Journal of Young Investigators RESEARCH ARTICLE

Shelf-life and Variances in Antimicrobial Properties of Honey from Meliponula bocandei and Meliponula ferruginea in Central Ghana

C. L. Cockburn1*, P. K. Kwapong2, D. A. Wubah3 and J. A. Wubah3

Many anthropological and biological studies detail indigenous people’s use of honey to treat various ailments, such as bacterial infections, sore throats, and digestive diseases. The purpose of this study was to examine the optimum storage method of stingless bee honey produced by Meliponula bocandei and Meliponula ferruginea in Central Ghana, near Kakum National Park. Additionally, another of the study’s goals was to determine whether increased shelf-time would affect the honey’s antimicrobial properties during a series of bioassays against Pseudomonas aeruginosa, an infectious bacterial showing increasing resistance to man-made antibiotics. Over three weeks, no significant difference was observed between two types of storage—covering the bottle in aluminum foil to prevent sunlight from entering or leaving the honey exposed to the light (p>0.05). There was, however, a significant difference between the two species’ honey in terms of pH, moisture content, and antimicrobial efficacy (all p<0.001). Honey produced by M. ferruginea had a significantly higher pH and moisture content than M. bocandei honey and did not have any antimicrobial activity against P. aeruginosa. Additionally, the mean zone of inhibition for the M. bocandei honey significantly increased between the initial and final bioassays (p=0.001). These data indicate that M. bocandei honey contains antimicrobial compounds that can be used against P. aeruginosa to fight bacterial infections as a substitute to man-made antibiotics. Understanding the antimicrobial properties of M. bocandei honey may help in the fight against P. aeruginosa and other common infectious bacteria that are quickly gaining resistance to antibiotics.

INTRODUCTION Stingless bees (: ) are found in the tropical noticed an increased crop production when using native stingless regions of Africa, South America, Australia, and Southern Asia, bee species to pollinate their farms. Beyond the agricultural but are believed to have originated in Africa (Daly et al. 1998). significance, propolis production, that is a resinous mixture of Because they lack a vestigial sting, stingless bees are essentially sap collected by bees, and honey provide naturist treatments harmless to humans, rarely going out of their way to attack against digestive, respiratory, cardiac, and rheumatic disorders individuals, and only employ fighting swarms when their colony (Pino 2006; Farnesi et al. 2009). Stingless bee honey is directly attacked (Gloag et al. 2008). Across the world, various has been found to contain antimicrobial agents such as cultures use stingless bees for honey and wax production, as well flavonoids (DeMera et al. 2004; Guerrini et al. 2008; Oddo et al. as for the bees’ outstanding pollination capacity. Numerous 2008). Additionally, studies have shown that stingless bee honey studies describe indigenous cultures’ and tribes’ use of stingless contains polyphenols, making it more resistant to fermentation bees to increase the yield of crops important for the community’s than the honey produced by the common honeybee, Apis melifera subsistence (Buchmann et al. 1996; Byarugaba 2004; Karikari (Guerrini et al. 2008). These two components of stingless bee and Kwapong. 2007; Mendes dos Santos et al. 2008). honey make it a useful medicinal aid in the fight against bacteria Furthermore, 177 crops in the world are dependent on stingless infections that cause thousands of deaths worldwide each year. bees for pollination (Karikari and Kwapong 2007). One of these infectious bacterial species, P. aeruginosa is an In Ghana, crops aggressive Gram-negative pathogen found in wounds, such as cocoa have been found to produce a better yield when particularly burns. P. aeruginosa is rapidly and continuously pollinated by stingless bees. A study by Karikari and Kwapong gaining resistance to common man-made antibiotics typically (2007) found that an overwhelming percentage of farmers used to treat bacterial infections (Estahbanati et al. 2002; Irfan et al. 2008; Kohler et al. 2009, Pappas et al. 2009; Strateva et al. 1*Department of Biology, James Madison University, 2009). Although there is a wealth of Harrisonburg, VA 22807, USA information available about stingless bee honey from South America, the equivalent knowledge about the African bee is 2Department of Entomology and Wildlife, University of Cape missing (Wagner et al. 2008). The purpose of this study was to Coast, Cape Coast, Ghana ascertain the optimum storage technique for M. bocandei and M. ferruginea honey, the two common stingless bee species in 3Department of Biological Sciences, Virginia Polytechnic Institute Ghana, determine its average shelf-life, and investigate the and State University, Blacksburg, VA 24061, USA antimicrobial activity of the honey with the course of time. We *To whom correspondence should be addressed: hypothesized that as stingless bee honey was stored for a longer [email protected] time period, the antimicrobial efficacy will decrease due to the

