Testimony of Bret Taylor Chief Technology Officer Facebook

"#$%&'()*!(+!,-#%!".*/(-! 01&#+!"#21)(/(3*!4++&2#-! 5.2#6((7!

,#+(-#!%1#!89:9!:#).%#!0(''&%%##!()!0(''#-2#;!:2&#)2#;!.)

>?/*!@A;!@BCB!

1601 South California Avenue, Palo Alto, California 94304 650.543.4800 – tel 650.543.4801 - fax

"##$!%&'()*##*+!,-%.)/%*!0#12(&(33()+!)%*2.*4!5(/6()!78'1-.9#*+!%*$!5(/6()9!#&! '-(!,#//.''((:!!;!%/!<)('!=%>3#)+!,-.(&!=(1-*#3#4>!?&&.1()!&#)!@%1(6##2:!!=-%*2!>#8!&#)!'-(! #AA#)'8*.'>!'#!6(!-()(!'#$%>!'#!'(9'.&>!6(&#)(!'-(!,#//.''((:!!!

DE#2?%&F#!:?''.-*!

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

;*!/>!'(9'./#*>!'#$%>!;!C.33!%$$)(99!'-)((!'#A.19:!!!"#$%+!;!C.33!$(91).6(!-#C!@%1(6##2! %*$!#'-()!9#1.%3!'(1-*#3#4.(9!%)(!/%2.*4!'-(!;*'()*('!%!&#)8/!&#)!9#1.%3!.*'()%1'.#*+!9-%).*4! .*&#)/%'.#*+!%*$!68.3$.*4!1#//8*.'.(9:!!;*!H89'!%!&(C!>(%)9!'-(!;*'()*('!-%9!6((*!')%*9&#)/($! &)#/!%*!.9#3%'($+!A%99.B(+!%*$!%*#*>/#89!(IA().(*1(!.*'#!%!8*.J8(3>!A#C()&83!/(%*9!#&! 1#**(1'.*4!C.'-!#'-()!A(#A3(+!$((A(*.*4!A()9#*%3!)(3%'.#*9+!%*$!1)(%'.*4!1#//8*.'.(9!'-%'! 6(''()!'-(!3.B(9!#&!#'-()9:!!!

&'()*++!;!C.33!$.91899!-#C!89()!1#*')#3!%*$!)(9A#*9.B(*(99!%)(!(99(*'.%3!'#!9-%).*4!%*$! 1#**(1'.*4!89.*4!@%1(6##2:!!=-(!A(#A3(!C-#!89(!@%1(6##2!98AA3>!@%1(6##2K9!1#*'(*'+!%*$!%)(! '-(!$).B.*4!&#)1(!6(-.*$!'-(!1#*'.*8($!.**#B%'.#*!%*$!1#*9'%*'!./A)#B(/(*'!#&!#8)!9()B.1(:!! ?8)!4#%3!.9!'#!/%2(!.'!9./A3()!&#)!A(#A3(!'#!1#**(1'!%*$!9-%)(+!%*$!'#!4.B(!'-(/!'-(!'##39!'#! 1#*')#3!'-(.)!.*&#)/%'.#*:!!!

,-"#++!;!C.33!$(91).6(!'-(!./A#)'%*'!(1#*#/.1!4)#C'-!1)(%'($!%*$!98AA#)'($!6>!'-(! A(#A3(!C-#!89(!@%1(6##2!%*$!6>!'-#9(!1#/A%*.(9!'-%'!.**#B%'(!6%9($!#*!@%1(6##2K9!9#1.%3!

1601 South California Avenue, Palo Alto, California 94304 650.543.4800 – tel 650.543.4801 - fax

'(1-*#3#4>:!!@%1(6##2!A)#B.$(9!%!A3%'&#)/!&#)!'-#89%*$9!#&!(*')(A)(*(8)9!'#!$(B(3#A+!#&&()+! %*$!/%)2('!B%38($!A)#$81'9!%*$!9()B.1(9!'#!A(#A3(!%1)#99!'-(!43#6(:!!G(!1#**(1'!%$B()'.9()9! C.'-!A(#A3(!.*!%!C%>!'-%'!.9!8*#6')89.B(+!%*$!'-%'!(*%63(9!'-(!%$B()'.9()!'#!$.)(1'!.*&#)/%'.#*! '#C%)$!'-(!A(#A3(!C-#!%)(!/#9'!3.2(3>!'#!&.*$!.'!)(3(B%*'!%*$!B%38%63(:!!G(!$#!'-.9!C.'-#8'! 9(33.*4!89()!.*&#)/%'.#*!'#!%$B()'.9()9!#)!4.B.*4!%$B()'.9()9!%11(99!'#!A()9#*%3!.*&#)/%'.#*:!!!!!

C9! "1#!"-.)$+(-'.%&F#!D++#2%!(+!:(2&./!"#21)(/(3*!

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

R.*1(!.'9!1)(%'.#*!.*!%!7%)B%)$!$#)/!)##/!6>!5%)2!S812()6()4!.*!LFFT+!@%1(6##2!-%9! 6((*!%'!'-(!&#)(&)#*'!#&!'-.9!1-%*4(+!4)#C.*4!&)#/!%!*('C#)2!%'!%!-%*$&83!#&!8*.B()9.'.(9!'#!%!

1 Internet Usage Statistics, The Internet Big Picture, World Internet Users and Population Stats, http://www.internetworldstats.com/stats.htm.

1601 South California Avenue, Palo Alto, California 94304 650.543.4800 – tel 650.543.4801 - fax

C#)3$C.$(!1#//8*.'>!#&!89()9!.*!#B()!MUF!1#8*').(9:!!V9!@%1(6##2!-%9!(IA%*$($+!C(!-%B(!%39#! 1#*'.*8%33>!.**#B%'($!%*$!./A3(/(*'($!*(C!'##39!&#)!89()9+!)(9A#*$.*4!'#!'-(!.//(*9(!A863.1! $(/%*$!&#)!/#)(!%*$!6(''()!C%>9!'#!9-%)(!%*$!1#**(1':!!=-(9(!.//(*9(3>!A#A83%)!.**#B%'.#*9! .*138$(!%!A-#'#O9-%).*4!&(%'8)(!'-%'+!C.'-!9#/(!EF!6.33.#*!A.1'8)(9!#*3.*(+!1#*9'.'8'(9!'-(! 3%)4(9'!A-#'#!%)1-.B(!.*!'-(!C#)3$W!%!PG%33Q!&(%'8)(!'-)#84-!C-.1-!89()9!1%*!A#9'!/(99%4(9!#*! '-(.)!&).(*$9K!.*$.B.$8%3!A%4(9W!%*$!'-(!PX(C9!@(($+Q!C-.1-!A)#B.$(9!89()9!8AO'#O'-(!/.*8'(! .*'()%1'.B(!1#*'(*'!6%9($!#*!8A$%'(9!6>!'-(!89()K9!&).(*$9!%*$!-.9!#)!-()!.*'()(9'9!%*$! 1#//8*.'.(9:!!Y%1-!#&!'-(!EFF!/.33.#*!A(#A3(!'-%'!89(!@%1(6##2!(IA().(*1(!'-(.)!#C*! A()9#*%3.Z($!-#/(A%4(!%*$!X(C9!@(($!C-(*!'-(>!4#!'#!@%1(6##2:1#/+!1#**(1'.*4!'-(/!'#! '-(.)!#C*!1#//8*.'>!#&!&).(*$9!%*$!.*'()(9'9:!

