerships in 6 states, including California and Utah. Fred Karger's Californians Against Hate called the boycott because the matriarch of the Garff family made a $100,000 donation in support of Prop 8.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 144 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-64 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story 5/9/09 San Diego Union-Tribune Name: Hotelier Manchester offering $125,000 to gay, lesbian groups State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Manchester, Hyatt

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Economic Retaliation This is a follow-up story about the boycott of the Manchester Grand Hyatt in San Diego - now 10 months after the boycott was called. Owner, Manchester, offered $125,000 (in cash and hotel credit) to lgbt groups (matching his $125,000 donation to support Prop 8. Unconfirmed reports say the hotel has lost $7 million in business due to the boycott.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 145 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-65 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story 1/19/09 NYTimes Name: Donors Against Gay Marriage want to be Anonymous State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Economic Retaliation Story is focused on the lawsuit in CA to stop disclosure of names of donors. It mentions boycotts and Alliance Defense Fund's laundry list of "bad acts" against Prop 8 supporters. No specific boycott mentioned.

Unwanted Communication Mentions allegations of threatening emails.

Actual Physical Violence Mentions "white powder" sent to a Mormon temple and a Knights of Columbus facility.

Job Loss/Fear of Losing Job Cites Richard Raddon's resignation from the LA Film Festival.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 146 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-66 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story 2/16/09 LA Times Name: LA College is sued over speech on gay marriage State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: "Jonathan Lopez", Matteson

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Additional Claims Story concerns a LA City College student suing because a teacher allegedly refused to let him finish a speech in a public speaking class because it spoke against marriage equality. Teacher also allegedly called the student a "fascist bastard."

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 147 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-67 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Radio web story (date uncertain, probably c. 11/12/08) - KNX 1070 Name: Gay Activists Protest Mormons in NYC State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Mormon

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Economic Retaliation Story is about the protest outside the Mormon temple in NYC a week or so after Prop 8 passed. Its last sentence says "Activists also are aiming boycotts and protests at businesses and individuals who contributed to the campaign to pass Proposition 8." Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 148 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-68 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story 2/13/09 San Diego Union-Tribune Name: Clinton Won't Cancel Talk at Boycotted Hotel State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Clinton, Manchester, Hyatt, Caster, "A-1 Storage"

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Economic Retaliation Story is about Bill Clinton's refusal to honor the boycott at the San Diego Grand Hyatt owned by Doug Manchester. Clinton was speaking to the International Franchise Association. Story also mentions, as a "target," A-1 Storage and its owner, Terry Caster, donor of almost $700,000 in support of Prop 8.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 149 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-69 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Magazine story 6/22/09 - Time Magazine - David Van Biema Name: The Church and Gay Marriage: Are Mormons Misunderstood State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Mormons, Pimentel

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Unwanted Communication This is generally a long story about the Mormon faith, but it begins with a story of Jay Pimentel, a Mormon in Alameda who contributed $1,500 to Prop 8 and then found that people in his neighborhood were receiving letters about him and his wife.

Job Loss/Fear of Losing Job The resignation of Scott Eckern (California Musical Theater) is mentioned as a Prop 8 aftermath against a Mormon donor to Prop 8.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 150 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-70 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story 5/12/09 Whittier Daily News Name: Prop 8 foes plan Protest at Long Beach Hyatt State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Manchester, Hyatt, "Long Beach"

Was the individual a donor: N Is the incident related to donation only: Y Is the incident related to petitions: N Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: N Is the incident related to other campaign activities: N If yes, explain involvement in campaign:

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Additional Claims This is a story about a protest at the Long Beach Hyatt. Reported goals are to get Hyatt to support marriage equality and to sever all ties with Doug Manchester. No boycott of the Long Beach Hyatt was called.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 151 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion, Ex K-71 (relates to Ex K-18, written by the subject of this story) Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story 2/3/09 New York Daily News Name: Artist Draws Ire for Same-Sex Nups Ban Support State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Mullarkey

