Original Jurisdiction

Daily Supplementary List Of Cases For Hearing On Thursday, 17th of December, 2020

CONTENT

SL COURT PAGE BENCHES TIME NO. ROOM NO. NO. HON'BLE CHIEF JUSTICE THOTTATHIL B. 1 On 17-12-2020 1 RADHAKRISHNAN 1 DB-I At 10:45 AM HON'BLE JUSTICE ARIJIT BANERJEE HON'BLE JUSTICE SANJIB BANERJEE 37 On 17-12-2020 2 2 HON'BLE JUSTICE ARIJIT BANERJEE DB-II At 10:45 AM HON'BLE JUSTICE I. P. MUKERJI 3 On 17-12-2020 3 4 HON'BLE JUSTICE KAUSIK CHANDA DB-III At 02:00 PM HON'BLE JUSTICE SOUMEN SEN 12 On 17-12-2020 4 HON'BLE JUSTICE SAUGATA 6 DB-V At 10:45 AM BHATTACHARYYA HON'BLE JUSTICE SUBRATA TALUKDAR 5 On 17-12-2020 5 7 HONBLE JUSTICE ANIRUDDHA ROY DB-VII At 10:45 AM HON'BLE JUSTICE TAPABRATA 25 On 17-12-2020 6 8 CHAKRABORTY SB-I At 02:00 PM 4 On 17-12-2020 7 HON'BLE JUSTICE ARINDAM SINHA 10 SB-II At 03:00 PM 36 On 17-12-2020 8 HON'BLE JUSTICE DEBANGSU BASAK SB-III,COMMERCIAL 16 At 10:45 AM BENCH 36 On 17-12-2020 9 HON'BLE JUSTICE DEBANGSU BASAK 17 SB-III At 10:45 AM 38 HON'BLE JUSTICE ASHIS KUMAR On 17-12-2020 10 SB-IV, COMMERCIAL 19 CHAKRABORTY At 02:00 PM BENCH HON'BLE JUSTICE ASHIS KUMAR 38 On 17-12-2020 11 20 CHAKRABORTY SB-IV At 02:00 PM HON'BLE JUSTICE RAJASEKHAR 13 On 17-12-2020 12 25 MANTHA SB-VI At 03:30 PM HON'BLE JUSTICE SABYASACHI 8 On 17-12-2020 13 26 BHATTACHARYYA SB-VII At 10:45 AM 39 HON'BLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI On 17-12-2020 14 SB-VIII, COMMERCIAL 29 BHATTACHARYA At 10:45 AM BENCH HON'BLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI 39 On 17-12-2020 15 30 BHATTACHARYA SB-VIII At 10:45 AM SL COURT PAGE BENCHES TIME NO. ROOM NO. NO. 26 On 17-12-2020 16 HON'BLE JUSTICE SHEKHAR B. SARAF 33 SB-IX At 03:00 PM 10 On 17-12-2020 17 HON'BLE JUSTICE RAVI KRISHAN KAPUR 34 SB-XII At 10:45 AM HON'BLE JUSTICE ARINDAM 23 On 17-12-2020 18 39 MUKHERJEE SB-XIII At 02:00 PM 24 On 17-12-2020 19 HON'BLE JUSTICE AMRITA SINHA 40 SB-XV At 10:45 AM HON'BLE JUSTICE ABHIJIT 22 On 17-12-2020 20 41 GANGOPADHYAY SB-XVI At 03:30 PM Original Side DAILY CAUSELIST For Thursday The 17th December 2020

COURT NO. 1 DIVISION BENCH (DB-I) AT 10:45 AM HON'BLE CHIEF JUSTICE THOTTATHIL B. RADHAKRISHNAN HON'BLE JUSTICE ARIJIT BANERJEE (VIA VIDEO CONFERENCE) NOTE:MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP THROUGH PHYSICALHEARING ONLY WHEN BOTH THE PARTIES ARE AGREED.

NOTE: THE HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE AND THE HON'BLE JUSTICE ARIJIT BANERJEE WILL TAKE PUBLIC INTEREST LITIGATIONS IN THE FIRST HALF ON AND FROM DECEMBER 9, 2020 UNTIL FURTHER ORDERS.

NOTE: AS LONG AS THE DIVISION BENCH OF THE HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE AND HON'BLE JUSTICE ARIJIT BANERJEE DOES NOT SIT - HON'BLE JUSTICE SANJIB BANERJEE AND HON'BLEJUSTICE ARIJIT BANERJEE - WILL SIT TOGETHER AND TAKE THE LIST ANDDETERMINATION OF HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE AND HON'BLE JUSTICE ARIJIT BANERJEE IN ADDITION TO THE LIST AND DETERMINATION OF HON'BLE JUSTICE SANJIB BANERJEE AND HON'BLE JUSTICE ANIRUDDHA ROY.

NOTE: NO MENTIONING IN COURT.

NOT SITTING.

Page 1 Of 41 Original Side DAILY CAUSELIST For Thursday The 17th December 2020

COURT NO. 37 DIVISION BENCH (DB-II) AT 10:45 AM HON'BLE JUSTICE SANJIB BANERJEE HON'BLE JUSTICE ARIJIT BANERJEE (VIA VIDEO CONFERENCE)

NOTE:MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP THROUGH PHYSICAL HEARING ONLY WHEN BOTH THE PARTIES ARE AGREED.

NOTE: THE HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE AND THE HON'BLE JUSTICE ARIJIT BANERJEE WILL TAKE PUBLIC INTEREST LITIGATIONS IN THE FIRST HALF ON AND FROM DECEMBER 9, 2020 UNTIL FURTHER ORDERS.

NOTE: AS LONG AS THE DIVISION BENCH OF THE HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE AND HON'BLE JUSTICE ARIJIT BANERJEEDOES NOT SIT - WILL SIT TOGETHER AND TAKE THE LIST AND DETERMINATION OF HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE AND HON'BLE JUSTICE ARIJIT BANERJEE IN ADDITION TO THE LIST AND DETERMINATION OF HON'BLE JUSTICE SANJIB BANERJEE AND HON'BLE JUSTICE ANIRUDDHA ROY.

NOTE : ON AND FROM MONDAY, 14TH DECEMBER, 2020 TO THURSDAY 24TH DECEMBER,2020 - WILL SIT TOGETHER AND IN ADDITION TO THEIR OWN LIST, TAKE ALL THE APPEALS RELATING TO LAND UNDER GROUP - I AND APPEALS RELATING TO TRANSPORT AND TELECOMMUNICATION UNDER GROUP - VII AND REGULATION OF INDUSTRIES AND ESSENTIAL COMMODITIES AND VARIOUS CENTRAL ORDERS UNDER GROUP - VIII AND CONNECTED APPLICATIONS.

NOTE: ON AND FROM i.e., 11TH DECEMBER, 2020 ORIGINAL SIDE MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP TILL 12 NOON IN COURT ROOM NO. 37

APPEALS FROM ORDERS 1 APO/24/2020 PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK MISS PARNA ROY WITH CS/188/2017 VS CHOUDHURY N. S. ENGINEERING PROJECT PVT. LTD. AND ORS. IA NO: GA/1/2020, GA/2/2020 WRIT APPEALS

(Bench ID-174051 ) 1/2 Page 2 Of 41 DAILY CAUSELIST COURT NO 37-FOR THURSDAY THE 17TH DECEMBER 2020 HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA - 2 -

2 APO/463/2014 CHENNAI NETWORK H.N. DATTA & CO. WITH WPO INFRASTRUCTURE LIMITED 420/2013 &ANR. VS MUNICIPAL CORPORATION & ORS. IA NO: GA/2/2019 3 APO/467/2014 DISHNET WIRELESS ATISH GHOSH & WITH WPO LIMITED & ORS. ASSOCIATES 388/2014 VS THE KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION & ORS. 4 APO/471/2014 INDUS TOWERS LTD & ORS. KHAITAN & CO WITH WPO 11/2013 VS FMA 807/2015 CAN THE KOLKATA MUNICIPAL 11536/2014 (A/S CORPORATION & ORS. MATTERS) 5 APO/475/2014 VIOM NET WORKS LIMITED H.N. DATTA & CO. WITH WPO AND ANOTHER 339/2014 VS KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND OTHERS IA NO: GA/3/2019 6 APO/34/2020 COMMISSIONER OF BHASKAR PROSAD WITH WPO CENTRAL EXCISE, BANERJEE 1442/2008 KOLKATA-IV, COMMISSIONERATE, VS ASSAM TUBES LTD. & ORS. IA NO: GA/1/2017(Old No:GA/1892/2017), GA/2/2017(Old No:GA/1893/2017) 7 APO/112/2020 PREMCHAND JUTE AND DEEPAK KUMAR JAIN WITH INDUSTRIES PRIVATE WPO/1111/2011 LIMITED AND ANR VS THE EMPLOYEES STATE INSURANCE CORPORATION AND ORS

(Bench ID-174051 ) 2/2 Page 3 Of 41 Original Side DAILY CAUSELIST For Thursday The 17th December 2020

COURT NO. 3 DIVISION BENCH (DB-III) AT 2:00 PM HON'BLE JUSTICE I. P. MUKERJI HON'BLE JUSTICE KAUSIK CHANDA (VIA VIDEO CONFERENCE)

NOTE:MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP THROUGH PHYSICAL HEARING ONLY WHEN BOTH THE PARTIES ARE AGREED.

