Final Report
Nordmann’s Greenshank Population Analysis, at Pantai Cemara Jambi
Cipto Dwi Handono1, Ragil Siti Rihadini1, Iwan Febrianto1 and Ahmad Zulfikar Abdullah1
1Yayasan Ekologi Satwa Alam Liar Indonesia (Yayasan EKSAI/EKSAI Foundation)
Surabaya, Indonesia
Background
Many shorebirds species have declined along East Asian-Australasian Flyway which support the highest diversity of shorebirds in the world, including the globally endangered species, Nordmann’s Greenshank. Nordmann’s Greenshank listed as endangered in the IUCN Red list of Threatened Species because of its small and declining population (BirdLife International, 2016). It’s one of the world’s most threatened shorebirds, is confined to the East Asian–Australasian Flyway (Bamford et al. 2008, BirdLife International 2001, 2012).
Its global population is estimated at 500–1,000, with an estimated 100 in Malaysia, 100–200 in Thailand, 100 in Myanmar, plus unknown but low numbers in NE India, Bangladesh and Sumatra (Wetlands International 2006).
The population is suspected to be rapidly decreasing due to coastal wetland development throughout Asia for industry, infrastructure and aquaculture, and the degradation of its breeding habitat in Russia by grazing Reindeer Rangifer tarandus (BirdLife International 2012).
Mostly Nordmann’s Greenshanks have been recorded in very small numbers throughout Southeast Asia, and there are few places where it has been reported regularly. In Myanmar, for example, it was rediscovered after a gap of almost 129 years. The total count recorded by the Asian Waterbird Census (AWC) in 2006 for Myanmar was 28 birds with 14 being the largest number at a single locality (Naing 2007). In 2011–2012, Nordmann’s Greenshank was found three times in Sumatera Utara province, N Sumatra. First, a flock of 13 birds was recorded on 17 Nov 2011 at Tanjung Rejo village (3°44'N, 98°46'E), Percut Sei Tuan Subdistrict. The other two records both relate to birds seen just 8 km from the first site at Sei Tuan village (3°42'N, 98°50'E), Pantai Labu Subdistrict three on 15 Dec 2011, and four on 13 Jan 2012 (Abdillah, Hasri and M. Iqbal, 2012).
During Far Eastern Curlew Survey, November 2019, we recorded 28 individuals of Nordmann’s Greenshank at Pantai Cemara, Jambi. This showed the potency of Pantai Cemara as one important site for Nordmann’s Greenshank in Indonesia.
Objective
Provide an updated data of Nordmann’s Greenshank population at Pantai Cemara Jambi
Identify the potencies and threats at Pantai Cemara as stopping site for Nordmann’s Greenshank species
Do the survey with local team to increase their identification ability
Ecosystem Essential Area, Pantai Cemara, Desa Sungai Cemara, Tanjung Jabung Timur Region, Jambi
Fig 01. Map of Pantai Cemara - Essential Ecosystem Area, Jambi (Ministry of Environment and
Forestry Republic of Indonesia, 2019)
Site Status :
Protected as Ecosystem Essential Area (Managed by Forestry Department of Jambi Province)
currently in the process to be proposed as Flyway Site Network
Potency :
- This site was visited by more than ten thousands of migratory shorebirds which searching for feeding and roosting ground during their migratory journey (Unpublished data of Migratory Shorebird Survey at Pantai Cemara, Jambi 2019).
- Local people in this site are eager to learn and involving them self to be the part of migratory shorebirds conservation. They see these birds as the potency of their village.
- Local government fully support the development and conservation activities for this site
Threat :
Direct threat
- Forest fire (but the effect are not as big as Sembilang NP) - Natural Predator (Eagle observed prey on Charadrius mongolus during the monitoring) - Plastic waste - Massive growth of Ipomea sp. and Avicennia sp.
Fig 02. Observation point at Pantai Cemara - Essential Ecosystem Area (Google Earth 2020)
Survey Method
We did our survey from November 17th, 2020 to November 21st, 2020 (5 days). We determine one observation point which will be able to access the wide beach with mixed sandy beach substrate type. We did the monitoring and training to the local people and local ranger during the monitoring activity. We reach the observation point by boat, and continue by foot.
Note about the habitat condition
There are massive growth of grass, Ipomea sp.and Avicennia sp. from 2019 (Fig.03).
Fig 03. Massive growth of grass, Ipomea sp., and Avicenna sp.
Survey Result
Table 01 : Result of Survey Activity at Pantai Cemara, Jambi between November 17th, 2020 - November 21st, 2020.