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Additional Claims This summarizes the experience of an artist, Maureen Mullarkey, who donated $1,000 to support Prop 8 and who had done some paintings with gay themes. Story says there had been no call for a boycott of her work. Mullarkey herself wrote a piece in The Weekly Standard (which is Ex K-18), and there she describes some of the correspondence she received.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 152 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Perry Motion , Ex K-72 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: "Note from the Editors" re an Anonymous Opinion Piece (date unknown) - Synapse - UCSF Student Newspaper Name: Note from the Editors State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Additional Claims The editors explain why they are allowing a piece to run anonymously in support of Prop 8 - pointing to the SF Chronicle's column by its editorial page editor, John Diaz, concerning a Prop 8 supporter who wrote a letter to that paper with harassment as a consequence. (The Diaz piece is Ex K-38.) They say they want "to spare the writer of any of the harassment that has occurred since the passage of Prop 8." Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 153 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Troupis Declaration in ProtectMarriage.com v. Bowen, Ex. M Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story 11/7/08 Deseret News Name: Hundreds Protest Over Prop 8 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 11/5-6/08 Location: CA Search Terms: Mormon, Westwood

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Vandalism There is a reference to a man jumping up and down on the roof of a squad car.

Actual Physical Violence Part of this story is about a demonstration outside a Mormon temple in the Westwood section of LA. From this and one other story of the LA event, we know someone threw eggs at the marchers and that the confrontation mentioned here between marchers and occupants of a pickup truck involved the truck's pro-Prop 8 sign being torn and a marcher getting a bloody nose from one truck occupant.

Police Action/Inaction Police were present at these marches. Seven people were arrested when more than 1,000 people protested and blocked traffic in West Hollywood the day after the election.

Additional Claims The point of this story as a "claim" seems to be the fact that Mormon temples were the focus of some marches.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 154 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Troupis Declaration in ProtectMarriage.com v. Bowen, Ex. AL Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Opinion 12/1/08 Long Beach Press-Telegram Name: Outing Prop 8 Donors State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Long Beach, CA Search Terms: Mormons, Mazor, "You Can't Hide Your Hate", "Long Beach"

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: ?

NOTES

Economic Retaliation This opinion piece talks of a website hosting the names of donors supporting Prop 8. It expressly says it does NOT advocate blacklists or boycotts, but the writer seems to feel that it does because the creator says he would never seek care from a doctor who contributed to Prop 8. The piece seems to believe that a boycott is a breach of civility against those who followed their consciences (and who should not be accused of "hate").

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 155 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Troupis Declaration in ProtectMarriage.com v. Bowen, Ex. BC Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Letter to the Editor by Denny Weinberg 11/28/08 - Ventura County Star Name: Customers Boost for Lassen's State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Lassen's

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Economic Retaliation This is a letter from a person who thinks boycotts like that of Lassen's should be condemned. He says he and his family will shop more at Lassen's to support them.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 156 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Messner's "Price of Prop 8" - Heritage Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Newspaper website - LA Times Name: The gay-marriage battle: follow the donors State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: "donor search"

Was the incident described in the media: Y? Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y?

NOTES

Additional Claims Not really a claim, rather a web page documenting that the LA Times provided a vehicle for users to "Find out who has given money to support or defeat the passage of Proposition 8." Data comes from CA Secretary of State.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 157 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Messner's "Price of Prop 8" - Heritage Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Newspaper website - Sacramento Bee Name: Search for Prop 8 donors State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: "donor search"

Was the incident described in the media: Y? Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y?

NOTES

Additional Claims Not really a claim, rather a web page documenting that the LA Times provided a vehicle for users to "search public records for Prop 8 donors by name, country or which side they supported." Data comes from CA Secretary of State.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 158 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Messner's "Price of Prop 8" - Heritage Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story - Dec. 2008 - Christian Examiner Name: Prop 8 Passage Spawns Protests, Violence and Vandalism State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: CA & WA Search Terms: "Mount Hope Church", Lansing, Olympia, "white powder", Castro, Christoffersen, Burgess, Eckern, Raddon, swastika, Fresno, Franklin, Autry, "San Jose", Modesto

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Economic Retaliation Story is a catalog of incidents, including El Coyote (Marjorie Christoffersen).