10 JYI | January 2013 | Vol. 25 Issue 1  2013 Journal of Young Investigators Journal of Young Investigators RESEARCH ARTICLE

breakdown of flavonoids and other antimicrobial compounds. pH vs. days, and pH vs. moisture content. A confidence interval Additionally, we hypothesized that covering the honey, therefore of p< 0.05 was used throughout this study for all statistical preventing the contact with light will decelerate the flavonoid analyses. breakdown and, therefore, the antimicrobial potency loss. Assay for inhibition of microbial growth At the beginning and conclusion of the three-week period, a MATERIALS AND METHODS bioassay was performed with the honey samples to test microbial growth inhibition. Each of the six honey samples was tested Origins of honey against a species of P. aeruginosa (G-, ATCC 27858). isolated Honey samples were collected from the International Stingless from a patient with a chronic leg ulcer at Central Regional Bee Centre at the border with Kakum National Park and located Hospital in Cape Coast, Ghana. After testing its resistance to a approximately 30 km north of University of Cape Coast, Ghana. series of common antibiotics, including penicillin and Three different honey samples were collected. Two were taken tetracycline, the bacteria was cultured on sensitivity agar from different M. bocandei hives—one natural log hive (honey (Biotech S.T.A.). 1) and one man-made hive (honey 3) built from wooden slats. Small 2 cm diameter disks of filter paper were soaked in The other honey sample was obtained from a M. ferruginea hive each nondiluted sample and placed into an oven to dry out, in found in a natural log (honey 2) order to prevent the honey from difusing outside of the disk and For each sample collection, small incisions were made altering the zone of inhibition. After drying overnight, one disk into the honey pots via a scalpel and the honey was either drained of each honey sample was placed onto the corresponding section into large containers or extracted with a syringe depending on the of a sensitivity agar plate containing P. aeruginosa (Figure 1). shape and size of the honey pot. The honey was then strained Three replicates for each bioassay plate were made, as well as a through multiple layers of mosquito net to remove any large control plate with P. aeruginosa only. The plates were incubated particles and, immediately afterwards, the initial pH and under aerobic conditions at 37C for 24 hours. temperature were measured and recorded with a Hanna HI83141 Portable pH/mV and Temperature Meter. As the honey samples were transported to the laboratory, the containers were covered and kept hidden from sunlight in order to prevent degradation of the honey as suggested by Guerrini et al. (2008).

Bottling and storage The honey from each hive was separated into transparent 50 mL vials that served as replicates. Half of the vials from each sample were left uncovered to allow sunlight entry , while the remaining half were covered with aluminum foil to prevent the light from entering and possibly degrading some of the honey’s natural compounds. Additionally, six vials—two from each hive with one covered and one uncovered—were set aside for use in the bioassays in order to prevent disturbance of the honey or transfer of foreign molecules from the environment into the vials by the pH meter probe. Figure 1. Diagram of bioassay plates used to test antimicrobial effectiveness of each honey samples. Plates were marked as Shelf-life quantification shown and honey disks were placed in the center of the allotted Beginning the day after the honey collection and ending 20 days space. later, the pH and temperature were measured daily using the pH meter described in section 2.1. All of the measurements were Quantification of microbial growth inhibition taken at 11:00 GMT each day in order to prevent variations in the Quantification of microbial growth inhibition was determined by pH and temperature due to the time of day and length of time measuring the diameter of the zone of inhibition from the center between measurements. Additionally, the moisture content was of the honey disk. For each bioassay including the replicates, the measured daily using a Stanley-Bellingham refractometer. Due to zones of inhibition for each honey sample were averaged and the mechanical problems with the refractometer, the moisture means were analyzed by a one-way ANOVA for mean zone of measurements were not started until day three. inhibition vs. bee species, mean zone of inhibition vs. bioassay The data from the entire 20 days were averaged and number (initial or final), and mean zone of inhibition vs. multiple one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) tests were uncovered/covered. performed, comparing the means for pH vs. uncovered/covered honey, moisture content vs. uncovered/covered honey, pH vs. bee species, moisture content vs. bee species, pH vs. temperature,

11 JYI | January 2013 | Vol. 25 Issue 1  2013 Journal of Young Investigators Journal of Young Investigators RESEARCH ARTICLE

temperature variation between samples only fluctuated from day to day due to the environmental temperature’s changes. There was, however, a significant difference between the shelf-life measurements of the bee species. For a one-way ANOVA of pH vs. bee species and moisture content vs. bee species, both resulting p-values were significant (p<0.001), M. ferruginea honey having to the higher pH and moisture content values (Figure 2, 3). Significant p values were also found for one-way ANOVA tests of pH vs. moisture content (p<0.001), pH vs. temperature (p=0.041), and moisture content vs. temperature (p=0.008). All other ANOVA tests returned nonsignificant values (all p>0.05).