NOTE: (1) ORIGINAL SIDE MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP AT 2:00 P.M. EVERYDAY EXCEPT FRIDAY.

(2) MENTIONING WILL BE ALLOWED ON EVERY MONDAY AND THURSDAY AT 2:00 P.M.

(3) ORIGINAL SIDE MATTERS WILL BE CALLED ON AT 2:00 P.M. OR UPON EXHAUSTION OF APPELLATE SIDE MATTERS WHICHEVER IS EARLIER.

NOTE: ON AND FROM MONDAY, 14TH DECEMBER, 2020 TO THURSDAY, 24TH DECEMBER, 2020 - WILL SIT TOGETHER AND TAKE THE DETERMINATION OF HON'BLE JUSTICE I. P. MUKHERJI AND HON'BLE JUSTICE MD. NIZAMUDDIN.

ON AND FROM MONDAY, 14TH DECEMBER, 2020 THE DIVISION BENCH PRESIDED OVER BY HON'BLE JUSTICE I. P. MUKERJI - WILL TAKE IN ADDITION TO THEIR OWN LIST, WILL TAKE ALL THE APPEALS RELATING TO MATRIMONIAL & FAMILY COURT & MATTERS RELATING TO GUARDIANSHIP INCLUDING APPLICATIONS CONNECTED THERETO;

ADMISSION OF APPEALS UNDER SECTION 30 OF THE EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION ACT, 1923

NOTE: APPEALS EXCLUDED FROM THE LIST WILL BE INCLUDED IN DUE COURSE.

NEW APPLICATIONS 1 APO/195/2014 SABI KORA AND ANR PARTHA GHOSH [S.A.] WITH VS WPO/400/2014 COAL LTD AND ORS IA NO: GA/1/2014(Old No:GA/1787/2014)

(Bench ID-174064 ) 1/2 Page 4 Of 41 DAILY CAUSELIST COURT NO 3-FOR THURSDAY THE 17TH DECEMBER 2020 HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA - 2 -

2 IA NO. GA/2/2018 PR. C.I.T. (CENTRAL)-1, YOGESH VATS (Old No: KOLKATA YOGESH VATS GA/911/2018) Vs M/S. NEZONE INDUSTRIES LTD. In ITAT/131/2018 3 IA NO. GA/2/2019 COMMISSIONER OF KAUSIK KANTI MAITI CUSTOMS (PREVENTIVE) KAUSIK KANTI MAITI Vs In CUSTA/37/2019 M/S. ASHOKA ENTERPRISE 4 ITAT/153/2019 PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER YOGESH VATS OF INCOME TAX-5, KOLKATA VS M/S. ANAND ENTERPRISES LTD IA NO: GA/1/2019(Old No:GA/1905/2019), GA/2/2019(Old No:GA/1906/2019) 5 ITAT/175/2019 HOUSING KHAITAN AND CO INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION VS DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX- CIRCLE 14(2) IA NO: GA/1/2019(Old No:GA/2436/2019) 6 IA NO. GA/2/2020 PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER YOGESH VATS (Old No: OF INCOME TAX-5, YOGESH VATS GA/320/2020) KOLKATA Vs L D S CITY PROJECTS PVT In ITAT/3/2020 LTD 7 IA NO. GA/1/2020 PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER YOGESH VATS (Old No: OF INCOME TAX-5, YOGESH VATS GA/319/2020) KOLKATA Vs L D S CITY PROJECTS PVT In ITAT/3/2020 LTD FOR HEARING 8 ITA/176/2018 COMMISSIONER OF YOGESH VATS BHASKAR INCOME TAX(IT & TP), SENGUPTA KOLKATA VS SRI HARTAJ SEWA SINGH 9 CUSTA/12/2019 COMMISSIONER OF BHASKAR PROSAD CUSTOMS PORT (KOL) BANERJEE VS M/S NIMALIGARH REFINERIES LTD IA NO: GA/2/2019(Old No:GA/608/2019)

(Bench ID-174064 ) 2/2 Page 5 Of 41 Original Side DAILY CAUSELIST For Thursday The 17th December 2020

COURT NO. 12 DIVISION BENCH (DB-V) AT 10:45 AM HON'BLE JUSTICE SOUMEN SEN HON'BLE JUSTICE SAUGATA BHATTACHARYYA (VIA VIDEO CONFERENCE)

NOTE:MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP THROUGH PHYSICAL HEARING ONLY WHEN BOTH THE PARTIES ARE AGREED.

NOTE: ORIGINAL SIDE MATTERS SHALL BE TAKEN UP ON TUESDAY AT THE FIRST SITTING OFTHE COURT.

Page 6 Of 41 Original Side DAILY CAUSELIST For Thursday The 17th December 2020

COURT NO. 5 DIVISION BENCH (DB-VII) AT 10:45 AM HON'BLE JUSTICE SUBRATA TALUKDAR HONBLE JUSTICE ANIRUDDHA ROY (VIA VIDEO CONFERENCE)

NOTE:MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP THROUGH PHYSICALHEARING

ON AND FROM WEDNESDAY, 9TH DECEMBER,2020 TO THURSDAY, 24TH DECEMBER, 2020 - WILL SIT TOGETHER AND TAKE THE DETERMINATION OF HON'BLE JUSTICE SUBRATA TALUKDAR AND HON'BLE JUSTICE SUBHASIS DASGUPTA

Page 7 Of 41 Original Side DAILY CAUSELIST For Thursday The 17th December 2020

COURT NO. 25 SINGLE BENCH (SB-I) AT 2:00 PM HON'BLE JUSTICE TAPABRATA CHAKRABORTY (VIA VIDEO CONFERENCE)

NOTE:MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP THROUGH PHYSICAL HEARING ONLY WHEN BOTH PARTIES ARE AGREED

NOTE : ON EVERY THURSDAY ORIGINAL SIDE MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP AT 2:00 P.M

COURT APPLICATIONS UNDER ART.226 1 WPO/65/2020 PRANATI MAHANTI SYED SHAMSUL VS AREFIN THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND 5 OTHERS 2 WPO/72/2020 MANJU ROY MAHAPATRA SYED SHAMSUL VS AREFIN THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND 5 OTHERS 3 WPO/82/2020 USHA DAS (MAHAPATRA) SYED SHAMSUL VS AREFIN THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND 5 ORS 4 WPO/119/2020 SUSMITA GAYEN ANJAN VS BHATTACHARYA THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS 5 WPO/135/2020 KAMALA PRADHAN SYED SHAMSUL VS AREFIN THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND 5 OTHERS 6 WPO/136/2020 HARIPRIYA GIRI SYED SHAMSUL VS AREFIN THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND 5 OTHERS 7 WPO/404/2020 KANIKA PAIK MONDAL ANJAN VS BHATTACHARYA THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS

(Bench ID-173909 ) 1/2 Page 8 Of 41 DAILY CAUSELIST COURT NO 25-FOR THURSDAY THE 17TH DECEMBER 2020 HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA - 2 -

8 WPO/406/2020 RIMPA GHOSH ANJAN VS BHATTACHARYA THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS 9 WPO/410/2020 RITA SURESH TIWARI ANJAN VS BHATTACHARYA THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS 10 WPO/411/2020 MALOY KUMAR DUTTA AND ANJAN ANR BHATTACHARYA VS THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS 11 WPO/412/2020 DEBI SAHA ANJAN VS BHATTACHARYA THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS 12 WPO/433/2020 MINATI KOLEY SYED SHAMSUL VS AREFIN THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS FOR HEARING 13 WPO/152/2020 CHAITALI DE SARKAR ANJAN VS BHATTACHARYA THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS IA NO: GA/1/2020 RESTORATION APPLICATION 14 IA NO. GA/1/2020 KAMAL MAHESHWARI (Old No: Vs SANTI DAS GA/642/2020) STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS

In WPO/553/2018 15 IA NO. GA/2/2020 KAMAL MAHESHWARI (Old No: Vs SANTI DAS GA/643/2020) STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS

In WPO/553/2018

(Bench ID-173909 ) 2/2 Page 9 Of 41 Original Side DAILY CAUSELIST For Thursday The 17th December 2020

COURT NO. 4 SINGLE BENCH (SB-II) AT 3:00 PM HON'BLE JUSTICE ARINDAM SINHA (VIA VIDEO CONFERENCE)

NOTE:MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP THROUGH PHYSICAL HEARING ONLY WHEN BOTH THE PARTIES ARE AGREED.