Vandalism Collects incidents of: (1) glued door locks in Olympia, WA; (2) 8 Mormon buildings in Salt Lake City vandalized; (3) signs converted to swastika at church in Riverside; (4) stealing yard signs in Carlsbad; (5) car and garage and yard sign spray-painted; and (6) cars keyed, signs defaced and a block thrown through an elderly couple's window.

Actual Physical Violence Recalls the "white powder" incidents at two Mormon temples and the Knights of Columbus headquarters in CT. Tells of Palm Springs woman, Phyllis Burgess, who had an oversized cross ripped from her hands by protesters. Carlsbad man punched two elderly neighbors when confronted about placing a "No" sign in front of their yard's "Yes" sign. Modesto man received 16 stitches under his eye following altercation with a man who tried to steal yard signs - the man was waiting to distribute the signs after a Catholic Mass.

Job Loss/Fear of Losing Job Describes the resignations of Scott Eckern (California Musical Theater) and Richard Raddon (LA Film Festival) and repeats the story of El Coyote where the manager, Marjorie Christoffersen, was also forced to resign. Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 159 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Harassment/Threats During Campaign Activities Describes the Christian group at their weekly event in the Castro facing angry residents who shouted, blew whistles and "sreamed profanities" at them. Also describes the death threats against the Fresno mayor (Autry) and Fresno pastor (Franklin).

Expressions of Religious Bigotry Tells of the Bash Back action at Mount Hope Church in Lansing, Michigan where the group allegedly disrupted a church services with yelling, the throwing of condoms, pulling the fire alarm and a couple kissing in the front of the church.

Expressions of Racism Reports on slurs against African-American men attempting to join an anti-Prop 8 protest.

Additional Claims Reports the story of the SUV with the window painted with "Bigots Live Here" parked so that an arrow pointed to a house with a "Yes on 8" sign.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 160 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Messner's "Price of Prop 8" - Heritage Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story 1/6/09 SF Chronicle Name: Vandals Desecrate Pro-Gay Church State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 1/4/2009 Location: San Francisco Search Terms: "Most Holy Redeemer", Castro, Catholic

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Vandalism Story of swastikas and other grafitti on Catholic church in the Castro which is gay- friendly. Only grafitti mentioned referenced SF's bishop.

Police Action/Inaction Police were investigating as a hare crime.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 161 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Messner's "Price of Prop 8" - Heritage Page # in Filing: Type of Document: TV web story 10/20/08 Name: Heated Gay Marriage Debate Playing Out in SJ Yard State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: San Jose Search Terms: "San Jose", Sundstrom

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Vandalism Yard sign stolen led to larger sign and then a reaction from a "No" person.

Harassment/Threats During Campaign Activities After Prop 8 supporter replaced stolen sign with a larger sign hung above garage, someone parked an SUV in front of the house, painted slogans such as "Bigots live here" on the SUV and then locked the vehicle and left.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 162 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Messner's "Price of Prop 8" - Heritage Page # in Filing: Type of Document: ADF Press Release 2/12/09 Name: Calif. Professor to Student: "Ask God What Your Grade Is." State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 11/24/2008 Location: LA Search Terms: "Jonathan Lopez", Matteson, "LA Community College"

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Additional Claims This is an Alliance Defense Fund press release on lawsuit filed on behalf of student who alleged that he was "censored and threatened" with expulsion for a speech in a public speaking class supporting Prop 8. Teacher allegedly called him a "fascist bastard." Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 163 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Messner's "Price of Prop 8" - Heritage Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Blog Posting - Pam's House Blend 11/7/08 Name: The N-Bomb is dropped on black passersby at Prop 8 protests State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: racism

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Expressions of Racism This blog posting focuses on attacks on the African-American community following the Prop 8 vote. Specific mention is made of the LA post-vote march on the Mormon temple in Westwood where African-American men marching with "No" signs were harassed and called "n***er."