Antimicrobial properties Overall, there were significant changes in the mean zone of inhibition over the course of three weeks. For both the initial and final bioassay, the M. ferruginea honey did not have a zone of inhibition for any of the three replicates, whereas both M. bocandei honey samples produced zones of inhibition for all bioassays (Figure 4). All of the one-way ANOVA tests were run once with each sample of honey Figure 2. Graph of the change in the mean pH (units) over time (days) included. Following those tests, the M. ferruginea honey for each of the six honey samples. samples were removed from the data to determine if there were any significant differences between initial and final bioassays for the samples of M. bocandei honey. One- way ANOVA tests of mean zone of inhibition vs. bee species (p<0.001) and mean zone of inhibition vs. bioassay number of M. bocandei samples (p<0.001) were found to be significant. All other ANOVA tests of mean zone of inhibition vs. M. bocandei samples only mean zone of inhibition vs. uncovered/covered, and mean zone of inhibition vs. bioassay number for all samples returned nonsignificant values.

DISCUSSION

As demonstrated in section 3.1., there was no significant difference between the storage methods of honey, indicating that sunlight does not affect the honey’s pH, moisture content, or temperature . However, the significant difference of the pH and moisture content of M. bocandei and M. ferruginea honey points out to a species difference. Kajobe (2006) suggests that different species of stingless Figure 3. Graph of the change in the mean moisture content (%) over bee will forage on different flower species depending on their preferences.. Therefore, the differences observed time (days) for each of the six honey samples . might be due to various chemical compositions in the respective plants.. Another possibility is that the rainy and dry seasons of Ghana affect how far the bees will look to forage and what plant species they will pollinate (Kajobe et al. 2005). RESULTS Additionally, the type of plants and flowers each species of bee forages on can affect the antimicrobial properties of the Shelf-life properties particular honey. This could explain why honey produced by M. Over the course of the three weeks, temperature, pH, and moisture ferruginea did not have any antimicrobial effectiveness against content fluctuated unsingnificantly-p>0.05— (Figure 2, 3) and P. aeruginosa, while honey produced by M. bocandei was very were at levels consistent with the standards set forth by Souza et effective against this particular bacterial species. al. (2006). Temperature of the honey was not graphed because the The fluctuations in temperature, pH, and

12 JYI | January 2013 | Vol. 25 Issue 1  2013 Journal of Young Investigators Journal of Young Investigators RESEARCH ARTICLE

moisture content over the three-week period are most likely due preserved through beekeepers and farmers education around the to the fluctuations in temperature and environmental conditions. world and the prevention of deforestation. There are a few sources of error that could have resulted from Further research needs to be performed on the shelf-life these fluctuations and possibly impacted the day-to-day results, of stingless bee honey over a longer period, taking into account but not the comparison between the two species. Because the additional variables, such as sucrose levels. More research study was performed during the rainy season, there were extreme should also be conducted on the foraging activity of M. bocandei variations in humidity and temperature, that could have impacted and M. ferruginea, in order to determine whether M. bocandei the moisture content of the honey. However, there was little collects nectar and pollen that contains particular flavonoids, effect of these fluctuations on the comparison of the honey while M. ferruginea does not. Another interesting direction produced by different species. would be to investigate whether the antimicrobial effectiveness As to what caused such a significant difference of honey corresponds to the antimicrobial effectiveness of between mean zones of inhibition between the initial and final propolis. bioassay of M. bocandei honey, we propose that there is possibly another shelf-life variable significantly changing and causing a ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS change in the antimicrobial properties of the honey. Although The author is thankful to the International Stingless Bee Centre, sunlight does not affect pH, moisture content, and temperature, University of Cape Coast Biotechnology Lab, and Central there may be a compound that is being affected. Studies have Regional Hospital for allowing the use of their laboratories and shown that sunlight does degrade honey compounds, which equipment and to Dr. Daniel Wubah, Dr. Peter K. Kwapong, Dr. could explain why the positive changes in antimicrobial efficacy Rofela Combey, Mr. Eric Frimpong, Mr. Courage Besah-Adenu, (Guerrini et al. 2008). and Dr. Kwame Aidoo for all their help and guidance. This project was funded by the National Science Foundation International Research Experience for Undergraduates grant (#0452779) to DAW.

REFERENCES

Amano, K et al. (2000) What are stingless bees, and why and how to use them as crop pollinators? - a review, JARQ 34, 183-190. [online] http://ss.jircas.affrc.go.jp/engpage/jarq/34- 3/amano/amano.htm (accessed on 30 July 2009).

Atrooz, OM et al. (2008) Studies on Physical and Chemical Analysis of Various Honey Samples and Their Antioxidant Activities. Journal of Biological Sciences 8: 1338-1342.

Brown, JC and C Albrecht (2001) The effect of tropical deforestation on stingless bees of the genus Melipona (Insecta: Hymenoptera: Apidae: Meliponini) in central Rondonia, Brazil. Journal of Biogeography 28: 623-634.

