The Political Ecology of Regionalism. the Political Ecology of Regionalism
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
EUROPEAN UNIVERSITY INSTITUTE EUROPEAN UNIVERSITY INSTITUTE Department of Political and Social Sciences Department of Political and Social Sciences The Political Ecology of Regionalism. STATE-SOCIETY RELATIONS IN NINE EUROPEAN REGIONS The Political Ecology of Regionalism. STATE-SOCIETY RELATIONS IN NINE EUROPEAN REGIONS by Jürgen R. Grote by Jürgen R. Grote Thesis submitted for assessment with a view to obtain the Degree of Doctor of the European University Institute Thesis submitted for assessment with Examining Jury: a view to obtain the Degree of Doctor of the Prof. Colin Crouch, EUI and Trinity College, Oxford (co-supervisor) Prof. Philippe C. Schmitter, EUI and University of Stanford (supervisor) European University Institute Prof. Volker Schneider, Universität Konstanz Prof. Carlo Trigilia, Università degli Studi di Firenze Florence, April 1998 Florence, April 1998 Contents Contents Chapter Five 5. Comparative results case by case 5.1. Structural equivalence and blockmodelling .............................. 253 5.2. Italy (with second thoughts on earlier work) ........................... 259 5.3. Germany ................................................................................. 287 5.4. France ..................................................................................... 305 5.5. Spain ....................................................................................... 317 Tables and figures ................................................................... iii 5.6. Wales ...................................................................................... 326 Preface and acknowledgements ............................................... v Chapter Six 6. The external relational performance of regions Chapter One 1. Introduction ............................................................................ 1 6.1. Reflexions on inner and outer space ......................................... 335 Chapter Two 2. Theoretical considerations 6.2. The regional-national-supranational link .................................. 344 2.1. Territorial interest intermediation ............................................ 16 2.2. Policy networks ....................................................................... 22 Chapter Seven 7. Conculding remarks ................................................................ 377 2.3. Policy domains, political ecologies and base points of action 36 Chapter Nine 8. Data appendix ......................................................................... 383 .... 2.4. In search of an appropriate model ........................................... 44 Chapter Ten 9. References .............................................................................. 411 Chapter Three 3. Tentative hypotheses 3.1. The structuring of private and public space ............................ 59 3.2. Italy ....................................................................................... 63 3.3. Germany ................................................................................ 84 3.4. France ................................................................................... 110 3.5. Spain ..................................................................................... 134 3.6. Wales .................................................................................... 152 Chapter Four 4. Approaching the empirical targets: an analysis of overall configurations 4.1. The research design and boundary specification ...................... 170 4.2. Measures employed for the analysis ........................................ 182 4.3. Reflexions on the role of redundancy in territorial networks ... 193 4.4. Comparing the organizational ecologies of regions ................. 213 - i - - ii - Grote, Jurgen R. (1998), The political ecology of regionalism : state-society relations in nine European regions European University Institute DOI: 10.2870/6951 Tables and figures Tables and figures Table 8.6 Distribution of actor categories across the positions ..................... 408 Table 8.7 Intensity of external contacts (national and EU dimensions) ......... 409 Table 8.8 Most central and prominent EU organizations .............................. 410 Figure 4.1 Overall density and centralization indicies ......................................... 217 Table 2.1 Typologies of policy networks ........................................................... 55 Figure 4.2 Baden-Württemberg: Multidimensional scaling of path distances ...... 231 Table 4.1 Overall sample and network statistics ................................................ 176 Figure 4.3 Languedoc-Roussillon: Multidimensional scaling of path distances .. 237 Table 4.2 Overall properties of networks .......................................................... 215 Figure 4.4 Sicily: Multidimensional scaling of path distances ............................ 240 Table 5.1 Sicily: Results of equivalence analysis (1992) .................................. 263 Figure 4.5 Hierarchical cluster analysis (dendogramm) ..................................... 247 Table 5.2 Sicily: Members of most central position (1992) ............................. 266 Figure 5.1 Sicily: Graphic representation of image matrix (1992) ..................... 265 Table 5.3 Sicily: Results of equivalence analysis (1995) ................................. 270 Figure 5.2 Sicily: Graphic representation of image matrix (1995) .................... 271 Table 5.4 Sicily: Members of most central position (1995) ............................. 272 Figure 5.3 Lombardy: Graphic representation of image matrix ........................ 280 Table 5.5 Lombardy: Members of most central position ................................. 282 Figure 5.4 Baden-Württemberg: Graphic representation of image matrix ......... 288 Table 5.6 Baden-Württemberg: Members of most central position .................. 295 Figure 5.5 Niedersachsen: Graphic representation of image matrix ................... 299 Table 5.7 Niedersachsen: Members of most central position ........................... 302 Figure 5.6 Rhone-Alpes: Graphic representation of image matrix .................... 307 Table 5.8 Rhone-Alpes: Members of most central position ............................. 309 Figure 5.7 Languedoc-Roussillon: Graphic representation of image matrix ...... 313 Table 5.9 Languedoc-Roussillon: Members of most central position .............. 314 Figure 5.8 Catalunya: Graphic representation of image matrix ......................... 319 Table 5.10 Catalunya: Members of most central position ................................. 320 Figure 5.9 Andalucia: Graphic representation of image matrix ........................ 322 Table 5.11 Andalucia: Members of most central position ................................. 324 Figure 5.10 Wales: Graphic representation of image matrix .............................. 327 Table 5.12 Wales: Members of most central position ...................................... 329 Figure 6.1 External performance of overall sample (1246 cases) ..................... 354 Table 6.1 Ranking of equivalence classes in two extra-regional dimensions ... 348 Figure 6.2 External performance of networks (274 cases) ............................... 354 Table 8.1 List of network members (organization list) per region ................. 383 Figure 6.3 External performance of public institutions ..................................... 360 Table 8.2 Members of equivalence classes ................................................... 392 Figure 6.4 External performance of private associations .................................. 360 Table 8.3 Blockmodels, density tables and image matrices .......................... 401 Figure 6.5 Dual network games in the European triad .................................... 367 Table 8.4 Positions and roles of blocks ........................................................ 404 Figure 8.1 Graphic representation of positions and roles ................................. 406 Table 8.5 Cohesion and self-esteem ............................................................. 407 - iii - - iv - Grote, Jurgen R. (1998), The political ecology of regionalism : state-society relations in nine European regions European University Institute DOI: 10.2870/6951 Preface and Acknowledgements Matthias of the University of Wales/College of Cardiff. To all of them I owe a great deal Preface and acknowledgements of gratitude, not least because they did not hesitate to ask their respondents obscure questions without having any idea what I intended to do with the answers. Many thanks also go to Giuliano Bianchi of Siena University, the then president of IRES Toscana, who encouraged me to undertake a first test of the method in an admittedly exotic political environment (Sicily). In the end, it turned out that the exotic nature of this case Most of the empirical research for this work was undertaken at the Mannheim Centre actually served to sharpen my understanding of the potentials and the limits of network for European Social Research (MZES) of Mannheim University where I was co- analysis. ordinator of the project on Regionen als Handlungseinheiten in der europäischen Politik These thanks would not be complete without mentioning those who guided my from 1993 to 1996. The project was funded by a generous grant from the Volkswagen endeavours over a longer period of time. These were, first of all, my professors, Colin Foundation. Some of our external teams also managed to raise substantial resources for Crouch and Philippe Schmitter, who have set me on the track of