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 164 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Messner's "Price of Prop 8" - Heritage Page # in Filing: Type of Document: PFAW - Message from Kathryn Kolbert, President Name: Blaming Black Voters for Prop 8 Loss is Wrong and Destructive State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Expressions of Racism This memo from the PFAW President is broadly about building the relationship between the lgbt and African-American communities. It uses Prop 8 as a jumping-off point, and it notes "appallingly racist ways" that the A-A community was blamed for Prop 8's passage and the fact that A-A supporters were "called racist epithets at protests about Prop 8."

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 165 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Messner's "Price of Prop 8" - Heritage Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Blog Posting - Truthwinsout.org 11/7/08 Name: Emulating Our Opponents is No Way … State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: race

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Expressions of Racism Posting by Truth Wins Our ED Wayne Besen expressing "grave disappointment" in the "scapegoating of minorities" for Prop 8, noting reports that "African-Americans have been "verbally abused and have had racial epithets hurled at them during Anti- Proposition 8 rallies.”

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 166 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Messner's "Price of Prop 8" - Heritage Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Opinion piece Townhall.com 11/26/08 Name: Mormons in the Crosshairs State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Mormons, "white powder", bomb

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Expressions of Religious Bigotry This opinion piece focuses on the Mormon church somewhat generally and then on the consequences of its support for Prop 8. It mentions the "white powder" scares and the Book of Mormon set on fire outside a temple in Colorado. It includes a reference to "bomb threats" at Mormon temples with no specifics.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 167 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Messner's "Price of Prop 8" - Heritage Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Opinion piece RealClearPolitics 11/26/08 - Maggie Gallagher Name: Above the Hate State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Gallagher, Mormons, "white powder"

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Expressions of Religious Bigotry Gallagher challenges the appropriateness of the "No on 8" ad called "Home Invasion" with Mormon missionaries as the subject.

Additional Claims This rhetorical piece by Gallagher has few specifics but is rather a broad, sweeping description of what she says has been happening: "extraordinary attacks have been unleased -- livelihoods threatened, artists blacklisted, property defaced, worship services blocked, and even some physical attacks directed at ordinary people ...." Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 168 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Messner's "Price of Prop 8" - Heritage Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Editorial NYTimes 11/29/08 Name: The Prop 8 Campaign Money State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Mormons, "fair elections"

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Additional Claims This NYTimes editorial is about Fred Karger's complaint to the CA Fair Elections Commission regarding alleged improprieties by the Mormon church in reporting campaign expenditures. Point seems to be that the Mormon church is being "targeted" by gay groups.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 169 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Messner's "Price of Prop 8" - Heritage Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Web posting Californians Against Hate 11/13/08 Name: Sworn Complaint Filed Against Mormon Church State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Mormons "fair elections"

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Additional Claims This is a californiansagainsthate blogspot posting about their complaint to CA authorities seeking an investigation of the campaign spending of the Mormon church.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 170 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Messner's "Price of Prop 8" - Heritage Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Editorial LA Times 11/11/08 Name: Prop 8's Battle Lessons State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Mormons, "home invasion"

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Expressions of Religious Bigotry This editorial is about the weaknesses in the "No on 8" campaign. It is cited here because it applauds the No campaign's "Mormon Home Invasion" ad as "hard-hitting" and wanted more like it.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 171 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Messner's "Price of Prop 8" - Heritage Page # in Filing: Type of Document: TV web story 11/06/08 Name: Several Gay Marriage Ban Protesters Arrested in Clashes with Police in CA State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: various Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Vandalism Mentions the man in LA arrested after jumping on top of a police car.

Police Action/Inaction This story talks of various post-election marches and counts 7 arrests in 3 separate incidents.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 172 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Messner's "Price of Prop 8" - Heritage Page # in Filing: Type of Document: TV web story CNN - mid-November 2008 Name: Same-sex Marriage Rallies Stretch Across Nation State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: various Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Additional Claims This is a story about marches around the country. It is cited by Heritage vis a vis protests at Mormon churches, but no such protest is mentioned (although a reference to protesters in Manhatten behind barricades may well be a reference to the protest at the NYC temple mentioned in other stories).

