7 - Careful Scrutiny in Models That Recognize the Uncertainty Faced by Bidders
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
- 7 - careful scrutiny in models that recognize the uncertainty faced by bidders. For instance, suppose that combinatorial bidding takes the form of a single round of sealed bids that are made prior to the single-MTA auctions. In the presence of uncertainty about other bidders' true economic valuations, bidders for national licenses could be expected to shade their sealed bids below their true economic values, lessening any bias toward allocating spectrum to national bidders rather than single-license bidders. t--- TABLE 1 THE BIDDERS· TRUE VAlUATIONS: A CASE WHERE LICENSE AGGREGATION IS EFFICIENT Ecol'lOll1c Value EConeII1c Value of Mlstern of Eastern Econo-1c Value of Bidder Reg'on Alone Region Alone HattoRI.1 L1 cense N 14 0 14 E 0 lS 15 N 12 12 30 ~---- TABLE 2 THE NATIONAL BIDDERS l BELIEFS Econolll'c Value Econoa'c Value of Mestern of Eastern Econal" Value of Bidder L1kel1hood Reqlon Alone Region Alone Nattonal License W 501 14 0 14 501 16 0 16 E sat. 0 15 15 SOt 0 17 17 N 10M 12 12 30 r----- TABlE 3 THE BIDDERS· TRUE VAUUATIONS: A CASE WHERE INDIVIDUAL LICENSES ARE EFFICIENT ECOOOlllc Value Econo-t c Va 1ue of Mestern of Eastern EcooOlllc Value of B1dder Reg10n Alone Rea'on Alone Nat1 0nal Ltc.Rs. M 14 15 29 E' 11 17 28 N 12 12 30 I• r----- APPENDIX A GN Docket No. 93-253 ALPHABETICAL LISTING OF PARTIES 1 ABBY DILLEY 2 ABRAHAM KYE, et al. 3 ADVANCED MIBILECOMM TECHNOLOGIES, INC. AND DIGITAL SPREAD SPECTRUM TECHNOLOGIES, INC. (AMT/DSST) 4 ANCHORAGE TELEPHONE UTILITY (ATU) 5 ALCATEL NETWORK SYSTEMS, INC. (ANS) 6 ALLIANCE FOR FAIRNESS and VIABLE OPPORTUNITY 7 ALLIANCE OR RURAL AREA TELEPHONE & CELLULAR SERVICE PROVIDERS (Alliance) 8 ALLIANCE TELCOM, Inc. 9 AMERICAN AUTOMOBILE ASSOCIATION, INC. (AAA) 10 AMERICAN MOBILE TELECOMMUNICATIONS ASSOCIATION, INC. 11 AMERICAN PERSONAL COMMUNICATIONS (APC) 12 AMERICAN PETROLEUM INST. (API) 13 AMERICAN TELEPHONE AND TELEGRAPH COMPANY (AT&T) 14 AMERICAN WIRELESS COMMUNICATION CORPORATION 15 AMERICAN WOMEN IN RADIO AND TELEVISION INC. 16 AMERITECH 17 AMSC SUBSIDIARY CORPORATION (AMSC) 18 ANDREA L. JOHNSON 19 ANDREAE & ASSOCIATES, INC. 20 ARCH COMMUNICATIONS GROUP (ARCH) 21 ASSOCIATION OF AMERICAN RAILROADS 22 ASSOCIATION FOR MAXIMUM SERVICE TELEVISION, INC. (MSTV) r ...- 23 ASSOCIATION OF AMERICA'S PUBLIC TELEVISION STATIONS (APTS) 24 ASSOCIATION OF PUBLIC-SAFETY COMMUNICATIONS OFFICIALS- INTERNATIONAL, INC. (APCO) 25 AT&T BELL LABS 26 BARAFF, KOERNER, OLENDER & HOCHBERG, P.C. 27 BELL ATLANTIC PERSONAL COMMUNICATIONS, INC. (Bell Atlantic) 28 BELL SOUTH 29 BERGNER, BOYETTE, BOCKORNY & CLOUCH, INC. 30 BROWN AND SCHWANINGER (B&S) 31 CABLEVISION INDUSTRIES CORPORATION 32 CALCELL WIRELESS INC. (Calcell) 33 CALIFORNIA MICROWAVE, INC. (CMI) 34 CALL-HER, L.L.C. 35 CATAPULT COMMUNICATIONS (Catapult) 36 CELLULAR SERVICE, INC. (CSI) 37 CELLULAR TELECOMMUNICATIONS INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION (CTIA) 38 CENCALL COMMUNICATIONS CORPORATION 39 CENTURY COMMUNICATIONS CORP. (Century) 40 CFW CINNUNICATIONS COMPANY, DENVER AND EPHRATA TELEPHONE AND TELEGRAPH COMPANY and LEXINGTON TELEPHONE COMPANY 41 CHICKASAW TELEPHONE COMPANY (Chickasaw) 42 CITIZENS UTILITIES COMPANY (Citizens) 43 