NOTE : 1) ON MONDAY, TUESDAY AND THURSDAY ORIGINAL SIDE MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP FROM 3:00 P.M.

2) ON WEDNESDAY ORIGINAL SIDE MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP FROM 10:45 A.M.

FOR DISMISSAL 1 CP/274/1967 TURNER MORRISON & CO [S.A.] LTD VS HUNGERFORD INVESTMENT TRUST LTD (IN LIQN) IA NO: CA/1/2015(Old No:CA/250/2015), CA/2/2015(Old No:CA/252/2015), CA/3/2015(Old No:CA/253/2015), CA/4/2015(Old No:CA/274/2015), CA/5/2017(Old No:CA/355/2017), CA/6/2017(Old No:CA/356/2017), CA/7/2017(Old No:CA/415/2017), CA/8/2017(Old No:CA/417/2017) 2 EC/144/2016 HULASH CHAND JAIN & SANDERSONS & NILANJAN PAL [S.A.] ORS. MORGANS CHOUDHURY VS SURESH KUMAR JAIN & ORS. 3 AS/11/2018 SOHAM SHIPPING PRIVATE R. K. KHANDELWAL & S.A. LIMITED CO. VS THE O. & INT. PARTIES IN THE VESSEL M. V. VSEVOLOD BELETSKY IA NO: GA/2/2019(Old No:GA/16/2019), GA/4/2019(Old No:GA/1262/2019), GA/5/2019(Old No:GA/1623/2019), GA/6/2019(Old No:GA/2156/2019), GA/7/2019(Old No:GA/2157/2019), GA/8/2019(Old No:GA/2838/2019) COURT APPLICATIONS UNDER ART.226

(Bench ID-173910 ) 1/6 Page 10 Of 41 DAILY CAUSELIST COURT NO 4-FOR THURSDAY THE 17TH DECEMBER 2020 HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA - 2 -

4 IA NO. GA/2/2020 SHIROMANI FLAT OWNERS ATISH GHOSH (Old No: ASSOCIATION & ORS ATISH GHOSH GA/466/2020) Vs KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION & ORS In WPO/45/2018 5 WPO/80/2019 MAGNUM ENTERPRISES ABHIRUP AND ANR. CHAKRABORTY VS THE KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS. IA NO: GA/1/2019(Old No:GA/841/2019) 6 WPO/258/2019 LAND AND BRICKS AND DAS AND COMPANY ENTERTAINMENTS LIMITED AND ANR VS THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS 7 WPO/302/2019 PRADIP KUMAR GHOSH AMAR KUMAR AND ANR. HALDAR VS KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS. 8 WPO/346/2019 SMT. BINA DEBI BAGARIA MOUMITA DAS AND ORS VS KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND 2 OTHERS IA NO: GA/1/2020(Old No:GA/498/2020) wt9 WPO/455/2019 SUSHIL KUMAR BAGARIA LAL MOHAN HAJRA AND ORS VS KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND 3 OTHERS IA NO: GA/1/2020(Old No:GA/501/2020) 10 WPO/418/2019 MAHBOOB ALAM SWARVANU SAHA VS THE KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS. 11 WPO/433/2019 SUKHAMOY MALLICK MAHABOOB AHMED VS THE KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS 12 WPO/435/2019 JIBAN KUMAR SEN M/S. N.C. BOSE AND VS CO. THE KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND 3 OTHERS 13 WPO/443/2019 SANJOY DUTTA DEB KUMAR VS CHANDRA THE KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS

(Bench ID-173910 ) 2/6 Page 11 Of 41 DAILY CAUSELIST COURT NO 4-FOR THURSDAY THE 17TH DECEMBER 2020 HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA - 3 -

14 WPO/444/2019 RAJKUMAR SINGH AND ANR ANJAN SOUNAK VS BHATTACHARYA BHATTACHARYA THE KOLKATA MUNICIPAL (FOR RES.5,6) CORPORATION AND ORS 15 WPO/446/2019 RAMPURIA INDUSTRIES MANNA AND CO. AND INVESTMENTS LIMITED AND ANR. VS KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS. 16 WPO/452/2019 PRABIR PALADHI AND 3 SUTIRTHA DAS NITIN KR. DAS (FOR OTHERS RES.9) VS THE KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND 8 OTHERS 17 WPO/469/2019 BIPIN MEHTA AND ORS PRADEEP PANDEY VS KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS 18 WPO/470/2019 SMT. SUHASINI LOHIA S. KAKRANIA AND CO. MUKHERJEE VS PRASAD & KOLKATA MUNICIPAL ASSO.(FOR PRO. CORPORATION AND ORS. RES. 16,17,18,22,24,28) 19 WPO/473/2019 KALLU BABU LALCHAND VINAY KUMAR HUF PUROHIT VS KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND 6 OTHERS 20 WPO/475/2019 MOHANLAL KHEMKA AND PRADEEP KUMAR ANR JEWRAJKA VS KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND 7 OTHERS 21 WPO/494/2019 MD. MEHTAB RAMPRAVESH SINGH IMTIYAZ ASLAM VS LODHI (FOR RES.6) KOLKATA MUNICIPALCORPORATION AND ORS. 22 WPO/504/2019 ADIBANSTALA MOHALLA PRIYANKAR BASU SEVA SAMITY AND ANR. MALLICK VS KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS. 23 WPO/505/2019 HARIS CHANDRA DALEI ALOTRIYA VS MUKHERJEE THE KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS. 24 WPO/519/2019 PRASANTA SEN SHARMISTHA LAHA VS THE KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS

(Bench ID-173910 ) 3/6 Page 12 Of 41 DAILY CAUSELIST COURT NO 4-FOR THURSDAY THE 17TH DECEMBER 2020 HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA - 4 -

25 WPO/557/2019 SUDIP KUSARYE AND ANR KOUSHIK VS BHATTACHARYYA KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND 4 OTHERS 26 WPO/577/2019 KRISHANA PRASAD SHAW SK SAMIM AKHTER VS THE KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS 27 WPO/594/2019 LAKHU DUBEY MAHABOOB AHMED VS THE KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS 28 WPO/600/2019 MD. ALLAUDDIN AND ORS SANCHITA VS CHAUDHURI KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS 29 WPO/606/2019 ABDUL KADER AND ORS. SK. REAZUL ISLAM SABYASACHI VS BHATTACHARJEE KOLKATA MUNICIPAL (PVT. RES.) CORPORATION AND ORS. 30 WPO/633/2019 RENU SHAW AND ANR. GAUTAM DAS VS THE KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS 31 WPO/635/2019 BIKASH KAMAL BANERJEE KHAITAN AND CO. VS KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS. 32 WPO/643/2019 RADHEYSHYAM KESHRI NILAY SENGUPTA GARGI GOSWAMI VS (FOR RES.6) STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS 33 WPO/646/2019 RATAN SINGH ARPITA BASU VS THE KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS. 34 WPO/6/2020 AFSHA NADIM RAMIJ MUNSI VS THE KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND 6 OTHERS 35 WPO/7/2020 OM PRAKASH BHARTIA TARUNJYOTI TEWARI VS THE KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS. 36 WPO/17/2020 SHAHID AHMED AND ORS NITIN KUMAR DAS VS KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS

(Bench ID-173910 ) 4/6 Page 13 Of 41 DAILY CAUSELIST COURT NO 4-FOR THURSDAY THE 17TH DECEMBER 2020 HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA - 5 -

37 WPO/30/2020 M/S. BRIJNATH DIPENDRA NATH KHANDELWAL AND CO. CHUNDER VS KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS. 38 WPO/40/2020 RARVEZ AHMED RAMPRAVESH SINGH VS KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS. 39 WPO/62/2020 SMT USHA JAISWAL PRODYOT KR. ROY VS THE KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS 40 WPO/64/2020 MD. MEHTAB RAMPRAVESH SINGH VS KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS. 41 WPO/73/2020 MIR MOHASIN ALI RAMIJ MUNSI VS THE KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND 20 OTHERS 42 WPO/74/2020 HILLMAN DEVELOPERS (P) SIMA CHAKRABORTY LTD AND ANR VS THE KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS 43 WPO/76/2020 MANISH KOCHAR EMON VS BHATTACHARYA THE KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS. 44 WPO/91/2020 SRI SANTOSH KUMAR SAPTARSHI MAL DALMIA VS THE KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS 45 WPO/96/2020 AJAY MADHOGARIA AND NILAY SENGUPTA ORS. VS KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS. IA NO: GA/1/2020 46 WPO/97/2020 SAMPA DUTTA AND ANR ANIRUDHA SARKAR VS THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS 47 WPO/127/2020 MR. HARSH VARDHAN RUIA SANCHARI VS CHAKRABORTY KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS. 48 WPO/134/2020 MD. QASIM SUNITI CHATTERJEE VS THE KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS