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 173 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Messner's "Price of Prop 8" - Heritage Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story SF Chronicle 11/15/08 Name: Prop 8 Protest Could Become National Movement State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Mormons, "Palo Alto", dentist, Fletcher, "white powder"

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Economic Retaliation Reports that Philip Fletcher, a Palo Alto dentist and Mormon (donated $1,000) says that two patients left over his donation.

Actual Physical Violence Mentions two Mormon temples receiving envelopes with white powder. Says FBI determined "not toxic" and does not "know who sent them."

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 174 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Messner's "Price of Prop 8" - Heritage Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story USA Today 11/13/08 Name: Anger Over Gay Marriage Vote Directed at Mormons State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: various Search Terms: Mormons

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Expressions of Religious Bigotry This is a long piece about the Mormon church and its involvement in Prop 8 and, in particular, the sense that it is being singled out for attack following Prop 8's passage. It notes chants of "Mormon scum" at a demonstration outside an LA temple following the election.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 175 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Messner's "Price of Prop 8" - Heritage Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Magazine Article - Meridian Magazine (no date) Name: The Hypocrisy of the Tolerance Movement State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Mormons, Eckern, "Home Invasion", "Palm Springs", cross, Burgess

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Actual Physical Violence Mentions the woman in Palm Springs who had the cross knocked out of her hands (Phyllis Burgess).

Job Loss/Fear of Losing Job Mentions Scott Eckern of California Musical Theater and his resignation due to a donation.

Expressions of Religious Bigotry Talks of protests at Mormon temples in LA, Manhattan, Salt Lake and San Diego with references to signs like "Mormon Scum," "Mormon Lies," "Latter-Day H8", "Go Back to Utah", and "Mormon Money." Mentions grafitti scrawled on walls around temple (without naming a city). Also discusses the Mormom "Home Invasion" ad, calling it "egregious."

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 176 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Messner's "Price of Prop 8" - Heritage Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story LA Times 11/14/08 Name: Incident Shuts Temple State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Mormons, Westwood, "white powder", Salt Lake

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Actual Physical Violence Story is about the white powder received at the LA Westwood Mormon temple and also mentions a similar envelope arriving at a temple in Salt Lake City. Notes no clarity on whether this was related to Prop 8. Also notes a statement from the LA Community Center decrying the incident (quoting statement).

Police Action/Inaction Police investigated (FBI).

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 177 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Messner's "Price of Prop 8" - Heritage Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story 11/18/08 Deseret News Name: FBI to run more tests on mystery substance mailed to LDS Church State & Campaign: Incident Date: Location: Salt Lake City Search Terms: Mormons, "white powder"

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Actual Physical Violence Story is about the white powder sent to Mormon temple in Salt Lake City as well as to a temple in LA and to the Knights of Columbus headquarters in New Haven, CT. FBI calls it a "domestic terrorism investigation," while noting "no evidence that linked the threats to Proposition 8 or its opponents."

Police Action/Inaction FBI investigation.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 178 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Messner's "Price of Prop 8" - Heritage Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Web story 11/12/08 TheDenverChannel.com Name: Police: Church Believes Fire Linked to California's Prop 8 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Littleton, CO Search Terms: Mormons, Littleton, Colorado, "Book of Mormon"

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Vandalism This is the story of the Book of Mormon found burning on the doorstep of a Mormon church in Littleton, Colorado.

Police Action/Inaction Police were investigating as a "bias-motivated arson." Story gives a police phone number for anyone with information.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 179 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Messner's "Price of Prop 8" - Heritage Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story 10/16/08 Bay Area Reporter Name: Prop 8 fight gets ugly on both sides State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Modesto, CA and Larchmont, CA Search Terms: Nunez, Modesto, Catholic, Stanislaus, Larchmont

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Vandalism In Larchmont (suburb of Sacramento), a teenager was taken into custody for burning "NO ON 8" signs. Later, another sign was stolen from the same home. (This is a counter-example.)

Actual Physical Violence This story repeats the story of Jose Nunez, who was waiting outside a Catholic church in Modesto (St. Stanislaus) to distribute signs when a man grabbed c. 75 signs and ran. Nunez pursued and when the two met, Nunez got punched, resulting in an "eye dripping in blood" (according to a Yes on 8 spokesperson).