COALITION FOR EQUITY IN LICENSING 44 COLE, RAYWID & BRAVERMAN 45 COMCAST CORPORATION (Comcast) 46 COMSAT MOBILE COMMUNICATIONS (COMSAT) 47 COMSAT WORLD SYSTEMS 48 COMTECH ASSOCIATES, INC. (CTA) t -- 49 CONVERGING INDUSTRIES 50 COOK INLET REGION, INC. 51 CORPORATE TECHNOLOGY PARTNERS (CTP) 52 COUNCIL OF 100 53 COX ENTERPRISES, INC. (Cox) 54 DATA LINK COMMUNICATIONS 55 DAVID F. GENCARELLI, ESQ. 56 DEVSHA CORPORATION 57 DIAL PAGE, INC. 58 DIVERSIFIED CELLULAR COMMUNICATIONS (DCC) 59 DOMESTIC AUTOMATION COMPANY 60 DUNCAN, WEINBERG, MILLER & PEMBROKE, P.C. 61 E.F. JOHNSON COMPANY 62 ECONOMICS AND TECHNOLOGY, INC. 63 EDWARD M. JOHNSON 64 EROCA DANIEL 65 FIBERSOUTH, INC. 66 FIRST CELLULAR OF MARYLAND, INC. 67 GENERAL COMMUNICATION, INC. 68 GEORGE E. MURRAY 69 GEOTEK INDUSTRIES, INC. (Geotek) 70 GTE SERVICE CORPORATION (GTE) 71 GVNW INC./MANAGEMENT 72 HENRY J. STAUDINGER 73 HUGHES AIRCRAFT COMPANY 74 HUGHES COMMUNICATIONS GALAXY, INC. 75 INDEPENDENT CELLULAR CONSULTANTS r -- 76 INDEPENDENT CELLULAR NETWORK, INC. 77 INDUSTRICAL TELECOMMUNICATIONS ASSOCIATION, INC. 78 INNER CITY BROADCASTING CORP. 79 INTELLIGENT VEHICLE-HIGHWAY SOCIETY OF AMERICA (IVHS AMERICA) 80 INTERDIGITAL COMMUNICATION CORP. 81 IOWA NETWORK SERVICES, INC. 82 IVHS AMERICA 83 JAJ CELLULAR 84 JEFF JOHNSTON 85 JMP TELECOM SYSTEMS. INC. (JMP) 86 JOHN DUDINSKY & ASSOCIATES 87 JOHN G. ANDRIKOPOULOS. et a1 88 JOINT COMMENTERS 89 LAW OFFICES OF RICHARD S. MYERS 90 LAW OFFICES OF WILLIAM E. ZIMSKY 91 LIBERTY CELLULAR. INC .• d/b/a KANSAS CELLULAR 92 LIGHTCOM INTERNATIONAL, INC. 93 LORAL QUALCOMM SATELLITE SERVICES. Inc. 94 LUXCEL GROUP, INC .• INC. 95 MCI TELECOMMUNICATIONS CORPORATION 96 MEANS EQUAL ACCESS NETWORK SERVICES. INC. 97 MEBTEL. INC. 98 MERCURY COMMUNICATIONS, L.C. (Mercury) 99 MILLIN PUBLICATIONS, INC. 100 MINNESOTA EQUAL ACCESS NETWORK SERVICES, INC. (Means) 101 MINORITY PCS COALITION 102 MOTOROLA, INC. 103 MW TV, INC. (MW TV) 104 McCAW CELLULAR COMMUNICATIONS, INC. (McCaw) 105 MUNICIPALITY OF ANCHORAGE d/b/a ANCHORAGE TELEPHONE UTILITY 106 NATIONAL ASSOCIAITON OF BLACK OWNED BROADCASTERS, INC. 107 NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF BUSINESS AND EDUCATIONAL RADIO, INC. (NABER) 108 NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF BROADCASTERS 109 NATIONAL RURAL TELECOM ASSOCIATION (NRTA) 110 NATIONAL TELECOMMUNICATIONS AND INFORMATION ADMINISTRATION (NTIA) 111 NATIONAL TELEPHONE COOPERATIVE ASSOCIATION (NTCA) 112 NEXTEL COMMUNICATIONS, INC. 113 NYNEX CORP (NYNEX) 113 ORGANIZATION FOR THE PROTECTION AND ADVANCEMENT OF SMALL TELEPHONE COMPANIES, THE (OPASTCO) 114 OYE AJAYI-OBE 115 PACIFIC BELL and NEVADA BELL (Pacific Bell/Nevada Bell) 116 PACIFIC TELECOM CELLULAR, INC. 117 PACTEL CORPORATION (PacTe1) 118 PACTEL PAGING 119 PACTEL PAGING and MIDCONTINENT MEDIA 120 PAGEMART, INC. (PageMart) 121 PAGING NETWORK, INC. (Page Net) 122 PALMER COMMUNICATIONS INCORPORATED 123 PCNS-NY, Inc. 124 PERSONAL COMMUNICATIONS NETWORK SERVICES OF NEW YORK, INC. (PCNS-NY) PHASE ONE COMMUNICATIONS, INC. PMN, INC. PNC CELLULAR INC. AND ITS AFFILIATES POINT COMMUNICATIONS COMPANY PRIMOSPHERE LIMITED PARTNERSHIP PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA QUENTIN L. BREEN QUICK CALL GROUP, THE RADIO TELECOM AND TECHNOLOGY, INC. RAM MOBILE DATA USA LIMITED PARTNERSHIP RAY COMMUNICATIONS