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

=#!1(3(6)%'(!'-(!EFF!/.33.#*!A(#A3(!'-%'!-%B(!6((*!(/A#C()($!%*$!1#**(1'($!6>! @%1(6##2+!3%9'!C((2!C(!3%8*1-($!%!*(C!%AA3.1%'.#*!1%33($!@%1(6##2!R'#).(9! \9'#).(9:&%1(6##2:1#/]+!C-.1-!%33#C9!.*$.B.$8%39!'#!9-%)(!9'#).(9!%6#8'!-#C!@%1(6##2!-%9! (*).1-($!'-(.)!3.B(9:!!V/#*4!'-(!'-#89%*$9!#&!(I%/A3(9!C(!-%B(!)(1(.B($!%)(!'-(!!#C.*4^!!!

• <(*!R%>3#)+!%!M_O>(%)O#3$!-.4-!91-##3!9'8$(*'+!'8)*($!'#!@%1(6##2!'#!#)4%*.Z(!%! 1#//8*.'>!(&&#)'!'#!)(68.3$!'-(!#3$(9'!#8'$##)!'-(%'()!.*!`(*'812>+!C-.1-!-%$!6((*! $%/%4($!6>!&3##$9!.*!5%>:!!

1601 South California Avenue, Palo Alto, California 94304 650.543.4800 – tel 650.543.4801 - fax

• 7#33>!0#9(+!%!/#'-()!.*!a-#(*.I+!1)($.'9!%!&).(*$K9!9'%'89!/(99%4(!%92.*4!C#/(*!'#! 1-(12!&#)!6)(%9'!1%*1()!C.'-!-()!6(.*4!$.%4*#9($!.*!'./(!'#!')(%'!'-(!$.9(%9(:!!R-(!89($! @%1(6##2!&#)!98AA#)'!$8).*4!'-(!')(%'/(*'!%*$!6(1%/(!%*!#*3.*(!A)(B(*'.#*!%$B#1%'(! -()9(3&:!!!

• 5%*>!-%B(!*#C!(B(*!6(48*!89.*4!@%1(6##2!'#!)(%1-!#8'!'#!'-(.)!1#//8*.'.(9!'#!&.*$! #)4%*!$#*#)9[R%)%-!=%>3#)!#&!a(**9>3B%*.%!J8.123>!*$!%!2.$*(>!$#*#)!%&'()! 9A(*$.*4!(.4-'!>(%)9!.*!)(*%3!&%.38)(:!!!

V9!/#)(!%*$!/#)(!A(#A3(!H#.*!%*$!89(!@%1(6##2+!'-(!A#99.6.3.'.(9!&#)!.*$.B.$8%3!%*$!1#33(1'.B(! %1'.#*!C.33!/83'.A3>!%3/#9'!(IA#*(*'.%33>:!

@%1(6##2!%*$!#'-()!9#1.%3!'(1-*#3#4.(9!-%B(!(B(*!A3%>($!%!2(>!$(/#1)%'.1!&8*1'.#*!%'! -#/(!%*$!%6)#%$:!!<(1%89(!'-(9(!9()B.1(9!%33#C!89()9!'#!J8.123>!9-%)(!.*&#)/%'.#*!%*$!68.3$! 1#//8*.'.(9+!$(/#1)%'.1!#)4%*.Z()9!-%B(!(/6)%1($!@%1(6##2!%9!%!2(>!'##3!.*!A3%1(9!981-!%9!

;)%*!%*$!,#3#/6.%:L!!"#B()*/(*'!3(%$()9!%*$!A#3.1>!/%2()9!%)(!*#C!89.*4!@%1(6##2!'#! 1#//8*.1%'(!C.'-!1.'.Z(*9:!

• ;*!'-(!N:`:+!a)./(!5.*.9'()!b%B.$!,%/()#*!3%8*1-($!%!P1)#C$9#8)1.*4Q!.*.'.%'.B(!'#!9((2! #8'!1.'.Z(*!A)#A#9%39!#*!18''.*4!4#B()*/(*'!9A(*$.*4:!!?*!%!C(6!1#*&()(*1(!C.'-!5%)2! S812()6()4+!a)./(!5.*.9'()!,%/()#*!'-%*2($!@%1(6##2!&#)!A)#B.$.*4!'-(!/($.8/!&#)!

981-!%*!.*.'.%'.B(:c!!!

• 7()(!%'!-#/(+!'-(!LFFU!A)(9.$(*'.%3!)%1(!-%9!6((*!1%33($!'-(!P@%1(6##2!Y3(1'.#*+Q!%9! a)(9.$(*'!?6%/%!%*$!R(*%'#)!51,%.*!)(3.($!#*!'-(!9()B.1(!&#)!$(B(3#A.*4!4)%99)##'9!

2 Lev Grossman, Iran Protests: Twitter, the Medium of the Movement, NEWSWEEK, June 17, 2009; Sibylla Brodzinsky, Facebook Used to Target Colombia’s FARC with Global Rally, CHRISTIAN SCI. MONITOR, Feb. 4, 2008. 3 Gina Lovett, Government Drafts in Facebook for Second Crowdsourcing Initiative, NEW MEDIA AGE, July 9, 2010, http://www.nma.co.uk/news/government-drafts-in-facebook-for-second- crowdsourcing-initiative/3015666.article.

1601 South California Avenue, Palo Alto, California 94304 650.543.4800 – tel 650.543.4801 - fax

98AA#)'+!%*$!@%1(6##2!1#9A#*9#)($!#*(!#&!'-(!A)(9.$(*'.%3!$(6%'(9!\'#4('-()!C.'-!%!

')%$.'.#*%3!/($.%!#8'3('+!V<,!X(C9]:T!!!

• ;'!.9!(9'./%'($!'-%'!/#)(!'-%*!cFF!5(/6()9!#&!,#*4)(99!89(!@%1(6##2!.*!'-(.)!#&&.1.%3!

1%A%1.'>:E!!!

• YB(*!&($()%3!%4(*1.(9!-%B(!%$#A'($!@%1(6##2!%9!%!A#C()&83!1#//8*.1%'.#*!'##3[LL!

#8'!#&!LT!/%H#)!&($()%3!%4(*1.(9!89(!@%1(6##2:d!

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

=#!'-%'!(*$+!.*!LFF_!@%1(6##2!3%8*1-($!@%1(6##2!a3%'&#)/+!C-.1-!%33#C9!$(B(3#A()9!'#! 1)(%'(!.**#B%'.B(!9#1.%3!%AA3.1%'.#*9!%*$!/%2(!'-(/!%B%.3%63(!'#!A(#A3(!C-#!89(!@%1(6##2:!! =-.9!.**#B%'.#*!/%$(!@%1(6##2!%*!(*')>!A#.*'!'#!%!*(C!8*.B()9(!#&!'##39+!(IA().(*1(9[%*$!#&!