Police Action/Inaction Police involved in both incidents, trying to identify a suspect in Modesto and arresting a boy in Larchmont.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 180 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Messner's "Price of Prop 8" - Heritage Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Web story 10/15/08 catholicnewsagency.com Name: Attack outside of Catholic church part of "wave of intimidation" says Yes on 8 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Modesto, Riverside Search Terms: Modesto, Nunez, Stanislaus, Riverside

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Vandalism As evidence of a "wave of intimidation and violence up and down the state," the Yes campaign references the theft of yard signs, a Riverside garage sprayed with grafitti (and also noted "verbal harassment of Prop 8 supporters on the freeway, including obscene gestures").

Actual Physical Violence This story repeats the story of Jose Nunez, who was waiting outside a Catholic church in Modesto (St. Stanislaus) to distribute signs when a man grabbed c. 75 signs and ran. Nunez pursued and when the two met, Nunez got punched, resulting in an injury that required "16 stitches for the wound below his left eye."

Additional Claims Verbal harassment on the freeway, including obscene gestures.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 181 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Messner's "Price of Prop 8" - Heritage Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Web story from protectmarriage.com 10/13/08 Name: Prop 8 Supporter Violently Attacked for Distributing Lawn Signs State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Modesto Search Terms: Modesto, Nunez, Stanislaus

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Actual Physical Violence This story repeats the story of Jose Nunez waiting to distribute signs at St Stanislaus Catholic Church in Modesto when a man stole c. 75 signs. After a chase, the two men engaged and Nunez took a punch that led to 16 stitches. The Yes campaign here urges anyone "attacked, threatened, or had yard signs stolen to file a police report and to email the campaign."

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 182 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Messner's "Price of Prop 8" - Heritage Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story 11/13/08 NYTimes Name: Theater Director Resigns Amid Gay-Rights Ire State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Eckern

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Job Loss/Fear of Losing Job This NYTimes story concerns the resignation of Scott Eckern of the California Musical Theater. It also discusses reactions from the gay community, including Marc Shaiman, who seemed to regret somewhat what he seems to have set in motion.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 183 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Messner's "Price of Prop 8" - Heritage Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Press Release - ADF 5/13/09 Name: ADF Files Suite against radical group that invaded Mich. Church State & Campaign: Incident Date: 11/9/2008 Location: Lansing, MI Search Terms: Lansing, "Bash Back" "Mount Hope Church"

Was the individual a donor: ? Is the incident related to donation only: ? Is the incident related to petitions: N Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: N Is the incident related to other campaign activities: N If yes, explain involvement in campaign:

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Expressions of Religious Bigotry Alliance Defense Fund press release about filing suit based on the actions of Bash Back in staging a protest at Mount Hope Church that is described as follows: group sprang up to disrupt the service and "shouted religious slurs, unfurled a sign, and threw fliers around the sanctuary while two women began kissing near the podium. The group pulled fire alarms as they ran out of the building."

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 184 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Messner's "Price of Prop 8" - Heritage Page # in Filing: Type of Document: TV web story 4/20/09 FoxNews.com Name: Miss California Sparks furor with Gay Marriage comments on Miss USA telecast State & Campaign: Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Prejean

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Additional Claims This is a story about Miss California, Carrie Prejean, and her comments regarding marriage equality. Heritage cites it as another "incident[] of hostility directed against expressions of traditional views on marriage and homosexuality."

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 185 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Messner's "Price of Prop 8" - Heritage Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Web story - The Advocate - Aug. 2009 Name: The Real Perez Hilton State & Campaign: Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Prejean

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Additional Claims Another story about Perez Hilton that includes the Carrie Prejean incident. Heritage cites it as noting the Hilton called Prejean "a dumb b***h."

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 186 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Messner's "Price of Prop 8" - Heritage Page # in Filing: Type of Document: News Story - 4/20/09 Christian Science Monitor Name: Miss California sparks outrage over gay marriage remarks State & Campaign: Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Prejean

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Additional Claims Another Carrie Prejean story, cited by Heritage because the co-director of Miss CA USA said, "Religious beliefs have no place in politics in the Miss CA family."