(Bench ID-173910 ) 5/6 Page 14 Of 41 DAILY CAUSELIST COURT NO 4-FOR THURSDAY THE 17TH DECEMBER 2020 HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA - 6 -

49 WPO/137/2020 GAYATRI GUPTA MAHESH KUMAR VS JOSHI KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS. 50 WPO/138/2020 TAPAS KUMAR MAJUMDAR CHIRANJIB SINHA VS STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS. 51 WPO/150/2020 MUSTARI BEGUM AND ORS. MAINAK SWARNOKAR VS THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS. 52 WPO/151/2020 SILICAL HOUSING VICTOR MOSES AND SYSTEMS LIMITED AND CO ORS VS KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS 53 WPO/182/2020 MR. ARTAK SARGSYAN CHIRANJIB SINHA VS STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS. 54 WPO/400/2020 ANIL GHOSH MR. SUNNY NANDY VS THE KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS. 55 WPO/407/2020 SMT NIHAR LAW AND ANR SYANTAN BOSE VS THE KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS 56 WPO/408/2020 MD. NASIM JAVED MAJID VS THE KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS. FOR HEARING 57 WPO/441/2012 MCLEOD RUSSEL INDIA KHAITAN & CO. [S.A.] LTD.& ANR. VS THE ASSISTANT DIRECTOR OF INCOME TAX-2(1), KOLKATA,

(Bench ID-173910 ) 6/6 Page 15 Of 41 Original Side DAILY CAUSELIST For Thursday The 17th December 2020

COURT NO. 36 SINGLE BENCH (SB-III,COMMERCIAL BENCH) AT 10:45 AM HON'BLE JUSTICE DEBANGSU BASAK (VIA VIDEO CONFERENCE)

NOTE:MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP THROUGH PHYSICAL HEARING ONLY WHEN BOTH THE PARTIES ARE AGREED.

PRESENTATION OF PLAINT 1 CS/147/2020 SELVEL ADVERTISING PVT SUNNY NANDY LTD VS APTO MEDIA SOLUTIONS PV T LTD 2 CS/148/2020 RATNAJEET FINVEST PVT NILAY SENGUPTA LTD VS VINLINE ENGINEERING PVT LTD

(Bench ID-174023 ) 1/1 Page 16 Of 41 Original Side DAILY CAUSELIST For Thursday The 17th December 2020

COURT NO. 36 SINGLE BENCH (SB-III) AT 10:45 AM HON'BLE JUSTICE DEBANGSU BASAK (VIA VIDEO CONFERENCE)

NOTE:MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP THROUGH PHYSICAL HEARING ONLY WHEN BOTH THE PARTIES ARE AGREED.

TO BE MENTIONED 1 ATA/3/2020 RAMA RANI MOITRA SUCHITRA SUR [FOR CORRECTION VS IN ORDER] SULEKHA LAHIRI AND CO NEW MOTIONS 2 IA NO. GA/1/2020 KANAK PROJECTS LIMITED HSA AND ANR. HSA Vs In RVWO/10/2020 KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS. 3 IA NO. GA/1/2020 SABYASACHI BANERJEE ARNAB SARDAR (Old No: Vs ARNAB SARDAR GA/430/2020) ASHA MIRCHANDANI AND OTHERS

In CS/24/2020 4 IA NO. GA/2/2020 SABYASACHI BANERJEE ARNAB SARDAR (Old No: Vs ARNAB SARDAR GA/540/2020) ASHA MIRCHANDANI AND OTHERS

In CS/24/2020 5 IA NO. GA/1/2020 SRI BIPLOB MANNA AND SUNNY NANDY ORS. SUNNY NANDY Vs In APO/152/2020 PRAHLAD HATI AND ORS. 6 AP/174/2020 SUNAINA RANI SHARMA SAPTARSHI DATTA VS DIVISIONAL RAILWAY MANAGER (BUILDING), EASTERN RAILWAY, HOWRAH 711101

(Bench ID-173912 ) 1/2 Page 17 Of 41 DAILY CAUSELIST COURT NO 36-FOR THURSDAY THE 17TH DECEMBER 2020 HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA - 2 -

7 AP/382/2020 FERTILIZER CORPORATION FOX AND MANDAL OF INDIA LIMITED VS BALMER LAWRIE AND CO. LTD. NEW CHAMBER APPLICATIONS 8 CS/887/1965 SM. MAYA RANI NAG & S.K. BHATTACHARJEE B.N. RUDRA OTHERS VS SM. NIHARBALA NAG & OTHERS IA NO: GA/5/2020(Old No:GA/315/2020), GA/6/2020, GA/7/2020 9 IA NO. GA/10/2020 HEMANTA KUMAR BHOTICA (Old No: & ANR. G.P.LATH & CO RAJESH KHAITAN & GA/761/2020) Vs CO SATYANARAYAN BERLIA

In CS/905/1981 10 IA NO. GA/18/2020 KEDAR NATH SEN (Old No: Vs T.C.DEY, S.MAITRA M.AGARWALLA & CO GA/586/2020) SULEKHA SEN

In CS/2/1996 11 IA NO. GA/2/2018 FAIR DEAL SUPPLIES V. RAJA RAO (Old No: LIMITED KAUSHIK BANERJEE GA/1833/2018) Vs ALLAHABAD BANK & ANR

In CS/195/2017 12 IA NO. GA/2/2020 TALAT AHMED & ORS. SINHA SANDIP KR. Vs SINHA & CO DATTA(RES.4,5) PRABHADEEP SANDIP KR. In EC/243/2017 CONSTRUCTION PV T LTD & DATTA(RES.4,5) ORS. 13 IA NO. GA/3/2020 IN THE GOODS OF - RABI GHOSH HIMANSHU DEBSHARMA RABI GHOSH (DEC.) In PLA/42/2019 Vs NA 14 EC/116/2020 RAMESH CO. SOUMALYA GANGULI VS IMPERIAL TUBES PRIVATE LIMITED IA NO: GA/2/2020(Old No:GA/877/2020) SPECIALLY ASSIGNED MATTERS 15 RVWO/6/2020 IMPERIAL TUBES PRIVATE KHAITAN AND CO. [S.A.] LIMITED VS RAMESH CO. IA NO: GA/1/2020(Old No:GA/901/2020), GA/2/2020(Old No:GA/902/2020)

(Bench ID-173912 ) 2/2 Page 18 Of 41 Original Side DAILY CAUSELIST For Thursday The 17th December 2020

COURT NO. 38 SINGLE BENCH (SB-IV, COMMERCIAL BENCH) AT 2:00 PM HON'BLE JUSTICE ASHIS KUMAR CHAKRABORTY (VIA VIDEO CONFERENCE)

NOTE:MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP THROUGH PHYSICAL HEARING ONLY WHEN BOTH THE PARTIES ARE AGREED.

NOTE: ORIGINAL SIDE MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP FROM 2:00 P.M

NOTE: ROSTER FOR COMMERCIAL APPELLATE DIVISION AND COMMERCIAL DIVISION, CALCUTTA HIGH COURT ON AND FROM MONDAY, THE 7TH DECEMBER, 2020 ISSUED ON 1ST DECEMBER, 2020 IS MODIFIED TO THE FOLLOWING EXTENT - MATTERS UNDER SECTION 11 OF THE ARBITRATION AND CONCILIATION ACT, 1996 INCLUDING APPLICATION CONNECTED THERETO.

NOTE: MENTIONING WILL BE PERMITTED ONLY ON THE VIRTUAL MODE INDICATING GROUP(S) OR SECTION(S) ALONG WITH GROUND OF URGENCY.

NOTE: COMMERCIAL BENCH WILL BE TAKEN UP FIRST.

Page 19 Of 41 Original Side DAILY CAUSELIST For Thursday The 17th December 2020

COURT NO. 38 SINGLE BENCH (SB-IV) AT 2:00 PM HON'BLE JUSTICE ASHIS KUMAR CHAKRABORTY (VIA VIDEO CONFERENCE)

NOTE:MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP THROUGH PHYSICAL HEARING ONLY WHEN BOTH THE PARTIES ARE AGREED.