RICHARD S. MYERS RICHARD L. VEGA GROUP, THE ROAMER ONE, INC. ROBERT LUTZ, et al. ROCHESTER TELEPHONE CORPORATION ROCKY MOUNTAIN TELECOMMUNICATIONS ASSOCIATION RURAL CELLULAR CORPORATION RURAL CELLULAR ASSOCIATION (RCA) RURAL TELEPHONE COMPANY SANTARELLI, SMITH & CARROCCIO SECURICOR PMR SYSTEMS LTD. SMALL RSA OPERATORS SMALL TELEPHONE COMPANIES OF LOUISIANA, THE SOUTHWESTERN BELL CORPORATION SPRINT CORPORATION (Sprint) STATE OF CALIFORNIA - PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION (CPUC) I 152 STEPHAN C. SLOAN 153 SUITE 21 GROUP 154 SYSTEMS ENGINEERING, INC. 155 TAXPAYER ASSETS PROJECT 156 TELEPHONE AND DATA SYSTEMS, INC. (TDS) 157 TELEPHONE ASSOCIATION OF MICHIGAN 158 TELEPHONE ELECTRONICS CORP. 159 TELEPOINT PERSONAL COMMUNICATIONS, INC. 160 TELHARC GROUP, INC., THE, and TELHARC TELECOMMUNICATIONS 161 TELOCATOR 162 THOMAS CREMA 163 THOMAS J. JASIEN 164 THUMB CELLULAR LIMITED PARTNERSHIP 165 TIME WARNER TELECOMMUNICATIONS 166 TRI-STATE RADIO CO. 167 TRW INC. 168 U. S. DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE 169 U.S. INTELCO NETWRKS, INC. 170 U.S. SMALL BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION 171 UNIQUE COMMUNICATIONS CONCEPTS 172 UNITED NATIVE AMERICAN TELECOMMUNICATIONS, INC. 173 UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE 174 UNITED STATES TELEPHONE ASSOCIATION 175 UTILITIES TELECOMMUNICATIONS COUNCIL 176 VALLEY MANAGEMENT, INC. (VMI) 177 VANGUARD CELLULAR SYSTEMS, INC. (Vanguard) 178 WARD LEBER r 179 WENDY C. COLEMAN d/b/a WCC CELLULAR 180 WESTERN WIRELESS, INC. (WWI) 181 WILLIAM E. ZIMSKY 182 WINDSONG COMMUNICATIONS, INC. 183 WIRELESS CABLE ASSOCIATION INTERNATIONAL, INC., THE (WCAI) 184 WIRELESS SERVICES CORPORATION (Wireless) 185 WISCONSIN WIRELESS COMMUNICATIONS ~---- CERTIFICATE OP SDVICE I certify that copies of the foregoing REPLY COMMENTS, for PP Docket No. 93-253, were served on each of tbe parties listed on the attached Service List, this 30th day of November, 1993, by first class United States mail, postage prepaid. r---- SERVICE LIST GN 93-253 - 7058F Cary S. Tepper David J. Brugger Meyer, Faller, Weisman Marilyn Mohrman-Gillis &Rosenberg, P.C. ASSOCIATION OF AMERICA'S 4400 Jenifer Street, N.W. PUBLIC TELEVISION STATIONS Suite 380 1350 Connecticut Avenue, N.W. Washington, D.C. 20554 SuHe 200 Counsel for THE QUICK CALL GROUP Washington, D.C. 20036 Terrence P. MeGarty William J. Fran~lin President William J. Franklin, Chartered The Telmarc Group, Inc., and, 1919 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W. Chairman Suite 300 TELMARC TELECOMMUNICATIONS, INC. Washington, D.C. 20006-3404 24 Hoodbine Rd. Attorney for DEVSHA CORPORATION Florham Park, NJ 07932 George Benson Andrew D. Lipman C.LO. Margaret M. Charles WISCONSIN WIRELESS COMMUNICATIONS Swid1er &Berlin, Chartered N. 615 Communication Or. 3000 K Street, N.W. Suite 2 Suite 300 Appleton, WI 54915 Washington, D.C. 20007 Attorneys for FIBERSOUTH, INC. EDWARD M. JOHNSON Louis Gurman P. O. Box 2688 Coleen Egan Crossville, TN 38557 Gurman, Kurtis, Blask &Freedman, Chartered 1400 Sixteenth Street, N.W. Suite 500 Washington, D.C. 20036 Attorneys for JAJ CELLULAR Scott K. Morris Henry A. Solomon Vice President - Law Haley, Bader &Potts MeCAW CELLULAR COMMUNICATIONS, Suite 900 INC. 4350 North Fairfax Drive 5400 Carillon Point Arlington,