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 187 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Messner's "Price of Prop 8" - Heritage Page # in Filing: Type of Document: TV web story - ABC News 4/20/09 Name: Perez Hilton "Floored" by Miss California State & Campaign: Incident Date: Location: Search Terms: Prejean

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Additional Claims Another Carrie Prejean story, cited by Heritage because both Prejean and Hilton say they believe she lost the title because of her answer.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 188 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Messner's "Price of Prop 8" - Heritage Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Web blog story 11/14/08 - KCPW Name: GLBT Advocates Condemn Attacks on LDS Church State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Location: Salt Lake City Search Terms: Mormon, "white powder", Colorado, "Equality Utah"

Was the individual a donor: Y Is the incident related to donation only: Y? Is the incident related to petitions: N Is the incident related to yard signs or bumper stickers only: N Is the incident related to other campaign activities: N If yes, explain involvement in campaign:

Was the incident described in the media: Y Is the incident referenced in other sources: Y

NOTES

Actual Physical Violence Story about the white powder sent to the Mormon temple in Salt Lake City; Equality Utah denounces all violence, vandalism and intimidation.

Expressions of Religious Bigotry Recounts the burning of the "Book of Mormon" on the steps of an LDS Church in Colorado.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 189 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Video Links Listed in “The Price of Prop 8” by Thomas Messner http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q28UwAyzUkE Page # in Filing: Type of Document: No on 8 Video Ad Name: Home Invasion: Vote No on Prop 8 State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: During No on 8 campaign Location: CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Additional Claims Ad depicting Mormons invading home of married same-sex couple and tearing up marriage license.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 190 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: · http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PvdDoLeFXh0&feature=related Page # in Filing: Type of Document: You Tube video Name: Gay Marriage Mormon Church Protest NYC State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: After Prop 8 loss Location: NYC Search Terms: Mormon Church

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Additional Claims Video montage of NYC protests against Mormon Church. Peaceful. Mostly signs being held up, chants for equal rights.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 191 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: · http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GxagcNFyHyc&feature=related Page # in Filing: Type of Document: You Tube video - narrated by Proponent of Prop 8 Name: Mormon Temple Los Angeles - Target of Gay anger & Mob - LGBT Protest - Join the Impact LA State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: After Prop 8 loss Location: Santa Clarita, CA Search Terms: Mormon Temple

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Additional Claims Video by Proponent of Prop 8 videotaping peaceful protests against Prop 8. Asking folks, "did the Mormons do something illegal?" Some protesters were verbally taunting people through fence of Mormon Church. Chanting, 'tax Mormon Church."

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 192 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: · http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P4m5yUhrXj0&feature=related Page # in Filing: Type of Document: You Tube video Name: No on Prop 8 Protest at Mormon Church, front gate State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 11/6/2008 Location: ? Search Terms: Mormons

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Additional Claims Peaceful protest video in front of Mormon Church.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 193 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=znXHJQSX78o Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Video Name: Palm Springs Prop 8 Rally Turns Ugly State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: After Prop 8 loss Location: Palm Springs, CA Search Terms: cross

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Additional Claims Reporting by Local 2 channel in Palm Springs. Shows elderly woman (Phyllis Burgess) holding a cross and Prop 8 sign. Sign knocked out of hand by protesters of Prop 8 and trampled. Protesters are yelling and screaming. The reporter keeps asking senior if she's okay and reports that they are "being attacked" (although No on 8 supporters are just yelling).