IUCN
- NO
- Spesies
- English Name
Chinese Egret
Local Name
Kuntul Cina
- Population Trend
- 17
- 18
- 19
- 20
- 21
Status
1
Egretta eulopotes
- Decreasing
- VU
- 1
- 1
- 1
- 1
- 1
DD (Data
- Deficient)
- 2
3456789
Charadrius dealbatus Charadrius leschenaultii Pluvialis squatarola Charadrius mongolus Pluvialis fulva
White-Faced Plover Greater Sandplover Grey Plover
Unknown Decreasing Decreasing Unknown
2
412
48
239
8
04
1
89 17
354
2
1
368
7
1
438
34
476
4
Cerek Pasir Besar Cerek Besar
LC LC LC LC LC NT NT LC LC LC LC LC EN EN EN LC LC
28
337
13
0
Lesser Sandplover Pacific Golden Plover Kentish Plover
Cerek Pasir Mongolia Cerek Krenyut Cerek Tilil
535
- 7
- Decreasing
Decreasing Decreasing Decreasing Increasing Decreasing Decreasing
Stable
Charadrius alexandrinus Charadrius peronii
- 0
- 0
- 0
- 0
- Malay Plover
- Cerek Melayu
Cerek Jawa
- 1
- 0
- 1
- 1
- 0
Charadrius javanicus
- Javan Plover
- 2
- 2
- 1
- 2
- 0
10 Hydropogne caspia 11 Sterna hirundo
- Caspian Tern
- Dara Laut Caspia
Dara Laut Biasa Dara Laut Tiram Dara Laut Jambul Dara Laut Kecil Kedidi Besar
32
0
20
0
23
0
41
0
44
- 0
- Common Tern
12 Gelochelidon nilotica 13 Thallasseus bergii 14 Stenula albifrons 15 Calidris tenuirostris
Common Gull-billed Tern Greater Crested Tern Little Tern
- 0
- 0
- 0
- 0
- 0
19 35 20 35 21 26 87
20 30 38
8
14 27
301
18
6
- 0
- 10
27
138
24
5
Decreasing Decreasing Decreasing Decreasing Decreasing Decreasing
38
366
11
0
Great Knot
16 Numenius madagascariensis Far Eastern Curlew
Gajahan Timur Trinil Nordmann Trinil Rawa
17 Tringa guttifer 18 Tringa stagnatilis 19 Xenus cinereus
Spotted Greenshank Marsh Sandpiper Terek Sandpiper
11 20 74
22
125
16 36
17
- 26
- Trinil Bedaran
20 Tringa totanus
- Common Redshank, Redshank Trinil Kaki Merah
- Unknown
Decreasing Decreasing Decreasing
Stable
LC LC LC LC LC LC NT NT NT NT NT NT NT LC
30 17
1
38 21
1
29 18
1
4
24
1
17 20
1
21 Numenius phaeopus 22 Actitis hypoleucos 23 Arenaria interpres 24 Tringa nebularia 25 Calidris alba
- Whimbrel
- Gajahan Penggala
- Trinil Pantai
- Common Sandpiper
Rudy Turnstone Common Greenshank Sanderling
Trinil Pembalik Batu Trinil Kaki Hijau Kedidi Putih
- 2
- 2
- 2
- 0
- 0
21
1
24
1
24
2
18
1
16
- 1
- Unknown
26 Limnodromus semipalmatus Asian Dowitcher
Trinil Lumpur Asia Biru Laut Ekor Hitam Biru Laut Ekor Blorok Kedidi Merah
Decreasing Decreasing Decreasing Decreasing Decreasing Decreasing Decreasing
125
5
234 525 485
0
70
220 562
0
78
328 569
0
68
469 368
0
27 Limosa limosa
Black-tailed Godwit Bar-tailed Godwit Red Knot
28 Limosa lapponica 29 Calidris canutus 30 Numenius arquata 31 Calidris ruficolis 32 Calidris ferruginea 33 Glareola maldivarum
520
0
Eurasian Curlew Red Necked Stint Curlew Sandpiper Oriental Pratincole
Gajahan Besar Kedidi Leher Merah Kedidi Gol-Gol Terik Asia
44
270 183
0
25
248 174
0
14
130 159
0
26
137 201
0
77
278 230
1
- 2207
- 2384 2233
- 2817
- 2791
Table 02 : Maximum Count of Far Eastern Curlew at Pantai Cemara, Jambi
Maximum Count of
Nordmann’s Greenshank
2019 2020
28 21
Table 03 : Maximum Count of Migratory Waterbird recorded at Pantai Cemara, Jambi
Maximum Count of Migratory
Waterbirds recorded
2019 2020
17,032
2,817
Table 04 : Maximum Count of Godwit recorded at Pantai Cemara, Jambi
Maximum Count of Black-tailed Godwit
3,700
Maximum Count of Bar-tailed Godwit
2,700
- Maximum Count of
- Maximum Count of
Great Knot
1950
Maximum Count of Far
- Asian Dowitcher
- Eastern Curlew
2019 2020
564 234
38
- 35
- 525
- 520
- 366
Fig 04. Chart of Nordmann’s Greenshank Max. Count Data 2019 and 2020 (unpublished data, EKSAI)
Fig 05. Chart of Near Threatened and Endangered Species at Pantai Cemara (2019 &2020) (unpublished data, EKSAI).