NOTE: ORIGINAL SIDE MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP FROM 2:00 P.M

NOTE: ROSTER FOR COMMERCIAL APPELLATE DIVISION AND COMMERCIAL DIVISION, CALCUTTA HIGH COURT ON AND FROM MONDAY, THE 7TH DECEMBER, 2020 ISSUED ON 1ST DECEMBER, 2020 IS MODIFIED TO THE FOLLOWING EXTENT - MATTERS UNDER SECTION 11 OF THE ARBITRATION AND CONCILIATION ACT, 1996 INCLUDING APPLICATION CONNECTED THERETO.

NOTE: MENTIONING WILL BE PERMITTED ONLY ON THE VIRTUAL MODE INDICATING GROUP(S) OR SECTION(S) ALONG WITH GROUND OF URGENCY.

NOTE: COMMERCIAL BENCH WILL BE TAKEN UP FIRST.

TO BE MENTIONED 1 IA NO. CA/10/2018 IN THE MATTER OF : BOSE O/L, HIGH COURT, (Old No: INFRASTRUCTURE LTD (IN CALCUTTA CA/89/2018) LIQN) SOUMYADEEP Vs BISWAS

In CP/184/2013 2 IA NO. CA/8/2017 IN THE MATTER OF : BOSE OFFICIAL (Old No: INFRASTRUCTURE LTD (IN LIQUIDATOR CA/161/2017) LIQN.) SOUMYADEEP Vs BISWAS

In CP/184/2013 COMPANY MATTER (NEW)

(Bench ID-173913 ) 1/5 Page 20 Of 41 DAILY CAUSELIST COURT NO 38-FOR THURSDAY THE 17TH DECEMBER 2020 HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA - 2 -

3 IA NO. CA/8/2020 IN THE MATTER OF : DIELES FORGE LTD (IN A.P.AGARWALLA LIQN ) In BIFR/299/1998 Vs RAJ KASERA -VS- O/L 4 IA NO. CA/19/2018 RE: RUBI STAR REAL O/L, HIGH COURT, (Old No: ESTATE & HOUSING CALCUTTA CA/117/2018) DEVELOPMENT LTD (IN ANANTA KUMAR LIQ) LALA Vs In CP/313/2012 5 IA NO. CA/20/2020 RE: RUBI STAR REAL ESTATE & HOUSING ANANTA KUMAR DEVELOPMENT LTD -AND- LALA In CP/313/2012 Vs SMT. REBA MANDAL AND ORS. NEW MOTIONS (SECTION 11) 6 AP/159/2019 WEST BENGAL GOLF R. GINODIA AND CO. ANURAG BAGARIA SOCIETY AND ANR. VS THE INDIAN GOLF UNION AND ORS. 7 AP/388/2019 KIRAN PATRA AND ANR SOUMO CHAUDHURY VS RATNA DEY AND ORS IA NO: GA/1/2019(Old No:GA/2968/2019) 8 AP/355/2020 SMARTWORKS COWORKING KANODIA AND CO. SPACES PVT. LTD. VS CODENATION SOLUTIONS LLP 9 AP/94/2020 ASESH SANYAL AND 3 ARPAN GUHA OTHERS VS RAM GOPAL MURARKA AND ANR 10 AP/102/2020 SRI DURGA CONSTRUCTION BIJON MAJUMDAR VS UNION OF INDIA AND ORS 11 AP/112/2020 SRI DURGA CONSTRUCTION BIJON MAJUMDAR VS UNION OF INDIA AND ORS 12 AP/139/2020 SHIPRA COMMERCIAL PVT SUPREEM NASKAR LTD. VS THE NEW INDIA ASSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED 13 AP/141/2020 TAPATI SAHA ASHIS KUMAR DUTTA VS CHOWDHURY PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED

(Bench ID-173913 ) 2/5 Page 21 Of 41 DAILY CAUSELIST COURT NO 38-FOR THURSDAY THE 17TH DECEMBER 2020 HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA - 3 -

14 AP/177/2020 ACES INFOTECH (P) BUDDHADEB GHOSH LIMITED VS KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION 15 AP/200/2020 M/S. REMCO AND CO. RAHUL SARKAR VS UNION OF INDIA AND ORS. IA NO: GA/1/2020(Old No:GA/878/2020) 16 AP/220/2020 SK. ANWAR HAQUE AND SHUVANIL ANR. CHAKRABORTY VS AMINA BEGUM AND ORS. 17 AP/303/2020 KAASHVI ESTATE SANDIP AGARWAL VS AND CO RAMA NARAYANA EDUCATION TRUST 18 AP/304/2020 KAUSHIK MUKHERJEE SATRAJIT SINHA ROY VS THE STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA LIMITED AND ANR 19 AP/312/2020 RIPLEY AND CO TIRTHANKAR DAS STEVEDORING AND HANDLING PRIVATE LIMITED VS STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA LIMITED 20 AP/316/2020 SHREE LAXMI IRON AND AVIJIT DEY STEEL WORKS PRIVATE LIMITED VS THE EASTERN RAILWAY AND ORS. 21 AP/319/2020 TARUN KANTI DAS SOURAV CHATTERJEE VS UNION OF INDIA AND ANR. 22 AP/326/2020 M/S. BALAJEE EDUCATION SOUMA SIL PRIVATE LIMITED VS BISHWAJIT BARNWAL 23 AP/329/2020 GILLANDERS ARBUTHNOT ABHIJIT RAY AND CO. LTD. VS STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA LIMITED 24 AP/332/2020 B. B. R. CONSTRUCTION A. N. COMPANY BHATTACHARYYA VS AND CO. UNION OF INDIA

(Bench ID-173913 ) 3/5 Page 22 Of 41 DAILY CAUSELIST COURT NO 38-FOR THURSDAY THE 17TH DECEMBER 2020 HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA - 4 -

25 AP/335/2020 AIRCARE ENTERPRISES AVIJIT DEY AND ORS. VS LEVER FOUNDATION, WEST BENGAL AND ANR. 26 AP/337/2020 M/S. EASTMAN CRUSHER GOUTAM KUMAR CO. (P) LTD. GOON VS LARSEN AND TOUBRO LIMITED 27 AP/345/2020 GYANESHWAR PRASAD FARHAN GHAFFAR AGARWAL VS DISHNET WIRELESS LIMITED 28 AP/348/2020 DOLLY CHAKRAVORTY SHABANA HASIN VS SHYAMAL RAY 29 AP/349/2020 BHARAT PETROLEUM SUMAN DEY CORPORATION LTD VS MAHESH SHAH 30 AP/363/2020 MCNROE CONSUMER SOBHAN KUMAR PRODUCTS PRIVATE PATHAK LIMITED VS ALLURE CONSUMER PRODUCTS PRIVATE LIMITED 31 AP/365/2020 NAUSHAD ALAM MAINAK SWARNOKAR VS PARTHA CHAKRABORTY 32 AP/366/2020 NAUSHAD ALAM MAINAK SWARNOKAR VS PARTHA CHAKRABORTY 33 AP/371/2020 RREPL- KIPL (JV) RIJU GHOSH VS EASTERN COALFIELDS LTD 34 AP/374/2020 M/S HINDUSTHAN SOMNATH SAHA BUILDERS VS IRCON INTERNATIONAL LIMITED 35 AP/375/2020 KRISHANU SAHA PRASANTA KUMAR VS BAGCHI SUDIP SATYAPRIYA CHAKRABORTY 36 AP/376/2020 M/S. ELGI EQUIPMENTS DIPANJAN DATTA LTD. VS M/S. HIRANMAYE ENERGY LTD.

(Bench ID-173913 ) 4/5 Page 23 Of 41 DAILY CAUSELIST COURT NO 38-FOR THURSDAY THE 17TH DECEMBER 2020 HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA - 5 -

37 AP/378/2020 INDWELL CONSTRUCTIONS PAL CHOUDHURI PVT. LIMITED AND CO. VS BHARAT HEAVY ELECTRICALS LIMITED (BHEL) ADJOURNED MOTION (SECTION-11) 38 AP/348/2019 R.K.ASSOCIATES AND M/S. L.P.AGARWALLA HOTELIERS PVT LTD AND CO. VS EASTERN RAILWAY,THROUGH ITS DEPUTY CHIEF COMMERCIAL MANAGER 39 AP/361/2019 RELIANCE COMMERCIAL ABM ASSOCIATES AMRIN KHATOON FINANCE LIMITED VS AXIS BANK LIMITED SPECIALLY FIXED MATTERS 40 AP/829/2019 KOLKATA METRO RAIL FOX AND MANDAL CORPORATION LTD VS SIMPLEX INFRASTRUCTURE LTD IA NO: GA/1/2020(Old No:GA/18/2020) wt41 AP/830/2019 KOLKATA METRO RAIL FOX AND MANDAL CORPORATION LTD VS SIMPLEX INFRASTRUCTURE LTD IA NO: GA/1/2020(Old No:GA/19/2020)

(Bench ID-173913 ) 5/5 Page 24 Of 41 Original Side DAILY CAUSELIST For Thursday The 17th December 2020

COURT NO. 13 SINGLE BENCH (SB-VI) AT 3:30 PM HON'BLE JUSTICE RAJASEKHAR MANTHA (VIA VIDEO CONFERENCE)

NOTE:MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP THROUGH PHYSICAL HEARING ONLY WHEN BOTH THE PARTIES ARE AGREED.