Figure 4. Plot of the mean zone of inhibition (mm) for both the initial and final bioassay of each of the six honey samples. Buchmann, SL and GP Nabhan (1996) The Forgotten Pollinators. Sample names were abbreviated to uc1 (uncovered honey 1), Island Press and Shearwater Books, Washington D.C. and c1 (covered honey 1), uc2 (uncovered honey 2), c2 (covered Covelo, CA. pp. 292. honey 2), uc3 (uncovered honey 3), and c3 (covered honey 3). Byarugaba, D (2004) Stingless bees (Hymenoptera: Apidae) of Bwindi impenetrable forest, Uganda and Abayanda indigenous knowledge. International Journal of Tropical Efforts need to be focused on conserving stingless bee Science 24: 117-121. species worldwide. These hold a wealth of knowledge that is virtually untapped in terms of chemical and medicinal Daly, HV et al. (1998) Introduction to Insect Biology and properties and are being threatened by deforestation of tropical Diversity. Oxford University Press, New York. pp. 680. rainforests. Often, stingless bee hives are destroyed by farmers who believe they pose a threat to their fields and will negatively DeMera, JH and ER Angert (2004) Comparison of the impact their crop yield (Brown et al. 2001). In order to continue antimicrobial activity of honey produced by Tetragonisa research on stingless bees, their natural habitat needs to be angustula (Meliponinae) and Apis mellifera from different

13 JYI | January 2013 | Vol. 25 Issue 1  2013 Journal of Young Investigators Journal of Young Investigators RESEARCH ARTICLE

phytogeographic regions of Costa Rica. Apidologie 35: 411- Oddo, LP et al. (2008) Composition and antioxidant activity of 417. Trigona carbonaria honey from Australia. Journal of Medicinal Food 11: 789-794. Estahbanati, HK et al. (2002) Frequency of Pseudomonas aeruginosa serotypes in burn wound infections and their Pappas, G et al. (2009) Current treatment of pseudomonal resistance to antibiotics. Burns 28: 340-348. infections in the elderly. Drugs Aging 26: 363-379.

Farnesi, AP et al. (2009) Effects of stingless bee and honey bee Pino, JA (2006) Volatile Constituents of Propolis from Honey propolis on four species of bacteria. Genetics and Molecular Bees and Stingless Bees from Yucatan. Journal of Essential Research 8: 635-640. Oil Research 18: 53-56.

Gloag, R et al. (2008) Nest defence in a stingless bee: What Souza, BA et al. (2006) Composition of Stingless Bee Honey: causes fighting swarms in Trigona carbonaria Setting Quality Standards. Interciencia 31: 867-875. (Hymenoptera, Meliponini)?. Insectes Sociaux 55: 387-391. Stow, A et al. (2007) Antimicrobial defenses increase with Guerrini, A et al. (2008) Ecuadorian stingless bee (Meliponinae) sociality in bees. Biol Lett 3: 422-424. honey: A chemical and functional profile of an ancient health product. Food Chemistry 114: 1413-1420. Strateva, T and Yordanov, D (2009) Pseudomonas aeruginosa: A phenomenon of bacterial resistance. J Med Microbiol Irfan, S et al. (2008) Metallo--lactamase-producing clinical 58:1133-1148. isolates of Acinetobactor species and Pseudomonas aeruginosa from intensive care unit patients of a tertiary care hospital. Indian Journal of Medical Microbiology 26: 243- 245.

Kajobe, R and CM Echazarreta (2005) Temporal resource partitioning and climatological influences on colony flight and foraging of stingless bees (Apidae; Meliponini) in Ugandan tropical forests. African Journal of Ecology 43: 267-275.

Kajobe, R (2006) Pollen foraging by Apis mellifera and stingless bees Meliponula bocandei and Meliponula nebulata in Bwindi Impenetrable National Park, Uganda. African Journal of Ecology 45: 265-274.

Karikari, AS and PK Kwapong (2007) A survey of indigenous knowledge of stingless bees (Apidae: Meliponini) in the central region of Ghana. Journal of the Ghana Science Association 9: 132-137.

Kohler, T and C van Delden (2009) Pseudomonas aeruginosa infections: from bench to bedside. Rev Med Suisse 5: 732- 734.

Mendes dos Santos, G and Y Antonini (2008) The traditional knowledge on stingless bees (Apidae: Meliponina) used by the Enawene-Nawe tribe in western Brazil. J Ethnobiol Ethnomed 4: published online.

Molan, PC (1997a) The antibacterial activity of honey. 1. The nature of the antibacterial activity. Bee World 73: 5-28.

Molan, PC (1997b) The antibacterial activity of honey. 2. Variation in the potency of the antibacterial activity. Bee World 73: 59-76.

14 JYI | January 2013 | Vol. 25 Issue 1  2013 Journal of Young Investigators