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 194 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nTuqXiHzZtk Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Video on You`Tube Name: Christians Assaulted in San Francisco State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: After Prop 8 loss Location: SF, CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Additional Claims Peaceful protest in Castro. Chanting. No violence. No Assaults.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 195 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Troupis Video Links http://abclocal.go.com/kfsn/video?id=6498621 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Video Name: ABC Action News Broadcast State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Post-Prop 8 loss Location: North Fresno, CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Additional Claims Video highlighting reaction of Fresno LGBT and ally community on Prop 8 loss. Some want peaceful protests, other (high school and college students) were more militant w/ protest, e.g., handcuffing self to City Hall door.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 196 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: http://www.nbclosangeles.com/news/local/Prop_8_Supporters_Lie_Low_Los_Angeles.ht ml Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Video Name: Prop 8 Supporters Lie Low- NBC broadcast State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 11/11/2008 Location: Santa Monica, CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Additional Claims Broadcast asserts that Yes on 8 supporters are not coming out b/c of fear and intimidation from Prop 8 opponents. They feel intimidated into silence. There has been alleged vandalism and harassment against churches. African-American church leaders feared retaliation so wouldn't speak to press. Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 197 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: http://abclocal.go.com/kabc/video?id=6496934 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Video Name: Passage of Prop 8 protests- ABC broadcast State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Post-Prop 8 loss Location: Los Angeles, Orange County, Pasadena, CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Additional Claims Video highlights protests against churches after Prop 8 loss. Documenting peaceful gatherings around CA.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 198 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: http://cbs2.com/video/[email protected] Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Video Name: Passage of Prop 8 protests, KCAL 9 broadcast State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 11/8/08 Location: Silver Lake, CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Additional Claims 10,000 people took to the streets after Prop 8 loss blocking traffic in a peaceful protest.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 199 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: http://cbs2.com/video/[email protected] Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Video Name: 3 Arrested in Prop 8 Protest in Long Beach, KCAL 9 broadcast State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 11/07/08 Location: Long Beach, CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Additional Claims Hundreds of protesters take to streets opposing Prop 8--protesting for more than 3 hours and refused to disperse.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 200 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: http://cbs2.com/video/[email protected] Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Video Name: Prop 8 Protesters Block Traffic- KAL9 broadcast State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 11/6/08 Location: Westwood, CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Additional Claims Prop 8 protests block traffic.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 201 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VziklUbtHAE (Link no longer active) This link is a video of the aforementioned inactive link: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jmMpPS8IRT0 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Video Name: News Broadcast as seen through YouTube State & Campaign: CA, Prop8 Incident Date: Location: Palm Springs, CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Additional Claims Protest turns into confrontation when pro 8 supporter holding a Yes on 8 sign and cross is pushed by Prop 8 protesters.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 202 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: Video Links Listed in both Exhibit K (Declaration of Nicole Moss) and Declaration of Sarah Troupis http://abclocal.go.com/kfsn/video?id=6545349 Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Video Name: More Prop 8 Threats: ABC Action News Broadcast State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 10/2008 and after Location: Fresno, CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Police Action/Inaction Fresno police and FBI involved in investigation.

Additional Claims Prop 8 death threats against Fresno mayor and Pastor Franklin. Death threat sent to Fresno Mayor and Pastor because of their support of Prop 8. One email threatened harm and a second email threatened to gun down both men. A third email sent but news cannot report.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 203 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: http://cbs2.com/video/[email protected] Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Video Name: Mayor, Pastor Receive Death Threats Over Prop 8- KCAL 9 Broadcast State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: 10/31/2008 Location: Fresno, CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Police Action/Inaction Fresno police investigating.

Additional Claims Pastor's home and church pelted with eggs. Pastor and Mayor received death threat email.

Doe v. Reed Claims of Harassment, Intimidation, etc. 204 of 204 Document Review 4/5/2010

Source: http://nbclosangeles.com/news/local/Protestors_Signal_Battle_over_Same_Sex_Marriage _Not_Over.html Page # in Filing: Type of Document: Photo Slide Show Name: Keep Your Magic Undies Off My Civil Rights State & Campaign: CA, Prop 8 Incident Date: Before Prop 8 vote Location: Los Angeles, CA Search Terms:

Was the incident described in the media: Is the incident referenced in other sources:

NOTES

Police Action/Inaction Seven people arrested in LA area street marches.

Additional Claims Photographs document mostly peaceful protests against Prop 8 in LA. Two photos non- peaceful protest: one man w/ bloody nose after hit by gay marriage opponent and another man shown on the ground after being pushed by prop 8 proponent b/c he ripped Yes on 8 banner from his truck.