NOTE : 1. ORIGINAL SIDE MENTIONING WILL BE ALLOWED UPON BEING LISTED AS "TO BE MENTIONED" ON EVERY TUESDAY AT 3:30 P.M. ONLY IN THE VIRTUAL MODE AS PER NOTIFICATION NO. 4286-RG, DATED 27.11.2020 FOLLOWING THE PRESCRIBED PROCEDURE.

2. ORIGINAL SIDE MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP ON EVERY FRIDAY AT 3.30 P.M.

Page 25 Of 41 Original Side DAILY CAUSELIST For Thursday The 17th December 2020

COURT NO. 8 SINGLE BENCH (SB-VII) AT 10:45 AM HON'BLE JUSTICE SABYASACHI BHATTACHARYYA (VIA VIDEO CONFERENCE)

NOTE:MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP THROUGH PHYSICAL HEARING ONLY WHEN BOTH THE PARTIES ARE AGREED.

NOTE: (I) ORIGINAL SIDE MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP FROM 10:45 A.M.TO 1:00 P.M. EVERYDAY.

(II) APPELLATE SIDE MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN FROM 2:00 P.M. TO 4:00 P.M. OR IMMEDIATELY AFTER COMPLETION OF ORIGINAL SIDE MATTERS, WHICHEVER IS EARLIER.

(III) MENTIONING WILL BE ALLOWED ONLY ON EVERY MONDAY AT THE FIRST SITTING.

(IV) ORIGINAL SIDE MATTER FIXED AT 2:00 P.M. FOR THIS DAY WILL BE TAKEN UP BEFORE THE APPELLATE SIDE MATTERS TO BE CALLED ON FROM 2:00 P.M.

COURT APPLICATIONS UNDER ART.226 1 WPO/155/2020 M/S. B. S. MEDICAL SUPREEM NASKAR INTERNATIONAL VS METRO RAILWAY, KOLKATA AND ORS. 2 WPO/369/2020 ASHA EXPO AND CO. LTD. ANURAG BAGARIA VS UCO BANK 3 WPO/424/2020 DEBABRATA CHAKRABORTY DEBASHIS SARKAR AND ORS VS TEH STATE BANK OF INDIA AND ANR FOR HEARING

(Bench ID-173934 ) 1/3 Page 26 Of 41 DAILY CAUSELIST COURT NO 8-FOR THURSDAY THE 17TH DECEMBER 2020 HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA - 2 -

4 WPO/309/2020 THE NORTH WESTERN SHIVANGI THARD [Pt.Hd.] CACHAR TEA COMPANY LIMITED AND ANR VS RESERVE BANK OF INDIA AND ORS 5 WPO/466/2019 MINA BEGUM PROP OF M/S SUPREEM NASKAR [Pt.Hd.] M N SULTANA ENTERPRISE VS THE KOLKATA PORT TRUST AND ANR wt6 WPO/559/2019 MINA BEGUM, PROPRITOR SUPREEM NASKAR OF M/S. M N SULTANA ENTERPRISE VS THE KOLKATA PORT TRUST AND ANR. 7 WPO/493/2019 NARESH KUMAR PODDAR MAINAK SWARNOKAR [AT 2:00 P.M.] VS UNION OF INDIA, THROUGH SECRETARY , MINISTRY OF CORPORATE AFFAIRS AND ANR 8 WPO/398/2019 HOOGHLY EXTRUSIONS SAMRAT DEY PAUL LTD AND ANR VS THE GOVERNMENT OF WEST BENGAL AND 3 OTHERS 9 WPO/502/2019 MAHABALI TECHNO SUBRATA MUKHERJEE ENGINEERS VS EASTERN COALFIELDS LIMITED AND ORS. 10 WPO/503/2019 MAHESHWARI FUELS AND SUBRATA MUKHERJEE ALLIED INDUSTRIES VS EASTERN COALFIELDS LIMITED AND ORS. 11 WPO/508/2019 NAND LAL SHAW PROTYUSHCHATTERJEE VS UNION OF INDIA AND ORS 12 WPO/512/2019 ATMA RAM SARAF ARINDAM LAHIRI VS THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND 4 OTHERS 13 WPO/524/2019 GLACIER ENGINEERING CO SINTHIA BALA AND ORS VS STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS 14 WPO/537/2019 CHAMPA IMPEX PRIVATE ANUJIT MOOKHERJI LIMITED AND ORS VS THE KARUR VYSYA BANK LIMITED AND ANR

(Bench ID-173934 ) 2/3 Page 27 Of 41 DAILY CAUSELIST COURT NO 8-FOR THURSDAY THE 17TH DECEMBER 2020 HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA - 3 -

15 WPO/541/2019 JAJU BROTHERS SHREYASI SANYAL VS THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES FOR KOLKATA PORT TRUST AND ORS 16 WPO/563/2019 DINESH DINDA DEBDUTTA BASU VS THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND 4 OTHERS 17 WPO/587/2019 CITY DEVCON PVT. LTD. ANJAN BHATTACHARYA AND ANR VS THE HOWRAH MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS 18 WPO/105/2020 MRITUNJAY SINGH DIPAK RANJAN VS MUKHERJEE THE UNION OF INDIA AND ORS. 19 WPO/278/2020 MONISHA GROVER AMALAKSHA JANA VS UNION OF INDIA AND ANR IA NO: GA/1/2020

(Bench ID-173934 ) 3/3 Page 28 Of 41 Original Side DAILY CAUSELIST For Thursday The 17th December 2020

COURT NO. 39 SINGLE BENCH (SB-VIII, COMMERCIAL BENCH) AT 10:45 AM HON'BLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA (VIA VIDEO CONFERENCE) NOTE: MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP THROUGH PHYSICAL HEARING ONLY WHEN BOTH THE PARTIES ARE AGREED

ADJOURNED MOTION 1 AP/206/2020 ADITYA KHAITAN AND ORS KHAITAN AND CO [S.A.] VS IL AND FS FINANCIAL SERVICES

(Bench ID-173939 ) 1/1 Page 29 Of 41 Original Side DAILY CAUSELIST For Thursday The 17th December 2020

COURT NO. 39 SINGLE BENCH (SB-VIII) AT 10:45 AM HON'BLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA (VIA VIDEO CONFERENCE)

NOTE:MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP THROUGH PHYSICAL HEARING ONLY WHEN BOTH THE PARTIES ARE AGREED.

NOTE : AFTER COMMERCIAL DIVISION MATTERS

TO BE MENTIONED 1 AP/322/2019 MANOJ KUMAR BHAGAT JOYJIT DUTTA AND ORS VS HIRALAL PANDEY IA NO: GA/1/2019, GA/2/2020(Old No:GA/73/2020), GA/3/2020(Old No:GA/602/2020), GA/4/2020(Old No:GA/603/2020), GA/5/2020(Old No:GA/672/2020) COURT APPLICATIONS UNDER ART.226 2 WPO/313/2020 SHIW KUMAR DALMIA M/S. CHATTERJEE, [S.A.] VS SIL AND CO. THE KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS. APPLICATION FOR RULE IN CONTEMPT 3 CC/43/2020 TIRUPATI VESSEL PRIVATE RUNA PALIT LIMITED VS ANKUSH RAJHANS AND ORS. 4 CC/44/2020 TIRUPATI VESSEL PRIVATE RUNA PALIT LIMITED VS PRAKASH CHANDRA YADAV AND ANR. NEW MOTIONS

(Bench ID-173917 ) 1/3 Page 30 Of 41 DAILY CAUSELIST COURT NO 39-FOR THURSDAY THE 17TH DECEMBER 2020 HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA - 2 -