4 Brian Stelter, ABC News and Facebook in Joint Effort to Bring Viewers Closer to Political Coverage, N.Y. TIMES, Nov. 26, 2007; Virginia Heffernan, Clicking and Choosing: The Election According to YouTube, N.Y. TIMES, Nov. 14, 2008; Matthew Fraser & Soumitra Dutta, Barack Obama and the Facebook Election, U.S. NEWS AND WORLD REP., Nov. 19, 2008. 5 Posting of Tony Romm to The Hill, ‘Congress on Facebook’ Goes Live, http://thehill.com/blogs/hillicon-valley/technology/97683-congress-on-facebook-goes-live (May 13, 2010 7:58 EDT). 6 Information Management: Challenges in Federal Agencies’ Use of Web 2.0 Technologies, Hearing Before the Subcomm. on Information Policy, Census, and National Archives of the H. Comm. on Oversight and Government Reform, 111th Cong. (July 21, 2010) (statement of Gregory C. Wilshusen, Director of Information Security Issues, Government Accountability Office).

1601 South California Avenue, Palo Alto, California 94304 650.543.4800 – tel 650.543.4801 - fax

1#8)9(+!4%/(9['-%'!$((A(*!'-(!1#**(1'.#*!%/#*4!A(#A3(!#*!'-(!;*'()*(':!!=-(!-8*$)($9!#&! '-#89%*$9!#&!%AA3.1%'.#*9!/%$(!%B%.3%63(!'-)#84-!@%1(6##2!a3%'&#)/!.*138$(!'-(!!#C.*4^!!

• =-(!0.1$'$!%AA3.1%'.#*+!C-.1-!A)#B.$(9!%*!#*3.*(!A3%'&#)/!&#)!.*$.B.$8%39!%*$! #)4%*.Z%'.#*9!'#!)%.9(!&8*$9!&#)!1-%).'%63(!1%89(9:!!!

• =-(!0"#(2'/)3/4)5$!%AA3.1%'.#*+!%!3#1%3!98AA#)'!4)#8A!&#)!/#'-()9!'-%'!$)%C9!#*!'-(! 1#33(1'.B(!2*#C3($4(!#&!'-(!1#//8*.'>!&#)!98AA#)':!!!

• =-(!6"#%-+.7/0.2'*+.#!%AA3.1%'.#*+!C-.1-!%33#C9!>#8!'#!')%12!6.)'-$%>9+!%**.B()9%).(9+! %*$!#'-()!./A#)'%*'!$%'(9!#&!&).(*$9:!!!

=-(9(!$(B(3#A/(*'9!#*!@%1(6##2!a3%'&#)/!4#!6(>#*$!/()(!9#1.%3.Z.*4+!%*$!A)#B.$(!)(%3+! /(%*.*4&83!.*'()%1'.#*9!&#)!A(#A3(!C-#!89(!@%1(6##2:!!!

Y%)3.()!'-.9!>(%)!C(!(I'(*$($!@%1(6##2!a3%'&#)/!'#!#&&()!'-.9!1#**(1'.B.'>!%*$! 189'#/.Z%'.#*!'#!#'-()!9.'(9!#*!'-(!;*'()*(':!!;*!VA).3+!C(!.*')#$81($!P9#1.%3!A384.*9+Q!(%9>O'#O 89(!'##39!'-%'!%33#C!A)(B.#893>!4(*().1!C(69.'(9!'#!6(1#/(!189'#/.Z($!'#!%*!.*$.B.$8%3K9! .*'()(9'9!%*$!*('C#)2!#&!&).(*$9!%*$!%99#1.%'.#*9:!!@#)!(I%/A3(+!%!@%1(6##2!89()!B.9.'.*4!%! C(69.'(!1%*!.*9'%*'3>!9-%)(!1#*'(*'!#&!.*'()(9'!6>!13.12.*4!#*!'-(!@%1(6##2!PD.2(Q!68''#*+!C-.1-! 1%*!6).*4!'-%'!1#*'(*'!'#!'-(!%''(*'.#*!#&!'-(!A()9#*K9!&).(*$9!#*!'-(.)!)(%3O'./(!X(C9!@(($!#*! '-(.)!-#/(!A%4(+!%*$!C-(*!'-(>!B.9.'!'-(!9%/(!9.'(:!!G.'-!9#1.%3!A384.*9+!C(69.'(9!%)(!.*9'%*'3>! /%$(!/#)(!9#1.%3+!.*'()%1'.B(+!%*$!)(3(B%*'!'#!'-(!.*$.B.$8%3W!%9!A(#A3(!/#B(!'-)#84-!'-(! ;*'()*('+!C(69.'(9!.*1)(%9.*43>!)(&3(1'!'-(.)!6#$>!#&!)(3%'.#*9-.A9!%*$!1#**(1'.#*9!#*!'-(! ;*'()*(':!!!

=-.9!189'#/.Z%'.#*!1%*!6(!9((*!#*!/%*>!#&!'-(!;*'()*('K9!/#9'!&)(J8(*'3>!B.9.'($! C(69.'(9:!!=-(!A#A83%)!/#B.(!$%'%6%9(+!;5b6+!C-.1-!A)(B.#893>!9()B($!9./A3>!%9!%!)(A#9.'#)>!#&! /#B.(!.*&#)/%'.#*+!*#C!#&&()9!%!C%>!&#)!&).(*$9!'#!9-%)(!.*&#)/%'.#*!%6#8'!'-(.)!&%B#).'(! /#B.(9!%*$!%1'#)9:!!=)%$.'.#*%3!*(C9!#8'3('9+!981-!%9!,XX!%*$!'-(!8.$-"*9%)*/:)$%+!-%B(!%39#!

1601 South California Avenue, Palo Alto, California 94304 650.543.4800 – tel 650.543.4801 - fax

%$#A'($!'-(!A#C()!#&!'-(!9#1.%3!*('C#)2+!#&&().*4!'-(!%6.3.'>!'#!%11(99!'%.3#)($!%*$! A()9#*%3.Z($!*(C9!9#8)1(9:!!;*9'(%$!#&!C%$.*4!'-)#84-!%*!(*'.)(!*(C9A%A()+!A(#A3(!C-#!89(! @%1(6##2!*#C!-%B(!'-(!#A'.#*!'#!½!#*!'-(!.*&#)/%'.#*!'-%'!.9!)(3(B%*'!.*!'-(!1#*'(I'!#&! '-(.)!.*'()(9'9!%*$!1#**(1'.#*9+!.*!/81-!'-(!9%/(!C%>!'-%'!5(/6()9!#&!'-.9!,#//.''((!%)(! 4)(('($!.*!'-(!/#)*.*4!6>!*(C9!13.A9!'-%'!-%B(!6((*!9(3(1'($!%11#)$.*4!'#!.998(9!#&!9A(1.%3! ./A#)'%*1(!'#!>#8!%*$!>#8)!1#*9'.'8(*'9:!!@%1(6##2K9!PD.2(Q!68''#*!-%9!6(1#/(!%!86.J8.'#89! &(%'8)(!#&!'-(!C(6+!%33#C.*4!.*$.B.$8%39!'#!J8.123>!%*$!(%9.3>!9-%)(!'-(.)!&%B#).'(!A%)'9!#&!'-(! ;*'()*('!C.'-!'-(.)!&).(*$9!%*$!6)#%$()!1#//8*.'.(9:!!!

V9!5%)2!S812()6()4!A8'!.'!%'!'-(!1#*&()(*1(!C-()(!@%1(6##2!3%8*1-($!'-(9(!9#1.%3!

