The Unintended Consequences of Protective Equipment in Gridiron Football Compared to Rugby Union
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Gladiator Gear: The unintended consequences of protective equipment in gridiron football compared to rugby union Cullum Brownbridge, BSc Applied Health Sciences (Sport Management) Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts Faculty of Applied Health Sciences, Brock University St. Catharines, Ontario © 2020 Abstract: Sports equipment has evolved over time to both enhance performance and reduce the injury risk. Protective equipment is particularly important in contact sports where injuries are frequent. In American and Canadian football, helmets and shoulder pads are two pieces of protective equipment that are strictly implemented to absorb hits of massive force to reduce the risk of head and upper body injuries respectively. While the risk of injury is reduced, the athlete's calculated perspective of risk might be altered. This change in risk equilibrium has the potential unintended consequence of the individual foregoing caution and playing in a faster and more aggressive style. This altered behavior not only increases the individual's own injury risk, but also puts other athletes who are on the receiving end of contact at greater risk. This displacement of risk is particularly dangerous when an athlete is hit in an area that is unprotected and vulnerable, or in an area where the equipment is not as effective as perceived. Drawing on existing research, theories of risk in sport, and qualitative interviews with 11 male, adult athletes who have competed in both football with significant protective equipment and rugby with minimal protective equipment, this study examines the relationships and potential disjuncture between sports equipment changes, athlete perceptions of injury risks, and actual injury risks. The purpose of this study is to compare physical contact, safety, and risk between the two high-contact sports, focusing on the different uses of mandated, protective equipment. Keywords: Risk Compensation; Football; Rugby Union; Protective Equipment; Sport Injuries Acknowledgements: I am indebted to Dr. Curtis Fogel, my supervisor and mentor, for your patience and guidance throughout this process. Your encouragement gave me the strength to push through the tough times, learn from my mistakes, and hone my abilities as I navigate the academic world. I would also like to thank my committee members; Dr. Philip Sullivan, Dr. Ryan Clutterbuck, and Dr. Phil White for their contributions to my work. Your expertise and guidance provided the checks and balances I required for this study. Thanks also to Brock University, the Faculty of Health Sciences, and all members of the Department of Sport Management for the resources and privilege to work among the best and brightest. With the most gratitude, thank you to my family, my support team. To my father Dr. Michael Brownbridge, for staying up late to proofread my work, our deep discussions on academia and research, and help laugh my way through the tough times. To my mother Vanessa Brownbridge, my spiritual leader, for your energy to make dark clouds go away and your unwavering belief in me, even if I sometimes did not believe in myself. Plum Brownbridge, my cairn terrier companion, for your much-needed play time, cuddling, and taking me out for walks. Finally, to my brother Kristian Brownbridge, for always lending an ear to my troubles and helping me keep life in perspective. Table of Contents Chapter 1 ......................................................................................................................................... 1 Introduction .................................................................................................................................... 1 Versions of Rugby ........................................................................................................................ 4 Versions of Gridiron Football ...................................................................................................... 6 Comparing Rugby to Gridiron Football ....................................................................................... 7 Chapter 2 ......................................................................................................................................... 9 Literature Review ............................................................................................................................ 9 Introduction................................................................................................................................. 9 Violence in sport.......................................................................................................................... 9 Pain and Injury in Gridiron Football .......................................................................................... 10 Pain and Injury in Rugby ............................................................................................................ 15 Athletes and Risk ....................................................................................................................... 17 Relevant Risk Research Outside the Context of Sport .............................................................. 18 Pain, Injury, and Risk Compensation in Sport ........................................................................... 20 Chapter 3 ....................................................................................................................................... 24 Methodology ................................................................................................................................. 24 Use of a Qualitative Approach .................................................................................................. 24 Semi-Structured Interviews ...................................................................................................... 25 Participant Sample .................................................................................................................... 28 Bracketing Experience ............................................................................................................... 29 Analysis Technique .................................................................................................................... 34 Ethical Considerations ............................................................................................................... 35 Research Design Limitations ..................................................................................................... 36 Chapter 4 ....................................................................................................................................... 41 Results ........................................................................................................................................... 41 Theme 1: Protective equipment – A false sense of security ..................................................... 42 Theme 2: Equipment as a tool .................................................................................................. 47 Theme 3: Different games, different contact ........................................................................... 51 Theme 4: Sport cultures value aggression differently .............................................................. 53 Theme 5: Superficial vs. Major Injury ....................................................................................... 57 Theme 6: Using rugby to make football safer ........................................................................... 58 Theme 7: Communication improves safety .............................................................................. 61 Chapter 5 ....................................................................................................................................... 64 Discussion...................................................................................................................................... 64 Different Perceptions of Risk Between Football and Rugby ..................................................... 65 Is there a Risk Compensation Effect with Protective Equipment in football? .......................... 66 Unexpected Findings ................................................................................................................. 67 Contribution to Existing Literature............................................................................................ 68 Chapter 6 ....................................................................................................................................... 71 Conclusion ..................................................................................................................................... 71 Implications ............................................................................................................................... 72 Limitations ................................................................................................................................. 75 Future Research ........................................................................................................................ 78 Conclusion ................................................................................................................................. 79 References .................................................................................................................................... 81 Appendix A: Interview