5 AP/377/2020 SMT. MADHABI MONDAL MUKHERJE AND ANR. ASSOCIATES VS CHOLAMANDALAM INVESTMENT AND FINANCE COMPANY LIMITED 6 AP/380/2020 SK MD ARIF HOSSAIN AND RAJKUMAR SAIN ANR VS SHRIRAM TRANSPORT FINANCE CO LTD 7 AP/381/2020 NATIONAL INSURANCE ARIJEET DOSS COMPANY LIMITED MULLICK VS DARJEELING ORGANIC TEA ESTATES PRIVATE LIMITED IA NO: GA/1/2020 8 AP/383/2020 M/S SOUTH CITY PROJECTS SAPTARSHI DATTA KOLKATA LIMITED AND ANR VS KOLKATA MUNICIPAL DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY ARBITRATION MOTION (ADJ.) SEC. 34 9 AP/579/2008 STATE OF WEST BENGAL PARITOSH SINHA MADAN MOHAN ROY VS PAM DEVELOPMENTS PRIVATE LIMITED 10 AP/965/2013 DIGHA SHANKARPUR INDUBHUSHAN DAS DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY VS A. K. ENTERPRISE 11 AP/1097/2013 STEEL AUTHORITY OF SUPRIYA DUBEY INDIA LTD -IISCO STEEL PLANT VS BALAJI INDUSTRIAL PRODUCTS LTD . 12 AP/147/2016 MARMAGOA STEELS LTD. A. N. DEY & ASSOCIATES VS BHATTACHARYYA & MSTC LTD. CO. 13 AP/532/2016 UNION OF INDIA APARNA BANERJEE VS NATIONAL CONSTRUCTION & TRADING COMPANY 14 AP/648/2016 IBRAHIM FATEHPURI & PRADEEP KUMAR ANR. VS AXIS BANK LTD. 15 AP/981/2016 PAM DEVELOPMENTS PVT. AMRITAM MANDAL LTD. VS UNION OF INDIA & ANR

(Bench ID-173917 ) 2/3 Page 31 Of 41 DAILY CAUSELIST COURT NO 39-FOR THURSDAY THE 17TH DECEMBER 2020 HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA - 3 -

16 AP/146/2017 MD. AFSAR FATEHPURI & MUKHERJE ANR ASSOCIATES VS SREI EQUIPMENT FINANCE LTD 17 AP/207/2017 SURESH KUMAR AGARWAL SUBIR SABUD VS L & T FINANCE LTD wt18 AP/214/2017 SURESH KUMAR AGARWAL SUBIR SABUD VS L & T. FINANCE LTD. 19 AP/377/2017 THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE RAJESH SINGH R. GINODIA & CO. CO. LTD VS MADHYA BHARAT PAPERS LTD 20 AP/195/2018 M/S CAPITAL CEMENT H.N.DATTA & CO AGENCY VS UNION OF INDIA 21 AP/797/2018 MOOKHERJEE, BISWAS AND ANS ASSOCIATES SIDDHANT PATHAK & ORS. GHOSH(RES.1,2,3) VS KANCHAN DUTTA & ORS. 22 AP/625/2019 LINDSAY INTERNATIONAL S KAKRANIA AND CO. ARUNABHA DEB [S.A.] PRIVATE LIMITED VS IFGL REFRACTORIES LTD. 23 AP/627/2019 LINDSAY INTERNATIONAL S KAKRANIA AND CO. ARUNABHA DEB [S.A.] PRIVATE LIMITED VS IFGL REFRACTORIES LTD.

(Bench ID-173917 ) 3/3 Page 32 Of 41 Original Side DAILY CAUSELIST For Thursday The 17th December 2020

COURT NO. 26 SINGLE BENCH (SB-IX) AT 3:00 PM HON'BLE JUSTICE SHEKHAR B. SARAF (VIA VIDEO CONFERENCE)

NOTE:MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP THROUGH PHYSICAL HEARING ONLY WHEN BOTH THE PARTIES ARE AGREED.

NOTE : 1) EVERYDAY ORIGINAL SIDE MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE COMPLETION OF THE APPELLATE SIDE MATTERS OR AT 3:00 P.M. WHICHEVER IS EARLIER.

2) ORIGINAL SIDE MENTIONING WILL BE ALLOWED IMMEDIATELY BEFORE THE ORIGINAL SIDE MATTERS ARE TAKEN UP.

3) MENTIONING FOR INCLUSION IN THE LIST SHALL BE ENTERTAINED ONLY UPON PROPER NOTICE

ON THURSDAY, THE 17TH DECEMBER, 2020 AND FRIDAY, THE 18TH DECEMBER, 2020 - WILL TAKE, IN ADDITION TO HIS OWN LIST AND DETERMINATION, URGENT MATTERS RELATING TO THE LIST OF HON'BLE JUSTICE RAJARSHI BHARADWAJ.

COURT APPLICATIONS UNDER ART.226 1 WPO/403/2020 NIRAJ KUMAR SHARMA VICTOR CHATTERJEE VS UNION OF INDIA AND ANR. 2 WPO/425/2020 M/S. ABIS EXPORTS (I) PVT. ABHISEK BARAN DAS LTD. VS UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.

(Bench ID-173918 ) 1/1 Page 33 Of 41 Original Side DAILY CAUSELIST For Thursday The 17th December 2020

COURT NO. 10 SINGLE BENCH (SB-XII) AT 10:45 AM HON'BLE JUSTICE RAVI KRISHAN KAPUR (VIA VIDEO CONFERENCE)

NOTE:MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP THROUGH PHYSICAL HEARING ONLY WHEN BOTH THE PARTIES ARE AGREED.

NOTE: (I) ORIGINAL SIDE MENTIONING EVERY WEDNESDAY AND THURSDAY AT 10:45 A.M.

(II) ORIGINAL SIDE MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP EVERY WEDNESDAY AND THURSDAY AT 10:45 A.M. BEFORE APPELLATE SIDE MATTERS. AFTER COMPLETION OF ORIGINAL SIDE MATTERS, APPELLATE SIDE MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP.

TO BE MENTIONED 1 WPO/362/2020 M/S SONAI FOOD NIBEDITA PAL MARKETING PVT LTD AND ANR VS THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS FOR HEARING (OLD MATTER) 2 IA NO. GA/1/2006 THE INDIAN RAYON & (Old No: INDUSTRIES LTD. & ANR DUBE & CO. N.Y.A GA/3842/2006) Vs THE UNION OF INDIA

In WPO/3015/1987 3 IA NO. GA/1/2006 M/S.NAPANI & SONS & ANR (Old No: Vs R.L.GAGGAR FOX & MANDAL GA/1886/2006) THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES FOR THE PORT CAL

In WPO/5306/1988

(Bench ID-173944 ) 1/5 Page 34 Of 41 DAILY CAUSELIST COURT NO 10-FOR THURSDAY THE 17TH DECEMBER 2020 HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA - 2 -

4 IA NO. GA/2/2006 KAJAL KANTI DASGUPTA (Old No: Vs N.MUKHOPADHYAY N.Y.A. GA/1744/2006) UNIOIN OF INDIA

In WPO/824/1990 5 IA NO. GA/2/2006 KAJAL KANTI DASGUPTA (Old No: Vs N.MUKHOPADHYAY N.Y.A. GA/1742/2006) UNION OF INDIA

In WPO/826/1990 6 IA NO. GA/2/2006 G.B.TIMBER INDUSTRIES & (Old No: ORS A.B. MUKHERJEE FOX & MONDAL GA/1525/2006) Vs THE CHAIRMAN CAL. PORT TRUST In WPO/2232/1990 7 IA NO. GA/2/2005 SRI CHANDRADIP RAI (Old No: Vs B.GHOSH GA/2822/2005) UNION OF INDIA

In WPO/1862/1998 8 IA NO. GA/1/2006 SYED SALAHUDDIN (Old No: Vs BACKBONE & CO. GA/3593/2006) C. E. S. C. LTD.

In WPO/890/2003 9 IA NO. GA/1/2005 HALL & ANDERSON LTD. & (Old No: ANR DUBE & CO. GA/3551/2005) Vs UNION OF INDIA

In WPO/1829/2004 10 IA NO. GA/1/2006 CELICA DEVELOPING (P) (Old No: LTD. N C BEHANI GA/2355/2006) Vs K M C

In WPO/1887/2004 11 IA NO. GA/1/2006 MD. IDRIS ALAM (Old No: Vs SYED SHAMSUL GA/1861/2006) STATE OF WEST BENGAL AREFIN

In WPO/2118/2004 12 IA NO. GA/3/2006 BHADURI & (Old No: COR ANIMESH DAS GA/1707/2006) Vs REGISTRAR OF SOCIETIES

In WPO/1646/2005

(Bench ID-173944 ) 2/5 Page 35 Of 41 DAILY CAUSELIST COURT NO 10-FOR THURSDAY THE 17TH DECEMBER 2020 HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA - 3 -

13 IA NO. GA/1/2006 SAMAR KUMAR NATH & (Old No: ORS. SK. REAZUL ISLAM GA/1814/2006) Vs W.B. LABOUR WELFARE BOARD In WPO/1901/2005 14 IA NO. GA/1/2006 JUTHIKA GHOSH. (Old No: Vs SOMAKAR GHOSH A K MANNA GA/1782/2006) STATE OF W B

In WPO/328/2006 15 IA NO. GA/1/2006 MULTIPLE RESORTS P LTD (Old No: & ANR. SANDERSON & GA/1517/2006) Vs MORGANS W B FINANCIAL CORPORATION In WPO/482/2006 16 IA NO. GA/1/2006 FORT GLOSTER (Old No: INDUSTRIES LTD. & ANR. RATNESH KUMAR RAI GA/1542/2006) Vs APPELLATE AUTHORITY FOR INDUSTRIAL FINAN In WPO/583/2006 17 IA NO. GA/1/2006 VINAYAK CONCLAVE PVT. (Old No: LTD. VICTOR MOSES & CO. GA/3647/2006) Vs STATE OF W.B.