A384.*9+!P?8)!4#%3!.9!e&#)f!A(#A3(!e'#f!-%B(!.*9'%*'3>!9#1.%3!(IA().(*1(9!C-()(B()!'-(>!4#:Q_!!V'! '-(!9%/(!'./(+!9#1.%3!A384.*9!$#!*#'!)(J8.)(!%*>!A()9#*%3!.*&#)/%'.#*!'#!A%99!&)#/!@%1(6##2!'#! %*!(I'()*%3!C(69.'(:!!a384.*9!A)#/#'(!%!'%.3#)($!;*'()*('!(IA().(*1(+!C-.3(!/%.*'%.*.*4!89()! 1#*')#3!#B()!A()9#*%3!.*&#)/%'.#*:!!R.*1(!'-(!3%8*1-!#&!9#1.%3!A384.*9!.*!VA).3!#&!'-.9!>(%)+!'-(>! -%B(!6((*!.*1#)A#)%'($!6>!/#)(!'-%*!cEF+FFF!C(69.'(9+!6).*4.*4!%!/#)(!A()9#*%3.Z($!;*'()*('! '#!/.33.#*9:!!!

@%1(6##2!.9!*#C!#&&().*4!%!A.3#'!A)#4)%/+!;*9'%*'!a()9#*%3.Z%'.#*+!C-.1-!C.33!%33#C! .*$.B.$8%39!'#!-%B(!%!/#)(!)#689'!A()9#*%3.Z($!(IA().(*1(!C.'-!A%)'*()!9.'(9+!.*.'.%33>!g(3A+! a%*$#)%+!%*$!5.1)#9#&'!b#19:1#/:!!=-(9(!9.'(9!*#C!A)#B.$(!%!')83>!A()9#*%3!%*$!'%.3#)($! (IA().(*1(!'#!B.9.'#)9!%9!9##*!%9!'-(>!%)).B(:!!=-(9(!.**#B%'.#*9!%$$)(99!A(#A3(K9!)(%3! &)89')%'.#*!C.'-!'-(!9'%'.1+!%*#*>/#89!;*'()*('!#&!'-(!A%9':!!;*9'(%$!#&!B.9.'.*4!%!4(*().1!C(69.'(! %*$!C%$.*4!'-)#84-!%!3#'!#&!.))(3(B%*'!1#*'(*'+!;*9'%*'!a()9#*%3.Z%'.#*!/%2(9!.'!A#99.63(!&#)!>#8! '#!4#!'#!%!9.'(!%*$!.//($.%'(3>!)(1(.B(!1#*'(*'!'-%'!.9!)(3(B%*'!'#!>#8!%*$!>#8)!&).(*$9+!'-(! A3%1(!>#8!3.B(+!%*$!'-(!'-.*49!>#8!3.2(!'#!$#:!!<>!#&&().*4!A()9#*%3.Z($!9()B.1(+!'-(9(!A%)'*()! 9.'(9!(IA().(*1(!4)(%'()!(*4%4(/(*'!&)#/!A(#A3(!C-#!89(!@%1(6##2:!

7 Mark Zuckerberg, CEO, Facebook, Inc., Remarks at f8 Developers’ Conference, Apr. 21, 2010.

1601 South California Avenue, Palo Alto, California 94304 650.543.4800 – tel 650.543.4801 - fax

@#)!(I%/A3(+!'-(!C(69.'(!g(3A!%3)(%$>!#&&()($!%!B%38%63(!9()B.1(!6>!1#/A.3.*4!89()! )(B.(C9!#&!)(9'%8)%*'9+!6%)9+!13869+!%*$!#'-()!9()B.1(9:!!=-(9(!)(B.(C9!1#83$!1#/(!&)#/!%*>! )(B.(C()+!%*>C-()(!#*!'-(!;*'()*(':!!=-)#84-!@%1(6##2K9!;*9'%*'!a()9#*%3.Z%'.#*+!g(3A!6(1%/(! %!'%.3#)($!(IA().(*1(!'-%'!.9!(B(*!/#)(!)(3(B%*'!%*$!89(&83:!!G-.3(!>#8!1%*!9'.33!)(%$!4(*().1! )(B.(C9!#*!'-(!9.'(+!>#8!1%*!%39#!*#C!1-##9(!'#!½!#*!)(B.(C9!6>!>#8)!&).(*$9!%*$! %1J8%.*'%*1(9:!!<>!(*%63.*4!>#8!'#!3(%)*!'-(!&%B#).'(!)(9'%8)%*'9!#&!A(#A3(!>#8!')89'!.*!%!1.'>! >#8K)(!B.9.'.*4!&#)!'-(!&.)9'!'./(+!;*9'%*'!a()9#*%3.Z%'.#*!.//(%98)%63>!.*1)(%9(9!'-(!B%38(!#&! '-(!9.'(:!!!

R./.3%)3>+!'-(!/89.1!9')(%/.*4!9()B.1(!a%*$#)%!%3)(%$>!#&&()($!%!-.4-3>!A()9#*%3.Z($! 9()B.1(!6>!89.*4!%$B%*1($!%34#).'-/9!'#!'%.3#)!/89.1!A3%>3.9'9!'#!>#8)!'%9'(9[6%9($!#*!'-(! /89.1!>#8!18))(*'3>!3.9'(*!'#+!a%*$#)%!.*')#$81(9!>#8!'#!*(C!/89.1!'-%'!>#8K)(!%39#!3.2(3>!'#! (*H#>:!!<>!%$#A'.*4!;*9'%*'!a()9#*%3.Z%'.#*+!a%*$#)%!1%*!/%4*.&>!'-(!A()9#*%3.Z%'.#*!#&!'-.9! (IA().(*1(!6>!.$(*'.&>.*4!/89.1!'-)#84-!'-(!3(*9!#&!>#8)!9#1.%3!*('C#)29:!!a(#A3(!-%B(!3#*4! )(3.($!#*!&).(*$9+!1#C#)2()9+!%*$!)(3%'.B(9!&#)!/89.1!)(1#//(*$%'.#*9W!*#C!a%*$#)%!1%*! (*-%*1(!'-.9!(IA().(*1(!#*3.*(!C.'-!'-(!-(3A!#&!@%1(6##2:!!?&!1#8)9(+!@%1(6##2!-%9!C#)2($! $.3.4(*'3>!'#!A)#B.$(!/83'.A3(!%*$!/(%*.*4&83!#AA#)'8*.'.(9!&#)!89()9!'#!3(%)*!%6#8'!%*$!1-##9(! '#!A%)'.1.A%'(!.*!;*9'%*'!a()9#*%3.Z%'.#*+!%*$!'#!(*98)(!'-%'!#8)!A%)'*()9!%$#A'!%*$!(*&#)1(! %$(J8%'(!A)#'(1'.#*9!&#)!A()9#*%3!.*&#)/%'.#*:!

@9! 5.2#6((7G$!5(2?$!()!8$#-!0()%-(/!.)

a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a(#A3(!