Pantai Cemara located at Desa Sungai Cemara, Tanjung Jabung Timur Region, Jambi
Province. It is designited as Essential Ecosystem Area in 2018 by the Governer of Jambi Province. This site known as one of the most important site for migratory shorebird along Sumatra Island. With mixed sandy beach texture of it’s substrate, this site used by more than ten thousands migratory shorebirds from 32 species (unpublished data, EKSAI Foundation).
In 2019 we also recorded three endangered species of migratory shorebird roosting and feeding on this site. We recorded 28 individuals of Spotted Greenshank (more than 1% of it’s population), 38 individuals of Far Eastern Curlew and 1950 individuals of Great Knot. This result showed the potency of this site as one of the most important site for migratory shorebirds in Indonesia. Generally, this numbers are declining on 2020 as we seen on table 01 and table 04.
If we see table 02, the number of Nordmann’s Greenshank also declining this year, even not drastically declining like Godwit.
The major change of Pantai Cemara mudflat is a massive growth of it’s vegetation (Ipomea sp., unidentified grass, mangroves and sea pine). During the survey, we notice that Nordmann’s Greenshank and other large shorebirds like Godwit, Curlew, and Asian Dowitcher and Great Knot never roost or foraging on mudflat with vegetation. Open mudflat without vegetation provide a better access to their prey (Finn et al, 2008). Despite the habitat change, Pantai Cemara still provide a suitable non-breeding site for more than 1% of Nordmann’s Greenshank global population. As it describe at Zocker et al (2018), Nordmann’s Greenshank usually recorded on softer mudflats sheltered by mangrove near with sandier mudflats. This habitat description are suitable with the condition and substrate type of Pantai Cemara estuarine inter-tidal mudflat. Despite the suitable condition of Pantai Cemara as non-breeding site for Nordmann’s Greenshank, the massive growth of it’s vegetation need to be watched and control so it will not disturbing the birds.
Fig 06. Nordmann’s Greenshank (personal documentation, 2020)
During the survey we trained local youth team to improve their identification skill for
Nordmann’s Greenshank (Fig 06). In five days we evaluate their ability to distinguish Nordmann’s Greenshank from other species and after five days training and evaluation, they are be able to identify the species correctly with minimum mistakes.
Fig 06. Nordmann’s Greenshank Identification training for local youth team (personal documentation, 2020)
Conclusion
- Despite the declining of numbers of migratory shorebirds at Pantai Cemara, maximum numbers of Nordmann’s Greenshank are stable, and Pantai Cemara still support more than 1% of Nordmann’s Greenshank population.
- The massive growth of vegetation at Pantai Cemara should become a concern to be managed, because it’s already affect the numbers of migratory shorebirds at Pantai Cemara.
- The local youth team’s skill to identify Nordmann’s Greenshank are hihgly improve during the training, and they will continue the monthly monitoring at Pantai Cemara.
(a)
(b)
References
BirdLife International. 2017. Numenius madagascariencis. The IUCN Red List of Threatened
Species 2017 : e.T22693199A118601473.
UNEP-CMS. 2017. Action Plan for Far Eastern Curlew. Australia Government : Philiphines. Bamford, M., Watkins, D., Bancroft, W., Tischler, D. & Wahl, J. 2008. Migratory Shorebirds of the
East Asian-Australasian Flyway; Population Estimes and Internationally Important Sites.
Wetland International - Oceana. Canberra Australia
Van de Kam, J., Battley, P, F., McCaffery, B.I., Roger, D.I., Hong, J.S., Moores, N., Ki, J. Y., Lewis,
J., & Piersma, T. 2010. Invisible Connection : Why Migrating Shorebirds Need the Yellow Sea.
CSIRO Poblushing : Melbourne.
Melville, D.S., Chen, Y. & Ma, Z.J. 2016. Shorebirds along the Yeallow Sea coast of China face an uncertain future - a review of threaths. Emu 116: 100-110
Barter,M., 2002. Shorebirds of the Yellow Sea : Importance, threats and conservation status.
Wetland International Global Series 9, International Wader Studies 12. Canberra, Australia
Finn, P.G., Catterall, C.P. & Driscoll, P.V. 2008. Prey versus substrate as determinants of habitat choice in a feeding shorebirds.
Zocker, C., Li, David.,Chowdury, S.U.,Iqbal,Muhammad & Yu, Chenxing.2018.Winter Distribution,
Habitat and Feeding Behaviour of Nordmann’s Greenshank Tringa guttifer