In WPO/729/2006 18 IA NO. GA/1/2006 A-ONE ENTERPRISE & ANR. (Old No: Vs SUDARSAN HALDER GA/1920/2006) STATE OF W.B.

In WPO/827/2006 19 IA NO. GA/1/2006 MD. HAMZA (Old No: Vs ABHAY CHARAN JANA GA/3189/2006) STATE OF W.B.

In WPO/1153/2006 20 IA NO. GA/1/2006 MD. SALAUDDIN (Old No: Vs AJOY SANKAR GA/3301/2006) THE K.M.C. SANYAL

In WPO/1170/2006 21 IA NO. GA/1/2006 MAHENDRA SINGH & ORS. (Old No: Vs ARUN KANTI BERA GA/3275/2006) STATE OF W.B. & ORS.

In WPO/1348/2006

(Bench ID-173944 ) 3/5 Page 36 Of 41 DAILY CAUSELIST COURT NO 10-FOR THURSDAY THE 17TH DECEMBER 2020 HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA - 4 -

22 IA NO. GA/1/2006 GLENCON INTERNATIONAL (Old No: Vs S. S. SHROFF GA/3328/2006) UNION OF INDIA

In WPO/1621/2006 FOR HEARING 23 WPO/100060/1995 LIFE INSURANCE SANJUKTA RAY CORPORATION OF INDIA VS 1ST LAND AQUISITION COLLECTOR,L.R.DEPT 24 WPO/2176/2004 EXIDE INDUSTRIES LTD. NILANJANA PAL VS COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX - I,KOLKATA 25 WPO/1127/2005 HINDUSTAN PETROLEUM SATYABRATA CORPORATION LTD. CHAKRABORTY VS THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS KOLKATA PORT TRUS 26 IA NO. GA/2/2020 M/S THE ROY BROS. S.S. AREFIN (Old No: Vs S.S. AREFIN GA/268/2020) STATE

In WPO/1948/2006 27 WPO/757/2016 PHANI BHUSHAN DAS TAPAN SARKAR VS LIFE INSURANCE CORPORATION OF INDIA & ORS IA NO: GA/1/2016(Old No:GA/3048/2016), GA/2/2017(Old No:GA/227/2017) 28 WPO/998/2016 DILIP KUMAR GHOSH SYED SHAMSUL VS AREFIN STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS 29 IA NO. GA/1/2020 ASHIM MALLICK A. V. ASSOCIATES (Old No: Vs A. V. ASSOCIATES GA/543/2020) THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS.

In WPO/1004/2016 30 WPO/59/2017 PRANAB KUMAR ROY TIRTHANKAR DEY VS UNITED BANK OF INDIA & ORS. 31 WPO/613/2017 BHARAT PODDAR & ORS. J.P.TIBREWAL & CO. VS THE KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION & ORS.

(Bench ID-173944 ) 4/5 Page 37 Of 41 DAILY CAUSELIST COURT NO 10-FOR THURSDAY THE 17TH DECEMBER 2020 HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA - 5 -

32 WPO/2/2018 BARUN DEB GHOSH & ORS. SUSANTA PAL VS THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS. 33 WPO/165/2018 SRI BISWAJIT SANTRA MAHABOOB AHMED MRINAL DAS (RES. VS 7,8) THE KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION & ORS 34 WPO/416/2018 KARUNA DAS ANJAN VS BHATTACHARYA THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS 35 WPO/471/2018 KALYAN BISWAS & ORS MAHABOOB AHMED VS KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION & ORS 36 WPO/9/2019 AMIT SHAW SAKTI PADA JANA VS THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS 37 WPO/48/2019 ABHIK KUSARI SOUVIK SEN FOX AND MANDAL VS (RES. NO. 1 AND 4) THE UNIVERSITY OF CALCUTTA AND ORS.

(Bench ID-173944 ) 5/5 Page 38 Of 41 Original Side DAILY CAUSELIST For Thursday The 17th December 2020

COURT NO. 23 SINGLE BENCH (SB-XIII) AT 2:00 PM HON'BLE JUSTICE ARINDAM MUKHERJEE (VIA VIDEO CONFERENCE)

NOTE:MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP THROUGH PHYSICAL HEARING ONLY WHEN BOTH THE PARTIES ARE AGREED.

NOTE: 1) ORIGINAL SIDE MATTERS SHALL BE TAKEN UP EVERYDAY AT 2:00 P.M.

2) ORDINARILY, SPECIALLY ASSIGNED MATTERS SHALL BE TAKEN UP ON FRIDAY AT 2:00 P.M.

3) AFTER COMPLETION OF ORIGINAL SIDE MATTERS, APPELLATE SIDE MATTERS SHALL BE AGAIN TAKEN UP.

FOR JUDGEMENT 1 IA NO. GA/4/2015 RAJEEV MAHESHWARI & PARAS KUHAD & (Old No: ORS. ASSOCIATES GA/2592/2015) Vs KHAITAN & CO. SHASHANK KOCHER & ORS.

In CS/195/2010

(Bench ID-173931 ) 1/1 Page 39 Of 41 Original Side DAILY CAUSELIST For Thursday The 17th December 2020

COURT NO. 24 SINGLE BENCH (SB-XV) AT 10:45 AM HON'BLE JUSTICE AMRITA SINHA (VIA VIDEO CONFERENCE)

NOTE:MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP THROUGH PHYSICAL HEARING ONLY WHEN BOTH THE PARTIES ARE AGREED.

NOTE: ORIGINAL SIDE MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP AT THE FIRST SITTING OF THE COURT.

AFTER COMPLETION OF ORIGINAL SIDE MATTERS, APPELLATE SIDE MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP.

CONTEMPT MATTERS 1 CC/6/2020 YUSUF KHAN SUBIR PAL WITH VS WPO/479/2017 KHALIL AHMED MUNICIPAL COMMISSIONER KMC AND ORS COURT APPLICATIONS UNDER ART.226 2 WPO/179/2020 PARTHA PRATIM MAITY SAMRAT DEY PAUL AND 17 ORS VS BORAD OF TRUSTEES FOR THE PORT OF KOLKATA AND ORS

(Bench ID-173956 ) 1/1 Page 40 Of 41 Original Side DAILY CAUSELIST For Thursday The 17th December 2020

COURT NO. 22 SINGLE BENCH (SB-XVI) AT 3:30 PM HON'BLE JUSTICE ABHIJIT GANGOPADHYAY (VIA VIDEO CONFERENCE)

NOTE:MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP THROUGH PHYSICAL HEARING ONLY WHEN BOTH THE PARTIES ARE AGREED.

NOTE: 1) ORIGINAL SIDE MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP EVERY TUESDAY AND THURSDAY AT 3:30 P.M.

2) MENTIONING ON THE ORIGINAL SIDE WILL BE ALLOWED EVERY TUESDAY AND THURSDAY AT 3:30 P.M.

COURT APPLICATIONS UNDER ART.226 1 WPO/121/2020 ORION SECURITY DEBASHIS SARKAR SOLUTIONS PVT LTD. VS UNION OF INDIA AND ORS 2 WPO/409/2020 GOUTAM KUMAR SARANGI KAKALI DUTTA VS THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS FOR HEARING 3 WPO/1568/2006 M/S. LIGHT HOUSE SOMNATH GANGULI (HUMAYAN PROPERTIES LTD VS STATE OF W.B. 4 WPO/1663/2008 AAJKAAL PUBLISHERS PVT. SUSHIL KUAMR LTD. KARMAKAR VS EMPLOYEES STATE INSURANCE CORPORATION & ANR. 5 WPO/1829/2008 HOOGLY MILLS PROJECTS M/S. DUBE & CO. LTD. & ANR. VS THE DIRECTOR ( SUPPLIES & DISPOSALS ) & ORS.

(Bench ID-173920 ) 1/1 Page 41 Of 41