1601 South California Avenue, Palo Alto, California 94304 650.543.4800 – tel 650.543.4801 - fax

C-#!89(!@%1(6##2!$('()/.*(!C-%'!1#*'(*'!.9!9-%)($!%*$!-#C!.'!.9!9-%)($:!!@%1(6##2!.9!68.3'! &)#/!'-(!6#''#/!8A+!'%2.*4!C-%'!C(!1%33!%!->A()O4)%99)##'9!%AA)#%1-!'#!9-%).*4!.*&#)/%'.#*:!

a(#A3(!C-#!89(!@%1(6##2!%)(!(*4%4($!.*!68.3$.*4!%!9%&(+!9(18)(!(IA().(*1(!&#)! '-(/9(3B(9!%*$!'-(.)!&).(*$9:!!V9!%!)(983'+!C(!-%B(!$(B(3#A($!A#C()&83!/(1-%*.9/9!&#)!9(3&O )(483%'.#*!%*$!89()!A)#'(1'.#*:!!;*$.B.$8%39!89(!9#1.%3!'(1-*#3#4.(9!'#!1#**(1'!%*$!9-%)(! .*&#)/%'.#*+!68'!'-(>!%39#!A3%>!%*!./A#)'%*'!)#3(!.*!A#3.1.*4!'-(!/($.8/!.'9(3&:!!;*!&%1'+!89()9! %)(!%1'.B(3>!.*B#3B($!.*!/#*.'#).*4!%*$!1#*')#33.*4!'-(.)!#*3.*(!A)(9(*1(9+!%*$!1%*!#&'(*! A)#B.$(!'-(!6(9'!1-(12!#*!%!1#/A%*>K9!.*&#)/%'.#*!9-%).*4!A#3.1.(9:!!V*!./A#)'%*'!)(1(*'!9'8$>! 6>!'-(!a(C!0(9(%)1-!,(*'()!*$!'-%'!E_h!#&!%$83'!;*'()*('!89()9!/#*.'#)!'-(.)!#*3.*(!

A)(9(*1(:U!!V/#*4!89()9!%4(!MU!'#!Li+!_Mh!-%B(!%$H89'($!'-(.)!9(''.*49!%*$!1#*')#39!'#! )(483%'(!-#C!/81-!'-(>!%)(!9-%).*4!C.'-!#'-()9+!%*$!dEh!#&!%33!9#1.%3O*('C#)2.*4!9.'(!89()9!

-%B(!$#*(!9#:i!!;&!'-(9(!89()9!&((3!'-%'!%!9()B.1(!.9!#B()9'(AA.*4!.'9!6#8*$9+!'-(>!C.33!%1'.B(3>! '%2(!9'(A9!'#!1#*')#3!'-(.)!#C*!A()9#*%3!.*&#)/%'.#*:!!!

@%1(6##2!1#*'.*8%33>!9((29!'#!./A)#B(!#8)!89()!.*'()&%1(+!#8)!$%'%O9-%).*4!A#3.1.(9+!%*$! '-(!#B()%33!(IA().(*1(!#&!A(#A3(!C-#!89(!#8)!9()B.1(:!!0(1(*'!1-%*4(9!'#!@%1(6##2K9!1#*')#39! %*$!A).B%1>!A#3.1>!A)#B.$(!%!A)./(!(I%/A3(!#&!-#C!9#1.%3!'(1-*#3#4.(9!-%B(!%!$>*%/.1!%6.3.'>!'#! )(9A#*$!'#!89()9!%*$!9(3&O1#))(1':!!?B()!'-(!3%9'!>(%)+!@%1(6##2!-%9!1#*'.*8($!'#!.**#B%'(!*(C! C%>9!'#!#&&()!9./A3()!%*$!6(''()!1#*')#39^!

• I-&F.2*!"-.)$&%&()!"((/9!!G-(*!@%1(6##2!.*')#$81($!%!*(C!A).B%1>!&)%/(C#)2!.*! b(1(/6()!#&!3%9'!>(%)+!C(!'##2!'-(!8*A)(1($(*'($!9'(A!#&!)(J8.).*4!%33!89()9!'#! *%B.4%'(!'-)#84-!%!A).B%1>!P')%*9.'.#*!'##3Q!'#!1#*&.)/!'-(.)!9(''.*49!&#)!9-%).*4! .*&#)/%'.#*!%*$!'#!1-%*4(!'-(!9(''.*49!.&!'-(>!1-#9(:!!;*9'%*'3>+!-8*$)($9!#&!/.33.#*9!#&!

8 MARY MADDEN & AARON SMITH, PEW INTERNET & AMERICAN LIFE PROJECT, PEW RESEARCH CENTER, REPUTATION MANAGEMENT AND SOCIAL MEDIA 8, 21 (May 26, 2010). 9 Id.

1601 South California Avenue, Palo Alto, California 94304 650.543.4800 – tel 650.543.4801 - fax

.*$.B.$8%39!'##2!'./(!'#!/(%*.*4&833>!(*4%4(!C.'-!'-(!1#*1(A'!#&!A).B%1>!%*$!1#*9.$()! C-('-()!'-(.)!9(''.*49!%118)%'(3>!)(&3(1'($!'-(.)!A)(&()(*1(9+!.*!%!/%**()!'-%'!-%$! *(B()!#118))($!6(&#)(+!#*!#)!#&&!'-(!;*'()*(':!

• 0()%#E%?./!I-&F.2*!0()%-(/9!!V39#!3%9'!>(%)+!@%1(6##2!$(A3#>($!%!1#*'(I'8%3!A).B%1>! 1#*')#3+!C-.1-!%33#C9!A(#A3(!'#!1#*')#3!C-#!C.33!9((!'-(.)!1#*'(*'!C-(*!.'!.9!9-%)($:!! D.2(!'-(!')%*9.'.#*!'##3+!@%1(6##2!9#84-'!'#!/%I./.Z(!6#'-!9./A3.1.'>!%*$!1#*')#3+!%! $(3.1%'(!6%3%*1(+!C-.3(!%99.9'.*4!(%1-!89()!'#!9(3(1'!'-(!(I'(*'!#&!9-%).*4!'-%'!/%2(9! '-(/!&((3!1#/&#)'%63(:!

• 4)#J0/&27!:1.-&)3!0()%-(/9!!;*!VA).3+!@%1(6##2!#&&()($!%!*(C!9./A3.&.($!1#*')#3!&#)! 9-%).*4!'-%'!3('9!A(#A3(!1#*')#3!#B()!'C(*'>!1%'(4#).(9!#&!.*&#)/%'.#*!C.'-!H89'!#*(! 13.12:!!@%1(6##2!./A3(/(*'($!'-(9(!1-%*4(9!%*$!%$$.'.#*9!'#!.'9!1#*')#39!C#)2.*4! J8.123>[.*!'-(!&%1(!#&!(*#)/#89!'(1-*.1%3!1#/A3(I.'>['#!)(9A#*$!'#!B.(C9!(IA)(99($! .*!'-(!89()!1#//8*.'>:!!;*!%$$.'.#*+!@%1(6##2!#&&()($!%*!(%9>!C%>!&#)!A(#A3(!'#!1#*')#3! '-(!%11(99!'-%'!a3%'&#)/!$(B(3#A()9!-%B(!'#!'-(.)!.*&#)/%'.#*:!!!

• K-.)?/.-!L.%.!I#-'&$$&()$9!!;*!j8*(+!@%1(6##2!6(1%/(!'-(!&.)9'!A)#B.$()!'#!)(J8.)(! $(B(3#A()9!'#!#6'%.*!P4)%*83%)!$%'%!A()/.99.#*9:Q!!b(B(3#A()9!89.*4!a3%'&#)/!/89'!*#C! 9A(1.&.1%33>!)(J8(9'!$%'%!$.)(1'3>!&)#/!'-(!.*$.B.$8%3[C-#!)('%.*9!'-(!83'./%'(!9./A3(! 1-#.1(!#&!C-('-()!'#!9-%)(!.*&#)/%'.#*!C.'-!%*!#8'9.$(!$(B(3#A():!!=-.9!4)%*83%)! A()/.99.#*9!/#$(3!%1'8%33>!4.B(9!A(#A3(!/#)(!1#*')#3!#B()!'-(.)!.*&#)/%'.#*!'-%*! 1#/A%)%63(!9()B.1(9+!C-.3(!%33#C.*4!$(B(3#A()9!'#!1#*'.*8(!'-(!B.6)%*'!.**#B%'.#*!'-%'! -%9!/%)2($!'-(!a3%'&#)/!(1#*#/>:!

=#!&%1.3.'%'(!)(9A#*9.B(*(99!'#!89()9+!@%1(6##2!.*')#$81($!%!P*#'.1(!%*$!1#//(*'Q!A)#1(99!&#)! B(''.*4!9#/(!#&!.'9!A#'(*'.%3!1-%*4(9+!/#$(3($!.*!A%)'!#*!'-(!&($()%3!4#B()*/(*'K9!)83(/%2.*4! A)#1($8)(9:!!=-.9!A)#1(99!%39#!9()B(9!'#!($81%'(!%*$!(*4%4(!89()9!%6#8'!A#'(*'.%3!A#3.1>! 1-%*4(9:!!V'!'./(9!C(!C.33!(B(*!-#3$!%!89()!B#'(!#*!A)#A#9($!A#3.1>!1-%*4(9+!%9!C(!$.$!.*!VA).3!

1601 South California Avenue, Palo Alto, California 94304 650.543.4800 – tel 650.543.4801 - fax

C-(*!C(!.998($!#8)!R'%'(/(*'!#&!0.4-'9!%*$!0(9A#*9.6.3.'.(9!%*$!)(B.9($!a).B%1>!a#3.1>:!!G(!%)(! %C%)(!#&!*#!;*'()*('O6%9($!1#/A%*>+!3%)4(!#)!9/%33+!'-%'!4#(9!'#!981-!3(*4'-9!'#!A863.1.Z(!%*$! .*1#)A#)%'(!.*$.B.$8%39K!&(($6%12!.*'#!'-#9(!2(>!$#18/(*'9:!!;'!.9!%!&8)'-()!)(&3(1'.#*!#&!#8)! 1#//.'/(*'!'#!-(%).*4!A(#A3(9K!B#.1(9!.*!'-(!4#B()*%*1(!#&!'-(.)!1#//8*.'>:!!=-.9! 1#//.'/(*'!')%*93%'(9!.*'#!)(%3!A)%1'.1%3!'##39!'-%'!A(#A3(!1%*!%*$!$#!89(:!

V9!C(!/#B(!&#)C%)$+!'-(!A(#A3(!C-#!89(!@%1(6##2!C.33!1#*'.*8(!'#!9-%A(!#8)!&8'8)(!6>! -#C!'-(>!6%3%*1(!'-(.)!$(/%*$!&#)!9-%).*4!%*$!1#**(1'.#*!#*!'-(!#*(!-%*$+!C.'-!'-(.)!$(9.)(! '#!1#*')#3!'-(!1#*'(*'!'-(>!9-%)(!#*!'-(!#'-()!-%*$:!!j89'!%9!C(!.**#B%'(!*(C!C%>9!&#)!9-%).*4! %*$!1#**(1'.#*+!C(!%39#!.**#B%'(!*(C!C%>9!'#!#&&()!89()9!1#*')#3:!!V*$+!#&!1#8)9(+!'-(!A(#A3(! C-#!89(!@%1(6##2!%39#!)('%.*!1#*')#3!#B()!'-(!9()B.1(!%*$!#&&()!89!)(%3O'./(!&(($6%12!6>!'-(! 1-#.1(9!'-(>!/%2(!OO!'#!H#.*+!'#!3(%B(+!'#!89(!#8)!'##39+!#)!'#!(*4%4(!3(99:!!;*!'-.9!C%>!'##+!.'!.9! '-(!A(#A3(!C-#!89(!@%1(6##2!'-%'!83'./%'(3>!$).B(!#8)!.**#B%'.#*:!!!

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d!.'!.*.'.%33>!$)(C!9')#*4! #AA#9.'.#*!&)#/!%!3%)4(!*8/6()!#&!@%1(6##2!89()9:!!VAA)#A).%'(3>+!9#/(!&#)/($!@%1(6##2! 4)#8A9!%4%.*9'!'-(!X(C9!@(($:!!G(!3.9'(*($+!/%$(!9#/(!/#$(9'!1-%*4(9+!%*$!*#C!/#9'! @%1(6##2!89()9!1#83$!*#'!./%4.*(!#8)!9()B.1(!C.'-#8'!.':!!!

@%1(6##2!.9!'-89!%*!(I%/A3(!#&!'-(!')(/(*$#89!9(3&O1#))(1'.B(!1%A%1.'>!#&!;*'()*('O 6%9($!9()B.1(9+!A%)'.183%)3>!C.'-!)(9A(1'!'#!'-(!6%3%*1(!6('C((*!#A(**(99!%*$!A).B%1>:!! @%1(6##2K9!)(9A#*9(!'#!89()!&(($6%12!-%9!-(3A($!.'!'#!6(1#/(!%!6(''()!9()B.1(!C-.3(!1#*'.*8.*4!

1601 South California Avenue, Palo Alto, California 94304 650.543.4800 – tel 650.543.4801 - fax

'#!(*-%*1(!'-(!89()!(IA().(*1(!%*$!A.#*(()!*(C!C%>9!'#!9-%)(!.*&#)/%'.#*:!!V*$+!@%1(6##2K9! A.#*(().*4!$(B(3#A/(*'!#&!89()!1#*')#39!&#)!'-(!.*&#)/%'.#*!'-(>!9-%)(!.9!%*!(I%/A3(!&#)! )(483%'#)9!.*!'-(!N:R:!%*$!%6)#%$!#&!-#C!%AA)#%1-(9!'-%'!B(9'!$(1.9.#*O/%2.*4!.*!.*$.B.$8%3! 89()9+!)%'-()!'-%*!.*!4#B()*/(*'!)(483%'#)9+!%)(!'-(!/#9'!A)#/.9.*4!/(%*9!#&!&8)'-().*4!89()! 9%'.9&%1'.#*!%*$!;*'()*('!.**#B%'.#*:!!!

?&!1#8)9(+!'-(!.*B#3B(/(*'!#&!'-(!&($()%3!4#B()*/(*'!.9!%39#!*(($($+!&#)!(I%/A3(+!'#! 48%)$!%4%.*9'!1)./.*%39!%*$!/.91)(%*'9!C-#!C#83$!3(B()%4(!'-(!;*'()*('K9!#A(**(99!'#!(*4%4(! .*!91%/9+!.$(*'.'>!'-(&'+!%*$!#'-()!%1'.B.'.(9!'-%'!1%89(!&.*%*1.%3!#)!(B(*!A->9.1%3!-%)/:!!=-%'!.9! C->!C(!%AA3%8$!,#*4)(99!&#)!(*%1'.*4!'%)4('($!9'%'8'(9!'-%'!%$$)(99!'-#9(!A)#63(/9!C.'-#8'! 1%6.*.*4!'-(!1)(%'.B(!&)(($#/!'-%'!.9!'-(!3.&(!&#)1(!#&!'-(!;*'()*(':!!=-(!,#/A8'()!@)%8$!%*$!

V689(!V1'+MF!'-(!,-.3$!?*3.*(!a).B%1>!a)#'(1'.#*!V1'+MM!%*$!'-(!,#*')#33.*4!'-(!V99%83'!#&!X#*O

R#3.1.'($!a#)*#4)%A->!%*$!5%)2('.*4!V1'!\'-(!P,VXORaV5Q!V1']ML!%33!-%B(!9()B($!'#!A)#'(1'! '-(!A863.1!&)#/!9#/(!#&!'-(!;*'()*('K9!$%*4()9!%*$!%**#>%*1(9:!!!

@%1(6##2!#&'(*!C#)29!%)/O.*O%)/!C.'-!'-(!4#B()*/(*'!.*!'-(9(!%)(%9:!!@#)!(I%/A3(+!.'! -%9!.*B#2($!'-(!,VXORaV5!V1'!B.4#)#893>!'#!$(&(*$!.'9!89()9!%4%.*9'!/%3.1.#89!#*3.*(!%''%129! %*$!'#!-(3A!/%2(!'-(!;*'()*('!9%&()!&#)!%33!6>!'%2.*4!9A%//()9!#8'!#&!1#//.99.#*^!!C(!-%B(!

#6'%.*($!'-(!'C#!3%)4(9'O(B()!1.B.3!H8$4/(*'9!8*$()!'-(!V1':Mc!!G(!%)(!%39#!A)#8$!'-%'!3%9'!>(%)! =0NR=(+!%!*#*A)#&.'!A).B%1>!9'%*$%)$O9(''.*4!#)4%*.Z%'.#*+!)%'($!@%1(6##2!#*(!#&!.'9!'(*!/#9'!

')89'($!1#/A%*.(9!6%9($!#*!%!A863.1!98)B(>!%*$!%*!(IA()'!)(B.(C:MT!!!

10 Pub. L. No. 99-474, 100 Stat. 1213 (Oct. 16, 1986). 11 Pub. L. No. 105-277, 112 Stat. 2581 (Oct. 21, 1998). 12 Pub. L. No. 108-187, 117 Stat. 2699 (Dec. 16, 2003). 13 A 2008 judgment against Adam Guerbez and Atlantis Blue Capital ($873 million) and a 2009 judgment against the “Spam King” Sanford Wallace ($740 million). 14 TRUSTe, Press Release: 2009 Most Trusted Companies in Privacy, Sept. 16, 2009.

1601 South California Avenue, Palo Alto, California 94304 650.543.4800 – tel 650.543.4801 - fax

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

=#!1#*138$(!#*!'-.9!'#A.1+!89()!1#*')#3!.9!1(*')%3!'#!-#C!@%1(6##2!#A()%'(9+!%*$!C.33! )(/%.*!9#:!!G(!9-%)(!'-(!1#//.'/(*'!#&!,#*4)(99!'#!(*98)(!%!9%&(+!9(18)(!;*'()*('!(IA().(*1(+! C-.3(!&%1.3.'%'.*4!'-(!.**#B%'.#*!%*$!9-%).*4!#&!.*&#)/%'.#*!'-%'!A(#A3(!(IA(1':!!G(!B%38(!#8)! )(3%'.#*9-.A9!C.'-!'-(!&($()%3!4#B()*/(*'+!C.'-!9'%'(9+!%*$!C.'-!(*&#)1(/(*'!%4(*1.(9! '-)#84-#8'!'-(!C#)3$+!%*$!C.33!1#*'.*8(!'#!C#)2!C.'-!,#*4)(99!%*$!#'-()9!'#!(*98)(!'-%'!#8)!

89()9+!(9A(1.%33>!>#8*4!A(#A3(+!-%B(!%!9%&(!%*$!A)#$81'.B(!;*'()*('!(IA().(*1(:ME!!

M9! 5.2#6((7G$!D2()('&2!H(/#!+(-!8$#-$!.)

@%1(6##2!%*$!.'9!3(%$()9-.A!%)(!$).B(*!6>!%!B.9.#*!#&!'-(!;*'()*('K9!1%A%1.'>!'#!/%2(!'-(! C#)3$!/#)(!1#**(1'($+!(*).1-.*4!#8)!A()9#*%3!3.B(9+!#8)!9#1.('>+!(B(*!#8)!$(/#1)%1>:!!<8'!#&! 1#8)9(!'-(!;*'()*('!.9!%39#!%*!./A#)'%*'!(1#*#/.1!A)(9(*1(+!A%)'.183%)3>!.*!'-(9(!1-%33(*4.*4!

15 Facebook offers its service to people age 13 and over. We clearly describe this age limit in our Privacy Policy, and if we learn that a child under 13 has shared information on our service, we will delete that information as quickly as possible. See also The Role of Innovation in Creating a Safer Online Environment – The Facebook Experience, Before the Subcomm. on Consumer Protection, Product Safety, and Insurance of the S. Comm. on Commerce, Science, and Transportation, 111th Cong. (2010) (Testimony of Timothy Sparapani, Director, Public Policy, Facebook), available at http://commerce.senate.gov/public/?a=Files.Serve&File_id=dac6055f-274c-4813-955a- 414ccd0c4b3a.

1601 South California Avenue, Palo Alto, California 94304 650.543.4800 – tel 650.543.4801 - fax

(1#*#/.1!'./(9:!!;'!.9!'-.9!(1#*#/.1!B.'%3.'>!'-%'!/%2(9!'-(!@%1(6##2!(IA().(*1(!A#99.63(!%*$! &)((!#&!1-%)4(!'#!#8)!89()9+!C.'-#8'!@%1(6##2!(B()!9-%).*4!A()9#*%33>!.$(*'.&.%63(!.*&#)/%'.#*! C.'-!%$B()'.9()9:!!!

;*!LFFi+!#*3.*(!)('%.3!9A(*$.*4!.*!'-(!N*.'($!R'%'(9!C%9!*(%)3>!kMcF!6.33.#*+!#*3>!93.4-'3>!

3#C()!'-%*!.*!LFFU!$(9A.'(!'-(!(*#)/#89!./A%1'!#&!'-(!)(1(99.#*!#*!'-(!N:R:!(1#*#/>:Md!!?*(! (9'./%'(!9844(9'9!'-%'!'-(!1#//()1.%3!;*'()*('!%$$9!kM:E!%#"22")*!.*!B%38(!'#!689.*(99(9!%*$!

1#*98/()9!C#)3$C.$(:M_!!V*$!.*!%!'./(!#&!(1#*#/.1!-%)$9-.A+!G(6!L:F[%*$!9#1.%3!*('C#)2.*4! 9()B.1(9!.*!A%)'.183%)[%)(!A)#B.$.*4!%!/81-!*(($($!9#8)1(!#&!H#69+!4)#C'-+!.*B(9'/(*'+!%*$! .**#B%'.#*:!!@%1(6##2!.9!%!N:R:O6%9($!1#/A%*>[(B(*!'-#84-!_Fh!#&!@%1(6##2!89()9!%)(! #8'9.$(!#&!'-(!N*.'($!R'%'(9+!UFh!#&!.'9!(/A3#>((9!%)(!3#1%'($!-()(:!!=-(!,-%.)/%*!#&!'-(! @($()%3!,#//8*.1%'.#*9!,#//.99.#*!)(1(*'3>!)(1#4*.Z($!-#C!'-(!(*')(A)(*(8).%3!A#C()!#&!

9()B.1(9!3.2(!@%1(6##2!1%*!$).B(!(1#*#/.1!4)#C'-!%*$!1)(%'(!H#69!-()(!%'!-#/(:MU!

@%1(6##2!a3%'&#)/+!C-.1-!-(3A9!1)(%'(!.**#B%'.B(!%*$!/#)(!A()9#*%3.Z($!(IA().(*1(9! &#)!89()9+!%39#!9()B(9!V/().1%*!689.*(99(9!%*$!C#)2()9!6>! '().*4!C-%'!.9!.*!%!9(*9(!%*!(*'.)(! a3%'&#)/!(1#*#/>:!!;'!.9!%!/%)2('A3%1(!'#!C-.1-!-8*$)($9!#&!'-#89%*$9!#&!'-.)$OA%)'>! $(B(3#A()9!/%>!6).*4!'-(.)!.$(%9!%*$!.*B(*'.#*9!%*$!#&&()!'-(/!'#!@%1(6##2!89()9:!!5#)(!'-%*! -%3&!%!/.33.#*!%AA3.1%'.#*9!%)(!*#C!%B%.3%63(!#*!a3%'&#)/:!!R#/(!#&!'-(9(!%AA3.1%'.#*9!%)(! %99#1.%'($!C.'-!689.*(99(9!'-%'!(/A3#>!-8*$)($9!#&!A(#A3(!%*$!-%B(!-8*$)($9!#&!/.33.#*9+! (B(*!6.33.#*9!#&!$#33%)9!.*!B%38(^!

16 Jeff Clabaugh, Online spending in 2009 falls, MILWAUKEE BUS. J., Feb. 9, 2010. 17 ROBERT D. ATKINSON ET AL., THE INFO. TECH. & INNOVATION FOUND., THE INTERNET ECONOMY 25 YEARS AFTER .COM 1, 4 (2010). 18 Referring to Facebook, FCC Chairman Julius Genachowski noted the power of the Internet’s “distributed innovation and ubiquitous entrepreneurship,” which creates “jobs and opportunity everywhere there is broadband.” Julius Genachowski, Chairman, Fed. Comms. Comm’n, Prepared Remarks at the Brookings Institute (Sept. 21, 2009), available at http://www.openInternet.gov/read- speech.html (emphasis added).

1601 South California Avenue, Palo Alto, California 94304 650.543.4800 – tel 650.543.4801 - fax

• D(%$.*4!4%/(9!$(B(3#A()!S>*4%+!1)(%'#)!#&!'-(!A#A83%)!@%)/B.33(!4%/(!'-%'!C%9! $(B(3#A($!#*!@%1(6##2!a3%'&#)/+!-%9!*(%)3>!M+FFF!(/A3#>((9+!8A!&)#/!c_E!(/A3#>((9! %!>(%)!%4#+!%*$!*#C!-%9!9#/(!TFF!H#6!#A(*.*49:!!;'9!4%/(9!-%B(!LMM!/.33.#*!A3%>()9! (B()>!/#*'-!\%11#)$.*4!'#!VAAb%'%:1#/K9!1#8*']+!%*$!'-(!1#/A%*>!-%9!6((*!B%38($!%'!

/#)(!'-%*!kT:E!6.33.#*:Mi!

• ;*!LFFi+!4%/(9!$(B(3#A()!a3%>&.9-!C%9!%1J8.)($!6>!Y3(1')#*.1!V)'9!&#)!%*!%/#8*'! )(A#)'($!'#!6(!%9!/81-!%9!kTFF!/.33.#*:!!V3'-#84-!6%9($!.*!'-(!N:`:+!a3%>&.9-!-%9! $(B(3#A($!%!9869'%*'.%3!A)(9(*1(!.*!'-(!N*.'($!R'%'(9+!C-.1-!.*138$(9!%'!3(%9'!)!

$(B(3#A/(*'!9'8$.#9:LF!

=-.9!B.6)%*'!(1#*#/>!#&!&(%'8)(9!%*$!%AA3.1%'.#*9!-%9!9-%''()($!'-(!6%)).()9!'-%'!/%>! -%B(!A)(B.#893>!3./.'($!C-%'!#*(!1#/A%*>!1#83$!#&&()!'#!89()9:!!@%1(6##2!&#)!.'9!A%)'!-(3A9! A)#'(1'!89()9K!a3%'&#)/!(IA().(*1(!6>!%)/.*4!89()9!C.'-!1#*')#3!#B()!'-(!.*&#)/%'.#*! %AA3.1%'.#*9!)(1(.B(+!'-)#84-!).4#)#89!A#3.1.(9!%*$!'(1-*.1%3!1#*')#39!'-%'!%AA3>!'#!#8)!a3%'&#)/+! %*$!.*!)(B.(C9!%*$!.*B(9'.4%'.#*9!1#*$81'($!6>!#8)!a3%'&#)/!?A()%'.#*9!=(%/:!!!

?*3.*(!%$B()'.9.*4!.9!#&!1#8)9(!%!1).'.1%3!1#/A#*(*'!#&!'-(!(1#*#/.1!4)#C'-!'-%'!'-(! ;*'()*('!-%9!9A8))($:!!V9!/(*'.#*($+!.'!%39#!(*%63(9!@%1(6##2!'#!#&&()!.'9!9()B.1(!&#)!&)((+! C.'-#8'!(B()!9-%).*4!A()9#*%33>!.$(*'.&.%63(!.*&#)/%'.#*!C.'-!%$B()'.9()9:!!@%1(6##2!6(3.(B(9! '-%'!9#1.%3!%$B()'.9(/(*'9!1#/A3(/(*'!'-(!C%>!A(#A3(!%3)(%$>!89(!@%1(6##2!'#!$.91#B()+! 9-%)(+!%*$!1#**(1'!C.'-!A(#A3(!%*$!'-(!C#)3$!%)#8*$!'-(/:!!G-('-()!.'K9!%!*(C!1%)+!13#'-(9+!#)! /89.1+!/%*>!#&!'-(!'-.*49!A(#A3(!$.91#B()!#*!'-(!;*'()*('!1#/(!&)#/!'-(.)!&).(*$9['-)#84-! @%1(6##2+!%$B()'.9()9!1%*!1#/A3(/(*'!C-%'!A(#A3(!3(%)*!&)#/!'-(.)!&).(*$9!.*!%*!8*#6')89.B(! C%>:!

19 Miguel Helft, Will Zynga Become the Google of Games?, N.Y. TIMES, July 24, 2010. 20 Erick Schonfeld, Not Playing Around. EA Buys Playfish for $300 Million, Plus a $100 Million Earnout, TECHCRUNCH, Nov. 9, 2009.

1601 South California Avenue, Palo Alto, California 94304 650.543.4800 – tel 650.543.4801 - fax

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

0()2/?$&()!

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

! !

1601 South California Avenue, Palo Alto, California 94304 650.543.4800 – tel 650.543.4801 - fax